HARFORD COMMUNITY COLLEGE Minutes of Open Meeting June 9, 2015 The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College met on Tuesday, June 9, 2015, at 6:00 p.m. in the Chesapeake Center Board Room. Trustees present: Mr. John Haggerty; Rev. Cordell E. Hunter, Sr.; Mr. Bryan E. Kelly; Dr. James W. McCauley; Richard D. Norling; Mrs. Jan Stinchcomb; Dr. James J. Valdes; and, Dr. Dennis Golladay as Secretary-Treasurer Trustee absent: Mrs. Doris G. Carey; Mr. Bradley R. Stover Staff present: C. Allen, A. Adams, M. Bandy, K. Callan, J. Cassady, D. Cruise, D. Dennis, K. Doan, N. Dysard, T. Franza, S. Garey, D. Grissom, A. Haggray, C. Hathaway, C. Henderson, E. Jackson, R. Johnson, P. Karwowski, K. Krsolovic, P. Labe, J. Mayhorne, B. Morrison, Z. Parker, G. Pizzuto, S. Phillips, L. Preston, C. Sherman, V. Swain, A. Ward and D. Wrobel Others: C. Garnett, student; L. Garnett, guest; D. Anderson, The Aegis I. CALL TO ORDER D. Golladay called the meeting to order. In accordance with Board of Trustees By-laws, the annual election of officers takes place at the first meeting following June 1. The Secretary-Treasurer presides. The following is noted for the record: The business of the Harford Community College Board of Trustees, as empowered by Maryland law, is to oversee all personnel, programs and facilities. The Board employs its president to implement and to interpret its policies. The Board directs the president to establish guidelines, procedures, and practices that flow from and support the policies of the Board of Trustees as contained in the Board Manual for By-laws and Policies. The Board meets the second Tuesday each month (except July) to consider and transact public business. At Board of Trustees meeting on May12 motion was made, seconded and approved to move into closed session to discuss personnel matters in accordance with Article 10-508 (a)(1)(i) and (ii) of the State Government article of the Annotated Code of Maryland, closed sessions permitted. II. ROLL CALL C. Sherman called the roll. Quorum was present. Board of Trustees 06/09/15 III. Page 2 ELECTION OF OFFICERS D. Golladay opened the floor for nominations for the office of Chair. R. Norling nominated James Valdes. J. Haggerty seconded the nomination. No other nominations were made. Motion was made by J. Haggerty to close the nominations; seconded by J. McCauley. Nominations were closed by unanimous vote. The Board agreed to forego written ballot; the vote, by acclamation, elected James Valdes as chair for 2015-2016. J. Valdes opened the floor for nominations for the office of Vice Chair. B. Kelly nominated Richard Norling. C. Hunter seconded the nomination. No other nominations were made. Motion was made by J. Haggerty to close the nominations; seconded by J. McCauley. Nominations were closed by unanimous vote. The Board agreed to forego written ballot; the vote, by acclamation, elected Richard Norling vice chair for 2015-2016. Dr. Valdes and Mr. Norling expressed appreciation for the opportunity to serve as officers of the Board for 2015-2016. IV. CONSENT AGENDA By consensus the Board approved the consent agenda. Items included: Agenda of the 06/09/15 meeting Minutes of the 05/12/15 regular session Review of National Guard Waivers (Continues the current tuition waiver for members of the Maryland National Guard and spouses and dependents of members of the Maryland National Guard when guard member is called to active duty) V. PUBLIC COMMENT No one addressed the Board during public comment. VI. BOARD REPORTS A. Chair’s Report J. Valdes noted upcoming events: July 13 – Foundation Summer Golf Swing August 11 – Board of Trustees meeting – 6 p.m. August 21 – Convocation and related activities o 11:30 a.m. – Picnic o 1:00 p.m. – Convocation (Chesapeake Center Theater) o 2:30 p.m. – Ice Cream Social J. Valdes provided an update on the presidential search. Academic Search, Inc. has been employed to provide executive search services for Harford Community College in the recruitment and appointment of a President. A conference call with Board of Trustees 06/09/15 Page 3 the firm is scheduled for June 17 during which the timeline for the search will be discussed. The chairs of the governance councils (administrator, faculty, staff and student) will be asked to identify a representative and alternate from their respective group to serve on the search committee. The committee will also include two members of the Harford County community and several trustees. The work of the committee will be time intensive. The role of the committee is to screen candidates’ application materials and recommend 10-12 semi-finalists for interviews with the committee, and submit comments and recommendations to the Board chair on candidates interviewed by the committee. The Board of Trustees has ultimate responsibility to select the President. The goal is to have a president selected by the end of the calendar year. B. Finance and Audit Committee Report R. Norling reported that the committee met on June 4 with two auditing firms. The first meeting was with the financial auditors (firm of Clifton Larson Allen). The firm was initially contracted to perform audit services for five