Safe Schools Procedures Manual 503-A (Student Discipline, Bullying Prevention and Intervention, Suspension and Expulsion) Category: Administered by: First adopted: Revision history: Next review: 1. Students Safe and Inclusive Schools Superintendent June 2010 June 2013 June 2018 General These procedures guide the discipline of students for inappropriate behavior, including bullying. They are based on a Progressive Discipline model, setting out the process for suspension and expulsion where necessary, appeals of suspensions and expulsions, and the establishment of a program for students on long term suspension and expulsion. 2. Terms and Definitions For the purposes of these procedures, the following definitions apply. Administrator An administrator includes a Superintendent, Principal or Vice-Principal with responsibility for the school in question. Adult student An adult student is a student who is eighteen (18) years old, or is sixteen (16) or seventeen (17) years old and is removed from parental control. Board employees who work with students Board employees who work with students include administrators, teachers, educational assistants, child and youth workers, social workers, psychologists, speech language pathologists and other professional and paraprofessional staff who have regular and direct contact with the Board’s students. June 2013 Page 1 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A Bullying As defined in section 1 of the Education Act, “bullying” means aggressive and typically repeated behaviour by a pupil where, (a) the behaviour is intended by the pupil to have the effect of, or the pupil ought to know that the behaviour would be likely to have the effect of, (i) causing harm, fear or distress to another individual, including physical, psychological, social or academic harm, harm to the individual’s reputation or harm to the individual’s property, or (ii) creating a negative environment at a school for another individual, and (b) the behaviour occurs in a context where there is a real or perceived power imbalance between the pupil and the individual based on factors such as size, strength, age, intelligence, peer group power, economic status, social status, religion, ethnic origin, sexual orientation, family circumstances, gender, gender identity, gender expression, race, disability or the receipt of special education; Bullying takes on different forms and contexts with age. It can be physical, verbal, social-emotional or through electronic means (cyberbullying). Bystanders contribute to bullying by doing nothing to prevent it or by becoming actively involved in supporting it. Cyberbullying As defined in section 1 of the Education Act, cyberbullying is bullying by electronic means, including, (a) creating electronic communications (e.g. a web page or a blog) in which the creator assumes the identity of another person; (b) impersonating another person as the author of content or messages posted on the internet; and (c) communicating material electronically to one or more individuals or posting material on a website that may be accessed by one or more individuals. June 2013 Page 2 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A Disproportionate impact Disproportionate impact is created when discipline impacts a student to a greater degree in comparison to his or her peers as a result of factors related to grounds protected by the Human Rights Code. Emergency administrator An Emergency Administrator is a Superintendent or Principal identified by the Principal of the school as the emergency contact should the administrator of the school not be available in emergency situations. Harassment Harassment is engaging in a course of vexatious conduct that is known or ought to reasonably be known to be unwelcome. Harassment is words, conduct or action that is directed at an individual and serves no legitimate purpose. This may include remarks, jokes, threats, name-calling, the display of material(s), touching or other behaviour that an individual knows or ought to know insults, intimidates, offends, demeans, annoys, alarms or causes that individual emotional distress, and may constitute discrimination when related to grounds protected by the Human Rights Code. Immutable characteristics Immutable characteristics are characteristics that an individual cannot change or that an individual cannot alter about themselves (such as height). Immediate risk Immediate risk occurs when an individual (a Board employee or other staff, students, or members of the community) might be impacted as a result of the behaviour being exhibited, or because the Board employee who works with students cannot leave another student(s) unattended in order to respond. Official date of receipt of notice Where notice is given to a person under this policy (see Section 13.5), it will be considered to have been received by the person in accordance with the following rules: June 2013 • if the notice is sent by mail or another method in which an original document is sent, the notice will be considered to have been received by the person to whom it was sent on the fifth school day after the day on which it was sent • if the notice is sent by fax or another method of electronic transmission, the notice will be considered to have been received by the person to whom it was sent on the first school day after the day on which it was sent. Page 3 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A Primacy of the code In a circumstance in which there is a conflict between Provincial law, such as the Education Act and Regulations, Policy Program Memoranda; school board policies and procedures, and the Human Rights Code of Ontario, the Human Rights Code is deemed to be more important. The inferior law must be applied in a manner consistent with the Human Rights Code (unless there is an explicit exception contained within the other law for such a circumstance). The principle of primacy of the Human Rights Code also requires school board policies and procedures to be interpreted and applied in a manner consistent with the Human Rights Code. Progressive discipline Progressive Discipline is a whole school approach that makes use of a continuum of proactive measures, interventions, supports and consequences to promote positive behaviours. In developing a Progressive Discipline approach, preventative practices, corrective and supportive strategies are used to reinforce positive behaviours. School climate A positive school climate is the sum of all the personal relationships within a school and exists when all members of the school community feel safe, comfortable and accepted. Teacher-in-charge A teacher-in-charge is a teacher delegated authority by the Principal to undertake specified duties with respect to student discipline in the absence of administration. Threat A threat is any statement, act or communication, by any means, including electronic means, of an intent to cause harm, whether physical or emotional, to any person or thing, in circumstances where the person threatened believes or has grounds to believe the threat may be carried out. Vandalism Vandalism is defined as willful damage to property. Weapon A weapon is defined as any article designed as a weapon or used or intended to be used for the purpose of threatening, intimidating or injuring a person. All firearms, including replica firearms and imitation firearms are always considered weapons. June 2013 Page 4 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 3. Positive School Climate 3.1 3.2 4. A positive school climate is: • inclusive and accepting of all students • based on multiple strategies that have a unifying purpose and reflect a common set of values • essential to student achievement and well-being • a whole school approach to positive, healthy behavior, and monitored and evaluated for effectiveness Characteristics of a positive school climate: • students and staff feel safe and are safe • healthy and inclusive relationships are promoted • all partners are actively engaged • students are encouraged to be positive leaders in their school community • bullying prevention and awareness-raising strategies are reinforced through programs addressing discrimination based on such factors as age, race, sexual orientation, gender, faith, disability and socio-economic disadvantage • improvement of learning outcomes for all students is emphasized • provides professional development for staff • supports students who have been bullied, engage in bullying and witness bullying Bullying Prevention and Intervention 4.1 4.2 June 2013 Bullying is a serious issue that has far-reaching consequences. Bullying adversely affects: • students’ ability to learn • healthy relationships • school climate • a school’s ability to educate its students Bullying will not be accepted on school property, at school-related activities, on school buses or in any other circumstance (e.g. Page 5 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A cyberbullying) where engaging in bullying will have a negative impact on the school climate. 