National Assembly Impact of Storming of Bastille • Great Fear: – In the rural areas, peasants rose up in arms against the nobility. – Chateaux were looted and burned in an attempt to destroy the feudal records of taxes & duties. – Many nobles were killed or driven from their homes. Great Fear: Between June and the beginning of August there were riots in the countryside. Peasants burned their nobles' chateaux, monasteries and buildings which housed public records. They particularly targeted documents which contained records of their feudal obligations. It was called "The Great Fear" and spread quickly throughout France. Between June and the beginning of August there were riots in the countryside. Peasants burned their nobles' chateaux, monasteries and buildings which housed public records. They particularly targeted documents which contained records of their feudal obligations. It was called "The Great Fear" and spread quickly throughout France. Rumors that drove the Great Fear • Was it true that Marie Antoinette had attempted to blow up the Assembly? • Were there really foreign brigands from England and Spain marching on rural France? • Were foreign powers preparing to invade and restore the king? • Had Polish troops landed at Dunkirk? Impact of Great Fear • August 4, 1789-National Assembly started to write a constitution to abolish the system of feudal privileges. • Taxes were now to be paid by everyone & based on what your earned. • All peasant obligations were abolished. • They passed the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen • Proposed by Lafayette • Based on the ideas of John Locke, Montesquieu, & the Declaration of Independence • Stated “Men are born free and remain free and equal in rights…and the source of power resides in the people.” • It guaranteed liberty, security, equal justice, fair taxes, freedom of speech, press, and religion to all Frenchmen. • Barely 300 words long • Printed cheaply on one single sheet of paper, so it could be distributed to everyone • Symbol of the new French social order Declaration of Rights of Man Declaration of Rights of Man • On August 26, 1789, the "Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen" was passed by the National Assembly. • This presented to the world a summary of the ideals and principles of the Revolution, and justified the destruction of a government based upon absolutism and privilege, and the establishment of a new regime based upon the inalienable rights of individuals, liberty, and political equality. • The Declaration became the preamble to the Constitution of 1791. • It has been referred to in almost every single revolutionary movement since 1789, and has been translated into nearly all major languages. • It is the basis of the constitutional foundations of many countries, including France's Fifth Republic. • Many ideas for the Declaration were from the Enlightenment, with the most important influence being John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (first published in England in 1690 at the time of the 'Glorious Revolution'). Declaration of the Rights of Man • By 1791, the Declaration had been transformed from a legislative document into a kind of political manifesto. • No one assisted this process more than Tom Paine, whose Rights of Man became one of the best-selling books in English history, and the bible of working-class radicals. • Paine reproduced the document, word for word, treating it as a sacred text that ushered in a new epoch of world history. • The King was never in favor of the Declaration and he refused to endorse it because he thought its clauses were too ambiguous. • He only sanctioned it under popular pressure on October fifth and sixth, 1791. • Since then, it has been adopted by all kinds of political groups, and has been used both to justify revolution and also to suppress it. • British cartoon making fun of the French Revolution and Declaration of Rights of Man and Citizen The tables were turned. The French Revolution had given the first and second estates less power than the third estate. The peasant now rides on the backs of the clergy and nobility, instead of supporting them. He carries the results of a hunt, which was forbidden in the old regime, and says vive le roi (the king) and vive la nation Constitution of 1791 • From July 6th, consecutive committees of the assembly, staffed mainly by lawyers worked hard to construct the document. • Finished in September of 1791, it was prefaced by the Declaration of the Rights of Man, voted in on August 26th of 1789. • The constitution of 1791 was far from a meager regularization of existing laws and practices, as sensible deputies had first wanted. • The monarchy was certainly preserved, with conventional aspects, but royal power was carefully restricted. Louis became the first 'functionary' of the state. • A permanent legislature, which the king could not disband, would make laws. • The