New York City Invitational -- Lincoln-Douglas Debate
The Bronx High School of Science
October 14-16, 2011
Prelim Speakers in Order
H/L
D H/L
PTS
J VAR
WINS
RND
1.
Noah Star (Lexington NS -- Lexington)
147.5
88.5
206.5
1.77
6
323
2.
Josh Tupler (University JT -- University)
146.58
88.08
205.08
1.43
7
803
3.
Stephanie Franklin (Walt Whitman SF -- Walt W)
146.5
88
205
1.43
6
924
4.
Andrew Eckholm (Stuyvesant AE -- Stuyvesant)
146.5
88
205
1.42
7
370
5.
Michelle Choi (Harvard-Westlake MC -- Harvard)
146.5
88
204.5
1.36
6
805
6.
Rebecca Kuang (Greenhill RK -- Greenhill)
146.5
87.5
205
1.46
5
546
7.
Daniel Tartakovsky (PV Peninsula DT -- PV Pen)
146
87.5
205
1.42
6
694
8.
Jacob Pritt (New Orleans Jesuit JP -- New Orl)
145.75
87.25
204.75
1.47
6
341
9.
Michael Fried (University MF -- University)
145.5
87
204
1.26
6
494
10. Carlton Bone (Suncoast Community CB -- Suncoa)
145.5
87
204
1.26
5
740
11. Andrew Glantz (Brentwood AG -- Brentwood)
145.5
87
203.5
1.22
5
146
12. Regan Grishaber (Aliso Niguel RG -- Aliso Nig)
145
87.5
201.5
.92
5
255
13. Grant Weisberg (Stuyvesant GW -- Stuyvesant)
145
87
202.5
1.08
6
814
14. Jim Huang (New Orleans Jesuit JH -- New Orlea)
145
87
202.5
1.07
5
807
15. Clay Spence (Strake Jesuit CS -- Strake Jesui)
145
86.5
201.5
1.05
5
207
16. Henry Zhang (PV Peninsula HZ -- PV Peninsula)
144.5
87
203
1.14
6
748
17. Geoffrey Kristof (Scarsdale GK -- Scarsdale)
144.5
87
202
1.01
5
259
18. Elana Leone (CESJDS EL -- CESJDS)
144.5
87
201.5
.91
6
173
19. Drew McCormick (Strake Jesuit DM -- Strake Je)
144.5
87
198.5
.54
5
119
20. Farhan Damani (Greenhill FD -- Greenhill)
144.5
86.5
202.5
1.19
5
753
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
144.5
144.5
144
144
144
144
143.5
143.5
143.5
86.5
86.5
86.5
86.5
86.5
86
86.5
86
86
202
201.5
202
201.5
201.5
202
200
201.5
200.5
1.01
.9
.98
.95
.93
1.04
.88
.9
.79
5
4
5
5
5
5
4
6
6
731
130
279
187
494
650
550
413
634
Kathy Qiu (Hockaday KQ -- Hockaday)
David Joannides (Fordham Prep DJ -- Fordham P)
Tom Cameron (Loyola Blakefield TC -- Loyola B)
Robbie Steirn (Cypress Bay RS -- Cypress Bay)
Annie Kors (Harvard-Westlake AK -- Harvard-We)
Danny DeBois (Harrison DD -- Harrison)
Eric Han (Stuyvesant EH -- Stuyvesant)
John Heizelman (Strake Jesuit JH -- Strake Je)
Moses Sloven (Valley MS -- Valley)
RND
RND
New York City Invitational -- Lincoln-Douglas Debate
Page 2
The Bronx High School of Science
October 14-16, 2011
Prelim Speakers in Order
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
Deep Dheri (Montville DD -- Montville)
Kyle Allen-Niesen (Brentwood KA -- Brentwood)
Yang Yi (Millburn YY -- Millburn)
Christian Morris (Lake Highland CM -- Lake Hi)
Katie Seevers (Walt Whitman KS -- Walt Whitma)
Mollie Cowger (Hockaday MC -- Hockaday)
Terrence Lonam (Lake Highland TL -- Lake High)
Matt Zavislan (George Washington CO MZ -- Geo)
Ally Brabant (Harrison AB -- Harrison)
Jacob Nails (Starr's Mill JN -- Starr's Mill)
Alon Daks (Scarsdale AD -- Scarsdale)
Corbin Hopper (Berkeley Carroll CH -- Berkele)
Megan Nubel (Valley MN -- Valley)
Annie Zhu (Hockaday AZ -- Hockaday)
Sammi Cannold (Byram Hills SC -- Byram Hills)
Natalia Sucher (Beacon NS -- Beacon)
Charlie Lasswell (Hunter College CL -- Hunter)
