Test Blueprinting: How to Build a Good Multiple Choice Test Item Presented by Amy Thibaut Director of Social Studies Spring Branch ISD World History 2nd six weeks 26 Instructional days/50 question test Topic Early India, China and Africa completed Suggested Timeframe 1 day % of Six # of Test Weeks Items 3.8% 2 Byzantine and Islamic Civilizations 10 days 38% 19 Middle Ages 15 days 57.6% 29 •% of days spent on a topic makes up what % of six weeks? •% of test questions should match % of six weeks spent on topic. How do we figure this? • # of days taught ÷ # of instructional days = % of six weeks spent on topic •Total # of items x % of weeks = # of topic items to be included on test Parts of a test item: The Stimulus •Any item that is used to answer the question •Not required of every question The stem •Poses the question The Distracter • Answer Choices Linking Items to Objective Items must measure what they purport to measure. • Use the objective as the guide to write the item • Use the objective to evaluate the item • Use content-specific terminology appropriate for the targeted grade level 8.20 Citizenship. The student understands the rights and responsibilities of citizens of the United States. The student is expected to : (B) summarize rights guaranteed in the Bill of Rights; Among the rights guaranteed by the First Amendment is the right to A. the free exercise of religion B. keep and bear arms C. due process of law D. a speedy and public trial Is this question aligned to the TEKS? Checking for Alignment • Get into groups by content group • Using the handout with 15 TAKS items and TEKS Correlations, read each question and determine if it is aligned to the TEKS listed at the end of the question. • How could the question be changed to make it more aligned to the TEKS? Qualities of a Good Multiple-Choice Item • Measures the skill for which it is written • Present the problem or question as clearly as possible • Has only one best and correct answer • Is as straightforward and concise as possible • Has four choices that are parallel in structure and logical • Contains option that are plausible, but incorrect • Is written in such a way that it is grade-appropriate So you’re the little woman who wrote the book that made this great war! Abraham Lincoln to Harriet Beecher Stowe, 1862 To which book is President Lincoln referring in the excerpt above? A. Uncle Tom’s Cabin B. The Wealth of Nations C. Democracy in America D. McGuffey’s Eclectic Reader Qualities of a Bad Multiple-Choice Item • Tests trivial information • Contains unnecessary/confusing information in the stem or options • Is tricky or cute • Gives clues (cues) to the correct answer (Clang associations) • Poses a question for which many defensible answers are possible • Contains a bias toward or against a group of individuals Which of the following kings of England was so bad that no king of England will name his son in honor of him? A. King William the Conqueror B. King Henry VIII C. King Charles II D. King John Critique the question Is there a Clang Association? Is it trivia? Effective Stems are… •focused on one idea •clear and concise •phrased as a direct question •phrased positively Writing Convincing Response Options • Use only one best, clearly correct answer • Develop plausible distracters • Use homogeneous answer choices • Avoid clues • Be efficient Use only one best, clearly correct answer • Avoid answer choices that overlap. • Avoid answer choices that are subsets of another option. • Avoid answer choices that could be defended as equally correct. Develop plausible distracters Plausible distracters include… • common misconceptions. • statements that sound logical but that are not based on the material given in the stimulus and question. • common or familiar phrases. • statements that are true but that do not answer the question. Use homogeneous answer choices Answer choices should be parallel in terms of content, structure, and length. • Distracters should be in the same form as the key. • No answer option should stand out. Be Efficient Answer choices should be brief. No longer than a sentence Repeated phrases should be placed into the stem • During the mid-1800s the expanding U.S. economy required better methods of communication. Communications were improved significantly by Samuel Morse’s invention of the A. Typewriter B. Telephone C. Telegraph D. phonograph Answer choices should be organized. • Alphabetical • Ascending or descending order • Shortest to longest • Same order as presented in stimulus Speaker 1: The government must give accused persons the right to a quick and public trial. Speaker 2: The government should not force citizens to house soldiers in their homes. Speaker 3: People should be allowed to peacefully protest actions of the government. Speaker 4: People should not be deprived of their property without fair payment. Which speaker is voicing a right guaranteed by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution? A. Speaker 1 B. Speaker 2 C. Speaker 3 D. Speaker 4 Writing Convincing