king was given a suspensive refusal over legislation that could postpone endorsement for up to five years, even though Mirabeau had proposed a permanent veto. • The monarch ran the executive power that would implement the laws; it was intensely disbelieved, because it might provide opportunities for a renewal of despotism. • Constitution of 1791 • Reorganized the government into three branches of government---system of checks and balances • The executive was the King – – – – conduct foreign affairs appoint ambassadors propose war Moved royal family from Versailles to the Tuileries Palace in Paris • It was a constitutional monarchy. • The legislative branch was the National Assembly – – – – – freely elected initiated & voted on all laws fixed taxes controlled expenditures declared war • The judicial branch consisted of popularly elected judges. – – – – Standardized the court system. Abolished the sale of judicial office. Juries were now citizen filled. Abolished the use of torture. • "The Roman Aristocrat" • The fattened clergyman and the well– bedecked nobleman go off unbothered while the figure in the foreground assesses carefully the value of a commoner. This complex image also includes a pig—likely a symbol for Louis XVI— with the cleric and the noble. Thus the print clearly attacks the upper classes and likely the monarch. But there is more. Specifically, the National Assembly had set a means test for voters, and a higher one for prospective officeholders. S o the gigantic female is measuring the commoner for his right to participate in the new revolutionary society. This then is also a critique of the National Assembly. Who, then, is the figure in the foreground? Perhaps it is the revolutionary legislature, represented here as an arrogant Roman Senate, a clearly oligarchical body. • • • • • • Weaknesses of the Constitution of 1791 • The chronic weakness of the executive and the unpopularity of the king's ministers, Louis himself felt, made the constitution not viable. • After his escape attempt and capture at Varennes in June 1791, some modifications were made to reinforce his position, but they failed to reassure him and his acceptance, on September 14th, was half-hearted. • The constitution, after so much debate and trouble, lasted only eleven months Additional Political Reforms of the National Assembly • All Frenchmen had basic rights of citizenship, but the right to hold office & vote was based on persons who owned property & paid taxes. • This eliminated several million from voting. • Constitution of 1791 • Civil Constitution of the Clergy Additional Political Reforms by the National Assembly • Moved royal palace from Versailles to the Tuileries. Tuileries Palace/Louvre • "Long Live Liberty" • • • • Cartoonists extrapolated more and more on a new Louis as the Revolution went along. Here, a rather rumpled King, dressed more like a shopkeeper than a monarch, opens a cage to let liberty out. Many scholars argue that the King was already desacralized as much as a couple of decades before the Revolution. Still Louis is associated with liberty here, and this treatment was mild compared with the personal attacks and the execution that would follow This print depicts the Third Estate—represented by the peasant at the rear of the chariot, the worker leading the horse, and the merchant driving— delivering to the National Assembly a petition listing "abuses" to be remedied. "Abuses to Suppress" print depicts the Third Estate—represented by the peasant at the rear of the chariot, the worker leading the horse, and the merchant driving—delivering to the National Assembly a petition listing "abuses" Source: mfr 88.133 Civil Constitution of the Clergy • On November 27, 1790, the deputies passed a decree saying that an oath of loyalty to the Civil Constitution must be taken by all bishops, parish priests, and their assistants. • Those who refused to take it were forced to leave their posts. • On the 26 of December, King Louis signed that decree. • This was a decision he would regret until the end of his life. • The members of the assembly thought that all prelates would eventually swear the oath. • They were wrong. Only eight did. • Pope Pius VI was against the oath, which did not become known to the public until April of 1791. • • • • • "Mea Culpa of the Pope" Although the revolutionaries long regarded the Pope as an enemy, their anger was stoked significantly by the papal decision to decree as unacceptable the Civil Constitution of the Clergy. This decision, hardly unexpected given the way that the revolutionary settlement upended church tradition and papal authority, apparently weighed heavily on Louis XVI. Some scholars believe it was this decision in Rome that turned the King down the path of no compromise. Civil Constitution of the Clergy • July 1790 • Since the government now paid the clergy’s salaries, it declared that the people will now elect their