Forays with Forams Patricia Miller, Ph.D., Earth & Environmental Science Educator MathScience Innovation Center Developed with funding from the MathScience Innovation Center Major Understanding Foraminifera, nicknamed "forams," are single-celled organisms that have inhabited Earth's marine and brackish waters for at least 550 million years, with thousands of species in both the fossil record and modern waters. Although forams are small, their importance to science is enormous! Because of their diversity, abundance, and sensitivity to environmental conditions, forams are used in petroleum exploration, stratigraphy, archaeology, coastal and estuarine ecology, and palaeooceanography. They are especially important indicators of changing conditions in oceans and estuaries, and of local and global climate change. Using hands-on activities and 21st century technology, students will explore how forams help scientists reconstruct ancient ocean conditions and track human impacts on the Chesapeake Bay. Grade/Subject ES, BIO, Ecology, Oceanography, Environmental Science, AP Environmental Science, AP Biology Objectives Introduce basic background information about forams as modern and fossil living organisms. (ES.11; BIO.5) Examine forams’ distinctive role as “proxies” for palaeoecology, palaeoclimatology, and water quality reconstructions. (ES.10, ES.11; BIO.8, BIO.9; AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VII.B; AP BIO LO 4.20, Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7) Reconstruct ocean evidence of changing climate using planktonic foram assemblages from an ocean sediment core. (ES.1, ES.2, ES.10, ES.11; BIO.1, BIO.8, BIO.9; AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VII.B; AP BIO LO 4.20, Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7 ) Track trends in environmental conditions in the Chesapeake Bay watershed from the 18th through 20th centuries using indicator species of benthic forams. (ES.2, ES.10, ES.11; BIO.8, BIO.9; AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VI.C; AP BIO LO 4.20, Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7 ) ; Time Forays with Forams Anticipatory Set: Forams – What & Why? Activity: Using planktonic forams to determine ocean climate history Activity: Chesapeake Bay – benthic forams as environmental indicators http://MathInScience.info 20 min 35 min 25 min © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 Discussion & closure Practice Assessments Materials 10 min Variable Variable For each team of three students: Student worksheet – one per team or per student. A simple way to place all of the worksheet on one piece of paper and to display each activity’s questions next to the data tables for the activity is to print the worksheets on tabloid sized paper, duplexed and flipped on the short edge. This orientation displays Pages 1 & 2 (first activity) on one side of the sheet and Pages 3 & 4 (second activity) on the other side. If printing on 8½ x 11” paper, print in portrait orientation and single-sided, so that students can separate the pages and place each activity’s data table page next to the questions page for the activity. One set of Deep Sea Core Samples sheets (laminated for re-use) Three copies of the Foram Provinces Key (printed double sided and laminated) One set of Patuxent Core Samples 1, 2, and 3 (laminated for re-use) Three copies of the identification key Major Benthic Foraminifera – Chesapeake Bay & Tidal Portions of Tributaries Set of 11 colored pencils, matched to the colors for the species in the Foram Provinces Key (many inexpensive sets of 10 or 12 colored pencils contain 10 of these colors; grey pencils can be purchased from Michael’s or A.C. Moore stores, or from online suppliers) Three Pink Pearl or similar erasers Small pencil sharpener (preferably one that will hold the shavings) Three dry erase or overhead projection markers. (Teachers will need to test to see which type of marker is compatible with the laminating film used for the Deep Sea and Patuxent Core Samples. Some combinations of dry erase markers and laminating film are extremely difficult to erase; in this case, overhead projection markers should be used.) Folder to hold the team’s laminated sheets Pencil pouch to hold colored pencils, erasers, pencil sharpener, and markers For the teacher: PowerPoint Presentation Student Worksheet Key Video: A Foram’s Tale “Molcer” software – 3-D viewer software, downloadable free from White Rabbit Corporation at http://www.white-rabbit.jp/molcerE.html Folder of selected foram species – files for 3-D and cat-scan views. Individual files should be hyperlinked to pictures in PowerPoint slide #6, as described in the Instructional Strategies section of the lesson plan. State and National Correlations Forays with Forams Virginia Standards of Learning: 2010 Earth Science (ES.1, ES.2, ES.10, ES.11); 2010 Biology (BIO.1, BIO.5, BIO.8, BIO.9) http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 AP Concepts and Science Practices: AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VI.C , VII.B; AP BIO LO 4.20, Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7 National Science Education Standards: Science in Regional & Social Perspectives; Environmental Quality; Natural & Human Induced Hazards; Science as Inquiry Instructional Strategies 1. Please note that in addition to the strategies outlined here, script and additional hints are included in the “Notes” portion of individual slides in the PowerPoint for this lesson. 