Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE
BANGALORE
Minutes of the 199h Meeting of SRC held at the
Conference Hall of NCTE, Bangalore from 22nd & 23rd December, 2010
The following members attended the Meeting:1.
Prof. C. Thangamuthu
-
Chairman
2
Prof. C. Seshadri
-
Member
3
Prof. P.J. Poulose
-
Member
4.
Prof.C.H.Vijayalakshmi
-
Member
5.
Prof. Sudhakar.
-
Member
6.
Fahmida Rahim (Karnataka) Deputy Director
Representative
(Attended both days i.e 22nd & 23.12.2010)
7
Mr. Kuruvilla John I.A.S
Principal Secretary Kerala
-
Representative, (Attended on 23.12.2010)
8
S.Uma. Joint Director (TN)
-
Representative ( Attended on 23.12.2010)
9.
Sri. Gangadharaiah
-
Convenor
The following members could not attend the Meeting :-
Prof. Syeda Akthar, Member, Prof. C.L. Anand Member & Representatives of
Pradesh, and U.T’s of Lakshadweep, Pondicherry & Andaman & NICO bar Islands
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
the Andhra
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
1
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE
NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION
BANGALORE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Minutes of 199th Meeting of SRC, NCTE
Sl.
Brief Description
Remarks of SRC
Confirmation of Minutes of 198th meeting
Confirmed
No.
1.
held on 24th-26th November 2010
2.
Noted
Action Taken Report (ATR) on the Minutes
of 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
2010
Inspection Report – Shifting Cases:
Sl.
No
Code
Remarks of SRC
Course
Name of the
Institution
3.
State
APS02114
D.Ed
KLS Teacher
Training
Institute,
Bangalore
KA
KLS Teacher Training institute, No.2, Manjunath Complex, Konappana Agrahara,
Hosur Road, Bangalore – 560 100, Karnataka has submitted application to SRC on
31.12.2003 for D.Ed course. Recognition has been granted by SRC for offering D.Ed
course with an intake of 50 students on 30.11.2004.
The institution was issued with a letter seeking documents for shifting of premises on
25.05.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 17.06.2009 and the same has been
included in the list of institutions where inspections have to be carried out for shifting
of premises.
The institution has submitted a letter on 29.01.2010 and has requested this office to
sanction No Objection permission for making correspondence in the new premises
address.
Further, the institution submitted fee for causing inspection on 06.02.2009. We have
not been able to conduct the inspection due to administrative reasons. Now, the
institution wants us to issue permission to use proposed address of the institution for
various communications with different departments.
The SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-30 March 2010 considered the reply of the
institution and decided to withdraw recognition. Accordingly, recognition was
withdrawn on 07.05.2010.
The institution preferred appeal against the withdrawal order to NCTE, Hqrs. The
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
2
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Appellate Authority has reversed the withdrawal order of SRC vide order dated
27.09.2010 with a direction to SRC to cause an inspection of the institution’s new
premises. Accordingly, inspection was carried on 12.11.2010 and the detailed VT
report is attached:
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :
 The total built up area as per VT report for D.Ed is only 10812 Sq.ft. which is
inadequate. As per the NCTE norms, 16,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for
D.Ed course.
 The No. of Library books in Library is 1844, which is inadequate as per NCTE
norms.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 Psychology lab, other labs / Physical education needs to be strengthened.
 Out of six faculty members, two members are not having the requisite
qualification (only B.Ed qualification) and one staff is having less than 50%
marks in M.A.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
4.
APS03593
APS08625
B.Ed
B.Ed-AI
Bethlahem
College of
Education,
Kanyakumari
TN
Nesamony Memorial Trust, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu submitted an application for
grant of recognition in the name of Bethlahem College of Education, Karungal,
Kanyakumari District-629157, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course on 27.12.2004.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and the recognition
was granted to the institution vide order dated 22.11.2005 with certain stipulated
conditions.
As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009, the office of
SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted recognition
either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises.
A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 181 st
meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution
which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
3
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit following
documents. The institution submitted its reply on 25.08.2010 stating that the
management decided to shift the institution to the permanent premises and started
the construction works. It is in the finishing stage of white washing and coloring, but
due to heavy rain in our district for the last six months, they are unable to finish the
building as planned. It will take some more time to complete the building. Hence the
institution requested to depute the inspection team after the completion of the
building.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The institution is also running B.Ed-AI & M.Ed course in the same premises.(no inspection
conducted for M.Ed course)
The initial proposal for recognition was at Sy.No. 611/15D2, 615/2,3D,616/1,3
Karungal, Paloor, Thipramalai, Kanyakumari as per Building Plan.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed & B.Ed – Al, is to be submitted.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
5.
APS04978
D.T.Ed
C.K.S.
College of
Education,
Vellore
TN
C.K.S. Educational Trust, Vellore, Tamilnadu submitted application for grant of
recognition to C.K.S. Teacher Training Institute, No.75, Railway Station Road,
Gudiyattam, Vellore District-632602, Tamilnadu for D.T.Ed course on 02.01.2006.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and the recognition
was granted to the institution vide order dated 23.10.2006 with certain stipulated
conditions.
The State Government of Tamilnadu vide letter No.6987/U1-80-1 dated 20.03.2008
has informed certain irregularities by self-financing Teacher Training Institutions and
recommended withdrawal of recognition for such institutions. The SRC considered
the letter in its 157th meeting held on 23-24th April 2008 and decided to issue notice
under section of NCTE Act. Accordingly notice under section 17 was issued to the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
4
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
institution on 17.06.2008. The institution submitted its reply on 16.07.2008.
SRC considered the reply in its 165th meeting held on 18th-19th October 2008 and
decided to cause inspection of the institution under section 17 of NCTE Act, to verify
the vericity of the compliance as claimed by the institution and also the structural
modifications/improvement/shifting to new building as claimed, on payment of reinspection fee of Rs.40000//- by the institution.
Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs.40000/- on 27.10.2008.
The institution submitted its reply on 11.11.2008 alongwith Rs.40000/-.
Meanwhile as per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
lease premises. A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action.
Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit following
documents. The institution submitted its reply on 23.08.2010 alongwith photocopies
of certain documents.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The management has not shown exclusively earmarked built up area for the
B.Ed programme which is also being run in the same building/campus. As
per VT report the built up area shown only for D.T.Ed programme is 16064
sq.ft. As per NCTE norms, a total built up area of 27,000 Sq.ft is required for
both B.Ed and D.T.Ed.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 Educational Technology lab needs to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
5
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
6.
APS03672
D.T.Ed
Mahendhira
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Salem
TN
Mahendhira Teacher Training Institute, Salem, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for
offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 17.11.2006 with the condition
to shift to own premises within 3 years.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action.
Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010. The institution has
submitted reply to this notice on 20.08.2010.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The institution is also running B.Ed course in the same premises. inspection of the
institution for B.Ed course already conducted on 13.09.2010 and placed in 197th SRC
meeting held on 13-14th October 2010 and decided to seek clarification. Reply not yet
received
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per VT report, the management is running D.T.Ed programmes along with
B.E course in the same campus, which is not permissible as per NCTE
norms. A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that
no other programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same
building / Campus, along with the existing Teacher Education Programme, is
to be submitted.
 Language leaning lab is not available.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
7.
APS05181
D.T.Ed
Durai
Murugan
Teacher
Training
Durai Murugan Educational Trust, Durai Murugan Teacher Training Institute, Vellore,
Tamilnadu has submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 02.01.2006.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 27.07.2007 for annual intake of 50 students.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
6
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Institute,
Vellore
TN
The institution vide letter dated 23.07.2010 informed that “as per the clause No.3(ii),
we have shifted from the rented premises at No.7, First East Main Road,
Gandhinagar, Vellore-632006 to own permanent premises with effect from 1st July
2010 at Duraimurugan Teacher Training Institute, Chitoor Main Road, Vellore632059”
As directed, a letter was issued to the institution on 11.08.2010 to submit the
documents. The institution vide letter dated 30.08.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- as
inspection fee for shifting of premises. The institution has not submitted any other
documents.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection of the institution was done on 17.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per VT report, the management is running Teacher Education Programme
in a multistoryed structure building. Basement floor and ground floors are
being used for D.Ed and B.Ed programmes. The remaining floors are being
used for running other programmes other than TEP, which is not permitted
as per NCTE norms.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
Campus along with the existing Course D.T.Ed and B.Ed course, is to be
submitted.
 Non-encumbrance Certificate submitted is in Tamil version, English version
of the same is to be submitted.
 Psychology lab is being shared with B.Ed course students, which is not
sufficient, to be strengthened.
 FDRs of Rs. 5 Lakhs and 3 Lakhs in joint names is to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
7
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
8.
APS04999
B.Ed
Durai
Murugan
College of
Education,
Vellore
TN
Durai Murugan College of Education, Vellore, Tamilnadu has submitted an
application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 30.12.2005.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed course was
granted on 27.08.2007 for annual intake of 100 students.
The institution in its letter dated 24.08.2010 stated as follows:
“We would like to inform you that as per the clause no.3(ii) laid down in the above
referred order, we have shifted from the rented premises at no.7, first East Main
Road, Gandhinagar, Vellore-632006 to the following own premises.
Durai Murugan College of Education
Chittoor Main Road
Vellore 632059
This is for your necessary further proceedings.”
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises on payment of
Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee.
Accordingly a letter has been issued to the institution to submit inspection fee of
Rs.40000/-. The institution vide letter dated 20.08.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- as
inspection fee for shifting of premises. .
The inspection was done on 17.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per VT report, the management is running T.E.P programmes in a
multistoryed building. Basement floor and ground floors are being used for
D.Ed and B.Ed programmes. The remaining floors are being used for running
other programmes other than TEP, which is not permitted as per NCTE
norms.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing D.T.Ed and B.Ed courses, is to be
submitted.
 Non-encumbrance Certificate submitted is in Tamil version, English version
of the same is to be submitted.
 Psychology lab is being shared with B.Ed course students, which is not
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
8
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
sufficient, to be strengthened.
 FDRs of Rs. 5 Lakhs and 3 Lakhs in joint names is to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
9.
APS00934
D.T.Ed
Sri Jayendra
Saraswathi
Swamiji
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Kanchipuram
TN
Sri Jayendra Saraswathi Swamiji Teacher Training Institute, Kancheepuram,
Tamilnadu has submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 31.12.2002.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 25.02.2004 for annual intake of 50 students.
The institution in its letter dated 23.08.2010 stated as follows
“ We are submitting herewith a Demand Draft bearing No.810227 dated 29.7.2010 for
Rs.40000/-(Forty Thousand) only in favour of Member Secretary, NCTE-Bangalore.
The amount being towards your charges for our new building and classrooms
constructions for the uise of Sri Jayendra Saraswathi Swamiji Teacher Training
Institute, Enathur, Kanchipuram-Tamilnadu.
We humbly request you to accept the Demand Draft and do the needful for our
Teacher Training Institute in this regard”.
In the recognition order, which was issued, to the institution on 28.02.2004, the
committee has noted that the institution will ensure that the permanent building is
constructed within a period of 3 years on the acquired land.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection was carried out on 18.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 Land documents with survey Nos of the land where the institution is to be
shifted are not submitted
 Address of the land as per questionnaire is to be submitted.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
9
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
competent Govt. authority
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
10.
APS03165
B.Ed
Bharathi
College of
Education,
Villupuram
Elayaperumal Educational & Charitable Trust, Salem, Tamilnadu submitted
application for grant of recognition to Bharathi College of Education, Near Power
House, Salem Chennai Main Road, Chinnasalem-606201, Villupuram, Tamilnadu for
B.Ed course on 03.02.2004.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and the recognition
was granted to the institution vide order dated 01.02.2006 with certain stipulated
conditions.
TN
As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009, the office of
SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted recognition
either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises.
A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 181 st
meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution
which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit following
documents. The institution submitted its reply on 01.09.2010 alongwith photocopies
of certain documents and questionnaire regarding infrastructure and instructional
facilities filled up. The institution paid a shifting fee of Rs. 40,000/- on 10.8.2010. The
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
10
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
institution is also running D.T.Ed course in the same building.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection was carried out on 15.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  It is observed from the VCD that the building where the B.Ed and D.T.Ed
programes are run is imcomplete.
 institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a competent
Govt. authority
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
11.
APS05312
D.T.Ed
Sri
Venkateshw
ara Teacher
Training
Institute,
Thiruvallur
Sri Venkateshwara Teacher Training Institute, Thiruvallur, Tamilnadu has submitted
an application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 02.01.2006.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 17.11.2006 for annual intake of 50 students. As per the recognition
order the institution was required to shift to its own premises within three years from
date of recognition.
The institution in its letter dated 23.08.2010 has stated as follows
“Sri Venkateshwara Teacher Training Institute, K.G. Kandigai has been recognized
by NCTE on 17.11.2006 and approved by DTERT on 09.03.2007.
TN
As per the rules and regulations of the above order, the own building has been
constructed after getting approval from local authority to a plinth area of 9500 sq.ft .
Fixing of doors and windows will be completed with in a month and shifting process
will be completed on or before 30.10.2010.
We will send DD of Rs.40000/- in favour of Member Secretary, NCTE-SRC,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
11
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Bangalore for getting permission to shift the institute to the newly constructed building
in Survey.No.157/8E3 of SVG Puram Village in Pallipet Taluk, Thiruvallur District,
Tamilnadu.
This we submit for favour of getting extension of time upto 30.10.2010 to occupy in
the newly constructed RCC building”.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection was carried out on19.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :
 The total built up area as per VT report for D.T.Ed is 10430 Sq.ft. which is
inadequate. As per the NCTE norms, 16,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required
for D.T.Ed course.
 As per the VCD and all the relevant documents, it is clear that the building
is incomplete.
 Land documents with survey Nos of the land where the institution is to be
shifted are not submitted
 Questionnaire is not submitted.
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land usage certificate from a
competent Govt. authority
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authority to be submitted.
 Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
12
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 The Language learning lab is not available.
 Education Technology lab is not shifted from the old building.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
12.
APS05042
B.Ed
SKB Educational Trust, Chennai, Tamilnadu submitted application for grant of
recognition to SKB College of Education, Pudur Village, Kunnavalam Post, Tiruvallur,
Tamilnadu for B.Ed course on 29.12.2005.
SKB College
of Education,
Thiruvallur
TN
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and the recognition
was granted to the institution vide order dated 30.08.2006 with certain stipulated
conditions.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of India, based
on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed NCTE for
taking action. In this regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC
in its 116th meeting held 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected and the
maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.
The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions which was granted recognition
in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under section 17
of the above institution was carried out on 17.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original
application file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
meeting held on 16-17th February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section
17 of NCTE Act, for the deficiencies noted. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
institution on 02.04.2009.
The institution submitted its reply on 29.05.2009, which was considered by SRC in its
180th meeting held on 29th July 2009 and SRC decided to seek for clarification.
Accordingly clarification letter was issued to the institution on 03.09.2009. the
institution submitted its reply on 07.09.2009.
Meanwhile as per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
lease premises. A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
13
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action.
Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit following
documents. The institution submitted its reply on 01.09.2010 alongwith photocopies
of certain documents.
The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection of the institution was carried out on 19.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The approved building plan is not clear and total builtup space is not
mentioned. English version of the plan is required.
 The institute has not submitted the Land usage certificate
from a
competent Govt. authority.
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authority to be submitted.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 Salaries are paid by cash and not through Bank.
 As per VCD the building, where T.E.P is being run appears to be as an
Hospital annexe, which may be clarified.
13.
APS04657
B.Ed
Dr.
Rajalakshni
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
Dr. Rajalakshmi college of education, Avadi, Chennai has submitted an application
for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 30.11.2005.
The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued on 26.5.2006 on
the following deficiencies;
 Registered land documents submitted in the name of individual and not in the
name of Trust/Society/Institution
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
14
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
College of
Education,
Chennai
TN
 Lease period of the land is less than 30 years.
 Building plan in original duly approved by the competent authority namely
Municipality/corporation/Gram Panchayat is not submitted.
 Fixed deposit receipt (FDR) in original for Rs. 5.00 lakhs towards endowment
fund has not been submitted.
 Fixed deposit receipt(FDR) in original for Rs. 3 lakhs towards Reserve fund has
not been submitted.
 An affidavit on Rs 100 stamp paper duly attested by the Oath Commissioner
stating the precise location of the land(village, district, state etc.) the total area in
possession and the permission of the competent authority to use the land for
educational purposes, mode of possession i.e. Ownership or lease has not been
furnished.
 Web site has not been launched by the institution.
The institution has submitted written representation on 30.8.2006.
The reply of the institution was scrutinised and found that some more additional
documents were not complete. Accordingly, final reminder was issued on 23.5.2007.




Building plan in original approved by competent authority is not submitted.
Fixed deposit towards Reserve fund of Rs. 3 lakhs is not submitted.
An affidavit of Rs. 100 stamp paper approved by notary is not submitted
Website has not been launched.
5. Accordingly, the institution has submitted reply on 5.6.2007 and also court order in
W.P. No. 12762 of 2006, the court has given the direction as follows; “….. the
respondent to consider the application of the petitioner and pass orders on merits and
in accordance with law within a period of three months herefrom. Accordingly, the writ
petition is disposed of”.
The inspection of the institution was carried out on 30.8.2007. The visiting team
report and other essential documents were placed before SRC in its 144th meeting
held on 12th October, 2007 and the Committee decided to issue showcause notice on
the following;
 The built up space not adequate for both existing and proposed course for
existing institute and proposed course.
 The structure of the building is not depicted.
 The furniture not suitable for B.Ed course.
 The institution has to clarify whether B.Ed courses is already running in the same
building.
Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 24.10.2007.
….2
The institution has submitted written representation on 22.11.2007. The reply was
placed before SRC in its 150th meeting held on 28th and 29th December, 2007. The
Committee decided to refuse recognition for the following deficiencies;
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
15
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 The built up space is not adequate for B.Ed course.
 The building is not suitable for running the B.Ed college.
 The furniture not suitable and inadequate for B.Ed course.
Accordingly, refusal order was issued to the institution on 11.1.2008.
Aggrieved by the refusal order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTEHqrs. and the appellate authority in its order dated 14.10.2008 conformed SRC
decision.
Aggrieved by the decision of the appellate authority, the institution approached
Hon;ble High Court of Delhi.
A judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in W.P. no. 8290 of 2009 passed on
14th September, 2009. The Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the above writ petition had
set aside the order of the SRC refusing the recognition on the institution and also the
order of the Appellate Authority confirming the order of SRC and directed as under;“For the foregoing reasons, the writ petition is allowed. The order dated 11th January,
2008 passed by the Southern Regional committee and order dated 14th October,
2008 passed by NCTE rejecting application of the petitioner for grant of recognition
for B.Ed course are set aside. The respondents are directed to grant recognition to
the petitioner for the B.Ed course forthwith. Considering the facts and circumstances,
the respondents are also liable to pay a cost of Rs. 30,000/- to the petitioner”.
A letter was addressed to the Member Secretary, NCTE asking for necessary
directions in the matter, since, the Hon’ble High Court had also quashed the order of
the appellate authority. The original file of the institution was forwarded NCTE-Hqrs.
and the office is not aware of the documents submitted by the institution to the office
as well as to the Appellate Authority. The appellate authority vide its order dated
13.10.2009 had directed as under;
“AND WHEREAS the Council noted that the Hon’ble High Court in their order dated
14.9.2009, set aside the Council’s order dated 14.10.2008 and inter alia directed the
Council to grant recognition to the institution for the B.Ed course forthwith. Therefore,
the Council’s order dated 14.10.2008 is hereby superseded with the direction to SRC
to immediately issue the order for recognition to the institution in suppression to its
earlier order dated 11.1.2008”.
In obedience to the appeal order dated 13.10.2009, this office has issued conditional
recognition letter vide this office letter no. F.SRO/NCTE/2009-10/16099 dated
15.10.2009. The address mentioned in the conditional recognition letter is as “Dr.
Rajalakshmi College of Teacher Education, Palavedu village, Mittanamalli Post,
Avadi, Chennai-600055, Tamilnadu”.
The institution has submitted written representation on 17.11.2009 requesting for
grant of un-conditional recognition order for starting B.Ed course.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
16
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Accordingly, un-conditional recognition order was issued vide order
F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed/2009/16869 dated 1.12.2009 at Dr. Rajalakshmi College of
Education, No. 29-30, Oragadam Road, Ambattur, Chennai-600053, Tamlinadu
The institution has submitted letter on 16.8.2010 for change of address in the SRC
recognition order dated 01.12.2009 by submitting that the above institution is in
Palavedu Village, Mittanamalli Post, Avadi, Chennai-53 and by claiming that the letter
of conditional recognition was send to above address vide No. F.SRO/NCTE/200910/16099 dated 15.10.2009.
The matter was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th and 16th
September, 2010.The Committee decided to issue Corrigendum and Notice Under
Section 17 with inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- and Questionnaire. The SRC took
decision to cause inspection due to the reason that at the time of first
inspection conducted on 30.8.2007 the management had shown incomplete
building / structure, where it intended to shift the institution. The inspection
report dt. 30.8.2007, clearly stated that the building flooring and fixation of
doors is yet to be completed. They could complete the building within a
fortnight.
Further report states that Teaching Staff are only identified (page 16 of the
report).
Again V.T report (Page 17, Item No. 2) remarks against class
room/Hall/Labs/Principal room & staff room etc., says “Class room, Halls, Lab
Principal room, staff room are adequate. Furniture are sufficient. As the
flooring was not completed they could not put the furniture in order. Otherwise
they are adequate.
The Photographs submitted by the institution clearly indicate that building is
incomplete and not complete in all respect.
In view of the above the committee decided to cause inspection at new address
to verify the facts and decided to cause inspection under section 17 of the
NCTE act and with that condition, it was decided to issue Corrigendum in this
address.
Accordingly, Corrigendum was issued to the institution on 20.9.2010. An inspection
letter was issued to the institution on 8.11.2010 asking for D.D. of Rs. 40,000/- along
with filled in Questionnaire.
Meantime, a letter from the institution was received on 23.11.2010 requesting for a
postponement of inspection.
Again a letter has been received on 29.11.2010 from the institution, threatening this
office to stop the inspection otherwise action will be taken to file appropriate
proceedings against the Regional Director.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
17
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
An inspection letter was issued to the institution on 8.11.2010 to be ready for
inspection between 10th and 20th November, 2010.
The VT members reached the institution for inspection on 25.11.2010.
In the meantime VT report has been received. As per VT report, V.T. members stated
that at the time of reaching the institution located at Avadi, Chennai on 25.11.2010 at
11.15 am the institution main gate was locked from outside and no body was
available to make enquires through the immediate vicinity of the gate/premises of the
campus. Visiting team members tried to contact them by using telephone mobile on
their land lines as well mobile of the correspondence/manager and no response
came for two days including previous day of the inspection.
Further, the VT members went to original address of the institution at No.29 & 30,
Orgadam Road, Ambattur, Chennai at which recognition to the institution was granted
with a condition to shift to permanent building within 3 years. The visiting team found
that at this site, one Hospital by name Rakhi Hospital is being run by Dr. S.
Rajalakshmi in whose name Teacher Education programme colleges is also
being run.
Since, nobody responded and unavailable V.T.was unable to do the inspection of Dr.
Rajalakshmi College of Education, Chennai (copy of VT report alongwith photographs
taken by VT members using their cell phone is enclosed).
The Committee considered the VT Report, Photographs and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The VT members reached the institution on 25.11.2010 for inspection; but the
main gate was locked from outside and no body from the institution was
available.The VT members tried to contact the correspondent / manager over
telephone line, on mobile but to no avail. This shows deliberate attempt on
the part of the management for preventing the inspection by the visiting team
and obstructing the official discharging duty of the VT of SRC; the
management sent a letter to threating SRC to initiate legal action against the
letter for attempting to cause shifting inspection as per NCTE Norms/Act. As
the said building was incomplete at the time of ealier inspection, inspection
of the same under Sec.17 was considered necessary and well within the
powers of the NCTE.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
18
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
14.
APS03911
D.T.Ed
Grace
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Kanyakumari
TN
Grace Teacher Training Institute, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu was granted recognition
for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 18.11.2005 with the
condition to shift to own premises within 3 years and D.T.Ed-AI with an intake of 50
students on 11.01.2008 at Grace Nursing Home Complex, PPM Junction,
Kaliakkavilai-629153, Kanyakumari District.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action.
The institution vide letter dated has submitted Rs.40000/- on 01.02.2010.
As per the decision of SRC a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 as
per file no. APS03911. The institution has submitted its reply on 06.09.2010 stating
that they have shifted to permanent building at Padanthalumoodu, Kanyakumari629194 from academic year 2007-08 vide letter dated 7.8.2007.
The institution is also running D.Ed Addl course and B.Ed course in the same
building/campus.
SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-19th September 2010 and
decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection was carried out on 22.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The management is running D.T.Ed programme along with D.T.Ed-Al &
B.Ed course in a five floor building. The total built up area as per VT report
for all the three courses D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al programme is (11895 + 3445
Sq.ft) and for B.Ed is 9036 Sq.ft. Total available area for all the 3 courses is
24376 Sq.ft which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms, 37,000 Sq.ft.
built up area is required for all the three courses.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
other programme is being run by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing Courses being run to be submitted.
 The No. of Library books in Library is 3808, which is not sufficient for all
the courses being run by the management.
 The Language learning lab is not available.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
19
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 Education Technology lab needs to be strengthened by procuring more
computers and educational CD.
 Science lab needs to be strengthened by procuring additional equipment/
apparatus.
 Psychology needs to be strengthened.
15.
APS08509
D.T.Ed-AI
Grace
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Kanyakumari
TN
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
Grace Teacher Training Institute, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu was granted recognition
for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 18.11.2005 with the
condition to shift to own premises within 3 years and D.T.Ed-AI with an intake of 50
students on 11.01.2008 at Grace Nursing Home Complex, PPM Junction,
Kaliakkavilai-629153, Kanyakumari District.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action.
The institution vide letter dated has submitted Rs.40000/- on 01.02.2010.
As per the decision of SRC a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 as
per file no. APS03911. The institution has submitted its reply on 06.09.2010 stating
that they have shifted to permanent building at Padanthalumoodu, Kanyakumari629194 from academic year 2007-08 vide letter dated 7.8.2007.
SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-19th September 2010 and
decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection was carried out on 22.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The management is running D.T.Ed-Al programme along with D.T.Ed &
B.Ed course in a five floor building. The total built up area as per VT report
for all the three courses D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al programme is (11895 + 3445
Sq.ft) and for B.Ed is 9036 Sq.ft, total for all the 3 courses is 24376 Sq.ft.
which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms, 37,000 Sq.ft. built up area is
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
20
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
required for all the three courses.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
other programme is being run by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing Courses being run to be submitted.
 The No. of Library books in Library is 3808, which is not sufficient for all
the courses being run by the management.
 The Language learning lab is not available.
 Education Technology lab needs to be strengthened by procuring more
computers and educational CD.
 Science lab needs to be strengthened by procuring additional equipment/
apparatus.
 Psychology needs to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
16.
APS08887
B.Ed
Grace
College of
Education,
Kanyakumari
TN
An application was submitted by Grace College of Education, Kanyakumari
TamilNadu for grant of recognition to B.Ed.,course (100) in the office of SRC-NCTE,
Bangalore on 12.07.2007
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the recognition was
granted to the institution vide order dt 03/03/2008 with stipulated conditions.
Shifting proposal was submitted by the institution on 06.09.2010. Shifting inspection
was conducted on 22.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The management is running D.T.Ed-Al programme along with D.T.Ed &
B.Ed course in a five floor building. The total built up area as per VT report
for all the three courses D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al programme is (11895 + 3445
Sq.ft) and for B.Ed is 9036 Sq.ft, total for all the 3 courses is 24376 Sq.ft.
which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms, 37,000 Sq.ft. built up area is
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
21
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
required for all the three courses.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
other programme is being run by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing Courses being run to be submitted.
 The No. of Library books in Library is 3808, which is not sufficient for all
the courses being run by the management.
 The Language learning lab is not available.
 Education Technology lab needs to be strengthened by procuring more
computers and educational CD.
 Science lab needs to
equipment/apparatus.
be
strengthened
by
procuring
additional
 Psychology needs to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
17.
APS00938
D.T.Ed
Jesus Christ
Teacher
Training
Institute for
Women
Dharmapuri
TN
Jesus Christ Teacher Training Institute for Women, Dharmapuri, Tamilnadu has
submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on
31.12.2002.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 09.09.2004 for annual intake of 50 students from the academic
session 2004-2005 with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
The institution vide letter dated 27.07.2010 has submitted a representation stating
that as per the guidelines of the NCTE, the institution has shifted to new address and
new building and has requesting for change of address from Jesus Christ Teacher
Training Institute for Women, Nellinagar, R.S (Backside), Dharmapuri-636703 to
Jesus Christ Teacher Training Institute for Women, Christ Garden, Collector
Bungalow Back Side, Vetrilaikaran Pallam, A. Jetthalli (Po), Dharmapuri-636708.
The institution has submitted Rs.40000/- .
The matter was considered by the Committee in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th
August 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.T.Ed.
Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee
and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
22
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from
the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four weeks
from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.
Accordingly a letter has been issued to the institution to submit the above documents.
The institution is also running B.Ed programme in the same building.
The inspection was carried out on 23.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  Location/Address of the land as per questionnaire is to be submitted.
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority. The plan is not readable and the approving
authority is in Tamil version. English version is needed.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
competent Govt. authority
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authority in English version is to be submitted.
 Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced. The institution has availed /
raised /loan on FDR’s.
 The Language learning lab is not available.
 Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.
 Science lab is having very limited resources, sufficient for limited no. of
experiments. Laboratory is to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
23
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
18.
APS04459
D.T.Ed
Prime
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Nagapatnam
TN
Prime Teacher Training Institute, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu has submitted an
application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 05.12.2005 and
D.T.Ed-AI on 17.12.2007 at Kilvelur Main Road, Kilvelur-611104, Nagapattinam,
Tamilnadu.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 02.09.2006 for annual intake of 50 students.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of India, based
on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed NCTE for
taking action. In this regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC
in its 116th meeting held 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected and the
maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.
The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions, which was granted recognition
in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under section 17
of the above institution was carried out on 17.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original
application file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
meeting held on 16-17 February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section 17
of NCTE Act.
As per the decision of SRC, Section 17 notice was issued on 02.04.2009. In reply to
the Notice, the institution has submitted written representation on 05.05.2009. The
reply was considered by SRC in its 180th meeting held on 29th July 2009 and decided
to cause inspection for shifting of premises to own building after submission of the
documents. Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 02.09.2009. The
institution submitted its reply on 22.09.2009 alongwith Rs.40000/-.
Meanwhile as per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
leased premises. A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action. Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit
following documents.
The institution submitted its reply on 12.08.2010 & 30.08.2010 alongwith photocopies
of certain documents stating the institution has already submitted its reply to the
same points in letter dated 22.9.2009.
SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-19th September 2010 and
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
24
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The institution is also running B.Ed programme in the same building.
The institution is also running B.Ed programme in the same Building.
The inspection of the institution was done on 24.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The management is running D.T.Ed programme along with D.T.Ed-Al &
B.Ed course in the same premises. The total built up area as per VT report
for all the three courses (D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-Al & B.Ed programmes) is (11160 +
9036 Sq.ft) is 20196 Sq.ft, which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms,
37,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for all the three courses.
 Address/Location of the land in the questionnaire is not mentioned/clean.
 Photo copy of FDRs for Rs. 5 Lakhs & 3 Lakhs from Karur Vysya Bank is
submitted. Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund &
Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 Science lab, Psychology lab & Education Technology lab are to be
strengthened with additional equipment/apparatus.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
19.
APS07816
D.T.Ed-AI
Prime
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Nagapatnam
TN
Prime Teacher Training Institute, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu has submitted an
application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 05.12.2005 and
D.T.Ed-AI on 17.12.2007 at Kilvelur Main Road, Kilvelur-611104, Nagapattinam,
Tamilnadu.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 02.09.2006 for annual intake of 50 students.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of India, based
on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed NCTE for
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
25
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
taking action. In this regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC
in its 116th meeting held 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected and the
maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.
The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions, which was granted recognition
in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under section 17
of the above institution was carried out on 17.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original
application file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
meeting held on 16-17 February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section 17
of NCTE Act.
As per the decision of SRC, Section 17 notice was issued on 02.04.2009. In reply to
the Notice, the institution has submitted written representation on 05.05.2009. The
reply was considered by SRC in its 180th meeting held on 29th July 2009 and decided
to cause inspection for shifting of premises to own building after submission of the
documents. Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 02.09.2009. The
institution submitted its reply on 22.09.2009 alongwith Rs.40000/-.
Meanwhile as per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
leased premises. A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action. Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit
following documents.
The institution submitted its reply on 12.08.2010 & 30.08.2010 alongwith photocopies
of certain documents stating the institution has already submitted its reply to the
same points in letter dated 22.9.2009.
SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-19th September 2010
and decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The institution is also running B.Ed programme in the same Building.
The inspection was done on 24.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The management is running D.T.Ed programme along with D.T.Ed-Al &
B.Ed course in the same premises. The total built up area as per VT report
for all the three courses D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-Al & B.Ed programme,is (11160 +
9036 Sq.ft) is 20196 sq.ft, which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
26
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
37,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for all the three courses.
 Address/Location of the land in the questionnaire is not mentioned/clean.
 Photo copy of FDRs for Rs. 5 Lakhs & 3 Lakhs from Karur Vysya Bank is
submitted. Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund &
Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 Science lab, Psychology lab & Education Technology lab are to be
strengthened with additional equipment/apparatus.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
20.
APS07344
B.Ed
Prime
College of
Education,
Nagapatnam
TN
Prime Teacher Training Institute, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu has submitted an
application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed 25.08.2006 at Kilvelur Main
Road, Kilvelur-611104, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed was granted
on 11.12.2007 for annual intake of 100 students.
Prime Teacher Training Institute, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu has submitted an
application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 05.12.2005 and
D.T.Ed-AI on 17.12.2007 at Kilvelur Main Road, Kilvelur-611104, Nagapattinam,
Tamilnadu.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 02.09.2006 for annual intake of 50 students.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of India, based
on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed NCTE for
taking action. In this regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC
in its 116th meeting held 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected and the
maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.
The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions, which was granted recognition
in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under section 17
of the above institution was carried out on 17.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original
application file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
meeting held on 16-17 February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section 17
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
27
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
of NCTE Act.
As per the decision of SRC, Section 17 notice was issued on 02.04.2009. In reply to
the Notice, the institution has submitted written representation on 05.05.2009. The
reply was considered by SRC in its 180th meeting held on 29th July 2009 and decided
to cause inspection for shifting of premises to own building after submission of the
documents. Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 02.09.2009. The
institution submitted its reply on 22.09.2009 alongwith Rs.40000/-.
Meanwhile as per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
leased premises. A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
action. Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit
following documents.
The institution submitted its reply on 12.08.2010 & 30.08.2010 alongwith photocopies
of certain documents stating the institution has already submitted its reply to the
same points in letter dated 22.9.2009.
SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-19th September 2010 and
decided to cause inspection for shifting of premises.
The inspection was done on 24.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The management is running D.T.Ed programme along with D.T.Ed-Al &
B.Ed course in the same premises. The total built up area as per VT report
for all the three courses, D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-Al & B.Ed programme, is (11160 +
9036 Sq.ft) is 20196 sq.ft, which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms,
37,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for all the three courses.
 Address/Location of the land in the questionnaire is not mentioned/clean.
 Photo copy of FDRs for Rs. 5 Lakhs & 3 Lakhs from Karur Vysya Bank is
submitted. Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund &
Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 Science lab, Psychology lab & Education Technology lab are to be
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
28
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
strengthened with additional equipment/apparatus.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
21.
APS02082
B.Ed
Mother
Theresa
B.Ed College
Bangalore
KA
Mother Theresa B.Ed College, No.357, Triveni Road, Yeshwanthpur,
Bangalore
District-560022, Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on
31.12.2003 The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed
course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 25.11.2004.
The institution in its letter dated 16.01.2008 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
The inspection was carried out on 24th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
The inspection was carried out on 24.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The management is running B.Ed programme in a built up area of 15212 sq.ft.
But the BCC shows over 75,000 Sq.ft is available and approved by the
competent authority. As per the Vt report an Engineering college is being
run in the same campus/building. which is against the norms and regulations
of the NCTE.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed, is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate
from a
competent Govt. authority.
 Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authority is to be submitted.
 Language learning lab is not provided.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
29
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 Physical Education staff/instructor is yet to be appointed.
 Salaries are paid through cash instead of through Bank.
 Affidavit of staff in position not submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
22.
APS01493
B.Ed
CMR College
of Education,
Bangalore
KA
CMR College of Education, CMR Janardhana Trust, CA No. 2,3 Cross, 6 th A Main,
HRBR Layout, Kalyan Nagar, Bangalore District-560043, Karnataka has submitted
application for offering B.Ed course on 12.12.2003. The institution has been granted
recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order
dated 25.11.2007.
The institution in its letter dated 16.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
The inspection was carried out on 24th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD.
The inspection was carried out on 24.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per VT report, the management is running D.Ed & B.Ed programme. In the
same
educational
complex/building,
besides
Teacher
Education
Programmes, other courses namely, Pharmacy, Law, M.B.A and Nursing are
also conducted, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.
 There is a discrepancy in the built up area data as given in the essential data
sheet. The built up area shown is 9570 sq.ft for B.Ed and also again in the
same data sheet it is shown that the built up area for B.Ed is 29600.75 sq.ft
and for D.Ed 28567.41 sq.ft. This is confirmed by the correspondent of the
institution by signing in the essential data sheet. The discrepancy is to be
explained.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
30
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed is to be submitted.

