VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
2005
C U M U L AT I V E I N D E X - V O L U M E 1 5 3 - 2 0 0 5
This listing is provided according to Plaintiff/Defendant names for your convenience.
Under this title is printed a list of all cases reported in the Pittsburgh Legal Journal,
a Supplement to the Lawyers Journal (Volume No. 153 - 2005). Subscribers can find
in this index immediate reference to any case reported in the PITTSBURGH LEGAL
JOURNAL. For identification purposes: (C)Capsule Summaries; and (J)Jury Verdicts.
3D Amusements, Inc. v. John Kovall, Roadrunner Amusements,
Inc., Dennis Martin, Joan Martin, Michelle Martin,
MMM 131 Forbes, Inc., Michele’s 1020 Washington Pike, Inc.,
Joan’s Place 1122, Inc., Greentree Saloon, Inc., and
JAM 1993 Restaurant, Inc. ..........................................................278
3-D Trucking, Inc. and John Thorpe, Jr.; Martin Cloonan v.; Joseph
Vinciguerra v. John R. Thorpe, Jr. and Martin Cloonan ..........231
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc.,
and Trafford Corporation
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation ................................290
Able-Hess Associates, Inc., WTW Architects, Inc. and;
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. Board of Public Education of the
School District of Pittsburgh v. ....................................................299
Abramson, Stewart N. v. Aegis Insurance Agency, Inc. ..................174
Abramson, Stewart N. v. AT&T Wireless Services, Inc. ..................176
Ace Tire & Parts, Inc., Preferred Car & Truck, Inc.,
John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard J. Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire
Company, Tarquinio Towing, John Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio
Towing and Scott A. Hoover; Frank Morganti and
Cynthia Jo Morganti v. ..................................................................102
Aegis Insurance Agency, Inc.; Stewart N. Abramson v. ..................174
Aetna US Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center, Allegheny
General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health System,
Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar, Carol Waldschmidt
in her own right and as Administratrix of the Estate of
Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v.; Donna Shedlock v.
UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System and
University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani, M.D.,
Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital; ..........................63
AIG Aviation, Inc., National Union Fire Ins. Co. and v.
Airburst Helicopters, Inc. et al. ....................................................70
Airburst Helicopters, Inc. et al.; National Union Fire Ins. Co.
and AIG Aviation, Inc. v. ................................................................70
(J)All Crane Rental Corporation; Thomas Polas v. ............................82
Allegheny County Airport Authority v. Construction General
Laborers and Material Handlers Union, 1058..............................11
Allegheny County Personnel Board; Lori Dobrosielski v. ..............105
Allegheny County Sanitary Authority v. Deloitte Consulting LLC
and Deloitte and Touche, LLP......................................................133
Allegheny County; Sto-Rox School District and
James C. Clifton v. ........................................................................193
Allegheny General Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services;
Rehabilitation Management Systems, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports
Medicine Services; West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc.
t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services and Tracee L. Kallet;
Amy W. Budner and Martin A. Budner v. ..................................173
Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation Corporation, et al. v.
Trafford Corporation; Lacey D. Cook, et al. v.
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc.,
and Trafford Corporation ............................................................290
Allegheny Mobile Home Park/t/d/b/a ; James Simon and Maureen
Simon v. Jane R. Mercer, Jack Mercer, John J. Ross,
Bonnie L. Ross, David L. Ross, Donna Bunce Fruend, ............215
(J)Ambrose, Pamela v. Henry Suffoletta ..............................................8
American International Resources, Inc. v. Russell E. Swanson v.
Christopher D. Moore....................................................................115
Anderson, Daniel W. and Shelby J. Anderson, his wife v.
Eugene N. Myers, M.D., and UPMC Presbyterian and
UPMC Eye and Ear Hospital ......................................................215
Anderson, Richard E., M.D. and Thomas R. Graham, M.D.;
Cynthia M. Liberto v. Suburban General Hospital, ..................241
(J)Anderson, Richard and Marcie Anderson, his wife v.
UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., 0UPMC Health System and
University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc. ......................................8
(J)AON Corp., AON Service Corp., AON Group, Inc., &
AON Consulting Worldwide, Inc.; Barbara Trant v. ..................229
Apple, Karen and Rodney Apple v. Ford Motor Company v.
Rodney Apple ..................................................................................54
(J)Artis, Cathy J., M.D., and South Hills Health System, t/d/b/a
Jefferson Regional Medical Center; Craig and Carol
Waugaman, husband and wife v. Ronald L. Boron, M.D., ..........10
AT&T Wireless Services, Inc.; Stewart N. Abramson v. ..................176
Atlantic States Insurance Company v. Northeast Networking
Systems, Inc., Clinton Boyd and Charles Fornicoia ..................119
Avonworth School District v. Pennsylvania Labor Relations
Board ................................................................................................37
(C)Auld, Jeannine G. v. Howard S. Auld, Sr. ....................................200
(J)Babula, Joseph L. and Marian Babula, his wife v.
David M. Lolley, M.D.; Cardiac Surgeons, Inc.;
Allegheny Valley Hospital; and Allegheny Valley Medical
Imaging and Radiology Oncologists, Inc., t/d/b/a
A V Medical Imaging; and Allegheny Valley Medical Imaging
and Radiation Oncology, Inc., t/d/b/a A V Medical Imaging ........8
Bank One Delaware, N.A. v. Gregory P. Mitchell ............................125
(J)Baran, James J., M.D. and Colo-Rectal Associates;
Harry Wells, Administrator of the Estate of Carole Wells,
Deceased v. ....................................................................................270
(J)Barrett, David v. Youngstown Kenworth, Inc. ..............................80
Bartolomucci, Robert, Rona Livingston Bartolomucci, his wife,
and Joseph L. Feucht v. Cavan Patterson and Samuel Price, II;
Thomas L. Patterson v. ....................................................................67
Bear Run Associates Limited Partnership v. Interactive Cable
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................41
(C)Becker, Alison v. David Gosselin ....................................................79
Bell, Regis; Commonwealth of PA v.....................................................56
(J)Benjamin, Steven; Anna Crnogorac and Anthony Crnogorac,
her husband v. ..................................................................................46
(J)Berner, Peter J v. Bizet & Co. Ltd., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,”
Walter V. Clark Associates, Inc., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,”
and Sandra K. Donnelley, individually........................................150
(J)Berry, Rakyia F. v. The May Department Stores Company, d/b/a
Kaufmanns, Charles A. Kramer, Administrator of the Estate of
Louis Kramer, Jr., Deceased, John Doe 1, John Doe 2, Jane Doe
1, Jane Doe 2, and Patrick Hillyard ..............................................8
Beshir, Juanita Wilborn v. Erie Insurance Group d/b/a Erie
Insurance Company ......................................................................197
Bianchi, James H., Jr.; Adolfo J. Marche, Administrator of
the Estate of Carol Marche, Deceased, v. County of
Allegheny v. ....................................................................................248
(J)Bianco, James and Jean Anne Bianco, his wife, and
Geno Bianco and Carla Bianco; Daniel Mazzie v. ....................152
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
(J)Bizet & Co. Ltd., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,” Walter V. Clark
Associates, Inc., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,” and Sandra K.
Donnelley, individually; Peter J. Berner v. ................................150
(J)Blucas, Renee v. The Western Pennsylvania Hospital and
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc.....................................46
Board of Public Education of the School District of Pittsburgh v.
WTW Architects, Inc. and Able-Hess Associates, Inc.;
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. ........................................................................299
Board of Township Supervisors of Kennedy Township v.
Keith Rose; Ken-Med Associates v. ............................................261
(J)Boggs, Donn S., Sr. and Marion Boggs, husband and wife v.
Anthony N. Okobi, M.D., Anthony N. Okobi, M.D., P.C.,
Kalyanmay Ghoshhajra, M.D. and Radiological Imaging
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................46
(J)Booth, Edwin W.; W. Scott Hart v...................................................270
(J)Boron, Ronald L., M.D., Cathy J. Artis, M.D., and South Hills
Health System, t/d/b/a Jefferson Regional Medical Center;
Craig Waugaman and Carol Waugaman, husband and wife v.....10
Borough of McDonald v. John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman,
County of Allegheny, West Allegheny School District &
North Fayette Township; Fort Cherry School District and ......265
Borough of Whitehall, et al.; Osiris Enterprises and Antonio F.
Moscatiello v. ....................................................................................25
Boyd, Clinton and Charles Fornicoia; Atlantic States Insurance
Company v. Northeast Networking Systems, Inc., ....................119
(C)Branch, Deanna v. Orpheus Roye ................................................122
BR Associates v. The Priority Mortgage Group v.
Craig Longwill................................................................................133
(J)Breault & Associates, P.C. v. John L. Fiorita, Jr. ..........................46
(J)Brose, James, a Minor, by Anne Brose, his Guardian v.
Zoological Society of Pittsburgh, a PA Corp. ................................80
Bryant, Marylynn Devaughn, a/k/a Marlynn Devaughn;
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............................................285
Buchleitner, Eugene C. v. Alan H. Perer and Swensen & Perer ....242
Budner, Amy W. and Martin A. Budner v. Allegheny General
Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services; Rehabilitation
Management Systems, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services;
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports
Medicine Services and Tracee L. Kallet ....................................173
Bulseco, Patricia, M.D., P.C.; Dawn Mapel & Michael Mapel v.
St. Clair Memorial Hospital, Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D.,
and ..................................................................................................131
Buncher Company v. Quaker Valley School District ........................44
Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement; Harry’s Holiday Park
Lounge, Inc. v. Pennsylvania State Police, ..................................223
Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement, Pennsylvania State
Police v. Jabby Joe, Inc. ................................................................204
Burns, John F., III and Leo Chini; Richard A. Toney v. Harmar
Township and Harmar Township Board of Supervisors, Robert
W. Seibert, Jr., James R. DiPalma, Donald R. Muse, ................160
(J)Burtt, Suzanne M. v. Port Authority of Allegheny County ........150
Campbell, Paul v. Aidan J. McKenna; Aidan J. McKenna v.
OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts Technologies, Inc.,
Mark Woodward and ....................................................................286
Canova Electrical Contracting, Inc.; Ravin, Inc. v...........................144
Capanet, Inc. v. Charapp Ford ............................................................121
(J)Carl, Jennifer L., Administratrix of the Estate of Jocelyn
Elizabeth Carl, Deceased and Jennifer Carl and Donald Carl,
in their own right v. Donald G. Carson, M.D., Kristine K.
Charles, M.D., Renata D. Hoca, M.D., and Oakland OB/GYN
Associates, Inc. ..................................................................................9
(J)Carolla, Sharon C. v. James P. Walker ..........................................150
CarParts Technologies, Inc., Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v.
Aidan J. McKenna; Aidan J. McKenna v.
OpenWebs Corporation, ................................................................286
Carpenter, David and Beatrice, and Frank and Elaine Pogel on
behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated v.
2005
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company ..................282
(J)Carson, Donald G., M.D., Kristine K. Charles, M.D., Renata D.
Hoca, M.D., and Oakland OB/GYN Associates, Inc.; Jennifer L.
Carl, Administratrix of the Estate of Jocelyn Elizabeth Carl,
Deceased and Jennifer Carl and Donald Carl, in their own
right v. ................................................................................................9
(J)Caruso, A. Thomas v. Cupka Café II; Richard Cupka, Jr.,
and Stephanie Cupka ......................................................................80
(C)Castillenti, Mary Elaine v. Joseph D. DePasquale........................77
(J)Catone, Guy A. and Guy A. Catone, D.M.D., Ltd.;
Mark Jacko and Mary Jo Jacko, husband and wife v. ................47
(J)Centers for Rehab Services; Linda A. Suttner v. ........................229
Charapp Ford; Capanet, Inc. v. ..........................................................121
(J)Charmello, Carmen, Jr. v. Port Authority of Allegheny
County ............................................................................................227
Charnovich, Richard; Robinson Township Library Association v.
Robinson Township, Board of Commissioners of Robinson
Township, and ................................................................................218
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v. Bryan Nesbitt
and Rosemarie Nesbitt
Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. v. Jonathan Q.
Fragapane, Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a Amber L. Madden ......184
Cheer-On, Sharon Hutchinson t/d/b/a v. Sharon Jackson,
Angela Crissman, Trent Gorrell, Sandy Ruggieri and
Amy Stake Corey Rose Schlemmer and Rosemary L. Vogel v.
Bernard L. Rottschaefer, M.D., Purdue Pharma Co.,
Purdue Frederick Co., P.F. Laboratories, Inc., and
Abbott Laboratories, et al. ............................................................205
Chini, Leo; Richard A. Toney v. Harmar Township and
Harmar Township Board of Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr.,
James R. DiPalma, Donald R. Muse, John F. Burns, III and....160
(J)Chiri, Joylene A. v. National Amusements, Inc.,
t/d/b/a Showcase Cinemas West ..................................................150
Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Russell N. Fedorka and
Nancy I. Fedorka..............................................................................29
(J)City of Pittsburgh v. Jan B. Jones;
Donald Wei, individually and on behalf of the Persons Entitled
to Share in the Estate of Evelyn Wei, Deceased v. ....................270
City of Pittsburgh and University of Pittsburgh; Gene Scott v.......249
City of Pittsburgh Municipal Pension Board; Wanda Rowe v.........256
City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment;
Shaun Cusick v. ..............................................................................209
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh; Lisa Kunst Vavro,
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Douglas Curry ....................302
Clifton, James C. v. Allegheny County; Sto-Rox School District
and ..................................................................................................193
Clinton, Maurice Devaughn; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..271
Colecchi, Kenneth William; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....153
Coleman, Kevin J.; Wahleeah Moore v. ............................................252
(J)Colo-Rectal Associates; Harry Wells, Administrator of the
Estate of Carole Wells, Deceased v.
James J. Baran, M.D. and ............................................................270
Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. Scott Miller;
Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. Nancy A. Stern and ........111
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Regis Bell....................................56
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Marylynn Devaughn Bryant,
a/k/a Marlynn Devaughn ..............................................................285
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Maurice Devaughn Clinton ....271
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth William Colecchi ......153
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Allan Dietz ................181
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bradley Duda ..........................262
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dale Dunson ............................303
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Wontae Fitzgerald ........213
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darrale Markese Gaines,
a/k/a Terrell Lane ..........................................................................145
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanley Joseph Greygor ..........279
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tiffany Cassandra Haines ......266
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Larry Holiday
a/k/a Larry Mitchell ......................................................................237
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darryl Demar Lawrence ........116
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dewayne Mahaffey ..................192
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Lenell Ptomey ..........................201
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Benjamin Alexander Raphael ....52
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Judith V. Reynolds ..................147
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v Terence P. Rice ........................217
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Meghan Marie Roytas ............235
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles J. Sadler ........................39
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas Thorton ......................199
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George D. Walls..........................30
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanford Williams ......................97
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ernest Woodall ........................245
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission;
Paul Joseph Hess and Tracey Lee Hess v.....................................21
Constantino, Abraham and Rose; Washington Mutual Bank v. ......241
Construction General Laborers and Material Handlers Union,
1058; Allegheny County Airport Authority v. ..............................11
Cook, Lacey D., et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc.,
and Trafford Corporation ............................................................290
(C)Corder, Cheryl A. v. Thomas V. D’Amico ......................................75
County of Allegheny v. James H. Bianchi, Jr.; Adolfo J. Marche,
Administrator of the Estate of Carol Marche, Deceased, v.......248
County of Allegheny, West Allegheny School District and
North Fayette Township; Fort Cherry School District &
Borough of McDonald v. John C. and Robin M. Gedman, ........265
(J)County of Allegheny; Frank S. Pucciarelli and
Ellen Pucciarelli v. David J. Graham and ..................................269
Cox, Donald L. v. Gregory A. Grace and Elizabeth Grace ..............212
(J)Crawford, Lawrence; Eboni Franklin v. ........................................80
(J)Crnogorac, Anna and Anthony Crnogorac, her husband v.
Steven Benjamin ..............................................................................46
Crum & Forster, Inc.; United States Fire Insurance Company;
and The North River Insurance Company; Regal Industrial
Corporation v. ..................................................................................93
(J)Cupka Café II; Richard Cupka, Jr., and Stephanie Cupka;
A. Thomas Caruso v. ........................................................................80
Curry, Douglas; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................302
Cusick, Shaun v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of
Adjustment ....................................................................................209
(J)Dague, David R. and Deborah A. Dague, his wife v.
