Performance Assessment of Leadership (PAL) Journal
Manuscript Evaluation Form
Please return this form attached to an e-mail message to kwe002@shsu.edu
bpolnik@shsu.elc
Manuscript Code or Title: Please Type Here
Reviewer Name:
Please rate the following items based on 1(lowest) to 3(highest).
Preliminary Overview
Significance
a. Value or usefulness to field or profession 1
b. Important and timely 1
2
2
3
3
Quality of the writing
a. Grammatical construction; writing style; use of non-sexist language 1 2
b. Overall clarity of ideas and expression 1 2 3
c. Presentation and interpretation of findings, discussion, and conclusions 1
Technical correctness
a. Adequacy of design/accuracy of analysis 1 2 3
b. Provides perspective of and extends existing literature 1 2 3
c. Inclusion of appropriate implications for practice and/or policy 1 2
Overall quality 1
2
3
2
3
3
3
Recommendation: 1 2 3
1) Do not recommend for publication in PAL Journal.
2) Reconsider after revisions
3) Accept for publication
General comments:
Paste or type comments here -- – Please use line numbers in manuscript to identify the
portion of text to which comments apply. Feedback to authors is always appreciated.
Please include comments and/or tracking changes on the manuscript. Attach along with
this form.