Antennas: from Theory to Practice
Yi HUANG
Department of Electrical Engineering & Electronics
The University of Liverpool
Liverpool L69 3GJ
Email: Yi.Huang@liv.ac.uk
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
1
• To give a brief review of antenna software development
• To introduce the basic theory behind computer simulation tools and
• To demonstrate how to use industrial standard software to analyse and design antennas
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
2
6.1 Introduction
• Antenna design is a complex issue.
• Analytical solutions can only be found for simple antennas
• Computer based methods have been introduced and many good computational tools are available, for example:
– NEC: numerical electromagnetic code
– HFSS: high frequency structure simulator
– CST Microwave Studio
– IE3D
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
3
6.2 Computational Electromagnetics
• Classification:
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
4
Method of Moment (MoM) z
Let’s take a dipole as an example. The source can either be an excitation at the feed from a transmission line or a plane wave
The boundary conditions are: on the surface the total electric field must be zero except in the feed gap, i.e
.
2l
2
y
E z
( z )
E
0
( z )
E
0
( z )
V
0 ,
0
,
z z
l
(1) or E i
( z ) for receiving case
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
5
Because: E
j
A
j
A
, A (r)
e
j
r
4
r
J (r' ) e j
ˆ r
r' dv '
On the surface of the antenna : and
E z
(
K ( z , z ' z )
)
l
l
K (
1
4
j
z , z '
2
z
2
)
I (
z '
2
) dz ' e
j
r r
,
2/l
We therefore need to solve the following Pocklington integral equation
l
l
K ( z , z ' )
I ( z ' ) dz '
E
0
( z ) (2)
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
6
Using the Method of Moment, the 1 st step is to approximate the unknown current by a series of known expansion/ basis functions F n
:
I ( z ' )
n
N
1
I n
F n
( z ' ) (3)
Then choose a set of weighting/testing functions W m
(z) and integrate: n
N
I n l
1 l l l
K ( z , z ' )
F n
( z ' )
dz ' ]
W m
( z ) dz
l l
W m
( z ) E
0
( z ) dz (4)
For m= 1 to M , the equations can be written in matrix form as or
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
7
If we choose pulse functions as the basis functions and the
Derac
functions as the weighting functions , that is we enforce the integral equation at N points on the axis of the antenna, this process is called point-matching : z z
N
I
N
I n
I(z)
I
1
1
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
8
Key issues:
• Selection of the basis and weighting functions
• Complexity, accuracy and convergence
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
9
Other characteristics of the antenna can be obtained using current distribution:
• Input impedance
– For a half-wavelength dipole, it is about 73 , which is linked to the diameter.
• Radiated field (hence the radiation pattern ):
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
10
Examples: current distribution and radiation pattern
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
11
FEM
• Finite Element Method (FEM) was originally developed for structural analysis.
• Particularly suitable for problems involving irregular boundaries and non-homogenous material properties.
• It may be implemented in four steps:
– Discretisation of the solution region into elements
(usually triangular, called “nodes”) and each element has approximated with a constant value;
– Generation of equations for the fields or potentials at each element;
– Integration or assembly of all elements;
– Solution of the resulting system of equations.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
12
An example: circular patch antenna
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
13
FDTD
• Finite Difference Time Domain (FDTD) method was introduced by Yee in 1966
• It imposes a rectangular grid over the region of interest and solves a discretized version of field equations at the nodes of the grid.
• The solution points for the electric field offset from the magnetic –field solution points.
• Since the dynamic problems involve time-changing electric and magnetic fields, Maxwell’s equations are solved at each grid point in an iterative manner.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
14
• To ensure that abrupt field changes do not occur between spatial sample locations:
t
c
1
1 x
1
y
1
z
2
• the biggest of x,
y and
z no more than l
/20
u n
(
i , x j , k )
u n
( i
1 / 2 , j , k )
u n
(
x i
1 / 2 , j , k )
O (
x
2
)
u n
( i ,
t j , k )
u n
1 / 2
( i , j , k )
u n
1 /
t
2
( i , j , k )
O (
t
2
)
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
15
An example: pulse propagation along a monopole
Absorbing boundary conditions are important.
Computational resource could be a problem for some cases
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
16
Another example: horn antenna pulse propagation
Other parameters can also be calculated using the known calculated fields and currents.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
17
Numerical Method Comparison
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
18
High-Frequency Methods
• Particularly suitable for electrically large structures which could be a problem for numerical methods
(memory, runtime or convergence)
• Field based methods
– Geometrical optics (GO) or ray optics.
