9/13/2010 Balance of Payments: Chapter Objective 3 Chapter Three •Components of the Balance of Payments (BOP) •How to interpret each component •How are the BOP components affected •Policy y implications p for managing g g BOP . 3-0 Chapter Outline z z Balance of Payments Accounting Balance of Payments Accounts z z z z z z The Current Account The Capital Account Statistical Discrepancy Official Reserves Account The Balance of Payments Identity Balance of Payments Trends in Major Countries 3-1 1 9/13/2010 Balance of Payments Accounting z The Balance of Payments is the statistical record of a country’s international transactions over a certain period of time presented in the form of double-entry bookkeeping. 3-2 Balance of Payments: Double-entry accounting system z z z If a transaction creates supply pp y of the nation's currencyy in the foreign g exchange market it is recorded as a Debits (eg Imports) z Debits are used to increase assets and decrease liabilities. If a transaction creates demand for the nation's currency in the foreign exchange market it is recorded as a Credit (eg Exports) z Credits are used to increase liabilities and decrease assets. Since the foreign g exchange g market clears (i.e. ( supply pp y = demand): ) DEBIT = CREDIT 2 9/13/2010 Balance of Payments Accounts: Components z They are composed of the following: z z z z The Current Account The Capital Account The Official Reserves Account Statistical Discrepancy 3-4 The Current Account z Includes: z z z z z z All imports and exports of merchandise/goods All imports and exports of services All income receipts and payments (from investments) All unilateral transfers of foreign aid If the debits exceed the credits, credits then a country is running a trade deficit. If the credits exceed the debits, then a country is running a trade surplus. 3-5 3 9/13/2010 Goods/ Merchandise Transactions Largest component of the Current Account, It consists of: z Exports: When US producers sell their products abroad, buyers (foreigners) supply their own currencies and create a demand for dollars in the FX market z It is recorded as a credit transaction (+) z Imports: When US residents buy products from abroad, they supply pp y dollars (and ( create a demand for foreign g currencies)) in the FX market. z It is recorded as a debit transaction (-) z Merchandise Export - Merchandise Import: Largely Negative (for US) z Examine US Merchandise Trade Balance Data z 4 9/13/2010 Service Transactions z z z Export and Import of Services Travel / Transportation / Financial / Insurance / Computer & Information / Construction / Communication The net difference (export - import) for US is: z z z Service Exports - Service Imports: Generally positive Smaller then Merchandise Export - Imports Has grown over the past years Other Current Accounts z Income Receipts and Payments Income (interest (interest, dividend, etc) received from US investment abroad minus income paid to foreigners investing in the US z Unilateral Transfers z z z Net of gift received from and given to foreign countries Mostlyy negative g Examine US Current Account Statistics 5 9/13/2010 US Current Account Flow (billion USD) Year 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Goods -77 -97 -132 -166 -174 -191 -198 -248 -348 -455 -429 -485 485 -550 -669 -787 -838 -819 -840 Service 46 58 62 67 78 87 90 82 83 75 64 61 54 62 76 85 119 144 Income 24 24 25 17 21 22 13 4 14 21 32 27 45 67 72 57 82 118 Transfer 10 -35 -40 -40 -38 -43 -45 -53 -50 -59 -51 -65 65 -71 -84 -90 -92 -113 -128 Current Account 3 -50 -85 -121 -114 -124 -141 -215 -302 -417 -385 -461 461 -523 -624 -729 -788 -731 -706 U.S. Balance of Payments Data 2007: (in $ billions) Credits Curent Account Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1 646 $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 -$135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 3-11 6 9/13/2010 U.S. Balance of Payments Data 2007 Credits Curent Account Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 IIn 2007, 2007 the h U.S. imported more than it exported, thus running a current account deficit of $731 billion. 3-12 The Capital Account z z The capital account measures the difference between U.S. sales of assets to foreigners and U.S. purchases of foreign assets. In 2007, the U.S. enjoyed a $775 billion capital account surplus—absent of U.S. borrowing from foreigners this “finances” foreigners, finances our trade deficit. deficit 3-13 7 9/13/2010 Capital Account Components z The capital account is composed of: z z z Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) portfolio investments other investments. 