2. Anticipatory Set: Forams – What and Why? This section of the lesson introduces basic background information about foraminifera (forams) and examines why forams are an important part of modern research in palaeoecology, palaeoclimatology and water quality reconstructions. For Slide 2, which introduces the lesson objective, use the slide’s notes to explain proxies and disciplines in which proxies are commonly used. Slides 3-6 cover basic information about modern and fossil forams; detailed notes accompany these slides; consult the notes for each slide. Slide 7 allows students to visualize several species of forams in 3-D, X-ray and cutaway views. Slide 8 contains a fascinating photo of a foram sculpture park and is hyperlinked to open the video “A Foram’s Tale,” featuring cutting edge research by internationally recognized scientists who are using modern forams and fossils of their species as proxies. 3. 3-D forams in Microscope View The lesson Forays with Forams is structured so that it can be taught in any classroom, regardless of whether microscopes or actual foram samples are available. In addition, the notes for this slide mention the time constraints involved with having students sort through numerous tiny foram specimens. The “samples” used in the two lesson activities are two-dimensional representations of forams viewed through a microscope. To supplement these views and to give students an idea of what they would see in three dimensions if they were actually manipulating forams shells on a microscope, Slide 7 contains nine 2-D illustrations of foram species from the identification chart Foram Provinces Key. Each of these illustrations in the slide should be hyperlinked to a file from the folder of files for 3-D and cat-scan views, as follows: ILLUSTRATION IN SLIDE 7 G. menardii P. obliquiloculata N. dutertrei G. siphonifera G. ruber Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info HYPERLINK TO : 000053_080423 menard.mol 000065_080423 p obliq.mol 000024_080423 neo duter.mol 000031_080423 g siph.mol 000027_080423 g ruber.mol © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 G. sacculifer G. inflata N. pachyderma G. bulloides 000039_080423 g sacc.mol 000030_080514 g infl.mol 000028_080423 neo pachy.mol 000073_081208 g bull.mol The 3-D/cat-scan files are from the series e-Foram Stock, electronic files constructed by scientists at Tohoku Unversity Museum in Japan, from cat scan tomography of actual foram tests and 3-D computer graphics reconstructions. Instructions for Using the 3-D Files: To display these files, you will need to download and install White Rabbit Corporation’s Molcer 3-D Image Viewer software, which can be downloaded free from their website http://www.whiterabbit.jp/molcerE.html. Project Slide 7 and explain that the students will be seeing the illustrations in their first activity (you may want to have the students view the illustrations on the laminated Foram Provinces Key while you do this). Click in turn on individual illustrations on the slide to open the associated hyperlinked e-Foram files. When each file opens, maximize it to full screen. The selected foram will appear in X-ray view inside a square made of thin white lines. (Note: The genus and species names displayed on the screen for the e-Foram may differ somewhat from those on Slide 7 and the Foram Provinces Key. The scientific names of particular species may have been changed since they were first described, and some references may contain either the older or the newer name; also, some researchers may use one of the names versus another. In the activities that follow the Anticipatory Set, we will use the genus and species names listed on the lesson’s laminated identification keys.) By dragging a side or a corner of the square, you will see that the image is actually a 3-D X-ray contained inside a square box. You can drag a side or corner of the box to rotate the 3-D X-ray image in a variety of directions and positions. You can also rotate the figures by using the rotate icons in the toolbar at the bottom of the screen, although this option is somewhat less versatile. [By clicking the “double rabbit” icon at the far right of the toolbar, the foram will display as a highly magnified view of the solid exterior of the foram, such as a student might observe under a binocular microscope or in a scanning electron microscope (SEM). This view may also be rotated by dragging or by using the rotation tools in the software’s toolbar. Rotating the solid view in this way gives the students a feel for what they might see if they were manipulating actual foram specimens on a microscope. (Clicking the “double rabbit” icon again will return the foram to its X-ray view.) With the foram in either the solid or X-ray view, clicking the carrot icon in the toolbar will produce a cut-away view of the interior of the foram’s test. Note that the carrot icon changes to a “sliced” half-carrot when this view is displayed, and also note that the icon of the “rabbit sticking its head through a square” becomes highlighted and active. Clicking this latter icon will display a Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 green square on the main image, representing the plane of the cut-away “slice,” inside the frame box that contains the foram (note that the rabbit head will disappear from the toolbar icon, leaving only a green-outline square icon). You can