Journal o/GlacioloD, Vol. 13.- No. 67,1974 THE INFLUENCE OF CLOUDINESS ON THE NET RADIATION BALANCE OF A SNOW SURFACE WITH HIGH ALBEDO By W. AMBACH (Physikalisches Institut der Universitat Innsbruck, Schopfstrasse 4 I , 6020 Innsbruck, Austria) ABSTRACT. The short-wave and long-wave radiant fluxes measured in the accumulation area of the Greenland ice sheet during a mid-summer period are discussed with respect to their dependence on cloudiness. At a cloudiness of 10/10, a mean val ue of 270 J /cm 2 d is obtained for the daily totals of net radiation balance, whereas a mean value of only 75 J /cm2 d is observed at 0/ 10. The energy excess of the net radiation balance with overcast sky is due to the significant influence of the incoming long-wave radiation and the high albedo of the surface (average of84% ). High values of net radiation balance a re therefore correlated with high values of long-wave radiation balance and low values of short-wave radiation balance. RESUME . L'injluence de la nebulositi SlIr le bilan radialif net d'une slIrface de neige a jort albedo . Le flux de rayonnement en ondes courtes et longues, mesure dans la zone d'accumulation de la calotte glaciaire du Groenland pendant un e demi-periode estivale est discute dans sa dependance par rapport a la nebulosit<'. Par une couverture nuageuse de 10/10 on obtient une valeur moyenne de 270 J /cm 2 d pour le totaljournalier du bilan radiatifnet, alors qu'on observe une valeur moyenne de seulement 75 J /cm 2 d a 0/10 de nebulosite. L'excedent energetique du bilan radia tif net sous ciel couvert est dil a I'influence significative du rayonnement incident de grande longueur d'onde et au fort albedo de la surface (en moyenne 84% ). Les valeurs elevees du bila n radiatif net sont done liees a ux fortes valeurs du bilan radiatif de gran de longueur d 'onde et aux faibles valeurs du bilan de rayonnement de courtes longueurs d'onde. ZUSAMMENFASSUNG. Der Einjluss von Bewolkung allj die Gesamtstrahl,mgsbilanz einer Schneejliiche mit hoher Albedo. Die kurzwelligen und langwelligen Strahlungsstri:ime werden fur eine Station im Akkumulationsgebiet des Gri:inlandischen Inlandeises fur eine hochsommerliche Periode in ihrer gegenseitigen Abhangigkeit und ihrer Abhangigkeit von der Bewi:ilkung diskutiert. Bei 10/ 10 Bewi:ilkung erhalt man als Mittelwert fur die Tagessummen der Gesamtstrahlungsbilanz 270 J /cm2 d wahren:l bei 0/ 10 Bewi:ilkung nur 7~ .J /cm2 d resultieren. Der gri:issere Energiegewinn durch Strahlung bei bedecktem Himmel ist in dem signifikanten Einfluss d er langwelligen Einstrahlung und der hohen Albedo (Mittel 84% ) begrundet. Grosse vVerte der Gesamtstrahlungsbilanz sind daher mit hohen Werten del' langwelligen Strahlungsbilanz und geringen 'Vert ~ n del' kurzwelligen Strahlungsbilanz korreliert. INTRODUCTION Results of radiation balance measurements in the accumulation area of the Greenland ice sheet (station Carrefour, 1850 m a.s.!., lat. 69 ° 49' 25" N., long. 47 ° 25' 57" W., EGIG U 1967), made between 13 May and 28 July 1967, are discussed from the viewpoint of a paradox which may be formulated as follows: The daily totals of the net radiation balance of a snow surface with high albedo increase with increasing cloudiness. This is also valid for midsummer periods, when the extraterrestrial incoming short-wave radiation is extremely high. The core of the paradox lies in the accentuation of the validity of this statement during mid-summer periods. If it were restricted to periods with low solar elevation it would be a triviality. An analysis of the