Response Options: Additional Considerations • Avoid use of “none of the above,” “all of the above,” or “I don’t know” • Avoid use of negative words in the answer options • Balance the keys Sensitivity Be aware of issues that are emotionally upsetting or distracting to an examinee • Death or severe illness • Extremes in socioeconomic conditions • Unfair representation of groups • Controversial topics Fairness Provide an equal opportunity for success • Item measures the intended objective • Content, context, and vocabulary are age and grade-level appropriate • Groups treated with dignity and respect Use homogeneous answer choices Distracter Guidelines If the key contains: Then distracters should NOT contain: A long phrase or sentence Short phrases or sentences A general rule Specific instances A complete statement Incomplete statements A means to an end End product Simple, common language Professional jargon Unqualified words or Qualifying words statements Negative descriptions Positive descriptions Use a variety of stimuli • • • • • • • • • • • Textbox of primary source material Graphs and Charts Pictures or illustrations Spoke Diagrams Multiple visuals: comparison maps, charts Political Cartoons Time lines Flow Charts Graphic designs Headlines Speaker Questions You Analyze the Question: • Using the handout provided, identify the problems, if any, you see with the test design of each question. Which of the following was not a characteristic of Greek art? A. It symbolized the pride of the people in their citystate. B. It expressed Greek love for harmony, balance, order, and moderation. C. It combined beauty and usefulness. D. It stressed the importance of the gods and the unimportance of humans. Rousseau: Man is born free, yet everywhere he is in chains. The government is created by a contract among the people and receives its powers from them. The government exits to serve the people, and when it no longer does so, the people may change it. Locke: All men have certain natural rights; the right to life, liberty, and property. The purpose of government is to protect these rights. If it fails to do so, the people may set up a new government. Voltaire: It is to him who masters our minds by the force of truth, not to those who enslave men by violence…that we owe our reverence. Popular government is in itself, therefore, less (unjust), less (hated) then despotic power. Montesquieu: There is no liberty if the judicial power is not separated from the legislative and executive branches. According to the theories of Locke and Rousseau, how did government originate? A. A social contract – an agreement among people. B. By God’s command C. By royal decree D. By elections held among the upper classes Rousseau: Man is born free, yet everywhere he is in chains. The government is created by a contract among the people and receives its powers from them. The government exits to serve the people, and when it no longer does so, the people may change it. Locke: All men have certain natural rights; the right to life, liberty, and property. The purpose of government is to protect these rights. If it fails to do so, the people may set up a new government. Voltaire: It is to him who masters our minds by the force of truth, not to those who enslave men by violence…that we owe our reverence. Popular government is in itself, therefore, less (unjust), less (hated) then despotic power. Montesquieu: There is no liberty if the judicial power is not separated from the legislative and executive branches. What was Montesquieu’s opinion of the French system of government before the revolution? A. It was perfect just the way it was. B. There was no liberty because there was no separation of powers C. The legislative branch was fine but the executive branch was weak. D. The executive branch was fine but the legislative branch was Which of the following is a definition of technology? A. the application of knowledge for practical ends B. the investigation of natural phenomena C. items created by artisans D. none of the above Which of the following is an example of technology? A. irrigation canals B. stone ax C.computers D. all of the above Karl Marx believed A. socialism could be achieved by peaceful progress B. socialism was inevitable because capitalism would selfdestruct C. socialism should reward the economic skills of the upper class D. socialism was an impossible solution to difficult times The leader of the Bolsheviks who successfully led the communist take-over of Russia was A. Vittorio Orlando B. Nicolai Lenin C.Leo Tolstoy D. James Joyce What is considered the first act of military aggression in World War II? A. The invasion of Ethiopia by Italy B. The invasion of China by Japan C. The invasion of Russia by Germany D. The attack of Pearl Harbor The Truman Doctrine said that the U.S. would help any country fighting against communism. This idea was popular because it would “bottle up” the communists. Therefore, it introduced the concept of A. appeasement B. isolationism C.containment D. imperialism