3-14 Capital Accounts Treatment z Capital account transactions: z z z Debit: z z z z z Reflects the flow of capital in and out of the US Affects the FX market: Increase in US investments overseas Decrease in overseas investments in the US Capital Outflow from the US It creates a supply of $ in FX market C di Credit: z z z z Decrease in US investments overseas Increase in overseas investments in the USI Capital Inflow into the US It creates a demand for $ in FX market 8 9/13/2010 Sovereign Wealth Funds z z Government-controlled investment funds are playing an increasingly visible role in international investments. SWFs are mostly domiciled in Asian and MidEast countries usually are responsible for recycling foreign exchange reserves of these countries swelled by trade surpluses and oil revenues. 3-16 U.S. Balance of Payments Data 2007 Credits Curentt A C Accountt Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 During the same year, the U.S. attracted net investment of $775 billion— clearly the rest of the world found the U.S. to be a good place to invest. 3-17 9 9/13/2010 The Official Reserves Account z Official reserves assets include: z z z Gold Foreign currencies Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) – a reserve positions with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) 3-18 Official Reserves Account Treatment z z z z Credit: Decrease in US Government’s holding of gold, FX, or SDR: transactions i by b Fedd or US Treasury Debit: Increase in US Government’s holding of gold, FX, or SDR : transactions by Fed or US Treasury Current Account Balance + Capital Account Balance + Official Reserve Account = 0 Used to offset the net effects of the Current and Capital Account balances. 10 9/13/2010 Statistical Discrepancy z z z There’s going to be some omissions and misrecorded transactions—so we use a “plug” figure to get things to balance. Exhibit 3.1 shows a discrepancy of $18 billion in 2006. In 2007 it was $ 41 billion 3-20 U.S. Balance of Payments Data 2007 Credits Curentt A C Accountt Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 In the real world, there is a statistical discrepancy – can be large in some years. 3-21 11 9/13/2010 The Balance of Payments Identity BCA + BKA + BRA = 0 where BCA = balance on current account BKA = balance on capital account BRA = balance on the reserves account Under a pure flexible exchange rate regime, BCA + BKA = 0 3-22 U.S. Balance of Payments Data 2007 Credits Curentt A C Accountt Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 Under a pure flexible exchange rate regime, these numbers would balance each other out. 3-23 12 9/13/2010 U.S. Balance of Payments Data 2006 Credits Curentt A C Accountt Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 -$136 -$733 -$333 -$295 -$662 Including that, the balance of payments identity should hold: BCA + BKA = – BRA -$41 $0.13 ($731) + $775 + ($41) = ($0.13) 3-24 What Economic and Political factors will Impact BOP components? z z z z z Inflation Business Cycles Interest rates FX prices Government Policy 13 9/13/2010 Inflation & BOT z If domestic inflation / price levels increase: z z Export will decrease Imports will increase z z BOT will decrease If domestic inflation / price levels decrease: z z Export will increase Imports will decrease z BOT will increase National Income (GNP) & BOT z If national income / prosperity increases: z Imports will increase more than exports: z z BOT will decrease: If national income / prosperity decreases: z Imports will decrease more than exports: z BOT will increase: 14 9/13/2010 Price Of Dollar & BOT z If the price of $ increases: z z Export will decrease: Imports will increase: z z BOT will decrease If the price of $ decreases: z z Export will increase: Imports will decrease: z BOT will increase Price of Dollar & BOT : Another Look Reasons why y decline in $ prices p will not always y correct the BOT deficit: (1) Capital flows into the US. (2) The producer of the import may respond by lowering price of their product. (3) The price of a currency does not change uniformly with all currencies (4) The J - Curve effect 15 9/13/2010 The J-Curve Effect Change in the Trade Balancce Following a currency depreciation, the trade