-,
....
'
TMCC
COURSE ASSESSMENT REPORT (CAR)
Revised 09/06/2012
Course Prefix, Number and Title: ACC 135-BOOKKEEPING I
Division/Unit: Division of Business/Accounting
Submitted by: G. Phillip Smilanick
Contributing Faculty:
Academic Year: 2012-2013
Assessment Semester: Fall D Spring~
Complete and electronically submit your assessment report to your Department Chair/Coordinator/Director. As needed, please attach supporting documents and/or
a narrative description of the assessment activities in your course.
Course Outcomes
In the boxes below, summarize
the outcomes assessed in your
course during the year.
I
Assessment Measures
In the boxes below, summarize
the methods used to assess course
outcomes during the last year.
I
Assessment Results
Use of Results
Effect on Course
In the boxes below, summarize
the results of your assessment
activities during the last year.
In the boxes below, summarize
how you are or how you plan to
use the results to improve student
learning.
Based on the results of this
assessment, will you revise your
outcomes? If so, please
summarize how and why in the
boxes below:
Learning Objectives from the
Textbook related to this Course
Outcome were grouped together.
Chapter assignments are made up
of algorithmic questions and each
assignment allows two attempts.
The range of results from attempt
one and two were analyzed to
determine the range of
improvement in mastering the
associated Learning Objectives.
The average score on the first
assignment attempt for skills
associated with this Learning
Outcome was 67.41 %. Students
who opted to finish the second
attempt for similar assignments
but with assignment data
changed scored 94.18%.
The results indicate that the
assignment parameters need to be
updated to increase rigor.
Students in this semester were
allowed to use prior attempt work
to base their second attemot.
The inclusion of a text based
assignment platfonn and Lecture
Capture have contributed greatly
to the increase in achievement of
students in this course. However,
the assignment questions and
parameters in the course will be
modified to include some more
challenging assignments.
Although the primary learning
method for this course is
repetitive, students can be better
challenged in the area of critical
reasoning.
No change in Student Learning
Outcome.
Learning Objectives from the
Textbook related to this Course
Outcome were grouped together.
Chapter assignments are made up
of algorithmic questions and each
The average score on the first
assignment attempt for skills
associated with this Learning
Outcome was 64.31 %. Students
who opted to finish the second
The inclusion of a text based
assignment platfonn and Lecture
Capture have contributed greatly
to the increase in achievement of
students in this course. However,
No change in Student Learning
Outcome.
Outcome #1
Successful students will
demonstrate the ability to use
basic principles of
double-entry accounting,
including journalizing, posting,
preparation of a
worksheet, and preparation of
basic financial statements.
Outcome# 2
Successful students will
demonstrate the ability to
account for banking and payroll
activities.
Page 1
-.A,
TMCC
COURSE ASSESSMENT REPORT (CAR)
Course Prefix, Number and Title: ACC 135-BOOKKEEPING I
Division/Unit: Division of Business/Accounting
Submitted by: G. Phillip Smilanick
Contributing Faculty:
Academic Year: 2012-2013
Course Outcomes
Assessment Measures
Assessment Results
assignment allows two attempts.
The range of results from attempt
one and two were analyzed to
determine the range of
improvement in mastering the
associated Learning Objectives.
attempt for similar assignments
but with assignment data
changed scored 91.59%.
The results indicate that the
assignment parameters need to be
updated to increase rigor.
Students in this semester were
allowed to use prior attempt work
to base their second attempt.
the assignment questions and
parameters in the course will be
modified to include some more
challenging assignments.
Although the primary learning
method for this course is
repetitive, students can be better
challenged in the area of critical
reasoning.
Projects were assigned requiring
students to demonstrate the
ability to prepare reports
necessary for further study in the
required manner. Formal reports
with specific formatting
requirements were submitted and
graded.
Comprehensive assignments
requiring students to navigate the
entire accounting cycle are used
to establish a foundation in
double entry bookkeeping which
extends into the following
course, ACC 136 and into ACC
20 I. Students were given
assignments with two attempts
and a comparison of the first and
second attempts were used to
assess improvement.
The average score on the first
assignment attempt for skills
associated with this Learning
Outcome was 54.73%. Students
who opted to finish the second
attempt for similar assignments
but with assignment data
changed scored 78.40%.
The inclusion of a text based
assignment platform and Lecture
Capture have contributed greatly
to the increase in achievement of
students in this course. However,
the assignment questions and
parameters in the course will be
modified to include some more
challenging assignments.
Although the primary learning
method for this course is
repetitive, students can be better
challenged in the area of critical
reasoning.
I
Use of Results
I
Effect on Course
Outcome #3
Successful students will
demonstrate the ability to prepare
for further course work in
accounting.
Page2
No change in Student Learning
Outcome.
