Title of Piece: ______________________________________
Author: _______________________________________
Peer Conferencer: _____________________________________
Yes
No
Comment
1. Is there evidence of prewriting activity
(brainstorm)?
2. Is the title interesting and does it fit the
piece?
3. Is the introduction effective?
4. Are paragraphs used to organize
information?
5. Are there enough details?
6. Does the writer stay on topic?
7. Is the writing interesting?
8. Does the author use strong and interesting
words?
9. Is the conclusion effective and relevant?
Describe at least 1 thing you really liked about this piece. Why do you like it?
Ask at least 1 question to the author about something you did not understand about the piece.