Douglas Meyers (Scarsdale DM -- Scarsdale)
Michael O'Krent (Harvard-Westlake MO -- Harva)
Will McGrew (Benjamin Franklin WM -- Benjamin)
Abbey Chapman (Woodlands AC -- Woodlands)
Benjamin Fife (Scarsdale BF -- Scarsdale)
Rupsha Basu (Hockaday RB -- Hockaday)
Zach Edelman (Scarsdale ZE -- Scarsdale)
Howard Wei (Ridge HW -- Ridge)
Jessica Levy (Walt Whitman JL -- Walt Whitman)
Naila Dharani (Brentwood ND -- Brentwood)
Norberto Romero (Newark Science NR -- Newark )
William Meyer (Princeton WM -- Princeton)
Brendan Gallagher (Harvard-Westlake BG -- Har)
Sijin Choi (Benjamin N Cardozo SC -- Benjamin)
Paul Zhou (Lexington PZ -- Lexington)
Renee Cai (Hockaday RC -- Hockaday)
Samantha Hom (Stuyvesant SH -- Stuyvesant)
Clara Collier (Marlborough CC -- Marlborough)
Adam Hoffman (Lexington AH -- Lexington)
Arjun Tambe (PV Peninsula AT -- PV Peninsula)
Raghav Bansal (Durham RB -- Durham)
Arjun Balaji (Chelmsford AB -- Chelmsford)
Nathalia Cibotti (Walt Whitman NC -- Walt Whi)
Michael Moorin (duPont Manual MM -- duPont Ma)
Ryan Protter (Princeton RP -- Princeton)
William Kim (Strake Jesuit WK -- Strake Jesui)
Patty-Jane Geller (Harrison PG -- Harrison)
Shiv Malhotra (Millburn SM -- Millburn)
Kristen Druse (Monticello KD -- Monticello)
Ingrid Yin (Barrington IY -- Barrington)
Noah Thaler (Scarsdale NT -- Scarsdale)
Katherine Schulder-Batti (Berkeley Carroll KS)
Vivek Raj (duPont Manual VR -- duPont Manual)
Tommy Choi (Harvard-Westlake TC -- Harvard-We)
H/L
D H/L
PTS
J VAR
WINS
RND
143
143
143
143
142.5
142.5
142.5
142.5
142.5
142.5
142.5
142.5
142
142
142
142
142
142
142
142
142
141.5
141.5
141.5
141.5
141.5
141.5
141.25
141
141
141
141
141
140.58
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.5
140.25
140
140
140
139.83
139.5
86
86
86
86
85.5
85.5
85.5
85.5
85.5
85
85
84.5
85.5
85.5
85.5
85.5
85.5
85
85
85
85
85
85
85
85
84.5
84.5
84.75
85
84.5
84.5
84.5
84.5
84.08
85
84.5
84.5
84.5
84
84
84
84
84
84
84
84
84
84
84
84.33
84
201
200
199
196
199.5
199.5
199.5
199.5
199
200
198.5
200.5
199
199
198.5
198.5
197
199
198.5
198.5
197.5
199
198
198
197.5
199
198
197.75
197
197.5
197.5
197.5
197
196.58
197
197.5
197
170.5
198
197
197
196.5
196.5
196.5
196.5
197.75
196.5
196
195.5
194.83
195.5
.89
.7
.58
.12
.73
.71
.68
.65
.57
.74
.51
.77
.69
.65
.53
.5
.27
.55
.54
.52
.39
.61
.49
.44
.41
.57
.49
.37
.28
.39
.35
.34
.27
.38
.31
.38
.28
.7
.43
.28
.27
.25
.23
.2
.2
.4
.2
.16
.1
4
5
5
5
5
5
4
4
5
4
5
3
5
5
4
4
4
4
4
4
3
4
5
4
4
5
5
4
3
4
4
5
5
5
3
5
3
3
4
4
4
3
4
4
4
4
3
4
3
3
4
156
331
465
834
814
802
624
580
601
260
723
973
320
463
650
279
230
483
618
155
947
912
738
276
672
346
483
532
450
758
546
570
555
673
829
656
358
918
371
654
843
597
349
239
134
324
832
788
371
132
471
.26
RND
RND
New York City Invitational -- Lincoln-Douglas Debate
Page 3
The Bronx High School of Science
October 14-16, 2011
Prelim Speakers in Order
81. Alexa White (Newark Science AW -- Newark Scie)
82. Alex Liao (Ridge AL -- Ridge)
83. Hannah Samson (University HS -- University)
84. Sydney Bub (Brentwood SB -- Brentwood)
85. Michael Sands (Kinkaid MS -- Kinkaid)
86. Saahil Jain (University SJ -- University)
87. Jack Wilson (Ridge JW -- Ridge)
88. Jonathan Conklin (Monticello JC -- Monticello)