balance may at first deteriorate before it improves. The shape depends on the elasticity of the imports and exports. exports As an example, consider an imported good for which there is no domestic producer. If demand is price inelastic, then following a depreciation the trade balance gets worse (until domestic production begins). Time 3-30 Government Policy & BOP z Methods used by governments to reduce BOT deficit: z z Currency depreciation Protectionism z z z quotas tariffs Regulating flow of international capital 16 9/13/2010 Mercantilism and the Balance of Payments z z z Mercantilism holds that a country should avoid trade deficits at all costs, even to imposing various restrictions on imports. Mercantilist ideas were criticized in the 18th century by such British thinkers as Adam Smith, David Ricardo, Ricardo and David Hume. Hume They argued that the main source of wealth in a country is its productive capacity not its trade surpluses. 3-32 Balance of Payments and the Exchange Rate Credits Curentt A C Accountt Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 Exchange rate $ P S D Q 3-33 17 9/13/2010 BOP & the Price Of Dollar z If Export > Import: BOT surplus z z z If Export < Import: BOT deficit z z z Excess supply for $ in the FX market Price of $ may decrease Net outflow of investments from US z z z Excess Demand for $ in the FX market P i off $ may increase Price i Excess supply E l for f $ in i the h FX market k Price of $ may decrease Net inflow of investments into US z z Excess demand for $ in the FX market Price of $ may increase Balance of Payments and the Exchange Rate Credits Curentt A C Accountt Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 Exchange rate $ P S D Q As U.S. citizens import and invest, they are supply dollars to the FOREX market. 3-35 18 9/13/2010 Balance of Payments and the Exchange Rate Credits Curent Account Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital p Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 $ -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 Exchange rate $ P S -$41 $0.13 D Q As U.S. citizens export and foreigners invest in the US, there is demand dollars at the FOREX market. 3-36 Balance of Payments and the Exchange Rate Credits Curent Account Exports Imports Income Reciepts Unilateral Transfers Balance on Curent Account Direct Investments Portfolio Investments Other Investments Balance on Capital p Account Statistical Discrepancies Official Reserve Debits $1,646 $818 $22 $238 $1,152 $675 $775 $ -$2,346 -$735 $135 -$731 -$333 -$295 -$662 -$41 $0.13 Exchange rate $ P S S1 D Q As the U.S. government sells dollars, the supply of dollars increases. 3-37 19 9/13/2010 Feedback Loop In the BOT z BOT deficit (decreases) in the US : Imports > Exports z z z z z Excess supply of $ in the FX market Price of $ will decline Export will increase and Imports will decrease BOT will increase BOT surplus (increases) in the US : Imports < Exports z z z z Excess demand for $ in the FX market Price of $ will increase Export will decrease and Imports will increase BOT will decrease Balance of Payments Trends z z Since 1982 the U.S. has experienced continuous deficits on the current account and continuous surpluses on the capital account. During the same period, Japan has experienced the opposite. 3-39 20 9/13/2010 Bal ance of Payments U.S. Balance of Payments 1982-2006 1000 800 600 400 200 0 -2001982 -400 -600 600 -800 -1000 U.S. BCA U.S. BKA 1987 1992 1997 2002 2007 Year Source: IMF International Financial Statistics Yearbook, various issues 3-40 Japan Balance of Payments 1982-2006 200 150 Year 100 50 0 -501980 Japan BCA Japan BKA 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 -100 100 -150 Balance of Payments Source: IMF International Financial Statistics Yearbook, various issues 3-41 21 9/13/2010 Balance of Payments Trends z Germany traditionally had current account surpluses. l z z z z From 1991 to 2001Germany experienced current account deficits. This was largely due to German reunification and the resultant need to absorb more output domestically to rebuild the former East Germany. y Since 2001 Germany returned to its earlier pattern. What matters is the nature and causes of the disequilibrium. 