I
'A
.
TMCC
COURSE ASSESSMENT REPORT (CAR)
C ourse Prefix, Number and T itle: ACC 135-BOOKKEEPING I
Division/Unit: Division of Business/Accounting
Submitted by: G. Phillip Smilanick
Contributing Faculty:
Academic Year: 201 2-201 3
P1ease enter your name and date below to confirm you have reviewed this report:
Title
Name
Date
Department Chair/Coordinator/Director
Dean
Marie Murgo lo-Poore
Vice President of Academic Affairs
Jane Nichols
l/N(
~Q 'Y\,rJ
{J
Page 3
6/ 19/20 13
"
~
u.)~'th~
CategOf)' Analysis; SPRING 2013 SECTION 1002 (Smilanick Ph~)
Report Created: 05120/13 07:40AM PDT
Report Date Rerge: 0112112013 - 05119/2013
ACC 135
4 34137
s 34137
1 32137
5
3
1
1
.earning Oblecdve: 02-03 AnelyZe the etreds of buslneu hnsac:lons on • linns . 2Exerclses
37/37
34137
32137
34137
2 34137
1 34137
1 32137
51.90%
Objective: 02-o4 Prepare ari lncxxne statement.
2Exerc1Ms
2 Problems
2 34137
1 34137
1 32137
52.50%
65.90%
64.70%
objective: 02-05 Prepare a statement of~ equRy and a balance lheel.
2Exerc1Ms
2 Problems
2 34137
1 34137
1 32137
61.00%
89.43%
tar 2 Problems
Objective: 03-01 Set up T accounts for assets, llabtlllles, and owners equity.
3Exerclsea
aptar 3 Problems
t
()bfec:IMI: 03-03 Determine the balarice of an ac:count.
3Exerdses
Objec!Ne: 03-04 Set up T acc:ounta for nwenue and expenses.
67.00%
93.
68.60%
54.40%
2 33137
1 34137
89.40%
4
1
2
1
34137
73.20%
70.50%
66.90%
70.40%
3 35137
1 35137
72.60%
33f.f1
33137
1 34137
3 Problems
89.
1 35137
35137
35137
2 35137
1 33137
1 34137
91. =
58.20%
4 35137
1
1
61.70%
67.33%
73.40%
63.90%
92..
95.1
90.70%1
95.20%
94.40%
94.90%
95.40%
95.20%1
94.50%1
94.90%
95.40%1
60.30%
70.40%
94.50%1
96.80%1
88.30%1
95.40%1
55.50%
95.soJ
72.50%
65.80%
89.40%
96.80%1
95.40%1
~----~--T-
35137
35137
33137
34137
54.70%
67.50%
62.30%
1 33137
1 33137
57.30%
62.30%
·88.:
2 35137
2 35137
64.80%
69.80%
95.80%
5 34137
2 32137
2 32/37
.1 34137
76.00%
72.70%
89.90%
13.20%
98.00%1
96.70%1
97.90%
98.20%1
4
1
2
1
34137
32/37
32137
34137
76.10%
74.00%
69.90%
73.20%
98.1
4
1
2
1
34137
32/37
32137
34137
75.90%
69.90%
69.90%
73.20%
98.20%1
Objadlve: 04-G4 Corntct emn made In 1he journal or ledger.
4Exesd9es
3 34137
2 32/37
1 34137
76.20%
74.20%
70.20%
98.20%1
98.20%
98.20%1
Objective: 05-01 Complete a trial bal8nce on a WOltcsheet.
5 Exen:iaes
s
34137
1· 33137
1 33137
.1 31137
71.70%
75.40%
'67.10%
66.90%
93.70%1
6
4
1
1
34137
33137
33137
31137
71.90%
71.90%
67.10%
66.90%
93.90%1
95.90%
95.10%:
. I
91.90%1
3 34137
1 33137
.1 33137
1 31137
71.40%
71.00%
67.10%
66.90%
93.40%
95.00%1
95.10%1
11.90%
.) 34137
53 20%
93
3Exesd9es
3Problams
1
Leaming Objective: 03-08 Pnipere an Income statement. a ata&errianl of owner s equil
3 ProblemS
.earning Objecllve: 04-01 Rec:Ofd nnwtial• In the genera1 joUmal.
4 Exen:ises
.eemlng Objective: 04-02 Prepare compound jouinal entries.
4 Exen:lses
4Problams
1
:EXAM t
I
Objec:tlve: 05-02 Prepare adjustment& fOr urncotded business transadion&.
1aplar 5 Exercise&
5 Problems
2
an Income statamenl ~al owners equity.
3
1
1
1
94.70%
98.50%1
88.30%.
95.4
1
88..
95.80%
98.1
97.
98..
97.!
