Tool 4: Rapid Market Assessment Tool1 Cash transfers enable people to purchase the things they need from local shops, stores, or service providers. In almost every context, individuals rely on markets to meet their daily needs – whether that is to shop for food, to buy water, to provide employment or services in exchange for income. In many contexts, these markets continue to function even in times of crises. Understanding to what extent markets are functioning, and whether those market systems can continue to provide for the needs of the target population is a key consideration when considering a cash based intervention. Market capacity should be assessed irrespective of whether an in-kind or a cash-based intervention is being considered, as an understanding of market capacity will help decide which of these types of intervention (or a combination) is most appropriate. It is always necessary to consider the supply side2; and ensure that the local market can meet the increased demand that may result from the emergency itself, and particularly from the demand associated with a potential CBI. Conducting an Emergency Market Mapping and Analysis (EMMA) exercise is the recommended option, however if staff time and capacity does not allow for this, minimum standards outlined below must be followed. This is an overview with key questions for a market assessment that need to be answered as part of any program that is looking to use cash transfers. These have been designed for all LWF staff to be able to use even if they are not livelihood/market experts. Key question What does it tell you? Where can you get the information? For an initial rapid market assessment, concentrate on the market supply of the commodities /services you think the target groups will buy. Needs assessment. Is there a market close to the target populations to access those commodities or services? If target populations have restricted access to the market either through marginalisation, physical distance, lack of commodities available, noncompetitive trader behaviour or some other factor/s, then cash may not be an appropriate response. Interviews with affected population. Did people purchase the required items from the market before the crisis? How much would it cost people to get to the market – and back with their commodities? (You have to consider this cost when deciding how much money to give people.) Traders are unlikely to bring in commodities to an area if they think that no one will buy them. Think about how many people are likely to purchase the items after cash distribution and to what extent that changes the trading opportunities. Information from any previous programmes in the area. Project objective What is the objective of the project? What do you expect the target groups to purchase with the cash? Access and preference 1 NB. If only a small number of people are excluded from the market, consider in-kind distribution for that group only. Slightly adapted from Save the Children Rapid Market Assessment Tool Supply side refers to market systems which supply food, essential items, assets, or other inputs to a target population. Sometimes also called ‘input’ markets. This distinguishes them from income (output) market systems, which are a source of income for a target population. Definition from the EMMA Toolkit 2 Market Functioning and Recovery Immediately after a shock the market may be disrupted and/or stop functioning completely. However, since people want to quickly return to their livelihoods, markets often recover quickly. It is better to support the local market and help the local economy, than to bring commodities in from outside and prevent people from making a livelihood. The ability of the market to respond to an increase in demand may be affected by government policies or taxes if they restrict movement of commodities between different parts of the country, or from outside the country. If the market is currently not functioning, providing cash to traders may be sufficient to get it started again. Markets are dynamic and can respond quickly if given the right support. If commodities are not getting into the market simply because the traders do not have the capital to cover high transport costs, consider providing a cash grant to traders. Are the required items available in the local market? Are there sufficient quantities available? At what price? At what quality? If not, is it likely that they could become available easily? (Traders are unlikely to bring commodities into an area if they think people can’t afford to buy them.) Has local stock been sold on, without the ability to replace it? Visit the market and collect price data. Did traders hold much stock, or relied on selling current stock before replacing it? What are the normal (pre-disaster) replacement times compared with the likely realities now? Use other secondary sources of market data (FAO, WFP, government). Historical market price bulletins. Identify the price levels of main food and key items and the quantities traded. Locate the main trade flows and market marketing actors. Be aware of normal seasonal price fluctuations as a normal increase at the time of the project may be misinterpreted as inflationary effect. Effect of cash distribution on demand. How has the shock affected the market system? Have warehouses been affected? Transport routes? Are there any barriers or restrictions to trade? How great are the stock losses? What are the overall trends in the quantities of commodities available? Are the markets functioning now? If not, how long are they expected to take to recover? Key informant interviews. Trader interviews: ask traders about market regulation. Are there any government restrictions of movement of commodities? Do traders face particular taxes on the purchase or movement of commodities? Trader interviews: ask local traders about their suppliers. Check if they think they can meet the demand and still provide high quality at reasonable prices. Regular price monitoring: This is an essential