Advancements in gender statistics and health: experiences from the Western Pacific Region

Anjana Bhushan, Technical Officer (Health in Development)

WHO/WPRO

3 rd Global Forum on Gender Statistics

Manila, 11-13 October 2010

ESA/STAT/AC.219/34

Keys to accelerating the development and better use of gender statistics

• Strengthening vital events monitoring with causes of death, through existing civil registration systems, demographic surveillance sites, or hospital statistics

• Harmonizing health surveys through a country-led national plan with increased focus on gender, equity, and social determinants for health

• Improving the timeliness, completeness and quality of facility- and survey-generated disaggregated data

• Developing a multi-sector culture of disaggregated data collection for deriving gender statistics and use aligned with national M&E and HIS frameworks

• Ensuring skills and capacity available for presentation, interpretation, dissemination, and use of gender statistics with different target audiences

Example 1: Proposed maternal and U5 death surveillance system, Lao PDR

Background

• Based on Cambodia experience

• 2005 Lao PDR census: about 2 maternal deaths; 36 under-five child deaths, including 26 infant deaths (71% of U5MR), every day

• Vital registration not functioning

• Routine reporting/surveillance system unreliable

• Provincial/district hospitals report deaths, but only about 13% births in health facilities (2005)

• Mobile phone network used by 60% of rural families

Objectives (May 2010-March 2011)

• Provide timely information on maternal and child deaths, followed by death review

• Monitor MNCH trends and strengthen achievement of MDGs 4, 5

• Inform MNCH programme planning, policy development and interventions' targeting

Proposed approaches

(1) Case reports

– By villagers, village health volunteers, health workers, witnesses

– Report all maternal and child (under-5) deaths anywhere

– Set up toll-free landline at central level for case reporting

– Encourage reporting through:

– government circular to all districts, health centers and village committees

– mass media campaign

– incentives to reporters

(2) Case records

– Call related health center to verify report, collect more information and enter into computer Epi-Info program

– Health centers to keep copy of death confirmation sheet for regular reporting and death audit

(3) Information utilization

– Update summary of records weekly on national map, by written report, on

MOH website

– Set up maternal and child death information room in Ministry of Health

– Analyze data and report monthly to MOH, provinces, districts

– Conduct maternal and neonatal death review and report annually

– Incorporate the surveillance system into HMIS

MCHC Team

MOH Info Room

Regular reports

MOH

– HMIS website

Example 2: Understanding gender-based violence in the Pacific

Background

WHO Multi-country Study on Women's Health and Domestic Violence

Against Women 2005

– gathered comparable data from over 24 000 women interviewed in 15 sites in 10 countries (including Japan, New Zealand, Samoa [Polynesia])

– found that VAW is widespread, with far-reaching health consequences, and demands a public health response

– called on governments to take concerted action, recommended actions for health, education, criminal justice sectors

Objectives

– estimate the prevalence of violence against women, with particular emphasis on physical, sexual and emotional violence by male intimate partners;

– assess the extent to which intimate partner violence is associated with a range of health outcomes;

– identify factors that may either protect or put women at risk of partner violence

– document and compare the strategies and services that women use to deal with violence by an intimate partner

Using the methodology in the Pacific

Socio-Cultural Research on Gender-Based Violence and Child

Abuse in Melanesia (Kiribati, 2008) and Micronesia (Solomon

Islands, 2008-09) project (funded by UNFPA, AusAID; implemented by SPC)

Kiribati: National representative study on intimate partner violence (Kiribati Family Health and Support Study), 2008

• Findings:

– 68% of ever-partnered women reported experiencing at least one act of physical or sexual violence, or both, by an intimate partner; 73% of all women aged 15-49 have experienced some form of physical or sexual violence, either by a partner or a non-partner

– VAW has a devastating impact on women, their families and communities

– Unequal power relations between men and women are the root cause

• Legal framework

: no specific domestic violence/VAW and VAW not addressed appropriately in existing laws

• Services

: Social Welfare Unit: day-to-day services, counseling; limited capacity; few NGOs active; limited reach and capacity; Catholic Women’s

Crisis Centre: shelter and care; underutilized due to social and cultural barriers faced by victims

Using the methodology in the Pacific

Kiribati

• Government response:

– Family Affairs and Sexual Offences Unit established in 2004 to manage cases of domestic violence, rape, abuse and other sexual offences

– Study endorsed by government, launched by President

– National Action Plan for elimination of VAW developed, policy being drafted

Partners’ response:

• Support to multi-sectoral VAW action :

• AusAID/WHO Gender Health and Development Programme, 2010-11

(Solomon Islands)

• Planned M ulti-year UN Joint Programme to EVAW, 2011 (Kiribati)

• Pacific UNiTE Campaign to End Violence Against Women

• Additional studies using WHO methodology: Vanuatu (nearing completion); Fiji: (commencing)

Example 3: Gender in the national TB programme review, Viet Nam

Findings:

• M/F ratio in TB cases increased from 1.6

to

2.1

• Why?

– Partly: biological/ epidemiological factors

– Partly: genderrelated barriers to access

4000

3500

3000

Trends in SM+

Viet Nam: 1990-1999)

2500

2000

1500

1000

500

0

1990 1992 1994 1996 1998

Male

Female

Viet Nam NTP findings

• Women have longer delay before diagnosis, because:

– they may consult less-qualified health care providers or self-medicate

– they may face barriers to access: distance and mobility

– they are less likely to present with ‘typical’ symptoms

• Women may produce sputum of poorer quality and quantity, decreasing their chances of diagnosis

Example 4: Other promising developments in Viet Nam

• General Statistics Office and line ministries, with UNDP’s support, are developing a M&E framework for the implementation of:

– the Law on Gender Equality

– the Law on Domestic Violence Control

• General Statistics Office, with WHO’s support, is finalizing the first national study on violence against women

• National Strategy on Gender Equality (2011-2020) and

National Targeted Programme for Gender Equality (2011-

15) are under development

• Joint Annual Health Review includes key indicators to assess health sector, including some on gender and health issues (e.g., sex ratio at birth, gender-based violence)

Example 5: Women’s health in the

Western Pacific Region

• Women's Health: Western Pacific Region , 2001.

– Contains country profiles

– Reviews progress and lessons learned in implementing Beijing

Declaration and Platform for Action (1995)

– Identifies constraints, priority areas, and areas of collaboration among partners

• Women and Health: Today’s Evidence, Tomorrow’s Agenda ,

2009.

– provides evidence on women's health needs and challenges over the lifecourse

– includes latest figures on health and leading causes of death in women.

• Agenda item on “Women’s health” , Western Pacific Regional

Committee Meeting, Oct 2010. Key messages:

– Women face distinct health needs through the lifecycle

– There are multiple determinants of women’s health

– Health systems are failing women

– The unfinished agenda can—and should—be addressed, through multisectoral action, health systems strengthening, and partnerships

• Women and Health in the Western Pacific Region , planned 2011: new regional report on women and health

Priorities for improving national HIS in the Western Pacific Region

• Advancing countries along

HIS continuum

• Improving data collection, analysis, quality, and use

• Providing better training, tools, and techniques

• Improving interoperability of databases and systems

Thank you