93.90%'
97.90%
1
99..
85.1
91 .!
1
~-
65.90%
s
71.70%
75.00%
67.10%
34137
t 33137
Qbiecllve: 06-01 Joumellza 8nd post dollng entries.
8 ExercileS
r6 Problems
2
.88mlng Objective: 06-02 Prepare • postcloslng trial balance.
:tmpter 8 Problems
.~ .ewnlng Objective: 07-01 Record a9dlt sales In a sales joumlil.
hapter 7 Problems
EXAM2
I
.88mlng ObJecllve: 07-02 Post
7 Exercises
rrom the sales journal ao the g.,,..... ledg.,. accounts.
.earning Objec:tive: 07-04 Record seles returns 8nd .UOW.llC8S In the general joUmal
7 Problems
2
irning Qbfectlve: 07-06 Prapm9. sc:haclule of ac:counts raoelvable.
7 Exercises
2
Objective: 07-09 Prepan. lhe state .... tai return.
1 Exen:lsea
.e arning Objective: 08-01 Record purchases of rnen:handlse on cradlt in a lhrae-colul
8 Exiiclaes
64.10IJ&J
1 31137
1 33137
1 31137
euo%
7
4
2
1
'32137
29137
29137
31137
72.40%
71.40%
66.40%
68.90%
1 29137
1 '29137
74.30%
70.30%
3 33137
2 32137
1 31137
55.50%
65.80%
68.60%
5
2
2
1
33137
'32137
'32137
31137
74.00%
74.80%
68.80%
68.60%
1 31137
1 31137
75.60%
71.60%
2 33fJ7
1 32137
1 31137
54.80%
64.20%
68.60%
1 31137
1 31137
75.60%
71.80%
2 33137
1 32137
1 31137
55.20%
68.50%
68.60%
1 32137
1 32137
79.50%
75.50%
1 32137
1 32137
75.10%
71.10%
4 32137
2 31137
74.5°"
74.60%_
95:
91.
96.
98.
96.
94.
94.
95.
94.
96.50%1
_98.60%
1 31137
1 31137
70.20%
Objective: 08-02 Post from the three-column ptin:haSea joufniil to the geiieil
:hapter 8 Problems
2
2 32137
1 31/37
1 31/37
56.20%
66.70%
69.20%
ing ObjecUve: 08-03 Post credit purd1ases from the purchases journal to the ace
2 32137
1 31137
1 31/37
56.20%
66.7o%
69.20%
5
3
1
1
32137
31/37
31/37
31/37
74.80%
75.()()%
89.70%
to.20%
95.M
2 32137
1 31/37
1 31/37
56.20%
96.20%
97.70%
2 32137
1 31/37
1 31/37
56.20%
66.7<1%
69.20%
96.20%
2 33137
1 33137
1 27/37
52.50%
66.00%
65.80%
92.50%
1 27/37
1 27137
72.80%
68.80%
I
91.80%1
91.80%
1 27137
.1 27137
72.80%
68.80%
91.80%1
Ing
09-04 Record cash payments In a cash payments journal.
1aptar 9 ProblefnS
1 32/37
1 32137
69.50%
65.50%
88.50%1
88.50%.
Objective: 09-05 Post from the cash payments journal to subskllary and geno
,apter 9 Problems
1 32137
1 32137
69.50%
65.50%
88.50%1
88.50%
1 33137
1 33137
77.10%
73.10%
96.10%
Leaming Objective: 09-07 Demonstrate a knowledge of internal control procedures for
EXAM3
1 2/37
1 2137
31 .00%
2.7.00%
50.00%
50.00%'
Leaming Objective: 09·09 Reconcire the monthly bank statement
3 33/37
52.20%
92.20%1
8 Problems
2
~ectlve:
k-mlng
08-04 Record Purchases Allums and allowances In the general jo
, apter 8 Exercises
1apter 8 Problems
:l
.earning bbtec:tive: 08-06 Compute the net delivered cost of purchases.
B Problems
2
.earning Objective: 09-03 Poat from the cash recieipts toufnal to subsiclary and gener
3 (a)
6btectiva:
-
-
-
-
--
-
Leaming Objective: 09-06 Demonstrate a knowledge of procedures for a petty cash fu
Chapter 9 Exercises
---
-
89.
66.70%
69.20%
96.80%1
99.00%1
97.70%
95.20%
97.70%.
95.20%
97.00%
91.80%
91.80%1
~
I
96.10%
Chapter 9 Exercises
Chapter 9 Problems
2 33137
1 32137
62.80%
64.80%
93.80%
90.80%
Leaming Objective: 09-10 Record any adjusting entries required from the bank reconc
Chapter 9 Exercises
Chapter 9 Problems
EXAM3
3
1
1
1
33137
33/37
32137
2137
57 60%
63.90%
64.80%
64 70%
86.40%
97.60%
90.80%
50.00%
Leaming Objective: 09-11 Understand how businesses use online banking to manage
Chapter 9 Exercises
1 33137
1 33137
74 .00%
70.00%
93.00%
93.00%
Leaming Objective· 10-02 Compute gross earnings of employees.
