Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of

advertisement

Research in the Klamath Basin

2007 Annual Report

Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of

Advanced Tri-State Potato Selections, 2007

Brian A. Charlton and Darrin A. Culp

1

Introduction

Russet production in the Klamath Basin is almost entirely used for fresh market consumption. Russet Norkotah and clonal variants of this variety comprise the majority of russet acreage in the Klamath Basin. Russet Burbank also constitutes a significant percentage of local russet acreage as several packing sheds continue to exclusively pack this variety. Despite this trend, growers are continually looking for alternative varieties that offer improved yields and better pack out with reduced inputs. Since its inception in

1985, the Tri-State Variety Development Program has focused on developing russets for processing and the fresh market. Additional emphasis has focused on developing dualpurpose russets that meet both processing and fresh market criteria. Due to increases in production costs, threats of new as well as continued pressure from endemic pests and diseases, additional breeding efforts have focused on improving genetic resistance.

Climatic constraints in the Klamath Basin result in a relatively short growing season; therefore, new varieties must mature relatively early while still producing acceptable yield and grade.

Every variety attains maximum yield potential at a given plant population and fertility rate per acre. Additionally, this information is needed to assist growers in attaining maximum economic returns. Tri-State cooperators routinely conduct cultural management trials to determine optimum seed spacing and fertility inputs for newly released varieties. With such diverse climatic and growing season conditions throughout the Tri-State area, it is important to conduct cultural management trials in more than one location. Six dual-purpose russet varieties and advanced selections were subjected to various in-row seed spacing at KBREC to determine optimum yield and grade.

Procedures

The trial included the following varieties and selections: Gem Star Russet,

A95109-1, and A93157-6LS (Idaho) and AO96160-3, AO96164-1, and AO96141-3

(Oregon). The trial was arranged in a split-plot design with 4 replications. Three population densities of 6, 9, and 12 inch comprised the main plots with variety and/or selection as the split plots. Individual plots measured 30 feet in length. The trial location

1

Assistant Professor and Faculty Research Assistant, respectively, Klamath Basin Research and Extension

Center, Klamath Falls, OR.

Acknowledgements: Partial financial support for this program from the Oregon Potato Commission; the

Cooperative State Research, Extension, and Education Service (CSREES); and the USDA Agricultural

Research Service (ARS) is gratefully recognized.

Reference to a product or company is for specific information only and does not endorse or recommend that product or company to the exclusion of others that may be suitable.

______________________________________________________________________________

Klamath Basin Research and Extension Center

Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of Advanced Tri-State Potato Selections, 2007 Page 25

Research in the Klamath Basin

2007 Annual Report was planted to teff grass for hay the previous year and treated with glyphosate in the fall of 2006. Gypsum was applied at a rate of 2000 lbs/acre on April 11. Field preparation following the gypsum application included two passes with an off-set disc, roto-tilling, and moldboard plowing to break and bury sod. The area was fumigated with Telone

TM

II

(dichloropropene, Dow AgroSciences) at 15 gal/acre (gpa) and Vapam (sodium methyldithiocarbamate, AMVAC) at 25 gpa on April 26, 2007 followed by a finishing harrow and packer on May 7. Dry fertilizer was broadcast pre-plant followed by liquid fertilizer at row bedding for a total of 165 lb Nitrogen (N), 80 lb Phosphate (P

2

O

5

), 100 lb

Potash (K

2

0) and 140 lb Sulfur (S) on May 9 and 10.

Seed for all trials was hand cut to approximately 1.5-2.0 oz/seed piece on May 9,

10 and 11, treated with Tops MZ (thiophamate-methyl, mancozeb, Bayer CropScience), and suberized for 2 weeks at 55

0

F and approximately 95 percent relative humidity. The trial was planted using 2-row planter on May 23. The insecticide Admire Pro

(imidacloprid, Bayer CropScience) at 5-6 fl. oz. / acre and the fungicide Quadris

(azoxystrobin, Syngenta) at 6-8 fluid oz. / acre were applied in furrow over the seed piece.