Sherman Spatz, D.M.D. ................................................................151
(C)D’Amico, Thomas V.; Cheryl A. Corder v. ....................................75
D’Andrea, Joseph v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality
of Penn Hills ....................................................................................58
DaSilva, Kimberly C.; Patrick J. Tallon v. ........................................164
(C)Daun-Smith, Arlene v. Steven Smith ............................................122
(C)Davern, Jason Edward v. Kendall Michelle Davern ..................122
Dayton, Richard v. Powerhouse Gym of Pittsburgh, Inc.,
Paul Fajerski, the Fajerski Family Limited Partnership and
Complete Fitness, L.P ....................................................................20
(J)Delligatti, Esther and Raymond Seitz, D.M.D.;
Jamie Ivanac v. ................................................................................82
(J)Delligatti, Esther and Raymond Seitz, D.M.D.;
Kara M. Tolmer v. ............................................................................82
(C)Dellone-Larkin, Cecelia A., M.D. v.
Gregory J. Larkin, M.D.................................................................124
Deloitte Consulting LLC and Deloitte and Touche, LLP;
Allegheny County Sanitary Authority v.......................................133
(J)Demma, Frank P. and Helen J. Demma, his wife, v. Gary F.
Rosenberger ......................................................................................9
(C)Demma, Marion A.; Leslie Raymond v. ........................................77
(C)DePasquale, Joseph D.; Mary Elaine Castillenti v. ......................77
Derzack, Michael and Karen v. Dolores and Ozias Shumba ..........139
2005
Devaughn, Marlynn, a/k/a, Marylynn Devaughn Bryant;
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............................................285
(C)Devincentis, Amy Cooper v. Steven Schulenburg ......................124
(C)D.H. v. R.H. ....................................................................................260
(J)Dietrick, David J., M.D. & Mercy Primary Care, Inc.; Barbara
and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the Estates of Anthony
Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors, Deceased, and Barbara and
Dennis Hawk in their own right v.;
And Barbara and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the
Estates of Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors,
Deceased, and Barbara and Dennis Hawk in their own right v.
Christopher Palombo, M.D. and Mercy Primary Care, Inc. ....269
(J)Dietz, Deborah, Executrix of the Estate of Ronald Dietz,
Deceased, and Deborah Dietz, Individually v. UPMC St.
Margaret Memorial Hospital........................................................227
Dietz, Michael Allan; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..............181
DiPalma, James R., Donald R. Muse, John F. Burns, III and Leo
Chini; Richard A. Toney v. Harmar Township and Harmar
Township Board of Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr., ..........160
(J)Diulus, Julie K. v. Salamon Murciano ............................................46
Dobrosielski, Lori v. Allegheny County Personnel Board ..............105
(J)Domat, Imad, M.D. and Pittsburgh Cardiology Consultants, Inc.;
Raymond Melani and Eileen Melani, his wife, v. ........................10
(J)Donnelley, Sandra K., individually; Peter J. Berner v.
Bizet & Co. Ltd., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,” Walter V. Clark
Associates, Inc., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,” and ......................150
(J)Donohue, Bryan C., M.D.; Elizabeth A. Saniga,
Administratrix of the Estate of Richard R. Saniga v. ..............228
Drab, Bernard & Elsie; Michael L. Vaughn v. ..................................207
Duda, Bradley; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................262
Dunlap, Mark and Patricia Dunlap v. Zoning Hearing Board
for the Township of Ross v. Township of Ross and the
Berkeley Hills Civic Association....................................................71
Dunmeyer, David v. Lowell Taylor ....................................................258
Dunson, Dale; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........................303
(J)Earley, Thomas and Marie; Barbara Welner v...............................48
Ecsedy, Brenda v. Allen Sethman and Anthony Sethman;
Timothy Minkus v. Anthony Sethman and Brenda Ecsedy;......148
Engelberg, Herman D.; Robert Jones and Marcella Jones v.
Prudential Realty Co. and ............................................................117
(J)Enriquez, Joel, M.D., Sharon Richards, C.R.N.A., St. Francis
Hospital of New Castle and St. Francis Health System;
Dawn A. Link and John D. Link v. ................................................47
Equitable Resources, Inc., and Trafford Corporation;
III Rivers Manor v.
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation ................................290
Erie Insurance Exchange v. Dustin M. Garger, Jonathan Miller
and Matthew Miller, Administrators of the Estate of
James C. Miller ..............................................................................143
Erie Insurance Group d/b/a Erie Insurance Company;
Juanita Wilborn Beshir v. ............................................................197
(C)Estate of Joel Pitlock, Brenda Hawkins, Executrix v.
Martha Jane Pitlock ......................................................................123
(J)Fallon, Sheri and James Fallon, individuals v. R.A.H.
Associates, Inc. and Heartland Corporation ..............................227
(J)Family Practice Medical Associates South, Inc., and Kiet A.
Hoang, M.D.; Susan Hogan, Personal Representative of the
Estate of Norberta Hogan v. Matthew Portz, M.D., ..................228
(J)Fastuca, Deborah L. v. John Spieler, Victoria A. Spieler and
Whitney West......................................................................................9
Fedorka, Russell N. and Nancy I. Fedorka; Citizens Bank of
Pennsylvania v. ................................................................................29
(C)Feng, Zhiping; Xinda Wang v.........................................................123
(J)Fiorita, John L., Jr.; Breault & Associates, P.C. v. ........................46
Fisfis-Prewett, Kristie; Steven T. Siwiak v. ......................................220
Fisfis-Prewett, Kristie; Steven T. Siwiak v. ......................................254
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
Fitzgerald, David Wontae; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......213
Ford Motor Company v. Rodney Apple; Karen Apple and
Rodney Apple v. ..............................................................................54
Forest Glen Condominium Association v.
Forest Green Commons Limited Partnership ............................281
Forest Green Commons Limited Partnership;
Forest Glen Condominium Association v. ..................................281
Fornicoia, Charles; Atlantic States Insurance Company v.
Northeast Networking Systems, Inc., Clinton Boyd and ..........119
Fort Cherry School District and Borough of McDonald v.
John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman, County of Allegheny,
West Allegheny School District & North Fayette Township......265
Fragapane, Jonathan Q., Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a Amber L.
Madden; Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. v.
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v. Bryan Nesbitt
and Rosemarie Nesbitt ..................................................................184
(J)Franklin, Eboni v. Lawrence Crawford ..........................................80
Frito-Lay, Inc.; Carl R. Grady and Diana Grady v. ..........................109
Fruend, Donna Bunce, t/d/b/a Allegheny Mobile Home Park;
James Simon and Maureen Simon v. Jane R. Mercer,
Jack Mercer, John J. Ross, Bonnie L. Ross, David L. Ross, ....215
Fusco, Louis, Luigi’s Place, Inc. d/b/a Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a
Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and Kathleen Wargo;
Mid-Continent Insurance Company v. ........................................191
Gaines, Darrale Markese, a/k/a Terrell Lane; Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania v. ..............................................................................145
Garger, Dustin M. Jonathan Miller and Matthew Miller,
Administrators of the Estate of James C. Miller;
Erie Insurance Exchange v...........................................................143
(J)Gazza, Janet v. Marian Phillips ......................................................48
Gedman, John C., Robin M. Gedman, County of Allegheny,
West Allegheny School District & North Fayette Township;
Fort Cherry School District and Borough of McDonald v. ........265
(J)General Motors Corporation; Kathy Machiko v...........................152
Gentile, Anthony F., M.D.; Michele Vogelsberger v. Magee-Womens
Hospital of UPMC Health System and ........................................295
(C)Giovengo, Dale v. Jennifer Giovengo ............................................75
(J)Givner, Brian C.; Karen Larry v. ..................................................151
Glen Arden Developers, Inc. and Houston-Starr Company;
HET Construction Company, Inc. v. ............................................289
Glosser, Daniel S., Glosser Manufacturing Co., M. Glosser & Sons,
Inc., David A. Glosser Foundation, Lesdan Realty, Inc.,
James Saly & Barnes & Saly, LLP; Raymond F. Lackner v. ........51
Gold Pumps, Inc., et al.; Larry E. Slayton v. ......................................36
(C)Gosselin, David; Alison Becker v. ..................................................79
Grace, Gregory A. and Elizabeth Grace; Donald L. Cox v. ............212
Grady, Carl R. and Diana Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc. ..........................109
(J)Graham, Allen H.; Carol & Fred Morabito, her husband v. ......269
(J)Graham, David J. and County of Allegheny;
Frank S. Pucciarelli and Ellen Pucciarelli v. ............................269
Graham, Thomas R., M.D.; Cynthia M. Liberto v. Suburban
General Hospital, Richard E. Anderson, M.D. and ..................241
(J)Grebiner, Patricia Ann v. Ronald E. Williams ............................269
Greenbriar Investment Company, LLC; National City Bank of
Pennsylvania v. Arthur J. and Eileen L. McGovern v. ................91
(J)Greer, Kristen Ann v. C.S. Kim, Soon Ar Kim, and Zegarelli’s
Hair Exsalonce, Inc. ......................................................................227
(J)Grenier, Ivan E.; William Varner, Jr. v. ........................................229
Gresock, John A., and Joanne Haduch, Lisa Kunst Vavro v.
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh ....................................298
Greygor, Stanley Joseph; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........279
Haduch, Joanne, Lisa Kunst Vavro, John A. Gresock, and v.
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh ....................................298
Haines, Tiffany Cassandra; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....266
Hairston, Darnell, Garrick Perkins, in his individual capacity,
and in his official capacity as an employee of Youth Advocate
Program; William Thompson, Jr. v. ..............................................23
2005
(J)Handlovitch, Mildred v. Michael Short, Thomas A. Short
and Joanne Short ..........................................................................228
Harmar Township and Harmar Township Board of Supervisors,
Robert W. Seibert, Jr., James R. DiPalma, Donald R. Muse,
John F. Burns, III and Leo Chini; Richard A. Toney v...............160
Harmar Township Board of Supervisors; and Harmar Township;
Richard and Kimberly Toney v. Robert Siebert, Jr., in his
capacity as a member of the Harmar Township Board of
Supervisors; Robert Siebert, Jr., an individual; ........................225
Harry’s Holiday Park Lounge, Inc. v. Pennsylvania State Police,
Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement ......................................223
(J)Hart, W. Scott v. Edwin W. Booth ..................................................270
(J)Hawk, Barbara and Dennis, Administrators of the Estates of
Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors, Deceased, and
Barbara and Dennis Hawk in their own right v.
Christopher Palombo, M.D. and Mercy Primary Care, Inc.
And Barbara and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the Estates of
Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors, Deceased, and Barbara
and Dennis Hawk in their own right v. David J. Dietrick, M.D.
and Mercy Primary Care, Inc. ........................................................269
(J)Heartland Corporation; Sheri Fallon and James Fallon,
individuals v. R.A.H. Associates, Inc. and ..................................227
(C)Hervert, Frank, Jr. v. Janie Hervert ..............................................78
Herzog, Elaine v. David A. Herzog ....................................................162
Hess, Paul Joseph and Tracey Lee Hess v. Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission ............................................21
HET Construction Company, Inc. v. Glen Arden Developers, Inc.
and Houston-Starr Company ........................................................289
(J)Hoang, Kiet A., M.D.; Susan Hogan, Personal Representative
of the Estate of Norberta Hogan v. Matthew Portz, M.D.,
Family Practice Medical Associates South, Inc., and ................228
(J)Hogan, Susan, Personal Representative of the Estate of
Norberta Hogan v. Matthew Portz, M.D., Family Practice
Medical Associates South, Inc., and Kiet A. Hoang, M.D. ........228
Holiday, Larry a/k/a Larry Mitchell; Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania v. ..............................................................................237
(J)Holtman, Charles J.; Susan B. Tusick v. ........................................10
Houston-Starr Company; HET Construction Company, Inc. v.
Glen Arden Developers, Inc. and ................................................289
Hunt, Stacey Edds v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance
Company ........................................................................................224
(C)Huston, Donna (Wade); Mark T. Wade v. ......................................76
Hutchinson, Sharon t/d/b/a Cheer-On v. Sharon Jackson, Angela
Crissman, Trent Gorrell, Sandy Ruggieri and Amy Stake Corey
Rose Schlemmer and Rosemary L. Vogel v. Bernard L.
Rottschaefer, M.D., Purdue Pharma Co., Purdue Frederick Co.,
P.F. Laboratories, Inc., and Abbott Laboratories, et al. ............205
Infinity Leader Insurance a/k/a Leader Insurance a/k/a Tico
Insurance Company, a/k/a Transport Insurance Company;
Charles R. Johnson v. ......................................................................1
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
In Re: Estate of Emelia Crowley, Deceased ....................................238
In Re: Estate of Edna Humphreys, Deceased ....................................35
In Re: Estate of Paraskevi Miller, a/k/a Freda Miller, deceased....107
In Re: Estate of Margaret S. Taylor ....................................................14
In Re: Estate of Henry A. Vincent ....................................................189
In Re: Anna Petosky, An Alleged Incapacitated Person ......................4
Interactive Cable Associates, Inc.; Bear Run Associates Limited
Partnership v. ..................................................................................41
(J)Ivanac, Jamie v. Esther Delligatti and
Raymond Seitz, D.M.D. ..................................................................82
Jabby Joe, Inc.; Pennsylvania State Police, Bureau of Liquor
Control Enforcement v. ................................................................204
(J)Jack, David I. and Jennifer Jack, husband and wife v.
Jerry Pitkavish ..............................................................................269
(J)Jacko, Mark and Mary Jo Jacko, husband and wife v.
Guy A. Catone and Guy A. Catone, D.M.D., Ltd. ........................47
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
(C)Jackson, Betty Jean and Carlton; Janey Jordan v. ......................76
Jackson, Elmer A., Jr. v. Sheila L. Jackson ......................................221
Jackson, Sharon, Angela Crissman, Trent Gorrell,
Sandy Ruggieri and Amy Stake Corey Rose Schlemmer
and Rosemary L. Vogel v. Bernard L. Rottschaefer, M.D.,
Purdue Pharma Co., Purdue Frederick Co., P.F. Laboratories,
Inc., and Abbott Laboratories, et al.; Sharon Hutchinson
t/d/b/a Cheer-On v. ........................................................................205
(C)Jacob, Terence P. v. Sandra J. Jacob ..............................................75
(J)Jefferson Hills Area Ambulance Association; Elizabeth Michak,
individually and as representative of the Estate of Andrew
Michak v. ........................................................................................152
(J)Jefferson Regional Medical Center, t/d/b/a; Craig Waugaman and
Carol Waugaman, husband and wife v. Ronald L. Boron, M.D.,
Cathy J. Artis, M.D., and South Hills Health System, ................10
Jefferson Woodlands Partners, LP; Michael F. Zavatchen, Jr. v.
RHF Holdings, Inc., and ..............................................................257
Johnson, Charles R. v. Tico Insurance Company, a/k/a Leader
Insurance, a/k/a Transport Insurance Company, a/k/a Infinity
Leader Insurance ..............................................................................1
(C)Johnson, Lisa Apijari v. James R. Johnson....................................78
(J)Jones, Charlotte and Clifford Jones, her husband v.
Charlotte J. Seddon, Raymond W. Seddon and Raymond W.
Seddon, Jr. ........................................................................................47
(J)Jones, Jan B.; Donald Wei, individually and on behalf of the
Persons Entitled to Share in the Estate of Evelyn Wei, Deceased
v. City of Pittsburgh v. ..................................................................270
Jones, Robert and Marcella Jones v. Prudential Realty Co. and
Herman D. Engelberg ..................................................................117
(C)Jordan, Janey v. Betty Jean and Carlton Jackson ........................76
(J)Josowitz, Steven, individually & t/d/b/a Josowitz Roofing;
Kelly Parker v. Josh and Melanie Lenthall, and ..........................81
Kandis, Michael v. Kennywood Entertainment Partners, L.P...........69
Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and Kathleen Wargo; Mid-Continent
Insurance Company v. Louis Fusco, Luigi’s Place, Inc.
d/b/a Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a ..............................................................191
(J)Kauer, Joseph v. Paul Kouknas, Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc.
and Post 456 Veterans of Foreign Wars ......................................150
(J)Kellner, Tiffany v. Harry N. Pasqual, D.M.D. ..............................270
Ken-Med Associates v. Board of Township Supervisors of
Kennedy Township v. Keith Rose ................................................261
Kennywood Entertainment Partners, L.P.; Michael Kandis v...........69
(J)Kern, Katherine F. and Duane E. Kern, Sr., her husband v.
