The US fiscal cliff

advertisement

The US fiscal cliff

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20237056

27 December 2012 Last updated at 10:56 GMT

Falling off the fiscal cliff would have a global economic impact, analysts say

Continue reading the main story

US Economy

Who first called it a 'fiscal cliff'?

Small firms wary of the cliff

Does California show the way?

Death, taxes and the GOP

The US faces a deadline to agree new legislation that could make or break the global economic recovery.

The so-called "fiscal cliff" has been on the horizon for two years, but now the 31

December deadline is almost here.

President Barack Obama has cut short his Christmas holiday in Hawaii to return to

Washington DC for yet more meetings to try to work out a solution. Negotiations are expected to continue right up to, or even slightly beyond, the end of the year.

Why are we here?

President Obama's administration has been at loggerheads with Congress over the level of government spending and tax rates. Congress refused to raise the US government's borrowing limit - the "debt ceiling" - which is set by statute.

But other legislation passed by Congress commits the federal government to spending and defines its ability to raise tax revenues, which threatens to push it through the statutory borrowing limit.

In a bid to break the stalemate, both sides agreed in August 2011 to set up a bi-partisan committee to find ways of capping US government spending over 10 years, plus find another $1.2tn (£758bn) in savings over the period.

The committee set its own ticking timebomb. Fail to reach a deal by 31 December, and automatic spending cuts and tax rises would be triggered. The committee failed.

Crisis jargon buster

Use the dropdown for easy-to-understand explanations of key financial terms:

Fiscal policy

Fiscal policy

The government's borrowing, spending and taxation decisions. If a government is worried that it is borrowing too much, it can engage in austerity - raising taxes and cutting spending. Alternatively, if a government is afraid that the economy is going into recession it can engage in fiscal stimulus - cutting taxes, raising spending and raising borrowing.

Glossary in full

What is the fiscal cliff?

On 31 December, a raft of temporary tax cuts is due to expire, just as huge automatic spending cuts are introduced.

This is the fiscal cliff that the US is staring over. Individuals and companies will be hit simultaneously with tax rises and reductions in government contracts, benefits and support.

Some $607bn of cuts and tax rises are planned, including reductions in the defence budget, the end of an employee tax holiday, changes to Medicare allowances and higher personal taxes.

The lower-paid will lose some child and income credits, while the long-term unemployed will lose their right to continue drawing benefits.

The political intention behind the cliff is that both sides have too much to lose:

Republicans are loath to allow the Bush-era tax cuts for high income earners to expire or defence spending be slashed; Democrats want to maintain President Obama's temporary measure to help the unemployed and low income earners, and to avoid deep cuts in nondefence spending.

To complicate matters further, the Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has warned that the government is running perilously close to its legal borrowing limit once again, although he has bought it an extra two months until the end of February through some accounting tricks.

President Obama has said he will not compromise on taxes for the rich

What are the origins of the crisis?

The roots of the current crisis date back to 2001, when President George W Bush's administration was trying to pass a programme of tax cuts worth $1.7bn.

Failure to secure the required majority in Congress meant the measures were pushed through under a rule that would result in the tax cuts expiring in 2011. In 2010, two years after Barack Obama was elected President, a deal was struck with the Republicancontrolled Congress to extend the deadline for two years.

Other tax changes and temporary spending measures were added to the legislation, which

President Obama hoped would bolster an economy that was sinking into recession and losing jobs at a rapid rate.

Why does it matter?

Analysts have painted a grim picture of the consequences for the world's largest economy, with some warning that the impact could push the long-running eurozone debt crisis into the shade.

"The US fiscal cliff represents the single biggest near-term threat to a global economic recovery," the Fitch ratings agency said recently. "The dramatic fiscal tightening implied by the fiscal cliff could tip the US and possibly the global economy into recession.

"At the very least it would be likely to halve the rate of global growth in 2013."

The IMF has warned that even the uncertainty raised by the fiscal cliff has hit global investment and job creation. If the US actually fell off the cliff it could knock possibly four percentage points of growth off the US and undermine the fragile confidence in the rest of the world, it said.

How will individuals suffer?

JP Morgan economist Michael Feroli has estimated that more than $550bn could be sucked out of the economy. "In all, the tax increases and spending cuts make up about 3.5% of

GDP, with the Bush tax cuts making up about half of that," he said.

