Business Sector Programme Support (BSPS)
Component 5: Business Sector Research with Institute of Labour Science and
Social Affairs (ILSSA) and Central Institute for Economic Management
(CIEM)
and
Poverty Reduction Grant (PRG)
Strengthening the Development Research and Policy Analysis Capacity of the
Central Institute for Economic Management (CIEM)
(Phase 2)
TRAVEL REPORT NO. 01/07
FOR TRAVEL TO VIETNAM UNDERTAKEN BY FINN TARP AND HENNING
TARP JENSEN JØRGEN BIRK MORTENSEN
JANUARY 2007
1. Introduction
This report briefly summarizes the activities and results of the travel to Vietnam undertaken by
Finn Tarp (5 to 15 January) and Henning Tarp Jensen (12 to 19 January) plus Jørgen Birk
Mortensen (7 to 16 January). The terms of reference (TOR) for the travel can be summarized as
follows:
1. Follow up on project implementation of the BSPS and PRG projects, and report to Danish
Embassy, CIEM and ILSSA.
2. Obtain comments on the following project outputs: provincial profiles, SME descriptive
report, and impact of WTO accession study. In addition agreement on publication steps
needs to be made. Also the final 2006 outputs under PRG research project 1 will be
reviewed.
3. Discussion of BSPS rural household survey, including final data base, and preparation of
analytical steps.
4. Planning of briefing trips to provinces in April.
5. Further work planning on PRG research projects 1 and 2
6. Ad hoc issues and work as required.
2. Activities performed and follow-up
The activities performed are summarized in accordance with the outline in the introduction in what
follows.
Ad. 1: Follow up on project implementation of the BSPS and PRG projects, and report to Danish
Embassy, CIEM and ILSSA.
Briefing and debriefing meetings were held with Henrik Vistisen of the Danish Embassy. The
same goes for Hong and Hoai (CIEM) and Vinh (ILSSA). All aspects of project planning and
implementation were reviewed.
Ad. 2: Finalization of deliverables/outputs
The following was achieved:
a. It was agreed with Ms. Hoai of CIEM that the DoE will submit all agreed 2006 research
deliverables under CIEM/Danida research project 1 before 1 February 2006 after so they
can be made publically available.
b. It was agreed with Dr. Thanh and Dr Huong of CIEM that they will provide any further
comments on 2006 WTO studies under CIEM/Danida research project 2 before end of
January 2007. Then the studies will be made publically available. Dr. Huong will draft a
policy brief on the basis of the two studies. The two concultancy reports still to be
delivered will be provided soonest.
c. It was agreed with Dr. Quang and Dr. Cuong of CIEM that they will provide any further
comments on the provincial profile study and the descriptive SME enterprise report before
end of January 2007. Then the studies will be made prepared for publication as soon as
possible. Policy briefs and news messages will be prepared in due course.
Ad. 3: BSPS rural household survey
The finalization of the 2006 BSPS rural household survey data occupied a central role during the
present visit. A considerable effort had been made by ILSSA staff to prepare for this and the data
were carefully reviewed. It will now form the basis for initiating the draft descriptive report which
will be continued in Copenhagen during the three-week visit of two CIEM and two IPSARD staff
from 25 January. Any corrections to the data base will also be discussed during this visit. The
planned deadline for the descriptive rural household report is end-March 2007 after work on indepth studies will begin.
-2 -
Ad. 4: Provincial visits/workshops
It was agreed with Dr. Quang, Dr. Cuong and Ms. Hoai that CIEM will take the lead on organising
two visits/workshops in Khanh Hoa and Nghe An in early May. In this work staff from
Copenhagen will be prepared to present and sicsuss the work carried out under the headings of the
2005 SME survey, 2006 Household survey and provincial profiles. Final dates should be
established soon for proper planning purposes.
Ad. 5: PRG research projects 1 and 2
A seminar entitled “Economic Analysis of Environmental Impact and Policy: Danish Experience
and Some Research Ideas for Vietnam” was organised by CIEM on 9 January. The programme is
attached in Annex 1. A news release on the seminar is being prepared and submitted to the Danish
Embassy. In the seminar Professor Jørgen Birk Mortensen gave a presentation on Danish
experiences and he also held meetings with a series of specialists in Vietnam, and provided
valuable input to the planning of environmental work under project 1. This work was agreed in a
series of meetings with Ms. Hong and Mr. Hai of CIEM, on the one hand, and F. Tarp, J. Birk
Mortensen and H. T. Jensen, on the side of DoE.
Henning Tarp Jensen subsequently followed up on the 2007 data requirements for research project
1 and 2 with GSO and CIEM. A set of mutually agreed TORs were developed, and they are
included in Annex 2.
Ad. 9: Ad hoc
A series of ad hoc activities were also carried out. They included in particular an intensive series of
data meetings with GSO to discuss access to relevant data and other information. Moreover, the
ASPS support to the rural household survey was reviewed with IPSARD and it was agreed that
DoE will contribute to the planned surveys in 2008 and 2010.
3. Final remarks
Work was carried out as planned in accordance with the TOR, and work is progressing smoothly
from 2006 to 2007.
The next visit of DoE has been planned for late April/early May 2007.
-3 -
Annex 1
PROGRAMME OF THE WORKSHOP
Economic Analysis of Environmental Impact and Policy:
International Experience and Some Research Ideas for Vietnam
Vietnam Trade Union Hotel, Hanoi, January 9, 2007
(Jointly organized by CIEM, MPI and DOE, Copenhagen University)
9 January 2007
08.00-08.30
08.30-9.00
9.00 - 9.45
09.45-10.15
10.15-10.35
10:35- 10:45
10:45 – 11:200
11:20 – 11:30
11:30 -
Registration
Opening remarks
Ass. Prof. Le Xuan Ba, CIEM
Vice President,
Prof. Finn Tarp, DoE,
University of Copenhagen
Chairs: Ass.Prof. Le Xuan Ba and Prof. Finn Tarp
Applied Environmental Economics Prof. Jǿrgen Birk Mortensen,
in the Danish Economic Council
DoE, University of
Copenhagen
Overview of Environmental Issues Mr. Nguyen Cong Thanh,
and Strategy in Vietnam
NEU – Project’s National
Consultant
Coffee break
Ideas of the Project’s Future
Prof. Finn Tarp, DOE,
Researches on Environmental
University of Copenhagen
Impact and Policy for Vietnam
Ms. Vu Xuan Nguyet Hong,
CIEM
Open Discussion
Conclusion
Ass. Prof. Le Xuan Ba
Lunch
At Western Restaurant,
1st floor, Vietnam Trade Union
Hotel
-4 -
Annex 2
TORs AGREED WITH GSO, CIEM AND DoE
Ha Noi, Vietnam
19. January, 2007
Terms of Reference: Time Series on Sector Level Data.
Counterpart: Government Statistical Office, Ha Noi.
Description of deliverables:


