STATUTORY FISHING RIGHTS ALLOCATION REVIEW PANEL IN THE MATTER OF: TREVOR GILMORE Applicant - and - AUSTRALIAN FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY Respondent ORDER 1. AFMA’s decision of 19 June 2007 as to the persons to whom a grant of Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) is to be made under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003 is set aside. 2. The Panel substitutes a decision as to the persons to whom a grant of SFRs is to be made under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003 in accordance with the Schedule attached and marked “Attachment A”. DATED Twenty-second of December 2008 Peter Baston Principal Member Statutory Fishing Rights Allocation Review Panel “Attachment A” Statutory Fishing Rights for the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Allocation of Quota Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003. CLIENT A G PURDON AJKA PTY LTD ALAN J ROBERTSON ANDREW F JOY ANKA FISHERIES PTY LTD ANTHONY & HEATHER GRAY ANTHONY GRAEME GRAY ANTHONY GUSS (GUSTO SUPER FUND) ANTONIO MUSUMECI ARTHUR MARKELLOS ARTHUR N & GAIL M SIFFORD ARTHUR N SIFFORD AUSTRALIAN CRAYFISH ENTERPRISES PTY LTD AUSTRALIAN FISHING ENTERPRISES PTY LTD BARRY G & VALMA J ALSOP BARRY J POWER BATFISH EDEN PTY LTD BEN BOYD FISHING CO PTY LTD BENJAMIN INNES BERNARD J KENNEDY BIRCHGOLD PTY LTD BLACK PYRAMID PTY LTD BLUEBEARDS SEAFOODS COMPANY P/L BRENDA ISABEL KLINGBERG BRETT MARTYN BRIAN J DAFF BRIAN K & HEATHER E BAILEY BRIAN S BOLDING BRUCE A TEDHAM C PUGLISI & SONS C R MARLOW & SON PTY LTD CAPE HOOD PTY LTD CHARISSA PTY LTD CHRIS CATSAMBALIS CHRISTINE M SECKOLD CHRISTOPHER & ANNE NEWMAN CRAIG A HARRISS & JUDITH A ROWLINGS ELEPHANT FISH 0 0 0 0 0 0 2176 0 0 0 0 2908 GUMMY SHARK 1208 1031 13889 7639 2605 0 49490 2040 0 3892 15144 42351 SCHOOL SHARK 248 47 1151 4483 0 2828 2417 0 0 0 2225 4491 SAW SHARK 4560 144880 23890 14377 1284 37111 15185 6016 16 0 20 2232 0 17 0 0 0 0 0 469 1044 856 0 21 604 55 0 0 15 6 236 5802 637 3655 692 19 12503 1924 0 17417 1035 41758 36662 9232 1208 2147 12733 8 0 2260 577 176 38 5929 3 840 0 0 409 397 30 1795 25 4623 8898 910 248 48 971 114 0 0 13 29 0 0 462 5623 0 13 2079 0 0 286 0 2539 661 2890 0 194 2165 0 745 0 338 185 0 4478 866 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8709 0 361 0 0 7137 2 Allocation of Quota Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003. CLIENT CRAIG D LAWRIE CRAIG GARLAND CRANVIC PTY LTD CULL FISHERIES PTY LTD CUNNINGHAM FISHERIES PTY LTD D R HIBBERD DARIN BROOKS DAVID & PAMELA WILSON DAVID A SHARP DELMARK HOLDINGS PTY LTD E, Z TOUMAZOS & SOUTHERN SEA EAGLES ELLIAAS & ZOE TOUMAZOS & SOUTHERN SEA EAGLES P/L ELLINAS & ZOE TOUMAZOS & SOUTHERN SEA EAGLES PTY LTD EMPRESS PEARL PTY LTD ENDYMON PTY LTD EOIN MALCOLM MCEACHERN ERIC G TAYLOR EW & VC JONES F & H TRAWLING CO. PTY LIMITED F C NEWMAN & M A M NEWMAN F M ROBERTS, M S THOMSEN, B J THOMSEN T/A T & R TRAWLING G & E PITLIANGAS PTY LTD G L & V R WALDEN G&E PITLIANGAS P/L, C, N & E PITLIANGAS, F & D HATZOPOULIS & F V VOTSIS-BIVOLTSIS GARRIE T HENNESS GARRY C WALTON GARY JOHN LLOYD GAZAK HOLDINGS PTY LTD GB & J COTTEE AND FC & M NEWMAN GEORGE TOWN SEAFOODS PTY LTD GERHARD WILMINK GREGORY HOWARD GREGORY PAUL PHILLIPS GUSTAV KRAUSE & JULIE KRAUSE H M