4.3 The Board will ensure that bullying prevention and positive school climate initiatives are reflected in its multi-year strategic plans, including the Board Improvement Plan for Student Achievement (BIPSA) and its Operational Plans. 4.4 The Board will post the Provincial Model Bullying and Prevention Plan on its website. 4.5 The Board’s Safe, Equitable and Inclusive School Steering Committee will receive feedback from community groups on the Board’s policies related to Safe Schools (#503) and Equity and Inclusive Education (#504) and be advised of any changes to these policies as a result of Ministry initiatives. 4.6 Schools will establish a Safe and Inclusive Schools Committee that will be chaired by a staff member. An existing school committee can assume this role. 4.7 Safe and Inclusive Schools Committees will be composed of: • at least one school administrator • one parent • one teacher • one student, where appropriate • one support staff member • one community partner 4.8 Schools will develop Bullying Prevention and Intervention Plans in consultation with their Safe and Inclusive Schools Committee and post their plan to their school’s website. 4.9 Schools will analyze the school climate through anonymous surveys of students, staff members and parents at least every two years. 4.10 Schools will update their Bullying Prevention and Intervention Plans based on the climate surveys. 4.11 The School Bullying Prevention Plan will be reviewed annually, and will include: • June 2013 the definition of bullying as outlined in this policy Page 6 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A • bullying prevention and intervention education programs and activities throughout all grades that focus on developing healthy relationships and provide leadership opportunities for students within the school • prevention and intervention strategies for staff and students to deal with bullying • strategies for supporting and educating students who have been bullied, students who have bullied others, and students who have been affected by observing and/or encouraging bullying (bystanders) • procedures for students, parents, school staff, and school volunteers to report incidents of bullying • procedures to address the issue of protection from retaliation for those who report incidents of bullying • steps the school will take in response to all incidents of bullying through a Progressive Discipline approach o strategies could range from early intervention to more intensive intervention in cases of persistent bullying, with possible referral to community or social service agencies o ongoing interventions may be necessary to sustain and promote positive student behaviour 4.12 June 2013 • the responsibility and roles of teachers, parents and students towards bullying, prevention and intervention • training strategies for members of the school community, and communication and outreach strategies that will inform students, staff, and parents throughout the school year about the Board’s Safe Schools Policy #503, and the consequences for bullying Communication and outreach information may be outlined in the school/student handbook and through other means such as: • the school’s Code of Conduct • school newsletters, handbooks and other in-house publications • assemblies and announcements • bulletin board postings • school council meetings and publications • staff meetings Page 7 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 5. • integration into classroom instruction • the school website • school activities Exclusion The Education Act section 265(1)(m) permits a Principal to refuse to admit to the school or a class someone whose presence in the school or classroom would, in the Principal’s judgment, be detrimental to the physical or mental well being of others. 5.1 The Board does not support the use of exclusion as a disciplinary measure. 5.2 Exclusion should be a temporary measure for the purpose of putting in place a plan to promote the student’s inclusion while supporting the safety of others. 5.3 The Principal considering exclusion will consult with the Superintendent responsible for the school, the Safe and Inclusive Schools Superintendent and where appropriate, the Superintendent responsible for Special Education. 5.4 When a Principal decides that it is necessary to exclude a student from school, the student’s parent or guardian or adult student will be informed as soon as possible of the exclusion and the right to appeal under section 265(1)(m) of the Education Act. 5.5 The parent or guardian or adult student will also be informed of the exclusion and the right to appeal in writing. 5.6 The Principal will inform the student’s teachers of the exclusion, and school work will be prepared and provided to the student for the duration of the exclusion. 5.7 If the parent or guardian or the adult student decides to appeal the exclusion, the parent or guardian or adult student will contact the Superintendent of the school. 5.8 The parent or guardian or adult student has the right to appeal to the Board of Trustees. 5.9 The appeal process will follow the procedures for the suspension appeal to the Board’s Student Discipline Committee (see section 13.8 of this procedures manual). June 2013 Page 8 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 6. Progressive Discipline Use of Progressive Discipline supports a safe, inclusive and accepting learning and teaching environment in which every student can reach his or her full potential. 6.1 All inappropriate student behavior, including bullying, must be addressed. 6.2 Responses to behaviours that are contrary to the Board and the school’s Codes of Conduct must be developmentally appropriate 6.3 The range of Progressive Discipline interventions, supports, and consequences used by the Board and all schools must be clear and developmentally appropriate, and must include learning opportunities for students in order to reinforce positive behaviours and help them make good choices. 6.4 For students with special education needs all interventions, supports and consequences must be consistent with the expectations in the student’s Individual Education Plan (IEP) and his/her demonstrated abilities. 6.5 It is the expectation of the Board that, all staff who work directly with students on a regular basis, will respond to any such inappropriate and disrespectful behaviour in accordance with Board procedures. This includes any behaviour that causes a negative school climate or for which a suspension or expulsion may be imposed. Staff will report behaviours which they have observed or heard during the course of their duties or otherwise while on school property or during a school-related event. 6.6 The Board and school administrators must consider all mitigating and other factors, as required by the Education Act, set out in Ontario Regulation 472/07 and reflected in student discipline settlements with the Human Rights Commission. 6.7 In order to promote and support appropriate and positive student behaviours, the Board supports the use of positive practices for prevention and positive behaviour management. 6.8 The Board also encourages Principals/designates to review and amend, as appropriate, IEPs, Behaviour Management Plans and Safety Plans at regular intervals and following an incident, to ensure that every student with special education needs is receiving appropriate accommodation up to the point of undue hardship. 