89. Shannon Carroll (Snohomish SC -- Snohomish)
90. Tori Seidenstein (Walt Whitman TS -- Walt Whi)
91. Jamis Barcott (Snohomish JB -- Snohomish)
92. Nikhil Nandu (Lake Highland NN -- Lake Highla)
93. Brent Freed (University BF -- University)
94. Daniel Zhao (Niskayuna DZ -- Niskayuna)
95. Jerry Chen (Lexington JC -- Lexington)
96. Julie Engel (Harvard-Westlake JE -- Harvard-W)
97. Emily Pasternack (Needham EP -- Needham)
98. Ryan Teehan (Delbarton RT -- Delbarton)
99. Hayley Kronthal (Harrison HK -- Harrison)
100.Sebastian De Armas (Trinity Prep SD -- Trinit)
101.Michael Yuan (Millburn MY -- Millburn)
102.Andrew O'Donahue (Collegiate AO -- Collegiate)
103.Sam Azbel (Lake Highland SA -- Lake Highland)
104.Alex Zhou (Valley AZ -- Valley)
105.Dustin Thomas (Monticello DT -- Monticello)
106.Isaac Hoffmann (James Madison Memoria IH -- J)
107.Neville Dusaj (Montville ND -- Montville)
108.Michelle Lee (Harvard-Westlake ML -- Harvard-)
109.Marie Bissell (duPont Manual MB -- duPont Man)
110.Brianna Lavelle (Lexington BL -- Lexington)
111.Julian Alvarez (Lake Highland JA -- Lake High)
112.Ariana Bagherian (Am Her Delray AB -- Am Her )
113.Jay Merritt (Myers Park JM -- Myers Park)
114.Rob Dyer (Potomac Senior RD -- Potomac Senior)
115.Jackson Lallas (Brentwood JL -- Brentwood)
116.Dane Chodos (Ridge DC -- Ridge)
117.Colin Murphy (Perkiomen Valley CM -- Perkiome)
118.Payton Shudak (Millard West PS -- Millard Wes)
119.Mathew Pregasen (Trinity Prep MP -- Trinity P)
120.Ben Slomski (Cathedral Prep BS -- Cathedral P)
121.Kevin Li (New Hope-Solebury KL -- New Hope-So)
122.Gujri Singh (West Windsor GS -- West Windsor)
123.Monica Amestoy (Flintridge SHA MA -- Flintrid)
124.Steve Phillips (Loyola Blakefield SP -- Loyol)
125.Josh Melnick (Lexington JM -- Lexington)
126.John Soneff (Brentwood JS -- Brentwood)
127.Amanda Drummond (Lake Highland AD -- Lake Hig)
128.Troy Thisler (Ft Lauderdale TT -- Ft Lauderda)
129.Arvind Raju (Trinity Prep AR -- Trinity Prep)
130.Christopher Li (Millburn CL -- Millburn)
131.Joseph Millman (Carpe Diem JM -- Carpe Diem)
H/L
D H/L
PTS
J VAR
WINS
RND
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.5
139.25
139
139
139
139
139
139
139
139
139
138.5
138.5
138.5
138.5
138
138
138
138
138
138
138
138
138
138
138
137.5
137.5
137.5
137.5
137.5
137.5
137
137
137
137
136.5
136.5
136.5
136.5
136.5
84
84
84
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.75
84
83.5
83.5
83.5
83.5
83
83
82.5
82
83.5
83.5
83
83
83.5
83
83
83
83
83
83
83
83
83
82.5
83
82.5
82.5
82.5
82.5
82
82.5
82.5
82
82
82
82
82
81.5
81.5
195.5
195
194
196
195.5
195.5
195.5
195.5
195
195
193
194.25
194.5
194.5
194.5
194.5
194.5
195
194.5
194
195
194
194
192
192
194
195
193
193
192.5
192.5
192.5
192.5
192
192
194
192.5
193.5
192
191
188
192
192
191.5
192
188
191.5
191.5
190.5
191.5
189
.24
.05
-.16
.12
.13
.08
.07
.05
.04
.01
-.3
-.06
-.08
.04
3
3
3
3
3
5
3
2
4
4
4
3
2
3
3
4
2
3
3
4
4
4
4
2
2
2
4
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
1
4
3
3
3
4
3
3
3
3
4
4
3
2
3
2
4
672
602
933
147
160
697
677
625
710
990
810
700
413
531
293
745
472
559
818
951
640
911
789
123
260
754
721
399
446
520
111
340
927
140
452
412
635
907
861
187
814
534
297
662
379