Otis Elevator Company, a corporation ..........................................80
(J)Kim, C.S., Soon Ar Kim, and Zegarelli’s Hair Exsalonce, Inc.;
Kristen Ann Greer v. ....................................................................227
Kormos, Jennifer v. John Urban and Heather Cain ........................275
(J)Kouknas, Paul, Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc. and Post 456
Veterans of Foreign Wars; Joseph Kauer v. ................................150
Kovall, John, Roadrunner Amusements, Inc., Dennis Martin,
Joan Martin, Michelle Martin, MMM 131 Forbes, Inc.,
Michele’s 1020 Washington Pike, Inc., Joan’s Place 1122, Inc.,
Greentree Saloon, Inc., and JAM 1993 Restaurant, Inc.;
3D Amusements, Inc. v. ................................................................278
(C)Kramer, Barbara; Robert Szymanski v. ......................................122
(J)Kramer, Melvin v. Port Authority of Allegheny County ..............47
Kramer, Melvin v. Port Authority of Allegheny County,
Pennsylvania ....................................................................................65
Lackner, Raymond F. v. Daniel S. Glosser, Glosser Manufacturing
Co., M. Glosser & Sons, Inc., David A. Glosser Foundation,
Lesdan Realty, Inc., James Saly & Barnes & Saly, LLP ..............51
(C)Lakhavani, Farhat J. v. Shankar T. Lakhavani ................................7
Lamar West, L.P., v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of
Monroeville and Municipality of Monroeville, Intervenor ........92
Lane, a/k/a Terrell; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Darrale Markese Gaines, ..............................................................145
(C)Larkin, Gregory J., M.D.;
2005
Cecelia A. Dellone-Larkin, M.D. v. ..............................................124
(J)Larry, Karen v. Brian C. Givner ....................................................151
Lawrence, Darryl Demar; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......116
Leader Insurance a/k/a Tico Insurance Company, a/k/a Transport
Insurance Company, a/k/a Infinity Leader Insurance;
Charles R. Johnson v. ......................................................................1
Lenart, Deborah Ann, M.D., and Patricia Bulseco, M.D., P.C.;
Dawn and Michael Mapel v. St. Clair Memorial Hospital,........131
(J)Lenthall, Josh and Melanie, & Steven Josowitz, individually
& t/d/b/a Josowitz Roofing; Kelly Parker v. ................................81
Liberto, Cynthia M. v. Suburban General Hospital, Richard E.
Anderson, M.D. and Thomas R. Graham, M.D. ........................241
(J)Link, Dawn A. and John D. Link v. Joel Enriquez, M.D.,
Sharon Richards, C.R.N.A., St. Francis Hospital of New Castle
and St. Francis Health System ......................................................47
Liss, George, et al.; Mistick PBT, et al. v...........................................186
(C)Little, Felicia v. Frank Little............................................................77
(J)Lolley, David M., M.D.; Cardiac Surgeons, Inc.; Allegheny Valley
Hospital; and Allegheny Valley Medical Imaging and Radiology
Oncologists, Inc., t/d/b/a A V Medical Imaging; and Allegheny
Valley Medical Imaging and Radiation Oncology, Inc., t/d/b/a
A V Medical Imaging; Joseph L. Babula and Marian Babula,
his wife v. ............................................................................................8
Longwill, Craig; BR Associates v. The Priority Mortgage
Group v. ..........................................................................................133
Loughren, Michael C. v. United Services Automobile
Association......................................................................................233
Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and Kathleen
Wargo; Mid-Continent Insurance Company v. Louis Fusco,
Luigi’s Place, Inc. d/b/a ................................................................191
Luigi’s Place, Inc. d/b/a Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a Katy’s Bar &
Lounge, Inc. and Kathleen Wargo; Mid-Continent Insurance
Company v. Louis Fusco, ..............................................................191
(J)Machiko, Kathy v. General Motors Corporation..........................152
(J)Machtiger, Harriet Gordon v. P & W Foreign Car Service Inc.,
Saab-Scania of America, Inc. and Chubb Group of Insurance
Companies ..........................................................................................9
Madden, Amber L.; Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc.
v. Jonathan Q. Fragapane, Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v. Bryan Nesbitt
and Rosemarie Nesbitt ..................................................................184
(J)Magee Womens Hospital of UPMC Health System and
Anthony F. Gentile, M.D.; Michele Vogelsberger v. ....................82
Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC Health System and
Anthony F. Gentile, M.D.; Michele Vogelsberger v. ..................295
Mahaffey, Dewayne; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ................192
Mapel, Dawn and Michael v. St. Clair Memorial Hospital,
Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D., and Patricia Bulseco,
M.D., P.C. ........................................................................................131
Marche, Adolfo J., Administrator of the Estate of Carol Marche,
Deceased, v. County of Allegheny v. James H. Bianchi, Jr ......248
(J)Marino, Michelle A. and Brad Marino, her husband v.
R & J Grocery, LLC ......................................................................151
(J)Marion, Donald, M.D.; Tracy H. Webber and Nichole Webber,
his wife v. Presbyterian University Hospital t/d/b/a
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center and ............................230
Marlin, Dean v. Cecilia Marlin ............................................................83
Martini, Anthony and Josephine Martini, His Wife;
John E. Murphy, Assignee of Ruth G. Murphy v. ........................18
Martino, Gail A. v. Patrick V. Martino, Jr. ..........................................87
Maxim, Patrick v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim)....................251
(J)May Department Stores Company, d/b/a Kaufmanns, Charles A.
Kramer, Administrator of the Estate of Louis Kramer, Jr.,
Deceased, John Doe 1, John Doe 2, Jane Doe 1, Jane Doe 2,
and Patrick Hillyard; Rakyia F. Berry v. ........................................8
(J)Mazzie, Daniel v. James Bianco and Jean Anne Bianco,
his wife, and Geno Bianco and Carla Bianco..............................152
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
McGhee, John, per Pa. Equipment Rental Co. and Turtle Creek
Industrial Park, L.P. v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough
of Turtle Creek and Turtle Creek Borough ..................................42
McGovern, Arthur J. and Eileen L. v. Greenbriar Investment
Company, LLC; National City Bank of Pennsylvania v. ..............91
McKenna, Aidan J. v. OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts
Technologies, Inc., Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v.
Aidan J. McKenna ........................................................................286
(J)Melani, Raymond and Eileen Melani, his wife, v. Imad Domat,
M.D. and Pittsburgh Cardiology Consultants, Inc. ......................10
Mercer, Jane R., Jack Mercer, John J. Ross, Bonnie L. Ross,
David L. Ross, Donna Bunce Fruend, t/d/b/a Allegheny
Mobile Home Park; James Simon and Maureen Simon v. ........215
(J)Michak, Elizabeth, individually and as representative of the
Estate of Andrew Michak v. Jefferson Hills Area Ambulance
Association......................................................................................152
Mid-Continent Insurance Company v. Louis Fusco, Luigi’s Place,
Inc. d/b/a Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and
Kathleen Wargo..............................................................................191
(J)Mielecki, Mary Lou and Anthony G. Mielecki, wife and
husband v. Jayne Reilly ................................................................228
Miller, Estate of James C.; Erie Insurance Exchange v.
Dustin M. Garger, Jonathan Miller and Matthew Miller,
Administrators of the ....................................................................143
Miller, Scott; Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. Nancy A. Stern
and Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. ..........................111
Minkus, Timothy v. Anthony Sethman and Brenda Ecsedy;
Brenda Ecsedy v. Allen Sethman and Anthony Sethman ..........148
Mistick PBT, et al. v. George Liss, et al.............................................186
Mitchell, Gregory P.; Bank One Delaware, N.A. v. ..........................125
Mitchell, Larry; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Larry Holiday a/k/a ......................................................................237
Moore, Christopher D.; American International Resources, Inc. v.
Russell E. Swanson v. ....................................................................115
Moore, Wahleeah v. Kevin J. Coleman ..............................................252
(J)Morabito, Carol & Fred, her husband v. Allen H. Graham ........269
(J)Morante, Dolores; Sarah Wible v...................................................230
Morganti, Frank & Cynthia Jo Morganti v. Ace Tire & Parts, Inc.,
Preferred Car & Truck, Inc., John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard
J. Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire Company, Tarquinio Towing,
John Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio Towing and Scott A. Hoover ....102
(J)Morrissey, Dean G., Jr. and Jacqueline A. Morrissey,
Individually and as Guardians of Dean J. Morrissey, an
incapacitated person v. State Auto Insurance ............................228
Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. v. Jonathan Q.
Fragapane, Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a Amber L. Madden
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v. Bryan Nesbitt
and Rosemarie Nesbitt ..................................................................184
(C)Mulder, Jeremy Daniel v. Kimberly Mulder ................................78
Mullen, Michael, In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief..........................272
Municipality of Monroeville, Intervenor; Lamar West, L.P., v.
Zoning Hearing Bd. of the Municipality of Monroeville and......92
(J)Murciano, Salamon; Julie K. Diulus v. ..........................................46
Murphy, John E., Assignee of Ruth G. Murphy v. Anthony Martini
and Josephine Martini, His Wife ..................................................18
(C)Murphy, Lori v. Randy Murphy ......................................................76
Muse, Donald R., John F. Burns, III and Leo Chini; Richard A.
Toney v. Harmar Township and Harmar Township Board of
Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr., James R. DiPalma, ..........160
Myers, Eugene N., M.D., and UPMC Presbyterian and UPMC
Eye and Ear Hospital; Daniel W. Anderson and Shelby J.
Anderson, his wife v. ....................................................................215
(J)National Amusements, Inc., t/d/b/a Showcase Cinemas West;
Joylene A. Chiri v...........................................................................150
National City Bank of Pennsylvania v. Arthur J. and Eileen L.
McGovern v. Greenbriar Investment Company, LLC ..................91
National City Bank, Pennsylvania v. James O.H. Williams and
2005
Jacqueline Williams v. Jacqueline Williams ..............................255
National Union Fire Ins. Co. and AIG Aviation, Inc. v.
Airburst Helicopters, Inc. et al. ....................................................70
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v.
Sharon Regional Health System; Marie Anne and
Joseph Viola v. Nichols & Associates, Inc. ....................................59
Nesbitt, Rosemarie; Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v.
Bryan Nesbitt and
Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. v. Jonathan Q.
Fragapane, Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a Amber L. Madden ......184
Nichols & Associates, Inc., Marie Anne and Joseph Viola v.;
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v.
Sharon Regional Health System; ..................................................59
Niren, Neil M., M.D., and James A. Trombetta; Trombetta, James,
Tara Trombetta and Julie Trombetta Gray v. Raymond James
Financial Services, Inc., Raymond James & Associates, Inc.,
Peter Gialames, and Edward Lewis v. ........................................167
Northeast Networking Systems, Inc., Clinton Boyd and
Charles Fornicoia; Atlantic States Insurance Company v. ........119
North Fayette Township; Fort Cherry School District and
Borough of McDonald v. John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman,
County of Allegheny, West Allegheny School District and........265
(J)Novak, Janice and Jason Novak, her husband v. Shannon Smith,
a/k/a Sharon Smith ........................................................................152
(J)Null, Betty Jean v. Diane Sober, M.D. and Women’s Health
Group ..............................................................................................152
Nunley, Sharon and Alonzo Nunley v. Shadyside Hospital................67
(J)Okobi, Anthony N., M.D., Anthony N. Okobi, M.D., P.C.,
Kalyanmay Ghoshhajra, M.D. and Radiological Imaging
Associates, Inc.; Donn S. Boggs, Sr. and Marion Boggs,
husband and wife v. ........................................................................46
(J)O’Konski, Edward D. v. Port Authority of Allegheny County ......81
(J)Ondechek, Jane; Michael Peterman and Sandra L. Peterman,
his wife, v. ........................................................................................81
OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts Technologies, Inc.,
Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v. Aidan J. McKenna;
Aidan J. McKenna v. ....................................................................286
Osiris Enterprises and Antonio F. Moscatiello v. Borough of
Whitehall, et al. ................................................................................25
(J)Otis Elevator Company, a corporation; Katherine F. Kern
and Duane E. Kern, Sr., her husband v. ........................................80
(C)Owens, Johnnie Mae v. Vernon Lee Owens ................................123
(J)P & W Foreign Car Service Inc., Saab-Scania of America, Inc.
and Chubb Group of Insurance Companies; Harriet Gordon
Machtiger v. ........................................................................................9
(J)Palombo, Christopher, M.D. and Mercy Primary Care, Inc.;
Barbara and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the Estates of
Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors, Deceased, and
Barbara and Dennis Hawk in their own right v.
And Barbara and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the
Estates of Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors,
Deceased, and Barbara and Dennis Hawk in their own right v.
David J. Dietrick, M.D. & Mercy Primary Care, Inc. ..................269
(J)Pappert, Marshall L. v. Donald Ramsey, Travelers Property
Casualty and The Travelers Indemnity Co. ..................................81
(J)Parker, Kelly v. Josh and Melanie Lenthall, & Steven Josowitz,
individually & t/d/b/a Josowitz Roofing ........................................81
(J)Pasqual, Harry N., D.M.D.; Tiffany Kellner v. ............................270
Patterson, Cavan and Samuel Price, II; Thomas L. Patterson v.
Robert Bartolomucci, Rona Livingston Bartolomucci,
his wife, and Joseph L. Feucht v. ..................................................67
Patterson, Thomas L. v. Robert Bartolomucci, Rona Livingston
Bartolomucci, his wife, and Joseph L. Feucht v.
Cavan Patterson and Samuel Price, II ..........................................67
(C)Peebles, Beth A. v. James M. Peebles ..............................................7
Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board; Avonworth School
District v. ........................................................................................37
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Pennsylvania State Police, Bureau of Liquor Control
Enforcement; Harry’s Holiday Park Lounge, Inc. v. ................223
Pennsylvania State Police, Bureau of Liquor Control
Enforcement v. Jabby Joe, Inc. ....................................................204
Perer, Alan H. and Swensen & Perer; Eugene C. Buchleitner v. ....242
Permenter, Natalie v. Jennifer Stiscak ................................................31
(C)Perrone, Lisa v. Wayne Perrone....................................................260
(J)Peterman, Michael and Sandra L. Peterman, his wife, v.
Jane Ondechek ................................................................................81
(J)Phillips, Marian; Janet Gazza v. ......................................................48
Pierce, Joni (formerly Joni Maxim); Patrick Maxim v. ..................251
(J)Pitkavish, Jerry; David I. Jack and Jennifer Jack, husband
and wife v. ......................................................................................269
(C)Pitlock, Martha Jane; Estate of Joel Pitlock, Brenda Hawkins,
Executrix v. ....................................................................................123
(J)Pittsburgh Cardiology Consultants, Inc.; Raymond Melani
and Eileen Melani, his wife, v. Imad Domat, M.D. and ..............10
(J)Pittsburgh Glass Center, Inc.; Catherine Pusateri and Vincent
Pusateri, wife and husband v. ........................................................10
Pogel, Frank and Elaine Pogel, David and Beatrice Carpenter,
on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated v.
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company ..................282
(J)Polas, Thomas v. All Crane Rental Corporation ............................82
(J)Port Authority of Allegheny County; Suzanne M. Burtt v. ........150
(J)Port Authority of Allegheny County;
Carmen Charmello, Jr. v. ..............................................................227
(J)Port Authority of Allegheny County; Melvin Kramer v. ..............47
Port Authority of Allegheny County, Pennsylvania;
Melvin Kramer v. ............................................................................65
(J)Port Authority of Allegheny County; Edward D. O’Konski v. ......81
(J)Portz, Matthew, M.D., Family Practice Medical Associates
South, Inc., and Kiet A. Hoang, M.D.; Susan Hogan, Personal
Representative of the Estate of Norberta Hogan v. ..................228
(J)Post 456 Veterans of Foreign Wars; Joseph Kauer v.
Paul Kouknas, Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc. and ..................150
Powerhouse Gym of Pittsburgh, Inc., Paul Fajerski, the Fajerski
Family Limited Partnership and Complete Fitness, L.P;
Richard Dayton v. ............................................................................20
(J)Presbyterian University Hospital t/d/b/a University of
Pittsburgh Medical Center and Donald Marion, M.D.;
Tracy H. Webber and Nichole Webber, his wife v. ....................230
Priority Mortgage Group v. Craig Longwill; BR Associates v. ......133
Progressive Northern Insurance Company v. Universal
Underwriters Insurance Company, Universal Underwriters
Group and Brent McNeely............................................................243
Prudential Realty Co. and Herman D. Engelberg; Robert Jones
and Marcella Jones v. ....................................................................117
Ptomey, Lenell; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ........................201
(J)Pucciarelli, Frank S. and Ellen Pucciarelli v.
David J. Graham and County of Allegheny ................................269
(J)Pusateri, Catherine and Vincent Pusateri, wife and husband v.
