Dr. Dwayne Winseck
Professor, School of Journalism and Communications Carleton
University
Director, Canadian Media Concentration Research Project
www.cmcrp.org
Media + Broadband Use and Rankings in Select OECD
Countries, 2012
OECD
Country
Ranks
Canada
UK
Korea
US
Japan
Italy
France
Spain
Germany
Australia
New Zealand
Chile
Mexico
Online Min/ IP Traffic/ Smart Phone Tablet Data/ Online Video TV Viewing Facebook (%
User/Month Capita (GB) Data/Mo/ Mo/Device Viewing/Mo Min/Day
Pop)
User (MB)
(MB)
(min)
(2011)
2478
2238
1800
2580
1314
1110
1674
1428
1476
1116
1110
1176
1128
36
316
508
26
304
991
48
528
1544
40
201
382
18
232
957
8
61
644
18
315
970
12
306
724
13
72
533
18
141
469
14
174
464
11
78
479
5
104
352
1488
1870
2842
1308
2842
1208
248
246
231
293
231
257
Wikipedia
Rank/Top
Websites
53
7
52
9
21
16
53
6
14
6
38
7
1094
209
39
10
989
243
37
10
1299
216
31
9
49
8
45
8
54
6
33
7
670
666
765
710
Sources: OECD (2013); Cisco Visual Networking Index; Internetworldstats (2013).
193
205
165
165
Overall Rank
1
2
3
3
5
7
4
6
7
8
10
9
11
Household Access to Media and ICTs by Quintile, 2011.
100.0%
80.0%
60.0%
Phone
Cable/DTH/IPTV
Cellphone
40.0%
High Speed Internet
20.0%
0.0%
Lowest Quintile
Second Quintile
Third Quintile
Fourth Quintile
Highest Quintile
Sources: Statistics Canada (2012). Survey of Household Spending in 2011.
Share of Spectrum in Active Use (Antenna),
2013
Mobilicity
1%
Summary of Spectrum Holdings (PCS,
AWS & GBRS), 2012
Mobilicity
2%
PublicMobile
1%
MTS
SaskTel
1%
3%
Videotron
2%
Eastlink
1%
WIND
2%
Wind
2%
Sasktel Eastlink
1%
1%
Shaw
2% MTS
1%
Others
2%
Videotron
3%
Bell
26%
Telus
19%
Bell
29%
Telus
15%
Rogers
44%
Rogers
42%
Sources: Loxcel (data current as of Nov 14, 2013)
Wireless Service Area Map with Number of Cellcos.
Sources: CRTC (2012). CMR 2013, p.168
Cellcos Subscriber Share by Province, 2012
Province
Bell
Telus
Rogers
New Entrants
Other
HHI
BC
18
40
39
3
0
3454
AB
23
50
24
3
0
3614
SK
10
10
9
0
71
5322
MB
5
9
33
0
53
4004
ON
28
20
44
6
1
3157
QC
33
28
29
10
0
2814
NB
58
23
19
0
0
4254
NS
54
29
16
0
0
4013
PEI
58
27
15
0
0
4318
NL
73
25
2
0
0
5958
TER
90
0
0
0
10
8200
Average
36
26.1
23
22
62
4090.8
Source: CRTC Monitoring Report, 2013 Table 5.5.5. Average not including Territories.
Share of Spectrum in Active Use (Antenna) In Canada’s Biggest CMAs, 2012
80
70
60
Rogers
Percentage
50
Telus
Bell
40
Wind
Videotron
MTS
30
Mobilicity
PublicMobile
20
10
0
Toronto
Montreal
Vancouver
Ottawa Gatineau
Calgary
Edmonton
Quebec
Winnipeg
Sources: Loxcel (data current as of Nov 14, 2012)
Hamilton
Composite Capital Investment in Wireless Infrastructure (based on OECD + BAML GWR)
Wireless
Japan
Slovak Republic
Turkey
Czech Republic
Austria
Mexico
Italy
Belgium
Greece
Finland
Israel
Hungary
Korea
Chile
OECD
Estonia
Norway
Luxembourg
France
New Zealand
Australia
Germany
Denmark
Canada
Portugal
Ireland
US
Netherlands
Sweden
Poland
UK
Spain
Switzerland
Iceland
Slovenia
Composite Rank Mobile Capex
(OECD)
1
3
4
6
2
7
9
11
10
16
8
12
23
5
20
14
13
15
18
26
17
31
28
27
34
19
30
25
22
21
33
32
35
29
24
Composite Rank (BoA) Mobile Capex Composite Mobile Rank (OECD+BoA)
3
3
5
6
11
7
7
7
12
6
14
12
2
20
6
14
16
15
13
5
15
1
8
9
4
19
10
16
19
21
11
18
17
29
24
Sources: OECD Investment in cellular mobile infrastructure in the OECD area Table 3.9; BAML Global Wireless Report
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
9
10
11
12
12
13
14
15
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
22