then drag a side or a corner of the green square on the main image to change the plane of the cut-away. If you then click the green square icon, the rabbit head will re-appear, and you can then rotate the box containing the foram to view the new cut-away image in various orientations. Clicking the carrot toolbar icon again will return the foram to its original full Xray or solid view and will de-activate the “rabbit sticking its head through a square” icon. If your course schedule allows, you may like to have your students experience 3-D and microscope examination of forams as detailed in the Extension section of this lesson plan. 4. Sculptural Forams: Slide 8 has a photo of a foram sculpture park in China. Students viewing forams through a microscope or in the e-Foram files are frequently captivated by the beauty and complexity of the tiny tests of these single-celled organisms. Many of the tests resemble microscopic sculptures, so it’s not surprising that even non-scientists have noticed forams’ beauty and variety! A sculptor and a scientist who works with forams collaborated to create a group of very large sculptures of forams, which are situated in a foram sculpture park in China. Visitors can stroll the path, examine the sculptures and read the information on the plaques for each sculpture. Slide 9 shows the work of a very creative baker, who decorated an apple pie with marzipan forams! The photo in Slide 9 should be hyperlinked to the video “A Foram’s Tale.” Alert the students about what to watch for: (1) cutting edge scientific research using modern forams and fossils of their species as proxies for palaeoclimate; (2) scientists handling ocean sediment cores, diving to collect living forams, working with living forams in various water conditions in the lab and examining fossils foram tests under the microscope; (3) footage of living forams moving and feeding. In projection mode, click on the photo to open the video. ACTIVITY: Using Planktonic Forams to Determine Ocean Climate History – New Zealand It is recommended that students work in teams of three for this activity and share their data. If more time is available for this lesson and materials are sufficient, you may have each individual student complete the entire activity. PowerPoint slides 10-18 provide introduction to the activity. Detailed notes accompany these slides. Slide 11 presents the objectives of the activity: identify foram species indicative of foraminiferal provinces (ocean climate regions); use Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 pie chart graphs of species percentages to determine foraminiferal provinces for several samples from a single ocean core; determine how ocean climate changed during the time period represented by the samples, and examine possible causes. Slide 12 illustrates the concept of Foraminiferal Provinces, or “ocean climate zones,” and how fossil foram assemblages (many of which we understand as proxies from work with modern, living forams, as in the video “A Foram’s Tale”) from ocean sediment cores can be used to trace changes in these zones through earlier times in Earth’s history. Slide 13 shows the location of the ocean sediment core on which this activity is based. Because of time constraints of sorting actual formaninfera from sediment, the activity utilizes representations of forams found in three sediment layers, representing three time periods ranging from 20,000 to 10,000 years ago. Slide 14 illustrates the layers and their ages. Remind the students that the oldest layer (the one deposited first) is on the bottom of the sequence – if using this lesson for an earth science class, ask them for the stratigraphic principle that states this relationship (Principle of Superposition). If you have access to actual core material, you may want to show it (and typical core layering) to the class. Alternatively, you can construct a simple model of a core using a 1½ or 2½ inch clear snap-top pill vial, filling it with three separate materials (e.g., sand, fine vermiculite, fine aquarium gravel) to represent the three layers, replacing the top, and using small adhesive labels on the outside of the vial to number the layers. Cutting small circles of overhead transparency film and inserting them between layers as you add each material will help keep the three layers separate. Instructions for the activity are on Page 1 of the Student Worksheet. Slides 1518 illustrate these instructions and provide additional hints. Slide 15 shows one of the three sheets representing microscope views of forams cleaned and separated from their respective sediment layers; this slide indicates the location of layer number and age on each of the sheets. The slide illustrates the use of the Foram Province Key to identify foram species. Students may use dry erase or overhead markers to keep track of forams identified. The number of each species in the sample should be recorded in the appropriate column in the data table on Page 2. Slide 16 illustrates one particular species that is recorded somewhat differently. This species, Neogloboquadrina pachyderma, which still inhabits modern oceans, is unusual in that it builds it shell coiling in one direction if it is living in warm water (so-called “right coiling”) and coiling in the opposite (mirror image – so-called “left coiling”) direction if it is living in cold water. (For many years, scientists have used relative percentages of right and left