6.9 The Board recognizes that, in some circumstances, positive practices might not be effective or sufficient to address inappropriate student June 2013 Page 9 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A behaviour. In such circumstances, the Board supports the use of consequences. 6.10 In circumstances where a student will receive a consequence for his/her behaviour, it is the expectation of the Board that the principle of Progressive Discipline, consistent with the Human Rights Code, Ministry of Education direction and PPM 145, will be applied, as appropriate. 6.11 Responsibilities of the Board June 2013 6.11.1 The Board will incorporate goals relating to Progressive Discipline in its multi-year plans. 6.11.2 The Board will provide information and support for schools to develop Progressive Discipline policies and procedures that include a range of strategies, interventions and supports with appropriate application of consequences, including suspensions and expulsions as warranted. 6.11.3 The Board will provide supports for students and awareness training for parents and community users and provide opportunities for staff professional development. 6.11.4 The Board will develop communication and information sharing strategies to help students, parents, staff, and others in the school community understand and support the Board’s and schools’ Progressive Discipline policies and procedures. 6.11.5 The Board will consult with school councils, Principals and other staff, students, parents, community partners, social service agencies, members of Aboriginal and faith communities, and other stakeholders, as appropriate through the Board’s Safe, Equitable and Inclusive Schools Steering Committee. 6.11.6 The Board will enhance and develop partnerships and protocols, as appropriate and possible, with community agencies, organizations and other members of the community including Police Services and Public Health, to facilitate the delivery of services, including prevention and intervention programs and referrals in support of students and their families. 6.11.7 The Board will develop training strategies and opportunities for administrators, teachers, school support and other staff on Progressive Discipline and this policy. Page 10 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 6.11.8 6.12 June 2013 The Board will establish performance indicators for monitoring, reviewing and evaluating the effectiveness of this policy and Progressive Discipline procedures (e.g. school climate surveys and analysis). Responsibilities of the school 6.12.1 The school will develop and implement a school-wide Progressive Discipline policy that includes a range of procedures that are consistent and in alignment with this policy, and the Board’s Code of Conduct and outlines circumstances where short-term suspensions, long-term suspensions or expulsions may be the response required. 6.12.2 The school will provide opportunities for students to improve the school climate by assuming leadership roles through such activities as peer mediation, mentorship, and other programs. 6.12.3 The school will support the establishment of student-led activities and organizations that promote a safe and equitable learning environment acceptance and respect for others, and a positive school climate, including those that promote gender equity, antiracism, the awareness and understanding of and respect for, people with disabilities, and those of all sexual orientations and gender equity, including those with the name “gay-straight alliance” or another similar name. 6.12.4 The school will provide opportunities for staff professional development, awareness training for parents and supported programs for bullies, the bullied and bystanders. 6.12.5 The school will ensure that the response for students with special education needs is consistent with the expectations in the student’s IEP; consider all factors including the particular student and the circumstances, the nature and severity of the behaviour, and the impact on the school climate when responding to inappropriate behaviour; encourage teachers, support staff and others, including school councils and volunteers to support and implement the school’s Progressive Discipline policy, and to be involved, as appropriate, in its development and ongoing review. 6.12.6 The school will build on existing partnerships and, where appropriate and possible, build new partnerships with community Page 11 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A agencies, including local Police Services, to support students and their families. 6.12.7 6.13 6.14 The school will involve and engage parents in the Progressive Discipline approach and ongoing dialogue on student achievement and behavior. Consequences 6.13.1 The Education Act, the Provincial Code of Conduct, the Upper Grand District School Board’s Code of Conduct and individual schools’ Codes of Conduct include expectations for all persons on school property. 6.13.2 Appropriate and consistent action must be taken to address inappropriate behaviours within the practice of Progressive Discipline. 6.13.3 Progressive Discipline creates the expectation that the degree of disciplinary action is in proportion to the severity of the behaviour exhibited, and that a student’s previous discipline history and other relevant factors will be taken into account. 6.13.4 It is understood that short-term and long-term suspensions and expulsions are consequences within Progressive Discipline, and in some circumstances, may be an appropriate first consequence. In the case of a serious incident, there may be required consequences for inappropriate behaviours. 6.13.5 The Board interprets the provisions of the Education Act and Regulations in a broad and liberal manner consistent with the Human Rights Code. The Principal or designate will consider whether or not the discipline will have a disproportionate impact on a student protected by the Human Rights Code and/or exacerbate the student’s disadvantaged position in society. Mitigating factors The mitigating factors to be considered by the Principal are: June 2013 • whether the student has the ability to control his or her behaviour • whether the student has the ability to understand the foreseeable consequences of his or her behaviour Page 12 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A • 6.15 whether the student’s continuing presence in the school does or does not create an unacceptable risk to the safety of any other individual at the school Other factors to be considered Other factors to be considered include: • the student’s academic, discipline and personal history • whether other Progressive Discipline has been attempted with the student, and if so, the Progressive Discipline approach(es) that has/have been attempted and any success or failure • whether the infraction for which the student might be disciplined was related to any harassment of the student because of race, colour, ethnic origin, place of origin, religion, creed, disability, gender or gender identity, sexual orientation or harassment for any other reason • the impact of the discipline on the student’s prospects for further education • the student’s age Where the student has an IEP or special education needs: 6.16 • whether the behaviour causing the incident was a manifestation of the student’s disability identified in the student’s IEP • whether appropriate individualized accommodation has been provided • whether a suspension is likely to result in aggravating or worsening the student’s behaviour or conduct • whether a suspension is likely to result in a greater likelihood of further inappropriate conduct • whether or not the student’s continuing presence at the school creates an unacceptable risk to the safety of anyone in the school Record The Principal or Vice-Principal should keep a record for each student with whom Progressive Discipline approach(es) are utilized. The record should include: • June 2013 the name of the student Page 13 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 7. 