FISHING CO PTY LTD IRONNET PTY LTD J & N JARVIS PTY LTD & DEWEBB PTY LTD J F, C R & A LAVALLE JACK MIRIKLIS MARINE PTY LTD ELEPHANT FISH 0 0 157 133 31 0 0 0 118 257 GUMMY SHARK 1556 715 450 565 244 47 7315 31 20017 9687 SCHOOL SHARK 247 334 205 10 2 9 57 46 6681 796 SAW SHARK 0 26787 25787 999 992 59478 6547 2661 465 31791 11163 411 5030 0 164 381 473 2 148 92 4037 12194 14825 1087 549 366 496 182 1193 426 5 0 15 2 0 619 1163 1415 236 1220 0 421 17 137 3203 0 57497 2119 18812 600 3397 1 754 17072 2893 3123 3 1 0 345 1126 5 11 0 0 0 0 898 237 15616 903 1502 49682 1105 5483 457 1965 6673 208 2015 26 5266 0 870 3319 1153 1165 0 467 2145 1 632 536 222 0 1505 7024 679 906 0 0 169 0 2678 302 1833 152 1004 126 357 2020 1211 155 806 907 628 0 0 3651 1091 662 0 0 0 4204 1963 3 Allocation of Quota Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003. CLIENT JAMES ALEXANDER HURSEY (SNR) JAMES P RACOVOLIS JARROD BRETT CHAMBERS JEFFREY W SCHMUCKER JIMMY ELIAS & SON P/L JOHN C GUILLOT JOHN CHARLES & CHERYL ANN GUILLOT JOHN E GRAY JOHN MAURICE BARRETT JOHN PALEOLOGOUDIAS JOHN R STEWART JOHN WILMOT & C WHEATLEY JOSEPH & WANDA STEVENS JOSEPH G PUGLISI K T NEWMAN KARL & FIONA KRAUSE KENNY FISHERIES PTY LTD KENTON G WAY KEVIN J GRAY KEVIN RONALD & CHERYL FRANCES NEWMAN KEVIN T, VT, KR & FE HASLAM KYRIAKOS TOUMAZOS L & A KAVADAS LEIGH CHAMBERS LEIGH COX LEIGH ROBERT & TANIA LYNETTE CASTLE LORAINE A & DAVID A HURSEY & J G SAYERS LORJONA PTY LTD LUCKY S FISHING PTY LTD M J GOULDEN MARK CHRISTOPHER NURSE & HAYLEY LOUISE NURSE MATTHEW P CONNALLY, DALE P CONNALLY & DIANE M CONNALLY MAYSAN P/L & ROSS HUGO MILLS MCLAUGHLIN CONSOLIDATED FISHERMEN LTD MERVYN H MARWOOD MICHAEL & TELLY ALESIOS MICHAEL A BELL MICHAEL J CRIPPS MICHAEL J O'NEILL ELEPHANT FISH 7 467 0 0 2 2985 GUMMY SHARK 13723 1563 1776 28953 27865 216 SCHOOL SHARK 2873 5 40 6136 12086 1197 SAW SHARK 232 681 548 1126 179 357 0 122 0 2581 0 0 0 0 0 447 799 6346 1794 18743 1886 21139 1176 5897 16 0 314 1121 0 857 0 6794 171 3407 0 252 270 33 169 20 974 506 0 697 0 5859 941 0 0 0 0 898 0 151 2 0 1899 0 599 0 0 46551 25056 5215 5301 6567 5573 16489 664 2877 0 14794 553 1152 4 0 0 2772 1660 4 0 3284 0 0 120 78 1555 848 9884 35884 269 1683 4549 1106 1863 6770 209 68 290 0 598 913 6 1665 37 1332 996 710 158 1496 0 371 0 0 0 0 0 6496 1208 2147 1909 1191 1100 248 7 92 0 41 0 0 0 0 291 1411 0 0 476 1000 4 Allocation of Quota Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003. CLIENT MICHAEL JOHN WHITE MICHAEL N KELLY MICHAEL PETER & SUSAN AMY MCCORMACK MICHAEL V HARDY MURES FISH CENTRE PTY LTD MURES FISHING PTY LTD N, E & C PITLIANGAS, F VOTSISBIVOLTSIS & F HATZOPOULOS NATHAN MAX ZWART NEALE BLUNDEN NEALE M LISK NEIL ANTHONY INNES NEIL WARREN HOSKING NICHOLAS POLGEEST OCEAN FRESH FISHERIES PTY LTD OPAL STAR FISHERIES PTY LTD ORION FISHING PTY LTD SUPERANNUATION FUND OWEN JAMES & CHRISTINE GRASSBY P, D & S CLARKE PACIFIC FISHERIES PTY LTD PARNKALLA INVESTMENTS PTY LTD PATRICK JAMES & MARIE DIANNE CLARK PATRICK JAMES CLARK PAUL A CLAUGHTON PERSY BARNETT FISHING CO PTY LTD PETER BELL PETER DOUGLAS ( DOUGLAS FISHING SUPER FUND) PETER G & UNA M ROCKLIFF PETER M LE MAITRE PETER TERENCE KELLY PIEDMONT INVESTMENTS PTY LTD R B LOWDEN PTY LTD RACOVOLIS AMALGAMATED FISH AGENTS PTY LTD