Project 2 Evaluation Form
Reviewer: ________________________________________ (your name here)
Website:_________________________________________ (give URL and Title)
Website Author: ___________________________________
Final Score DIVIDE BY 2:__________________________________ (out of 60)
IMPORTANT: ONLY ENTER IN THE TEXT BOXES HIGHLIGHTED IN YELLOW
Evaluation Scale
Proficie
nt
4
Needs
Missing/
Not
Improvem Incomple Applicab
ent
te
le
2-3
0-1
N/A
Evaluation Criteria
Points
A. Web Site Layout
1. Home Page has compelling, interesting information "above the
fold" (before scrolling down) at 800x600 resolution. Good
contrast between text and background. The repetitive information
(header/logo & navigation) take up no more than 1/4 - 1/3 of the
browser window at 800x600 resolution.
2. Consistent site header/logo
3. Consistent navigation area
4. Informative page title that conveys purpose of the site
succinctly. Page footer area -- copyright, last update, contact email address
5. Balance of text/graphics/white space on page, and good
contrast between text and background
Web Site Layout Points Earned
Web Site Layout Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total Points Possible (20 - 4 points for
each N/A)
B. Content
1. Minimum number of words (3000)
2. Abstract conveys purpose of online presentation
3. Introduction / Overview covers contents of online presentation
4. Background –adequately covers history of topic, also gives
description of topic
5. Issues – covers different views of the topic in detail
6. Results – interviews covered in detail,
7. Opinion(s) – covers authors opinion on topic in detail
8. Summary – gives adequate summarization of points covered in
paper
9. References – minimum number of references given
10. References – adequate specification of references
11. Appendix – description of the “Activity” (e.g. interview) you
did, (e.g. list questions asked, all of the answers given). Give
details of person(s) involved.
Content Points Earned
Content Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total Points Possible (44 - 4 points for
each N/A)
C. Navigation
1. Main navigation links are clearly and consistently labeled
2. Navigation is easy to use for target audience.
3. If image, sound, Flash, or DHTML is the main navigation,
clear text links are in the footer section of the page.
(accessibility).
4. All navigation hyperlinks work.
Navigation Points Earned
Navigation Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total by Points Possible (16 - 4 points
for each N/A)
D. Content Level
1. Whenever possible techniques of writing for the Web are used:
bullet points, short sentences in short paragraphs, use of white
space, etc.
2. Content does not include outdated material.
3. Content is free of typographical and grammatical errors.
Content Level=l Points Earned
Content Level Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total Points Possible (12 - 4 points for
each N/A)
E. Multimedia
1. Each audio/video/flash file used serves a clear purpose.
2. The audio/video/flash files used enhance rather than distract
from the site.
Multimedia Points Earned
Multimedia Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total Points Possible (8 - 4 points for
each N/A)
F. Presentation – YOUTUBE (give 0 points if URL to youtube video not
given)
1. Introduction page present containing:




Name
Course Number
Project 2
Presentation Title
2. Presentation was clear to understand
3. Presentation covered all important areas of the tutorial
Content Presentation Points Earned
Presentation Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total Points Possible (12 - 4 points for
each N/A)
G. Functionality
1. All hyperlinks work.
Functionality Points Earned
Functionality Percentage
Divide Points Earned by Total Points Possible (4 - 4 points for
each N/A)
Summary
A. Page Layout
B. Content
C. Navigation
D. Color and Graphics
E. Multimedia
F. Content Presentation
G. Functionality
Final Points Earned
Out of 120 points
Final Percentage
Divide Final Points Earned by
Total Points Possible (120 - 4 points for each N/A)
General Comments:
© Lynne Grewe