short-wave and long-wave radiation balance as dependent on the cloudiness makes the paradox understandable. Cloudiness decreases the short-wave radiation balance and increases long-wave radiation balance, which means that it has opposite effect in the two spectral ranges. From the results of measurements it follows that the influence oflongwave radiation balance prevails. Figure I gives a schematic drawing of radiant fluxes, the indices 0/10 and 10/ 10 being the degree of cloudiness. It shows that the incoming short-wave radiation G, the reflected short-wave radiation R, the incoming long-wave radiation A, and the outgoing long-wave radiation E, vary with cloudiness in the following manner: G(IO/IO) R( IO/ 10) ." : < < G(0/ 10), R(O/ IO), A(IO/10) E (10/10) 73 > A(0/10), ~ E (0/10). JOURN AL 74 OF GLACIO LOGY incomi ng extrate rrestri al shortw ave radiation I I ~ atmosp here clear sky overca st sky 0/10 10/10 R G shortw ave range A G E shortw ave range longwave range net radiation flux Fig. I. R A E longwave range B=G-R +A - £ Schematic drawing of the radiant jlllxes with clear and overcast sky. The mean values for the daily totals of the net radiatio n albedo of 84 % at Station Carrefo ur, are the following: * daily totals at 0 /10 cloudin ess: 18 daily totals at 10/ 10 cloudin ess: 65 differen ce: 47 balance B obtaine d for a mean cal/cm 2 d cal /cm 2 d cal/cm 2 d been studied in detail by The radiatio n balance of polar snow and ice surface s has already Holmg ren (1971), for (1970). s several authors , above all by Holmg ren (1971) and Hoinke (Devon Ice Cap) in s surface snow frozen of balance n radiatio exampl e found out that the 2 d with a clear sky. cal/cm 2 mid-su mmer is +40 cal/cm d with dense cloudiness, and +20 ly influen ced by long-w ave Hoinke s (1970) mentio ned that the net radiatio n balance is decisive on data from "Little (based evident being thus radiatio n balance , the influen ce of cloudin ess rn (1952), with Dirmhi and er Sauber a.s.l., m 000 3 at Americ a V", Antarc tica). In the Alps 2 d at 0/10 cloudin ess cal/cm 25 of balance n radiatio net a d an albedo of 80%, obtaine of snow and ice surface s and +69 cal/cm 2 d at 10/10. Furthe r studies on the radiatio n balance J). ([CI964 s have been reviewe d and discussed by Hoinke SHORT- WAVE RADIAN T FLUX AND CLOUDIN ESS ave radiatio n G and Figure 2 shows the ratio betwee n the daily totals of incomi ng short-w The ratio varies time. of n functio a as surface tal horizon a extrate rrestria l radiatio n I on '" SI-units: 1 cal/cm> d = 0.484 W/m2 ; 1 cal/cm 2 h = 11.63 W/m2. INFLUENCE OF CLOUDINESS ON NET R ADIATION 75 BALANC E ..... EGIG J[. HOOO - CARREFOUR :1=69°1,9 ' 25" N )., =1,7°25 ' 57 " W -900 -800 800 ~ 700 700 - ~600 600 - ~500 500 - I MAY JUNE JULY I 0,8 mean value =0,74 MAY Fig. - JUNE 21 ;: JULY D aily totals of extraterrestrial radiation on a horizontal surface I and of incoming short-wave radiation G as dependent on time. T he ratio CI I is plotted in the lower part of the diagram, the resulting mean value is 0.74 . 2. between 0.56 and 0.85, having a mean value of o. 74. These variations are due to differences in cloudiness (Fig. 3). At 10/ 10, they are large because of the different opacity of clouds. T he period of m easu rement is approximately symmetrical to 2 I June (Fig. 2), showing extremely high values of extraterrestrial radiation. LONG-WAVE RADIAT ION BALANCE AND CLOUDINESS Figure 4 confirms the relation between long-wave radiation balance and cloudiness which has been found over snow a nd ice surfaces already by several authors : T h e long-wave radiation balance shows strongly negative values at a cloudiness of 0/ 10 and slightly negative JOURNAL 6 _ 0,8 ~ 6 OF 6 66 _ 6_ 6 6 6 666 66 _ _ 6 6 GLACIOLOGY 66 6 6 6 6 66 6 6 6 - 6 6 6 66 66 6 666 1f6 6 6 ....... 