Labs, centralized library, A.V. Hall, Auditorium and D.Ed course are shared
with other programmes and are located in the separate block opposite
D.Ed/B.Ed block/Building.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 Certificates of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a competent
Govt. authority
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
23.
APS01865
B.Ed
Acharya
College of
Education,
Bangalore
KA
Acharya College of Education, 89&90, Soladevana Halli, Hesaraghatta Main Road,
Chikkabanavara Post, Bangalore-560090, Karnataka has submitted application for
offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by
SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
30.11.2004.
The institution in its letter dated 05.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
The inspection was carried out on 25th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached.
From the papers filed along with the VT Report, it is seen that as per letter dated
21.09.2010 given by the State Bank of India, the land and building belonging to JMJ
Education Society, Bangalore situated at Sy.No.80, 90 and 91 at Soladevanahalli,
Bangalore North Taluk measuring 10 Acres and 3 Guntas is Equitably Mortgaged to
State Bank of India.
The inspection was carried out on 25.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
31
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following 
The management is also running in the same campus/building
Engineering and Management courses, which is not permissible as per
NCTE norms.

The built up area with asbestos roof sheets is 13215 sq.ft, which is not
permissible. As per NCTE norms 16000Sq.ft is required. Asbestos
sheet roof is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
other programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same
building / Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed is to be
submitted.

On observation from VCD report the building is roofed with Asbestos
sheets.

The latest Building Completion Certificate
Government Engineer is not submitted.

Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities is in Tamil Version. English version to
be submitted.

Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.

The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority.
from the competent
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
24.
APS02421
B.Ed
St. Francis
B.Ed
College,
Bangalore
KA
St.Francis B.Ed College, Sevasadan Orphanage & Training Institute, P.B.3417, 3rd
Block, Kormangala, Bangalore District, Karnataka has submitted application for
offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by
SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
29.11.2004.
The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
32
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
The inspection was carried out on 25th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
The inspection was carried out on 25.11.2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The management is running B.Ed programme in a built up area of 11098.83
Sq.ft. as per VT report, which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms,
16,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for the B.Ed course.
 As per the VT and other relevant particulars , besides B.Ed college, the
management is running 1) Orphanage 2) ITI 3) CBSC School 4) State
Syllabus School 5) PU College & 6) Jyothi Sadan (Training place for
brothers), in the same complex/building/compound.
 30% of the total building is covered with tin-sheet roof which is not
permissible as per NCTE norms.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 Original Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the original approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land usage certificate
from a
competent Govt. authority
 Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Photocopy of FDR’s of duration 1 year only submitted. The management
has to submit fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund &
Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank for a duration of 5 years.
 The science lab is shared with High School in the building/campus.
 Psychology lab and Physical education department needs to
strengthened.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
be
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
33
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 The Physical education teacher is shared with High School.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
25.
APS02013
B.Ed
CMA B.Ed
college,
Bangalore
KA
CMA B.Ed College, O.T.C. Road, Cubbonpet, Bangalore District-560002,
Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.
The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course
with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 29.11.2004. The new address
for shifting is OTC Road, Corss, Cubbonpet, Bangalore – 560 002, Karnataka.
The institution in its letter dated 30.11.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
The inspection was carried out on 25th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
The inspection was carried out on 25.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per the VT report the built up area of 10870 Sq.ft is earmarked in a
multistory building which is still under construction, which is inadequate.
As per the NCTE norms, 16,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for the B.Ed
course.
 The management is running PUC College for Women, Degree College for
Women& State Open University study centre are being run in the same
building along with B.Ed programme, which is not permitted as per NCTE
norms.
 B.Ed programme is conducted in 2nd floor and the remaining floors are
used for conducting other than Teacher Education Programme.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
34
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 In the Original Affidavit on Rs. 100/- submitted, Plot No. and Address not
mentioned, built up area is also not mentioned.
 The institute has not submitted the original approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate
from a
competent Govt. authority
 The management has to submit 3 Lakhs fixed deposits in joint name
towards Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank for a duration of 5 years.
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 Psychology lab and Education technology lab needs to be strengthened.
 Teaching faculty is not as per NCTE norms/specifications.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
26.
APS01729
D.Ed
South India
Premier
D.Ed
Institute,
Bangalore
KA
South India Premier D.Ed Institute, 27, 5th Cross, 8th Main, Byrasandra Main Road,
Jayanagar 1st Block East, Bangalore-560011, Karnataka has submitted application
for offering D.Ed course on 30.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition
by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
25.11.2004.
The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
Inspection was proposed to the institution during 24-26 November 2010.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
The
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
35
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
institution has requested to postpone the inspection due to personal reasons vide
letter dt.25.11.2010. Hence the inspection of the institution could not be carried out.
Letter from VT members and the institution is enclosed. As per visit’s letter it is
having nil strength. Hence the request to postpone the inspection.
Date of inspection 26.11.20101.(Not carried out)
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following As per VT report the inspection of the institution could not be carried out as
the Secretary of the institution has submitted a letter requesting the VT
members to postpone the inspection and also letter addressed to the SRC
NCTE Bangalore that the institution has shifted to its own building; and that the
response to D.Ed course is negligible and the strength is nil in the institution.
The management has not submitted the following documents to the VT
members for inspection.
 Land documents with survey Nos of the land where the institution is to be
shifted are not submitted.
 Address of the land as per questionnaire is to be submitted.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate
from a
competent Govt. authority.
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced.
 As per VT report the institution is not functioning at the given address.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
36
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
27.
APS01213
D.T.Ed
Meenakshi
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Salem
TN
Meenakshi Mani Teacher Training Institute, Salem, Tamilnadu was granted
recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
20.01.2005 and D.T.Ed-AI witn an intake of 100 students on 11.10.2006 at
No.60, Kamarajar Street, Chinna Thirupathy Post, Salem-636008, Tamilnadu
with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
The institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of
Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on 06.10.2010 stating that “the institution
got recognition orders in the old address. Now we are running the all classess
in the new premises from 01.05.2008. The same has been informed to Salem
District, DTERT, Director and Principal. New building address as detailed
below:
Meenakshi Teacher Training Institute
Thumbal Main Road
Yethapur Post, Attur Taluk
Salem-636117
The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
October 2010 and decided to cause inspection.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following 
As per the VT report the built up area for D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-Al and B.Ed
course is 20868 Sq.ft. which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms, the
total built up area required is 37,000 Sq.ft for all the above three
courses.

As per the VCD report it is observed that the building is in incomplete
stage. To run the courses in an incomplete building is against the
regulations of NCTE.

Another institution, Kamarajar College of Education is running in the
same semifinished building.

Adddress of the land as per questionnaire is to be submitted.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
37
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010

Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.

The latest Building Completion Certificate
Government Engineer is not submitted.

The institute has submitted the Land useage certificate in Tamil Version
but it should be in English also.

Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent
Authorised person / Authority to be submitted.

Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced.

Language learning lab is not available.

Psychology lab and Education technology lab needs to be strengthened.
from the competent
Government
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
28.
APS06292
D.T.Ed-AI
Meenakshi
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Salem
TN
Meenakshi Mani Teacher Training Institute, Salem, Tamilnadu was granted
recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
20.01.2005 and D.T.Ed-AI witn an intake of 100 students on 11.10.2006 at
No.60, Kamarajar Street, Chinna Thirupathy Post, Salem-636008, Tamilnadu
with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
The institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of
Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on 06.10.2010 stating that “the institution
got recognition orders in the old address. Now we are running the all classess
in the new premises from 01.05.2008. The same has been informed to Salem
District, DTERT, Director and Principal. New building address as detailed
below:
Meenakshi Teacher Training Institute
Thumbal Main Road
Yethapur Post, Attur Taluk
Salem-636117
The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
October 2010 and decided to cause inspection.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
38
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –

As per the VT report the built up area for D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed (Addl) and B.Ed
course is 20868 Sq.ft. which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms the
total built up area required is 37,000 Sq.ft for all the above three
courses.

As per the VCD report it is observed that the building is in incomplete
stage. To run the courses in an incomplete building is against the
regulations of NCTE.

Another institution, Kamarajar College of Education is running in the
same semi finished building.

Address of the land as per questionnaire is to be submitted.

Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.

The latest Building Completion Certificate
Government Engineer is not submitted.

The institute has submitted the Land useage certificate in Tamil Version
but it should be in English also.

Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent
Authorised person / Authority to be submitted.

Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced.

Language learning lab is not available.
from the competent
Government
 Psychology lab and Education technology lab need to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
29.
APS04505
APS08752
D.T.Ed
TET Teacher Training Institute, Namakkal District, Tamilnadu submitted an
application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 07.12.2005 &
D.T.Ed-AI on 24.05.2007.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
39
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
D.T.Ed-AI
TET Teacher
Training
Institute for
Women,
Namakkal
TN
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
was granted on 26.10.2006 for annual intake of 50 students & D.T.Ed-AI at No.6/907,
Trichy Road, Netaji Nagar, Namakkal District-637001, Tamilnadu.
The institution vide letter dated 20.09.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- stating as follows
“TET Teacher Training Institute for Women is owned by Takwa Educational Trust is
functioning in rented building.
The trust has 4.00 acres of land in survey no 272/4J at Vasanthapuram Village, Namakkal
District under document no.2755/2005 at 10-11-2005. The new RCC building for the institute
is constructed and ready for occupation.
So, we request your goodself to grant permission to shift the institute to the newly constructed
own building in our own land”.
No documents relating to shifting of premises is received alongwith the letter.
The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
2010 and decided to cause inspection.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following 
As per the VT, VCD & other relevant evidences it is observed that the
building construction is incomplete. To run the courses in an
incomplete building is against the regulations of NCTE.

Address of the land as per questionnaire is to be submitted.

Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.

The latest Building Completion Certificate
Government Engineer is not submitted.

The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from the
competent Government Authority.

Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
from a Nationalised Bank for Rs. 5 Lakhs & 3 Lakhs respectively, for
D.T.Ed-Al course is to be produced.

Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
from the competent
Government
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
40
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010

Language learning lab is not available.

Education technology lab need to be strengthened.