Chapter 10 Exercises
Chapter 1o Problems
EXAM 3 (a)
4
1
2
1
32137
31137
31137
27137
57.60%
63.90%
64.80%
64.70%
88.40%
99.00%
92.80%
83.70%
Leaming Objective. 10-03 Determine employee deductions for social security tax.
Chapter 1O Exercises
Chapter 10 Problems
EXAM 3(a)
4
1
2
1
32137
31/37
31/37
27137
57.60%
63.90%
64.80%
6470%
87.60%
86.90%
92.80%
83.70%
Leaming Objechve: 10-04 Determine employee deductions for Medicare lax.
Chapter 10 Exercises
Chapter 10 Problems
EXAM 3 (a)
4
1
2
1
32137
31/37
3 1/37
27137
57.60%
63.90%
64.80%
64.70%
88.30%
9780%
9280%
83.70%
Leaming Objective: 10-05 Determine employee deductions for income lax.
Chapter 10 Exercises
Chapter 1O Problems
EXAM 3 (a)
4
1
2
1
32137
31137
31/37
27/37
57.60%
63.90%
64.80%
64.70%
88.40%
99.50%
92.80%
83.70%
Leaming Objective: 10-06 Enter gross earnings, deductions. and net pay in the payrol
Chapter 1O Problems
1 3 1137
1 3 1/37
78.50%
74.50%
97.50%
97.50%
Leaming Objective. 10-07 Journalize payron transactions in !he general joumal
Chapter 10 Exercises
Chapter 10 Problems
4 31137
2 31/37
2 31/37
54.70%
67.50%
62.30%
94.30%
9900%
92.80%
Leaming ObJectrve: 11-02 Compute and record the employers social security and Mee
Chapter 11 Exercises
Chapter 11 Problems
2 30/37
1 30/37
1 30137
58.70%
66.40%
73.20%
98.70%
97.40%
9920%
Leaming Objective. 11-03 Record deposit of social security, Medicare. and employee
Chapter 11 Exercises
EXAM 3(a)
2 32137
1 30/37
1 27/37
55.80%
68.50%
6920%
95.80%
99.50%
95.20%
5 30137
54.70%
9450%
Leaming Objective. 11-06 Compute and record llab1llty for federal and state
unempto ~
Chapter 11 Exercises
Chapter 11 Problems
3 30137
2 30137
6750%
62.30%
98.80%
91 .80%
Leaming Objective: 11--07 Prepare an Employers Federal Unemployment Tax Return,
Chapter 11 Problems
1 30137
1 30137
65.40%
61 .40%
84.40%
84.40%
.eaming ObjecllVi: 11:o8 CCimjiUt.--nKiiid work.S cOfriP8iiS880ii insui'ance pnm
11 Ex8n:lsas
ObJecave: 12..01 Detemllne 1he adjuStment for marchandlle ~. and.
:~r 12 Exei'cises
.. 12 Problems
3
3 (•)
I Objedlve: 12-02 Compute lldjustri1enls for accrued and prapeid expen88 ltet
12 Exen:iMs
.earning ()bfeclive: 12~ Compute adjmlmenta for accrued and deferred income lter
12Ex.-dsea
Leaming Objective: 12-04 Complete a 10-column worbheet
Chapter 12 Problems
EXAM3
EXAM3 (a}
Leaming Objective: 13--03 Prepare a classified balance sheet from the worksheet
,EXAM3
i.iii1!!i Olateome L
Leaming Outcome 2
Leaming Outcome 3
·-
·r30137
1 30l37
71.00%
4
1
1
1
1
3 1/37
3 1/37
28137
1137
27137
58.7o%
73.40%
7
3
2
1
1
31/37
31/37
28137
2137
27/37
5
1
2
1
1
4
2
1
1
58.60%
3Ul0%
55.80%
86.1~
85.80%1
87.20%,
64.20%
22.00%
69.90%
50.00%1
3 1137
31137
28137
2137
27/37
55.80%
85.
58.70%
81.70%'
87.20%1
30/37
28137
2/37
27/37
56.10%
64.20%
22.00%
69.90%
86.10%
87.20%
50.00%
88.90%
60.10%
56. 10%
79.10%
79. 10%
87:-iii
: Rta%
1 2/37
1 2137
59.20%
31.00%
88.
50.00%1
88.90%1
64.31 %
54.13%
9 1.59%
78.40%