"OOVBM3FQPSU
UI"OOJWFSTBSZ
74/-EMBERS
!SOF&EBRUARY
!LBANIA
!NGOLA
!NTIGUAAND"ARBUDA
!RGENTINA
!RMENIA
!USTRALIA
!USTRIA
"AHRAIN+INGDOMOF
"ANGLADESH
"ARBADOS
"ELGIUM
"ELIZE
"ENIN
"OLIVIA
"OTSWANA
"RAZIL
"RUNEI$ARUSSALAM
"ULGARIA
"URKINA&ASO
"URUNDI
#AMBODIA
#AMEROON
#ANADA
#ENTRAL!FRICAN2EPUBLIC
#HAD
#HILE
#HINA
#OLOMBIA
#ONGO
#OSTA2ICA
#ÙTED)VOIRE
#ROATIA
#UBA
#YPRUS
#ZECH2EPUBLIC
$EMOCRATIC2EPUBLICOF
THE#ONGO
$ENMARK
$JIBOUTI
$OMINICA
$OMINICAN2EPUBLIC
%CUADOR
%GYPT
%L3ALVADOR
%STONIA
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
&IJI
&INLAND
&ORMER9UGOSLAV2EPUBLICOF
-ACEDONIA&92/-
4HISREPORTISALSOAVAILABLEIN&RENCHAND3PANISH
0RICE#(&
4OORDERPLEASECONTACT
74/0UBLICATIONS
7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
RUEDE,AUSANNE#('ENEVA
4EL&AX
%MAILPUBLICATIONS WTOORG
)33.
)3".
0RINTEDIN3WITZERLAND
6
¥7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
&RANCE
'ABON
4HE'AMBIA
'EORGIA
'ERMANY
'HANA
'REECE
'RENADA
'UATEMALA
'UINEA
'UINEA"ISSAU
'UYANA
(AITI
(ONDURAS
(ONG+ONG#HINA
(UNGARY
)CELAND
)NDIA
)NDONESIA
)RELAND
)SRAEL
)TALY
*AMAICA
*APAN
*ORDAN
+ENYA
+OREA2EPUBLICOF
+UWAIT
+YRGYZ2EPUBLIC
,ATVIA
,ESOTHO
,IECHTENSTEIN
,ITHUANIA
,UXEMBOURG
-ACAO#HINA
-ADAGASCAR
-ALAWI
-ALAYSIA
-ALDIVES
-ALI
-ALTA
-AURITANIA
-AURITIUS
-EXICO
-OLDOVA
-ONGOLIA
-OROCCO
-OZAMBIQUE
-YANMAR
.AMIBIA
.EPAL
.ETHERLANDS
.EW:EALAND
.ICARAGUA
.IGER
.IGERIA
.ORWAY
/MAN
0AKISTAN
0ANAMA
0APUA.EW'UINEA
0ARAGUAY
0ERU
0HILIPPINES
0OLAND
0ORTUGAL
1ATAR
2OMANIA
2WANDA
3AINT+ITTSAND.EVIS
3AINT,UCIA
3AINT6INCENTTHE'RENADINES
3ENEGAL
3IERRA,EONE
3INGAPORE
3LOVAK2EPUBLIC
3LOVENIA
3OLOMON)SLANDS
3OUTH!FRICA
3PAIN
3RI,ANKA
3URINAME
3WAZILAND
3WEDEN
3WITZERLAND
#HINESE4AIPEI
4ANZANIA
4HAILAND
4OGO
4RINIDADAND4OBAGO
4UNISIA
4URKEY
5GANDA
5NITED!RAB%MIRATES
5NITED+INGDOM
5NITED3TATESOF!MERICA
5RUGUAY
6ENEZUELA
:AMBIA
:IMBABWE
"OOVBM3FQPSU
UI"OOJWFSTBSZ
&OREWORDBYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
4HISYEARMARKSTHETH!NNIVERSARYOFTHE74/)TISANOCCASIONFORUSTOREFLECT
ONTHETENYEARSTHATHAVEPASSEDANDCONSIDERWAYSOFPRESERVINGANDIMPROVINGTHOSE
THINGSWEHAVEDONEWELLWHILEADDRESSINGAREASWHEREWECANDOBETTER!SONEOFTHE
CONTRIBUTIONSTOTHISEXERCISEWEHAVEINCLUDEDASPECIALSECTIONINTHISYEARS!NNUAL2EPORT
TOREVIEWSOMEOFTHEIMPORTANTDEVELOPMENTSINTHE74/SINCEANDTOIDENTIFYSOME
OFTHECHALLENGESTHATLIEAHEAD/NBALANCE)CANSAYWITHCONFIDENCETHATTHESEPAST
TENYEARSHAVEBEENASUCCESS7EHAVELEARNEDIMPORTANTLESSONSABOUTTRANSPARENCYAND
INCLUSIVENESSANDTHATTHEREISNOALTERNATIVETOTHEGLOBALTRADINGSYSTEMININTERNATIONAL
COMMERCE
4HEINCREASINGPUBLICINTERESTINTHE74/SWORKSINCEITSCREATIONINHASBEEN
MATCHEDBYAGROWINGDEMANDFORMOREINFORMATIONABOUTTHEORGANIZATIONANDTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM4HE74/3ECRETARIATHASWORKEDTOMEETTHISEXPECTATIONBY
EXPANDINGITSINFORMATIONACTIVITIESTOINCLUDEABROADERRANGEOFPUBLICATIONSANEXTENSIVE
)NTERNETSITEANDNUMEROUSOUTREACHACTIVITIES
4HIS!NNUAL2EPORTISAGUIDEANDCOMPENDIUMCOVERINGTHEINSTITUTIONALASPECTSOFTHE
74/ITSREGULARACTIVITIESTHEWORKOF74/-EMBERSANDTHE3ECRETARIATSBUDGETANDSTAFF
4HE7ORLD4RADE2EPORTPUBLISHEDATMIDYEARPROVIDESRESEARCHANDANALYSISOFPROBLEMS
ANDISSUESWHICHCURRENTLYCONFRONTTHEGLOBALTRADINGSYSTEM
)NTHEFALLOFEACHYEARTHE74/PUBLISHESITSDETAILEDCOMPILATIONOF)NTERNATIONAL4RADE
3TATISTICS4HESEANNUALPUBLICATIONSCONSTITUTEACOMPREHENSIVEREVIEWOFTRADEISSUES
DEVELOPMENTSANDINITIATIVESFOREACHYEAR4HEYAREPARTOFTHE74/SCONTINUINGEFFORTSTO
WORKINAMANNERWHICHISTRANSPARENTINFORMATIVEANDINTUNEWITHTHEEXPECTATIONSOFTHE
PUBLICAROUNDTHEWORLD
3UPACHAI0ANITCHPAKDI
$IRECTOR'ENERAL
)))
4ABLEOF#ONTENTS
#HAPTER/NEn/VERVIEW
)NTRODUCTION 4RADEDEVELOPMENTS 4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA &ULLIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING 74/REGULARACTIVITY #HAPTER4WOn74/ACTIVITIES
0!24) ) 4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$! )) 74/ACCESSIONNEGOTIATIONS ))) 7ORKOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL )6 4RADEINGOODS 64RADEINSERVICES 6) 4RADERELATEDASPECTSOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS42)03 6)) 2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING 6))) 4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW-ECHANISM )8 #OMMITTEEON"ALANCEOF0AYMENTS2ESTRICTIONS 8 #OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS 8) #OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT 8)) #OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT 8))) #OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND!DMINISTRATION 8)6 0LURILATERAL!GREEMENTS 0!24)) ) #OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSANDRELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY )) 0UBLICINFORMATIONACTIVITIES !NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDINGREMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY !NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS #HAPTER4HREEn/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
4HEORGANIZATION 3ECRETARIAT 74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS 74/BUDGET 74/TH!NNIVERSARY
74/TH!NNIVERSARYnHIGHLIGHTSOFTHEFIRSTDECADE -INISTERIALCONFERENCES !CCESSIONSTOTHE74/n 4RADEINSERVICES -ARKETACCESS !GRICULTURE 4HE42)03!GREEMENT 74/DISPUTESETTLEMENT 4HE74/!PPELLATE"ODY 2ULES 4RADEPOLICIESREVIEW 4RADEANDENVIRONMENT 'OVERNMENTPROCUREMENT #OMPETITIONPOLICY #OHERENCE 4RADEANDFINANCE 4EXTILES 4ECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDTRAINING $EVELOPMENT %CONOMIC2ESEARCH 4RADESTATISTICS 74/LIBRARY %XTERNAL2ELATIONS 0UBLICANDMEDIAINFORMATION 6
,ISTOFTABLESCHARTSANDBOXES
#HAPTER4WOn74/ACTIVITIES
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
"OX))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
4ABLE))
7AIVERSUNDER!RTICLE)8OFTHE74/!GREEMENT %XPORTERSSUBJECTTOINITIATIONSOFCOUNTERVAILINGINVESTIGATIONS*ULYn*UNE 3UMMARYOFCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYACTIONS*ULY*UNE 3UMMARYOFANTIDUMPINGACTIONS*ULYn*UNE %XPORTERSSUBJECTTOTWOORMOREINITIATIONSOFANTIDUMPINGINVESTIGATIONS*ULYn*UNE
2EQUESTFORCONSULTATIONS "ACKGROUNDONTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK .'/ATTENDANCEATMINISTERIALCONFERENCES )NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVER3TATUSINTHE74/ASAT*ULY )NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/ /BSERVERSTATUSINCERTAINOTHERBODIES )NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn
/BSERVERSTATUSINCOMMITTEESUNDERTHEPLURILATERALTRADEAGREEMENTS #HAPTER4HREEn/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
4ABLE)))
4ABLE)))
4ABLE)))
4ABLE)))
4ABLE)))
4ABLEOFREGULARSTAFFBYNATIONALITY $ISTRIBUTIONOFSTAFFPOSITIONSWITHINTHE74/gSVARIOUSDIVISIONS 74/3ECRETARIATBUDGETFOR "UDGETFORTHE!PPELLATE"ODYANDITS3ECRETARIAT -EMBERSgCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHE74/BUDGETANDTHEBUDGETOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODY 74/TH!NNIVERSARY
#HART
4ABLE
#HART
#HART
3ECTORFOCUSOFCURRENTCOMMITMENTS.OVEMBER #OMMITMENTSOFDIFFERENTGROUPSOF-EMBERS.OVEMBER 3ECTORPROFILEOFINITIALOFFERS.OVEMBER #ONTENTOFINITIALOFFERSNEWCOMMITMENTSVERSUSIMPROVEMENTS.OVEMBER .UMBEROF424!ACTIVITIES 74/TECHNICALASSISTANCEnEXPENDITURE 74/TECHNICALASSISTANCEnRESOURCES 6))
!BBREVIATIONSANDSYMBOLS
!0%#
!3%!.
#%&4!
#)3
%#5
%&4!
%5
&$)
'$0
'.0
)-&
,!)!
-%2#/352
.!&4!
/%#$
4/4
5.#4!$
!SIA0ACIFIC%CONOMIC#OOPERATION
!SSOCIATIONOF3OUTH%AST!SIAN.ATIONS
#ENTRAL%UROPEAN&REE4RADE!GREEMENT
#OMMONWEALTHOF)NDEPENDENT3TATES
%UROPEANCURRENCYUNIT
%UROPEAN&REE4RADE!SSOCIATION
%UROPEAN5NION
&OREIGNDIRECTINVESTMENT
'ROSS$OMESTIC0RODUCT
'ROSS.ATIONAL0RODUCT
)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UND
,ATIN!MERICAN)NTEGRATION!SSOCIATION
3OUTHERN#OMMON-ARKET
.ORTH!MERICAN&REE4RADE!GREEMENT
/RGANISATIONFOR%CONOMIC#OOPERATIONAND$EVELOPMENT
TERMSOFTRADE
5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
CIF
FOB
NA
COSTINSURANCEANDFREIGHT
FREEONBOARD
NOTAVAILABLE
4HEFOLLOWINGSYMBOLSAREUSEDINTHISPUBLICATION
NOTAPPLICABLE
FIGUREISZEROORBECAMEZERODUETOROUNDING
5NITED3TATESDOLLARS
"ILLIONMEANSONETHOUSANDMILLION
-INORDISCREPANCIESBETWEENCONSTITUENTFIGURESANDTOTALSAREDUETOROUNDING
5NLESSOTHERWISEINDICATEDIALLVALUEFIGURESAREEXPRESSEDIN53DOLLARSIITRADEFIGURESINCLUDETHEINTRATRADEOFFREETRADEAREAS
CUSTOMSUNIONSREGIONALANDOTHERCOUNTRYGROUPINGSIIIMERCHANDISETRADEFIGURESAREONACUSTOMSBASISANDIVMERCHANDISE
EXPORTSAREFOBANDMERCHANDISEIMPORTSARECIF$ATAFORTHELATESTYEARAREPROVISIONAL
#HAPTER/NE
/6%26)%7
/VERVIEW
)NTRODUCTION
/VERVIEW
)NTRODUCTION
HASBEENAVERYACTIVEANDPRODUCTIVEYEARFORTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMBOTH
INTERMSOFPROGRESSINTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!ASWELLASINTHE74/SREGULAR
WORK4HESEDEVELOPMENTSHAVETAKENPLACEAGAINSTTHEBACKDROPOFAMUCHHEALTHIER
GLOBALECONOMY4HE$$!WASGIVENANIMPORTANTBOOSTWITH-EMBERSDECISIONIN*ULY
ONAPACKAGEOFMEASURESTOCONCRETELYADVANCETHENEGOTIATIONSINSOMEOFTHEAREAS
WHICHHADUNTILTHENBEENAMONGTHEMOSTDIFFICULTANDINTRACTABLE4HE*ULY$ECISIONOF
THE'ENERAL#OUNCILPUTTHE$$!FIRMLYBACKONTRACKAFTERTHEDISAPPOINTINGOUTCOMETO
THE74/S&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN#ANCÞN7ITHPROGRESSINALLAREASINPARTICULAR
ONAGRICULTUREANDADETERMINATIONONTHEFUTURETREATMENTOFTHEh3INGAPOREISSUESvTHE
PARAMETERSOFTHENEGOTIATIONSARECLEARER4HECHALLENGENOWBEFORE-EMBERSISTOBUILD
UPONTHESEFOUNDATIONSINORDERTODEVELOPTHECONSENSUSNECESSARYTOCONCLUDETHE2OUND
4HISWILLREQUIRECONSIDERABLETECHNICALWORKASWELLASSERIOUSPOLITICALCOMMITMENTAND
DETERMINATION
7ORKHASALSOCONTINUEDINSETTLINGDISPUTESPROVIDINGSURVEILLANCEOF-EMBERSTRADE
POLICIESANDIMPLEMENTINGTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDAGREEMENTS"YTHEENDOFTHETOTAL
NUMBEROFCASESBROUGHTTOTHE74/SDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMHADRISENTO"ETWEEN
*ANUARYANDTHEENDOF-ARCH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWSWERECONDUCTED4HEYEAR
ALSOSAWTHEENDOFTHETENYEARTRANSITIONALIMPLEMENTATIONPERIODOFTHE!GREEMENT
ON4EXTILESAND#LOTHINGWHICHHADBEENAGREEDASPARTOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUND4HISBROUGHT
TOANENDMORETHANYEARSOFTRADERESTRICTINGTEXTILESQUOTAS
)NADDITIONTHE74/3ECRETARIATHASCONTINUEDTOINTENSIFYITSEFFORTSTOPROVIDEMORE
ANDVARIEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEACTIVITIESASWELLASTOREACHOUTTOTHEWIDERPUBLIC/VER
THECOURSEOFTHEYEARMORETHANTECHNICALASSISTANCEACTIVITIESWEREUNDERTAKEN%FFORTS
HAVEALSOBEENMADETOSTEPUPPOLICYCOHERENCEWITHTHE"RETTON7OODSINSTITUTIONS4WO
'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGSWEREDEVOTEDTOCOHERENCEIN
&URTHERMORETHE74/ISBECOMINGAMOREUNIVERSALORGANIZATION&OLLOWINGDOMESTIC
RATIFICATIONPROCEDURES#AMBODIAAND.EPALBECAME74/-EMBERSIN4HISBRINGS
THETOTAL74/-EMBERSHIPUPTO!SOF$ECEMBER'OVERNMENTSWERE
ACTIVELYPURSUINGACCESSIONTOTHE74/#OPINGWITHANINCREASINGLYLARGEANDDIVERSE
MEMBERSHIPISAMONGTHEMAJORCHALLENGESFACINGTHE74/7ITHTHISINMINDTHE$IRECTOR
'ENERALHADASKEDAGROUPOFEMINENTPERSONSTOREFLECTUPONTHESYSTEMICCHALLENGESTHE
74/FACESANDHOWTHISINSTITUTIONCOULDBEREINFORCEDANDEQUIPPEDTOMEETTHEM)N
*ANUARYTHISGROUPCHAIREDBY0ETER3UTHERLANDRELEASEDTHEIR2EPORTh4HE&UTUREOF
THE74/!DDRESSING)NSTITUTIONAL#HALLENGESINTHE.EW-ILLENNIUMv4HE2EPORTANDITS
RECOMMENDATIONSARECURRENTLYUNDERCONSIDERATIONBY74/-EMBERS
4RADEDEVELOPMENTS
)NTHEWORLDECONOMYRECORDEDITSSTRONGESTGROWTHINMORETHANADECADE
PROVIDINGTHEFOUNDATIONSFORANEXPANSIONOFWORLDTRADE7ORLD'$0GREWBYPERCENT
ANDWORLDMERCHANDISETRADEROSEBYPERCENTINREALTERMS4HEYEARALSOWITNESSED
ANARROWINGOFTHEGAPBETWEENTHEREGIONAL'$0GROWTHRATESOFTHEFASTESTGROWINGAND
THELEASTDYNAMICREGIONSBETWEENAND!SINRECENTYEARSDEVELOPING!SIAAND
#OMMONWEALTHOF)NDEPENDENT3TATES#)3MEMBERCOUNTRIESREPORTEDTHESTRONGESTOUTPUT
GROWTHWORLDWIDEATTOPERCENT3OUTH!MERICAS'$0GROWTHACCELERATEDTOPERCENT
INTHEREGIONSSTRONGESTGROWTHSINCE.ORTH!MERICASGROWTHPICKEDUPIN
REACHINGPERCENTWHICHSLIGHTLYEXCEEDSTHEGLOBALAVERAGE0ROVISIONALDATAFOR
!FRICAANDTHE-IDDLE%ASTPOINTTOANECONOMICGROWTHINCLOSETOTHEGLOBALAVERAGE
4HISWOULDREPRESENTAMARKEDIMPROVEMENTAGAINSTTHERECORDOFTHES4HEREWERE
SOMEWEAKERSPOTSHOWEVERONTHEGLOBALECONOMICMAP4HEEUROAREARECORDEDGROWTHOF
PERCENTWHICHISONLYAMARGINALIMPROVEMENTINECONOMICACTIVITY)N*APANECONOMIC
GROWTHGROUNDTOAHALTAFTERTHEFIRSTQUARTEROFBUTSTILLGAINEDANAVERAGEEXPANSION
OFPERCENTONAYEARTOYEARBASIS
/VERVIEW
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
4HISOUTPUTANDTRADEGROWTHWASACHIEVEDAGAINSTTHEBACKGROUNDOFSHARPLYHIGHER
PRICESFORFUELSANDMANYOTHERPRIMARYCOMMODITIES4HEDECLINEOF&$)FLOWSOBSERVEDFROM
THROUGHWASARRESTEDANDREVERSEDIN-AJOREXCHANGERATEADJUSTMENTS
ININCLUDEDTHEFURTHERAPPRECIATIONOFMOST%UROPEANCURRENCIESANDMANY!SIAN
CURRENCIESVISÌVISTHE53DOLLAR4HEEUROANDTHEYENINPARTICULARAPPRECIATEDONAN
ANNUALAVERAGEBASISBYPERCENTANDPERCENTRESPECTIVELY
4HELOWERVALUEOFTHE53DOLLARAGAINSTTHECURRENCIESOFMAJORTRADERSCOMBINEDWITH
THEMARKEDRISEINTHEPRICESFORFUELSMETALSANDMANYAGRICULTURALRAWMATERIALSLEDTO
ANINCREASEINTHEDOLLARPRICESOFINTERNATIONALLYTRADEDGOODSBYPERCENT5NDERTHE
COMBINEDIMPACTOFSTRONGERREALTRADEGROWTHANDTHEMARKEDINCREASEINPRICESTHE
DOLLARVALUEOFWORLDMERCHANDISETRADEROSEBYPERCENTREACHINGTRILLIONDOLLARS
#OMMERCIALSERVICESEXPORTSAREESTIMATEDTOHAVEINCREASEDBYPERCENTTOTRILLION
4HEACCELERATIONINTHEVALUEGROWTHOFCOMMERCIALSERVICESTRADECANBEPARTLYATTRIBUTEDTO
THERECOVERYINTRAVELEXPENDITURE!SINHOWEVERCOMMERCIALSERVICESTRADEMEASURED
ONABALANCEOFPAYMENTSBASISLAGGEDBEHINDTHATOFWORLDMERCHANDISETRADEANDASINTHE
PREVIOUSYEARTHESHARPRISEINCOMMODITYPRICESAGAINPLAYEDAMAJORROLEINTHISOUTCOME
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDASAWSOMEVERYPOSITIVEADVANCESINBUILDINGON
THEELEMENTSTHATHADEMERGEDATANDSINCETHE74/S&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEHELD
IN#ANCÞNIN4HE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEEANDITSSUBSIDIARYBODIESWERE
REACTIVATEDINEARLY!PRINCIPALOBJECTIVEFORTHEFIRSTHALFOFTHEYEARWASTOTAKETHE
NECESSARYACTIONSTHATWOULDREENERGIZETHENEGOTIATIONS3UBSTANTIVEPREPARATIONSTOWARDS
FRAMEWORKLEVELAGREEMENTSASPARTOFABROADERPACKAGETOBEAGREEDATTHE*ULYMEETING
OFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILBEGANIMMEDIATELYAFTERTHEAPPOINTMENTOFANEWSLATEOFOFFICERS
FORREGULAR74/BODIESINCLUDINGTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILANDTHENEGOTIATINGBODIESIN&EBRUARY
)NTENSIVECONSULTATIONSWEREHELDBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILANDBYTHE
$IRECTOR'ENERALAS#HAIRMANOFTHE4.#4HECHALLENGEWASTOTRANSLATETHESTRONGPOLITICAL
COMMITMENTTOTHESUCCESSOFTHE$$!NEGOTIATIONSINTOCONCRETEACTION
/N*UNETHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL#HAIRMANANNOUNCEDATANINFORMALMEETINGATTHE
LEVELOF(EADSOF$ELEGATIONTHATTHE*ULY$ECISIONCOULDCOVERNINEMAINELEMENTSINCLUDING
AGRICULTURECOTTONNONAGRICULTURALMARKETACCESSDEVELOPMENTAND3INGAPOREISSUES
!FTERVERYINTENSIVECONSULTATIONSBOTHIN'ENEVAANDALSOINCAPITALSTHEFIRSTDRAFTOFTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCIL$ECISIONWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERSFORTHEIRCONSIDERATIONON*ULY
!FTERFURTHERCONSULTATIONSANDREVISIONSTHE$ECISIONWASFURTHERREVISEDANDADOPTEDBY
-EMBERSINTHEEVENINGOF*ULY
-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEADOPTIONOFTHE*ULY$ECISIONASABREAKTHROUGHANDSAIDTHAT
ITWOULDREINVIGORATETHENEGOTIATIONSANDASSIST-EMBERSTOACHIEVETHEOBJECTIVESSETIN
$OHAIN.OVEMBER)TWASSTRESSEDTHATWHILETHE*ULY$ECISIONPROVIDEDIMPORTANT
SIGNPOSTSITWASIMPERATIVEFOR-EMBERSTOBUILDONITBYCONTINUINGTOENGAGEINTENSIVELY
ANDWORKINASPIRITOFCOMPROMISETOADVANCETHENEGOTIATINGAGENDA
4HE&RAMEWORKON!GRICULTUREWHICHWASAGREEDASPARTOFTHE*ULYPACKAGEHASBEENA
MAJORSTEPFORWARDINTHISTECHNICALLYCOMPLEXANDPOLITICALLYSENSITIVEAREA)TFLESHESOUTTHE
$OHAMANDATEBYESTABLISHINGSPECIFICOBJECTIVESFORTHENEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTUREANDTHE
MEANSTOACHIEVETHEM7HILETHE&RAMEWORKHASLEFTMANYPOLITICALISSUESFORRESOLUTIONAT
THESUBSEQUENTSTAGEOFTHENEGOTIATIONSITALREADYREFLECTSIMPORTANTMOVEMENTSTOWARDS
CONVERGENCEINALLTHREEPILLARSOFMARKETACCESSEXPORTCOMPETITIONANDDOMESTICSUPPORT
INCLUDINGTHEHISTORICCOMMITMENTTOELIMINATEALLFORMSOFEXPORTSUBSIDIZATIONATADATETO
BEAGREED!SPARTOFTHISAGREEMENT-EMBERSACHIEVEDABREAKTHROUGHINCOTTONWHICHIS
SOIMPORTANTTOCOTTONFARMERSINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESPARTICULARLYLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
IN7EST!FRICA&ORMANY74/-EMBERSPARTICULARLYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAGOODMARKET
ACCESSDEALINAGRICULTURECOUPLEDWITHTHEELIMINATIONOFALLFORMSOFEXPORTSUBSIDIZATION
ANDSUBSTANTIALREDUCTIONSINTRADEDISTORTINGSUPPORTHOLDSTHEPROMISEOFAMPLENEW
GROWTHANDEMPLOYMENTOPPORTUNITIESTHROUGHTRADEINCLUDINGTHROUGHBROADENINGTHE
AVENUESFORMUTUALLYADVANTAGEOUS3OUTH3OUTHTRADE
,IKEWISETHEFRAMEWORKONNONAGRICULTURALMARKETACCESS.!-!WASTOBEASTEPPING
STONETOWARDSFULLMODALITIES!SDISCUSSIONSONTHISSUBJECTWEREPURSUEDITBECAMECLEAR
THATTWOAPPROACHESWEREBEINGESPOUSED4HEREWERETHOSE-EMBERSWHOSOUGHTTOKEEP
THE.!-!TEXTWHICHORIGINATEDFROMTHESECONDREVISIONOFTHEDRAFT#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL
4EXTTHESOCALLED$ERBEZTEXTUNCHANGED7HILETHEREWEREOTHERSWHOWISHEDTO
NEGOTIATETHATTEXTANDINTRODUCEAMENDMENTS4HECOMPROMISEREACHEDWASTOINCLUDEA
NEWPARAGRAPHTOTHATORIGINALTEXTTOGIVEANOVERALLLEVELOFCOMFORT
/VERVIEW
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
)NSERVICES-EMBERSAGREEDTOSUBMITTHEIRREVISEDOFFERSBYTHEENDOF-AY
OUTSTANDINGINITIALOFFERSSHOULDBETABLEDASSOONASPOSSIBLE#ONCERNSHADBEENEXPRESSED
THATTHENEGOTIATIONSONSERVICESWEREFALLINGBEHINDINRELATIONTOTHEOTHERTWOMARKET
ACCESSNEGOTIATIONS"YTHEENDOFALMOSTTWOYEARSAFTERTHETARGETDATEFORTHE
SUBMISSIONOFINITIALOFFERSTHEREREMAINEDNOTONLYAVERYSIGNIFICANTNUMBEROF-EMBERS
WHOHADNOTYETDONESOBUTTHEREWASALSOASENSEOFDISSATISFACTIONWITHTHESUBSTANCE
CONTAINEDINTHEOFFERSTHATHADBEENSUBMITTED-OREOVERONTHERULEMAKINGSIDEOFTHE
NEGOTIATIONSDOMESTICREGULATIONEMERGENCYSAFEGUARDMEASURESGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENT
ANDSUBSIDIESTHATHADBEENCONTINUEDAFTERTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRELATIVELYLITTLEPROGRESS
HASBEENACHIEVEDWITHTHEPOSSIBLEEXCEPTIONOFDOMESTICREGULATIONOVERTHEPAST
MONTHS
!GREEMENTWASALSOFINALLYREACHEDONHOWTHEh3INGAPORE)SSUESvnTRADEFACILITATION
TRADEANDINVESTMENTTRADEANDCOMPETITIONPOLICYANDTRANSPARENCYINGOVERNMENT
PROCUREMENTnSHOULDBEHANDLED.EGOTIATIONSARETOBELAUNCHEDONTRADEFACILITATION
WHILETHEOTHERTHREEISSUESWILLNOTBENEGOTIATEDINTHIS2OUND
4HE*ULY$ECISIONCOMMITS-EMBERSTOFULFILLINGTHEDEVELOPMENTDIMENSIONOFTHE$$!
ANDSETSOUTAROADMAPFORFURTHERPURSUINGTHEREVIEWOFSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENT
$URINGTHECOURSEOFWORKONSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTHADFOCUSSEDON
TRYINGTOBUILDUPONTHEPROGRESSTHATHADBEENACHIEVEDUPTOTHE74/S&IFTH-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEWHERE-EMBERSHADAGREEDINPRINCIPLETOAGREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSBUT
HADNOTADOPTEDTHEM!CCORDINGLYWORKINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADE
AND$EVELOPMENTMAINLYFOCUSSEDONEXPLORINGABROADERANDMOREOVERARCHINGAPPROACHTO
SPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTINTHE74/SOASTOBREAKTHEIMPASSEANDTRYANDREACH
ANAGREEMENTONPOSSIBLERECOMMENDATIONSFORTHEREMAINING!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALS
)TISHOPEDTHATTHISAPPROACHORSOMEOFTHEELEMENTSCONTAINEDTHEREINWOULDHELPTO
ACHIEVECONVERGENCEONTHEREMAININGWORKANDENABLETHE3PECIAL3ESSIONTOhREPORTTOTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILWITHCLEARRECOMMENDATIONSFORADECISIONvBY*ULYASMANDATEDIN
THE*ULY$ECISION
/VERTHECOURSEOFWORKALSOCONTINUEDONALLOTHERAREASOFTHE$OHA
$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
!LTHOUGHTHEWORKOFTHE.EGOTIATING'ROUPON2ULESWASFORATIMEDELAYEDAFTER
THE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN#ANCÞNWORKRESUMEDINTHESPRINGANDINTENSIFIEDDURING
THECOURSEOFTHEYEAR)NTHEAREAOF!NTI$UMPINGAND3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING
-EASURESINCLUDING&ISHERIES3UBSIDIESTHE'ROUPSHIFTEDEMPHASISFROMAFORMALPROCESS
OFISSUEIDENTIFICATIONTOANINFORMALPROCESSINVOLVINGANINDEPTHEXAMINATIONOFDETAILED
ELABORATEDPROPOSALSSUBMITTEDBYPARTICIPANTS4HEFOCUSOFTHE'ROUPSINFORMALWORKWAS
ONTRADEREMEDIESANAREAATTRACTINGOUTOFELABORATEDPROPOSALSSUBMITTED
)NTHEAREAOFREGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTS24!CONSIDERABLEPROGRESSHASBEENACHIEVED
INIDENTIFYINGTHEESSENTIALELEMENTSFORANIMPROVEMENTINTRANSPARENCYOFSUCHAGREEMENTS
-OREFOCUSEDDISCUSSIONSARENEEDEDATTHISSTAGETOFURTHERTHEWORKON24!SYSTEMIC
ISSUES
)NTRADEANDENVIRONMENT-EMBERSCONTINUEDTOEXPLORETHERELATIONSHIPBETWEEN74/
RULESANDSPECIFICTRADEOBLIGATIONSINMULTILATERALENVIRONMENTALAGREEMENTS-%!
4WOAPPROACHESHAVEBEENPURSUEDINPARALLELUNDERTHISMANDATEANDARESTILLUNDERWAY
4HEFIRSTHASCONSISTEDOFNATIONALEXPERIENCESHARINGONTHENEGOTIATIONANDIMPLEMENTATION
OFTRADEMEASURESIN-%!SANDTHESECONDOFADISCUSSIONOFCERTAINPOTENTIALOUTCOMES
-EMBERSHAVEALSOSTEPPEDUPWORKONTHEMANDATERELATINGTOTRADELIBERALIZATIONIN
ENVIRONMENTALGOODS4HEINPUTSOFVARIOUSINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSSUCHAS5.#4!$AND
THE7ORLD#USTOMS/RGANIZATIONATTHE/CTOBERMEETINGASWELLASATA74/7ORKSHOPON
%NVIRONMENTAL'OODSCONTRIBUTEDTOTHIS
.EGOTIATIONSALSOCONTINUEDWITHRESPECTTOIMPROVINGANDCLARIFYINGTHE$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING4HESENEGOTIATIONSHADBEENEXTENDEDIN*ULYWITHTHENEW
TARGETDATETOCONCLUDETHENEGOTIATIONSSETFOR-AY)NTHEFIRSTHALFOFTHEYEARTHE
#HAIRMANOFTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY3PECIAL3ESSIONURGED-EMBERSTOWORKTOGETHER
TOWARDSBUILDINGTHEBASISFORANAGREEMENT"Y-AYSOMEDELEGATIONSHADMADESOME
ADDITIONALWRITTENCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHENEGOTIATIONSWHICHWEREWELCOMEDBYPARTICIPANTS
ANDTHE#HAIRMANWASABLETOREPORTADDITIONALPROGRESSTOTHE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS
#OMMITTEE!LTHOUGHAFINALOUTCOMESTILLHADNOTBEENREACHEDBYTHEENDOF-AY
THEREWASAGREEMENTAMONG-EMBERSTHATTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONCONTINUEDTONEEDMORETIME
TOCOMPLETEITSWORK!CCORDINGLYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILADOPTEDINTHECONTEXTOFTHE
SOCALLED*ULY0ACKAGEARECOMMENDATIONFORTHECONTINUATIONOFWORKINTHE3PECIAL
3ESSIONBUTTHISTIMEWITHNOSPECIFICTARGETDATE)NTHESECONDHALFOFTHEYEARWORK
CONTINUEDONTHEBASISINPARTICULAROFTHEADDITIONALWRITTENCONTRIBUTIONSPUTFORWARDBY
SOME-EMBERSALLOWINGGOODPROGRESSONTHESPECIFICISSUESCOVEREDINTHESETEXTSWHICH
INCLUDEREMANDhSEQUENCINGvANDPOSTRETALIATIONISSUES4HENEGOTIATIONSONTHE$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDINGFALLOUTSIDETHESINGLEUNDERTAKINGOFTHE$$!
WASTHELASTYEAROFIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE74/!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND
#LOTHING!4#)NTHELASTQUARTEROFTHEYEARONTHEBASISOFTHE#OMPREHENSIVE2EPORT
BYTHE4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODY4-"ANDDOCUMENTSBY-EMBERSTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADE
IN'OODS#4'CONDUCTEDTHEFINALMAJORREVIEWOFIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHETHIRDSTAGEOF
INTEGRATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT4HEREVIEWWASSUCCESSFULLYCONCLUDEDON$ECEMBERTHE
SAMEDAYTHATTHE4-"HELDITSTHANDFINALMEETING
$UETOCONCERNSRAISEDBY-EMBERSREGARDINGEXPECTEDADJUSTMENTCHALLENGESTHE#4'
CONSIDEREDANITEMONh0OST!4#!DJUSTMENT2ELATED)SSUESv4HEDISCUSSIONSPROVIDEDA
BETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHECHALLENGESFACEDBYCONCERNED-EMBERSANDHOWTHEYCOULDBE
BETTERADDRESSED-EMBERSARECONTINUINGWITHCONSULTATIONSWITHTHEACTIVEANDPOSITIVE
SUPPORTOFTHE"RETTON7OODSINSTITUTIONS
!4#EXPIRYANDTHECONCLUSIONOFTHETENYEARTRANSITIONALIMPLEMENTATIONPERIODNOT
ONLYHASTHEPOTENTIALTOCONTRIBUTETOINCREASEDGLOBALWELFAREANDEFFICIENCYGAINSBUTALSO
ENHANCEDTHEINSTITUTIONALANDLEGALSTABILITYANDPREDICTABILITYOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADING
SYSTEM)TWASAHISTORICACHIEVEMENT
/VERVIEW
74/REGULARACTIVITY
&ULLIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING
74/REGULARACTIVITY
$ISPUTESETTLEMENT
)NTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMCONTINUEDTOMAINTAINAHIGHLEVELOFACTIVITY
-EMBERSINITIATEDNEWCASESOVERTHEYEARBRINGINGTHETOTALNUMBEROFCASESOVERTHE
FIRSTTENYEARSOFOPERATIONOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTTOAREMARKABLEWITHABOUTHALFOF
THESECASESEVENTUALLYLEADINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFAPANEL4HE$3"ESTABLISHEDSEVEN
NEWPANELSPANELREPORTSWERECIRCULATEDANDFIVEAPPEALSWERENOTIFIED!PPELLATE"ODY
ANDORPANELREPORTSWEREADOPTEDINEIGHTCASES%IGHTAUTHORIZATIONSTORETALIATEWERE
ALSOGRANTEDALLINRESPECTOFASINGLEMATTER4HESEFIGURESCONFIRM-EMBERSCONTINUED
CONFIDENCEINTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMOFTHE74/ANDALSOINDICATETHESYSTEMS
CONTINUEDABILITYTOHANDLEARELATIVELYHEAVYCASELOAD
4RADEPOLICYREVIEW
4HE74/ALSOCONTINUEDTOPERFORMITSSURVEILLANCEOF-EMBERSTRADEPOLICIESAND
PRACTICES"ETWEEN*ANUARYANDENDOF-ARCH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWSWERE
CONDUCTEDBYTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY4HISEXERCISECONTINUESTOBEHIGHLYAPPRECIATED
ANDVALUEDBY-EMBERSASONEOFTHEMAINELEMENTSPROVIDINGTRANSPARENCYTOTRADE
REGIMESANDINBRINGINGGREATERUNDERSTANDINGOFANDHENCEPROVIDINGIMPROVEDADHERENCE
TOTHERULESANDPRINCIPLESTHATUNDERPINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM)NCREASINGLY
ALSOTHEEXERCISEHASBECOMEANIMPORTANTELEMENTINTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDCAPACITY
BUILDINGFORDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
4ECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDING
4HE74/AGAINTOOKONAHIGHLEVELOFCOMMITMENTINPROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCEAND
CAPACITYBUILDINGTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESSUPPORTEDBYACORRESPONDINGLEVELOFFINANCIAL
COMMITMENTFROMDONOR-EMBERS4HISISINRECOGNITIONOFTHECONSIDERABLEEXPERTISEALL
COUNTRIESNEEDINORDERTOEXERCISETHEIR74/RIGHTSANDOBLIGATIONSTOREAPTHEBENEFITS
OFMEMBERSHIPINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDTOPARTICIPATEMOREFULLYINTHE
NEGOTIATIONSnDEFININGTHEIRINTERESTSANDUNDERSTANDINGTHEIMPLICATIONSOFPROPOSALSBY
OTHERPLAYERS
)NORDERTOENHANCETHERELEVANCEANDEFFECTIVENESSOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEANEW
APPROACHTOTHEDESIGNOFTHE4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCEAND4RAINING0LANWASADOPTED
4HE0LANWASARTICULATEDAROUNDASETOFPRODUCTSWITHCLEARLYDEFINEDOBJECTIVESFOREACH
WHICHTOGETHERWITHAGREATERDEGREEOFFLEXIBILITYINIMPLEMENTATIONWASDESIGNEDTO
INCREASERESPONSIVENESSTOTHENEEDSOF-EMBERS/VERACTIVITIESWEREUNDERTAKENIN
THECOURSEOFTHEYEAR4HESEINCLUDEDEIGHTTHREEMONTHTRADEPOLICYCOURSESHELDBOTH
IN'ENEVAANDINSPECIFICREGIONS)NADDITIONTOTHEUSUALAIMSOFSUCHCOURSESTOPROVIDE
BROADBUTINTENSIVETRAININGINALLASPECTSOFTHE74/THEONESHELDREGIONALLYAIMEDAT
DEVELOPINGLOCALCAPACITYFORTRAININGANDANALYSISTHROUGHPARTNERSHIPSWITHLOCALACADEMIC
INSTITUTIONSANDWITHACADEMICSFROMWITHINTHEREGION
/VERVIEW
74/REGULARACTIVITY
-ANYOFTHETECHNICALASSISTANCEACTIVITIESWEREUNDERTAKENJOINTLYBETWEENTHE74/
ANDOTHERINTERNATIONALAGENCIES4HE74/CONTINUEDTOBEACTIVEINTWOLARGESCALEJOINT
PROGRAMMESTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES)&ANDTHE*OINT
)NTEGRATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE0ROGRAMMETO3ELECTED,EASTDEVELOPEDANDOTHER!FRICAN
#OUNTRIES*)4!04HE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKENTEREDANEWPHASEWITHTHECOMPLETIONOF
ITSSECONDEVALUATIONIN&EBRUARY4HE)&7ORK0ROGRAMMEADOPTEDBYTHE)&3TEERING
#OMMITTEEOUTLINESBROADAREASOFACTIONANDGOVERNSTHEOPERATIONSOFTHE)&UNTILTHE
3IXTH74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE!TTHEENDOF,$#SWEREATDIFFERENTSTAGESOF
THE)&PROCESS
7AYSWERESOUGHTTOSTRENGTHENINTERAGENCYCOOPERATIONINTECHNICALASSISTANCEAND
CAPACITYBUILDING4HENEEDTOHELPDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESADDRESSSUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTS
SOTHEYAREABLETOBETTERBENEFITFROMOPPORTUNITIESARISINGFROMPARTICIPATIONINTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMISRECOGNISEDANDINVOLVESACTIONTHATGOESBEYONDTHEMANDATE
ANDCOMPETENCEOFTHE74/
4HE74/3ECRETARIATALSOORGANIZEDTWOONEWEEKBRIEFINGSESSIONSON74/ISSUESAND
THESTATUSOFTHENEGOTIATIONSIN-AYAND.OVEMBERFORTHOSE74/-EMBERSAND
/BSERVERSTHATDONOTHAVEAREPRESENTATIONIN'ENEVA2EPRESENTATIVESFROMREGIONAL
ECONOMICORGANIZATIONSWEREALSOINVITEDTOTHESETWOh'ENEVAWEEKSv4HISACTIVITYWHICH
WASSTARTEDIN.OVEMBERHASPROVENTOBEVERYPOPULARANDOFFERSREPRESENTATIVES
OF74/-EMBERSWITHOUTMISSIONSIN'ENEVAANOPPORTUNITYTOKEEPABREASTOFTHESTATUS
OFWORKINDIFFERENT74/BODIESINCLUDINGTHENEGOTIATINGBODIES)NADDITIONTHE'ENEVA
7EEKSALSOPROVIDEPARTICIPANTSWITHTHEOPPORTUNITYTOMEETSOMEOFTHEIRTRADINGPARTNERS
ANDFORTHEMTOVISITOTHER'ENEVABASEDINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
3TRENGTHENINGTHE74/ASANINSTITUTION
74/CONTINUESTOBECOMEAMOREUNIVERSALANDGLOBALORGANIZATION&OLLOWINGDOMESTIC
RATIFICATION.EPALAND#AMBODIAWERERECEIVEDAS-EMBERSIN4HESEWERETHEFIRST
TWO,$#STOACCEDEUNDERTHESPECIALPROCEDURESFOR,$#SESTABLISHEDIN
4HETOTALMEMBERSHIPOFTHE74/NOWSTANDSAT7ORKING0ARTIESWEREESTABLISHED
FOR!FGHANISTAN)RAQAND,IBYAIN!SOF$ECEMBER'OVERNMENTSWERE
ACTIVELYPURSUINGACCESSIONTOTHE74/
4HEYEARWASALSONOTABLEYEARINTERMSOF74/RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
PARLIAMENTARIANSANDPARLIAMENTARYGROUPINGSANDINTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONS4HE74/HOSTEDITSPUBLICSYMPOSIUMIN-AYWHICHFOCUSEDON
THE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA!TTRACTINGARECORDNUMBEROFPARTICIPANTSFROM
GOVERNMENTSPARLIAMENTSCIVILSOCIETYTHEBUSINESSSECTORACADEMIAANDTHEMEDIA
THESYMPOSIUMHASBECOMEANIMPORTANTFIXTUREONTHEYEARLYCALENDAROFTRADERELATED
INTERNATIONALEVENTS)TISPARTOFABROADERONGOINGEFFORTBYTHE74/TOENGAGEWITHCIVIL
SOCIETY4HE74/FURTHEREXTENDEDITSPROGRAMMEOFOUTREACHACTIVITIESFORCIVILSOCIETY
ANDPARLIAMENTARIANS!FIRSTEVERREGIONALWORKSHOPFORCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVES
IN&RENCHSPEAKING!FRICAWASHELDIN3ENEGALIN.OVEMBER4HEREWEREALSOREGIONAL
WORKSHOPSCONDUCTEDIN.EW:EALANDFORPARLIAMENTARIANSFROMTHE0ACIFIC-OROCCO
FORPARLIAMENTARIANSFROM&RANCOPHONE!FRICAAND3INGAPOREFORPARLIAMENTARIANSFROM
VARIOUS!SIANCOUNTRIES4HEWORKSHOPSAREDESIGNEDTOHELPCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVESAND
LEGISLATORSBETTERUNDERSTANDTHE74//VERTHECOURSEOFTHEYEARTHE74/CONTINUEDITS
ACTIVEANDCONSTRUCTIVEENGAGEMENTWITHTHE5NITED.ATIONSSYSTEMANDOTHERINTERNATIONAL
INTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSINCLUDINGTHROUGHATTENDANCEATKEYINTERNATIONAL
CONFERENCESANDPARTICIPATIONINREGULARMEETINGSOFTHERELEVANTINSTITUTIONS
%FFORTSWEREALSOMADETOSTEPUPPOLICYCOHERENCEWITHTHE"RETTON7OODSINSTITUTIONS
$URINGTHEREWERETWO'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGSDEVOTEDTO#OHERENCEISSUES!TTHE
FIRSTMEETINGTHE!CTING-ANAGING$IRECTOROFTHE)-&-S!NNE+RUEGERPRESENTEDTHE
)-&SNEWLENDINGPOLICYnTHE4RADE)NTEGRATION-ECHANISM5NDERTHE4RADE)NTEGRATION
-ECHANISM)-&FINANCINGISBEINGMADEAVAILABLETOHELP-EMBERSCOPEWITHBALANCEOF
PAYMENTSADJUSTMENTTHATISBROUGHTABOUTBYTHEEFFECTSOFMULTILATERALTRADELIBERALIZATION
ONTHEIRECONOMIESnFOREXAMPLETHEEROSIONOFTRADEPREFERENCESRESULTINGFROMTHE
REDUCTIONOF-&.TARIFFSANDTHEEFFECTSOFTHEENDINGOFIMPORTQUOTASONTEXTILESAND
CLOTHINGEXPORTS4HE-ANAGING$IRECTOROFTHE)-&-RDE2ATOANDTHE0RESIDENTOFTHE
7ORLD"ANK-R7OLFENSOHNPARTICIPATEDINTHESECONDMEETINGATWHICHTHEYUNDERLINED
THEIRSTRONGSUPPORTFORTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
4HE74/3ECRETARIATHASALSOBEENACTIVEINITSRESEARCHOUTPUTINCLUDINGTHROUGHTHE
RELEASEOFTHE7ORLD4RADE2EPORTIN3EPTEMBER4HISINCLUDESAFOCUSONTHEROLEOF
INTERNATIONALCOOPERATIONINSECURINGPOLICYCOHERENCEASWELLASESSAYSONNONRECIPROCAL
PREFERENCESANDTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMTHELIBERALIZATIONOFSERVICESTRADETHROUGH
THETEMPORARYMOVEMENTOFLABOURANDGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONS4HISISTHESECONDOF
SUCHREPORTSANDISDESIGNEDTODEEPENPUBLICUNDERSTANDINGOFTRADEANDTRADERELATED
/VERVIEW
74/REGULARACTIVITY
POLICYISSUESANDTOCONTRIBUTETOAMOREINFORMEDCONSIDERATIONOFTHEOPTIONSFACING
GOVERNMENTS
!SACONTRIBUTIONTODEBATESABOUTHOWTOSTRENGTHENTHE74/FORTHEFUTURETHE
$IRECTOR'ENERALHADASKEDEIGHTEMINENTPERSONSTOFORMA#ONSULTATIVE"OARDTOREFLECT
UPONTHESYSTEMICCHALLENGESTHE74/FACESANDHOWTHISINSTITUTIONCOULDBEREINFORCEDAND
EQUIPPEDTOMEETTHEM)N*ANUARYTHISGROUPCHAIREDBY0ETER3UTHERLANDRELEASED
THEIR2EPORTh4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/!DDRESSING)NSTITUTIONAL#HALLENGESINTHE.EW
-ILLENNIUMv4HE2EPORTANDITSRECOMMENDATIONSARECURRENTLYUNDERCONSIDERATIONBY74/
-EMBERS
#HAPTER4WO
74/ !#4)6)4)%3
74/DOCUMENTSREFERREDTOINTHISREPORTAREIDENTIFIEDBYINDIVIDUALCODES
EX74,WHICHCANBEUSEDTOFINDANDDOWNLOADTHEMFROMTHE74/
WEBSITEATWWWWTOORG,OOKUNDER$OCUMENTSFORTHE$OCUMENTS/NLINE
DATABASE4O RETRIEVE A SPECIFIC DOCUMENT SELECT THE 3EARCH FUNCTION AND
INSERTTHEDOCUMENTCODEINTHEhDOCUMENTSYMBOLvWINDOW
74/ACTIVITIES
0!24)
4HISCHAPTERPROVIDESANOUTLINEOFTHEMAINACTIVITIESOFTHE74/DURING
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
) 4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
4HE&OURTH74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWASHELDIN$OHA1ATARFROMTO.OVEMBER
-INISTERSADOPTEDA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONSETTINGOUTABROADWORKPROGRAMMEFOR
THE74/FORTHECOMINGYEARS4HISWORKPROGRAMMECALLEDTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
INCORPORATESBOTHEXPANDEDNEGOTIATIONSnGOINGBEYONDTHEMANDATEDNEGOTIATIONSIN
AGRICULTUREANDSERVICESWHICHSTARTEDINnASWELLASOTHERACTIVITIESANDDECISIONS
DESIGNEDTOADDRESSTHECHALLENGESFACINGTHETRADINGSYSTEMANDINTERESTOFTHEDIVERSE
MEMBERSHIPOFTHE74/
-INISTERSALSOADOPTEDA$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED)SSUESAND#ONCERNS
WHICHREPRESENTEDASIGNIFICANTANDCREDIBLEEFFORTTOADDRESSTHECONCERNSOFDEVELOPING
COUNTRIESREGARDINGTHEIREXPERIENCEWITHTHEIMPLEMENTATIONANDOPERATIONOFEXISTING74/
!GREEMENTSANDTOFACILITATETHEIRACTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHE74/ANDFULLERINTEGRATIONINTO
THEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM5NDERTHE$ECISION-INISTERSTOOKIMMEDIATEACTIONTOADDRESS
ANUMBEROFTHECONCERNSRAISEDBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSANDAGREEDTHATREMAINING
IMPLEMENTATIONISSUESWOULDBEADDRESSEDINTHECOURSEOFTHEFUTUREWORKPROGRAMMEOFTHE
74/ASSETOUTINTHE-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION-INISTERSFURTHERDIRECTEDTHAT74/TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCESHOULDFOCUSASAMATTEROFPRIORITYONASSISTINGDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINTHISAREAOF
ACTIVITY
!$ECLARATIONONTHE42)03!GREEMENTAND0UBLIC(EALTHWASALSOADOPTEDBY-INISTERSIN
RESPONSETOTHECONCERNSEXPRESSEDABOUTTHEPOSSIBLEIMPLICATIONSOFTHE42)03!GREEMENTFOR
ACCESSTODRUGS4HE$ECLARATIONEMPHASIZESTHATTHE42)03!GREEMENTDOESNOTANDSHOULD
NOTPREVENT-EMBERSFROMTAKINGMEASURESTOPROTECTPUBLICHEALTHANDREAFFIRMSTHERIGHTOF
-EMBERSTOUSETOTHEFULLTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE42)03!GREEMENTWHICHPROVIDEFLEXIBILITYFOR
THISPURPOSE)TMAKESCLEARTHATTHE42)03!GREEMENTSHOULDBEINTERPRETEDANDIMPLEMENTED
INAMANNERSUPPORTIVEOF74/-EMBERSRIGHTTOPROTECTPUBLICHEALTH4HE$ECLARATION
INCLUDESANUMBEROFIMPORTANTCLARIFICATIONSOFSOMEOFTHEFORMSOFFLEXIBILITYAVAILABLEINTHE
!GREEMENTINPARTICULARCOMPULSORYLICENSINGANDPARALLELIMPORTATION)NADDITIONITPROVIDES
FORANEXTENSIONUNTILOFTHETRANSITIONPERIODFORLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESINREGARD
TOTHEPROTECTIONANDENFORCEMENTOFPATENTSANDUNDISCLOSEDINFORMATIONWITHRESPECTTO
PHARMACEUTICALPRODUCTS
4HENEGOTIATIONSTOBEPURSUEDUNDERTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONWERETOBECONCLUDEDNO
LATERTHAN*ANUARY.EGOTIATIONSONTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDINGWERETO
BECONCLUDEDNOLATERTHAN-AYANDTHOSEONAMULTILATERALREGISTEROFGEOGRAPHICAL
INDICATIONSFORWINESANDSPIRITSBYTHE&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN0ROGRESSWASTOBE
REVIEWEDATTHE&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN#ANCÞN-EXICOFROM3EPTEMBER
4HENEGOTIATIONSTAKEPLACEINA4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEEWHICHWASSETUPBYTHE
$OHA$ECLARATIONWHICHINTURNASSIGNEDITTOCREATESUBSIDIARYNEGOTIATINGBODIESTOHANDLE
INDIVIDUALNEGOTIATINGSUBJECTS4HE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE4.#OPERATESUNDERTHE
AUTHORITYOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL/THERWORKUNDERTHEWORKPROGRAMMETAKESPLACEINOTHER
74/COUNCILSANDCOMMITTEES
)NA$ECISIONONTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMMEADOPTEDIN*ULYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
AGREEDTOCONTINUETHENEGOTIATIONSLAUNCHEDAT$OHABEYONDTHETIMEFRAMESETOUTIN
PARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONLEADINGTOTHE3IXTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCETOBEHELDIN(ONG+ONG#HINAFROM$ECEMBERSEEUNDERTHE
FOLLOWINGSECTION4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILALSOAGREEDTHATNEGOTIATIONSONTHE$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDINGWOULDCONTINUEONTHEBASISSETOUTBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHOSE
NEGOTIATIONSINHISREPORTTOTHE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEEIN*UNE)TWASFURTHER
AGREEDTHATTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILANDOTHERRELEVANTBODIESWOULDREPORTINLINEWITHTHEIR$OHA
MANDATESTOTHE(ONG+ONG-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEANDALSOTHATTHEMORATORIAINTHE$OHA
$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATIONRELATED)SSUESAND#ONCERNSANDINTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONWOULD
BEEXTENDEDUNTILTHAT#ONFERENCE
&OLLOWUPTOTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
!TTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN3EPTEMBER74/-INISTERSINSTRUCTEDTHAT
THEIROFFICIALSCONTINUEWORKINGONOUTSTANDINGISSUESANDTHATTHISWORKBECOORDINATEDBY
THE'ENERAL#OUNCIL#HAIRMANINCLOSECOOPERATIONWITHTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALWITHTHEAIM
OFTAKINGTHEACTIONNECESSARYBY$ECEMBERTOENABLE-EMBERSTOMOVETOWARDSA
SUCCESSFULANDTIMELYCONCLUSIONOFTHENEGOTIATIONS-INISTERSALSOUNDERTOOKTOMAINTAIN
THEHIGHLEVELOFCONVERGENCEONTEXTSINTHOSEAREASWHERETHISHADBEENREACHED
!SPARTOFSPECIFICACTIONTOFOLLOWUPON-INISTERSDIRECTIVES-EMBERSAGREEDIN
DISCUSSIONSORGANIZEDSOONAFTER#ANCÞNBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILAND
$IRECTOR'ENERALTHATINITIALWORKWOULDFOCUSONFOURKEYOUTSTANDINGISSUESWHICH
EMERGEDASIMPORTANTCONCERNSANDKEYELEMENTSINFURTHERPROGRESSn!GRICULTURE#OTTON
.ON!GRICULTURAL-ARKET!CCESSANDTHE3INGAPOREISSUESnWITHTHEUNDERSTANDING
THATTHISFOCUSWOULDNOTINANYWAYLESSENTHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEOTHERISSUESWITHINTHE
$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA/NTHISBASISTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINCLOSE
COOPERATIONWITHTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCONDUCTEDASERIESOFINTENSIVECONSULTATIONSWITH
-EMBER'OVERNMENTSBOTHIN'ENEVAASWELLASINCAPITALSWITHAVIEWTOMOVINGTHE
PROCESSFORWARDFOCUSSINGONTHESEKEYOUTSTANDINGISSUES)NTHEIRREPORTTOTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILIN$ECEMBERTHE#HAIRMANANDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALIDENTIFIEDKEYISSUES
FORFURTHERWORKINEACHOFTHEFOURAREASSTRESSINGONCEAGAINTHATTHEINITIALFOCUSON
THESEFOURAREASINNOWAYLESSENEDTHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEOTHERISSUESWITHINTHE$OHA
$EVELOPMENT!GENDAINPARTICULAROFTHESPECIFICDEVELOPMENTRELATEDISSUESWITHINTHE
$$!WHICHWOULDNEEDFULLATTENTIONININLINEWITHTHE$OHAMANDATES2EGARDING
FURTHERWORKONTHESEANDOTHERISSUESUNDERTHE$$!THEIRREPORTRECOMMENDEDTHATALLOF
THE$$!BODIESSHOULDRESUMETHEIRWORKEARLYINTOBUILDONTHEELEMENTSTHATHAD
EMERGEDATANDSINCE#ANCÞNANDTHATTHE4.#SHOULDBEREACTIVATEDTOCARRYOUTITS$OHA
MANDATETOSUPERVISETHEPROGRESSANDOVERALLCONDUCTOFTHENEGOTIATIONS4HENEXT#OUNCIL
#HAIRMANTOGETHERWITHTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALWOULDCONTINUETOMAINTAINOVERSIGHTOFTHOSE
ASPECTSOFTHE$$!WHICHFELLOUTSIDETHE4.#SMANDATE
!CCORDINGLYIN-EMBERSRESTARTEDWORKACROSSTHEWHOLEBREADTHOFTHE$$!
