MODERN ERA: 1750 - 1914 CHANGES IN THE NATURE AND FUNCTIONS OF STATE STRUCTURES ENLIGHTENMENT Enlightenment Voltaire (1694-1778) All human knowledge comes from sense perceptions Life, Liberty and Property; 1689 English Bill of Rights Allowed persons to revolt against an oppressive ruler Adam Smith: laws of supply and demand determine price Montesquieu: checks, balances, balanced government Deism Champion of religious liberty and individual freedom Prolific writer; father of Enlightenment John Locke Thinkers called philosophes Sought natural laws that governed human society Center of Enlightenment was France Theory of progress was ideology of philosophes Apply reason/science to society, government, law Popular among thinkers of Enlightenment Accepted existence of a god Denied supernatural teachings of Christianity God the Clockmaker Ordered the universe according to rational and natural laws Impact of Enlightenment Weakened the influence of organized religion Encouraged secular values based on reason rather than revelation Subjected society to rational analysis, promoted progress and prosperity Enlightenment applied science to every day life and made science practical THE ENLIGHTENMENT Revolutionary Ideas Popular sovereignty Relocating sovereignty in the people Traditional monarchs Claimed a "divine right" to rule Derived from God, unquestionable Monarch unanswerable to people Constitutional Limitations Aristocracy, Enlightenment challenged king Glorious Revolution of 1688 Made the monarch responsible to the people John Locke's theory of contractual government Authority comes from the consent of the governed Freedom and equality Demands for freedom of worship Freedom of expression, assembly Demands for political and legal equality Equality not extended to all Condemned legal, social privileges of aristocrats Jean-Jacques Rousseau, The Social Contract Women, Peasants, laborers, slaves, or people of color Originally only extended to tax paying males with education Ideals of Enlightenment were significant global influence STAGES OF POLITICAL REVOLUTIONS • • • • • • • • The Stage is Set • State is economically weak, government is ineffective • New ideas arise, new groups arise to challenge status-quo, intellectual movements influence change Old Regime Loses Control • Old elites attempt to reassert privileges • Some short term event sparks a conflict, disaster rallies forces who oppose old elites • Government too divided and weak to suppress revolt Moderate Phase of the Revolution • Moderates come to power, initiate changes • Electorate expanded, constitution liberalized, some reforms initiated Reaction to the Moderates Arise • Moderates enact only limited reforms • Radicals mobilize their supporters demanding more extensive reforms Radicals Seize Control • Radicals take control of state and revolution • Radicals enact sweeping changes, eliminate old institutions completely Radical Reign of Terror • Foreign, domestic opposition arises to challenge radicals • Radicals react, remove opponents, seek to institutionalize, spread their ideology Moderate Return • Moderates who come to represent the majority remove radicals • End the most radical reforms, return privileges to many groups, lose contact with people Rise of a Strong Leader or Authoritarianism • Usually a military leader arises to oppose moderates • Seizes control of state, institutionalizes revolution, revolution ends REVOLUTIONS 1750 – 1914 American Revolution 1776 – 1783 French Revolution 1789 – 1799 Haitian Revolution 1793 – 1802 Latin American Revolutions 1810 – 1822 Mehmet Ali in Egypt, 1820s European Revolutions 1820s – 1848 Belgium revolts from Netherlands Greece revolts from Ottoman Empire French Revolutions in 1830 and 1848 European Revolutions in 1848: Italy, Central Europe Polish Revolutions 1830, 1863 Meiji Restoration (Japan) 1867 Young Turks (Ottoman Empire) 1908 – 1920s 1st Iranian Revolution 1905 1st Russian Revolution 1905 Mexican Revolution 1910 – 1920 Chinese Revolution 1911 – 1912 THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION Tension between Britain, American colonies Legacy of Seven Years' War Colonial protest British debt, North American tax burden Colonists increasingly independent minded Over taxes, trade policies, Parliamentary rule Colonial boycott of British goods Attacks on British officials; Boston Tea Party, 1773 Political protest over representation in Parliament Continental Congress, 1774 British troops, colonial militia skirmished at the village of Lexington, 1775 The Declaration of Independence, 4 July 1776 Thirteen united States of America severed ties with Britain Declaration inspired by Enlightenment, Locke's theory of government