6 11) 0,6 6- E ;:, 11) EG/GII ~ III "t> '- ~ 0,4 (!) 0, 2 cloudiness 0110 4110 2110 6110 . 10110 8110 Fig. 3. The ratio C/I (C = incoming short-wave radiation, I = extraterrestrial radiation) as afunction of cloudiness. -12 ~ ~ E ~ Iij ~ -10 lu , -8 !~ 1,09 11272 1,1 I '« I 1,0 3330 I ~ 50 o I I 0110 2110 o -8 '« -6 '03 "-+---+---+---t cloudiness frequency 100 -1 lu , 25 31 cloud. 0110 150 ~ Iij 59 o ----+---- +----0 r--+ ---+ 0 .. -12 ~ ""E ~ I -5 ...., ~! EGIGII 0 h r . 6110 8110 10/10 0 -2 I j - 0 -.2 cloud. 10lTO I - 50 100 frequency I '110 -4 +I, ~ 150 Fig. 4. The long-wave radiation balance A-E as a function of cloudiness (1247 individual values) . The arrows give the standard deviation, figures indicate numbers of samples for each group of cloudiness, the frequency distribution at 0/10 and 10/10 cloudiness are given in the left part and right part of the diagram. INFLUENCE OF CLO UDINESS ON NET RADIATION 77 BALANCE values at 10/10, the relation being interpreted better in terms of a quadratic law than a linear one. Hourly estimates of cloudiness and hourly totals of long-wave radiation balance were used for the evaluation, comprising I 247 individual observations. RADIATION BALANCE AND CLOUDINESS Figure 5 shows the daily totals of radiant ftuxes for two series of measurements over snow surfaces with high albedo (EGIG I, EGIG 11 ); for the EGIG I series (Camp IV-EGIG 1959, I 013 m a .s.!., lat. 69° 40' 05· N., long. 49° 37' 58· W .) only those daily totals which satisfy the condition of albedo larger than 70 % have been used. For EGIG 11, the condition of albedo larger than 70 % was satisfied throughout the whole series. The mean value of the albedo was 84%, a value which has been stated for dry snow surfaces of polar regions also by other authors . 800 (JOO ~ _6 600 ~--~ :>.:===:::::::::!"':!_ E "A -R "- 3 ~I.l _ _------~--: -R EGIG 11 mun 200 : : m~an ~/b~do~70% ~/G-R ~~G-R :-+--:t---+---+--- ~ 0110 400 EGIGI ~/b~do=84% -8 2110 4110 6110 8/10 ~ .- 200 -0-8 -------- t---t---t---t---t---t------. . . ~--A-E "A-E cloudiness -200 600 -6 400 o _E -A 10110 _______ 0110 cloudiness • o -200 2110 4110 6110 8110 10110 Fig . 5 . Daily totals of the ra:iiantjiuxes as dependent on the cloudiness for two series of meaSllrements (EGIG I and EGIG 11). For groups of cloudiness see Table I. The paradox is evident in Figure 5: The increase in the net radiation balance from minimum cloudiness toward maximum cloudiness, amounts in the case of EGIG I from 27 call cm2 d to 83 cal/cm 2d and in the case of EGIG 11 from 18 cal/cm 2d to 65 cal/cm 2d. In order to get a sufficient number of cases for the various groups of cloudiness, the classification of Table I was used. The increase in net radiation balance with cloudiness becomes better understa!ldable when comparing the respective dependence of short-wave and long-wave radiation balances on cloudiness. The increase in the long-wave balance A-E with increasing cloudiness is greater than the corresponding decrease of short-wave balance G-R. JOURNAL OF GLACIOLOGY TABLE I. GROUPS OF CLOUDINESS IN THE EGIG I AND EGIG II SERIES Groups of cloudiness c in the series of EGIG I : Estimation of cloudiness in tenths, three times a day o ~ c ~ 5.1; 1.5 < c ~ 4.5 ; 4·5 < c ~ 8.5; 8·5 < c ~ 10 Number of samples 3 3 3 8 Groups of cloudiness c in the series of EGIG II: Hourly estimations of cloudiness in tenths 0; 0 < c ~ 2; 2 < C ~ 4; 4 < c ~ 6; 6 < c ~ 8 ; 8 < c < 10; Number of samples 13 12 7 II 4 9 10 9 HOURLY VARIATIONS OF RADIANT FLUXES AS DEPENDENT ON CLOU DINESS Figure 6 gives the hourly variations of the radiant fluxes for a cloudiness OfO/ 1O and 10/10 and an albedo larger than 70%. Although the amplitude of the hourly variation of net radiation at 0 / 10 is larger than at 10/ I 0, at a cloudiness of 0 / 10 the daily total , represented as the area below the curve of B is composed of almost equal negative and positive parts. At a cloudiness of 10/10, however, only the positive part of net radiation balance will be important, as n egative values of B are negligible. 90 1 Albedo > 70%.cIo u d. 0/70 60 ~ 1~ 30 0 TST -20 Oh • 12h 24h EGIG J[ 90 Albedo> 70%,cloud. 10/70 60 ~ E ~ ~ u 30 o -20 • Fig. 6. Mean hourly variations of the radiant jiuxes G, R, A, E and B for a cloudiness of 0/ IO and la/la. INFLUENCE OF CLOUDINESS ON NET RADIATION 79 BALANCE .... ~ E .. ~ 100 r- ~ -.----+---------~--------_4----------+_--------~--------_4----------+ III I EGIG J[ A6. A6. 50 +--------+------+-----+-------+----- ~ 6. ll~ I> '" ---------t.._ o ---+---t---+--- ---+--100 200 A A '" '" A A'" i A I> '" --~+-a~~~+~~A~---+--- 300 I> J.A A -50 A A : - MJ. I I 1>'" I> I> AA '" II> I> I>"'~ I> A [cal/cm 2dJ ~ -f----- 500 ---+--- 500 I I i ! 700 Fig. 7. Relation between the incoming long-wave radiation A and the net radiation balance B. EGIG J[ + r,. ~slimal~d 50+-------+-------4-------~ + lA -50~~--4---~_4--~--+_~--~--~--~~--~i--~~ Fig. 8. Relation between the incoming short-wave radiation G and the net radiation balance B. 80 JOURNAL OF GLACIOLOGY RELATIONS BETWEEN THE RADIANT FLUXES (DAILY TOTALS) Hoinkes (1970) has already pointed out that the radiation balance at high albedo values is governed mainly by long-wave radiant fluxes. Figure 7 proves that the incoming long-wave radiant flux A is in positive correlation with the net radiation balance B. The range of values coincides also quantitatively with the range given by Hoinkes (1970) whose data, measured during the early Antarctic summer (September 1957 to January 1958), also show very well the range of negative values of net radiation balance. The incoming short-wave radiation G, however, is in a weak negative correlation to the net radiation balance B (Fig. 8). The fact that the present series of measurements is nearly symmetrical with respect to the solstice ( 13 May to 28 July) means that the change in extraterrestrial radiant flux is small. The relations between the net radiation balance B and the short-wave and long-wave balances are shown for individual months in Figure 9. Owing to the separate treatment of the individual months, changes of extraterrestrial radiant flux are of minor importance. Again, long-wave radiation balance A-E is in good positive correlation to the net radiation balance B; the short-wave radiation balance G-R, however, shows only weak negative correlation to the net radiation balance B. The relation between the short-wave radiation balance G- R and the long-wave radiation balance A- E in Figure 10 is still clearer. The paradox mentioned above is expressed numerically as follows: A decrease of the short-wave radiation balance G-R by 100 caljcmld (owing to increased cloudiness) is related to an increase of the long-wave radiation balance A-E by approximately 150 cal/cm 2 d . This relation is applicable to each individual month . Hence the quantitive explanation of the paradox follows: at a high albedo, a decrease (owing