The Pittsburgh Glass Center, Inc...................................................10
Quaker Valley School District; The Buncher Company v. ................44
(J)R & J Grocery, LLC; Michelle A. Marino and Brad Marino,
her husband v. ................................................................................151
(J)R.A.H. Associates, Inc. and Heartland Corporation;
Sheri Fallon and James Fallon, individuals v. ............................227
(J)Ramakrishna, Nagamalli, M.D.; Richard Stoyer and
Susan Stoyer, husband and wife v. St. Francis Health System,
St. Francis Medical Center and....................................................151
(J)Ramsey, Donald, Travelers Property Casualty and
The Travelers Indemnity Co.; Marshall L. Pappert v. ................81
Raphael, Benjamin Alexander;
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ................................................52
Ravin, Inc. v. Canova Electrical Contracting, Inc. ..........................144
Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., Raymond James &
Associates, Inc., Peter Gialames, and Edward Lewis v.
2005
Neil M. Niren, M.D., and James A. Trombetta; James
Trombetta, Tara Trombetta and Julie Trombetta Gray v. ........167
(C)Raymond, Leslie v. Marion A. Demma ..........................................77
Regal Industrial Corporation v. Crum & Forster, Inc.;
United States Fire Insurance Company; and The North River
Insurance Company ........................................................................93
Rehabilitation Management Systems, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine
Services; West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc.
t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services and Tracee L. Kallet;
Amy W. Budner and Martin A. Budner v. Allegheny General
Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services; ..............................173
(J)Reilly, Jayne; Mary Lou Mielecki and Anthony G. Mielecki,
wife and husband v. ......................................................................228
Retirement Board of Allegheny County; Janice C. Vinci v. ............211
Reynolds, Judith V.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ................147
RHF Holdings, Inc., and Jefferson Woodlands Partners, LP; Michael
F. Zavatchen, Jr. v...........................................................................257
Rice, Terence P.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v ......................217
Robinson Township Library Association v. Robinson Township,
Board of Commissioners of Robinson Township,
and Richard Charnovich ..............................................................218
Robinson Township, Board of Commissioners of Robinson
Township, and Richard Charnovich; Robinson Township
Library Association v.....................................................................218
Rose, Keith; Ken-Med Associates v. Board of Township
Supervisors of Kennedy Township v. ..........................................261
(J)Roseman, Sharon R., M.D.; Ann Weir v. UPMC Community
Medicine, Inc., Valley Medical Facilities, Inc. &........................230
(J)Rosenberger, Gary F.; Frank P. Demma and Helen J. Demma,
his wife, v. ..........................................................................................9
Ross, John J., Bonnie L. Ross, David L. Ross, Donna Bunce
Fruend, t/d/b/a Allegheny Mobile Home Park; James Simon
and Maureen Simon v. Jane R. Mercer, Jack Mercer, ..............215
Rowe, Wanda v. City of Pittsburgh Municipal Pension Board........256
(C)Roye, Orpheus; Deanna Branch v.................................................122
Roytas, Meghan Marie; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ..........235
(J)Ruff, Michele and Kristin Ruff, a minor v. Anna Rae
Schreckengost ..................................................................................48
Sadler, Charles J.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................39
(J)Saniga, Elizabeth A., Administratrix of the Estate of
Richard R. Saniga v. Bryan C. Donohue, M.D. ..........................228
(J)Schreckengost, Anna Rae; Michele Ruff and Kristin Ruff,
a minor v. ..........................................................................................48
(C)Schulenburg, Steven; Amy Cooper Devincentis v.......................124
Scott, Gene v. City of Pittsburgh and University of Pittsburgh......249
(J)Seddon, Charlotte J., Raymond W. Seddon and Raymond W.
Seddon, Jr.; Charlotte Jones and Clifford Jones, her
husband v. ........................................................................................47
Segway Internet Technologies, Inc.;
TRC Parkway Center, LLC v...........................................................49
Seibert, Robert W., Jr., James R. DiPalma, Donald R. Muse,
John F. Burns, III and Leo Chini; Richard A. Toney v.
Harmar Township and Harmar Township
Board of Supervisors, ..................................................................160
(J)Seitz, Raymond, D.M.D.; Jamie Ivanac v.
Esther Delligatti and ......................................................................82
Sethman, Anthony and Brenda Ecsedy; Timothy Minkus v.;
Brenda Ecsedy v. Allen Sethman and Anthony Sethman ..........148
Shadyside Hospital; Sharon Nunley and Alonzo Nunley v. ..............67
Sharon Regional Health System, National Union Fire
Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v.; Marie Anne & Joseph Viola v.
Nichols & Associates, Inc. ..............................................................59
Shedlock, Donna v. UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health
System and University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc.,
Paul Dascani, M.D., Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands
Hospital; Carol Waldschmidt in her own right and as
Administratrix of the Estate of Robert Waldschmidt,
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
deceased, v. Aetna US Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care
Center, Allegheny General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny
Health System, Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar ..............63
(J)Short, Michael, Thomas A. Short and Joanne Short;
Mildred Handlovitch v. ................................................................228
(J)Showcase Cinemas West; Joylene A. Chiri v.
National Amusements, Inc., t/d/b/a ............................................150
Shumba, Dolores and Ozia; Michael and Karen Derzack v. ..........139
Sieber, Michele v. Glenn Sieber ..........................................................72
Siebert, Robert, Jr., in his capacity as a member of the Harmar
Township Board of Supervisors; Robert Siebert, Jr., an
individual; Harmar Township Board of Supervisors; and
Harmar Township; Richard and Kimberly Toney v. ................225
Simon, James and Maureen Simon v. Jane R. Mercer,
Jack Mercer, John J. Ross, Bonnie L. Ross, David L. Ross,
Donna Bunce Fruend, t/d/b/a Allegheny Mobile Home
Park ................................................................................................215
Siwiak, Steven T. v. Kristie Fisfis-Prewett........................................220
Siwiak, Steven T. v. Kristie Fisfis-Prewett........................................254
Slayton, Larry E. v. Gold Pumps, Inc., et al. ......................................36
(C)Smith, Marguerite Grier v. Stewart Smith ....................................76
(J)Smith, Shannon a/k/a Sharon Smith; Janice Novak and
Jason Novak, her husband v. ........................................................152
(C)Smith, Steven; Arlene Daun-Smith v. ..........................................122
(J)Sober, Diane, M.D. and Women’s Health Group;
Betty Jean Null v. ..........................................................................152
(J)Sousa, Caryn G. and James P. Sousa, her husband v.
Rebecca Amy Stage ......................................................................229
(J)South Hills Health System, t/d/b/a Jefferson Regional Medical
Center; Craig and Carol Waugaman, husband and wife v.
Ronald L. Boron, M.D., Cathy J. Artis, M.D., and ......................10
(J)Spatz, Sherman, D.M.D.; David R. Dague and
Deborah A. Dague, his wife v. ......................................................151
(J)Spieler, John, Victoria A. Spieler and Whitney West; Deborah L.
Fastuca v. ............................................................................................9
Sports Medicine Services; Rehabilitation Management Systems,
Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services; West Penn Allegheny
Health System, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services and
Tracee L. Kallet; Amy W. Budner and Martin A. Budner v.
Allegheny General Hospital, t/d/b/a............................................173
(J)St. Clair Memorial Hospital, Patricia J. Bulesco, M.D. and
Patricia J. Bulesco, M.D., P.C.; Ravikant and Pooja Tripathi,
Parents and Administrators of the Estate of Rhea Tripathi,
Deceased v. ......................................................................................48
St. Clair Memorial Hospital, Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D., and
Patricia Bulseco, M.D., P.C.; Dawn and Michael Mapel v.........131
(J)St. Francis Hospital of New Castle and St. Francis Health
System; Dawn A. Link & John D. Link v. Joel Enriquez, M.D.,
Sharon Richards, C.R.N.A., ............................................................47
(J)St. Francis Health System, St. Francis Medical Center and
Nagamalli Ramakrishna, M.D.; Richard Stoyer and
Susan Stoyer, husband and wife v. ..............................................151
(J)Stage, Rebecca Amy; Caryn G. Sousa and James P. Sousa,
her husband v. ................................................................................229
Staley, Gary and Rose Staley v. Gary J. Staley and Kelly Staley ....84
Staley, Gary J. and Kelly Staley; Gary Staley and Rose Staley v. ....84
(J)State Auto Insurance; Dean G. Morrissey, Jr. and
Jacqueline A. Morrissey, Individually and as Guardians of
Dean J. Morrissey, an incapacitated person v. ..........................228
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company;
Frank and Elaine Pogel and David and Beatrice Carpenter,
on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated v. ....282
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company;
Stacey Edds Hunt v. ......................................................................224
Stern, Nancy A. and Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v.
Scott Miller; Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. ....................111
Stiscak, Jennifer; Natalie Permenter v. ..............................................31
2005
Sto-Rox School District and James C. Clifton v.
Allegheny County ..........................................................................193
(J)Stoyer, Richard and Susan Stoyer, husband and wife v.
St. Francis Health System, St. Francis Medical Center and
Nagamalli Ramakrishna, M.D. ....................................................151
Suburban General Hospital, Richard E. Anderson, M.D. and
Thomas R. Graham, M.D.; Cynthia M. Liberto v. ......................241
(J)Suffoletta, Henry; Pamela Ambrose v...............................................8
(J)Suttner, Linda A. v. Centers for Rehab Services ........................229
Swanson, Russell E. v. Christopher D. Moore; American
International Resources, Inc. v. ..................................................115
Swartz, John H., Jr. and Richard J. Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire
Company, Tarquinio Towing, John Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio
Towing and Scott A. Hoover; Frank Morganti and
Cynthia Jo Morganti v. Ace Tire & Parts, Inc., Preferred Car
& Truck, Inc., ................................................................................102
Swensen & Perer; Eugene C. Buchleitner v. Alan H. Perer and ....242
(C)Szymanski, Robert v. Barbara Kramer ........................................122
Tallon, Patrick J. v. Kimberly C. DaSilva..........................................164
Tarquinio Towing, John Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio Towing and
Scott A. Hoover; Frank Morganti and Cynthia Jo Morganti v.
Ace Tire & Parts, Inc., Preferred Car & Truck, Inc.,
John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard J. Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire
Company, ........................................................................................102
Taylor, Lowell; David Dunmeyer v. ..................................................258
Thompson, William, Jr. v. Darnell Hairston, Garrick Perkins,
in his individual capacity, and in his official capacity as an
employee of Youth Advocate Program ..........................................23
Thorpe, John R., Jr. and Martin Cloonan; Joseph Vinciguerra v.;
Martin Cloonan v. 3-D Trucking, Inc. and John Thorpe, Jr. ....231
Thorton, Thomas; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................199
Tico Insurance Company, a/k/a Leader Insurance, a/k/a Transport
Insurance Company, a/k/a Infinity Leader Insurance;
Charles R. Johnson v. ........................................................................1
(J)Tolmer, Kara M. v. Esther Delligatti and
Raymond Seitz, D.M.D. ..................................................................82
Toney, Richard A. v. Harmar Township and Harmar Township
Board of Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr., James R.
DiPalma, Donald R. Muse, John F. Burns, III and
Leo Chini ........................................................................................160
Toney, Richard and Kimberly v. Robert Siebert, Jr., in his
capacity as a member of the Harmar Township Board of
Supervisors; Robert Siebert, Jr., an individual; Harmar
Township Board of Supervisors; and Harmar Township ..........225
Township of Ross and the Berkeley Hills Civic Association;
Mark Dunlap and Patricia Dunlap v. Zoning Hearing Board
for the Township of Ross v. ............................................................71
Trafford Corporation; Lacey D. Cook, et al. v.
Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation Corporation, et al. v.
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc.,
and Trafford Corporation ............................................................290
Transport Insurance Company, a/k/a Infinity Leader Insurance,
Leader Insurance a/k/a Tico Insurance Company;
Charles R. Johnson v. ......................................................................1
(J)Trant, Barbara v. AON Corp., AON Service Corp.,
AON Group, Inc., & AON Consulting Worldwide, Inc. ..............229
(J)Travelers Property Casualty & The Travelers Indemnity Co.;
Marshall L. Pappert v. Donald Ramsey, ........................................81
TRC Parkway Center, LLC v.
Segway Internet Technologies, Inc. ..............................................49
(J)Tripathi, Ravikant and Pooja, Parents and Administrators
of the Estate of Rhea Tripathi, Deceased v. St. Clair
Memorial Hospital, Patricia J. Bulesco, M.D. and Patricia J.
Bulesco, M.D., P.C. ..........................................................................48
Trombetta, James, Tara Trombetta and Julie Trombetta Gray v.
Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., Raymond James &
Associates, Inc., Peter Gialames, and Edward Lewis v.
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Neil M. Niren, M.D., and James A. Trombetta ..........................167
(J)Tusick, Susan B. v. Charles J. Holtman ..........................................10
United Services Automobile Association; Michael C.
Loughren v. ....................................................................................233
United States Fire Insurance Company; and The North River
Insurance Company; Regal Industrial Corporation v.
Crum & Forster, Inc.; ......................................................................93
Universal Underwriters Insurance Company, Universal
Underwriters Group and Brent McNeely; Progressive
Northern Insurance Company v. ..................................................243
University of Pittsburgh; Gene Scott v. City of Pittsburgh and......249
(J)University of Pittsburgh Medical Center/t/d/b/a and
Donald Marion, M.D.; Tracy H. Webber and Nichole Webber,
his wife v. Presbyterian University Hospital..............................230
(J)UPMC Community Medicine, Inc., Valley Medical Facilities, Inc.
& Sharon R. Roseman, M.D.; Ann Weir v. ..................................230
(J)UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System and
University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc.; Richard Anderson
and Marcie Anderson, his wife v. ....................................................8
UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System and University
of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani, M.D., Medical
Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital, Donna Shedlock v.;
Carol Waldschmidt in her own right and as Administratrix
of the Estate of Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v. Aetna US
Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center, Allegheny
General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health System,
Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar ........................................63
UPMC Presbyterian and UPMC Eye and Ear Hospital;
Daniel W. Anderson and Shelby J. Anderson, his wife v.
Eugene N. Myers, M.D., and ........................................................215
(J)UPMC St. Margaret Memorial Hospital; Deborah Dietz,
Executrix of the Estate of Ronald Dietz, Deceased, and
Deborah Dietz, Individually v. ....................................................227
Urban, John and Heather Cain; Jennifer Kormos v. ......................275
(J)Valley Medical Facilities, Inc. & Sharon R. Roseman, M.D.;
Ann Weir v. UPMC Community Medicine, Inc., ........................230
(J)Varner, William, Jr. v. Ivan E. Grenier ........................................229
Vaughn, Michael L. v. Bernard & Elsie Drab....................................207
Vavro, Lisa Kunst, John A. Gresock, and Joanne Haduch v.
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh ....................................298
Vincent, Henry A., In Re: Estate of ..................................................189
Vinci, Janice C. v. Retirement Board of Allegheny County ............211
Vinciguerra, Joseph v. John R. Thorpe, Jr. and Martin Cloonan;
Martin Cloonan v. 3-D Trucking, Inc. and John Thorpe, Jr. ....231
Viola, Marie Anne and Joseph v. Nichols & Associates, Inc.;
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v.
Sharon Regional Health System; ..................................................59
(J)Vogelsberger, Michele v. Magee Womens Hospital of
UPMC Health System and Anthony F. Gentile, M.D. ..................82
Vogelsberger, Michele v. Magee-Womens Hospital of
UPMC Health System and Anthony F. Gentile, M.D. ................295
(C)Wade, Mark T. v. Donna (Wade) Huston ........................................76
Waldschmidt, Carol in her own right and as Administratrix
of the Estate of Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v. Aetna US
Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center, Allegheny
General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health System,
Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar; Donna Shedlock v.
UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System and
University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani, M.D.,
Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital; ..........................63
(J)Walker, James P.; Sharon C. Carolla v...........................................150
Walls, George D.; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................30
(C)Wang, Xinda v. Zhiping Feng ........................................................123
Wargo, Kathleen; Mid-Continent Insurance Company v.
Louis Fusco, Luigi’s Place, Inc. d/b/a Lou Magoo’s,
a/k/a Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and ..........................................191
Washington Mutual Bank v. Abraham and Rose Constantino ........241
2005
(J)Waugaman, Craig and Carol Waugaman, husband and wife v.
Ronald L. Boron, M.D., Cathy J. Artis, M.D., and South Hills
Health System, t/d/b/a Jefferson Regional Medical Center ......10
(J)Webber, Tracy H. and Nichole Webber, his wife v.
Presbyterian University Hospital t/d/b/a University of
Pittsburgh Medical Center and Donald Marion, M.D. ..............230
(J)Wei, Donald, individually and on behalf of the Persons Entitled
to Share in the Estate of Evelyn Wei, Deceased v.
