4A6(1) Failure Case Study Group 17 WTC.pptx

advertisement

World Trade Centre

Collapse

Group 17

Valerie Scott

Dan Kennedy

Timeline

• World Trade Centre first proposed

-1943

• Minoru Yamasaki nominated as lead architect

-September 1962

• Design implemented by Worthington, Skilling, Helle & Jackson

Structural Engineers

• Original design of towers unveiled to the public

-January 1964.

• First ground breaking on site

-August 1966

Timeline

• North tower completed

-December 1972

• South Tower completed

-July 1973

• Fire in the North Tower

-February 1975

• Bombing in underground garage of North Tower

-February 1993

• Terrorist Attacks

-September 11 2001

Information

• Cost of Construction

– $400 million at the time (roughly equivalent to $2.2 billion today).

• 50,000 people worked in the towers daily.

• 200,000 passed through the buildings daily.

• Original design of 80 storeys was increased 110 storeys at the request of the Port Authority.

Structure

• Tube Frame Design

– steel core, columns around perimeter.

• Core contained elevators and utility shafts.

• Large column space between perimeter and core bridged by prefabricated floor trusses.

• Weight saved by using lightweight fire resistant materials.

• Windows were narrow as architect was afraid of heights

–caused objections

New York Skyline

(prior to attacks)

Failure

• On September 11 2001, a number of large commercial passenger aircraft were hijacked by terrorists. Two of these were later crashed into the twin towers.

• Both planes had departed Boston for California

– Full fuel tanks.

• Planes were ER variants

- Extended Range – more fuel

Attack on Twin Towers

Failure

• North Tower struck between 93 rd and 99 th floors at 8:46am

• South Tower struck between 77 th and 85 th floors at 9:02am

• North Tower collapsed after 102 minutes at 10:28am

• South Tower collapsed after 56 minutes at 9:59am

Failure

Failure

• The towers, despite having been built to the same design spec failed in different ways.

• Both failures were from a combination of impact damage and structural components that were compromised and weakened by the heat from the fires.

North Tower

• Fire weakened the core columns and caused the floors on the south side of the building to sag.

• The floors pulled the heated south perimeter columns inward, reducing their capacity to support the building above.

• Neighbouring columns quickly became overloaded as columns on the south wall buckled. The top section of the building tilted to the south and began its descent.

South Tower

• The core was damaged severely at the southeast corner and was restrained by the east and south walls via the hat truss and the floors.

• The steady burning fires on the east side of the building caused the floors there to sag.

• The floors pulled the heated east perimeter columns inward, reducing their capacity to support the building above.

• The neighbouring columns quickly became overloaded as columns on the east wall buckled.

South Tower

• The top section of the building tilted to the east and to the south and began its descent.

• WTC2 collapsed more quickly than WTC 1 because there was more aircraft damage to the building core, including one of the heavily loaded corner columns

• There were also early and persistent fires on the east side of the building, where the aircraft had extensively dislodged insulation from the structural steel.

Failure

Findings

• In the report carried out by NIST, it was found that neither the impact nor the fire alone would have been likely to have caused the towers to fail.

• The impact sustained by the towers from the aircraft was less than a quarter of the wind resisting capabilities of the towers.

• Although both towers collapsed vertically, damage was still caused to surrounding buildings, many of which either failed or had to be condemned.

Conclusions

• In the case of the twin towers, the failure was not as a result of inadequate design, but resulted from an attack which was designed to cause it to fail.

• The towers were in fact designed to withstand an aircraft strike, as the Empire state building had previously been struck accidentally by a B-25 bomber in 1945.

• It was for this reason that Extended Range planes were chosen to cause the fire damage necessary for failure.

New York Skyline

(present day)

Finally

• Fatalities :

• Clean-up:

• Rubble Removed:

2753

8 Months

1610000 t

• One World Trade Centre Building Due to open April 2013 at a cost of $3 Billion

Finally

Download