INLINEWITHTHE$OHAMANDATESANDTHE#OUNCIL#HAIRSSTATEMENTIN$ECEMBER
INCLUDINGONANUMBEROFSPECIFICDEVELOPMENTRELATEDISSUES4HEREALSOEMERGEDAWIDELY
SHAREDUNDERSTANDINGINEARLYTHATWORKUNDERTHE$$!INTHEFIRSTHALFOFTHEYEAR
SHOULDRESULTINANOUTCOMEBYTHEENDOF*ULYTHATWOULDUNLOCKKEYISSUESANDPROVIDE
MOMENTUMANDDIRECTIONTOGUIDE-EMBERSWORKACROSSALLFRONTSAFTER*ULY4HEBASIC
PREMISETHATEMERGEDTHROUGHNUMEROUSCONSULTATIONSWASTHATTHETASKWASTOTAKETHE
ACTIONNECESSARYATTHELEVELOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTOENSURECONTINUEDPROGRESSOFTHE
NEGOTIATIONSANDTHEWORKPROGRAMMEASAWHOLE3UBSTANTIVEELEMENTSFORTHESOCALLED
*ULYPACKAGEBEGANTOEMERGEFROMWORKONSUBSTANTIVEISSUESUNDERTAKENINTHE4.#AND
RELEVANTNEGOTIATINGGROUPSASWELLCONSULTATIONSCONDUCTEDBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILONTHEHANDLINGOFTHE3INGAPOREISSUESnTRADEFACILITATIONTRANSPARENCYIN
GOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTINTERACTIONBETWEENTRADEANDCOMPETITIONPOLICYANDRELATIONSHIP
BETWEENTRADEANDINVESTMENTnINTHEWORKPROGRAMME
/NTHEBASISOFTHEWORKUNDERTAKENINTHERELEVANTNEGOTIATINGGROUPSANDBYTHEIR
#HAIRSACTINGAS&ACILITATORSASWELLASINTENSIVECONSULTATIONSUNDERTAKENBYTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCIL#HAIRMANAND$IRECTOR'ENERALONISSUESTHATCOULDBEPROGRESSEDTHROUGH
SUCHCONSULTATIONSAFIRSTOVERALLDRAFTTEXTOFTHE*ULYPACKAGEWASPUTTO-EMBERSFOR
CONSIDERATIONON*ULYASAPLATFORMFORFURTHERMOREINTENSIVEWORKTHROUGHTOTHEENDOF
*ULY&OLLOWINGTHECIRCULATIONOFTHISFIRSTTEXTTHE#HAIRMANAND$IRECTOR'ENERALARRANGEDA
FURTHERPROCESSOFCONSULTATIONSINORDERTOFACILITATE-EMBERSEFFORTSTORESOLVEOUTSTANDING
ISSUESANDMOVETOWARDSAGREEMENTONAFINALTEXTLEADINGUPTOA'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETING
ATTHEENDOF*ULY)NTHELEADUPTOTHIS'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETING74/-INISTERSALSOMET
INTENSIVELYINVARIOUSFORMATSANDGROUPINGSAROUNDTHEWORLDINCLUDINGATTHECONCLUDING
STAGESOFTHEDISCUSSIONSIN'ENEVA
!TTHEENDOF*ULYFOLLOWINGTWOWEEKSOFINTENSENEGOTIATIONS-EMBERSFINALLYFULFILLED
THEGOALOFTAKINGTHENECESSARYDECISIONSONKEYISSUESTOENSURECONTINUEDPROGRESSOF
THENEGOTIATIONSANDTOPUTTHE$$!BACKONTRACK)NTHE$ECISIONOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
FRAMEWORKAGREEMENTSWEREPUTINPLACEFORTHENEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTUREnINCLUDING
COTTONnANDNONAGRICULTURALMARKETACCESS-EMBERSALSOAGREEDTOAPACKAGEON
DEVELOPMENTISSUESANDTOOKADECISIONTOBEGINNEGOTIATIONSONTRADEFACILITATIONANDTHAT
THEOTHERTHREE3INGAPOREISSUESWOULDNOTBENEGOTIATEDDURINGTHIS2OUND-EMBERS
FURTHERAGREEDTOCONTINUETHENEGOTIATIONSBEYONDTHETIMEFRAMEOF*ANUARYSETIN
THE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONANDTHATTHENEXT-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWOULDBEHELDIN
(ONG+ONG#HINAIN$ECEMBER4HE$ECISIONDEMONSTRATED-EMBERSCOMMITMENT
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
7ORKOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILONTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
TOFULFILLINGTHE$OHAMANDATESANDASENSEOFTHEPATHTOWARDSTHATSHAREDGOALLEAVING
THEWAYOPENTOMOVINGAHEADWITHRENEWEDMOMENTUMANDASENSEOFPURPOSETOWARDSA
SUCCESSFULCONCLUSIONOFTHE2OUND
)NADDITIONTOITSWORKCULMINATINGINTHE*ULY$ECISIONONTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMMETHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILASPARTOFITSOVERALLREVIEWANDOVERSIGHTFUNCTIONCONTINUEDTOKEEPUNDER
REGULARREVIEWTHEWORKOFTHE4.#UNDERASTANDINGITEMONITSAGENDA!LSOINKEEPINGWITH
THEFRAMEWORKANDPROCEDURESAGREEDIN-ARCHFORTHECONDUCTOFTHEWORKPROGRAMME
ONSMALLECONOMIESPROVIDEDFORINTHE$$!THE'ENERAL#OUNCILREVIEWEDTHEPROGRESS
OFWORKINTHISAREAUNDERASTANDINGITEMONITSAGENDA4HESUBSTANTIVEWORKRELATINGTO
THISWORKPROGRAMMEISUNDERTAKENINDEDICATEDSESSIONSOFTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND
$EVELOPMENT7ITHREGARDTOTHEHARMONIZATIONWORKPROGRAMMEINTHERULESOFORIGINAREAIN
VIEWOFTHETECHNICALLYCOMPLEXANDPOLITICALLYIMPORTANTISSUESTHATREMAINTOBECONSIDERED
THE'ENERAL#OUNCILEXTENDEDTO*ULYTHEDEADLINEFORCOMPLETIONOFNEGOTIATIONSONCORE
POLICYISSUES7ORKONTHESEISSUESWASCONTINUEDOVERTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEWINCONSULTATIONS
CONDUCTEDBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE#OMMITTEEON2ULESOF/RIGINATTHEREQUESTANDONBEHALF
OFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL#HAIR&OLLOWINGRESOLUTIONOFTHECOREPOLICYISSUESTHE74/#OMMITTEE
ON2ULESOF/RIGINISTOCOMPLETETHEREMAININGTECHNICALWORKBY$ECEMBER
&URTHERMOREINFOLLOWUPTOTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE*ULY$ECISIONONTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMME
REGARDINGTHESECTORALINITIATIVEONCOTTONTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN$ECEMBERRECEIVEDAREPORTBY
THE$IRECTOR'ENERALONTHEDEVELOPMENTASSISTANCEASPECTSOF#OTTON
7ORK0ROGRAMME
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
4HEPARAGRAPHSBELOWFOLLOWTHEORDEROFTHE7ORK0ROGRAMMEASSETOUTINTHE$OHA
$ECLARATIONANDTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATIONRELATEDISSUESANDCONCERNS4HERELEVANT
MANDATEISINCLUDEDAFTEREACHHEADING
)MPLEMENTATIONRELATEDISSUESANDCONCERNS
4HEFULLTEXTOFTHE$ECISIONCANBEFOUNDIN
74/DOCUMENT74,
7EATTACHTHEUTMOSTIMPORTANCETOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONRELATEDISSUESAND
CONCERNSRAISEDBY-EMBERSANDAREDETERMINEDTOFINDAPPROPRIATESOLUTIONSTOTHEM
)NTHISCONNECTIONANDHAVINGREGARDTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL$ECISIONSOF-AYAND
$ECEMBERWEFURTHERADOPTTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED)SSUESAND
#ONCERNSINDOCUMENT74-).TOADDRESSANUMBEROFIMPLEMENTATIONPROBLEMS
FACEDBY-EMBERS7EAGREETHATNEGOTIATIONSONOUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATIONISSUES
SHALLBEANINTEGRALPARTOFTHE7ORK0ROGRAMMEWEAREESTABLISHINGANDTHATAGREEMENTS
REACHEDATANEARLYSTAGEINTHESENEGOTIATIONSSHALLBETREATEDINACCORDANCEWITHTHE
PROVISIONSOFPARAGRAPHBELOW)NTHISREGARDWESHALLPROCEEDASFOLLOWSAWHERE
WEPROVIDEASPECIFICNEGOTIATINGMANDATEINTHIS$ECLARATIONTHERELEVANTIMPLEMENTATION
ISSUESSHALLBEADDRESSEDUNDERTHATMANDATEBTHEOTHEROUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATION
ISSUESSHALLBEADDRESSEDASAMATTEROFPRIORITYBYTHERELEVANT74/BODIESWHICHSHALL
REPORTTOTHE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEEESTABLISHEDUNDERPARAGRAPHBELOWBYTHE
ENDOFFORAPPROPRIATEACTIONv
4HE#OMMITTEE#HAIRMANHELDINFORMALCONSULTATIONSWITHINTERESTEDMEMBERSONTHE
TEXTOFTHE2EPORT74"/02.OVEMBERONWORKUNDERTAKENINACCORDANCE
WITHPARAGRAPHBOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONANDREPORTEDTOTHE$IRECTOR
GENERAL
!GRICULTURE 4HE#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTUREHASAMANDATEGIVENBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
TOPURSUETHREEIMPLEMENTATIONMATTERS4HEFIRSTISSUECONCERNSTHEEXAMINATIONOFMEANS
FORAMOREEFFECTIVEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE-ARRAKESH-INISTERIAL$ECISIONON-EASURES
CONCERNINGTHE0OSSIBLE.EGATIVE%FFECTSOFTHE2EFORM0ROGRAMMEON,EAST$EVELOPEDAND
.ET&OOD)MPORTING$EVELOPING#OUNTRIES.&)$#$ECISION)NTHISCONTEXTTHE#OMMITTEE
FURTHERCONSIDEREDAPROPOSALBYTHE74/!FRICAN'ROUPCALLINGFORNEWMECHANISMS
TOADDRESSIMPORTFINANCINGDIFFICULTIESOFTHELEASTDEVELOPEDANDNETFOODIMPORTING
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES4HE#OMMITTEEISTOSUBMITRECOMMENDATIONSTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
CONCERNINGTHISMATTERBY*ULY4HESECONDIMPLEMENTATIONISSUECONCERNSTHE
MANAGEMENTOFTARIFFQUOTAREGIMES5NDERA'ENERAL#OUNCILDECISION-EMBERSWITHTARIFF
QUOTACOMMITMENTSAREREQUIREDTOPROVIDEUPDATEDNOTIFICATIONSTOTHE#OMMITTEEON
!GRICULTUREWHICHINCLUDEDETAILSONGUIDELINESANDPROCEDURESFORTHEALLOTMENTOFTARIFF
QUOTASINORDERTOENSURETHATTARIFFQUOTASAREADMINISTEREDINATRANSPARENTEQUITABLE
ANDNONDISCRIMINATORYMANNER4HENOTIFICATIONSRECEIVEDINTHISWAYARESYSTEMATICALLY
REVIEWEDBYTHE#OMMITTEE4HETHIRDIMPLEMENTATIONISSUECONCERNSIMPLEMENTATION
OF!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREDEVELOPMENTOFINTERNATIONALLYAGREED
DISCIPLINESTOGOVERNTHEPROVISIONOFEXPORTCREDITSEXPORTCREDITGUARANTEESORINSURANCE
PROGRAMMES4HEREWERENOFURTHERDEVELOPMENTSINTHISAREAOFWORKOFTHE#OMMITTEEAS
-EMBERSAREPURSUINGTHEIRINTERESTSONTHISMATTERINTHE$OHANEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTURE
#USTOMSVALUATION 4HE#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATIONRECEIVEDAMANDATEFROM
-INISTERSAT$OHATOADDRESSFIVEOUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATIONRELATEDISSUESANDTOCARRYOUT
THEWORKINPARAGRAPHOFTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED)SSUESAND#ONCERNS
INACCORDANCEWITHPARAGRAPHOFTHE-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION4HEFIVEOUTSTANDING
ISSUESCONCERNSPECIFICPROVISIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTON#USTOMS6ALUATIONANDPARAGRAPH
DEALSWITHINFORMATIONEXCHANGEAMONGCUSTOMSADMINISTRATIONSAIMEDATRELIEVING
CONCERNSRELATEDTOTHEACCURACYOFTHEDECLAREDVALUE&OLLOWINGITSREPORTTOTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILIN'6!,SEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTTHE#OMMITTEERECEIVEDTHE
REQUESTEDADVICEANDTECHNICALINPUTFROMTHE4ECHNICAL#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATION
4HE#HAIRMANOFTHE#OMMITTEEHELDASERIESOFINFORMALCONSULTATIONSONTHEMATTERTAKING
INTOACCOUNTTHEINFORMATIONRECEIVEDANDTHE#OMMITTEESPREVIOUSWORK(OWEVERTHE
#OMMITTEEWASUNABLETOREACHACONSENSUSTOCONCLUDEITSWORKUNDERTHE-INISTERIAL
MANDATEINPARAGRAPHOF74-).4HE#OMMITTEEWILLCONTINUETOADDRESSTHIS
MATTERIN
3ANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURES 4HE303#OMMITTEESWORKREGARDINGTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTPROGRESSEDINSEVERALAREASIN4HE#OMMITTEE
COMPLETEDITSWORKPROGRAMMEON%QUIVALENCEWHICHINCLUDEDCLARIFICATIONSONTHE$ECISION
ON%QUIVALENCE )N/CTOBERTHE#OMMITTEEADOPTEDANELABORATIONOFAPROCEDURE
INWHICHANIMPORTINGCOUNTRYSHOULDCONSIDERANYREQUESTSFOR3$ORTECHNICALASSISTANCE
MADEINRESPONSETOTHEIRNOTIFICATIONOFANEWMEASUREANDNOTIFYTHE303#OMMITTEEOF
ACTIONSTAKENINRESPONSETOTHISREQUEST )NADDITIONTHE#OMMITTEECONTINUEDDISCUSSION
OFPROBLEMSLINKEDWITHTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEPROVISIONSFORRECOGNITIONOFPESTAND
DISEASEFREEAREAS
4RADERELATEDINVESTMENTMEASURES 0URSUANTTO0ARAGRAPHBOFTHE$OHA
-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONANDTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODS#4'DECISIONOF-AY
THE#OMMITTEEON4RADE2ELATED)NVESTMENT-EASURESWASASSIGNEDTHERESPONSIBILITYFOR
CONDUCTINGWORKONTHEOUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATIONISSUESRELATEDTOTHE42)-S!GREEMENT
ASCONTAINEDINTIRETSTOOFDOCUMENT*/"2EV&OLLOWINGTHE$ECISION
ADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILON!UGUSTANDTHEREQUESTOFTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE
.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE4.#TOASSISTHIMINHISCONSULTATIONSUNDERPARAGRAPHBOF
THE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONIN.OVEMBERTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE42)-S#OMMITTEE
CONDUCTEDINFORMALCONSULTATIONSONTHEOUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATIONISSUESRELATEDTOTHE
42)-S!GREEMENTFOCUSSINGONAJOINTPROPOSALBY"RAZILAND)NDIAUNDERTIRET'42)-3
7
4ECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADE 4HE4"4#OMMITTEEHASCONTINUEDTODEVELOPITSAPPROACH
TOTECHNICALASSISTANCE$URINGITFOCUSEDONTRANSPARENCYRELATEDASPECTSOFTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE2EGARDING3UPPLIERS$ECLARATIONOF#ONFORMITY3$O#-EMBERSENGAGEDINAN
EXCHANGEOFEXPERIENCES
4RADERELATEDASPECTSOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS42)03 0URSUANTTOPARAGRAPH
OFTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLEOFTHE42)03!GREEMENT)0#THE
#OUNCILTOOKUPATITSMEETINGIN$ECEMBERTHESECONDANNUALREVIEWOFDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY
-EMBERSREPORTSONTHEIRIMPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLE4HE#OUNCILHADADOPTEDTHIS
DECISIONIN&EBRUARYGIVINGEFFECTTOTHEINSTRUCTIONOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
INPARAGRAPHOFTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED)SSUESAND#ONCERNSTOPUTIN
PLACEAMECHANISMFORENSURINGTHEMONITORINGANDFULLIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEOBLIGATIONSIN
QUESTION
0ARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED)SSUESAND#ONCERNS
DIRECTEDTHE42)03#OUNCILTOCONTINUEITSEXAMINATIONOFTHESCOPEANDMODALITIESFOR
COMPLAINTSOFTHETYPESPROVIDEDFORUNDERSUBPARAGRAPHSBANDCOF!RTICLE88)))OF
'!44ANDMAKERECOMMENDATIONSTOTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
-INISTERSHADAGREEDTHATINTHEMEANTIME-EMBERSWOULDNOTINITIATESUCHCOMPLAINTS
UNDERTHE42)03!GREEMENT)NTHELIGHTOFTHEDECISIONONTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMME
ADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILON!UGUSTTHE#OUNCILDISCUSSEDTHISISSUEATITS
MEETINGIN$ECEMBERANDTOOKNOTEOFANUPDATED3ECRETARIATNOTESUMMARIZINGTHEPOINTS
RAISEDINTHE#OUNCILSEARLIERSUBSTANTIVEDISCUSSIONSOFTHISMATTER)0#72EV
0URSUANTTOPARAGRAPHDOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILS$ECISIONOF!UGUSTASITRELATES
TOOUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATIONISSUESANDCONCERNS-R4HOMPSON&LÙRES$EPUTY$IRECTOR
'ENERALINITIATEDATTHEREQUESTOFTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALATECHNICALLEVELCONSULTATION
AIMEDATCLARIFYINGTHEISSUESRELATEDTOEXTENSIONOFTHEPROTECTIONOFGEOGRAPHICAL
INDICATIONSPROVIDEDFORIN!RTICLEOFTHE42)03!GREEMENTTOPRODUCTSOTHERTHANWINES
ANDSPIRITS
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
'3032EV
'303
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
!GRICULTURE0ARAGRAPHSAND
7ERECOGNIZETHEWORKALREADYUNDERTAKENINTHENEGOTIATIONSINITIATEDINEARLY
UNDER!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREINCLUDINGTHELARGENUMBEROF
NEGOTIATINGPROPOSALSSUBMITTEDONBEHALFOFATOTALOF-EMBERS7ERECALLTHELONG
TERMOBJECTIVEREFERREDTOINTHE!GREEMENTTOESTABLISHAFAIRANDMARKETORIENTEDTRADING
SYSTEMTHROUGHAPROGRAMMEOFFUNDAMENTALREFORMENCOMPASSINGSTRENGTHENEDRULESAND
SPECIFICCOMMITMENTSONSUPPORTANDPROTECTIONINORDERTOCORRECTANDPREVENTRESTRICTIONS
ANDDISTORTIONSINWORLDAGRICULTURALMARKETS7ERECONFIRMOURCOMMITMENTTOTHIS
PROGRAMME"UILDINGONTHEWORKCARRIEDOUTTODATEANDWITHOUTPREJUDGINGTHEOUTCOMEOF
THENEGOTIATIONSWECOMMITOURSELVESTOCOMPREHENSIVENEGOTIATIONSAIMEDATSUBSTANTIAL
IMPROVEMENTSINMARKETACCESSREDUCTIONSOFWITHAVIEWTOPHASINGOUTALLFORMSOFEXPORT
SUBSIDIESANDSUBSTANTIALREDUCTIONSINTRADEDISTORTINGDOMESTICSUPPORT7EAGREETHAT
SPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESSHALLBEANINTEGRALPARTOFALL
ELEMENTSOFTHENEGOTIATIONSANDSHALLBEEMBODIEDINTHE3CHEDULESOFCONCESSIONSAND
COMMITMENTSANDASAPPROPRIATEINTHERULESANDDISCIPLINESTOBENEGOTIATEDSOASTOBE
OPERATIONALLYEFFECTIVEANDTOENABLEDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTOEFFECTIVELYTAKEACCOUNTOFTHEIR
DEVELOPMENTNEEDSINCLUDINGFOODSECURITYANDRURALDEVELOPMENT7ETAKENOTEOFTHENON
TRADECONCERNSREFLECTEDINTHENEGOTIATINGPROPOSALSSUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSANDCONFIRM
THATNONTRADECONCERNSWILLBETAKENINTOACCOUNTINTHENEGOTIATIONSASPROVIDEDFORINTHE
!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURE
-ODALITIESFORTHEFURTHERCOMMITMENTSINCLUDINGPROVISIONSFORSPECIALAND
DIFFERENTIALTREATMENTSHALLBEESTABLISHEDNOLATERTHAN-ARCH0ARTICIPANTSSHALL
SUBMITTHEIRCOMPREHENSIVEDRAFT3CHEDULESBASEDONTHESEMODALITIESNOLATERTHANTHEDATE
OFTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE4HENEGOTIATIONSINCLUDINGWITHRESPECT
TORULESANDDISCIPLINESANDRELATEDLEGALTEXTSSHALLBECONCLUDEDASPARTANDATTHEDATEOF
CONCLUSIONOFTHENEGOTIATINGAGENDAASAWHOLE
4HENEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTUREWHICHHADSTARTEDINUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE
!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURECONTINUEDINTOANDUNDERPARAGRAPHSANDOF
THE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION4HEOBJECTIVEFORMOSTOFTHATTIMEHADBEENTOESTABLISH
MODALITIESNOLATERTHAN-ARCH4HEWIDEDIFFERENCESINPOSITIONSBETWEEN
-EMBERSMEANTITWASNOTPOSSIBLETOACHIEVETHISOBJECTIVEANDINTHETHIRDQUARTEROF
-EMBERSATTENTIONSWITCHEDTONEGOTIATINGADETAILEDFRAMEWORKONWHICHMODALITIES
WOULDBEBASED(OWEVERDESPITEINTENSIVEEFFORTSINTHERUNUPTOANDATTHE
TH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEITWASNOTPOSSIBLETOREACHAGREEMENTNORWASITPOSSIBLETOFIND
ACOMPROMISELATERIN
)NUNDERANEW#HAIRMAN!MBASSADOR4IM'ROSEROF.EW:EALANDTHE3PECIAL
3ESSIONOFTHE#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTURERESTARTEDITSWORKONNEGOTIATINGAFRAMEWORK
WHICHALL-EMBERSCOULDAGREETO)NTHISNEWPHASE-EMBERSWERESTRONGLYENCOURAGED
TOCONDUCTNEGOTIATIONSWITHEACHOTHERRATHERTHANTRYINGTONEGOTIATEWITHTHE#HAIR
ASHADHAPPENEDINTHEPAST4HISINITIATIVEBYTHE#HAIRMANWASGREATLYHELPEDBYTHE
FACTTHATINTHELATTERPARTOFMAJORNEGOTIATINGCOALITIONSHADEMERGEDWHICH
INCREASINGLYSPOKEWITHONEVOICEINCLUDINGTHE'THE!FRICAN'ROUPTHEGROUPOFLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTHE'ANDTHE'4HELETTERSINEARLYFROM!MBASSADOR
:OELLICKhSHOULDNOTBEALOSTYEARvANDFROM#OMMISSIONERS,AMYAND&ISCHLER
INDICATINGTHE%#SREADINESSTOELIMINATEEXPORTSUBSIDIESSUBJECTTOEQUIVALENTANDPARALLEL
COMMITMENTSWITHRESPECTTOALLOTHERFORMSOFEXPORTSUBSIDIZATIONPROVIDEDANESSENTIAL
POLITICALIMPETUS)NDEEDTHENEGOTIATIONSGRADUALLYSHIFTEDFROMAhDECLARATORYvPHASE
OVERAhLISTENINGvPHASETOAhCOMPROMISEvPHASEATANDBETWEENTHE'ENEVAh!GRICULTURE
7EEKSvTHATTOOKPLACEIN-ARCH!PRILAND*UNEOFSEEDOCUMENTS4.!'2
4.!'2AND4.!'2
!LTHOUGHTHE'ENEVABASEDPROCESSWASCRITICALTOTHISPHASEOFTHENEGOTIATIONS
THEPARALLELEXTERNALPROCESSWASALSOVITALLYIMPORTANT!NUMBEROF-EMBERSTOOKTHE
OPPORTUNITYTOFURTHERTHENEGOTIATIONSTHROUGHMEETINGSWITHINANDBETWEENDIFFERENT
NEGOTIATINGGROUPSTHATTOOKPLACEATDIFFERENTVENUESAROUNDTHEWORLD4HESEMEETINGS
GAVEFURTHERPOLITICALGUIDANCETOENABLETHE'ENEVABASEDNEGOTIATORSTOMOVEFORWARD
4HEDIFFERENCESINNEGOTIATINGPOSITIONSAMONG-EMBERSWEREGRADUALLYNARROWEDBUT
SERIOUSDIFFICULTIESREMAINED%VENTUALLYFOLLOWINGINTENSIVEANDCONTINUOUSNEGOTIATIONSIN
*UNEAND*ULYCONSENSUSWASREACHEDONAFRAMEWORKONAGRICULTUREASPARTOFTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCIL$ECISIONOF!UGUSThTHE&RAMEWORKvSEE!NNEX!OF74,
4HE&RAMEWORKGREATLYAUGMENTEDTHEMANDATEOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEBY
GIVINGITBOTHGREATERCLARITYANDGREATERPRECISION&OREXAMPLE
s /NEXPORTCOMPETITIONTHE&RAMEWORKCOMMITS-EMBERSTOELIMINATEALLFORMS
OFEXPORTSUBSIDIESBYADATECERTAINANDESTABLISHESCLEARGUIDELINESFORTHE
DEVELOPMENTOFDETAILEDRULESANDCOMMITMENTSONEXPORTCREDITSEXPORTING
STATETRADINGENTERPRISESANDFOODAID
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
s )NTHEAREAOFDOMESTICSUPPORTITREINFORCESTHECOMMITMENTTOACHIEVE
SUBSTANTIALREDUCTIONSOFALLTRADEDISTORTINGSUPPORTBYREQUIRINGINTERALIA
THAT
O THOSEWITHHIGHERLEVELSOFTRADEDISTORTINGDOMESTICSUPPORTSHOULD
REDUCETHEMBYGREATERAMOUNTS
O PRODUCTSPECIFICCAPSOF!MBER"OXSUPPORTBEINTRODUCED
O THEDEMINIMISLIMITSBEREDUCEDWITHSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIAL
TREATMENTFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
O "LUE"OXSPENDINGBECAPPEDAND
O ASADOWNPAYMENTOFTHEOVERALLREDUCTIONOFTRADEDISTORTING
DOMESTICSUPPORTTHESUMOF!MBER"OXPERMITTEDDEMINIMISAND
"LUE"OXSUPPORTSWILLBEREDUCEDBYPERCENTINTHEFIRSTYEAROF
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHENEWREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTS
s )NMARKETACCESSAKEYACHIEVEMENTOFTHE&RAMEWORKISTHEAGREEMENTTHAT
THESTANDARDOFhSUBSTANTIALIMPROVEMENTvLAIDDOWNINTHE$OHAMANDATE
WILLAPPLYFOREACHAGRICULTURALPRODUCT7HILETHE&RAMEWORKENVISAGES
FLEXIBILITYFORSENSITIVEPRODUCTSTHEYWILLALSOBESUBJECTTOTHISSTANDARD
4ARIFFREDUCTIONSWILLBEACHIEVEDBYATIEREDFORMULAAPPLYINGGREATER
REDUCTIONSFORHIGHERBOUNDTARIFFS4ARIFFESCALATIONWILLBEADDRESSEDTHUS
IMPROVINGTHEOPPORTUNITIESFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTOCLIMBUPTHEVALUE
ADDEDLADDER5NDERSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTTHE&RAMEWORKPROVIDES
FORLOWERREDUCTIONSANDLONGERIMPLEMENTATIONPERIODSFORDEVELOPING
COUNTRIESALONGWITHTHEFLEXIBILITYTODECLARESOMEPRODUCTSASh3PECIAL
0RODUCTSvANDTOHAVEACCESSTOASPECIALSAFEGUARDMECHANISM4HEFULLEST
LIBERALIZATIONOFTRADEINTROPICALAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSANDTHEISSUEOF
PREFERENCEEROSIONAREAMONGTHEOTHERMATTERSTOBEADDRESSED
s /NCOTTONTHE&RAMEWORKSTIPULATESINTERALIATHATINVIEWOFITSVITAL
IMPORTANCEFORDEVELOPINGANDESPECIALLYLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTHIS
SECTORWILLBEADDRESSEDAMBITIOUSLYEXPEDITIOUSLYANDSPECIFICALLYWITHINTHE
AGRICULTURENEGOTIATIONS)NACCORDANCEWITHTHE&RAMEWORKINLATEA
3UB#OMMITTEEON#OTTONWASESTABLISHEDUNDERTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE
#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTURE
!LTHOUGHTHE&RAMEWORKREFLECTSIMPORTANTMOVEMENTSINPOSITIONSTOWARDSCONVERGENCE
MOSTNOTABLYINEXPORTCOMPETITIONITHASALSOBEENCLEARTHATMUCHMOREWORKWOULDBE
NEEDEDBEFOREMODALITIESCOULDBEESTABLISHED4HENEGOTIATIONSIN'ENEVARESUMEDSOON
AFTERTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL$ECISIONOF!UGUSTANDIN/CTOBER.OVEMBERAND$ECEMBER
ANOTHERTHREEh!GRICULTURE7EEKSvWEREHELDTHATADDRESSEDSPECIFICISSUESRAISEDINTHE
&RAMEWORKSEEDOCUMENTS4.!'24.!'2AND4.!'2
.EGOTIATIONSDURINGTHESE!GRICULTURE7EEKSTOOKPLACEATANUMBEROFDIFFERENTLEVELS
&ORAFIRSTREADINGOFSPECIFICISSUESRAISEDINTHE&RAMEWORKINFORMALMEETINGSOFTHE3PECIAL
3ESSIONGAVEDELEGATIONSTHEOPPORTUNITYTOMAKESTATEMENTSOUTLININGTHEIRINITIALPOSITIONS
!TASUBSEQUENT!GRICULTURE7EEKTHESEISSUESWERETHENCONSIDEREDINGREATERDETAILAT
INFORMALOPENENDEDCONSULTATIONSTOWHICHALLDELEGATIONSWEREINVITED3OMEOFTHEMORE
TECHNICALANDCOMPLEXISSUESWEREALSODISCUSSEDBYSMALLERGROUPSOFDELEGATIONS)NTHIS
WAYTHE#HAIRMANWASABLETODEVELOPDRAFTOUTLINETEXTSONAVARIETYOFSPECIFIC&RAMEWORK
PROVISIONSWHICHWERECIRCULATEDTOALLDELEGATIONSFORTHEPURPOSESOFCONSULTATIONSANDIN
ORDERTOENSURETRANSPARENCY4HISPROCESSCONTINUEDINTHEFIRSTMONTHSOFANDHAS
RESULTEDINFURTHERPROGRESSINTHENEGOTIATIONS
3ERVICES0ARAGRAPH
4HENEGOTIATIONSONTRADEINSERVICESSHALLBECONDUCTEDWITHAVIEWTOPROMOTING
THEECONOMICGROWTHOFALLTRADINGPARTNERSANDTHEDEVELOPMENTOFDEVELOPINGANDLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES7ERECOGNIZETHEWORKALREADYUNDERTAKENINTHENEGOTIATIONSINITIATED
IN*ANUARYUNDER!RTICLE8)8OFTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4RADEIN3ERVICESANDTHE
LARGENUMBEROFPROPOSALSSUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSONAWIDERANGEOFSECTORSANDSEVERAL
HORIZONTALISSUESASWELLASONMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONS7EREAFFIRMTHE'UIDELINESAND
0ROCEDURESFORTHE.EGOTIATIONSADOPTEDBYTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESON-ARCH
ASTHEBASISFORCONTINUINGTHENEGOTIATIONSWITHAVIEWTOACHIEVINGTHEOBJECTIVES
OFTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4RADEIN3ERVICESASSTIPULATEDINTHE0REAMBLE!RTICLE)6
AND!RTICLE8)8OFTHAT!GREEMENT0ARTICIPANTSSHALLSUBMITINITIALREQUESTSFORSPECIFIC
COMMITMENTSBY*UNEANDINITIALOFFERSBY-ARCH
)NACCORDANCEWITHTHEMANDATESETOUTINPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT
!GENDATHE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESHELDFOURMEETINGSIN
4HEREPORTSOFTHESEMEETINGSARECONTAINEDINDOCUMENTS4.3-TO4.3-
4HE3PECIAL3ESSIONADDRESSEDTHEMATTERSREFERREDTOUNDERITEMSITOIV
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
I 0ROPOSALSRELATINGTOTHENEGOTIATIONSUNDER!RTICLE8)8OFTHE'!43
-EMBERSCONTINUEDTODISCUSSVARIOUSNEGOTIATINGPROPOSALSSUBMITTEDTOTHE3PECIAL
3ESSIONONANUMBEROFSERVICESSECTORSMODESOFSUPPLYANDOTHERHORIZONTALISSUES
!SHASBEENTHECASESINCE*UNETHEDISCUSSIONWASSTRUCTUREDACCORDINGTONEW
PROPOSALSRECEIVED
-EMBERSHADSUBSTANTIVEEXCHANGESONABROADRANGEOFISSUESONTHEBASISOFSIX
FORMALCOMMUNICATIONSRELATINGTO-ODELOGISTICSSERVICESIMPROVEDSCHEDULINGOF
SPECIFICCOMMITMENTSSUPPLYOFSERVICETHROUGHCOMMERCIALPRESENCEANDELECTRONIC
VISAORWORKPERMITSYSTEMSCONTAINEDIN74/DOCUMENTS4.37TOAND
)N3EPTEMBERTHE#OUNCILHELDDISCUSSIONSABOUTTWOEXPERTMEETINGSRELATINGTO
TRADEMIGRATIONMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONSANDDEVELOPMENTBASEDONPRESENTATIONS
BYREPRESENTATIVESOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL/RGANIZATIONFOR-IGRATIONTHE/RGANISATIONFOR
%CONOMIC#OOPERATIONAND$EVELOPMENT/%#$THE5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON4RADE
AND$EVELOPMENT5.#4!$ANDTHE7ORLD"ANK)N$ECEMBERTWO-EMBERSMADE
PRESENTATIONSRELATINGTOMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONS
II !SSESSMENTFORTRADEINSERVICES
!RTICLE8)8OFTHE'!43MANDATESTHATTHE#OUNCILCARRYOUTANASSESSMENTOFTRADE
INSERVICESINOVERALLTERMSANDONASECTORALBASISWITHREFERENCETOTHEOBJECTIVESOF
THE!GREEMENTINCLUDINGTHOSESETOUTIN!RTICLE)64HEASSESSMENTOFTRADEINSERVICES
FIGURESASASTANDINGITEMONTHEAGENDAOFTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONINKEEPINGWITHTHE
'UIDELINESAND0ROCEDURESFORTHE.EGOTIATIONSON4RADEIN3ERVICES3,
4HE#OUNCILSDISCUSSIONSUNDERTHISITEMWEREBASEDONONEFORMALCOMMUNICATION
FROM4HE3EPARATE#USTOMS4ERRITORYOF4AIWAN0ENGHU+INMENAND-ATSU4.37
RELATEDTOTELECOMMUNICATIONSERVICESASWELLASTHREEPRESENTATIONSBYREPRESENTATIVESOF
THE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRETHE/%#$AND5.#4!$4HELATTERTWOPRESENTATIONSRELATED
RESPECTIVELYTOASTUDYENTITLEDh3ERVICES"ARRIERSAND4HEIR%CONOMIC)MPACT%XAMPLESOF
"ANKINGAND4ELECOMMUNICATION3ERVICESIN3ELECTED4RANSITION%CONOMIESvANDTHEh7ORLD
)NVESTMENT2EPORT4HE3HIFT4OWARDS3ERVICESv
III 2EVIEWOFPROGRESSINTHENEGOTIATIONS
!SAGREEDIN*ULYTHE#OUNCILCONTINUEDTOINCLUDETHISSTANDINGITEMONITS
AGENDAASAMEANSTOPROMOTETRANSPARENCYANDALLOWTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONTOFULFILL
ITSFUNCTIONASTHEBODYOVERSEEINGTHENEGOTIATIONS)TALSOPROVIDES-EMBERSWITH
ANOPPORTUNITYTORAISEISSUESOFCONCERNTHATMIGHTEMERGEINCONSULTATIONSANDTO
COMMUNICATETHEIRIMPRESSIONSONPROGRESSINTHENEGOTIATIONS
3UBSTANTIVEDISCUSSIONSUNDERTHISITEMWEREHELDATALLMEETINGSHELDIN!MONG
OTHERMATTERS-EMBERSPRESENTEDANDRESPONDEDTOINITIALOFFERSREPORTEDONBILATERAL
CONSULTATIONSUPDATEDTHE#OUNCILONWORKBEINGCONDUCTEDINSOMEFRIENDSGROUPSAND
REITERATEDTHEIRNEGOTIATINGINTERESTSINTERMSOFSECTORSMODESOFSUPPLYANDREMOVALOF
-&.EXEMPTIONS
!TTHEMEETINGIN-ARCHITWASAGREEDTHATANEXISTINGSUBITEMRELATINGTOPARAGRAPH
OFTHE'UIDELINESFOR.EGOTIATIONS3,WOULDBEINCORPORATEDINTOTHEGENERAL
DISCUSSIONUNDERTHISITEMANDREFLECTEDINITSTITLE3UBSTANTIVEDISCUSSIONSINTHISREGARD
WEREHELDONTHEBASISOFTWOCOMMUNICATIONSFROMAGROUPOF-EMBERSRELATINGTOTHE
#OUNCILSWORKUNDERPARAGRAPHANDTOTOURISMSERVICES4.37AND4.37
IV #ONSIDERATIONOFPROPOSALSONSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTPROVISIONS
3UBSEQUENTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILS$ECISIONONTHEh*ULY0ACKAGETHE#HAIRMANOFTHE
3PECIAL3ESSIONATTHE.OVEMBERMEETINGOFTHE#OUNCILPROPOSEDTOENGAGEINFURTHER
WORKUNDERTHISITEM
V 2EPORTSBYTHECHAIRMANTOTHETRADENEGOTIATIONSCOMMITTEE
4HE#HAIRMANOFTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESSUBSEQUENTTO
EACHMEETINGREPORTEDTOTHE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE4HESEREPORTSARECONTAINEDIN
74/DOCUMENTS4.3TO4.34HEREPORTCONTAINEDIN4.3DATED*ULYCONTAINS
THERECOMMENDATIONSAGREEDTOBYTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONONWHICHTOPURSUEFURTHERPROGRESS
INTHESERVICESNEGOTIATIONS!SLIGHTLYAMENDEDVERSIONOFTHESERECOMMENDATIONSWAS
ADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINTHEh*ULY0ACKAGEv
VI #OMMITTEEONTRADEINFINANCIALSERVICES
4HE#OMMITTEEHELDFOURFORMALMEETINGSINTHEREPORTSARECONTAINEDIN74/
DOCUMENTS3&).-TO4HEANNUALREPORTOFTHE#OMMITTEETOTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADE
IN3ERVICESISCONTAINEDIN74/DOCUMENT3&).4HE#OMMITTEECONTINUEDMONITORING
THEACCEPTANCEOFTHE&IFTH0ROTOCOLTOTHE'!43WHICHISSTILLTOBERATIFIEDBY"RAZIL
*AMAICAANDTHE0HILIPPINES-EMBERSCONTINUEDTHEIRCONSIDERATIONOFACOMMUNICATION
VII #OMMITTEEONSPECIFICCOMMITMENTS
4HE#OMMITTEEON3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTS#3#ISMANDATEDTOOVERSEETHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFSERVICESCOMMITMENTSANDTHEAPPLICATIONOFTHEPROCEDURESFORTHE
MODIFICATIONOFSCHEDULESITALSOSEEKSTOIMPROVETHETECHNICALACCURACYANDCOHERENCEOF
SCHEDULESOFCOMMITMENTSANDLISTSOF-&.EXEMPTIONS4HE#OMMITTEEHASCONCENTRATED
ITSWORKONSERVICESCLASSIFICATIONANDTHESCHEDULINGOFCOMMITMENTSWITHAVIEWTO
FACILITATINGTHECURRENTROUNDOFNEGOTIATIONSONTRADEINSERVICES
$URINGTHEPERIODUNDERCONSIDERATIONTHE#OMMITTEEHELDFOURFORMALMEETINGS
4HEREPORTSOFTHOSEMEETINGSARECONTAINEDINDOCUMENTS3#3#-TO4HE
#OMMITTEEADDRESSEDANEWCLASSIFICATIONPROPOSALREGARDINGENERGYSERVICESAND
CONTINUEDDELIBERATIONSONTHECLASSIFICATIONOFLEGALSERVICES)NTHEAREAOFSCHEDULING
OFSPECIFICCOMMITMENTSSEVERALTECHNICALQUESTIONSWEREEXAMINED!SMANDATEDBYTHE
#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES2EGULAR3ESSIONTHE#OMMITTEEALSOADDRESSEDISSUESRELATING
TOPARAGRAPHOF!RTICLE88OFTHE'!43
4HE!NNUAL2EPORTOFTHE#OMMITTEEON3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTSTOTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADE
IN3ERVICESISCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT3#3#
VIII 7ORKINGPARTYON'!43RULES
4HE7ORKING0ARTYON'!432ULESISMANDATEDTOCARRYOUTNEGOTIATIONSONEMERGENCY
SAFEGUARDMEASURES'!43!RTICLE8GOVERNMENTPROCUREMENT!RTICLE8)))AND
SUBSIDIES!RTICLE86)NITHELDFIVEFORMALMEETINGSTHEREPORTSARECONTAINEDIN
DOCUMENTS370'2-TO4HEANNUALREPORTOFTHE7ORKING0ARTYTOTHE#OUNCIL
FOR4RADEIN3ERVICESISCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT370'2$ELEGATIONSCONTINUEDTHEIR
EXAMINATIONOFISSUESRELATEDTOTHEQUESTIONOFEMERGENCYSAFEGUARDMEASURES$IFFERENT
VIEWSCONTINUEDTOBEEXPRESSEDREGARDINGTHEDESIRABILITYANDFEASIBILITYOFANEMERGENCY
SAFEGUARDMECHANISM-EMBERSALSODECIDEDTOEXTENDTHENEGOTIATINGMANDATEFORTHESE
NEGOTIATIONSSEEDOCUMENT3,WHICHOTHERWISEWOULDHAVELAPSEDIN-ARCH
/NGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTDISCUSSIONSFOCUSEDONTHEPROPOSALFROMTHE%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIESFORAFRAMEWORKOFRULESTHATWOULDGOVERNTHESCHEDULINGOFCOMMITMENTS
$ELEGATIONSCONTINUEDTOHOLDDIVERGENTVIEWSHOWEVERONWHETHERTHENEGOTIATING
MANDATEIN!RTICLE8)))ACTUALLYENCOMPASSESMARKETACCESSISSUES#ONCERNINGSUBSIDIES
THE7ORKING0ARTYPURSUEDITSCONSIDERATIONOFISSUESRELATEDTOTHEPOTENTIALNEEDFOR
DISCIPLINESONTRADEDISTORTINGSUBSIDIES
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
FROM-ALAYSIAENTITLEDh#HALLENGESINTHE&INANCIAL3ERVICES3ECTORv3&).7AND
ADDRESSEDAPROPOSALFROM.ORWAYONTHELIBERALIZATIONOFMARINEANDENERGYINSURANCE
-EXICOAND#HINESE4AIPEIMADEPRESENTATIONSONDIFFERENTASPECTSOFTHEIRREGULATORY
FRAMEWORKFORFINANCIALSERVICES4HE#OMMITTEEALSOCONTINUEDITSDISCUSSIONSOFAPROPOSAL
SUBMITTEDBY!NTIGUAAND"ARBUDAONBEHALFOFAGROUPOFCOUNTRIES3&).72EV
!TTHEINVITATIONOFTHE#OMMITTEETHE/%#$PRESENTEDADOCUMENTENTITLEDh-ANAGING
2EQUEST/FFER.EGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE'!43THE#ASEOF)NSURANCE3ERVICESvWHICHISPART
OFAJOINTPROJECTBETWEEN/%#$AND5.#4!$&INALLYATTHELASTMEETINGOFTHEYEARTHE
#OMMITTEECARRIEDOUTTHETHIRD4RANSITIONAL2EVIEWOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONBY#HINAOFITS
74/COMMITMENTSPURSUANTTOSECTIONOFTHE0ROTOCOLONTHE!CCESSIONOFTHE0EOPLES
2EPUBLICOF#HINA4HERELEVANTREPORTBYTHE#OMMITTEETOTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES
ISCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT3&).
IX 7ORKINGPARTYONDOMESTICREGULATIONS
4HE7ORKING0ARTYON$OMESTIC2EGULATION70$2ISMANDATEDTODEVELOPDISCIPLINES
TOENSURETHATMEASURESRELATINGTOLICENSINGREQUIREMENTSTECHNICALSTANDARDSAND
QUALIFICATIONREQUIREMENTSDONOTCONSTITUTEUNNECESSARYBARRIERSTOTRADEINSERVICES)T
ALSOASSUMEDTHEMANDATEOFTHEFORMER7ORKING0ARTYON0ROFESSIONAL3ERVICESINCLUDING
DEVELOPINGGENERALDISCIPLINESFORPROFESSIONALSERVICES4HE70$2HELDFOURFORMAL
MEETINGSANDONEINFORMALMEETINGIN4HEREPORTSOFTHEFORMALMEETINGSAREFOUND
INDOCUMENTS370$2-TO
4HE70$2CONTINUEDTOEXAMINE*APANSINFORMALPAPER$RAFT!NNEXON$OMESTIC
2EGULATIONASWELLASAPAPERFROMTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES0ROPOSALFOR$ISCIPLINES
ON,ICENSING0ROCEDURES)TALSODISCUSSEDANINFORMALPAPERBY(ONG+ONG#HINAON
THE2ELATIONSHIPOF2EGULATORY$ISCIPLINESWITH.ATIONAL4REATMENTANDAFORMALPAPER
BY#OLOMBIAENTITLED%XAMPLESOF-EASURES2ELATINGTO!DMINISTRATIVE0ROCEDURESFOR
/BTAINING6ISASOR%NTRY0ERMITS!FORMALPAPERON-EXICOS%XPERIENCEOF$ISCIPLINES
ON4ECHNICAL3TANDARDSAND2EGULATIONSIN3ERVICESASWELLASTHE5NITED3TATESINFORMAL
SUBMISSION0ROPOSALFOR4RANSPARENCY$ISCIPLINESIN$OMESTIC2EGULATIONRECEIVED
COMMENTS4HE70$2FURTHERDISCUSSEDA3ECRETARIATNOTE.ECESSITY4ESTSINTHE
74/ANDCONTINUEDTOREVIEWTHEMEASURESINCLUDINGADDITIONALEXAMPLESPROVIDEDBY
DELEGATIONSLISTEDINTHEINFORMAL3ECRETARIATPAPER%XAMPLESOF-EASURESTOBE!DDRESSED
BY$ISCIPLINESUNDER'!43!RTICLE6)
2EGARDINGPROFESSIONALSERVICES-EMBERSMADEFURTHERCOMMENTSONANINFORMALPAPER
FROM)NDIAON2ECOGNITION)SSUESANDON.EW:EALANDSINFORMALPAPER)MPLEMENTATION
OF!RTICLE6)/BLIGATIONSIN%NGINEERING3ERVICES4HE70$2ALSODISCUSSEDAFORMAL
SUBMISSIONBY!USTRALIA0ROFESSIONAL2ECOGNITIONIN!USTRALIA4HE3ECRETARIATUPDATED
-EMBERSONTHERESULTSOFTHECONSULTATIONSWITHINTERNATIONALPROFESSIONALSERVICES
ORGANIZATIONSCONCERNINGTHEPOTENTIALSUITABILITYOFTHE$ISCIPLINESON$OMESTIC2EGULATION
INTHE!CCOUNTANCY3ECTORFOROTHERPROFESSIONS
!7ORKSHOPON$OMESTIC2EGULATIONWASHELDATTHEREQUESTOFTHE70$2IN'ENEVA
FROMTO-ARCH4HEOBJECTIVEWASTOBRINGTOGETHERANDINFORMREGULATORSTRADE
NEGOTIATORSANDOTHERRELEVANTOFFICIALSOFTHEBACKGROUNDANDPROGRESSTODATEOFTHEWORK
TAKINGPLACEINTHE70$24HEREWEREBETWEENANDPARTICIPANTSALLPRESENTATIONS
AREPOSTEDONTHE74/WEBSITE
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
X 4ARGETEDTECHNICALASSISTANCETOENABLEEFFECTIVEPARTICIPATIONIN
THESERVICESNEGOTIATIONS
2EGARDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCETHE'ENERAL#OUNCILADOPTEDINTHECONTEXTOFTHE*ULY
0ACKAGEARECOMMENDATIONTHATTARGETEDASSISTANCEBEPROVIDEDTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
WITHAVIEWTOENABLINGTHEMTOPARTICIPATEEFFECTIVELYINTHENEGOTIATIONS4ODEVELOPA
BETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFINDIVIDUAL-EMBERSNEEDSTHE3ECRETARIATHASSINCEDEVELOPED
INCONSULTATIONWITHDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYDELEGATESAGENERALTEMPLATEFORNATIONALSERVICES
SEMINARS3COPEANDCONTENTOFINDIVIDUALMISSIONSAREADJUSTEDTOTHEINTERESTSEXPRESSEDBY
THEAUTHORITIESONTHEBASISOFTHISTEMPLATE
-ARKETACCESSFORNONAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS0ARAGRAPH
7EAGREETONEGOTIATIONSWHICHSHALLAIMBYMODALITIESTOBEAGREEDTOREDUCE
ORASAPPROPRIATEELIMINATETARIFFSINCLUDINGTHEREDUCTIONORELIMINATIONOFTARIFFPEAKS
HIGHTARIFFSANDTARIFFESCALATIONASWELLASNONTARIFFBARRIERSINPARTICULARONPRODUCTS
OFEXPORTINTERESTTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES0RODUCTCOVERAGESHALLBECOMPREHENSIVEAND
WITHOUTAPRIORIEXCLUSIONS4HENEGOTIATIONSSHALLTAKEFULLYINTOACCOUNTTHESPECIALNEEDS
ANDINTERESTSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRYPARTICIPANTSINCLUDINGTHROUGHLESS
THANFULLRECIPROCITYINREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTSINACCORDANCEWITHTHERELEVANTPROVISIONSOF
!RTICLE886)))BISOF'!44ANDTHEPROVISIONSCITEDINPARAGRAPHBELOW4OTHISEND
THEMODALITIESTOBEAGREEDWILLINCLUDEAPPROPRIATESTUDIESANDCAPACITYBUILDINGMEASURES
TOASSISTLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTOPARTICIPATEEFFECTIVELYINTHENEGOTIATIONS
)NTHEAFTERMATHOFTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL-EETINGTHEIMMEDIATEOBJECTIVEOFTHE
NEW#HAIRMANOFTHE.ON!GRICULTURAL-ARKET!CCESS'ROUP.!-!'ROUP(%3TEFÉN
(*ØHANNESSON)CELANDWASTOPROVIDEAMUCHNEEDEDOPPORTUNITYFORDELEGATIONS
TOENGAGEONAONETOONEBASISANDHAVEAFRANKEXCHANGEOFVIEWS4HETIMEFOR
REGURGITATINGNATIONALPOSITIONSWASLONGGONEANDINHISVIEWITWASTHEMOMENT
FORDELEGATIONSTONEGOTIATEANDENHANCETHEIRUNDERSTANDINGOFEACHOTHERSPOSITION
!SARESULTTHEPLENARYSESSIONSWEREFORMALITIESWHICHOPENEDANDCLOSEDTHETHREE
DAYMEETINGS4HEINTERVENINGTIMEWASGIVENTODELEGATIONSTOENTERINTOBILATERALAND
PLURILATERALCONSULTATIONS3UCHTYPESOFMEETINGOFTENCALLEDBOOKENDTYPEMEETINGS
BROUGHTSOMEDIVIDENDSINSOFARASDELEGATIONSBEGANTODEMONSTRATESERIOUSENGAGEMENT
INTHE.!-!NEGOTIATIONS4HERATHERLACKLUSTREATMOSPHEREFOLLOWINGTHE#ANCÞN
-INISTERIAL-EETINGDISSIPATEDANDWASREPLACEDBYAMORECONSTRUCTIVEANDPRODUCTIVE
WORKENVIRONMENT)NTHISCONNECTIONANIMPLICITUNDERSTANDINGWASREACHEDQUITEEARLY
ONAMONG.!-!NEGOTIATORSTHATANIMMEDIATEOBJECTIVEWOULDBETOWORKTOWARDS
AFRAMEWORKON.!-!MODALITIESBEFOREEND*ULY4HEFRAMEWORKWASTOBEA
STEPPINGSTONETOWARDSFULLMODALITIES!SDISCUSSIONSONTHISSUBJECTWEREPURSUEDIN
THE'ROUPITBECAMECLEARTHATTWOAPPROACHESWEREBEINGESPOUSED4HEREWERETHOSE
-EMBERSWHOSOUGHTTOKEEPTHE.!-!TEXTWHICHORIGINATEDFROMTHESECONDREVISIONOF
THEDRAFT#ANCÞN-INISTERAL4EXTTHESOCALLED$ERBEZTEXTUNCHANGED7HILETHEREWERE
OTHERSWHOWISHEDTONEGOTIATETHATTEXTANDINTRODUCEAMENDMENTS4HECOMPROMISE
REACHEDWASTOINCLUDEANEWPARAGRAPHTOTHATORIGINALTEXT4HISNEWPARAGRAPH
COMMONLYREFERREDTOASTHEhVEHICLEvSERVEDTHEPURPOSEOFGIVING-EMBERSADEQUATE
COMFORTTOSIGNOFFONTHE.!-!FRAMEWORKANDEVENTUALLYTHEh*ULYPACKAGEv&OLLOWING
AGREEMENTONTHEh*ULYPACKAGEvMOREFORMALLYKNOWNASTHE!UGUST'ENERAL
#OUNCIL$ECISIONTHE.!-!'ROUPHASBEENUNDERTAKINGMUCHNEEDEDTECHNICAL
WORKONANUMBEROFELEMENTSSELECTEDBYTHE#HAIRMANFROM!NNEX"OFTHATDECISION
WHICHCONTAINSTHE.!-!FRAMEWORK4HETECHNICALISSUESDISCUSSEDTOWARDSTHEEND
OFTHEYEARWERETARIFFPEAKSHIGHTARIFFSANDTARIFFESCALATIONPRODUCTSOFINTERESTTO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESLESSTHANFULLRECIPROCITYINREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTSCREDITFORBOUND
AUTONOMOUSLIBERALIZATIONMEASURESBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESSINCETHE5RUGUAY2OUND
PRODUCTCOVERAGEANDPARTICIPATIONINSECTORALSAPPROPRIATESTUDIESANDCAPACITYBUILDING
MEASURESANDTARIFFREVENUEDEPENDENCY4HISWORKHASKEPTTHE'ROUPBUSYFORTHE
REMAINDEROF
h7ITHAVIEWTOCOMPLETINGTHEWORKSTARTEDINTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADE2ELATED
!SPECTSOF)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY2IGHTS#OUNCILFOR42)03ONTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOF
!RTICLEWEAGREETONEGOTIATETHEESTABLISHMENTOFAMULTILATERALSYSTEMOFNOTIFICATION
ANDREGISTRATIONOFGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSFORWINESANDSPIRITSBYTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE7ENOTETHATISSUESRELATEDTOTHEEXTENSIONOFTHEPROTECTIONOF
GEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSPROVIDEDFORIN!RTICLETOPRODUCTSOTHERTHANWINESANDSPIRITS
WILLBEADDRESSEDINTHE#OUNCILFOR42)03PURSUANTTOPARAGRAPHOFTHIS$ECLARATIONv
4HE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OUNCILFOR42)03WHICHDEALSWITHTHENEGOTIATIONS
MANDATEDUNDER!RTICLEANDPARAGRAPHFIRSTSENTENCEOFTHE$OHA$ECLARATION
ESTABLISHMENTOFAMULTILATERALSYSTEMOFNOTIFICATIONANDREGISTRATIONOFGEOGRAPHICAL
INDICATIONSFORWINESANDSPIRITSRESUMEDITSWORKIN!PRILUNDERTHECHAIRMANSHIP
OF!MBASSADOR-ANZOOR!HMADFROM0AKISTAN)THELDFOURFORMALMEETINGSON!PRIL
*UNE3EPTEMBERAND.OVEMBER)NPARAGRAPHFOFTHE$ECISIONOF
!UGUSTTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTOOKNOTEOFTHEREPORTTOTHE4.#BYTHE3PECIAL3ESSION
OFTHE42)03#OUNCILANDREAFFIRMED-EMBERSCOMMITMENTTOPROGRESSINTHISAREAOF
THENEGOTIATIONSINLINEWITHTHE$OHAMANDATE!PARTFROMTHE!PRILMEETINGWHICH
DEALTWITHORGANIZATIONALMATTERSALLTHEMEETINGSADDRESSEDVARIOUSSUBSTANTIVEISSUES
NAMELYLEGALEFFECTSANDPARTICIPATIONADMINISTRATIVEANDOTHERBURDENSANDANUMBER
OFISSUESOFTECHNICALORPROCEDURALNATURERELATINGTOTHEOPERATIONOFANOTIFICATIONAND
REGISTRATIONSYSTEM!TTHE.OVEMBERMEETINGDELEGATIONSALSOADDRESSEDISSUESRELATEDTO
THENOTIFICATIONPHASEWHICHHADBEENDISCUSSEDINSOMEDETAILINBEFORETHE#ANCÞN
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE!LTHOUGHTHESEDISCUSSIONSPROVEDUSEFULPOSITIONSREMAINED
DIVIDEDESPECIALLYONTHETWOKEYISSUESOFLEGALEFFECTSANDPARTICIPATION
2ELATIONSHIPBETWEENTRADEANDINVESTMENT0ARAGRAPHS
2ECOGNIZINGTHECASEFORAMULTILATERALFRAMEWORKTOSECURETRANSPARENTSTABLE
ANDPREDICTABLECONDITIONSFORLONGTERMCROSSBORDERINVESTMENTPARTICULARLYFOREIGNDIRECT
INVESTMENTTHATWILLCONTRIBUTETOTHEEXPANSIONOFTRADEANDTHENEEDFORENHANCED
TECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHISAREAASREFERREDTOINPARAGRAPHWE
AGREETHATNEGOTIATIONSWILLTAKEPLACEAFTERTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
ONTHEBASISOFADECISIONTOBETAKENBYEXPLICITCONSENSUSATTHAT3ESSIONONMODALITIESOF
NEGOTIATIONS
7ERECOGNIZETHENEEDSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESFORENHANCED
SUPPORTFORTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHISAREAINCLUDINGPOLICY
ANALYSISANDDEVELOPMENTSOTHATTHEYMAYBETTEREVALUATETHEIMPLICATIONSOFCLOSER
MULTILATERALCOOPERATIONFORTHEIRDEVELOPMENTPOLICIESANDOBJECTIVESANDHUMANAND
INSTITUTIONALDEVELOPMENT4OTHISENDWESHALLWORKINCOOPERATIONWITHOTHERRELEVANT
INTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSINCLUDING5.#4!$ANDTHROUGHAPPROPRIATEREGIONALAND
BILATERALCHANNELSTOPROVIDESTRENGTHENEDANDADEQUATELYRESOURCEDASSISTANCETORESPOND
TOTHESENEEDS
)NTHEPERIODUNTILTHE&IFTH3ESSIONFURTHERWORKINTHE7ORKING'ROUPONTHE
2ELATIONSHIP"ETWEEN4RADEAND)NVESTMENTWILLFOCUSONTHECLARIFICATIONOFSCOPEAND
DEFINITIONTRANSPARENCYNONDISCRIMINATIONMODALITIESFORPREESTABLISHMENTCOMMITMENTS
BASEDONA'!43TYPEPOSITIVELISTAPPROACHDEVELOPMENTPROVISIONSEXCEPTIONSAND
BALANCEOFPAYMENTSSAFEGUARDSCONSULTATIONANDTHESETTLEMENTOFDISPUTESBETWEEN
-EMBERS!NYFRAMEWORKSHOULDREFLECTINABALANCEDMANNERTHEINTERESTSOFHOMEAND
HOSTCOUNTRIESANDTAKEDUEACCOUNTOFTHEDEVELOPMENTPOLICIESANDOBJECTIVESOFHOST
GOVERNMENTSASWELLASTHEIRRIGHTTOREGULATEINTHEPUBLICINTEREST4HESPECIALDEVELOPMENT
TRADEANDFINANCIALNEEDSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESSHOULDBETAKENINTO
ACCOUNTASANINTEGRALPARTOFANYFRAMEWORKWHICHSHOULDENABLE-EMBERSTOUNDERTAKE
OBLIGATIONSANDCOMMITMENTSCOMMENSURATEWITHTHEIRINDIVIDUALNEEDSANDCIRCUMSTANCES
$UEREGARDSHOULDBEPAIDTOOTHERRELEVANT74/PROVISIONS!CCOUNTSHOULDBETAKENAS
APPROPRIATEOFEXISTINGBILATERALANDREGIONALARRANGEMENTSONINVESTMENT
3INCETHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCENOMEETINGSOFTHE7ORKING'ROUPONTHE
2ELATIONSHIPBETWEEN4RADEAND)NVESTMENTWEREHELDPENDINGADECISIONBYTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILONTHEFUTUREDIRECTIONOFWORKINTHISAREA/N!UGUSTTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
DECIDEDTHATTHISISSUEREFERREDTOINPARAGRAPHSOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION
WOULDNOLONGERFORMPARTOFTHEWORKPROGRAMMESETOUTINTHAT$ECLARATIONANDTHEREFORE
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OUNCILFOR42)03PARAGRAPH$OHA
THATNOWORKTOWARDNEGOTIATIONSONTHISISSUEWOULDTAKEPLACEWITHINTHE74/DURINGTHE
$OHA2OUND74,PARAGRAPHG3INCETHISDECISIONWASTAKENNOMEETINGSOFTHE
7ORKING'ROUPHAVEBEENHELD
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
)NTERACTIONBETWEENTRADEANDCOMPETITIONPOLICY
0ARAGRAPHS
2ECOGNIZINGTHECASEFORAMULTILATERALFRAMEWORKTOENHANCETHECONTRIBUTIONOF
COMPETITIONPOLICYTOINTERNATIONALTRADEANDDEVELOPMENTANDTHENEEDFORENHANCEDTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHISAREAASREFERREDTOINPARAGRAPHWEAGREETHAT
NEGOTIATIONSWILLTAKEPLACEAFTERTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEONTHEBASISOF
ADECISIONTOBETAKENBYEXPLICITCONSENSUSATTHAT3ESSIONONMODALITIESOFNEGOTIATIONS
7ERECOGNIZETHENEEDSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESFORENHANCED
SUPPORTFORTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHISAREAINCLUDINGPOLICYANALYSIS
ANDDEVELOPMENTSOTHATTHEYMAYBETTEREVALUATETHEIMPLICATIONSOFCLOSERMULTILATERAL
COOPERATIONFORTHEIRDEVELOPMENTPOLICIESANDOBJECTIVESANDHUMANANDINSTITUTIONAL
DEVELOPMENT4OTHISENDWESHALLWORKINCOOPERATIONWITHOTHERRELEVANTINTERGOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONSINCLUDING5.#4!$ANDTHROUGHAPPROPRIATEREGIONALANDBILATERALCHANNELSTO
PROVIDESTRENGTHENEDANDADEQUATELYRESOURCEDASSISTANCETORESPONDTOTHESENEEDS
)NTHEPERIODUNTILTHE&IFTH3ESSIONFURTHERWORKINTHE7ORKING'ROUPONTHE
)NTERACTIONBETWEEN4RADEAND#OMPETITION0OLICYWILLFOCUSONTHECLARIFICATIONOFCORE
PRINCIPLESINCLUDINGTRANSPARENCYNONDISCRIMINATIONANDPROCEDURALFAIRNESSANDPROVISIONS
ONHARDCORECARTELSMODALITIESFORVOLUNTARYCOOPERATIONANDSUPPORTFORPROGRESSIVE
REINFORCEMENTOFCOMPETITIONINSTITUTIONSINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHROUGHCAPACITYBUILDING
&ULLACCOUNTSHALLBETAKENOFTHENEEDSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY
PARTICIPANTSANDAPPROPRIATEFLEXIBILITYPROVIDEDTOADDRESSTHEM
3INCETHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCENOMEETINGSOFTHE7ORKING'ROUPONTHE
)NTERACTIONBETWEEN4RADEAND#OMPETITION0OLICYWEREHELDPENDINGADECISIONBYTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILONTHEFUTUREDIRECTIONOFWORKINTHISAREA/N!UGUSTTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILDECIDEDTHATTHISISSUEREFERREDTOINPARAGRAPHSOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL
$ECLARATIONWOULDNOLONGERFORMPARTOFTHEWORKPROGRAMMESETOUTINTHAT$ECLARATION
ANDTHEREFORETHATNOWORKTOWARDNEGOTIATIONSONTHISISSUEWOULDTAKEPLACEWITHINTHE
74/DURINGTHE$OHA2OUND74,PARAGRAPHG3INCETHISDECISIONWASTAKENNO
MEETINGSOFTHE7ORKING'ROUPHAVEBEENHELD
4RANSPARENCYINGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENT0ARAGRAPH
2ECOGNIZINGTHECASEFORAMULTILATERALAGREEMENTONTRANSPARENCYINGOVERNMENT
PROCUREMENTANDTHENEEDFORENHANCEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHIS
AREAWEAGREETHATNEGOTIATIONSWILLTAKEPLACEAFTERTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEONTHEBASISOFADECISIONTOBETAKENBYEXPLICITCONSENSUSATTHAT3ESSION
ONMODALITIESOFNEGOTIATIONS4HESENEGOTIATIONSWILLBUILDONTHEPROGRESSMADEINTHE
7ORKING'ROUPON4RANSPARENCYIN'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENTBYTHATTIMEANDTAKEINTO
ACCOUNTPARTICIPANTSDEVELOPMENTPRIORITIESESPECIALLYTHOSEOFLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY
PARTICIPANTS.EGOTIATIONSSHALLBELIMITEDTOTHETRANSPARENCYASPECTSANDTHEREFOREWILL
NOTRESTRICTTHESCOPEFORCOUNTRIESTOGIVEPREFERENCESTODOMESTICSUPPLIESANDSUPPLIERS
7ECOMMITOURSELVESTOENSURINGADEQUATETECHNICALASSISTANCEANDSUPPORTFORCAPACITY
BUILDINGBOTHDURINGTHENEGOTIATIONSANDAFTERTHEIRCONCLUSION
3INCETHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCENOMEETINGSOFTHE7ORKING'ROUPON
4RANSPARENCYIN'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENTWEREHELDPENDINGADECISIONBYTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILONTHEFUTUREDIRECTIONOFWORKINTHISAREA/N!UGUSTTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
OFTHE74/DECIDEDTHATTHISISSUEREFERREDTOINPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL
$ECLARATIONWOULDNOLONGERFORMPARTOFTHEWORKPROGRAMMESETOUTINTHAT$ECLARATION
ANDTHEREFORETHATNOWORKTOWARDNEGOTIATIONSONTHISISSUEWOULDTAKEPLACEWITHINTHE
74/DURINGTHE$OHA2OUND74,PARAGRAPHG3INCETHISDECISIONWASTAKENNO
MEETINGSOFTHE7ORKING'ROUPHAVEBEENHELD
4RADEFACILITATION0ARAGRAPH
2ECOGNIZINGTHECASEFORFURTHEREXPEDITINGTHEMOVEMENTRELEASEANDCLEARANCEOF
GOODSINCLUDINGGOODSINTRANSITANDTHENEEDFORENHANCEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITY
BUILDINGINTHISAREAWEAGREETHATNEGOTIATIONSWILLTAKEPLACEAFTERTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEONTHEBASISOFADECISIONTOBETAKENBYEXPLICITCONSENSUSATTHAT
3ESSIONONMODALITIESOFNEGOTIATIONS)NTHEPERIODUNTILTHE&IFTH3ESSIONTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADE
IN'OODSSHALLREVIEWANDASAPPROPRIATECLARIFYANDIMPROVERELEVANTASPECTSOF!RTICLES66)))
AND8OFTHE'!44ANDIDENTIFYTHETRADEFACILITATIONNEEDSANDPRIORITIESOF-EMBERS
INPARTICULARDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES7ECOMMITOURSELVESTOENSURING
ADEQUATETECHNICALASSISTANCEANDSUPPORTFORCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHISAREA
&OLLOWINGASERIESOFCONSULTATIONSUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL-EMBERS
AGREEDTOLAUNCHNEGOTIATIONSON4RADE&ACILITATIONINADECISIONADOPTEDON!UGUST )NLINEWITHTHEMODALITIESFORTHENEGOTIATIONSSETOUTIN!NNEX$OFTHATDECISIONTHE4RADE
.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEEATASESSIONOF/CTOBERESTABLISHEDA.EGOTIATING'ROUPON
4RADE&ACILITATIONANDAPPOINTEDITS#HAIR
!FIRSTMEETINGOFTHE.EGOTIATING'ROUPWASHELDSOONTHEREAFTER.OVEMBER
LEADINGTOTHEADOPTIONOFA7ORK0LANANDSCHEDULEOFMEETINGS4.4&-EMBERSALSO
AGREEDTOINVITERELEVANTINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSTOATTENDFORMALSESSIONSOFTHE'ROUP
ONANADHOCBASIS!SECONDMEETINGTOOKPLACEONAND.OVEMBER)TSAW-EMBERS
ENGAGEINANEDUCATIONALANDSTOCKTAKINGPROCESSWITHCONTRIBUTIONSALSOBEINGMADEON
THEAGREEDAGENDAOFTHE'ROUP
)NTHELIGHTOFEXPERIENCEANDOFTHEINCREASINGAPPLICATIONOFTHESEINSTRUMENTS
BY-EMBERSWEAGREETONEGOTIATIONSAIMEDATCLARIFYINGANDIMPROVINGDISCIPLINESUNDER
THE!GREEMENTSON)MPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLE6)OFTHE'!44ANDON3UBSIDIESAND
#OUNTERVAILING-EASURESWHILEPRESERVINGTHEBASICCONCEPTSPRINCIPLESANDEFFECTIVENESSOF
THESE!GREEMENTSANDTHEIRINSTRUMENTSANDOBJECTIVESANDTAKINGINTOACCOUNTTHENEEDS
OFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDPARTICIPANTS)NTHEINITIALPHASEOFTHENEGOTIATIONS
PARTICIPANTSWILLINDICATETHEPROVISIONSINCLUDINGDISCIPLINESONTRADEDISTORTINGPRACTICES
THATTHEYSEEKTOCLARIFYANDIMPROVEINTHESUBSEQUENTPHASE)NTHECONTEXTOFTHESE
NEGOTIATIONSPARTICIPANTSSHALLALSOAIMTOCLARIFYANDIMPROVE74/DISCIPLINESONFISHERIES
SUBSIDIESTAKINGINTOACCOUNTTHEIMPORTANCEOFTHISSECTORTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES7ENOTE
THATFISHERIESSUBSIDIESAREALSOREFERREDTOINPARAGRAPH
7EALSOAGREETONEGOTIATIONSAIMEDATCLARIFYINGANDIMPROVINGDISCIPLINESAND
PROCEDURESUNDERTHEEXISTING74/PROVISIONSAPPLYINGTOREGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTS4HE
NEGOTIATIONSSHALLTAKEINTOACCOUNTTHEDEVELOPMENTALASPECTSOFREGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTS
4HE.EGOTIATING'ROUPON2ULESMETWITHINCREASINGINTENSITYINHOLDINGSIX
MEETINGCLUSTERSONANTIDUMPINGANDSUBSIDIESCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESINCLUDING
FISHERIESSUBSIDIESh!$3#-vANDSEVENFORMALANDINFORMALMEETINGSON24!SDURINGTHE
COURSEOFTHEYEAR-OSTMEETINGSON!$3#-ALSOINCLUDEDINTENSIVEWORKININFORMALOPEN
ENDEDSESSIONS&ORMALPROPOSALSANDOTHERSUBMISSIONSMADETOTHE'ROUPWERECIRCULATED
EITHERASUNRESTRICTEDDOCUMENTSINTHE4.2,7SERIESWHILEASOFTHELATERHALFOFTHE
YEARINFORMALPROPOSALSWERECIRCULATEDBOTHAS*/"ANDASUNRESTRICTED4.2,'%.