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Final Composite Wireline Ranking: Penetration, Speed, Price (34 Countries)
Country
Korea
Denmark
Germany
Estonia
Japan
Netherlands
Sweden
France
Iceland
Switzerland
Belgium
Finland
United Kingdom
Slovak Republic
Austria
Czech Republic
Luxembourg
Israel
Hungary
Norway
Portugal
Canada
United States
Slovenia
Italy
Greece
Poland
Australia
Spain
New Zealand
Ireland
Turkey
Chile
Mexico
Penetration per
100 Population
(OECD)1
4
3
9
22
17
2
12
5
7
1
10
14
8
31
19
29
13
20
28
6
26
11
15
23
27
24
30
18
21
16
25
34
32
33
Rank by Actual Rank by Mean Cost Rank by Composite
Mean Download
of Monthly BB
of 6 Price Baskets
Speeds (FCC)2
Plans (FCC)2
(OECD)1
Final Wireline Rank
1
2
1
1
6
10
6
2
12
1
8
3
7
3
4
4
5
9
5
4
3
16
18
6
2
4
21
6
18
5
20
8
10
8
24
9
4
34
14
10
8
18
18
11
20
7
13
11
24
14
8
11
15
15
2
14
23
13
10
15
13
11
16
16
9
22
26
17
27
12
12
18
21
20
3
19
16
23
31
20
11
24
17
21
19
26
25
22
14
30
27
23
25
31
7
23
31
6
23
25
30
19
15
26
26
21
11
26
22
28
22
28
17
27
33
29
28
29
27
30
29
25
30
31
33
17
29
32
32
32
32
33
34
33
34
34
Final Composite Wireless Ranking: Penetration, Speed, Price (33 Countries)
Country
Denmark
Finland
Sweden
Norway
Poland
Korea
Austria
Japan
Australia
United States
Luxembourg
Slovenia
Iceland
Czech Republic
Germany
Slovak Republic
Estonia
Canada
Ireland
France
Italy
Turkey
Spain
Switzerland
Greece
New Zealand
Portugal
United Kingdom
Netherlands
Hungary
Israel
Chile
Mexico
Penetration per
100 Population
(OECD)1
5
1
2
8
15
4
18
7
3
6
9
30
12
20
27
28
11
25
14
23
21
32
19
17
24
10
26
13
15
33
22
31
34
Advertised
Price: Monthly
Download Speed Plan and Cost per
(OECD)1
GB of Data (FCC)2 Composite Rank
1
4
1
7
12
2
8
10
2
5
15
4
3
11
5
4
22
6
9
7
7
15
15
8
23
12
9
15
17
9
29
3
11
11
2
12
30
1
12
17
8
14
11
8
15
14
5
16
26
14
17
2
27
18
21
22
19
17
18
20
13
25
21
21
6
21
19
21
21
26
18
24
6
32
25
24
28
25
10
30
27
30
24
28
25
31
29
19
20
30
32
26
31
29
29
32
32
32
33
Final Industry Ranking: Wireless + Wireline, for Penetration, Speed, Price
Country
Denmark
Korea
Sweden
Japan
Finland
Germany
Estonia
Iceland
Austria
Norway
France
Luxembourg
Czech Republic
Slovak Republic
Poland
United States
Switzerland
Netherlands
Slovenia
Australia
United Kingdom
Canada
Italy
Portugal
Hungary
Israel
Ireland
Spain
Greece
Turkey
New Zealand
Chile
Mexico
Sources: OECD, FCC
Final Wireless Rank
1
6
2
8
2
15
17
12
7
4
20
11
14
16
5
9
24
29
12
9
28
18
21
27
30
31
19
21
25
21
25
32
33
Final Wireline Rank
2
1
6
4
11
3
4
9
15
20
8
17
16
14
26
23
10
6
23
28
11
22
25
21
19
18
31
29
26
32
30
33
34
Final Top-Level Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
7
9
10
11
11
13
13
15
16
17
13
18
19
21
22
23
24
25
25
27
27
29
30
31
32
33
Average Revenue Per User by Country (OECD), 1998-2012
800
US
Canada
Linear (Canada)
700
600
500
United Kingdom
Linear (OECD)
France
400
Canada
300
United States
G7
200
OECD
100
Linear (Canada)
Linear (OECD)
0
1998
1999
2000
Sources: OECD (2013).
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Operating Profits, Rogers, BCE and Telus vs Canadian Industry Average, 1990-2012
25
BCE
20
Rogers
15
Telus
10
AVG All Industries
5
0
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
2010
2011
Sources: Corporate Annual Reports + Statistics Canada Summary Table - Operating profit margin by industries
2012
Bell, Rogers, Telus & Canada EBITA vs OECD + G7
50%
40%
OECD Average
G7 Average
Canada
30%
G7 Average
OECD Avg
Bell Wireless
Rogers
20%
Telus
10%
0%
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012