Furniture in Faculty / staff room needs to be strengthened.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
30.
APS01857
B.Ed
SKM
Teachers
College No,
Bangalore
KA
S.K.M Teachers College, No.26, 1st Main Road, Vijayanandanagar, Near Police
Quarters, Nandini Layout, Bangalore-560096, Karnataka has submitted application
for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition
by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
13.12.2006.
The institution in its letter dated 16.09.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
The inspection was carried out on 26th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documents, it is clear that the
institution is running the B.Ed. programme in a building which is roofed with
asbestos sheets and also electrical work is incomplete. This is against the
NCTE Norms. Incomplete building is not suitable to run Teacher Education
Programme.
 The institution is functioning in a asbestos sheets roofed building which is
being shared for running MBA & BCA colleges. This is a gross violation of
norms on the part of the management to share the same building with other
programmes.
 The land area/space is 0.5 acres 20,000 Sq.ft which is not sufficient for
running B.Ed programme.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed is to be submitted.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
41
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 Seating arrangement is not made for the students to read/refer the books in
the library.
 The institution is taking / borrowed the library books from another library for
.references use by students.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a competent
Govt. authority.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from the
competent Government Authority.
 Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund from a
Nationalised Bank for Rs. 5 Lakhs & 3 Lakhs respectively to be submitted.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 The materials are to be procured for other labs/Physical Education
department.
 The Physical education Director/staff is yet to be appointed.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
31.
APS02036
B.Ed
KKECS B.Ed
College,
Bangalore
KA
KKECS B.Ed College, No.90/1, 90/2, Mahakavi Kuvempu Road, 5th Cross,
Malleshwaram, Bangalore-560003, Karnataka has submitted application for offering
B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 03.12.2004.
The institution in its letter dated 07.12.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The institution has applied for
shifting to Sy.No.322.A, Khata No.54, Assessment Register No.3/2, Ambalipura
Village, Varthur Hobli, Bangalore South Taluk.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
42
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The inspection was carried out on 26th November 2010. The inspection report has
been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The institution is running B.Ed programme along with B.Pharm & MBA in the
same education complex/ building. This is against the NCTE norms.
 No separate playground is available for B.Ed course and the management is
sharing the playground with B.Pharm and MBA programmes.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer is not submitted.
 The details of the land documents are not submitted to the Visiting Team.
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a competent
Govt. authority.
 The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from the
competent Government Authority.
 Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund from a
Nationalised Bank for Rs. 5 Lakhs & 3 Lakhs respectively to be submitted.
 Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.
 Language learning lab is not available.
 The Physical education department facilities/Computer lab/other lab facilities
are shared with students of other programmes.
 Physical education Director/Staff is not appointed.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
43
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
32.
APS01513
D.Ed
Nehru
Memorial
Teacher
Training
College,
Bangalore
KA
Nehru Memorial Teacher Training College, 6/23/1, 9th Cross, 4th Main Road,
Chamrajapet, Bangalore-560018, Karnataka has submitted application for offering
D.Ed course on 17.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 26.12.2005.
The institution in its letter dated 15.01.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
Inspection was proposed to the institution during 24-26 November 2010. The
institution vide letter dated 28.10.2010 has stated that the institution was established
in the own land and building and hence inspection is not necessary. Hence the
inspection of the institution could not be carried out. Letter from VT members and the
institution is enclosed.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  The institution did not submit land documents, Affidavits, By-laws, Building
plan, Building Completion Certificate, Land useage certificate, Nonencumbrance Certificate FDR’s in joint names towards Endowment &
Reserve fund and other relevant documents.
 When the VT members visited the institution on 26.11.2010 for inspection, the
management people were not available; the principal present at the time of
visit and informed that the inspection is not required as the institute claimed
that it was established in the own land & building; and the VT was not
allowed to do the inspection of the institution; This was a deliberate attempt
on the part of the management not to allow the visiting team members for
inspecting the institution and preventing VT from discharging their official
duty, well within the powers of NCTE.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
available with no further notice.
33.
APS06356
D.T.Ed
New Ideal
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Tirunelveli
New Ideal Teacher Training Institute, Chettiyuranipati, Alundar Panchayat,
Srirangam, Trichy District, Tamilnadu had been granted recognition by SRC-NCTE
for running the D.T.Ed course with an annual intake of 50 by SRC vide Order
No.18307 dated 26.06.2008.
As per G.O. No. 94 dated 03.05.2008 issued by the Govt of Tamilnadu, the DTERT,
Tamilnadu had envisaged inspection of the institution for affiliation for D.T.Ed course.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
44
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
TN
The Director, DTERT vide letter No. Rc.No.6801/C4/2008 dated 20.06.2009 had
stated that the Inspection Committee had inspected the institution and deficiencies
have been noted. The matter was considered by SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6-7
August 2008 and decided to issue notice under section 17. Accordingly a notice was
issued to the institution on 24.10.2008.
The institution submitted its reply on 28.01.2009, which was placed before SRC in its
171st meeting held on 16-17 March 2009 and the committee decided to communicate
those replies to the Government of Tamilnadu for their considered response, for
necessary action. Accordingly a letter was issued to DTERT on 01.04.2009.The
Director, DTERT vide letter No. Rc.No.6801/C4/2008 dated 19.06.2009 had stated
that the Inspection Committee had inspected the institution and the noted deficiencies
in the institution.
The said letter of DTERT was considered by SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th21st August 09 whereby SRC decided to issue Show Cause Notice u/s 17 of the
NCTE Act by sending Questionnaire and also to call remarks on deficiencies
mentioned against the institutions. Accordingly, a notice was issued on 27.08.2009.
The institution has not submitted its reply even after completion of stipulated period,
the matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 and
decided to issue final notice to the institution. Accordingly, final notice was issued on
01.06.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 17.06.2010.
The written representation was considered by SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21st22nd July 2010 and+ it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.T.Ed.
Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee
and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from
the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four weeks
from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.
Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs.40000/- on 02.08.2010
& 27.08.2010. The institution did not submit its reply. SRC considered the matter in
its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 and decided to cause inspection
in anticipation of inspection fee.
The visiting team members visited the institution on 1.12.2010 stated that the institute
withdraw their D.T.Ed proramme. In this regard, the institution is already sent their
letter of request about this to NCTE. However, so far the institute has not run the
D.T.Ed programme due to administrative reasons is examined on the spot(copy
enclosed.)
The institution vide its letter dated 23.11.2010 informed that so far the institute has
not run the D.T.Ed programme due to administrative reasons. Now the trust has
decided not to run the D.T.Ed program hence requested to withdraw the approval of
the D.T.Ed programme.
The Committee considered the request of the Institution for closure of D.T.Ed
course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the recognition for
(APS06356) D.T.Ed course with immediate effect, as no admission was ever
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
45
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
made to the course.
It is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further
admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.
Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with
SRC NCTE, Bangalore.
Appeal & Section 13, 14 & 17 Inspection Report:
Sl.
No
Code
Remarks of SRC
Course
Name of the
Institution
34.
State
AOS00573
AOS00388AP
SS01656
Pre-Primary.
D.Ed, & B.Ed
The Oxford
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Bangalore
KA
The Oxford Teacher Training Institute, J.P. Nagar 1st Phase, Bangalore560078, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering Pre-primary,
D.Ed and B.Ed courses with an intake of 80, 90 and 100 students vide
order dated 16.01.2001, 12.09.1996 and 30.11.2004 respectively
NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.12.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
inspection report dated 03.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE
Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE,
Hqrs has requested SRC to look into the matter to take action under
Section 17 of the NCTE Act and take appropriate action against the
institution.
The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect
that no other programme is being run/shared by the institution
in the same building / Campus, along with the existing Courses
B.Ed, D.Ed & NTT is to be submitted.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
46
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 The size of the multipurpose hall is 288.54 sq.ft only, which is
inadequate, as per the NCTE guideline.
 No. of books in the library are only 4350. Which are not
sufficient for the all the three courses run by the institution.
 The fire safety measurement provided in the building is to be
furnished.
 Three of the faculty members do not possess Post Graduate
degree in Education.
 The details of PF/CPF payments of staff is not maintained.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
35.
APS03319
APS01959
D.Ed
D.Ed-AI
Sharanabasav
eshwara D.Ed
College,
Bellary
KA
Sharanabasaveshwara D.Ed College, Kanamadugu, Kudligi Taluk,
Bellary District-583218, Karnataka submitted an application for grant of
recognition on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition for
offering D.Ed-AI course with an intake of 100 students which includes
existing intake of 60 students and additional intake of 40 students vide
order dated 28.12.2004.
NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 06.12.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
inspection report dated 23.06.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE
Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE,
Hqrs has requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain the
adherence of relevant NCTE norms & standards by the institution and
take appropriate action against institution.
The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following  As per VT report the built up area shown for D.Ed and D.Ed-Al
programme is 1130 Sq.mtrs. which is grossly inadequate as per
NCTE norms. As per the norms, 21,000 sq.ft built-up area is
required.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
47
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
36.
37.
APS02257
APS05563
D.Ed
D.Ed-AI
S.U.J. D.Ed
College,
Bellary
KA
APS09549
D.Ed
Sri Kanakadas
D.Ed College,
Bagalkot
KA
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
S.U.J D.Ed College, Ujjaini, Kudligi Taluk, Bellary District- 583136,
Karnataka submitted an application for grant of recognition on
02.01.2006. The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed-AI
course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 21.08.2007 which
includes existing intake of 50 students and additional intake of 50
students.
NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 06.12.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
inspection report dated 24.06.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE
Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE,
Hqrs has requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain the
adherence of relevant NCTE norms & standards by the institution and
take appropriate action.
The inspection was carried out on 24/6/2010.
The Committee considered the VT report of the institution & other
related documents along with the original file of the institution and
decided to continue recognition accorded to the institution.
Sri.Kanakadas D.Ed College, C/o Beereshwar High School, No.289 &
290, Bilagi, Bagalkot – 587116, Karnataka Shri. Kanakadas D.Ed.
College, Bijapur, Karnataka had applied seeking for grant of recognition
to D.Ed. course on 30.06.2008. The application was processed and an
inspection was conducted to the institution on 14.3.2009. The VT report
along with along with all necessary documents were placed before 172nd
meeting of SRC held on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to issue
Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued on 16.4.2009.
The institution submitted its written representation on 25.4.2009 &
29.4.2009. SRC in its 175th meeting of SRC held on 13-14 May, 2009
considered the written representation and decided to cause re-inspection.
The decision of SRC was communicated to the institution vide letter
dt.2.6.2009. The institution vide letter dated 29.6.2009 has requested for
postponement of the inspection.
The SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 considered the
letter received on 3.7.2009 and decided to refuse recognition.
Accordingly, Refusal order was issued to the institution on 30.07.2009.
The institution preferred appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act. The
Appellate Authority considered the appeal and confirmed the refusal
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
48
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
order of SRC vide order dated 12.04.2010.
Aggrieved by the Appellate Authority order, the institution filed W.P.
16446 of 2010 in the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka, Circuit Bench at
Dharwad and the case has been Disposed of on 16.09.2010. The
judgement reads as follows:
“…. The writ petition is allowed. Impugned orders are set aside. The 1 st
respondent (SRC, NCTE) is directed to re-inspect the petitioner institution
after fixing a date and after communicating the same to the institution.
The decision regarding recognition can be taken in accordance with law
thereafter.”
Accordingly re-inspection was carried out on 10.11.2010 as per
court directions.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice. for the following –
 As per the building plan the total built up area for the course
D.Ed shown is 16000Sq.ft. But in the essential data sheet total
built up area is only 10948 Sq.ft which is concurred by the
management of the institution.
 The Building Plan approved by competent authority is to be
submitted.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund &
Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan
from a competent Govt. authority
 Land documents with survey Nos of the land where the
institution is to be shifted are not submitted. English version is
to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refysed
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
49
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
38.
APS04362
B.Ed
B.K.R.College
of Education,
Thiruvallur
TN
Sola Raju Dhanuskodi Raja Thai Ammal Memorial Educational
Charitable Trust, B.K.R. College of Education, No.45/22E, Madras Bye
Pass Road, Thiruttani-631209, Thiruvallur District, Tamilnadu submitted
an application to SRC for grant of recognition for offering B.Ed course on
27.12.2004.
The inspection of the institution was conducted and the report was placed
before the SRC in its meeting held on 19th October 2005 and decided to
accord recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed course from the
academic session 2006-2007.
In the meanwhile, some of the institutions which have been granted
recognition for the subsequent year have preferred appeal before NCTE,
New Delhi to reconsider their cases of grant of recognition for the session
2005-06 itself instead of 2006-07. The NCTE, New Delhi vide order
No.F.No.89-156/2005 Appeal dated 28.09.2005 has remanded back the
case to SRC with a direction to reconsider these cases immediately for
grant of recognition for the session 2005-06.
SRC in its 104th meeting held on 9th–10th November, 2005 has
considered the legal opinion obtained in this regard and has taken a
decision to grant recognition for the session 2005-06 to those institutions
who have submitted belated NOCs/Endorsements and also the essential
documents mentioned in Appendix-1B of NCTE Regulations as one time
exception. Accordingly, recognition order was issued to the institution on
24.11.2005.
SRC in its 181st Meeting held on 20-21 August, 2009 it was decided that
the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
after the expiry of 3 years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of
NCTE Act, for further action. As per the decision of SRC a notice under
Section 17 was issued to the institution on 16.09.2009. The reply from
the institution has not been received so far.
The Committee considered the matter in its 192nd meeting held on 10th11th May 2010 and decided to withdraw recognition granted to the
institution for B.Ed. course. Accordingly withdrawal order was issued to
the institution on 01.07.2010.
Aggrieved by the withdrawal order, the institution preferred an appeal to
NCTE-Hqrs. The Appellate Authority in its order dated 17.09.2010
reversed SRC’s order dated 01.07.2010 with the direction to SRC for
causing composite inspection of the own premises of the institution for all
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
50
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
the recognised Teacher Training programme of NCTE, after obtaining a
payment of Rs.40000/- from the institution and for further decision
thereafter within 30 days of issue of this order and thereafter pass
appropriate order.
The institution has submitted Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fees. The
committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
October 2010 and decided to cause composite inspection.
The institution was also granted recognition to M.Ed course on
11.12.2007 and D.T.Ed course on 12.08.2005.
Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 24.11.2010.
Composite inspection is conducted for 3 courses. Inspection fee submitted is
RS.40000/- as per Appellate order dated. 01.7.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The Built up area earmarked for B.Ed course is 10,000 Sq.ft D.Ed
& D.T.Ed(Al) -24225 Sq.ft, M.Ed – 24225 Sq.ft.The same is also
corroborated by the management in the essential data. The
B.Ed programme requires a built up area of 16,000 sq.ft, as per
the norms.
 The management is running in the same complex a college of
Engineering and a college of Nursing courses. .
 A Certificate from the Government / Affiliating body to the effect
that no other programme is being run/shared by the institution
in the same building / Campus, along with the existing Course
D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed(Al), B.Ed & M.Ed programmes is to be submitted.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from
a competent Govt. authority.
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the necessary
documents for land, building approval and completion
certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and others etc., is
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
51
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
39.
APS05027
M.Ed
B.K.R.College
of Education,
Thiruvallur
TN
Sola Raju Dhanuskodi Raja Thai Ammal Memorial Education Charitable
Trust, B.K.R College of Education, No. 45/22E, Madras Bye Pass Road,
Thiruttani-631209, Thiruvallur District, Tamilnadu submitted an
application to SRC for grant of recognition for offering B.Ed course on
27.12.2004.
The institution was also granted recognition to M.Ed course on
11.12.2007 and D.T.Ed course on 12.08.2005.
SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 and decided to
withdraw recognition granted to the institution for B.Ed course.
Accordingly withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 01.07.2010.
Aggrieved by the withdrawal order, the institution preferred an appeal to
NCTE-Hqrs. The Appellate Authority in its order dt. 17.09.2010 reversed
SRCs order dt. 01.07.2010 with the direction to SRC for causing
composite inspection of the own premises of the institution for all the
recognized Teacher Training Programe of NCTE, after obtaining a
payment of Rs. 40000/-from the institution and for further decision
thereafter within 30 days of issue of this order and thereafter pass
appropriate order.
The institution has submitted Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fees. The
committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
October 2010 and decided to cuase composite inspection.
As per the decision of SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
2010, composite inspection of the institution was conducted on
24.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The Built up area earmarked for B.Ed course is 10,000 Sq.ft D.Ed
& D.T.Ed(Al) -24225 Sq.ft, M.Ed – 24225 Sq.ft.The same is also
corroborated by the management in the essential data. The
shortage of built up area for B.Ed resulting in the possible
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
52
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
withdrawal of its recognition would automatically nullify the
ongoing M.Ed programme.
 The management is running in the same complex a college of
Engineering course and Nursing college.
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect
that no other programme is being run/shared by the institution
in the same building / Campus, along with the existing Course
B.Ed, D.T.Ed, M.Ed & D.T.Ed – Al is to be submitted.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from
a competent Govt. authority.
 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the necessary
documents for land, building approval and completion
certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and others etc., is
to be submitted.
40.
APS01210
D.T.Ed
B.K.R.Teacher
Training
Institute,
Thiruvallur
TN
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
Sola Raju Dhanuskodi Raja Thai Ammal Memorial Education Charitable
Trust, B.K.R College of Education, No. 45/22E, Madras Bye Pass Road,
Thiruttani-631209, Thiruvallur District, Tamilnadu submitted an
application to SRC for grant of recognition for offering B.Ed course on
27.12.2004.
The institution was also granted recognition to M.Ed course on
11.12.2007 and D.T.Ed course on 12.08.2005.
SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 and decided to
withdraw recognition granted to the institution for B.Ed course.
Accordingly withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 01.07.2010.
Aggrieved by the withdrawal order, the institution preferred an appeal to
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
53
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
NCTE-Hqrs. The Appellate Authority in its order dt. 17.09.2010 reversed
SRCs order dt. 01.07.2010 with the direction to SRC for causing
composite inspection of the own premises of the institution for all the
recognized Teacher Training Programe of NCTE, after obtaining a
payment of Rs. 40000/-from the institution and for further decision
thereafter within 30 days of issue of this order and thereafter pass
appropriate order.
The institution has submitted Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fees. The
committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
October 2010 and decided to cuase composite inspection.
As per the decision of SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
2010, composite inspection of the institution was conducted on
24.11.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –
 The management is running in the same complex
Engineering college and Nursing college.
an
 A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect
that no other programme is being run/shared by the institution
in the same building / Campus, along with the existing Course
B.Ed, D.T.Ed, M.Ed & D.T.Ed – Al is to be submitted.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from
a competent Govt. authority.
 Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
 Duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the necessary
documents for land, building approval and completion
certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and others etc., is
to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
54
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
41.
APS00863
APS04501
D.T.Ed
D.T.Ed-AI
Joseph
Chellamuthu
Teacher
Training
Institute for
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
Joseph Chellamuthu Educational Trust, Joseph Teacher Training
Institute, No.4, Arputha Nagar, Keerambur, Namakkal-637207,
Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with an
intake of 50 students vide order dated 12.01.2005 and D.T.Ed-AI vide
order dated 20.09.2006.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of
India, based on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd)
has directed NCTE for taking action. In this regard, it has been
envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC in its 116th meeting held 2223 August 2006 should be re-inspected and the maintenance of Norms
and Standards should be verified.
Women,
Namakkal
TN
The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions, which was
granted recognition in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of
MHRD, inspection under section 17 of the above institution for D.T.Ed-AI
was carried out on 16.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original application
file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
meeting held on 16-17 February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice
under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a notice was issued to the
institution on 04.04.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 27.4.2009.
The SRC considered the reply in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July
2009 and decided to issue notice.
Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 31.07.2009. The
institution has not submitted its reply even after completion of stipulated
period, the matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting held on
20-21 April 2010 and the Committee considered the above matter and
decided to serve Final Notice. Accordingly final notice was issued on
01.06.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 29.06.2010.
The Committee decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.T.Ed
courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in
Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to
building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate separately for
each course, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
Minutes.
Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs.40000/- on
03.08.2010 & 27.08.2010. The institution did not submit its reply. SRC
considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection in anticipation of inspection fee.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
55
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The institution submitted Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee on
08.12.2010.
The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.12.2010.
The brief details of the VT report are given below:
The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.12.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :
 An Arts & Science college and a school are also being run in the
same building/complex. This is against the regulations of NCTE.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 Duly filled in Questionnaire is to be submitted.
 Non-encumbrance Certificate from the copetent Government
Authority is to be submitted.
 Along with the existing courses D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al the institution
is running B.Ed courses also in the name of Arputha Jothi College
of Education in the same complex.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
42.
APS08772
B.Ed
Arputha Jothi
B.Ed College,
An application was submitted by Arputha Jothi College of Education,
No.4, Arputha Nagar, Keerambur, Namakal. Tamilnadu for grant of
recognition to B.Ed.,course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on
31/05/2007.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules
and Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
56
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Namakkal
TN
recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt 28.11.2007 with
stipulated conditions.
The VT members inspected the institution on 2.12.2010 while the
inspection which was carried out as per their visit schedule for inspection
of Joseph Chellamuthu Educational Trust, Joseph Teacher Training
Institute, No.4, Arputha Nagar, Keerambur, Namakkal-637207,
Tamilnadu on 2.12.2010, Since the Arputha Jothi B.Ed college Namakkal
is also situated in the same complex and run by the above institution
(Joseph Chellamuthu Educational Trust).
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority.
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted on the prescribed format.
 Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
43.
APS08096
D.T.Ed
Sri
Sundareswari
Sundareswari Medical Educational Research and Social Welfare
Charitable Trust, Sri Sundareswari Teacher Training Institute, No.12,
Madavarvalakam Street, Srivilliputtur, Virudhunagar-626125, Tamilnadu
had been granted recognition by SRC-NCTE for running the D.T.Ed
course with an annual intake of 50 by SRC vide Order No.18559 dated
04.03.2008.
Teacher
Training
Institute,
As per G.O. No. 94 dated 03.05.2008 issued by the Govt of Tamilnadu,
the DTERT, Tamilnadu had envisaged inspection of the institution for
affiliation for D.T.Ed course. The Director, DTERT vide letter No.
Rc.No.6796/C5/2008 dated 20.06.2008 had stated that the Inspection
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
57
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Srivilliputtur
TN
Committee had inspected the institution and noted the deficiencies in the
institution: The said letter of DTERT was considered by SRC in its 161st meeting
held on 6th-7th Aug 08 whereby SRC decided to issue Show Cause Notice
u/s 17 and to call for remarks with documentary proof/s on deficiencies
pointed out by the DTERT, Chennai to take necessary action.
Accordingly, a notice was issued on 24.10.2008.
The institution has not submitted its reply even after completion of
stipulated period, the matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting
held on 20-21 April 2010 and the Committee considered the above
matter and decided to serve Final Notice. Accordingly final notice was
issued on 20.05.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 18.06.2010.
The Committee decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.T.Ed
courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs. 40,000/inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in
Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to
building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate separately for
each course, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
Minutes.
Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs. 40000/- on
02.08.2010 & 02.09.2010. The institution did not submit its reply. SRC
considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to cause inspection.
Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs. 40000/towards inspection fee on 09.11.2010. The institution submitted Rs.
40000/- on 09.12.2010.
The management is also running B.Ed course.
The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.12.2010.
The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:
 Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted on the prescribed format.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority.
 The total area of the space (Site) as per building plan and
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
58
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
earmarked built up area for the course is not mentioned in the
building plan.
 From the observation of VCD, it appears that there is a School
functioning in the same campus/building.
 Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available with no
further notice.
Court Cases/Appeal/Notice/Complaint/Shifting/Miscellaneous Cases:
Sl.
No
44.
Code
Course
Particulars
State
APS09117
D.Ed
S.V.R College
of Elementary
Teacher
Education,
Khammam
Remarks of SRC
An application was submitted by Bhargavi Educational Society, Khammam,
A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE,
Bangalore vide dated 19.11.2007. The consent letter was issued to the
institution as per NCTE Regulation 2007 vide dated 26.09.2008 directing to
give consent for inspection alongwith as self attested copy of the completion
certificate of building for which affidavit, building plan and land documents
were submitted. The Institution submitted its reply consent letter dated
06.10.2008.
AP
The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s), to
this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for
the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned
along with processing fees and documents.
The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
59
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in
the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
numbers than required.
Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs
informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed ,
D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been considered in
NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/Permission to any
institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses
also”.
Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were
considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 and
SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of
Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training
Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided
to close the applications.
As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 17.05.2009
The institution has approached to Hon’ble High court of Andhra Pradesh
W.P.31046/2010 in W.P. No. 24265/2010 without making appeal to
appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE Act
The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order on 29.09.2010 vide
W.P.M.P.No.31046 of 2010 in W.P. No. 24265/2010 as under:“In the light to considers passed by this court in the similar writ petitions
w.p.No. 6712/2009, w.p.no. 9360/2010 and w.p. no. 11078/2010 there shall
be a direction to the first respondent to consider the petitioner’s application
for starting D.Ed course in accordance with law without reference to the
state Govt’s Policy dated 07.01.2009.”
The matter was placed in 197th meeting of SRC held on 13th – 14th ocy,
2010, wherein the SRC decided to Re-submit the application for
continuation. As per direction of SRC a letter was sent to the institution on
19.10.10 with request to submit original form alongwith land use certificate,
BCC, Applicationfee, land documents and other relevant documents.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
60
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The SRC considered the Hon’ble court orders and all the relevant
documents and decided to take further action in the matter, subject to the
fulfilment of all the requirements by the institution as per the norms and
regulations.
The following deficiencies has been submitted by the institution on letter
dated 01.12.2010.
1. FDR of Rs 5.00 lakh submitted in original
2. FDR of Rs 3.00 lakh submitted in original
3. BCC in the prescribed proforma duly signed
by the local civil authority.
 Further, the land use certificate Dt. 18.2.2009 is to be notarized.
 Notarised English version copy of registered land document is to be
submitted.
The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and
decided to cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils
all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified
by the institution, as per the norms.
45.
APS09473
D.Ed
Shanthiniketha
n Education
Society for
Women,
Nalgonda
AP
An application was submitted by Shantinikethan Education Society for
Women, Nalgonda, A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office
of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 17.04.2008.
The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s), to
this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for
the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned
along with processing fees and documents.
The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in
the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
numbers than required.
Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs
informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed ,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
61
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been considered in
NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/Permission to any
institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses
also”.
Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were
considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 and
SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of
Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training
Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided
to close the applications.
As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 22.04.2009
The institution has approached the Hon’ble High court of Andhra Pradesh
W.P.11038/2009 without making appeal to appellate authority under section
18 of NCTE Act
The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order on 23.09.2010 vide
W.P.M.P.No.30904 of 2010 in W.P. No. 24142/2010 as under:“In the light of the orders passed by this court in the similar writ petitions
W.P.No. 6712/2009, W.P.no. 9360/2010 and W.P. no. 11078/2010 there
shall be a direction to the first respondent to consider the petitioner’s
application for starting D.Ed course in accordance with law without
reference to the state Govt’s Policy dated 07.01.2009.”
The SRC considered the Hon’ble court orders and all the relevant
documents and decided to take further action in the matter, subject to the
fulfillment of all the requirements by the institution as per the norms and
regulations.
As per the decision of SRC a deficiency letter was issued to the institution
on 16.11.2010.
In reply to the letter dated 16.11.2010 institution submitted its written
representation on 30.11.2010.
The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and
decided to cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils
all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified
by the institution, as per the norms.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
62
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
46.
APS09331
D.Ed
S.V.Model
D.Ed College,
Rangareddy
AP
Sub:- S.V Model D.Ed College, Arundhathi Education Society, Sy no. 250,
ward no. 1, Dommarpachampally, Quthubullapur, Ranga Reddy-500855,
Andhra Pradesh (APS09331) Course:D.Ed
An application was submitted by Arundhathi Educational society, Ranga
Reddy Dist, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed. course in the
office of SRC-NCTE Bangalore vide dated 05.08.2008. The file was under
process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of the State
Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, physical
Education, Language Pandit course (S).
The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect. A
letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new
colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in numbers
than required. A letter dated 17the March, 2009 was received from NCTE
Hqrs informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other courses like
B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical Education courses have further been considered
in NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/permission to
any institution in the state Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed. and physical Education Courses
also”. The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
it has been decided not to recommend the name of the institution.
The State Govt. letter dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th
March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
Teacher Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and
decided to close the applications.
As per direction of Southern Regional committee a letter was sent to
correspondent of the institution on 22.04.2010 with intimation that the
application submitted by Arundhathi Educational Society, Ranga Reddy
Dist, Andhra Pradesh here by closed. No further correspondence
whatsoever will be entertained in this regard.
Institution has approached Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh at
Hyderabad in W.P.No.25762 of 2010 in writ petition no. 20287/2010 without
approached to Appellate authority NCTE under section 18 of NCTE Act,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
63
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
1993. The Court order dated 31.12.209 states as under –
“ In the light of the order passed by this court in the similar writ petitions
WP no. 6712/2009, WP no. 9360/2010 and WP no. 11078/2010, there shall
be a direction to the first respondent to consider the petitioner’s application
for starting D.Ed course in accordance with law without reference to the
State Govt. ‘s policy dated 17.10.2009.”
Institution had previously submitted processing fee of Rs 40,000/which is deposited into NCTE Account.
The matter was placed before 196th meeting of SRC held on 15th –16th
September, 2010, the Regional Committee decided to application be
process.
The institution has submitted original FDR of five and three lacks,
BCC dated 07.09.10, Affidavit dated 08.09.10 and copy of land documents
for sy no. 250 situated at Dommar Poohampally village, Quthbullapur
Mandal, Ranga Reddy Distt, Andhra Pradesh. The building plan on the said
land are available in the file. The SRC may provide names of VT Member
for causing inspection. The SRC had vide its letter dated 19.09.2008 sought
consent of inspection for causing inspection and in view of state Govt’s ban
the file was closed.
The matter was again placed in 197th meeting held on 13th –14th Oct, 2010
the sRC decided to cause inspection. As per direction of Regional
Committee inspection caused on 09.11.10. The matter was again placed in
198th meeting of SRC held on 24th – 26th Nov, 2010 wherein the Regional
Committee decided to issued showcause notice; however the minutes of the
meeting were awaiting confirmation, for necessary action.
Meanwhile the institution has approached to Hon’ble High court of Andhra
Pradesh in writ petition no.30160/2010 wherein the Hon’ble High court has
directed as under:“Having head the learned counsel on either side and gone through the
material papers and in as much as the State Govt has issued admission
orders to the similarly situated college for the academic year 2010-2011,
this writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to constitute a
committee and place the inspection report before it for is consideration and
to pass appropriate orders as to whether the permission is to be granted to
the petitioner to establish a college for imparting D.Ed course from the
academic year 2010-2011 or not. The said process shall be completed as
expeditiously as possible preferably within a period of ten days from the
date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall be no order as to costs”.
The copy of court order is received on 08-12-2010.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
64
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The SRC considered the Hon’ble High Court orders and all the relevant
documents and decided to take final decision in the matter as per the
court orders subject to the fulfillment of all the requirements by the
institution as per the norms and regulations, and after the receipt of
reply received from the institution to the show cause notice issued as
per decision of the SRC meeting held on 24th – 26th Nov, 2010.
47.
APS09641
B.Ed
Hazi Kareem
College of
Education,
Kurnool
AP
An application was submitted by Saleem Minority Educational Service
Society, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh in the name of Hazi Kareem
College of Education, Kurnool District, A.P for grant of recognition to B.Ed
course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 24.10.2008.
The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s), to
this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for
the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned
along with processing fees and documents.
The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in
the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
numbers than required.
Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs
informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed ,
D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been considered in
NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/Permission to any
institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses
also”.
Further the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were
considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 and
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
65
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of
Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training
Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided
to close the applications.
As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 28.04.2009 and
processing fee of Rs.40000/- was returned.
The institution has approached to Hon’ble High court of Andhra pradesh
without making appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE Act
The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order on 06.05.2010 vide
W.P.No.11078 of 2010 to consider the application of the petitioner without
making reference to the recommendation of State Government policy dated
07.01.2009.
The Committee considered the matter in its 193rd Meeting held on 21-22
June 2010 and decided to process the application.
The Committee considered the matter in its 195th Meeting held on 17-18
August, 2010 and decided to call for clarification from the institution.
The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and
decided to cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils
all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified
by the institution, as per the norms.
48.
APS02555
B.Ed
Gayathri
Educational
Society,
Mahabubnagar
District
AP
An application was submitted by Gayathri Educational Society,
Mahabubnagar District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to
B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 03.02.2004
The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the institutions
for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit
course(s).
The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of
Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of
State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
66
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
exceeding in numbers than required.
A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other
courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further
been decided that no further Recognition/ Permission to any
institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for
the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical
Education courses also”.
The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it
has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution. The
letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-26 March,
2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for the
year 2009-2010 and decided to close the applications.
As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 29.04.2009
The Institute has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.P.No.28641 of
2010 without approached to appellate authority.
Now, the Hon’ble High Court has passed an order on 19.11.2010 vide
W.P.No.28641 of 2010 reads as hereunder:
“It may be true that the State Government as well as the first respondent
have reviewed the situation as to the necessary or otherwise of according
permission to establish new colleges of education in the State in future and
that the existing institutions are found to be adequate. However, the right
that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their application and the
consideration thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken away on
account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever
an application is made, it must be considered and processed in accordance
with the provisions of law that existed as on the date of presentation.
Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made
thereafter.
Hence, the writ petition is also disposed of reiterating the same directions as
noticed supra. No costs.”
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
67
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The institution was caused inspection by SRC on 29.04.2005. A
deficiency letter dated 01.10.2008 was also issued and the institution
replied on 20.01.2009.
Again a letter dated 09.01.2009 to institution was issued for submitting the
following documents, which were submitted on 28.01.2009.
1. Affidavit dated 21.09.2009
2. Copy of Building Completion certificate (26,000 Sq.ft signed by
Government Engineer) for S.No. 261/2 Tadiparthy, Andhra Pradesh.
3. Copy of Land usage certificate from Tasildhar.
Apart from this the institution has submitted photo copies of FDR’s of Rs.5
lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs
In the mean while, in view of the recommendations of the State Government
of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical
Education, Language Pandit course(s) SRC decided to close the file vide
order dated 29.04.2009.
The SRC considered the Hon’ble court orders and all the relevant
documents by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the
premises as the earlier visit was more than five year old dated
29.4.2005.The institution is directed to submit the following within 30
days of the receipt of the notice, all the necessary documents for land,
building approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt.
Engineer and other relevant documents along with Demand Draft of
Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards the B.Ed course in favour of “The
Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore, for due consideration
and necessary orders.
49.
APS09669
B.Ed
Palnadu
College of
Education,
Guntur District
AP
An application was submitted by Ushodaya Residential School Committee,
Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed course in
the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 30.10.2008
The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the institutions for
conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s).
The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of State
Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new
colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
68
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in numbers
than required.
A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs informing
that the
“The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and
Physical Education courses have further been decided that no further
Recognition/ Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be
considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed,
and Physical Education courses also”.
The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has
been decided not to recommend the name of this institution. The letters
dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 was considered
by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC decided
to accept the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh,
not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
State of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to close the
applications.
As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 27.04.2009 and
original application and DD for Rs.40000/- to the institution is returned.
The Institute has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.P.No.21400/2010.
Now, the Hon’ble High Court has passed an order on 27.08.2010 as
hereunder:
“In the light of he orders passed by this court in similar W.P.Nos.6714 of
2009, 9360 of 2010, there shall be a direction to the 1st respondent to
consider the petitioner’s application for starting B.Ed., course in accordance
with law without reference to the State Government’s policy dated
17.01.2009.
Post along with W.P. Nos 6714 of 2009, 9360of 2010 and 11078 of 2010”.
SRC considered the matter in its 196th Meeting held on 15-16 September,
2010 Meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010 meeting and directed the
Management/institution to resubmit the old application returned by SRC
along with necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land,
building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion Certificate from
competent Government Engineer/authority and other relevant aspects for
processing and for necessary action.
As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on
25.10.2010. In response to this office letter dated 25.10.2010 the institution
has submitted reply vide letter dated 27.11.2010.
As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted following
documents vide letters dated 29.11.2010 :-
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
69
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
1. Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-)
2. Land documents-The Deed of Sale is Executed on 25th of November
2006 for Sy No 158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B. in favour of
Ushodaya Residential School Committee, Dachepalli.
3. BCC Certificate from Assistant Engineer. dated 10-11-2008, for Sy
No 158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B.Ed, Narayanapuram, Built
up area-17553.5 Sq.ft.
4. Land use Certificate by Tahsildar.
5. Approved Building Plan by Assistant Engineer, for Sy No-158/9A,
158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B.Ed, Land area-Ac.1-10guntas, Built up
area-1632.5 Sq.mts.
6. FDR submitted in photo copy original verified.
7. Encumbrance Certificate
8. Bye laws of Society Registration
9. Copy of Affidavit of Rs 100/- Sy No-158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A,
158/12B.Ed, Land area-Ac.1-10guntas, Built up area-1632.5 Sq.mts.
10. Copy of Original Application
50.
APS03213
D.Ed
Navodaya
College of
Education,
Mahabubnagar
AP
The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and
other documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
inspection.
Navodaya College of Education, Mahabubnagar District-509209,Andhra
Pradesh
Navodaya College of Education, Mahabubnagar District-509209, Andhra
Pradesh has submitted application for D.Ed on 30.01.2004. The application
was closed vide order dated 29.04.2009 in view of State ban endorsed by
NCTE, Hqrs.
The institution has moved to Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in
W.P.11930 of 2009 and judgement dated 14.12.2010 reads as follows:
“It may be true that the State Government as well as the 1st respondent
have reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according
permission to establish new colleges of education in the State in future and
that the existing institutions are found to be adequate. However, the right
that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their applications and the
consideration therefore by the 1st respondent cannot be taken away on
account of the changes of policy. It is settled principal of law that whatever
an application is made, it must be considered and processed in accordance
with the provision of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are
made thereafter.
Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take
necessary steps as contemplated in its communication…… and pass
appropriate orders……….”
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
70
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Now, the institution has submitted a letter dated 20.12.2010 along with the
following documents :
1. Judgement in W.P. 11930 of l2010 dated 14.12.2010.
2. Sale Deed along with notarised English version.
3. Application Form
4. Land Usage certificate
5. Land Conversation certificate
6. Building Completion Certificate
7. Copy of FDR of 5+3 Lakhs
8. Rejected order copy dated 29.01.2009.
9. Building plan
10. Affidavit
11. Deficiency letter dated 09.01.2009
12. Reply to Deficiency letter dt.17.01.2009
Hence, the institution has requested SRC, NCTE to issue Recognition order
for D.Ed course as per court order and directions.
The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and
other documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
inspection.
51.
APS07515
B.Ed
Padmavathi
College of
Education,
Dharmapuri
TN
Padmavathi College of Education, Sekkampatti, Harur Taluk, Dhramapuri
Dt. Tamilnadu
The institution has submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition
for B.Ed course on 23.10.2006.
The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
carried out on 25.4.2007. The visiting team report was placed before SRC in
its 135th meeting held on 7-8th June, 2007. The Committee decided to issue
notice. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on on 27.06.2007.
The institution submitted its written representation on 09.07.2007 &
11.07.2007. The reply was considered by SRC in its 139th meeting held on
6th-8th August 2007 and decided to issue seek clarification from the
institution.
Clarification letter was issued to the institution on 31.08.2007. The institution
submitted its reply to clarification on 06.09.2007. The reply was considered
by SRC in its 148th meeting held on 27-28th November 2007 and decided to
issue conditional recognition to the institution.
Recognition to the institution was granted on 03.12.2007 and got affiliation
from the Board/University dtd. 2.1.2008. The institution in its letter
dt.27.11.2008 has submitted Rs.40000/- for shifting and has proposed to
change the following:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
71
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010