to greater cloudiness) in the short-wave radiation balance G-R even in mid-summer is more than compensated for by an increase in the long-wave radiation balance A- E. The energy gain owing to radiation is about 50 caljcm 2 d higher when the sky is overcast than when cloudless, although maximum values of the incoming short-wave radiation of more than 800 cal/cm 2 d occur in this period. On the basis of the measured radiant fluxes, it can be estimated that the effect under discussion occurs at an albedo larger than 75 %. This means that large areas of the polar i<;e sheets fulfill the c9ndition for this paradoxical effect. For hourly totals of net radiation balance, however, the paradox cannot in general be established. INSTRUMENTATION, CALIDRATlON AND EVALUATION Instrumentation, calibration and evaluation followed a method described earlier (Ambach, 1963). Two solarimeters (Moll-Gorczynski) and a Lupolene instrument by R. Schulze were used as radiation detectors . Calibration in the short-wave range was made in the field using direct solar radiation at levelled detector surfaces by means of a Linke-Feussner actinometer. The temperature coefficient of the instruments was applied. Calibration in the long-wave range was made in the laboratory following a previously described method (Ambach and others, 1963). For the evaluation, the difference in the sensitivities of the thermopiles of the Lupolene instrument to short-wave radiation and long-wave radiation was taken into account. The results of calibration in the short-wave range confirm the dependence of the calibration factor on solar elevation as observed in earlier studies. Because of an azimuth effect, there are slight differences in the calibration factor for series measured before noon and after noon (Fig. 11). The calibration factor for isotropic radiation 11 was calculated according to the formula given by Liljequist (1956) I ~ = f",. sin 2h f (h) dh, o INFLUENCE OF CLOUDINESS ON NET RADIATION EGIGI 100 100 I 53 E i Ii MAY_ III I I r C\j ~ 50 ~ I i , I '0 0 0 o 01 0 0% 0 0 1 I I - o -50 -100 JULY ~ c o °o l lXl o III o ---- ~ 6 b. 50 ~ III 6 o ---- -6- -6-A 11 b. /1 ~ I i 50 100 I E ~ Cij . 0- • - Ii -so 150 o C'\j 50 - 6 i 6 - ~ 100 i !tJ 6 · -r - I I 100 - I I -150 -t- I G-R fca/km 2dJb. 0 ~ -so - E i 6 ! I - !ti C'\j ! I I I A -£ [cal/cm 2dJ I I I i---- M~Y_ - - -I- 1 ---- + --~~t- ~-- ~--- o orP 0 ! o , 0 0 I I o 6 I I - 50 6 : 6 6 t~ _ _ _ _ ~ --b.-~-Q~~+---- . A-E [cal!cm 2dJ 00 JULY o 4:,-lr- ..... -~-- -+- ---0 G-R [ca/!cm 2dJ • I 6 /1/1 I I -50 81 BALANCE o 4 i L----+----+----+----...I-.----+----_ _ _~_ _____!1_50 -150 -100 -50 o 50 100 150 Fig. 9. Relation between the net radiation balance B and the long-wave radiation balance A-E, as well as short-wave radiation balance G-R. JO U RNAL .., '"E ...., ...., ~ E u -" " ~ l<J, ~ A A ~ ~A A A AA A '<{ A GLAC IOL OGY I ;:: '"E EGIG 1l ~ ~ -150 OF ~ - -r- A " - l<J, AA '<{ A ~ L!:l ..: A -150 A '<{ A A"l 6,AAA A AA A A A A AAA -100 -100 A A ~ A A AA A A A ;AA ~ - 50 A A -50 A A I A . o - -'- - + - -1- 0 100 2000 I ... 50 Fig. 10 . , A A G -R [callcm 2 dJ A A G-R [callcm 2 dJ AA A .. --'1--+--1- - .. 100 I I - 100 200 G- R [ca/lcm 2dJ 200 0 A I I MAY JUNE I I JULY I ... 50 Relalioll betwee/! the short-wave radiatioll balance G-R and the long-wave radiation balance A - E . t £GIGll ...., '" .-:: c: ;:, I ..; Jxl0-J o --:a:I.J,.-----I-- '" ·5 ~r: .......-: Lupo/~n~ radiom~l~r .6 -t ----- i I I ~ I , f.(z=OJ=2.7t.xl0-J- fSo/arim~l~r pt: f.(z=0J=1.5t.7xlO-J __ 1 I • morning 0 afl~rnoon I 1 600 Fig. 11. 