To Paradise by Hanya Yanagihara. Summary
and analysis. Download PDF.
Plot Summary
First part overview:
Second part overview:
Third part overview:
To Paradise analysis
Key Facts
Character List
Literary devices
Suggested Essay Topics
Plot Summary
First part overview:
The first part of "To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara is set in an alternate version of
1893 New York City, which is part of the Free States, a region where same-sex
relationships are accepted and encouraged by society. This section of the book
introduces us to a young, wealthy, and naive protagonist named David Bingham, who
lives in a grand house in Washington Square with his stern and protective grandfather,
Easman. Despite the freedom and acceptance of same-sex relationships in this
alternate society, David's life is constrained by his grandfather's expectations and the
societal pressures to enter into a beneficial marriage.
David's world is turned upside down when he meets Charles Griffith, a charming and
persuasive man from the South, a region with different laws and attitudes towards
relationships and society. Charles is visiting New York, and he and David quickly form a
deep and passionate connection. This relationship offers David a glimpse of true
happiness and freedom, but it also exposes him to the risks and dangers of defying
societal expectations and his grandfather's plans.
The narrative explores themes of love, freedom, and societal constraints, juxtaposing
the personal happiness of the characters against the backdrop of a society that is both
progressive in some ways and deeply conservative in others. Through David's
relationship with Charles, Yanagihara delves into the complexities of love, the struggle
for personal autonomy, and the impact of societal norms on individual lives.
As the story unfolds, David is faced with difficult choices about his future, his family, and
his relationship with Charles. The narrative subtly hints at broader political and social
tensions within the Free States and beyond, setting the stage for the exploration of
these themes in the subsequent parts of the book.
"To Paradise" uses this first part to establish a world that is both familiar and distinctly
different from our own, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of freedom, love, and the
pursuit of happiness in the context of societal expectations and constraints. Through the
lens of an alternate historical New York, Yanagihara sets the groundwork for a complex
and multi-layered narrative that spans centuries and examines the recurring struggles
for personal and collective paradise.
Second part overview:
The second part of "To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara transports readers to 1993, in a
New York City that is recognizable yet distinct from our own. This section shifts focus to
a new set of characters, primarily centered around a young Hawaiian man named
Charlie, who is grappling with the realities of life during the AIDS epidemic. Unlike the
first part's alternate historical setting, this section presents a world more closely aligned
with our own, albeit with subtle differences that hint at alternate historical outcomes.
Charlie is in a relationship with David Bingham, a successful lawyer from a wealthy and
influential family. Their relationship is strained, not just by the societal stigma associated
with AIDS but also by the personal struggles and secrets that both men harbor. Charlie,
who is deeply in love with David, navigates the complexities of their relationship,
balancing his desire for closeness with the need to protect himself from the potential
heartbreak of loss.
This part of the book delves into themes of love, loss, and the quest for belonging in a
world that often seems indifferent to individual suffering. The shadow of the AIDS
epidemic looms large over the characters, shaping their experiences and interactions.
The narrative explores the impact of illness on relationships, the fear and prejudice
surrounding AIDS, and the resilience of the human spirit in the face of adversity.
Through Charlie's perspective, readers are given a window into the challenges faced by
the LGBTQ+ community during this period, including discrimination, the struggle for
rights and recognition, and the search for meaning and connection in a world that can
feel overwhelmingly hostile. The story also touches on issues of family, inheritance, and
societal expectations, echoing themes from the first part of the book but grounding them
in a more familiar historical context.
As Charlie's relationship with David unfolds, the narrative weaves together personal and
political threads, creating a rich tapestry of love, loss, and longing. Yanagihara uses this
section to examine the ways in which personal lives are intertwined with broader social
and historical currents, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of paradise—not just as
a place or a state of being, but as a pursuit that is inherently fraught with challenges and
contradictions.
Overall, the second part of "To Paradise" offers a poignant and deeply moving
exploration of the human condition, set against the backdrop of a critical period in recent
history. Through the lives of Charlie, David, and the people around them, Yanagihara
crafts a narrative that is both specific in its details and universal in its themes,
connecting the past with the present in unexpected and thought-provoking ways.
Third part overview:
The third part of "To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara propels readers into the near future,
setting the narrative in the year 2093 in a version of New York that has been drastically
transformed by climate change, pandemics, and authoritarian governance. This section of the
book introduces a new protagonist, a young man named Charlie (a name that echoes through
each part of the novel, linking the disparate narratives) who lives with his grandfather in a
society where personal freedoms are severely restricted under the guise of public health and
safety.
In this future world, the government exercises tight control over its citizens, using the threat of
disease and environmental disaster as justification for its surveillance and authoritarian
measures. Despite the oppressive regime, there exists a form of resistance and a longing
among individuals to connect with others and seek out moments of joy and love amidst the
bleakness of their controlled lives.
Charlie's narrative is intertwined with his relationship with an older man, whose mysterious past
and connection to the resistance movement draws Charlie into a dangerous quest for truth and
freedom. The story delves into themes of love, sacrifice, and the enduring human spirit in the
face of dystopian adversity. It explores the lengths to which individuals will go to find a sense of
paradise, whether through love, rebellion, or the pursuit of a better world.
This part of the book also reflects on the enduring nature of human connections and how they
can transcend time and place. The parallels between the characters and their struggles across
the three parts of the novel suggest a cyclical view of history and human nature, where love and
the quest for freedom and happiness are constant, even in the face of changing societal norms
and challenges.
Yanagihara's vision of the future in this section is both a warning and a reflection on current
global issues, including climate change, pandemics, and the balance between security and
liberty. Through the story of Charlie and his journey, the novel invites readers to contemplate
the choices facing humanity and the importance of preserving the values of love, freedom, and
paradise, however they may be defined.
In sum, the third part of "To Paradise" serves as a powerful conclusion to the novel's exploration
of utopian and dystopian themes, connecting the threads of past, present, and future into a
compelling narrative about the human condition and the universal search for paradise amidst
the trials of existence.
To Paradise analysis
"To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara is a sprawling and ambitious novel that spans three
centuries and imagines alternate versions of America. It is a book that defies easy
categorization, weaving together themes of love, freedom, societal norms, and the
quest for utopia. Through its interconnected narratives set in 1893, 1993, and 2093,
Yanagihara crafts a complex tapestry that explores the evolving nature of American
society and the timeless human yearning for a better world. This analysis seeks to delve
into the novel's intricate storytelling, thematic depth, and character development,
offering insights into its significance and impact.
Narrative Structure and Setting
The novel is divided into three parts, each set in a different century and an alternate
version of New York City. The first part, set in 1893, presents an America where gay
marriage is not only accepted but expected, offering a provocative reimagining of
historical societal norms. The second part takes place in 1993, in a New York grappling
with the AIDS epidemic, reflecting a more recognizable reality but focusing on the
personal tragedies and societal indifference faced by the gay community. The final part
envisions a dystopian future in 2093, where authoritarian rule, pandemics, and climate
change have drastically altered the fabric of society.
This triptych structure allows Yanagihara to explore the themes of love, loss, and the
pursuit of happiness across different societal contexts, highlighting both progress and
regression in America's social landscape. Each part, while distinct in setting and
characters, is connected through recurring names, motifs, and the overarching quest for
a personal and societal paradise.
Themes and Motifs
One of the central themes of "To Paradise" is the concept of utopia and the human
desire to create or find a place of perfect happiness. Yanagihara examines this idea
both in the literal sense of societal and political constructs and in the more personal
realms of love and relationships. The novel questions the feasibility of utopia,
suggesting that the pursuit of an idealized world often comes with unintended
consequences and moral compromises.
Another significant theme is the exploration of love in its various forms, including
romantic, familial, and platonic love. The relationships depicted in the novel are complex
and deeply felt, reflecting the joys and sorrows of connection and the sacrifices
individuals are willing to make for those they love. Through these relationships,
Yanagihara delves into the human capacity for love and compassion, even in the face of
adversity.
The novel also addresses issues of freedom and oppression, particularly in the context
of societal norms and government control. Each section of the book presents characters
who must navigate the constraints imposed by their respective societies, whether those
constraints are related to sexuality, health, or political freedom. Yanagihara uses these
narratives to critique the ways in which societies attempt to regulate and suppress
individuality and difference.
Character Development
"To Paradise" features a diverse cast of characters, each richly drawn and intricately
connected to the novel's themes. The characters' struggles and desires serve as the
emotional core of the book, driving the narrative forward and providing a human
perspective on the broader societal issues at play. Yanagihara excels at creating
empathetic and nuanced characters who resonate with readers, making their journeys
deeply affecting.
Conclusion
"To Paradise" is a masterful work that challenges readers to contemplate the nature of
happiness, the cost of progress, and the enduring human need for connection and love.
Hanya Yanagihara has crafted a novel that is both a sweeping historical epic and an
intimate exploration of individual lives. Its ambitious scope, complex characters, and
thought-provoking themes make it a significant contribution to contemporary literature.
"To Paradise" invites readers to reflect on the past, consider the present, and imagine
the future, all while pondering the universal quest for a paradise that may be forever just
out of reach. Through its exploration of alternate Americas, the novel offers a meditation
on the possibilities and pitfalls of the human condition, making it a profound and
compelling read.
Key Facts
Genre
Literary Fiction, Speculative Fiction,
Dystopian
Publication Date
January 11, 2022
Publisher
Doubleday
Setting
The novel is set across three timelines: 1893,
1993, and 2093, each depicting an alternate
version of New York City and America more
broadly.
Main Characters
- In the 1893 section, characters navigate a
society where gay marriage is normalized
within a reimagined New York. - The 1993
section deals with characters facing the AIDS
epidemic, capturing personal and communal
tragedies. - The 2093 section presents a
dystopian future afflicted by authoritarianism,
pandemics, and climate change, focusing on
characters' struggles for survival and
connection. Characters across sections share
names and traits, linking the narratives.
Themes
- The quest for utopia and the concept of
paradise - Love in its various forms (romantic,
familial, platonic) - Freedom vs. oppression,
societal norms, and government control Disease and pandemics as societal and
personal disruptors - Climate change and
environmental degradation
Narrative Style
The novel employs a third-person narrative,
offering deep insights into the thoughts,
feelings, and motivations of its characters.
The writing style is rich and descriptive, with a
focus on character development and thematic
exploration.
Significance
The novel is significant for its imaginative
reworking of American history and its
speculative look at the future, offering a
potent commentary on current societal issues
such as LGBTQ+ rights, governmental power,
and environmental crises. It is a thoughtprovoking read that encourages reflection on
the nature of paradise, the cost of utopia, and
the enduring human capacity for love and
resilience in the face of adversity.
Character List
Given the breadth of "To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara and its spanning across three
centuries in alternate versions of America, the character list is extensive and diverse, with some
characters sharing names but existing in different timelines and contexts. Below is a selection of
key characters from each part of the book, along with a brief analysis.
Part One: 1893, New York
- David Bingham: A young man of wealth and privilege, living in an alternate 1893 New York
where same-sex unions are accepted. He grapples with societal expectations, personal desire,
and the weight of his family's legacy. David is a character caught between duty and his quest for
personal happiness.
- Charles Griffith: David’s suitor, who represents a potential for love and freedom outside the
constraints of David’s societal obligations. Charles is passionate and persuasive, offering David
a glimpse into a life led by love rather than duty.
- Edward Bishop: David's fiancé, chosen by his grandfather. Represents the societal
expectations and obligations that David feels pressured by. Edward is a symbol of the path that
David is expected to follow, one that aligns with family and societal expectations.
Part Two: 1993, Manhattan
- Charlie Fuller: A young man navigating life and love in Manhattan during the AIDS epidemic.
Charlie's story reflects the fear, loss, and activism associated with the era. His character
provides insight into the struggles of the LGBTQ+ community during a time of crisis.
- Peter: Charlie's older partner, who offers him a sense of stability and love amidst the chaos.
Peter's character embodies the generation affected by AIDS, grappling with the reality of the
disease while trying to maintain hope and love.
- Jason: A friend of Charlie’s, representing a broader scope of the LGBTQ+ community's
experiences during the AIDS epidemic. His character adds depth to the narrative, showcasing
different responses and attitudes towards the crisis.
Part Three: 2093, New York
- Charles Griffith: Living in a future dystopian New York under authoritarian rule, this Charles is
a young man in a society ravaged by climate change and pandemic diseases. He embodies the
struggle for personal freedom and love in a world defined by surveillance, control, and societal
collapse.
- David Bingham: Charles’s lover, whose mysterious disappearance propels the narrative. This
David symbolizes the pursuit of happiness and love in a world where such pursuits are fraught
with danger and political implications.
- Rosalind Bingham: A key figure in the authoritarian regime, and David’s aunt. Her character
explores themes of power, family loyalty, and the moral compromises made in the name of
governance and control.
Analysis Across the Timelines
The recurring names and mirrored struggles across the centuries in "To Paradise" serve to
underscore the themes of love, freedom, and the search for paradise amidst societal
constraints. Yanagihara uses these characters to explore how the quest for personal happiness
and fulfillment evolves yet remains fundamentally the same across different societal structures.
Each character, whether living in an alternate past, the near-present, or a dystopian future,
faces the challenge of navigating their desires against the backdrop of their respective societies'
norms and expectations.
The characters in "To Paradise" are intricately drawn, with their stories interweaving to form a
rich tapestry that reflects on the human condition. Through them, Yanagihara examines the
enduring pursuit of love and freedom, the notion of utopia, and the sacrifices individuals make in
their search for personal paradise.
Literary devices
"To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara is a complex and multifaceted novel that employs a
wide range of literary devices to explore themes of love, freedom, utopia, and dystopia
across different versions of America over three centuries. Below are some of the key
literary devices Yanagihara uses:
1. **Parallel Narratives**
The novel is structured into three parts, each set in a different year (1893, 1993, 2093)
and version of New York City. Yanagihara uses parallel narratives to draw connections
between different time periods and to explore how themes of love, freedom, and
societal constraints are both timeless and shaped by historical context.
2. **Motif**
Motifs of paradise and disease recur throughout the novel, serving as symbols of the
characters' quest for happiness and love, and the societal barriers that impede these
quests. The notion of "paradise" is explored as both a physical place and a state of
being, while disease (from tuberculosis to AIDS to fictional pandemics) symbolizes both
literal illness and societal decay.
3. **Symbolism**
Yanagihara employs symbolism extensively, with specific elements (such as the birds in
the 1893 section) representing freedom or the desire for escape. Buildings and places,
like the Bingham mansion or the dystopian New York of 2093, symbolize the constraints
placed on the characters by their societies and the roles they are expected to play.
4. **Allusion**
The novel alludes to historical and literary texts, including references to the AIDS crisis
of the 1980s and 1990s, dystopian literature, and American history. These allusions
enrich the narrative by providing deeper context and inviting readers to draw
connections between the fictional world of the novel and real historical events and
themes.
5. **Characterization**
Yanagihara uses deep characterization to explore the inner lives and struggles of her
characters. Through detailed backstories and introspective narration, readers gain
insight into the characters' desires, fears, and motivations. This device helps to
humanize the characters and make their quests for love and freedom universally
relatable.
6. **Foreshadowing**
Foreshadowing is used to hint at future events and revelations, creating suspense and
drawing thematic connections between the different parts of the novel. For example,
early mentions of disease or societal decay in the 1893 section foreshadow the more
explicit depictions of pandemics and authoritarianism in the 2093 section.
7. **Irony**
Yanagihara employs both situational and dramatic irony to underscore the tragic
elements of the characters’ stories and to critique societal norms. Characters often find
themselves in situations where their pursuit of happiness leads to unintended
consequences, highlighting the ironies inherent in the search for paradise within
restrictive societies.
8. **Juxtaposition**
The author juxtaposes different societies, time periods, and characters’ experiences to
highlight contrasts and similarities. This device is used to explore how different social,
political, and historical contexts shape the characters' lives and relationships, and how,
despite these differences, fundamental human desires and conflicts remain constant.
Through these and other literary devices, Hanya Yanagihara crafts a richly textured
narrative that invites readers to reflect on the nature of love, freedom, and the pursuit of
happiness across different historical and speculative landscapes. "To Paradise" is a
testament to the power of fiction to explore complex themes and to resonate with
readers on a deeply personal level.
Suggested Essay Topics
1. How does "To Paradise" explore the concept of utopia and dystopia, and what
does it suggest about the pursuit of a perfect society?
- The novel presents different versions of America that each embody aspects of
utopian and dystopian societies. Through these portrayals, the book questions the
feasibility of a perfect society and examines the costs associated with striving for such
an ideal. Discuss how each section of the book presents elements of utopia and
dystopia, and analyze what these depictions suggest about human nature and societal
organization.
2. In what ways does "To Paradise" address themes of love and freedom, and
how are these themes interconnected?
- Love and freedom are central themes that recur throughout the novel's different
narratives. Explore how the characters' quests for love are influenced by their societal
contexts and personal freedoms (or lack thereof). Examine how Yanagihara portrays
the intersection of love and freedom as both a source of fulfillment and a cause of
conflict.
3. What role do disease and pandemics play in "To Paradise," and how do they
influence the characters' lives and societies?
- Disease is a recurring motif that symbolizes both literal illness and broader societal
ills. Analyze how the depiction of disease and pandemics affects the characters and the
structure of their societies. Consider how these elements serve as catalysts for change,
reflection, or repression within the narrative.
4. How does "To Paradise" use parallel narratives and characters across its three
parts to examine historical and speculative social issues?
- The novel's structure allows for the exploration of themes across different historical
and speculative settings. Discuss how the parallel narratives and recurring character
names/types create a dialogue between the past, present, and future. Analyze how this
approach allows Yanagihara to comment on social issues that persist over time and
speculate on their future trajectories.
5. Examine the portrayal of authority and resistance in "To Paradise." How do
characters navigate oppressive systems, and what does this reveal about human
resilience and conformity?
- Throughout the novel, characters encounter various forms of authority, from familial
expectations to governmental control. Investigate how characters resist or conform to
these forces, and analyze what their choices reveal about the nature of authority and
individual agency. Consider how Yanagihara uses these dynamics to comment on the
balance between societal order and personal freedom.
6. Discuss the significance of setting in "To Paradise." How do the different
versions of New York City and the fictional Free States reflect the themes of the
novel?
- The settings in "To Paradise" are richly detailed and serve as more than just
backdrops for the narrative. Explore how the various depictions of New York City and
the concept of the Free States contribute to the novel's exploration of utopia, freedom,
and societal constraints. Analyze how the settings influence the characters' lives and
the development of the themes.
7. How does "To Paradise" challenge traditional narratives of American history
and identity?
- Yanagihara reimagines American history and presents alternative versions of the
United States. Discuss how these speculative histories challenge conventional
narratives about American identity, freedom, and progress. Analyze how the novel
invites readers to reconsider the stories we tell about our past and their implications for
our present and future.
Each of these questions invites a deep examination of the themes, characters, and
narrative structure of "To Paradise," encouraging a nuanced analysis of Hanya
Yanagihara's complex and thought-provoking novel.