bishops. • Priest had to give an oath of loyalty to the constitution just like other government officials. • This split the Catholic clergy into two groups: those who took the oath & those who formed the counterrevolutionary groups. Civil Constitution of the Clergy • Throughout history, the Church had owned 6% of the National lands. • Louis XVI and Necker decided to remove the Church from society and give the Church Lands to the people. • By doing this, the people would be happier. • The changes in the Church which followed the seizure of its possessions is a perfect example of the feeling of the National Assembly. • The Bishops argued that the legislation affected the church so profoundly, in spiritual as well as temporal matters, that individual clerics could not be expected to give their consent until the whole church had considered it. • In practice, this meant waiting for papal approval. • Departments were very anxious to fill empty clerical posts, and the first sales of church lands under the provisions of the law nationalizing church property on November 2, 1789, were due to begin in the autumn. Political Cartoon: “Reducing the Clergy” Impact of the Civil Constitution of the Clergy • The relations between the jurors and the nonjurors became increasingly bitter as the hope that the church would sanctify and back the Revolution faded farther and farther away, just like to the hopes for national unity: the forces of the reaction and the counterrevolution could now argue that they fought to defend the church and religion from attack by the Revolutionaries. • A cartoon representing Louis XVI as "King James" with one face turned towards the Constitution and the other towards the non-juring clergy. Other Mobs & Riots • October 5, 1789: Women’s Bread March on Versailles • King refused to approve the Declaration of Rights of Man & bashed the revolution at a banquet. • In response to this insult of the Revolution, a crowd of housewives marched from Paris to Versailles saying they were upset about the high cost of bread. • The housewives presented their demands to the National Assembly peacefully. • That night, a mob stormed the palace and broke into the royal bedchambers. • The royal family barely escaped. • Two of the King’s bodyguards were murdered and beheaded and their heads were carried around on pikes. • After this, the royal family and National Assembly moved the seat of government from Versailles to the Tuileries Palace in Paris. Women’s March on Versailles Edmund Burke wrote of the attack on Marie Antoinette’s bedchamber A band of cruel ruffians and assassins, reeking…with blood, rushed into the chamber of the queen and pierced with an hundred strokes and poniards the bed, from whence this persecuted woman had but just time to fly almost naked and through ways unknown to the murderers had escaped to seek refuge at the feet of a king and husband, not secure of his own life for a moment.” • “ mémorable de Versailles, le lundi 5 Octobre 1789. [Memorable Day at Versailles, October 5, 1789] Caption: Nos Modernes Amazones glorieuses de leurs Victoires revinrent à Cheval sur les Canons, avec plusieurs Messieurs de la Garde Nationale, tenant des branches de Peupliers au bruit des cris réitérés de Vive la Nation, Vive le Roi. [View English translation] Source: Museum of the French Revolution 90.46.129 6. Journée Economic Reforms of the National Assembly November 1789 • • Confiscated the land & wealth of the Church to pay off debts • Government now took the responsibility of paying for education, social services, & salaries of the clergy. • Church land was used as a security for additional loans to avoid bankruptcy. • Assignats – Government bonds could be exchanged for a new paper currency called Assignats but there was a 5% interest rate on them. – Assignats were only used to buy Church land and were then destroyed. – After a while, the assignats were treated as regular currency. But lost 25% of their face value. • The use of Assignats created a new class of property owners loyal to the revolution. • Uniform system for weights & measures • Abolished guild restrictions. • Abolished customs transported within the country. Flight to Varennes • On the 20 June 1791, Louis XVI, Marie-Antoinette, their children and closest servants fled Paris in secret, hoping to reach the Luxembourg border and to join the Austrian troops there. • Unfortunately for the King, the royal party made it only as far as the small town of Varennes. • A man called Drouet, who was a local postmaster, recognized them. Louis was brought back to Paris on June 22. • Surrounded by the National Guard as they passed through the streets of the capital, the people watched the royal family with silence and hostility. • The King had left a proclamation behind explaining his rejection of the Revolution's "complete anarchy": many thought he had renounced the right to lead the French nation. The Arrest of the