DOCUMENTSFORTHEPURPOSESOFTRANSPARENCY
7ITHRESPECTTOANTIDUMPINGANDSUBSIDIESANDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESINCLUDING
FISHERIESSUBSIDIESTHEWORKOFTHE'ROUPEVOLVEDSUBSTANTIALLYIN7HILETHE'ROUP
CONTINUEDTOMEETINFORMALSESSIONTOCONSIDERADDITIONALISSUESIDENTIFIEDBY0ARTICIPANTS
THEFOCUSOFTHE'ROUPSACTIVITIESSHIFTEDTOWARDSAMUCHMOREDETAILEDEXAMINATIONAND
INTERACTIVEEXCHANGEINOPENENDEDINFORMALSESSIONSONISSUESPREVIOUSLYIDENTIFIEDONTHE
BASISOFTWENTYEIGHTINFORMALELABORATEDPROPOSALSSUBMITTEDBY0ARTICIPANTSDURINGTHE
LATTERHALFOFTHEYEAR-EETINGCLUSTERSALSOINCLUDEEXTENSIVEOPPORTUNITIESFORBILATERALAND
PLURILATERALCONTACTSAMONGDELEGATIONS
7ITHRESPECTTO24!STHE'ROUPHASFURTHERREFINEDMOSTOFTHEELEMENTSTOIMPROVE
24!STRANSPARENCYINCLUDINGTHOSERELATEDTOTHENOTIFICATIONANDREVIEWOF24!S)TALSO
HELDAFIRSTROUNDOFDISCUSSIONSONARANGEOFSYSTEMICISSUESINPARTICULARTHEDEFINITION
OFSUBSTANTIALLYALLTHETRADEIN'!44!RTICLE88)624!SANDDEVELOPMENTPREFERENTIAL
RULESOFORIGINANDTHESCOPEOFOTHERRESTRICTIVEREGULATIONSOFCOMMERCE&ORFURTHER
DISCUSSIONOFTHESEISSUESTHE'ROUPINVITEDSPECIFICSUBMISSIONSFROMPARTICIPANTS
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
74/RULES0ARAGRAPHSAND
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING0ARAGRAPH
7EAGREETONEGOTIATIONSONIMPROVEMENTSANDCLARIFICATIONSOFTHE$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING4HENEGOTIATIONSSHOULDBEBASEDONTHEWORKDONETHUSFAR
ASWELLASANYADDITIONALPROPOSALSBY-EMBERSANDAIMTOAGREEONIMPROVEMENTSAND
CLARIFICATIONSNOTLATERTHAN-AYATWHICHTIMEWEWILLTAKESTEPSTOENSURETHATTHE
RESULTSENTERINTOFORCEASSOONASPOSSIBLETHEREAFTER
4HENEGOTIATIONSONhIMPROVEMENTSANDCLARIFICATIONSvTOTHE$35WEREINITIALLYINTENDED
TOBECONCLUDEDBY-AYBUTTHETIMEFRAMEFORCONCLUDINGTHEWORKHADBEEN
EXTENDEDIN*ULYFORANADDITIONALYEARUNTIL-AY )N-ARCH!MBASSADOR$AVID3PENCEROF!USTRALIAWASAPPOINTEDAS#HAIRMAN
OFTHE$3"3PECIAL3ESSION3OMEADDITIONALPROGRESSWASMADEINTHE3PECIAL3ESSION
74,$ECISIONADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILON!UGUST
3EE!NNUAL2EPORTP
INTHEFIRSTFEWMONTHSOFBUILDINGONTHEWORKDONETHUSFAR3OMEDELEGATIONS
MADEADDITIONALWRITTENCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHENEGOTIATIONSDURINGTHISPERIODWHICH
WEREWELCOMEDBYPARTICIPANTS(OWEVERWORKHADBEENSLOWTORESUMEINTHEPERIOD
IMMEDIATELYFOLLOWINGTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEANDBY-AYTHEREWAS
AGREEMENTAMONG-EMBERSTHATMORETIMEWASREQUIREDTOCOMPLETETHEDISPUTESETTLEMENT
NEGOTIATIONSANDTHATWORKSHOULDCONTINUETOWARDSCLARIFICATIONSANDIMPROVEMENTS
TOTHE$35 /N!UGUSTASPARTOFTHE*ULY0ACKAGETHE'ENERAL#OUNCILADOPTEDA
RECOMMENDATIONBYTHE4.#THATWORKINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONSHOULDCONTINUEONTHEBASIS
SETOUTINTHE#HAIRMANSREPORTTOTHE4.# 4WOFURTHERMEETINGSOFTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONWEREHELDINON/CTOBERAND
.OVEMBER"OTHOFTHESEMEETINGSWEREESSENTIALLYDEVOTEDTOTHEDISCUSSIONOFAN
INFORMALJOINTCONTRIBUTIONBY!RGENTINA"RAZIL#ANADA)NDIA.EW:EALANDAND.ORWAY
4HISCONTRIBUTIONWHICHHADBEENPRESENTEDATTHEENDOF-AYFOCUSEDONTHREEISSUES
WHICHHADBEENINDISCUSSIONINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONREMANDSEQUENCINGANDPOST
RETALIATIONISSUES
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
4RADEANDENVIRONMENT0ARAGRAPHS
7ITHAVIEWTOENHANCINGTHEMUTUALSUPPORTIVENESSOFTRADEANDENVIRONMENTWE
AGREETONEGOTIATIONSWITHOUTPREJUDGINGTHEIROUTCOMEON
I THERELATIONSHIPBETWEENEXISTING74/RULESANDSPECIFICTRADEOBLIGATIONSSETOUTIN
MULTILATERALENVIRONMENTALAGREEMENTS-%!S4HENEGOTIATIONSSHALLBELIMITEDIN
SCOPETOTHEAPPLICABILITYOFSUCHEXISTING74/RULESASAMONGPARTIESTOTHE-%!IN
QUESTION4HENEGOTIATIONSSHALLNOTPREJUDICETHE74/RIGHTSOFANY-EMBERTHATIS
NOTAPARTYTOTHE-%!INQUESTION
II PROCEDURESFORREGULARINFORMATIONEXCHANGEBETWEEN-%!3ECRETARIATSANDTHE
RELEVANT74/COMMITTEESANDTHECRITERIAFORTHEGRANTINGOFOBSERVERSTATUS
III THEREDUCTIONORASAPPROPRIATEELIMINATIONOFTARIFFANDNONTARIFFBARRIERSTO
ENVIRONMENTALGOODSANDSERVICES
7ENOTETHATFISHERIESSUBSIDIESFORMPARTOFTHENEGOTIATIONSPROVIDEDFORIN
PARAGRAPH
7EINSTRUCTTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTINPURSUINGWORKONALLITEMS
ONITSAGENDAWITHINITSCURRENTTERMSOFREFERENCETOGIVEPARTICULARATTENTIONTO
I THEEFFECTOFENVIRONMENTALMEASURESONMARKETACCESSESPECIALLYINRELATIONTO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINPARTICULARTHELEASTDEVELOPEDAMONGTHEMANDTHOSE
SITUATIONSINWHICHTHEELIMINATIONORREDUCTIONOFTRADERESTRICTIONSANDDISTORTIONS
WOULDBENEFITTRADETHEENVIRONMENTANDDEVELOPMENT
II THERELEVANTPROVISIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTON4RADE2ELATED!SPECTSOF)NTELLECTUAL
0ROPERTY2IGHTSAND
III LABELLINGREQUIREMENTSFORENVIRONMENTALPURPOSES
7ORKONTHESEISSUESSHOULDINCLUDETHEIDENTIFICATIONOFANYNEEDTOCLARIFYRELEVANT
74/RULES4HE#OMMITTEESHALLREPORTTOTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
ANDMAKERECOMMENDATIONSWHEREAPPROPRIATEWITHRESPECTTOFUTUREACTIONINCLUDINGTHE
DESIRABILITYOFNEGOTIATIONS4HEOUTCOMEOFTHISWORKASWELLASTHENEGOTIATIONSCARRIEDOUT
UNDERPARAGRAPHIANDIISHALLBECOMPATIBLEWITHTHEOPENANDNONDISCRIMINATORY
NATUREOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMSHALLNOTADDTOORDIMINISHTHERIGHTSAND
OBLIGATIONSOF-EMBERSUNDEREXISTING74/AGREEMENTSINPARTICULARTHE!GREEMENTONTHE
!PPLICATIONOF3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESNORALTERTHEBALANCEOFTHESERIGHTS
ANDOBLIGATIONSANDWILLTAKEINTOACCOUNTTHENEEDSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIES
7ERECOGNIZETHEIMPORTANCEOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHE
FIELDOFTRADEANDENVIRONMENTTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINPARTICULARTHELEASTDEVELOPED
AMONGTHEM7EALSOENCOURAGETHATEXPERTISEANDEXPERIENCEBESHAREDWITH-EMBERS
WISHINGTOPERFORMENVIRONMENTALREVIEWSATTHENATIONALLEVEL!REPORTSHALLBEPREPARED
ONTHESEACTIVITIESFORTHE&IFTH3ESSION
4HE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTSWORKPROGRAMMESPANSOVERABROADRANGE
OFISSUESINCLUDINGGOODSSERVICESANDINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS )TSORIGINSANDTHETERMS
OFREFERENCECANBEFOUNDIN-ARRAKESH-INISTERIAL$ECISIONON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTOF
!PRIL
4HEMANDATEOFTHE#4%ISTWOFOLD
hTOIDENTIFYTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTRADEMEASURESANDENVIRONMENTALMEASURESIN
ORDERTOPROMOTESUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENTvAND
hTOMAKEAPPROPRIATERECOMMENDATIONSONWHETHERANYMODIFICATIONSOFTHEPROVISIONS
OFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMAREREQUIREDCOMPATIBLEWITHTHEOPENEQUITABLEANDNON
DISCRIMINATORYNATUREOFTHESYSTEMv
3EE2EPORTBYTHE#HAIRMANTOTHE4.#
4.$3
3EE74,!UGUST
3EE2EPORTBYTHE#HAIRMANTOTHE4.#
4.$3
4HETENITEMSOFTHE#4%WORKPROGRAMMEARE
LISTEDONTHE74/WEBSITE
3INCETHE$OHA-INISTERIAL3ESSIONIN.OVEMBERWORKHASSPLITINTOTWOSEPARATE
TRACKSITHENEGOTIATINGTRACK0ARAGRAPH CONDUCTEDINTHE#4%3PECIAL3ESSION
#4%33ANDIITHEREGULARWORKOFTHE#4%0ARAGRAPHSANDCONDUCTEDUNDERTHE
#4%2EGULAR
4HEFULLLISTOFDOCUMENTSTHATHAVEBEENCIRCULATEDINBOTHTHE#4%2EGULARANDTHE
#4%33SINCE*ANUARYINCLUDINGISCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT74#4%).&2EV
AVAILABLEONTHE74/WEBSITE
.EGOTIATIONS#4%33
)NTHETHE#4%33CONTINUEDTOPURSUETHETHREEDIFFERENTCOMPONENTSOFITS
MANDATE0ARAGRAPHSIIIANDIIITHATAREPRESENTEDABOVE5NDER0ARAGRAPHI
TWOAPPROACHESWEREPURSUEDINPARALLEL/NEAPPROACHWASTODISCUSSPOTENTIALOUTCOMES
FORTHENEGOTIATIONWHICHWASLEDBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES%#THROUGHDOCUMENT
4.4%7)NTHISDOCUMENTTHE%#SUGGESTEDTHATCERTAINhGOVERNANCEPRINCIPLESvBE
EXPLOREDTOGOVERNTHE74/-%!RELATIONSHIP!NOTHERAPPROACHWASTOSHARENATIONAL
EXPERIENCESINRELATIONTOTHENEGOTIATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTRADEMEASURESIN-%!S
)NTHISAPPROACHWASLEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESAND!USTRALIAWHOSHAREDTHEIRNATIONAL
EXPERIENCESWITHRESPECTTOCERTAIN-%!SINDOCUMENTS4.4%7AND!NUMBEROF
OTHER-EMBERSALSOSHAREDTHEIRNATIONALEXPERIENCESORALLYWITHTHE#OMMITTEE
5NDER0ARAGRAPHIIWHILETHEREWERENONEWSUBMISSIONSBY-EMBERSIN
-EMBERSCONTINUEDTOEXPLOREDIFFERENTAVENUESFORENHANCINGCOOPERATIONANDINFORMATION
EXCHANGEBETWEENTHE74/ANDENVIRONMENTALORGANIZATIONSANDEXAMINEDVARIOUSCRITERIA
FORTHEGRANTINGOFOBSERVERSTATUS5NDER0ARAGRAPHIIIDISCUSSIONONTHEIDENTIFICATION
OFhENVIRONMENTALGOODSvCONTINUED#HINASHAREDITSVIEWSONHOWTHESENEGOTIATIONS
COULDBETAKENFORWARDINDOCUMENT4.4%7#ANADACOMMENTEDONTHECATEGORIES
OFENVIRONMENTALGOODSTHATCOULDUSEFULLYBECONSIDEREDINTHENEGOTIATIONSINDOCUMENT
*/"AND#HINESE4AIPEISUBMITTEDITSPRELIMINARYLISTOFENVIRONMENTALGOODSIN
DOCUMENT4.4%7&URTHERMORETHE3ECRETARIATORGANIZEDA7ORKSHOPON%NVIRONMENTAL
'OODSTOASSISTINTHECLARIFICATIONOFTHECONCEPTOFANENVIRONMENTALGOOD4HE2EPORT
OFTHIS7ORKSHOPISCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT*/"ANDTHEPRESENTATIONSMADEINITS
CONTEXTAREALLAVAILABLEONLINE
0ARAGRAPHNUMBERSREFERTOTHE$OHA
-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONUNLESSOTHERWISESTATED
HTTPWWWWTOORGENGLISHTRATOP?E
ENVIR?EWKSP?GOODS?OCT?EWKSP?GOODS?
OCT?EHTM
2EGULARWORK#4%2EGULAR
)NPURSUANCEOFTHEMANDATESFROM-INISTERSIN$OHATHE#4%RESTRUCTUREDITSWORKSO
ASTOBETTERREFLECTTHEMANDATETHEREIN0ARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION
INSTRUCTSTHE#4%INPURSUINGWORKONALLITEMSONITSAGENDAWITHINITSCURRENTTERMSOF
REFERENCETOGIVEPARTICULARATTENTIONTOTHEFOLLOWINGISSUES
THEEFFECTSOFENVIRONMENTALMEASURESONMARKETACCESSESPECIALLYINRELATIONTO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINPARTICULARTHE,$#SANDTHOSESITUATIONSWHERETHEELIMINATIONOR
REDUCTIONOFTRADERESTRICTIONSANDDISTORTIONSWOULDBENEFITTRADETHEENVIRONMENTAND
DEVELOPMENT
THERELEVANTPROVISIONSOFTHEAGREEMENTON42)03AND
LABELLINGREQUIREMENTSFORENVIRONMENTALPURPOSES
$URINGTHETHREEMEETINGSHELDINEACHOFTHESEITEMSWEREDISCUSSED4HE#4%
ALSOCONTINUEDITSANALYSISOFTHEOTHERITEMSOFITSWORKPROGRAMME/N)TEMOFTHE
PROGRAMMEWITHRESPECTTOTHETRANSPARENCYOFTRADEMEASURESUSEDFORENVIRONMENTAL
PURPOSESTHE3ECRETARIATPROVIDEDADEMONSTRATIONANDEXPLANATIONONTHENEW#2.FACILITY
WHICHWOULDENABLETHESEARCHANDRETRIEVALOFENVIRONMENTRELATEDNOTIFICATIONS
-OREOVER-EMBERSDISCUSSEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGPURSUANT
TO0ARAGRAPH)NASPARTOFCONTINUEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEINTHETRADEAND
ENVIRONMENTAREATHE3ECRETARIATORGANIZEDINCOOPERATIONWITHTHE5.%05.#4!$ASWELL
ASANUMBEROF-%!STHREEREGIONALSEMINARSONTRADEANDENVIRONMENTFORGOVERNMENT
OFFICIALSFROMDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES4HESEWEREHELDIN*ORDAN6IETNAM
AND'ENEVAFOR!RABAND-IDDLE%AST!SIANAND0ACIFICASWELLAS3UB3AHARAN!FRICAN
COUNTRY-EMBERSRESPECTIVELY4HEOBJECTIVEOFTHESESEMINARSISTORAISEAWARENESSONTHE
LINKAGESBETWEENTRADEENVIRONMENTANDSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENTANDTOFURTHERENHANCE
THEDIALOGUEBETWEENTRADEANDENVIRONMENTPOLICYMAKERSIN74/-EMBERSANDACCEDING
GOVERNMENTS)SSUESOFRELEVANCETOTRADEANDENVIRONMENTANDTHERULESOFTHE74/ASWELL
ASSPECIFICCONCERNSINEACHREGIONAREADDRESSED0ARAGRAPHALSOENCOURAGESTHESHARING
OFEXPERTISEANDEXPERIENCEONNATIONALENVIRONMENTALREVIEWS!NUMBEROF-EMBERS
INFORMEDTHE#4%OFTHEIREXPERIENCEINTHISRESPECT2ELEVANTINFORMATIONWASALSOPROVIDED
BYSOMEOBSERVERS
2EGARDINGSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENT0ARAGRAPHINHAVINGHEARDINA
SERIESOFBRIEFINGSCOVERINGAREASOFNEGOTIATIONWHEREENVIRONMENTALASPECTSWEREMOST
RELEVANT!GRICULTURE2ULES3ERVICESAND-ARKET!CCESSFOR.ON!GRICULTURAL0RODUCTSTHE
#4%SOUGHTWAYSTOCARRYFORWARDITSWORK)NTHISRESPECTTHE#HAIRPERSONOFTHE#4%MET
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
WITHHERCOUNTERPARTOFTHE#4$TOEXCHANGEINFORMATIONONHOWTHEMANDATESHADBEEN
TAKENUPINTHETWORESPECTIVE#OMMITTEES-OREOVER-EMBERSDISCUSSEDAPROPOSALFOR
HOLDINGALEARNINGEVENTONSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENTWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFTHEMANDATE
UNDER0ARAGRAPH/NSUBSTANTIVEDISCUSSION.EW:EALANDIDENTIFIEDTHEDEVELOPMENTAL
ANDENVIRONMENTALASPECTSOFTHEFISHERYSUBSIDIESNEGOTIATIONS!NUMBEROF-EMBERS
CLARIFIEDTHEIRPOSITIONSINTHISRESPECT
3MALL%CONOMIESn#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
$EDICATED3ESSION
h 7EAGREETOAWORKPROGRAMMEUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTO
EXAMINEISSUESRELATINGTOTHETRADEOFSMALLECONOMIES4HEOBJECTIVEOFTHISWORKISTO
FRAMERESPONSESTOTHETRADERELATEDISSUESIDENTIFIEDFORTHEFULLERINTEGRATIONOFSMALL
VULNERABLEECONOMIESINTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDNOTTOCREATEASUBCATEGORY
OF74/-EMBERS4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILSHALLREVIEWTHEWORKPROGRAMMEANDMAKE
RECOMMENDATIONSFORACTIONTOTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEv
-EMBERSCONTINUEDTHEIR7ORK0ROGRAMMEON3MALL%CONOMIESINDURINGTWO
FORMALMEETINGS$ETAILEDREPORTSOFTHESEMEETINGSCANBEFOUNDINDOCUMENTS74#/-4$
3%-AND!TTHETH$EDICATED3ESSIONTWONEWSUBMISSIONSWEREDISCUSSED4HE
FIRSTWASAPROPOSALBYTHREELANDLOCKEDDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWHORAISEDSEVERALSPECIFIC
TRADECONCERNSANDPROPOSEDINCREASEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEFORLANDLOCKEDECONOMIESIN
THEAREAOFEXPORTDIVERSIFICATIONANDFORCOMPLYINGWITH74/RULESINTHEAREAOFSANITARY
ANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURES 4HESECONDPROPOSALWASASUBMISSIONBYSIXISLANDSTATES
WHICHFOCUSSEDONPREFERENCESANDSUBSIDIESANDWHICHSOUGHTTOFURTHERREFINESOMEOF
THEPROPOSALSCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT74#/-4$3%7 !TTHETH$EDICATED3ESSION
-EMBERSDISCUSSEDHOWTHEMANDATECONTAINEDINTHE*ULY$ECISION WOULDAFFECTTHEWORK
BEINGCARRIEDOUTINTHE$EDICATED3ESSION-ANYEXPRESSEDRENEWEDINTERESTINTHEWORK
INTHISAREAANDSEVERALCALLEDFORINFORMALCONSULTATIONSTOBEGINSOON"ARBADOSDREW
ATTENTIONTOPARAGRAPHHOFTHE$ECISIONWHICHITSAIDREAFFIRMEDTHEIMPORTANCE-EMBERS
ATTRIBUTEDTOPARAGRAPHCONCERNINGSMALLECONOMIES"ARBADOSINTERPRETEDPARAGRAPHH
ASMARKINGADEADLINEFORTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTOMAKERECOMMENDATIONSTO-INISTERSAND
THATTHE3IXTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWASNOWANEWhTIMELINEFORACHIEVINGASUBSTANTIVE
CONCRETEANDCONCLUSIVEOUTCOMETOTHE7ORK0ROGRAMMEON3MALL%CONOMIESv
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
4RADEDEBTANDFINANCE0ARAGRAPH
74#/-4$3%7
74#/-4$3%7
74,
7EAGREETOANEXAMINATIONINA7ORKING'ROUPUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILOFTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTRADEDEBTANDFINANCEANDOFANYPOSSIBLE
RECOMMENDATIONSONSTEPSTHATMIGHTBETAKENWITHINTHEMANDATEANDCOMPETENCEOF
THE74/TOENHANCETHECAPACITYOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMTOCONTRIBUTETOA
DURABLESOLUTIONTOTHEPROBLEMOFEXTERNALINDEBTEDNESSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESANDTOSTRENGTHENTHECOHERENCEOFINTERNATIONALTRADEANDFINANCIALPOLICIES
WITHAVIEWTOSAFEGUARDINGTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMFROMTHEEFFECTSOFFINANCIALAND
MONETARYINSTABILITY4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILSHALLREPORTTOTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEONPROGRESSINTHEEXAMINATION
4HE7ORKING'ROUPMETIN-AYTOTAKEUPTHEISSUEOFTRADEFINANCE0REVIOUSLYIN
*ANUARYASAFOLLOWUPTOAMEETINGSPONSOREDBYTHE)-&INTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
HADINVITEDAGROUPOFEXPERTSTOEXCHANGEIDEASONHOWTHE74/MIGHTBESTBEABLETO
CONTRIBUTETOIMPROVINGTHEACCESSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTOMOREPLENTIFULANDSECURE
SOURCESOFTRADEFINANCING-EMBERSBASEDTHEIRDISCUSSIONONTHEREPORTOFTHEMEETING
OFTHE%XPERT'ROUPNOTINGTHATTHEINTERESTOFMEMBERSHADPROVIDEDABOOSTTOREGIONAL
DEVELOPMENTBANKSANDOTHERINSTITUTIONSTOEXPANDTHEIRPROGRAMMESINTHISAREA-EMBERS
COMMENTEDONTHEDISCUSSIONINTHE%XPERT'ROUPWHICHHADREVOLVEDAROUNDTWOAREAS
OF74/WORKTHE$OHANEGOTIATIONSONSERVICESPARTICULARLYFINANCIALSERVICESANDWORK
UNDERTHECOHERENCEMANDATEPARTICULARLYVIGILANCEINKEEPINGMARKETSOPENINPERIODSOF
FINANCIALCRISESANDAVOIDINGTHEUSEOFTRADEMEASURESTHATMIGHTUNDERMINECOORDINATED
EFFORTSBYTHEINTERNATIONALFINANCIALCOMMUNITYINEXCEPTIONALCIRCUMSTANCESTOMAINTAIN
LINESOFCREDIT2EPRESENTATIVESOFTHE)-&ANDTHE7ORLD"ANKGAVEPRESENTATIONSREGARDING
THEIRWORKINTHISAREA)N*ULYTHE#HAIRMANREPORTEDTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILSUGGESTING
THATTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEIN&INANCIAL3ERVICESMIGHTWISHTOFOLLOWUPTHEISSUEOFTRADE
FINANCING
#ONTINUINGTOADDRESSTHEMESIDENTIFIEDFORFURTHEREXAMINATIONINTHE2EPORTTOTHE
&IFTH-INISTERIALTHE7ORKING'ROUPTOOKUPh4RADEAND&INANCIAL-ARKETSvATITS/CTOBER
MEETING4HE'ROUPHEARDPRESENTATIONSFROMTHE)-&ONEXCHANGERATEVOLATILITYANDTRADE
ANUPDATETOASTUDYANDFROMTHE3ECRETARY'ENERALOFTHE&INANCIAL3TABILITY&ORUM
&3&4HE)-&STUDYMORECOMPREHENSIVETHANTHEPREVIOUSONEFOUNDNOROBUSTNEGATIVE
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENVOLATILITYANDTRADEFLOWS4HEREPRESENTATIVEOFTHE&3&MADECLEAR
THATTHEADOPTIONOFINTERNATIONALSTANDARDSANDCODESHADBEENANDWOULDCONTINUETO
BEIMPORTANTTOENSUREFINANCIALSTABILITY!TITSTHIRDMEETINGIN$ECEMBERTHE7ORKING
'ROUPMETTODISCUSSTHETOPICOFh"ETTERCOHERENCEINTHEDESIGNANDIMPLEMENTATIONOF
TRADERELATEDREFORMSANDMONITORINGvWITHPRESENTATIONSBY5.#4!$ONPOLICYCOHERENCE
BETWEENTRADEANDFINANCEANDTHE7ORLD"ANKONITSWORKTOADDRESSSUPPLYSIDE
CONSTRAINTSINCLUDINGTRADEFACILITATION
4RADEANDTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGY
$URINGTHE7ORKING'ROUPON4RADEAND4RANSFEROF4ECHNOLOGY7ORKING'ROUP
HELDTHREEFORMALMEETINGS 4HEWORKUNDERTAKENBYTHE7ORKING'ROUPININCLUDED
THECONTINUATIONOFTHEANALYSISOFTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTRADEANDTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGY
ANDTHECONSIDERATIONOFANYPOSSIBLERECOMMENDATIONSONSTEPSTHATMIGHTBETAKENWITHIN
THEMANDATEOFTHE74/TOINCREASEFLOWSOFTECHNOLOGYTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
)NCONTINUINGTHEANALYSISOFTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEEN4RADEAND4RANSFEROF4ECHNOLOGY
-EMBERSACKNOWLEDGEDTHEUSEFULANALYTICALWORKDONEBYTHE7ORKING'ROUPIN
IDENTIFYINGBROADTHEMESRELATEDTOTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGY(OWEVERTHEYFELTTHATFURTHER
WORKWASNEEDEDTOELABORATEANDDEVELOPACOMMONANDSHAREDUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE
ISSUESINVOLVED!NUMBEROFISSUESCAMEUNDERDISCUSSIONAND-EMBERSHIGHLIGHTED
AMONGOTHERSTHEIMPORTANCEOFCONSIDERINGTHEDEFINITIONALISSUESOFTECHNOLOGYTRANSFER
THEVARIOUSCHANNELSOFTECHNOLOGYTRANSFERANDTHECONDITIONSUNDERWHICHTHESECOULD
BEOPERATIONALIZEDTHEROLEOFHOMECOUNTRYANDHOSTCOUNTRYMEASURESTHEENABLING
ENVIRONMENTFOREXAMPLE)02SINVESTMENTREGIMESREGULATORYSTRUCTUREGOODGOVERNANCE
INFRASTRUCTUREANDHUMANRESOURCECAPACITYBUILDING-EMBERSFELTTHATWHILEITWAS
IMPORTANTTOCONSIDERWHATCOULDBEDONEBYDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESANDBYTHEPRIVATESECTOR
INDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESWHICHINMOSTCASESWERETHEACTUALOWNERSOFTHETECHNOLOGYTO
FACILITATETECHNOLOGYTRANSFERITWASCONSIDEREDEQUALLYIMPORTANTTOEXAMINEWHATCOULDBE
DONETOIMPROVETHEENABLINGENVIRONMENTINTHERECIPIENTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTOFACILITATE
THETRANSFERANDABSORPTIONOFTECHNOLOGY
5.#4!$MADEAVAILABLETOTHE7ORKING'ROUPASTUDYON@&ACILITATING4RANSFEROF
4ECHNOLOGYTO$EVELOPING#OUNTRIES!3URVEYOF(OME#OUNTRY-EASURES4HESTUDY
SURVEYEDAGENCIESANDPROGRAMMESINDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESOFFERINGHOMECOUNTRY
MEASURESTOFACILITATETECHNOLOGYTRANSFER4HESTUDYCOMPRISINGFOURPARTSIDENTIFIED
EXISTINGHOMECOUNTRYMEASURESWHICHENCOURAGEDTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGYINVARIOUSMODES
TODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINPARTICULARTOTHELEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES,$#S4HEFIRST
PARTOFTHESTUDYCONTAINEDSEVENMAJORTYPESOFHOMECOUNTRYMEASURESTHESECONDPART
ATTEMPTEDTOANALYSETHEMEASURESHIGHLIGHTINGWHERETHESEMEASURESHADBEENMOST
PREDOMINANTANDWHERETHEREMIGHTBEGAPSWITHRESPECTTOTHETYPOLOGYTHETHIRDPART
IDENTIFIEDFURTHEREFFORTSTHATCOULDBECONSIDEREDINTHEFUTURETOFACILITATETECHNOLOGY
TRANSFERTHROUGHADDITIONALHOMECOUNTRYMEASURESWHILETHEFOURTHPARTOFTHESTUDY
HIGHLIGHTEDTHEIMPORTANCEOF3OUTH3OUTHCOOPERATIONINTHETRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGY
-EMBERSAGREEDTHATHOMECOUNTRYMEASURESCOULDCOMPLEMENTANDREINFORCETHEHOST
COUNTRYEFFORTSTOTRANSFERANDBENEFITFROMTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGY(OWEVERTHEYFELTTHAT
HOSTCOUNTRYMEASURESWEREALSOEQUALLYSIGNIFICANTIFTECHNOLOGYTRANSFERWASTOBEAWIN
WINSITUATIONFORBOTHHOMEANDHOSTCOUNTRIES4HEIMPORTANCEOF3OUTH3OUTHCOOPERATION
WASALSOUNDERLINEDINTHISCONTEXT
$URINGTHECOURSEOFTHEDISCUSSIONSONTHEPROVISIONSRELATINGTOTECHNOLOGYTRANSFERIN
THE74/!GREEMENTSANUMBEROF-EMBERSEXPRESSEDTHEVIEWTHATEXAMININGTHEEFFECT
OFTHESEPROVISIONSINCLUDINGWHETHERORNOTTHEYHADFULFILLEDTHEOBJECTIVEOFPROMOTING
TRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGYWOULDPROVIDEABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHELINKAGEBETWEENTRADE
ANDTECHNOLOGYTRANSFER(OWEVEROTHER-EMBERSFELTTHATTHE7ORKING'ROUPNEEDEDTO
BECAUTIOUSINITSPRESUMPTIONTHAT74/!GREEMENTSWERENOTFULFILLINGTHEIROBJECTIVES
-EMBERSALSOBEGANCONSIDERATIONOFTHEFIRSTTWORECOMMENDATIONSCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT
747'4447NAMELYIANEXAMINATIONOFTHEDIFFERENTPROVISIONSCONTAINEDINVARIOUS
74/!GREEMENTSRELATINGTOTECHNOLOGYTRANSFERANDIITHEPROVISIONSCONTAINEDIN
VARIOUS74/!GREEMENTSWHICHMAYHAVETHEEFFECTOFHINDERINGTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGYTO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES!TTHETH3ESSION-EMBERSADOPTEDTHE7ORKING'ROUPSREPORTTO
THE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
4ECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDCAPACITYBUILDING0ARAGRAPHS
4HEREPORTSOFTHESEMEETINGSARECONTAINED
INDOCUMENTS747'444-
747'4447
7ECONFIRMTHATTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDCAPACITYBUILDINGARECOREELEMENTS
OFTHEDEVELOPMENTDIMENSIONOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDWEWELCOMEAND
ENDORSETHE.EW3TRATEGYFOR74/4ECHNICAL#OOPERATIONFOR#APACITY"UILDING'ROWTH
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
AND)NTEGRATION7EINSTRUCTTHE3ECRETARIATINCOORDINATIONWITHOTHERRELEVANTAGENCIES
TOSUPPORTDOMESTICEFFORTSFORMAINSTREAMINGTRADEINTONATIONALPLANSFORECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENTANDSTRATEGIESFORPOVERTYREDUCTION4HEDELIVERYOF74/TECHNICALASSISTANCE
SHALLBEDESIGNEDTOASSISTDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESANDLOWINCOME
COUNTRIESINTRANSITIONTOADJUSTTO74/RULESANDDISCIPLINESIMPLEMENTOBLIGATIONSAND
EXERCISETHERIGHTSOFMEMBERSHIPINCLUDINGDRAWINGONTHEBENEFITSOFANOPENRULESBASED
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM0RIORITYSHALLALSOBEACCORDEDTOSMALLVULNERABLEANDTRANSITION
ECONOMIESASWELLASTO-EMBERSAND/BSERVERSWITHOUTREPRESENTATIONIN'ENEVA7E
REAFFIRMOURSUPPORTFORTHEVALUABLEWORKOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTREWHICHSHOULDBE
ENHANCED
7EUNDERSCORETHEURGENTNECESSITYFORTHEEFFECTIVECOORDINATEDDELIVERYOF
TECHNICALASSISTANCEWITHBILATERALDONORSINTHE/%#$$EVELOPMENT!SSISTANCE#OMMITTEE
ANDRELEVANTINTERNATIONALANDREGIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALINSTITUTIONSWITHINACOHERENT
POLICYFRAMEWORKANDTIMETABLE)NTHECOORDINATEDDELIVERYOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEWE
INSTRUCTTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCONSULTWITHTHERELEVANTAGENCIESBILATERALDONORSAND
BENEFICIARIESTOIDENTIFYWAYSOFENHANCINGANDRATIONALIZINGTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR
4RADE2ELATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCETO,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIESANDTHE*OINT)NTEGRATED
4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE0ROGRAMME*)4!0
7EAGREETHATTHEREISANEEDFORTECHNICALASSISTANCETOBENEFITFROMSECURE
ANDPREDICTABLEFUNDING7ETHEREFOREINSTRUCTTHE#OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND
!DMINISTRATIONTODEVELOPAPLANFORADOPTIONBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN$ECEMBERTHAT
WILLENSURELONGTERMFUNDINGFOR74/TECHNICALASSISTANCEATANOVERALLLEVELNOLOWERTHAN
THATOFTHECURRENTYEARANDCOMMENSURATEWITHTHEACTIVITIESOUTLINEDABOVE
7EHAVEESTABLISHEDFIRMCOMMITMENTSONTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDCAPACITY
BUILDINGINVARIOUSPARAGRAPHSINTHIS-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION7EREAFFIRMTHESESPECIFIC
COMMITMENTSCONTAINEDINPARAGRAPHSANDANDALSO
REAFFIRMTHEUNDERSTANDINGINPARAGRAPHONTHEIMPORTANTROLEOFSUSTAINABLYFINANCED
TECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGPROGRAMMES7EINSTRUCTTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
TOREPORTTOTHE&IFTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWITHANINTERIMREPORTTO
THE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN$ECEMBERONTHEIMPLEMENTATIONANDADEQUACYOFTHESE
COMMITMENTSINTHEIDENTIFIEDPARAGRAPHS
&OLLOWINGTHE&OURTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEHELDIN$OHA1ATARTHE3ECRETARIATHAS
TAKENONANUNPRECEDENTEDLEVELOFCOMMITMENTTOPROVIDETECHNICALASSISTANCEAND
CAPACITYBUILDINGTODEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESINACCORDANCEWITHTHE
MANDATECONTAINEDINTHEABOVEMENTIONEDPARAGRAPHS3EVERALSTEPSWERETAKENBYTHE
74/3ECRETARIATTOENSURETHEFULLIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEMANDATEADOPTEDBY-INISTERS
4HESESTEPSINCLUDEDTHEFORMULATIONANDAPPROVALBY-EMBERSOFANANNUAL74/4ECHNICAL
!SSISTANCE0LANTHEESTABLISHMENTOFASEPARATEFUNDhTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
'LOBAL4RUST&UNDv$$!'4&TOSECURETHENECESSARYEXTRABUDGETARYFINANCINGOFTHE0LAN
ANDTHEREORGANIZATIONOFTHE74/3ECRETARIATFOROPTIMALUSEOFAVAILABLERESOURCES
7ITHTHECREATIONOFTHE)NSTITUTEFOR4RAININGANDTECHNICALCOOPERATION-ARCHA
NEWDIMENSIONWASADDEDTO424!ANDTRADECAPACITYBUILDING!NEWFORMATANDAPPROACH
FORTHEDESIGNANDTHEPLANNINGOF424!WASINTRODUCEDINTHE4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCEAND
4RAINING0LANSFORANDWHICHWEREADOPTEDBY-EMBERSINTHE#OMMITTEEON
4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT4HISNEWAPPROACHFOUNDSTRONGOVERALLSUPPORTFROMTHEDONORS
ANDBENEFICIARIESALIKE4HELAST4!0LANCOVERINGTHEYEARWASADOPTEDIN$ECEMBER
OFANDISCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT74#/-4$72EV4HE0LANBUILDSON
EXPERIENCEGAINEDANDLESSONSLEARNEDWITHTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOF4!0LANFOR
)TINCORPORATESCONCERNSANDINTERESTSRAISEDBYDONORSANDBENEFICIARIESINTHEINFORMAL
ANDFORMALCONSULTATIONS)TALSOCONSOLIDATESTHENEWAPPROACHADOPTEDFORTHEDELIVERYOF
4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCEAND4RAININGANDREFINESSOMEOFTHEPRODUCTSANDCONCEPTS
4RADITIONALLY74/HASPROVIDEDTWOMAINTYPESOFTRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCETHE
'ENEVABASEDCOURSESTHATHAVEBEENCARRIEDOUTFORNEARLYYEARSTHESOCALLED
THREEMONTHTRADEPOLICYCOURSEISTHEBESTKNOWNOFTHESEANDREGIONALLYBASEDASWELLAS
NATIONALACTIVITIESUSUALLYOFASHORTERDURATIONANDFOCUSINGONMORESPECIFICISSUES-ORE
RECENTLYTHE3ECRETARIATEMBARKEDONASIGNIFICANTPROGRAMMEBASEDONPARTNERSHIPSWITH
ACADEMICINSTITUTIONSINTHEREGIONSTOPROVIDESIMILARCOURSESASTHE'ENEVABASED4RADE
POLICYCOURSESINTHEFIELD4HEACADEMICINSTITUTIONSTHATHAVEBEENIDENTIFIEDINVARIOUS
REGIONSPROVIDEBOTHFORTHEVENUESFORTHESOCALLEDREGIONALTRADEPOLICYCOURSESANDAS
POTENTIALDISPENSERSTHEMSELVESOFTRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCETRAININGOFTRAINERS
/THERINNOVATIONSINCLUDEGUIDANCEONNEEDSASSESSMENTINCREASEDFOCUSON,$#SOUTREACH
TONONGOVERNMENTALSECTORSESPECIALLYPARLIAMENTARIANSETRAININGANDHIGHERLEVEL
PROGRAMMEAIMEDATOFFICIALSALREADYHAVINGBEENTHROUGHTHEBASICTRAINING
!SANINTEGRALPARTOFTHE0LANTHE3ECRETARIATISCONTINUINGTOPLAYANACTIVEROLEIN
THREELARGESCALEJOINTPROGRAMMESTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES
)&THE*OINT)NTEGRATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE0ROGRAMME*)4!0OFFEREDTOSELECTED,$#S
ANDOTHER!FRICAN#OUNTRIESANDTHE3TANDARDS4RADE$EVELOPMENT&ACILITY34$&4HESE
PROGRAMMESAREAMULTICOUNTRYMULTIAGENCYCAPACITYBUILDINGPROGRAMMESIMPLEMENTED
BYTHE74/ANDOTHERPARTNERINSTITUTIONSSUCHAS5.#4!$7ORLD"ANK7ORLD#USTOMS
/RGANIZATIONANDOTHERS
4HE3ECRETARIATHASALSOCONTINUEDTOWORKCLOSELYWITHANUMBEROFBILATERALREGIONAL
AND)NTERNATIONALPARTNERSINCLUDINGOTHERORGANIZATIONSREGIONALDEVELOPMENTBANKSAND
OTHERBODIESWHOCANPROVIDERELEVANTEXPERTISEINTHEFIELD4HEMAINOBJECTIVEOFTHIS
COLLABORATIONISTOFOCUSEFFORTSAVOIDUNNECESSARYDUPLICATIONANDINCREASECOORDINATIONOF
ACTIVITIES!SARESULTTHE3ECRETARIATCONTINUEDTOCONCLUDE-/5SWHICHARENOWINEFFECT
ANDAREFULLYOPERATIONAL3EVERALOFTHESE-/5SINVOLVEACTIONSTHATGOBEYONDTHEMANDATE
ANDCOMPETENCEOFTHE74//NESUCH-/5THATCOULDBEMENTIONEDRELATESTOTHEJOINT
COOPERATIONBETWEENTHE74/AND5.)$/ADDRESSINGSUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTSINCONJUNCTION
WITHMARKETACCESSRELATEDISSUES
!TPRESENTTHE)NSTITUTESEEMSTOHAVEREACHEDITSMAXIMUMCAPACITYWITHOVER
ACTIVITIESCARRIEDOUTINWITHATOTALBUDGETALLOCATIONOFOVER#(&-ILLION
COMBININGREGULARBUDGETANDEXTRABUDGETARYFUNDINGOBTAINEDTHROUGHTHE$$!'4&
4HISISMUCHMORETHANWHATWASDONEONLYAFEWYEARSAGOIEPRIORTOTHEESTABLISHMENT
OFTHE$$!'4&7HILETHENUMBEROFACTIVITIESHASCONSISTENTLYINCREASEDINALLREGIONSIN
THEPASTSEVERALYEARSTHE!FRICANCONTINENTHASBEENTHEREGIONWHERETHELARGESTNUMBER
OFACTIVITIESHAVEBEENEXECUTEDREFLECTINGPRIORITIESSETBY-EMBERS-OREOVERPARTICULAR
ATTENTIONISGIVENTOTHENEEDSOFTHELEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESASWELLASTOSMALLAND
VULNERABLEECONOMIES
7EACKNOWLEDGETHESERIOUSNESSOFTHECONCERNSEXPRESSEDBYTHELEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIES,$#SINTHE:ANZIBAR$ECLARATIONADOPTEDBYTHEIR-INISTERSIN*ULY
7ERECOGNIZETHATTHEINTEGRATIONOFTHE,$#SINTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMREQUIRES
MEANINGFULMARKETACCESSSUPPORTFORTHEDIVERSIFICATIONOFTHEIRPRODUCTIONANDEXPORTBASE
ANDTRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDING7EAGREETHATTHEMEANINGFUL
INTEGRATIONOF,$#SINTOTHETRADINGSYSTEMANDTHEGLOBALECONOMYWILLINVOLVEEFFORTSBYALL
74/-EMBERS7ECOMMITOURSELVESTOTHEOBJECTIVEOFDUTYFREEQUOTAFREEMARKETACCESS
FORPRODUCTSORIGINATINGFROM,$#S)NTHISREGARDWEWELCOMETHESIGNIFICANTMARKETACCESS
IMPROVEMENTSBY74/-EMBERSINADVANCEOFTHE4HIRD5.#ONFERENCEON,$#S,$#)))
IN"RUSSELS-AY7EFURTHERCOMMITOURSELVESTOCONSIDERADDITIONALMEASURESFOR
PROGRESSIVEIMPROVEMENTSINMARKETACCESSFOR,$#S!CCESSIONOF,$#SREMAINSAPRIORITYFOR
THE-EMBERSHIP7EAGREETOWORKTOFACILITATEANDACCELERATENEGOTIATIONSWITHACCEDING
,$#S7EINSTRUCTTHE3ECRETARIATTOREFLECTTHEPRIORITYWEATTACHTO,$#SACCESSIONSIN
THEANNUALPLANSFORTECHNICALASSISTANCE7EREAFFIRMTHECOMMITMENTSWEUNDERTOOKAT
,$#)))ANDAGREETHATTHE74/SHOULDTAKEINTOACCOUNTINDESIGNINGITSWORKPROGRAMME
FOR,$#STHETRADERELATEDELEMENTSOFTHE"RUSSELS$ECLARATIONAND0ROGRAMMEOF!CTION
CONSISTENTWITHTHE74/SMANDATEADOPTEDAT,$#)))7EINSTRUCTTHE3UB#OMMITTEEFOR
,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIESTODESIGNSUCHAWORKPROGRAMMEANDTOREPORTONTHEAGREED
WORKPROGRAMMETOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILATITSFIRSTMEETINGIN
7EENDORSETHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR4RADE2ELATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCETO
,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES)&ASAVIABLEMODELFOR,$#STRADEDEVELOPMENT7EURGE
DEVELOPMENTPARTNERSTOSIGNIFICANTLYINCREASECONTRIBUTIONSTOTHE)&4RUST&UNDAND74/
EXTRABUDGETARYTRUSTFUNDSINFAVOUROF,$#S7EURGETHECOREAGENCIESINCOORDINATION
WITHDEVELOPMENTPARTNERSTOEXPLORETHEENHANCEMENTOFTHE)&WITHAVIEWTOADDRESSING
THESUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTSOF,$#SANDTHEEXTENSIONOFTHEMODELTOALL,$#SFOLLOWINGTHE
REVIEWOFTHE)&ANDTHEAPPRAISALOFTHEONGOING0ILOT3CHEMEINSELECTED,$#S7EREQUEST
THE$IRECTOR'ENERALFOLLOWINGCOORDINATIONWITHHEADSOFTHEOTHERAGENCIESTOPROVIDEAN
INTERIMREPORTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN$ECEMBERANDAFULLREPORTTOTHE&IFTH3ESSION
OFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEONALLISSUESAFFECTING,$#Sv
!CCESSIONS
)NTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION-EMBERSCOMMITTEDTHEMSELVESTOACCELERATINGTHE
ACCESSIONOF,$#S3IGNIFICANTPROGRESSHASSINCEBEENMADEINACCELERATINGTHEACCESSIONOF
,$#STOTHE74/7ORKINITIATEDBYTHE3UB#OMMITTEEON,$#SRESULTEDINTHEADOPTIONOF
THE'UIDELINESON,$#S!CCESSIONBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN .INE,$#S ARECURRENTLY
INDIFFERENTSTAGESOFTHEACCESSIONPROCESS)N.EPALAND#AMBODIABECAMETHEFIRST
,$#STOACCEDETOTHE74/SINCEWHILSTSEVERALACCEDING,$#S#APE6ERDE"HUTAN
,AO0EOPLES$EMOCRATIC2EPUBLICAND9EMENHELDTHEIRFIRST7ORKING0ARTY-EETINGS
4HE74/7ORK0ROGRAMMEFORTHE,$#S ADOPTEDAFTERTHE$OHA-INISTERIALATTACHES
HIGHIMPORTANCETOTHEACCESSIONOF,$#S!SPARTOFTHAT7ORK0ROGRAMMEINTHE
3UB#OMMITTEECONSIDEREDTHEITEMONACCESSIONOF,$#SATITSTHANDTH3ESSIONS
74,
!FGHANISTAN"HUTAN#APE6ERDE%THIOPIA
,AO0$23AMOA3UDAN6ANUATUAND9EMEN
74#/-4$,$#
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
,EASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES0ARAGRAPHSAND
!TTHETH3ESSIONA3ECRETARIATPAPERONTHESTATEOFPLAYOF,$#ACCESSIONS WAS
CONSIDERED4HENEEDTOCONTINUEIMPLEMENTINGTHE'UIDELINESON,$#S!CCESSION
ANDTHEIMPORTANCEOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGATALLSTAGESOFTHE
ACCESSIONPROCESSWEREEMPHASISED!TTHATMEETINGTHE3ECRETARIATWASREQUESTEDTO
PREPAREANOTEONTHETYPEOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEPROVIDEDTOACCEDING,$#S!TTHE
TH3ESSIONOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEE-EMBERSCONSIDEREDTHENOTEBYTHE3ECRETARIAT
ON4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCEFOR!CCEDING,$#S WHICHPROVIDEDANOVERVIEWOFTHETYPEOF
TECHNICALASSISTANCEREQUIREDTOASSIST,$#SINTHEIRACCESSIONPROCESS)TALSOINCLUDED
ANONEXHAUSTIVESUMMARYOFTHEASSISTANCEPROVIDEDBYTHE74/3ECRETARIATBY74/
-EMBERSASWELLASTHATOFFEREDBYOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS4HEIMPORTANCEOF
CONTINUINGTOPROVIDEASSISTANCETOTHOSE,$#STHATHADCOMPLETEDTHEACCESSIONPROCESS
BUTSTILLFACEDDIFFICULTIESFULFILLINGTHEIRCOMMITMENTSWASUNDERSCORED!TITSTH3ESSION
-EMBERSWELCOMED#AMBODIAASAFULL74/-EMBERANDASTHESECOND,$#AFTER.EPAL
TOHAVEACCEDEDTOTHE74/INBRINGINGTHETOTALNUMBEROF,$#-EMBERSTO
74/ACTIVITIES
4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!
3PECIALAND$IFFERENTIAL4REATMENTn#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND
$EVELOPMENT3PECIAL3ESSION
*OB
74#/-4$,$#7
0ARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONMANDATESALLSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIAL
TREATMENT3$PROVISIONSTOBEREVIEWEDWITHAVIEWTOSTRENGTHENINGTHEMANDMAKING
THEMhMOREPRECISEEFFECTIVEANDOPERATIONALv)NTHATCONTEXTPARAGRAPHALSO
ENDORSESTHEWORKPROGRAMMEON3$SETOUTINTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED
)SSUESAND#ONCERNS
5PTOTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWORKINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OMMITTEE
ON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTHADRESULTEDINRECOMMENDATIONSBY-EMBERSFORSPECIFIC
ACTIONON!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALS!FURTHERTHREERECOMMENDATIONSWEREADDED
AT#ANCÞNBRINGINGTHENUMBEROF!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSONWHICH-EMBERSHAD
AGREEDTOINPRINCIPLETO!FTER#ANCÞNWORKINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONGOTUNDERWAYWITH
THEELECTIONOFNEW#HAIRPERSONSANDDURINGTHREEFORMALMEETINGSANDALARGE
NUMBEROFINFORMALMEETINGSWEREHELDATWHICH-EMBERSCONSIDEREDDIFFERENTPOSSIBLE
ALTERNATIVESOFTAKINGTHEWORKON3$FORWARD$URINGTHEFIRSTOFTHESEMEETINGSTHE
#HAIRMANOFTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONPUTANUMBEROFQUESTIONSTO-EMBERSONHOWTO
STRUCTURETHEFUTUREWORKWHAT-EMBERSWISHEDTODOWITHTHEPROPOSALSTHATTHEY
HADAGREEDTOINPRINCIPLEHOWTHECURRENTDISCUSSIONSON3$COULDBEMADEMORE
PRODUCTIVEANDWHATSUGGESTIONS-EMBERSHADONTHEWAYFORWARDTOFULFILTHE$OHA
-ANDATEOFMAKING3$MOREPRECISEEFFECTIVEANDOPERATIONAL
7HILETHEDISCUSSIONSONTHESEISSUESWEREONGOINGTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILASPARTOFTHE
*ULY$ECISIONINSTRUCTEDTHEh#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTIN3PECIAL3ESSIONTO
EXPEDITIOUSLYCOMPLETETHEREVIEWOFALLTHEOUTSTANDING!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSAND
REPORTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWITHCLEARRECOMMENDATIONSFORADECISIONBY*ULYv
4HE#OUNCILALSOINSTRUCTEDTHE#OMMITTEEhTOADDRESSALLOTHEROUTSTANDINGWORK
INCLUDINGONTHECROSSCUTTINGISSUESTHEMONITORINGMECHANISMANDTHEINCORPORATION
OF3$TREATMENTINTOTHEARCHITECTUREOF74/RULESASREFERREDTOIN4.#4$AND
REPORTASAPPROPRIATETOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILv&URTHERMORETHE#OUNCILASKEDALL74/
BODIESTOWHICH#ATEGORY))PROPOSALSHADBEENREFERREDhTOEXPEDITIOUSLYCOMPLETE
THECONSIDERATIONOFTHESEPROPOSALSANDREPORTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWITHCLEAR
RECOMMENDATIONSFORADECISIONASSOONASPOSSIBLEANDNOLATERTHAN*ULYv
4HE#HAIRMANOFTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONINPURSUANCEOFTHISMANDATECONTINUEDTO
CARRYOUTCONSULTATIONSONTHEWAYFORWARD-EMBERSFELTTHATATTEMPTINGTOADDRESSTHE
REMAINING!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSASHADBEENDONEINTHEPASTWASUNLIKELYTO
RESULTINANYPROGRESS#ONSEQUENTLYITWASSUGGESTEDTHATITWOULDBEMOREPRODUCTIVE
IFTHEUNDERLYINGISSUESTHATTHEPROPOSALSWERESEEKINGTOADDRESSBEIDENTIFIEDAND
THESEPROPOSALSTHENDISCUSSEDONTHEBASISOFTHEIRCATEGORISATIONINTOTHEMATICCLUSTERS
-EMBERSALSOSUGGESTEDTHATWHILETHE#ATEGORY))PROPOSALSCOULDCONTINUETOBEDEALT
WITHINTHEDIFFERENT74/BODIESTOWHICHTHEYHADBEENREFERREDITWASIMPORTANTFOR
THE3PECIAL3ESSIONTOMAINTAINASUPERVISORYROLEOFTHEWORKBEINGCARRIEDOUTINTHOSE
BODIES
"ASEDONTHECONSULTATIONSTHE#HAIRMANSUBSEQUENTLYPUTFORWARDANINFORMAL
CONCEPTUALAPPROACHONFUTUREWORKBUILTONTHEBASICPREMISETHATFLEXIBILITYIN74/
RULESSHOULDFACILITATEDEVELOPMENTANDTHATTHESEFLEXIBILITIESSHOULDBEMADEAVAILABLE
ONASITUATIONALBASISWHILSTENSURINGTHATTHEREISNOAPRIORIEXCLUSIONOFANYDEVELOPING
COUNTRYFROMSUCHASITUATIONALFLEXIBILITY4HOUGH-EMBERSDURINGTHECONSULTATIONS
HELDINHAVEBEENCAUTIOUSLYPOSITIVEABOUTTHE#HAIRMANSAPPROACHTHEYHAVE
CONTINUEDTOSTRESSTHATFURTHERWORKMUSTBECONSISTENTWITHPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA
-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONANDPARAGRAPHOFTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED
)SSUESAND#ONCERNS-OST-EMBERSHAVEALSOSTATEDTHATGIVENTHE*ULYDEADLINEIT
ISIMPORTANTFORTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONTOQUICKLYBEGINTOADDRESSTHEREMAINING!GREEMENT
SPECIFICPROPOSALS
4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE
4HE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE4.#WASESTABLISHEDBY-INISTERSAT$OHAWITH
THESPECIFICTASKSOFESTABLISHINGAPPROPRIATENEGOTIATINGMECHANISMSASREQUIREDAND
SUPERVISINGTHEPROGRESSOFTHENEGOTIATIONS/PERATINGUNDERTHEAUTHORITYOFTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILTHE4.#METTWICEINTHEFIRSTHALFOFDISCUSSINGREPORTSBYTHE#HAIRPERSONS
OFTHEBODIESUNDERTAKINGNEGOTIATIONSINSPECIFICSUBJECTAREAS)NTHISPERIODTHE4.#THE
#HAIRPERSONSANDTHE#HAIRMANPLAYEDAKEYROLEINTHEWORKLEADINGTOTHEADOPTIONOFTHE
*ULY$ECISIONWHICHALLOWED-EMBERSTOTAKENECESSARYDECISIONSONKEYISSUESTOENSURE
CONTINUEDPROGRESSINTHENEGOTIATIONS
)N/CTOBERTHE4.#METAGAINTOESTABLISHTHE.EGOTIATING'ROUPON4RADE&ACILITATION
ANDTOAPPOINTITS#HAIRPERSONASINSTRUCTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINTHE*ULY$ECISION
!TITSLASTMEETINGOFTHEYEARIN$ECEMBERALLOFTHE#HAIRPERSONSREPORTEDONTHESTATE
OFPLAYINTHEIRRESPECTIVEAREASOFTHENEGOTIATIONSSEVERALOFTHEMUNDERLININGTHE
NEEDTOSTEPUPTHEPACEOFWORKEARLYINTHENEWYEAR4HE#HAIRMANSUGGESTEDTHATIT
WOULDBETIMELYANDAPPROPRIATETOINVITETHE4.#EARLYINTORENEWITSCOLLECTIVE
CONSIDERATIONOFTHEWAYFORWARDFORTHE2OUNDASAWHOLE(EANNOUNCEDHISINTENTIONTO
LAUNCHAPROCESSOFCOLLECTIVEREFLECTIONWHICHHEHOPEDWOULDLEADTOANEARLYCOMMON
UNDERSTANDINGONTHEOBJECTIVESFORLOOKINGTOTHE(ONG+ONG-INISTERIALANDBEYOND
74/-EMBERSHIPISOPENTOANY3TATEORCUSTOMSTERRITORYHAVINGFULLAUTONOMYIN
THECONDUCTOFITSTRADEPOLICIES!SOF$ECEMBER'OVERNMENTSWEREACTIVELY
PURSUINGACCESSIONTOTHE74/!FGHANISTAN!LGERIA!NDORRA!ZERBAIJAN"AHAMAS"ELARUS
"HUTAN"OSNIAAND(ERZEGOVINA#APE6ERDE%THIOPIA)RAQ+AZAKHSTAN,AO0$2,EBANON
,IBYA2USSIAN&EDERATION3AMOA3AUDI!RABIA3ERBIAAND-ONTENEGRO3EYCHELLES3UDAN
4AJIKISTAN4ONGA5KRAINE5ZBEKISTAN6ANUATU6IET.AM9EMEN
)NTHE74/RECEIVEDTWONEW-EMBERS.EPALAND#AMBODIA7ITHTHEIRENTRY
THETOTALMEMBERSHIPOFTHE74/NOWSTANDSATWITH-EMBERSACCOUNTINGFORMORE
THANPERCENTOFWORLDTRADE4HISREPRESENTSASIGNIFICANTADVANCEINTHEIMPORTANTTASK
OFMAKINGTHE74/ANDTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMITEMBODIESTRULYGLOBALINSCOPEAND
APPLICATION.EPALAND#AMBODIAMEMBERSHIPALSOMARKSTHEFIRSTTWO,$#STOACCEDEUNDER
THEPROCEDURESESTABLISHEDIN
74/ACTIVITIES
74/ACCESSIONNEGOTIATIONS
)) 74/ACCESSIONNEGOTIATIONS
))) 7ORKOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCIL'#ISENTRUSTEDWITHCARRYINGOUTTHEFUNCTIONSOFTHE74/AND
TAKINGACTIONSNECESSARYTOTHISEFFECTINTHEINTERVALSBETWEENMEETINGSOFTHE-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEINADDITIONTOCARRYINGOUTTHESPECIFICTASKSASSIGNEDTOITBYTHE74/
!GREEMENT7ORKOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINRELATIONTOTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAIS
COVEREDIN3ECTION))ABOVE$URINGTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEWOTHERWORKOFTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILINCLUDEDTHEFOLLOWING
!CCESSIONS
$URINGTHEPERIODCOVEREDBYTHISREPORTTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONSIDEREDAPPLICATIONS
FROMFOUR'OVERNMENTSn!FGHANISTAN)RAN)RAQAND,IBYAnFORACCESSIONTOTHE74/
!GREEMENT4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILAGREEDTOESTABLISHWORKINGPARTIESTOEXAMINETHE
APPLICATIONSFROM!FGHANISTAN)RAQAND,IBYAASTHEFIRSTSTEPINTHEIRRESPECTIVEACCESSION
PROCESSES7ITHREGARDTOTHEREQUESTFROM)RANDISCUSSIONSTHROUGHTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEW
MADECLEARTHATALTHOUGHALARGEPARTOFTHEMEMBERSHIPCONTINUEDTOBESUPPORTIVEOFAN
EARLYANDPOSITIVEACTIONONTHISREQUESTONTHEBASISOFTHEPROVISIONSIN!RTICLE8))OFTHE
74/!GREEMENTTHEREWASNOCONSENSUSATTHISTIMETOACCEPT)RANSREQUESTANDTOSETUP
AWORKINGPARTYFORTHISPURPOSE
&OLLOWING#HINASACCESSIONTOTHE74/IN$ECEMBERANDINACCORDANCEWITH
THETRANSITIONALREVIEWPROVISIONSIN#HINAS0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSIONTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN
$ECEMBERCONDUCTEDITSTHIRDREVIEWOF#HINASIMPLEMENTATIONOFITS74/COMMITMENTS
4HEFOLLOWINGISSUESWEREADDRESSEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINTHECOURSEOFTHEREVIEW
REPORTSOFSUBSIDIARY74/BODIESONTHEIRRESPECTIVEREVIEWSOF#HINASIMPLEMENTATIONOF
THE74/!GREEMENTANDOFTHERELATEDPROVISIONSOFTHE0ROTOCOLDEVELOPMENTOF#HINAS
TRADEWITH74/-EMBERSANDOTHERTRADINGPARTNERSANDRECENTDEVELOPMENTSANDCROSS
SECTORALISSUESREGARDING#HINASTRADEREGIME5NDERTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE0ROTOCOLTHIS
REVIEWISTOTAKEPLACEINEACHOFTHEEIGHTYEARSFOLLOWINGTHEFIRSTREVIEWINWITHA
FINALREVIEWINTHETENTHYEARORATANEARLIERDATEDECIDEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
74/ACTIVITIES
7ORKOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
7AIVERSUNDER!RTICLE)8OFTHE74/!GREEMENT
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONSIDEREDANDGRANTEDANUMBEROFREQUESTSFORWAIVERSFROM
OBLIGATIONSUNDERTHE74/!GREEMENTASSETOUTIN4ABLEBELOW
!LSOIN*ULYAND$ECEMBERUNDERPROVISIONSOF!RTICLE)8OFTHE74/!GREEMENTWHICH
REQUIRETHATANYWAIVERGRANTEDFORAPERIODOFMORETHANONEYEARBEREVIEWEDNOTLATER
THANONEYEARAFTERITISGRANTEDTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONDUCTEDAREVIEWOFTHEFOLLOWING
MULTIYEARWAIVERS
#ANADAn#!2)"#!.GRANTEDON/CTOBERUNTIL$ECEMBER
74,
#UBAn!RTICLE86OF'!44GRANTEDON$ECEMBERUNTIL$ECEMBER
74,
%#n!UTONOMOUS0REFERENTIAL4REATMENTTOTHE#OUNTRIESOFTHE7ESTERN"ALKANS
GRANTEDON$ECEMBERUNTIL$ECEMBER74,
%#n4HE!#0%#0ARTNERSHIP!GREEMENTGRANTEDON.OVEMBERUNTIL
$ECEMBER74,
%#n4RANSITIONAL2EGIMEFORTHE%#!UTONOMOUS4ARIFF2ATE1UOTASON)MPORTSOF
"ANANASGRANTEDON.OVEMBERUNTIL$ECEMBER74,
%L3ALVADORn!GREEMENTON)MPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLE6))OF'!44GRANTEDON
*ULYUNTIL-ARCH74,
+IMBERLEY0ROCESS#ERTIFICATION3CHEMEFOR2OUGH$IAMONDSGRANTEDON-AY
UNTIL$ECEMBER74,
,$#Sn!RTICLEOFTHE42)03!GREEMENTWITHRESPECTTOPHARMACEUTICALPRODUCTS
GRANTEDON*ULYUNTIL*ANUARY74,
0REFERENTIAL4ARIFF4REATMENTFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIESGRANTEDON*UNE
UNTIL*UNE74,
5NITED3TATESn&ORMER4RUST4ERRITORYOFTHE0ACIFIC)SLANDSGRANTEDON/CTOBER
UNTIL$ECEMBER74,
5NITED3TATESn#ARIBBEAN"ASIN%CONOMIC2ECOVERY!CTGRANTEDON.OVEMBER
UNTIL$ECEMBER74,
/THERISSUES
)N-AYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILHEARDAPRESENTATIONBYTHE!CTING-ANAGING$IRECTOROF
THE)-&ONTHE&UNDS4RADE)NTEGRATION-ECHANISMINITIATIVEWHICHAIMEDTOMITIGATETHE
CONCERNSOFSOME-EMBERSTHATIMPLEMENTATIONOF74/!GREEMENTSBYOTHERSMIGHTGIVE
RISETOTEMPORARYBALANCEOFPAYMENTSSHORTFALLS3UBSEQUENTLYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILALSO
CONSIDEREDONTHEBASISOFAREPORTBYTHE#HAIROFTHE7ORKING'ROUPON4RADE$EBTAND
&INANCETHEQUESTIONOFTRADEFINANCINGFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESDURINGPERIODSOFFINANCIAL
CRISIS
7ITHREGARDTOTHEDATEOFTHE3IXTH3ESSIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCETOBEHELDIN
(ONG+ONG#HINATHE'ENERAL#OUNCILAGREEDIN/CTOBERTHATTHE#ONFERENCEWOULDBE
HELDON$ECEMBER
!LSOIN/CTOBERTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILHELDADISCUSSIONONCOHERENCEINGLOBALECONOMIC
POLICYMAKINGANDCOOPERATIONBETWEENTHE74/)-&AND7ORLD"ANKFOCUSSINGON
STRENGTHENINGCOOPERATIONAMONGTHETHREEORGANIZATIONSPARTICULARLYINRESPECTOFTECHNICAL
ANDFINANCIALSUPPORTFORTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMMEANDITSIMPLEMENTATION4HE0RESIDENTOF
THE7ORLD"ANKANDTHE-ANAGING$IRECTOROFTHE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UNDPARTICIPATED
ATTHEMEETING
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILALSONOTEDIN/CTOBERTHATUNDER0ROCEDURESFORTHE!PPOINTMENT
OF$IRECTORS'ENERALADOPTEDIN$ECEMBERTHEPROCESSFORTHEAPPOINTMENTOFTHE
NEXT$IRECTOR'ENERALWOULDBEGINON$ECEMBERWITHAFORMALNOTIFICATIONFROMTHE
#HAIRMANTOALL-EMBERSATTHATTIMEANDALSONOTEDTHETIMELINESFORTHEAPPOINTMENT
PROCESSASSETOUTINTHE0ROCEDURESOF$ECEMBER
)NKEEPINGWITHTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL$ECISIONOF!UGUSTONTHE
)MPLEMENTATIONOF0ARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONONTHE42)03!GREEMENTAND0UBLIC
(EALTHTHE42)03#OUNCILREVIEWEDTHEFUNCTIONINGOFTHESYSTEMSETOUTINTHAT$ECISION
WITHAVIEWTOENSURINGITSEFFECTIVEOPERATIONANDREPORTEDONITSOPERATIONTOTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILIN$ECEMBER
!SPARTOFITSOVERALLOVERSIGHTFUNCTIONANDINPURSUANCEOFA$ECISIONCONCERNING
PROCEDURESFORTHEOVERVIEWOF74/ACTIVITIESANDFORREPORTINGUNDERTHE74/THE'ENERAL
#OUNCILALSOCONDUCTEDAYEARENDREVIEWOF74/ACTIVITIESONTHEBASISOFANNUALREPORTS
FROMALLSUBSIDIARYBODIESANDREVIEWEDMATTERSRELATINGTOTHEOPERATIONOFTHE74/
BUDGETASWELLASOFTHE74/PENSIONPLAN
!MONGOTHERISSUESBROUGHTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILFORCONSIDERATIONDURINGTHEPERIOD
UNDERREVIEWWEREISSUESRELATINGTO-EMBERSRIGHTSUNDERTHEPROVISONSOFTHE74/
!GREEMENTSWITHREGARDTOTHEACCESSIONTOTHE%UROPEAN5NIONOFTENNEWMEMBER3TATES
IN-AYAREPORTFROMTHE*OINT!DVISORY'ROUPOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRE
AJOINTSUBSIDIARYORGANOFTHE5.#4!$AND74/ASWELLASOTHERISSUESOFCONCERNTO
INDIVIDUAL-EMBERS
4ABLE))
7AIVERSUNDER!RTICLE)8OFTHE74/!GREEMENT
$URINGTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEWTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILGRANTEDTHEFOLLOWINGWAIVERSFROMOBLIGATIONSUNDERTHE74/!GREEMENT
7AIVERS
'RANTEDON
%XPIRYDATE
$ECISION
!RGENTINAn)NTRODUCTIONOF(ARMONIZED3YSTEMCHANGESINTO74/3CHEDULESOF4ARIFF#ONCESSIONS
/CTOBER
!PRIL
74,
)SRAELn)NTRODUCTIONOF(ARMONIZED3YSTEMCHANGESINTO74/3CHEDULESOF4ARIFF#ONCESSIONS
-AY
/CTOBER
74,
/CTOBER
/CTOBER
74,
-ALAYSIAn)NTRODUCTIONOF(ARMONIZED3YSTEMCHANGESINTO74/3CHEDULESOF4ARIFF#ONCESSIONS
-AY
!PRIL
74,
0ANAMAn)NTRODUCTIONOF(ARMONIZED3YSTEMCHANGESINTO74/3CHEDULESOF4ARIFF#ONCESSIONS
-AY
!PRIL
74,
)NTRODUCTIONOF(ARMONIZED3YSTEMCHANGESINTO74/3CHEDULESOF4ARIFF#ONCESSIONSA
&EBRUARY
$ECEMBER
74,
$ECEMBER $ECEMBER
74,
3ENEGALn-INIMUMVALUESINREGARDTOTHE!GREEMENTONTHE)MPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLE6))OF'!44 -AY
*UNE
74,
!LBANIAn)MPLEMENTATIONOFSPECIFICCOMMITMENTSINTELECOMMUNICATIONSSERVICES
$ECEMBER
74,
-AY
A
)6 4RADEINGOODS
$URINGTHEYEARTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODS#4'METSEVENTIMESINFORMAL
SESSION4HE#OUNCILCARRIEDOUT#HINAS4RANSITIONAL2EVIEWINCONNECTIONWITHPARAGRAPH
OFTHE0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSIONOF#HINAWITHRESPECTTOTHEINFORMATIONREQUIREMENTSSTIPULATED
IN!NNEX)!OFTHE0ROTOCOLTHE#OUNCILREPORTTOGETHERWITHTHEREPORTSOFITSSUBSIDIARY
BODIESWERESENTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL/N42)-STHE#OUNCILDISCUSSEDTHEREVIEWOFTHE
OPERATIONOFTHE42)-S!GREEMENTUNDER!RTICLEANDCONSIDEREDAREQUESTFOREXTENSION
OFTHETRANSITIONPERIODUNDERTHE42)-S!GREEMENT4HE#OUNCILTOOKNOTEOFTHEPERIODIC
REPORTSOFTHE#OMMITTEEON-ARKET!CCESSANDDISCUSSEDANDORAPPROVEDANUMBEROF
WAIVERREQUESTSUNDER!RTICLE)8OFTHE74/!GREEMENTINCLUDINGWAIVERREQUESTSRELATINGTO
THEINTRODUCTIONOFTHE(ARMONIZED3YSTEMANDCHANGESINTOTHE74/3CHEDULES
OFTARIFFCONCESSIONS4HE#4'ADOPTEDTHETERMSOFREFERENCEUNDERWHICHTHE#24!WOULD
EXAMINETWENTYTRADEAGREEMENTS$ETAILSOFALLWAIVERSANDTRADEAGREEMENTSCANBEFOUND
INDOCUMENT',
#ONCERNING0OST!4#!DJUSTMENT2ELATED)SSUES-EMBERSPRESENTEDTWODIFFERENT
SUBMISSIONS)NITIAL3UBMISSIONON0OST!4#!DJUSTMENTRELATED)SSUES'#72EV
AND#ONTRIBUTIONONTHE$EBATEON0OST!4#2ELATED)SSUES'#7
/NTHE%#ENLARGEMENTTHE#4'AGREEDONTHEEXTENSIONOFTHEDEADLINEASSETOUTINTHE
COMMUNICATIONFROMTHE%#',ANDREFEREDTHEMATTERTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
4HE#4'ALSOCONDUCTEDTHE4HIRDANDFINAL-AJOR2EVIEWOFTHE)MPLEMENTATIONOF
THE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING!4#PURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHATAGREEMENT
&ORTHE-AJOR2EVIEWTHE#OUNCILHADBEFOREITTHE#OMPREHENSIVE2EPORTOFTHE4EXTILES
-ONITORING"ODY',AND"ACKGROUND3TATISTICAL)NFORMATIONWITH2ESPECTTOTHE
4RADEIN4EXTILESAND#LOTHING',)NADDITIONMEMBERSOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL4EXTILES
AND#LOTHING"UREAU)4#"CIRCULATEDACOMMUNICATIONCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT'#7
4HE-AJOR2EVIEWWASCONCLUDEDATAMEETINGOFTHE#4'ON$ECEMBERWITHTHE
ADOPTIONOFTHE2EPORTCIRCULATEDINDOCUMENT',
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
&OR-EMBERSLISTEDINTHE!NNEXTOTHE$ECISIONANDFOROTHER-EMBERSACCORDINGTOPARAGRAPHBOFTHE$ECISION
2ULESOFORIGIN
4HEMAINOBJECTIVEOFTHE!GREEMENTON2ULESOF/RIGINISTOHARMONIZENONPREFERENTIAL
RULESOFORIGINANDTOENSURETHATSUCHRULESDONOTTHEMSELVESCREATEUNNECESSARY
OBSTACLESTOTRADE4HE!GREEMENTSETSOUTA(ARMONIZATION7ORK0ROGRAMME(70FOR
THEHARMONIZATIONOFNONPREFERENTIALRULESOFORIGINTOBEACCOMPLISHEDBYTHE#OMMITTEE
ON2ULESOF/RIGIN#2/INCONJUNCTIONWITHTHE7ORLD#USTOMS/RGANIZATIONS4ECHNICAL
#OMMITTEEON2ULESOF/RIGIN4#2/-UCHWORKWASDONEINTHE#2/ANDTHE4#2/
ANDSUBSTANTIALPROGRESSWASACHIEVEDINTHETHREEYEARSFORESEENINTHE!GREEMENTFOR
COMPLETIONOFTHEWORK(OWEVERDUETOTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHEISSUESTHE(70COULDNOT
BEFINALIZEDWITHINTHEFORESEENDEADLINE*ULY
4HE#2/CONTINUEDITSWORKUNDERTHEMANDATEFROMTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL'#4HEPACE
OFTHE(70BEGANTOACCELERATEANDTHE#2/RESOLVEDMORETHANOUTSTANDINGISSUESIN
ANDINASARESULTOFWHICHTHENUMBEROFUNRESOLVEDISSUESISNOWREDUCED
TO!TTHE'#MEETINGIN*ULYTHE#2/HADFORWARDEDCOREPOLICYISSUESTO
THE'#FORDISCUSSIONANDDECISION'2/!MAJORSTUMBLINGBLOCKTOTHEPROGRESSOF
THE(70WASTHESOCALLEDIMPLICATIONSISSUEIETHEIMPLICATIONSOFTHEIMPLEMENTATION
OFTHEHARMONIZEDRULESOFORIGINUPONOTHER74/!GREEMENTS-EMBERSHAVEDIFFERING
VIEWSONHOWTOINTERPRET!RTICLEAOF!GREEMENTON2ULESOF/RIGIN)N*ULYTHE'#
SET*ULYASTHENEWDEADLINEFORCOMPLETIONOFTHECOREPOLICYISSUES4HE'#ALSO
MANDATEDTHE#2/FOLLOWINGRESOLUTIONOFTHECOREPOLICYISSUESTOCOMPLETEITSREMAINING
TECHNICALWORKBY$ECEMBER4HENEGOTIATINGTEXTSARECONTAINEDINDOCUMENTS
'2/ANDITSADDENDA
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
-ARKETACCESS
4HE#OMMITTEEMETTHREETIMESIN)TCONTINUESTOMAKEPROGRESSINITSWORK
RELATINGTOTHETRANSPOSITIONOFSCHEDULESOFCONCESSIONSINTOTHE(ARMONIZED3YSTEM(3
ANDTHEINTRODUCTIONOF(3AND(3CHANGESTOSCHEDULESOFCONCESSIONS
)NCONNECTIONWITHTHESEEXERCISESSOMEWAIVERDECISIONSWEREAPPROVEDBYTHE#OMMITTEE
ANDFORWARDEDTOTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSAND'ENERAL#OUNCILFORACTION4HE
'ENERAL#OUNCILALSOAPPROVEDNEWPROCEDURESDRAWNUPBYTHE#OMMITTEERELATINGTOTHE
INTRODUCTIONOF(3CHANGESTOSCHEDULESOFCONCESSIONS74,
4HE#OMMITTEETOOKNOTEOFTHEWORKDONEBYTHE3ECRETARIATONTHE)NTEGRATED$ATA
"ASE)$"ANDTHE#ONSOLIDATED4ARIFF3CHEDULES#43DATABASEINCLUDINGTHENUMEROUS
TECHNICALASSISTANCEACTIVITIES4HE#OMMITTEEAPPROVEDTHETECHNICALANDPROCEDURAL
RECOMMENDATIONSMADEBYTHE3ECRETARIATREGARDINGTHELINKINGOFTHETWODATABASES
'-!3EVERALREQUESTSFORACCESSTOTHESETWODATABASESWERERECEIVEDAND
APPROVEDBYTHE#OMMITTEENAMELYFROMTHE5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMICAND3OCIAL
#OMMISSIONFOR!SIAANDTHE0ACIFICTHE#ARIBBEAN2EGIONAL.EGOTIATINGMACHINERYTHE
#!2)#/-3ECRETARIATTHE5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMIC#OMMISSIONFOR%UROPETHE0ACIFIC
)SLANDS&ORUM3ECRETARIATTHE!.$%!.#OMMUNITY3ECRETARIATANDTHE#OMMONWEALTH
3ECRETARIAT4HE#OMMITTEECONDUCTEDTHETHIRDREVIEWFORESEENUNDERPARAGRAPHOFTHE
0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSIONOFTHE0EOPLES2EPUBLICOF#HINA4HE#OMMITTEEALSOAGREEDTHATTHE
3ECRETARIATSHOULDPREPAREAREVISEDDOCUMENTONTHEBASISOFWHICHTHEREVIEWFORESEEN
INTHEDECISIONENTITLED$ECISIONON.OTIFICATION0ROCEDURESFOR1UANTITATIVE2ESTRICTIONS
',WOULDBEUNDERTAKEN(OWEVERSUCHADOCUMENTWASTOBEPREPAREDONCEA
COMPARABLEANDREPRESENTATIVESETOFQUANTITATIVERESTRICTIONNOTIFICATIONSWASRECEIVED
4HE#OMMITTEETOOKNOTEOFTHELATESTTARIFFINFORMATIONAVAILABLEINTHE3ECRETARIAT
)MPORTLICENSING
4HE!GREEMENTON)MPORT,ICENSING0ROCEDURESESTABLISHESDISCIPLINESONTHEUSERSOF
IMPORTLICENSINGSYSTEMSWITHTHEPRINCIPALOBJECTIVEOFENSURINGTHATTHEPROCEDURESAPPLIED
FORGRANTINGIMPORTLICENCESDONOTINTHEMSELVESRESTRICTTRADE)TCONTAINSPROVISIONS
TOENSURETHATAUTOMATICIMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURESARENOTUSEDINSUCHAMANNERAS
TORESTRICTTRADEANDTHATNONAUTOMATICIMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURESLICENSINGFORTHE
PURPOSESOFIMPLEMENTATIONOFQUANTITATIVEOROTHERRESTRICTIONSDONOTACTASADDITIONAL
RESTRICTIONSONIMPORTSOVERANDABOVETHOSEWHICHTHELICENSINGSYSTEMADMINISTERSAND
ARENOTADMINISTRATIVELYMOREBURDENSOMETHANABSOLUTELYNECESSARYTOADMINISTERTHE
RELEVANTMEASURES"YBECOMING-EMBERSOFTHE74/GOVERNMENTSCOMMITTHEMSELVES
TOSIMPLIFYINGANDBRINGINGTRANSPARENCYTOTHEIRIMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURESANDTO
ADMINISTERINGTHEMINANEUTRALANDNONDISCRIMINATORYMANNER
4HEOBLIGATIONSCONTAINEDINTHE!GREEMENTINCLUDEPUBLICATIONOFIMPORTLICENSING
PROCEDURESNOTIFICATIONTOTHE#OMMITTEEON)MPORT,ICENSINGFAIRANDEQUITABLE
APPLICATIONANDADMINISTRATIONSIMPLIFICATIONOFPROCEDURESANDPROVISIONOFFOREIGN
EXCHANGETOPAYFORLICENSEDIMPORTSONTHESAMEBASISASFORIMPORTSOFGOODSNOT
REQUIRINGIMPORTLICENCES4HE!GREEMENTESTABLISHESTIMELIMITSFORPROCESSINGOFLICENCE
APPLICATIONSPUBLICATIONOFINFORMATIONCONCERNINGLICENSINGPROCEDURESANDNOTIFICATIONTO
THE#OMMITTEE
4HE#OMMITTEEON)MPORT,ICENSINGHELDTWOMEETINGSDURINGTHISPERIODNOTEDTHATHE
LACKOFCOMPLIANCEOF-EMBERSWITHTHETRANSPARENCYOBLIGATIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTHAD
BEENTHEMAINPREOCCUPATIONOFTHE#OMMITTEEFORSOMETIMEREVIEWEDNOTIFICATIONS
SUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSUNDERVARIOUSPROVISIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTANDCARRIEDOUTITS
THIRD4RANSITIONAL2EVIEWPURSUANTTO3ECTIONOFTHE0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSIONOF#HINAAND
THETHBIENNIALREVIEWOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONANDOPERATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT
4RADEININFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYPRODUCTS)4!