3-42 Balance of Payments Trends in Major Countries 1982-2006 Balan ce of Payments 1000 500 0 1982 1987 1992 1997 2002 -500 -1000 Year 2007 China BCA China BKA Japan BCA Japan BKA Germany BCA Germany BKA UK BCA UK BKA U.S. BCA U.S. BKA Source: IMF International Financial Statistics Yearbook, various issues 3-43 22 9/13/2010 Relationship between Balance of Payments and National Income Accounting z National income (Y), or gross domestic product (GDP) is equal to the sum of the nominal consumption (C) of goods and services, private investment (I), government spending (G), and the difference between exports (X) and imports (M): Y ≡ GDP ≡ C + I + G + (X – M) 3-44 Relationship between Balance of Payments and National Income Accounting z z Private savings is defined as the amount left from national income after consumption and taxes (T) are paid: S ≡ Y – C – T or S ≡ C + I + G + (X – M) – C – T N that Note h BCA ≡ X – M and d we can rearrange the h last equation as (S – I) + (T – G) ≡ X – M ≡ BCA 3-45 23 9/13/2010 Relationship between Balance of Payments and National Income Accounting z z z (S – I) + (T – G) ≡ X – M ≡ BCA This shows that there is an intimate relationship between a country’s BCA and how it finances its domestic investment and pays for government spending. If (S – I) < 0 then a country’s domestic savings is insufficient to finance domestic in vestment. Similarly, if (T – G) < 0, then tax revenue is insufficient to cover government spending and a government budget deficit exists. 3-46 Relationship between Balance of Payments and National Income Accounting z z (S – I) + (T – G) ≡ X – M ≡ BCA When BCA < 0, 0 government budget deficits and or part of domestic investment are being financed by foreign-controlled capital. To reduce a BCA deficit, one of the following must occur: z z z For a given level of S and I, the government budget deficit (T – G) must be reduced For a given level of I and (T – G), S must be increased For a given level S and (T – G), I must fall. 3-47 24 9/13/2010 Top Ten Countries with which the U.S. has a Trade Deficit: 2009 Country Name China Japan Mexico Federal Republic of Germany Nigeria Venezuela Canada Saudi Arabia Italy Malaysia Deficit D fi it i in Millions of US$ -20,223.56 -5,432.84 -5,138.50 -3,221.08 -2,062.90 -1,606.19 -1,418.62 -1,395.11 -1,344.03 -1,158.27 Year To Date D Deficit fi it i in Millions ofUS$ -208,687.97 -40,160.48 -42,310.19 -25,035.84 -13,295.18 -16,585.34 -17,178.56 -10,302.54 -12,897.85 -11,679.86 3-48 Top Ten Countries with which the U.S. has a Trade Deficit: 1998 Year-To-Date Country Name Japan China Federal Republic Of Germany Mexico Taiwan Canada Italy Korea, Republic Of France Malaysia Deficit in Millions of US$ -5,249.77 -4,707.49 -1,754.84 -1,604.54 -1,452.96 -1,239.68 1,239.68 -1,075.63 -943.84 -900.04 -858.85 Deficit in Millions of US$ -31,018.24 -25,119.73 -10,798.21 -7,138.59 -6,628.92 -8,245.93 8,245.93 -5,659.12 -4,176.92 -2,463.38 -3,748.75 3-49 25 9/13/2010 MAJOR FOREIGN HOLDERS OF TREASURY SECURITIES: 2000 MAJOR FOREIGN HOLDERS OF TREASURY SECURITIES: 2009 26 9/13/2010 China's Foreign Exchange Reserve Levels (US$ Billion) 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 3-52 (Credits +; debits -) Current account Exports of goods and services Goods Services Income receipts Imports of goods and services Goods, balance of payments basis Services Income payments Unilateral current transfers, net 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 1281186 909016 372171 535263 1995362 1692817 -302546 -462905 -105772 1452783 1035868 416916 682221 2212023 1875324 -336700 -634136 -91481 1648665 1160366 488299 829602 2350763 1983558 -367206 -730049 -115548 1839012 1304896 534116 796528 2537814 2139548 -398266 -644554 -122026 1570797 1068499 502298 588203 1945705 1575443 -370262 -466783 -124943 Capital account Capital account transactions, net 13116 -1788 384 6010 -140 1475719 -122 -22273 1453324 -413993 -366512 -23089 -649730 156077 -4848 -529615 -140465 -52256 541342 -566266 -36235 -251199 -71207 -207625 1285729 2374 5346 1293449 -244922 -365129 -181299 -502099 690540 -351141 197897 421153 422631 -629552 -268680 -208213 124428 -277087 1247347 259268 213334 -421 26260 20095 988079 112638 132300 450386 8447 69572 214736 n.a. 33758 2065169 487939 428401 2816 22365 34357 1577230 243151 -58229 683245 2227 244793 462043 29710 -4727 2107655 481043 269897 5436 109019 96691 1626612 271210 66845 605414 -10675 182355 511463 6222 79552 454722 550770 591381 8912 -153423 103900 -96048 328334 161411 -166490 29187 -36522 -411968 -32947 84991 305736 450030 441056 57971 -70851 21854 -144294 134707 22781 59 12632 -1460 -313013 50804 162497 Financial account U.S.