8. • the date of the incident or behaviour • the nature of the incident or behaviour • the considerations taken into account • the Progressive Discipline approach used • the outcome • the contact with the student’s parent/guardian (unless the student is an adult student) Monitoring and Review 7.1 Safe and Inclusive Schools Teams will monitor and review effectiveness of safe schools policies and procedures and recommend improvement, where necessary. 7.2 Every two years each school will conduct voluntary, anonymous school climate surveys of parents, staff and students to evaluate the effectiveness of its safe school policies and procedures including questions about bullying, harassment related to immutable characteristics including those protected by the Human Rights Code, gender-based violence, and sexual assault; and accommodate special needs students to provide an opportunity for response. 7.3 School Improvement Plans will address issues of bullying, gender based violence, homophobia, sexual, racial and special needs related harassment and inappropriate sexual behavior. 7.4 The results of climate surveys will be shared with Safe and Inclusive School Committee in order to assist the committee to build strategies in School Improvement Plans and to improve the school climate deficits identified. Delegation of Authority 8.1 Whenever possible, the Board will attempt to have an administrator present on school property. 8.2 A Principal may delegate authority for discipline matters to a Vice-Principal or teacher-in-charge. 8.3 A delegation of authority to a teacher-in-charge will only come into effect if there are no administrators present on school property. June 2013 Page 14 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 8.4 When a Vice-Principal is delegated the authority of a Principal, that authority does not include the final decision regarding student suspensions exceeding five school days or a recommendation to the Board to expel a student. 8.5 A teacher-in-charge, if delegated authority: • will receive reports about suspension and expulsion infractions and inform the Principal, Vice-Principal, or the Superintendent for the school at the earliest opportunity • will contact the police in an emergency or in the event of an incident requiring police involvement • may conduct an initial investigation of situations involving activities that must be considered for a suspension or expulsion, and report all the details of the initial investigation to the Principal • may consider and implement Progressive Discipline measures following the investigation of an incident that does not warrant an investigation for consideration of a suspension or a recommendation for expulsion • may contact the parents of a student who has been harmed as the result of a serious incident and the parents of the student who participated in the incident as long as it is limited to the nature of the harm to the student and the nature of the activity that resulted in the harm • may provide information to the parent/guardian of a victim, who is not an adult student, where the teacher-in-charge is not of the opinion that informing the parent/guardian would put the student at risk of harm • may inform the parent/guardian that an administrator will provide them with further information about the activity causing harm and the steps that will be taken to support the victim and ensure the victim’s safety • may inform a parent/guardian of an adult student if that student consents to the disclosure of information 8.6 A teacher-in-charge will not be delegated authority to share with the parent/guardian of a victim the name of the suspected perpetrators and/or the discipline measures that might be taken by the school to address the infraction, and suspend a student. 8.7 If a teacher-in-charge is uncertain or uncomfortable about the duties that have been delegated and/or the possible application of the Human Rights June 2013 Page 15 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A Code, an administrator or the Superintendent for the school should be contacted immediately. 8.8 9. Delegation of authority must be provided in writing and include a time frame and resources available. All members of the school must be notified of the delegate’s name and the time frame for the designation. Responding to Incidents of Inappropriate Behaviour 9.1 Provided that there is no immediate risk of physical harm to any individual, responses to inappropriate behaviour will be made in a timely, supportive and sensitive manner and in an effort to stop and correct the behaviour. 9.2 Responses must be developmentally appropriate and take into consideration any special education needs that the student might exhibit, or about which the employee might be aware. Responses may include one or more of the following: • ask the student to stop the behaviour • identify the behaviour as inappropriate and disrespectful • explain the impact of the behaviour on others and the school climate • model appropriate communication • ask the student for a correction of the behaviour by restating or rephrasing the comments • ask the student to apologize for the behaviour • ask the student not to repeat the behaviour • ask the student to explain why and how a different choice with respect to the behaviour would have been more appropriate and respectful • where applicable, identify the application of the Human Rights Code 9.3 A response by the staff to the incident will not prevent or preclude the Principal or Vice-Principal from imposing appropriate Progressive Discipline, up to and including a recommendation for expulsion from all schools. 9.4 Where, in the opinion of the Board employees who work with students, the behaviour observed or heard might lead to suspension or suspension and a recommendation for expulsion, the employee must report the behaviour June 2013 Page 16 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A verbally to the Principal or designate at the earliest opportunity and again in writing before the end of the school day. 10. 9.5 The employee will follow the procedures outlined for reporting incidents when reporting in writing. 9.6 For all other behaviour, the employee will report the behaviour to the Principal/Vice-Principal/teacher-in-charge at the earliest convenient opportunity. 9.7 The Principal/Vice-Principal will consider whether or not further discipline is appropriate in the circumstances. 9.8 Parents and guardians may contact the Superintendent for the school if they are not satisfied with the school’s response to an incident. Suspension and Expulsion Infractions 10.1 June 2013 The infractions for which a suspension may be imposed by the Principal include: • uttering a threat to inflict serious bodily harm on another person • possessing alcohol or illegal drugs • being under the influence of alcohol • swearing at a teacher or at another person in a position of authority • committing an act of vandalism that causes extensive damage to school property at the student’s school or to property located on the premises of the student’s school • bullying (including cyber bullying) • any act considered by the Principal to be injurious to the moral tone of the school • any act considered by the Principal to be injurious to the physical or mental well-being of members of the school community • persistent opposition to authority • habitual neglect of duty • a serious breach of the Board’s or school’s Code of Conduct Page 17 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 10.2 June 2013 The infractions for which a Principal may consider recommending to the Board that a student be expelled from the student’s school or from all schools of the Board include: • possessing a weapon, including possessing a firearm • using a weapon to cause or to threaten bodily harm to another person • committing physical assault on another person that causes bodily harm requiring treatment by a medical practitioner • committing sexual assault • trafficking in weapons or illegal drugs • committing robbery • giving alcohol to a minor • bullying, if the student has previously been suspended for bullying and the students’ continuing presence in the school