4HE-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONON4RADEIN)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY0RODUCTS)4!WASAGREED
TOIN3INGAPOREINANDHASBEENACCEPTEDBY74/-EMBERSANDSTATESORSEPARATE
CUSTOMSTERRITORIES5LTIMATELYTHETARIFFSONCOMPUTERSTELECOMMUNICATIONSEQUIPMENT
SEMICONDUCTORSSEMICONDUCTORMANUFACTURINGEQUIPMENTSOFTWAREANDSCIENTIFIC
INSTRUMENTSWILLBEREDUCEDTOZEROMOSTOFTHISOCCURREDON*ANUARYAND*ANUARY
FORMOSTPARTICIPATINGCOUNTRIESWHILETHEREMAININGITEMSFORCERTAINPARTICIPANTSWILL
GRADUALLYREACHZEROWITHASLIGHTLYLONGERIMPLEMENTATIONPERIOD4HEDETAILSARECONTAINED
INEACHPARTICIPANTSSCHEDULEOFCOMMITMENTS4HE#OMMITTEEHASCONTINUEDITSWORKONTHE
NONTARIFFMEASURES.4-SWORKPROGRAMMETOIDENTIFY.4-STHATIMPACT)4TRADEANDTO
EXAMINETHEECONOMICANDDEVELOPMENTALIMPACTS)NTHISRESPECT'UIDELINESFOR
%-#%-)CONFORMITYASSESSMENTPROCEDURESWERERECENTLYAPPROVED!DDITIONALLY
THECOMMITTEEPROCEEDEDWITHITSWORKONCLASSIFICATIONDIVERGENCESREVIEWEDTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE$ECLARATIONWELCOMEDTHEPARTICIPATIONOF(UNGARYAND-ALTAAND
NOTEDTHATCONSULTATIONSCONTINUEDWITHRESPECTTO)4!))
$URINGTHE#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATIONHASHELDTWOFORMALMEETINGSON
-ARCH'6!,-AND/CTOBER'6!,-
$URINGTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEWNODEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSMAINTAINEDDELAYED
APPLICATIONOFTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTINACCORDANCEWITHTHEPROVISIONSOF!RTICLE
OFTHE!GREEMENT!TYEARENDFOUR-EMBERSMAINTAINEDRESERVATIONSGRANTEDUNDER
PARAGRAPH!NNEX)))FORMINIMUMVALUESORUNDERTHE!RTICLE)8WAIVERPROVISIONS
%L3ALVADOR'UATEMALA3ENEGALAND3RI,ANKA
)NTHEAREAOFNOTIFICATIONS-EMBERSARETOENSURETHATTHEIRLAWSREGULATIONSAND
ADMINISTRATIVEPROCEDURESCONFORMWITHTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTANDAREREQUIRED
TOINFORMTHE#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATIONOFANYCHANGESINTHISREGARD3UCH
NOTIFICATIONSARESUBJECTTOEXAMINATIONINTHE#OMMITTEE!TYEAREND-EMBERSHAVE
NOTIFIEDTHEIRNATIONALLEGISLATIONONCUSTOMSVALUATIONTHISFIGUREINCLUDESTHE-EMBERS
WHICHHAVESUBMITTEDCOMMUNICATIONSINDICATINGTHATTHEIRLEGISLATIONNOTIFIEDUNDER
THE4OKYO2OUND#USTOMS6ALUATION!GREEMENTREMAINEDVALIDUNDERTHE74/#USTOMS
6ALUATION!GREEMENTANDDOESNOTINCLUDEINDIVIDUAL%%#-EMBERS&IFTYFIVE-EMBERS
HAVENOTYETMADEANYNOTIFICATION
!TITSMEETINGOF/CTOBERTHE#OMMITTEEADOPTEDITSREPORTTOTHE#OUNCIL
FOR4RADEIN'OODS!DOPTIONOFTHEFOURTHFIFTHSIXTHSEVENTHEIGHTHANDNINTHANNUAL
REVIEWSREMAINSBLOCKEDBYANUNRESOLVEDISSUECONCERNINGONE-EMBERSINTERPRETATIONOF
PARAGRAPH!NNEX)))OFTHE!GREEMENT!TTHISMEETINGTHE#OMMITTEEALSOCOMPLETED
#HINAS4RANSITIONAL2EVIEWINACCORDANCEWITH3ECTIONOFTHE0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSIONOF
#HINA)TSUBMITTEDITSREPORTONTHIS2EVIEWTOTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSIN'6!,
AND#ORR!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENTESTABLISHEDA74/4ECHNICAL#OMMITTEEUNDER
THEAUSPICESOFTHE7ORLD#USTOMS/RGANIZATION7#/TOPROMOTEATTHETECHNICALLEVEL
UNIFORMITYOFINTERPRETATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT4HE4ECHNICAL#OMMITTEE
PRESENTEDREPORTSONITSTH ANDTH3ESSIONSDURINGTHEYEAR
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
#USTOMSVALUATION
4EXTILESANDCLOTHING
4HE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING!4#ENTEREDINTOFORCEON*ANUARY
)TWASATENYEARTRANSITIONALAGREEMENTWITHAPROGRAMMETOGRADUALLYINTEGRATETHETEXTILE
ANDCLOTHINGSECTORFULLYINTO'!44RULESANDDISCIPLINESBYTHEENDOF5NDER
THE!4#WHENPRODUCTSWEREINTEGRATEDTHEYWEREREMOVEDFROMTHE!GREEMENTAND
NORMAL'!44RULESHENCEFORTHAPPLIEDTOTHEIRTRADE&URTHERMOREIFTHEINTEGRATEDPRODUCTS
WERESUBJECTTOBILATERALQUOTASCARRIEDOVERFROMTHEFORMER-ULTIFIBRE!RRANGEMENTTHESE
QUOTASHADTOBEREMOVED4HEINTEGRATIONWASTOBEACHIEVEDTHROUGHTHREESTAGESINTHE
FIRSTSTAGEPRODUCTSACCOUNTINGFORATLEASTOFTHETOTALVOLUMEOFEACH
COUNTRYSIMPORTSINAFURTHERINTHESECONDSTAGEINTHETHIRD
STAGEON*ANUARYAMINIMUMOFOFPRODUCTSWEREINTEGRATED4OTALPRODUCT
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
INTEGRATIONWASINATLEASTOFTHE-EMBERSTOTALIMPORTSIN)TWAS
ESTIMATEDTHATABOUTOFIMPORTSUNDERSPECIFICQUOTARESTRICTIONSHADBEENLIBERALIZED
BYTHEMAINIMPORTING-EMBERSATTHEBEGINNINGOFTHETHIRDSTAGE4HEPROCESSWAS
COMPLETEDON$ECEMBERWITHTHEINTEGRATIONOFALLREMAININGPRODUCTSANDTHEFULL
REMOVALOFTHEQUOTAREGIME
4HEMAJORREVIEWOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!4#DURINGTHETHIRDANDFINALSTAGEOFTHE
INTEGRATIONPROCESSWASUNDERTAKENBYTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSINTHEFALLOFON
THEBASISOFACOMPREHENSIVEREPORTCIRCULATEDIN*ULYBYTHE4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODY
4HEREVIEWWASCOMPLETEDBYTHE#4'IN$ECEMBERDOCUMENT',
4HEPROSPECTSRELATEDTOTHETERMINATIONOFTHE!4#ON$ECEMBERANDTHE
POSSIBLEIMPACTOFAQUOTAFREEENVIRONMENTONTRADEANDPRODUCTIONPATTERNSOFTEXTILES
ANDCLOTHINGAROUNDTHEWORLDINWERETWOFACTORSTHATINFLUENCEDCONSIDERABLYTHE
WORKOFTHE74/INTHISAREAIN)NTHISCONTEXTTHECHALLENGESANDOPPORTUNITIESOF
ADJUSTMENTFACINGBOTHDEVELOPINGEXPORTING-EMBERSASWELLASDEVELOPEDIMPORTING
-EMBERSWERETHEFOCUSOF74/TECHNICALCOOPERATIONACTIVITIESRELATEDTOTHE!4#
3OME-EMBERSEXPRESSEDINMIDCONCERNABOUTTHEADJUSTMENTCHALLENGESWHICH
WEREPRESENTEDBYTHEINCOMINGELIMINATIONON*ANUARYOFALLTHEQUANTITATIVE
RESTRICTIONSHITHERTOMAINTAINEDPURSUANTTOTHE!4#!TTHEIRREQUESTANITEMONh0OST!4#
ADJUSTMENTRELATEDISSUESvWASINTRODUCEDONTHEAGENDAOFTHE#4'IN/CTOBER0ROPOSALS
WEREMADEDOCUMENTS'#72EVAND'#7WHICHDESPITEUNDERSTANDING
FORTHEISSUESDIDNOTENJOYCONSENSUS4HECONSIDERATIONOFTHESEISSUESHADNOTYETBEEN
COMPLETEDATTHEENDOF!LSOSEVERAL,EAST$EVELOPED-EMBERSRAISEDIN/CTOBER
ASIMILARISSUEINTHECONTEXTOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEEON,$#S!SUBMISSIONON-ARKET
!CCESSFOR,$#SINTHE4EXTILESAND#LOTHING3ECTORAFTERTHE%XPIRYOF!4#WASMADE
DOCUMENT74#/-4$,$#7ANDDISCUSSED)NVIEWOFTHEDIVERGENCESOFOPINIONON
THEMATTERCONSIDERATIONOFTHEISSUEWASNOTCOMPLETEDIN
4HE4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODY4-"
4HE4-"HADTHETASKOFSUPERVISINGTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!4#ANDEXAMINING
ALLMEASURESTAKENUNDERTHIS!GREEMENTANDTHEIRCONFORMITYWITHIT)TCONSISTEDOFA
#HAIRMANANDTENMEMBERSWHOACTEDINTHEIRPERSONALCAPACITY)TWASASTANDINGBODYAND
METASNECESSARYTOCARRYOUTITSFUNCTIONSRELYINGMAINLYONNOTIFICATIONSANDINFORMATION
SUPPLIEDBY-EMBERSUNDERTHERELEVANTPROVISIONSOFTHE!4#
4HECOMPOSITIONOFTHE4-"SMEMBERSHIPFORTHETHIRDSTAGEOFTHEINTEGRATIONPROCESS
UNDERTHE!4#WASDECIDEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN$ECEMBER
4HEDECISIONINCLUDEDTHEALLOCATIONOFTHETENSEATSTO74/-EMBERSORTOGROUPINGSOF
-EMBERSIECONSTITUENCIESWHICHINTURNAPPOINTEDANINDIVIDUALTOBETHE4-"MEMBER
ACTINGONANADPERSONAMBASIS4HE4-"MEMBERSCOULDAPPOINTTHEIRALTERNATES!LTERNATES
WERESELECTEDFROMWITHINTHECONSTITUENCYOFTHEMEMBER-OSTOFTHECONSTITUENCIES
OPERATEDONTHEBASISOFROTATION
!TTHEBEGINNINGOFTHEFOLLOWING74/-EMBERSAPPOINTEDINDIVIDUALSTOSERVE
ASMEMBERORALTERNATEINTHE4-""RAZIL'UATEMALA0ERU#ANADA.ORWAY#HINA
0AKISTAN-ACAO#HINA%GYPT)NDIATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES(ONG+ONG#HINA
+OREA"ANGLADESH)NDONESIA4HAILAND*APAN3WITZERLAND"ULGARIA4URKEYANDTHE
5NITED3TATES
4HE4-"TOOKALLOFITSDECISIONSBYCONSENSUS(OWEVERCONSENSUSWITHINTHE4-"DID
NOTREQUIRETHEASSENTORTHECONCURRENCEOFTHOSEMEMBERSAPPOINTEDBY74/-EMBERS
WHICHWEREINVOLVEDINANUNRESOLVEDISSUEUNDERREVIEWBYTHE4-"4HE4-"ALSOHADITS
OWNDETAILEDWORKINGPROCEDURES
)NTHE4-"HELDTWELVEFORMALSESSIONS4HEDETAILEDREPORTSOFTHESEMEETINGSARE
CONTAINEDINDOCUMENTS'4-"2TO4HE4-"PREPAREDCONSIDEREDANDADOPTEDA
COMPREHENSIVEREPORTTOTHE#4'ONTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!4#DURINGTHETHIRDSTAGEOF
THEINTEGRATIONPROCESSDOCUMENT',)NADDITIONTHE4-"ADOPTEDANANNUALREPORT
TOTHE#4'COVERINGTHEPERIOD/CTOBERTO/CTOBERALSOPROVIDINGAN
OVERVIEWOFTHEISSUESHANDLEDBYTHE4-"DURINGTHATTIME',
4HE4-"EXAMINEDANUMBEROFNOTIFICATIONSANDCOMMUNICATIONSRECEIVEDFROM74/
-EMBERSINRESPECTOFACTIONSTAKENUNDERTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE!4#INCLUDINGINTEGRATION
PROGRAMMESANDANUMBEROFISSUESINRESPECTOFOTHEROBLIGATIONSUNDERTHE!4#
-ORESPECIFICALLYTHE4-"INTERALIAEXAMINEDTHEPROGRAMMESOFTHEFOURTHSTAGE
OFTHEINTEGRATIONPROCESSOF"RAZIL#ANADA#HINA#HINESE4AIPEI#OLOMBIA#OSTA2ICA
%L3ALVADORTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES)NDIA*APAN+OREA.ORWAY2OMANIA3RI,ANKA
3WITZERLAND4URKEYANDTHE5NITED3TATES)NESSENCEWITHSLIGHTLYDIFFERENTFORMULATIONS
EACHOFTHESENOTIFICATIONSINDICATEDTHATON*ANUARYTHENOTIFYING-EMBERSWILL
INTEGRATEINTO'!44ALLTEXTILEANDCLOTHINGPRODUCTSTOWHICHTHE!4#APPLIESTHAT
WERENOTINCLUDEDINTHERESPECTIVE-EMBERSFIRSTSECONDANDTHIRDSTAGEINTEGRATION
PROGRAMMES4HE4-"INTERALIANOTEDTHATEACHOFTHE-EMBERSCONCERNEDCONFIRMED
!GRICULTURE
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
THATONTHEFIRSTDAYOFTHESTMONTHTHATTHE74/!GREEMENTWOULDBEINEFFECTTHEIR
RESPECTIVETEXTILESANDCLOTHINGSECTORWOULDBEINTEGRATEDINTO'!44)TALSONOTED
FURTHERMORETHATINTHEIRRESPECTIVENOTIFICATIONS#ANADATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
4URKEYANDTHE5NITED3TATESHADSTATEDSPECIFICALLYTHATON*ANUARYALLREMAINING
RESTRICTIONSUNDERTHE!4#WOULDBEELIMINATED4HE4-"NOTEDTHATONLYTHREENOTIFICATIONS
CONTAINEDADETAILEDLISTOFTHEPRODUCTSTOBEINTEGRATEDINTHEFINALSTAGEANDOBSERVED
THATINORDERTOINJECTTHENECESSARYTRANSPARENCYINTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!4#IT
WOULDBEUSEFULIFTHE-EMBERSCONCERNEDCOULDPROVIDEADETAILEDLISTOFTHEPRODUCTSTOBE
INTEGRATEDON*ANUARY
4HE4-"CONTINUEDITSEXAMINATIONSTARTEDINOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE
GROWTHONGROWTHPROVISIONSFORESEENIN!RTICLEOFTHE!4#ASREGARDSTHE&ORMER
9UGOSLAV2EPUBLICOF-ACEDONIA&92/-ALSOWITHREFERENCETOTHELEGALINSTRUMENTS
OFACCESSIONOF&92/-TOTHE74/)NTHE4-"HADINVITEDTHE5NITED3TATESTO
RECONSIDERITSPOSITIONANDTOIMPLEMENTTHEFULLPERCENTINCREASEINTHERESPECTIVE
GROWTHRATESAPPLICABLETO3TAGEALSOFORTHEYEAR(AVINGCONSIDEREDTHERESPONSE
PROVIDEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESTHE4-"INTERALIAEXPRESSEDITSCONCERNTHATTHE5NITED
3TATESHADNOTIMPLEMENTEDFORTHEYEARTHEFULLPERCENTINCREASEINTHERESPECTIVE
GROWTHRATESAPPLICABLETO3TAGE
4HE4-"CONSIDEREDACOMMUNICATIONRECEIVEDFROMANUMBEROFITSMEMBERSREQUESTING
THATITREVIEWPURSUANTTO!RTICLETHEh;I=NTRODUCTIONBYTHE%UROPEAN5NIONOFQUOTA
RESTRICTIONSINTHEMARKETSOFTENNEWLYACCEDINGSTATES-EMBERSOFTHE74/v(AVING
EXAMINEDINTERALIAARESPONSEBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESTOTHE"ODYSREQUESTTO
PROVIDEANYRELATEDNOTIFICATIONANDASAPPROPRIATEINFORMATIONINRESPECTOFTHERESTRICTIONS
INTRODUCEDBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESON-AYTHE4-"FOUNDTHATTHEACTIONBY
THE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESCOULDNOTFINDJUSTIFICATIONUNDERTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE!4#
4HE4-"REVIEWEDANOTIFICATIONBYTHE5NITED3TATESFOLLOWINGTHEACCESSIONOF
#AMBODIATOTHE74/OFTHEQUANTITATIVERESTRICTIONSITMAINTAINEDONIMPORTSFROM
#AMBODIAOFTHEPRODUCTSCOVEREDBYTHE!4#ONTHEDAYPRIORTOTHEDATEOFACCESSIONOF
#AMBODIATOTHE74/)NTAKINGNOTEOFTHENOTIFICATIONTHE4-"EXPRESSEDITSCONCERN
THATTHE5NITED3TATESHADNOTIMPLEMENTEDTHEFULLPERCENTINCREASEFORTHEYEAR
INTHERESPECTIVEGROWTHRATESAPPLICABLETOIMPORTSOFPRODUCTSSUBJECTTOQUANTITATIVE
RESTRICTIONSFROM#AMBODIA4HE4-"REITERATEDALSOTHATITSREVIEWANDTAKINGNOTEOFTHE
53NOTIFICATIONWASWITHOUTPREJUDICETOTHERIGHTSOF#AMBODIAUNDERTHE!4#INCLUDINGTHE
PROVISIONSOF!RTICLE
4HE#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTUREREGULARMEETINGSCONTINUEDITSSYSTEMATICREVIEWOFTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOF74/COMMITMENTSRESULTINGFROMTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDORACCESSIONTOTHE
74/4HISREVIEWISUNDERTAKENONTHEBASISOFNOTIFICATIONSSUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSINTHE
AREASOFTARIFFQUOTAADMINISTRATIONANDUTILISATIONSPECIALSAFEGUARDSDOMESTICSUPPORTAND
EXPORTSUBSIDIESASWELLASEXPORTPROHIBITIONSANDRESTRICTIONS
)NTHECOURSEOFTHEFOURMEETINGSHELDINANUMBEROFMATTERSRELATINGTOTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFCOMMITMENTSWERERAISEDBY-EMBERSUNDERTHEPROVISIONSOF!RTICLE
OFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURESEEREPORTOFTHEMEETINGS'!'2TO
/NEOFTHESEIMPLEMENTATIONISSUESCONCERNEDCERTAINFOODAIDOPERATIONSOFTHE5NITED
3TATES3EVERAL-EMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERNTHATSKIMMILKPOWDERPROVIDEDASFOODAIDFOR
SALEONTHEMARKETOFTHERECIPIENTCOUNTRYMONETIZATIONHADTHEEFFECTOFDISPLACING
COMMERCIALIMPORTS)NADDITIONANUMBEROF-EMBERSRAISEDMARKETACCESSPROBLEMSFOR
AVARIETYOFPRODUCTSENTERING#OLOMBIATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES-OLDOVA0ANAMA
4URKEYAND6ENEZUELA4HEYREQUESTEDTHATTHEDIFFICULTIESTHATEXPORTERSWEREFACINGINTHE
AREASOFTARIFFQUOTAADMINISTRATIONIMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURESORTARIFFSAPPLIEDBYTHE
IMPORTING-EMBERSBEADDRESSED$URINGTHE#OMMITTEESTHIRDREVIEWOF#HINASACCESSION
COMMITMENTSUNDERTHE4RANSITIONAL2EVIEW-ECHANISMSEVERAL-EMBERSRAISEDISSUES
REGARDING#HINASIMPLEMENTATIONOFTARIFFQUOTACOMMITMENTS
)NORDERTOASSIST-EMBERSINIMPLEMENTINGTHEIREXISTINGCOMMITMENTSANDINFULLY
PARTICIPATINGINTHEONGOINGNEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTURETHE!GRICULTUREAND#OMMODITIES
$IVISIONCARRIEDOUTNUMEROUSTECHNICALCOOPERATIONACTIVITIESDURINGBOTHATANDFROM
HEADQUARTERSANDTHROUGHMISSIONSTOANUMBEROFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
3ANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURES
4HE!GREEMENTONTHE!PPLICATIONOF3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESTHE303
!GREEMENTESTABLISHESTHERIGHTSANDOBLIGATIONSOF-EMBERSREGARDINGMEASURESTAKEN
TOENSUREFOODSAFETYTOPROTECTHUMANHEALTHFROMPLANTORANIMALSPREADDISEASESOR
TOPROTECTPLANTANDANIMALHEALTHFROMPESTSANDDISEASES'OVERNMENTSMUSTENSURETHAT
THEIR303MEASURESAREBASEDUPONSCIENTIFICPRINCIPLES-EASURESWHICHAREBASEDUPON
INTERNATIONALSTANDARDSAREPRESUMEDTOBECONSISTENTWITHTHEOBLIGATIONTOBESCIENTIFICALLY
JUSTIFIED7HENGOVERNMENTSIMPLEMENTMEASURESTHATAREMORESTRICTTHANINTERNATIONAL
STANDARDSTHESEMEASURESMUSTBEBASEDUPONARISKASSESSMENT'OVERNMENTSAREOBLIGED
TOPROVIDEADVANCENOTICEWHENPROPOSEDNEWORMODIFIEDREGULATIONSDIFFERFROMRELEVANT
INTERNATIONALSTANDARDS
4HE303#OMMITTEEMEETSATLEASTTHREETIMESAYEAR)NTHE#OMMITTEECONSIDERED
SPECIFICTRADECONCERNSRAISEDBY-EMBERSONAWIDERANGEOFISSUESINCLUDINGMEASURES
TAKENINRESPONSETOFOOTANDMOUTHDISEASEAND"3%MEASURESRELATINGTOPOULTRYDISEASES
INCLUDINGAVIANINFLUENZAMEASURESDEFININGMAXIMUMRESIDUETESTINGREQUIREMENTSAND
MEASURESAFFECTINGTRADEINMEATFISHANDFRESHFRUIT 4HE#OMMITTEEALSOCONSIDEREDTHE
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESRULESONTRACEABILITYANDLABELLINGOFGENETICALLYMODIFIEDORGANISMS
ANDONFOODANDFEEDASWELLASIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEINTERNATIONALPHYTOSANITARYSTANDARD
ONWOODPACKAGINGMATERIAL
4HE303#OMMITTEEINITIATEDITS3ECOND2EVIEWOFTHE!GREEMENTATITS*UNE
MEETING4HEREPORTOFTHENEXTREVIEWWILLBEPREPAREDFORTHE3IXTH3ESSIONOFTHE
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN$ECEMBER4HE3ECRETARIATHASPRODUCEDABACKGROUND
DOCUMENTWHICHPROVIDESDETAILSOF#OMMITTEEACTIVITIESSINCETHEFIRSTREVIEWINAS
WELLASADDITIONALINFORMATIONWHICH-EMBERSHAVEREQUESTEDBEINCLUDEDDURINGTHECOURSE
OFTHE3ECOND2EVIEW !SOF$ECEMBERNOTIFICATIONSHAVEBEENCIRCULATEDNOTINCLUDING
CORRIGENDAADDENDAANDREVISIONS4HENUMBEROFNOTIFICATIONSINWASPER
CENTHIGHERTHANTHENUMBEROFNOTIFICATIONSIN/NEHUNDREDTHIRTYSIX-EMBERS
PERCENTHADNOTIFIEDANENQUIRYPOINTANDPERCENTHADIDENTIFIEDTHEIR
NATIONALNOTIFICATIONAUTHORITY )N-ARCHTHE3ECRETARIATESTABLISHEDAMECHANISMTO
CIRCULATEINFORMATIONONTHEAVAILABILITYOFUNOFFICIALTRANSLATIONSOFDRAFTREGULATIONSNOTIFIED
BY-EMBERS 74/STECHNICALASSISTANCEACTIVITIESINTHE303AREACONTRIBUTETOWARDSTHESTRENGTHENING
OFTHECAPACITIESOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINMEETINGSTANDARDSFORMARKETACCESSOFFOODAND
OTHERAGRICULTURALCOMMODITIES)NTHE74/3ECRETARIATORGANIZEDSIXNATIONALSEMINARS
ANDSEVENREGIONALWORKSHOPS4HEPROGRAMMESOFTHESEACTIVITIESINCLUDEPRESENTATIONS
ONTHETRANSPARENCYOBLIGATIONSDISPUTESETTLEMENTIMPLEMENTATIONPROBLEMSSPECIFIC
TRADECONCERNSANDTECHNICALSCIENTIFICISSUESSUCHASRISKANALYSISANDEQUIVALENCEASWELL
ASTHEWORKUNDERTAKENBYTHETHREESTANDARDSETTINGORGANIZATIONSREFERENCEDINTHE303
!GREEMENT#ODEX/)%AND)00#
4ODATE0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSHAVEBEENISSUEDFORFOUR303RELATEDISSUES
%#(ORMONES!USTRALIA3ALMON„*APAN6ARIETALSAND*APAN&IRE"LIGHT 4WO0ANELSINITIATED
DELIBERATIONSDURING4HEFIRST0ANELISCONSIDERINGTHE5NITED3TATES#ANADAAND
!RGENTINASCOMPLAINTAGAINSTTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREGARDINGMEASURESAFFECTINGTHE
APPROVALANDMARKETINGOFBIOTECHPRODUCTS4HESECOND0ANELWASESTABLISHEDTOREVIEWTHE
EXISTENCEORCONSISTENCYWITHTHECOVERED!GREEMENTSOF*APANSMEASURESTAKENTOCOMPLYWITH
RECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODYIN*APANn !PPLES)NADDITION
A0ANELTOCONSIDERCOMPLAINTSBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESANDTHE0HILIPPINESREGARDING
!USTRALIASQUARANTINEPROCEDURESWASESTABLISHEDINBUTNEVERFORMALLYCOMPOSED
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
3AFEGUARDS
'3032'3032ANDCORRIGENDUM'
3032ANDCORRIGENDAAND'303'%.
2EV
'303'%.2EV
'303'%.2EV
'303'%.
74$3AND74$374$374$3
AND74$3
#OUNTING%#ANDALLTHEMEMBER3TATES
ASONE4HEREARECURRENTLY74/-EMBERS
ONTHISBASIS
74/-EMBERSMAYTAKEhSAFEGUARDvACTIONSWITHRESPECTTOAPRODUCTIFINCREASED
IMPORTSOFTHATPRODUCTARECAUSINGORTHREATENTOCAUSESERIOUSINJURYTOTHEDOMESTIC
INDUSTRYTHATPRODUCESLIKEORDIRECTLYCOMPETITIVEPRODUCTS0RIORTOTHE5RUGUAY2OUND
SAFEGUARDMEASURESCOULDBEAPPLIEDONTHEBASISOF!RTICLE8)8OF'!444HE74/
!GREEMENTON3AFEGUARDSESTABLISHESADDITIONALSUBSTANTIVEANDPROCEDURALREQUIREMENTS
FORAPPLYINGNEWSAFEGUARDMEASURES)TALSOSTIPULATESTHAT-EMBERSSHALLNOTSEEKTAKEOR
MAINTAINANYVOLUNTARYEXPORTRESTRAINTSORDERLYMARKETINGARRANGEMENTSORANYOTHERSIMILAR
MEASURESWHICHAFFORDPROTECTION
$URINGTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEWTHE#OMMITTEEON3AFEGUARDSHELDTWOREGULARMEETINGS
IN!PRILAND/CTOBER
.OTIFICATIONANDEXAMINATIONOFSAFEGUARDSLAWSANDORREGULATIONSOF-EMBERS
4HE#OMMITTEECONTINUEDITSREVIEWOFNOTIFICATIONSUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENT
CONCERNINGNATIONALLEGISLATIONANDORREGULATIONSINTHEAREAOFSAFEGUARDS&OR-EMBERS
WITHSUCHLEGISLATIONANDORREGULATIONSTHESENOTIFICATIONSCONSISTOFTHEFULLANDINTEGRATED
TEXTTHEREOF&OR-EMBERSWITHOUTSUCHLEGISLATIONANDORREGULATIONSTHESENOTIFICATIONS
INFORMTHE#OMMITTEEOFTHISFACT
!SOF$ECEMBER-EMBERS HADNOTIFIEDTHE#OMMITTEEOFTHEIRDOMESTIC
SAFEGUARDSLEGISLATIONANDORREGULATIONSORMADECOMMUNICATIONSINTHISREGARDTOTHE
#OMMITTEE'3'.DOCUMENTSERIES4HIRTYTWO-EMBERSHADNOTASOFTHATDATEMADE
SUCHANOTIFICATION4HEEXTENTOFTHENONCOMPLIANCEWITHTHISNOTIFICATIONOBLIGATIONAND
THEIMPLICATIONSOFTHISSITUATIONWEREDISCUSSEDATTHEREGULARMEETINGSOFTHE#OMMITTEE
HELDDURINGTHEREVIEWPERIOD
.OTIFICATIONSOFACTIONSRELATEDTOSAFEGUARDMEASURES$URINGTHE#OMMITTEE
RECEIVEDANDREVIEWEDAVARIETYOFNOTIFICATIONSOFACTIONSRELATEDTOSAFEGUARDMEASURES
4HE#OMMITTEEREVIEWEDNOTIFICATIONSREGARDINGINITIATIONOFNEWINVESTIGATIONTHREE
NOTIFICATIONSOFAPPLICATIONOFPROVISIONALMEASURESSIXNOTIFICATIONSCONCERNINGFINDINGOF
SERIOUSINJURYORTHREATTHEREOFCAUSEDBYINCREASEDIMPORTSFOURNOTIFICATIONSOFTERMINATION
OFSAFEGUARDINVESTIGATIONWITHNOSAFEGUARDMEASUREIMPOSEDNINENOTIFICATIONS CONCERNINGDECISIONTOAPPLYSAFEGUARDMEASUREANDFOURNOTIFICATIONSCONCERNINGTHENON
APPLICATIONOFSAFEGUARDMEASURETODEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERS
3UBSIDIESANDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURES
4HE!GREEMENTON3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING-EASURESTHEh3#-!GREEMENTv
REGULATESTHEPROVISIONOFSUBSIDIESANDTHEIMPOSITIONOFCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESBY
-EMBERS4HE!GREEMENTAPPLIESTOSUBSIDIESTHATARESPECIFICTOANENTERPRISEORINDUSTRY
ORGROUPOFENTERPRISESORINDUSTRIESWITHINTHETERRITORYOFA-EMBER3PECIFICSUBSIDIES
AREDIVIDEDINTOTWOCATEGORIESPROHIBITEDSUBSIDIESUNDER0ART))OFTHE!GREEMENTAND
ACTIONABLESUBSIDIESUNDER0ART)))OFTHE!GREEMENT 0ART6OFTHE!GREEMENTGOVERNSTHE
CONDUCTOFCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYINVESTIGATIONSANDTHEAPPLICATIONOFCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURES
BY-EMBERS0ARTS6)))AND)8OFTHE!GREEMENTPROVIDESPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENT
RESPECTIVELYFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSANDFOR-EMBERSINTRANSFORMATIONTOAMARKET
ECONOMY
!RTICLEEXTENSIONS $EVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSSUBJECTTOTHEEIGHTYEAR
TRANSITIONPERIODIN!RTICLEBOFTHE3#-!GREEMENTFORTHEELIMINATIONOFEXPORT
SUBSIDIESHADTHEPOSSIBILITYNOTLATERTHAN$ECEMBERTOSEEKEXTENSIONOFTHIS
TRANSITIONPERIOD)NTHE#OMMITTEEAPPROVEDREQUESTSFOREXTENSIONFORCALENDAR
YEAROFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSINRESPECTOFSPECIFICPROGRAMMESPURSUANT
TO!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENT -OSTOFTHESEIEPROGRAMMESOF-EMBERSWERE
REQUESTSBASEDONTHEPROCEDURESCONTAINEDIN'3#-WHICHHADBEENAPPROVEDBY
-INISTERSAT$OHAINTHE$ECISIONON)MPLEMENTATION2ELATED)SSUESAND#ONCERNSONE
-EMBERSREQUESTINRESPECTOFTWOPROGRAMMESWASBASEDONTHELANGUAGEINPARAGRAPH
OFTHATSAME$ECISIONANDEIGHTPROGRAMMESWEREONTHEBASISOF!RTICLEALONE
)NTHE#OMMITTEECONDUCTEDTHEMANDATEDSTANDSTILLANDTRANSPARENCYREVIEWOFTHESE
EXPORTSUBSIDYPROGRAMMESANDAGREEDTOCONTINUEFORCALENDARYEARCERTAINOFTHE
EXTENSIONSPREVIOUSLYGRANTEDBYTHE#OMMITTEEFORCALENDARYEARSAND4HESE
CONTINUATIONSOFEXTENSIONSFORCALENDARYEARWEREGRANTEDPURSUANTTOTHEPROCEDURES
IN'3#-ANDCANBEFOUNDINDOCUMENTS'3#-!DD'3#-!DD
!NNEX6))B )NPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA)MPLEMENTATION$ECISION-INISTERSAGREED
THAT!NNEX6))BTOTHE!GREEMENTINCLUDEDTHE-EMBERSTHATWERELISTEDTHEREINUNTILTHEIR
'.0PERCAPITAREACHED53INCONSTANTDOLLARSFORTHREECONSECUTIVEYEARS
&ROM*ANUARYTHEMETHODOLOGYFORCALCULATINGCONSTANTDOLLARSSETFORTHIN
'3#-!PPENDIXAPPLIES4HE3ECRETARIATCIRCULATEDINDOCUMENT'3#-!DD
ANOTEREFLECTINGI'.)PERCAPITAINCONSTANTDOLLARSCOVERINGTHETHREEMOSTRECENT
YEARSFORWHICHDATAAREAVAILABLEANDII'.)PERCAPITAINCURRENTDOLLARS
FORTHEYEAR!CCORDINGLY!NNEX6))BTOTHE3#-!GREEMENTINCLUDESTHEFOLLOWING
-EMBERSTHATARELISTEDTHEREINUNTILTHEIR'.0PERCAPITAREACHES53INCONSTANT
DOLLARSFORTHREECONSECUTIVEYEARS"OLIVIA#AMEROON#ONGO#ÙTED)VOIRE%GYPT
'HANA'UYANA(ONDURAS)NDIA)NDONESIA+ENYA.ICARAGUA.IGERIA0AKISTAN0HILIPPINES
3ENEGAL3RI,ANKAAND:IMBABWE
.OTIFICATIONANDREVIEWOFSUBSIDIES 4RANSPARENCYISESSENTIALFORTHEEFFECTIVE
OPERATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT4OTHISEND!RTICLEOFTHE3#-!GREEMENTREQUIRESTHAT
-EMBERSMAKEANOTIFICATIONOFSPECIFICSUBSIDIESBY*UNEOFEACHYEAR!TITS-AY
MEETINGTHE#OMMITTEECONTINUEDTHEUNDERSTANDINGREACHEDINTHAT-EMBERS
WOULDGIVEPRIORITYTOSUBMITTINGNEWANDFULLNOTIFICATIONSEVERYTWOYEARSANDWOULDDE
EMPHASIZETHEREVIEWOFUPDATINGNOTIFICATIONS4HE#OMMITTEEWILLONCEAGAINREVIEWTHIS
ARRANGEMENTIN4HENEWANDFULLNOTIFICATIONSMAYBEFOUNDINDOCUMENTSERIES
'3#-.!TABLEINDICATINGTHESTATUSOFSUBSIDYNOTIFICATIONSTO.OVEMBER
ISREPRODUCEDIN!NNEX!OFTHE#OMMITTEESREPORTTOTHE#4'',
4HE#OMMITTEECONTINUEDITSREVIEWOFTHESENEWANDFULLSUBSIDYNOTIFICATIONSASWELLAS
UPDATINGNOTIFICATIONSFROMPREVIOUSYEARSATITSREGULARANDSPECIALMEETINGSIN!PRILAND
.OVEMBER
0ERMANENT'ROUPOF%XPERTS 4HE!GREEMENTPROVIDESFORA0ERMANENT'ROUPOF
%XPERTSh0'%vCOMPOSEDOFFIVEINDEPENDENTPERSONSHIGHLYQUALIFIEDINTHEFIELDSOF
SUBSIDIESANDTRADERELATIONS4HEROLEOFTHE0'%INVOLVESTHEPROVISIONOFASSISTANCETO
)NADDITIONTHEREWASONENOTIFICATION
CONCERNINGTHEEXTENSIONOFASAFEGUARD
MEASURE
4HEPROVISIONSOF0ART)6OFTHE!GREEMENT
ONNONACTIONABLESUBSIDIESLAPSEDON
*ANUARYASTHEREWASNOCONSENSUSIN
THE#OMMITTEEON3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING
-EASURESPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE3#-
!GREEMENTTOEXTENDTHESEPROVISIONS
!NTIGUAAND"ARBUDA"ARBADOS"ELIZE
#OLOMBIA#OSTA2ICA$OMINICA$OMINICAN
2EPUBLIC%L3ALVADOR&IJI'RENADA'UATEMALA
*AMAICA*ORDAN-AURITIUS0ANAMA0APUA
.EW'UINEA3T+ITTSAND.EVIS3T,UCIA3T
6INCENTANDTHE'RENADINES4HAILAND5RUGUAY
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
PANELSWITHRESPECTTOWHETHERASUBSIDYISPROHIBITEDASWELLASTHEPROVISIONOFADVISORY
OPINIONSATTHEREQUESTOFTHE#OMMITTEEORA-EMBER !LTHOUGHTHE0'%HASDRAFTED2ULES
OF0ROCEDUREANDSUBMITTEDTHEMTOTHE#OMMITTEEFORITSAPPROVALTHEDRAFT2ULESHAVENOT
YETBEENAPPROVEDBYTHE#OMMITTEE
.OTIFICATIONANDREVIEWOFCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYLEGISLATION 0URSUANTTO!RTICLE
OFTHE!GREEMENTANDADECISIONOFTHE#OMMITTEE-EMBERSAREREQUIREDTONOTIFYTHEIR
COUNTERVAILINGDUTYLEGISLATIONANDORREGULATIONSORTHELACKTHEREOFTOTHE#OMMITTEE
!TABLEINDICATINGTHESTATUSOFLEGISLATIVENOTIFICATIONSTO.OVEMBERISREPRODUCED
IN!NNEX#OFTHE#OMMITTEESREPORTTOTHE#4'',!TITSSPRINGAND
AUTUMNMEETINGSTHE#OMMITTEECONTINUEDITSREVIEWOFLEGISLATIVENOTIFICATIONS
#OUNTERVAILINGACTIONS #OUNTERVAILINGACTIONSTAKENDURINGTHEPERIOD*ULYn
*UNEARESUMMARIZEDIN4ABLES)AND))BELOW7HILENOTIFICATIONSAREINCOMPLETE
THEDATAAVAILABLEINDICATETHATNEWCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYINVESTIGATIONSWEREINITIATED
INTHEREVIEWPERIOD!SOF*UNE-EMBERSREPORTEDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURES
INCLUDINGUNDERTAKINGSINFORCE
4ABLE))
%XPORTERSSUBJECTTOINITIATIONSOFCOUNTERVAILINGINVESTIGATIONS
*ULYn*UNEA
!FFECTED#OUNTRY
)NITIATIONS
!FFECTED#OUNTRY
)NITIATIONS
#ANADA
#HINESE4AIPEI
#HINA
4HAILAND
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
B
)NDIA
4OTAL
A
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
4HETABLEISBASEDONINFORMATIONFROM-EMBERSTHATHAVESUBMITTEDSEMIANNUALREPORTSANDISINCOMPLETEDUETOA
SIGNIFICANTNUMBEROFMISSINGNOTIFICATIONSORNOTIFICATIONSNOTPROVIDINGINFORMATIONREQUIREDBYTHENOTIFICATIONFORMAT
ADOPTEDBYTHE#OMMITTEE
B
)NCLUDESINITIATIONSINRESPECTOFINDIVIDUAL%#-EMBER3TATES'REECE)TALY3PAIN
4ABLE))
3UMMARYOFCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYACTIONS*ULY*UNE
2EPORTINGPARTY
!RGENTINA
!USTRALIA
#ANADA
#OSTA2ICA
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
-EXICO
.EW:EALAND
0ERU
3OUTH!FRICA
5NITED3TATES
6ENEZUELA
4OTAL
)NITIATIONS
0ROVISIONAL
$EFINITIVE
5NDERTAKINGS -EASURESINFORCE
DEFINITIVEDUTIES
ORUNDERTAKINGS
ON
!NTIDUMPINGPRACTICES
4HECURRENTMEMBERSHIPOFTHE0'%ISAS
FOLLOWS-ESSRS/KAN!KTAN9UJI)WASAWA
(YUNG*IN+IM!SGER0ETERSENAND4ERENCE0
3TEWART
!RTICLE6)OF'!44ALLOWS-EMBERSTOAPPLYANTIDUMPINGMEASURESONIMPORTSOFA
PRODUCTWITHANEXPORTPRICEBELOWITShNORMALVALUEvUSUALLYTHECOMPARABLEPRICEOFTHE
PRODUCTINTHEDOMESTICMARKETOFTHEEXPORTINGCOUNTRYIFSUCHIMPORTSCAUSEORTHREATEN
TOCAUSEMATERIALINJURYTOADOMESTICINDUSTRY4HE!GREEMENTON)MPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLE
6)OF'!44hTHE!GREEMENTvSETSFORTHDETAILEDRULESCONCERNINGTHEDETERMINATIONS
OFDUMPINGINJURYANDCAUSALLINKANDTHEPROCEDURESTOBEFOLLOWEDININITIATINGAND
CONDUCTINGANTIDUMPINGINVESTIGATIONS)TALSOCLARIFIESTHEROLEOFDISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELS
INDISPUTESCONCERNINGANTIDUMPINGACTIONSTAKENBY74/-EMBERS
.OTIFICATIONANDREVIEWOFANTIDUMPINGLEGISLATION74/-EMBERSAREUNDERA
CONTINUINGOBLIGATIONTONOTIFYTHEIRANTIDUMPINGLEGISLATIONANDORREGULATIONSORLACK
THEREOF-EMBERSWHOENACTNEWLEGISLATIONORAMENDEXISTINGLEGISLATIONAREREQUIREDTO
NOTIFYTHENEWTEXTORAMENDMENT!SOF$ECEMBER-EMBERSCOUNTINGTHE%#
ASASINGLE-EMBER HADSUBMITTEDNOTIFICATIONSREGARDINGANTIDUMPINGLEGISLATIONANDOR
REGULATIONS4WENTYEIGHT-EMBERSHADNOTYETSUBMITTEDANOTIFICATION2EVIEWOF-EMBERS
NOTIFICATIONSOFLEGISLATIONCONTINUESATTHEREGULARMEETINGSOFTHE#OMMITTEEON!NTI
$UMPING0RACTICESONTHEBASISOFWRITTENQUESTIONSANDANSWERS
3UBSIDIARYBODIES4HE#OMMITTEEHASTWOSUBSIDIARYBODIESTHE7ORKING'ROUP
ON)MPLEMENTATIONFORMERLYKNOWNASTHE!D(OC'ROUPON)MPLEMENTATIONANDTHE
)NFORMAL'ROUPON!NTI#IRCUMVENTION4HESEBODIESMEETTWICEAYEARINREGULARSESSIONIN
CONJUNCTIONWITHTHEREGULARMEETINGSOFTHE#OMMITTEE
4HE7ORKING'ROUPON)MPLEMENTATIONCONSIDERSPRINCIPALLYTECHNICALISSUESCONCERNING
THE!GREEMENT!TITSMEETINGSIN!PRILAND/CTOBERTHE7ORKING'ROUPCONTINUED
DISCUSSIONSONASERIESOFTOPICSREFERREDTOITBYTHE#OMMITTEEIN!PRILAND
!PRIL$ISCUSSIONPROCEEDEDONTHEBASISOFPAPERSSUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSDRAFT
RECOMMENDATIONSPREPAREDBYTHE3ECRETARIATANDINFORMATIONSUBMITTEDBY-EMBERS
CONCERNINGTHEIROWNPRACTICES
)NTHE)NFORMAL'ROUPON!NTI#IRCUMVENTION-EMBERSDISCUSSTHEMATTERSREFERREDTO
THE#OMMITTEEBY-INISTERSINTHE-INISTERIAL$ECISIONON!NTI#IRCUMVENTION4HE
)NFORMAL'ROUPMETIN!PRILAND/CTOBERANDCONTINUEDDISCUSSIONSONTHETHREE
TOPICSUNDERTHEAGREEDFRAMEWORKFORDISCUSSIONShWHATCONSTITUTESCIRCUMVENTIONvhWHAT
ISBEINGDONEBY-EMBERSCONFRONTEDWITHWHATTHEYCONSIDERTOBECIRCUMVENTIONvANDhTO
WHATEXTENTCANCIRCUMVENTIONBEDEALTWITHUNDERTHERELEVANT74/RULESTOWHATEXTENT
CANITNOTANDWHATOTHEROPTIONSMAYBEDEEMEDNECESSARYv
!NTIDUMPINGACTIONS!NTIDUMPINGACTIONSTAKENDURINGTHEPERIOD*ULY
n*UNEARESUMMARIZEDIN4ABLES6AND64HETABLESAREINCOMPLETE
BECAUSECERTAIN-EMBERSHAVENOTSUBMITTEDTHEREQUIREDSEMIANNUALREPORTSFORTHIS
PERIODORHAVENOTPROVIDEDALLOFTHEINFORMATIONREQUIREDBYTHEFORMATADOPTEDBYTHE
#OMMITTEE4HEDATAAVAILABLEINDICATETHATINVESTIGATIONSWEREINITIATEDDURINGTHE
PERIOD4HEMOSTACTIVE-EMBERSINTERMSOFINITIATIONSWERETHE5NITED3TATES)NDIA
#HINA4URKEYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES+OREA#ANADA
-EXICOAND3OUTH!FRICA!SOF*UNE-EMBERSREPORTEDANTIDUMPING
MEASURESINCLUDINGUNDERTAKINGSINFORCE/FTHEMEASURESINFORCEREPORTED
PERCENTWEREMAINTAINEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESPERCENTBY)NDIAPERCENTBYTHE
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESANDPERCENTEACHBY!RGENTINA#ANADAAND3OUTH!FRICA/THER
-EMBERSREPORTINGMEASURESINFORCEEACHACCOUNTEDFORPERCENTORLESSOFTHETOTAL
0RODUCTSEXPORTEDFROM#HINAWERETHESUBJECTOFTHEMOSTANTIDUMPINGINVESTIGATIONS
INITIATEDDURINGTHEPERIODFOLLOWEDBYPRODUCTSEXPORTEDFROMTHE5NITED3TATES
#HINESE4AIPEITHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESAND+OREAEACH*APANAND)NDIA
4HEREMAINING-EMBERSEXPORTINGPRODUCTSSUBJECTTOINVESTIGATIONEACHWERESUBJECT
TOFEWERTHANINVESTIGATIONS
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
4OACCOUNTFORTHEFACTTHAT#YPRUSTHE
#ZECH2EPUBLIC%STONIA(UNGARY,ATVIA
,ITHUANIA-ALTA0OLANDTHE3LOVAK2EPUBLIC
AND3LOVENIAACCEDEDTOTHE%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIESASOF-AYTHEANTI
DUMPINGLEGISLATIONSTHATTHEYHADNOTIFIED
PRIORTOTHATDATEARENOLONGERSEPARATELY
COUNTEDINTHISTALLY
4ABLE))
3UMMARYOFANTIDUMPINGACTIONS*ULYn*UNE
)NITIATIONS
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
!RGENTINA
!USTRALIA
"RAZIL
#ANADA
#HINA
#OSTA2ICA
%GYPT
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
INCLUDINGNEW-EMBER
3TATESACCEDED
)NDIA
)NDONESIA
)SRAEL
*AMAICA
*APAN
+OREA
-ALAYSIA
-EXICO
.EW:EALAND
0AKISTAN
0ERU
0HILIPPINES
3OUTH!FRICA
#HINESE4AIPEI
4HAILAND
4RINIDADAND4OBAGO
4URKEY
5NITED3TATES
6ENEZUELA
4OTAL
0ROVISIONAL
MEASURES
$EFINITIVE
0RICE
-EASURES
$UTIES
5NDERTAKINGS
INFORCE
ON*UNE
4ABLE))
%XPORTERSSUBJECTTOTWO ORMOREINITIATIONSOFANTIDUMPINGINVESTIGATIONS
*ULYn*UNE
!FFECTEDCOUNTRY
4HEREPORTINGPERIODCOVERS*ULYn
*UNE4HETABLEISBASEDON
INFORMATIONFROM-EMBERSHAVINGSUBMITTED
SEMIANNUALREPORTSFORTHATPERIODANDIS
INCOMPLETEDUETOMISSINGREPORTSANDOR
MISSINGINFORMATIONINREPORTS
)NCLUDESDEFINITIVEPRICEUNDERTAKINGS
#OUNTRIESTHESUBJECTOFONLYONEINITIATIONOF
ANANTIDUMPINGINVESTIGATIONWERE!USTRALIA
%CUADOR)RAN.IGERIA2OMANIA3RI,ANKA
3WITZERLAND5KRAINE5RUGUAYAND5ZBEKISTAN
4HEREPORTINGPERIODCOVERS*ULYn
*UNE4HETABLEISBASEDON
INFORMATIONFROM-EMBERSHAVINGSUBMITTED
SEMIANNUALREPORTSFORTHATPERIODANDIS
INCOMPLETEDUETOMISSINGREPORTSANDOR
MISSINGINFORMATIONINREPORTS
$OESNOTINCLUDEEXPORTERSSUBJECTTOONLY
ONEINITIATIONSEENOTEABOVE4HETOTAL
NUMBEROFINITIATIONSWAS
4OTAL
!FFECTEDCOUNTRY
4OTAL
#HINA
#ANADA
5NITED3TATES
6IET.AM
#HINESE4AIPEI
"RAZIL
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESANDOR-EMBER3TATES -EXICO
+OREA
!RGENTINA
*APAN
"ELARUS
)NDIA
3AUDI!RABIA
4HAILAND
3INGAPORE
2USSIA
3OUTH!FRICA
)NDONESIA
4URKEY
-ALAYSIA
5NITED!RAB%MIRATES
4OTAL
4ECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADE
$URINGTHE#OMMITTEEHELDTHREEMEETINGSTHEREPORTSARECONTAINEDIN
'4"4-AND#ORRIGENDA!TEACHMEETINGTHE#OMMITTEECONSIDEREDSPECIFIC
TRADECONCERNSBROUGHTTOITSATTENTIONBY-EMBERS-UCHOFTHE#OMMITTEESWORKIN
FOCUSEDONTHEFOLLOWUPTOTHERECOMMENDATIONSCONTAINEDINTHE4HIRD4RIENNIAL
2EVIEW'4"4)NPARTICULARTHE#OMMITTEEHELDON*UNEA3PECIAL-EETING
WHICHFOCUSEDON#ONFORMITY!SSESSMENT0ROCEDURES'4"4-!DD!TTHISMEETING
-EMBERSCONSIDEREDINTERALIAISSUESRELEVANTTOACCREDITATIONANDSUPPLIERSDECLARATION
OFCONFORMITY3$O#4HISISPARTOFANONGOINGEFFORTTOPROMOTEABETTERUNDERSTANDING
OF-EMBERSCONFORMITYASSESSMENTSYSTEMSANDINSODOINGIMPROVING-EMBERS
IMPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLESOFTHE4"4!GREEMENT)NRESPECTOFTRANSPARENCYTHE4"4
#OMMITTEEHELDON.OVEMBERITS&OURTH3PECIAL-EETINGON0ROCEDURESFOR
)NFORMATION%XCHANGE4HISMEETINGPROVIDEDAFORUMFOR-EMBERSTOEXCHANGEEXPERIENCES
REGARDINGTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTRANSPARENCYPROVISIONSOFTHE4"4!GREEMENTATATECHNICAL
LEVELnINPARTICULARWITHRESPECTTOTHEFUNCTIONINGOFNOTIFICATIONPROCEDURESANDENQUIRY
POINTS'4"4-!NNEX!TITSLASTMEETINGOFTHEYEARTHE#OMMITTEEADOPTEDAWORK
PROGRAMMEFORTHEPREPARATIONOFTHE&OURTH4RIENNIAL2EVIEW'4"4-!NNEXAND
#ORR
4HE7ORKING0ARTYON3TATE4RADING%NTERPRISESWASESTABLISHEDINACCORDANCEWITH
PARAGRAPHOFTHE5NDERSTANDINGONTHE)NTERPRETATIONOF!RTICLE86))OFTHE'!44
ANDHELDITSFIRSTMEETINGIN!PRIL4HE7ORKING0ARTYHELDAFORMALMEETINGIN
.OVEMBER
4HE7ORKING0ARTYSMAINTASKISTOREVIEWTHENOTIFICATIONSANDCOUNTERNOTIFICATIONS
SUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSONTHEIRSTATETRADINGACTIVITIES.OTIFICATIONSSHALLBEMADEIN
ACCORDANCEWITHTHEQUESTIONNAIREONSTATETRADINGADOPTEDIN!PRIL'342AND
REVISEDIN.OVEMBER'3422EV2EVIEWSOFTHENOTIFICATIONSSUBMITTEDARE
CONDUCTEDINFORMALMEETINGSOFTHE7ORKING0ARTY)N.OVEMBERTHE7ORKING0ARTY
DECIDEDONACHANGEINTHEFREQUENCYOFTHENOTIFICATIONSREQUIRING-EMBERSTOSUBMIT
NEWANDFULLNOTIFICATIONSEVERYTWOYEARSANDELIMINATINGTHEREQUIREMENTFORUPDATING
NOTIFICATIONS'3424HISCHANGEHASBEENIMPLEMENTEDASOFTHEYEAR.OTIFICATIONS
MUSTBEMADEBYALL-EMBERSREGARDLESSOFWHETHERTHE-EMBERMAINTAINSANYSTATE
TRADINGENTERPRISESANDREGARDLESSOFWHETHERANEXISTINGSTATETRADINGENTERPRISEHAS
CONDUCTEDANYTRADEDURINGTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEW
7ITHREGARDTOTHEMAINTASKOFTHE7ORKING0ARTYnTHEREVIEWOFNOTIFICATIONSnATITS
.OVEMBERMEETINGTHE7ORKING0ARTYREVIEWEDNOTIFICATIONSNEWANDFULL
NOTIFICATIONS OF!RMENIA"ULGARIA#ROATIA'HANA(ONG+ONG#HINA)NDONESIA*APAN
,ATVIA,IECHTENSTEIN-ACAO#HINA0ANAMA3INGAPORE3URINAME3WITZERLAND#HINESE
4AIPEIAND4HAILANDUPDATINGNOTIFICATIONSOF!USTRALIA#OLOMBIA#ROATIA#ZECH
2EPUBLIC%STONIA/MAN0ANAMA2OMANIA3INGAPORE3LOVAK2EPUBLIC#HINESE4AIPEI
4HAILANDTHE5NITED3TATESAND:AMBIAUPDATINGNOTIFICATIONSOF!USTRALIA#OLOMBIA
#ROATIAANDTHE5NITED3TATESNEWANDFULLNOTIFICATIONSOF!USTRALIA#OLOMBIAAND
THE5NITED3TATESUPDATINGNOTIFICATIONSOF!USTRALIAANDTHE5NITED3TATES
UPDATINGNOTIFICATIONSOFTHE5NITED3TATESAND.EWANDFULL.OTIFICATIONSOFTHE
5NITED3TATES!TTHATMEETINGTHE7ORKING0ARTYALSOADOPTEDITS!NNUAL2EPORTTOTHE
#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSFORTHEYEAR',
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINGOODS
3TATETRADINGENTERPRISES
4RADERELATEDINVESTMENTMEASURES42)-S
.EW:EALANDSUBMITTEDANEWANDFULL
NOTIFICATIONTHEDAYBEFORETHEMEETING4HIS
NOTIFICATIONWILLBEREVIEWEDATTHESUBSEQUENT
MEETINGOFTHE7ORKING0ARTY
4HE!GREEMENTON4RADE2ELATED)NVESTMENT-EASURESREQUIRES74/-EMBERSTO
ELIMINATETRADERELATEDINVESTMENTMEASURES42)-STHATAREINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLE)))OR
!RTICLE8)OF'!44-EMBERSWEREGIVENATRANSITIONPERIODTOELIMINATE42)-SNOTIFIED
WITHINDAYSOFTHEENTRYINTOFORCEOFTHE74/!GREEMENTnTWOYEARSINTHECASEOF
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRY-EMBERSFIVEYEARSINTHECASEOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSAND
SEVENYEARSINTHECASEOFLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY-EMBERS4WENTYSIXSUCHNOTIFICATIONS
WEREMADE
5NDER!RTICLEOFTHE42)-S!GREEMENTTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODS#4'MAY
EXTENDTHETRANSITIONPERIODATTHEREQUESTOFANINDIVIDUALDEVELOPINGORLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRY-EMBERTHATDEMONSTRATESPARTICULARDIFFICULTIESINIMPLEMENTINGTHEPROVISIONSOF
THE!GREEMENT)N*ULYEIGHTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESn!RGENTINA#OLOMBIA-ALAYSIA
-EXICO0AKISTANTHE0HILIPPINES2OMANIAAND4HAILANDWEREGIVENEXTENSIONSOFTHE
TRANSITIONPERIODUNTILTHEENDOFANDIN.OVEMBERTHE#4'GRANTEDADDITIONAL
EXTENSIONSTOTHESE-EMBERSFORPERIODSUPTOEND)NLATE$ECEMBER0AKISTAN
REQUESTEDAFURTHEREXTENSIONOFTHREEYEARSFORTHEMAINTENANCEOFCERTAIN42)-SINITS
AUTOMOBILEINDUSTRY#ONSULTATIONSONTHISREQUESTBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE#4'AREONGOING
)NTHE42)-S#OMMITTEEHELDONEFORMALMEETING/CTOBER4HE#OMMITTEE
REVIEWEDTHESTATUSOF-EMBERSNOTIFICATIONSUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE42)-S!GREEMENT
CONCERNINGPUBLICATIONSINWHICHINFORMATIONON42)-SCANBEFOUND0URSUANTTOTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILS$ECISIONOF!UGUSTATITSMEETINGTHE42)-S#OMMITTEEALSO
CONSIDEREDTHEPROPOSALSONSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTTHATWERESUBMITTEDBYTHE
!FRICAN'ROUPINDOCUMENT4.#4$72EVWITHRESPECTTO!RTICLEAND!RTICLEOFTHE
42)-S!GREEMENT)NADDITIONTHE#OMMITTEECOMPLETEDITSTHIRDANNUALREVIEWUNDERTHE
4RANSITIONAL2EVIEW-ECHANISMOF#HINAS0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSIONANDSUBMITTEDITSREPORTTO
THE#4'',AND#ORR&OLLOWINGTHEREQUESTBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS
#OMMITTEE4.#TOASSISTHIMINHISCONSULTATIVEPROCESSUNDERPARAGRAPHBOFTHE
$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONIN.OVEMBERTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE42)-S#OMMITTEE
HELDINFORMALCONSULTATIONSONTHEOUTSTANDINGIMPLEMENTATIONISSUESRELATEDTOTHE42)-S
!GREEMENT$URINGTHE#4'CONTINUEDTHE!RTICLEREVIEWOFTHEOPERATIONOFTHE
42)-S!GREEMENT
64RADEINSERVICES
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADEINSERVICES
#OUNCILFOR4RADE)N3ERVICES
4HE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESHELDSEVENFORMALMEETINGSDURING2EPORTSOFTHE
MEETINGSARECONTAINEDINDOCUMENTS3#-TO4HESEREPORTSASWELLASTHEANNUAL
REPORTBYTHE#OUNCILCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT3#SHOULDBEREADINCONJUNCTIONWITHTHIS
SUMMARY$URINGTHEREPORTINGPERIODTHE#OUNCILADDRESSEDTHEFOLLOWINGMATTERS
0ROPOSALSFORATECHNICALREVIEWOF'!43PROVISIONSn!RTICLE88 !TITSMEETING
ON-ARCHTHE#OUNCILCONSIDEREDTHEREPORT3#7BYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE
#OMMITTEEON3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTS#3#WHICHSUMMARIZEDTHETECHNICALDISCUSSIONSON
ISSUESARISINGFROMTHESCHEDULINGOFCOMMITMENTSINACCORDANCEWITH!RTICLE88!TITS
MEETINGON*UNETHE#OUNCILAGREEDTOREVERTTOTHISITEMUPONSPECIFICREQUEST
2EQUESTFORAWAIVERFROMSPECIFICCOMMITMENTSUNDERTHE'!43PURSUANTTO
PARAGRAPHSANDOF!RTICLES)8OFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE7ORLD
4RADE/RGANIZATION !TITSMEETINGON-ARCHTHE#OUNCILAPPROVED!LBANIAS
REQUESTANDADOPTEDTHEREPORT3#TOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL4HEDRAFTDECISIONATTACHED
TOTHEREPORTWASFORWARDEDTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILADOPTEDTHE
DECISIONON-AYWHICHWASISSUEDINDOCUMENT74,
.EGOTIATIONSONEMERGENCYSAFEGUARDMEASURESUNDER!RTICLE8OFTHE
'!43nDEADLINEFORTHENEGOTIATIONS !TITSMEETINGON-ARCHTHE#OUNCIL
CONSIDEREDTHECOMMUNICATION3#7FROMTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE7ORKING0ARTY
ON'!432ULES70'2WHICHPROPOSEDTOEXTENDTHEDEADLINEOFTHENEGOTIATIONSON
EMERGENCYSAFEGUARDMEASURESUNDER!RTICLE84HE#OUNCILADOPTEDTHE&IFTH$ECISIONON
.EGOTIATIONSON%MERGENCY3AFEGUARD-EASURES3,WHICHSTIPULATESTHATSUBJECT
TOTHEOUTCOMEOFTHEMANDATEINPARAGRAPHOF!RTICLE8THERESULTSOFSUCHNEGOTIATIONS
SHALLENTERINTOEFFECTONADATENOTLATERTHANTHEDATEOFENTRYINTOFORCEOFTHERESULTSOF
THECURRENTROUNDOFSERVICESNEGOTIATIONS
4RANSITIONALREVIEWUNDER3ECTIONOFTHE0ROTOCOLONTHE!CCESSIONOFTHE0EOPLES
2EPUBLICOF#HINA !TITSMEETINGON.OVEMBERTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES
CONDUCTEDANDCONCLUDEDTHETHIRD4RANSITIONAL2EVIEWUNDER3ECTIONOFTHE0ROTOCOLON
THE!CCESSIONOFTHE0EOPLES2EPUBLICOF#HINA4HE#OUNCILTOOKNOTEOFTHEREPORTFROM
THE#OMMITTEEON4RADEIN&INANCIAL3ERVICESONITSREVIEWCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT3&).