To change the premises of Padmavathi College of Education at
Sekkampatti, Harur, Dharmapuri District to newly constructed college
premises at Idaikal, Pappakudi, Ambasamudram Taluk, Tirunelveli
District.
To change the name of “Padmavathi College of Education” as “Merit
College of Education”, Idaikal, Pappakudi, Ambasamudram Taluk,
Tirunelveli District.
To change the management from “Madras Education and Research
Integrated Trust” to “Merit Educational and Charitable Trust”,
Ambasamudram.
A letter was issued to the institution on 09.06.2009 (copy enclosed) to
submit the following essential documents so that the proposal for shifting of
premises by the institution may be examined :



Land documents in the name of Society/institution where the
proposed College is to be shifted.
Building Completion Certificate with details of built up area and that
the building is constructed for proposed shifting of B.Ed. College
from the Government Engineer.
…2
Infrastructural and instructional facilities provided for shifting the
College.
Original fixed deposit receipt for Rs.5 lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs from a
Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years to be submitted.
The institution filed a W.P.9226/2009 in the Hon’ble High Court of Madras
requesting to direct the SRC, NCTE to process the letter dt.8.12.2008,
where the request for change of premises of Padmavathi College of
Education from the present premises to the premises at Idaikal,
Ambasumudram Taluk, Tirunelveli was submitted.
The Hon’ble High Court of Madras in its judgement dt.10.06.2009 has
directed the SRC to process the application of the petitioner dt.8.12.2008
and pass appropriate orders thereon, if the petitioner has complied with the
requirements including the submission of the relevant documents by RD,
SRC vide its letter dt.9.6.2009. Further, it has directed that the decision has
be to taken within a period of eight weeks from the date of such compliance
submitted by the petitioner institution.
The reply of the institution has been received on 24.06.2009. The institution
has submitted that as it was informed that it is not possible to consider the
request made in the application for the change of name from Padmavathi
College of Education to Merit College of Education and to shift the
premises, the Demand Draft already taken for Rs.40,000/- was not handed
over. The contention of the institution is not clear from this submission.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
72
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
However, it is submitted that the application dated 08.12.2008 from
Padmavathi College of Education for shifting of premises from Sekkampatti
to Idaikal was submitted along with Rs.40,000/-. The institution has
requested to consider the documents and pass appropriate orders to admit
students in B.Ed course in the academic session 2009-2010 in newly
constructed permanent premises at Idaikal.
It appears from the letter dated 24.06.2009 received in response to this
office letter dated 09.06.2009 that the Sale deed Sl.No.D 072900 that it has
been executed between Merit Educational and Charitable Trust situated at
No.1, Gomathinagar, Ambasamudram, Ambasamudram Taluk, Tirunelveli
District and Padmavathi College of Education at Survey Nol.187/1 and
187/2 and not with Madras Education and Research Integrated Trust, which
had applied for recognition for Padmavathi College of Education,
Dharmapuri District, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course. Further, it is also observed
from the Sale deed that Padmavathi College of Education is executing sale
deed from Survey No.187/1 and 187/2 as purchaser for the schedule of
property at the same address which is not legally acceptable.
The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court of Madras order dated
10.6.2009 in W.P.No. 9226 of 2009 and the representations of the
Chairman, Padmavathi College of Education, the document submitted for
change of the premises and observed as follows:

The recognition was accorded to the Padmavathi College on
3.12.2007 as per regulations of NCTE, 2006. The institution
submitted Registered land lease deed for 99 years along with the
application (Registered on 16th October 2006) for grant of recognition
to the B.Ed. course. The application was processed and the
recognition accorded to continue in the same land and building as
per regulations of 2006.
….3
The representations of the institution indicate that now, the
Management desires to change the location of Padmavathi College
from Sekkampatti, Dharmapuri Dt. to Idaikal, Ambasamudram Taluk,
Tirunelveli Dt., Tamilnadu.
But, the records show that the
recognition was not granted in temporary premises. Therefore, the
Committee decided to issue Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act to
the institution and call the explanation violating the regulations of
NCTE and requesting for shifting of premises against the
regulations.
SRC decided to issue notice under section 17.Accordingly, show cause
notice was issued to the institution on 06.08.2009 (copy enclosed) for the
following reasons:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
73
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010






The reasons for shifting from permanent accommodation at
Sekkampatti, Dharmapuri Dt. to another permanent accommodation
at Idaikal, Ambasamudram Taluk, Tirunelveli Dt., Tamilnadu and
change of Trust, which amounts to selling an existing institution and
starting of a new institution as such, with a commercial / speculation
motive.
The Management of Madras Education and Research Integrated
Trust Chairman got recognition for Padmavathi College of Education
at Sekkkampatti, Dharmapuri whereas now the Management sent
the Sale Deed between Merit Educational and Charitable Trust and
Padmavathi College of Education.
The Management has to send the Trust deeds of both the Trusts and
also to clarify about the reasons for the change of Trust.
The Management has also to clarify whether the assets of Madras
Educational and Charitable Research Integrated Trust are
transferred to Merit Educational Trust or the MERIT Educational
Trust, which is in no way connected, has sold the land to the
Padmavathi College.
The documents of the existing location i.e., land document, building
plan, building Completion, List of the faculty has to be submitted.
The Fixed deposit receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs towards endowment fund
and Rs. 3 lakhs towards Reserve fund kept in joint account for 5
years is to be submitted in Original.
The institution submitted its reply on 27.08.2009. The SRC considered the
reply in its 183rd meeting held on 22nd September 2009 and decided not to
permit the shifting of College from one permanent location in one District to
another District, which is tentamount to starting of a new College, using the
approval of NCTE given for a different institution in a different region. There
is no provision for such geographical shifting, in Regulations of NCTE.
The same was informed to the institution on 03.11.2009. Meantime, the
institution has filed another court order in W.P. No. 26328 of 2009.
Accordingly, the original file of the institution was sent to the advocate on
18.8.2010.
A court judgement has been received from the Hon’ble High Court on
16.12.2010, the court has ordered as follows “……the impugned order
passed by the first respondent(SRC-NCTE) is quashed and the matter is
remanded to the first respondent for fresh consideration in terms of the
relevant regulations and other instructions governing the shifting of the
institution. It is made clear that the first respondent shall do the said
exercise within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order. The writ petition is disposed of accordingly. No costs”.
Court order dt.03.12.2010 in W.P.26328 of 2009 is placed before SRC
along with relevant file for direction and decision.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
74
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The SRC considered the Hon’ble court orders and decided to refer the
matter to the Headquarters for guidance (without waiting for
confirmation of minutes), as the matter involves violation of the very
spirit of the regulations and norms and as it would open up the
possible misuse of NCTE recognition orders granted for a particular
institution in a particular District/State, for establishing another
institution in another District/State, and thereby treating the teacher
education institution as a mobile/commercial venture and also treating
the NCTE recognition orders as a marketable license/commodity for
speculative gains of the vested interests.
52.
APS08525
B.Ed-DE
Annamalai
University,
Directorate of
Distance
Education,
Annamalai
Nagar
TN
Annamalai University, Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai Nagar,
Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering B.Ed-DE course with an
intake of 500 students on 09.04.2008.
Meanwhile a letter dated 24.9.2010 has been received from Shr.
Elangovadav, Working President, Tamilnadu Samajwadi Party addressed to
Chairman, NCTE, New Delhi.
The letter reads as follows: “We Tamilnadu Samajwadi Party Office Bearers
want to meet you during October 6th 2010 on Convocation at Annamalai
University. We want to submit a Memorandum in regarding Students
Admission B.Ed course in Distance Education, Annamalai University. Hence
we want an appointment on the same date for the above mentioned matter”.
As directed by, NCTE-Hqrs letter dated 5.10.2010 was issued to the
Registrar, Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai University and
Dean, Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai University seeking
information about number of students enrolled in the above programme
during the year 2008, 2009 and 2010 and also about the no of students
appeared and passed the examination during the said years. But the
university has not submitted reply so far.
The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
October 2010 and decided to cause inspection under section 17 of NCTE.
Again a reminder was issued to the university on 01.11.2010.
Inspection of the university was conducted on 21-22nd November 2010, SRC
considered the VT report in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November
2010 and the committee decided to seek clarification from the university.
The university submitted its reply on 25.11.2010.
Meanwhile, another complaint dated 27.11.2010 received on 14.12.2010
has been received from President, Tamilnadu Samajwadi Party stating as
follows:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
75
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
“I am asking your attention, admission in B.Ed, D.D.E Annamalai University
I come to understood that there are countless violations in admissions of
students of B.Ed, in Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai
University in the years of 2008-2009, 2009-2010. I want a proper enquiry
regarding this. I am again and again asking Chairman NCTE to undertake
sufficient enquiry regarding the above mentioned B.Ed admission in D.D.E
Annamalai University, Tamilnadu State”.
Number of RTI queries being received regarding courses run by the
Annamalai University.
As per record D.P.Ed, B.P.Ed and M.P.Ed both Regular & Distance mode is
not recognized by SRC-NCTE.
It has been brought to the notice of NCTE-SRC that Annamalai University is
offering certain courses under its Faculty of Education which have not been
recognized as provided under NCTE Act and Regulations. On 29.11.2010 a
letter was addressed to the Registrar, Annamalai University, Cuddalore
seeking the following;
1. Copies of recognition orders for each course, if any – copies may be
forwarded.
2. Whether the above courses are run on regular basis or Distance
Education mode; specify separately.
3. Recognition obtained for each Study Centre, Course wise, Location
Wise - enclose copies of the orders if any.
4. Details of each Study Centre course wise along with infrastructural
and other facilities.
5. The date of starting of each course with intake.
6. The following admission details may be furnished for each course;
 No. of applications received for each course.
 No. of students admitted for each course.
 No of students appeared in examination for each course.
 No of students passed/qualified in each course.
7. No. of students allotted to each study centres, year wise, course
wise.
8. No. of faculty appointed on a full time regular basis and distance
mode for each of the courses.
In reply the University vide its letter dated 2.12.2010 has stated as follows;
“We are offering D.P.Ed, B.P.Ed, M.P.Ed and M.Ed courses through oncampus mode only with due approval of the appropriate authorities of the
University Viz., Syndicate, Academic and Senate. The strength of the
Physical Education Faculty is 111.
Further, we wish to inform you that we are not offering the D.P.Ed., B.P.Ed.,
M.P.Ed and M.Ed courses through Distance Education mode and hence the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
76
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
other particulars required does not arise”.
A letter was also issued to the university on 7.12.2010 in continuation to this
office letter dated 29.11.2010 regarding applications for admissions to
D.P.Ed., B.P.Ed and M.P.Ed courses called for by the university in their
website. A reminder is also issued on 20.12.2010.
They were requested that admissions and admission process for these
courses (D.P.Ed, B.P.Ed and M.P.Ed) may be stopped immediately. They
were
also
directed
to
withdraw
the
advertisement
inviting
applications/admissions for the said courses.
The reply from the university has not been received so far.
53.
The SRC considered the matter and decided to inform the University
that the NCTE will be constrained to take all necessary steps including
the issue of public-notice/Press note, in leading newspapers bringing
to the attention of the public about the conduct of the unrecognized
programmes by the Annamalai University, action be taken without
waiting for the confirmation of minutes of the meeting.
AOSO0156
DBHPS Lal Bahadur Shastri College of Education, 113/114, S.C. Road,
B.Ed
Sheshadripuram, Bangalore – 560020, Karnataka for B.Ed Course of one
DBHPS Lal
year duration. The institution was granted recognition for offering B.Ed course
Bahadur
with an intake of 100 students from the session 2000-2001 vide. Order
Shastri College dated 10.07.2000.
of Education,
Bangalore
SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the
KA
complaint and decided to call for the remarks from the institution on the
allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka. Accordingly, letter was
issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. SRC in its 191st meeting held on
20-21 April 2010 considered the written representation submitted on
30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection under section 17.
Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 3.6.2010 and the Committee
considered the Report and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course
for the following reasons : As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management, the
total built-up-area of the building comes to 6736 sq.ft. which is far
short of the NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
 Language lab. is not available.
 Games and Sports facilities is not available. Corporation Ground is
being used.
 As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management, 2 staff
members do not possess requisite qualification as per NCTE norms.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decided to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect. It is made clear that the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
77
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the
date of issue of this order. The State Government/Affiliating University be
informed accordingly.
Accordingly, recognition was withdrawn vide order dated 02.08.2010 and
the institution has preferred appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act, to NCTE,
Hqrs. The appeal file has already been sent to Hqrs. The decision of
appeal is awaited.
Now, a letter from NCTE, hqrs in its letter dated 30.11.2010 has forwarded a
complaint against DBHPS Lalbahadur Shastri College of Education,
Bangalore received through e-mail from Whistle Blowerr.
The committee noted the above points received from Headquarters
office, as the recognition had already been withdrawn for the above
institution.
54.
---Hindi -DE
Complaint on
trade of marks
cards and
certificate in
respect of
Hindi Distance
Education
KA
Received Complaint on trade of marks cards and certificate in respect of
Hindi Distance Education, on the following 5 institutions.of Kanataka:
1) ASP00602. B.Ed, DBHPS Dr. B.D Jatti College of Education,
Belgaum.
DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti College of Education, Civil Hospital Road, Ayodhya
Nagar, Belgaum – 590 001, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for
offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60 students from the session 20002001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.
A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi Prachar
Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson, NCTE, New
Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-administration of DBHPS
institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was forwarded to SRC from
NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant has requested NCTE to
make investigation and to punish the real culprits and the officials
concerned.
Further, this office is in receipt of another letter dated 19.08.2009 from
Sri.Om Narain, Lecturer of Hari Bawa Inter College Gawan, Badaun District,
Uttar Pradesh regarding malpractices in B.Ed College of Dakshin Bharath
Hindi Prachar Sabha, Karnataka. The above letter was forwarded by
NCTE, Hqrs on 16.11.2009.
The complainant states that the annual intake in B.Ed classes was fixed at
100 students and the following colleges are admitting more than 100
students and adjusting these excess students against the leftover vacant
seats for the preceding years i.e.2007-2008 & 2008-2009:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
78
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
1.
2.
3.
DBHPS Dr.B.D.Jatti Siksha College, Afzalpur, Takke Athani
Road, Bijapur – 586101, Karnataka
DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti Siksha College, Jila Hasptal Rasta
(District Hospital Road), Belgaum – 590001.
Vishveshwara Siksha College, K.R. Mohalla, Bani Vilas
Road, Mysore – 570 004.
Further, the complainant has stated that these students neither attend the
classes nor go to teaching schools, even then they get more than 80%
marks and has requested to investigate into the matter and punish the
defaulters.
SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the above
two complaints and decided to call for the following remarks from the
institution on the allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka.
Accordingly, letter was issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The
institution submitted its written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its
191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 considered the written
representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection
under section 17.
Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 01.06.2010 and the Committee
considered the Report and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course
for the following reasons : As per VT Report and as countersigned by the institution, the total builtup-area earmarked for the course is 8,109 sq.ft.; but on calculation, the
total built–up–area comes to only 4976.43 sq.ft. It is far less than NCTE
norms of 16,000 sq.ft. of built-up-area.
 As per VT report and as countersigned by the institution, three teachers
are not qualified as per NCTE norms.
 As per VT report and as countersigned by the institution, the institution is
in the habit of carrying forward the shortage of admissions(unfilled seats
of previous years) to the next year and is admitting more than the
stipulated intake of 100 in subsequent years as and when demand
increases/comes.
This unacademic/commercial practice is not
acceptable as per the norms.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect.
It is made clear that
the institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to
the date of issue of this order.
The State Government/affiliating University be informed accordingly.
2) APS00598. B.Ed, DBHPS Rajiv Gandhi College of Education
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
79
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Dharwad.
DBHPS Rajiv Gandhi College of Education, D.C. Compound, Dharwad –
580001, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed.
course with an intake of 60 students from the session 2000-2001 vide order
dated 10.07.2000.
A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi Prachar
Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson, NCTE, New
Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-administration of DBHPS
institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was forwarded to SRC from
NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant has requested NCTE to
make investigation and to punish the real culprits and the officials
concerned.
SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the
complaint and decided to call for the remarks from the institution on the
allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka. Accordingly, letter was
issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The institution submitted its written
representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its 191st meeting held on 20-21 April
2010 considered the written representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and
decided to cause inspection under section 17. Accordingly, inspection was
carried out on 02.06.2010
Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 01.06.2010 and the Committee
considered the Report and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course
for the following reasons : As per VT Report and as countersigned and admitted by the institution, the
total built-up-area of the building comes to 7963 sq.ft. It is far short of the
NCTE norm of 16,000 sq.ft.
 As per VT Report and as admitted by the institution, one Lecturer and
Principal do not possess requisite qualification and are not qualified as
per NCTE norms.
 Records were not produced to verify the quantum of admissions done by
the College giving room for suspecting the credentials.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect. It is made clear that the
institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the
date of issue of this order. The State Government/ affiliating University be
informed accordingly.
3) APS00596 B.Ed,
Bijapur.
DBHPS Dr. B.D Jatti College of Education
DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti College of Education, Afzalpur Takke, Bijapur -
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
80
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
506102, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed.
course with an intake of 60 students from the session 2000-2001 vide order
dated 10.07.2000.
A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi Prachar
Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson, NCTE, New
Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-administration of DBHPS
institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was forwarded to SRC from
NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant has requested NCTE to
make investigation and to punish the real culprits and the officials
concerned.
Further, this office is in receipt of another letter dated 19.08.2009 from
Sri.Om Narain, Lecturer of Hari Bawa Inter College Gawan, Badaun District,
Uttar Pradesh regarding malpractices in B.Ed College of Dakshin Bharath
Hindi Prachar Sabha, Karnataka. The above letter was forwarded by
NCTE, Hqrs on 16.11.2009.
The complainant states that the annual intake in B.Ed classes was fixed at
100 students and the following colleges are admitting more than 100
students and adjusting these excess students against the leftover vacant
seats for the preceding years i.e.2007-2008 & 2008-2009:
1. DBHPS Dr.B.D.Jatti Siksha College, Afzalpur, Takke Athani Road, Bijapur
– 586101, Karnataka
2. DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti Siksha College, Jila Hasptal Rasta (District Hospital
Road), Belgaum – 590001.
3. Vishveshwara Siksha College, K.R. Mohalla, Bani Vilas Road, Mysore –
570 004.
Further, the complainant has stated that these students neither attend the
classes nor go to teaching schools, even then they get more than 80%
marks and has requested to investigate into the matter and punish the
defaulters.
SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the above
two complaints and decided to call for the following remarks from the
institution on the allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka.
Accordingly, letter was issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The
institution submitted its written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its
191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 considered the written
representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection
under section 17.
Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 03.06.2010 and the Committee
considered the Report and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course
for the following reasons :-
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
81
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 As per VT Report and as admitted/countersigned by the institution, the
total built-up-area of the building comes to 6208 sq.ft. which is far short of
the NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
 Shiksha Snatak course is also being run in the same building.
 Psychology lab. materials needs to be strengthened. There is no
Language learning lab.
 In 2008-09 and 2009-10 academic year , institutions have made
admissions of 120 and 121 respectively which is more than the intake
sanctioned and thus violated NCTE norms.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect. It is made clear that the
institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the
date of issue of this order. The State Government/ affiliating University be
informed accordingly.
4) APS0156
Bangalore
B.Ed. DBHPS Lal Bahadur Shastri College of Education
DBHPS Lal Bahadur Shastri College of Education, 113/114, S.C. Road,
Sheshadripuram, Bangalore – 560 020, Karnataka was granted recognition
by SRC for offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60 students from the
session 2000-2001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.
A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi Prachar
Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson, NCTE, New
Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-administration of DBHPS
institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was forwarded to SRC from
NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant has requested NCTE to
make investigation and to punish the real culprits and the officials
concerned.
SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the
complaint and decided to call for the remarks from the institution on the
allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka. Accordingly, letter was
issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. SRC in its 191st meeting held on
20-21 April 2010 considered the written representation submitted on
30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection under section 17.
Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 3.6.2010 and the Committee
considered the Report and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course
for the following reasons : As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management, the total
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
82
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
built-up-area of the building comes to 6736 sq.ft. which is far short of the
NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
 Language lab. is not available.
 Games and Sports facilities is not available. Corporation Ground is being
used.
 As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management, 2 staff
members do not possess requisite qualification as per NCTE norms.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect. It is made clear that the
institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the
date of issue of this order. The State Government/Affiliating University be
informed accordingly
5) APS00600, B.Ed. DBHPS Basaveswara College of Education,
Mysore.
DBHPS Basaveswara College of Education, ‘Hindi Bhavan’ V.V. Road,
K.R.Mohalla, Mysore – 570 004, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC
for offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60 students from the session
2000-2001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.
A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi Prachar
Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson, NCTE, New
Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-administration of DBHPS
institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was forwarded to SRC from
NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant has requested NCTE to
make investigation and to punish the real culprits and the officials
concerned.
Further, this office is in receipt of another letter dated 19.08.2009 from
Sri.Om Narain, Lecturer of Hari Bawa Inter College Gawan, Badaun District,
Uttar Pradesh regarding malpractices in B.Ed College of Dakshin Bharath
Hindi Prachar Sabha, Karnataka. The above letter was forwarded by
NCTE, Hqrs on 16.11.2009.
The complainant states that the annual intake in B.Ed classes was fixed at
100 students and the following colleges are admitting more than 100
students and adjusting these excess students against the leftover vacant
seats for the preceding years i.e.2007-2008 & 2008-2009:
1.
DBHPS Dr.B.D.Jatti Siksha College, Afzalpur, Takke Athani
Road, Bijapur – 586101, Karnataka
2.
DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti Siksha College, Jila Hasptal Rasta
(District Hospital Road), Belgaum – 590001.
3.
Vishveshwara Siksha College, K.R. Mohalla, Bani Vilas
Road, Mysore – 570 004.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
83
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Further, the complainant has stated that these students neither attend the
classes nor go to teaching schools, even then they get more than 80%
marks and has requested to investigate into the matter and punish the
defaulters.
SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the above
two complaints and decided to call for the following remarks from the
institution on the allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka.
Accordingly, letter was issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The