years (20102014). Last year the Board extended the contract for an additional year (2015). An RFP for auditing services for future years will be issued in the Fall. The committee also met with McGladrey, the firm conducting the process and control audits. The internal control audit is intended to identify any risk areas so that adjustments can be made to minimize risk exposure. C. Member Reports B. Kelly reported that he attended the Harford Leadership Academy (HLA) graduation. He commented on the Academy which is a community development program. It is designed to promote the development of existing and emerging leaders and to create a committed, involved, and diverse network of leaders in Harford County. Participants are given opportunities to learn from today's leaders. C. Hunter reported that he attended the nurse pinning ceremony and the Harford County Electrical Contractors Association graduation. VII. PRESIDENT’S REPORT A. Information Items The Board information packet included a report on the President’s meetings and activities over the last month. Dr. Golladay noted specifically: Professor Scott West, a member of Harford’s English faculty, has been selected to attend a National Endowment for the Humanities Summer Institute for Advanced Topics in the Digital Humanities. He was chosen from a national applicant pool to attend one of only five Advanced Topics in the Digital Humanities Summer Institutes and the only one designed specifically for community college faculty. The Accreditation Commission for Education in Nursing Evaluation Review Panel met on Thursday, June 4, to review the College’s nursing program and Board of Trustees 06/09/15 B. Page 4 voted unanimously to support the recommendation by the site visitors to continue full accreditation. Copy of the President’s Annual Report to the Community was distributed. Recognition and Presentation of Certificates to Students Nominated to the 2015 All-USA Community College Academic Team Harford Community College students Caitlin Bechtel and Casey Garnett were nominated for the 2015 All-USA Community College Academic Team in recognition of scholarly achievements and leadership accomplishments. Both were recognized recently at the 21st All-Maryland Academic Team celebration. Caitlin and Casey were invited to the Board meeting to be presented certificates of recognition for their nomination. Caitlin was unable to attend as she is out of town. Casey was congratulated on her achievement and presented a certificate of recognition. C. Introduction of New Employees New employees Mark Bandy, manager for web and social media; Tammy Dennis, financial aid associate; Dawn Grissom, project director – TAACCCT Grant (Trade Adjustment Assistance Community College Career Trade Grant); and Eric Jackson, student leadership and orientation specialist; were introduced to the Board. D. Enrollment Report Enrollment reports for Summer and Fall were reviewed. The summer report is the official report that is submitted to the State. Summer 2015 enrollment is -0.4% compared to Summer 2014. As of June 9, Fall 2015 enrollment is down 1% from Fall 2014. It is too soon to predict where final enrollment will be. The drop for nonpayment will occur within a few days which will affect the current fall numbers. E. Capital Projects Update R. Johnson gave the monthly capital projects update. Hickory Center project is progressing. It is on time and under budget. Grandstands at the Harford Sports Complex have been installed. The facility is used almost daily March through November and the grandstands are a good addition to the complex. Board of Trustees 06/09/15 VIII. Page 5 ACTION ITEMS A. FY 2016 Operating Budget Over the last ten months the Board has reviewed and discussed the FY 2016 proposed operating budget. The budget presented is a balanced budget without any transfer-in. It remains the same as the budget presented to the Board at the May 12 meeting. Board members noted that the County increased its allocation to the College for FY 2016 by $299,232. Trustees also complimented staff on improvements to the budget process, accessibility of information, and transparency in the process. Motion was made by B. Kelly, seconded by J. McCauley: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College approves the FY 2016 operating budget request totaling $46,634,212. This operating budget includes an increase of county resident tuition rates to $116 per credit hour. Out-of-county tuition will be set at $203 per credit hour, and out-of-state tuition will be set at $290 per credit hour. Vote: Unanimously approved. B. FY 2015 Capital Budget and Capital Improvement Program The capital budget and capital improvement program (CIP) establishes the schedule of planned expenditures and commitments for FY 2016 and the subsequent five fiscal years. The CIP is intended to plan for the College’s needs for additional facility improvements. The CIP is from FY 2016 – FY 2021 and integrates academic and physical planning on a college-wide basis. The CIP establishes an itinerary for accomplishing improvements in existing facilities and proposed new infrastructure investments based on the Facilities Master