WHICHFORMEDPARTOFTHE#OUNCILSREPORTONTHISMATTERTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONTAINEDIN
DOCUMENT3#
2EVIEWOF-&.EXEMPTIONS !TITSMEETINGON*UNETHE#OUNCILADDRESSED
THESECONDREVIEWOF-&.EXEMPTIONSINACCORDANCEWITHTHEDECISIONADOPTEDATTHE
CONCLUSIONOFTHEPREVIOUSREVIEW!TITSMEETINGON3EPTEMBERTHE#OUNCILAGREED
THATTHESECONDREVIEWWOULDBECONDUCTEDINDEDICATEDSESSIONS!TTHEFIRSTSUCHSESSION
WHICHWASHELDON.OVEMBERTHE#OUNCILEXAMINED-&.EXEMPTIONSLISTEDFOR
!LL3ECTORSBUSINESSSERVICESCOMMUNICATIONSERVICESCONSTRUCTIONANDRELATEDENGINEERING
SERVICESANDDISTRIBUTIONSERVICES
$ERESTRICTIONOFDOCUMENTS !TITSMEETINGON3EPTEMBERTHE#OUNCIL
HELDDISCUSSIONSININFORMALMODEREGARDINGTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREQUESTFORTHE
CONTINUEDRESTRICTIONOFPARTSOFTHEREPORT3#-OFTHE#OUNCILSMEETINGOF*UNE
!TITSMEETINGON.OVEMBERTHE#OUNCILREACHEDANAGREEMENTONTHIS
MATTER
)MPLEMENTATION!RTICLE6))OF'!43 !TITSFOURFORMALMEETINGSINTHE#OUNCIL
CONTINUEDTODISCUSSISSUESRELATINGTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLE6))OFTHE'!43BASED
ONASUBMISSIONFROM)NDIA
4HE#OUNCILFOR42)03FOLLOWEDUPTHEREVIEWSOFTHENATIONALIMPLEMENTINGLEGISLATION
OFCERTAINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSTHATWEREINITIATEDINANDFOLLOWINGTHE
EXPIRYOFTHEIRTRANSITIONPERIODATTHEBEGINNINGOFANDINITIATEDTHEREVIEWSOFTWO
NEWLYACCEDED-EMBERS!TTHEENDOFTHEYEARTHECOMPLETIONOFREVIEWSWASPENDING
!TITSMEETINGIN$ECEMBERTHE#OUNCILUNDERTOOKTHETHIRDANNUALTRANSITIONALREVIEWOFTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONBY#HINAOFITS74/COMMITMENTSINTHE42)03AREAPURSUANTTO3ECTION
OFITS0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSION
4HE#OUNCILCONTINUEDITSWORKPURSUANTTOPARAGRAPHOFTHE$ECISIONONTHE
)MPLEMENTATIONOF0ARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONONTHE42)03!GREEMENTAND
0UBLIC(EALTH74,4HISPARAGRAPHINSTRUCTEDTHE42)03#OUNCILTOINITIATEBYTHE
ENDOFWORKONTHEPREPARATIONOFANAMENDMENTTOTHE42)03!GREEMENTTOREPLACE
THEPROVISIONSOFTHE$ECISIONWITHAVIEWTOITSADOPTIONWITHINSIXMONTHSIEBY*UNE
!TITSMEETINGIN*UNETHE#OUNCILAGREEDTOCONTINUEITSWORKINITIATEDATITS
MEETINGIN.OVEMBERONTHEPREPARATIONOFTHEAMENDMENTWITHAVIEWTOTHE42)03
#OUNCILMAKINGARECOMMENDATIONBYTHEENDOF-ARCHSOTHATTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
COULDCONCLUDEITSWORKONTHEAMENDMENTATITSFIRSTMEETINGTHEREAFTER!TITSMEETINGIN
$ECEMBERTHE#OUNCILCARRIEDOUTTHEFIRSTANNUALREVIEWPURSUANTTOPARAGRAPHOFTHE
$ECISIONOFTHEFUNCTIONINGOFTHESYSTEMSETOUTINTHE$ECISION
0URSUANTTOPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONTHE#OUNCILCONTINUED
ITSDISCUSSIONSRELATEDTOTHEREVIEWOFTHEPROVISIONSOF!RTICLEBTHERELATIONSHIP
BETWEENTHE42)03!GREEMENTANDTHE#ONVENTIONON"IOLOGICAL$IVERSITYANDTHEPROTECTION
OFTRADITIONALKNOWLEDGEANDFOLKLORE4HE#OUNCILRECEIVEDANUMBEROFNEWPAPERSFROM
-EMBERSRELATEDTOTHESETOPICS
4HE#OUNCILAGREEDTHATDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY-EMBERSWOULDUPDATETHEINFORMATIONON
THEIRTECHNICALANDFINANCIALCOOPERATIONACTIVITIESPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENT
INTIMEFORTHE#OUNCILSMEETINGIN3EPTEMBER5PDATEDINFORMATIONWASALSORECEIVEDFROM
ANUMBEROFINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSOBSERVERSTOTHE#OUNCILASWELLASFROMTHE
74/3ECRETARIAT&URTHERMOREATEACH#OUNCILMEETINGTHE74/AND7)0/3ECRETARIATS
REPORTEDONTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEIR*OINT)NITIATIVEON4ECHNICAL#OOPERATIONFOR,EAST
$EVELOPED#OUNTRIESLAUNCHEDIN*UNE
)NTHELIGHTOFTHE$ECISIONONTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMMEADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILON!UGUSTTHE#OUNCILDISCUSSEDATITSMEETINGIN$ECEMBERTHESPECIAL
ANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTPROPOSALSREFERREDTOITANDTOOKNOTEOFANINFORMAL3ECRETARIAT
NOTESUMMARIZINGTHE#OUNCILSWORKSOFARONTHESEPROPOSALS
4HE#OUNCILSWORKONTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOF!RTICLEASWELLASONNONVIOLATION
ANDSITUATIONCOMPLAINTSISDESCRIBEDIN3ECTION))ONTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAABOVE
/THERISSUESDISCUSSEDINTHE42)03#OUNCILINCLUDEDTHEREVIEWOFIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE
42)03!GREEMENTUNDER!RTICLETHEREVIEWOFTHEAPPLICATIONOFTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE
3ECTIONONGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSUNDER!RTICLEANDAREQUESTFROM-ALDIVESFOR
ANEXTENSIONOFTHETRANSITIONPERIODUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE42)03!GREEMENT&URTHER
INFORMATIONCANBEFOUNDINTHE!NNUAL2EPORTOFTHE#OUNCILFOR42)03)0#
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADERELATEDASPECTSOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS
42)03
6) 4RADERELATEDASPECTSOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS42)03
6)) 2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
5NDERSTANDING
/VERVIEW
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONVENESASTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY$3"TODEALWITHDISPUTES
ARISINGFROMANYAGREEMENTCONTAINEDINTHE&INAL!CTOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDTHATISCOVERED
BYTHE5NDERSTANDINGON2ULESAND0ROCEDURES'OVERNINGTHE3ETTLEMENTOF$ISPUTES
$354HE$3"WHICHMETTIMESDURINGHASTHESOLEAUTHORITYTOESTABLISH
DISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELSADOPTPANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSMAINTAINSURVEILLANCEOF
IMPLEMENTATIONOFRECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSANDAUTHORIZESUSPENSIONOFCONCESSIONSIN
THEEVENTOFNONIMPLEMENTATIONOFRECOMMENDATIONS
$ISPUTESETTLEMENTACTIVITYIN
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
)NTHEYEARTHE$3"RECEIVEDNOTIFICATIONSFROM-EMBERSOFFORMALREQUESTS
FORCONSULTATIONSUNDERTHE$35$URINGTHISPERIODTHE$3"ALSOESTABLISHEDPANELSTO
DEALWITHSEVENNEWCASESANDADOPTEDPANELANDOR!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTSINCASES
)NADDITIONMUTUALLYAGREEDSOLUTIONSWERENOTIFIEDINTHREECASES4HEFOLLOWINGSECTION
BRIEFLYDESCRIBESTHEPROCEDURALHISTORYANDWHEREAVAILABLETHESUBSTANTIVEOUTCOMEOF
THESECASES)TALSODESCRIBESTHEIMPLEMENTATIONSTATUSOFADOPTEDREPORTSWHERENEW
DEVELOPMENTSOCCURREDINTHECOVEREDPERIOD)NORDERTOPROVIDETHEMOSTUPTODATE
INFORMATIONAVAILABLEATTHETIMEOFWRITINGCONCERNINGCASESTHATWEREACTIVEIN
DEVELOPMENTSFROM*ANUARYUNTIL&EBRUARYAREREFLECTED.EWCASESINITIATED
INARENOTREFLECTEDHERE4HECASESARELISTEDINORDEROFTHEIR$3NUMBER!DDITIONAL
INFORMATIONONEACHOFTHESECASESCANBEFOUNDONTHE74/SWEBSITEATWWWWTOORG
5NITED3TATESn4AXTREATMENTFOR&OREIGN3ALES#ORPORATIONSCOMPLAINTBY
THE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE0ANELREPORTSEE!NNUAL2EPORTPFORADESCRIPTIONOF
THE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSEE!NNUAL2EPORTPFORADESCRIPTIONOFTHECOMPLIANCE
0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTPFORINFORMATIONONTHE
AUTHORIZATIONTOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N.OVEMBERTHE%#REQUESTEDTHE5NITED3TATESTOENTERINTOCONSULTATIONS
UNDER!RTICLESANDOFTHE$35!RTICLEOFTHE3#-!GREEMENT!RTICLEOF
THE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREAND!RTICLE88))OFTHE'!44WITHRESPECTTOTHE
!MERICAN*/"3#REATION!CTOFTHE*/"3!CTENACTEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESON
/CTOBER!CCORDINGTOTHE%#THE*/"3!CTWASINTENDEDTOIMPLEMENTTHE$3"S
RECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSINTHISCASECOMPLIANCEPHASEBUTFAILEDTODOSOPROPERLY
ANDWASINCONSISTENTWITHTHESAMEPROVISIONSOFTHE74/!GREEMENTASTHEPREDECESSOR
LEGISLATION)NPARTICULARTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESCONSIDEREDTHAT3ECTIONOFTHE*/"3
!CTCONTAINSTRANSITIONALPROVISIONSWHICHWILLALLOW53EXPORTERSTOCONTINUETOBENEFITFROM
THE74/INCOMPATIBLE&3#2EPLACEMENTAND%XTRATERRITORIAL)NCOME%XCLUSION!CTAINTHE
YEARSANDWITHRESPECTTOALLEXPORTTRANSACTIONSANDBFORANINDEFINITEPERIOD
WITHRESPECTTOCERTAINBINDINGCONTRACTSTHUSFAILINGTOWITHDRAWTHESUBSIDYANDIMPLEMENT
THE$3"SRECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGS/N.OVEMBER!USTRALIAREQUESTEDTO
JOINTHECONSULTATIONS/N*ANUARYTHE%#NOTIFIEDTHE$3"THATCONSULTATIONS
HADFAILEDTOSETTLETHEDISPUTEANDTHATITWASREQUESTINGTHEESTABLISHMENTOFAPANEL
PURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE$35!TITSMEETINGOF*ANUARYTHE$3"DEFERREDTHE
ESTABLISHMENTOFAPANEL!TITSMEETINGOF&EBRUARYTHE$3"AGREEDTOREFERTHE
MATTERTOTHEORIGINALPANEL
5NITED3TATESn!NTIDUMPING!CTOFCOMPLAINTBYTHE%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSSEE!NNUAL2EPORTP
FORDETAILEDINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONPLEASESEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
PAND74/!NNUAL2EPORTPAND74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N3EPTEMBERTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREQUESTEDTHE!RBITRATORSTO
REACTIVATETHEARBITRATIONPROCEEDINGINTHISDISPUTESINCENOLEGISLATIONHADBEENADOPTED
TOREPEALTHE!CTANDTOTERMINATETHECASESPENDINGBEFORETHE5NITED3TATESCOURTS
)NACCORDANCEWITHTHISREQUESTTHE!RBITRATORSRESUMEDTHEARBITRATIONPROCEEDINGONTHE
SAMEDAY/N&EBRUARYTHEDECISIONBYTHE!RBITRATORSWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS
'IVENTHATTHENULLIFICATIONORIMPAIRMENTRESULTSFROMTHE!CTASSUCHANDNOT
FROMPARTICULARINSTANCESOFAPPLICATIONOFTHATLAWTHE!RBITRATORSDECIDEDTOSETANUMBER
OFPARAMETERSIDAMAGESPAIDBY%#COMPANIESASARESULTOFJUDGEMENTSUNDERTHE
!CTANDIIAMOUNTOFANYSETTLEMENTREACHEDBETWEENAN%#COMPANYANDA53
COMPLAINANTPURSUANTTOA!CTCOMPLAINTWITHWHICHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESWILL
HAVETOCOMPLYWHENCALCULATINGTHEAMOUNTOFCOUNTERMEASURESITPLANSTOIMPOSERATHER
THANSETTINGAFIXEDVALUEOFTRADEWHICHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESSHOULDNOTEXCEED
WHENSUSPENDINGITS74/OBLIGATIONSAGAINSTTHE5NITED3TATES
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn0ROTECTIONOFTRADEMARKSANDGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONS
FORAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSANDFOODSTUFFSCOMPLAINTSBYTHE5NITED3TATESAND
!USTRALIA74$374$3
&ORINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N!UGUSTTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBE
ABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORKINSIXMONTHSDUETOTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHECASEANDTHATTHE0ANEL
EXPECTEDTOISSUEITSFINALREPORTTOTHEPARTIESBEFORETHEENDOFYEAR4HEREPORTIS
EXPECTEDTOBECIRCULATEDTO74/-EMBERSINMID-ARCH
-EXICOn-EASURESAFFECTINGTELECOMMUNICATIONSSERVICESCOMPLAINTBY
THE5NITED3TATES74$3
&ORDETAILSCONCERNINGTHEREQUESTFORESTABLISHMENTOFTHEPANELSEE74/!NNUAL
2EPORTP
4HE0ANELWASCOMPOSEDON!UGUST/N!PRILTHE0ANELREPORTWAS
CIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELRULEDTHAT-EXICOVIOLATEDITS'!43COMMITMENTSBECAUSE
A-EXICOFAILEDTOENSUREINTERCONNECTIONATCOSTORIENTEDRATESFORTHECROSSBORDER
SUPPLYOFFACILITIESBASEDBASICTELECOMSERVICESCONTRARYTO!RTICLEBOFITS2EFERENCE
0APERB-EXICOFAILEDTOMAINTAINAPPROPRIATEMEASURESTOPREVENTANTICOMPETITIVE
PRACTICESBYFIRMSTHATAREAMAJORTELECOMSUPPLIERCONTRARYTO!RTICLEOFITS2EFERENCE
0APERANDC-EXICOFAILEDTOENSUREREASONABLEANDNONDISCRIMINATORYACCESSTOAND
USEOFTELECOMMUNICATIONSNETWORKSCONTRARYTO!RTICLEAANDBOFTHE'!43!NNEXON
4ELECOMMUNICATIONS)NRESPECTOFCROSSBORDERTELECOMSERVICESSUPPLIEDONANONFACILITIES
BASISIN-EXICOHOWEVERTHE0ANELRULEDTHAT-EXICODIDNOTVIOLATEITSOBLIGATIONSBECAUSE
ITHADNOTTAKENCOMMITMENTSFORTHESESERVICES
/N*UNETHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE0ANEL2EPORT!TTHESAMETIME-EXICOANDTHE
5NITED3TATESREACHEDANAGREEMENTON-EXICOSCOMPLIANCEWITHTHERECOMMENDATIONSOF
THE0ANEL2EPORT4HEAGREEMENTSTATESTHATAREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMETOCOMPLYWITHTHE
RECOMMENDATIONSOFTHE2EPORTISMONTHS
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
5NITED3TATESn!NTIDUMPINGMEASURESONCERTAINHOTROLLEDSTEELPRODUCTS
FROM*APANCOMPLAINTBY*APAN74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSSEE!NNUAL2EPORTP
FORDETAILSOFIMPLEMENTATIONUPUNTIL$ECEMBERSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
FORDETAILSOFIMPLEMENTATIONUPUNTIL$ECEMBERSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N*ULYTHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE$3"THATITPROPOSED
THATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEFORIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHERECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGS
OFTHE$3"BEMODIFIEDSOASTOEXPIREON*ULYANDTHATITHADCONSULTEDWITH
*APANREGARDINGTHISPROPOSAL!TITSMEETINGON!UGUSTTHE$3"AGREEDTOTHE
REQUESTBYTHE5NITED3TATESFORANEXTENSIONOFTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEFORTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHERECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"
#HILEn0RICEBANDSYSTEMANDSAFEGUARDMEASURESRELATINGTOCERTAIN
AGRICULTURALPRODUCTSCOMPLAINTBY!RGENTINA74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTSSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
PFORDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHISREPORTUPUNTIL$ECEMBER
SEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
!TTHE$3"MEETINGON*ANUARY#HILEAND!RGENTINANOTEDTHATTHEYHAD
CONCLUDEDABILATERALAGREEMENTREGARDINGTHEPROCEDURESUNDER!RTICLESANDOFTHE
$35)NTHISREGARD#HILENOTEDTHATTHEISSUEOFSEQUENCINGBETWEEN!RTICLESAND
REQUIREDAMULTILATERALSOLUTIONSINCEADHOCAGREEMENTSONLYAPPLIEDTOSPECIFICDISPUTES
!RGENTINANOTEDTHATTHEPARTIESWOULDSHORTLYENTERINTOCONSULTATIONSREGARDINGTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONISSUES/N-AY!RGENTINAREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITH#HILEUNDER
!RTICLEOFTHE$35
5NITED3TATESn#OUNTERVAILINGMEASURESCONCERNINGCERTAINPRODUCTSFROMTHE
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESCOMPLAINTBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES74$3
&ORDETAILSOFTHE0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTSSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
PAND74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N-ARCHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESCONSIDERINGTHATTHEMEASURESTAKEN
BYTHE5NITED3TATESTOCOMPLYWITHITS74/OBLIGATIONSWEREUNSATISFACTORYREQUESTED
THATTHEYENTERINTOCONSULTATIONSUNDER!RTICLESANDOFTHE$35AND!RTICLEOF
THE3#-!GREEMENT/N3EPTEMBERPURSUANTTO!RTICLESANDOFTHE$35
!RTICLEOFTHE3#-!GREEMENTAND!RTICLE88)))OF'!44THE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
REQUESTEDTHATAPANELBEESTABLISHEDASITDISAGREEDWITHTHE5NITED3TATESASTOTHE
EXISTENCEORCONSISTENCYWITHACOVEREDAGREEMENTOFMEASURESTAKENTOCOMPLYWITHTHE
RECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"!TITSMEETINGOF3EPTEMBERTHE$3"
ESTABLISHEDTHEPANEL"RAZIL+OREAAND#HINARESERVEDTHEIRRIGHTSASTHIRDPARTIES/N
/CTOBERTHE0ANELWASCOMPOSED/N*ANUARYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANEL
INFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHE0ANELEXPECTEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORKIN-AY
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
5NITED3TATESn#OUNTERVAILINGDUTIESONCERTAINCORROSIONRESISTANTCARBONSTEEL
FLATPRODUCTSFROM'ERMANY74$3
!TTHE$3"MEETINGOF!PRILTHE5NITED3TATESINFORMEDTHATITHADFULLY
IMPLEMENTEDTHE$3"SRECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSON!PRILBYREVOKINGTHE
COUNTERVAILINGDUTYORDERONCORROSIONRESISTANTCARBONSTEELFLATPRODUCTSFROM'ERMANY
5NITED3TATESn#ONTINUED$UMPINGAND3UBSIDY/FFSET!CTOFJOINT
COMPLAINTBY!USTRALIA"RAZIL#HILE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES)NDIA)NDONESIA
*APAN+OREAAND4HAILAND74$3AND#ANADAAND-EXICO74$3
&ORINFORMATIONREGARDINGTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE!NNUAL2EPORTPP
ANDFORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE0ANEL2EPORTSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
FORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTANDTHEARBITRATIONUNDER!RTICLECOFTHE
$35SEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N*ANUARYTHE$3"WASINFORMEDTHATTHE5NITED3TATESHADMUTUALLYAGREED
TOMODIFYTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEWITH4HAILAND!USTRALIAAND)NDONESIARESPECTIVELY
SOASTOEXPIREON$ECEMBER/N*ANUARYONTHEGROUNDSTHATTHE5NITED
3TATESHADFAILEDTOIMPLEMENTTHE$3"RECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSWITHINTHEREASONABLE
PERIODOFTIME"RAZIL#HILETHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES)NDIA*APAN+OREA#ANADAAND
-EXICOREQUESTEDTHE$3"SAUTHORIZATIONTOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOF
THE$35/N*ANUARYTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTEDINACCORDANCEWITH!RTICLE
OFTHE$35THATTHEMATTERBEREFERREDTOARBITRATIONSINCETHE5NITED3TATESOBJECTEDTOTHE
LEVELOFSUSPENSIONOFCONCESSIONSPROPOSEDBYTHEFOREGOINGPARTIES!TITSMEETINGON
*ANUARYTHE$3"DECIDEDTOREFERTHEMATTERTOARBITRATION
/N!UGUSTTHEARBITRATORCIRCULATEDITSDECISIONS4HE!RBITRATORAREJECTED
THEPOSITIONOF"RAZIL#ANADA#HILETHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES)NDIA*APAN+OREAAND
-EXICOTHATTHELEVELOFSUSPENSIONOFCONCESSIONSOROTHEROBLIGATIONSSHOULDBEEQUIVALENT
TOTHEDISBURSEMENTSMADEBYTHE5NITED3TATESUNDERTHEMEASUREATISSUEIE#$3/!
4HE!RBITRATORCONSIDEREDTHATTHISINTERPRETATIONWASNOTSUPPORTEDBYTHETERMSOF!RTICLE
88)))OF'!44ORTHE$354HE!RBITRATORFOUNDITAPPROPRIATETORELYONTHEECONOMIC
EFFECTOFTHEMEASUREASINPREVIOUS!RTICLEARBITRATIONSB4HE!RBITRATORAPPLIED
ANECONOMICMODELAIMEDATASSESSINGTHEEFFECTOFDISBURSEMENTSUNDERTHE#$3/!
ONEXPORTSOFTHEABOVEMENTIONED-EMBERSTOTHE5NITED3TATESANDCAMEUPWITHA
COEFFICIENTWHICHMULTIPLIEDBYTHEAMOUNTSDISBURSEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESUNDERTHE
#$3/!INRELATIONTOANTIDUMPINGORCOUNTERVAILINGDUTIESCOLLECTEDONIMPORTSFROMEACH
OFTHETHOSE-EMBERSGAVEANASSESSMENTOFTHEECONOMICEFFECTOFTHE#$3/!ONEXPORTS
FROMEACHOFTHOSE-EMBERSFORAGIVENPERIODC4HE!RBITRATORSDECISIONSDONOTPROVIDE
FORANACTUALSINGLEVALUEOFTRADENOTTOBEEXCEEDEDBYTHEABOVEMENTIONED-EMBERS
WHENSUSPENDINGCONCESSIONSOROTHEROBLIGATIONSVISÌVISTHE5NITED3TATES4HEAWARDS
ALLOWTHOSE-EMBERSTOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSOROTHEROBLIGATIONSUPTOAMAXIMUMVALUE
OFTRADETOBECALCULATEDBYMULTIPLYINGTHEPUBLISHEDAMOUNTOFDISBURSEMENTSUNDERTHE
#$3/!FORAGIVENYEARBYTHECOEFFICIENTCALCULATEDBYTHE!RBITRATOR
/N.OVEMBER"RAZILTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES)NDIA*APAN+OREA#ANADA
AND-EXICOREQUESTEDAUTHORIZATIONTOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSOROTHEROBLIGATIONSUNDER
!RTICLEOFTHE$35!TITSMEETINGOF.OVEMBERTHE$3"AUTHORIZEDTHE
SUSPENSIONOFCONCESSIONS/N$ECEMBER#HILEREQUESTEDAUTHORIZATIONTOSUSPEND
CONCESSIONSOROTHEROBLIGATIONSUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35!TISMEETINGOF
$ECEMBERTHE$3"AUTHORIZEDTHESUSPENSIONOFCONCESSIONS
/N$ECEMBERAND*ANUARY!USTRALIA4HAILANDAND)NDONESIA
RESPECTIVELYREACHEDAN5NDERSTANDINGWITHTHE5NITED3TATESWITHRESPECTTOTHISDISPUTE
!TITSMEETINGOF*ANUARYTHE$3"AGREEDTOTAKENOTEOFTHESE5NDERSTANDINGS
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn!NTIDUMPINGDUTIESONMALLEABLECASTIRONTUBEOR
PIPEFITTINGSFROM"RAZILCOMPLAINTBY"RAZIL74$3
&ORDETAILSREGARDINGTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELANDSUSPENSIONANDRESUMPTION
OFTHE0ANELSWORKSEE!NNUAL2EPORTPFORDETAILSCONCERNINGTHE0ANELAND
!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N-ARCHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITHADREASSESSED
ITSFINDINGSRELATEDTOTHECONTESTEDMEASUREBYTAKINGFULLYINTOACCOUNTTHEFINDINGSAND
CONCLUSIONSSETOUTINTHE0ANELAND!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTSASEXPLAINEDINTHE#OUNCIL
2EGULATION%#.OOF-ARCHANDTHUSHADFULLYCOMPLIEDWITHTHE$3"
RULINGSANDRECOMMENDATIONSINTHISDISPUTEANDWITHINTHEDEADLINEAGREEDUPONBETWEEN
THEDISPUTINGPARTIES!TTHE$3"MEETINGON!PRIL"RAZILCONTESTEDTHISASSERTION
"RAZILSTATEDTHATWHEREASITWASTRUETHATTHE%#HADRECALCULATEDTHEDUMPINGMARGIN
WITHOUTUSINGTHEZEROINGMETHODOLOGYITHADNOTFULLYIMPLEMENTEDTHEFINDINGSOFTHE
!PPELLATE"ODYRELATINGTOTHEDUEPROCESSREQUIREMENTSCONTAINEDINTHE!NTI$UMPING
!GREEMENT4HE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESDISPUTED"RAZILSCLAIM
-EXICOn-EASURESAFFECTINGTHEIMPORTOFMATCHESCOMPLAINTBY#HILE
74$3
/N&EBRUARY#HILEINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWISHEDFORMALLYTOWITHDRAWTHE
REQUESTFORCONSULTATIONSANDBRINGTHISMATTERTOACLOSEASITSCOMPLAINTSHADBEEN
ADEQUATELYMETASARESULTOFNEGOTIATIONSWITH-EXICO
5NITED3TATESn3UNSETREVIEWOFANTIDUMPINGDUTIESONCORROSIONRESISTANT
CARBONSTEELFLATPRODUCTSFROM*APANCOMPLAINTBY*APAN74$3
&ORFURTHERDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEREQUESTFORESTABLISHMENTOFTHEPANELSEE74/!NNUAL
2EPORTPFORDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEPANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSSEE74/
!NNUAL2EPORTPP
/N*ANUARYTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTANDTHE0ANEL2EPORTAS
MODIFIEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORT
*APANn-EASURESAFFECTINGTHEIMPORTATIONOFAPPLESCOMPLAINTBYTHE5NITED
3TATES74$3
&ORFURTHERDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEREQUESTFORESTABLISHMENTOFAPANELSEE74/!NNUAL
2EPORTPFORINFORMATIONONTHEPANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSSEE74/
!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N&EBRUARY*APANANDTHE5NITED3TATESINFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHEYHADAGREED
THATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEFORTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE$3"SRECOMMENDATIONSAND
RULINGSWOULDBEFROM$ECEMBERTO*UNE/N*UNETHEPARTIES
INFORMEDTHE$3"OFAN5NDERSTANDINGREGARDINGPROCEDURESUNDER!RTICLESANDOFTHE
$35/N*ULYTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTEDTHE$3"TOESTABLISHAPANELUNDER!RTICLE
OFTHE$35ANDAUTHORIZATIONTOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSOROTHEROBLIGATIONSWITHRESPECT
TO*APANUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35)NACCORDANCEWITH*APANSREQUESTTHISLATTERMATTER
WASREFERREDTOARBITRATIONATTHE$3"MEETINGOF*ULY/N!UGUSTBOTH
PARTIESREQUESTEDTHE!RBITRATORTOSUSPENDTHEARBITRATIONPROCEEDINGUNTILADOPTIONBYTHE
$3"OFITSRECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHEFORMERPROCEEDINGIETHEPANELPROCEEDING
UNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35)NRESPECTOFTHEPANELPROCEEDINGUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE
$35ATITSMEETINGON*ULYTHE$3"DECIDEDTOREFERTHEMATTERRAISEDBYTHE5NITED
3TATESTOTHEORIGINALPANEL!USTRALIA"RAZIL#HINATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES.EW:EALAND
AND#HINESE4AIPEIRESERVEDTHEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS/N/CTOBERTHE0ANELINFORMED
THE$3"THATDUEINPARTICULARTOTHENEEDTOCONSULTSCIENTIFICEXPERTSTHE0ANELWASNOTABLE
TOISSUEITSREPORTWITHINDAYSANDTHATTHE0ANELEXPECTEDTOCIRCULATEITSFINALREPORTTO
-EMBERSDURINGTHESECONDHALFOFTHEMONTHOF-AY
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
!RGENTINAn$EFINITIVESAFEGUARDMEASUREONIMPORTSOFPRESERVEDPEACHES
COMPLAINTBY#HILE74$3
&ORDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELANDTHE0ANELREPORTSEE74/
!NNUAL2EPORTP
!TTHE$3"MEETINGOF*ANUARY!RGENTINAANNOUNCEDTHATTHESAFEGUARD
MEASUREATISSUEHADBEENWITHDRAWNON$ECEMBERINLINEWITHTHEAGREEMENT
REACHEDBETWEEN!RGENTINAAND#HILEANDTHUSINITSVIEWITHADIMPLEMENTEDTHE$3"S
RECOMMENDATIONS#HILEWELCOMEDTHEWITHDRAWALOFTHEMEASUREBY!RGENTINA
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn#ONDITIONSFORTHEGRANTINGOFTARIFFPREFERENCESTO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESCOMPLAINTBY)NDIA74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHE0ANEL2EPORTSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N*ANUARYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESNOTIFIEDTHE$3"OFITSDECISIONTOAPPEAL
CERTAINISSUESOFLAWCOVEREDINTHE0ANEL2EPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPED
BYTHEPANELANDITFILEDA.OTICEOF!PPEALWITHTHE!PPELLATE"ODY/N!PRILTHE
!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE!PPELLATE"ODYUPHELDTHE0ANELS
FINDINGTHATTHE%NABLING#LAUSEOPERATESASANEXCEPTIONTO!RTICLE)OFTHE'!44
ANDTHEREFORETHATTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESASTHERESPONDINGPARTYWASREQUIREDTO
PROVETHATITSSPECIALARRANGEMENTSTOCOMBATDRUGPRODUCTIONANDTRAFFICKINGSATISFYTHE
CONDITIONSSETOUTINTHE%NABLING#LAUSE(OWEVERINCONTRASTTOTHE0ANELTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYFOUNDTHATTHECOMPLAININGPARTYISOBLIGEDTORAISETHERELEVANTPROVISIONSOFTHE
%NABLING#LAUSEINMAKINGITSCLAIM4HE!PPELLATE"ODYFOUNDTHAT)NDIAHADSUFFICIENTLY
RAISEDPARAGRAPHAOFTHE%NABLING#LAUSEBEFORETHE0ANEL4HE!PPELLATE"ODYREVERSED
THE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHETERMNONDISCRIMINATORYINFOOTNOTETOPARAGRAPHAOF
THE%NABLING#LAUSEREQUIRESTHEPROVISIONOFIDENTICALTARIFFPREFERENCESTOALLDEVELOPING
COUNTRIESWITHOUTDIFFERENTIATIONEXCEPTASREGARDSAPRIORILIMITATIONSONIMPORTSFROM
CERTAINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES.EVERTHELESSTHE!PPELLATE"ODYUPHELDFORDIFFERENTREASONS
THE0ANELSCONCLUSIONTHATTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESFAILEDTODEMONSTRATETHATITS
CHALLENGEDMEASUREISJUSTIFIEDUNDERPARAGRAPHAOFTHE%NABLING#LAUSE
!TITSMEETINGON!PRILTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTANDTHE
0ANELREPORTASMODIFIEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORT
!TTHE$3"MEETINGON-AYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREAFFIRMEDITSINTENTION
TOFULLYCOMPLYWITHTHERECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"INAMANNERTHATRESPECTED
ITS74/OBLIGATIONSANDTHATITWOULDNEEDAREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMETOIMPLEMENTTHE
RECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"ANDWASWILLINGTODISCUSSTHISMATTERWITH)NDIA
INACCORDANCEWITH!RTICLEBOFTHE$35/N*ULY)NDIAREQUESTEDTHATTHE
REASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEBEDETERMINEDTHROUGHBINDINGARBITRATIONPURSUANTTO!RTICLE
COFTHE$35DUETOTHEFAILURETOREACHANAGREEMENTWITHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
ONTHISMATTER/N!UGUSTPURSUANTTO)NDIASREQUESTOF*ULYTHE$IRECTOR
'ENERALAPPOINTEDANARBITRATORUNDER!RTICLECOFTHE$35/N3EPTEMBER
THE!RBITRATORDECIDEDTHATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEFORIMPLEMENTATIONWOULDEXPIRE
ON*ULY
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
5NITED3TATESn%QUALIZING%XCISE4AXIMPOSEDBY&LORIDAONPROCESSEDORANGE
ANDGRAPEFRUITPRODUCTSCOMPLAINTBY"RAZIL74$3
&ORDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N-AYTHE5NITED3TATESAND"RAZILINFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHEYHADREACHEDA
MUTUALLYAGREEDSOLUTIONUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35
5NITED3TATESn&INALCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYDETERMINATIONWITHRESPECTTOCERTAIN
SOFTWOODLUMBERFROM#ANADACOMPLAINTBY#ANADA74$3
&ORFURTHERDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEREQUESTFORESTABLISHMENTOFA0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL
2EPORTPPFORINFORMATIONONTHEPANELREPORTANDTHENOTIFICATIONTOTHE
$3"OFTHE5NITED3TATESDECISIONTOAPPEALTHEPANELREPORTSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYCIRCULATEDITS2EPORTTO-EMBERSON*ANUARY4HE!PPELLATE
"ODYUPHELDTHE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHE5NITED3TATESHADCORRECTLYDETERMINEDTHAT
HARVESTINGRIGHTSGRANTEDBY#ANADIANPROVINCIALGOVERNMENTSINRESPECTOFSTANDINGTIMBER
CONSTITUTETHEPROVISIONOFGOODSUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE3#-!GREEMENT4HE!PPELLATE
"ODYREVERSEDTHE0ANELSINTERPRETATIONOF!RTICLEDOFTHE3#-!GREEMENTANDTHUS
ALSOREVERSEDTHE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHE5NITED3TATESHADIMPROPERLYDETERMINEDTHE
EXISTENCEANDAMOUNTOFTHEBENEFITRESULTINGFROMTHEFINANCIALCONTRIBUTIONPROVIDED
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYEXAMINEDTHISISSUEINTHELIGHTOFITSOWNINTERPRETATIONOF!RTICLED
BUTFOUNDTHATITWASUNABLETOCOMPLETETHELEGALANALYSISOFWHETHERTHE5NITED3TATES
HADCORRECTLYDETERMINEDBENEFITINTHISINVESTIGATIONDUETOINSUFFICIENTFACTUALFINDINGSBY
THE0ANELANDINSUFFICIENTUNDISPUTEDFACTSINTHE0ANELRECORD4HE!PPELLATE"ODYUPHELD
THE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHE5NITED3TATESACTEDINCONSISTENTLYWITHPROVISIONSOFTHE3#-
!GREEMENTANDTHE'!44BYFAILINGTOANALYZEWHETHERSUBSIDIESWEREPASSEDTHROUGH
INSALESOFLOGSBYTIMBERHARVESTERSWHOOWNSAWMILLSTOUNRELATEDPRODUCERSOFSOFTWOOD
LUMBER4HE!PPELLATE"ODYHOWEVERREVERSEDTHE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHE5NITED3TATES
ACTEDINCONSISTENTLYWITHITS74/OBLIGATIONSBYFAILINGTOCONSIDERWHETHERSUBSIDIESWERE
PASSEDTHROUGHINSALESOFLUMBERBYSAWMILLSTOUNRELATEDLUMBERREMANUFACTURERS
/N&EBRUARYTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTANDTHE0ANEL2EPORT
ASMODIFIEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORT
/N!PRIL#ANADAANDTHE5NITED3TATESINFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHEYHADAGREED
THATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMESHOULDBETENMONTHSTHATISFROM&EBRUARYTO
$ECEMBER/N$ECEMBERCONSIDERINGTHATTHEMEASURESALLEGEDLYTAKENBY
THE5NITED3TATESTOCOMPLYWITHTHE$3"SRECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSWEREINCONSISTENT
WITH53OBLIGATIONSUNDERTHERELEVANT74/!GREEMENTS#ANADAREQUESTEDTHEESTABLISHMENT
OFAPANELUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35ANDAUTHORIZATIONTOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSOROTHER
OBLIGATIONSWITHRESPECTTOTHE5NITED3TATESUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35/N*ANUARY
INRESPECTOFTHE!RTICLEPROCEEDINGTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTEDTHATTHEMATTER
BEREFERREDTOARBITRATIONINACCORDANCEWITH!RTICLEOFTHE$35!TITSMEETINGOF
*ANUARYTHE$3"SOAGREED)NRESPECTOFTHE!RTICLEPROCEEDINGATTHESAME
MEETINGTHE$3"DECIDEDTOREFERTHEMATTERRAISEDBY#ANADATOTHEORIGINALPANEL#HINA
ANDTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESRESERVEDTHEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS0URSUANTTOABILATERAL
AGREEMENTESTABLISHEDBETWEEN#ANADAANDTHE5NITED3TATESTHE!RTICLEARBITRATION
PROCEEDINGWASSUSPENDEDUNTILTHECOMPLETIONOFTHE!RTICLEPROCEEDING
5RUGUAYn4AXTREATMENTONCERTAINPRODUCTSCOMPLAINTBY#HILE74$3
&ORINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N*ANUARY#HILEAND5RUGUAYINFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHEYHADREACHEDA
MUTUALLYAGREEDSOLUTIONUNDER!RTICLEPARAGRAPHSANDOFTHE$35
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
5NITED3TATESn&INALDUMPINGDETERMINATIONONSOFTWOODLUMBERFROM#ANADA
COMPLAINTBY#ANADA74$3
&ORDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N!PRILTHE0ANELREPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUNDTHATIN
ITSFINALDUMPINGDETERMINATIONTHE53$EPARTMENTOF#OMMERCE$/#FAILEDTOCOMPLY
WITHTHEREQUIREMENTSOF!RTICLESOFTHE!$!GREEMENTBECAUSEITDIDNOTTAKEINTO
ACCOUNTALLEXPORTTRANSACTIONSBYAPPLYINGTHEZEROINGMETHODOLOGYWHENCALCULATINGTHE
MARGINOFDUMPING/NEMEMBEROFTHE0ANELISSUEDADISSENTINGOPINIONREGARDINGTHE
FINDINGONZEROING4HE0ANELFOUNDTHATALLOTHERCLAIMSSUBMITTEDBY#ANADAFAILED
/N-AYTHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAINISSUESOFLAW
COVEREDINTHE0ANEL2EPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE0ANEL/N
!UGUSTTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE!PPELLATE"ODY
UPHELDTHE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHE5NITED3TATESACTEDINCONSISTENTLYWITH!RTICLE
OFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTINDETERMININGTHEEXISTENCEOFMARGINSOFDUMPINGON
THEBASISOFAMETHODOLOGYINCORPORATINGTHEPRACTICEOFZEROING4HE!PPELLATE"ODY
FURTHERMOREREVERSEDTHE0ANELSFINDINGTHATTHE5NITED3TATESDIDNOTACTINCONSISTENTLY
WITH!RTICLESANDOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTINITSCALCULATION
OFTHEAMOUNTFORFINANCIALEXPENSEFORSOFTWOODLUMBERFOR!BITIBI#OMPANYnONEOFTHE
#ANADIANCOMPANIESUNDERINVESTIGATIONnBUTDIDNOTMAKEFINDINGSONWHETHERTHE5NITED
3TATESACTEDCONSISTENTLYORINCONSISTENTLYWITHTHESEPROVISIONS4HE!PPELLATE"ODYALSO
UPHELDTHE0ANELSFINDINGSTHATTHE5NITED3TATESDIDNOTACTINCONSISTENTLYWITH!RTICLES
ANDOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTINITSCALCULATIONOFTHEAMOUNTFOR
BYPRODUCTREVENUEFROMTHESALEOFWOODCHIPSASOFFSETSINTHECASEOF4EMBEC#OMPANY
ANOTHEROFTHE#ANADIANCOMPANIESUNDERINVESTIGATION
!TITSMEETINGON!UGUSTTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTANDTHE
0ANELREPORTASMODIFIEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORT
/N/CTOBER#ANADAREQUESTEDTHATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEBE
DETERMINEDTHROUGHBINDINGARBITRATIONPURSUANTTO!RTICLECOFTHE$35/N
$ECEMBER#ANADAANDTHE5NITED3TATESINFORMEDTHE$3"THATPURSUANTTO
!RTICLEBOFTHE$35THEYHADMUTUALLYAGREEDTHATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIME
TOIMPLEMENTTHERECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"WOULDBESEVENANDONEHALF
MONTHSTHATISFROM!UGUSTTO!PRIL)NADDITIONTHEYINFORMEDTHAT
INLIGHTOFTHEAGREEMENTTHEPROCEEDINGUNDER!RTICLECOFTHE$35SHOULDBE
TERMINATED/N$ECEMBERTHE2EPORTOF!RBITRATORWASCIRCULATEDNOTINGTHATIN
LIGHTOFTHEABOVEAGREEMENTBETWEENTHEPARTIESITWOULDNOTBENECESSARYFORHIMTOISSUE
ANAWARD
5NITED3TATESn3UBSIDIESONUPLANDCOTTONCOMPLAINTBY"RAZIL74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N3EPTEMBERTHEREPORTOFTHE0ANELWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANEL
FOUNDTHATAAGRICULTURALEXPORTCREDITGUARANTEESARESUBJECTTO74/EXPORTSUBSIDY
DISCIPLINESANDTHREE5NITED3TATESEXPORTCREDITGUARANTEEPROGRAMMESAREPROHIBITEDEXPORT
SUBSIDIESWHICHHAVENO0EACE#LAUSEPROTECTIONANDAREINVIOLATIONOFTHOSEDISCIPLINESB
THE5NITED3TATESALSOGRANTSOTHERPROHIBITEDSUBSIDIESINRESPECTOFCOTTONANDC5NITED
3TATESDOMESTICSUPPORTPROGRAMMESINRESPECTOFCOTTONARENOTPROTECTEDBYTHE0EACE
#LAUSEANDCERTAINOFTHESEPROGRAMMESRESULTINSERIOUSPREJUDICETO"RAZILSINTERESTSINTHE
FORMOFPRICESUPPRESSIONINTHEWORLDMARKET
/N/CTOBERTHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDTHE$3"OFITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAIN
ISSUESOFLAWCOVEREDINTHE0ANEL2EPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE
0ANEL/N$ECEMBERTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYNOTIFIEDTHE#HAIROFTHE
$3"THATDUETOTHENUMEROUSANDCOMPLEXISSUESARISINGINTHEDISPUTETHEINTERVENING
74/HOLIDAYPERIODANDTHEOTHERAPPEALSEXPECTEDDURINGTHESAMEPERIODTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYWOULDBEUNABLETOISSUEITSREPORTWITHINTHEDAYPERIODREFERREDTOIN!RTICLE
OFTHE$35"RAZILANDTHE5NITED3TATESCONFIRMEDTHATTHEYWOULDDEEMTHE!PPELLATE
"ODY2EPORTINTHISPROCEEDINGISSUEDNOLATERTHAN-ARCHTOBEAN!PPELLATE"ODY
2EPORTCIRCULATEDPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE$35
5NITED3TATESn3UNSETREVIEWSOFANTIDUMPINGMEASURESONOILCOUNTRYTUBULAR
GOODSFROM!RGENTINACOMPLAINTBY!RGENTINA74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N*ULYTHEREPORTOFTHE0ANELWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUND
THATA#ERTAINPROVISIONSOF5NITED3TATESLAWREGARDINGWAIVERSINSUNSETREVIEWSAND
CERTAINPROVISIONSOFTHE53$EPARTMENTOF#OMMERCE$/#3UNSET0OLICY"ULLETIN30"
CONCERNINGTHE$/#SOBLIGATIONTODETERMINELIKELIHOODOFCONTINUATIONORRECURRENCE
OFDUMPINGINSUNSETREVIEWSWEREINCONSISTENTWITH5NITED3TATESOBLIGATIONSUNDER
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
CERTAINPROVISIONSOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT7ITHRESPECTTOTHE$/#SLIKELIHOOD
DETERMINATIONSINTHE/#4'OILCOUNTRYTUBULARGOODSSUNSETREVIEWTHE0ANELFOUNDTHAT
THE$/#ACTEDINCONSISTENTLYWITHCERTAINPROVISIONSOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTBUT
THATITDIDNOTACTINCONSISTENTLYWITHOTHERPROVISIONSOFTHAT!GREEMENTANDBTHE5NITED
3TATESLAWSSTANDARDFORTHELIKELIHOODOFCONTINUATIONORRECURRENCEOFINJURYDETERMINATIONS
INSUNSETREVIEWSANDTHE)4#SDETERMINATIONSINTHE/#4'SUNSETREVIEWWERENOT
INCONSISTENTWITHTHERELEVANTARTICLESOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT
5NITED3TATESn3UNSETREVIEWSOFANTIDUMPINGMEASURESONOILCOUNTRYTUBULAR
GOODSFROM!RGENTINACOMPLAINTBY!RGENTINA74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N*ULYTHEREPORTOFTHE0ANELWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUND
THATA#ERTAINPROVISIONSOF5NITED3TATESLAWREGARDINGWAIVERSINSUNSETREVIEWSAND
CERTAINPROVISIONSOFTHE3UNSET0OLICY"ULLETIN30"CONCERNINGTHE$/#S$EPARTMENTOF
#OMMERCEOBLIGATIONTODETERMINELIKELIHOODOFCONTINUATIONORRECURRENCEOFDUMPINGIN
SUNSETREVIEWSWEREINCONSISTENTWITH5NITED3TATESOBLIGATIONSUNDERCERTAINPROVISIONS
OFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT7ITHRESPECTTOTHE$/#SLIKELIHOODDETERMINATIONSIN
THE/#4'OILCOUNTRYTUBULARGOODSSUNSETREVIEWTHE0ANELFOUNDTHATTHE$/#ACTED
INCONSISTENTLYWITHCERTAINPROVISIONSOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTBUTTHATITDIDNOT
ACTINCONSISTENTLYWITHOTHERPROVISIONSOFTHAT!GREEMENTANDBTHE5NITED3TATESLAWS
STANDARDFORTHELIKELIHOODOFCONTINUATIONORRECURRENCEOFINJURYDETERMINATIONSINSUNSET
REVIEWSANDTHE)4#SDETERMINATIONSINTHE/#4'SUNSETREVIEWWERENOTINCONSISTENTWITH
THERELEVANTARTICLESOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT
/N!UGUSTTHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDITSINTENTIONTOAPPEALCERTAINISSUESOFLAW
COVEREDINTHEPANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE0ANEL4HE
!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTWASCIRCULATEDON.OVEMBER4HE!PPELLATE"ODYREVERSEDTHE
0ANELSFINDINGTHATONEPROVISIONOFTHE3UNSET0OLICY"ULLETINWASINCONSISTENTASSUCHWITH
!RTICLEOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT4HE!PPELLATE"ODYALSOFOUNDTHATTHE0ANELHAD
NOTMETITSOBLIGATIONUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35TOMAKEANOBJECTIVEASSESSMENTOFTHE
MATTERBEFOREITINTHEANALYSISLEADINGTOTHISFINDING4HEREFORETHE!PPELLATE"ODYWASNOT
ABLETOREACHITSOWNCONCLUSIONONTHEBASISOFTHEFACTSBEFOREITASTOTHE74/CONSISTENCY
OFTHE3UNSET0OLICY"ULLETIN4HE!PPELLATE"ODYUPHELDALLTHEOTHERFINDINGSOFTHE0ANEL
THATWEREAPPEALEDINCLUDINGTHE0ANELSFINDINGSTHATA5NITED3TATESSTATUTORYPROVISION
ANDADMINISTRATIVEREGULATIONAREINCONSISTENTASSUCHWITH!RTICLEOFTHE!NTI$UMPING
!GREEMENTANDTHATTHESAMEADMINISTRATIVEREGULATIONISALSOINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLES
ANDOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT4HE!PPELLATE"ODYUPHELDALLOFTHE0ANELSFINDINGS
ONAPPEALWITHRESPECTTOTHEINJURYRELATEDASPECTOFTHESUNSETREVIEWDETERMINATIONATISSUE
/N$ECEMBERTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTANDTHE0ANEL
2EPORTASMODIFIEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORT
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn#USTOMSCLASSIFICATIONOFFROZENBONELESSCHICKENCUTS
COMPLAINTSBY"RAZIL74$3AND4HAILAND74$3
&ORINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N*UNE"RAZILAND4HAILANDREQUESTEDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCOMPOSETHE
PANEL/N*UNETHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCOMPOSEDTHEPANEL/N*ULY#HILE
INFORMEDTHE0ANELTHATITDIDNOTWISHTOPARTICIPATEASTHIRDPARTYINTHEPANELPROCEEDINGS
/N3EPTEMBER#OLOMBIAINFORMEDTHE0ANELTHATITDIDNOTWISHTOPARTICIPATE
ASTHIRDPARTYINTHEPANELPROCEEDINGS/N.OVEMBERTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANEL
INFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBEABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORKINSIXMONTHSDUETOTHE
COMPLEXITYOFTHECASEANDTHESENSITIVITYOFTHELEGALANDFACTUALQUESTIONSTHATHADBEEN
RAISEDANDTHATTHE0ANELHOPEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORKBYTHEENDOF-ARCH
+OREAn-EASURESAFFECTINGTRADEINCOMMERCIALVESSELSCOMPLAINTBY
THE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N-AYFOLLOWINGTHEPASSINGAWAYON!PRILOFTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE
0ANELANDPURSUANTTOAJOINTREQUESTOFTHEPARTIESON-AYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
APPOINTEDANEW#HAIRMANTOTHE0ANEL
#ANADAn-EASURESRELATINGTOEXPORTSOFWHEATANDTREATMENTOFIMPORTED
GRAINCOMPLAINTBYTHE5NITED3TATES74$3
&ORDETAILSCONCERNINGTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
/N!PRILTHE0ANELREPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUNDTHATA
THE5NITED3TATESHADFAILEDTOESTABLISHITSCLAIMTHAT#ANADAHADBREACHEDITSOBLIGATIONS
UNDER!RTICLE86))OFTHE'!44WITHRESPECTTOTHE#ANADIAN7HEAT"OARD#7"B
3ECTIONCOFTHE#ANADA'RAIN!CTAND3ECTIONOFTHE#ANADA'RAIN2EGULATIONS
WEREINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLE)))OFTHE'!44ANDWERENOTJUSTIFIEDUNDER
!RTICLE88DOFTHE'!44C3ECTIONSANDOFTHE#ANADA4RANSPORTATION
!CTWEREINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLE)))OF'!44ANDDTHE5NITED3TATESHADFAILEDTO
ESTABLISHITSCLAIMTHATSECTIONOFTHE#ANADA'RAIN!CTWASINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLE)))
OFTHE'!44AND!RTICLEOFTHE42)-S!GREEMENT
/N*UNETHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAINISSUESOFLAW
COVEREDINTHE0ANEL2EPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE0ANEL/N
!UGUSTTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE!PPELLATE"ODY
FOUNDTHATSUBPARAGRAPHSAANDBOF!RTICLE86))OFTHE'!443TATE4RADING
%NTERPRISESARENECESSARILYRELATEDTOEACHOTHERSUBPARAGRAPHAISTHEGENERALAND
PRINCIPALPROVISIONANDSUBPARAGRAPHBEXPLAINSITBYIDENTIFYINGTHETYPESOFDIFFERENTIAL
TREATMENTINCOMMERCIALTRANSACTIONSTHATAREMOSTLIKELYTOOCCURINPRACTICE4HEREFOREIN
MOSTIFNOTALLCASESPANELSWOULDNOTBEINAPOSITIONTOMAKEANYFINDINGOFVIOLATIONOF
!RTICLE86))UNTILTHEYHAVEPROPERLYINTERPRETEDANDAPPLIEDSUBPARAGRAPHSAANDB
OFTHAT!RTICLE)NTHEPRESENTDISPUTEALTHOUGHTHE0ANELASSUMEDTHATINCONSISTENCYWITH
SUBPARAGRAPHBISSUFFICIENTTOESTABLISHABREACHOF!RTICLE86))ITSANALYTICALAPPROACH
WASNEVERTHELESSCONSISTENTWITHTHE!PPELLATE"ODYSINTERPRETATIONOFTHERELATIONSHIP
BETWEENSUBPARAGRAPHSAANDB4HE!PPELLATE"ODYFOUNDTHATTHE5NITED3TATESCLAIM
RELATINGTOTHEPHRASESOLELYBASEDONCOMMERCIALCONSIDERATIONINTHEFIRSTCLAUSEOF
SUBPARAGRAPHBOF!RTICLE86))WASBASEDONAMISCHARACTERIZATIONOFASTATEMENTMADE
BYTHE0ANELANDTHEREFOREDISMISSEDTHISGROUNDOFAPPEAL)NEXAMININGANADDITIONAL
ARGUMENTSUBMITTEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESTHE!PPELLATE"ODYAGREEDWITHTHE0ANELTHAT
ALTHOUGHSTATETRADINGENTERPRISES34%SMUSTACTINACCORDANCEWITHCOMMERCIAL
CONSIDERATIONSTHISISNOTEQUIVALENTTOANOUTRIGHTPROHIBITIONON34%SUSINGTHEIRPRIVILEGES
WHENEVERSUCHUSEMIGHTDISADVANTAGEPRIVATEENTERPRISES4HE!PPELLATE"ODYUPHELD
THE0ANELSINTERPRETATIONOFTHETERMENTERPRISESINTHESECONDCLAUSEOFSUBPARAGRAPH
BOF!RTICLE86)))NADDITIONTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREJECTEDTHE5NITED3TATESCLAIMSTHAT
THE0ANELHADFAILEDTOEXAMINETHEMEASURECHALLENGEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESINITSENTIRETY
ANDHADNOTDISCHARGEDITSOBLIGATIONSUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35&INALLYTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYUPHELDTHE0ANELSFINDINGTHATINTHEPARTICULARCIRCUMSTANCESOFTHISCASE#ANADAS
PRELIMINARYOBJECTIONTOTHEADEQUACYOFTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTFORESTABLISHMENTOFA
PANELUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35WASNOTUNTIMELYSOLELYBECAUSEITWASNOTRAISEDATTHE
$3"MEETINGSATWHICHTHEPANELREQUESTWASCONSIDERED
!TITSMEETINGON3EPTEMBERTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTAND
THE0ANELREPORTASUPHELDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYREPORT
/N.OVEMBER#ANADAANDTHE5NITED3TATESINFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHEY
HADAGREEDTHATTHEREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMESHOULDBEMONTHSANDDAYSTHATIS
3EPTEMBERTO!UGUST
5NITED3TATESn)NVESTIGATIONOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#OMMISSIONINSOFTWOOD
LUMBERFROM#ANADACOMPLAINTBY#ANADA74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N-ARCHTHE0ANELREPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUNDTHATIN
ITSFINALTHREATOFINJURYDETERMINATIONTHE53)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#OMMISSION53)4#FAILED
TOCOMPLYWITHTHEREQUIREMENTSOF!RTICLESANDTHE!$!GREEMENTAND!RTICLE
ANDOFTHE3#-!GREEMENTINFINDINGALIKELYIMMINENTSUBSTANTIALINCREASEINIMPORTS
ANDACAUSALLINKBETWEENIMPORTSANDTHREATOFINJURYTOTHEDOMESTICINDUSTRYINTHE5NITED
3TATESPRODUCINGSOFTWOODLUMBER4HE0ANELFOUNDTHATTHE53)4#SFINDINGOFLIKELIHOODOF
SUBSTANTIALLYINCREASEDIMPORTSWASNOTCONSISTENTWITHTHEREQUIREMENTSOFTHE!GREEMENTS
ANDTHATTHECAUSATIONCONCLUSIONRESTEDONTHISINCONSISTENTFINDING4HE0ANELTHEREFORE
FOUNDTHATTHEANTIDUMPINGANDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESIMPOSEDBYTHE5NITED3TATES
ONIMPORTSOFSOFTWOODLUMBERFROM#ANADAWEREINCONSISTENTWITHTHE5NITED3TATES
OBLIGATIONSUNDERTHOSEPROVISIONSANDRECOMMENDEDTHATTHOSEMEASURESBEBROUGHTINTO
CONFORMITYWITH5NITED3TATESOBLIGATIONS
!TITSMEETINGON!PRILTHE$3"ADOPTEDTHE0ANELREPORT/N/CTOBER
BOTHPARTIESJOINTLYINFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHEYHADMUTUALLYAGREEDTHATTHEREASONABLE
PERIODOFTIMETOIMPLEMENTTHERECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"WOULDBENINE
MONTHSTHATISFROM!PRILTO*ANUARY!TTHE$3"MEETINGON*ANUARY
THE5NITED3TATESSTATEDTHATITHADIMPLEMENTEDTHE$3"SRECOMMENDATIONSAND
RULINGSBYAMENDINGTHE53ANTIDUMPINGANDCOUNTERVAILINGDUTYORDERCONCERNEDAND
#ANADASTATEDITWASREVIEWINGTHERESULTSOF53IMPLEMENTATION