institution submitted its written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its
191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 considered the written
representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection
under section 17. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 04.06.2010.
The Committee considered the VT report and observed the following:As per the VTR, and examination of other relevant documents, it was
observed that
1. The built-up-area is only 4368.2 sq.ft., which is far short of the NCTE
norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
2. Sports facilities, Games facilities are not available.
3. Library is having only 800 books related to Education, which are
grossly inadequate.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect. But, it is made clear that
the institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to
the date of issue of this order. The State Government/ affiliating University
be informed accordingly.
The SRC decided to call for remarks from the institution regarding
Complaint on Trade of Marks Cards and Certificate in respect of Hindi
Teacher Education programmes from the above five institutions in
Karnataka; though the recognition of these institutions had already
been withdrawn, the matter is pursued for any foul play on the conduct
of programme in the past.
55.
APS01884
D.Ed
Sri Rudramuni
Swamiji D.Ed
College,
Tumkur District
KA
Sri.Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed College, Tiptur, Pin – 572201, Tumkur District,
Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed. course with an intake
of 50 students vide order dated 01.12.2004 in a temporary premises with a
condition that it should shift to its own building within 3 years, i.e., on or
before 30.11.2007. The Institution is still running in temporary premises and
not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3 years and
after lapse of time period of more than 6 years.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
84
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Now the institution in its letter dated 14.06.2010 has submitted a proposal
for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee vide
A letter dated 25.11.2010 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
forwarding a copy of the letter dated 29.10.2010 received from Sri
Nandakumar Complainant against Sri.Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed
College, Tumkur District, Karnataka. NCTE, Hqrs had requested
SRC to look into the facts of the complaint by placing before the
Regional Committee in the ensuing meeting and take action under the
provision of the NCTE Act and to furnish action taken report to the
Hqrs.
 The committee considered the Headquarters
communication
regarding the complaint against Sr. Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed
College, Tumkur district, Karnataka, and decided to cause shifting
inspection of the premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The
institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the
receipt of the notice, duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the
necessary documents for land, building approval and completion
certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and other relevant
documents towards the D.Ed course being run and to ascertain
infrastructural and instructional facilities.
 The Committee considered the complaint and decided to call for
Affidavit from the complainant.
56.
APS08226
D.T.Ed
Akathiyar
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Pudukottai
TN
Akathiyar Teacher Training Institute has submitted an application for grant
of recognition to D.T.Ed course on 21.02.2007. Recognition to the institution
was granted on 11.12.2007.
A letter No.6805/C3/2008 dt.20.06.2008 was received from the State
Government of Tamilnadu on the above institution informing the deficiencies
that exist and non-maintenance of Norms and Standards prescribed for
D.T.Ed course by NCTE.
The letter of the State Government referred above was placed before SRC
in its 161st meeting of SRC held on 6-7 August, 2008. The SRC considered
the letter of the State Government of Tamilnadu along with the application
file of the institution and decided to issue notice under Section 17 of NCTE
Act. Accordingly, notice u/s 17 was issued to the institution on 24.10.2008.
The institution submitted its reply on 28.11.2008. The reply was placed
before SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 and decided to
communicate the reply to the State Government of Tamilnadu for their
considered response, for necessary action. Accordingly, a letter was sent to
The Director, DTERT on 04.03.2009.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
85
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
DTERT vide letter No.Rc.No.8872/C3/2009 dated 19.06.2009 had stated
that the inspection committee had inspected the institution and the
deficiencies are noted in the institution.
The Committee in its 181st Meeting held on 20-21 August, 2009 considered
the complaint received from the Director, DTERT, Chennai and decided to
issue showcause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act by sending
Questionnaire and also to call remarks on deficiencies mentioned against
the institution. Accordingly, notice under section 17 was issued to the
institution on 27.08.2009. The institution vide letter dated 22.09.2009 has
submitted reply along with the court order.
The committee in its 185th Meeting held on 26-27 November, 2009
considered the reply to the Notice and has decided to conduct inspection
under section 17 after submission of fee of Rs.40,000/- by the institution.
Accordingly, a letter was sent to the institution on 05.01.2010 to submit
Rs.40000/- inspection fee. The institution submitted its reply on 08.02.2010
along with Rs.40000/-.
Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 07.07.2010. The
VT report was considered by SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21st-22nd July
2010 and decided to call for clarification from the institution. Accordingly a
letter was issued to the institution on 23.08.2010 to submit the reply within
21 days. The reply from the institution was not received, SRC considered
the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 and
decided issue show cause notice for not responding to the letter issued
to the institution on 23.8.2010 for clarification.
Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 26.10.2010. The
institution submitted its reply on 26.11.2010.
The Committee considered the written reply of the institution on the
above matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and
decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons: The building has asbestos sheeted roof in the first floor and toilets ,
this is against the NCTE norms.
 Education technology lab is is to strengthened..
 Language Lab is not available.
 Library is in a hall. Library has got 1115 books, of which only 800
numbers are related to Education.
 As per the State Government report, part time and retired teachers
are appointed.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
86
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The reply submitted by the institution on 26.11.2010 for the above
queries, has not given proper genuine reasons.
As the institution was already served a show cause notice and given
opportunity/time of 30 days for explaining its position, the Committee
decides to withdraw the recognition for D.T.Ed. course with effect from
2012-13 to enable the present batch of student to complete the course.
But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any
further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order. The
DTERT, Government of Tamilnadu be informed accordingly for
necessary enforcement.
57.
APS08469
D.T.Ed
Sri Lakshmi
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Perambalur
TN
K.N. Kuppusamy Educational Trust, Perambalur District, Tamilnadu
has made application for grant of recognition to Sri Lakshmi Teacher
Training Institute, T. Palur Road, Jayankondam, Perambalur District,
Tamilnadu for D.T.Ed course to SRC on 28.02.2007.
The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
conducted on 29.08.2007. Recognition to the institution was granted on
11.01.2008.
Meanwhile, NCTE-Hqrs has forwarded a complaint copy received against
the institution from Nurse Associations Government Hospital, Jayankondam
(Ministry Reference).
SRC considered the complaint in its 193rd meeting held on 22nd-23rd June
2010 and decided to call for remarks from the institution and to obtain
affidavit from the complainant. Accordingly a letter was issued to institution
and complainant dt.27.7.2010.
The institution vide letter dated 29.11.2010 submitted its reply stating as
follows:
“First of all we wish to state that there is no such nurse association in
Jayankondam. This is an attempt made by my porfessional and political
enemies to hurdle my progress. It is an unauthorized petition.
Our K.N. Kupusamy Educational Trust owns about 25 acres of land.
Out of which 10.5 acres of land has been allotted to KKC College of
Engineering & Technology, 5 acres of land is allotted for the functioning of
the educational institution (B.Ed& D.T.Ed) and the remaining land is kept in
reserve for our future program. The Engineering College and the
educational institution are functioning in separate buildings constructed in
the land exclusively allotted to them.
Further I wish to state that very same complaint had already been
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
87
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
sent to the AICTE and the same was investigated by the AICTE. A
committee constituted by the Regional Office, AICTE, Chennai comprising
of a civil engineer, a legal expert and the local Revenue Authority
(Thasilthar) has inspected the spot on 16.03.2010
Based on the report of the committee and after perusal, the AICTE,
New Delhi has sanctioned approval for starting Engineering College. The
College started functioning from the academic year 2010-2010. This clearly
reveals that the complaint is not genuine.
The other complaints against me and my son are purely personal
and is launched by my political and professional enemies to interrupt my
progress. Those complaints are not true”.
58.
7177
B.Ed
Yalamarty
College of
Education,
Visakhapatna
m,
AP
The reply from the complainant is not received. A reminder has been issued
has been issued on 14.12.2010.
The Committee noted the remarks from the institution.
Yalamarty College of Education, Visakhapatnam District, Andhra Pradesh
submitted an application for B.Ed course on 27.06.2006. The application
was processed and the recognition was granted to the institution vide order
dated 20.04.2007 with stipulated conditions.
The society submitted an application for TPT course vide application
dated.11.03.2008 in the office of SRC. The same was processed and
inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.07.2008. The VTR, VCD
and other relevant documents were placed before SRC in its 162nd meeting
held on 20th-30st August 2008. The committee decided to issue notice to the
institution for the reasons mentioned therein. Accordingly, a notice was
issued to the institution dated.28.08.2008. The institution submitted its
written representation on 06.10.2008. The same was placed before SRC in
its 166th meeting held on 18th-19th October 2008. The SRC after careful
consideration of all aspects decided to refuse recognition for TPT course.
While considering the written representation for TPT course the Committee
also decided to issue notice under section 17 for the existing B.Ed course
for taking action. Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on
19.01.2009. The institution submitted its written representation on
10.02.2009. on 15.05.2009 TPT was recognized on the basis of appeal.
The written representation was considered by SRC in its 170th meeting held
on 16th & 17th February 2009. The committee considered the reply in the
light of the letter dated 13th March 2009 received from NCTE-Hqrs and
decide to ask the institution to submit own registered exclusive land
documents as per Para 8(7) of NCTE Act, 2007 of NCTE regulation:The Para 8(7) of regulations 2007 of NCTE reads as “No institution
shall be granted recognition under these regulations unless it is in
possession of required land on the date of application. The land free
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
88
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
from all encumbrances could be either on ownership basis or on
lease from Government/Government institutions for a period of not
less than 30 years.
In cases where under relevant State/UT
Administration law shall prevail. However, no building could be taken
on lease for running any teacher training course”.
Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 09.04.2009. The
institution submitted its written representation on 06.05.2009.
SRC
considered the written representation in its 176th meeting held on 27th-28th
meeting May 2009 and decided to cause Inspection to the institution under
Section 17 of NCTE Act for the B.Ed. course. Accordingly, a letter seeking
clarification was issued to the institution on 25.06.2009. The institution has
submitted its reply on 28.07.2009.
The Committee in its 181st Meeting held on 20-30 August, 2009 decided to
issue Showcause Notice and Notice was issued to the institution on
2.9.2009 under Section 17 of NCTE Act asking the Management to submit
the Certificate from the affiliating body of Pharmacy College and Institute of
Computer Science courses stating that the building constructed on Sy.No.
125/23, 128/7, 128/8 has not been used for the respective courses, except
for B.Ed course recognized by NCTE.
Institution has submitted reply to the Notice on 22.9.2009. The Committee
considered the matter and decided to cause Inspection under Section 17
with fee of Rs.40,000/- by the institution.
Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 05.01.2010. The
institution has not submitted its reply even after expiry of stipulated period.
The matter was considered by SRC in its 193rd Meeting held on 30-22
June, 2010 and SRC decided to cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed
course under section 17 of NCTE Act.
Accordingly, inspection of the institution was carried out on 26.08.2010.
Meanwhile an order has been received in the office of SRC from Hon’ble
High Court in W.P.M.P NOS: 24378 & 24379 of 2010 in W.P. NO: 19250 of
2010. The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order dated 16.08.2010 as
under:“The petitioner institution was directed to be inspected by the National
Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) by order of this Court dated
05.07.2010 in W.P.M.P. No.2061 of 2010 in W.P. No.1552 of 2010. This
exercise was directed to be completed upon payment of inspection fee by
the petitioner within six weeks. In the meanwhile, counseling for B.Ed,
admissions for the academic year 2010-2011 has commenced. Therefore ,
the petitioner college runs the risk of not being given admissions for this
academic year pending its inspection by the NCTE.
In that view of the matter, there shall be a direction to the third respondent
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
89
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
University to consider the case of the petitioner for granting affiliation for the
academic year 2010-2011 without reference to the approval of the NCTE
subject to the petitioner fulfilling all other conditions of eligibility for such
affiliation. Upon such affiliation being granted, the fourth respondent shall
include the petitioner college in the process of second phase of counseling
for making admissions to the B.Ed course for the academic year 20102011”.
The Committee in its 196th meeting held on 15-16, September 2010
considered the VT report, all the relevant documentary evidence and it was
decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :
 The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
Government Engineer is not submitted.
 The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
competent Govt. authority.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including
the withdrawal, based on the records available, with no further notice.
59.
APS02162
B.Ed
Jnana Bharathi
B.Ed College,
Chikamanglore
KA
Jnana Bharathi B.Ed College, N.H.206, Kadur-577548, Chikmangalore
District, Karnataka has submitted application for B.Ed course on
31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition for B.Ed course
with an intake of 100 students on 01.12.2004.
As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May
2009, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have
been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction
of own building or in lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed course in the
State of Karnataka.
A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its
176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the
expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE
Act for further action. As per the decision of SRC, notice dated 02.09.2009
was issued asking to explain as to why the institution has not shifted to its
own premises as on date by supporting with relevant documents along with
Questionnaire.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
90
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The institution did not respond to the Notice served on the institution, for
their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the lapse of three
years stipulated period permitted in their conditional orders of recognition
and the matter was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16
September 2010. SRC decided to issue Showcause Notice and accordingly
showcause notice was issued to the institution on 26.10.2010.
The institution submitted its written representation on 29.11.2010. The
institution is yet to submit Bye-laws of the Trust/society and further,
60.
SRCAPP
110
B.Ed
Aazad College
of Education,
Prakasam
AP
The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to
cause Shifting inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, under
Section 17 of NCTE Act, to verify the facts and directed the institution
to submit the filled in Questionnaire, Land & Building documents,
Land use Certificate, Encumbrance certificate and all other relevant
documents including shifting inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- within 30
days from the date of the letter for further necessary action.
An application was submitted by SR Educational and Rural Development
Society submitted an application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition to
Aazad College of Education, Kandukur, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh
for B.Ed course on 03.11.2009.
The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
Government for recommendation on 20.11.2009. A deficiency letter was
issued to the institution on 22.12.2009 for the following points:1. Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent
authority:- The land does not seem to be registered with the Govt.
authority (competent authority) hence land document duly registered
with competent authority to be submitted.
2. Notarized copy of change of land use certificate issued by the
competent authority:- The institution has not submitted notarized copy of
land use certificate issued by the Competent Authority. Hence the
institution is required to submit notarized copy of CLU (Agricultural
lands-conversion to Non-Agricultural purpose) issued by Competent
Authority.
3. Minority Certificate:- The institution is claimed as minority institution as
per application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
certificate in this regard. Hence the institution is required to submit
minority certificate issued by Competent Authority.
The State Government has made negative recommendation vide letter no.
22042/Gen.II/A2/2009 dated 05.01.2010. The institution submitted its written
representation on 22.02.2009.
The SRC considered the written representation in its 190th meeting held on
29-30th March 2010 and the committee decided to reject the application for
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
91
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
want of valid Minority Certificate from the Competent Authority.
The institution has filed appeal under Section 18 of NCTE Act, before the
Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi against the refusal order of SRC.
The Appellate Authority has vide order dated 19.07.2010 remanded back
the case to SRC.
The order of appellate authority dated 19.7.2010 remanding the case was
considered by the Committee and it was decided to cause inspection of the
institution for B.Ed. Course, on payment of Rs.40, 000/- inspection fee and
on submission of relevant supporting documents relating to building, land,
including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
Engineer, Land Use Certificate and others.
The institution has submitted inspection fee, inspection was however carried
out on 18.09.2010, in anticipation of the fee payment.
The VT report was considered by the committee in its 197th meeting held on
13th-14th of October 2010, and also VCD and all the relevant documentary
evidences and it was decided to serve show cause notice for the following:
 As per the VT report the built-up area earmarked for the sadi course
is 3556.59 sq.mts, whereas as per bulding completion certificate dt.
10.7.2009 the built up area is given as 16742 sq.ft. The discrepancy
between building plan, building completion certificate and VT report
shoud be explained.
 A certificate is to be produced from the Affiliating University/ body to
the effect that no other programme is being run by the management
in the same building/campus, along with the existing B.Ed,
course/programme. The evidence of exclusive land and building in a
separately earmarked campus to be submitted.
 The institution be asked to pay the inspection of Rs. 40,000/immediately.
The institution has submitted its reply to the Show Cause Notice vide
its letter dt. 15.12.10 and the matter was considered in 199th meeting.
61.
9637
B.Ed
Sri
Narayanadri
College of
Education,
The SRC considered the VT report, VCD, reply to the show cause
notice and all relevant documents and decided to issue LOI.for grant
of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual
intake of 100(One hundred only)(one unit) for the academic year 201112 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly
constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State
Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the
commencement of the academic session.
An application was submitted by Lakshmi Vishnu Priya Educational Women
& Rural Development Society, Kadapa Distt, Andhra Pradesh for grant of
recognition to B.Ed Course in the office of SRC-NCTE Bangalore vide dated
24.10.2008.
The file
was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
92
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Kadapa District recommendations of the State Govt. of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated
AP
07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
conducting B.Ed., D.Ed., and physical Education. Another letter dated
17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE Head Quarters informing that the
recommendation of the Govt. of AP not to grant recognition/permission in
respect of other courses like B.Ed., D.Ed. and physical Education courses
have further considered in SRC and decided to no further
recognition/permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh.
The above letter dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 and 17.03.2009 were
considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25-26th March 2009 and
decided to accept the recommendation of State Govt. and not to grant
recognition to any of the teacher training institution in the state AP for the
year of 2009-2010 and return the application with procession fee on
28.04.2009.
The institution ignored to approach Appellate Authority, NCTE Head
Quarters and directly approached Hon’ble High Court in writ petition no
13354/2010 wherein the Hon’ble High court passed an order as under:This writ petition is filed for the following substantive relief:“the writ petition is disposed of in terms of the above-mentioned order in writ
petition no 6712/2009 with a direction to the 3rd respondent to consider the
application of the petitioner and pass appropriate orders within six weeks.”
The order copy in 6712 of 2009 shall form part of this order.
The matter was considered by the Committee in its 194th Meeting held on
30-22 July, 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for
B.Ed course, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on submission
of all the relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including
Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer
and Land Use Certificate.
Accordingly, inspection of the institution was carried on 04.09.2010. The
institution has till date not submitted inspection fee of Rs.40000/- though we
have written to institution on 06.08.2010.
The Committee in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary evidences and
was decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institute
has replied on 18.11.2010.
 The institution be directed that a Certificate from the Government
Affiliating University/body to the effect that no other programme is
being run/shared by the institution in the same building / Campus,
along with the B.Ed be submitted, and also the Inspection fee of Rs.
40,000/-, within a period of 30 days failing which final decision,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
93
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
including refusal of recognition wil be taken. This is to be treated as
the show cuase notice.
62.
APS01662
APS05394
D.Ed
D.Ed-AI
Shree
Gomatesh
Education
Society’s
Marathi
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Belgaum
KA
Shree Gomatesh Education Society’s Marathi Teacher Training Institute,
Ankali-591303, Chikodi Taluk, Belgaum District, Karnataka has submitted
application for D.Ed course on 28.12.2005. The institution has been
granted recognition for D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
19.11.2007.
A letter No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (B) dated 18.06.2009 has been received from
the Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher Education, Education
Department, Government of Karnataka which has recommended SRC to
withdraw the recognition granted to D.Ed college, as the institution is not
maintaining Norms and Standards as prescribed by NCTE.
The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting of SRC held on 1314 July 2009. The SRC considered the recommendation of the State
Government of Karnataka regarding withdrawal of recognition to D.Ed
college and decided to issue showcause notice under section 17 of the
NCTE Act.
Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on
12.08.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 20.08.2009. The written
representation was placed before SRC in its 183rd meeting held on
22.09.2009 and SRC decided to issue notice under section 17 of NCTE Act
after submission of filled in Questionnaire along with documents.
Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 31.10.2009. The
institution has submitted its written representation on 23.11.2009. SRC in
its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the written
representation and decided to seek clarification on the following: Whether the institution has obtained permission for shifting from SRCNCTE, Bangalore.
 Year of Construction of the new premises.
 Date of Building Completion Certificate.
 FDRs are not in Joint Account since 2007.
Further, a letter dated 03.03.2010 has been received from the State
Government of Karnataka stating that the government has reconsidered the
decision taken with respect to Gomatesh Education Society’s Marathi D.Ed
College and has requested NCTE to restore the recognition granted to the
institution. The matter was placed before SRC in its 190th meeting held on
29-30 March 2010 and decided to issue final notice.
Accordingly, final notice was issued to the institution on 04.05.2010. The
institution submitted its written representation on 26.05.2010. SRC in its
193rd meeting held on 30-22 June 2010 considered the written
representation and decided to cause inspection under section 17.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
94
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
In the meantime, NCTE, Hqrs. vide its letter dated 09.07.2010 has
forwarded a copy of the inspection report dated 20.05.2010 conducted
under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the
inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against
the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
SRC in its 194th meeting held on 30-22 July 2010 considered the VT report
& decided to issue Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution
on 01.09.2010.
As per the decision of SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 30-22 July 2010
inspection was carried out under section 17 on 31.08.2010.
The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010 considered
the VT Report and decided to issue Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of
NCTE Act. Accordingly, showcause notice was issued to the institution on
26.10.2010.
The institution submitted its written representation on
23.11.2010. The details are given below:
The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and
other related documents along with the original file of the institution
and also the written reply of the institution dt. 23.11.2010, for the
showcause notice issued vide letter dt. 26.10.2010 and decided to
continue recognition accorded to the institution.
63.
APS01936
B.Ed
Sarvodaya
B.Ed College
Bangalore
KA
Sarvodaya B.Ed College, No.12, 10th Main, Binny Layout, Nagarabavi Road,
Vijayanagar, Bangalore-560040, Karnataka has submitted application for
B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition
for B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 04.04.2006.
As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May
2009, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have
been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction
of own building or in lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed course in the
State of Karnataka.
A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its
176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the
expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE
Act for further action.
As per the decision of SRC, it was served a notice dated 02.09.2009 under
Section 17 of the NCTE Act asking to explain as to why the institution has
not shifted to its own premises as on date by supporting with relevant
documents along with Questionnaire. Notice was issued on 02.09.2009 for
the following deficiencies:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
95
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010










Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
Member Secretary NCTE” Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
name of the institution/Society/Trust.
Building Plan of the new building duly approved by the Government
authority.
Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
prescribed format(Format enclosed).
Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
Purposes only should be submitted.
Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
should submitted.
Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve Fund
in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
Certificates of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
submitted.
The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
Notary attestation should be submitted.
The institution did not care to respond to the Notice served on the institution,
for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the lapse of three
years stipulated period permitted in their conditional orders of recognition
and the matter was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16
September 2010. SRC decided to issue Showcause Notice and accordingly
showcause notice was issued to the institution on 27.10.2010.
The institution submitted its written representation on 26.11.2010 and has
stated that the Sarvodaya B.Ed College is housed in its own building and
the land of the Trust is Civic Amenity site allotted by the Government of
Karnataka measuring 0.75 acres and the address of the site is as same as
the recognition given by the NCTE. The institution has also stated that the
institution is running in its own building and hence the shifting of premises of
the B.Ed college does not arise. The institution has further stated that the
land is allotted by Government of Karnataka and the institution is having its
own building. In view of the above, the institution has requested to drop the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
96
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
show cause notice issued by NCTE, Bangalore.
The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
documents and decided to cause inspection at the premises Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the
following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in
Questionnaire along with all the necessary documents for land,
building approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt.
Engineer and other relevant documents, along with inspection fee of
Rs. 40,000/-, failing which further action will be taken with no further
notice.
64.
SRCAPP75
M.Ed
Annamalai
University,
Directorate of
Distance
Education,
Cuddalore
TN
Annamalai University, Directorate of
Annamalainagar, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu
Distance
Education,
Annamalai University, Directorate of Distance Education, Plot No.89/24, 2B,
2C & 3, 76/1,2, 1st Street, Thiruvetkulam, Annamalainagar, Chidambaram,
Cuddalore-608002, Tamilnadu submitted its application for M.Ed-DE course
through on-line on 24.10.2009. Application of the above university was
received by SRC on 30.10.2009. The application was processed and
deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009.
The university submitted its written representation on 17.02.2010, which
was considered by SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25th-26th February,
2010 and the Committee decided to reject the application on the following
grounds:
 The application does not fulfill the pre-requisite conditions including DEC
approval for grant of recognition to the M.Ed course through Distance
Education mode.
Accordingly, the application was rejected vide order F.SRC/NCTE/M.EdDE/2010/18362 dated. 13.04.2010.
The university preferred Appeal under section 18 against the rejection
order. The Appellate Authority vide order dated 22.09.2010 reversed with
the direction to SRC for issuing a show cause notice mentioning the refusal
ground and for further decision thereafter.
SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010 considered the
appeal order and decided issue show cause notice mentioning the refusal
ground and for further decision thereafter.
Accordingly notice was issued to the university on 09.11.2010 mentioning
the refusal ground. The university vide its letter dated 19.11.2010 submitted
its reply to notice stating as follows”
“The Annamalai University is one of the largest residential and unitary type
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
97
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
university in India having programmes both in on campus and Distance
Mode. The Department of Education was established in the year 1953 and
has 53 faculty members on the whole both on campus and distance mode.
Almost all the faculty members are holding Doctoral degree in Education
having specialized in the different fields of education. The Department of
Education has produced 75 Ph.ds and 240 M.Phil’s and more than 50
scholars are doing Ph.D at present.
The Department of Education used to conduct international and national
seminar, symposia and work shop every year. The Annamalai University
offered B.Ed degree programme since 1979 through Distance mode which
is very popular among the teachers all over India owing to its academically
strong teaching faculty, in depth lesson material and infrastructural
facilities.
The Directorate of Distance Education has celebrated its Silver Jubilee in
2004. There are 19 faculty members with a professors, 2 Associate
Professors and 14 Assistant Professors exclusively in the education wing of
D.D.E. The B.Ed programme through Distance mode was started in the
year 2008 after getting due recognition from NCTE.
We are pleased to inform that the B.Ed programme through Distance mode
is being offered in this background only.
We have conducted a national level workshop under the chairmanship of
Prof. N.K. Dash, Professor of Education, IGNOU on 11th and 12th of
November 2010. We are taking all efforts to prepare and finalize the selfinstructional material for M.Ed course Distance mode. Thus we always
conduct the programmes in tune with the NCTE. Hence the NCTE may be
pleased to approve our proposal to enable more educationists with higher
academic qualification can participate in nation building.
Meanwhile, the university in continuation to the reply dated 19.11.2010,
again submitted the following reply vide letter dated 03.12.2010:
“We have fulfilled all the requirements to run the M.Ed course through
Distance Mode except having our own lesson materials.
We have conducted a national level workshop on 11th and 12th of
November 2010 under the chairmanship of Prof. N.K. Dash, Professor of
Education, IGNOU. We churned out a Curriculum. Or faculty members
received the ideas from the workshop, and they have engaged themselves
fully in developing the M.Ed lesson materials. We have to develop the
lesson materials in tune with National Curriculum frame work as well as to
produce academically enriched Quality Lesson surrounding areas are badly
affected due to heavy rain and floods caused by the near by Veeranam
Lake. We could not speed up our official machinery and academicians as
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
98
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
we expected. Owing to these reasons some more time is required to
develop the lesson material. Although we have got approval for the M.Ed
coursed from Distance Education Council, we understand that the final
lesson material has to be sent to the Distance Education Council for
Approval, it also requires time.
Hence under these conditions, we pray that we may be given a time to two
months to submit the lesson materials to NCTE. We assure you that we will
stick on to time and submit the necessary documents along with lesson
materials as stated.
The request of the management for extension of time to submit the
lesson materials to NCTE and for DEC approval cannot be complied
with.
The unit may apply fresh after fulfilling the requisite
requirements as sper norms.
65.
APS05218
B.Ed
Sri Raja
Rajeswari
College of
Education,
Vellore District
TN
Sri Raja Rajeswari College of Education, Vellore, Tamilnadu had submitted
an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
02.01.2006.
The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed
course was granted on 26.10.2006 for annual intake of 100 students.
The institution in its letter dated 02.09.2010 stated as follows
“ I wish to submit that we launched our institution with the sole intention of
including B.Ed Programme to the poor and village students at a very
nominal fees and we have succeeded in achieving the same for the past 3
years, since our institution is located in a very remote village, the
construction of the pucca building could not be completed within the
prescribed time limitation. The construction is going on and we will inform
you as soon as the construction work is completed”.
The institution has been inspected at Walajapet, Vellore District and granted
recognition at Walajapet address where the institution entered a lease
agreement of only three years as per lease deed dated 22.11.2005. The
institution has also submitted another lease deed dated 17.10.2005 which is
for 40 years but the address in this lease deed as per schedule of lease
deed is Vellore District, Arakkonam Registration District, Arcot Taluk,
Chakkarmallur Village.
Hence the institution, as per recognition order dated 26.10.2006 was
supposed to shift to its own premises/building within 3 years from the date
of recognition.
SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 decided to issue
show cause notice to the institution. Accordingly notice was issued to the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
99
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
institution on 26.10.2010.
The institution vide letter 26.11.2010 stated as follows:
“We started the B.Ed programme in the leased out building at the time of
launching the same Subsequently the entire building along with another
building was transferred in favor of our Trust on 16.09.2008 itself by way of
a settlement deed. Thus the entire building under lease became the own
property of the Trust. A Xerox copy of the same is enclosed herewith for
your perusal. The total extent of the building available is 125sq.ft. Thus we
are running the institution in the premises only.
Further I submit that to facilitate more amenities and infrastructures to the
students we are now constructing a modern building in a vast area in the
land situated at Chakramallur Village, Arcot Taluk. This land has been taken
on lease for 40 years and we have already submitted the relevant document
to you. Through we started to work 1 year age, due to the labors problem
we could not complete the building in time. Now the work is going on very
speedily and the same is about to be completed in 2 months time.
I undertake to shift the entire institution within a period of 2 months.
Hence I request you to grant me 2 months time only for shifting to the new
building”.
The committee considered the request and decided to cause
inspection of the institution in Feb 2011; if the institution is not ready
for inspection with completion of building, further action will be taken
with no further notice.
66.
APS01576
D.Ed
Christ D.Ed
Institute,
Bangalore
KA
Chirst D.Ed Institute, No.68, Jyothi Nagar, Kaggalipura, Bangalore,
Karnataka has submitted application for D.Ed course on 26.12.2003. The
institution has been granted recognition for D.Ed course with an intake of 50
students on 02.12.2004.
A letter No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (B) dated 18.06.2009 was received from the
Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher Education, Education Department,
Government of Karnataka and has recommended SRC to withdraw the
recognition granted to D.Ed college, as the institution is not maintaining
Norms and Standards as prescribed by NCTE.
The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting of SRC held on 1314 July 2009. The SRC considered the recommendation of the State
Government of Karnataka regarding withdrawal of recognition to D.Ed
college and decided to issue showcause notice under section 17 of the
NCTE Act.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
100
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 12.08.2009. The
institution submitted its reply on 28.08.2009. The written representation was
placed before SRC in its 183rd meeting held on 22.09.2009 and decided to
issue notice under section 17 of NCTE Act after submission of filled in
Questionnaire along with documents. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the
institution on 04.11.2009.
The institution has submitted its written
representation on 27.11.2009 and 11.12.2009. SRC in its 188th meeting
held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the written representation and
decided to seek clarification. Accordingly, a clarification letter was issued to
the institution on 04.03.2010. The institution has submitted its clarification
on 24.03.2010 and SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-30 March 2010
decided to call clarification for the discrepancy which affects the credibility of
the statements. Accordingly, another clarification letter was issued to the
institution on 07.05.2010. The institution submitted its clarification on
02.06.2010.
The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 30-22 June 2010 considered the
clarification letter and decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.Ed
Courseto verify the facts, Accordingly the inspection was carried on
02.08.2010.
The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010 considered the
matter and decided to issue Showcause Notice. Accordingly, notice was
issued to the institution on 26.10.2010. The institution has submitted written
representation on 25.11.2010. The details are given below:
Based on the reports submitted by the institution to the show cause
notice and the VT reports and other related documents, it is
concluded that the management is not maintaining norms and
standards prescribed for D.Ed course by NCTE. The institution is
running other programmes like LKG, High School and PUC in the
same camapus, with no exclusive earmarking of land and building for
D.Ed as per NCTE norms. The photographs submitted clearly indicate
the construction is in progress and incomplete.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for D.Ed. course with effect from 2012-13 to enable the
present batch of student to complete the course. But, it is made clear
that the institution is debarred from making any further admission
subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
67.
APS01805
B.Ed
Auckland
Auckland College of Education, #22, Hegde Nagar Main Road,
Chokkanahalli, Yelahanka Hobil, Bangalore North-560064, Karnataka has
submitted application for B.Ed course on 30.12.2003. The institution has
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
101
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
College of
Education,
Bangalore
North
KA
been granted recognition for B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on
04.01.2006.
As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May
2009, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have
been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction
of own building or in lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed., course in the
State of Karnataka.
A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its
176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the
expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE
Act for further action. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
dated 08.09.2009.
The institution did not care to respond to the Notice served on the institution,
for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the lapse of three
years stipulated period permitted in their conditional orders of recognition.
The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010 considered the
matter and decided to issue Showcause Notice. Accordingly, notice was
issued to the institution on 25.10.2010. The institution submitted its written
representation on 15.12.2010.
 The institution has stated that “we extremely regret the inconvenience
caused to the esteemed body the first letter under your reference was not
delivered to us due to postal confusions”. The management has further
stated that the institution was granted recognition to its own land and
building situated at No.32, Bheemanahally, Bidadi hobil, Bangalore –
Mysore Main Road, Ramanagar Taluk and Ramanagar Distirct- 562109.
The building and additional floor are being Constructed to start B.Ed
courses from the year 2011-12. The institution has also stated that they
have not made any admissions during the year 2009-10 and 2010-11 due
to non-availability of required number of students and they are also
applying for change of medium from Tamil to English medium from 201112. Hence, the institution has requested to continue the recognition for
further period and has also stated that they are making efforts for shifting
of college from the present lease/rent premises to permanent/ own place
at No. 32, Bheemanahally, B.M. Road, Bidadi hobli, Ramanagar Taluk,
Ramanagar District-562109, Karnataka.
 The reply of the management to the show cuase notice was duly
considered. The institution has not shifted/moved to its own
premises even after the lapse of more than five now, though it
should have shifted within this stipulated period of three years.
Even now, the management claims that the building is under
construction.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
102
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
recognition for B.Ed. course with effect from 2010-11 to enable the
present batch of student to complete the course.. But, it is made clear
that the institution is debarred from making any further admission
subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
68.
APS02098
D.Ed
Sri
Basaveshwara
Rural D.Ed
College,
Bangalore
rural
KA
Sri. Basaveshwara Rural D.Ed College, Yelethatahalli, Channapatna
Taluk, Bangalroe Rural District, Karnataka has submitted application
for D.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted
recognition for D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
23.12.2004.
A letter No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (B) dated 18.06.2009 was received from the
Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher Education, Education Department,
Government of Karnataka and has recommended SRC to withdraw the
recognition granted to D.Ed college, as the institution is not maintaining
Norms and Standards as prescribed by NCTE.
The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting of SRC held on 1314 July 2009. The SRC considered the recommendation of the State
Government of Karnataka regarding withdrawal of recognition to D.Ed
college and decided to issue show cause notice under section 17 of the
NCTE Act. Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 12.08.2009.
The institution submitted its reply on 02.09.2009. The written representation
was placed before SRC in its 183rd meeting held on 22.09.2009 and decided
to issue notice under section 17 of NCTE Act after submission of filled in
Questionnaire along with documents.
Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 03.11.2009. The
institution has submitted its written representation on 04.12.2009. SRC in
its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the written
representation and decided to seek clarification. Accordingly, clarification
letter was issued to the institution on 05.03.2010.
The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 30-22 June 2010 considered the reply
& decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.Ed. Course, under
Section 17 of NCTE Act, to verify the facts. Accordingly, the inspection was
carried out on 02.08.2010.
The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 21-22 September, 2010 considered
the matter and decided to issue Showcause Notice. Accordingly,
showcause notice was issued on 26.10.2010. The institution has submitted
written representation on 09.12.2010.
The reply by the management to the show cuase notice was duly
considered. Considering the VT report, and other lelated documents,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
103
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
69.
0360
B.Ed
Global Institute
of Advanced
Study in
Education,
Chittoor
and deficiencies observed in non-maintenance of Norms and
Standards as prescribed by NCTE, the Committee decides to withdraw
the recognition for D.Ed. course with effect from 2012-13 to enable the
present batch of student to complete the course.. But, it is made clear
that the institution is debarred from making any further admission
subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The DSERT,
Government of Karnataka be informed accordingly for necessary
enforcement.
An application was submitted by Global Institute of Advance Study in
Education, Chittor, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed., course
in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 31.12.2001
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards in vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt 06.05.2003 with
stipulated conditions that it shall shift to the permanent premises within a
period of three years.
AP
The SRC, NCTE, Bangalore received a written communication containing
remarks on the deficiencies pointed out by the Dean, Faculty of Education,
S.V. University, Tirupati, A.P.
The Committee in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August, 2010
considered the deficiencies pointed out in the staff list and decided to
call for clarification from the institution.
The committee considered the clarification / reply submitted by the
institution and decided to note the reply submitted by the institution
for the Show Cause Notice dated 3/12/2010.
70.
APS02037
APS04696
D.Ed
D.Ed-AI
Karnataka
Grameen
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Belgaum
KA
Karnataka Grameen Teacher Training Institute, Harugeri Cross, Raibag
Taluk, Belgaum District-591220, Karnataka submitted an application for
grant of recognition on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition
for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
30.11.2004. Further, the institution was granted recognition for D.Ed-AI with
an intake of 50 students on 29.04.2008 thus making an annual intake of 100
students.7
NCTE , Hqrs vide its letter dated 22.09.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
inspection report dated 21.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE
Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE,
Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the institution Under
Section 17 of the NCTE Act .
The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October, 2010 considered the
VT report of the institution, VCD and other related documents along with the
original file of the institution and decided to seek clarification. Accordingly,
clarification letter was issued to the institution on 03.12.2010. The institution
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
104
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
has submitted its clarification on 16.12.2010. The details are as under:
The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and
other related documents, clarification from the institution vide letter dt.
16.12.2010, along with the original file of the institution and decided to
continue recognition accorded to the institution.
71.
APS05128
B.Ed
Arumugam
Pillai Seethai
Ammal College
of Education,
Sivagangai
TN
Arumugam Pillai Seethai Ammal College of Education, Sivagangai District,
Tamilnadu submitted application for granted of recognition to B.Ed course
on 28.12.2005.
The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering
B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 22.10.2006 at Madurai
Road, Tiruppattur-630211, Sivagangai Tamilnadu with the condition to
shift to own premises within 3 years.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 wherein it was
decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 11.09.2009. The
institution did not submit its reply.
The list of institutions were notices were returned undelivered and reply not
received were published in the website on 20.7.2010 giving 10 days to
submit reply. The institution did not submit its reply.
SRC considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to issue notice. Accordingly notice was issued to the
institution on 26.10.2010. The institution has submitted its written
representation alongwith DD of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on
26.11.2010 stating as follows:
The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting
inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and
instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
72.
APS05648
D.T.Ed
V.S. Teacher
Training
Institute,
Kancheepuram
District,
Tamilnadu
TN
V.S Teacher Training Institute, Kancheepuram, Tamilnadu submitted
application for grant of recognition to D.T.Ed course 02.01.2006.
Recognition was granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of
50 students on 02.11.2007 at Thirukkalukundram, Kancheepuram603109, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
3 years.
The institution vide its letter dated 29.11.2010 has stated as follows:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
105
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
“V.S. Teacher Training Institute, Thirukkalukundram, Kanchipuram-603109,
Tamilnadu has been permanently shifted to following own premises.
Here the fees of shifted of building of Rs.40000/- drawn in favour of Member
Secretary, NCTE payable at Bangalore is enclosed. The copy of the NCTE
order along with staff approval and affiliation order of the Director, DTERT,
Tamilnadu is enclosed for reference:
New Permanent Address:
Mangalam Village
Thirukkalukundram Post
Thirukkalukundram Taluk
Kanchipuram District
Tamilnadu
Pin:603109
The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting
inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and
instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
73.
APS04531
B.Ed
Annai College
of Education,
Dharmapuri
TN
Annai College of Education, Dharmapuri District, Tamilnadu submitted
application for granted of recognition to B.Ed course on 15.12.2005.
The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering
B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 08.11.2006 at Salem Main
Road, Nambipatty Village, Doddampatty Post, Pappireddipatty taluk,
Dharmapuri-636903 Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
within 3 years.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was
decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 11.09.2009. The
institution did not submit its reply.
The list of institutions were notices were returned undelivered and reply not
received were published in the website on 20.7.2010 giving 10 days to
submit reply. The institution did not submit its reply.
SRC considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to issue notice. Accordingly notice was issued to the
institution on 26.10.2010. The institution has submitted its written
representation alongwith DD of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
106
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
24.11.2010 stating as follows:
The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting
inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and
instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
74.
APS04695
B.Ed
Annai
Meenakshi
College of
Education,
Tirunelveli
TN
Annai Meenakshi College of Education, Tirunelveli District, Tamilnadu has
submitted application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
27.12.2005.
The application was processed and the recognition was granted for offering
B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 19.07.2007 at No.10,
Pambukovil Sandai Road, Puthukudi Village, Puliangudi Post, Shivagiri
Taluk, Tirunelveli, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
within 3 years.
Meantime a complaint was received against the institution, SRC considered
the complaint in its 171st meeting held on 16-17th March 2009 and decided
to issue notice to the institution under section 17. Accordingly notice dated
5.5.09 was issued to the institution on 05.05.2009 on the following grounds.