coiling N. pachyderma from ocean sediments to estimate ancient ocean temperatures; for an activity involving this kind of analysis, see MSiC’s lesson Climate Detectives. Caution the students that if they find this species in their sample, they will need to examine each individual carefully to match it exactly to the Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 correct coiling direction on the Foram Province Key. If more than half of the forams of this species in a sample coil to the right, record the total number of N. pachyderma in the corresponding space (8th from top) in the data column. If more than half of the forams of this species in a sample coil to the left, record the total number of N. pachyderma in the corresponding space (2nd from bottom) in the data column. Students should not enter any numbers in the last space in the column unless a sample is composed almost entirely of left-coiling N. pachyderma. Some researchers, particularly if they are analyzing a large number of samples from a core, use a pie-chart “shorthand” to identify, at a glance, a particular sample’s Foraminiferal Province or to track changes and trends in ocean climate during the time interval represented by the core. Note on the Foram Province Key that certain groupings of colors associated with individual foram species are associated with specific Foram Provinces (e.g., reds and oranges with tropical provinces). By plotting on a pie chart the percentage of each species in a sample, using the color associated with the species in the ID chart, one can visually estimate the Foram Province for the sample by the grouping of the dominant colors in the completed pie chart. Slides 17 and 18 use a hypothetical example to illustrate how this is done. Remind students that this is only an example, and their results will probably be different from the illustration. Each team member converts the number of each species in their sample to percent of the total forams in the sample. To simplify this exercise in the interest of time, each sample on the laminated sheets contains 25 forams (with species proportional to the percentages in the actual core). Students can check their data by adding the numbers of indicator species recorded for each sample, making sure the total equals 25, and they can check their conversions to percents by adding all percentages in a sample, making sure the total equals 100%. Slide 17: The blank pie charts are divided into 20 segments, each representing 5%. Starting at the top of the pie (“12 o’clock” position) and proceeding clockwise, the students should plot the species from their sample in the order they are listed in the Data Sheet, coloring in the percentage of each indicator species using the colored pencils corresponding to the colors in the identification key. Slide 18: Use the dominant colors in the pie chart and the Identification Key to determine the Foraminiferal Province for each of the three samples. In this example, greens and yellow dominate the pie chart - on the Identification Key these are the colors (and foram assemblage) indicative of the Subtropical Province. NOTE: In this lesson plan, students color the pie charts by hand with colored pencils. If your students have access to spreadsheets or graphing calculators in which they can specify the 11 colors used in the identification Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 key, they may create their pie charts using one of these tools. Based on their shared data and their resulting pie charts, the teams should discuss and complete Questions 5 and 6 on page 1 of the worksheet. The entire class then reviews and discusses the activity and the questions. Cleanup: If dry erase markers have been used, students should use a Kimwipe or facial tissue to erase them from the laminated sheets for the three core samples. If overhead markers have been used, students should erase them with a damp paper towel. Core sample sheets and Foram Provinces Keys should be returned to the team’s folder, and colored pencils, pencil sharpener and erasers returned to the team’s pencil pouch. ACTIVITY: Chesapeake Bay – Benthic Forams As Environmental Indicators Students continue to work in teams of 3. PowerPoint slides 19-28 provide introduction to the activity. Detailed notes accompany these slides. Slide 20 presents the objectives of the activity: identify key benthic foram species in several simulated samples from a core of Chesapeake Bay sediment; calculate species percentages in each sample; determine trends in environmental conditions in the Bay’s watershed during the time period represented by the samples and examine possible causes. Slides 21 and 22 review the major problem affecting the Bay: excess nutrient input causing eutrophication. Slide 22 illustrates sources of nutrient pollution and the process and effects of eutrophication within the Bay’s waters. Be sure to point out a major source that many people often forget – atmospheric deposition of nitrogen, which originates from vehicle exhausts and power plant emissions. Slide 23 explains how benthic forams can be useful indicators in studies of water pollution and other environmental stressors (salinity, climate or hydrological conditions) in coastal and estuarine environments. Although scientists understand the major problems affecting the Bay today and in the past few decades, when did these problems begin? Have other stressors affected the Bay’s water quality