creates an unacceptable risk to the safety of another person • an activity that is motivated by bias, prejudice or hate based on race, colour, national or ethnic origin, language, religion, sex, age, mental or physical disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, or another similar factor • an act considered by the Principal to be significantly injurious to the moral tone of the school and/or to the physical or mental wellbeing of others • a pattern of behaviour that is so inappropriate that the student's continued presence is injurious to the effective learning and/or working environment of others • activities engaged in by the student on or off school property that cause the student's continuing presence in the school to create an unacceptable risk to the physical or mental well-being of other person(s) in the school or Board • activities engaged in by the student on or off school property that have caused extensive damage to the property of the Board or to goods that are/were on Board property • the student has demonstrated through a pattern of behaviour that s/he has not prospered by the instruction available to him or her and that s/he is persistently resistant to making changes in behaviour which would enable her/him to prosper Page 18 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 11. • any act considered by the Principal to be a serious violation of the requirements for student behaviour and/or a serious breach of the Board or school Code of Conduct • where a student has no history of discipline or behaviour intervention, or no relevant history, a single act, incident or infraction considered by the Principal to be a serious violation of the expectations of student behaviour and/or a serious breach of the Board or school Code of Conduct Reporting Suspension and Expulsion Infractions to the Principal 11.1 The purpose of reporting incidents is to ensure that the Principal/VicePrincipal is aware of the behaviour. 11.2 When a Board staff member or transportation provider (the reporter) becomes aware of any infractions for which a suspension may be imposed by the Principal or any infractions for which a Principal may consider recommending to the Board that a student be expelled, she or he must report the infraction and any details to the Principal, Vice-Principal or teacher-in-charge at the earliest, safe opportunity and no later than the end of the school day, or end of a transportation run if reported by a transportation provider. 11.3 Where two (2) or more Board staff and/or transportation providers become aware of the same incident, each will make a report to the Principal, VicePrincipal or teacher-in-charge. 11.4 Wherever possible, it is expected that the reporter will provide a verbal report to the Principal, Vice-Principal or teacher-in-charge at the earliest, safe opportunity. 11.5 In addition to 11.4 above, a written electronic report using the online Safe Schools Incident Report form must be submitted, when it is safe to do so and no later than the end of the school day or the end of the transportation run. 11.5.1 June 2013 The Principal or Vice-Principal will receive email notification that an incident report has been filed. After logging into the Safe Schools Incident Report system and viewing the report, the Principal or Vice-Principal will indicate whether or not action was or will be taken, saving this information to the incident report’s database record. Upon save, the reporter will receive an automatic email notification indicating whether or not action was taken. No information identifying students will be included in the notification. Page 19 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 11.6 11.7 11.5.2 If the Principal or Vice-Principal indicates that no action has been taken in regards to the incident report, the reporter will delete the email notification described in 11.5.1. 11.5.3 The Principal or Vice-Principal will maintain a record of the incident report for a minimum of one year, electronically or printed. After that time, it will be deleted or destroyed unless the matter has become the subject of a court proceeding. 11.5.4 If the Principal or Vice-Principal indicates that action has been taken, the reporter may opt to delete the email notification from the Safe Schools Incident Reporting tool. If he or she chooses to retain it in electronic or print form, it must be retained in a secure location for a minimum of one year. In circumstances where disciplinary action is taken by the Principal or Vice-Principal, a printed copy of the incident report will be filed in that student’s Ontario Student Record (OSR). 11.6.1 The Principal or Vice-Principal will ensure that all information contained in the incident report that could identify other students has been redacted (removed or blacked-out) before it is filed in the OSR of the student who has been disciplined. When action is taken against more than one student, a printed copy of the incident report will be filed in each student’s OSR, as above. 11.6.2 The printed incident report will be retained for a minimum of one year. Where the victim has also demonstrated inappropriate behaviour resulting in Progressive Discipline short of suspension, the printed incident report should only be filed in the victim’s OSR if the parents of the victim have been informed. 11.7.1 11.8 Where the victim has not demonstrated any inappropriate behaviour the printed incident report will only be filed in the victim’s OSR with the consent of the victim’s parent or guardian. If the victim is an adult student, the victim’s consent is required before an incident report is filed in his/her OSR. 11.8.1 June 2013 Where the parents have not been informed a copy of the incident report will not be filed in the victim’s OSR. If an incident report has been filed in the victim’s OSR, it should be retained for a minimum of one year. Page 20 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 11.9 In circumstances where an incident report is destroyed or deleted, it must be destroyed in accordance with the Board’s Records Management Manual. 11.10 In circumstances where an incident report is retained but not filed in a student’s OSR or the Safe Schools Incident Reporting system, it must be stored in a secure location, and measures must be taken to ensure access is limited and that all personal information is protected. 11.11 If the Principal has identified the incident as violent, and if the student engaged in the incident is a student of the school, the incident report must be retained in that student’s OSR for: • one year, if the student’s suspension was quashed or withdrawn and the record of suspension expunged (documentation of any other action taken, other than suspension or expulsion, must also be retained for this period) • three years, if the student was suspended for the violent incident • five years, if the student was expelled for the violent incident 11.12 Where a proceeding has been undertaken or an application has been made to the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario, the incident report will be retained until such proceeding or application has been finally resolved. 11.13 Each year the Principal will review with all staff their duty to report as outlined above. This review will include instructions regarding the use of the Safe Schools Incident Reporting system. 12. Notification 12.1 June 2013 Notifying the Parent/Guardian 12.1.1 Incidents for which a suspension, or a recommendation for expulsion are being considered, the Principal or Vice-Principal will provide information to the parent/guardian of the victim, unless in the opinion of the Principal or Vice-Principal this would put the victim at risk of harm, and would not be in the victim’s best interest. 12.1.2 Where the victim is an adult student, the Principal or VicePrincipal will inform the parent/guardian only with the victim’s consent. 