Plan. Over the last several months, the plan has been presented to and reviewed by the Board. With regard to the regional workforce center, the College is exploring all possible funding alternatives to keep the project moving forward. There is significant community interest in the project. The biggest project for FY 2016 is Edgewood Hall renovation/expansion. Request for bids will be issued and plans are to begin the project after the holidays. Motion was made by R. Norling, seconded by J. Haggerty: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College approves the FY 2016 proposed capital budget and capital improvement program request totaling $12,593,344. Vote: Unanimously approved. Board of Trustees 06/09/15 C. Page 6 Contract Authorization: 1. Fully Hosted Payment Gateway Software Solution The College issued a request for proposal for a fully hosted enterprisewide payment gateway solution. Among the requirements were: Industry-standard encryption for all confidential and sensitive data. Existing real time ability to integrate with Banner (Ellucian) general ledger. Ability to allow students to make real-time online tuition payments through Banner. A student payment plan for students who choose to make deferred interest free payments over the course of the semester. Six proposals were received and after evaluation by the committee, three were deemed unacceptable and eliminated from further consideration. Oral presentations and proposal review meetings were held by the evaluation committee with the three remaining bidders – Nelnet, Higher One (Cashnet), Core Business Technologies. After oral presentations it was apparent to the committee that both the Higher One and Core Business Technologies products have better integration tools with Banner and were more robust in their functionality. However, the Nelnet student payment plans work well, their model for administering the payment plans represents the best value, and to change the payment plans would not be desirable unless there was a good reason. It was decided to request revised proposals for a hybrid model. The College requested pricing for payment plans only from Nelnet, and pricing for all other software solutions from all three vendors. The committee recommends a hybrid model as the best value to the College, with student payment plans remaining with Nelnet, and the remaining payment software being purchased from Higher One (Cashnet). The president supports the committee’s recommendation. Motion was made by B. Kelly, seconded by J. Stinchcomb: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College approves the award of two contracts for payment gateway software solutions. One contract is to be awarded to Nelnet Business Solutions of Lincoln, Nebraska, for the administering of student payment plans only. The student payment plan participation fee will be $35 per plan with Nelnet refunding $10 per payment plan to the College. Based on approximately 1,600 payment plans per year, this amounts to a rebate of $16,000 in the first year, and $80,000 over five years. Board of Trustees 06/09/15 Page 7 The other contract is to be awarded to Higher One Inc. of New Haven, Connecticut, utilizing their ePayment, eMarket and Cashiering software solution. The cost in the first year will be $79,605, and over five years the cost will be $278,116.20. The net cost to the College utilizing the hybrid approach will be $63,605 in the first year and $198,116.20 over five years. Vote: Unanimously approved. 2. Software Revitalization – Ellucian The College uses Ellucian (formerly SCT/Banner Sungard) software systems to support the financial, payroll, human resources, student, financial aid, document management, and development systems. The Ellucian software also includes the Luminis software used for the OwlNet web portal and last year the College purchased the additional module Degree Works. Ellucian offers a revitalization service to improve the usage and understanding of the College’s Banner Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system. This service will help College staff to better understand how to use HCC’s Banner data to support and enhance the College and the way the College does business. This includes Banner functionality, data and reporting, and present and future enhancements. Ellucian will provide business process modeling (BPM), a detailed assessment of the functional use of Banner ERP, and applied process-based training. Banner ERP is a very large software system and through employee turnover, lack of documentation and on-going training, the College does not currently have enough expertise in certain areas. Ellucian has the personnel capable of helping to refocus the College’s use and understanding of HCC’s Banner ERP. Banner revitalization will be on an ongoing process and is expected to be a two to three year engagement. Revitalization is targeted to the following six areas: Admissions, Records & Registration, Financial Aid, Human Resources & Payroll, Advancement, and Finance & Accounts Receivable. The total cost from Ellucian (Banner) is $179,160 which will be evenly distributed over the six functional areas over the two to three year engagement at $29,860 per area. Motion was made by C. Hunter, seconded by J. McCauley: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College accepts the contract with Ellucian (Banner) for business process revitalization Board of Trustees 06/09/15 Page 8 services as described above. The services will be provided for six functional areas over the next two to three years. The cost will be $29,860 per functional area, for a total cost of $179,160 over the next two to three years. The College has the option to exit the contract after the completion of any area engagement without a penalty. Vote: Unanimously approved. 