1-- z~n;lh d;sl.. nc~ z 1 soo The calibration fa ctors of the solarimeter and of the L/lpolene instrument (Schulze ) as dependent on zenith distance. INFLUENCE OF CLOUDINESS ON NET RADIATION BALANCE where f (h) represents the dependence of the calibration factor on the solar elevation h, averaged over values measured in the morning and in the afternoon. For cloudless days, the evaluation was made by using the calibration factor as dependent on solar elevation. The share of sky radiation on cloudless days known from calibration measurements was evaluated with an adequate calibration factor h, which was calculated according to the formula given by Liljequist (1956) : Jcos h = f (h) dh. "/2 I h o Graphs for the evaluation of the formulae are shown in Figure 12. Days with a cloudiness of more than 0/ IO were treated with a calibration factor for isotropic radiation, as there exist no continuous records of diffuse sky radiation. The influence of the instrument holder on the albedo was accounted for by relative measurements with a portable solarimeter. EGIGI 4 , ,I Lupo/Me rlldiometer I ....... I / f ....... ....... 300 "..c: :::::;. ~ .!:; Cl) I , E ~ , / 800 I I I Solarimeter , E o.! 1 ~ '~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0 V) u V) u t ....... E o.! "- ~ .!:; 600 Cl) 1.00 Fig . Evaluation curves/or calculating the calibration/actor/or diffuse isotropic radiation and/or diffuse sky radiatioll with a clear sky. 12. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Fonds zur Forderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung is thanked for supporting the evaluations. I also want to thank Mr G. Markl for assisting in the field work and Mr P. Quehenberger and Mrs J. Conen for helping with the evaluation. MS. received 16 July 1973 JOURNAL OF GLACIOLOGY REFERENCES Ambach, W. 1953. Untersuchungen zum Energieumsatz in der Ablationszone des griinlandischen Inlandeises (Camp IV- EGIG, 59° 40' oS" N, 49° 37' SS" W). Meddelelser om Grenland, Bd. 174, Nr. 4· Ambach, W., and others. 1953. Ober die Eichung des Strahlungsbilanzmessers nach R. Schulze (Lupolengerat), von W. Ambach, E. Beschorner und H. [C.] Hoinkes. Archiv fur Meteorologie, Geophysik und Bioklimatologie, Ser. B, Bd. 13, Ht. I, p. 75-95. Hoinkes, H. C. [cI964.] Glacial meteorology. (In Odishaw, H ., ed. Research in geophysics. Vol. 2. Solid earth and interface phenomm!l. Cambridge, Mass. , Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, p . 391-424.) Hoinkes, H. C . 1970. Radiation budget at Little America V, 1957. [Union Geodisiq~e et Geophysiq~e Internationale. Association Internation~le d' Hydrologie Sci~'ltifique.] [International Council of Scientific Unions. Scientific Committee on Antarctic Research. International Association of Scientific Hydrology. Commission of Snow and Ice.] International Symposium on Antarctic Glaciological Exploration (lSAGE), Hanover, New Hampshire, U.S.A ., 3-7 September 1968, P· 25 3-84· Holmgren, B. 1971. Climate and energy exchange on a sub·polar ice cap in summer. Arctic Institute of North America Devon Island Expedition 1961 - 1963. Part E. Radi3.lion climate. Meddelandenfrdn Uppsala Universitets Meteorologiska Institution, Nr. I l l . Liljequist, G . H. 1956. Energy exchange of an Antarctic snowfield. Short-wave radiation (Maudheim, 71 ° 03' S., 10° 56' W.). Norwegian-British-Swedish Antarctic Expedition, 1949-52. Scientific Results, VoI. 2, Part lA. Sauberer, F., and Dirmhirn, I. 1952. Der Strahlungshaushalt horizontaler Gletscherflachen auf dem hohen Sonnblick. Geografiska Annaler, Arg. 34, Ht. 3-4, p . 251-g0.