during recent centuries, and if so, can these stressors possibly affect the Bay again? How can we approach these questions for parts of the Bay’s history prior to modern intensive scientific studies? In this activity, students will use 3 laminated sheets with representations of microscope views of benthic forams from seven samples from a sediment core retrieved from the tidal Patuxent River (Maryland) where it joins the Bay (the field of view in these representations is the same as that for the New Zealand core, approximately 6 mm. The representations are based on actual research data. The Bay watershed and location of the core are shown in Slide 24. Slide 25 lists calendar year dates for the foram samples. Slide 26 shows one of the core sample sheets. The calendar year of each sample Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 is indicated directly above the sample’s microscope view. The slide also illustrates the use of the identification key for determining species. Slide 27 illustrates recording of foram numbers and species percentages. The instructions for this activity are at the top of Page 3 of the Student Worksheet and are similar to the first part of the planktonic forams activity. Each team member will work with one of the sheets, using the identification key for Major Benthic Foraminifera to identify and record the number of each indicator species present in each of their samples and recording numbers of each species present in the data table on Page 4. Students may use dry erase or overhead markers to keep track of forams identified in a sample. To simplify this exercise in the interest of time, each sample contains 20 forams (with species proportional to the percentages in the actual core). Students can check their data by adding the numbers of indicator species recorded for each sample year, making sure the total equals 20. For each species identified in a sample, students calculate and record that species’ percentage of the total forams in the sample. Because each sample contains 20 forams, 100% of the sample is 20 * 5, so students can use the same proportion to determine each individual species’ percentage. They can check their calculations by adding all percentages in a sample year, making sure the total equals 100. Team members will share their results. Using the results in the data table and the descriptions of the benthic foram species in the identification key (illustrated on Slide 28), student should answer Questions 4-9 on Page 3 of the worksheet. (Note that salinity numbers in the key are in per mil.) Slide 29 illustrates some tree rings related to Question 10 – this slide can be projected while the students work on the questions and during the discussion afterward. Question 10 cannot be answered directly from the data in this activity, but students should use what they have learned to predict what they might expect to see in a Chesapeake Bay sediment core sample from the time period indicated in this question. The class should discuss their responses to the questions. Cleanup: Depending on the kind of markers used, use Kimwipes or damp paper towels to clean markers from the laminated core sample sheets. Replace the sheets and identification keys in the folder and return the markers to the pencil pouch. Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 Practice 1. “Finding Neo” Activity in MSiC’s Lesson Climate Detectives (search “Climate Detectives” on http://MathInScience.info) In an activity based on actual ocean core data, students analyze 2-D simulated microscope views of Neogloboquadrina pachyderma samples to determine proportions of “right coiling” vs. “left coiling” tests and thus relative ocean temperatures during the time interval represented by the samples. 2. Tracking Global Climate Change: Microfossil Record of the Planetary Heat Pump – Paul Loubere http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Loubere.html Part of the University of California Museum of Palaeontology series “Learning from the Fossil Record,” this classroom lesson contains two exercises that may be useful for further practice: (1) Exercise: Interpreting Foraminiferal Percentages, and (2) Exercise: The Atlantic During the Last Glacial Epoch. Both exercises apply the use of forams as climate proxies. Closure As part of lesson closure, some questions to discuss might include: How can forams be used as proxies to determine climate trends and water quality trends for ocean and estuarine waters in times past (prior to reliable scientific investigations)? Why is it important to be able to do this? Why are forams unusually effective proxies for these kinds of information? Cleanup of the materials is listed in the lesson plan instructions for each of the two activities. Extensions Forays with Forams University of California Museum of Palaeontology’s (Berkeley) website Learning from the Fossil Record http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Learning.html contains a wealth of information about foraminifera, along with some excellent extension activities: Microfossils by Jere Lipps provides an overview of the use of various microfossils, including forams, for teaching science at a variety of levels. http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Lipps1.html Foram Facts – An Introduction to Foraminifera by Karen Wetmore provides extensive background information about forams. http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Wetmore.html