DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE
TRINITY COLLEGE
Senior Freshman course 2013-2014
History of Political Thought (PO2610)
EDDIE HYLAND Contact: [email protected] Tel Ext. 1100
OVERVIEW
The general aim of the course is to introduce students to the emergence and
development of the major ideas, theories and controversies in political thought from
the time of classical Greece to the beginning of the twentieth century. The course
will fall into four fairly distinct sections.
1.
In the first we will deal with the classical world of Greece and Rome: we will
be looking at the first emergence of such ideas as “democracy”, “justice”, “natural
law” and so on.
2.
In the second section we will treat of the influence of Christianity on political
thought in the medieval period.
3. Thirdly, we look at the great flourishing of political theory in the
16th-18th
centuries, with special reference to such topics as the nature of man and
society, the social contract, the nature of the state, the function and limits
of government.
4. The final section encompasses those theorists of the 19th century who
contributed to the formulation of the political problems of the present era,
such as Marx and J. S. Mill.
LEARNING OUTCOMES
Students should acquire a general overview of the major political thinkers from
ancient Greece until the present. They should become familiar with the main themes
of political thought, such as the nature of the state, the basis of political legitimacy. In
addition, students will also be expected to acquire a more detailed knowledge of a
selection of the main political theorists.
LECTURES AND SEMINARS
1.
Attendance at lectures is voluntary.
2.
All students are required to attend class seminar meetings (once every TWO
weeks, beginning in the 5th teaching week of the first semester (this is the
week beginning 21nd of Oct. 2013) and write TWO class papers during the
year. Papers should be about 1,500 words long and accompanied by a
bibliography.
Essays are to be submitted via <turniitin.com>
Course Title: History of Political Thought
Class ID 6806250
Password: HPT2013
The first essay is due on Sunday 10th of November 2013
The second essay is due on Sunday 2nd of March 2014
1
The two essays together count for 25% of the overall grade for the year.
3. There is an annual examination at the end of the academic year taken by
all full-year two semester students.
4. One Semester students do not sit an examination. They are assessed on the
basis of TWO essays, the first submitted at the end of the study week in the
semester that they are at TCD and the second at the end of that semester.
Dr Hyland has office hours between 10.00-11 am, on Tuesdays, during teaching
term in room 4.05, College Green
GENERAL READING GUIDE
A.
Books that provide selections from primary texts
1. Masters of Political Thought (three volumes) edited by M. B. Foster, W. T.
Jones and L. W. Lancaster.
These books contain a good selection of quite long extracts from the classic
works of political theory ranging from the pre-Platonic period to Marx. They also
contain useful commentaries by the editors on the texts quoted. s.
2. Some interesting and important selections from primary texts which are not
included in the Masters series can be found in Western Political Heritage by
W. Y. Elliot and N. A. MacDonald (Prentice Hall, 1963)
3. Classical Political Theories: From Plato to Marx, (ed), Robert Brown (London
1990).
B.
4. Classics of Moral and Political Theory, Michael L. Morgan (ed.), Hackett
Publishing Company, Indianapolis (Cambridge,1992).
(This is an excellent collection of , in many cases, the complete texts
of the relevant political thinkers)
Commentaries
1. W. T. Bluhm, Theories of the Political System, a good attempt at
demonstrating the relevance of certain classic political theories to
contemporary political problems (Prentice Hall, 1965).
2. G. H. Sabine, A History of Political Theory, standard textbook. It gives a good
survey of political thought (N.Y., 1961).
3. S. S. Wolin, Politics and Vision, consists of a series of sophisticated
interpretative essays. A serious work, well worth close study. (Little, Brown
and Co., 1960).
4. J. Plamenatz, Man and Society (two volumes) provides a good critical
analysis of modern political theories of Machiavelli to Marx. (Longman,
London, 1970).
5. L. J. Macfarlane, Modern Political Theory (Nelson, London, 1970).
6. D. Thomson, Political Ideas (Penguin Books, 1970)
2
7. R. N. Berki, History of Political Theory (Dent, 1976)
8. E. Wood and N. Wood, Class Ideology and Ancient Political Theory (Oxford,
1978)
9. M. Forsyth and M. Keens-Soper (eds.), A Guide to the Political Classics:
Plato to Rousseau (Oxford, 1988).
10. Brian Redhead, From Plato to Nato (BBC publications)
11. Iain Hampsher-Monk, A History of Modern Political Thought,( Basil Blackwell,
1992.)***
12. Edward Bryan Portis, Reconstructing the Classics: Political Theory from
Plato to Marx, (N. Jersey, 1994).
13. J. S. McClelland, A History of Western Political Thought, (London, 1996)***
14. Janet Coleman, A History of Political Thought, Vols. I and II (Oxford, 2000)
15. David Boucher and Paul Kelly, Political Thinkers From Socrates to the
Present(Oxford. 2003) ***
16. Alan Ryan, On Politics; A History of Political Thought from Herodotus to the
Present (London, 2012)This is a recently published (very large) book that is
written in a very engaging and accessible style that is not afraid to relate
thinkers both to their historical contexts and to other thinkers in the history of
political thought. It also contains an excellent guide to further reading.
17. John Rawls, Lectures on the History of Political Philosophy (Harvard, 2007) –
a very sympathetic and close reading of political theorists from Hobbes to
Marx by one of the great political theorists of the 20th century
18. Joseph M. Bryant, Moral codes and social structure in ancient Greece (New
York, 1996) – a sophisticated work containing material relevant to Athenian
democracy, Plato, Aristotle, Epicureanism and Stoicism
Students’ attention is drawn to the series Great Political Thinkers published by
Edward Elgar, Cheltenham. There are volumes on most of the great political
theorists and each contains an extensive collection of the most important writings on
each political theorist. Oxford University Press also publishes a “very short
introduction” series covering most of the political theorists that we deal with. Details
can be found in the Alan Ryan book mentioned above.
C.
Monographs
Unwin University Books publish a series of monographs on the major political
thinkers. The ones so far available are:
1.
2.
3.
3
J. B. Morrall, Aristotle (1977)
R. Plant, Hegel (1972)
M. Evans, Marx (1972)
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
F. O’Gorman, Burke (1974)
R. J. Halliday, John Stuart Mill (1972)
J. Steintrager, Bentham (1977)
D. D. Raphael, Hobbes (1977)
G. Parry, Locke (1977)
R. W. Hall, Plato (1982)
Two recently published books are of relevance as background to ancient
Greek political thought, they are: Polis: An Introduction to the Ancient
Greek City-State, Mogens Hansen, (Oxford. 2006) and Ancient Greek
Political Thought in Practice. Paul Cartledge, ( Cambridge, 2009)
D. Oxford University Press publish a series, Past Masters, containing volumes on
Aristotle, Plato, Machiavelli, Marx and Hegel. These books are short, readable
and readily available. They are excellent introductions to their subject.
E. The bi-annual journal History of Political Thought, published since 1980,
contains many important articles on all the political thinkers covered in the
course.
F. STUDENTS’ ATTENTION IS DRAWN to The Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy, there are entries on ALL the political theorists covered in the course.
They are of an EXCELLENT standard and have in addition a very
comprehensive and up-to-date extra bibliography. THIS IS AVAILABLE FREE
ON-LINE.***
*** ITEMS ARE RECOMMENDED AS REALLY GOOD INTRODUCTORY
OVERVIEWS.
Seminar and essay topics
HOW TO APPROACH READING FOR SPECIFIC TOPICS.
In general I have not placed chapters from the historical overview books on the specialised
bibliography for each topic, BUT THE BEST WAY TO START READING for a specific
area is to read the relevant section of, for example, The Masters of Political Thought, the
entry in The Stanford Encyclopedia and the relevant chapter from the J S McLelland book
and/or Political Thinkers from Socrates to The Present. The other overview books for
specific periods could also be consulted. Such as the Cambridge Companion series,
Plamenatz’s Man and Society or Hampsher-Monk’s A History of Modern Political Though
1. Was Athenian ‘demokratia’ democratic in the modern sense of the term?
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
h)
4
M. H. Hansen, Was Athens a Democracy (Copenhagen, 1989)
A.H.M. Jones, Athenian Democracy (Oxford, 1975)
M.I. Finley, Democracy, Ancient and Modern (London, 1969)
D. Held, Models of Democracy (London,1987) Ch. 1
G. Sartori, Democratic Theory (New York, 1965)
M. H. Hansen, The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes (Oxford, 1992)
J. Dunn (ed.), Democracy: the unfinished journey (Oxford, 1992)
G. C. Field, Political Theory (London, 1965) Final Chapter
i) J. Ober and C Hedrick (eds) Demokratia: a conversation on democracies ancient and
modern (Princeton, 1996) esp. Introduction and Part One ‘Liberty, equality and law’
NOTE 1:
There is a VERY VALUABLE website relevant to Athenian Democracy available at:
Demos; Classical Athenian Democracy, it contains extensive material relevant to all aspects
of Athenian Democracy.
NOTE 2: If you are having difficulties accessing the Jones book most of the chapters are
available as separate articles: ‘The Economic Basis of Athenian democracy’, Past and
Present I (1952); ‘The Athenian Democracy and Its Critics’, Cambridge Historical Journal,
13, (1953); ‘The Social Structure Of Athens in the Fourth Century BC’, Economic History
Review, 8 (1955). All these are accessible through JStorr
Students choosing to do their essay on this topic might like to look at some readings that
discuss the modern concept of democracy such as R. Dahl, On Democracy, (New Haven,
1998) or J L Hyland, Democratic Theory : The philosophical foundations. Ch 3( Manchester
,1995)
2. Is ‘justice’ anything more than a tool used by the strong to oppress the weak?
a) Plato, The Republic, book 1(Oxford, 1978)
b) J. Annas, An introduction to Plato’s Republic, (Oxford: 1981)
c) G. Klosko, The development of Plato’s political theory (London: 1986), ch. 1
d) R. C Cross and W D Woozley, Plato’s Republic (London: 1979), ch. 2
e) T. Y. Henderson, “In defence of Thrasymachus”, American philosophical
quarterly, vol. 7, no. 3 (1970), pp. 218-228. On photocopy reserve.
f) I. Dilman, Morality and the inner life (London: 1979), chs 6 and 7
3. Why, according to Plato, should only philosophers rule?
a) Plato, The Republic (Oxford, 1978 )
b) G. Klosko, The development of Plato’s political theory (London: 1986)
c) J. Wolff, An introduction to political philosophy (Oxford: 1996), ch 3
d) R. Dahl, Democracy and its critics (Yale: 1989), chs 4 and 5
e) T. L .Thorson (ed), Plato: totalitarian or democrat (New Jersey: 1963)
f) C. D. C. Reeve, Philosopher kings (Princeton: 1988)
g) The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Political Thought.(Cambridge,2000)
ed. C Rowe and M Schofield, Chs 8 and 10
h) J. Ober, Political Dissent in Democratic Athens,: Intellectual Critics of Popular
Rule,(Princeton, 1998) Ch. 4
4. What does Aristotle mean by his thesis that ‘man is a political animal’?
a) Aristotle, The Politics.(Cambridge, 1988,) edited by Stephen Everson
b) R. G. Mulgan, Aristotle’s political theory (Oxford: 1979)
c) J. Barnes, The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle (Cambridge: 1995), esp. ch. by
Taylor
d) D.Keyt and F. Miller, A Companion to Aristotle’s Politics (Oxford: 1991), chs 1,
4, 5
e) S Marc Cohen, The Four Causes, available @
http://faculty.washington.edu/smcohen/320/4causes.htm
f) Jean Roberts, The Routledge Philosophy Guidebook to Aristotle and the Politics,
(Routledge, 2009)
g) John B Morrall, Aristotle, ( London, 1977 )
5
h) The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Political Thought(Cambridge, 2000)
ed. C Rowe and M Schofield, pp. 310-20.pp. 344-65, pp. 366-389
i) R. G. Mulgan,’ Aristotle and the value of political participation’ Political
Theory, 18(1990) 195-215
5. In what sense, if any, were the Stoics egalitarian political theorists?
a) H. Baldry, The Unity of Mankind in Greek Thought Esp. chs. 5 and 6.
b) J. McClelland, A History of Western Political Thought, (London, 1996), ch. 5
c) S. S. Wolin, Politics and Vision (Boston 1970), ch. 3
d) A. Erskine, The Hellenistic Stoa; Political Thought and Action (London 1989)
e) Malcolm Schofield, “Epicurean and Stoic Political Thought”, in The Cambridge
History of Greek and Roman Political Thought, (Cambridge, 2000)
f) F. H. Sandbach, The Stoics, (Bristol, 1989)
g) J. M. Bryant, Moral Codes and Social Structures in Ancient Greece, (New York,
1996), chs on Epicurus and the Stoics
6. Why, for St Augustine, is the state primarily a remedial institution?
a) St Augustine, The Political Writings, ed. by H Paolucci,(Chicago, 1962)
b) R. Price, Augustine (London: 1996)
c) J.McClelland, A history of Western political thought, ch 6
d) H. Deane, The political and social ideas of St Augustine (Columbia: 1963)
e) E.Pagels, Adam, Eve and the serpent (London: 1989), esp. ch 4 and 5
f) R. Martin, ‘The two cities in Augustine’s political philosophy’, Journal of the
History of Ideas, 33,(1972) 195-216
g) P. R. L. Brown, ‘Saint Augustine’ in B Smalley, ed., Trends in Medieval Political
Thought, (Oxford, 1965)
h) G. O’Daly. Augustine’s City of God: A Reader’s Guide.(Oxford, 1999)(This is a
detailed overview of Augustine’s City of God, for students who might have a special
interest)
For readings from St Augustine himself item a) above is excellent. Also, there are
extensive citations in the H. Deane book, which is highly recommended.
7. In what way is Natural Law central to Aquinas’ political theory?
a) Aquinas, Selected political writings, edited by A P D’Entreves (Oxford: 1954)
b) J. Finnis, Aquinas; Moral, Political and Legal Theory (Oxford, 1998)
c) D.J. O Connor, Aquinas and natural law
d) P. E. Sigmund, St Thomas Aquinas on politics and ethics (New York: 1988)
e) N. Kretzmann and E. Stump (eds), The Cambridge Companion to Aquinas, esp. chs.
on ethics and politics
f) The Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy, (1982) (eds.) N. Kretzman, A.
Kenny, J. Pinborg and E. Stump, articles on Aquinas.
g) J. P. Canning, A History of Medieval Political Thought 300-1450(1996) Ch. 3
The Sigmund book, in particular, has very apposite selections from Aquinas’ works,
including the relevant sections from his Summa Theologia.
8. Does Machiavelli’s political thought subordinate morality to political expediency?
a) Machiavelli, The Prince.ed, ed. By Q Skinner and R Price( Cambridge, 1991)
6
b) Q.Skinner, Machiavelli (Oxford: 1981), Now available as: Machiavelli: A very short
introduction, (2000)
c) D. L. Jensen (ed.), Machiavelli, esp chs. by Croce, Cassirer, Maritain and Meinecke
d) J.Shklar, Ordinary Vices (Harvard: 1984), esp. chs. 1 and 4
e) J. Shklar, The Faces of Injustice (Yale:1990)
f) C. Cruise-O’Brien, The Suspecting Glance (London: 1972)
g) Maurizio Viroli, How to Read Machiavelli.(London, 2008)
h) G. Bock, Q. Skinner and M. Viroli, eds. Machiavelli and Republicanism, esp the chs.
By Skinner and Viroli.
i) I. Berlin, ‘The originality of Machiavelli’ in Against the Current.(Oxford, 1979)
9. Why, for Hobbes, is the desire for power so central to his conception of the ‘natural condition
of mankind’, which can only be remedied by the creation of an absolute sovereign?
a) Hobbes, Leviathan, ed. by R Tuck(Cambridge 1991)
b) P. Springborg,(ed.), The Cambridge companion to Hobbes’s Leviathan,(Cambridge,
2007), esp chs. 4,5 and 7.
c) I. Hampsher-Monk, A history of modern political thought (Oxford: 1992)
d) T. Sorrell, The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes (Cambridge: 1995), ch. 9
e) J. Hampton, Hobbes and the Social Contract Tradition (Cambridge: 1986)
f) J. Dunn, The History of Political Theory and other Essays (Cambridge: 1996), ch. 4
g) C. B. Macpherson, The political theory of possessive individualism.(Oxford,1962)
h) T. Sorrel. Hobbes, (1986)
i) N. Malcolm, Aspects of Hobbes, (2002)
j) R. Tuck, Hobbes: A very short introduction,(Oxford, 2002)
k) Stephen Pinker, The Better Angels of Our Nature, Ch.2, pp31-58( Allen Lane,
London, 2011)
l) N. Warburton, J. Pike and D. Matravers (eds) Reading political philosophy:
Machiavelli to Mill (Open University Press, 2000) – chs 2.1 and 2.2 – readings by
C.B McPherson and Jean Hampton ***
10. What role do natural rights play in Locke’s account of limited government?
a) John Locke, Second Treatise of Government,(Cambridge, 1960)
b) I. Hampsher-Monk, A history of modern political thought, ch. 2
c) V. Chappell, The Cambridge companion to Locke, (Cambridge: 1994)
d) J. Dunn, Locke, (Oxford: 1985). Available as : Locke: A very short introduction.
e) G. Parry, Locke (London 1980)
f) R. Ashcraft, Locke’s Two Treatises of Government, ( London, 1987 )
11. Was Rousseau a ‘dreamer of democracy’?
a) J.-J. Rousseau, The Social Contract and Discourses,( London, 1973)
b) I. Hampsher-Monk, A history of modern political thought, ch. 4. (Oxford, 1992)
c) R. Harrison, Democracy (London: 1993), ch. 4
d) R. Wokler (ed.), Rousseau and liberty (Manchester: 1995), esp. parts 2 and 3
e) J. Miller, Rousseau: dreamer of democracy (Yale: 1984)
f) J. L. Talmon, The origins of totalitarian democracy (London, 1966) esp. Introduction
and Ch.III.
g) P. Riley (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Rousseau,(Cambridge, 2001)
h) J. Cohen, Rousseau; a free community of equals,(Oxford, 2010)
i) N.J.H. Dent, Rousseau,(Oxford, 1988)
j) M. Viroli, Jean-Jacques Rousseau and the “Well Ordered Society”,(Cambridge,
1984)
7
k) Matthew Simpson, Rousseau: a guide for the perplexed (London, 2007) ****
12. Critically examine Mill’s arguments for maximising individual liberty.
a) J S Mill, On Liberty,(Cambridge, 1989)
b) J Gray (ed), ‘On liberty’ in focus (London: 1991) esp. chs by Ten, Wollheim, Berlin
and Ryan
c) I Hampsher-Monk, A history of modern political thought, ch. 8
d) C L Ten, Mill on liberty (Oxford: 1980)
e) G Himmelfarb, On liberty and liberalism (New York: 1974).
13. What does Marx mean when he claims that capitalism alienates human beings from
their labour?
a) Karl Marx, Economic and philosophic manuscripts in D McLellan (ed.) Karl Marx:
selected writings (Oxford: 1977)
b) R. Schacht, Alienation (New York: 1970)
c) I. Meszaros, Marx’s theory of alienation (London: 1970)
d) J. Plamenatz, Karl Marx’s philosophy of man (Oxford: 1977). pp. 61-172
e) L. Wilde, ‘The Early Marx’ in Political Thinkers from Socrates to the Present. Eds. D
Boucher and P. Kelly, (Oxford, 2003). pp. 404-418
f) Jon Elster. Making Sense of Marx,(Cambridge, 1985) chs. 2 and 9
g) John Rawls, Lectures on the History of Political Philosophy, (Harvard, 2008) pp.354372
8