IEEE SYSTEMS JOURNAL
REVIEW FORM
Paper Number:
Title:
Author(s):
OVERALL EVALUATION:
Contribution: Very Significant______ Important ________ Tutorial_______ Minor___ None____
Quality: Excellent_____ Good______ Fair______ Poor______
RECOMMENDATION: (Important, please read page 2, then check appropriate statements below)
_____ Accept as is
_____ Accept with minor revisions by author or editor require no re-review
_____ Accept if needed. Complete rewriting is required. Comments on page 2.
_____ Reject
______ Not applicable (out of scope)
CONFIDENTIAL RECOMMENDATIONS AND COMMENTS FOR EDITOR(s):
SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS AND COMMENTS FOR AUTHOR:
IMPORTANT: Specific comments to be sent to the author should be written, without identifying yourself,
on second page and additional pages if warranted.
PLEASE RETURN THIS FORM BEFORE ___________________
REFEREE’S NAME AND EMAIL:
______________________________
_______________________________
Date ______________.
Please e-mail the review to isj@unimi.it
Paper Review
REFEREE'S COMMENTS (To be sent to author)
Paper Number ________________
(SUGGESTIONS TO THE REFEREE: Please do the following: 1) Answer the 3 questions below, 2)
briefly state your version of the contribution being made, and 3) indicate to the author any corrections
which should be made and describe how the paper can be improved with revisions or rewriting.)
1) Does the Introduction state the purpose of the paper? __________
2) Is the significance of the paper explained relative to previous work? __________
3) Is the paper clearly written and well organized? _________
4) Briefly, the contribution of the paper appears to be the following:
Suggestions for improving the paper: (Use extra page, if necessary)