RACOVOLIS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD RAPTIS FISHING LICENCES P/L RAYMOND & JUDITH A DICKIE RAYMOND J OTTEY RC & SE CUNNINGHAM RICHARD WILLIAM HOWARD ROBERT C CHIRGWIN ROBERT C MORGAN ELEPHANT FISH 60 617 GUMMY SHARK 3445 537 SCHOOL SHARK 397 136 SAW SHARK 0 136 259 0 0 60 23 1912 180 209 3503 496 1221 0 0 0 0 15521 210 0 0 0 0 0 309 41 41 0 5209 3925 40 145 18412 2714 304 19920 0 310 0 29 1448 248 154 11216 0 0 0 127 1280 1111 1674 510 0 0 6105 0 90 353 32 0 15824 515 70 15204 3033 0 13 4918 780 1086 0 0 197 14248 5549 2810 0 0 0 0 13729 10 3815 729 2485 10 630 0 8 0 0 553 9 1607 120 2874 1342 360 149 0 3008 160 1413 28494 1268 142411 427 19 6880 268 28240 3 1999 681 0 14027 360 1295 158 953 126 1578 2891 0 0 0 0 0 842 33857 31015 3443 626 410 636 1509 4 5745 5040 193 0 0 411 3495 1070 19425 6663 0 0 0 0 1 229 328 5 Allocation of Quota Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003. CLIENT ROBERT C YOUNG ROBERT FERGUSON ROBERT FISH ROBERT P BARRETT ROCKFISH 1 PTY LIMITED RODGER GRAHAM (SNR) RODNEY G & BRONWYN L CASEMENT RODNEY G CASEMENT RODNEY G SMITH RODNEY JW FRIEND ROGER MICHAEL FOURTER ROSMA FISHING CO PTY LIMITED RUSSELL C FROST S & J SEAFOOD SUPPLY PTY LTD S, S & J SOTIRAKIS SANPOOL FISHERIES PTY LTD SARRIBA PTY LTD SCOTT A GLUYAS SCOTT ALBERT GLUYAS (ATF JOTORI SUPERANUATION FUND) SHANE A BEVIS SHAUN V RANSOM AND VERONICA J PEARCE SHAYNE LESLIE BARLING & ANNMAREE FRIEND SIME SARIN SIMOAN PTY LTD SIMON K TIDSWELL SKYANEE PTY LTD SLIDELL PTY LTD STEPHEN GIBBONS & SUSAN CLEMENTS STEPHEN V CHAMBERS STEPHEN WILLIAM JOHN FARQUHAR STEVE SPRALJA STEVEN W CLARK SYDNEY FISH MARKET PTY LTD T & DP GUARNACCIA PTY LTD & HUNT MORREY PTY LTD T & M VAN BOOM & LUCAS HILL T & V PARISSOS TANIA L VON STANKE TASMAN BLUE PACIFIC PTY LTD THE FISH FACTORY PTY LTD FAMAZOS THEO PETER HAIRON ELEPHANT FISH 0 4250 0 0 0 0 3175 1934 0 357 292 1898 193 0 29 2288 392 0 GUMMY SHARK 2418 82940 2670 3014 108 9675 60538 55489 72 16805 918 55190 4965 12 1224 26855 2963 1999 SCHOOL SHARK 535 7371 1471 397 4 2266 5375 4984 520 958 322 3224 488 77 261 4995 486 418 SAW SHARK 0 6071 0 0 0 154 0 0 0 767 0 0 438 937 4 1741 0 31 65 2930 3117 28412 408 300 42538 60302 9954 230 13 13643 10399 150 151 430 8062 11557 0 2387 427 112 0 120 784 0 4176 18 260 25701 6 3409 0 1 925 0 906 3 914 5287 0 3811 115 219 83 521 2966 50 328 0 1998 0 55545 34417 0 0 35598 3 5887 21117 476 0 5416 10 8222 1546 287 1923 6089 0 0 14553 0 2 402 0 26121 16361 0 4235 608 5443 2305 0 2679 4037 2292 0 6 Allocation of Quota Statutory Fishing Rights (SFRs) under the Southern and Eastern Scalefish and Shark Fishery Management Plan 2003. CLIENT THEODORUS & MIRANDA VAN BOOM, LUCAS & MARGARET HILL THEOPHILOS TOUMAZOS TIMOTHY JOHN KIELY TOBERFISH PTY LTD TREVOR R GILMORE UDO WINKELHOFER V M HARDY VALENTE HOLDINGS PTY LTD VICKI A SMITH W J FOUNTAIN PTY LTD W M & J E CULL PTY LTD WAYNE L CHEERS WELLINGTON CAPE PTY LTD WILLIAM P RITTER WILLIAM R WATTS WOODSTEIN PTY LTD YOSHIKO STYNES ELEPHANT FISH GUMMY SHARK SCHOOL SHARK SAW SHARK 945 351 0 757 0 0 34 0 0 0 399 368 0 1365 422 591 9 242 15 17 5882 10677 1144 5429 4476 573 8608 49875 11683 222 1420 720 4767 3172 0 5732 917 0 635 951 839 34 10 14245 3703 11 9 21 851 37 0 1105 0 0 1174 0 0 0 7528 2457 35 554 2103 2125 1 498 280 125 7