City of Pittsburgh v. Jan B. Jones ................................................270
(J)Weir, Ann v. UPMC Community Medicine, Inc., Valley Medical
Facilities, Inc. & Sharon R. Roseman, M.D. ..............................230
(J)Wells, Harry, Administrator of the Estate of Carole Wells,
Deceased v. James J. Baran, M.D. and
Colo-Rectal Associates ..................................................................270
(J)Welner, Barbara v. Thomas and Marie Earley ..............................48
(C)Werner, Anthony Mark v. Cynthia Louise Werner ......................200
Werner, Eric J. and Melanie v. Zoning Hearing Board of the
Borough of Sewickley....................................................................271
West Allegheny School District and North Fayette Township;
Fort Cherry School District and Borough of McDonald v.
John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman, County of Allegheny, ....265
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine
Services and Tracee L. Kallet; Amy W. Budner and Martin A.
Budner v. Allegheny General Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine
Services; Rehabilitation Management Systems, Inc.
t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services;................................................173
(J)Western Pennsylvania Hospital and West Penn Allegheny
Health System, Inc.; Renee Blucas v. ............................................46
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. Board of Public Education of the
School District of Pittsburgh v.
WTW Architects, Inc. and Able-Hess Associates, Inc...............299
Whitfield, Tammy v. Scott Whitfield..................................................179
(J)Wible, Sarah v. Dolores Morante ..................................................230
Williams, James O.H. and Jacqueline Williams v. Jacqueline
Williams; National City Bank, Pennsylvania v. ..........................255
(J)Williams, Ronald E.; Patricia Ann Grebiner v. ............................269
Williams, Stanford; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ....................97
(J)Women’s Health Group; Betty Jean Null v. Diane Sober, M.D.....152
Woodall, Ernest; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. ......................245
Woodward, Mark and Paul Campbell v. Aidan J. McKenna;
Aidan J. McKenna v. OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts
Technologies, Inc., ........................................................................286
Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. Nancy A. Stern and
Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. Scott Miller ............111
WTW Architects, Inc. and Able-Hess Associates, Inc.;
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. Board of Public Education of the
School District of Pittsburgh v. ....................................................299
(J)Youngstown Kenworth, Inc.; David Barrett v. ..............................80
Zavatchen, Michael F., Jr. v. RHF Holdings, Inc., and Jefferson
Woodlands Partners, LP................................................................257
(J)Zegarelli’s Hair Exsalonce, Inc.; Kristen Ann Greer v.
C.S. Kim, Soon Ar Kim, and ........................................................227
Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Sewickley; Eric J. and
Melanie Werner v. ..........................................................................271
Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of Turtle Creek and Turtle
Creek Borough; John McGhee, per Pa. Equipment Rental Co.
and Turtle Creek Industrial Park, L.P. v. ......................................42
Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of Monroeville
and Municipality of Monroeville, Intervenor;
Lamar West, L.P., v. ........................................................................92
Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of Penn Hills;
Joseph D’Andrea v. ..........................................................................58
Zoning Hearing Board for the Township of Ross v. Township of
Ross and the Berkeley Hills Civic Association; Mark Dunlap
and Patricia Dunlap v. ....................................................................71
(J)Zoological Society of Pittsburgh, a PA Corp.; James Brose,
a Minor, by Anne Brose, his Guardian v. ......................................80
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
2005
C U M U L AT I V E I N D E X - V O L U M E 1 5 3 - 2 0 0 5
This listing is provided according to subject matter for research purposes.
Under this title is printed a list of all cases reported in the Pittsburgh Legal Journal,
a Supplement to the Lawyers Journal (Volume No. 153 - 2005). Subscribers can find
in this index immediate reference to any case reported in the PITTSBURGH LEGAL
JOURNAL. For identification purposes: (C)Capsule Summaries; and (J)Jury Verdicts.
16 P.S. §4701(J)(1)—
Janice C. Vinci v. Retirement Board of Allegheny County ............211
36 P.S. §1961—
John E. Murphy, Assignee of Ruth G. Murphy v.
Anthony Martini and Josephine Martini, His Wife......................18
75 Pa.C.S.A. §3802(a)(2)—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Bradley Duda ..........................262
402A Strict Liability—
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc., and
Trafford Corporation ....................................................................290
Abandonment—
Lamar West, L.P., v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality
of Monroeville and Municipality of Monroeville,
Intervenor ........................................................................................92
Abutting Landowners—
John E. Murphy, Assignee of Ruth G. Murphy v. Anthony Martini
and Josephine Martini, His Wife ..................................................18
Accessory Use—
Joseph D’Andrea v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of
Penn Hills ........................................................................................58
Admissibility of Evidence—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Alimony Modification—
(C)Marguerite Grier Smith v. Stewart Smith......................................76
(C)Jeannine G. Auld v. Howard S. Auld, Sr. ....................................200
Allegheny County Personnel Board Hearing—
Lori Dobrosielski v. Allegheny County Personnel Board ................105
Amended Pleadings—
American International Resources, Inc. v. Russell E. Swanson v.
Christopher D. Moore....................................................................115
Americans With Disabilities Act/Rehabilitation Act—
Melvin Kramer v. Port Authority of Allegheny County, Pa. ..............65
Amount of Compensatory Damages—
David Dunmeyer v. Lowell Taylor ....................................................258
Amount of Punitive Damages—
David Dunmeyer v. Lowell Taylor ....................................................258
Amount of Verdict for Pain & Suffering, Past & Future—
David Dunmeyer v. Lowell Taylor ....................................................258
Appeal—
Pennsylvania State Police, Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement
v. Jabby Joe, Inc.............................................................................204
Application of Pa.R.C.P. 1910.12(h)(2)—
(C)Alison Becker v. David Gosselin ....................................................79
Admissibility of Testimony—
In re: Estate of Paraskevi Miller, a/k/a Freda Miller,
deceased..........................................................................................107
Appointment of Counsel—
Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. v. Jonathan Q.
Fragapane, Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a Amber L. Madden;
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v. Bryan Nesbitt
and Rosemarie Nesbitt ..................................................................184
After-Discovered Evidence—
Steven T. Siwiak v. Kristie Fisfis-Prewett ........................................220
Appointment of Guardian—
In Re: Anna Petosky, An Alleged Incapacitated Person ......................4
Agency—
Richard Dayton v. Powerhouse Gym of Pittsburgh, Inc., Paul
Fajerski, the Fajerski Family Limited Partnership and Complete
Fitness, L.P ......................................................................................20
Apportionment of Liability—
Larry E. Slayton v. Gold Pumps, Inc., et al.........................................36
Agreement to Pay Counsel Fees—
(C)Lisa Perrone v. Wayne Perrone ....................................................260
Airplane Rental Liability Insurance Exclusion Clause—
National Union Fire Ins. Co. and AIG Aviation, Inc. v. Airburst
Helicopters, Inc. et al. ....................................................................70
Alimony—
(C)Dale Giovengo v. Jennifer Giovengo ..............................................75
Gail A. Martino v. Patrick V. Martino, Jr. ............................................87
(C)Anthony Mark Werner v. Cynthia Louise Werner ......................200
Patrick Maxim v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim) ....................251
Arbitration—
Bank One Delaware, N.A. v. Gregory P. Mitchell ............................125
Arbitration Appeals—
Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. Nancy A. Stern and
Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. Scott Miller ............111
Arbitration Clause—
HET Construction Company, Inc. v.
Glen Arden Developers, Inc. and Houston-Starr Company......289
Arbitrators Award “Essence Test”—
Allegheny County Airport Authority v. Construction General
Laborers and Material Handlers Union, 1058..............................11
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Arbitrator’s Scope of Authority—
Ravin, Inc. v. Canova Electrical Contracting, Inc. ..........................144
Arrest—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles J. Sadler ........................39
Article VIII of Pennsylvania Constitution—
Sto-Rox School District and James C. Clifton v.
Allegheny County ..........................................................................193
Assignment of Patent Rights—
Raymond F. Lackner v. Daniel S. Glosser, Glosser Manufacturing
Co., M. Glosser & Sons, Inc., David A. Glosser Foundation,
Lesdan Realty, Inc., James Saly & Barnes & Saly, LLP ..............51
Attorney Advice—
Harry’s Holiday Park Lounge, Inc. v. Pennsylvania State Police,
Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement ......................................223
Attorneys’ Fees and Costs—
Michael F. Zavatchen, Jr. v. RHF Holdings, Inc., and Jefferson
Woodlands Partners, LP................................................................257
Automatic Telephone Solicitation—
Stewart N. Abramson v. Aegis Insurance Agency, Inc. ..................174
Automobile Accident—
Paul Joseph Hess and Tracey Lee Hess v. Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission ............................................21
Karen Apple and Rodney Apple v. Ford Motor Company v. Rodney
Apple ................................................................................................54
Progressive Northern Insurance Company v. Universal
Underwriters Insurance Company, Universal Underwriters
Group and Brent McNeely............................................................243
Bad Faith—
Frank Pogel and Elaine Pogel and David Carpenter and
Beatrice Carpenter, on behalf of themselves and
all others similarly situated v.
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company ..................282
Bankrupt Entities—
Larry E. Slayton v. Gold Pumps, Inc., et al.........................................36
Bias of Juror—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Bicycle/Pedestrian—
(J)Frank S. Pucciarelli and Ellen Pucciarelli v. David J. Graham
and County of Allegheny ..............................................................269
Breach of Contract—
Frank Pogel and Elaine Pogel and David Carpenter and
Beatrice Carpenter, on behalf of themselves and
all others similarly situated v.
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company ..................282
Breach of Employment Contract—
Aidan J. McKenna v. OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts
Technologies, Inc., Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v.
Aidan J. McKenna ........................................................................286
Breach of Warranty—
Carl R. Grady and Diana Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc. ..........................109
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc., and
2005
Trafford Corporation ....................................................................290
Burden of Adducing Expert Evidence—
Michael Kandis v.
Kennywood Entertainment Partners, L.P. ....................................69
Burden of Proof—
(C)Jeannine G. Auld v. Howard S. Auld, Sr. ....................................200
Business Valuation—
(C)Anthony Mark Werner v. Cynthia Louise Werner ......................200
“Buy-Back” Provisions—
Janice C. Vinci v. Retirement Board of Allegheny County ............211
Calculation of Income—
(C)Robert Szymanski v. Barbara Kramer ........................................122
Certificate of Merit—
Amy W. Budner and Martin A. Budner v. Allegheny General
Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services; Rehabilitation
Management Systems, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services;
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports
Medicine Services and Tracee L. Kallet ....................................173
Child Protective Services Law—
William Thompson, Jr. v. Darnell Hairston, Garrick Perkins,
in his individual capacity, and in his official capacity as an
employee of Youth Advocate Program ..........................................23
Child Support—
(C)Cheryl A. Corder v. Thomas V. D’Amico ........................................75
(C)Leslie Raymond v. Marion A. Demma ..........................................77
(C)Mary Elaine Castillenti v. Joseph D. DePasquale ........................77
(C)Felicia Little v. Frank Little ............................................................77
(C)Deanna Branch v. Orpheus Roye..................................................122
(C)Robert Szymanski v. Barbara Kramer ........................................122
Wahleeah Moore v. Kevin J. Coleman ..............................................252
City Ordinance Regulating Vendor Locations—
Gene Scott v. City of Pittsburgh and
University of Pittsburgh ..............................................................249
Civil Service—
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
Claim for Personal Services—
In Re: Estate of Henry A. Vincent ....................................................189
Claim of Estoppel—
Natalie Permenter v. Jennifer Stiscak ................................................31
Code of Judicial Conduct Canon 3(C)(1) and 3(a)(4)—
Tammy Whitfield v. Scott Whitfield ..................................................179
Collateral Estoppel—
Robert Jones and Marcella Jones v. Prudential Realty Co. and
Herman D. Engelberg ..................................................................117
Cynthia M. Liberto v. Suburban General Hospital, Richard E.
Anderson, M.D. and Thomas R. Graham, M.D. ........................241
Collective Bargaining Agreement—
Avonworth School District v. Pennsylvania Labor
Relations Board................................................................................37
Commercial Lease—
TRC Parkway Center, LLC v. Segway Internet Technologies, Inc. ..49
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
Common Law Arbitration—
Ravin, Inc. v. Canova Electrical Contracting, Inc. ..........................144
Compliance With Notice Provisions—
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v. Sharon Regional
Health System, Marie Anne and Joseph Viola v. Nichols &
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................59
Compulsory Non-Suit—
Carl R. Grady and Diana Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc. ..........................109
Jennifer Kormos v. John Urban and Heather Cain ........................275
Computer Services—
Allegheny County Sanitary Authority v. Deloitte Consulting LLC
and Deloitte and Touche, LLP......................................................133
Concealment of Driver’s Identity—
Natalie Permenter v. Jennifer Stiscak ................................................31
Concurrent/Consecutive Sentences—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Benjamin Alexander
Raphael ............................................................................................52
Condition of Road—
Adolfo J. Marche, Administrator of the Estate of Carol Marche,
Deceased, v. County of Allegheny v. James H. Bianchi, Jr. ......248
Confession—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Charles J. Sadler ........................39
Confession of Judgment—
BR Associates v. The Priority Mortgage Group v.
Craig Longwill................................................................................133
Confidential Relationship—
Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Russell N. Fedorka and Nancy I.
Fedorka ............................................................................................29
In re: Estate of Emelia Crowley, Deceased ......................................238
Conflict of Laws—
Karen Apple and Rodney Apple v. Ford Motor Company v. Rodney
Apple ................................................................................................54
Conflicts in Policy Language—
Progressive Northern Insurance Company v. Universal
Underwriters Insurance Company, Universal Underwriters
Group and Brent McNeely............................................................243
Consent Order When Zoning Board Not a Party—
Eric J. and Melanie Werner v. Zoning Hearing Board of the
Borough of Sewickley....................................................................271
Contempt—
(C)Lisa Apijari Johnson v. James R. Johnson ....................................78
Contempt and Sanctions—
(C)Jeannine G. Auld v. Howard S. Auld, Sr. ....................................200
Contract—
(J)Harriet Gordon Machtiger v. P & W Foreign Car Service Inc.,
Saab-Scania of America, Inc. and Chubb Group of Insurance
Companies ..........................................................................................9
(J)Renee Blucas v. The Western Pennsylvania Hospital and West
Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. ............................................46
(J)Breault & Associates, P.C. v. John L. Fiorita, Jr. ..........................46
(J)Peter J. Berner v. Bizet & Co. Ltd., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,”
Walter V. Clark Associates, Inc., t/d/b/a the “Bizet Group,”
2005
and Sandra K. Donnelley, individually........................................150
(J)Kathy Machiko v. General Motors Corporation ..........................152
Fort Cherry School District and Borough of McDonald v.
John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman, County of Allegheny,
West Allegheny School District & North Fayette Township......265
Contract Interpretation—
(C)Lisa Perrone v. Wayne Perrone ....................................................260
Contractual Statute of Limitations—
Regal Industrial Corporation v. Crum & Forster, Inc.; United States
Fire Insurance Company; and The North River Insurance
Company ..........................................................................................93
Coroner’s Inquest Testimony—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darrale Markese Gaines,
a/k/a Terrell Lane ..........................................................................145
Coroner’s Power to Conduct Inquest and Issue Subpoenas—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Judith V. Reynolds ..................147
Counsel and Expert Witness Fees and Costs—
Mistick PBT, et al. v. George Liss, et al.............................................186
Counsel Fees—
(C)Lori Murphy v. Randy Murphy ......................................................76
(C)Anthony Mark Werner v. Cynthia Louise Werner ......................200
(C)Jeannine G. Auld v. Howard S. Auld, Sr. ....................................200
Court Review of Grievance—
Allegheny County Airport Authority v. Construction General
Laborers and Material Handlers Union, 1058..............................11
Credibility—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Lenell Ptomey ..........................201
Criminal Law—
Commonwealth of
Commonwealth of
Commonwealth of
Commonwealth of
Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania
v.
v.
v.
v.
v.
Stanford Williams ......................97
Dewayne Mahaffey ..................192
Thomas Thorton ......................199
Lenell Ptomey ..........................201
Ernest Woodall ........................245
Cross Examination—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darrale Markese Gaines,
a/k/a Terrell Lane ..........................................................................145
Custody—
(C)Farhat J. Lakhavani v. Shankar T. Lakhavani ................................7
(C)Janey Jordan v. Betty Jean and Carlton Jackson ........................76
(C)Jason Edward Davern v. Kendall Michelle Davern ..................122
(C)Amy Cooper Devincentis v. Steven Schulenburg........................124
Patrick J. Tallon v. Kimberly C. DaSilva ..........................................164
(C)Lisa Perrone v. Wayne Perrone ....................................................260
Custody Alleged Ex Parte Communication Between Court and
Reunification Therapist, Visitation Supervisor—
Tammy Whitfield v. Scott Whitfield ..................................................179
Custody Relocation—
(C)Jeremy Daniel Mulder v. Kimberly Mulder..................................78
Daycare—
(C)Robert Szymanski v. Barbara Kramer ........................................122
Dead Man’s Act—
In re: Estate of Paraskevi Miller, a/k/a Freda Miller, deceased ....107
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
2005
(C)The Estate of Joel Pitlock, Brenda Hawkins, Executrix v.