The American Revolution, 1775-1781 British advantages: strong government, navy, army, loyalists in colonies American advantages: European allies, George Washington's leadership Weary of a costly conflict, British forces surrendered in 1781 Building an independent state: Constitutional Convention, 1787 Constitution guaranteed freedom of press, of speech, and of religion Republic based on principles of freedom, equality, popular sovereignty Full legal and political rights were granted only to men of property FRENCH REVOLUTION & NAPOLEON Summoning the Estates General Financial crisis: half of government revenue went to national debt King Louis XVI forced to summon Estates General to raise new taxes Many representatives wanted sweeping political and social reform First and Second Estates (nobles, clergy) tried to limit Third Estate (commoners) National Assembly Formed by representatives of Third Estate, 17 June 1789 Demanded a written constitution and popular sovereignty Angry mob seized the Bastille on 14 July, sparked insurrections in many cities National Assembly wrote the "Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen" "Liberty, equality, and fraternity“: slogan and values of the National Assembly The Assembly abolished the feudal system, altered the role of church France became a constitutional monarchy, 1791 The Convention and the Reign of Terror Replaced National Assembly under new constitution, 1791 Austrian and Prussian armies invaded France to restore ancien régime Convention abolished the monarchy and proclaimed France a republic King Louis XVI and Queen Marie Antoinette executed, 1793 Radical Jacobins dominated Convention in 1793-94 in "reign of terror" Revolutionary changes: in religion, dress, calendar, women's rights The Directory, 1795-1799 A conservative reaction against the excesses of the Convention Executed the Jacobin leader Robespierre, July 1794 Napoleonic France was Enlightened Despotism Brought stability: blended monarchy, autocracy, democracy Made peace with the Roman Catholic church and pope Reformed French economic, banking system: mercantilism Extended freedom of religion to Protestants and Jews Civil Code of 1804: political and legal equality for all adult men Code Napoleon: becomes one of the world’s great legal traditions Restricted individual freedom, especially speech and press THE POLITICAL SPECTRUM HAITIAN REVOLUTION Saint-Domingue Rich French colony on western Hispaniola Society dominated by small white planter class 90 percent of population were slaves Horrendous working conditions Large communities of escaped slaves (maroons) Ideas of Enlightenment reached educated blacks Free blacks fought in American war Widespread discontent White settlers sought self-governance Gens de couleur sought political rights Slaves wanted freedom Slave revolt began in 1791 Factions of white settlers, gens de couleur, slaves battled each other French troops arrived in 1792; British, Spanish intervened in 1793 Slaves conquer whole island including Spanish part Whites driven into exile, executed Toussaint Louverture (1744-1803) Son of slaves, literate, son of Enlightenment Skilled organizer, built strong, disciplined army Controlled most of Saint-Domingue by 1797 Created a constitution in 1801 Arrested by French troops; died in jail, 1803 Haiti Yellow fever ravaged French troops; defeated, driven out by slave armies Declared independence in 1803; republic established in 1804 Civil War followed until 1810; kingdom to 1820 Dominican Republic independent in 1844 LATIN AMERICA Stages Enlightenment, US Revolution, French Revolution influence creoles Creoles feel marginalized by peninsulares, mercantilism French Revolution, Napoleon occupy Iberia: creoles, peninsulares hate Colonies left on their own, begin to make decisions without benefit of mother country Creoles lead independence movements, form militias, resist return of Spain Civil wars, turmoil, suffering followed as creoles battle Spain for control Conservatives take control of new states after independence Result Many newly independent nations Mexico: Grito de Dolores, Fr. Hidalgo & Morelos, Iturbide South America: Simon Bolivar (North), Jose de San Martin (Central) Brazil: Different – peaceful split from Portugal, new ruler becomes emperor Haiti: Different – a slave revolt, rebellion led to independence After Independence Life for majority of people (mestizos, mulattos, Blacks, Indians) little changed, marginalized Societies remained largely casted Small powerful elite of creole families ruled independent states Church is part of the government structure; assists governing elite – rise of anti-clericalism Rule by military strongmen called caudillos