Item 1: Trade (yearly time series covering 1997-2005)
o Exports (112 IO sectors)
o Imports (112 IO sectors)
o Import Tariffs (112 IO sectors)
Delivery Date: February 19, 2007
Item 2: Prices (yearly time series covering 1999-2005)
o Producer Prices (112 IO sectors)
o Import Prices (112 IO sectors)
o Export Prices (112 IO sectors)
Delivery Date: March 19, 2007

Item 3: Investment by Sector of Destination (yearly time series covering 1999-2005)
o Government (infrastructure, health, education)
o Private Domestically Owned Enterprises (112 IO sectors)
o Private Foreign Owned Enterprises (112 IO sectors)
o State Enterprises (112 IO sectors)
Delivery Date: April 16, 2007

Item 4: Supply (yearly time series covering 1999-2005)
o Gross Output (112 IO sectors)
o Value Added at Factor Cost (112 IO sectors)
o Capital Value Added (112 IO sectors)
Delivery Date: April 30, 2007
Item 5: Other (longer time series)
o Gross Output (28 sectors; 1995-2005)
Delivery Date: May 14, 2007

Sector Specification (28 sectors – unique mapping to 112 IO sectors):



Agricultural Sectors (6): Paddy, Other Crops; Livestock & Poultry; Forestry; Fish
Farming; Fishery.
Industrial Sectors (15): Oil & Gas; Mining; Processed Seafood, Processed Rice; Other
Agricultural Processing; Textiles; Paper; Wood; Rubber; Non-Metallic Mineral Products;
Transport Equipment; Metal Products; Other Manufacturing; Electricity &
Water, Construction.
Service Sectors (7): Transport; Communication; Trade; Financial Services; Public
Administration; Hotels & Restaurants; Other Services.
-5 -
Total Payment: $6,500
Payment Schedule:




Initial Payment (January 22): $2,500
Upon Delivery of Items 1 & 2 (March 19): $1,000
Upon Delivery of Item 3 & 4 (April 30): $1,000
Final Payment upon Approval of Deliverables 1-5: $2,000
-6 -