Martha Jane Pitlock ......................................................................123
Do-Not-Call Lists—
Stewart N. Abramson v. AT&T Wireless Services, Inc. ..................176
Declaratory Judgment—
(J)Dean G. Morrissey, Jr. and Jacqueline A. Morrissey,
Individually and as Guardians of Dean J. Morrissey, an
incapacitated person v. State Auto Insurance ............................228
Driving Under Influence—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Bradley Duda ................................................................................262
De Facto Merger—
Aidan J. McKenna v. OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts
Technologies, Inc., Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v.
Aidan J. McKenna ........................................................................286
Defamation—
Osiris Enterprises and Antonio F. Moscatiello v. Borough of
Whitehall, et al. ................................................................................25
Richard and Kimberly Toney v. Robert Siebert, Jr., in his
capacity as a member of the Harmar Township
Board of Supervisors; Robert Siebert, Jr., an individual;
Harmar Township Board of Supervisors;
and Harmar Township ..................................................................225
(J)Barbara Trant v. AON Corp., AON Service Corp.,
AON Group, Inc., & AON Consulting Worldwide, Inc. ..............229
Default Judgment—
Bank One Delaware, N.A. v. Gregory P. Mitchell ............................125
Defense of Consent—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George D. Walls..........................30
Delay of Trial—
Patrick Maxim v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim) ....................251
De Novo Hearing—
Lori Dobrosielski v. Allegheny County Personnel Board ................105
De Novo Review—
Wanda Rowe v. City of Pittsburgh Municipal Pension Board ........256
Dental Malpractice—
(J)David R. Dague and Deborah A. Dague, his wife v.
Sherman Spatz, D.M.D. ................................................................151
(J)Tiffany Kellner v. Harry N. Pasqual, D.M.D. ..............................270
Driving Under the Influence of Alcohol—
Timothy Minkus v. Anthony Sethman and Brenda Ecsedy
Brenda Ecsedy v. Allen Sethman and Anthony Sethman ..........148
Drug Test—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Stanley Joseph Greygor ................................................................279
Dual Agency—
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v.
Sharon Regional Health System, Marie Anne and
Joseph Viola v. Nichols & Associates, Inc. ....................................59
Due Process—
Lori Dobrosielski v. Allegheny County Personnel Board ................105
Duty Arising from Third Party Conduct—
Thomas L. Patterson v. Robert Bartolomucci, Rona Livingston
Bartolomucci, his wife, and Joseph L. Feucht v.
Cavan Patterson and Samuel Price, II ..........................................67
Duty to Stop for Yellow Light—
Joseph Vinciguerra v. John R. Thorpe, Jr. and Martin Cloonan
Martin Cloonan v. 3-D Trucking, Inc. and John Thorpe, Jr. ....231
Earning Capacity—
(C)Leslie Raymond v. Marion A. Demma ..........................................77
(C)Felicia Little v. Frank Little ............................................................77
(C)Jeannine G. Auld v. Howard S. Auld, Sr. ....................................200
Easement Agreements—
Forest Glen Condominium Association v.
Forest Green Commons Limited Partnership ............................281
Effect of Integration Clause/Waiver—
Michael L. Vaughn v. Bernard & Elsie Drab ....................................207
Deviations from Guidelines—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Larry Holiday a/k/a
Larry Mitchell ................................................................................237
Effect of Supersedeas—
Harry’s Holiday Park Lounge, Inc. v. Pennsylvania State Police,
Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement ......................................223
Dimensional Variance—
Ken-Med Associates v. Board of Township Supervisors
of Kennedy Township v. Keith Rose ............................................261
Effect on Claim Arising from Subsequent Medical Treatment—
Sharon Nunley and Alonzo Nunley v. Shadyside Hospital ................67
Discipline of Teacher—
Avonworth School District v.
Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board ............................................37
Electricity—
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc., and
Trafford Corporation ....................................................................290
Discovery—
Frank Morganti and Cynthia Jo Morganti v.
Ace Tire & Parts, Inc., Preferred Car & Truck, Inc.,
John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard J. Swartz
t/d/b/a Ace Tire Company, Tarquinio Towing, John Doe(s)
t/d/b/a Tarquinio Towing and Scott A. Hoover ..........................102
Employee Compensation—
Raymond F. Lackner v. Daniel S. Glosser, Glosser Manufacturing
Co., M. Glosser & Sons, Inc., David A. Glosser Foundation,
Lesdan Realty, Inc., James Saly & Barnes & Saly, LLP ..............51
Divorce Decree—
Elmer A. Jackson, Jr. v. Sheila L. Jackson........................................221
Dog Law—
Jennifer Kormos v. John Urban and Heather Cain ........................275
Enforcement of Agreement—
(C)Lori Murphy v. Randy Murphy ......................................................76
Equal Credit Opportunity Act—
National City Bank, Pennsylvania v. James O.H. Williams and
Jacqueline Williams v. Jacqueline Williams ..............................255
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
Equitable Distribution—
(C)Dale Giovengo v. Jennifer Giovengo ..............................................75
(C)Frank Hervert, Jr. v. Janie Hervert ..............................................78
Gail A. Martino v. Patrick V. Martino, Jr. ............................................87
(C)Johnnie Mae Owens v. Vernon Lee Owens ..................................123
(C)Xinda Wang v. Zhiping Feng..........................................................123
(C)The Estate of Joel Pitlock, Brenda Hawkins, Executrix v.
Martha Jane Pitlock ......................................................................123
Patrick Maxim v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim) ....................251
Equitable Reimbursement—
(C)Xinda Wang v. Zhiping Feng..........................................................123
Establishing Income for Self-Employed Payor—
Patrick Maxim v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim) ....................251
Excessive Sentence—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth William Colecchi ......153
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Meghan Marie Roytas ............235
Excludable Time—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanford Williams ......................97
Exclusion Under Insurance Policy—
Mid-Continent Insurance Company v. Louis Fusco, Luigi’s Place,
Inc. d/b/a Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and
Kathleen Wargo..............................................................................191
Executor’s Fiduciary Duty—
In Re: Estate of Henry A. Vincent ....................................................189
Expert Testimony—
Carl R. Grady and Diana Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc. ..........................109
Extraordinary Relief—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Factors—
(C)Dale Giovengo v. Jennifer Giovengo ..............................................75
Failure to Comply with Psychiatric Evaluation—
Patrick Maxim v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim) ....................251
Failure to Order Transcript—
(C)Alison Becker v. David Gosselin ....................................................79
Failure to Present Petition to Strike—
BR Associates v. The Priority Mortgage Group v.
Craig Longwill................................................................................133
Fair Shares Act—
Larry E. Slayton v. Gold Pumps, Inc., et al.........................................36
2005
Gist of the Action Doctrine—
Regal Industrial Corporation v. Crum & Forster, Inc.; United States
Fire Insurance Company; and The North River Insurance
Company ..........................................................................................93
Allegheny County Sanitary Authority v. Deloitte Consulting LLC
and Deloitte and Touche, LLP......................................................133
Governmental Immunity—
Adolfo J. Marche, Administrator of the Estate of Carol Marche,
Deceased, v. County of Allegheny v. James H. Bianchi, Jr. ......248
Grandparent Custody Action—
(C)Janey Jordan v. Betty Jean and Carlton Jackson ........................76
Grandparent Visitation Act—
Gary Staley and Rose Staley v. Gary J. Staley and Kelly Staley ......84
Grounds for Vacating Award—
Ravin, Inc. v. Canova Electrical Contracting, Inc. ..........................144
Grounds to Open/Vacate Decree—
Elmer A. Jackson, Jr. v. Sheila L. Jackson........................................221
Guardianship Fees—
In Re: The Estate of Edna Humphreys, Deceased ............................35
Guilty Plea—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Meghan Marie Roytas ............235
Hearing Impairment—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George D. Walls..........................30
Hearsay—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tiffany Cassandra Haines ......266
High Crime Area—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Allan Dietz ................181
High Public Official Immunity—
Osiris Enterprises and Antonio F. Moscatiello v. Borough of
Whitehall, et al. ................................................................................25
Richard and Kimberly Toney v. Robert Siebert, Jr., in his capacity
as a member of the Harmar Township Board of Supervisors;
Robert Siebert, Jr., an individual; Harmar Township Board of
Supervisors; and Harmar Township............................................225
Home Rule Charter—
Sto-Rox School District and James C. Clifton v.
Allegheny County ..........................................................................193
Homicide—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darryl Demar Lawrence ........116
Fall Down—
(J)Charlotte Jones and Clifford Jones, her husband v. Charlotte J.
Seddon, Raymond W. Seddon and Raymond W. Seddon, Jr. ......47
Identity of Defendant—
Natalie Permenter v. Jennifer Stiscak ................................................31
Forum Non Conveniens—
Stacey Edds Hunt v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance
Company ........................................................................................224
Immunity—
William Thompson, Jr. v. Darnell Hairston, Garrick Perkins, in his
individual capacity, and in his official capacity as an employee of
Youth Advocate Program ................................................................23
Full and Fair Disclosure—
Dean Marlin v. Cecilia Marlin ..............................................................83
General Durable Power of Attorney—
In re: Estate of Paraskevi Miller, a/k/a Freda Miller, deceased ....107
General Release—
Sharon Nunley and Alonzo Nunley v. Shadyside Hospital ................67
Indemnification—
Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania v. Russell N. Fedorka and
Nancy I. Fedorka..............................................................................29
Ineffective Assistance of Counsel—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George D. Walls..........................30
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanford Williams ......................97
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
2005
Ineffectiveness of Counsel—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Lenell Ptomey ..........................201
Jury Selection—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Wontae Fitzgerald ........213
In Loco Parentis—
Michael and Karen Derzack v.
Dolores and Ozias Shumba ..........................................................139
Just Cause—
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
Insanity Defense—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Darryl Demar Lawrence ..............................................................116
Insolvency—
In Re: The Estate of Edna Humphreys, Deceased ............................35
Insufficient Evidence—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth William Colecchi ......153
Insurance—
Frank Pogel and Elaine Pogel and David Carpenter and
Beatrice Carpenter, on behalf of themselves and
all others similarly situated v.
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company ..................282
Insurer’s Duty to Defend—
Erie Insurance Exchange v. Dustin M. Garger, Jonathan Miller
and Matthew Miller, Administrators of the Estate of
James C. Miller ..............................................................................143
Intentional Discrimination—
Melvin Kramer v. Port Authority of Allegheny County, Pa. ..............65
Interference with Prospective Contractual Relations—
Osiris Enterprises and Antonio F. Moscatiello v. Borough of
Whitehall, et al. ................................................................................25
Interim Partial Custody Relief—
Gary Staley and Rose Staley v. Gary J. Staley and Kelly Staley ......84
Interstate Agreement on Detainers—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ernest Woodall ........................245
Interstate Standard—
Stacey Edds Hunt v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance
Company ........................................................................................224
Inter Vivos Gift—
In re: Estate of Emelia Crowley, Deceased ......................................238
Inventory Searches—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Marylynn Devaughn Bryant, a/k/a Marlynn Devaughn............285
Irrevocable Licenses—
Bear Run Associates Limited Partnership v. Interactive Cable
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................41
Judgment of Non Pros—
Capanet, Inc. v. Charapp Ford ............................................................121
Judicial Notice of Labor Statistics—
(C)Cheryl A. Corder v. Thomas V. D’Amico ........................................75
Jurisdiction—
Juanita Wilborn Beshir v. Erie Insurance Group d/b/a Erie
Insurance Company ......................................................................197
Jury Question—
Melvin Kramer v. Port Authority of Allegheny County
Pennsylvania ....................................................................................65
Last Antecedent Rule of Statutory Construction
to Interpret Policy of Insurance—
Frank Pogel and Elaine Pogel and David Carpenter and
Beatrice Carpenter, on behalf of themselves and
all others similarly situated v.
State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company ..................282
Last Hired/First Fired Rule—
Lisa Kunst Vavro, John A. Gresock, and Joanne Haduch v.
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh ....................................298
Library Code—
Robinson Township Library Association v. Robinson Township,
Board of Commissioners of Robinson Township, and
Richard Charnovich ......................................................................218
Local Agency Law—
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance Act (LERTA) Status—
The Buncher Company v. Quaker Valley School District..................44
Mandamus—
The Buncher Company v. Quaker Valley School District..................44
Mandamus Action Under the Police Tenure Act—
Richard A. Toney v. Harmar Township and Harmar Township
Board of Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr., James R. DiPalma,
Donald R. Muse, John F. Burns, III and Leo Chini....................160
Material Misrepresentation—
Fort Cherry School District and Borough of McDonald v.
John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman, County of Allegheny,
West Allegheny School District & North Fayette Township......265
MCARE Act—
Daniel W. Anderson and Shelby J. Anderson, his wife v.
Eugene N. Myers, M.D., and UPMC Presbyterian and
UPMC Eye and Ear Hospital ......................................................215
Medical/Hospital Liability—
(J)Richard Anderson and Marcie Anderson, his wife v. UPMC
Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System and University of
Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc. ..............................................................8
(J)Jennifer L. Carl, Administratrix of the Estate of Jocelyn Elizabeth
Carl, Deceased and Jennifer Carl and Donald Carl, in their own
right v. Donald G. Carson, M.D., Kristine K. Charles, M.D.,
Renata D. Hoca, M.D., & Oakland OB/GYN Associates, Inc. ........9
Medical Malpractice—
(J)Joseph L. Babula and Marian Babula, his wife v.
David M. Lolley, M.D.; Cardiac Surgeons, Inc.;
Allegheny Valley Hospital; and Allegheny Valley Medical
Imaging and Radiology Oncologists, Inc., t/d/b/a
A V Medical Imaging; and Allegheny Valley Medical Imaging
and Radiation Oncology, Inc., t/d/b/a A V Medical Imaging ........8
(J)Raymond Melani and Eileen Melani, his wife, v. Imad Domat,
M.D. and Pittsburgh Cardiology Consultants, Inc. ......................10
(J)Craig Waugaman and Carol Waugaman, husband and wife v.
Ronald L. Boron, M.D., Cathy J. Artis, M.D., and South Hills
Health System, t/d/b/a Jefferson Regional Medical Center ......10
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
(J)Donn S. Boggs, Sr. and Marion Boggs, husband and wife v.
Anthony N. Okobi, M.D., Anthony N. Okobi, M.D., P.C.,
Kalyanmay Ghoshhajra, M.D. and Radiological Imaging
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................46
(J)Mark Jacko and Mary Jo Jacko, husband and wife v.
Guy A. Catone and Guy A. Catone, D.M.D., Ltd. ........................47
(J)Dawn A. Link and John D. Link v. Joel Enriquez, M.D., Sharon
Richards, C.R.N.A., St. Francis Hospital of New Castle and St.
Francis Health System ....................................................................47
(J)Ravikant and Pooja Tripathi, Parents and Administrators of
the Estate of Rhea Tripathi, Deceased v. St. Clair Memorial
Hospital, Patricia J. Bulesco, M.D. and Patricia J. Bulesco,
M.D., P.C. ..........................................................................................48
Donna Shedlock v. UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System
and University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani,
M.D., Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital;
Carol Waldschmidt in her own right and as Administratrix
of the Estate of Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v.
Aetna US Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center,
Allegheny General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health
System, Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar ..........................63
(J)Michele Vogelsberger v. Magee Womens Hospital of UPMC
Health System and Anthony F. Gentile, M.D. ..............................82
(J)Richard Stoyer and Susan Stoyer, husband and wife v.
St. Francis Health System, St. Francis Medical Center and
Nagamalli Ramakrishna, M.D. ....................................................151
(J)Elizabeth Michak, individually and as representative of the
Estate of Andrew Michak v. Jefferson Hills Area Ambulance
Association......................................................................................152
(J)Betty Jean Null v. Diane Sober, M.D. and
Women’s Health Group ................................................................152
(J)Deborah Dietz, Executrix of the Estate of Ronald Dietz,
Deceased, and Deborah Dietz, Individually v. UPMC St.
Margaret Memorial Hospital........................................................227
(J)Susan Hogan, Personal Representative of the Estate of Norberta
Hogan v. Matthew Portz, M.D., Family Practice Medical
Associates South, Inc., and Kiet A. Hoang, M.D. ......................228
(J)Elizabeth A. Saniga, Administratrix of the Estate of Richard R.