Potato Hills were bedded up and leveled off with a rolling cultivator and bar, then sprayed with the pre-emergence herbicides of Dual II Magnum (s-metalachlor, Syngenta) at 1.3 pt./ acre and Prowl H2O (pendimethalin, BASF) at 1.5 pt./ acre. Following application, the herbicides were incorporated with .43 inches of irrigation. Matrix

(rimsulfuron, Dupont) was applied post-emergence at 1 oz. / acre on July 5 and incorporated with .25 inches of irrigation. A total of 19.7 inches of water was applied during the growing season with sprinklers arranged in a 40- by 48-ft. pattern and naturally occurring precipitation.

Plant stands were monitored on June13 and 27. On July 26 the fungicide Ridomil

Gold Bravo (mefenoxam/chlorothalinil, Syngenta) and the insecticide Leverage

(imidacloprid, cyfluthrin, Bayer CropScience) was applied aerially. Another application of Ridomil Gold was applied on August 10 at labeled rates. Vine kill took place on

September 10 with rolling followed by a Reglone (diquat dibromide, Syngenta) application at 1.5 pt. /acre with a ground sprayer.

Tubers were harvested using a one-row digger-bagger on October 10. All tubers from each plot were stored at 55

0

F until grading from November 5. Using the USDA potato grade standards, each plot was graded into U.S. No. 1s, No. 2s, B’s and culls. B size is any tuber under 4 oz. U.S. No. 1s were separated by weight to 4- to 8-oz, 8- to 12oz, and over 12-oz groupings. Subsamples of approximately 10 lbs from the 8- to 12 oz. fraction were used to determine specific gravity by the weight-in-air, weight-in-water method. Ten tubers from the over 12-oz group were selected at random to determine percent internal defects. Potatoes were cut lengthwise and inspected for hollow-heart, brown center, vascular discoloration, internal brown spot, stem end discoloration, and corky ring spot.

Potatoes were downgraded to No. 2s or culls if growth cracks, knobs, or misshapen tubers were severe enough according to USDA grade standards. Yields for

U.S. No. 1s were not adjusted to account for external blemishes such as Rhizoctonia or silver scurf or internal defects such as hollow heart, brown center, and others.

______________________________________________________________________________

Klamath Basin Research and Extension Center

Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of Advanced Tri-State Potato Selections, 2007 Page 26

Research in the Klamath Basin

2007 Annual Report

Data collected from grading was analyzed using SAS for Linear Models 9.1 (SAS

Institute Inc.) software. Least significant differences (LSDs) were calculated based on the student’s t test at the 5 percent probability level. Only a portion of the data obtained is reported here.

Results and Discussion

Emergence data (not shown) were collected 21 and 35 days after planting. All entries had achieved at least 90 percent emergence and final stands exceeded 95 percent in all treatments. A high incidence of hollow heart was observed in GemStar (26 percent) and 6LS (25 percent); data not shown. Seed spacing did not affect the incidence of hollow heart in either of these two varieties which suggests other factors (environmental, genetic, etc) are largely responsible for this tendency. Although hollow heart is usually more prominent in larger sized tubers, both these varieties exhibited problems in smaller tuber sizes (8-12 oz).

Yield, grade, and tuber size distribution data are presented in Table 1. AO96164-

1 produced significantly higher total yield than all other entries. However, this selection and AO96141-3 produced significantly lower US No. 1 yield than all other entries.

AO96164-1 and AO96141-3 also had significantly higher US No. 2 yield than all other entries which suggesting these varieties are not well suited for fresh market production in the Klamath Basin. A95109-1 had the highest US No. 1 yield among the other entries; however, the difference was not significant. This selection appears well suited for fresh market production in the Klamath Basin due to favorable yields and few internal and external defects.

A significant difference was observed among seed spacing. A linear trend was observed with higher total and US No. 1 yield at denser populations and gradually decreasing with increased spacing. Interestingly, US No. 1 yield for 6 and 9 inch spacing were not significantly different but were for total yield. AO96160-3 and A95109-1 produced significantly higher US No. 1 yield at the 6 inch spacing while all other entries showed no differences between 6 and 9 inch. Seed spacing had no significant difference on yield of tubers over 12 oz.