Royal Family at Varennes Royal Family’s Flight to Varennes • The King had been communicating with his brother-inlaw, the Holy Roman Emperor in Austria to raise an army to take back control of France. • They plotted their escape. • But they were intercepted, and thousands of people lined the road to watch their forced return by the National Guard. • Anti-revolutionary documents were found. The people realized the King would never work with the revolution • Now the royal family were prisoners. Royal Flight to Varennes • The Flight to Varennes (June 20-21, 1791) was a significant episode in the French Revolution during which King Louis XVI of France and his immediate family were unsuccessful in their attempt to escape from the radical agitation of the Jacobins in Paris. • Their destination was the fortress town of Montmédy in northeastern France, a Royalist stronghold from which the King hoped to initiate a counter-revolution. • This represents a turning point after which popular hostility towards the monarchy as an institution. • The various disguises included: Louis- a dress and a black wig, Marie- a servant dressed in a plain grey dress and a veil, and Count Axel Fersendressed as a coachman for Marie. • Marie in the end was the one to be discovered. She was supposed to be a humble servant, but she still acted like a stuck up royal when they were inspecting her fake passport. • "Louis XVI Stopped in his Flight at Varennes" • This romantic English painting of the King’s flight suggests only a few feet separated the King from escape. Royal Flight to Varennes Public’s Reaction to Their Escape • When the King and Queen returned, the public spat on the King and tore the Queen’s clothing. • Messages were written on the walls of the city. One of them was: “Anyone clapping for the King will be whipped; Anyone booing the King will be hanged.” • When the new Emperor of Austria threatened to invade France and set the Queen and King free, the people acted like a mob to arrest them and defend their city. • The mob killed the guards and anyone else in sight and in the palace including the maids. • Louis and Marie were thrown in prison. Flight to Varennes Political Cartoon on Louis Impact of the Flight to Varennes • Despite this treachery, the King was not punished. • The Assembly, wanting neither a Regency nor to redraft their brand new Constitution, declared that he had been kidnapped; his unacceptance of the Revolution, they claimed, had been manufactured by his advisors. • The Constitution of 1791, which passed in August, confirmed the King's position. • His use of the royal veto to block the Legislative Assembly's measures against priests and emigrés, however, continued to undermine his standing. • The family of pigs is brought back to the pigsty! Legislative Assembly And Political Parties of the French Revolution Reaction to the Constitution of 1791: Why the National Assembly Stepped Down? • The lower classes felt betrayed by the Constitution of 1791. • It did not live up to the expectations set by the Declaration of Rights of Man. • Most of the peasants and sans-culottes did not qualify to vote or hold office under the Constitution of 1791. • This led to a split between the middle class and the lower class. • The lower class felt the old feudal system had now been replaced with a new aristocracy based upon wealth. Reaction to the Constitution of 1791: Formation of the Legislative Assembly • A new election was held. • If you had been a representative to the National Assembly, you could not serve on the Legislative Assembly. • A new group of delegates was elected---most dissatisfied by the Constitution of 1791. • The Legislative Assembly was split into political factions or parties over the different goals for the Revolution. Reaction to the Constitution of 1791: Why the political parties developed? • The actions of the National Assembly had splintered the revolutionaries. • Some were happy with the moderate reforms. • Others wanted more radical reforms. • Some wanted to return to the old way of doing things. Emigres or Royalists • They were the most conservative group. • They were made up of nobles and clergy members that had fled the country because of the revolution. • They wanted to undo the revolution and restore the Old Regime. • They helped to organize European nations to fight the French revolutionaries. Emigres or Royalists • Key Figures: a)Louis XVI b)Marie Antoinette c)Comte d’Artois d)Comte d’Provence e)”Tonunneau” Mirabeau Gironde/Girondin Political Party • Dominated the newly formed Legislative Assembly from 1792- October 1793---overall they supported the Constitutional Monarchy • Beliefs were: a)favored a republican government b)were federalists and wanted a government set up like the USA c)extremely idealistic group d)wanted to spread the ideals of the revolution all over Europe e)believed in Rousseau’s ideals of personal liberty f)inexperienced in the