5NITED3TATESn!NTIDUMPINGMEASURESONIMPORTSOFCEMENTFROM-EXICO
COMPLAINTBY-EXICO74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N!UGUST-EXICOREQUESTEDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCOMPOSETHEPANEL/N
3EPTEMBERTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCOMPOSEDTHEPANEL
5NITED3TATESn!NTIDUMPINGMEASURESONOILCOUNTRYTUBULARGOODS/#4'FROM-EXICO
COMPLAINTBY-EXICO74$3
&ORINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N!UGUSTTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBE
ABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORKINSIXMONTHSANDTHATTHE0ANELEXPECTEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORKIN
-ARCH
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
-EXICOn#ERTAINMEASURESPREVENTINGTHEIMPORTATIONOFBLACKBEANSFROM
.ICARAGUACOMPLAINTBY.ICARAGUA74$3
/N-ARCH.ICARAGUAINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWISHEDFORMALLYTOWITHDRAWTHE
REQUESTFORCONSULTATIONSASITSCOMPLAINTSHADBEENADEQUATELYADDRESSEDASARESULTOF
NEGOTIATIONSWITH-EXICO
5NITED3TATESn-EASURESAFFECTINGCROSSBORDERSUPPLYOFGAMBLINGANDBETTING
SERVICESCOMPLAINTBY!NTIGUAAND"ARBUDA74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N*ANUARYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBE
POSSIBLETOCOMPLETEITSWORKINSIXMONTHSANDNOTIFIEDTHATITHOPEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORK
BYTHEENDOF!PRIL)NTHECONTEXTOFTHENEGOTIATIONSFORAMUTUALLYAGREEDSOLUTIONTO
THEDISPUTETHEPARTIESREQUESTEDTHE0ANELTOSUSPENDTHEPANELPROCEEDINGSINACCORDANCE
WITH!RTICLEOFTHE$35UNTIL!UGUST/N*UNETHE0ANELAGREED
TOTHISREQUEST4HEPARTIESSUBSEQUENTLYREQUESTEDACONTINUATIONOFTHESUSPENSIONUNTIL
/CTOBERANDTHE0ANELAGREEDTOTHEREQUESTON!UGUST
5LTIMATELYTHEPARTIESWEREUNABLETOACHIEVEAMUTUALLYAGREEDSOLUTIONANDON
.OVEMBERTHE0ANEL2EPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO74/-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUND
THATATHE'!433CHEDULEOFTHE5NITED3TATESHADBEENINTERPRETEDTOINCLUDESPECIFIC
COMMITMENTSFORGAMBLINGANDBETTINGSERVICESUNDERTHESUBSECTORENTITLED/THER
2ECREATIONAL3ERVICESEXCEPTSPORTINGBTHREE53FEDERALLAWSANDTHEPROVISIONSOFFOUR
53STATELAWSONTHEIRFACEPROHIBITEDONESEVERALORALLMEANSOFDELIVERYINCLUDEDINMODE
OF'!43IECROSSBORDERSUPPLYCONTRARYTOTHE5NITED3TATESSPECIFICMARKETACCESS
COMMITMENTSFORGAMBLINGANDBETTINGSERVICESFORMODE4HEREFORETHE5NITED3TATESHAD
FAILEDTOACCORDSERVICESANDSERVICESUPPLIERSOF!NTIGUATREATMENTNOLESSFAVOURABLETHAN
THATPROVIDEDFORUNDERTHETERMSLIMITATIONSANDCONDITIONSAGREEDANDSPECIFIEDINTHE
533CHEDULECONTRARYTO!RTICLE86)AND!RTICLE86)OFTHE'!43IECONCERNINGMARKET
ACCESSC!NTIGUAHADFAILEDTODEMONSTRATETHATTHEMEASURESATISSUEWEREINCONSISTENT
WITH!RTICLES6)AND6)OFTHE'!43IECONCERNINGDOMESTICREGULATIONDTHE5NITED
3TATESWASNOTABLETOINVOKESUCCESSFULLYTHE'!43EXCEPTIONSPROVISIONS)NTHISREGARD
THE5NITED3TATESWASNOTABLETODEMONSTRATETHATTHERELEVANTLAWSWERENECESSARY
UNDER!RTICLE8)6AAND8)6COFTHE'!43IEEXCEPTIONSPROVISIONSINCLUDINGFORPUBLIC
MORALSANDTHATTHEYWERECONSISTENTWITHTHEREQUIREMENTSOFTHECHAPEAUOF!RTICLE8)6OF
THE'!43
/N*ANUARYTHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAINISSUESOF
LAWCOVEREDINTHEPANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE0ANEL
/N*ANUARY!NTIGUAAND"ARBUDANOTIFIEDTHE$3"OFITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAIN
ISSUESOFLAWCOVEREDINTHEPANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE
0ANEL4HE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTWILLBECIRCULATEDNOLATERTHAN!PRIL
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn%XPORTSUBSIDIESONSUGARCOMPLAINTSBY!USTRALIA
74$3"RAZIL74$3AND4HAILAND74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
/N/CTOBERTHE0ANELREPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HE0ANELFOUNDINTER
ALIATHATATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESANNUALBUDGETARYOUTLAYANDQUANTITYCOMMITMENT
LEVELSFOREXPORTSOFSUBSIDIZEDSUGARWEREDETERMINEDWITHREFERENCETOTHEENTRIESSPECIFIED
IN3ECTION))0ART)6OFITS3CHEDULEANDTHATTHECONTENTOF&OOTNOTEINRELATIONTO
THESEENTRIESWASOFNOLEGALEFFECTANDDIDNOTENLARGEOROTHERWISEMODIFYTHE%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIESSPECIFIEDCOMMITMENTLEVELSBPRODUCERSEXPORTERSOF!#0)NDIAEQUIVALENT
SUGARTHATEXCEEDEDTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTLEVELSRECEIVED
SUBSIDIESWITHINTHEMEANINGOF!RTICLEAOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURECPRODUCERS
EXPORTERSOF#SUGARTHATEXCEEDEDTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTLEVELS
RECEIVEDPAYMENTSONEXPORTBYVIRTUEOFGOVERNMENTALACTIONWITHINTHEMEANINGOF!RTICLE
-EASURESAFFECTINGTHEAPPROVALANDMARKETINGOFBIOTECHPRODUCTSCOMPLAINTS
BYTHE5NITED3TATES74$3#ANADA74$3AND!RGENTINA74$3
&ORINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
/N&EBRUARYTHE5NITED3TATES#ANADAAND!RGENTINAREQUESTEDTHE
$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCOMPOSETHEPANEL/N-ARCHTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCOMPOSED
THEPANEL!RGENTINAINRESPECTOFTHE5NITED3TATESAND#ANADASCOMPLAINTS!USTRALIA
"RAZIL#ANADAINRESPECTOFTHE5NITED3TATESAND!RGENTINASCOMPLAINTS#HILE#HINA
#OLOMBIA%L3ALVADOR(ONDURAS-EXICO.EW:EALAND.ORWAY0ARAGUAY0ERU#HINESE
4AIPEI4HAILAND5RUGUAYANDTHE5NITED3TATESINRESPECTOF#ANADASAND!RGENTINAS
COMPLAINTSRESERVEDTHEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS
/N*ULYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBE
ABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORKINSIXMONTHSDUEINTERALIATOTHEPARTIESCOMMONREQUESTFOR
ADDITIONALTIMETOPREPARETHEIRREBUTTALS/N!UGUSTTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANEL
INFORMEDTHE$3"THATTHATTHE0ANELESTIMATEDTHATITWOULDISSUEITSFINALREPORTTOTHE
PARTIESBYTHEENDOF-ARCHANDTHATTHEDELAYWASDUETOTHEPARTIESCOMMON
REQUESTFORADDITIONALTIMETOPREPARETHEIRREBUTTALSASWELLASTHE0ANELSDECISIONTOSEEK
SCIENTIFICANDTECHNICALEXPERTADVICEPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENTON3ANITARY
AND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESAND!RTICLEOFTHE$35
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
COFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREITHROUGHSALESOF#BEETTO#SUGARPRODUCERS
BELOWTHEIRTOTALCOSTSOFPRODUCTIONANDIIINTHEFORMOFTRANSFERSOFFINANCIALRESOURCES
THROUGHCROSSSUBSIDIZATIONRESULTINGFROMTHEOPERATIONOFTHE%#SUGARREGIME
/N$ECEMBER!USTRALIA"RAZIL4HAILANDANDTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESNOTIFIED
THE$3"OFAPROCEDURALAGREEMENTREGARDINGTHETIMEPERIODUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE
$35REQUESTINGTHEPOSTPONEMENTOFTHECONSIDERATIONOFTHEPANELREPORTSINTHECASE
ANDSEEKINGTHEEXTENSIONOFTHECORRESPONDINGTIMEPERIODIN!RTICLEOFTHE$35UNTIL
*ANUARY
/N*ANUARYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESNOTIFIEDITSDECISIONTOCERTAINISSUES
OFLAWCOVEREDINTHEPANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHEPANEL
/N*ANUARY!USTRALIA"RAZILAND4HAILANDNOTIFIEDTHEIRDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAIN
ISSUESOFLAWCOVEREDINTHEPANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHE
PANEL/N*ANUARYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYNOTIFIEDTHE#HAIROFTHE
$3"THATINTHELIGHTOFTHECONSTRAINTSEXPRESSEDBYCERTAINPARTICIPANTSREGARDINGTHEDATE
OFTHEORALHEARINGANDTHECONCURRENTCASELOADOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYASWELLASTRANSLATION
REQUIREMENTSTHE!PPELLATE"ODYWOULDBEUNABLETOCIRCULATEITS2EPORTWITHINTHEDAY
PERIODREFERREDTOIN!RTICLEOFTHE$354HE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES!USTRALIA"RAZIL
AND4HAILANDCONFIRMEDTHATTHE!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTINTHISPROCEEDINGISSUEDNOLATER
THAN!PRILSHALLBEAN!PPELLATE"ODY2EPORTCIRCULATEDPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOF
THE$35
5NITED3TATESn,AWSREGULATIONSANDMETHODOLOGYFORCALCULATINGDUMPING
MARGINSZEROINGCOMPLAINTBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES74$3
/N*UNETHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITHTHE5NITED
3TATESCONCERNINGAMETHODOLOGYUSEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESAMONGOTHERSINTHECALCULATION
OFDUMPINGMARGINSKNOWNASZEROING4HEZEROINGMETHODOLOGYGENERALLYSPEAKING
INVOLVESTREATINGSPECIFICPRICECOMPARISONSWHICHDONOTSHOWDUMPINGASZEROVALUES
INTHECALCULATIONOFAWEIGHTEDAVERAGEDUMPINGMARGIN4HEREQUESTCONCERNEDSPECIFIC
PROVISIONSOFTHE534ARIFF!CTOFANDTHE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMERCEIMPLEMENTING
REGULATIONASWELLAS53$EPARTMENTOF#OMMERCEMETHODOLOGYANDITSDETERMINATIONSIN
SPECIFICCASESINVOLVINGPRODUCTSIMPORTEDFROMTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES4HE%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIESCONSIDEREDTHATTHE!CTREGULATIONMETHODOLOGYANDANUMBEROFSPECIFIC
DETERMINATIONSAPPEAREDTOBEINCONSISTENTWITHTHE5NITED3TATESOBLIGATIONSUNDERVARIOUS
PROVISIONSOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTTHE'!44ANDTHE74/!GREEMENT
/N&EBRUARYTHE%#REQUESTEDTHEESTABLISHMENTOFAPANEL!TITSMEETINGON
-ARCHTHE$3"ESTABLISHEDAPANEL!RGENTINA"RAZIL#HINA)NDIA*APAN+OREA
-EXICO.ORWAYAND#HINESE4AIPEIRESERVEDTHEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS/N-ARCH
(ONG+ONG#HINARESERVEDITSTHIRDPARTYRIGHT/N-ARCH4URKEYRESERVEDITSTHIRD
PARTYRIGHT/N/CTOBERTHE0ANELWASCOMPOSED
-EXICOn$EFINITIVEANTIDUMPINGMEASURESONBEEFANDRICECOMPLAINTBY
THE5NITED3TATES74$3
/N&EBRUARYTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTEDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCOMPOSETHE
0ANEL/N&EBRUARYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCOMPOSEDTHEPANEL/N!UGUST
THE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBEABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORK
INSIXMONTHSDUETOTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHEMATTERANDTHATTHE0ANELEXPECTEDTOISSUEITS
FINALREPORTTOTHEPARTIESIN.OVEMBER/N.OVEMBERTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE
0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITEXPECTEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORKIN-ARCH
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
5NITED3TATESn#OUNTERVAILINGDUTYINVESTIGATIONONDYNAMICRANDOMACCESS
MEMORYSEMICONDUCTORS$2!-SFROM+OREACOMPLAINTBY+OREA74$3
&ORDETAILSRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
&URTHERTOASECONDREQUESTTOESTABLISHAPANELBY+OREATHE$3"ESTABLISHEDAPANEL
ATITSMEETINGON*ANUARY#HINATHE%#*APANAND#HINESE4AIPEIRESERVEDTHEIR
THIRDPARTYRIGHTS/N&EBRUARY+OREAREQUESTEDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCOMPOSE
THEPANEL/N-ARCHTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCOMPOSEDTHEPANEL/N!UGUST
THE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBEABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORK
INSIXMONTHSANDTHATTHE0ANELEXPECTEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORKIN$ECEMBER
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn#OUNTERVAILINGMEASURESONDYNAMICRANDOMACCESS
MEMORYCHIPSFROM+OREACOMPLAINTBY+OREA74$3
&ORINFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
P
&URTHERTOASECONDREQUESTTOESTABLISHAPANELBY+OREATHE$3"ESTABLISHEDAPANELAT
ITSMEETINGON*ANUARY#HINA*APAN#HINESE4AIPEIANDTHE5NITED3TATESRESERVED
THEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS
/N-ARCHTHE0ANELWASCOMPOSED&OLLOWINGTHERESIGNATIONOFTHE
#HAIRPERSONON*UNEANEW#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANELWASAPPOINTEDON*ULY
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn-EASURESAFFECTINGCOMMERCIALVESSELSCOMPLAINTBY
+OREA74$3
/N3EPTEMBER+OREAREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
CONCERNINGCERTAINMEASURESBYTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESANDITSMEMBER3TATESINFAVOUR
OFTHEIRSHIPBUILDINGINDUSTRYWHICHACCORDINGTO+OREAWEREINCONSISTENTWITHTHEIR74/
OBLIGATIONS/N3EPTEMBER#HINAREQUESTEDTOJOINTHECONSULTATIONS&URTHERTO
ASECONDREQUESTTOESTABLISHAPANELBY+OREATHE$3"ESTABLISHEDAPANELATITSMEETING
ON-ARCH#HINA*APANANDTHE5NITED3TATESRESERVEDTHEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS/N
-AYTHE0ANELWASCOMPOSED/N.OVEMBERTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE0ANEL
INFORMEDTHE$3"THATITWOULDNOTBEABLETOCOMPLETEITSWORKINSIXMONTHSANDTHATTHE
0ANELHOPEDTOCOMPLETEITSWORKBYTHEENDOF&EBRUARY
$OMINICAN2EPUBLICn-EASURESAFFECTINGTHEIMPORTATIONANDINTERNALSALEOF
CIGARETTESCOMPLAINTBY(ONDURAS74$3
&ORADESCRIPTIONOFTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELSEE74/!NNUAL2EPORTP
&OLLOWINGESTABLISHMENTOFTHE0ANELATTHE$3"MEETINGOF*ANUARYON
&EBRUARYTHE0ANELWASCOMPOSED
/N.OVEMBERTHE0ANELREPORTWASCIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HEMAINFINDINGS
OFTHE0ANELWEREI4HETRANSITIONALSURCHARGEANDTHEFOREIGNEXCHANGEFEEIMPOSED
BYTHE$OMINICAN2EPUBLICWEREINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLE))BOF'!44ANDTHE
FOREIGNEXCHANGEFEEWASNOTJUSTIFIEDUNDER!RTICLE86AOF'!44IITHESTAMP
REQUIREMENTIMPOSEDONCIGARETTESBYTHE$OMINICAN2EPUBLICWASINCONSISTENTWITH
!RTICLE)))OF'!44C(ONDURASDIDNOTDEMONSTRATETHATTHEBONDREQUIREMENT
IMPOSEDONCIGARETTEIMPORTERSBYTHE$OMINICAN2EPUBLICVIOLATEDEITHER!RTICLE8OR
!RTICLE)))OF'!44ANDDBEFORETHELEGISLATIONWASAMENDEDIN*ANUARY
THE$OMINICAN2EPUBLICIMPOSEDITS3ELECTIVE#ONSUMPTION4AXONIMPORTEDCIGARETTESIN
AMANNERINCONSISTENTWITH!RTICLES)))AND8OF'!44/N*ANUARYTHE
$OMINICAN2EPUBLICNOTIFIEDITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAINISSUESOFLAWCOVEREDINTHE
PANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHEPANEL/N&EBRUARY
(ONDURASNOTIFIEDTHE$3"OFITSDECISIONTOAPPEALCERTAINISSUESOFLAWCOVEREDINTHE
PANELREPORTANDCERTAINLEGALINTERPRETATIONSDEVELOPEDBYTHEPANEL4HE!PPELLATE"ODY
2EPORTWILLBECIRCULATEDNOLATERTHAN!PRIL
-EXICOn4AXMEASURESONSOFTDRINKSANDOTHERBEVERAGESCOMPLAINTBY
THE5NITED3TATES74$3
/N-ARCHTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITH-EXICOCONCERNING
CERTAINTAXMEASURESIMPOSEDBY-EXICOONSOFTDRINKSANDOTHERBEVERAGESTHATUSEANY
SWEETENEROTHERTHANCANESUGAR4HETAXMEASURESCONCERNEDINCLUDEIAPERCENT
TAXONSOFTDRINKSANDOTHERBEVERAGESTHATUSEANYSWEETENEROTHERTHANCANESUGAR
BEVERAGETAXWHICHISNOTAPPLIEDTOBEVERAGESTHATUSECANESUGARANDIIAPER
CENTTAXONTHECOMMISSIONINGMEDIATIONAGENCYREPRESENTATIONBROKERAGECONSIGNMENT
ANDDISTRIBUTIONOFSOFTDRINKSANDOTHERBEVERAGESTHATUSEANYSWEETENEROTHERTHANCANE
SUGARDISTRIBUTIONTAX4HE5NITED3TATESCONSIDEREDTHATTHESETAXESWEREINCONSISTENT
#HINAn6ALUE!DDED4AXONINTEGRATEDCIRCUITSCOMPLAINTBYTHE5NITED3TATES
74$3
/N-ARCHTHE5NITED3TATESREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITH#HINACONCERNING
#HINASPREFERENTIALVALUEADDEDTAX6!4FORDOMESTICALLYPRODUCEDORDESIGNED
INTEGRATEDCIRCUITS)#
4HE5NITED3TATESCLAIMEDTHATALTHOUGH#HINAPROVIDESFORAPERCENTRATEOF6!4
ON)#SENTERPRISESIN#HINAAREENTITLEDTOAPARTIALREFUNDOFTHE6!4ON)#STHATTHEYHAVE
PRODUCEDRESULTINGINALOWER6!4RATEONTHEIRPRODUCTS)NTHE5NITED3TATESVIEW#HINA
THUSAPPEARSTOBESUBJECTINGIMPORTED)#STOHIGHERTAXESTHANAPPLIEDTODOMESTICALLY
PRODUCED)#SANDTOBEACCORDINGLESSFAVOURABLETREATMENTTOIMPORTED)#S)NADDITIONTHE
5NITED3TATESCLAIMEDTHAT#HINAALLOWSFORAPARTIALREFUNDOF6!4FORDOMESTICALLYDESIGNED
)#STHATBECAUSEOFTECHNOLOGICALLIMITATIONSAREMANUFACTUREDOUTSIDEOF#HINA)NTHE
5NITED3TATESVIEW#HINATHUSAPPEAREDTOBEPROVIDINGFORMOREFAVOURABLETREATMENT
OFIMPORTSFROMONE-EMBERTHANFROMOTHERSANDALSOISDISCRIMINATINGAGAINSTSERVICES
ANDSERVICESUPPLIERSOFOTHER-EMBERS4HE5NITED3TATESCONSIDEREDTHATTHESEMEASURES
AREINCONSISTENTWITHTHE#HINASOBLIGATIONSUNDER!RTICLES)AND)))OFTHE'!44THE
0ROTOCOLONTHE!CCESSIONOFTHE0EOPLES2EPUBLICOF#HINA74,AND!RTICLE86))OF
THE'!43
/N-ARCHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESREQUESTEDTOJOINTHECONSULTATIONS
/N-ARCH*APANREQUESTEDTOJOINTHECONSULTATIONS/N!PRIL-EXICOAND
THE3EPARATE#USTOMS4ERRITORYOF4AIWAN0ENGHU+INMENAND-ATSUREQUESTEDTOJOINTHE
CONSULTATIONS/N!PRIL#HINAINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITHADACCEPTEDTHEREQUESTS
OFTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES*APANAND-EXICOTOJOINTHECONSULTATIONS
/N*ULY#HINAANDTHE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDTHE$3"THATTHEYHADREACHED
ANAGREEMENTWITHRESPECTTOTHEMATTERRAISEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESINITSREQUESTFOR
CONSULTATIONS
+OREAn!NTIDUMPINGDUTIESONIMPORTSOFCERTAINPAPERFROM)NDONESIA
COMPLAINTBY)NDONESIA74$3
/N*UNE)NDONESIAREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITH+OREACONCERNINGTHEIMPOSITION
OFDEFINITIVEANTIDUMPINGDUTIESBY+OREAONIMPORTSOFBUSINESSINFORMATIONPAPERAND
UNCOATEDWOODFREEPRINTINGPAPERFROM)NDONESIAANDCERTAINASPECTSOFTHEINVESTIGATION
LEADINGTOTHEIMPOSITIONOFSUCHDUTIES
!CCORDINGTOTHEREQUESTFORCONSULTATIONSFROM)NDONESIA+OREAISVIOLATINGANUMBEROF
ITS74/OBLIGATIONSUNDERTHE'!44ANDTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENT/N!UGUST
)NDONESIAREQUESTEDTHEESTABLISHMENTOFAPANEL!TITSMEETINGON!UGUST
THE$3"DEFERREDTHEESTABLISHMENTOFAPANEL&URTHERTOASECONDREQUESTTOESTABLISH
APANELBY)NDONESIATHE$3"ESTABLISHEDAPANELATITSMEETINGON3EPTEMBER
#ANADA#HINATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES*APANANDTHE5NITED3TATESRESERVEDTHEIRTHIRD
PARTYRIGHTS/N/CTOBER)NDONESIAREQUESTEDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOCOMPOSETHE
PANEL/N/CTOBERTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALCOMPOSEDTHEPANEL
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
WITH!RTICLE)))OF'!44INPARTICULAR!RTICLE)))FIRSTANDSECONDSENTENCESAND!RTICLE
)))THEREOF#ANADA#HINATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES'UATEMALA*APANAND0AKISTAN
RESERVEDTHEIRTHIRDPARTYRIGHTS/N!UGUST0AKISTANINFORMEDTHE$3"THATITDID
NOTWANTTOPARTICIPATEASATHIRDPARTYINTHEPANELPROCEEDINGS/N!UGUSTTHE
0ANELWASCOMPOSED
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn!NTI$UMPING$UTIESONCERTAINFLATROLLEDIRONORNON
ALLOYSTEELPRODUCTSFROM)NDIACOMPLAINTBY)NDIA74$3
/N*ULY)NDIAREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITHTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
CONCERNINGTHEIMPOSITIONOFDEFINITIVEANTIDUMPINGMEASURESONIMPORTSOFCERTAINFLAT
ROLLEDPRODUCTSOFIRONORNONALLOYSTEELFROM)NDIA!CCORDINGTOTHE)NDIANREQUESTTHE
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESWEREVIOLATING!RTICLEOFTHE!NTI$UMPING!GREEMENTWHICH
REQUIRESTHATANANTIDUMPINGDUTYSHALLBECOLLECTEDONANONDISCRIMINATORYBASISON
IMPORTSOFTHEPRODUCTFROMALLSOURCESFOUNDTOBEDUMPEDANDCAUSINGINJURY)NDIA
CLAIMEDTHATWHILEANTIDUMPINGMEASURESWEREINFORCEAGAINST)NDIANIMPORTSINTOTHE
#OMMUNITYNOMEASURESWEREINFORCEAGAINSTIMPORTSOFTHESAMEPRODUCTCONCERNEDFROM
%GYPT3LOVAKIAAND4URKEYINSPITEOFTHEFACTTHATTHEPRODUCTSIMPORTEDFROMTHELATTER
THREECOUNTRIESWEREALSOFOUNDBYTHE#OMMISSIONTOBEDUMPEDANDCAUSINGINJURYTOTHE
#OMMUNITYINDUSTRY
/N/CTOBER)NDIAANDTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESNOTIFIEDTHE$3"THATTHEY
HADREACHEDANAGREEMENTWITHRESPECTTOTHEMATTERRAISEDBY)NDIAINITSREQUESTFOR
CONSULTATIONS
4ABLE))
2EQUESTFORCONSULTATIONS
74/ACTIVITIES
2ESOLUTIONOFTRADECONFLICTSUNDERTHE74/S$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING
$ISPUTE
#OMPLAINANT
$ATEOFREQUEST
)NDIAn"ATTERIES74$3
"ANGLADESH
%#n#OMMERCIAL6ESSELS74$3
+OREA
53n(ARD2ED3PRING7HEAT74$3
#ANADA
53n3OFTWOOD,UMBER6))74$3
#ANADA
-EXICOn0ROVISIONAL#OUNTERVAILING-EASURESON/LIVE/ILFROMTHE
%#74$3
%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESn3ELECTED#USTOMS-ATTERS74$3
5NITED3TATES
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESAND#ERTAIN-EMBER3TATESn-EASURES
!FFECTING4RADEIN,ARGE#IVIL!IRCRAFT74$3
5NITED3TATES
5NITED3TATESn-EASURES!FFECTING4RADEIN,ARGE#IVIL!IRCRAFT
74$3
%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES
)NDIAn!NTI$UMPING-EASURESON#ERTAIN0RODUCTSFROMTHE
3EPARATE#USTOMS4ERRITORYOF4AIWAN0ENGHU+INMENAND-ATSU
74$3
#HINESE4AIPEI
5NITED3TATESn3ECTIONOFTHE4ARIFF!CTOF74$3
%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES
5NITED3TATES#ONTINUED3USPENSIONOF/BLIGATIONSINTHE
%#n(ORMONES$ISPUTES74$3
%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES
#ANADAn#ONTINUED3USPENSIONOF/BLIGATIONSINTHE
%#n(ORMONES$ISPUTE74$3
%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES
5NITED3TATESn:EROINGAND3UNSET2EVIEWS74$3
*APAN
*APANn)MPORTQUOTASONDRIEDLAVERANDSEASONEDLAVER74$3
+OREA
5NITED3TATESn0ROVISIONAL!NTI$UMPING-EASURESON3HRIMPFROM
4HAILAND74$3
4HAILAND
!PPELLATE"ODYAPPOINTMENTANDREAPPOINTMENTS
/N*UNE-R'EORGES!BI3AABAND-R!6'ANESANEACHCOMMENCEDANEW
TERMOFOFFICEHAVINGBEENAPPOINTEDBYTHE$3"ON.OVEMBERTOASECONDFOUR
YEARTERMTHATWILLEXPIREON-AY-R9ASUHEI4ANIGUCHIWASALSOAPPOINTEDTO
ASECONDFOURYEARTERMON.OVEMBER(ISSECONDFOURYEARTERMBEGANON
$ECEMBERANDWILLEXPIREON$ECEMBER/N$ECEMBER-R4ANIGUCHI
WASELECTEDBYHISCOLLEAGUESTOSERVEAS#HAIRMANOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYFOR2ULE
OFTHE7ORKING0ROCEDURESFOR!PPELLATE2EVIEWPROVIDESTHATTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYWHOISELECTEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODY-EMBERSSHALLBERESPONSIBLEFORTHEOVERALL
DIRECTIONOF!PPELLATE"ODYBUSINESS
4HESEAPPOINTMENTSWEREMADEACCORDINGTO!RTICLEOFTHE5NDERSTANDINGON2ULES
AND0ROCEDURES'OVERNINGTHE3ETTLEMENTOF$ISPUTES$35WHICHSTIPULATESTHATTHE
!PPELLATE"ODYSHALLCOMPRISEPERSONSOFRECOGNIZEDAUTHORITYWITHDEMONSTRATEDEXPERTISE
INLAWINTERNATIONALTRADEANDTHESUBJECTMATTEROFTHECOVEREDAGREEMENTSGENERALLY
4HIS!RTICLEALSOREQUIRESTHATTHE!PPELLATE"ODYMEMBERSHIPBEBROADLYREPRESENTATIVE
OFTHE74/MEMBERSHIP4HESEAPPOINTMENTSWEREMADEFOLLOWINGCONSULTATIONSWITH74/
-EMBERSANDONTHEBASISOFAPROPOSALBYA3ELECTION#OMMITTEECOMPRISINGTHE$IRECTOR
'ENERALANDTHE#HAIRPERSONSOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTHE$3"THE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN
'OODSTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESANDTHE42)03#OUNCIL
$35NEGOTIATIONS
4HESECASESAPPEARINORDEROFDATE
REQUESTED-OREINFORMATIONONTHESEREQUESTS
CANTOBEFOUNDONTHE74/WEBSITE4HELIST
DOESNOTINCLUDETHOSEDISPUTESWHEREAPANEL
WASEITHERREQUESTEDORESTABLISHED
3EE!NNUAL2EPORTP
4HENEGOTIATIONSONhIMPROVEMENTSANDCLARIFICATIONSvTOTHE$35WEREINITIALLYINTENDED
TOBECONCLUDEDBY-AYBUTTHETIMEFRAMEFORCONCLUDINGTHEWORKHADBEEN
EXTENDEDIN*ULYFORANADDITIONALYEARUNTIL-AY )N-ARCH!MBASSADOR$AVID3PENCEROF!USTRALIAWASAPPOINTEDAS#HAIRMAN
OFTHE$3"3PECIAL3ESSION3OMEADDITIONALPROGRESSWASMADEINTHE3PECIAL3ESSION
INTHEFIRSTFEWMONTHSOFBUILDINGONTHEWORKDONETHUSFAR3OMEDELEGATIONS
MADEADDITIONALWRITTENCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHENEGOTIATIONSDURINGTHISPERIODWHICH
WEREWELCOMEDBYPARTICIPANTS(OWEVERWORKHADBEENSLOWTORESUMEINTHEPERIOD
IMMEDIATELYFOLLOWINGTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEANDBY-AYTHEREWAS
AGREEMENTAMONG-EMBERSTHATMORETIMEWASREQUIREDTOCOMPLETETHEDISPUTESETTLEMENT
NEGOTIATIONSANDTHATWORKSHOULDCONTINUETOWARDSCLARIFICATIONSANDIMPROVEMENTS
TOTHE$35 /N!UGUSTASPARTOFTHE*ULY0ACKAGETHE'ENERAL#OUNCILADOPTEDA
RECOMMENDATIONBYTHE4.#THATWORKINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONSHOULDCONTINUEONTHEBASIS
SETOUTINTHE#HAIRMANSREPORTTOTHE4.# 4WOFURTHERMEETINGSOFTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONWEREHELDINON/CTOBERAND
.OVEMBER"OTHOFTHESEMEETINGSWEREESSENTIALLYDEVOTEDTOTHEDISCUSSIONOFAN
INFORMALJOINTCONTRIBUTIONBY!RGENTINA"RAZIL#ANADA)NDIA.EW:EALANDAND.ORWAY
4HISCONTRIBUTIONWHICHHADBEENPRESENTEDATTHEENDOF-AYFOCUSEDONTHREEISSUES
WHICHHADBEENINDISCUSSIONINTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONREMANDSEQUENCINGANDPOST
RETALIATIONISSUES
3EE2EPORTBYTHE#HAIRMANTOTHE4.#
4.$3
3EE74,!UGUST
3EE2EPORTBYTHE#HAIRMANTOTHE4.#
4.$3
4HEOBJECTIVESOFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW-ECHANISM402-ASESTABLISHEDIN!NNEX
OFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENTARETOCONTRIBUTETOIMPROVEDADHERENCEBYALL-EMBERSOF
THE74/TOITSRULESDISCIPLINESANDCOMMITMENTSANDTHUSTOTHESMOOTHERFUNCTIONINGOF
THEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM4HE402REVIEWSAIMTOACHIEVEGREATERTRANSPARENCYINAND
UNDERSTANDINGOFTHETRADEPOLICIESANDPRACTICESOF-EMBERS4HE-ECHANISMENABLESTHE
REGULARCOLLECTIVEAPPRECIATIONANDEVALUATIONOFTHEFULLRANGEOFINDIVIDUAL-EMBERS
TRADEPOLICIESANDPRACTICESINALLAREASCOVEREDBYTHE74/!GREEMENTSANDOFTHEIR
IMPACTONTHEFUNCTIONINGOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM2EVIEWSTAKEPLACEAGAINSTTHE
BACKGROUNDOFTHEWIDERECONOMICANDDEVELOPMENTALNEEDSPOLICIESANDOBJECTIVESOFTHE
-EMBERCONCERNEDASWELLASTHEEXTERNALTRADINGENVIRONMENT4HEYARENOTINTENDEDTO
SERVEASABASISFORTHEENFORCEMENTOFOBLIGATIONSFORDISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEDURESORTO
IMPOSENEWPOLICYCOMMITMENTS
2EVIEWSARECONDUCTEDINTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY402"AFULLMEMBERSHIPBODY
OFEQUALRANKINGTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILANDTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY$URINGTHE
402"WASCHAIREDBY!MBASSADOR-ARY7HELAN)RELAND
5NDERTHE402-THEFOURLARGESTTRADINGENTITIESATPRESENTTHE%UROPEAN5NION%5
THE5NITED3TATES*APANAND#HINAAREREVIEWEDEVERYTWOYEARSTHENEXTLARGEST
TRADINGPARTNERSEVERYFOURYEARSANDTHEREMAINING74/-EMBERSEVERYSIXYEARSWITH
ALONGERINTERVALENVISAGEDFORLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES)THASBEENAGREEDTHATTHESE
INTERVALSMAYIFNECESSARYBEAPPLIEDWITHAFLEXIBILITYOFSIXMONTHSEXTENSION
"YTHEENDOFATOTALOFREVIEWSHADBEENCONDUCTEDCOVERING74/
-EMBERSWITH#ANADATHE%UROPEAN5NIONANDTHE5NITED3TATESHAVINGBEENREVIEWED
SEVENTIMESAND*APANSIXTIMESNINE-EMBERS!USTRALIA"RAZIL(ONG+ONG#HINA
)NDONESIA2EPUBLICOF+OREA.ORWAY3INGAPORE3WITZERLANDAND4HAILANDFOURTIMES
FOUR-EMBERS#HILE)NDIA-ALAYSIA-EXICOTHREETIMESAND-EMBERSTWICE$URING
THE402"CARRIEDOUTREVIEWSOFINCHRONOLOGICALORDER5NITED3TATES'AMBIA3RI
,ANKA3INGAPORE"ENIN"URKINA&ASO-ALI"ELIZE3URINAME2EPUBLICOF+OREA2WANDA
.ORWAY%UROPEAN5NION"RAZIL,IECHTENSTEINAND3WITZERLAND4HE#HAIRPERSONSCONCLUDING
REMARKSFORTHESEREVIEWSAREINCLUDEDIN!NNEX)4HEPROGRAMMEFORTHEYEARINCLUDES
REVIEWSINCLUDING*APANFORTHESEVENTHTIME
/VERTHEPASTFEWYEARSGREATERFOCUSHASBEENPLACEDONREVIEWSOFLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESASENCOURAGEDBYTHE.OVEMBER(IGH,EVEL-EETINGON)NTEGRATED)NITIATIVES
FOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES4RADE$EVELOPMENT"YTHEENDOF402REVIEWSHAD
COVEREDOFTHE,$#STHATARE74/-EMBERS
!SREQUIREDIN!NNEXOFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENTESTABLISHINGTHE-ECHANISM
THE402"UNDERTOOKINANAPPRAISALOFTHEOPERATIONOFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW
-ECHANISM/VERALL-EMBERSFOUNDTHATTHE402-WASFUNCTIONINGEFFECTIVELYANDTHATITS
MISSIONANDOBJECTIVESREMAINEDIMPORTANT4HERESULTSOFTHE!PPRAISALWEREPRESENTEDTO
THE4HIRD-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN3EATTLE
4HE402"ISALSORESPONSIBLEFORCARRYINGOUTTHE!NNUAL/VERVIEWOFDEVELOPMENTSINTHE
INTERNATIONALTRADINGENVIRONMENTTHATHAVEANIMPACTONTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMON
THEBASISOFAN!NNUAL2EPORTBYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
3UBSTANTIALPROGRESSHASCONTINUEDTOBEMADEINENHANCINGAWARENESSOFTHE402-
$OCUMENTSDISTRIBUTEDFORREVIEWSAREAVAILABLETOALLDELEGATIONSOF74/-EMBERSIN
ELECTRONICFORMATTHROUGHTHE3ECRETARIATS$OCUMENT-ANAGEMENT3YSTEM0RESSBRIEFINGS
AREHELDREGULARLYBYTHE#HAIRORTHE$IRECTOROFTHE4RADE0OLICIES2EVIEW$IVISIONAND
INSOMECASESBYTHE-EMBERUNDERREVIEW4HESUMMARYOBSERVATIONSOFTHE3ECRETARIAT
74/ACTIVITIES
4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW-ECHANISM
6))) 4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW-ECHANISM
2EPORTTHE74/PRESSRELEASETHECONCLUDINGREMARKSBYTHE#HAIRAND4022EPORTSARE
AVAILABLEIMMEDIATELYONTHE74/WEBSITE402REPORTSAREPUBLISHEDONBEHALFOFTHE74/
BY"ERNAN!SSOCIATES4HISCOMMERCIALARRANGEMENTAIMSTOENSUREAWIDEANDEFFICIENT
DISTRIBUTIONOFTHEREPORTS
)8 #OMMITTEEON"ALANCEOF0AYMENTS2ESTRICTIONS
5NDERTHE#HAIRMANSHIPOF-R'IULIO4ONINI)TALYINTHE#OMMITTEEON
"ALANCEOF0AYMENTS2ESTRICTIONSMETTOCONSULTWITH"ANGLADESHANDAPPROVEDTHE
CONTINUEDMAINTENANCEOFITSIMPORTRESTRICTIONSINACCORDANCEWITH!RTICLE86)))"4HENEXT
CONSULTATIONWHEN"ANGLADESHISEXPECTEDTOSUBMITATIMETABLEFORTHEPHASEOUTOFITS
RESTRICTIONSISSCHEDULEDFORSPRING"ANGLADESHISTHEONLY-EMBERTHATMAINTAINS
RESTRICTIONSFORBALANCEOFPAYMENTSPURPOSES
4HE#OMMITTEEALSOCOMPLETEDITSTHIRDANNUALREVIEWUNDERTHE4RANSITIONAL2EVIEW
-ECHANISMOF#HINAS0ROTOCOLOF!CCESSION
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS
8 #OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS
4HISNUMBERTOTALSNOTIFICATIONSMADE
UNDER'!44!RTICLE88)6'!43!RTICLE6AND
THE%NABLING#LAUSEASWELLASACCESSIONS
TOEXISTING24!SFORACOMPLETELISTOF24!S
NOTIFIEDTOTHE'!4474/SEEHTTPWWWWTO
ORGENGLISHTRATOP?EREGION?EREGION?EHTM
4HE%5PLUSTHREE%&4!MEMBERSTATES
4HEACCESSIONOF#YPRUSTHE#ZECH2EPUBLICS
%STONIA(UNGARY,ATVIA,ITHUANIA-ALTA
0OLANDTHE3LOVAKREPUBLICAND3LOVENIA
TERMINATEDTHEBILATERALAGREEMENTSBETWEEN
THENEWMEMBERSANDTHE%5ANDITREPEALED
THETRADERELATEDASPECTSOFALLEXISTING
AGREEMENTSAMONGTHENEWMEMBERSAS
WELLASTHOSEBETWEENTHELATTERANDTHIRD
PARTIESWITHWHICHTHE%5ALREADYHADINPLACE
PREFERENTIALAGREEMENTS!SARESULTOFTHIS
ENLARGEMENTNOTIFIED24!SWEREABROGATED
ON-AY
#ROATIARECEIVEDCANDIDATESTATUSIN*UNE
THUSJOINING"ULGARIA2OMANIAAND
4URKEY
4HE3TABILITY0ACTPROCESSINVOLVES!LBANIA
"OSNIAAND(ERZEGOVINA"ULGARIA#ROATIA
&92/-2OMANIAAND3ERBIAAND-ONTENEGRO
4HE&4!NETWORKISCURRENTLYBEINGEXTENDEDTO
-OLDOVAAND5.-)++OSOVO
!GREEMENTSCONCLUDEDTODATEINCLUDE
2OMANIA"ULGARIATHE&ORMER9UGOSLAV
2EPUBLICOF-ACEDONIA&92/-#ROATIA
AND!LBANIA4HE%&4!3TATESAND4URKEYARE
PURSUINGSIMILARNEGOTIATIONS
4HE-EDITERRANEANPARTNERSARE!LGERIA
%GYPT)SRAEL*ORDAN,EBANON-OROCCO
0ALESTINIAN!UTHORITY3YRIA4UNISIAAND4URKEY
#YPRUSAND-ALTAWEREPARTNERSTOTHEPROCESS
BEFOREACCEDINGTOTHE%5ON-AY
4HE!SSOCIATION!GREEMENTBETWEENTHE
%5AND%GYPTENTEREDINTOFORCEON*UNE
WHILENEGOTIATIONSWITH3YRIAHAVE
RECENTLYBEENCONCLUDEDTHUSCOMPLETING
THEGRIDOFBILATERAL24!S!SWITHTHEOTHER
NETWORKSOFINTRA%UROPEAN24!NEGOTIATIONS
THE%&4!3TATESAND4URKEYAREPURSUING24!
NEGOTIATIONSWITHTHESESAMECOUNTRIES
%0!SARERECIPROCAL&4!SSUPPOSEDTO
REPLACETHEEXISTINGNONRECIPROCALSYSTEMS
OFPREFERENCESUNDERTHE#OTONOU!GREEMENT
BETWEENTHE%5ANDTHE!#0COUNTRIES
%0!NEGOTIATIONSWITH#ENTRAL!FRICA
#%-!#AND7EST!FRICA%#/7!3WERE
OPENEDIN/CTOBER.EGOTIATIONS
WITH%ASTERNAND3OUTHERN!FRICA%3!THE
#ARIBBEAN&ORUMOF!#03TATES#!2)&/25-
THE3OUTHERN!FRICAN$EVELOPMENT#OMMUNITY
3!$#ANDWITHTHE0ACIFIC!#03TATESWERE
OPENEDIN
2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS24!SAREAPROMINENTFEATUREOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADING
SYSTEM-43ANDTHEYHAVEBECOMEFORMANY74/-EMBERSACENTRALOBJECTIVEINTHE
CONDUCTOFTHEIRCOMMERCIALPOLICY4HENUMBEROF24!SASWELLASTHEWORLDSHAREOFTRADE
UNDERTHEMHASBEENSTEADILYINCREASINGOVERTHELASTTENYEARSWASNOEXCEPTION
TOTHISTREND/NTHECONTRARYINPARALLELWITHSLUGGISHPROGRESSINMULTILATERALTRADE
NEGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!THERUSHTOFORGE24!SHASFURTHER
ACCELERATED7ITHTHENOTIFICATIONOF24!SDURINGTHECOURSEOFTHEYEARTHISHASINDEED
BEENTHEMOSTPROLIFIC24!PERIODINTHEHISTORYOFTHE'!4474/ 4HEMANYPROPOSALSFOR
NEW24!SINADDITIONTOTHOSEALREADYUNDERNEGOTIATIONSUGGESTNOSLOWINGDOWNOF24!
ACTIVITIESINTHEIMMEDIATEFUTURE
$EVELOPMENTSININTHEGLOBALLANDSCAPEOF24!SPOINTTOSOMEMAJORTRENDS
COUNTRIESACROSSTHEWORLDINCLUDINGTHOSETRADITIONALLYRELIANTONMULTILATERALTRADE
LIBERALIZATIONAREINCREASINGLYMAKING24!SACENTREPIECEOFTHEIRCOMMERCIALPOLICY
3ECOND24!SAREBECOMINGINCREASINGLYCOMPLEXINMANYCASESESTABLISHINGREGULATORY
TRADEREGIMESTHATGOBEYONDMULTILATERALLYAGREEDTRADEREGULATIONS4HIRDRECIPROCAL
PREFERENTIALAGREEMENTSBETWEENDEVELOPEDDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAREONTHEINCREASE
POINTINGTOADECREASINGRELIANCEBYSOMEDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESONNONRECIPROCALSYSTEMSOF
PREFERENCES&OURTH24!DYNAMICSSHOWINSPITEOFREGIONALIDIOSYNCRASIESAGENERALPATTERN
OFEXPANSIONANDCONSOLIDATIONONTHEONEHANDWEAREWITNESSINGAPROLIFERATIONOFCROSS
REGIONAL24!SWHICHACCOUNTFORALARGEPROPORTIONOFTHETOTALINCREASEIN24!SONTHE
OTHERREGIONALTRADINGBLOCKSONCONTINENTWIDESCALEAREINTHEMAKING
%UROPEHASTHEGREATESTCONCENTRATIONOF24!SWITHTHE%UROPEAN5NION%5AND
THE%UROPEAN&REE4RADE!SSOCIATION%&4!REPRESENTINGTHEMAINCONTINENTALHUBS4HE
ACCESSIONTOTHE%UROPEAN5NION%5OFTENNEWMEMBERSON-AYEXPANDEDTHE
%UROPEANINTERNALMARKETTOCOUNTRIES ENCOMPASSINGMILLIONCITIZENSANDACCOUNTING
FORROUGHLYPERCENTOFWORLDTRADE4HE%5ENLARGEMENTALSOCONSOLIDATEDTHEEXTENSIVE
NETWORKONINTRA%UROPEAN24!SBUILTOVERTHEYEARSBYCONSIDERABLYREDUCINGTHENUMBER
OFEXISTINGAGREEMENTS 4HISPROCESSOFEXPANSIONANDCONSOLIDATIONISLIKELYTOCONTINUEIN
THECOMINGYEARSASMORECOUNTRIESAREADDEDTOTHELISTOFCANDIDATESFOR%5ACCESSION 4HEPROCESSOF3TABILIZATIONAND!SSOCIATIONIN3OUTH%ASTERN%UROPEADDSFURTHERTOTHE
NUMBEROF24!SIN%UROPEWITHTHEESTABLISHMENTOFANETWORKOFBILATERAL&4!SAMONGTHE
EIGHTCOUNTRIESPARTIESTOTHE3TABILITY0ACT ANDTHROUGHBILATERALAGREEMENTSBETWEENTHE
%5ANDTHESECOUNTRIES !SIMILARPROCESSISUNDERWAYBETWEENTHE%5ANDCOUNTRIESIN
.ORTH!FRICAANDTHE-IDDLE%ASTWITHTHEAIMTOESTABLISHA%URO-EDITERRANEAN&REE4RADE
!REABY &URTHERAFIELDTHE%5ISENGAGEDIN&4!NEGOTIATIONSWITHTHEMEMBERS
OFTHE'ULF#OOPERATION#OUNCIL'##ANDOF-%2#/352ANDOF%CONOMIC0ARTNERSHIP
!GREEMENTS%0!S WITHTHE!FRICAN#ARIBBEANAND0ACIFIC!#0GROUPOFCOUNTRIES 4HE%&4!3TATESHAVEONGOINGNEGOTIATIONSWITH#ANADAANDWITHTHE3OUTH!FRICAN
#USTOMS5NION3!#5HAVEBEENEXPLORINGTHEPOSSIBILITYOF&4!NEGOTIATIONSWITH4HAILAND
ANDHAVERECENTLYLAUNCHEDNEGOTIATIONSWITH+OREA
)NTHE7ESTERN(EMISPHERETHE5NITED3TATESHASSIGNEDIN&4!SWITH!USTRALIA
-OROCCOANDASPARTOFTHE$OMINICAN2EPUBLICn#ENTRAL!MERICAN&REE4RADE!GREEMENT
$2#!&4!WITH#OSTA2ICA%L3ALVADOR'UATEMALA(ONDURAS.ICARAGUAANDTHE
$OMINICAN2EPUBLICITHASCONCLUDEDNEGOTIATIONSWITH"AHRAINANDITISEXPLORINGTHE
POSSIBILITYOFSIMILARAGREEMENTSWITH/MANANDTHE5NITED!RAB%MIRATES5!% ITHAS
ADVANCEDNEGOTIATIONSWITHTHE3!#5OPENEDNEGOTIATIONSWITHTHREEMEMBERSOFTHE
!NDEAN#OMMUNITY#OLOMBIA%CUADORAND0ERUANDWITH0ANAMAANDANNOUNCED
ITSINTENTIONTOOPEN&4!NEGOTIATIONSWITH4HAILAND)N,ATIN!MERICAEFFORTSTOWARDS
CONSOLIDATIONANDDEEPENINGOFTHENETWORKOF24!SAMONG,ATINAND#ENTRAL!MERICAN
COUNTRIESAREUNDERWAY-%2#/352MEMBERSHAVEBEENWORKINGTOWARDSTHEOBJECTIVEOF
AFULLFLEDGEDCUSTOMSUNION HAVECONCLUDEDAFRAMEWORKAGREEMENTWITHTHREEMEMBERS
OFTHE!NDEAN#OMMUNITYWHICHAIMSTOTHEGRADUALESTABLISHMENTOFA&4! WHILE-EXICO
HASSIGNALLEDITSINTENTIONTOAPPLYFORASSOCIATEMEMBERIN-%2#/352&URTHERAFIELD
-EXICOHASCONCLUDEDNEGOTIATIONSWITH*APAN#HILEWITH+OREA0ANAMAISNEGOTIATINGWITH
3INGAPORE-%2#/352WITH)NDIAANDA-%2#/352#HINA&4!ISBEINGCONSIDERED!SFOR
THE&REE4RADE!REAOFTHE!MERICAS&4!!THEREHASBEENNOMAJORBREAKTHROUGHINTHE
TROUBLEDNEGOTIATIONSIN
4HEINTERESTIN24!SIN!SIA0ACIFICHASFURTHERINTENSIFIEDIN3INGAPOREHASSIGNED
AN&4!WITH*ORDANHASLAUNCHEDNEGOTIATIONSWITH+OREA+UWAIT1ATAR0ANAMA0ERU
ANDISCONSIDERINGNEGOTIATIONSWITH"AHRAIN%GYPTAND3RI,ANKA *APANHAVINGSEALED
AN&4!WITH-EXICOISNOWEXPLORINGTHEPOSSIBILITYOFONEWITH#HILEITHASLAUNCHED
NEGOTIATIONSWITH+OREA-ALAYSIATHE0HILIPPINESAND4HAILANDINORDERTOSTRENGTHENITS
TIESWITH!3%!.COUNTRIES.EGOTIATIONSWITHTHELATTERASAGROUPARESCHEDULEDTOOPENIN
!SFOR+OREABESIDESITSNEGOTIATIONSWITH*APANAND3INGAPOREANDTHEAGREEMENT
CONCLUDEDWITH#HILEITHASBEENHOLDINGJOINTSTUDYTALKSWITH!3%!.ONPLANSFORAN&4!
4HAILANDHASOPENEDNEGOTIATIONSWITH.EW:EALANDSIGNEDAN&4!WITH!USTRALIAANDIS
CONSIDERING&4!SWITHTHE%&4!3TATESANDWITHTHE5NITED3TATES#HINANEGOTIATIONSON
THE&4!WITH!3%!.AREINPROGRESS WHILEFEASIBILITYSTUDIESAREBEINGUNDERTAKENON&4!S
WITH!USTRALIA.EW:EALANDAND#HILE!FRAMEWORKAGREEMENTENVISAGINGPOSSIBLE&4!
NEGOTIATIONSWITHTHECOUNTRIESOFTHE'##WASSIGNEDIN*ULY!TTHEBROADERREGIONALLEVEL
!3%!.#HINA*APANAND+OREAAREDISCUSSINGPLANSFORAN%AST!SIAN#OMMUNITYASANEW
FRAMEWORKFORREGIONALCOOPERATION!SFOR!USTRALIAAND.EW:EALANDNEGOTIATIONSONAN
&4!BETWEENTHEMAND!3%!.COUNTRIESARESCHEDULEDTOBELAUNCHEDINEARLY
4HISBRIEFOVERVIEWOF24!DYNAMICSSKETCHESANINCREASINGLYCOMPLEXTRADINGLANDSCAPE
CHARACTERIZEDBYTHECOEXISTENCEOF-&.TRADECONDITIONSWITHTHEMULTIPLICATIONOFLAYERS
OFTRADEPREFERENCES3UCHSITUATIONRAISESCONCERNSONTHEINTEGRITYOFTHE-43)NPARTICULAR
THEDEVELOPMENTOFNON-&.TRADINGNETWORKSEACHSUBJECTTOITSOWNREGULATORYREGIME
POSESSYSTEMICCHALLENGESTOTHE-43BYUNDERMININGTRANSPARENCYANDPREDICTABILITYIN
TRADERELATIONS4HISMAYULTIMATELYALTERGLOBALTRADEPATTERNSTHROUGHAMONGOTHERSTRADE
ANDINVESTMENTDIVERSION
.OTWITHSTANDINGTHESERISKSTHENUMBEROF24!SISINCREASING.OTIFIED24!SINFORCE
TOTALLEDBY$ECEMBER74/-EMBERSAREALLOWEDTOPARTICIPATEINREGIONAL
INITIATIVESALBEITSUBJECTTOCERTAINCRITERIAANDPROCEDURES 4HE#OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL
4RADE!GREEMENTS#24!THEBODYENTRUSTEDWITHVERIFYINGTHECOMPLIANCEOF24!SWITH
THERELEVANT74/PROVISIONSMETTHREETIMESINTOCARRYOUTTHEEXAMINATIONOFAN
INCREASINGLYLONGBACKLOGOF24!S (OWEVERTHE#24!MADENOFURTHERPROGRESSONITS
MANDATEOFCONSISTENCYASSESSMENTDUETOLONGSTANDINGINSTITUTIONALPOLITICALANDLEGAL
DIFFICULTIES3INCETHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE74/-EMBERSHAVEBEENUNABLETOREACH
CONSENSUSONTHEFORMATANDTHESUBSTANCEOFTHEREPORTSONANYOFTHEEXAMINATIONS
ENTRUSTEDTOTHE#24!4HELACKOFANEFFECTIVEMONITORINGMECHANISMEXACERBATESTHE
SYSTEMICCHALLENGESTHAT24!SMAYPOSETOTHE-43
$$!NEGOTIATIONSON24!SWHICHARETAKINGPLACEUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE.EGOTIATING
'ROUPON2ULESAIMATADDRESSINGTHESECHALLENGESBYCLARIFYINGANDIMPROVINGTHERELEVANT
DISCIPLINESANDPROCEDURESUNDEREXISTING74/PROVISIONS4HESENEGOTIATIONSHADPROGRESSED
MEANINGFULLYONTRANSPARENCYISSUESBYTHETIMEOFTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL3INCEEARLY
WORKHASPROGRESSEDONTHOSEISSUESWITHAVIEWTORESOLVINGTHEIMPASSEOFTHE#24!AND
EXERCISEBETTERSURVEILLANCEOF24!DYNAMICS"YENDTHESCOPEOFTHENEGOTIATIONSHAD
ALSOBEENENLARGEDTOINCLUDESYSTEMICISSUESWHICHMAYSUGGESTINCREASINGCONCERNSBY
MANY-EMBERSOVERTHEPOSSIBLENEGATIVEEFFECTSOF24!SONTHIRDPARTIESTRADEANDONTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMASAWHOLE
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS
4HE&4!WITH"AHRAINAND-OROCCOFALLUNDER
THE-IDDLE%AST&REE4RADE)NITIATIVEPROPOSED
BY0RESIDENT'7"USHIN-AYWHICH
FORESEESAPLANOFGRADUATEDSTEPSTOEXPAND
ANDDEEPENECONOMICTIESBETWEENTHE5NITED
3TATESAND-IDDLE%ASTERNNATIONSTHROUGH
4RADEAND)NVESTMENT&RAMEWORK!GREEMENTS
4)&!S"ILATERAL)NVESTMENT4REATIES")4SAND
COMPREHENSIVE&REE4RADE!GREEMENTS&4!S
4HE&4!WITH"AHRAINANDTHOSEONESPROPOSED
WITH/MANANDTHE5!%RAISEALSOQUESTIONS
CONCERNINGTHEIRIMPACTONTHEFUNCTIONINGOF
THE'###USTOMS5NIONTOWHICHTHESETHREE
COUNTRIESAREPARTY
-%2#/352HAVEBEENFOCUSINGAMONG
OTHERSONTHEELIMINATIONOFTHEEXCEPTIONS
TOTHECOMMONEXTERNALTARIFFTHEENTRY
INTOFORCEOFTHE0ROTOCOLOF-ONTEVIDEOON
4RADEIN3ERVICESANDTHEENTRYINTOFORCEOF
THE0ROTOCOLOF/LIVOSFORTHE3ETTLEMENTOF
$ISPUTES
4HESEARE#OLOMBIA%CUADORAND6ENEZUELA
&REETRADEWITH"OLIVIAAND0ERUISREGULATED
UNDERTHEAGREEMENTSCONCLUDEDBETWEEN
-%2#/352AND"OLIVIAAND0ERURESPECTIVELY
3INGAPOREHASONGOINGNEGOTIATIONSWITH
#ANADA)NDIA-EXICOAND04RILATERAL&4!
COMPRISING#HILEAND.EW:EALAND
4HE&RAMEWORK!GREEMENTON
#OMPREHENSIVE%CONOMIC#OOPERATION
BETWEEN!3%!.ANDTHE0EOPLES2EPUBLICOF
#HINAINCLUDINGITS%ARLY(ARVESTPROGRAMME
WASNOTIFIEDTOTHE74/IN$ECEMBER
#ONTAINEDIN'!44!RTICLE88)6FOR
AGREEMENTSCOVERINGTRADEINGOODSANDIN
'!43!RTICLE6FORAGREEMENTSINTHEAREA
OFTRADEINSERVICES4HE$ECISIONOF
THE'!44#OUNCILON$IFFERENTIALAND-ORE
&AVOURABLE4REATMENT%NABLING#LAUSE
GOVERNSTHECONCLUSIONOFPREFERENTIAL
ARRANGEMENTSAMONGDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
TRADEINGOODSONLY
!SOF$ECEMBERTHE#24!HADATOTAL
OFAGREEMENTSUNDEREXAMINATION
3EE3ECTION)OFTHISREPORTONTHE$OHA
$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
8) #OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
4HE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTIN2EGULAR3ESSION#4$HELDFOURFORMAL
MEETINGSINTHTOST3ESSION$ETAILEDREPORTSOFTHESEMEETINGSCANBEFOUNDIN
DOCUMENTS74#/-4$-/NEINFORMALMEETINGWASALSOHELDIN
4HE#OMMITTEES!NNUAL2EPORTCONTAINEDINDOCUMENT74#/-4$PROVIDESA
DETAILEDACCOUNTOFALLTHEACTIVITIESOFTHE#4$IN!PARTFROMRECEIVINGNOTIFICATIONS
REGARDINGMARKETACCESSFORDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESITCONSIDERED
THEDECLININGTERMSOFTRADEFORPRIMARYCOMMODITIESANDITSIMPLICATIONTOTRADEAND
DEVELOPMENTOFPRIMARYCOMMODITYEXPORTINGCOUNTRIESPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA
$ECLARATIONONIDENTIFYINGANDDEBATINGDEVELOPMENTALANDENVIRONMENTALASPECTSOFTHE
NEGOTIATIONSINORDERTOHELPACHIEVETHEOBJECTIVEOFHAVINGSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENT
APPROPRIATELYREFLECTEDTHEDEVELOPMENTDIMENSIONOFELECTRONICCOMMERCEANDTHE
GRADUATIONOFTHE-ALDIVESFROMLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRYSTATUS
4HE74/STECHNICALASSISTANCEANDTRAININGACTIVITIESWEREDISCUSSEDTHROUGHOUTTHE
YEAR!TITSTH3ESSIONTHE#OMMITTEEADOPTEDTHEPLANOF2EGIONAL4RADE0OLICY#OURSES
ANDATITSTH3ESSIONITS!NNUAL2EPORTON4RAININGAND4ECHNICAL#OOPERATIONTHE&OURTH
1UARTERLY2EPORTON)MPLEMENTATIONOFTHE0LANANDTHE4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION
!UDIT2EPORT!TTHETH3ESSION-EMBERSDISCUSSEDTHEDRAFT4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE
0LANANDATTHEST3ESSIONREQUESTEDTWOREVISIONSBEFOREAGREEINGTOADOPTTHE
0LANINDOCUMENT74#/-4$72EV!LSOATITSST3ESSIONTHE#OMMITTEEHEARD
APRESENTATIONBYTHE)NTERNATIONAL$EVELOPMENT,AW/RGANIZATION)$,/ONITSVARIOUS
TRAININGACTIVITIESINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
!STHE74/BODYWHICHCONSIDERSNOTIFICATIONSUNDERTHE%NABLING#LAUSERELATINGTO
NONRECIPROCALPREFERENTIALTREATMENTOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAND,$#STHE#OMMITTEE
RECEIVEDINNOTIFICATIONSOFINCREASEDMARKETACCESSFOR,$#SFROMTHE'OVERNMENTS
OF!USTRALIA #ANADA )CELAND *APAN AND3WITZERLAND 4HESENOTIFICATIONSWEREASFAR
ASTHEYRELATETO,$#SREFERREDTOTHE3UB#OMMITTEEON,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIESFOR
CONSIDERATIONANDREPORTINGBACK4HE'OVERNMENTOF*APANALSONOTIFIEDTHE#OMMITTEE
OFCERTAINCHANGESTOITS'ENERALIZED3YSTEMOF0REFERENCESSCHEME 4HE#OMMITTEEALSO
REVIEWEDANOTIFICATIONFROM#HINARELATEDTOITSACCESSIONTOTHE"ANGKOK!GREEMENTIN
ANDITSIMPLEMENTATIONOFCONCESSIONSUNDERTHAT!GREEMENTSINCE*ANUARY 4HE#4$ALSOREVIEWEDTHEREPORTSOFTHE*OINT!DVISORY'ROUPONTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE
#ENTRE5.#4!$74/*!'4HEREPORTOFTHETH3ESSIONOFTHE*!' HELDON!PRIL
WASPRESENTEDBYTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE*!'ATTHETH3ESSIONOFTHE#4$
$ISCUSSIONSONTHEISSUEOFh$ECLININGTERMSOFTRADEFORPRIMARYCOMMODITIESANDITS
IMPLICATIONTOTRADEANDDEVELOPMENTOFPRIMARYCOMMODITYEXPORTINGCOUNTRIESvCONTINUED
ATTHETH3ESSIONWITHANEXAMINATIONOFPROPOSALSMADEBYTHEDELEGATIONSOF+ENYA
4ANZANIAAND5GANDACONTAINEDINDOCUMENT74#/-4$7ANDANINVENTORYOF
DOCUMENTSRELATINGTOTHECOMMODITYISSUECOMPILEDBYTHE3ECRETARIATANDCONTAINEDIN
DOCUMENT74#/-4$7!TITSTH3ESSIONTHE#OMMITTEEHADBEFOREITTWONEW
SUBMISSIONSONEFROMTHEDELEGATIONOF3WITZERLAND74#/-4$7THEOTHERFROM
THEDELEGATIONSOF+ENYA4ANZANIAAND5GANDA74#/-4$7"OTHSUBMISSIONS
CONTAINEDSUGGESTIONSONPOSSIBLEWAYSTOMOVEFORWARDONTHEISSUEOFCOMMODITIES!TITS
TH3ESSIONTHE#OMMON&UNDFOR#OMMODITIESMADEAPRESENTATIONTOTHE#OMMITTEE!T
ITSST3ESSION5.#4!$MADEAPRESENTATIONCONCERNINGITSRECENTWORKONCOMMODITIES
5NDERTHESTANDINGAGENDAITEMRELATINGTOPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL
$ECLARATIONONIDENTIFYINGANDDEBATINGTHEDEVELOPMENTALASPECTSOFTHEVARIOUS
NEGOTIATIONSINORDERTOHELPACHIEVETHEOBJECTIVEOFHAVINGSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENT
APPROPRIATELYREFLECTEDPRESENTATIONSWEREMADEONTHEDEVELOPMENTALASPECTSOFTHE
DISPUTESETTLEMENTANDTHERULESNEGOTIATIONS/NTHEISSUEOFELECTRONICCOMMERCEANOTHER
STANDINGITEMONTHE#OMMITTEESAGENDATHE#OMMITTEEDISCUSSEDSOMEOFTHEINTER
LINKAGESBETWEENECOMMERCEANDDEVELOPMENTISSUESANDADDRESSEDTHEPOSSIBILITYOF
INVITINGOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSWITHEXPERIENCEINTHISAREATOCONTRIBUTETO
DISCUSSIONSINTHE#OMMITTEE!TTHETH3ESSIONITWASAGREEDTHATTHE)NTERNATIONAL
4ELECOMMUNICATIONS5NION)45WOULDBEINVITEDTOAFUTUREMEETINGTOPRESENTTHE)45S
PREPARATIONSFORTHESECONDPHASEOFTHE7ORLD3UMMITONTHE)NFORMATION3OCIETYIN4UNIS
INANDTHETRADERELATEDASPECTSOFECOMMERCEFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
!TTHETH3ESSIONTHE-ALDIVESPRESENTEDASUBMISSION74#/-4$7RELATING
TOITSPOSSIBLEGRADUATIONFROM,$#STATUS4HEDOCUMENTFOCUSESONTHE-ALDIVESCALLFOR
-EMBERSTOSECUREANAPPROPRIATEMECHANISMTOENSURETHATGRADUATING,$#SCANMAKE
ASMOOTHTRANSITIONTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRYSTATUS3EVERAL-EMBERSSTRESSEDTHENEEDFOR
COHERENCEBETWEENTHE5NITED.ATIONSANDTHE74/INREGARDTOGRADUATIONTODEVELOPING
COUNTRYSTATUSFROM,$#STATUSANDTHE#HAIRMANSAIDHEWOULDHOLDCONSULTATIONS
4WO3ECRETARIATPAPERSWERECIRCULATEDTO-EMBERS4HEFIRSTCONTAINEDALISTOF74/SPECIAL
ANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTPROVISIONSFOR,$#S74#/-4$7ANDTHESECONDAN
INFORMALBACKGROUNDNOTEONTHE5.SGRADUATIONPROCESS
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
74#/-4$.
74#/-4$.!DD
74#/-4$.AND#ORR
74#/-4$.!DD
74#/-4$.!DD
74#/-4$.!DD
74#/-4$.