part of all projects that are using cash transfers as it provides information on whether recipients are able to purchase the commodities at reasonable prices throughout the project. Market Prices/availability What is the normal seasonal pattern of prices for the required items? How have these been impacted by the shock? Be aware of normal seasonal price fluctuations as a normal increase at the time of the project may be misinterpreted as inflationary effect. Effect of cash distribution on demand. What is the likely impact on the market prices if many recipients demand the same/similar items? Will traders be able to rapidly re-stock these items? Be aware of normal seasonal price fluctuations as a normal increase at the time of the project may be misinterpreted as inflationary effect Effect of cash distribution on demand Seasonal calendar. Trader interviews: Ask traders about price seasonality and about their supply chain. Ask them if they think they could cope with an increase in demand for their item/s. Would they be able to supply at a reasonable price? Market mapping (i.e. EMMA). Seasonal calendar. Trader interviews: Ask traders about price seasonality and about their supply chain. Ask them if they think they could cope with an increase in demand for their item/s. Would they be able to supply at a reasonable price? Market mapping (i.e. EMMA). Seasonal calendar. Trader interviews: Ask traders about price seasonality and about their supply chain. Ask them if they think they could cope with an increase in demand for their item/s. Would they be able to supply at a reasonable price? Market mapping (i.e. EMMA). Price trends/inflation Is the market undergoing inflation postdisaster? Could cash transfers cause or contribute to inflation of prices in the market? If cash is causing the inflation it Initially, market prices may increase due to the shock itself – e.g. increased transport costs, loss of stocks, difficulty getting to area etc. May need to check market prices in neighbouring markets. If a price rise is noted – is it because of the project or not? On-going price monitoring is required to check price Visit the market and conduct regular price monitoring. Record prices so they can be compared over time. Trader interviews. Coordination with other actors in the area. 2|P a g e disadvantages non-recipients because commodities are more expensive. If outside factors are causing inflation it disadvantages recipients because the cash being provided will not hold its value. movement. If prices are increasing: Discuss with traders to find out why price is increasing. There are a number of options to be considered depending on why prices are increasing. Increase cash grant. Change from cash to in-kind distribution. Market performance/competition How is the market performing? Market performance is a measure of the extent to which the market makes commodities and services available at affordable prices to meet demand. Market performance includes: Market structure: number of buyers and sellers, size of markets, volume of product traded Level of competition: the number of traders and the extent to which markets are competitive and allow entry by new actors, or are controlled by a few actors who monopolise power. Level of integration: how well is the market linked into larger markets? Availability of market services: especially banking, finance and credit, that affect the market system. Would more traders be prepared to start operating in the area if they knew there would be a CBI? When markets perform well, buyers are able to find what they need, when they need it, at a price that reflects the trader’s costs plus a reasonable trading profit. If there are several traders who trade the same commodity it is more likely that consumers (buyers) will get a good price. If traders are in competition, prices should increase only as much as costs for traders increase. If traders have market power however, prices can increase faster than costs increase. If the market is linked to outside markets that were not affected it is likely that it can restart fairly quickly. Market price data: Find out if prices of the required commodities were available at reasonable price before the shock. Trader interviews: Who were their suppliers were before the crisis? Can they restart their business? How many other traders there are, and of what size, in the market for their particular commodity. Does trade exist between markets and to what extent are markets integrated? If an emergency occurs and the market is not integrated, aid supplies may be needed because prices are too high for many of the poor households and new supplies may not arrive through markets. (NB: Calculate the difference in price between 2 markets, minus the cost of transporting commodities. If the price is higher than the cost of transporting, the market is not well integrated). If traders are unwilling to come in the area, then an in kind distribution would make more sense—also there may be a security risk or access issues which it will be important to find out about. If they are willing to come into the area, look at voucher or cash as this will help stimulate the market as well and have multiplier effects in the area. Ask traders if they would be interested and able to cope with an increase in demand. If there are any constraints, see if they can be addressed. Ask about the main constraints and risks they face and whether this discourages other traders. Market mapping (i.e. EMMA). Multiplier effects Is it likely that a cash injection will have a number of positive multiplier effects in the local economy? If the commodities that are purchase locally are also produced locally, multiplier effects are likely to be stronger. Market Mapping. Will Cash for Work projects impact on local labour markets? Usually a qualitative observation made after discussion with people involved in the market supply/value chain Market Mapping. Further Reading Emergency Market Mapping and Analysis Toolkit: http://emma-toolkit.org/ 3|P a g e