– Geometrical theory of diffraction (GTD)
– Uniform theory of diffraction (UTD)
• Current based methods
– Physical optics (PO) or wave optics, building on
Huygens’s principle.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
19
6.3 Examples of CAD Design and Analysis
• There are many EM simulation tools: some are simple and cheap whilst the others are complex and expensive. Here we are going to introduce two software packages: one simple and cheap, the other is complex and expensive.
• For wire type antennas, we are going to use
EZNEC software (<$100), which is based on MoM.
• For more complicated antennas, we are going to use Ansoft’s HFSS (>$10000), which is based on the finite element method.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
20
EZNEC
• A powerful but very easy-to-use programme for modelling and analyzing various (especially wire-type) antennas in their intended operating environment. It was developed by
Roy Lewallen (W7EL). The major features are that
– The antenna is constructed by straight wire conductors, thus a surface structure is approximated with wire meshes.
– The input of the antenna is done via a spreadsheet-like entry, the start and end coordinates are required, so is the number of segments.
– The simulation set-up is very straightforward and many short-cuts are built in
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
21
– The computation is very fast and efficient.
– 2D current distribution and 2D and 3D plots of radiation patterns are available; other information such as the gain, input impedance, VSWR, 3dB beamwidth, front-to-back ratio, takeoff angle, and sidelobe characteristics are also readily available.
– If required, transmission lines, a realistic ground, and loads to simulate loading coils, traps, or similar components can be selected and added to the simulation.
– Antenna descriptions and pattern plots are easily saved and recalled for future analysis.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
22
Design example
14 MHz (20 m band) is one of the amateur radio
(ham radio) bands widely used around the world.
Assume that you are going to make a dipole as a transceiver antenna which will be placed in your garden. Use EZNEC to design the antenna and analyse the effects of the ground plane on the antenna input impedance, gain and radiation pattern. Horizontal polarisation is assumed.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
23
2.
3.
4.
Solution:
• 14 MHz has a wavelength of 21.4 m. To make a resonant and efficient dipole, the dipole length L should be close to l
/2, which is affected by the ground.
• Now let’s use EZNEC Demo V.50 (it is free!) to aid the analysis and design. The simulation should follow these steps:
1.
define the antenna view the input antenna run the simulation check the results
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
24
User interface (Src: Source; FF: far field; NF: near field)
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
25
Wires input interface
Source input interface
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
26
Antenna view showing controls and current distribution
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
27
VSWR and impedance of a dipole in free space
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
28
VSWR and impedance of a dipole 3 m above a perfect ground
See changes?
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
29
Radiation pattern and gain of a dipole in free space
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
30
Radiation pattern and gain of the dipole above a ground
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
31
Radiation pattern for a dipole placed 9 m above a real ground
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
32
Another design example
Two quarter-wave monopoles are separated by a quarter-wavelength. They are placed above a perfect ground plane and fed with the same amplitude and variable phase. Analyse how the phase difference in the feed affects the array performance and compare with theoretical results.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
33
Solution:
For convenience, we choose the frequency to be 300 MHz and assume the array is made of perfect conducting wire with a diameter of 2 mm. Each quarter-wave monopole is divided into 8 segments (< l
/20). There are now two sources placed at the ends of the monopoles.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
34
Phase difference
0
= 0
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
35
Phase difference
0
= 90 degrees
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
36
Array factor:
Thus
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
37
EZNEC for more complicated structures
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
38
HFSS
• High frequency structure simulator (HFSS) utilizes a 3D full-wave FEM to compute the circuit and field behaviours of high-frequency and high-speed components.
• The major features include:
– Suitable for almost all structures and configurations
(wire- or non-wire-types);
– All antenna results are given, and some animated results may also be shown;
– Easy to optimise the design (using its parametric function or Optimetrics software);
– Good accuracy.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
39
Design example
Planar Inverted F Antennas (PIFAs) are popular in mobile phones. The main reasons are that a). they are of low profile; b). their radiation patterns are near omni-directional; c). they are installed above the phone circuitry, “re-using” the space within the phone to some degree; d). they exhibit a low specific absorption rate (SAR).
Design a dual-band PIFA for a GSM mobile handset. It should cover 880 – 960 MHz (E-GSM 900) and 1710 –
1880 MHz (DCS 1800 or GSM 1800). The dimensions should be small enough for a standard mobile handset.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
40
Design idea:
The two centre frequencies are 920 MHz and 1755
MHz.
We should create two current paths which are about ¼ of the wavelengths.
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
41
Feed tab
Shorting tab
Detailed dimensions of the design
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
42
HFSS simulation to validate and tune the design
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
43
Convergence plot
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
44
S11 in dB plot
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
45
3D radiation pattern
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
46
Meshes and current distribution
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
47
The antenna was made
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
48
and measured
Antennas: from Theory to Practice
49