)4#DOCUMENT)4#!'8886))
3UB#OMMITTEEON,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES
)NTHE3UB#OMMITTEEHELDTHREEFORMALMEETINGSALLOFWHICHWERECHAIREDBY
!MBASSADOR)ANDE*ONG.ETHERLANDS4HEWORKOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEEFOCUSESONTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE74/7ORK0ROGRAMMEFOR,$#S74#/-4$,$#4HE7ORK
0ROGRAMMEAGREEDBY-EMBERSON&EBRUARYFOCUSESONTHEFOLLOWINGISSUES
MARKETACCESSFOR,$#STRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINITIATIVES
FOR,$#SPROVIDINGASAPPROPRIATESUPPORTTOAGENCIESASSISTINGWITHTHEDIVERSIFICATION
OF,$#SPRODUCTIONANDEXPORTBASEMAINSTREAMINGASAPPROPRIATEINTOTHE74/SWORK
THETRADERELATEDELEMENTSOFTHE,$#)))0ROGRAMMEOF!CTIONPARTICIPATIONOF,$#SINTHE
-ULTILATERAL4RADING3YSTEMACCESSIONOF,$#STOTHE74/ANDFOLLOWUPTO74/-INISTERIAL
$ECLARATIONSAND$ECISIONS
)NTHE3UB#OMMITTEECONSIDEREDTHEITEMONACCESSIONOF,$#SATITSTH
ANDTH3ESSIONS!TTHETH3ESSIONA3ECRETARIATPAPERONTHESTATEOFPLAYOF,$#S
ACCESSIONSWASCIRCULATEDTOFACILITATEDISCUSSION 4HENEEDTOCONTINUEIMPLEMENTINGTHE
'UIDELINESON,$#S!CCESSIONANDTHEIMPORTANCEOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITY
BUILDINGATALLSTAGESOFTHEACCESSIONPROCESSWEREEMPHASISED!TTHATMEETINGTHE
3ECRETARIATWASREQUESTEDTOPREPAREANOTEONTHETYPEOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEPROVIDED
TOACCEDING,$#S!TTHETH3ESSIONOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEETHENOTEBYTHE3ECRETARIATON
4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCEFOR!CCEDING,$#SWASDISCUSSED -EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEPAPERWHICH
PROVIDEDANOVERVIEWOFTHETYPEOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEREQUIREDTOASSIST,$#SINTHEIR
ACCESSIONPROCESS)TALSOINCLUDEDANONEXHAUSTIVESUMMARYOFTHEASSISTANCEPROVIDED
BYTHE74/3ECRETARIATBY74/-EMBERSASWELLASTHATOFFEREDBYOTHERINTERNATIONAL
ORGANIZATIONS4HEIMPORTANCEOFCONTINUINGTOPROVIDEASSISTANCETOTHOSE,$#STHATHAD
COMPLETEDTHEACCESSIONPROCESSBUTSTILLFACEDDIFFICULTIESFULFILLINGTHEIRCOMMITMENTSWAS
UNDERSCORED!TITSTH3ESSION-EMBERSWELCOMED#AMBODIAASAFULL74/-EMBERAND
ASTHESECOND,$#AFTER.EPALTOHAVEACCEDEDTOTHE74/INBRINGINGTHETOTAL
NUMBEROF,$#-EMBERSTO
-ARKETACCESSFOR,$#SWASCONSIDEREDINALLTHEMEETINGSOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEEIN
!TTHETH3ESSIONOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEETHE3ECRETARIATPRESENTEDANOTEONTHE
ANNUALREVIEWOFMARKETACCESSFORPRODUCTSORIGINATINGFROM,$#S74#/-4$,$#7
ALSOISSUEDAS4.-!34HENOTECONTAINEDINFORMATIONREGARDING,$#SEXPORTPROFILE
TARIFFMEASURESINITIATIVESANDIMPROVEMENTSMADEINPROVIDINGMARKETACCESSFOR,$#S
ASWELLASTHEUTILIZATIONOFPREFERENCESASASPECIALTOPIC)NLINEWITHTHE,$#MARKET
ACCESSREPORTINGPROCEDURESTHE3UB#OMMITTEEDISCUSSEDTHREENOTIFICATIONSFORWARDED
TOITBYTHE#4$4HESENOTIFICATIONSWEREBY!USTRALIA#ANADAAND3WITZERLAND -EMBERS
WELCOMEDTHEINITIATIVESTAKENTOIMPROVEMARKETACCESSFOR,$#S!TTHETH3ESSIONTHE
3UB#OMMITTEECONSIDEREDASUBMISSIONBYTHE,$#SIN74#/-4$,$#7CONCERNING
MARKETACCESSFORTEXTILESANDCLOTHINGAFTERTHEEXPIRYOFTHE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND
#LOTHING!4#4HE,$#SREQUESTEDTHE74/TOUNDERTAKEASTUDYONISSUESRELATINGTO
THETERMINATIONOFTHE!4#4HE3UB#OMMITTEEAGREEDTHATITS#HAIRMANWOULDUNDERTAKE
CONSULTATIONSONTHEWAYFORWARDTODEALWITHTHEREQUESTFROM,$#S
!TTHETHTHANDTH3ESSIONSOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEE-EMBERSCONSIDEREDTRADE
RELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGINITIATIVESFOR,$#S!TITSTH3ESSION
THE#HAIRMANOFTHE)&3TEERING#OMMITTEE)&3#REPORTEDONDEVELOPMENTSINTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK)&INCLUDINGTHEADOPTIONOFAN)&7ORK
0ROGRAMME74)&3#!SSISTANCETOADDRESSSUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTSWASCONSIDEREDATTHE
THANDTH3ESSIONSOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEE!TBOTHMEETINGSDISCUSSIONSWEREBASEDON
ANOTEPREPAREDBYTHE3ECRETARIAT74#/-4$,$#7-EMBERSEMPHASIZEDTHENEED
TOFURTHERSTRENGTHENTHECOOPERATIONOF74/WITHOTHERORGANIZATIONSINORDERTOBETTER
ADDRESSSUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTSOF,$#S!TTHETH3ESSIONREPRESENTATIVESOF5.)$/THE
7ORLD"ANKAND)4#BRIEFEDTHE3UB#OMMITTEEONHOWTHEYWEREASSISTINGTHE,$#SIN
ADDRESSINGTHESUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTS!TITSTH3ESSIONTHE3UB#OMMITTEEREQUESTEDTHE
3ECRETARIATTOPROVIDEASUMMARYOFTHESTATEOFIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEACTIONSIDENTIFIED
INTHE!CTION-ATRICESOFTHE$IAGNOSTIC4RADE)NTEGRATION3TUDIES$4)3OFTHE)NTEGRATED
&RAMEWORKPROCESSINSOFARASTHESEACTIONSRELATETOSTRENGTHENINGOFSUPPLYSIDECAPACITY
ANDIDENTIFYFACTORSIMPEDINGPROGRESSINTHEIRIMPLEMENTATION 4HEITEMONPROVIDINGSUPPORTTOAGENCIESASSISTINGWITHTHEDIVERSIFICATIONOF,$#S
PRODUCTIONANDEXPORTBASEWASCONSIDEREDATTHETH3ESSIONOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEE
!REPRESENTATIVEOF5.#4!$BRIEFEDTHE3UB#OMMITTEEONWORKUNDERTAKENBY5.#4!$
INSUPPORTOF,$#SPRODUCTIONANDEXPORTBASE-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEWORKUNDERTAKEN
BY5.#4!$ANDEXPRESSEDANINTERESTININVITINGOTHERORGANIZATIONSTOBRIEFTHE3UB
#OMMITTEEATFUTUREMEETINGS
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
*/"
74#/-4$,$#7
74#/-4$.74#/-4$.!DD
74#/-4$.!DD
!TITSTH3ESSIONONn*ANUARY
THE3UB#OMMITTEEON,$#SMANDATED
THE3ECRETARIATTOPREPAREAPAPERTHAT
WILLLOOKINTOOPTIONSFORIMPROVING,$#S
COMPETITIVENESSINTHETEXTILEANDCLOTHING
BUSINESS
3UBSEQUENTLYISSUEDAS74#/-4$,$#
7!DD
3EETHE)&WEBSITEWWW
INTEGRATEDFRAMEWORKORGFORMOREDETAILED
INFORMATIONONTHE)&
4HE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES
)NTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA-INISTERSENDORSEDTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR
,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES)&ASAVIABLEMODELFOR,$#STRADEDEVELOPMENT)N
THE)&ENTEREDACRUCIALSTAGEOFIMPLEMENTATIONANDEXPANDEDDRAMATICALLYINTHENUMBER
OFBENEFICIARIES3INCEITSINCEPTIONINANDITSRESTRUCTURINGINTHE)&HASRAISED
ITSVISIBILITYCONSIDERABLYINTHELEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESASWELLASINTHEINTERNATIONAL
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
DEVELOPMENTCOMMUNITY)NTWO-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONSONEBYTHE4RADE-INISTERS
OFTHE,$#SATTHEIRMEETINGIN$AKARANDONEBYTHE4RADE-INISTERSOFTHE!FRICAN5NION
ATTHEIRMEETINGIN+IGALIINCLUDEDPOSITIVEREFERENCESTOTHE)&4HETEXTSOFTHETWO
$ECLARATIONSARECONTAINEDINRESPECTIVELYDOCUMENTS74,$AKAR$ECLARATIONAND
74,+IGALI$ECLARATION-OREOVERTHE)&FIGUREDPROMINENTLYINSEVERALHIGHLEVEL
INTERNATIONALTRADEANDDEVELOPMENTEVENTS
"ASEDONTHEOUTCOMEOFTHESECONDMAJOREVALUATIONOFTHE)&INTHE)NTEGRATED
&RAMEWORK3TEERING#OMMITTEE)&3#nTHEBODYWHICHOVERSEESTHEWORKINTHE
)&nAPPROVEDA7ORK0ROGRAMMEONFOLLOWUPACTIONSTOIMPLEMENTRECOMMENDATIONSOF
THEEVALUATION4HE7ORK0ROGRAMMECONTAINEDINDOCUMENT74)&3#PROPOSESANUMBER
OFACTIONSTOBEACHIEVEDBY$ECEMBER!TTHEENDOFLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESWEREATDIFFERENTSTAGESOFTHE)&PROCESS)NTHECOURSEOFTHEYEAR.ATIONAL
6ALIDATION7ORKSHOPSnTHESTEPINTHE)&PROCESSWHEREBYTRADERELATEDPRIORITYPOLICIES
ANDASSISTANCENEEDSAREBEINGVALIDATEDBYTHECOUNTRYnWEREHELDIN,$#SNAMELY
IN"URUNDI#AMBODIA$JIBOUTI%THIOPIA'UINEA,ESOTHO-ADAGASCAR-ALAWI-ALI
-AURITANIA-OZAMBIQUE.EPAL3ENEGALAND9EMEN)NTHEFOLLOWINGSEVENCOUNTRIES
STARTEDTHE$IAGNOSTIC4RADE)NTEGRATION3TUDY$4)3nASTEPINTHE)&PROCESSnNAMELY
"ENIN#HAD,AO0$22WANDA3AO4OMEAND0RINCIPE4ANZANIAAND:AMBIA!LSOTHE
)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK7ORKING'ROUP)&7'nTHEBODYRESPONSIBLEFOROVERALLMANAGEMENT
OFTHE)&PROCESSnAGREEDTOSTARTTHE$4)3PROCESSINTHEFOLLOWINGSEVEN,$#S!NGOLA
"URKINA&ASO5GANDA.IGER-ALDIVESTHE'AMBIAAND3IERRA,EONE2EQUESTSTOJOINTHE
)&BYTHE#ENTRAL!FRICAN2EPUBLIC#OMOROSTHE$EMOCRATIC2EPUBLICOF#ONGO%QUATORIAL
'UINEA,IBERIA3UDANAND(AITIAREBEINGCONSIDERED
4HERESTRUCTURED)&HASITSOWN)&4RUST&UNDCONSISTINGOFTWO7INDOWS7INDOW)
FORTHEPREPARATIONOFTHE$4)3AND7INDOW))FORTHEFUNDINGOFSMALLCONCRETEPRIORITY
CAPACITYBUILDINGPROJECTSDERIVEDFROMTHE$4)3$URINGPLEDGESTOBOTH7INDOWSOF
THE)&4RUST&UNDHADBEENMOVINGINLINEWITHTHETRANSFERS%FFORTSTOENCOURAGEADDITIONAL
PLEDGESWEREINITIATEDINTOENSURETHEVIABILITYOFTHE)&4RUST&UND)NPARALLEL,$#S
MADEPROGRESSININTEGRATINGTHEIR$4)3SINTOTHEIR0230SAND#ONSULTATIVE'ROUPAND2OUND
4ABLEPROCESSES
$URINGTHE)&7'STEPPEDUPITSEFFORTSTOCREATEAWARENESSABOUTTHE)&)N
/CTOBER)&STAKEHOLDERSPARTICIPATEDINAWORKSHOPONPRE$4)3SUPPORTIN+IGALI
2WANDAAIMEDATBUILDINGUPAWARENESSONTHE)&4HE7ORKSHOPPROVIDEDAFORUMFOR
SHARINGOFKNOWLEDGEANDEXPERIENCESBETWEENREPRESENTATIVESOFTHOSE,$#STHATHAD
COMPLETEDTHE$4)3ANDTHOSEEMBARKINGONTHE)&PROCESS4HE7ORKSHOPALSOWELCOMED
THEINITIATIVEOF5.#4!$TOPREPAREAN)&MANUALWHICHWILLBEREADYIN$URING
THE)&ALSOINCREASEDCOOPERATIONWITHOTHERPROGRAMMESSUCHASTHE*)4!0ANDTHE
STANDARDSANDTRADEDEVELOPMENTFACILITY34$&4HETHREEAGENCIESWHICHCOLLABORATEBOTH
IN*)4!0ANDTHE)&)4#5.#4!$AND74/ENGAGEDINAREGULAREXCHANGEOFINFORMATION
REGARDINGIMPORTANTDOCUMENTSANDMISSIONSPLANNEDUNDEREITHERINITIATIVEFORTHETEN,$#S
WHICHAREBOTHPARTOFTHE)&AND*)4!0&OREACHOFTHESECOUNTRIESTHE)&3ECRETARIATAND
THE*)4!0COORDINATIONUNITEQUALLYENSUREDTHATEXISTINGRELEVANTDOCUMENTSSUCHASTHE
$4)3INTHECASEOFTHE)&WEREUSEFULLYTAKENINTOACCOUNTINDRAWINGUP*)4!0SCOUNTRY
DOCUMENTSANDVICEVERSA3IMILARLYCOORDINATIONBETWEENTHE)&ANDTHE34$&ISONGOING
BYALLOCATINGFUNDINGFROMTHE34$&TONEEDSFORASSISTANCEINTHEAREAOF303STANDARDS
EXPRESSEDINTHE$4)3UNDERTHE)&
)NTHE$$!74/-INISTERSENDORSETHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR4RADE2ELATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCEFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES)&ASA
VIABLEMODELFOR,$#STRADEDEVELOPMENT
4HE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKISAPROCESSTHATWASESTABLISHEDTOSUPPORT,$#GOVERNMENTSINTRADECAPACITYBUILDINGANDINTEGRATINGTRADE
ISSUESINTOOVERALLNATIONALDEVELOPMENTSTRATEGIES)TISANINTERNATIONALINITIATIVETHROUGHWHICHTHE)-&)4#5.#4!$5.$07ORLD"ANK
ANDTHE74/COMBINETHEIREFFORTSWITHTHOSEOFLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESANDDONORSTORESPONDTOTHETRADEDEVELOPMENTNEEDSOF,$#S
4HISINTEGRATEDAPPROACHWASLAUNCHEDIN/CTOBERATTHE(IGH,EVEL-EETINGON)NTEGRATED)NITIATIVESFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES
4RADE$EVELOPMENTORGANIZEDBY74/INRECOGNITIONOFTHESUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTSFACING,$#S4HE)&WASRESTRUCTUREDAFTERITSFIRSTMANDATED
EVALUATIONIN4HERESTRUCTURED)&ISAPROCESSUSINGEXISTINGCHANNELSTOENSURETHATTHETRADERELATEDASSISTANCENEEDSOFEACHCOUNTRY
AREINCLUDEDINTHEDIALOGUEBETWEENGOVERNMENTSANDTHEIRDEVELOPMENTPARTNERSONTHEOVERALLDEVELOPMENTPOLICYTOBEIMPLEMENTEDIN
EACHCOUNTRY)TAIMSTOIINCORPORATETRADEPOLICYINTOTHEHEARTOFTHE,$#SNATIONALDEVELOPMENT
PLANSINCLUDINGCOMPONENTSAIMEDATREDUCINGPOVERTYINTHECOUNTRYANDIIASSISTINTHECOORDINATIONANDDELIVERYOFTRADERELATED
ASSISTANCEASPROVIDEDBYEACHOFTHECOREAGENCIESINTHEIRRESPECTIVEFIELDSOFCOMPETENCEANDBYOTHERDEVELOPMENTPARTNERS0RINCIPALLY
THROUGHSUCH
INSTRUMENTSASTHE0OVERTY2EDUCTION3TRATEGY0APERS0230SOROTHERNATIONALDEVELOPMENTPLANSTHE)&SEEKSTOENSURECOUNTRYOWNERSHIP
PARTNERSHIPANDCOORDINATIONINTHEPROCESSTOINTEGRATETRADEINTONATIONALDEVELOPMENTPLANS
)NTHE)&IMPLEMENTATIONINCLUDESTHREEBROADSTEPS&IRSTTHEPREPARATIONOFA$IAGNOSTIC4RADE)NTEGRATION3TUDY$4)34HE$4)3ASSESSES
THECOMPETITIVENESSOFTHEECONOMYANDIDENTIFIESIMPEDIMENTSTOEFFECTIVEINTEGRATIONINTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDTHEGLOBAL
ECONOMY
3ECONDBASEDONTHEFINDINGSOFTHESTUDYAN!CTION-ATRIXISDEVELOPEDINCONSULTATIONWITHALLNATIONALINTERESTEDPARTNERSSUCHAS
GOVERNMENT-INISTERSANDOFFICIALSTHEPRIVATESECTORANDTHECIVILSOCIETYANDACADEMIAATANATIONALVALIDATIONWORKSHOP4HE!CTION-ATRIX
SPELLSOUTASETOFPOLICYRECOMMENDATIONSANDPRIORITYTECHNICALASSISTANCENEEDSTOOVERCOMETHECONSTRAINTSIDENTIFIEDINTHESTUDY,ASTLY
THETRADEPOLICYPRIORITIESAREINCORPORATEDINTOTHECOUNTRYS.ATIONAL$EVELOPMENT0LANSUCHASTHE0230ANDTHEPRIORITYTECHNICALASSISTANCE
NEEDSAREFEDINTODONORSFINANCINGFORASUCHASTHE7ORLD"ANK#ONSULTATIVE'ROUPMEETINGS#'OR5.$02OUND4ABLES/FTENAN
)MPLEMENTATION7ORKSHOPISHELDWITHTHECOUNTRYSDONORCOMMUNITYATTHENATIONALLEVELPRIORTOTHISLASTSTEPINWHICHDEVELOPMENT
PARTNERSCANEXPRESSANINTERESTINSUPPORTINGPARTSOFTHE!CTION-ATRIX
"ASEDONTHEOUTCOMEOFTHESECONDMAJOREVALUATIONOFTHE)&INTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK3TEERING#OMMITTEE)&3#APPROVEDA
7ORK0ROGRAMMEONFOLLOWUPACTIONSTOIMPLEMENTRECOMMENDATIONSOFTHEEVALUATION4HE7ORK0ROGRAMMECONTAINEDINDOCUMENT
74)&3#PROPOSESANUMBEROFACTIONSTOBEACHIEVEDBY$ECEMBER
4HEMANAGEMENTSTRUCTUREOFTHE)&CONSISTSOFTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK3TEERING#OMMITTEE)&3#ANDTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK7ORKING
'ROUP)&7'4HE)&3TEERING#OMMITTEEOVERSEESTHEWORKOFTHE)&7'ANDPROVIDESPOLICYDIRECTIONASSESSESPROGRESSANDENSURESTOTAL
TRANSPARENCYINTHE)&PROCESS)TISATRIPARTITEARRANGEMENTWITHREPRESENTATIONFROMAGENCIESDONORSAND,$#S!LL74/-EMBERSAND
/BSERVERSCANPARTICIPATEINTHE)&3#)TSMEETINGSAREHELDATTHE74/4HE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK7ORKING'ROUP)&7'ISRESPONSIBLEFORTHE
DAYTODAYOVERALLMANAGEMENTOFTHE)&INCLUDINGMONITORINGANDEVALUATIONOFFIELDRESOURCESANDOVERSIGHTOFTHE)&4RUST&UND4HE)&7'
ISCHAIREDBYTHE74/ANDCONSISTSOFREPRESENTATIVESOFTHEAGENCIESANDTWOREPRESENTATIVESEACHFROMLEASTDEVELOPEDANDDONORCOUNTRIES
SELECTEDONAROTATINGBASISIN3WITZERLANDANDTHE%UROPEAN#OMMISSIONFIRSTSIXMONTHSANDTHE5NITED3TATESLATTERPARTOF
REPRESENTEDDONORSAND"ANGLADESHAND4ANZANIATHE,$#S4HE/%#$HASOBSERVERSTATUS4HE74/WHICHHOUSESTHE)&3ECRETARIATINITS
,$#5NITINTHE$EVELOPMENT$IVISIONSERVICESBOTHTHE)&3#AND)&7'MEETINGS&INALLYTHE5.$0ONBEHALFOFTHESIXAGENCIESMANAGES
THE)&4RUST&UND
!SPARTOFTHE)&RESTRUCTURINGTHE)&TRUSTFUND)&4&WASESTABLISHEDBYVOLUNTARYCONTRIBUTIONSFROMBILATERALANDMULTILATERALDONORSTHEFUND
HASTWO7INDOWS7INDOW)FUNDSTHEPREPARATIONOFTHE$4)3ANDAPROJECTDESIGNEDTOSTRENGTHENTHE)&&OCALPOINTSINTHE-INISTRIESOF
4RADEWHILE7INDOW))PROVIDESFUNDINGFORSMALLCONCRETEPRIORITYCAPACITYBUILDINGPROJECTSDERIVEDFROMTHE$4)3!CTION-ATRIXINTHETIME
BETWEENTHECOMPLETIONOFTHE$4)3ANDACCESSINGOFFUNDINGTHROUGHTHECONSULTATIVEGROUPROUNDTABLES0230PROCESSES74)&3#2EV
!TTHEENDOFLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESWEREATDIFFERENTSTAGESOFTHE)&PROCESS4HISINCLUDESREQUESTSTOJOINTHE)&FROMSEVEN
,$#SWHICHAREBEINGCONSIDERED
!TTHEENDOFANDCOUNTINGFROM)&SRESTRUCTURING.ATIONAL6ALIDATION7ORKSHOPSHADBEENCOMPLETEDIN,$#SNAMELYIN"URUNDI
#AMBODIA$JIBOUTI%THIOPIA'UINEA,ESOTHO-ADAGASCAR-ALAWI-ALI-AURITANIA-OZAMBIQUE.EPAL3ENEGALAND9EMEN)NTHE
FOLLOWINGCOUNTRIESSTARTEDTHE$IAGNOSTIC4RADE)NTEGRATION3TUDY$4)3NAMELY"ENIN#HAD,AO0$22WANDA3AO4OMEAND0RINCIPE
4ANZANIAAND:AMBIA!LSOTHE)&7'AGREEDTOSTARTTHE$4)3PROCESSINTHEFOLLOWING,$#S!NGOLA"URKINA&ASO5GANDA.IGER-ALDIVES
THE'AMBIAAND3IERRA,EONE2EQUESTSTOJOINTHE)&BY#ENTRAL!FRICAN2EPUBLIC#OMOROSTHE$EMOCRATIC2EPUBLICOF#ONGO%QUATORIAL
'UINEA,IBERIA3UDANAND(AITIAREBEINGCONSIDERED
!FTERTHE)&SFIRSTYEARSANINCREASEINNUMBEROFDEVELOPMENTPROJECTSWITHTRADECOMPONENTSINANINCREASINGNUMBEROFCOUNTRIESCANBE
NOTED
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
"OX))"ACKGROUNDONTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK
8)) #OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT
3EETHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAIN0ART)ABOVEFOR#4%ACTIVITIESINPAGE
8))) #OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND!DMINISTRATION
)NASPARTOFITSONGOINGRESPONSIBILITIESTHE#OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND
!DMINISTRATION"&!CONTINUEDTOMONITORTHEFINANCIALANDBUDGETARYSITUATIONOFTHE
/RGANIZATION)TFORMULATEDRECOMMENDATIONSTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILONASSESSMENTTO
THEBUDGETANDADVANCETOTHE7ORKING#APITAL&UND)TCONSIDEREDELEMENTSRELATEDTO
PERSONNELMANAGEMENTANDHEARDPROGRESSREPORTSONTHE74/0ENSION0LANASWELLAS
OTHERISSUES
74/ACTIVITIES
#OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND!DMINISTRATION
-AJORAREASOFACTIVITY
$URINGTHECOURSEOFTHE#OMMITTEEEXAMINEDTHERECALCULATIONOFTHE
DEPENDENCYALLOWANCESUSINGTHESALARYMETHODOLOGYADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILON
-AY74'#-4OTHISEFFECTITMADEARECOMMENDATIONTOTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILWHICHADOPTEDITON-AY74'#-
4HE#OMMITTEEREVIEWEDTHEGUIDELINESONVOLUNTARYCONTRIBUTIONSFROM.ON
'OVERNMENTALDONORSASSTIPULATEDANDMADEARECOMMENDATIONTOTHISEFFECT74"&!
TOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWHICHADOPTEDITON!UGUST74'#-
4HE#OMMITTEERECALLEDTHENEEDEXPRESSEDBYTHE-EMBERSINTOMONITORAND
CONTROLTHEUSEOFTEMPORARYASSISTANCEINTHE74/4HE#OMMITTEEEXAMINEDTHEISSUEIN
THECOURSEOFANDFORMULATEDGUIDELINESWHICHWEREENDORSEDBYTHEOMMITTEE
!7ORKING'ROUPONSECURITYMATTERSWASESTABLISHEDWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFTHE
#OMMITTEEANDCONVENEDONANUMBEROFOCCASIONSTODISCUSSSECURITYMATTERS
4HE#OMMITTEEEXAMINEDTHEEXPENDITURESOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODY/PERATING&UND!"/&
ANDAGREEDONTHEFUNDINGOFITSDEFICITIN
!FTERINDEPTHDISCUSSIONSONAWIDERANGEOFQUESTIONSINCLUDINGAPROGRAMMETO
ENHANCETHESAFETYANDSECURITYINTHE74/THE#OMMITTEEFORMULATEDARECOMMENDATION
TOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWITHREGARDTOAREVISEDBUDGETFORANDTHEWAYSANDMEANSTO
FINANCETHEBUDGET
4HE#OMMITTEEALSODISCUSSEDANDORWASINFORMEDABOUTTHEFOLLOWINGPOINTSINTHE
VARIOUSMEETINGSITHEREVISEDBUDGETESTIMATESOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRE
5.#4!$74/IITHESITUATIONOFCONTRIBUTIONSFORTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA'LOBAL
4RUST&UND$$!'4&ANDIIIALETTERFROMTHE#HAIRMANOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODY
2EPORTSOFTHEMEETINGSARECONTAINEDINDOCUMENTS74"&!74"&!AND74
"&!
8)6 0LURILATERALAGREEMENTS
!GREEMENTON'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENT
4HEFOLLOWING74/-EMBERSARE0ARTIESTOTHEPLURILATERAL!GREEMENTON'OVERNMENT
0ROCUREMENTOF#ANADATHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESWITHREGARDITSPREVIOUS
MEMBER3TATESINADDITIONTOSINCE-AYITSNEWMEMBER3TATES(ONG+ONG
#HINA)CELAND)SRAEL*APAN+OREA,IECHTENSTEINTHE+INGDOMOFTHE.ETHERLANDSWITH
RESPECTTO!RUBA.ORWAY3INGAPORE3WITZERLANDANDTHE5NITED3TATES!LBANIA"ULGARIA
'EORGIA*ORDANTHE+YRGYZ2EPUBLIC-OLDOVA/MAN0ANAMAAND#HINESE4AIPEIAREIN
VARIOUSSTAGESOFNEGOTIATINGTHEIRACCESSIONTOTHE!GREEMENT
$URINGTHE#OMMITTEEPURSUEDITSNEGOTIATIONSUNDER!RTICLE88)6OFTHE
!GREEMENT4HESECOVERTHEFOLLOWINGELEMENTSSIMPLIFICATIONANDIMPROVEMENTOFTHE
!GREEMENTINCLUDINGWHEREAPPROPRIATEADAPTATIONTOADVANCESINTHEAREAOFINFORMATION
TECHNOLOGYEXPANSIONOFTHECOVERAGEOFTHE!GREEMENTANDELIMINATIONOFREMAINING
DISCRIMINATORYMEASURESANDPRACTICESWHICHDISTORTOPENANDCOMPETITIVEPROCUREMENT
!PARTICULAROBJECTIVEOFTHENEGOTIATIONSISTOMAKETHE!GREEMENTMOREACCESSIBLETONON
PARTIESTHEREBYFACILITATINGTHEEXPANSIONOFTHEMEMBERSHIPOFTHE!GREEMENT
4OFACILITATETHENEGOTIATIONPROCESSTHE#OMMITTEEADOPTEDIN*ULYASET
OFMODALITIESFORTHENEGOTIATIONSONTHEEXTENSIONOFCOVERAGEANDELIMINATIONOF
DISCRIMINATORYMEASURES'0!4HEMODALITIESCALLFORNEGOTIATIONSTOBECONCLUDEDBY
THEBEGINNINGOF0URSUANTTOTHESEMODALITIESINTHE!UTUMNOFTHE0ARTIES
TOTHE!GREEMENTINITIATEDNEGOTIATIONSWITHRESPECTTOHORIZONTALASPECTSOFTHECOVERAGE
OFTHE!GREEMENT)NADDITIONBILATERALCOVERAGENEGOTIATIONSWERELAUNCHEDWITHTHE
SUBMISSIONOFINITIALOFFICIALREQUESTSBY0ARTIES
)N$ECEMBERTHE#OMMITTEEADOPTEDADECISIONALLOWING)SRAELTOMODIFYITS
!PPENDIX)SOASTOEXTENDBYONEYEARIEUNTILTHEENDOFTHEPERIODTOREDUCEITS
OFFSETSUNDERTHE!GREEMENTFROMTOPERCENTOFTHEVALUEOFTHECOVEREDPROCUREMENT
INVOLVED/THERMATTERSCONSIDEREDBYTHE#OMMITTEEDURINGTHEPERIODHAVEBEEN
MODIFICATIONSTOTHE!PPENDICESTOTHE!GREEMENTSTATISTICALREPORTSANDNOTIFICATIONSOF
THRESHOLDFIGURESINNATIONALCURRENCIES
4HIS!GREEMENTENTEREDINTOFORCEON*ANUARY4HEREARE3IGNATORIESTOTHE
!GREEMENT!USTRIA"ULGARIA"ELGIUM#ANADA$ENMARK%GYPT%STONIATHE%UROPEAN
#OMMUNITIES&RANCE'EORGIA'ERMANY'REECE)RELAND)TALY*APAN,ATVIA,ITHUANIA
,UXEMBOURG-ACAO#HINA-ALTA.ETHERLANDS.ORWAY0ORTUGAL2OMANIA3PAIN
3WEDEN3WITZERLAND#HINESE4AIPEITHE5NITED+INGDOMANDTHE5NITED3TATES4HOSE74/
-EMBERSWITHOBSERVERSTATUSINTHE#OMMITTEEARE!RGENTINA!USTRALIA"ANGLADESH"RAZIL
#AMEROON#HINA#OLOMBIATHE#ZECH2EPUBLIC&INLAND'ABON'HANA(UNGARY)NDIA
)NDONESIA)SRAELTHE2EPUBLICOF+OREA-AURITIUS.IGERIA/MAN0OLAND3INGAPORETHE
3LOVAK2EPUBLIC3RI,ANKA4RINIDADAND4OBAGO4UNISIAAND4URKEY4HE2USSIAN&EDERATION
AND3AUDI!RABIAAREALSOOBSERVERSASARETHE)-&AND5.#4!$
4HE!GREEMENTELIMINATESALLCUSTOMSDUTIESANDOTHERCHARGESONIMPORTSOFCIVILAIRCRAFT
PRODUCTSANDREPAIRSBINDSTHEMATZEROLEVELANDREQUIRESTHEADOPTIONORADAPTATION
OFENDUSECUSTOMSADMINISTRATION4HE!GREEMENTPROHIBITSSIGNATORIESFROMREQUIRING
OREXERTINGPRESSUREONPURCHASERSTOPROCURECIVILAIRCRAFTFROMAPARTICULARSOURCEAND
PROVIDESTHATPURCHASERSOFCIVILAIRCRAFTPRODUCTSSHOULDBEFREETOSELECTSUPPLIERSON
THEBASISOFCOMMERCIALANDTECHNICALFACTORSONLY4HE!GREEMENTREGULATESSIGNATORIES
PARTICIPATIONINORSUPPORTFORCIVILAIRCRAFTPROGRAMMESANDPROHIBITSSIGNATORIESFROM
REQUIRINGORENCOURAGINGSUBNATIONALENTITIESORNONGOVERNMENTALBODIESTOTAKEACTIONS
INCONSISTENTWITHITSPROVISIONS
)NTHE#OMMITTEEAGAINREVERTEDTOTHESTATUSOFTHE!GREEMENTINTHE74/
FRAMEWORK3IGNATORIESHOWEVERREMAINEDUNABLETOADOPTTHE$RAFT0ROTOCOL
2ECTIFYINGTHE!GREEMENTON4RADEIN#IVIL!IRCRAFTTHATWASPROPOSEDBYTHE#HAIRPERSON
IN!PRIL4HUSALTHOUGHTHE!GREEMENTISPARTOFTHE74/!GREEMENTITREMAINS
OUTSIDETHE74/FRAMEWORK4HE#OMMITTEEALSODISCUSSEDINTERALIAhENDUSEvCUSTOMS
ADMINISTRATIONINCLUDINGAREVISEDPROPOSALBYONE3IGNATORYCONCERNINGTHEDEFINITION
OFhCIVILvVShMILITARYvAIRCRAFTBASEDONINITIALCERTIFICATIONANDMATTERSCONCERNING
IMPROVEDOPERATIONOF!RTICLEWITHREGARDTOINDUCEMENTS)TWASPROPOSEDTHATTHE
#OMMITTEEIDENTIFYFACTORSTHATCOULDFACILITATETHEEFFECTIVENESSOF!RTICLEINCLUDINGA
BETTERMECHANISMFORCOMMUNICATIONAMONG3IGNATORIES&INALLYTHE#OMMITTEEDISCUSSED
THEENLARGEMENTOFTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESANDITSRELATIONSHIPWITH!RTICLEOFTHE
!GREEMENTANDQUESTIONSWEREPUTTOTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESINTHISREGARD
74/ACTIVITIES
0LURILATERAL!GREEMENTS
!GREEMENTON4RADEIN#IVIL!IRCRAFT
0!24))
) #OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSANDRELATIONSWITHCIVIL
SOCIETY
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
2ELATIONSWITHNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSCIVILSOCIETY
4HE74/SRELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETYCONTINUEDTOEVOLVEWITHNUMEROUSACTIVITIESAND
EXCHANGESFOCUSINGONSPECIFICASPECTSRELATEDTOTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAAND
NEGOTIATIONS2ELATIONSWITH.ON'OVERNMENTAL/RGANIZATIONS.'/SARESPECIFIEDIN!RTICLE
6OFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE74/ANDWEREFURTHERELABORATEDINA
SETOFGUIDELINES74,ADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN*ULY4HEGUIDELINES
hRECOGNIZETHEROLE.'/SCANPLAYTOINCREASETHEAWARENESSOFTHEPUBLICINRESPECTOF74/
ACTIVITIESv
7HILEMEMBERSOFCIVILSOCIETYAND.'/REPRESENTATIVESAREINDAILYCONTACTWITHTHE
74/3ECRETARIATAND74/-EMBERSTHEYALSOATTEND74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCESAND
PARTICIPATEINISSUESPECIFICSYMPOSIA"RIEFINGSONMEETINGSOFTHEMAJOR74/#OUNCILS
AND#OMMITTEESAREALSOORGANIZEDREGULARLYFOR'ENEVABASEDREPRESENTATIVES4HE74/
3ECRETARIATRECEIVESALARGENUMBEROFMEETINGREQUESTSFROM.'/SFROMALLOVERTHEWORLD
ANDTHE74/S$IRECTOR'ENERALAND3ECRETARIATSTAFFREGULARLYMEETREPRESENTATIVESFROM
.'/S74/3ECRETARIATOFFICIALSPARTICIPATEASOFTENASPOSSIBLEINMAJORMEETINGSWHERE
SUBJECTSOFINTERESTTOCIVILSOCIETYAREDISCUSSED
3INCETHEADOPTIONOFTHEGUIDELINESTHE74/3ECRETARIATHASENHANCEDITSDIALOGUE
WITHCIVILSOCIETY)NTHERUNUPTOTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINSEVERALNEW
ACTIVITIESINVOLVING.'/SWEREPROPOSEDANDAGREEDTOBY74/-EMBERS74).&
!MONGOTHERS.'/SCANBEINVITEDTOTHE74/TOINFORMALLYPRESENTTHEIRRECENTPOLICY
RESEARCHANDANALYSISDIRECTLYTO74/-EMBERS)NTHE74/3ECRETARIATINCREASEDTHE
NUMBEROF.'/BRIEFINGSONMAJOR74/MEETINGSANDBEGANLISTINGTHEBRIEFINGSCHEDULES
ONITSWEBSITE)NANDTHEBRIEFINGSWEREPRIMARILYBASEDONTHEPREPARATIONSFOR
THE&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEHELDIN#ANCÞN-EXICOIN3EPTEMBERANDITSFOLLOW
UPINPARTICULARTHEADOPTIONBY74/-EMBERSOFTHE@*ULY0ACKAGE
!MONTHLYLISTOF.'/POSITIONPAPERSRECEIVEDBYTHE3ECRETARIATISCOMPILEDAND
CIRCULATEDFORTHEINFORMATIONOF74/-EMBERS3INCETHEMONTHLYELECTRONICNEWS
BULLETINFOR.'/SHASBEENREPLACEDBYABIWEEKLY74/5PDATEFURTHERFACILITATINGACCESS
TO74/INFORMATION3UBSCRIPTIONREQUESTSSHOULDBESENTBYEMAILTOTHEFOLLOWINGADDRESS
NGOBULLETIN WTOORG
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCES
.'/ATTENDANCEAT74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCESISBASEDONABASICSETOFREGISTRATION
PROCEDURESDECIDEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTHESENORMALLYINVOLVEI.'/SAREALLOWED
TOATTENDTHE0LENARY3ESSIONSOFTHE#ONFERENCEANDII.'/APPLICATIONSTOREGISTERARE
ACCEPTEDBYTHE74/3ECRETARIATONTHEBASISOF!RTICLE6IE.'/SHAVETODEMONSTRATE
THATTHEIRACTIVITIESAREhCONCERNEDWITHMATTERSRELATEDTOTHOSEOFTHE74/v)NFORMATION
ONTHESEPROCEDURESCANBEFOUNDONTHE74/WEBSITE
4HETABLEBELOWGIVESTHENUMBERSOF.'/ATTENDEESATTHEFIVE74/-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCESHELDUNTILNOW4HE&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN#ANCÞN-EXICOSAWTHE
HIGHESTNUMBEROFCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVESIN74/SHISTORY
4ABLE))
.'/ATTENDANCEATMINISTERIALCONFERENCES
-INISTERIAL
.OOFELIGIBLE.'/S
.'/SWHOATTENDED
.OOFPARTICIPANTS
3INGAPORE
'ENEVA
3EATTLE
APPROX
$OHA
#ANCÞN
3INCE74/SANNUALPUBLICSYMPOSIUMHASPROVIDEDCIVILSOCIETYWITHOPPORTUNITIES
TOENGAGEWITHGOVERNMENTOFFICIALSACADEMICSANDOTHERCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVES
4HEFIVESYMPOSIAHELDUNTILNOWHAVESHOWNTHATGOVERNMENTSANDCIVILSOCIETYCANHAVE
OPENANDCONSTRUCTIVEDIALOGUESONISSUESWHEREDIFFERENCESEXISTBUTWHEREPOSSIBLE
SOLUTIONSCANALSOBEIDENTIFIEDANDDISCUSSED)NATHREEDAYSYMPOSIUMWITHSOME
PARTICIPANTSWASHELDATTHE74/%NTITLED-ULTILATERALISMATA#ROSSROADSTHE
SYMPOSIUMFEATURED74/ORGANIZEDWORKSESSIONSANDALSOTWENTYFIVESESSIONSORGANIZED
BY.'/SONTOPICSOFTHEIRCHOICE$EVELOPMENTOPPORTUNITIESFUNCTIONINGOFTHE74/
ANDAGRICULTUREWEREAMONGTHEMAINISSUESDISCUSSED!NOTHERSYMPOSIUMISPLANNEDFOR
TO!PRILTHISEVENTTAKESONSPECIALSIGNIFICANCEASITCOINCIDESWITHTHETH
ANNIVERSARYOFTHE74/0ARTICIPANTSWILLBEABLETODISCUSSh4HE74/AFTER9EARS'LOBAL
0ROBLEMSAND-ULTILATERAL3OLUTIONSv
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
4HE74/WORKSCLOSELYWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSAND
ESPECIALLYTHOSEINVOLVEDWITHTRADERELATEDSUBJECTS4HE74/COOPERATESANDCOORDINATES
WITHTHE5NITED.ATIONSANDMANYOFITSAGENCIESWITHTHE"RETTON7OODSINSTITUTIONSAND
WITHOTHERINTERNATIONALANDREGIONALBODIES
)NITSEFFORTSTOFURTHERTHEDEVELOPMENTDIMENSIONOFTRADETHE74/WORKSCLOSELYWITH
THE5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT5.#4!$!MAJORFOCUSOFJOINT
WORKCONCERNSCAPACITYBUILDINGANDPROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCETODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
ANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES5.#4!$ISAMAJORPARTNERINTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK
FOR4RADE2ELATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCETO,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES)&ANDALSOTHE*OINT
)NTEGRATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE0ROGRAMME*)4!0!SWELLMANYINTERREGIONALMEETINGS
ANDTRAININGACTIVITIESAREORGANIZEDTOASSISTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYREPRESENTATIVESTOLEARN
MOREABOUT74/TRADEISSUESANDNEGOTIATIONS3UCHACTIVITIESARESPONSOREDEITHERBY
74/OR5.#4!$ORBOTHANDINVOLVESTAFFFROMBOTHORGANIZATIONS/THERINTERNATIONAL
INTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSTHATCOOPERATEWITHTHE74/ONTHEDEVELOPMENT
DIMENSIONPARTICULARLYTHE)&AND*)4!0INCLUDETHE5NITED.ATIONS$EVELOPMENT0ROGRAMME
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UNDAND7ORLD"ANK
4HE74/REMAINSAPARTICIPANTINVARIOUSACTIVITIESORGANIZEDBYTHE5NITED.ATIONSITS
AGENCIESANDOTHERINTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS4HE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
ATTENDSREGULARLYMEETINGSOFTHE5.#HIEF%XECUTIVES"OARD#%"74/3ECRETARIATOFFICIALS
ALSOPARTICIPATEINTHE"OARDSSUBSIDIARYBODIES!SWELLTHE74/3ECRETARIATISREPRESENTED
ONAHIGHLEVEL5NITED.ATIONSCOORDINATIONCOMMITTEEMONITORINGPROGRESSTOWARDS
ACHIEVINGTHE5NITED.ATIONS-ILLENNIUM'OALS74/ALSOPARTICIPATESINAFOLLOWUP
MECHANISMRELATINGTOTHE)NTERNATIONAL#ONFERENCEON&INANCINGFOR$EVELOPMENT
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
3YMPOSIA
/UTREACHACTIVITIESFORPARLIAMENTARIANSANDCIVILSOCIETY
)NTHE74/EXTENDEDITSPROGRAMMEOFOUTREACHACTIVITIESFORCIVILSOCIETYAND
PARLIAMENTARIANS!FIRSTEVERWORKSHOPFORCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVESIN&RENCHSPEAKING
!FRICAWASHELDIN3ENEGALIN.OVEMBER4HEREWEREALSOREGIONALWORKSHOPSCONDUCTEDIN
.EW:EALANDFORPARLIAMENTARIANSFROMTHE0ACIFIC-OROCCOFORPARLIAMENTARIANSFROM
&RANCOPHONE!FRICAAND3INGAPOREFORPARLIAMENTARIANSFROMVARIOUS!SIAN#OUNTRIES
4HEWORKSHOPSAREDESIGNEDTOHELPCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVESANDLEGISLATORSBETTER
UNDERSTANDTHE74/ANDPROVISIONSOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION4HEYAREADDITIONAL
TONATIONALWORKSHOPSFORPARLIAMENTARIANSCARRIEDOUTASPARTOFTHE74/SREGULARTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCEWORK
/NEVERYPOSITIVEEFFECTOFTHEPROGRAMMEOFOUTREACHACTIVITIESWASTHE
ENHANCEMENTOFCLOSEWORKINGRELATIONSWITHNUMEROUSCIVILSOCIETYANDPARLIAMENTARY
ORGANIZATIONS4HESERELATIONSWEREFURTHERAUGMENTEDTHROUGH74/ATTENDANCEATMAJOR
EVENTSSUCHASTHE"RUSSELS3ESSIONOFTHE0ARLIAMENTARY#ONFERENCEONTHE74/ORGANIZED
JOINTLYBYTHE)NTER0ARLIAMENTARY5NIONAND%UROPEAN0ARLIAMENTIN.OVEMBER
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
#OOPERATIONWITHTHE)-&ANDTHE7ORLD"ANK#OHERENCE
4HE74/SCOOPERATIONWITHTHE)-&ANDTHE7ORLD"ANKISBASEDONTHE-ARRAKESH
h$ECLARATIONONTHE#ONTRIBUTIONOFTHE74/TO!CHIEVING#OHERENCEIN'LOBAL%CONOMIC
0OLICY-AKINGvANDONTHE74/SFORMALCOOPERATIONAGREEMENTSWITHTHE)-&ANDTHE
7ORLD"ANK#OOPERATIONATTHESTAFFLEVELEXTENDSTOMANYAREASOFTHE74/INCLUDING
ONRESEARCHTOPICSEXCHANGEOFSTATISTICALDATAANDTRADEPOLICYINFORMATIONANDTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCEANDTRAINING-OREDETAILEDINFORMATIONISAVAILABLEINTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALS
!NNUAL2EPORTON#OHERENCE
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILHELDITSSECONDFORMALMEETINGON#OHERENCEON/CTOBER
&ORTHESECONDYEARINAROWTHE-ANAGING$IRECTOROFTHE)-&ANDTHE0RESIDENTOFTHE
7ORLD"ANKPARTICIPATEDINTHEMEETINGnUNDERLININGTHEIMPORTANCEBOTHAGENCIESATTACH
TOTHECURRENT$OHANEGOTIATIONSANDTODEEPENINGCOOPERATIONWITHTHE74/4HEMAIN
THEMEOFTHEMEETINGWASESTABLISHINGLONGTERMCOHERENCEBETWEENGOVERNMENTSTRADE
FINANCEANDDEVELOPMENTPOLICIESATTHEDOMESTICLEVELANDATTHEMULTILATERALLEVELWITH
SUPPORTFROMTHETHREEORGANIZATIONSINPROVIDINGHIGHQUALITYPOLICYANALYSISTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGANDADJUSTMENTASSISTANCE!MONGTHEISSUESTHAT-EMBERS
FELTWARRANTEDATTENTIONINTHISCONTEXTWERETHEEFFECTSOFTHEENDOFTEXTILEQUOTASUNDER
THE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHINGTHEEROSIONOFPREFERENCEMARGINSASARESULT
OFMULTILATERALLIBERALIZATIONTHEFISCALEFFECTSOFTARIFFLIBERALIZATIONANDTHETIMINGAND
SEQUENCINGOFREFORMSTOTRADEANDOTHERECONOMICPOLICIES
4HE)-&ANDTHE7ORLD"ANKCONTINUETOEXPANDTHEIRPROGRAMMESRELATEDTOTRADEAND
THESUPPORTOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!4HE)-&HASSTEPPEDUPITSCAPACITY
TOPROVIDETECHNICALASSISTANCEESPECIALLYINCUSTOMSADMINISTRATIONANDTARIFFPOLICYITHAS
INCREASEDTHETRADEFOCUSOFITS!RTICLE)6#ONSULTATIONSANDITHASREITERATEDITSREADINESS
TOSUPPORT-EMBERSDEALINGWITHTHEMACROECONOMICEFFECTSOFPRICEOROTHERSHOCKS
THROUGHITS0OVERTY2EDUCTIONAND'ROWTH&ACILITY02'&)NADDITIONTHE)-&SNEW4RADE
)NTEGRATION-ECHANISM4)-nDESIGNEDTOPROVIDEFINANCIALSUPPORTTO-EMBERSTHAT
FACEANETNEGATIVEIMPACTONTHEIRBALANCEOFPAYMENTSASARESULTOFIMPLEMENTATIONOF
MULTILATERALTRADECOMMITMENTSnWASMADEOPERATIONALINWITH"ANGLADESHBEINGTHE
FIRSTCOUNTRYTOOBTAINFUNDINGUNDERTHEARRANGEMENT4HE7ORLD"ANKHASALSOCONTINUED
TOEXPANDTHESIGNIFICANTSUPPORTITALREADYPROVIDES-EMBERSINPARTICULARINTHECONTEXT
OFTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK)&FOR4RADE2ELATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCETHE3TANDARDSAND
4RADE$EVELOPMENT&ACILITY34$&ANDITSWORKONTRADEFACILITATIONCARRIEDOUTUNDERTHE
UMBRELLAOFTHE"ANKSNEW$OHA$EVELOPMENT)NITIATIVE
4HE$ECISIONTAKENATTHE*ULY'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGALSOIDENTIFIESNEWAREASWHERE
74/COOPERATIONWITHTHE)-&ANDTHE7ORLD"ANKSHOULDBEEXPANDED-EMBERSHAVE
AGREEDTOWORKMULTILATERALLYWITHTHEINTERNATIONALFINANCIALINSTITUTIONSONDEVELOPMENT
ASPECTSOFTHE3ECTORAL)NITIATIVEON#OTTON)NTHISREGARDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALISINSTRUCTED
TOCONSULTWITHTHE)-&AND7ORLD"ANKAMONGOTHERSTODIRECTEFFECTIVELYEXISTING
PROGRAMMESANDANYADDITIONALRESOURCESTOWARDSDEVELOPMENTOFTHEECONOMIESWHERE
COTTONHASAVITALIMPORTANCE4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILS$ECISIONALSOCALLSFORPROVIDING
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESINTRANSITIONINPARTICULARLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESWITHENHANCEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGTOINCREASETHEIR
EFFECTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHENEGOTIATIONSTOFACILITATETHEIRIMPLEMENTATIONOF74/
RULESANDTOENABLETHEMTOADJUSTANDDIVERSIFYTHEIRECONOMIES-EMBERSHAVEFURTHER
ENCOURAGEDIMPROVEDCOORDINATIONWITHOTHERAGENCIESINCLUDINGUNDERTHE)NTEGRATED
&RAMEWORKFOR,$#SANDTHE*OINT)NTEGRATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE0ROGRAMME*)4!0
)NADDITION74/-EMBERSHAVEINVITEDTHE)-&AND7ORLD"ANKTOWORKWITHOTHERRELEVANT
INTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSTOMAKETECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGMOREEFFECTIVE
ANDOPERATIONALTOSUPPORTTHENEGOTIATIONSONTRADEFACILITATION
/PPORTUNITIESFORCONSULTATIONSATTHEHEADSOFAGENCYLEVELAROSEATTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILMEETINGON#OHERENCEIN/CTOBERATMEETINGSOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY
AND&INANCE#OMMITTEE)-&#ANDTHE$EVELOPMENT#OMMITTEEAT%#/3/#ANDOTHER
INTERGOVERNMENTALMEETINGS!TTENTIONINTHESECONSULTATIONSFOCUSEDONACTIONSTHATCOULD
BETAKENTOHELPADVANCETHE$OHATRADENEGOTIATIONSANDWORKPROGRAMMEINCLUDING
MOBILIZINGTHEACTIVESUPPORTOF&INANCEAND$EVELOPMENT-INISTERS
4ABLE))
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/
ASAT*ULY
4HEGUIDELINESONOBSERVERSTATUSFORINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS74,!NNEXPROVIDETHATREQUESTSFOR
OBSERVERSTATUSFROMORGANIZATIONSSHALLNOTBECONSIDEREDFORMEETINGSOFTHE"UDGET#OMMITTEEORTHE$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT"ODYTHEREFORETHESEBODIESARENOTLISTEDINTHETABLE!LSONOTLISTEDARETHE4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODY
WHICHHASNOINTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONOBSERVERSAND!CCESSION7ORKING0ARTIES
4HE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRE5.#4!$74/ASAJOINTSUBSIDIARYORGANOFTHE74/AND5.#4!$ISNOTREQUIRED
TOFORMALLYSUBMITAREQUESTFOROBSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/BODIESANDISINVITEDASAPPROPRIATETOATTEND
MEETINGSOFTHOSE74/BODIESITWISHESTOATTEND74'#-ITEM4HE)4#ISTHEREFORENOTLISTEDINTHIS
TABLE
4HE)-&AND7ORLD"ANKHAVEOBSERVERSTATUSIN74/BODIESASPROVIDEDFORINTHEIRRESPECTIVE!GREEMENTSWITH
THE74/74,ANDARENOTLISTEDINTHISTABLE
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSWITHUNIVERSALREPRESENTATIONAREINITALICS!N8INDICATES
OBSERVERSTATUSA0INDICATESTHATCONSIDERATIONOFTHEREQUESTFOROBSERVERSTATUSISPENDING
4HEBODIESLISTEDINTHE4ABLE))ARERESPECTIVELYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL'#4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY402"
#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODS#4'#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES#43#OUNCILFOR42)0342)03THE#OMMITTEES
ON!NTI$UMPING0RACTICES!$03UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING-EASURES3#-3AFEGUARDS3'!GRICULTURE
!'3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURES303"ALANCEOF0AYMENTS2ESTRICTIONS"/032EGIONAL4RADE
!GREEMENTS#24!4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT#4$4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT#4%-ARKET!CCESS-!)MPORT
,ICENSING,)#2ULESOF/RIGIN2/4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADE4"44RADE2ELATED)NVESTMENT-EASURES
42)-3#USTOMS6ALUATION6!,!DDITIONALINFORMATIONCONCERNINGTHEOBSERVERSTATUSOFTHELISTED
ORGANIZATIONSINTHE'!44#/.42!#4).'0!24)%3'!44#03#OUNCILOF2EPRESENTATIVES'!44#.#,AND
#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT'!44#4$ISPROVIDEDINTHELASTTHREECOLUMNS
4ABLE))%XPLANATORY.OTE
4ABLE))PROVIDESINFORMATIONONOBSERVERSTATUSINTHEFOURBODIESUNDERTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES
NAMELYTHE#OMMITTEESON&INANCIAL3ERVICESAND3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTSANDTHE7ORKING0ARTIESON'!43
2ULESAND$OMESTIC2EGULATIONASWELLASINTHE7ORKING'ROUPSON4RANSPARENCYIN'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENT
THE2ELATIONSHIPBETWEEN4RADEAND)NVESTMENTTHE)NTERACTIONBETWEEN4RADEAND#OMPETITION0OLICY4RADE
$EBTAND&INANCE4RADEAND4RANSFEROF4ECHNOLOGY
4ABLE))%XPLANATORY.OTE
)NFORMATIONFORTHE#OMMITTEESUNDERTHE0LURILATERAL4RADE!GREEMENTSISPROVIDEDIN4ABLE))NAMELY
THE#OMMITTEEON'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENT'0!THE#OMMITTEEON4RADEIN#IVIL!IRCRAFT4#!ANDTHE
#OMMITTEEOF0ARTICIPANTSINTHE%XPANSIONOF4RADEIN)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY0RODUCTS)4!
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
4ABLE))%XPLANATORY.OTE
4ABLE))
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/
'!44#.#,
'!44#4$
6!,
'!44#03
4"4
42)-3
2/
8
,)#
#4%
8
-!
#4$
#24!
"/03
!'
303
8
3'
8
3#-
#43
42)03
8
!$0
#4'
402"
'#
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
5.BODIESANDSPECIALIZEDAGENCIES
5.
5NITED.ATIONS
#"$
#ONVENTIONON"IOLOGICAL$IVERSITY
#)4%3
#ONVENTIONON)NTERNATIONAL4RADEIN
%NDANGERED3PECIES
)00#
&!/)NTERNATIONAL0LANT0ROTECTION
#ONVENTION
8
#ODEX
&!/7(/*OINT#ODEX!LIMENTARIUS
#OMMISSION
8
&!/
&OOD!GRICULTURE/RGANIZATIONOF
THE5NITED.ATIONS
)45_
)NTERNATIONAL4ELECOMMUNICATION5NION 0
5.!)$3
*OINT5NITED.ATIONS0ROGRAMMESON
()6!)$3
8
0
0
0
8
8
0
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
;__=
-ONTREAL0ROTOCOLON3UBSTANCESTHAT
$EPLETETHE/ZONE,AYER
0
#3$
5NITED.ATIONS#OMMISSIONFOR
3USTAINABLE$EVELOPMENT
8
5.#4!$
5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON4RADE
$EVELOPMENT
8
5.$0
5NITED.ATIONS$EVELOPMENT
0ROGRAMME
0
%#!
5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMIC#OMMISSION
FOR!FRICA
%#%
5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMIC#OMMISSION
FOR%UROPE
%#,!#
5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMIC#OMMISSION
FOR,ATIN!MERICATHE#ARIBBEAN
8
8
8
8
%3#!0
5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMIC3OCIAL
#OMMISSIONFOR!SIATHE0ACIFIC
8
8
8
8
5.%3#/
5NITED.ATIONS%DUCATIONAL3CIENTIFIC
AND#ULTURAL/RGANIZATION
5.%0
5NITED.ATIONS%NVIRONMENT
0ROGRAMME
5.&###
5NITED.ATIONS&RAMEWORK#ONVENTION
OF#LIMATE#HANGE
5.)$/
5NITED.ATIONS)NDUSTRIAL$EVELOPMENT 0
/RGANIZATION
7&0
5NITED.ATIONS7ORLD&OOD0ROGRAMME
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
0
8
8
8
8
0
0
III
0
8
8
8
8
IV
0
8
8
8
7(/
7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION
7)0/
7ORLD)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY/RGANIZATION 8
0
V
VI
8
8
III
8
8
8
4ABLE))CONTINUED
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/
'!44#.#,
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
VIII
0
8
8
'!44#4$
0
6!,
8
'!44#03
2/
8
4"4
,)#
8
42)-3
-!
8
#4%
III
#4$
0
#24!
VII
"/03
VII
!'
3'
VII
303
3#-
0
!$0
#43
0
42)03
#4'
402"
'#
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
/THERORGANIZATIONS
!#0
!FRICAN#ARIBBEAN0ACIFIC'ROUP
0
OF3TATES
/!0)
!FRICAN)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY
0
/RGANIZATION
!2)0/
!FRICAN2EGIONAL)NDUSTRIAL0ROPERTY
0
!5
!FRICAN5NION
0
0
0
!.$%!.#OMMUNITY
!!!)$
III
8
!RAB!UTHORITY!GRICULTURAL)NVESTMENT
8
0
AND$EVELOPMENT
0
III
!-5
!RAB-AGHREB5NION
0
0
0
!-&
!RAB-ONETARY&UND
0
0
0
!4&0
!RAB4RADE&INANCING0ROGRAM
0
0
0
!0##
!SIANAND0ACIFIC#OCONUT#OMMUNITY
")0-
"UREAU)NTERNATIONALDES0OIDSET
-ESURES
#!2)#/-
#ARIBBEAN#OMMUNITY3ECRETARIAT
8
8
#!%-#
#ENTRAL!FRICAN%CONOMIC-ONETARY
8
8
0
0
0
8
8
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
/RG
#OMMUNITY
#&#
#OMMON&UNDFOR#OMMODITIES
#/-%3!
#OMMON-ARKETFOR%ASTERNAND
IX
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
8
0
0
0
0
0
3OUTHERN!FRICA
#OMMONWEALTH3ECRETARIAT
#-!
7#!
'##
8
#ONFERENCEOF-INISTERSOF!GRICULTURE
8
8
0
OF7ESTAND#ENTRAL!FRICA
#OOPERATION#OUNCILFORTHE!RAB3TATES 0
0
0
0
0
8
0
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
OFTHE'ULF
%#/7!3
III
%CONOMIC#OMMUNITYOF7EST!FRICAN
3TATES
%#/
%CONOMIC#OOPERATION/RGANIZATION
0
0
%"2$
%UROPEAN"ANKFOR2ECONSTRUCTION
0
8
0
0
0
8
0
0
0
0
III
8
0
8
8
8
8
0
0
0
0
8
$EVELOPMENT
%&4!
%UROPEAN&REE4RADE!SSOCIATION
'/)#
'ULF/RGANIZATIONFOR)NDUSTRIAL
III
0
0
0
8
VIII
0
0
0
8
8
0
#ONSULTING
)!$"
)NTER!MERICAN$EVELOPMENT"ANK
))#!
)NTER!MERICAN)NSTITUTEFOR#OOPERATION
0
0
0
0
8
III
ON!GRICULTURE
4ABLE))CONTINUED
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/
)!)'#
'!44#.#,
'!44#4$
6!,
'!44#03
4"4
III
)NTER!RAB)NVESTMENT'UARANTEE
42)-3
2/
,)#
-!
#4%
#4$
#24!
"/03
!'
303
3'
3#-
!$0
#43
42)03
#4'
402"
'#
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
0
#OOPERATION
)#!/
)NTERNATIONAL#IVIL!VIATION/RGANIZATION
)##!4
)NTERNATIONAL#OMMISSIONFORTHE
V
8
#ONSERVATIONOF!TLANTIC4UNA
)%#
)NTERNATIONAL%LECTROTECHNICAL
8
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
#OMMISSION
)'#
)NTERNATIONAL'RAINS#OUNCIL
/)%
)NTERNATIONAL/FFICEOF%PIZOOTICS
/),-
)NTERNATIONAL/RGANIZATIONOF,EGAL
-ETROLOGY
)3/
)NTERNATIONAL/RGANIZATIONFOR
3TANDARDIZATION
)0'2)
)NTERNATIONAL0LANT'ENETIC2ESOURCES
0
8
8
8
8
8
VIII
8
8
0
8
8
)NSTITUTE
)4#"
)NTERNATIONAL4EXTILESAND#LOTHING
0
8
8
8
"UREAU
)44/
)NTERNATIONAL4ROPICAL4IMBER
0
/RGANIZATION
50/6
)NTERNATIONAL5NIONFORTHE0ROTECTION
8
OF.EW6ARIETIESOF0LANTS
)6)
)NTERNATIONAL6ACCINE)NSTITUTE
0
/)6
)NTERNATIONAL6INEAND7INE/FFICE
0
)S$"
)SLAMIC$EVELOPMENT"ANK
0
0
0
0
3%,!
,ATIN!MERICAN%CONOMIC3YSTEM
0
0
0
0
!,!$)
,ATIN!MERICAN)NTEGRATION!SSOCIATION
,!3
,EAGUEOF!RAB3TATES
/%#3
/RGANIZATIONOFTHE%ASTERN#ARIBBEAN
0
0
0
0
0
0
III
0
III
X
0
8
8
III
8
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
VIII
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
3TATES
/)&
/RGANISATION)NTERNATIONALEDELA
0
&RANCOPHONIE
/!3
/RGANIZATIONOF!MERICAN3TATES
0
/%#$
/RGANIZATIONFOR%CONOMIC#OOPERATION
8
0
0
0
0
8
8
0XI
8
0
0
0
0
XII
XII
XII
8
III
8
8
8
0
8
8
0
III
0
0
0
III
8
8
8
8
$EVELOPMENT
/)#
/RGANIZATIONOFTHE)SLAMIC#ONFERENCE
/0%#
/RGANIZATIONOFTHE0ETROLEUM
%XPORTING#OUNTRIES
/)23!
III
2EGIONAL)NTERNATIONAL/RGANIZATIONFOR
0LANT0ROTECTIONAND!NIMAL(EALTH
0ACIFIC)SLANDS&ORUM
0
0
8
4ABLE))CONTINUED
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINTHE74/
'!44#.#,
8
'!44#4$
6!,
4"4
42)-3
2/
,)#
-!
#4%
#4$
0
#24!
0
"/03
0
!'
0
303
0
3'
0
3#-
0
'!44#03
0ERMANENT3ECRETARIATOFTHE'ENERAL
!$0
#43
42)03
3)%#!
402"
0
'#
#4'
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
8
8
8
4REATYON#ENTRAL!MERICAN%CONOMIC
)NTEGRATION
3OUTH#ENTRE
3%!&$%#
III
0
X
3OUTHEAST!SIAN&ISHERIES$EVELOPMENT
#ENTRE
3!$#
3OUTHERN!FRICAN$EVELOPMENT
0
0
0
8
0
III
505
5NIVERSAL0OSTAL5NION
7!%-5
7EST!FRICAN%CONOMIC-ONETARY
0
0
0
5NION
7#/
74/
7ORLD#USTOMS/RGANIZATION
0
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
V
7ORLD4OURISM/RGANIZATION
4!",%))
/BSERVERSTATUSINCERTAINOTHERBODIES
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
&INANCIAL '!43 $OMESTIC
3PECIFIC
7ORKING'ROUP
7ORKING
7ORKING
7ORKING 7ORKING
3ERVICES 2ULES 2EGULATION #OMMITMENTS ON4RANSPARENCY 'ROUPONTHE 'ROUPON4HE 'ROUP
IN'OVERNMENT 2ELATIONSHIP
0ROCUREMENT
'ROUPON
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
#OMMUNITY
)NTERACTION ON4RADE 4RADEAND
BETWEEN4RADE
BETWEEN
$EBTAND 4RANSFEROF
AND)NVESTMENT
4RADEAND
&INANCE 4ECHNOLOGY
#OMPETITION
0OLICY
5.BODIESANDSPECIALIZEDAGENCIES
5.
5NITED.ATIONS
&!/
&OODAND!GRICULTURAL
/RGANIZATION
5.#)42!,
5NITED.ATIONS#OMMISSIONON
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE,AW
5.#4!$
5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON
4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
%#,!#
5NITED.ATIONS%CONOMIC
#OMMISSIONFOR,ATIN!MERICA
THE#ARIBBEAN
5.)$/
5NITED.ATIONS)NDUSTRIAL
$EVELOPMENT/RGANIZATION
7)0/
7ORLD)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY
/RGANIZATION
8
8
8
8
XIII
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
0
XIV
8
8
/THER/RGANIZATIONS
!#0
!FRICAN#ARIBBEAN0ACIFIC
8
8
'ROUPOF3TATES
!5
!FRICAN5NION
0
4!",%))CONTINUED
/BSERVERSTATUSINCERTAINOTHERBODIES
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
&INANCIAL '!43 $OMESTIC
3PECIFIC
7ORKING'ROUP
7ORKING
7ORKING
7ORKING 7ORKING
3ERVICES 2ULES 2EGULATION #OMMITMENTS ON4RANSPARENCY 'ROUPONTHE 'ROUPON4HE 'ROUP
IN'OVERNMENT 2ELATIONSHIP
0ROCUREMENT
'ROUPON
)NTERACTION ON4RADE 4RADEAND
BETWEEN4RADE
BETWEEN
$EBTAND 4RANSFEROF
AND)NVESTMENT
4RADEAND
&INANCE 4ECHNOLOGY
#OMPETITION
0OLICY
'/)#
%NERGY#HARTER#ONFERENCE
0
'ULF/RGANIZATIONFOR)NDUSTRIAL
0
#ONSULTING
)!)3
)NTERNATIONAL!SSOCIATIONOF
0
0
)NSURANCE3UPERVISORS
74/ACTIVITIES
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSAND
RELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
3%,!
,ATIN!MERICAN%CONOMIC
0XV
0
0XVI
XV
XIV
8
0
0
0
0
3YSTEM
/!3
/%#$
/RGANIZATIONOF!MERICAN3TATES
/RGANIZATIONFOR%CONOMIC
0
8
8
8
8
0
8
#OOPERATIONAND
$EVELOPMENT
/)#
/RGANIZATIONOFTHE)SLAMIC
0
#ONFERENCE
3OUTH#ENTRE
505
5NIVERSAL0OSTAL5NION
0
4!",%))
)NTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSn/BSERVERSTATUSINCOMMITTEESUNDERTHEPLURILATERALTRADEAGREEMENTS
3EEEXPLANATORYNOTE
'0!
4#!
5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
8
8
!FRICAN#ARIBBEANAND0ACIFIC'ROUPOF3TATES
#ENTRAL!MERICAN)NSTITUTEOF0UBLIC!DMINISTRATION
#OMMON-ARKETFOR%ASTERNAND3OUTHERN!FRICA
%UROPEAN&REE4RADE!SSOCIATION
)NTER!MERICAN$EVELOPMENT"ANK
/RGANIZATIONFOR%CONOMIC#OOPERATIONAND$EVELOPMENT
7ORLD#USTOMS/RGANIZATION
0
0
0
0
8
0
)4!
5.BODIESANDSPECIALIZEDAGENCIES
5.#4!$
/THER/RGANIZATIONS
!#0
)#!0
#/-%3!
%&4!
)!$"
/%#$
7#/
8
8XVII
_
4HE)453ECRETARIATSHALL;ALSO=BEINVITEDASANOBSERVERTOMEETINGSOFRELEVANT74/BODIESOTHERTHANTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESANDTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEEXCLUDING
THE#OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND!DMINISTRATION$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY!PPELLATE"ODYAND$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT0ANELSWHERETHATBODYCONSIDERSTHATMATTERSOFCOMMON
INTERESTTOBOTHORGANIZATIONSWILLBEUNDERDISCUSSION
__
4HE#OUNCILAGREEDTOAREQUESTFROMTHE*OINT5NITED.ATIONS0ROGRAMMEON()6!)$35.!)$3FOROBSERVERSTATUSDURINGTHE#OUNCILSDISCUSSIONSONTHE42)03!GREEMENTAND
PUBLICHEALTH
III
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSONAMEETINGBYMEETINGBASIS
IV
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSPENDINGFINALAGREEMENTONTHEAPPLICATIONOFTHEGUIDELINESFOROBSERVERSTATUSFORINTERNATIONALINTERGOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONSINTHE74/
V
4HE#OUNCILAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUS
VI
4HE#OUNCILAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSONTHEUNDERSTANDINGTHATTHE74/WOULDBEGIVENRECIPROCALOPPORTUNITIESTOOBSERVEMEETINGSOFALLFUNCTIONALBODIESUNDER
THE7(/INCLUDINGTHOSEATTHEREGIONALLEVELEXCEPTWHENMEETINGSARELIMITEDTO-EMBERGOVERNMENTSONLY
VII
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSPENDINGTHEOUTCOMEOFTHEHORIZONTALPROCESS
VIII
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSPENDINGFURTHERDECISIONS
IX
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSONAMEETINGBYMEETINGBASISTOTHE#&#WHEN#OMMODITYITEMISONTHEAGENDA
X
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUS
XI
4HE#OUNCILHADAGREEDTOGRANTOBSERVERSTATUSTOTHE/%#$FORITS3PECIAL3ESSIONSON4ELECOMMUNICATIONS3ERVICESON*UNE
XII
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSWITHACCESSTORESTRICTEDDOCUMENTSSUBJECTTOOBJECTIONTOSUCHACCESSBYA-EMBERINPARTICULARCASES
XIII
4HE5.#)42!,LISTEDBELOWREPRESENTSTHE5.