-owned assets abroad, excluding financial derivatives (increase/financial outflow (-)) U.S. official reserve assets U.S. government assets, other than official reserve assets -546631 14096 5539 U.S. private assets Direct investment Foreign securities U.S. claims on unaffiliated foreigners reported by U.S. nonbanking concerns U.S. claims reported by U.S. banks and securities brokers/14/ Foreign-owned assets in the United States, excluding financial derivatives (increase/financial inflow (+)) Foreign official assets in the United States U.S. government securities O Other U.S. S government liabilities/11/ / / U.S. liabilities reported by U.S. banks and securities brokers Other foreign official assets/12/ Other foreign assets in the United States Direct investment U.S. Treasury securities U.S. securities other than U.S. Treasury securities U.S. currency U.S. liabilities to unaffiliated foreigners reported by U.S. nonbanking concerns U.S. liabilities reported by U.S. banks and securities brokers/15/ Financial derivatives, net Statistical discrepancy (sum of above items with sign reversed) 3-53 Summary: 27 BOP Practice Problems Set #1 1. Please enter the alphabets associated with each transaction listed below in the proper cells in the following table. Credit Debit Goods / Merchandise Service Income Payment/Receipt Unilateral Transfers Capital Account Official Reserve 2. Based on the transaction amounts, please calculate the following Balance of Payment accounts: Balance of Trade Current Account Balance Capital Account Balance List of transactions a. Payment of $20 million in Social Security to US citizens living in Costa Rica b. Sale overseas of Elvis Presley CDs valued at $15 million. c. Tuition receipts of $30 million by American universities from foreign students. d. Payment of $8 million consulting fees to Arthur Andersen by a Mexican firm e. Sale of a $100 million Eurobond issue in London by IBM. f. Payment of $10 million in interest by IBM to its Eurobond investors in London g. Purchase by TI of memory chips valued at $60 million from Toshiba, in Japan. h. Purchase of $25 million in East European stocks by Fidelity Investments (USA). i. Fidelity receives $5 million in dividends from its East European stock investment j. US Federal Reserve sells $20 million of Japanese bonds k. US Federal Reserve buys $30 million of Japanese yen BOP Practice Problems Set #2 1. Please enter the numbers associated with each transaction listed below in the proper cells in the following table. Credit Debit Goods / Merchandise Service Income Payment/Receipt Unilateral Transfers Capital Account Official Reserve 2. Based on the transaction amounts, please calculate the following Balance of Payment accounts: Balance of Trade Current Account Balance Capital Account Balance List of transactions 1.Purchase of $35 million in Japanese bonds by Vangaurd (USA). 2. A $25 million US aid to Bosnia 3.$45 million sales by All State Insurance in France 4.Purchase by HP of components valued at $65 million from Hyndai, in Korea. 5. Payment of $10 million in dividends by GE to its investors in Frankfurt 6. A $120 million stock issue in Frankfurt by GE. 7. Purchase of $50 million French Francs by the US Federal Reserve 8. Purchase of $60 million in Japanese Govt Bonds by the US Federal Reserve 9. Foreign tourists spending $15 million in New Orleans 10. Sale of Star Wars DVD, valued at $55 million, in China. Economic Effects of Balance of Payment Changes: A Summary US exports to foreign country Foreign imports from US US export US import US imports from foreign country Foreign exports to US US BOT with foreign country US trade deficit with foreign country US inflation is higher than foreign inflation US inflation is lower than foreign inflation US GNP increasing, foreign GNP constant US GNP decreasing, foreign GNP constant US dollar appreciates / foreign currency depreciates US dollar depreciates / foreign currency appreciates US Govt increases tariffs on foreign goods US Govt decreases tariffs on foreign goods Foreign Govt increases tariffs on US Foreign Govt decreases tariffs on US US Govt increases quotas on foreign goods US Govt decreases quotas on foreign goods Foreign Govt increases quotas on US Foreign Govt decreases quotas on US US BOT increases = US trade deficit decreases US BOT decreases = US trade deficit increases US dollar Foreign currency