practical dealings of government Gironde/Girondin Party • Key Leaders: a)Brissot b)The Rolands c)Marquis de Condorcet d)Charlotte Corday Jacobin Political Party • Most radical of the political parties. • Beliefs: a)wanted to execute the King to remove possible threat b)wanted to allow all people to vote c)thought it was okay to use terror to force people into accepting the radical ideas Jacobin Party • Key Figures: a)Jean Paul Marat-publisher of the propaganda newspaper the Friend of the People b)Danton-a lawyer and powerful orator; okay with using terror until it got out of hand. He called for it to end and was beheaded by the guillotine. c)Maximilien Robespierre-wanted a republic based on the virtues of the Revolution. Became the dictator during the National Convention. Economic Problems Facing Legislative Assembly • Inflation, unemployment, and falling wages • Shortages of food as merchants held back produce to raise prices. • Girondins did not want to face the severe economic problems, so they tried to distract the French people by spreading the revolution to the rest of Europe through war. Declaration of War War on Austria, Prussia, & Belgium • “Crusade” to spread Liberty, Equality, & Fraternity • Legislative Assembly declared war on April 20, 1792. • The King supported the war, but for a very different reason. He hoped the European powers would defeat the revolutionaries and restore the Old Regime. • Lafayette supported the war, because he was ambitious to become a war hero and gain national leadership. • Marat, & other radicals, hoped the war would completely destroy the remains of the monarchy in France. • At first, the French Army was badly defeated by the Austrians. • Many of the best officers were nobles who had fled the country. War on Austria, Prussia, & Belgium • The French Army’s soldiers were poorly trained & undisciplined. • The Girondins were shocked they were losing, & they tried to blame it on the King & other “enemies of the revolution.” • In response to this, the King fired the Girondin minister & vetoed the decrees against the emigres & non-juring priests. War in Europe Effects of the War • The sans-culottes demonstrated in the streets for limits on the price of food. • The Legislative Assembly was losing control to the hands of angry mobs. • Food riots broke out in the countryside. • When the King vetoed the Legislative Assembly’s call for 20,000 volunteer soldiers, the sans-culottes and peasants took action. • A mob of 8,000 Parisians attacked the morning session of the Legislative Assembly armed with pikes, clubs, & guns. • They then moved on to the Tuileries Palace where they screamed at the King and forced him to wear a red liberty cap. • Eventually the mob drifted away. Effects of the War • Austria was set to invade France. • The National Guard, the Federes, marched to Paris in July 1792. • They were not there to maintain order, but to take violence against anyone they believed opposed the revolution. • Radical journalists, like Marat, encouraged the violent behavior with inflammatory articles. • They demanded “people’s justice” and death for “traitors and enemies of the revolution.” Effects of War Effects of the War • On August 10, 1792, the mobs attacked the Tuileries Palace & massacred the royal bodyguards. • This was attack was now as important as the Storming of the Bastille. • Due to this violence, the Legislative Assembly removed Louis as King and imprisoned the whole royal family. • New elections were to be held for a new legislative body known as the National Convention. Attack on Tuileries Palace Siege of the Tuileries" This hand–tinted engraving depicts the storming of the Tuileries Palace by what appear to be small groups of well–organized soldiers of the Marseilles National Guard. The positive image of the sans–culottes is reinforced by commentaries that attribute their action to the "despotism" of Louis XVI and the "treason" of his agents against France. Effects of the War • In the meantime, an executive council of 6 ministers were appointed to run France. 5 were Girondins. 1 was Danton, the founder of the Cordeliers Club. • Danton was willing to sacrifice anything for the revolution. • Meanwhile, the war continued to go badly. • By the end of August 1792, the Austrian, Prussian, and émigré troops were crossing into France through the Netherlands. • It seemed like Paris was going to fall. Battle of Valmy • On September 2, 1792, Danton gave a passionate speech that called for all citizens to defend Paris. • As church bells tolled, he said: “It is time, gentlemen, for the Assembly to become a true council of war. • The bells are a signal to charge against the enemies of our country…To defeat them, we need boldness, and always boldness, and France will then be saved.” • Thousands of Parisians marched to the town of Valmy and defeated the invaders. • On September 20, 1792, they beat the foreigners. Impact of Danton’s