Hygienic atmosphere for conducting classes are not maintained.
Teachers are absent frequently.
The institution has not provided laboratory facilities.
The building is roofed with asbestos sheets.
Basic amenities like toilets and drinking water is not provided
adequately.
 The institution should submit duly filled in Questionnaire (enclosed)
along with complete details on infrastructural, instructional facilities and
approved staff list
The institution did not submit its reply.
Meanwhile, SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where-in it
was decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 08.10.2009. The
institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of
Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on 29.11.2010 stating as follows:
The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting
inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and
instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
107
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
75.
APS04202
B.Ed
Arunachala
College of
Education,
Thiruvannamal
ai
TN
Arunachala College of Education, Thiruvannamalai District, Tamilnadu
submitted application for granted of recognition to B.Ed course on
29.12.2004.
The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering
B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 03.11.2005 at Old No.26,
New No.74, Kosa street, Thiruvannamalai-606601, Tamilnadu with the
condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was
decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 15.09.2009. The
institution did not submit its reply.
The list of institutions were notices were returned undelivered and reply not
received were published in the website on 20.7.2010 giving 10 days to
submit reply. The institution did not submitted its reply.
SRC considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
2010 and decided to issue notice. Accordingly notice was issued to the
institution on 26.10.2010. The institution has submitted its written
representation alongwith DD of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on
06.12.2010 stating as follows :
76.
5074
M.Ed
Sree Narayana
College of
Teacher
Education,
Kozhikode
KL
The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting
inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and
instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
An application was submitted by Sree Narayana College of Teacher
Education, Kozhikode, kerala for grant of recognition to M.Ed course on
28.11.2005 course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt 24.11.2008 with
stipulated conditions.
Sree Narayana college of teacher education, Kozhikode, kerala went for an
appeal with the appellate authority dt. 28.05.2010 against the order No.
SRO/NCTE/2010/18902, Dt. 17/05/2010 of the SRC for withdrawing
recognition for conducting M.Ed course on the ground “The recognition is
withdrawn for M.Ed course due to shortage of built up area w.e.f 2010-11.
The institution has preferred an appeal dt. 01/06/2010 to the NCTE New
Delhi agsinst the said order.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
108
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The appellant had filed a writ petition against the SRC’s order withdrawing
its recognition for the M.Ed course before the Hon;ble High Court of Kerala
Bench at Ernakulum and the Hon’ble High Court vide its order dt. 15.6.10
directed the NCTE to dispose the appeal filed by the institution within a
period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment. The
NCTE Hqrs received the judgment on 30.6.2010 and listed the case for
hearing on 21.07.2010.
The appellate authority heard the appeal of the institution on 21.07.2010.
After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VI report and
after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing. The Council
reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to acceipt the
appeal and reverse SRC’s order dated 17.05.2010 with direction to the SRc
to restore recognition of the institution immediately. Accordingly, the appeal
was accepted and the order dated 17.05.2010 of the SRC reversed.
The Appellate authority in their order letter dt. 19/11/2010 reversed SRC’s
order dated 17.05.2010 with direction to the SRC to restore recognition of
the institution immediately.
The committee considered the appellate authority order Dt. 19.11.2010
and decided to restore recognition of the institution.
77.
7178
0350
M.Ed
B.Ed
MNR Rural PG
College of
Education,
Medak
AP
M.N.R. Educational Trust, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh has been granted
recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students
on 04.04.2001 in the name of MNR College of Education and M.Ed course
with an intake of 25 students on 17.07.2007 and enhancement of intake
vide order dated 24.08.2010
A letter dated 26.10.2010 has been received and has requested for
common name for both B.Ed and M.Ed course as “MNR Rural PG College
of Education” in accordance with Osmania University’s letter dated
25.09.2010.
As per VTR dated 20.12.2006 of M.Ed course and order dated 04.04.2001
of B.Ed the address of running both courses is same i.e Fasalwadi,
Sangareddy Mandal, Medak-502294, Andhra Pradesh. As per building plan
for M.Ed, B.Ed and D.Ed the location is S.No.574 Fasalwadi Village. As per
MIS D.Ed recognition is given on 26.08.2005 to MNR college of Education
in the same address.
The committee considered the request of the management and
decided to permit the that change of name as “MNR Rural PG College
of Education” for both B.Ed and M.Ed course subject to payment of
Rs. 40,000/- for each course.
78.
7219
8701
“Andra Pradesh State Harijana Development Society”, No.8-155,
Chilakaluripet. R.K Street, Guntur District – 522616, Andhra Pradesh.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
109
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
8689
7152
B.Ed
D.Ed
D.Ed
B.Ed
Andhra
Pradesh State
Harijana
Development
Society,
Guntur District
AP
Andhra Pradesh State, Harijana Development Society, resembles as a
Govt. Organisation but it is a Non Govt.Organaisation. The Mandal
Educational Officer and others Govt Officials advised to change the name of
the above Society to another name, not to create problems in future from
the Govt.
A letter dated 19.11.2010 has been received from the society and has
requested for change of name for B.Ed & D.Ed courses as
“B.R.Educational Society”, instead of “Andhra Pradesh State Harijana
Development Society”, No. 8-155, Chilakaluripet. R.K Street, Guntur
District – 522616, Andhra Pradesh.
Further the Society is running the following Institutions and the
details are given below.
Sl
N
o
1
Code
No
Name of The Institution
7219
2
8701
3
8689
Batchu Rambotlu
College of Education
No.1-1160,AnakapalliRoad,
Narsipatnam,
Visakhapatnam-Dist531116, Andhra
Pradesh
Batchu Rambotlu
College of Education
No.1-1160,AnakapalliRoad,
Narsipatnam,
Visakhapatnam-Dist531116, Andhra
Pradesh
Batchu Rambotlu
College of
Education,D.No.6-786,
Near Enadu Compound,
NH-5, Naidupet, Guntur
Dist-522005, Andhra
Pradesh.
4
7152
Batchu Rambotlu
College of
Education,D.No.6786, Near Enadu
Compound, NH-5,
Naidupet, Guntur
Dist-522005,
Andhra Pradesh.
Course
Intake
Date of Recognition
B.Ed
100
22.05.2007
D.Ed
50
26.02.2009
D.Ed
50
07.11.2008
B.Ed
100
12.04.2007
The committee considered the matter and decided that change of
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
110
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
name of the “Andhra Pradesh State Harijana Development Society”,
No. 8-155, Chilakaluripet. R.K Street, Guntur District – 522616, Andhra
Pradesh as “B.R.Educational Society” No. 8-155, Chilakaluripet. R.K
Street, Guntur District – 522616, Andhra Pradesh is permitted subject
to the remittance of Rs. 40,000/- for effecting the change of name of
the management with the usual conditions.
79.
APS05346
D.Ed
Anjuman
Teacher
Training
Institute, Uttara
Kannada
District
KA
Anjuman Teacher Training Institute, NH-17, Shamshuddin Circle, Bhatkal581230, Uttara Kannada District, Karnataka submitted an application to
SRC on 30.12.2005 for D.Ed course. The institution was granted recognition
for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
21.11.2007.
The institution has submitted a letter on 15.12.2010 has stated that the
institution did not get any students from Central Admission Cell as well as
management quota for admission and hence the course could not be
started. The institution has requested to withdraw the recognition and return
the Fixed Deposit Receipts.
The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of D.Ed
course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the
recognition for (APS05346) D.Ed course with effect from 2012-2013, in
order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed, course, if any,
to complete their final year course.
But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any
further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.
Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.
80.
APS05065
D.T.Ed
Concord
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Krishnagiri
TN
Concord Teacher Training Institute, Krishnagiri, Tamilnadu submitted
application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2005.
Recognition was granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of
50 students on 08.11.2006 at Thirukkalukundram, Kancheepuram603109, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
3 years.
The institution vide letter dated 15.12.2010 stated as follows:
“we have started the D.T.Ed in the year 2006-07 in the above address and
deposited an Endowment fund of Rs. 800000/- in the joint name of the
correspondent of the institution and the Director of NCTE, Bangalore as far
the norms of the NCTE. But the Tamilnadu Government has not given the
staff approval and we closed the institution. Due to closure of the institution
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
111
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
we want to cancel the endowment amount deposited in the SBI, Krishnagiri
and withdraw the recognition of our institution.
So I request you to issue the NOC letter to cancel and withdraw the
endowment amount deposited in the bank”.
The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of
D.T.Ed course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the
recognition for (APS05065) D.T.Ed course with effect from 2012-2013,
in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed, course, if
any, to complete their final year course.
But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any
further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.
Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.
81.
APS04621
D.T.Ed
T.S.M.
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Villupuram
TN
T.S.M Teacher Training Institute, Villupuram, Tamilnadu submitted
application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course.
Recognition was granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of
50 students on 26.10.2006 at Kanyamoor-606201, kallakurichi,
Villupuram, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
within 3 years.
The institution vide letter dated 13.121.2010 stated as follows:
“Our T.S.M. Teacher Training Institute, Kaniyamoor-606201 functioned for
four years from 2006-07. Now there is no admission in T.S.M Teacher
Training Institute, for the past two years (2009-10 & 2010-11). So we want
to close the institution immediately. We shall be grateful to you if our joint
account FDR Rs. 800000/- will be refunded to us at an early date. We have
remitted the same on at the time of opening the institution”.
The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of
D.T.Ed course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the
recognition for (APS04621) D.T.Ed course with effect from 2012-2013,
in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed, course, if
any, to complete their final year course.
But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any
further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
112
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.
Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.
82.
APS00144
D.T.Ed
D.V.D Teacher
Training
Institute,
Kanyakumari
District,
Tamilnadu
TN
D.V.D Teacher Training Institute, Kottar, Nagercoil – 629 002, Kanyakumari
District, Tamilnadu submitted application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed
course. Recognition was granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an annual
intake of 80 students which includes the existing intake of 40 and an
additional intake of 40, vide order dated. 04.09.2002.
The institution vide its letter dated 13.12.2010 has stated as follows:
“DVD Teacher Training Institute is an Aided, Non-minority boys institution.
This institution exists since 1953 and has been enjoying the permanent
recognition. As per the NCTE norms we are in possession of all the items of
infrastructure pertaining to a full-fledged Teacher Training Institution. To
impart better education to the poor and the socially backward pupils in and
around our area and to produce quality teachers the institution was
established by the Desika Vinayagar Devasthanam Trust, Kottar, Nagercoil.
As per NCTE orders (F.SRO/NCTE/97-98/5080 dt. 09.02.1998,
F.SRO/NCTE/2002-2003/2770 dt.04.09.2002), we have been permitted to
have the intake of 80 boy students. As per the State Government order 153
dt. 19.09.2001, 60% (48 seats) seats are filled up by the Government
through single window system and 40% (32 seats) by the management.
From the academic year 2007-08 onwards many seats remain
vacant both in Government and Management allotments (Herewith I present
a table showing the decrease in admission from 2007-08).
Besides, the D.El.Ed qualified teachers are eligible to get
appointment only in primary schools. Nowadays male candidates are not
interested to do the D.El.Ed courses because in primary school
appointments chances are less for male candidates.
The management wants to convert the institution into a coeducational institution from the academic year 2011-2012, so as to continue
the educational service to the economically and socially backward female
students also. We are proud that we have sufficient well-qualified teaching
and non-teaching staff infrastructure. So I request your good self to do the
needful to convert our institution into a co-educational one.
The committee considered the request of the management and
decided to permit the management for converting the existing
institution (APS00144) D.T.Ed course for boy students into a coeducational institution from the academic year 2011-12.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
113
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
83.
----Ban on
Teacher
Training
Course in the
State
Government
view.
KL
A letter has been received in the office of SRC from Higher Education (B)
Department dated 03.12.2010 wherein State Govt. of Kerala has observed
as under.
The State Govt. have already communicated to the NCTE their policy
assessment vide Govt. letters that there is no scope for starting new training
colleges or new courses or enhancement of seats in the existing training
colleges in the state.
The study conducted by SCERT that 23000students were passing their
B.Ed course every year in the state and there is scarcity for getting job. The
number of B..Ed centers in the state during 2000 was 21 and it has been
raised to 198 during 2010. Moreover about 3000 seats were left vacant in
the training colleges during 2008.2009 and 2010. If such circumstance
continues the training colleges will be complelled to closed down and there
arise chances for facing difficulties for providing employment to the trained
youths.
It is informed that the considered policy decision of the State Govt. not to
permit new training colleges or enhancement of existing seats be
considered favourably as it deserves. So as to avoid the aforesaid hard
ships.
The Committee considered matter and the letter received from Higher
Education (B) Department Govt of Kerala, dated 03.12.2010 and
decided to note the matter.
84.
-----Consideration
of processing
of new
applications
which have
been received
after 7th
October 2010
AP
This office in receipt of several applications which have been received after
7 days of the online submission.
As per clause 7(1-A) of the Regulation 2009 wherein it is stipulated that “the
application submitted online but not followed by dispatch through registered
post or by hand with the documents mentioned at (1) to (VII) above within 7
days shall be considered as incomplete and shall be summarily rejectd with
reasons recorded in writing and returned to the applicant along with
processing fees within 30 days of the receipt of the application”.
In this regard, for the following institutions clarification letters were issued to
submit the proof of date of dispatch of their application for further processing
and consideration as theyh had not mentioned dispatch date on their letter
heads/covering letters. Reply from the institutions is still awaited. Due to
this reason the letters to State Government for their recommendations are
held up.
Sl
No
1
2
Applic
ation
code
SRC
APP30
1
SRC
APP31
Name of the
Institution
Kalam College of
Elementary
Education
Mohammadens
College of
Cours
e
Date of online
Submitted
D.Ed
D.Ed
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
29.09.2010
Date of hard
copy
submitted
11.10.2010
Date of
clarification
letter sent
06.12.2010
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
09.12.2010
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
114
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
1
3
SRC
APP30
6
4
SRC
APP32
4
SRC
APP33
6
SRC
APP30
0
SRC
APP45
9
SRC
APP44
4
SRC
APP29
7
SRC
APP38
7
SRC
APP37
6
SRC
APP34
3
SRC
APP46
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
85.
----Consideration
SRC
APP34
2
SRC
APP37
2
SRC
APP34
6
SRC
APP33
9
SRC
APP36
7
SRC
APP33
7
Elementary
Education
Mohammadens
College of
Education for
women
Azeezia College of
Education for
women
Azeezia College of
Elekmentary
Education
Modern College of
Elementary
Education
Brindavan Institute
of Teacher
Education
CVS Krishna Theja
College of
Education
Musthafa College
of Education
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
10.12.2010
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
10.12.2010
D.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
10.12.2010
D.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
03.12.2010
M.Ed
01.10.2010
11.10.2010
07.12.2010
D.Ed
01.10.2010
18.10.2010
10.12.2010
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
06.12.2010
B.Ed
30.09.2010
12.10.2010
06.12.2010
D.Ed
28.09.2010
18.10.2010
06.12.2010
D.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
06.12.2010
M.Ed
01.10.2010
11.10.2010
03.12.2010
D.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
06.12.2010
B.Ed
28.09.2010
18.10.2010
03.12.2010
Mina College of
Education
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
06.12.2010
Stella College of
Education
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
06.12.2010
Motati Nagi Reddy
Memorial Society
HPT
30.09.2010
19.11.2010
06.12.2010
Afsana College of
B.Ed Education
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
06.12.2010
Little Flower
College of
Education
CMR Institute of
Elementary
Teacher Education
Srujana College of
Elementary
Education
Sree Dattha
Brindavan Institute
of Teacher
Education
Stella College of
Elementary
Education
MR Institute of
Teacher Education
The Committee considered the above list of applications and decided
to reject the same as they were not received within the stipulated date.
This office is in receipt of several applications have been received for
seeking recognition B.Ed, M.Ed, D.Ed & B.P.Ed courses for the session
2011-2012. In this matter the management has submitted two or three
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
115
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
of processing
new
application two
or more
courses
submitted by
the institution
for the session
2011-12
AP
course in one time.
It is ascertained that after scrutiny of above applications in accordance with
clause 8 (2) and 8 (3) of NCTE regulations 2009, that :“In the first instance and institution shall be considered for grant of
recognition of only one course for the basic unit as prescribed in the Norms
and Standards for the particular teacher education programme”.
“An institution can apply for one basic unit only of an additional course or for
an additional unit of the existing recognized course after completion of three
academic session of the respective course, for which the institution shall
submit application before the cut of date prescribed for submission of
applications in the year succeeding the completion of three academic
sessions”.
In this regard some of the institution have submitted more than one
application for seeking recognition of their courses for the session 20112012. As per NCTE regulations 2009 reproduced above, an institution shall
be considered for grant of recognition of only one course for a basic unit as
prescribed in the Norsm and Standards for the particular teacher education
programme. As per rules and regulations a letter was sent to the institution
with requested to immediately inform the name of the course institution
wants, to run for further processing and consideration. As per regulations
2009 (8 (2)) and 8 (3) an institution cannot apply for more than one course
at one time.
The office has sought the institutions stand as to which course they want to
run. Some have replied but in nearly 15 cases of Andhra Pradesh, the SRC
has not heard from the institutions. SRC may kindly decide w.r.t treatment
of such applications:1. Whether we should return all of applications made in such
cases or
2. Whether we should process any one of their applications and
if so, then for which course.
The above facts are placed before SRC for necessary direction / guidance.
List of institutions and stands is enclosed.
Sr
NO
01
Code
no.
SRC
APP3
63
Society
Name
Benaiah
Christian
Educational
Society
II
Floor,
Dwarakanag
ar,
Vishakhapat
nam-530016,
College Name
Jeremiah
College
of
Education
673,673, Street
No.1,
Burugupudi,
Korukonda
Mandal,
East
Godavari-
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
Cour
se
Date of
submission
on line
Date
of
hard copy
received in
SRC
Clarificati
on letter
sent
to
institution
B.Ed
29.09.2010
06.10.2010
29.10.10
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
116
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
02
SRC
APP3
84
03
SRC
APP3
97
04
SRC
APP4
06
05
06
SRC
APP4
24
SRC
APP4
44
AndhraPrade
sh.
Benaiah
Christian
Educational
Society
II
Floor,
Sathya
Surya
Complex,
Dwarakanag
ar,
Vishakhapat
nam-530016,
AndhraPrade
sh.
Islamia
Educational
Society
5-155C,
Pattabhi
Street,
Markapuram,
Prakasam523316,
Andhra
Pradesh
Islamia
Educational
Society
5-155C,
Pattabhi
Street,
Markapuram,
Prakasam 523316,
Andhra
Pradesh
CVS Krishna
Murthy Theja
Charities
131,
Chadalawad
a
Nagar,
Daminedu,
Settipalli,
Tirupati,
Chittoor517506,
AndhraPrade
sh
CVS Krishna
Murthy Theja
Charities
131,
Chadalawad
a
Nagar,
Daminedu,
Settipalli,
Tirupati,
Chittoor517506,
AndhraPrade
sh
533292,
AndhraPradesh
Jeremiah
College
of
Education
673,673, Street
No.1,
Burugupudi,
Korukonda
Mandal,
East
Godavari533292,
AndhraPradesh
D.Ed
30.09.2010
06.10.2010
29.10.10
Asha College of
Education
52/2,
Yellapuram,
Markapuram,
Prakasam523316,
Andhra Pradesh
B.Ed
29.09.2010
06.10.2010
10.10.10
Asha College of
Education
52/2,
Yellapuram,
Markapuram,
Prakasam523316,
Andhra Pradesh
D.El.
29.09.2010
06.10.2010
30.10.10
CVS
Krishna
Theja College of
Education
131,
#1,
Daminedu,
Settipalli,
Tirupati,
Chittoor517506,
AndhraPradesh
M.E
01.10.2010
18.10.2010
29.10.10
CVS
Krishna
Theja College of
Education
131, 3219/2000,
#2, Daminedu,
Settipalli,
Tirupati,
Chittoor517506,
AndhraPradesh
D.Ed
01.10.2010
18.10.2010
29.10.10
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
Ed
d
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
117
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
07
SRC
APP3
98
Dr
S
A
Rawoof
Educational
Society
4/130,
Chandabada
,
Nandyal,
Kurnool518501,
AndhraPrade
sh
08
SRC
APP3
95
09
SRC
APP3
24
10
SRC
APP3
36
Dr
S
A
Rawoof
Educational
Society
4/130,
Chandbada,
Nandyal,
Kurnool518501,
AndhraPrade
sh
Azeezia
Educational
and Welfare
Socirty
5-8-75,
Manyam
Chalka,
Nalgonda508001,
AndhraPrade
sh.
Azeezia
Educational
and Welfare
Socirty
5-8-75,
Manyam
Chalka,
Nalgonda508001,
AndhraPrade
sh.
Mohammade
ns
Educational
&
Welfare
Society,
No.369,
Gazinagar,
Devarakonda
, Nalgonda508248,
Andhra
Pradesh
Mohammade
ns
Educational
And Welfare
Society
S.No-369,
Vuppuvagu,
11
SRC
APP3
06
12
SRC
APP3
11
Ameena
Rawoof
D.Ed
College,
147/3,
Rythunagar
Shales, Chabolu
Road,
Rythunagar,
Nandyal,
Kurnool518502,
AndhraPradesh
Ameena
Rawoof College
of Education
147/3, Chabolu
Road,
Rythunagar,
Nandyal,
Kurnool518502,
AndhraPradesh.
D.Ed
28.09.2010
06.10.2010
29.10.10
B.Ed
30.09.2010
06.10.2010
29.10.10
Azeezia College
of Education for
Women
S.No
337,
Manyamchal,
Nalgonda508001,
AndhraPradesh.
B.Ed
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
29.10.10
Azeezia College
of Elementary
Education
S.No
337,
Manyamchal,
Nalgonda508001,
AndhraPradesh.
D.Ei.
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
29.10.10
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
29.10.10
29.09.2010
11.10.2010
29.10.10
Mohammadens
College
of
Education
for
Women,
No.369, Vuppu
Vagu,
Gazinagar,
Devarakonda,
Nalgonda508248, Andhra
Pradesh
Mohammdens
College
of
Elementary
Education
S.No-369,
Vuppuvagu,
Gazinagar,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
Ed
B.Ed
D.Ed
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
118
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
13
SRC
APP2
83
14
SRC
APP2
86
15
86.
-----Shifting of
premises as
regulation
SRC
APP2
87
Gazinagar,
Devarakonda
, Nalgonda508248,
AndhraPrade
sh
Ameeruddin
Academy of
general
Technical &
Professional
Educational
Society
903/1A,
Yedavalli
Village,
Giddalur,
Prakasam523357,
AndhraPrade
sh
Ameeruddin
Academy of
General
Technical
and
Professional
Educational
Society,
No.903/1A,
Yedavalli,
Giddalur523357,
Andhra
Pradesh
Ameeruddin
Academy of
General
Technical
And
Professional
Educational
Society
903/1A,
Yedavalli,
Giddalur,
Prakasam523357,
AndhraPrade
sh.
Devarakonda,
Nalgonda508248,
AndhraPradesh
Hazarath
Ameeruddin
College
of
Education
903/1A,
Yedavalli
Village,
Giddalur,
Prakasam523357,
AndhraPradesh
Mynoddin
Elementary
Teacher
Training
Institute,
No.903/1A,
Yedavalli,
Giddalur523357, Andhra
Pradesh
Hazarath
Ameerudin
M.Ed College
903/1A,
Yedavalli,
Giddalur,
Prakasam523357,
AndhraPradesh.
B.Ed
28.09.2010
08.10.2010
29.10.10
28.09.2010
08.10.2010
29.10.10
28.09.2010
08.10.2010
29.10.10
D.El.
Ed
M.E
d
Only one application for each of the institution (as per regulations); if
the institution does not make explicit choice within stipulated period,
the lowest level of the programmes, applied for by the respective
institution be taken up for consideration.
SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st Aug 2009 wherein it was decided
that the institution which have not shited to the permanent premises even
after the expirey of three years time limit be issued notice under section 17
of NCTE Act for further action.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
119
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
2002 within 3
years to
permanent
structure from
the date of
issue of
recognition
TN
Accordingly, notices were issued to these institutions. Notices were not
issued to some institutions and notices issued to sime institutions were
retunred un-delivered. As per the direction, the list of such institutions were
published in the web site on 20-07.2010 giving 10 days to submit reply.
The stipulated period has been expired, the following institutions did not
submit their reply so far. The matter was considered by SRC in its 196th
meeting held on 15th – 16th Sept.2010 and decided to issue notice.
Accordingly notices were issued to the institutions on 26.10.2010.
As per column No. 8 only 6 institution has replied to the notice remaining 5
institutions have not submitted even after issuing show cause notice twice
and and publishing the list in the web site. .
Sl.
No
01.
App
Code
Rec
Date
Institution
APS0
4202
30/12
/2004
Arunachala
College Of
Education
No.26. Kosa
Street
Thiruvannamal
ai - 606601
Tamilnadu
02.
APS
0453
1
15/1
2/20
05
03.
APS
0460
8
15/0
7/20
05
04.
APS
0512
8
28/1
2/20
05
05.
APS
Annai
College Of
Education
Annai Edun
Trust
Nambipatti
Village
Doddampatti,
Pappireddipa
tt
Dharmapuri 636903
Tamilnadu
Arumugam
Nallamani
College Of
Education
Madurai 625011
Tamilnadu
Arumugam
Pillai Seethai
Ammal
College Of
Edun
Sivagangai 630211
Tamilnadu
Auxilium
Cours
e
B.Ed
(100)
B.Ed
(100)
B.Ed
(100)
Status
Notice
No &
Date
Date of
Reply
submit
ted
40000/Submitt
ed/Not
15728
15.09.20
09
06.12.
2010
Yes
Lease
for
34yrs
15671
11.09.2
009
24.11.
2010
Yes
Lease
for
35yrs
15791
17.09.2
009
Reply
not
receiv
ed
No
Lease
for
30yrs
15676
11.09.2
009
26.11.
2010
Yes
Lease
16026
08.11.
Yes
Granted
03/11/20
05
Granted
08/11/2
006
Granted
23/12/2
005
B.Ed
(50)
Granted
22/10/2
006
B.EdE
Granted
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
Land &
buildin
g
status
Rented
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
120
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
0367
4
24/1
2/20
04
06.
APS
0623
8
02/0
9/20
05
07.
APS
0475
5
02/0
1/20
06
08
APS
0305
5
31/1
2/20
03
09.
APS
0438
6
29/1
2/20
04
College Of
Education
Salesian
Sisters,
Regunathapu
ram P.O.,
Karambakudi
(Via),
Pudukottai –
622302
Tamilnadu
Devi
Venkatachala
m College Of
Education
Devi
Venkatachala
m
Educational
Valayampattu
,
Vaniyambadi,
Vellore 635751
Tamilnadu
Devi
Venkatachala
m Teacher
Training
Institute
Devi
Venkatachala
m Edun Trust
246, Md Ali
Bazzar Road
Vaniyambad
Vellore Tamilnadu
G.P. Teacher
Education
Training
Institute
No.23,
Koviloor
Road
Sivarajpet
Tirupattur
Vellore 635601
Tamilnadu
Jai Sai Tr
Ainig College
#52/57, Sri
Sai Nagar
Kulaiyapatti
Road Via
Udyanpatti,
d
(100)
B.Ed
(100)
D.T.E
d
(50)
D.T.E
d
(50)
B.Ed
(100)
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
01/02/2
006
for
50yrs
08.10.2
009
2010
Lease
for
20yrs
15717
14.09.2
009
Reply
not
receiv
ed
No
Lease
for
20yrs
15704
14.09.2
009
Reply
not
receiv
ed
No
Lease
for
99yrs
15752
16.09.2
009
Reply
not
receiv
ed
No
Lease
for
30yrs
15770
16.09.2
009
08.11.
2010
No
Granted
06/10/2
006
Granted
24/10/2
006
Granted
29/06/2
005
Granted
26/12/2
005
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
121
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Airport
Trichy /
Tiruchirapalli
- 620007
Tamilnadu
10.
11.
APS
0353
3
15/1
0/20
04
Padmavani
College Of
Education
For Women
3/221, Ksv
Nagar,
Narasothipatt
y
Salem – 04
Tamilnadu
APS
0110
2
31/1
2/20
02
Nachiyaram
mal College
Of Physical
Education
Near
Lakshmi Mills
Lakshmipura
m P.O.
Kovilpatti
Tuticorin 628502
Tamilnadu
Lease
for
30yrs
B.Ed
(100)
10.11.
2010
(Shifting
ltr sent
on
12.06.2
009)
Granted
28/09/2
006
Lease
for
99yrs
TTI
(100)
Not
issued
16069
12.10.2
009
Granted
01/09/2
006
Letter
return
ed
back
on
16.09.
2009
Reply
receive
d for
shifting
letter
on
20.04.2
009
alongw
ith
Rs.400
00/No
The Committee decided to issue a final Showcause Notice to the five
institutions ( 1/ APS04608, 2/ APS0623, 3/ APS04755, 4/APS03055 & 5/
APS01102) for withdrawal of the recognition as the institutions have
not shifted to permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
stipulated time limit and also have not responded to the two show
cause notices.
87.
----Proceedings of
the Director of
Teacher
Education,
Research &
Training,
Chennai,
Tamilnadu
TN
The following institutions were granted recognition and later withdrawn
recognition on various reasons. A copy of withdrawal orders of the following
institutions were forwarded to the concerned examination affiliating body
(DTERT, Chennai, Tamil Nadu).
The affiliating body DTERT, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, vide various letters
informed that granting approval to the staff list of the following institutions
are hereby withdrawn
Sl.
No
1.
Code
&
Date
APS0
5019
29/12/
Name & Address Of The
Institution
Vettri Vel Teacher Training
Institute
Vettri Vel Education Trust
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
Course &
Intake
D.T.ED
(50)
Status
Recognition
Withdrawn
04/02/2010
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
122
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
2005
2.
APS0
4606
19/12/
2005
3.
APS0
4412
07/12/
2005
4.
APS0
0866
31/12/
2002
5.
APS0
4418
01/12/
2005
6.
APS0
4780
30/12/
2005
7.
APS0
1094
31/12/
Door No 7b,Pavadi
Muniyappan K
9th Ward, Tharamangalam
Salem - 636502
Tamilnadu
Bharathi Teacher Training
Institute
Bharth Edun Trust
No 307, Thadagam Road,
Gct Post
Coimbatore - 641013
Tamilnadu
Excel Teacher Training
Institute
Trust For Eudn And Social
Devl
68, Jkk Sundaram Nagar,
Komarapalayam
Namakkal - 638183
Tamilnadu
St. Judes Teacher Training
Institute
21/9, Iii Cross Street,
Vp Colony, Ayanavaram
Chennai - 600023
Tamilnadu
Excel Teacher Training
Institute For Women
Trust For Eudn And Social
Devl
68, Jkk Sundaram Nagar
Komarapalyam
Namakkal - 638183
Tamilnadu
SRI LAKSHMI TEACHER
TRAINING INSTITUTE
SRI LAKSHMI EDUN &
SOCIAL TRUS
MIHAMMED ALI 2SD
STREET
THIRUVALLUR TOWN
THIRUVALLUR - 602001
Tamilnadu
Bell College Of Education
1/9,
K.V.K Nagar,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
D.T.Ed
(50)
Recognition
Withdrawn
27/08/2010
Order NO
:20796
D.T.Ed
(50)
Recognition
Withdrawn
01/09/2010
Order No
:20896
D.T.ED
(100)
Recognition
Withdrawn
23/08/2010
Ord
No.20582
D.T.ED
(100)
Recognition
Withdrawn
01/09/2010
Order No.
20899
D.T.Ed
(50)
Recognition
Withdrawn
02/09/2010
Order No
:20917,
B.ED
(50)
Recognition
Withdrawn
25/06/2010
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
123
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
2002
8.
APS0
4365
28/02/
2002
9.
APS0
6115
30/12/
2005
10.
APS0
4454
28/10/
2005
Tuticorin - 628008
Tamilnadu
St. Catherine Teacher
Training Institute
No. 38/40, Dhanalakshmi
Enclav
North Boag Road,
T. Nagar
Chennai - 600017
Tamilnadu
M.G. TEACHER TRAINING
INSTITUTE
M.G. EDUN TRUST
PENNADAM
TITTAGUDI
CUDDALORE - 606105
Tamilnadu
Susila Teacher Training
Institute
Susila Edun Trust
Kuppusamy Nagar,
Chennai Main
Veeracholapuram,
Kallakurichi
Villupuram - 606206
Tamilnadu
Order
No.19532Recognition
Withdrawn
02/09/2010
Order No
:20920,
D.T.Ed
(100)
D.T.Ed
(50)
Recognition
Withdrawn
20/08/2010
Ord
No.20519
D.T.ED-AI
(50)
Recognition
Withdrawn
24/08/2010
Order No
:20652
The committee noted the contents of the various letters received from
affiliating body DTERT, Chennai.
88.
---Consideration
of letter
received from
DTERT
TN
A letter dt. 21.12.2010 received from the Director, DTERT requesting for
granting additional 10 seats to each of the following institutions, for
accommodating 50 students of Umaiyal TTI, Theni whose recognition was
withdrawn on 27.9.2010:1.
District Institute of Education
and
Training,Uthamapalayam,
Theni District-625533
SRC-NCTE granted recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 20.7.2000(A0S0175)
2.
Chellammal Teacher
Training Insttiute, Theni
Road, Near Taluk Office,
Andipatti, Theni District625534-
SRC-NCTE granted recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 24.10.2006 with an intake of 50
students(APS04678)
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
124
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
3.
SKA Teacher Training
Institute, Yethakoil Road,
Andipatti, Theni District625512
SRC-NCTE granted recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 8.3.2004 with an intake of 40
students(APS00986)
4.
Sowrashtra Teacher training
Institute, Near Police
Quarters, Veerapandi, Theni
District-625534
SRC-NCTE granted recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 24.10.2006 with an intake of 50
students(APS04855)
5.
Theni Kammavar Sangam
Teacher training Institute,
Theni Roadi Koduvilarpatty
Post, Veerapandi via, Theni
District – 625534
Thiravium Teacher Training
Institute, Periyakulam road,
Kailasapatti, Theni District625533.
SRC-NCTE granted recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 8.3.2004 with an intake of 50
students(Code: APS00822)
6.
89.
SRCAPP
65
B.Ed-AI
Shadan
College of
Education,
Hyderabad
AP
SRC-NCTE granted recognition for D.T.Ed
course on 30.8.2008 with an intake of 50
students(Code: APS08530)
The Committee decided to inform DTERT, Tamil Nadu that action for
redistribution of candidates of sanctioned intake in any of the
institutions, be taken without violating NCTE Norms.
An application was submitted by Shadan Educational Society, Plot No-6-2978.
village Khairatabad. Post-Khairatabad. Taluka – Khairatabad.
Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Shadan
College of Education. 6-2-978, Khairatabad, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh,
for B.Ed (Al) intake from 160 seats to 200 seats course.of one year duration
under section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional
Committee, NCTE on 29.10.2009.
The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued to the
institution on 22.12.2009. The institution submitted its written representation
on 08.02.2010.
The SRC considered the matter in its 190th meeting held on 29th-30th March
2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other
related documents. NCTE Act 1993, regulations and guidelines from time to
time laid on the table, written representation from the institution, the
regional committee decided to reject the application on the following
grounds:Minority Status Certificate submitted is not from the competent authority.
Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the applicant institution on
03.05.2010.as per direction of Regional Committee.
The Appellate Authority order dt. 23.08.2010 has remanded back the case
to SRC with a direction to process the case further on merit.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
125
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The SRC considered the Appellate Authority order and decided to reprocess
the application.
The institution has submitted the following in letter dt. 25.10.2010. Minority
Certificate dated.16.08.1999 issued by Secretary, Minorities Welfare
Department, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh. and Govt. of Andhra Pradesh order
dt. 23.03.1999, extracts of memorandum of association and bye-laws is also
for perusal in terms of observation in Appellate order dt. 23.08.2010.Para 4.
The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and
other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to
cause inspection.
90.
----Appeal orders:
KA, TN
Karnataka: Sl.
No. 1 to 6
Tamil Nadu
Sl.No. 7 to 9
1/AOS00300
B.Ed
K.L.E Society’s
college of
Education
Hubli
KA
K.L.E Society;s college of Education, Vidyanagar, Hubli-580 021, Dharwad
District, Karnataka has been granted recognition for B.Ed course Vide order
dated 18.07.2000.
Further, the institution had submitted app;ication for starting K.L.E Societiy’s
College of Education, No. 3236, Sakhare English Medium School Campus,
Unkal Cross, Vidyanagar, Hbuli-580 031, Dharwad District, Karnataka
(SRCAPP78) has submitted application for sarting M.Ed course on
29.10.2009. Deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009.
The institution submitted its written representation on 22.02.2010. The reply
for deficiency letter was placed before SRC in its 190th meeting held on 2930 March 2010 and SRC decided to cuase inspection. Accordingly,
inspection was carried 9ut to the institution on 05.05.2010.
SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10-11 May 2010 considered the matter
decided to refuse recognition to the M.Ed course for the following reasons:

In the First floor B.Ed course in is being run, Nursing Colege is being
run in the Second floor, and the gound floor is now allotted for M.Ed
course.

Pharmacy College is also run in the same building.

Conduct of Teacher Education Programmes along with other
programmes (Pharmacy, Nursing as in present case) is against the
regulations of NCTE.
Further, the Committee also decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 of
NCTE, Act, for B.Ed couse for violation of NCTE regulations, (i.e. B.Ed
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
126
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
being offered in the same building along with Pharmacy and Nursing
programmes).
Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
07.06.2010.
The institution has submitted its representation dt. 25.06.2010.
The committee considered the matter in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July
2010 and decided to withdraw recognition of the institution for offering B.Ed.
course for the following reasons:
 Nursing college is run in the second floor of the same building where the
B.Ed. course is being run. As per NCTE norsm, no other programmes are
allowed in the same building where teaching of educational programmes
are being conducted.
Under the above gounds, the committee decides to withdraw the recognition
for B.Ed course with immediate effect. It is made clear that the institution is
debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the date of
issue of this order. The State Government/affiliating University be informed
accordingly.
Accordingly, withdrawal order was issued to the institution vide order dated
F.SRS/NCTE/2010-2011/20778. Dt 27.08.2010.
Now
the
institution
has
filed
appeal
Under
Section 18 of NCTE Act, before the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi
against the rejection order of SRC.
Appeal reversed for getting re-inspection of the institution to verify whether
the nursing/pharmacy colleges have been shifted and the institution is now
functioning as per the prescribed NCTE norms and if so to restore
recognition of the institution.
The committee considered the Appellate authority order dated
19/11/2010 for considering the recognition of the institution after reinspecting the institution whether the institution has shifted the
nursing/pharmacy colleges to different premises and functioning as
per the prescribed NCTE norms.
2/SRCAPP 188
B.P.Ed
An application was submitted by V.V Sangha B.P.Ed Talikoti Muddlibhal
Bijapur Karnataka for grant of recognition to B.P.Ed.,course in the office of
SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 31/10/2009
V.V. Sangha
B.P.Ed College SRC in its order letter dt. 31/05/2010 refused for grant of recognition to V.V
Bijapur
Sangha Bijapur for conducting B.P.Ed course on the grounds that:
KA
The appellant preferred an appeal dt. 21/06/2010 to the NCTE New Delhi
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
127
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
under section 18 of the NCTE Act. 1993 against the said order.
1/Psychology lab and Language labs are not established,
2/ Games and sports facilites are inadequate.
3/ Degree colleges (B.A. B.Com) and D.Ed courses are run in the same
building.
4/ As per VT report, at present the infrastructural and instructional facilities
are not sufficient.
5/ It is mentioned in the VT report the space allocated for built-up area for
D.Ed course is 588.80 Sq.ft, which is far less than the NCTE norms.
After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT report and
after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council
reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the
appeal and reverse SRC’s order dt. 31.05.2010 with directon to the SRC to
issue a show cause notice to the institution and take further action
thereafter.
Appeal reversed and directed SRC to issue Show Cause Notice to the
institution and take further action thereafter.
The committee considered the Appellate authority order Dt. 19.11.2010
and decided to issue Show Cause notice Under Section 17 of NCTE
Act as follows:
1/Psychology lab and Language labs are not established,
2/ Games and sports facilites are inadequate.
3/ Degree colleges (B.A. B.Com) and D.Ed courses are run in the same
building.
4/ As per VT report, at present the infrastructural and instructional
facilities are not sufficient.
5/ It is mentioned in the VT report the space allocated for built-up area
for D.Ed course is 588.80 Sq.ft, which is far less than the NCTE norms.
The institution be directed to reply to the above show cause notice
within 30 days of the issue of notice, failing which final action
including refusal of recognition will be taken based on the available
information, with no further notice.
3/ APS02316
B.Ed
Capital
Teacher
Training
College
Bangalore
An application was submitted by Capital Teacher Training College
Bangalore, Karnataka for grant of recognition to B.Ed.,course in the office of
SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 31/12/2003.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the institution for B.Ed course (100 intake) from
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
128
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
KA
the session 2004-2005 vide order dt29.11.2004 with stipulated conditions.
As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting, the office of SRC has reviewed
the files of the institution who have been granted recognition either in a
rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises.
Accordingly, a list of such institutions was prepared and placed before SRC
in its 176th meeting held on 27 – 28 May 2009 wherein, it was decided that
the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after
the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of
NCTE Act for further action.
Hence, notice was served to the institution on 01.09.2009 asking to explain
as to why the institution has not shifted to its own premises as on date along
with required documents listed therein. The institution has submitted its
reply on 27.11.2009 SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-30 March 2010
considered the written representation and decided to cause inspection
under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
03.06.2010.
Further, NCTE, Hqrs on 20.05.2010 (copy annexed) has forwarded a
complaint with its enclosures against the institution received from Nirmala
of New Delhi.
The Committee considered the V.T. Report and decided to withdraw
recognition for B.Ed. course for the following reasons : B.Ed. is functioning in the School building.
 The total Built-up- area is only 5800 sq.ft. and is not sufficient to run B.Ed.
course as per NCTE norms. As per NCTE norms, 16,000 sq.ft. is
required.
 No sufficient built-up-area is earmarked exclusively for running B.Ed.
programme.
As per NCTE norms, no other programme is allowed to run along with
Teacher Education programmes, in the same building.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for B.Ed. course with immediate effect. It is made clear that the
institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the
date of issue of this order. The State
Accordingly, wirhdrawal order was issued to the institution vide order dt.
F.SRC/NCTE/2010-2011/20162. 02.08.2010.
The institution has filed an appeal Under Section 18 of NCTE Act, before
the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi against the rejection order SRC.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
129
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Appeal reversed and directed SRC to issue Show Cause Notice under
section 17 of the NCTE Act 1993 and thereafter take appropriate action..
The committee considered the Appellate authority order Dt. 19.11.2010
and decided to issue Show Cause notice Under Section 17 of NCTE
Act as follows:
 B.Ed. is functioning in the School building.
 The total Built-up- area is only 5800 sq.ft. and is not sufficient to run
B.Ed. course as per NCTE norms. As per NCTE norms, 16,000 sq.ft.
is required.
 No sufficient built-up-area is earmarked exclusively for running B.Ed.
programme.
As per NCTE norms, no other programme is allowed to run along with
Teacher Education programmes, in the same building.
The institution be directed to reply to the above show cause notice
within 30 days of the issue of notice, failing which final action
including refusal of recognition will be taken based on the available
information, with no further notice.
4/ SRCAPP135
B.P.Ed
Hulkoti Co-Op
Education
Society.
Gadag
KA
An application was submitted by Hulkoti Co-Op Education Sciety Gadag
Karnataka for grant of recognition to B.P.Ed,course in the office of SRCNCTE, Bangalore on 30/10/2009
SRC in its order dt. 04/05/2010 refused the grant of recognition to the
institution for conducting B.P.Ed course on the ground that “The institution
has snot replied to the deficiency letter even after the expirey of stipulated
period of 60 days.
The correspondent, Hulkoti Co-op Education Society preferred an appeal dt.
16/06/2010 to the NCTE New Delhi under section 18 of the NCTE Act. 1993
against the said order.
After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after
considering oral arguments advanced during hearing, the Council reached
the conclusion that there was no ground to acceipt the appeal and hence it
should be reject. Accordingly, the appeal was rejected and the SRC’s order
dt. 04/05/2040 was confirmed.
Appeal was rejected and the SRC order dated 04.05.2010 is confirmed.
The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt. 19/11/2010
confirming the SRC’s order dt. 04.05.2010.
5/ APS01532
D.Ed
An application was submitted by B.C.N Rotary Vidya Samsthe Karnataka for
grant of recognition to D.Ed.,course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
130
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
B.C.N. Rotary
Vidya
Samshte,
Laxmeshwar
KA
on 22.12.2003
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the institution for D.Ed course (50 intake) vide
order dt 1.12.2004 with stipulated conditions.
SRC vide letter dated. 29/07/2010 withdrawn the recognition of the
institution for conducting D.Ed course on the grounds:
1/ The institution is also running PUC course in the same building.
2/ The built up area is 10584 Sq.ft sharing with PUC. It is not as per NCTE
norms.
3/ No. of bookds as on the date as per the VTR is 1000 only which is not
sufficient. Every year the D.Ed institution is required to add at least 200
books.
Against the withdrawal of recognition order dt. 29/07/2010, The institution
has preferred an appeal dt. 18/08/2010 to the NCTE New Delhi.
After submission of the appeal, the appellant through his letter dt.
13.10.2010 forwarding a copy of the order of the Hon’ble High Court of
Karnataka Circuit Bench of Dharwad. Dt. 20.8.2010 in the wrti petition No.
65067 of 2010 (LDDN REG.P) informed that after conducting a reinspection of the institution as directed by the Hon’ble High Court, the SRC
in their 196th meeting held on 15-16 Sept.2010 has restored the recognition
to the institution and order dated 01.11.2010 was issued to the institution by
the SRC. In these circumstances the appeal become infructuous.
The appeal has become infructuous, NCTE has restored the recognition of
the institution as per the Court Order, in the 196th meeting.
The committee considered the Appellate authority order dt. 1811/2010
and noted the contents.
6/ APS05859
D.Ed
Brilliant D.Ed
College
Manjunath
Nagar,
Robertsonpet,
KGF. Kolar
KA
An application was submitted by Briliant D.Ed College Roberstsonpet, KGF,
Koilar District, Karnataka for grant of recognition to D.Ed.,course in the
office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 02.01.2006
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the institution for D.Ed course (50 intake) vide
order dt 17.09.2007 with stipulated conditions.
SRC withdrawn the recognition for conducting D.Ed course on the grounds
1/ There is a discrepancy between the building plan and building completion
certificate in terms of built up space.
2/ Buil up space is inadequate as per the records provided by the institution
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
131
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
itself.
The management went for an appeal against the order of SRC dt.
04/03/2010 for recognition withdrawal,
The appellate authority after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal,
affidavit, report and after considering oral arguments advanced during
hearing, the council reached the conclusion that there was no ground to
accept the appeal and hence it should be rejected. Accordingly, the appeal
was rejected and the SRC’s order dt. 04.03.2010 was confirmed.
The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt. 19/11/2010
confirming the SRC’s order dt. 04.05.2010.
7/ 4365
D.T.Ed
St. Catherine
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Chennai
TN
St. Catherine Teacher Training, Chennai has submitted an application for
seeking grant of recognition to D.T.Ed course on 28.2.2002.
The application was processed and inspection of the institution was carried
out and finally SRC in its 104th meeting held on 8th and 9th November, 2005
approved to accord recognition to offer D.T.Ed programme with an intake of
50 students from the session 2005-2006 with the condition that approved
staff list from the Director DTERT, Chennai, be submitted to SRC before
making admissions. Accordingly, a recognition order was issued to the
institution on 21.11.2005, with the condition the institution will ensure that
the permanent building is constructed within a period of 3 years on the
acquired land.
Besides the specific condition with recognition order, a general
circular/Notice was put up on the website and also a Press Note was also
issued to the effect that all such institutions in temporary accommodation
should move to their own permanent premises within the stipulated period of
three years failing which action will be taken, including withdrawal of
recognition.
Meantime, an undated letter received from the institution on 6.7.2010 along
with D.D. of Rs. 40,000/- dated 31st January, 2010, with the request to give
one more year relaxation for the inspection of their own building because
due to various reasons work is not fully completed. As soon as it will get
over, the same will be informed to the office of SRC and requested for
postponement of inspection.
The Committee considered the request and decided that the request be not
complied with and has decided to withdraw recognition for the D.T.ED.
course on the following reasons: As per the Norms of NCTE, the institution should have shifted to the
permanent building within three years from the date of recognition.
 SRC had already decided in its 160th Meeting held on 31st July-1st August,
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
132
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
2008 that all those institutions which were given recognition in temporary
buildings on condition that they shall move to permanent premises within
three years period and the same decision was communicated and also
put up on the NCTE website and a Press note was also issued to the
above effect.
 Now, the Management is requesting for extension of time by another one
year, even after running the institution in temporary accommodation for a
period of above five years which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.
 The institution was given recognition on 21.11.2005 in a temporary
premises with a specific condition that the institution should move to a
permanent premise within a period of three years i.e., on or before
20.11.2008.
 The institution, almost two years after the lapse of three year stipulated
period, now on 6.7.2010 requested for relaxation of one more year as the
construction work is not completed.
 The institution’s request for extension of time by another one year,
extension of time in this regard cannot be granted as per the regulations
of NCTE.
 The request for extension of time does not seem to be genuine as the
Demand Draft for inspection for shifting is dated January 30, 2010, was
purported to have sent along with an undated covering letter which was
received by the office on July 6, 2010(after a lapse of over five months).
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for D.T.Ed. course w.e.f. 2011-12, as a special case in order to
enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed. course to complete their
final year course.
The Committee also decided to return the fee of
Rs.40,000/- as the building is not ready for inspection and one more years
time is requested by the institution.
It is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further
admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The State Government/ Affiliating University be informed accordingly for
necessary enforcement.
The correspondent of the said institution preferred an appeal dt. 04/10/2010
to the NCTE New Delhi against the said order.
After perusal of documents, memorandum of apapeal affidavit, VT report
and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the
Council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept
the appeal and reverse the SRC’s order dt. 02.09.2010 with direction to the
SRc to issue show cause notice to the institution and, thereafter take
appropriate decision. Accordingly, the appeal was accepted and the order
dt. 02.09.2010 reversed.
Reverse the SRC order Dated 02.09.2010 with a direction to SRC to issue
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
133
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
show cause notice to the institution and thereafter take appropriate decision.
The committee considered the Appellate authority order Dt. 19.11.2010
and decided to issue Show Cause notice Under Section 17 of NCTE
Act as follows:
 As per the Norms of NCTE, the institution should have shifted to the
permanent building within three years from the date of recognition.
 SRC had already decided in its 160th Meeting held on 31st July-1st
August, 2008 that all those institutions which were given recognition
in temporary buildings on condition that they shall move to
permanent premises within three years period and the same
decision was communicated and also put up on the NCTE website
and a Press note was also issued to the above effect.
 Now, the Management is requesting for extension of time by another
one year, even after running the institution in temporary
accommodation for a period of above five years which is not
permissible as per NCTE norms.
 The institution was given recognition on 21.11.2005 in a temporary
premises with a specific condition that the institution should move
to a permanent premise within a period of three years i.e., on or
before 20.11.2008.
 The institution, almost two years after the lapse of three year
stipulated period, now on 6.7.2010 requested for relaxation of one
more year as the construction work is not completed.
 The institution’s request for extension of time by another one year,
extension of time in this regard cannot be granted as per the
regulations of NCTE.
 The request for extension of time does not seem to be genuine as
the Demand Draft for inspection for shifting is dated January 30,
2010, was purported to have sent along with an undated covering
letter which was received by the office on July 6, 2010(after a lapse
of over five months).
The institution be directed to reply to the above show cause notice
within 30 days of the issue of notice, failing which final action
including refusal of recognition will be taken based on the available
information, with no further notice.
8/ 4780
D.T..Ed
Sri Lakshmi
Teacher
Training
Institute,
Tiruvallur
TN
Sri Lakshmi TTI, Thiruvallur, Tamilnadu was issued notice u/s 17 on
22.7.2008 on the basis of complaint received from State
Government/individual in the state of Tamilnadu.
The matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting held 20-21st April
2010 and it was decided to issue final notice to the institution to submit the
reply within 21 days. Accordingly, final Notice was issued on 31.5.2010.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
134
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
This office has not received any reply from the institution so far.
Hence, the Committee considered the matter and decided to withdraw
recognition for the following reasons: The Intitution was served Notice on 22.07.2008 and Final Notice on
31.5.2010, for which the institution did not reply to both the Notices, based
on the complaints received from the State Govt of Tamil Nadu after due
inspection.
The specific points of deficiencies pointed by the DTERT Tamil Nadu are as
follows:
 The TTI is functioning in the Higher Secondary School Campus.
 Building License, Stability Certificate, Sanitary Certificate, Fire Protection
Certificate have not all been obtained.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for D.T.Ed. course w.e.f. 2011-12, as a special case in order to
enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed. course to complete their
final year course.
It is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further
admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The State Government/ Affiliating University be informed accordingly for
necessary enforcement.
The institution went for an appeal against SRC’s order dt. 02/09/2010 for
withdrawing recognition for D.T.Ed course .
After perusal of documents, memorandum of apapeal affidavit, VT report
and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the
Council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept
the appeal and reverse the SRC’s order dt. 02.09.2010 with direction to the
SRC to consider reply of the institution to the show cause notice and take
appropriate decision thereafter. Accordingly, the appeal was accepted and
the order dt. 02.09.2010 reversed.
Reverse the SRc order dated 02.09.2010 and direction to SRC to consider
reply of the institution and issue show cause notice to the institution and
take appropriate decision thereafter.
The committee considered the Appellate authority order Dt. 19.11.2010
and decided to issue Show Cause notice Under Section 17 of NCTE
Act as follows:
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
135
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 The Institution was served Notice on 22.07.2008 and Final Notice on
31.5.2010, for which the institution did not reply to both the Notices,
based on the complaints received from the State Govt of Tamil Nadu
after due inspection.
The specific points of deficiencies pointed by the DTERT Tamil Nadu
are as follows:
 The TTI is functioning in the Higher Secondary School Campus.
 Building License, Stability Certificate, Sanitary Certificate, Fire
Protection Certificate have not all been obtained.
The institution be directed to reply to the above show cause notice
within 30 days of the issue of notice, failing which final action
including refusal of recognition will be taken based on the available
information, with no further notice.
9/ 5980
8538
D.T.Ed
J.S.J.V
Teacher
Training
Institute
Cuddalore
TN
J.S.J.V Teacher Training Institute, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu had submitted an
application for grant of recognition to D.T.Ed course. Recognition to the
institution was granted to the institution on 23.12.2006 for D.T.Ed course
with an intake of 50 students.
As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting of SRC held on 13-14th May
2009, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have
been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction
of own building or in lease premises. A list of such institutions has been
prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st
August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have not
shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time
limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 16.09.2009.
The institution has not submitted reply to the above notice so far. Instead
the institution has submitted letter dated 12.04.2010 requesting for change
of name from J.S.J.V. Teacher Training Institute to C.K. Teacher
Training Institute. The matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting
held on 20th-21st April 2010. The Committee considered the brief note about
the College and also the complaints received against the institution and has
decided to issue Final Notice to the institution on the following grounds: To explain as to why the institution has not shifted to its own premises,
even after the expiry of three years (i.e., on 22.12.2009).
 The Committee also decided that the change of Name from J.S.J.V.
Teacher Training Institute to C.K. Teacher Training Institute cannot be
considered as the institution is still in temporary accommodation and
any change of Name and character of the institution is not permitted, at
this stage.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
136
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
As per the decision of SRC, final notice was issued to the institution on
18.05.2010. The institution has submitted its reply on 01.06.2010.
The Committee considered the reply to the Notice and decided to withdraw
recognition for the following: The institution has not shifted from temporary accommodation to its own
premises, even after the expiry of three years (i.e., on 22.12.2009).
 The building plan is not submitted.
 Building Completion Certificate is not submitted.
 No evidence of any efforts towards shifting to permanent premises as per
the norms.
Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
recognition for D.T.Ed. course w.e.f. 2011-12, as a special case in order to
enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed. course, if any, to complete
their final year course. But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred
from making any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
order. The DTERT, Government of Tamilnadu be informed accordingly for
necessary enforcement.
Accordingly,
withdrawal
order
was
issued
vide
order
F.SRO/NCTE/2010/20030, Dt. 27.07.2010. Recognition to D.T.Ed-Al was
also withdrawn on vide order F.SRO/NCTE2010/21089. Dt. 14.09.2010.
Reverse the SRC order dated 27.07.2010 with direction to SRC to examine
the reply furnished by the institution and take appropriate decision
thereafter.
The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt. 19/11/2010 and
decided to issue a show cause notice as follows:
 The institution has not shifted from temporary accommodation to its
own premises, even after the expiry of three years (i.e., on
22.12.2009).
 The building plan is not submitted.
 Building Completion Certificate is not submitted.
 No evidence of any efforts towards shifting to permanent premises
as per the norms.
The institution be directed to reply to the above show cause notice
within 30 days of the issue of notice, failing which final action
including refusal of recognition will be taken based on the available
information, with no further notice.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
137
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
91.
APS02118
D.Ed
Gnana
Bharathi D.Ed
College,
Davanagere
KA
Gnana Bharathi D.Ed College, Vinayaka Extension, 3rd Main, Near Vidyanagar,
Davanagere – 577 004, Karnataka has been granted recognition by SRC for
offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 24.12.2005.
The State Government of Karnataka in its letter addressed to Ministry of
HRD, Government of India, New Delhi and NCTE has recommended for
withdrawal of recognition of some institutions in the state of Karnataka as
the institutions are lacking infrastructural, instructional facilities and staff.
The matter was placed before SRC in its 134th meeting of SRC held during
29-31 May and 1 June,2007. The Regional Committee has decided to
cause inspection of the institutions recommended for withdrawal of
recognition by state Government of Karnataka under Section 17 of NCTE
Act,1993 to verify the veracity of the objections raised and also the facilities
provided by the institutions as per norms & standard prescribed by NCTE.
Accordingly, an inspection team was constituted by SRC-NCTE which
visited the above institution on 10.08.2007. The report of the inspection
team was placed before the Southern Regional Committee in its sub
committee meeting of SRC held on 24th August,2007.The SRC considered
the VT report, VCD, original file and other documents submitted by the
institution and decided to issue notice under section 17. Accordingly, notice
was issued to the institution on 05.09.2007.
The Committee in its 177th Meeting held on 22-23 June, 2009 considered
the representation of the institution dated 11.05.2009 and has decided to
cause inspection and to call for documents for shifting. Accordingly, a letter
to the institution has been issued on 10.08.2009. As the institution has not
submitted any reply to the letter, the matter was placed before SRC in its
189th meeting held on 25-26 February 2010 and SRC decided to issue
notice. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 07.04.2010. The
institution submitted its written representation on 26.04.2010.
SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10-11 May 2010 considered the matter and
decided to withdraw recognition of the institution for the D.Ed. course.
Further, the SRC decided that the withdrawal takes effect from the
academic session 2011-12 in order to enable the ongoing batch of
programme to be completed. However, no more fresh admissions shall be
made after the date of the order of withdrawal.
Accordingly, order for withdrawing recognition was issued to the institution
on 29.06.2010.
The institution moved Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.No.22681 of
2010 and the court has considered the request made by the petitioner
regarding consideration of its appeal on or before 13.08.2010 and was
accepted. The respondent Appellate Authority was directed to consider and
decide the appeal before 13.08.2010.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
138
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
The institution in its letter dated 16.08.2010 has enclosed the Appellate
Authority order dated 13.08.2010 for restoring of recognition, wherein the
Appellate Authority reads as follows:
“….. remand back the case to SRC with a direction to cause an
inspection of the institution at the new premises and take further
action. In the meantime, the SRC should restore recognition to the
appellant institution immediately within 15days of issuing the
appellate order.”
The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the
matter and decided to continue recognition as per the appellate authority
order and it was also decided to cause inspection to the institution under
section 17 on payment of Rs.40,000/-. The institution had already made
payment on 13.07.2009. As per the decision of SRC, the recognition of the
institution was restored vide order dated 02.09.2010.
Further, as per the decision of SRC, inspection was carried out between 9 10 September 2010 for shifting of premises. The inspection report was
placed before SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 and
decided to continue recognition accorded to the institution. Accordingly, as
per the decision of SRC, the file was put up and it has been observed that
the SRC has not conferred its decision regarding shifting of premises.
Hence, once again the details of the visiting team report for shifting of
premises is attached below:
The Committee considered the VT report of the institution and other
related documents along with the original file of the institution for
shifting to new/permanent premises and decided to permit shifting to
new premises.
92
APS07198
B.Ed
Sri Veda
Narayana
College of
Education,
Chittoor
AP
Sri Veda Narayana college of Education, 1-297, Lakshminagar, Puttur,
Chittoor-517583, Andhra Pradesh, was granted recognition for B.Ed course
with an annual intake of 100 students vide order dated 26.06.2007.
The SRC, NCTE, Bangalore received a written remarks on the deficiencies
pointed out by the Dean, Faculty of Education, Sri.Venkateshwara
University, Tirupati,A.P.
SRC in its 195th Meeting held on 17-18 August, 2010 considered the letter
received from S. V. University and decided to call for clarification from the
institution. Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution for seeking
clarification on 27.09.2010. The institution has submitted its clarification on
02.10.2010 and the details are as under.
The Committee considered the reply of the institution and it was
decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
following deficiencies: The management has not appointed the staff by duly constituted
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
139
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
staff selection committee. The management has to submit the staff
approval list from the Affiliating University within 60 days of the
notice.
In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue Notice to the
institution and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
make a written representation within 60days from the date of issue of
the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to
take a final decision in the matter, failing which action will be taken
including the withdrawal, based on the records available, with no
further notice.
93
APS02647
B.Ed
B.Pulla Rao
College of
Education,
Mahabubnagar
District
AP
An application was submitted by B. Pulla Rao College of Education,
Chityala Village, Wanaparthy, Mahabubnagar District, Andhra Pradesh for
grant of recognition to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the university vide order dt 30.09.2005 with
stipulated conditions.
The NCTE Hqrs vide letter dated.14.07.2009 forwarded a compliant made
by 1. Sreenivasulu Goud 2. Satyanarayana Reddy 3. Thirupathaiah 4.
Pedda Kotaiah 5. Lokanath Reddy and 6. Kurumurthy Yadav against
B.Pulla Rao College of Education, Andhra Pradesh with the request to
cause inspection under section 17 of NCTE Act and also to verify the facts
provided by the complainant. Following complaints have been made by the
complainant:


The college has been violating NCTE norms and standards and the
college has shown pucca building at the time of inspection, which was
school building named Saketha Public School, Vengal Rao Nagar,
Wanaparthy Town, which was neither own nor leased building.
After getting recognition from NCTE-SRC they shifted college to Chityala
which is asbestos roof and the college has violated NCTE norms by
conducting college at POULTRY FORM SHED.
Even after completion of 4 academic year also they did not constructed
pucca (RCC) building by faith on Osmania University authorities and
NCTE-SRC authorities that they can manage them.
The Committee considered the complaint in its 179th meeting of SRC held
on 23rd July 2009 and decided to issue showcause Notice under section 17
of NCTE Act as per regulations of NCTE 2007. As per the decision of SRC,
Notice was issued to the institution on 17.08.2009.
Institution had not submitted reply till date and the matter was considered by
the committee and decided to cause inspection of the institution to verify the
facts, under section 17 of NCTE Act.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
140
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
As per direction of Regional committee an inspection caused on 09.05.2010
to applicant institution on the basis of complaint.
The matter was again placed before 192nd meeting of SRC held on 10th –
11th May, 2010 the Regional committee considered the matter on the basis
of complaint, visiting team report along with CD and decided to continue the
recognition.
Thereafter a complaint received through HQtrs on 24.05.2010 from
Sri.O.Ramachandra Pillai, Journalist, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh as under
: NCTE SRC team visited to Unauthorized poultry farm shed on
09.05.2010. the management offered each 3 (three lakh Rupees) to
each team member for favorable report.
 The team members agreed to the management offer, the management
arranged A.C Innova car and 5 star hotel for team members. Team
stayed in hotel for three days under guidance of team the management
made sealing with thermacol to each class, office, all labs for
videograph for avoiding form shed roof.
 Inspection finished with in fifteen minutes, team wrote false, bogus
report before management even though this report is confidential this
report before management. Even though this report is confidential this
report has to send by the team to NCTE office, but here team handed
over to the management.
 After getting xerox of the report the management posted to NCTE. The
report is available with management this is violation of the NCTE
norms.
In the meanwhile, SRC – NCTE had already caused inspection U/s 17 and
it was considered in 192nd Meeting of SRC which has decided to continue
the recognition.
A complaint letter has also received in the office of SRC on 02.06.2010 from
State Govt. The State Govt has observed as follows on the basis of
inspection committee which inspected the said college on 19.05.2010: After verifying the records, it is found that NCTE visiting team
inspected the building located at #42-224/A, vengalaraonagar,
Vanaparthy town, Mahboobnagar, Distt, but management was
permitted to start the college at Chiyala(V), Vanaparthy (M),
Mahboobnagar Distt. Which is 2 Kms away from Vanaparthy Town.
It is a serious lapse on the part of NCTE authorities.
 It is fact that the college is being run in temporary poultry farm
sheds.
 Neither the sheds nor the land where the college is located as on
date, are not in the name of the society but in name of an individual
Mr. Bhanu Prakash (the fact is accepted by Mr. Bhanu Prakash
also.)
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
141
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010

All the class rooms and laboratories are located in temporary sheds
roofed with asbestos sheets.
The Committee considered the above in the 193rd SRC meeting held on 2122 June 2010 and decided to serve Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act
for the following:The Complainant has pointed out the following serious deficiencies: It is fact that the college is being run in temporary poultry farm
sheds.
 The management made false-sealing with thermacoal roofing to
each class room, office room and all labs. and videographed
concealing the asbestos sheet/roof/shed.
 All the class rooms and laboratories are located in temporary sheds
roofed with asbestos sheets.”
 Neither the sheds nor the land where the college is located as on
date, are not in the name of the society but in name of an individual
Mr. Bhanu Prakash (the fact is accepted by Mr. Bhanu Prakash
also.)
After verifying the records, it is found that NCTE visiting team inspected the
building located at #42-224/A, Vengalaraonagar, Vanaparthy town,
Mahboobnagar, Distt, but permitted the management to start the college at
Chiyala(V), Vanaparthy (M), Mahboobnagar Distt. which is 2 Kms away from
Vanaparthy Town.
Accordingly a Notice dated 29.07.2010 was issue on the above points and
the institution was given opportunity to make written representation within
30 days on why recognition cannot be withdrawn based upon serious
deficiencies of the institution failing which action including the withdrawal of
recognition, will be initiated based on the available records.
Meanwhile SRC office has also received an W.P.No.17542/10 filed by
K.Krishnaiah. In this regard brief history of the case forwarded to legal
counsel on 10.08.2010.
The institution has replied to the SRC Notice vide letter dated 12.08.2010
and gist of the same is given below:Osmania University, Hyderabad has endorsed a copy of a letter dated
03.08.2010 written to Andhra Pradesh state council for Highly Education
regarding enquiry report submitted by their committee. In this regard
university has issued Show cause Notice to the management of Pulla Rao
College of Education, Chityala, Wanaparthy(M), Mahabubnagar District as
under:

That the college is running in a Poultry shed and the accommodation
and facilities provided are not as per NCTE and OU norms.
Neither the shed nor the land where the college is located as on date
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
142
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010

are in the name of the Society.
As per the NCTE norms the college needs to be shifted to its own
premises after completion of three academic years but the college is still
running in the temporary premises.
It is stated in the universities letter that management has informed that the
college is running in the same building which was shown to the NCTE Team
and for which accorded approval situated at Chitanya (Village)
Wanaparthy(M), Mahabubnagar District.
Further, it is stated that the management submitted another letter dated
24.07.2010 enclosing a Registered Document informing the University that
the land on which the Pulla Rao College of Education, Chityala, Wanaparthy
is existing has been got Registered in the name of My Home Educational
Society which is offering B.Ed course.
The explanation submitted by the Pulla Rao College of Education was
placed before the APSCHE committee and the committee examined the
issue in detail and resolved that “ the explanation submitted by the College
along with the documents submitted may be forwarded to the APSCHE for
its
consideration
in
terms
of
the
APSCHE
Lr.No.APSCHE/Secy/CETS/May/2010, dated 22.05.2010.
The management has also stated that the construction of the building will be
started soon after completion of the construction of the building. The date of
sale deed is 09.07.2010 in favour of My Home Educational Society.
The Committee in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
considered the matter and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
Section 17 of NCTE Act. Show cause notice issued on 28.10.2010.
The institution has replied vide letter dt. 27.11.2010 for the deficiencies
pointed in the notice:
The committee observed the following serious deficiencies.
The committee considered the reply of the institution to the show
cause notice and all the relevant documents.
 The management has purchased the land only on 9.7.2010, though
the institution should have possessed land on or before the date of
the original application i.e, 31.12.2003.
 The management has not submitted any documents to support the
construction of the new building. The management now claims that
the construction will be started soon, though the three year
stipulated period was over by 30.9.2008. Now more than five year
period is over since the college started functioning in temporary
premises.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
143
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
 The institution is still running the B.Ed course in the Poultry shed,
for over five years now as reported by the affiliating university.
 The NCTE V.T members were deceived and misled by giving false
evidence and showing a different building; and by submitting false
photographs of the building by the management. This is
unbecoming of a Teacher Education Institution.
Bassed on the above grave deficiencies the committee decides to
withdraw the recognition of the B.Ed course run by the B. Pulla Rao
College of Education, Chityala Vilage, Wanaparthy, Mahabubnagar
District, Andhra Pradesh with effect from the beginning of academic
year 2011.12. The current ongoing batch 2010-11 students in B.Ed,
course, if any would be permitted to complete their course.
But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any
further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.
The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.
Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.
94
APS07190
B.Ed
Smt & Sri
Gurrala
Krishna Rao
Vasanthamma
Degree & P.G.
College, East
Godavari
AP
Smt & Sri Gurrala Krishna Rao Vasanthamma Degree & P.G.College,
Mallina Nagar, Rajahmundry, East Godavari-533103 Andhra Pradesh has
been granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed Course of one year
duration with annual intake of 100 students on 04.10.2007.
A letter dated 20.11.2010 has been received and has requested for
change of name for B.Ed Course as “Sharada College of
Education”Pidimgoyya, Rajahmundry. From the perusal of the request it is
found that institute also wants to shift to new premises, though the institution
has not mentioned it clearly in their request letter.
The committee considered the request and decided not to permit Smt
& Sri Gurrala Krishna Rao Vasanthamma Degree & P.G College Mallina
Nagar, Rajahmundry, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh for
change in the name and also location (from one permanent premise
originally permitted to another place).
95
APS02735
B.Ed
Jnana Bharathi
Elementary
Teacher
Training
College,
Ananthpur
AP
Jnana Bharathi Elementary Teacher Training College, Kalyanadurga(Po)
Ananthpur District-515761, Andhra Pradesh was granted recognition for
D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 26.08.2005.
A complaint was received from Advocate under the instruction of
G.Sundarshan S/o G.Venkataswamy on 23.08.2010 in the office of SRC
and has raised the following points against Jnana Bharathi College of
Education, Ananthpur, Andhra Pradesh.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
144
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Mr.Sudarshan has provided an affidavit of Rs.100/- to support his veracity of
complaint along with supporting documents.
“The institution Jnana Bharathi College of Education was founded by you
only with an object to make money but not to impart any knowledge on
aspirants who get admitted in your institution upon payment of high
premium or donation. Ever since its inception of the college 2002-2003, you
have not got infrastructure as required under U.G.C Norms. Though you
realize money heavily you do not invest in establishment but you want to
enrich yourself. G.Sundarshan was appointed for the post of Lecturer in
Psychology by you under appointed order dated 30.01.2007 with scale of
pay as per UGC norms. Though my client was appointed as Lecturer in
Psychology, his services were also extended to teaching English and other
subjects. This was done by you as you have not appointed sufficient
teaching staff for the B.Ed college and by utilizing the services of skeleton
staff for all purposes, you have saved lot of money in establishment. You
are very deceptive in payment salary. You have the habit of obtaining
acquaintance on bank stamped papers and scribble whatever figure
according to your convenience thereby cheated the teaching staff. My client
was was handed over only Rs.7,500/- per month during 2002-2003, and in
2009-2010 you were giving Rs.9500/- per month and assured my client that
you would deposit the scale of payment as per UGC norms in Bank to
deposit as provident fund. The payments are in cash which was deliberately
made by hand though you were asked to pay through cheque. My client
informs you that the teaching staffs appointed by you have to be informed to
Dean, College Development Council, S.K.University, Ananthpur, periodically
with a copy marked to teaching staff for reference. When my client started
asking for deposit of salary in Bank, you have evaded cleverly and
ultimately on 15.06.2010, you have asked my client to withdraw from college
and seek appointment elsewhere.
You have made alternate appointment with due intimation to college
Development Council, of S.K.University, without legally terminating the
services of my client. You have not served any letter of terminating the
services of my client and my clients appointment unless terminated,
continuous makes you liable to pay the salary and all concomitant benefits
until legally terminated. My client as per the UGC norms have to be paid the
Rs8,71,700/- dated till 15.06.2010 which were retained by you without
payment either as salary or as provident fund as assured by you. A
statement is appended for convenience. You have not properly accounted
so far the monies received by you as donation or premium.
My client was due till 15.06.2010 the Rs.8,71,700/- as stated in the
appended statement. As per the appended a statement of account you have
to honor Rs.8,71,700/- within 7 days from the date of receipt of this notice
failing which action appropriate will be initiated against you and also the
institution for flouting all the norms, rules, guide lines of University grants
commission in running the institution as per the permission accorded to
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
145
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
you”.
SRC in its 196th Meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010 considered the
Complaint and decided to call for remarks from the institution. Further, SRC
also decided to issue direction to the complainant to approach the University
and / or seek legal remedy.
Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution for seeking clarification for
remarks on the complaint on 28.10.2010.
The institution has submitted its clarification on the complaint on 05.12.2010
along with the following documents
1. Copy of audited Balance Sheet.
2. Copy of Certificate of affiliation from S.K. University for the academic
year 2010-2011.
3. Copy of Approved list of teaching staff from S.K. University.
4. Copy of acquittance register.
5. Copy of attendance register.
The committee considered the reply of the institution and decided to
note the reply.
96
APS00045
B.Ed
Bharath
College of
Education,
Cuddapah
AP
Bharath College of Education, Cuddapah District, Andhra Pradesh was
granted recognition for B.Ed course with annual intake of 100 students vide
order dated 04.04.2003.
SRC, NCTE, Bangalore received a written communication containing
remarks on the deficiencies pointed out by the Dean, Faculty of Education,
S.V. University, Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh. SRC in its 195th meeting held on
17-18 August, 2010 considered the deficiencies pointed out in staff list and
decided to call clarification from the institution
Accordingly clarification letter was issued to the institution on 27.09.2010.
The institution submitted its clarification on 18.10.2010 and the details are
given below:
The committee considered the reply of the institution and decided to
note the reply.
97
APS00285
B.Ed
Vivekananda
College of
Education,
Chittoor
AP
Vivekananda College of Education, #115A, Nehru Street, Tirupathi, Chittoor
District-517201, Andhra Pradesh for grant recognition to B.Ed course vide
order dated on 03.03.2003.
The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt 03.03.2003 with
stipulated conditions.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
146
Minutes-199th Meeting of SRC
22nd-23rd December 2010
Shifting proposal was submitted by the institution on 03.09.2007. Shifting
inspection was conducted on 23.09.2010. The Visiting Team report was
placed before SRC.
The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14October, 2010 considered the
VT Report and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve
Showcause Notice, Under Section 17 of NCTE. Accordingly, Show Cause
Notice was issued to the institution on 03.12.2010. Building completion
certificate from the competent Government Engineer not submitted.
 Land use certificate and Encumbrance certificate from the competent
Government Authority not submitted.
 The Science Lab, Psychology Lab and Library, rest rooms needs to be
strengthened as they are moderately adequate.
The institution submitted its written representation on 20.12.2010 as follows:
The institution has submitted Approved completion certificate, Land use
certificate and encumbrance certificate and library and lab bills.
The Committee considered the VT Report and VCD and all the relevant
documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :
 In the BCC it is mentioned that the ground floor consists of 8522
sq.ft of RCC roof and as large as 6500 sq.ft of asbestos roof which is
a serious violation of norms.
In view of the above, the Committee considered the reply of the
institution, VT report and VCD and decided to issue a Showcause
Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including
the withdrawal, based on the records available, with no further notice.
(Gangadharaiah)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE
(Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Chairman, SRC, NCTE
147