12.1.3 When notifying the parent/guardian of a victim of an incident, the Principal or Vice-Principal will: Page 21 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A • identify the nature of the harm to the student • provide information on the steps being taken by the school to protect the student’s safety, including the nature of any discipline in response to the incident • provide information about the supports that will be provided for the student in response to the harm that resulted from the activity Where the victim has been harassed, bullied or suffered violence because of one or more immutable characteristics, or has been sexually assaulted, the Principal or Vice-Principal will share contact information about community contacts/professional supports available to the parent/guardian/student. 12.1.5 A written list will be made available to the victim and/or the victim’s parent/guardian. 12.1.6 Supports will also be posted on the Board’s website. 12.1.7 The Principal or Vice-Principal may inform the victim’s parent/guardian: • whether or not formal discipline was imposed on the student(s) disciplined, excluding any personal information • specific disciplinary measures that might have been imposed • if the student(s) disciplined will no longer be attending the same school as the victim If the parent/guardian is not satisfied with the measures being taken to protect and support the victim, the parent/guardian may contact the Superintendent for the school to request a review of the measures being taken by the school. Not notifying a Parent/Guardian 12.2.1 June 2013 identify the nature of the incident 12.1.4 12.1.8 12.2 • Where, in the opinion of the Principal, Vice-Principal or teacherin-charge, providing information to the victim’s parent/guardian would put the victim at risk of harm, or where the victim is an adult student and does not consent to his/her parent/guardian Page 22 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A being informed, the Principal/Vice-Principal/teacher-in-charge will not inform the victim’s parent/guardian. 12.2.2 12.3 • consider, as a result of the victim’s disclosure, whether or not the victim is a child in need of protection and, if so, make a report to the Family and Children’s Services of Guelph and Wellington County (FCSGW) or Dufferin Child and Family Services (DCAFS), and if in doubt, make a no-names call to inquire about the appropriateness of making a report • document in Maplewood why the parent/guardian was not notified • inform the Superintendent for the school that the parent/guardian was not informed and why; inform the employee who reported the potential of harm that the parent/guardian was not informed and why • inform other staff working to support the student, as appropriate • inform the victim of the steps being taken by the school to protect the victim’s safety, supports available Notifying the Parent/Guardian of the student who has participated in a serious incident 12.3.1 June 2013 The Principal or Vice-Principal will: The Principal or Vice-Principal will: • disclose the nature of the activity that resulted in harm to the other student • disclose the nature of the harm to the other student • disclose the nature of any disciplinary measures taken in response to the activity • indicate the supports that will be provided for the student in his/her participation in the activity • invite the parents/guardians to have a discussion about the supports that will be provided for their child Page 23 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 12.4 Not notifying a Parent/Guardian 12.4.1 12.4.2 13. Where, in the opinion of the Principal or Vice-Principal providing information to the parent would put the student at risk of harm from the parent or guardian the Principal/Vice-Principal will: • document the rationale for the decision • notify the teacher who reported the incident • notify the Superintendent for the school of the decision • notify other Board employees of the decision, if appropriate • refer the student to Board resources or a communitybased service provider than can provide appropriate confidential support to the student when his/her parents are not notified In circumstances where board employees have a reason to believe that a student may be in need of protection CFSGW or DCAFS must be called to report that the child is in need of protection. If in doubt, make a non-names call to inquire about the appropriateness of making the report. Suspension of Students 13.1 The Board supports the use of suspensions where a student has committed one or more of the infractions outlined in section 10.1 of this procedures manual. 13.2 Suspension considerations June 2013 13.2.1 A Principal may not suspend a student for any suspension infractions more than once for the same occurrence 13.2.2 In considering whether to suspend a student, a Principal will take into account the following mitigating factors: • the student does not have the ability to control his or her behaviour • the student does not have the ability to understand the foreseeable consequences of his or her behaviour Page 24 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A • 13.3 June 2013 the student’s continuing presence in the school does not create an unacceptable risk to the safety of any person 13.2.5 If the student does not have the ability to control his or her behaviour, or understand the consequences, the Principal will consider other disciplinary actions. 13.2.6 Where the student’s continuing presence in the school does not create an unacceptable risk to the safety of any person, the Principal may or may not suspend a student based on the severity of the infraction. 13.2.7 Where a student’s presence in the school creates an unacceptable risk, a short-term suspension may be imposed in order to arrange for appropriate accommodations of the student. Length of suspension 13.3.1 A student may be suspended for an infraction for a minimum of one (1) school day and a maximum of twenty (20) school days. 13.3.2 Where the student is able to control his/her behaviour and is able to understand the foreseeable consequences of his/her behaviour, the Principal will consider whether the following factors mitigate the length of a suspension or the decision to apply a suspension as a form of discipline for the student: • the student’s history • whether a Progressive Discipline approach has been used with the student • whether the activity for which the student may be or is being suspended or expelled was related to any harassment of the student because of his or her race, ethnic origin, religion, disability, gender or sexual orientation or to any other harassment • how the suspension or expulsion would affect the student’s ongoing education • the age of the student • in the case of a student for whom an IEP has been developed: Page 25 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A o whether the behaviour was a manifestation of a disability identified in the student’s IEP o whether appropriate individualized accommodation has been provided o whether the suspension or expulsion is likely to result in an aggravation or worsening of the student’s behaviour or conduct 13.4 13.5 June 2013 13.3.3 In consideration of the length of a suspension, the Principal will consult with the Superintendent for the school when considering a suspension for more than five (5) days. 13.3.4 Suspensions of ten (10) days or longer will be reported to the Board by the Superintendent for the school. Programs for suspended students 13.4.1 Homework packages will be made available for the student who is suspended for one (1) day or longer. 13.4.2 A student suspended for more than five (5) days will be referred to a Long-Term Suspension Program. The Principal of the school, in consultation with the student’s teacher will develop a Student Action Plan (SAP) to direct the activities and learning involved in the program. Cooperation with the student and the student’s parents will be sought in developing the SAP. 13.4.3 Participation in the recommended program is not mandatory. 13.4.4 Should a student choose not to participate in a recommended program, homework packages will continue to be available only on request, and following the completion of previously provided assignments. Procedural steps 13.5.1 Within 24 hours of the decision to suspend, the Principal will make all reasonable efforts to inform the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian. 13.5.2 The Principal will inform the student’s teachers of the suspension. 