3. Furniture for Hickory Center The Hickory Center, currently under construction, will house office space for computer and technology services, procurement, Bravo, copy center and a storage space for surplus equipment. New furniture for these spaces includes workstations, chairs, and shelving which is required when construction is completed this summer. Three vendors provided quotes for the furniture. All used existing competitive contracts to price the required furniture. The furniture and layouts were reviewed with technology services, copy center, and facilities (for Bravo). The low bidder, Contemporary Business Interiors of Belcamp, Maryland, is recommended. Motion was made by J. Haggerty, seconded by J. Stinchcomb: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College authorizes a contract with Contemporary Business Interiors of Belcamp, Maryland, in the amount of $93,330.19 for furniture for Hickory Center. Installation will take place upon completion of the building construction. Vote: Unanimously adopted. IX. PERSONNEL A. Personnel Update Staffing changes are reported to the Board as an information item. The Board approves personnel activity related to administrators and tenure-track faculty. Five personnel items reported this month require Board action. Appointments Jessica A. Adams, assistant professor of transitional studies mathematics, effective August 15, 2015 Mark T. Bandy, manager for web and social media, effective June 1, 2015 Evan T. A. Bucklin, assistant professor of physics, effective August 15, 2015 Board of Trustees 06/09/15 Page 9 Patricia A. Burt, assistant professor of music (extended term faculty), effective August 15, 2015 Megan A. Cornett, director for admissions, effective May 30, 2015 Tammy L. Dennis, financial aid associate, effective May 23, 2015 Heidi F. Kunert, administrative assistant IV, effective May 9, 2015 Dr. Stephen R. Seidel, associate professor of chemistry, effective August 15, 2015 Separations Mary F. Austin, director for admissions, effective June 12, 2015 Tiffany L. Morrell, financial aid associate, effective May 12, 2015 Retirements Dr. Deborah L. Greener-Orr, nursing faculty (term faculty), effective May 21, 2015 Judith A. Grimm, associate professor of nursing, effective June 15, 2015 Patricia Hogan, director for community education, effective July 17, 2015 Motion was made by B. Kelly, seconded by J. Stinchcomb: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College approves the appointment of: Jessica A. Adams, assistant professor of transitional studies mathematics, effective August 15, 2015; Evan T. A. Bucklin, assistant professor of physics, effective August 15, 2015; and Dr. Stephen R. Seidel, associate professor of chemistry, effective August 15, 2015. and The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College acknowledges receipt of letter of retirement from: Judith A. Grimm, associate professor of nursing, effective June 15, 2015; and Patricia Hogan, director for community education, effective July 17, 2015 XII. CLOSED SESSION J. Valdes asked for a motion to go into closed session to discuss personnel matters. In accordance with State Government Article of the Annotated Code of Maryland, Article 10 Section 508(a)(1)(i) and (ii), motion was made by B. Kelly, seconded by J. McCauley to go into closed session. Seven voted in favor of the motion; no one opposed the motion; motion adopted. Board of Trustees 06/09/15 Page 10 At 7:00 p.m. the Board moved into closed session. The closed session adjourned at 7:10 p.m. RETURN TO OPEN SESSION In an effort to recognize the excellent service and contributions made by the Harford Community College faculty and staff, better than budgeted financial results will allow for a one-time service recognition payment in 2015. The total payment to all eligible employees is equivalent to a 3% increase and totals approximately $674,000. The service recognition is a one-time payment and will not be added to the employee’s base salary. The FY 2016 Harford Community College operating budget does not include an increase for salaries. Motion was made by B. Kelly, seconded by C. Hunter: The Board of Trustees of Harford Community College approves a one-time 3 percent service recognition payment to all eligible employees payable within the FY 2015 fiscal year. The payments are one-time only. Vote: Unanimously adopted. X. ADJOURNMENT The Board meeting adjourned at 7:20 p.m. ____________________________________ Dennis Golladay Secretary-Treasurer ____________________________________ James J. Valdes Chair