becomes common; armies turn on people Struggle between liberals and conservatives, centrists and federalists to define state structures Developments limited to exportable goods, industries and most assets controlled by foreigners Heavy British, American investment in resources leads to Western financial control Standouts: Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, Chile OTTOMAN REFORM, REORGANIZATION Attempt to reform military Led to violent Janissary revolt (1807-1808), suppression of Janissaries Reformer Mahmud II (1808-1839) became sultan after revolt Janissaries resisted, Mahmud had them killed; reforms followed He built an European-style army, academies, schools, roads, and telegraph Legal, educational reforms Called Tanzimat ("reorganization") era (1839-1876) Ruling class sought sweeping restructuring to strengthen state Broad legal reforms, modeled after Napoleon's civic code State reform of education (1846), free and compulsory primary education (1869) Undermined authority of the ulama, enhanced the state authority Opposition to Tanzimat reforms Religious conservatives critical of attack on Islamic law and tradition Legal equality for minorities resented by some, even a few minority leaders Young Ottomans wanted more reform: freedom, autonomy, decentralization High-level bureaucrats wanted more power, checks on the sultan's power Cycles of reform and repression 1876, coup staged by bureaucrats who demanded a constitutional government New sultan Abd al-Hamid II (1876-1909) The Young Turks Proved an autocrat: suspended constitution, dissolved parliament, and punished liberals Reformed army and administration: became source of the new opposition After 1889, an active body of opposition led by army, navy officers Called for universal suffrage, equality, freedom, secularization, women's rights Forced Abd al-Hamid to restore constitution, dethroned him (1909) Nationalistic: favored Turkish dominance within empire, led to Arab resistance The empire survived only because of distrust among European powers MUSLIM RESISTANCE Resistance Muslim universities Muslim Army Officers in Service of Europeans Often educated in western style universities, learned western ideas Become source of anti-Western activities even while supporting reform Revolt in the Sudan Egypt nominally ruled Sudan, attempted to enforce control Egypt able to control Nile farmers; opposition comes from nomads, herders Rule greatly resented as it was corrupt, overtaxed peasants British pressure Egyptians to eradicate slavery, upsetting Muslims (Koran allows) Muhammad Achmad “The Mahdi” (1870s) Direct descendant of the Prophet Muhammad; proclaims jihad against Egyptians, British masters Wahhabis Reformer: A very puritanical form of Islam, seeks to purify Islam Purge Islam of problems; reform, modernize but not at expense to Islam Overran all of Sudan, threatens Egypt, killed British commander at Khartoum Khalifa Abdallahi and the Mahdist state Frequently organized education around western model Educated several generations of students The Mahdi dies; his successor builds an Islamic state under rule of Koran Threatens to overrun all of Middle East, drive out foreigners, westernizers; British intervene Reality: Reformers Discredited Religious revivalists who wanted a return to a pure Islam proved unsuccessful Reformers willing to borrow some western ideas could not win over people British (Europeans) will send in army to crush revolts, threats to Europeans QING (MANCHU) CHINA Qing China (1622 – 1911) Nomadic dynasty from Manchuria Retained much of Chinese political traditions, institutions Retained examination system Ruled through Confucian scholars Qing Army To rule, maintained strict separation of Chinese, Manchu Chinese not allowed to settle in Manchuria Manchurians not allowed to marry Chinese Manchurian nomadic army based on cavalry Unwilling to use modern weapons Rot from Within begins in 18th century Emperor isolated, ineffective Bureaucracy Public works (dikes, water management) reduced, river silted Military in decline, fleet in trouble, armies unreliable Peasants lot deteriorated Too large and cumbersome, corrupt and conservative Examination system riddled with favoritism, elitism, cheating Wealthy buy positions in bureaucracy Bureaucrats had no qualifications, training Diversion of state funds to private families Surrounded by eunuchs, advisors who kept him isolated Lived in Forbidden City at center of Beijing Extreme politics amongst bureaucrats, eunuchs, harem Food shortages, landlord demands Bandits on roads, beggars everywhere Lack of innovation, reform or insight CHINA UNDER PRESSURE The Taiping rebellion Internal turmoil in China in the