13.5.3 The Principal will prepare a written notice of suspension to include: Page 26 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 13.6 13.7 June 2013 • the reason for the suspension • the duration of the suspension • information about any program for the suspended student (if the suspension is for more than five (5) days) • information about the right to appeal, including the relevant parts of the policy pertaining to the appeal of suspensions • the name of the Superintendent for the school 13.5.4 Where the student has committed to attend a suspension program, a Principal will prepare a SAP, prior to the first day of the program. 13.5.5 The written notice of the suspension will be promptly sent to the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian. 13.5.6 Where the incident is a serious violent incident, a Violent Incident Report will be completed, and police involved as outlined in the Police/School Board Protocol. Conditions for students under suspension 13.6.1 Students under suspension are not allowed to be on the property of any school or engaged in any school-related activities, unless required by the attendance in a suspension program, or approved by the Principal. 13.6.2 A student who has an assignment due during the suspension period, must make arrangements for the assignment to be delivered to the school by the due date. 13.6.3 Tests missed due to a suspension will be rescheduled or excluded from the final evaluation of the student, at the discretion of the Principal. Re-entry from suspension 13.7.1 A student may return to his/her school on the school day following the last date of the suspension. 13.7.2 The student will report to the Principal or Vice-Principal to discuss the prevention of further misconduct. The Page 27 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A parent/guardian of the student may be invited at the discretion of the Principal or Vice-Principal. 13.7.3 13.8 13.9 A re-entry meeting will be held for the return of a student from a suspension program of more than ten (10) days. Suspension appeals 13.8.1 The appeal of a suspension does not stay the suspension. 13.8.2 The adult student or the student’s parent/guardian may appeal a suspension. 13.8.3 A suspension pending a consideration of an expulsion cannot be appealed while the incident is under investigation. Notice of appeal 13.9.1 A person who has the right to appeal must give written notice of his/her intention to appeal to the Superintendent for the school within ten (10) days of the commencement of the suspension. 13.9.2 Where the suspension was imposed as an alternative to an expulsion, an appeal may be filed within five (5) days of receipt of the said notice. 13.9.3 The Superintendent for the school will acknowledge receipt of the appeal and provide a date on which the Board’s Discipline Committee will hear the appeal. 13.10 Appeal hearing June 2013 13.10.1 The Discipline Committee of the Board will hear the appeal within fifteen (15) days of the receipt of the notice of appeal unless the parties to the appeal agree to an extension. Suspension appeals will be heard, In Camera (closed session), by the Discipline Committee of the Board. 13.10.2 The student (whether a party to the appeal or not) may speak for up to ten (10) minutes to the appeal at the meeting of the Discipline Committee. 13.10.3 The appeal hearing will proceed in spite of the absence of the appellant. Page 28 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 13.11 Appeal procedures 13.11.1 The Superintendent for the school will provide information on the relevant parts of the legislation, Board Policies, and Board and School Codes of Conduct. 13.11.2 The adult student or the student’s parent/guardian will have up to ten (10) minutes to outline the reasons for the appeal. 13.11.3 The Principal will state the reasons for the suspension and provide background information in support of the decision to suspend. 13.11.4 Members of the Committee may question both the appellant and the Principal for clarity. 13.11.5 The Committee will retire to make a determination. 13.11.6 The Committee may: • confirm the suspension and its duration • confirm the suspension but shorten its duration • quash the suspension and order the record be expunged 13.11.7 The decision of the Board on suspension appeals is final. 14. Suspension Investigation and Possible Expulsion 14.1 When a Principal has reasonable grounds to believe that a student has committed one or more infractions outlined in section 10.1 of this procedures manual, the Principal will suspend the student. 14.2 Should the Principal believe that the student is unable to control his/her behaviour or is unable to understand the foreseeable consequences of his/her behaviour, the Principal may choose not to suspend, and therefore not to proceed to an expulsion. 14.3 Notwithstanding 14.2 above, where a student’s presence in the school creates an unacceptable risk, a short-term suspension may be imposed in order to arrange for appropriate accommodations of the student. 14.4 Where a Principal has suspended a student for an infraction listed in section 10.1 of this procedures manual, the Principal will conduct an June 2013 Page 29 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A investigation to determine whether to recommend an expulsion to the Board. 14.5 Expulsion consideration 14.5.1 In consideration of whether to recommend a student for expulsion the Principal will consider the gravity of the offence and the effect of the student’s presence on the welfare of other students and staff. 14.5.2 The following factors, if considered mitigating by the Principal, may cause the Principal not to recommend an expulsion and may alter the length of the suspension imposed: • the student’s continued presence in school does not create an unacceptable risk to the safety of any other person • the student’s history • whether a Progressive Discipline approach has been used with the student • whether the activity for which the student may be, or is being suspended or expelled, was related to any harassment of the student because of his or her race, ethnic origin, religion, disability, gender or sexual orientation, or to any other harassment • how the suspension or expulsion would affect the student’s ongoing education • the age of the student • in the case of a student for whom an IEP has been developed: o whether the behaviour was a manifestation of a disability identified in the student’s IEP o whether appropriate individualized accommodation has been provided o whether the suspension or expulsion is likely to result in an aggravation or worsening of the student’s behaviour or conduct June 2013 Page 30 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 14.6 14.7 Principal’s investigation 14.6.1 The Principal will conduct an investigation promptly following the suspension of the student under section 14.1 above. 14.6.2 As part of the investigation, the Principal will: • interview the student and where the student is not an adult the student’s parent/guardian • interview witnesses who the Principal believes can contribute relevant information • review the student’s past history of discipline, including steps taken in Progressive Discipline • consider the effect of the student’s presence on the welfare of others in the school • consult with special education staff when dealing with an identified student • consult with the Superintendent for the school to ensure that proper procedures have been followed Principal’s determination 14.7.1 Following the investigation, the Principal will determine whether to recommend an expulsion to the Board. 14.7.2 The Principal may recommend: • an expulsion from all schools of the Board, or an expulsion from the school the student was attending with a recommendation for an alternate school • If the Principal decides not to recommend an expulsion, the Principal may: o uphold the suspension imposed including the length of the suspension o uphold the suspension and modify the length of the suspension o withdraw the suspension and expunge the record June 2013 Page 31 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 14.8 Principal notification 14.8.1 Following the investigation, the Principal will promptly notify, in writing, the adult student or the parent/guardian of his/her decision. 