The US-based Tax Policy Center (TPC) estimates that the average annual tax bill for each

American would rise by $3,500. The super-rich face an average tax rise of $120,500 a year, while the lowest earners will see an increase of about $412.

For the middle earners - about 60% of the population - the TPC estimates that the average annual tax rise would be about $2,000.

Tax year

How the Bush tax cuts were brought in

1993-

2000 2001 2002

2003-

2008

2009-

2012

2012 tax brackets

2013 scenarios

Tax cuts expire

Tax cuts expire for top incomes

Source: Tax Foundation, IRS

Tax brackets shown for unmarried individuals

President

Bottom

rate

Bill Clinton

15%

George W Bush

10% 10% 10%

Barack Obama

10%

Up to

$8,700

15% 15% 15% 15%

$8,700-

$35,350

28%

31%

27.5% 27% 25%

30.5% 30% 28%

25%

28%

15%

10%

15%

$35,350-

$85,650

28% 25%

$85,650-

$178,650 31%

28%

36%

Top rate 39.6%

35.5% 35% 33%

39.1% 38.6% 35%

33%

35%

$178,650-

$388,350 36%

33% or 36%*

Over

$388,350 39.6% 39.6%

*President Obama has previously called for the tax cut to expire for those earning over

$250,000

Surely there is scope for compromise?

Yes. And that is what all of the meetings in Washington have been trying to find.

Some analysts believe the problem is the very notion of a fiscal cliff itself; the idea of an all-or-nothing deadline after which the US economy could be forced into the abyss.

Economists Josh Bivens and Andrew Fieldhouse, in a paper for the Washington-based

Economic Policy Institute , say that "fiscal cliff" is a poor metaphor.

Policymakers should, instead, be talking of a fiscal obstacle course - a series of barriers that should be looked at individually and make compromise easier.

There may even be an opportunity for positive change, some argue, as policies that don't have any economic benefit can be replaced for tax changes or spending decisions that promote growth.

Getting rid of the Bush-era tax cuts for higher income earners (a focus of debate in

Washington) would have a negligible impact on economic growth, they argue. Whereas some of the automatic budget cuts would do harm.

"Policymakers and economic commentators should stop talking about the upcoming fiscal cliff and talk more plainly about what is needed," the two economists say, arguing that economic growth should be the priority in all policy decisions.

Republican John Boehner says Democrats should agree to more spending cuts

Any sign that Congress and the administration are taking this on board?

Republicans control the House of Representatives in Congress, and enjoy a blocking minority in the Democrat-controlled Senate, while the Democrat President Obama wields a veto, so any deal will need to be backed by both political parties.

Republicans seem to be coming round to the need for high income earners to pay more taxes. However, most Republican members of Congress have publicly pledged not to raise taxes.

One concession, outlined by Glenn Hubbard , economic advisor to the failed Mitt Romney presidential campaign, would have the rich pay more by closing tax loopholes that they currently benefit from.

President Obama however has claimed that such measures simply wouldn't raise enough tax to be worthwhile. He continues to insist that the Bush-era tax cuts for the wealthiest

2% must be allowed to expire.

The Republican Speaker of the House of Representatives, John Boehner, has also offered to allow the tax cut to expire just for those earning more than $1m as part of a compromise "Plan B" offer. But that has now been scrapped due to lack of support from his own party.

President Obama has previously insisted that taxes must rise on all those earning in excess of $250,000, but has offered to raise that threshold to $400,000.

He also offered a change to the way Social Security cost-of-living adjustments are made for some recipients, cuts to government healthcare programmes, and called for a two-year extension of the debt ceiling.

Is there a way forward?

This whole issue has been characterised by brinkmanship, with neither side refusing to blink first.

But as the collapse of the Republican Plan B shows, even when President Obama and Mr

Boehner do make concessions, they cannot be sure of bringing the rest of their party with them.

Mr Boehner's lack of control over the more extreme members of the Republican party is seen by analysts as both a liability, because of the difficulty carrying their votes, and an asset, as a way of forcing more concessions from the president.

But although the language on either side has sounded more conciliatory since the elections, the gap between their respective positions remains substantial.

Most analysts agree, however, that a deal will be done, because the alternative for both sides is so unpalatable.

Download