later nineteenth century The Taiping ("Great Peace") program proposed by Hong Xiuquan Gentry sided with government; regional armies had European weapons Taipings defeated in 1864; the war claimed twenty to thirty million lives Reform frustrated The Self-Strengthening Movement (1860-1895) Blended Chinese cultural traditions with European industrial technology Built shipyards, railroads, weapon industries, steel foundries, academies Not enough industry to make a significant change Powerful empress dowager Cixi opposed changes The hundred-days reforms (1898) Called for end of Qing dynasty; resented Manchu rule Radical social change: no private property, footbinding, concubinage Popular in southeast China; seized Nanjing (1853), moved on Beijing Taiping defeat by combined Qing and foreign troops Population grew by 50 percent; land and food more slowly; poverty strained resources Other problems: official corruption, drug addiction Four major rebellions in 1850s and 1860s; the most dangerous was the Taiping Two Confucian scholars advised radical changes in imperial system Young emperor Guangxu inspired to launch wide-range reforms Movement crushed by Cixi; emperor imprisoned; reformers killed The Boxer rebellion Real name: the Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists, 1899-1900 Local militia attacked foreigners, foreign legations, Chinese Christians Crushed by European and Japanese troops Chinese forced to sign humiliating treaties Collapse of Qing dynasty in 1912 CHINESE REVOLUTION Reform Fails Chinese elites unwilling, unable to reform Boxer Rebellion shows weakness of state, humiliating to Chinese Chinese leaders Leaders educated abroad, especially Japan, US Sun Yat-sen Sun’s Three Principles of the People Local army rebellion followed by many armies Joined by United League members 2/3 of provinces join rebels 1912 Nationalism: Overthrow Manchus, end foreign hegemony Democracy: Popularly elected republican form of government People's Livelihood: help people, regulate means of production, land 1911 Revolution broke out in Hubei Founds United League in Tokyo using Chinese foreign funds Wins support of many military officers, foreign exiles Last Emperor abdicates Sun Yat-sen inaugurated as first president General Yuanshikai in Beijing takes control Sun resigns as president to unify the state Results Revolution did not establish a stable republic China fell into warlords' rule Through unequal treaties, foreign states still controlled economy of China Growth of Chinese nationalism, radicalism JAPAN: SHOGUN TO EMPEROR Crisis and reform in early nineteenth century Emperor isolated, secluded; shogun = military dictator Centralized bureaucracy; alliances with feudal lords Japan not unaware of what was going on in wider world Dutch allowed to visit Japan at Nagasaki once a year Crisis Crop failure, high taxes on agriculture, rising rice prices All led to protests and rebellions Reforms and ideas conflict Government: Neo-Confucian conservative reforms Dutch Learning: Support western studies, reforms, working with west; anti-Chinese National Studies: praised Japanese traditions, emperor, Shinto led to ultranationalism Foreign pressure on Japan European wanted her to reverse long-standing closed door policy Europeans wanted to trade, wanted safe ports for whaling fleets 1844 requests by British, French, U.S. for the right of entry rebuffed 1853 U.S. Commodore Perry sailed U.S. fleet to Tokyo Bay, demanded entry Japan forced to accept unequal treaties with U.S., other western countries The end of Tokugawa rule British, French, Russians demand, receive similar treaties to US Widespread opposition to shogun rule, especially in provinces Dissidents rallied around emperor in Kyoto, attack foreigners Tosa-Satsuma Samurai Rebellion/Civil War breaks out in 1866 The Meiji restoration, 1868 Dissident Samurai militia loyal to emperor defeats Shogun’s troops The boy emperor Mutsuhito, or Meiji, regained authority; Shogunate abolished End of almost seven centuries of military rule in Japan RUSSIA: EMPIRE UNDER PRESSURE Post-1812 Great concern with defense, liberal ideas as threat to old order Government introduced reforms to improve bureaucracy Made an alliance with the conservative powers of Europe to maintain order December Uprising 1825 Death of Alexander I prompted some western-oriented officers to rebel Suppressed mercilessly by new tsar Nicholas I Orthodoxy, autocracy and nationality State became very repressive, secret police Policeman of Europe: used army to suppress revolutions Suppressed rebellion in Poland Policy of foreign wars to divert domestic problems Serfdom Issue Russia needed work force in order to industrial Serfdom not