Preparation Techniques for Use of Foraminifera in the Classroom by Scott Snyder and Brian Huber discusses collection, processing, concentrating, and examination of forams in the science classroom. http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Snyder&Huber.html Using Microfossils in Petroleum Exploration by Brian J. O’Neill discusses the use of microfossils for biostratigraphy and palaeonvironmental analysis in exploration for oil and gas. http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/ONeill.html http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 Assessment Foraminifera in the Middle School Classroom (http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Olson1.html) Climate Analysis Using Planktonic Foraminifera (http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Olson2.html) Inferring Ancient Environments from Fossil Foraminifera (http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/fosrec/Olson3.html) all by Hilary Clement Olson discuss the benefits to students of using forams in middle school life science and earth science and include two middle school classroom exercises. Sample items are provided for use in checking students’ understanding. For the student product’s resources, please provide the students with a list OF links including those listed in the Extensions and Resources sections of this lesson plan. Student Paper-Pencil Quiz and Answer Key Student Product and Grading Rubric The following table shows how the assessment items are related to specific objectives. Objective Introduce basic background information about forams as modern and fossil living organisms. (ES.11; BIO.5) Forays with Forams PaperPencil Quiz 4, 7, 8 Examine forams’ distinctive role as “proxies” for palaeoecology, palaeoclimatology and water quality reconstructions. (ES.10, ES.11; BIO.8, BIO.9; AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VII.B; AP BIO LO 4.20; Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7) 2, 3 Reconstruct ocean evidence of changing climate, using planktonic foram assemblages from an ocean sediment core. (ES.1, ES.2, ES.10, ES.11; BIO.1, BIO.8, BIO.9; AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VII.B; AP BIO LO 4.20, Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7 ) 5, 6 Track trends in environmental conditions in the Chesapeake Bay watershed from the 18th through 20th centuries, using indicator species 1, 5 http://MathInScience.info Product/ Performance Student Product © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 of benthic forams. (ES.2, ES.10, ES.11; BIO.8, BIO.9; AP ES I.A, II.A, II.D, VI.C; AP BIO LO 4.20, Sci Prac 1, 2, 5, 6, 7 ) Teaching Tips Discussion and instructions for using the Molcer 3-D Image Viewer to display three dimensional images of forams are provided in Section 3 of Instructional Strategies. References Foraminifera EU Project This project was established to foster the interest in foraminifera and provide valuable information for everyone from amateurs to senior scientists. The project, which has a long list of contributing scientists from around the globe, maintains a website with an extensive image database, articles and publications, technical hints, localities, a newsletter, a Facebook page and other resources http://www.foraminifera.eu/ and https://www.facebook.com/foraminifera.eu Kane Scientific Company http://www.kaneforam.com/ is a supplier of models of fossil forams. Manighetti & Northcote, Fabulous Foraminifera: examining past climates using microscopic marine organisms, v. 8 no. 3, September 2000, Water & Atmosphere Online, National Institute of Water & Atmospheric Research Ltd., New Zealand. Microfossil Image Recovery And Circulation for Learning and Education ("MIRACLE") website Postgraduate Unit of Micropalaeontology at University College London Foraminifera are one of seven groups of microfossils features on this website. Forams are given a brief introduction, followed by a very simplified, illustrated evolutionary history and a series of images. Useful reference site. http://www.ucl.ac.uk/GeolSci/micropal/foram.html Murray, John, 2006, Ecology and applications of benthic foraminifera. New York, Cambridge University Press. Reference text. Poster: Foraminifera—Earth's Microscopic Recordkeepers Howard Hughes Medical Institute, BioInteractive Resources for Science Teachers & Studentsconcerning water. This poster illustrates forams many shapes and sizes and details the importance of foraminifera in discovering significant changes in Earth's past: as timekeepers of geologic age, as indicators of mass extinction and climate changes and as pollution monitors. http://www.hhmi.org/biointeractive/poster-foraminifera-earths-microscopicrecordkeepers Scott, D.B., F.S. Medioli, and C.T. Schafer, 2001. Monitoring Coastal Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014 Environments Using Foraminifera and Thecamoebian Indicators. New York, Cambridge University Press. Reference text. MathScience Innovation Center Information on educational programs and resources available to students, teachers and school divisions, along with procedures for registering for programs. www.MyMSiC.org MathScience Innovation Center: Online Resources Learn through online virtual classrooms, web-based lessons and online courses. Access proven lesson plans and instructional modules. www.mathinscience.info Forays with Forams http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2014