Speech • Danton had thrown out a challenge to all the countries who were against the French. • “The kings in alliance to try to intimidate us. We hurl at their feet, as a gage of battle, the French king’s head.” Battle of Valmy September Massacres • But the nationalistic rage that Danton’s speech went beyond the Battle of Valmy. • The sans-culottes lashed out at revolutionary enemies they saw at home. • For 5 days, the bloodthirsty mobs attacked & butchered imprisoned priests, nobles, & royalists. • 1,200 alone were killed in Paris. • It spread all over France to cities like Rheims, Lyons, & Marseilles. • Robespierre, Danton, & the Girondins did nothing to stop it. September Massacres September Massacres in Paris • Saturday, Sept 1: names of clerical prisoners were drawn up and a deportation decree passed the following day • But the wholesale slaughter of criminals imprisoned at the Concergerie and the clergy at the monastery of the Carmelites had already begun • 60 common criminals were killed by mobs at the Bernardins prison • The local authorities and governments did nothing to stop the slaughter "Massacre of the Prisoners of St. Germain Abbey” Massacre at the Carmelite Convent • 150 priests had been held prisoners for a few weeks. • The mob broke in, and the Archbishop fell to his knees, begging for mercy, and was slashed across the face by a sword. • One prisoner tried to escape up the chimney so the jailer shot his musket up the void. When this did not work, he lit a fire and when the choking man fell down into the hearth, he was finished off with swords and hatchets. September Massacres • Gangs of citizens broke into prisons and hospitals where women, the poor, and the insane were held. • Gangs of citizens broke in with any weapons that had and set about killing. • They would pause every now and then to eat and drink wine, using the mutilated bodies as tables and chairs. “Massacre of the Priests" •This image, also reproduced from the newspaper R*volutions de Paris, shows crowds massacring refractory clergy and prisoners. •The panels depict the former convent of the Carmelites (where 163 were killed) and the prison known as the Force, which had formerly been used to incarcerate prostitutes, where approximately 300 defrocked clergy were executed. September Massacres • At the Conciergerie, which held a load of prisoners awaiting trial, 378 out of 488 prisoners were hacked to pieces and piled in bloody, twitchy heaps. • As the carts carrying the corpses away were loaded, some of the women who were helping stopped every now and again to dance amongst the slippery bodies. Massacre of Priests September Massacres at Saint Firmin • September 3 at 5:30AM: a mob arrived at Saint Firmin • They rounded up the prisoners and took some out into the street to execute them. • Priests were brought to the courtyards and slaughtered with pikes, sabers, and clubs. • The priests found on upper levels were killed outright. • Francois and two other priests were hurled from the third floor windows to the ground below • Some women gouged out the eyes from cadavers with scissors Massacre des prisonniers. [Massacre of the Prisoners] Caption: Massacre des prisonniers de la Prison du Châtelet et de la Maison de Bicétre le deux et trois Septembre et jours suivantes au nombre d'environ huit cents Source: Museum of the French Revolution L88.343 Medium: Etching Dimensions: 9 x 15 cm Commentary (numbers refer to pages in essays): Focuses on a single episode – Cameron, 1 Precedents – Censer-Hunt, 3; DayHickman, Discussion F Violence – Censer-Hunt, 1 12. September Massacres at Versailles • Massacre of the prisoners being transported through Versailles • The mob then broke into the make-shift prison in the queen’s stables and massacred them. • 7 or 8 men superficially examined the jailer’s record book and condemned…”this monster, sold to the court, …an aristocrat • Galoy was taken to the kitchen where his legs were broken with an iron bar and his skull smashed September Massacres Totals • Victims were stripped of their clothes & their naked bodies thrown into carts to be taken to the Vaugirard Cemetery. • Leaving a trail of blood on the ground. • Also tossed into wells or buried in shallow graves. • Totals are not certain, but… • 74 priests and 1 layman killed at Villette • 32 priests killed at Saint Germain • No priests, but female prostitutes, criminals, mentally ill, and orphan girls were raped and slaughtered at Salpetiere • In Paris, the estimate is 1400 Political Cartoon on September Massacres Next Step in the Revolution • National Convention met for the first time on September 21, 1792. • It abolished the monarchy and declared France a republic. • In November 1792, the National Convention declared it would help any other nation revolt against their monarchy. • Now the revolution was in the hands of radicals and mobs. Victory of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity