Assessment Rubric for a Collaborative Group Report
Point Value
Presentation
Participation
Communication
Attitude
Good 4-3
Developing 2
Beginning 1
Presenters were all very
confident in delivery and
they did an excellent job
of engaging the class.
Preparation is very
evident.
Outstanding 5
Presenters were
occasionally confident
with their presentation
however the presentation
was not as engaging as it
could have been.
Presenters were
unconfident and
demonstrated little
evidence of planning prior
to the presentation.
They participate actively
and help in directing the
group in setting goals and
meeting goals.
They thoroughly complete
assigned tasks and
actively participate in
helping the group work
together better.
They share many ideas
related to the goals and
encourage all group
members to share their
ideas.
They listen attentively to
others and are empathetic
to other people's feelings
and ideas.
They are exceptionally
positive and constructive;
encourage other group
members
They participate in their
group and show concern
for goals. They participate
in goal setting and
meeting goals.
They complete assigned
tasks and demonstrate
effort to help the group
work together.
They freely share ideas.
They listen to others and
considers other people's
feelings and ideas.
Presenters were not
consistent with the level
of confidence/
preparedness they
showed the classroom but
had some strong
moments.
They sometimes
participate in a group and
show concern for some
goals.
They participate
marginally in goal setting
and in meeting goals.
They complete some
assigned tasks.
They share ideas when
encouraged.
They allow sharing by all
group members.
They listens to others and
consider other people's
feelings and ideas.
Neutral; neither
encouraging nor
discouraging;
disinterested in the
performance of others
Disparaging; negative,
withdrawn or belligerent;
absent
Positive; supportive;
mostly constructive and
upbeat
They participate minimally
and show a little concern
for goals.
They watch but don't
participate in goal setting.
They complete assigned
tasks late or turns in work
incomplete.
They do not share ideas.
They watch but do not
contribute to discussions
and do not show
consideration for others.
Contribution
Organization
Score
Material Scoring
Content: 25 points
Creativity: 15 points
Appropriateness: 10 points
Outstanding contribution;
above and beyond; work
is excellent in form and
substance
The presentation was
well-organized, wellprepared, and easy to
follow.
Good quality work; few
revisions or additions are
necessary
The presentation had
organized ideas but could
have been much stronger
with better preparation.
Poor quality work;
substantive errors; much
revision and editing are
required
There were minimal signs
of organization or
preparation.
Poor quality; little, if any,
contribution to group
goals
The presentation lacked
organization and had little
evidence of preparation.