efficient Lack of workers in cities an obstacle to economic development Gap between western, eastern Europe economic systems Emancipation of serfs by Alexander II begun in 1863 Due to loss in Crimean War Serfs gained right to own land, got most of the land from nobles Nobles kept best and gave worst to serfs Serfs had no political rights; had to pay a redemption tax on land: kept them in permanent debt Emancipation did not increase agricultural production Tsar was careful to preserve aristocratic order; serfs received no political rights Political and legal reforms followed 1864: creation of zemstvos Local assemblies with representatives from all classes Tended to only see local interests and not national concerns; legal reform more successful A weak system: nobles dominated, tsar held veto power Small middle class grew; improved corps of army officers; middle class politicians, bureaucrats Literacy increased; readership spread; some women enter intellectual community RUSSIAN REPRESSION & MARXISM Cycles of protest and repression Peasants Often landless, no political power Frustrated by lack of meaningful reform Peasant uprisings become more common than serf as frustration heightened Population increased as potato introduced, increasing pressures on society Social Protest Antigovernment protest and revolutionary activity increased in 1870s Middle Class, some aristocrats advocated rights, political representation Radical Intelligentsia advocated socialism and anarchism, recruited in countryside Repression by tsarist authorities: secret police, censorship Russification: sparked ethnic nationalism, attacks on Jews tolerated Terrorism emerges as a tool of opposition Radicals wanted solution to social issue from a Russian perspective Young intellectuals went directly to the peasants Most opposed westernization, autocracy, capitalism Many became peasant anarchists Alexander II, the reforming tsar, assassinated by a bomb in 1881 Nicholas II (1894-1917), more oppressive, conservative ruler Marxism and the Reality of Russia Marx foresaw a revolution by workers Russia lacked lack worker base; society was largely peasant Workers tended to be radical but misdirected Russia lacked a middle class running society prior to revolution The Bolsheviks (Russian Marxists) & Vladimir Ilyich Lenin From middle class bureaucratic family, was an intellectual Argued that proletariat was developing in advance of revolution Felt Russia could have a revolution without a middle class phase Organized an elite revolutionary party to lead workers, peasants Organized the Bolsheviks Party was secretive as Russian secret police everywhere Infiltrated unions, workers organizations, peasant groups Agitated against government, organized secret cells to lead revolution MARXISM: Workers will stage a revolution and overthrow capitalism, state LENINISM: Will only succeed with the leadership of an elite group of revolutionaries RUSSIAN REVOLUTION OF 1905 Russian Revolution of 1905 Military defeat, humiliation in Russo-Japanese War was cause Massive protests followed news of defeat Workers tended towards non-Marxist socialists; Marxists marginalized Sought to achieve ends without full scale revolution A Fizzled Revolution Tsar forced to accept elected legislature, the Duma Many parties elected with conflicting interests Unable, unwilling to cooperate Rendered ineffective by tsar, bureaucracy Stolypin Reforms Poor workers of St. Petersburg march to palace to ask tsar for help Unarmed workers shot down by government troops Peasants seized landlords' property, killed landlords Workers formed soviets (worker councils) in cities, factories Workers mounted general strikes in St. Petersburg, Moscow Peasant insurrections in countryside against landlords Police repressions ineffective, just upset people Bloody Sunday massacre Russia always diverted domestic tension by short, successful wars In 1870s, 1880s had expanded against Ottoman Empire Reforms allowed peasants to buy land; end redemptive payments Small group of very successful peasant landowners began to arise Rights for workers gradually ignored, cancelled Army failed to support revolution For the Future Nicholas II was weak, ill-advised, unwilling to end autocracy Russian Marxists emboldened, reorganized, radicalized Peasants, workers radicalized, unlikely to cooperate in future NATIONALISM & IMPERIALISM Nationalism heavily involved in imperialism Source of national pride, strength to acquire colonies Non-Westerners soon learned to be nationalist India Two types of state-structures in India Educated Indians met, with British approval, to discuss public affairs Congress aired grievances about colonial rule, sought Indian