Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Misure Fiscali
Milan, 25 October 2018
Auditorium TECNIMONT
Best Practice in the Engineering of the Metering Systems
1
Ermanna Deldossi
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Best Practice:
Collection of technique, solutions, procedures or methodology
not limited to technical disciplines that,
through experience and research,
has proven to reliably lead to a desired result.
Metering System:
an assemblage or combination of things or parts
based on multiple disciplines and know how
forming a complex or unitary whole of measure
2
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Project Team: members, structure, organization, competence, rules,
responsability
Project Management &
Team work selection
3
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Teamwork _Work package
and Planning
4
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
RW
Phase
12.3% ENG
9.1% FBR
Monthly
Type
Monthly
Jun‐15
‐
‐
RW
Phase
12.3% ENG
9.1% FBR
Cumulative
Type
Jun‐15
RW
Phase
12.3% ENG
9.1% FBR
Man Power
0
0
Cumulative
Type
Jun‐15
‐
‐
Man Power
Jul‐15
888
Aug‐15
382
Sep‐15
700
Oct‐15
Nov‐15
410
333
Dec‐15
412
Jan‐16
546
928
Feb‐16
Mar‐16
217
93
4,657
5,948
Apr‐16
May‐16
159
530
Jun‐16
327
420
Jul‐16
Jul‐15
888
0
Aug‐15
1,269
0
Sep‐15
1,969
0
Oct‐15
Nov‐15
2,379
2,711
0
0
Dec‐15
3,123
0
Jan‐16
3,669
928
Feb‐16
Mar‐16
3,886
3,979
5,585
11,533
Apr‐16
May‐16
4,069
4,228
12,978
13,508
Jun‐16
4,555
13,928
Jul‐16
4,579
13,936
Jul‐15
Aug‐15
Sep‐15
Oct‐15
Dec‐15
Jan‐16
Feb‐16
Apr‐16
Jun‐16
Jul‐16
6
3
‐
5
‐
Nov‐15
3
‐
3
‐
3
‐
4
7
‐
Mar‐16
2
32
ENG Man Power
90
1,445
1
40
May‐16
1
10
2
4
3
3
1
1
FBR Man Power
7
45
6
40
40
6
5
35
5
4
3
3
3
32
30
4
3
25
3
20
3
2
2
15
2
1
1
1
1
5
‐
‐
0
Team work_Workload
5
10
10
7
4
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
3
24
8
1
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Team work_Progress Control
6
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Team work_progress Control
7
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Preliminary Analysis:
• Risks
• Opportunities
• Objectives
PM has in charge this study which is even based on the input of the engineering analysis.
and in the PEP definition share the related information with the project team and stakeholders;
Of course even the engineering should be informed of the risks, opportunities and goals of the
project.
Goals, Risks & Opportunities
8
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
What End User asks
What End User gets
9
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
What is the battery limit?
Engineering point of view requires the deep reading of all technical
project specifications (process, mechanical, automation, …) in order to:




identify anything is required or needs to be included and do not forget anything is due
guarantee the compliance with the project requirements
put in evidence any “critical” issue or requirements to be engineered
find evidence of all existing or potential limits, requirement and incongruencies in
norms, laws and Standards applied
 highlight any potential deviations
 distinguish what is clearly not contractually due
Scope of Work
10
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
What is the battery limit?
Project specification analysis from the Engineering is fundamental to PM
to define the complete scope of work both in terms of technical and
Contractual Term & Conditions
PM will use the results of the Engineering analysis to evaluate any potential impact based on
what is contractually agreed, expected from EPC, from Client, necessary to perform…..in order
to define with the contractor the effective scope of supply without any misunderstanding.
Scope of Work
11
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Analysis vincolous:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Process data
Ambient condition
Space availability
Utilities provided
Mechanical requirement
Instrument capability
Performance requirement
Local laws obligations
Standards and Rules recommendations
Customer Best Practice guideline
………
Vincolous
12
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Analysis vincolous:
• Instrument capability
Vincolous
13
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Analysis vincolous:
• Pressure Loss
Vincolous
14
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
15
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Analysis vincolous:
• Wind and heartquake
• Stress Analysis
Vincolous
16
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Vincolous
17
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
• Analysis vincolous
• Mixing verification with CFD simulation
Vincolous
18
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
19
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
• Analysis vincolous
• Space availabillity
Vincolous
20
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
• Analysis vincolous
• Accessibiity
Vincolous
21
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
• Analysis vincolous
• Logistic
Vincolous
22
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
• Analysis vincolous
• Transport and allocation
Vincolous
23
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Chiusura Brief
Alto
Scope of Work
Feasibility
Risparmio con la Value Engineering
Impact
GAIN
LOSS
Conclusione
Avvio
Basso
Chiusura Design
Engineering
for
Costruction
Preliminary
Engineering
Design
24
Construction
Hand‐over and
commissioning
Progress (t, %)
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Evidence of the work performed:
• Quality Plan
• Performance
Engineering shall provide documents, calculation report and /or integrate solution
which could be needed to support and verify the quality and the performance
agreed
Acceptance Criteria
25
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Evidence with documents:
Acceptance Criteria
26
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Evidence with dynamic
in house test:
Acceptance Criteria
27
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Evidence
with test on site
if properly foreseen
by the engineering:
Acceptance Criteria
28
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Lesson & Learned
29
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
Lesson & Learned
30
Best Practice in the Engineering of Metering Systems
31