491
371
759
144
348
600
-.02
-.06
-.03
-.06
-.15
.06
-.01
-.15
-.36
-.37
-.16
-.01
-.21
-.29
-.24
-.36
-.37
-.37
-.36
-.43
-.12
-.33
-.08
-.44
-.59
-.88
-.39
-.41
-.51
-.35
-.93
-.51
-.52
-.62
-.5
-.82
RND
RND
New York City Invitational -- Lincoln-Douglas Debate
Page 4
The Bronx High School of Science
October 14-16, 2011
Prelim Speakers in Order
132.Matthew Agar-Johnson (Collegiate MA -- Colleg)
133.Akhil Jalan (PV Peninsula AJ -- PV Peninsula)
134.Loullyana Saney (Stuyvesant LS -- Stuyvesant)
135.Nathaniel Korn (Walt Whitman NK -- Walt Whitm)
136.Monica Shah (Barrington MS -- Barrington)
137.Chris Bird (duPont Manual CB -- duPont Manual)
138.Olivia Qiu (Montville OQ -- Montville)
139.Vivek Shimpi (Delbarton VS -- Delbarton)
140.Jordan Curry (Pinecrest JC -- Pinecrest)
141.Ethan Singer (Ft Lauderdale ES -- Ft Lauderda)
142.Lena Mandell (Fiorello LaGuardia LM -- Fiorel)
143.Breann Pugnetti (George Washington CO BP -- G)
144.Jake Steirn (Cypress Bay JS -- Cypress Bay)
145.Doron Darnov (Marlboro DD -- Marlboro)
146.Tyler Good-Cohn (Loyola Blakefield TG -- Loyo)
147.Alex Odonnell (Needham AO -- Needham)
148.Danielle Dinstein (Byram Hills DD -- Byram Hi)
149.Kanika Mohan (Trinity Prep KM -- Trinity Prep)
150.Timmy Makkar (North Allegheny TM -- North All)
151.Ian Vicnansky (Ft Lauderdale IV -- Ft Lauderd)
152.Jamie Fonarev (Lexington JF -- Lexington)
153.Lucas Smith (Monticello LS -- Monticello)
154.Victor Bramble (NFA VB -- NFA)
155.Jose Rodriguez (Cypress Bay JR -- Cypress Bay)
156.Jesse Pollac (Ft Lauderdale JP -- Ft Lauderda)
157.Lexi Leib (Byram Hills LL -- Byram Hills)
158.John Hordines (NFA JH -- NFA)
159.Casey Smith (Lake Mary Prep CS -- Lake Mary P)
160.Zaid Kajani (Kinkaid ZK -- Kinkaid)
161.Samuel Liu (Millburn SL -- Millburn)
162.Jonathan Wong (Benjamin N Cardozo JW -- Benja)
163.Andaya Sugayan (Snohomish AS -- Snohomish)
164.Luis Ramirez (NFA LR -- NFA)
165.Daniel Guerrero (Myers Park DG -- Myers Park)
166.Ashley Segovia (Lexington AS -- Lexington)
167.Jordan Kaplan (University JK -- University)
168.Chan Park (Hun CP -- Hun)
169.Nick DiBiase (Lake Mary Prep ND -- Lake Mary )
H/L
D H/L
PTS
J VAR
WINS
RND
136.33
136
136
136
136
135.5
135.5
135.5
135.5
135.5
135.5
135.5
135.5
135
135
135
135
134.58
134.5
134.5
134.5
134.5
134
134
133.66
133.5
133
132.91
132
131.91
131.5
131.5
131.25
130.91
130.5
130.5
130.5
130.25
81.33
82
81.5
81
81
81.5
81.5
81.5
81
81
81
81
81
81
81
81
81
80.58
81
80.5
80.5
80.5
81
80.5
80.16
80
80
80.41
80
78.91
79
78
78.25
78.41
78.5
78.5
78
77.25
191.33
190
192
191
190.5
189.5
189.5
189.5
190.5
190.5
190.5
189
188.5
189
189
188
164
189.58
188
189.5
187.5
186.5
188.5
186
186.66
189.5
185.5
184.91
184.5
184.91
185
185.5
183.75
184.91
183.5
181.5
183.5
183.75
-.38
-.73
-.3
-.57
-.57
-.74
-.79
-.81
-.59
-.65
-.67
-.82
-.9
-.67
-.82
-.87
-.44
-.72
-.98
-.79
-.95
-1.12
-.93
-1.3
-1.19
-.7
-1.36
-1.44
-1.51
-1.4
-1.29
-1.36
-1.6
-1.31
-1.6
-1.9
-1.64
-1.62
4
2
2
3
2
2
2
2
3
3
2
3
2
2
2
2
3
2
2
2
3
2
1
1
3
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
1
2
1
2
2
1
511
278
229
829
359
269
969
663
867
530
786
397
590
478
779
390
690
789
741
186
595
809
526
141
916
301
906
819
626
429
600
217
194
967
452
639
461
231
RND
RND