AO96141-3 and AO96164-1 will not be evaluated in future cultural management trials due to poor tuber appearance for the fresh market. GemStar Russet has performed well in yield trials at KBREC and has excellent tuber appearance; however, erratic problems with hollow heart make it a risky choice in the Klamath Basin. In addition, this variety masks PVY symptoms which present multiple challenges for raising clean certified seed. Therefore, it is likely this variety will not gain commercial acceptance on a large scale. AO96160-3 has nice tuber appearance, although not quite as attractive as

Russet Norkotah, and may find a niche in the Klamath Basin. This selection will be further evaluated in seed spacing trials in 2008. 6LS also has performed quite well in the

Klamath Basin, exhibiting excellent tuber appearance and yield. Like GemStar, this variety has shown a propensity to develop hollow heart. Commercial experience in the region has also demonstrated this propensity; therefore, if large-scale acceptance is to occur, additional management studies are needed to lower this risk. A95109-1 appears the best suited among all entries for commercial acceptance in the Klamath Basin. Tuber

______________________________________________________________________________

Klamath Basin Research and Extension Center

Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of Advanced Tri-State Potato Selections, 2007 Page 27

Research in the Klamath Basin

2007 Annual Report appearance is excellent, yield and grade is very comparable to Russet Norkotah (standard fresh market variety in the region), and few internal and external defects are observed.

This selection will also be further evaluated in seed spacing trials in 2008.

______________________________________________________________________________

Klamath Basin Research and Extension Center

Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of Advanced Tri-State Potato Selections, 2007 Page 28

Research in the Klamath Basin

2007 Annual Report

Table 1. Effect of seed spacing on yield, grade, and tuber size distribution of Gem Star, AO96160-3, A95109-1, 6LS,

AO96141-3 and AO96164-1 grown at the Klamath Basin Research and Extension Center.

Variety Trt.

1

Yield U.S. No. 1s

4-8 oz 8-12 oz > 12 oz Total

Yield

< 4 oz No. 2's culls Total

Gem Star 1

2

3

90

45

47

132

96

78

150

215

151 cwt/acre

372

357

275

39

16

16

50

65

35

9

20

23

470

458

349

AO96160-3

A95109-1

6LS

AO96141-3

AO96164-1

1

2

3

1

2

3

1

2

3

1

2

3

1

2

3

175

121

114

130

108

96

128

102

95

107

82

60

208

142

126

142

142

110

182

114

140

144

133

98

136

100

83

92

111

111

112

72

66

130

108

117

113

128

79

43

59

69

68

65

73

428

335

289

442

330

353

386

363

272

311

246

216

342

312

306

40

32

32

42

32

46

79

58

46

89

88

63

104

73

60

50

41

46

37

20

32

30

11

12

70

55

74

130

117

110

17

22

27

18

26

21

10

15

7

21

18

28

34

33

25

547

419

355

550

425

458

482

441

371

504

422

378

597

520

504

Variety Main Effect:

Gem Star

AO96160-3

A95109-1

6LS

AO96141-3

AO96164-1

CV (%)

LSD (0.05)

61

137

112

108

83

158

111

25

102

131

145

125

106

105

51

25

Seed Spacing Main Effect:

1

2

3

CV (%)

LSD (0.05)

140

100

89

119

34

138

116

103

72

NS

103

108

93

37

NS

1/

Treatment seed spacing: 1 = 6 inch, 2 = 9 inch, 3 = 12 inch

172

83

118

107

69

57

143

101

335

351

375

340

258

320

42

53

380

324

285

71

72

23

61

35

40

80

79

156

11

66

50

44

103

13

50

18

46

29

66

119

226

20

61

51

51

50

NS

18

11

22

22

31

22

110

11

18

22

22

53

NS

426

440

478

431

435

540

33

53

525

447

402

66

50

______________________________________________________________________________

Klamath Basin Research and Extension Center

Effects of Plant Population on Yield and Grade of Advanced Tri-State Potato Selections, 2007 Page 29

Download