Saniga v. Bryan C. Donohue, M.D. ..............................................228
(J)Tracy H. Webber and Nichole Webber, his wife v. Presbyterian
University Hospital t/d/b/a University of Pittsburgh Medical
Center and Donald Marion, M.D. ................................................230
(J)Ann Weir v. UPMC Community Medicine, Inc., Valley Medical
Facilities, Inc. & Sharon R. Roseman, M.D. ....................................230
(J)Barbara and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the Estates of
Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors, Deceased,
and Barbara and Dennis Hawk in their own right v.
Christopher Palombo, M.D. and Mercy Primary Care, Inc.
And Barbara and Dennis Hawk, Administrators of the
Estates of Anthony Hawk and Aaron Hawk, Minors,
Deceased, and Barbara and Dennis Hawk in their own right v.
David J. Dietrick, M.D. & Mercy Primary Care, Inc. ..................269
(J)Harry Wells, Admr. of the Estate of Carole Wells, Deceased v.
James J. Baran, M.D. and Colo-Rectal Associates ....................270
Melzer—
(C)Deanna Branch v. Orpheus Roye..................................................122
Memorandum Opinion—
Cynthia M. Liberto v. Suburban General Hospital, Richard E.
Anderson, M.D. and Thomas R. Graham, M.D. ........................241
“Mere Encounter” v. “Investigative Detention”—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Michael Allan Dietz ......................................................................181
Military—
Patrick J. Tallon v. Kimberly C. DaSilva ..........................................164
2005
Miller Act—
Regal Industrial Corporation v. Crum & Forster, Inc.; United States
Fire Insurance Company; and The North River Insurance
Company ..........................................................................................93
Mitigation of Income Loss—
(C)Cheryl A. Corder v. Thomas V. D’Amico ........................................75
Modification—
(C)Cheryl A. Corder v. Thomas V. D’Amico ........................................75
(C)Deanna Branch v. Orpheus Roye..................................................122
Modification of Support—
(C)Lisa Apijari Johnson v. James R. Johnson ....................................78
Mootness—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanford Williams ......................97
Mortgage Defendants’ Counterclaim Not Permitted—
Washington Mutual Bank v. Abraham and Rose Constantino ........241
Motion for Directed Verdict—
Joseph Vinciguerra v. John R. Thorpe, Jr. and Martin Cloonan
Martin Cloonan v. 3-D Trucking, Inc. and John Thorpe, Jr. ....231
Motion for Partial Summary Judgment—
Robert Jones and Marcella Jones v. Prudential Realty Co. and
Herman D. Engelberg ..................................................................117
Motion for Post-Trial Relief—
3D Amusements, Inc. v. John Kovall, Roadrunner Amusements,
Inc., Dennis Martin, Joan Martin, Michelle Martin,
MMM 131 Forbes, Inc., Michele’s 1020 Washington Pike, Inc.,
Joan’s Place 1122, Inc., Greentree Saloon, Inc.,
and JAM 1993 Restaurant, Inc.....................................................278
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. Board of Public Education of the
School District of Pittsburgh v.
WTW Architects, Inc. and Able-Hess Associates, Inc...............299
Motion for Reconsideration—
Pennsylvania State Police, Bureau of Liquor Control
Enforcement v. Jabby Joe, Inc. ....................................................204
3D Amusements, Inc. v. John Kovall, Roadrunner Amusements,
Inc., Dennis Martin, Joan Martin, Michelle Martin,
MMM 131 Forbes, Inc., Michele’s 1020 Washington Pike, Inc.,
Joan’s Place 1122, Inc., Greentree Saloon, Inc.,
and JAM 1993 Restaurant, Inc.....................................................278
Motion for Recusal—
Tammy Whitfield v. Scott Whitfield ..................................................179
Motion for Summary Judgment—
Atlantic States Insurance Company v. Northeast Networking
Systems, Inc., Clinton Boyd and Charles Fornicoia ..................119
Motion to Compel—
Frank Morganti and Cynthia Jo Morganti v. Ace Tire & Parts, Inc.,
Preferred Car & Truck, Inc., John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard J.
Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire Company, Tarquinio Towing, John
Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio Towing and Scott A. Hoover..............102
Motion to Compel Production of Personnel Files—
Donna Shedlock v. UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System
and University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani,
M.D., Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital;
Carol Waldschmidt in her own right and as Administratrix
of the Estate of Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v.
Aetna US Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center,
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Allegheny General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health
System, Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar ..........................63
Motion to Quash—
Lisa Kunst Vavro, John A. Gresock, and Joanne Haduch v.
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh ....................................298
Motion to Suppress—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v
Terence P. Rice ..............................................................................217
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Marylynn Devaughn Bryant, a/k/a Marlynn Devaughn............285
Motor Vehicle—
(J)Pamela Ambrose v. Henry Suffoletta................................................8
(J)Frank P. Demma and Helen J. Demma, his wife, v.
Gary F. Rosenberger..........................................................................9
(J)Deborah L. Fastuca v. John Spieler, Victoria A. Spieler and
Whitney West......................................................................................9
(J)Susan B. Tusick v. Charles J. Holtman ..........................................10
Natalie Permenter v. Jennifer Stiscak ................................................31
(J)Anna Crnogorac and Anthony Crnogorac, her husband v.
Steven Benjamin ..............................................................................46
(J)Julie K. Diulus v. Salamon Murciano..............................................46
(J)Michele Ruff and Kristin Ruff, a minor v.
Anna Rae Schreckengost ................................................................48
(J)Janet Gazza v. Marian Phillips ........................................................48
(J)Edward D. O’Konski v.
Port Authority of Allegheny County ..............................................81
(J)Michael Peterman and Sandra L. Peterman, his wife, v.
Jane Ondechek ................................................................................81
(J)Suzanne M. Burtt v. Port Authority of Allegheny County ..........150
(J)Sharon C. Carolla v. James P. Walker ..........................................150
(J)Karen Larry v. Brian C. Givner ....................................................151
(J)Janice Novak and Jason Novak, her husband v.
Shannon Smith, a/k/a Sharon Smith ............................................152
Donald L. Cox v. Gregory A. Grace and Elizabeth Grace ..............212
(J)Carmen Charmello, Jr. v. Port Authority of Allegheny Co. ........227
(J)Mildred Handlovitch v. Michael Short, Thomas A. Short and
Joanne Short ..................................................................................228
(J)Mary Lou Mielecki and Anthony G. Mielecki, wife and
husband v. Jayne Reilly ................................................................228
(J)Caryn G. Sousa and James P. Sousa, her husband v.
Rebecca Amy Stage ......................................................................229
(J)William Varner, Jr. v. Ivan E. Grenier ..........................................229
(J)Sarah Wible v. Dolores Morante....................................................230
Joseph Vinciguerra v. John R. Thorpe, Jr. and Martin Cloonan
Martin Cloonan v. 3-D Trucking, Inc. and John Thorpe, Jr. ....231
(J)David I. Jack and Jennifer Jack, husband and wife v.
Jerry Pitkavish ..............................................................................269
(J)Carol & Fred Morabito, her husband v. Allen H. Graham ........269
(J)W. Scott Hart v. Edwin W. Booth....................................................270
(J)Donald Wei, individually and on behalf of the Persons
Entitled to Share in the Estate of Evelyn Wei, Deceased v.
City of Pittsburgh v. Jan B. Jones ................................................270
2005
Natural Gas—
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc., and
Trafford Corporation ....................................................................290
Negligence—
Carl R. Grady and Diana Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc. ..........................109
New Trial—
Steven T. Siwiak v. Kristie Fisfis-Prewett ........................................220
New Trial on Damages—
Michele Vogelsberger v. Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC
Health System and Anthony F. Gentile, M.D. ............................295
Nexus Between Execution and Mortgage Default Necessary—
Washington Mutual Bank v. Abraham and Rose Constantino ........241
Nonconforming Use—
Lamar West, L.P., v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of
Monroeville and Municipality of Monroeville, Intervenor ........92
Notice—
Bear Run Associates Limited Partnership v. Interactive Cable
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................41
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
Notice Requirements—
John McGhee, per Pa. Equipment Rental Co. and Turtle Creek
Industrial Park, L.P. v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Borough of
Turtle Creek and Turtle Creek Borough ......................................42
Occurrence Coverage v. Claims Made Coverage—
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v. Sharon Regional
Health System, Marie Anne and Joseph Viola v. Nichols &
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................59
One Recovery for an Injury—
Paul Joseph Hess and Tracey Lee Hess v. Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission ............................................21
Opening of Confessed Judgment—
TRC Parkway Center, LLC v. Segway Internet Technologies, Inc. ..49
Opening of Decedent’s Intestate Estate—
In Re: The Estate of Edna Humphreys, Deceased ............................35
Oral Modification of Property Settlement Agreement—
(C)Mark T. Wade v. Donna (Wade) Huston ........................................76
Municipalities Planning Code (MPC)—
Ken-Med Associates v. Board of Township Supervisors
of Kennedy Township v. Keith Rose ............................................261
Eric J. and Melanie Werner v. Zoning Hearing Board of the
Borough of Sewickley....................................................................271
Other Tort—
(J)Rakyia F. Berry v. The May Department Stores Company, d/b/a
Kaufmanns, Charles A. Kramer, Administrator of the Estate of
Louis Kramer, Jr., Deceased, John Doe 1, John Doe 2, Jane Doe
1, Jane Doe 2, and Patrick Hillyard, ..............................................8
(J)Catherine Pusateri and Vincent Pusateri, wife and husband v.
The Pittsburgh Glass Center, Inc...................................................10
(J)Melvin Kramer v. Port Authority of Allegheny County ................47
(J)Barbara Welner v. Thomas and Marie Earley ..............................48
(J)Thomas Polas v. All Crane Rental Corporation ............................82
(J)Kara M. Tolmer v. Esther Delligatti and Raymond Seitz,
D.M.D. ..............................................................................................82
(J)Jamie Ivanac v.
Esther Delligatti & Raymond Seitz, D.M.D. ................................82
National Arbitration Forum—
Bank One Delaware, N.A. v. Gregory P. Mitchell ............................125
Pa. R.Crim.P. 704(B)—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Multiple Civil Action—
(J)Marshall L. Pappert v. Donald Ramsey, Travelers Property
Casualty and The Travelers Indemnity Co. ..................................81
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
Pa. R.C.P. 4011(b)—
Donna Shedlock v. UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System
and University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani,
M.D., Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital; Carol
Waldschmidt in her own right and as Administratrix of the
Estate of Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v. Aetna US
Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center, Allegheny General
Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health System, Antonios Zikos
and Ravikumar Alagar ....................................................................63
Pa. R.E. 613(C)—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
2005
Policy Exclusion for Intentional Bodily Injury—
Erie Insurance Exchange v. Dustin M. Garger, Jonathan Miller
and Matthew Miller, Administrators of the Estate of James
C. Miller ..........................................................................................143
Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act—
Paul Joseph Hess and Tracey Lee Hess v. Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission ............................................21
Power of Attorney—
In Re: Anna Petosky, An Alleged Incapacitated Person ......................4
Pa. R.E. 804—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tiffany Cassandra Haines ......266
Preemption—
American International Resources, Inc. v. Russell E. Swanson v.
Christopher D. Moore....................................................................115
Parole Officer—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Douglas Curry ..........................302
Pre-existing, Nonconforming Use—
Shaun Cusick v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Bd. of Adjustment ......209
Partial Custody—
Michael and Karen Derzack v. Dolores and Ozias Shumba............139
Prejudice—
Capanet, Inc. v. Charapp Ford ............................................................121
“Pass Through” Claim—
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. Board of Public Education of the
School District of Pittsburgh v.
WTW Architects, Inc. and Able-Hess Associates, Inc...............299
Preliminary Objections—
Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. Nancy A. Stern and
Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. Scott Miller ............111
Juanita Wilborn Beshir v. Erie Insurance Group d/b/a
Erie Insurance Company ..............................................................197
Paternity—
Wahleeah Moore v. Kevin J. Coleman ..............................................252
Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board—
Pennsylvania State Police, Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement
v. Jabby Joe, Inc.............................................................................204
Pension—
(C)Johnnie Mae Owens v. Vernon Lee Owens ..................................123
Pension Plan—
Janice C. Vinci v. Retirement Board of Allegheny County ............211
Pension Valuation Expert—
(C)Terence P. Jacob v. Sandra J. Jacob ..............................................75
Peremptory Judgment Under Pa. R.C.P. 1098—
Richard A. Toney v. Harmar Township and Harmar Township
Board of Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr., James R. DiPalma,
Donald R. Muse, John F. Burns, III and Leo Chini....................160
Permanent Alimony—
(C)Frank Hervert, Jr. v. Janie Hervert ..............................................78
Permitted Use—
Joseph D’Andrea v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of
Penn Hills ........................................................................................58
Petition to Set Aside Sheriff ’s Sale—
National City Bank of Pennsylvania v. Arthur J. and Eileen L.
McGovern v. Greenbriar Investment Company .......................... 91
Petition to Strike Default Judgment—
National City Bank of Pennsylvania v. Arthur J. and Eileen L.
McGovern v. Greenbriar Investment Company .......................... 91
Premises Liability—
(J)James Brose, a Minor, by Anne Brose, his Guardian v.
Zoological Society of Pittsburgh, a PA Corp. ................................80
(J)A. Thomas Caruso v. Cupka Café II; Richard Cupka, Jr.,
and Stephanie Cupka ......................................................................80
(J)Eboni Franklin v. Lawrence Crawford ..........................................80
(J)Katherine F. Kern and Duane E. Kern, Sr., her husband v.
Otis Elevator Company, a corporation ..........................................80
(J)Kelly Parker v. Josh and Melanie Lenthall, & Steven Josowitz,
individually & t/d/b/a Josowitz Roofing ........................................81
(J)Joseph Kauer v. Paul Kouknas, Paul Kouknas Enterprises, Inc.
and Post 456 Veterans of Foreign Wars ......................................150
(J)Joylene A. Chiri v. National Amusements, Inc., t/d/b/a
Showcase Cinemas West ..............................................................150
(J)Michelle A. Marino and Brad Marino, her husband v.
R & J Grocery, LLC ......................................................................151
(J)Daniel Mazzie v. James Bianco and Jean Anne Bianco,
his wife, and Geno Bianco and Carla Bianco..............................152
Amy W. Budner and Martin A. Budner v. Allegheny General
Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services; Rehabilitation
Management Systems, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services;
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports
Medicine Services and Tracee L. Kallet ....................................173
(J)Sheri Fallon and James Fallon, individuals v.
R.A.H. Associates, Inc. and Heartland Corporation ..................227
(J)Kristen Ann Greer v. C.S. Kim, Soon Ar Kim, and
Zegarelli’s Hair Exsalonce, Inc. ..................................................227
(J)Patricia Ann Grebiner v.
Ronald E. Williams ........................................................................269
Prenuptial Agreement—
Dean Marlin v. Cecilia Marlin ..............................................................83
Petition to Tax Costs—
Eugene C. Buchleitner v. Alan H. Perer and Swensen & Perer......242
Prescriptive Easement—
James Simon and Maureen Simon v. Jane R. Mercer, Jack Mercer,
John J. Ross, Bonnie L. Ross, David L. Ross, Donna Bunce
Fruend, t/d/b/a Allegheny Mobile Home Park ..........................215
Plea Bargain—
Commonwealth of Pa. v. Benjamin Alexander Raphael ....................52
Present Ability to Pay—
(C)Lisa Apijari Johnson v. James R. Johnson ....................................78
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Presumption of Good Faith—
William Thompson, Jr. v. Darnell Hairston, Garrick Perkins,
in his individual capacity, and in his official capacity as an
employee of Youth Advocate Program ..........................................23
Primary Custody Determination—
(C)Jeremy Daniel Mulder v. Kimberly Mulder..................................78
Prior Consistent Statements—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Private Cause of Action Under Federal Telephone Consumer
Protection Act (TCPA)—
Stewart N. Abramson v. AT&T Wireless Services, Inc. ..................176
Private School Reasonableness—
(C)Mary Elaine Castillenti v. Joseph D. DePasquale ........................77
Private School Tuition—
(C)Cecelia Dellone-Larkin, M.D. v.
Gregory J. Larkin, M.D.................................................................124
(C)D.H. v. R.H. ....................................................................................260
Probation Revocation—
Commonwealth of Pa. v. Benjamin Alexander Raphael ....................52
Procurement Code—
W.G. Tomko, Inc. v. Board of Public Education of the Sch. Dist. of Pgh. v.
WTW Architects, Inc. & Able-Hess Associates, Inc. ................299
Product Liability—
Karen Apple and Rodney Apple v. Ford Motor Company v.