self-rule 1906, All-India Muslim League Sought an Indian society based on European science and traditional Hinduism Used press to mobilize educated Hindus and advance reform The Indian National Congress, founded 1885 Princely States: States ruled by Indian princes, assisted by British officials British possessions: States ruled directly by British Ram Mohan Roy (1772-1833), "father of modern India" Formed to advance interests of Indian Muslims Limited reform, 1909; Wealthy Indians could elect representatives to local councils Indian nationalism Many studied in Western schools, learned western knowledge to get ahead Many defined their sense of nation as response to imperialism A powerful movement, achieved independence in 1947 India served as a model for anti-colonial campaigns in other lands Other Examples Sepoy Rebellion in India (1856) Meiji Restoration in Japan 1898 Boxer Rebellion in China Late 1800s Mahdist Rebellion and State in the Sudan 1898 Boer War in South Africa 1905 Iranian, 1910 Mexican, 1911 Chinese Revolutions IRANIAN REVOLUTION OF 1905-1911 Causes Intellectuals feel that to save Iran they would have to limit Shah’s power Encroachment by Russians, British on Iranian territory upset Iranians Initiated by the Majilis or Iranian Parliament 1905: A year of demonstrations and strikes Parliamentarians tended to be educated, merchants, clerics, young Introduced the constitutional concept of government 1906 Constitutionalists failed to protect victory against domestic, international threats Trade Russian influence for British control Took at face value Mohammed Ali Shah's pledges to respect constitution 1907-1908 UK, Russia prepare to divide Iran into “spheres of influence” Mohammed Ali Shah used opportunity to overthrow constitution Shah attempts to kill constitutionalists, forced to abdicate, flees Spheres of influence Anglo-Russian convention signed on August 31, 1907 Divided Iran into three zones People were sovereign and their representatives were delegated to enact the laws Old Shah abdicates, new shah accepts constitutional limitations 1910 Russia took Northern part British zone paralleled the Persian Gulf, Indian empire Neutral zone across center of country open to both interests Russia invades Helps old Shah reestablish his rule in Iran MEXICAN REVOLUTION 1911- 1920 The Revolution (1910-1920) Middle class joins peasants, workers overthrow Diaz Class Factions 1910-1914: all rebels vs. Diaz and Huerta 1914-20: Carranza, Obregon vs. Zapata, Villa Regional Revolutions: North, South, Yucatan Course of the Revolution Liberal Middle Class Leaders Francisco Madero rules at first General Huerta, army side with landowners, kills Madero Venustiano Carranza Organizes coalition with Villa, Zapata, Obregon US troops sent by Wilson support Carranza, Huerta resigns Peasant, Common Rebels Seeks middle class constitutional democracy Opposes land reform; landless peasants attack large landowners Peasant armies win pitched battles against government troops Pancho Villa led northern rebels, especially landless peasants Emiliano Zapata initiates land reform in the Southern areas he controls US Intervenes in 1914 (Veracruz) and 1916 (Chasing Pancho Villa) Civil War 1914 – 1917: Constitutionalists (Carranza) win, reestablish control Women’s Roles: Soldaderas (camp followers), Soldiers, Political Activists New Constitution of 1917 brought sweeping reform Advanced nationalist, radical views Universal male suffrage (hostile to women) Power, property of Church restricted Free, secular, obligatory primary education Returned lands seized illegally; curbed foreign ownership 8 hour work day, Minimum wage, Strikes legal CHINESE REVOLUTION Reform Fails Chinese elites unwilling, unable to reform Boxer Rebellion shows weakness of state, humiliating to Chinese Chinese leaders Leaders educated abroad, especially Japan, US Sun Yat-sen Sun’s Three Principles of the People Local army rebellion followed by many armies Joined by United League members 2/3 of provinces join rebels 1912 Nationalism: Overthrow Manchus, end foreign hegemony Democracy: Popularly elected republican form of government People's Livelihood: help people, regulate means of production, land 1911 Revolution broke out in Hubei Founds United League in Tokyo using Chinese foreign funds Wins support of many military officers, foreign exiles Last Emperor abdicates Sun Yat-sen inaugurated as first president General Yuanshikai in Beijing takes control Sun resigns as president to unify the state Results Revolution did not establish a stable republic China fell into warlords' rule Through unequal treaties, foreign states still controlled economy of China Growth of Chinese nationalism, radicalism