14.8.2 Where the Principal has decided to recommend that the Board consider an expulsion, the notification will include: 14.8.3 14.9 • a copy of the Board’s Safe Schools Policy, and • contact information for the Superintendent for the school Where the Principal has decided not to recommend an expulsion, but instead, modify or uphold the suspension, the notification will include information about the right to appeal the suspension. Superintendent’s review 14.9.1 Following receipt of the recommendation of the Principal by the Superintendent for the school, the Superintendent may offer the parent or the adult student an opportunity to review the Principal’s decision and the evidence supporting that decision. 14.10 Expulsion hearing 14.10.1 Where the Principal has decided to recommend to the Board that the student be expelled, the Discipline Committee of the Board will conduct a hearing within twenty (20) days of the first day of the suspension, unless the parties to the expulsion agree otherwise. 14.10.2 The Superintendent for the school will notify the parties to the hearing of the date and time of the hearing, including information about the proceedings. 14.11 Principal’s report 14.11.1 Where the Principal recommends an expulsion to the Board, the Principal will prepare a report including: • a summary of the findings of the investigation, including o the suspension infraction o Principal’s recommendation June 2013 Page 32 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A o incident leading to the suspension o current credit count o current program o Principal’s investigation o parent interview conducted o past misconduct and steps taken in progressive discipline o consideration of mitigating circumstance o rationale behind the recommendation • a recommendation of whether to expel from the school or all the schools of the Board, and either: o a recommendation for placement of the student, should the expulsion recommendation be from the school only, or o a recommendation for a program for expelled students if expelled from all the schools of the Board 14.12 Notification of hearing 14.12.1 The Superintendent for the school will notify the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian of the time and place of the hearing. 14.12.2 Included in the notification will be: • the Principal’s report to the Board • a copy of the relevant parts of this Safe Schools procedures manual dealing with expulsion hearings • a statement that the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian may respond to the Principal’s report in writing • the name and contact of the Superintendent for the school 14.13 The expulsion hearing 14.13.1 Parties to the expulsion hearing will be the Principal or designate the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian and the June 2013 Page 33 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A student should she/he choose to make a submission to the Board. 14.13.2 The procedures for the hearing will be in the following order: • the Superintendent for the school will review the relevant regulations and policies governing student behaviour including those governing student discipline • the Principal will present the report and may call evidence in respect to the infraction • the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian will present his/her report (if submitted), or have up to ten (10) minutes to verbally present his/her point of view on the discipline of the student including possible consequences for the behaviour • the non-adult student may have up to five (5) minutes to present information • the Committee may ask questions of all parties to the expulsion hearing • the Committee will retire In Camera (closed session) to consider the outcome of the hearing 14.13.3 The expulsion hearing will proceed in spite of the absence of the adult student and/or the student’s parent or guardian. 14.14 Committee determination 14.14.1 June 2013 The Committee will consider the following in making its determination: • all evidence and information provided by the parties to the hearing • the gravity of the misconduct • the effect of the continued presence of the student in the school or other schools • whether Progressive Discipline was or should have been employed • any mitigating factors that may apply • other such matters as deemed appropriate by the Discipline Committee Page 34 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 14.14.2 Upon deliberation, the Committee may: • expel the student from all the schools of the Board • expel the student from the school the student was attending and recommend another school within the Board • not expel the student but uphold the suspension • not expel the student and modify the suspension • not expel the student and quash the suspension and expunge the record of the suspension 14.15 Committee notification 14.15.1 The decision of the Committee will be communicated promptly in writing to all parties of the expulsion hearing. 14.15.2 Where the Committee has decided to expel the student, the notice will include: • the reasons for the expulsion • information about the right to appeal 14.16 Appeal 14.16.1 If the Committee decides to expel a student, the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian may appeal the expulsion to the Child and Family Services Review Board. 14.16.2 If the Committee decides to uphold, modify, or quash the suspension, the decision of the Committee is final. 14.16.3 An appeal of the Committee’s decision to expel does not stay the expulsion. 14.17 Program 14.17.1 Where the Committee decides to expel a student from all schools of the Board, the Committee will assign the student to a program for expelled students. 14.17.2 A SAP will be developed for the student and will include both academic and non-academic objectives. June 2013 Page 35 of 36 SAFE SCHOOLS PROCEDURES MANUAL 503-A 14.18 Conditions under expulsion 14.18.1 A Student under expulsion from all schools of the Board is not allowed to engage in any school-related activities, and is not allowed to be on the property of any school, unless required by the attendance in a suspension/expulsion program. 14.18.2 A Student under expulsion from his/her original school, is not allowed to engage in any related activities of that school, and is not allowed to be on the property of that school. 14.19 Re-entry from an expulsion 14.19.1 When a student has completed a program for expelled students as outlined in the SAP, the student will be readmitted to school. The principal of the school for expelled students will determine if the program has been completed successfully or the program objectives have been met. 14.19.2 When a student is expelled from one school of the board the adult student or the student’s parent/guardian may apply in writing to the Superintendent for that school to have the student readmitted to that school. The Superintendent of that school will determine if the student will be readmitted to that school. The student must demonstrate readiness to prosper in the instruction at the school and that his or her presence in the school will no longer be detrimental to the welfare of others. 14.19.3 When a student is expelled from all schools of the board, the adult student or his/her parent or guardian may apply in writing to the Superintendent for the school the student was expelled from for the student to be readmitted to a school of the board. The Superintendent for the expelling school will determine if the student should be readmitted to a school of the Board. 14.19.4 Should an expelled student not successfully complete the program for expelled students, the adult student or his/her parent guardian my apply for re admission to a school of the board by demonstrating to the Superintendent of the expelling school that the SAP objectives designed for that student have been met. 14.19.5 The decision of the Superintendent for the school is appealed by requesting to delegate to the Board. June 2013 Page 36 of 36