Rodney Apple ..................................................................................54
(J)David Barrett v. Youngstown Kenworth, Inc. ................................80
Production of Surveillance—
Frank Morganti and Cynthia Jo Morganti v. Ace Tire & Parts, Inc.,
Preferred Car & Truck, Inc., John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard J.
Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire Company, Tarquinio Towing, John
Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio Towing and Scott A. Hoover..............102
Professional Liability Action—
(J)Linda A. Suttner v. Centers for Rehab Services ..........................229
Professional Liability Claim—
Amy W. Budner and Martin A. Budner v. Allegheny General
Hospital, t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services; Rehabilitation
Management Systems, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports Medicine Services;
West Penn Allegheny Health System, Inc. t/d/b/a Sports
Medicine Services and Tracee L. Kallet ....................................173
Professional Liability Insurance—
National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh v. Sharon Regional
Health System, Marie Anne and Joseph Viola v. Nichols &
Associates, Inc. ................................................................................59
Professional Negligence Action—
Allegheny County Sanitary Authority v. Deloitte Consulting LLC
and Deloitte and Touche, LLP......................................................133
Promise Not to Cause Injury—
Daniel W. Anderson and Shelby J. Anderson, his wife v.
Eugene N. Myers, M.D., and UPMC Presbyterian and
UPMC Eye and Ear Hospital ......................................................215
Promise of Cure—
Daniel W. Anderson and Shelby J. Anderson, his wife v.
Eugene N. Myers, M.D., and UPMC Presbyterian and
2005
UPMC Eye and Ear Hospital ......................................................215
Promissory Estoppel—
Regal Industrial Corporation v. Crum & Forster, Inc.; United States
Fire Insurance Company; and The North River Insurance
Company ..........................................................................................93
Promotion—
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
Proof of Common Law Marriage—
(C)Arlene Daun-Smith v. Steven Smith ............................................122
Propensity to Attack—
Jennifer Kormos v. John Urban and Heather Cain ........................275
Public Policy—
HET Construction Company, Inc. v.
Glen Arden Developers, Inc. and Houston-Starr Company......289
Punitive Damages—
Karen Apple and Rodney Apple v. Ford Motor Company v.
Rodney Apple ..................................................................................54
Punitive Damages in Automobile Accident—
Timothy Minkus v. Anthony Sethman and Brenda Ecsedy
Brenda Ecsedy v. Allen Sethman and Anthony Sethman ..........148
Quash Search Warrant—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth William Colecchi ......153
Quasi-Contract Action—
In Re: Estate of Henry A. Vincent ....................................................189
Rape—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. George D. Walls..........................30
Rational Derivation Subtest—
Allegheny County Airport Authority v. Construction General
Laborers and Material Handlers Union, 1058..............................11
Real Estate Assessment Limitations—
Sto-Rox School District and James C. Clifton v.
Allegheny County ..........................................................................193
Real Estate Seller Disclosure Law—
Michael L. Vaughn v. Bernard & Elsie Drab ....................................207
Real Party In Interest—
Richard Dayton v. Powerhouse Gym of Pittsburgh, Inc., Paul
Fajerski, the Fajerski Family Limited Partnership and Complete
Fitness, L.P ......................................................................................20
Reasonable Diligence—
Steven T. Siwiak v. Kristie Fisfis-Prewett ........................................220
Reasonable Expectations of the Insured—
National Union Fire Ins. Co. and AIG Aviation, Inc. v. Airburst
Helicopters, Inc. et al. ....................................................................70
Record Costs—
Eugene C. Buchleitner v. Alan H. Perer and Swensen & Perer......242
Reduction in Salary as a Reduction in Rank—
Richard A. Toney v. Harmar Township and Harmar Township
Board of Supervisors, Robert W. Seibert, Jr., James R. DiPalma,
Donald R. Muse, John F. Burns, III and Leo Chini....................160
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
2005
Rehabilitation of Credibility—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
& Associates, Inc., Peter Gialames, and Edward Lewis v.
Neil M. Niren, M.D., and James A. Trombetta ..........................167
Release of Additional Defendant—
Adolfo J. Marche, Administrator of the Estate of Carol Marche,
Deceased, v. County of Allegheny v. James H. Bianchi, Jr. ......248
Search of Parolee’s Residence—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Wontae Fitzgerald ........213
Reliability of Tipster—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v Terence P. Rice ........................217
Relocation—
(C)Jason Edward Davern v. Kendall Michelle Davern ..................122
Remittitur of Jury’s Damage Award—
Michele Vogelsberger v. Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC
Health System and Anthony F. Gentile, M.D. ............................295
Request for Continuance of Trial—
Steven T. Siwiak v. Kristie Fisfis-Prewett ........................................254
Res Ipsa Loquitur—
Michael Kandis v. Kennywood Entertainment Partners, L.P. ..........69
Res Judicata—
Donald L. Cox v. Gregory A. Grace and Elizabeth Grace ..............212
Retirement Age—
(C)Terence P. Jacob v. Sandra J. Jacob ..............................................75
Retroactive Increase of Alimony Pendente Lite—
Patrick Maxim v. Joni Pierce (formerly Joni Maxim) ....................251
Retroactivity—
Wahleeah Moore v. Kevin J. Coleman ..............................................252
Reversionary Interest—
John E. Murphy, Assignee of Ruth G. Murphy v. Anthony Martini
and Josephine Martini, His Wife ..................................................18
Review of Actions of Attorneys in Fact—
In re: Estate of Paraskevi Miller, a/k/a Freda Miller, deceased ....107
Rule 600 Violation—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanford Williams ......................97
Sanctions—
Sharon Hutchinson t/d/b/a Cheer-On v. Sharon Jackson, Angela
Crissman, Trent Gorrell, Sandy Ruggieri and Amy Stake;
Corey Rose Schlemmer and Rosemary L. Vogel v. Bernard L.
Rottschaefer, M.D., Purdue Pharma Co., Purdue Frederick Co.,
P.F. Laboratories, Inc., and Abbott Laboratories, et al. ............205
School District—
Fort Cherry School District and Borough of McDonald v.
John C. Gedman, Robin M. Gedman, County of Allegheny,
West Allegheny School District & North Fayette Township......265
Scope of FCC Exemption Rule—
Stewart N. Abramson v. Aegis Insurance Agency, Inc. ..................174
Scope of Official Duty—
Osiris Enterprises and Antonio F. Moscatiello v. Borough of
Whitehall, et al. ................................................................................25
Scope of Review of Arbitration Award—
James Trombetta, Tara Trombetta and Julie Trombetta Gray v.
Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., Raymond James
Self-Defense—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Lenell Ptomey ..........................201
Sentencing Guidelines—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Larry Holiday a/k/a
Larry Mitchell ................................................................................237
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Stanley Joseph Greygor ..........279
Sequestration of Witness—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David Wontae Fitzgerald ........213
Service of Process—
National City Bank of Pennsylvania v. Arthur J. and Eileen L.
McGovern v. Greenbriar Investment Company .......................... 91
Bank One Delaware, N.A. v. Gregory P. Mitchell ............................125
Servicemembers Civil Relief Act—
Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. v. Jonathan Q.
Fragapane, Amber L. Fragapane a/k/a Amber L. Madden;
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation v. Bryan Nesbitt
and Rosemarie Nesbitt ..................................................................184
Settlement—
Larry E. Slayton v. Gold Pumps, Inc., et al.........................................36
Sexual Assault of Minor—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Shared Legal and Alternating Weeks of Physical Custody—
(C)Amy Cooper Devincentis v. Steven Schulenburg........................124
Spousal and Child Support—
Michele Sieber v. Glenn Sieber ............................................................72
Spousal Guarantee—
National City Bank, Pennsylvania v. James O.H. Williams and
Jacqueline Williams v. Jacqueline Williams ..............................255
Stalking—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Meghan Marie Roytas ............235
Standard of Review—
Lori Dobrosielski v. Allegheny County Personnel Board ................105
Standing—
Richard Dayton v. Powerhouse Gym of Pittsburgh, Inc., Paul
Fajerski, the Fajerski Family Limited Partnership and Complete
Fitness, L.P ......................................................................................20
Gary Staley and Rose Staley v. Gary J. Staley and Kelly Staley ......84
Standing to Contest Variance—
Eric J. and Melanie Werner v. Zoning Hearing Board of the
Borough of Sewickley....................................................................271
Statute of Limitations—
Natalie Permenter v. Jennifer Stiscak ................................................31
Michael C. Loughren v. United Services Automobile
Association......................................................................................233
Statutory Appeal of Civil Service Commission’s Decision—
Lisa Kunst Vavro, John A. Gresock, and Joanne Haduch v.
VOLUME 153
Supplement to The Lawyers Journal
Civil Service Commission of Pittsburgh ....................................298
Statutory Bad Faith—
Michael C. Loughren v. United Services Automobile
Association......................................................................................233
Stillborn Child—
Dawn Mapel and Michael Mapel v. St. Clair Memorial
Hospital, Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D., and Patricia Bulseco,
M.D., P.C. ........................................................................................131
Storage Tank and Spill Prevention Act—
Mistick PBT, et al. v. George Liss, et al.............................................186
2005
Suppression of Statements—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth William Colecchi ......153
Tapes—
Frank Morganti and Cynthia Jo Morganti v. Ace Tire & Parts, Inc.,
Preferred Car & Truck, Inc., John H. Swartz, Jr. and Richard J.
Swartz t/d/b/a Ace Tire Company, Tarquinio Towing, John
Doe(s) t/d/b/a Tarquinio Towing and Scott A. Hoover..............102
Testamentary Capacity—
In Re: Estate of Margaret S. Taylor ....................................................14
Third-Party Standing—
Michael and Karen Derzack v. Dolores and Ozias Shumba............139
Stream of Commerce—
Lacey D. Cook, et al. v. Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation
Corporation, et al. v. Trafford Corporation
III Rivers Manor v. Equitable Resources, Inc., and
Trafford Corporation ....................................................................290
Tirado Requirements—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Larry Holiday a/k/a
Larry Mitchell ................................................................................237
Strict Liability—
Carl R. Grady and Diana Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc. ..........................109
Tortious Interference—
Aidan J. McKenna v. OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts
Technologies, Inc., Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v.
Aidan J. McKenna ........................................................................286
Striking a Complaint—
Sharon Hutchinson t/d/b/a Cheer-On v. Sharon Jackson, Angela
Crissman, Trent Gorrell, Sandy Ruggieri and Amy Stake;
Corey Rose Schlemmer and Rosemary L. Vogel v. Bernard L.
Rottschaefer, M.D., Purdue Pharma Co., Purdue Frederick Co.,
P.F. Laboratories, Inc., and Abbott Laboratories, et al. ............205
Total & Permanent Disability Under Pension Act of 1975 —
Wanda Rowe v. City of Pittsburgh Municipal Pension Board ........256
Transfer of Stock—
In re: Estate of Emelia Crowley, Deceased ......................................238
Subrogation—
Donald L. Cox v. Gregory A. Grace and Elizabeth Grace ..............212
Transferred Intent—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Lenell Ptomey ..........................201
Substantial Evidence—
In Re: Appeal of Battalion Chief Michael Mullen............................272
UIM Coverage—
Charles R. Johnson v. Tico Insurance Company, a/k/a Leader
Insurance, a/k/a Transport Insurance Company, a/k/a Infinity
Leader Insurance ..............................................................................1
Substantially Prevailing Party—
Michael F. Zavatchen, Jr. v. RHF Holdings, Inc., and Jefferson
Woodlands Partners, LP................................................................257
Sufficiency of Complaint Under Pa. R.C.P. 1019 and 1042—
Worldwide Asset Purchasing, LLC v. Nancy A. Stern and
Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. Scott Miller ............111
Sufficiency of Evidence—
Commonwealth of PA v. Regis Bell......................................................56
Summary Judgment—
Thomas L. Patterson v. Robert Bartolomucci, Rona Livingston
Bartolomucci, his wife, and Joseph L. Feucht v.
Cavan Patterson and Samuel Price, II ..........................................67
Mid-Continent Insurance Company v. Louis Fusco, Luigi’s Place,
Inc. d/b/a Lou Magoo’s, a/k/a Katy’s Bar & Lounge, Inc. and
Kathleen Wargo..............................................................................191
Support Actual Earnings—
Elaine Herzog v. David A. Herzog ....................................................162
Support Enforcement—
(C)Beth A. Peebles v. James M. Peebles ..............................................7
Suppression Motion—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dale Dunson ............................303
Suppression of Evidence Obtained During Traffic Stop Questioning
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v.
Maurice Devaughn Clinton ..........................................................271
Unavailable Witness—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darrale Markese Gaines,
a/k/a Terrell Lane ..........................................................................145
Underinsurance Benefits—
Michael C. Loughren v. United Services Automobile
Association......................................................................................233
Undue Influence—
In Re: Estate of Margaret S. Taylor ....................................................14
Uniform Condominium Act—
Forest Glen Condominium Association v.
Forest Green Commons Limited Partnership ............................281
Uniform Firearms Act—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas Thorton ......................199
Unopened Streets—
John E. Murphy, Assignee of Ruth G. Murphy v. Anthony Martini
and Josephine Martini, His Wife ..................................................18
Unreasonable Search and Seizure—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Allan Dietz ................181
Unreasonably Burdensome Discovery—
Donna Shedlock v. UPMC Presbyterian, Inc., UPMC Health System
and University of Pittsburgh Physicians, Inc., Paul Dascani,
M.D., Medical Alliance, P.C. and Highlands Hospital;
VOLUME 153
Cumulative Index to the Pittsburgh Legal Journal
2005
Valid Consideration—
(C)Mark T. Wade v. Donna (Wade) Huston ........................................76
Zoning—
John McGhee, per Pa. Equipment Rental Co. and Turtle Creek
Industrial Park, L.P. v. Zoning Hearing Board of the
Borough of Turtle Creek and Turtle Creek Borough ..................42
Joseph D’Andrea v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality
of Penn Hills ....................................................................................58
Shaun Cusick v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of
Adjustment ....................................................................................209
Variance—
Shaun Cusick v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Board of
Adjustment ....................................................................................209
Zoning Ordinance—
Lamar West, L.P., v. Zoning Hearing Board of the Municipality of
Monroeville and Municipality of Monroeville, Intervenor ........92
Voluntary Retirement—
(C)Marguerite Grier Smith v. Stewart Smith......................................76
Zoning Ordinance Permitted Uses—
Mark Dunlap and Patricia Dunlap v. Zoning Hearing Board for the
Township of Ross v. Township of Ross and the Berkeley Hills
Civic Association..............................................................................71
Carol Waldschmidt in her own right and as Administratrix
of the Estate of Robert Waldschmidt, deceased, v.
Aetna US Healthcare, St. John’s Lutheran Care Center,
Allegheny General Hospital, West Penn Allegheny Health
System, Antonios Zikos and Ravikumar Alagar ..........................63
Voter Referendum—
Robinson Township Library Association v. Robinson Township,
Board of Commissioners of Robinson Township, and Richard
Charnovich......................................................................................218
Wage Payment and Collection Law—
Aidan J. McKenna v. OpenWebs Corporation, CarParts
Technologies, Inc., Mark Woodward and Paul Campbell v.
Aidan J. McKenna ........................................................................286
Waiver—
HET Construction Company, Inc. v.
Glen Arden Developers, Inc. and Houston-Starr Company......289
Waiver of Issues—
Atlantic States Insurance Company v. Northeast Networking
Systems, Inc., Clinton Boyd and Charles Fornicoia ..................119
Warrant Issued Prior to Affiant Being Sworn—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kenneth William Colecchi ......153
Warrantless Search—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dewayne Mahaffey ..................192
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Douglas Curry ..........................302
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dale Dunson ............................303
Weapons Search—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dale Dunson ............................303
Wife’s Counsel’s Failure to Timely Raise Economic Claims—
Elmer A. Jackson, Jr. v. Sheila L. Jackson........................................221
Workers’ Compensation—
Robert Jones and Marcella Jones v. Prudential Realty Co. and
Herman D. Engelberg ..................................................................117
Atlantic States Insurance Company v. Northeast Networking
Systems, Inc., Clinton Boyd and Charles Fornicoia ..................119
Writ of Habeas Corpus—
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas Thorton ......................199
Written Request Requirement—
Charles R. Johnson v. Tico Insurance Company,
a/k/a Leader Insurance, a/k/a Transport Insurance Company,
a/k/a Infinity Leader Insurance ......................................................1
Wrongful Death Act—
Dawn Mapel and Michael Mapel v. St. Clair Memorial
Hospital, Deborah Ann Lenart, M.D., and Patricia Bulseco,
M.D., P.C. ........................................................................................131