XIV
4HE7ORKING'ROUPAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUS
XV
4HE7ORKING'ROUPHADAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSFORITSMEETINGSOF.OVEMBERAND&EBRUARYONLY
XVI
4HE7ORKING'ROUPHADAGREEDTOGRANTADHOCOBSERVERSTATUSFORITSMEETINGSOF.OVEMBERAND-ARCHONLY
XVII
4HE#OMMITTEEAGREEDTOINVITETHE7#/ASANOBSERVERWHENEVERTHEISSUESOF(3CLASSIFICATIONAND(3AMENDMENTSWEREONTHEAGENDA
)) 0UBLICINFORMATIONACTIVITIES
4HEPOSITIVECHANGEINPUBLICPERCEPTIONSOFTHE74/WHICHCOINCIDEDWITHTHELAUNCH
OFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDACONTINUEDASTHENEGOTIATIONSADVANCED4HEAGREEMENT
ONTHE*ULY0ACKAGEAPPROVEDBY74/-EMBERSON!UGUSTWASPARTICULARLY
IMPORTANTINRAISINGPUBLICAWARENESSANDSUPPORTFORTHEORGANIZATION4HE74/$ISPUTE
SETTLEMENTSYSTEMCONTINUEDTOBEHIGHLYREGARDEDASANEFFECTIVEMEANSFORDEALINGWITH
TRADEDISPUTESESPECIALLYASDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWEREALSOSHOWNTOBEUSINGTHESYSTEMTO
GOODEFFECT
0UBLICDEBATEONTHE74/HASLARGELYSHIFTEDFROMCONDEMNATIONTOADISCUSSIONOFTHE
VALUEOFVARIOUSNEGOTIATINGPOSITIONSUNDERTHE$OHA!GENDAANDONPROPOSALSTOIMPROVE
ANDREFORMTHE74/SYSTEM
4HISSIGNIFICANTSHIFTINTHEFOCUSOFTHEDEBATEON74/ISSUESISLARGELYDUETOTHE
EXISTENCEOFABETTERUNDERSTANDINGAMONGTHEGENERALPUBLICANDAMONGJOURNALISTSABOUT
THEROLEANDWORKOFTHEORGANIZATION
!NUMBEROFSPECIFICEFFORTSINCONTRIBUTEDTOTHISNEWENVIRONMENTFORPUBLIC
DEBATEONTHE74/INCLUDING
ASUSTAINEDLEVELOFCONTACTSWITHTHEPUBLICTHROUGHINFORMATIONBRIEFINGSATTHE
74/INVOLVINGABOUTPARTICIPANTS
REGULARCONTACTWITHJOURNALISTSIN'ENEVATHROUGHPRESSBRIEFINGSNEWS
CONFERENCESANDPHOTOOPPORTUNITIESASWELLASREGULARCONTACTWITHTHEJOURNALISTS
AROUNDTHEGLOBEWHOHAVEREGISTEREDTOUSEOURINTERNET-EDIANEWSROOM-OSTOFTHEM
RECEIVEDWEEKLYEMAILBULLETINSONDEVELOPMENTSATTHE74/
-ORETHANINDIVIDUALSHAVESELFREGISTEREDWITHOURCONTACTSDATABASETO
RECEIVEREGULAREMAILBULLETINSON74/DEVELOPMENTS4HISLISTISCOMPRISEDLARGELYOF
ACADEMICSCONSULTANTSGOVERNMENTOFFICIALSANDSTUDENTSWITHASPECIFICINTERESTINTRADE
ISSUES
4HEREWEREOVERPUBLICEMAILENQUIRIESANDCOMMENTSRECEIVEDBYTHE74/
OVERTHEYEAR
4HE74/DISTRIBUTEDNEARLYBOOKSANDINFORMATIONBROCHURESFREEOFCHARGE)N
%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISHTOTHEPUBLICANDTO74/-EMBERSDURING
4HE74/WEBSITEWWWWTOORG
4HENUMBEROFVISITORSTOTHE74/WEBSITECONTINUESTOGROWATTHERATEOFPER
MONTH4HEREWEREMILLIONVISITSTOTHEWEBSITEDURINGABOUTPERMONTH
FROMABOUTCOUNTRIESANDOVERMILLIONHITSINDICATINGAHIGHLEVELOFNAVIGATION
THROUGHTHESITE5SERSOFTHESITEDOWNLOADEDMILLIONSOFPAGESOF74/PUBLICATIONSAND
DOCUMENTSINCLUDINGOVERCOPIESOFTHE74/!NNUAL2EPORTABOUTCOPIES
OFTHE7ORLD4RADE2EPORTANDABOUTCOPIESOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICS
74/ACTIVITIES
0UBLICINFORMATIONACTIVITIES
2EGULARCONTACTSWITHMEDIAANDTHEPUBLIC
74/0UBLICATIONS
!LISTOFBOOKSANDBROCHURESWEREPRODUCEDDURINGIN%NGLISH&RENCHAND
3PANISH4HEFULLLISTOFCURRENT74/PUBLICATIONSISINCLUDEDAS!NNEX))ATTHEENDOFTHIS
PUBLICATION
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDINGREMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE
0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
#ONCLUDING2EMARKS
5NITED3TATES
4HISSEVENTH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOFTHE5NITED3TATESHASPROVIDEDAFRUITFULDIALOGUE
BETWEENTHE5NITED3TATESANDITSTRADINGPARTNERS4HEHIGHLEVELOFPARTICIPATIONBY
-EMBERSINTHE2EVIEWUNDERLINESTHEKEYROLETHATTHE53PLAYSINWORLDTRADE)SHOULD
LIKETOEMPHASIZETHAT-EMBERSRECOGNIZEDTHATTHE53ECONOMYHASREMAINEDANENGINE
OFGLOBALGROWTHANDTHATINPARTTHANKSTOITSGENERALOPENNESSHASDEMONSTRATEDSTRONG
RESILIENCEINTHEFACEOFVARIOUSSHOCKSSINCE(OWEVERALTHOUGHCOUNTERCYCLICAL
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
MACROECONOMICPOLICYHASPROMOTEDGROWTHMANY-EMBERSRAISEDTHEMATTEROFTHE
SUSTAINABILITYOFTHETWINDEFICITS
-EMBERSACKNOWLEDGEDTHEUNIQUESTATUSOFTHE5NITED3TATESINTHEMULTILATERALTRADING
SYSTEMANDWEREGREATLYAPPRECIATIVEOFTHE53LEADERSHIPINTHE74/OFITSCOMMITMENT
TOTRADELIBERALIZATIONANDTOTHESUCCESSFULCOMPLETIONOFTHE$$!)NTHISCONTEXTMANY
-EMBERSEXPRESSEDTHEIRAPPRECIATIONFOR!MBASSADOR:OELLICKSRECENTLETTERONHOWTHE
$$!MAYBEMOVEDFORWARD
3EVERAL-EMBERSWERECRITICALOFTHE53UNEVENRECORDOFCOMPLIANCEWITH74/
RULINGSPOINTINGOUTTHATTHISCOULDUNDERMINETHECREDIBILITYOFTHE$35-EMBERSNOTED
THEGROWINGINVOLVEMENTOFTHE5NITED3TATESINREGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTSWITHMANY
CONSIDERINGSUCHINITIATIVESSUPPORTIVEOFMULTILATERALEFFORTSWHILEOTHERSQUERIEDTHEIR
POSSIBLEIMPACTONTHIRDCOUNTRIESANDONTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM!NUMBEROF
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESPRAISED53UNILATERALPREFERENCESANDTHE53CONTRIBUTIONTOTRADE
CAPACITYBUILDING
-EMBERSAGREEDTHATTHE53TRADEREGIMEISOPENANDTRANSPARENTBUTMANYNOTEDTHAT
MARKETACCESSBARRIERSEXISTINAFEWIMPORTANTAREAS3EVERAL-EMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERN
ABOUTTARIFFPEAKSNONADVALOREMDUTIESTARIFFESCALATIONANDTHE53TARIFFQUOTASYSTEM
PARTICULARLYINSECTORSSUCHASTEXTILESANDCLOTHINGOFCONCERNTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
6ARIOUS-EMBERSREFERREDTOCERTAIN303ANDENVIRONMENTALMEASURESASUNJUSTIFIEDBARRIERS
TOTRADE1UESTIONSWEREPOSEDONOTHERMEASURESLIKECUSTOMSFEESRULESOFORIGINLABELLING
REQUIREMENTSANDTRADERESTRICTIONS.EW53SECURITYRELATEDMEASURESCONSTITUTEDAMAJOR
THEMEOFDISCUSSION)NTHISRESPECTCONCERNSWEREEXPRESSEDREGARDINGCOMPLIANCECOSTS
AND-EMBERSURGEDTHE5NITED3TATESTOIMPLEMENTSECURITYMEASURESINTHELEASTTRADE
RESTRICTIVEMANNER
4HECONTINUEDACTIVEUSEOFCONTINGENCYMEASURESBYTHE5NITED3TATESWASASOURCEOF
CONCERNANDTHE5NITED3TATESWASINVITEDTOEXERCISERESTRAINTININITIATINGINVESTIGATIONS
7HILESATISFACTIONWASEXPRESSEDFORTHERECENTDISMANTLEMENTOFSAFEGUARDSONSTEEL
PRODUCTSFOLLOWINGA74/RULINGCONCERNWASVOICEDWITHRESPECTTOTHELACKOFPROGRESSIN
REPEALINGOTHERLEGISLATIONFOUNDTOBE74/INCONSISTENT
!NOTHERISSUERAISEDWASASSISTANCETOTHEAGRICULTURESECTOR-EMBERSPOINTEDOUTTHAT
THE&ARM!CTWASYETTOBENOTIFIED4HEYWERECONCERNEDABOUTDIFFERENTASPECTS
OFTHE!CTINCLUDINGITSPOTENTIALFORINCREASEDMARKETDISTORTINGSUPPORT-EMBERSALSO
QUESTIONEDTHE!CTSCOMPATIBILITYWITHTHEAIMSOFTHE$$!ASWELLASTHEEFFECTOFEXPORT
CREDITGUARANTEESCHEMES
$ISCUSSIONSONMARKETACCESSINSERVICESFOCUSEDMAINLYONTELECOMMUNICATIONS
MARITIMEFINANCIALANDPROFESSIONALSERVICESANDONMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONS
-EMBERSENCOURAGEDTHE5NITED3TATESTOREVIEWTHE*ONES!CTANDTOCONSIDERTABLINGAN
OFFERONMARITIMETRANSPORT1UESTIONSWERERAISEDWITHRESPECTTOTHEEFFECTTHATVISAAND
QUALIFICATIONRECOGNITIONREQUIREMENTSMAYHAVEONMARKETACCESSFORFOREIGNWORKERS
)CONCLUDEBYTHANKINGTHE53DELEGATIONFORTHENUMEROUSORALANDWRITTENRESPONSES
ANDEXPLANATIONSITPROVIDEDDURINGTHEMEETINGWELOOKFORWARDTORECEIVINGANSWERS
ONOUTSTANDINGQUESTIONS)HOPETHATOURDISCUSSIONSINTHISREVIEWWILLCONTRIBUTETOOUR
ONGOINGLIBERALIZATIONEFFORTSTOTHEBENEFITOFTHE5NITED3TATESANDTHE74/COMMUNITYAT
LARGE!ND)THANKTHE5NITED3TATESFORTHEMOTORROLEITHASCONTINUEDTOPLAYINTHEWORLD
ECONOMY
4HE'AMBIA
4HISFIRST4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOF4HE'AMBIAHASBEENFRUITFULANDCOMPREHENSIVEAND
WENOWHAVEABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOF4HE'AMBIASTRADEPOLICIESANDPRACTICES
/URDISCUSSIONHASBEENFACILITATEDBYTHEINFORMATIVECONTRIBUTIONOFTHE(ONOURABLE
%DWARD3INGHATEY3ECRETARYOF3TATEFOR4RADE)NDUSTRYAND%MPLOYMENTANDHISDELEGATION
ASWELLASBYTHEINCISIVECOMMENTSBYOURDISCUSSANT-R.EIL-C-ILLAN
-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEUNILATERALREFORMSTAKENBY4HE'AMBIASINCETHELATES
4HESEHAVESUBSTANTIALLYLIBERALIZEDTHEECONOMYANDCONTRIBUTEDTOREAL'$0GROWTH
RATESOFOVERONAVERAGEOVER)NLIGHTOFRECENTPOLICYSLIPPAGESTHATHAVE
ACCENTUATEDTHEVULNERABILITYOFTHEECONOMY-EMBERSENCOURAGED4HE'AMBIATO
CONSOLIDATEMACROECONOMICREFORMSWITHAVIEWTOPROMOTINGPRIVATEINVESTMENTAND
DIVERSIFYINGPRODUCTIONANDEXPORTSINORDERTOACHIEVEITSOBJECTIVEOFBECOMINGAMIDDLE
INCOMECOUNTRYBYTHEYEAR
-EMBERSSTRESSEDTHAT4HE'AMBIADOESNOTIMPLEMENTANYTARIFFPREFERENCESANDHAS
FULLYRELIEDONTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMTOPROMOTEITSTRADE4HEYSHARED4HE'AMBIAS
DESIRETOSEEPROGRESSINNEGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA3OME-EMBERS
POINTEDOUTTHATFURTHERTARIFFREFORMINCLUDINGREDUCTIONOFTHEMARGINSBETWEENBOUND
ANDAPPLIEDRATESANDANINCREASEINTHECOVERAGEOFBOUNDTARIFFSWOULDENHANCETHE
PREDICTABILITYOFTHETARIFFREGIME-EMBERSENCOURAGED4HE'AMBIATOIMPLEMENTTHE74/
3RI,ANKA
4HISSECOND4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOF3RI,ANKAHASPROVIDEDACONSTRUCTIVEEXCHANGEOF
VIEWSBETWEEN3RI,ANKAANDITSTRADINGPARTNERSTHEREBYCLARIFYINGMANYASPECTSOF
3RI,ANKASTRADEPOLICYREGIME4HERESULTINGDISCUSSIONHASBEENGREATLYFACILITATEDBYTHE
VALUABLECONTRIBUTIONSOF3ECRETARY7ICKREMASINGHETOGETHERWITHTHEOTHERMEMBERSOFHIS
DELEGATIONANDOURDISCUSSANT!MBASSADOR-UHAMMAD.OOR9ACOB
-EMBERSCOMMENDEDTHE'OVERNMENTSEFFORTSTOPRESSAHEADWITHTHERECONSTRUCTION
ANDREHABILITATIONPROGRAMMEOUTLINEDINTHEPOLICYDOCUMENT2EGAINING3RI,ANKA4HEY
ENCOURAGEDTHEAUTHORITIESTOCONTINUETRADEANDOTHERECONOMICREFORMSWHICHALONGWITH
LASTINGPEACEWOULDBEESSENTIALFORTHEACHIEVEMENTOFSUSTAINEDECONOMICGROWTHAND
POVERTYREDUCTION-EMBERSREITERATEDTHEIRSUPPORTFOR3RI,ANKASPEACEANDREFORMPROCESS
ANDEXPRESSEDTHEIRREADINESSTOCONTRIBUTETOIT4HEYPRAISED3RI,ANKASPRIVATIZATION
INITIATIVEANDSTEPSTODEREGULATETHEPETROLEUMANDENERGYSECTORS#ONCERNSWERERAISED
ABOUT3RI,ANKASHEAVYDEPENDENCYONAFEWEXPORTMARKETSANDPRODUCTSSUCHASTEXTILES
ANDCLOTHING
-EMBERSAPPRECIATED3RI,ANKASCONSTRUCTIVEINVOLVEMENTINTHE74/ANDURGEDTHE
AUTHORITIESTOCONTINUEITSACTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHECURRENTNEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTURE
INDUSTRIALPRODUCTSANDSERVICES4HEYNOTED3RI,ANKASSHIFTTOWARDSREGIONALAGREEMENTS
)NRESPONSETHEAUTHORITIESREITERATEDTHECOUNTRYSFIRMCOMMITMENTTOTHEPRIMACYOFTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMSTRESSINGTHATTHEIRREGIONALAGREEMENTSWOULDCOMPLEMENT
MULTILATERALISM
3EVERAL-EMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERNABOUTTHETARIFFREGIMESLACKOFPREDICTABILITYAND
TRANSPARENCY4HEYALSONOTEDINTERALIATHEHIGHLEVELOFAPPLIED-&.TARIFFSPARTICULARLY
FORAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSTHELOWPERCENTAGEOFBOUNDRATESTHELARGEGAPBETWEENBOUND
ANDAPPLIEDRATESHIGHTARIFFESCALATIONANDCONSEQUENTLYHIGHEFFECTIVEPROTECTION-EMBERS
ALSOREMARKEDONOTHERIMPORTCHARGESNOTABLYTHESURCHARGEANDTHE0ORTSAND!IRPORTS
$EVELOPMENT,EVYANDENCOURAGED3RI,ANKATOOVERHAULITSDUTYEXEMPTIONS-EMBERS
REFERREDTOTHESPECIALIMPORTLICENSINGREGIMEANDSOUGHTCLARIFICATIONONWHICHGOODSARE
SUBJECTTOLICENSINGFORECONOMICREASONS)NADDITIONQUESTIONSWERERAISEDREGARDING
IMPORTRESTRICTIONSONMEATPRODUCTSIMPORTPROHIBITIONSON'-PRODUCTSSTANDARDSAND
CONTINGENCYMEASURES
-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHESIMPLIFICATIONOFCUSTOMSPROCEDURESPARTICULARLYTHEINTRODUCTION
OFCOMPUTERIZEDSYSTEMSFORCUSTOMSCLEARANCEANDENCOURAGEDFURTHERSTREAMLINING
/NGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENT-EMBERSCOMMENTEDINTERALIAONTHEEXISTENCEOFPRICE
PREFERENCESFORLOCALLYMANUFACTUREDPRODUCTSANDLOCALWORKCONTRACTSASWELLASONTHE
OPACITYOFTENDERINGPROCEDURES3RI,ANKAWASENCOURAGEDTOREFORMTHEPROCUREMENT
SYSTEMAND-EMBERSWELCOMED3RI,ANKASANNOUNCEDINTENTIONTOAPPLYFOROBSERVERSTATUS
INTHE'0!-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEINTRODUCTIONOFNEWINTELLECTUALPROPERTYLEGISLATIONAND
EMPHASIZEDTHENEEDTOFOLLOWTHISUPWITHEFFECTIVEIMPLEMENTATIONANDENFORCEMENT
/NSERVICES-EMBERSEXPRESSEDTHEIRAPPRECIATIONFORSTEPSTAKENBYTHEAUTHORITIESTO
REDUCESTATEINVOLVEMENTANDELIMINATEFOREIGNEQUITYRESTRICTIONSINFINANCIALSERVICES4HEY
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
#USTOMS6ALUATION!GREEMENTANDTOENSURETHATCUSTOMSPROCEDURESDONOTGENERATEEXTRA
COSTSFORIMPORTERS
-EMBERSNOTEDTHAT4HE'AMBIASAGRICULTURALPOLICYOBJECTIVESARETOINCREASERURAL
INCOMESANDTOACHIEVEFOODSECURITYANDSOUGHTCLARIFICATIONABOUTTHECODIFICATIONOF
LANDTENUREANDEFFORTSTOINCREASEVALUEADDEDINTHESECTOR4HEYWELCOMED4HE'AMBIAS
PLANTODEVELOPITSMANUFACTURINGSECTORFORPOVERTYREDUCTIONANDECONOMICDIVERSIFICATION
PURPOSES3OME-EMBERSMENTIONED4HE'AMBIASINVOLVEMENTININTERNATIONALTRADEIN
DIAMONDSANDURGEDITTOCONSIDERPARTICIPATINGINTHE+IMBERLEY0ROCESS-EMBERSPRAISED
4HE'AMBIAFORHAVINGTAKENSUBSTANTIALCOMMITMENTSINSERVICESUBSECTORSBUTURGEDITTO
IMPLEMENTREFORMSTOMAKEITSPOLICIESANDPRACTICESFURTHERMATCHITSCOMMITMENTS
-EMBERSALSOASKEDQUESTIONSONOTHERISSUESNOTABLYFUTUREECONOMICREFORM
PROGRAMMEINTERNALTAXATIONSTANDARDSAND303GOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTFREEZONES
INVESTMENTINCENTIVESPRIVATIZATIONANDPROTECTIONOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS
-EMBERSEXPRESSEDTHEIRAPPRECIATIONFORTHERESPONSESPROVIDEDBYTHE'AMBIAN
DELEGATIONANDLOOKEDFORWARDTORECEIVINGWRITTENANSWERSTOANYOUTSTANDINGQUESTIONS
)NCONCLUSIONITISMYFEELINGTHATTHIS4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWHASHIGHLIGHTEDTHE
COMMITMENTOFTHE'AMBIANAUTHORITIESTOFURTHERLIBERALIZETHEIRECONOMY)AMPLEASED
THATMANY-EMBERSIDENTIFIEDWAYSINWHICHTHEYWEREPROVIDINGTRADERELATEDTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCETO4HE'AMBIAANDHAVECOMMITTEDTHEMSELVESTOCONTINUEASSISTINGIT
.EVERTHELESS)FEELITIMPORTANTTOCALLATTENTIONTO4HE'AMBIASSUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTS
THATSTILLNEEDTOBEADDRESSED&URTHERASSISTANCEBYTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYWILLHELP
4HE'AMBIATOFULLYINTEGRATEINTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMAND)URGEBOTHTHE74/
-EMBERSHIPANDTHE3ECRETARIATTOBERECEPTIVETOTHISNEED
COMMENDEDEFFORTSTOLIBERALIZETHETELECOMMUNICATIONSMARKETANDENCOURAGED3RI,ANKATO
CONTINUETHISPROCESS
-EMBERSALSOEXPRESSEDTHEIRAPPRECIATIONOFTHEORALANDWRITTENRESPONSESPROVIDED
BYTHE3RI,ANKANDELEGATIONTHEYLOOKFORWARDTORECEIVINGREPLIESTOANYOUTSTANDING
QUESTIONS
)NCONCLUSIONTHIS2EVIEWHASPROVIDED-EMBERSWITHCONSIDERABLEINSIGHTINTO3RI
,ANKASTRADEANDTRADERELATEDPOLICIES)THASHELPEDTOIDENTIFYAREASWHEREFURTHER
REFORMSCOULDESTABLISHTHEBASISFORSUSTAINEDECONOMICGROWTHANDTHUSLASTINGPEACE
ANDPROSPERITY-EMBERSENCOURAGED3RI,ANKATOLIBERALIZEITSTRADEREGIMEFURTHERANDTO
CONTINUEITSACTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHE$$!NEGOTIATIONS
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
3INGAPORE
7EHAVEHADAMOSTINFORMATIVEANDCONSTRUCTIVEDISCUSSIONOF3INGAPORESTRADEPOLICIES
ANDPRACTICES4HEDISCUSSIONBENEFITEDGREATLYFROMTHEVALUABLECONTRIBUTIONSMADEBY
0ERMANENT3ECRETARY(ENG3WEE+EATANDHISDELEGATIONBYOURDISCUSSANT!MBASSADOR
%IRIK'LENNEINLEADINGTHEDISCUSSIONTODAYANDBY-EMBERSOFTHE402"3EVERAL-EMBERS
HAVEALSOTHANKED3INGAPOREFORITSEFFORTSINFACILITATINGMULTILATERALTRADEDISCUSSIONS
ESPECIALLYINTHEAREASOF42)03ANDAGRICULTURE
4HIS3INGAPORES&OURTH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWHASDEMONSTRATEDTHATITSECONOMYREMAINS
ONEOFTHEMOSTOPENTOINTERNATIONALTRADEANDINVESTMENT4HISOPENNESSINGREATPART
HASHELPED3INGAPOREWEATHERRECENTECONOMICSHOCKSSUCHASTHE!SIANFINANCIALCRISISAND
MORERECENTLYTHEGLOBALECONOMICSLOWDOWNWHICHWASCOMPOUNDEDBYTHE3!23CRISIS
ANDEVENTSINTHE-IDDLE%AST-EMBERSCOMMENDED3INGAPORESCONTINUINGREFORMSAIMED
ATPROMOTINGACOMPETITIVEECONOMYTHATISGLOBALIZEDENTREPRENEURIALANDDIVERSIFIEDINTHE
FACEOFTHESESHOCKS3OME-EMBERSSOUGHTFURTHERDETAILSONTHENATUREOFTHESEREFORMS
ESPECIALLYEFFORTSTOENHANCEWAGEFLEXIBILITYEMPLOYMENTANDTRAININGANDTOADDRESSTHE
CHALLENGEOFANAPPARENTRECENTDECLINEINTOTALFACTORPRODUCTIVITYALTHOUGH)HAVENOTED
3INGAPORESCOMMENTSINTHISREGARDS
-EMBERSNOTEDTHATWITHINTERNATIONALTRADEAMOUNTINGTOABOUTTHREETIMES'$0
3INGAPOREREMAINSCOMMITTEDTOARULESBASEDMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM3EVERAL
-EMBERSHOWEVERNOTEDTHENUMBEROFBILATERALFREETRADEAGREEMENTS3INGAPORE
HASSIGNEDSINCEITSPREVIOUS2EVIEWANDASKEDHOWITRECONCILEDTHISTRENDWITHITS
PARTICIPATIONINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM-EMBERSURGED3INGAPORETOMAINTAINITS
PARTICIPATIONINCURRENT74/NEGOTIATIONS4HEREPRESENTATIVEOF3INGAPORESTRESSEDHIS
COUNTRYSCOMMITMENTTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDRESPONDEDTHATITSBILATERAL
&4!SARE74/PLUSANDCOULDCONTRIBUTETOFURTHERMULTILATERALTRADELIBERALIZATION
3INGAPOREWASALSOACTIVELYPARTICIPATINGINTHECURRENT74/NEGOTIATIONSANDWOULDDOITS
UTMOSTTOENSURETHEIRSUCCESS
-EMBERSRAISEDQUESTIONSABOUTCERTAINASPECTSOF3INGAPORESTRADEPOLICYINCLUDING
CUSTOMSPROCEDURESANDTRADEFACILITATIONTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENBOUNDANDAPPLIED
TARIFFRATESTHEUSEOFSPECIFICDUTIESIMPORTLICENSINGPOLICIESPARTICULARLYWITHREGARDTO
RICESTANDARDSAND3INGAPORESRELATIVELYSTRINGENT303POLICY1UESTIONSWEREALSORAISED
ABOUT3INGAPORESGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTPROCEDURESANDTHEENFORCEMENTOFINTELLECTUAL
PROPERTYRIGHTS)TWASNOTEDTHAT3INGAPORESUSEOFCONTINGENCYMEASURESISRELATIVELY
LIMITED
3INCERESTRICTIONSTOINTERNATIONALTRADEARERELATIVELYFEW-EMBERSWEREMOSTLY
INTERESTEDIN3INGAPORESRECENTANDONGOINGDOMESTICREFORMS3EVERAL-EMBERSWELCOMED
3INGAPORESANNOUNCEMENTOFANECONOMYWIDECOMPETITIONPOLICYTOBEPUTINPLACEOVER
THENEXTFEWYEARS7HILENOTINGTHATSOMEREFORMSHADBEENCARRIEDOUTWITHREGARDTO
GOVERNMENTLINKEDCORPORATIONS',#SHELDBYTHE'OVERNMENTHOLDINGCOMPANY4EMASEK
-EMBERSSOUGHTFURTHERDETAILSONINTERALIADEMYSTIFYING4EMASEK',#SANDTHEIRFURTHER
DISINVESTMENTMEASURESTOENSUREFAIRCOMPETITIONBETWEENTHEMANDOTHERPRIVATESECTOR
COMPANIESASWELLASEFFORTSTOREDUCEGOVERNMENTINVOLVEMENTINTHEECONOMY1UESTIONS
WEREALSORAISEDWITHREGARDTOTAXANDNONTAXINCENTIVESANDTHESECTORSINWHICHTHEYARE
CURRENTLYCONCENTRATED
7ITHREGARDTOSERVICES-EMBERSNOTEDMAJORREFORMSESPECIALLYINTELECOMMUNICATIONS
ANDBANKINGANDINSURANCESERVICES4HEYNOTEDTHATLIBERALIZATIONOFTELECOMMUNICATIONS
SERVICESINPARTICULARHASRESULTEDINBENEFITSFORCONSUMERSANDENCOURAGED3INGAPORETO
CONTINUEFURTHERREFORMSINOTHERSECTORSASWELL&URTHERDETAILSWEREREQUESTEDONBANKING
ANDINSURANCETRANSPORTAUDIOVISUALSERVICESPROFESSIONALSERVICESANDTOURISM3OME
-EMBERSALSOREQUESTEDINFORMATIONON3INGAPORES'!433CHEDULE
4OCONCLUDE)WOULDLIKETOTHANKTHE3INGAPOREDELEGATIONONITSORALANDWRITTEN
RESPONSESPROVIDEDDURINGTHEMEETINGANDONCEAGAINTOCONGRATULATE3INGAPOREONBEING
ANEXEMPLARY-EMBEROFTHE74/ANDFORITSEFFORTSINHELPINGUSTOBETTERUNDERSTAND
ITSTRADERELATEDPOLICIES/URDISCUSSIONSHAVEALSOHELPEDUSTOAPPRECIATETHESIGNIFICANT
CHALLENGESFACING3INGAPORETODAYANDTHE'OVERNMENTSMEASURESTOADDRESSTHESE
CHALLENGES
4HISSECONDTRADEPOLICYREVIEWOF"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIHASALLOWEDUSALLAFAR
BETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFRECENTDEVELOPMENTSINTHEIRTRADEANDRELATEDPOLICIESANDINTHE
CHALLENGESTHEYFACE/URDIALOGUEHASBEENTHOROUGHANDCOMPREHENSIVESTIMULATEDBY
THEFULLANDOPENENGAGEMENTOFTHEHIGHLEVELDELEGATIONSTHEINSIGHTFULCOMMENTSBYTHE
DISCUSSANTANDTHEMANYINTERVENTIONSBY-EMBERS
-EMBERSCOMMENDED"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIFORTHEIRCONCERTEDEFFORTSAT
MACROECONOMICSTABILIZATIONANDFORTHEIRSTRUCTURALREFORMSINTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEW
4HEYNOTEDTHATSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENTANDPOVERTYALLEVIATIONREMAINEDACHALLENGEAS
DIDELEMENTSOFGOVERNANCEANDCERTAINSTRUCTURALDISADVANTAGES)NTHISCONNECTION"ENIN
"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIWEREENCOURAGEDTOMOVEAHEADWITHTHEIRREFORMPROGRAMMES
INCLUDINGPRIVATIZATIONANDMARKETANDPRODUCTDIVERSIFICATION
-EMBERSWEREAPPRECIATIVEOFTHEEFFORTSMADEBYTHETHREECOUNTRIESTOSIMPLIFY
THEIRTARIFFSTRUCTURETHROUGHTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE7!%-5COMMONEXTERNALTARIFF
REDUCINGUNILATERALLYTHEAVERAGE-&.TARIFFOFTWOOFTHETHREE-EMBERSUNDERREVIEW
"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALICONFIRMEDTHEIRCOMMITMENTTOTHEMULTILATERALSYSTEMAND
TOTHE74/3OME-EMBERSSUGGESTEDTHATTHECOUNTRIESUNDERREVIEWSHOULDSEEKTO
NARROWTHEGAPBETWEENTHEIRBOUNDANDAPPLIEDRATES-EMBERSALSONOTEDTHEIMPOSITION
OFADDITIONALBORDERLEVIESANDCHARGESASWELLASTHEUSEBY"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIOF
7!%-5AGREEDADMINISTEREDPRICESFORCUSTOMSVALUATIONPURPOSESANDPROGRESSMADE
RECENTLYONTHISMATTER
-EMBERSEMPHASIZEDTRADEASADEVELOPMENTTOOLANDUNDERLINEDTHEIMPORTANCEOF
THE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKANDOTHERCOOPERATIONINITIATIVES"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALI
DIDNOTBENEFITFULLYFROMTHEIR74/MEMBERSHIPASTHEIROWNRESOURCECONSTRAINTSDID
NOTALWAYSALLOWTHEMTOIDENTIFYANDOREXPLOITOPPORTUNITIES3EVERAL-EMBERSINDICATED
THATDESPITETHEIRDIRECTORINDIRECTCONTRIBUTIONINPROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCETOAND
PROMOTINGTRADEWITHTHE-EMBERSUNDERREVIEWTHEPROGRESSINTHEIRINTEGRATIONINTOTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMHADBEENSLOW-ANY-EMBERSUNDERLINEDTHEIRCOMMITMENTTO
CONTINUINGTOPROVIDETRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCETOTHETHREECOUNTRIES
-EMBERSNOTEDTHEDEPENDENCEOF"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIONCOTTONANDOTHER
AGRICULTURALCOMMODITIES4HEYRAISEDSEVERALQUESTIONSINTHISRESPECTWHILERECALLING
RECENTCOTTONRELATEDDEVELOPMENTSINTHE74/3OMEEXPRESSEDSUPPORTFORTHEGRADUAL
ELIMINATIONOFTHECOTTONSUPPORTPRACTICESOFCERTAINDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
-EMBERSSOUGHTFURTHERCLARIFICATIONON
)NVESTMENTINCENTIVES
INTERREGIONALINTEGRATIONPROCESS
RENEGOTIATIONOFTARIFFBINDINGS
ANTIDUMPINGREGULATIONSANDCOMPETITIONPOLICY
TECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADE
STATETRADINGENTERPRISES
GOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTPRACTICESANDPROSPECTS
INTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS
ISSUESRELATINGTOFINANCIALSERVICESTELECOMMUNICATIONSENERGYTRANSPORTAND
TOURISM
-EMBERSEXPRESSEDAPPRECIATIONFORTHEREPLIESPROVIDEDBYTHEDELEGATIONSOF
"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIANDLOOKEDFORWARDWITHINTERESTTOFURTHERRESPONSESAND
CLARIFICATIONS
)NCONCLUSIONTHE#HAIRPERSONSAIDTHATTHEREVIEWHADENABLED-EMBERSTOTAKE
NOTEOFTHEPROGRESSMADEBY"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALISINCETHEIRFIRSTREVIEWAND
OFTHEDEVELOPMENTPROBLEMSTHEYFACED4HEIMPRESSIVEPARTICIPATIONBYDELEGATIONSIN
THEMEETINGTHENUMBEROFQUESTIONSPOSEDANDTHELIVELYDISCUSSIONDEMONSTRATEDTHE
IMPORTANCEATTACHEDTOTHISTRADEPOLICYREVIEW3HEENCOURAGED"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND
-ALITOCONTINUEIMPLEMENTINGTHEIRREFORMPROGRAMMESWITHAVIEWTOENHANCINGTHE
TRANSPARENCYPREDICTABILITYANDCREDIBILITYOFTHEIRFOREIGNTRADEREGIMESANDCONFIRMING
THEIRADHERENCETO74/PRINCIPLES"UTTHATOBSERVATIONHADTOBEPUTINTOCONTEXT"ENIN
"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIFACEDREALRESOURCECONSTRAINTSTECHNICALASSISTANCEWASREQUIRED
FROMTHE74/ANDOTHERCOMPETENTORGANIZATIONS4HENEEDSHADBEENCLEARLYIDENTIFIEDIN
THE3ECRETARIATREPORTSANDEFFORTSSHOULDBEMADETOMEETTHEM)NADDITIONTHETRADING
PARTNERSCOULDCONTRIBUTEBYENSURINGTHATTHEIRMARKETSWEREOPENTOPRODUCTSFROM"ENIN
"URKINA&ASOAND-ALIANDBYFURTHEREXPLORINGOPPORTUNITIESTOASSISTTHEMINACHIEVING
THEIRDEVELOPMENTOBJECTIVES
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
"ENIN"URKINA&ASOAND-ALI
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
"ELIZEAND3URINAME
4HEFIRST4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWSOF"ELIZEAND3URINAMEHAVESHEDCONSIDERABLELIGHT
ONTHETRADEANDINVESTMENTPOLICIESANDPRACTICESOFBOTHCOUNTRIES7EOWETHISTO
THEDOCUMENTATIONPREPAREDFORTHEMEETINGTOTHEVALUABLECONTRIBUTIONSMADEBY
THEDELEGATIONSOF"ELIZEAND3URINAMETOTHECOMMENTSOFOURDISCUSSANTANDTOTHE
INVOLVEMENTOFSEVERAL-EMBERSOFTHE402")AMVERYPLEASEDTHATDESPITETHEIRHEAVY
AGENDAS-INISTERS#OURTENAYAND*ONG4JIEN&ACHOSETOCOMETOTHISMEETINGANDSEEIT
ASTESTAMENTTOTHEIR'OVERNMENTSDESIRETOPRACTICALLYDEMONSTRATETHEIRCOMMITMENTTO
THEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
-EMBERSCOMMENDED"ELIZEAND3URINAMEONTHEIRECONOMICANDINSTITUTIONAL
REFORMEFFORTSWHICHINCLUDEAUTONOMOUSANDREGIONALINITIATIVESTOLIBERALIZETRADEAND
INVESTMENT4HEPROGRESSACHIEVEDONTHESEFRONTSISSIGNIFICANT-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHE
EFFORTSMADEBYBOTHCOUNTRIESDESPITETHEIRLIMITEDINSTITUTIONALCAPACITYANDLACKOFA
PERMANENTREPRESENTATIONIN'ENEVA(OWEVERTHEYALSOURGED"ELIZEAND3URINAMETO
FULFILTHEIROUTSTANDING74/NOTIFICATIONOBLIGATIONSIFNECESSARYWITHTHEAIDOFTHE74/
3ECRETARIAT
3OME-EMBERSPOINTEDTOTHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEPARTICIPATIONOF"ELIZEAND3URINAME
IN#!2)#/-ASASTEPPINGSTONETOWARDSGREATERINTEGRATIONINTHEGLOBALECONOMY
ANDASANENGINEOFGROWTH4HEYALSOSOUGHTCLARIFICATIONONFUTUREDEVELOPMENTSIN
#!2)#/-ANDOTHERPREFERENTIALARRANGEMENTSINVOLVING"ELIZEAND3URINAME
7HILENOTINGTHEDIFFERENCESINTHEECONOMICPERFORMANCESOF"ELIZEAND3URINAME
-EMBERSUNDERLINEDTHENEEDTOINCREASETHECOHERENCEOFMACROECONOMICPOLICYMAKING
INBOTHCOUNTRIESTOENSURESUSTAINABLEGROWTH"ELIZEAND3URINAMEWEREENCOURAGED
TOCONTINUEDIVERSIFYINGTHEIREXPORTBASESBOTHINTERMSOFMARKETSANDPRODUCTS)NTHIS
REGARDSOME-EMBERSPOINTEDTO"ELIZESSUCCESSINDEVELOPINGITSTOURISMSECTORASA
STEPINTHERIGHTDIRECTION
-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEDECLINEOFAVERAGEAPPLIED-&.TARIFFSIN"ELIZEAND3URINAME
OVERTHEYEARS#ONCERNSWEREEXPRESSEDHOWEVERWITHRESPECTTOTHERELATIVELYHIGH
LEVELSOFTARIFFPROTECTIONENJOYEDBYTHEAGRICULTURESECTORSOFBOTHCOUNTRIES"ELIZEAND
3URINAMEWEREINVITEDTOLOWERTHEIRTARIFFBINDINGSTORATESCLOSERTOAPPLIEDRATESINORDER
TOIMPROVETHEPREDICTABILITYOFTHEIRTRADEREGIMES-EMBERSNOTEDWITHCONCERNTHAT
CERTAINAPPLIEDTARIFFRATESEXCEEDTHEIRBOUNDLEVELS
-EMBERSALSOASKED"ELIZEAND3URINAMEQUESTIONSRELATEDTOCUSTOMSTECHNICAL
REGULATIONSSANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURESINCENTIVESCHEMESGOVERNMENT
PROCUREMENTSTATEOWNEDENTERPRISESANDTHEPROTECTIONOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS
/NSECTORALPOLICIES-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHEEFFORTSBY"ELIZEAND3URINAMETO
LIBERALIZETRADEINSERVICESBUTHIGHLIGHTEDTHENEEDTOSTRENGTHENTHEREGULATORY
FRAMEWORKDEVELOPINFRASTRUCTUREANDPROMOTECOMPETITION-EMBERSSOUGHT
ADDITIONALINFORMATIONONSECTORALPOLICIESANDMARKETACCESSCONDITIONSINELECTRICITY
TELECOMMUNICATIONSBANKINGTOURISMANDDISTRIBUTIONANDBUSINESSSERVICES.OTINGTHEIR
CURRENTLYLIMITED'!43COMMITMENTS-EMBERSINVITED"ELIZEAND3URINAMETOEXPAND
THOSECOMMITMENTSINTHECONTEXTOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
!SREGARDSSPECIFICISSUESRAISEDINCONNECTIONWITH"ELIZESTRADEPOLICIESSOME
-EMBERSQUESTIONEDTHEAPPLICATIONOFCERTAINDOMESTICTAXESTOIMPORTSONLY3EVERAL
-EMBERSALSOEXPRESSEDCONCERNABOUTTHEPOSSIBLEDISTORTIONSINDUCEDBY"ELIZESNON
AUTOMATICLICENSINGREGIMEANDENCOURAGED"ELIZETOBRINGITINTOCOMPLIANCEWITH74/
DISCIPLINES"ELIZEREITERATEDITSCOMMITMENTTOFULFILLINGTHERELEVANT74/OBLIGATIONSAND
NOTEDTHATITINTENDSTOUNDERTAKEAREVIEWOFITSLICENSINGSYSTEM
2EGARDING3URINAMESOME-EMBERSCONSIDEREDTHATTHEPROCEDURESFORAPPROVING
INVESTMENTSARECUMBERSOMEANDUNDERSCOREDTHENEEDTOACCELERATEPUBLICSECTOR
REFORMSANDREDUCETHEDEGREEOFGOVERNMENTINTERFERENCEINTHEECONOMY)NTHISRESPECT
THERECENTESTABLISHMENTOFAONESTOPWINDOWFORBUSINESSLICENSINGISAPOTENTIALLY
SIGNIFICANTSTEP)NRELATIONTOTARIFFBINDINGSTHEYSOUGHTDETAILSONTHESTATUSOF
3URINAMESRENEGOTIATIONUNDER!RTICLE886)))OFTHE'!443URINAMEWASCONGRATULATEDFOR
ELIMINATINGTHELICENSINGSYSTEMPREVIOUSLYINPLACETOPROTECTDOMESTICPRODUCERS
7EAPPRECIATETHEORALANDWRITTENRESPONSESANDEXPLANATIONSPROVIDEDBYTHE
DELEGATIONSOF"ELIZEAND3URINAME
)NCONCLUSIONITISMYSENSETHATTHIS2EVIEWHASAMPLYFULFILLEDTHEOBJECTIVEOF
EXPANDINGOURUNDERSTANDINGOFTHETRADEREGIMESOF"ELIZEAND3URINAMEANDTHE
CONTEXTWITHINWHICHTHEYAREFORMULATEDANDIMPLEMENTED)NTHISREGARDWEHAVE
BEENMADEAWAREOFTHEREALDIFFICULTIESFACEDBY"ELIZEAND3URINAMEINPARTICIPATINGIN
THEMULTILATERALSYSTEM/VERCOMINGTHESECHALLENGESISIMPORTANTASTHE74/REMAINS
THEBESTFORUMTODEVELOPARULESBASEDTRADESYSTEM$RAWINGONTHEVIEWSOFFERED
BY-EMBERSINTHISMEETING"ELIZEAND3URINAMEARENOWINABETTERPOSITIONTOCHART
FUTUREPOLICYADJUSTMENTSTHATWOULDSERVEBOTHTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDTHEIR
INDIVIDUALDEVELOPMENTNEEDS
4HISFOURTH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOFTHE2EPUBLICOF+OREAHASCONTRIBUTEDSIGNIFICANTLY
TOANIMPROVEDINFORMEDUNDERSTANDINGOFRECENTDEVELOPMENTSIN+OREANTRADEAND
RELATEDPOLICIES/URDISCUSSIONHASGREATLYBENEFITEDFROMTHECOMPREHENSIVEENGAGEMENT
OFTHE+OREANDELEGATIONLEDBY!MBASSADOR#HOI(YUCKTHEINSIGHTFULCOMMENTSFROM
OURDISCUSSANT!MBASSADOR-UHAMAD.OOR9ACOBANDMANYTHOUGHTFULINTERVENTIONSBY
-EMBERS
-EMBERSNOTED+OREASIMPRESSIVEECONOMICPERFORMANCEUNDERPINNEDBYGENERALLY
PRUDENTMACROSTABILIZATIONPOLICIESONGOINGTRADELIBERALIZATIONANDCORPORATEAND
FINANCIALSECTORRESTRUCTURING+OREAWASENCOURAGEDTOCONTINUETHESEMARKETORIENTED
REFORMS!MAJORCHALLENGEISTOENSURECONTINUEDECONOMICIMPROVEMENTSGIVENTHE
ECONOMYSRELIANCEONEXPORTSTOCOMPENSATEFORWEAKDOMESTICDEMANDTHISISAPOTENTIAL
SOURCEOFVULNERABILITY
-EMBERSWELCOMED+OREASACTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
INCLUDINGTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA)TISIMPORTANTTHAT+OREASINCREASINGINVOLVEMENT
INBILATERALREGIONALTRADINGARRANGEMENTSISCOMPATIBLEWITHTHEMULTILATERALSYSTEMAND
THATSUCHAGREEMENTSARESUFFICIENTLYCOMPREHENSIVETOLIBERALIZE+OREASTRADEREGIMEIN
DIFFICULTAREASSUCHASAGRICULTUREWHEREMOSTPROTECTIONEXISTS7HILESOME-EMBERSNOTED
THATHIGHAGRICULTURALPROTECTIONREFLECTEDFOODSECURITYANDOTHERMULTIFUNCTIONALCONCERNS
OTHER-EMBERSURGED+OREATOREFORMITSAGRICULTURALPOLICIESCOMMENTINGTHATCONTINUED
HIGHLEVELSOFPRICESUPPORTANDTARIFFSASWELLASOTHERFORMSOFPROTECTIONUNDERMINE
ECONOMICEFFICIENCYANDPENALIZE+OREANCONSUMERS4HECONTRASTBETWEENLOWINDUSTRIALAND
HIGHAGRICULTURALTARIFFSWASALSONOTED
-ANY-EMBERSTHOUGHTTHATTHEMULTIPLICITYOFRATEBANDSVARIOUSFLEXIBLETARIFFSAND
OTHERTYPESOFDUTIESMAKETHE+OREANTARIFFSTRUCTURESOMEWHATCOMPLEXANDENCOURAGED
ITSSIMPLIFICATION!GRICULTURALTARIFFQUOTASAREOFPARTICULARCONCERNINCLUDINGTHEPOSSIBLE
RESTRICTIVEIMPACTONIMPORTSOFTHEIRADMINISTRATION+OREAWASURGEDTOREDUCEHIGHTARIFFS
ONSOMEINDUSTRIALPRODUCTSANDTORAISETHECOVERAGEOFTARIFFBINDINGSANDNARROWTHEGAP
BETWEENBOUNDANDAPPLIEDLEVELS
-ANYMEMBERSNOTEDTHAT+OREAHADMADESUBSTANTIALEFFORTSTOFURTHERLIBERALIZE
ITSFOREIGNINVESTMENTREGIMETHISWASIMPORTANTATATIMEWHEN&$)INFLOWSHADFALLEN
3OME-EMBERSENQUIREDABOUTTHERANGEOFTAXANDOTHERINCENTIVESPROVIDEDTOATTRACT
INVESTMENTINCLUDINGTHEUSEOFVARIOUSTYPESOFZONES
-EMBERSAPPRECIATED+OREASMOVESTOHARMONIZESTANDARDSANDOTHERTECHNICAL
BARRIERSTOTRADEWITHINTERNATIONALNORMSBUTALSOENCOURAGEDITTODOMOREINTHISREGARD
ESPECIALLYINTHEAREASOFFOODRELATEDSTANDARDSLABELLINGPROVISIONSASWELLASDUPLICATIVE
INSPECTIONANDTESTINGREQUIREMENTSINCLUDINGFORPHARMACEUTICALS3OME-EMBERSWORRIED
ABOUTTHEPOSSIBLETRADERESTRICTIVENESSOFSOME+OREAN303MEASURESANDENCOURAGED+OREA
TOREVIEWTHEM
-EMBERSWELCOMEDEFFORTSBY+OREATOIMPROVETHETRANSPARENCYOFITSGOVERNMENT
PROCUREMENTANDTOSTRENGTHENCORPORATEGOVERNANCEANDITSCOMPETITIONLEGISLATIONAND
ENFORCEMENTINCLUDINGONTHEOPERATIONSOFCHAEBOLS3TEPSTOSTRENGTHENINTELLECTUAL
PROPERTYRULESANDTHEIRENFORCEMENTWEREALSORECOGNIZEDANDCOMPLIMENTEDINCLUDING
+OREASRECENTACCESSIONTOTHE7)0/#OPYRIGHT4REATYANDTHESTREAMLININGOFPATENT
APPLICATIONS3ERVICESLIBERALIZATIONESPECIALLYOFTHEFINANCIALANDTELECOMMUNICATIONSECTORS
WASWELCOMEDALTHOUGHSEVERAL-EMBERSNOTEDTHATCERTAINPOSSIBLEWEAKNESSESREMAININ
THEREGULATORYREGIMEFORTELECOMMUNICATIONS
-EMBERSSOUGHTCLARIFICATIONONARANGEOFOTHERISSUESINCLUDINGREGULATORYREFORM
PARTICULARLYOFCUSTOMSPROCEDURESANDCONTINGENCYMEASURESSTATETRADINGSUBSIDIES
PRIVATIZATIONSERVICESLIBERALIZATIONFUTUREAGRICULTURALREFORMSTRADEARRANGEMENTSFORRICE
RULESOFORIGINREFORMSINFISHERIESANDLABOURMARKETS
-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHEORALANDWRITTENRESPONSESTOTHEIRQUESTIONSPROVIDEDBYTHE
+OREANDELEGATIONANDLOOKEDFORWARDTORECEIVINGANSWERSONANYOUTSTANDINGQUESTIONS
4HISSUCCESSFULLYCONCLUDESOUR2EVIEWOF+OREA4HEWIDEINTERESTSHOWNBY-EMBERS
WITHMANYADVANCEQUESTIONSINTERVENTIONSANDHIGHATTENDANCEREFLECTTHEIMPORTANTROLE
THAT+OREAPLAYSINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM7ENOWHAVEAMUCHBETTERANDCURRENT
UNDERSTANDINGOFITSTRADERELATEDPOLICIESANDMEASURESANDAPPRECIATETHECHALLENGES
FACING+OREAALONGWITHEFFORTSTOADDRESSTHEMINAWAYTHATISCONSISTENTWITHTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
2EPUBLICOF+OREA
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
2WANDA
4HEPRESENT2EVIEWHASALLOWED-EMBERSTOCOMETOABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOF
2WANDASECONOMICSITUATIONITSRECONSTRUCTIONEFFORTSSINCETHEGENOCIDETHE
ENORMOUSCHALLENGESITSTILLFACESANDITSREFORMAGENDA&ORTHISWEHAVEBEENGREATLY
HELPEDBY2WANDASDELEGATIONLEDBY0ROF0AUL-ANASSEH.SHUTI-INISTEROF#OMMERCE
)NDUSTRY)NVESTMENT0ROMOTION4OURISMAND#OOPERATIVESANDBYTHEDISCUSSANT
-R.EIL-C-ILLAN
-EMBERSCOMMENDED2WANDAONITSMACROECONOMICREFORMEFFORTSWHICHHAVERESULTED
INITSECONOMICGROWTHDURINGTHEPASTTENYEARS4HEYNOTED2WANDASDEPENDENCEONTEA
ANDCOFFEEANDSTRESSEDTHATITSHIGHPRODUCTIONCOSTSDUETOPOORINFRASTRUCTUREENERGY
SHORTAGESANDHIGHTRANSPORTCOSTSRELATEDTOITSLANDLOCKEDGEOGRAPHICALSITUATIONNEEDED
TOBEADDRESSEDTOIMPROVEITSSUPPLYSIDECAPACITYANDDIVERSIFYITSECONOMY4OTHISEND
-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHE'OVERNMENTSECONOMICPROGRAMME2WANDA6ISION
$EBTRELIEFUNDERTHE()0#INITIATIVEANDINCREASEDFOREIGNDIRECTINVESTMENTSHOULDALSOHELP
-EMBERSCOMMENDED2WANDAONTHEROLEITPLAYEDINHELPINGTOMOVEFORWARDTHE
$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAANDWERESUPPORTIVEOFITSINTENTTOESTABLISHANATIONAL
COMMITTEEONTHE74/ISSUES-EMBERSCONGRATULATED2WANDAFORITSPARTICIPATIONINTHE
FREETRADEAREAOF#/-%3!ANDWELCOMEDTHEINCREASEINITSTRADEWITHTHEOTHERMEMBERS
(OWEVER-EMBERSWARNEDAGAINSTTHECHALLENGESANDCOMPLEXITYOFACTIVEINVOLVEMENT
INSEVERALOVERLAPPINGTRADEREGIMES4HEYALSONOTEDTHEPOTENTIALGAINSFOR2WANDAFROM
IMPROVEMENTSINMARKETACCESSTHATWOULDARISEFROMCOMPLETIONOFNEGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE
$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAESPECIALLYINAGRICULTURE3OMECONCERNSWERERAISEDHOWEVER
ABOUTTHEDIFFICULTIESFACEDBY2WANDAINFULFILLINGITSOBLIGATIONS
-EMBERSSTRESSEDTHATFURTHERMACROECONOMICANDSTRUCTURALREFORMSWOULDALLOW
2WANDATOINCREASEITSBENEFITSFROMTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDINVITED2WANDA
TOFURTHERIMPROVETHETRANSPARENCYANDPREDICTABILITYOFITSTRADEREGIME-EMBERSWERE
PLEASEDTHAT2WANDAWASPARTICIPATINGINTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK)&ANDSUPPORTED
THE'OVERNMENTSCALLFORTHE$IAGNOSTIC4RADE)NTEGRATION3TUDY$4)3TOBECOMPLETEDAS
SOONASPOSSIBLE4HEYCONSIDEREDTHATTHE)&COULDHELPTOMEETPRIORITYTECHNICALASSISTANCE
NEEDSANDINTEGRATETRADEREFORMSINTO2WANDASOVERALLPOVERTYREDUCTIONSTRATEGY
3OMECLARIFICATIONWASSOUGHTONTHEINFORMALSECTORTHEENACTMENTOFTHENEWPUBLIC
PROCUREMENTLAWEXISTINGLEGISLATIONONINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTSINSTITUTIONALFRAMEWORK
JUDICIARYREFORMINVESTMENTREGIMEEXPORTPROMOTIONSTRATEGYPRIVATIZATIONCOMPETITION
POLICYSERVICESSANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURESOTHERDUTIESANDCHARGESANDPRICE
CONTROLS
-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHERESPONSESPROVIDEDBYTHE2WANDANDELEGATION
)THINKTHATTHISMEETINGHASALLOWEDAPROFOUNDREFLECTIONONASSISTANCENEEDED
BY2WANDAINTHERECONSTRUCTIONOFITSECONOMY)THASDRAWNATTENTIONTO2WANDAS
DETERMINATIONTOCONTINUEWITHECONOMICREFORMSASWELLASTOAREASINWHICHPOLICYREFORMS
COULDBEFURTHERENHANCED)TRUSTTHATTHEMAINCONSIDERATIONSOFTHIS2EVIEWWILLBEINCLUDED
INTOTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKPROCESSINORDERTOREINFORCETHELINKAGESBETWEENTRADEPOLICY
ANDPOVERTYREDUCTIONSTRATEGY)URGEALL-EMBERSTOSUPPORT2WANDAINITSEFFORTSTOTACKLE
THECHALLENGESITFACESANDTOBEATTENTIVETOITSREQUESTFORTECHNICALASSISTANCE
.ORWAY
7EHAVECONDUCTEDTHISFOURTH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOF.ORWAYINAFRIENDLYANDWELL
INFORMEDMANNERANDOURDIALOGUEHASBEENVERYCONSTRUCTIVE7EHAVEGREATLYBENEFITED
FROMTHEVALUABLECONTRIBUTIONOFTHE.ORWEGIANDELEGATIONLEDBY-R(ARALD.EPLE
$IRECTOR'ENERALOFTHE-INISTRYOF&OREIGN!FFAIRSTHEVERYINSIGHTFULCOMMENTSBYOUR
DISCUSSANT-R!LEXANDER'ROSSANDTHEACTIVEINVOLVEMENTOFALARGENUMBEROF-EMBERS
!TTHEOUTSETALLOWMETOHIGHLIGHTTHECONSIDERABLESUPPORTOF-EMBERSFOR.ORWAYS
SOLIDMACROECONOMICPERFORMANCESINCEITSLAST2EVIEWINWITHLOWINFLATIONAND
UNEMPLOYMENTRATESGENERALLYOPENINVESTMENTREGIMEANDGROWTHWELLABOVEOTHER
INDUSTRIALIZEDCOUNTRIES-EMBERSALSORECOGNIZEDTHATOILANDGASMADEACONSIDERABLE
CONTRIBUTIONTO.ORWAYSPROSPERITY-EMBERSWELCOMED.ORWAYSFIRMCOMMITMENTTOAND
ACTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMINCLUDINGTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT
!GENDA-EMBERSNOTEDTHAT.ORWAYISALSOACTIVEINTHEREGIONALANDBILATERALFORA
4HEYEXPRESSEDAPPRECIATIONFORITSSUBSTANTIALDIRECTAIDTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDTO74/
TECHNICALASSISTANCEINPARTICULARANDFORITSFARREACHING'30SCHEMEFORLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIES
-EMBERSCOMMENDED.ORWAYONITSVERYLIBERALTRADEREGIMEFORNONAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS
ANDONITSFULLIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE74/!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHINGWELLINADVANCE
OFTHETIMELINEAGREED(OWEVERDIVERGENTVIEWSWEREEXPRESSEDONITSAGRICULTURALPOLICY
)NDEEDSOME-EMBERSSHAREDACOMMONPOSITIONONTHECONCEPTOFNONTRADECONCERNS
%UROPEAN5NION
4HISSEVENTH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOFTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES%#HASBEENCONDUCTED
INAFRIENDLYANDCOMPREHENSIVEMANNERANDOURDIALOGUEHASBEENVERYCONSTRUCTIVE
7EHAVEGREATLYBENEFITEDFROMTHEENGAGEMENTOFTHE%#DELEGATIONLEDBY-R0IERRE
$EFRAIGNE$EPUTY$IRECTOR'ENERAL$'4RADETHEVERYINSIGHTFULCOMMENTSBYOURDISCUSSANT
!MBASSADOR$ON3TEPHENSONANDTHEACTIVEINVOLVEMENTOFALARGENUMBEROF-EMBERS
-EMBERSCOMMENDEDTHE%#ONITSCONTINUEDEFFORTSTOWARDSALIBERALTRADEREGIME
ANDONITSMONETARYDISCIPLINE4HESEEFFORTSHAVECONTRIBUTEDTOAFURTHERDECLINEINITS
ALREADYLOWINFLATIONANDTOEXTERNALCURRENTACCOUNTSURPLUSINTHELASTFEWYEARS-EMBERS
WELCOMEDTHEONGOINGRECOVERYOFTHE%#SECONOMYFOLLOWINGASLOWDOWNSINCE
THEYHOPEDTHATTHERECOVERYWOULDBESUSTAINEDGIVENTHEPOSITIVEIMPACTTHISMIGHT
HAVEONUNEMPLOYMENTANDFISCALDEFICITSWITHINTHE%#ANDONTHEGLOBALECONOMYIN
GENERAL-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHE%#SSTRONGCOMMITMENTTOANDACTIVEPARTICIPATIONIN
THEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMINCLUDINGITSSTRONGLEADERSHIPINSTRIKINGADEALONTHE*ULY
0ACKAGE4HEYEXPRESSEDAPPRECIATIONFORITSSUBSTANTIALCONTRIBUTIONTOTHE74/S'LOBAL
4RUST&UNDFORTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDFORITSNONRECIPROCALPREFERENCESTODEVELOPING
COUNTRIESUNDERITS'30SCHEMEAND#OTONOU!GREEMENTANDTO,$#SUNDERTHE%VERYTHING
"UT!RMSINITIATIVE.EVERTHELESSSEVERALMEMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERNSONITSPLANNEDREFORMS
OFTHE'30SCHEMEANDHOPEDTHATITWOULDBEOBJECTIVEANDCONSISTENTWITHTHE74/RULES
ANDPRINCIPLES-EMBERSALSONOTEDTHATTHE%#S-&.TRADEREGIMEAPPLIEDTOONLYNINE
74/-EMBERSBECAUSEOFITSACTIVEINVOLVEMENTINVARIOUSPREFERENTIALTRADEARRANGEMENTS
-EMBERSCOMMENDEDTHE%#ONITSLIBERALTRADEREGIMEFORNONAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS
3OME-EMBERSSHAREDTHE%#SNONTRADEJUSTIFICATIONFORITS#OMMON!GRICULTURAL0OLICY
#!0(OWEVEROTHER-EMBERSNOTEDTHATDESPITETHEONGOINGREFORMOFTHE#!0MAINLY
THROUGHTHEDECOUPLINGOFPAYMENTSFROMPRODUCTIONAGRICULTUREREMAINSPROTECTEDBYHIGH
TARIFFRATESACOMPLEXTARIFFSTRUCTUREANDBYHIGHLEVELSOFDOMESTICSUPPORTANDEXPORT
SUBSIDIES!RGUINGTHATSUCHPROTECTIONUNDERMINESECONOMICEFFICIENCYANDPENALISED
BOTH%#TAXPAYERSANDCONSUMERSTHEYURGEDTHE%#TOFURTHERLIBERALIZEITS#!03EVERAL
MEMBERSALSOASKEDTHE%#TOPROVIDEINFORMATIONONITSSPECIFICAGRICULTURALPOLICY
INCLUDINGTHEREFORMSOFSUGARANDBANANAREGIMES
-EMBERSNOTEDTHENEWOPPORTUNITIESPROVIDEDBYTHEENLARGEMENTOFTHE%##ONCERNS
WEREEXPRESSEDABOUTTHE%#SCONSISTENCYWITHANDCOMMITMENTSTOTHE74/RULESAND
DISCIPLINESASARESULTOFITSENLARGEMENTTOMEMBERSINPARTICULARTHENEEDTOPROVIDE
ADEQUATEINFORMATIONANDCOMPENSATIONTO-EMBERS6ARIOUS-EMBERSRAISEDCONCERNS
ABOUTTHECONTINUEDACTIVEUSEOFCONTINGENCYTRADEREMEDIESBYTHE%#ANDEXPRESSED
FEARSTHATTHISMIGHTINCREASEWITHTHEELIMINATIONOFTEXTILESANDCLOTHINGQUOTASATTHEEND
OFTHISYEAR#ONCERNSWEREALSOEXPRESSEDABOUTTHELACKOFHARMONIZATIONWITHINTHE%#
INAREASSUCHASINTERNALTAXRATESANDCERTAINSERVICES4HE%#STECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADE
AND303MEASURESINCLUDINGTHENEW2%!#(SYSTEMFORCHEMICALSWEREDEEMEDSTRINGENT
ANDBURDENSOME-EMBERSSOUGHTFURTHERCLARIFICATIONONTHE%#SCOMMONFISHERIESPOLICY
THESCHEMEFORTHE'-/SANDBIOTECHNOLOGYPRODUCTSCUSTOMSPROCEDURESRULESOFORIGIN
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
WHICHWASATTHEHEARTOFTHEJUSTIFICATIONFOR.ORWAYSAGRICULTURALPOLICY
"YCONTRASTOTHERSEXPRESSEDCONCERNSONTHISISSUEANDABOUT.ORWAYSHIGHLEVELOF
PROTECTIONOFAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSBYMEANSOFACOMPLEXTAXATIONSYSTEMANDLARGESUPPORT
ANDURGED.ORWAYTOREFORMITSPOLICY4HEYCOMMENTEDTHATSUCHPROTECTIONUNDERMINED
ECONOMICEFFICIENCYANDPENALIZEDBOTH.ORWEGIANTAXPAYERSANDCONSUMERS
3OME-EMBERSSHARED.ORWAYSCONCERNONTHEWIDESPREADTENDENCYTORESORTTOTRADE
REMEDYACTIONSCOMMENDING.ORWAYONTHERENUNCIATIONOFANYSUCHMEASUREOVERTHEPAST
YEARS1UESTIONSWEREPOSEDONPUBLICENTERPRISESWITHSOME-EMBERSURGING.ORWAYTO
FURTHERREDUCETHEDEGREEOFPUBLICOWNERSHIPINITSECONOMY-EMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERNS
ANDREQUESTEDINFORMATIONONADMINISTRATIONOFTARIFFQUOTAS303MEASURESANDTECHNICAL
REGULATIONS4HEYALSOSOUGHTFURTHERCLARIFICATIONONTHEFOREIGNINVESTMENTREGIMEINCENTIVE
SCHEMESCOMPETITIONLEGISLATIONGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTPROTECTIONOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTY
RIGHTSANDONSPECIFICACTIVITIESSUCHASFISHERIESMARITIMETRANSPORTANDFINANCIALSERVICES
-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHERESPONSESPROVIDEDBYTHE.ORWEGIANDELEGATIONANDLOOKED
FORWARDTOFURTHERWRITTENREPLIES
)NCONCLUSIONITISMYFEELINGTHATTHEWIDEINTERESTSHOWNBY-EMBERSWITHMANY
ADVANCEWRITTENQUESTIONSINTERVENTIONSANDHIGHATTENDANCEREFLECTSTHEIMPORTANTROLE
THAT.ORWAYPLAYSINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM7ENOWHAVEAMUCHBETTERAND
UPDATEDUNDERSTANDINGOFITSTRADERELATEDPOLICIESANDPRACTICESANDAPPRECIATETHE
CHALLENGESITFACESANDITSEFFORTSTOADDRESSTHEMINAWAYTHATISCONSISTENTWITHTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM&URTHERLIBERALIZATIONOF.ORWAYSAGRICULTURALSECTORWOULD
SUPPORTITSWIDELYRECOGNIZEDACTIONSINFAVOUROFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESMAINLYTHOSEWITHA
KEYINTERESTINAGRICULTURE
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
TARIFFQUOTAADMINISTRATIONGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTSTATEAIDANDSUBSIDIESPROGRAMMES
PROTECTIONOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTSINCLUDINGGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSBUSINESS
REGULATIONANDCOMPETITIONPOLICYANDONSPECIFICACTIVITIESINCLUDINGENERGYSTEELFINANCIAL
SERVICESTELECOMMUNICATIONSANDTRANSPORT
-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHERESPONSESPROVIDEDBYTHE%#DELEGATIONANDLOOKEDFORWARD
TORECEIVINGWRITTENANSWERSONANYOUTSTANDINGQUESTIONS
)NCLOSING)WOULDLIKETOTHANKTHE%#DELEGATIONONITSORALANDWRITTENRESPONSES
PROVIDEDDURINGTHEMEETING4HIS2EVIEWHASOFFEREDTHEOPPORTUNITYFORAMUCHBETTERAND
UPDATEDUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE%#SPOLICIESANDPRACTICESANDFORACOLLECTIVEAPPRECIATION
OFTHECHALLENGESITFACESANDITSEFFORTSTOADDRESSTHEMINA74/CONSISTENTWAY4HEWIDE
INTERESTSHOWNBY-EMBERSWITHMANYADVANCEWRITTENQUESTIONSINTERVENTIONSANDHIGH
ATTENDANCEREFLECTSTHEVITALIMPORTANCEOFTHE%#TOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
)TAPPEARSTHATTHEMAINAREASWHEREMANY-EMBERSWOULDLIKETOHAVETHE%#S
POSITIVEANDEXPEDITIOUSRESPONSEARETHE74/ISSUESRELATEDTOITSENLARGEMENTANDTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFITSAGRICULTURALANDTECHNICALREGULATIONSREFORMS4HISWOULDSTRENGTHEN
BOTHITSSUPPORTFORTHEMULTILATERALSYSTEMANDITSWIDELYRECOGNIZEDACTIONSINFAVOUROF
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESMAINLYTHOSEWITHAKEYINTERESTINAGRICULTURE
4HE#HAIRSTATEDTHATTHE!NNUAL2EPORT744027HADBEENCIRCULATEDAND
PROPOSEDITSADOPTION4HEREPORTWASADOPTED
4HEREPRESENTATIVESOF!USTRALIAAND#HILEAGREEDTHATTHEREWASCONSIDERABLEROOMFOR
IMPROVEMENTINTHEWAYTHE402MEETINGSWEREHANDLED-EMBERSSHOULDNOTONLYTHINK
SERIOUSLYABOUTTHEREVIEWCYCLEBUTALSOONWHETHERTHEFORMATADOPTEDWASENSURINGTHE
MOSTOPENDISCUSSIONANDANALYSISOFEACHOTHERSPOLICIES
4HE#HAIRNOTEDTHATTHISWASPARTOFTHEAPPRAISALPROCESSANDASKEDTHE3ECRETARIATTO
TAKETHEFLOOR
4HE$IRECTOROFTHE4RADE0OLICIES2EVIEW$IVISION#"OONEKAMPNOTEDTHATAN
!PPRAISALOFTHE/PERATIONOFTHE402-SHOULDBEUNDERTAKENINPREPARATIONFORTHE(ONG
+ONG#HINA-INISTERIAL!NINFORMALNOTETOSTARTTHISPROCESSWASBEINGPREPARED
4HEDISCUSSIONSINTHE402"FORTHE!PPRAISALWOULDBEAGOODOPPORTUNITYTOCONSIDERTHE
WHOLEREVIEWPROCESSINCLUDINGTHEMEETINGSANDCONTENTOFTHE3ECRETARIATREPORT
/NEPROCEDURALCHANGEWASALREADYINTHEMAKINGATTHEFORTHCOMING402"MEETING
IN$ECEMBERONTHE/VERVIEWOF$EVELOPMENTSINTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADING%NVIRONMENT
TWODISCUSSANTSWOULDBEINVITEDTOCONSIDERTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALSREPORTFORTHATMEETING
ITWASHOPEDTHATTHISWOULDHELPTHE402"TOHOLDANACTIVEDEBATECENTREDONTHE
ECONOMICSOFTHEISSUES
4HEREPRESENTATIVEOF!USTRALIAASKEDTHE!MBASSADORFORTHE%UROPEAN#OMMISSIONTO
REFLECTTHEOUTCOMEOFTHISTRADEPOLICYREVIEWINHISPRESSSTATEMENT
"RAZIL
4HISFOURTH4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWOF"RAZILHASPROVIDEDTHEOPPORTUNITYFORAFRUITFUL
DIALOGUEBETWEEN"RAZILANDOTHER74/-EMBERS7EHAVEGREATLYBENEFITEDFROMTHE
COMPREHENSIVEENGAGEMENTOFTHE"RAZILIANDELEGATIONLEDBY!MBASSADOR4ARRAGÙANDBY
THEINSIGHTFULCOMMENTSOFOURDISCUSSANT!MBASSADOR3PENCER7HILENOTINGTHAT"RAZIL
HADBEENAFFECTEDBYADVERSEDOMESTICANDEXTERNALDEVELOPMENTSDURINGTHEPERIODUNDER
2EVIEW-EMBERSRECOGNIZEDANDWELCOMED"RAZILSCONTINUINGREFORMS4HESEHADRESULTED
INPRIMARYFISCALSURPLUSESDECREASEDINFLATIONANDINCREASEDRESILIENCETOSHOCKS-EMBERS
NOTEDTHATGROWTHHADRESUMEDLARGELYTRIGGEREDBYINCREASEDANDDIVERSIFIEDEXPORTSTO
NONTRADITIONALMARKETS
-EMBERSWEREGREATLYAPPRECIATIVEOF"RAZILSACTIVEPARTICIPATIONINTHE74/OFITS
COMMITMENTTOTRADELIBERALIZATIONANDOFTHEROLEPLAYEDBY"RAZILINADVANCINGTHE$$!
(OWEVERSEVERAL-EMBERSNOTEDTHAT"RAZILHADNOTPARTICIPATEDINTHENEGOTIATIONS
ON)4!ANDHADTODATENOTRATIFIEDTHE&OURTHAND&IFTH0ROTOCOLSTOTHE'!43"RAZILS
ACTIVEINVOLVEMENTIN74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEDURESWASNOTEDASWEREITSEFFORTSTO
ENHANCE3OUTH3OUTHCOOPERATION3EVERAL-EMBERSALSOREFERREDTOTHEGROWINGNUMBER
OFPREFERENTIALTRADEAGREEMENTSRECENTLYNEGOTIATEDORCURRENTLYUNDERNEGOTIATIONBY
"RAZILANDEXPRESSEDTHEIRHOPETHATSUCHINITIATIVESWOULDBESUPPORTIVEOFEFFORTSATTHE
MULTILATERALLEVEL1UESTIONSWERERAISEDWITHRESPECTTOTHETIMETABLEFORCOMPLETIONOFTHE
-%2#/352INTEGRATIONPROCESS
-EMBERSPOINTEDOUTTHEIMPORTANCEOFINVESTMENTPARTICULARLYFOREIGNDIRECT
INVESTMENTFOR"RAZILSFUTUREGROWTHPROSPECTSBUTEXPRESSEDSOMECONCERNWITHRESPECT
TOREMAININGRESTRICTIONSTOFOREIGNPARTICIPATION-EMBERSPOSEDQUESTIONSONTHEDECISION
BYTHE%XECUTIVETOWITHDRAWALLBILATERALINVESTMENTAGREEMENTSFROMCONSIDERATIONFOR
RATIFICATIONBY#ONGRESS
-EMBERSAGREEDTHAT"RAZILSTRADEREGIMEHADBECOMEMOREOPENANDTRANSPARENT
DURINGTHEPERIODUNDERREVIEWBUTMANYNOTEDTHATMARKETACCESSBARRIERSPERSISTINA
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX)n4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYn#ONCLUDING
REMARKSBYTHE#HAIROFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY
FEWBUTIMPORTANTAREAS"RAZILSAPPLIEDTARIFFHADDECLINEDSINCETHELAST2EVIEWIN
BUTESCALATIONANDSOMEPEAKSREMAINED-EMBERSALSONOTEDTHATREDUCINGTHESTILLLARGE
GAPBETWEENAPPLIEDANDBOUNDRATESWOULDENHANCETHEPREDICTABILITYOFITSTRADEREGIME
#ONCERNSWEREEXPRESSEDABOUTTHERANGEANDCOMPLEXITYOFNONTARIFFCHARGESONIMPORTS
BOTHATTHESTATEANDATTHEFEDERALLEVELS-EMBERSOBSERVEDTHAT"RAZILSIMPORTLICENSING
REGIMEHADBEENSTREAMLINEDBUTHIGHLIGHTEDTHESTILLLARGENUMBEROFPRODUCTSSUBJECTTO
NONAUTOMATICLICENSINGREQUIREMENTS"RAZILSCONTINUEDACTIVEUSEOFCONTINGENCYMEASURES
WASASOURCEOFCONCERNFORSOME-EMBERSAND"RAZILWASINVITEDTOEXERCISERESTRAINT
INTHEIRUSE1UESTIONSWEREPOSEDONOTHERMEASURESLIKECUSTOMSPROCEDURESTECHNICAL
REGULATIONSAND303REQUIREMENTS
-EMBERSSOUGHTCLARIFICATIONWITHRESPECTTOTHERATIONALEFORMAINTAININGAMAILORDER
REGIMEANDFOREXPORTTAXESANDEXPRESSEDCONCERNABOUTDOMESTICCONTENTANDOTHER
REQUIREMENTSFORACCESSINGTHEWIDERANGEOF"RAZILSSUPPORTPROGRAMMES-EMBERS
ALSONOTEDTHATSEVERALOF"RAZILSMANUFACTURINGINDUSTRIESHADBECOMEINTERNATIONALLY
COMPETITIVEBUTQUESTIONEDTHEUSEOFTARIFFESCALATIONANDOTHERSUPPORTINSOMEINDUSTRIES
"RAZILWASURGEDTOMAKEASIGNIFICANTCONTRIBUTIONINTHEONGOING.!-!NEGOTIATIONS
$ISCUSSIONSONSERVICESFOCUSEDMAINLYONTHETELECOMMUNICATIONSMARITIMETRANSPORT
ANDONFINANCIALANDPROFESSIONALSERVICES-EMBERSQUERIED"RAZILSLEGALPROVISIONSALLOWING
THE%XECUTIVETODECIDEONFOREIGNPARTICIPATIONINFINANCIALSERVICESANDTELECOMMUNICATIONS
"RAZILWASALSOENCOURAGEDTOENHANCEITS'!43COMMITMENTSANDMAKEASUBSTANTIAL
CONTRIBUTIONINTHESERVICESNEGOTIATIONS
)NCONCLUSIONTHIS2EVIEWHASCONFIRMED"RAZILSPROGRESSTOWARDSGREATERTRANSPARENCY
INANDLIBERALIZATIONOFITSTRADEANDINVESTMENTREGIME4HEEXPORTLEDRECOVERYEXPERIENCED
OVERTHELASTYEARPROVIDESCONCRETEEVIDENCEOFTHEBENEFITSOF"RAZILSCLOSERINTEGRATIONIN
THEGLOBALECONOMY(OWEVERTOENSURETHESUSTAINABILITYOFTHEGAINSALREADYACHIEVEDAND
TRANSLATETHEMINTOHIGHERLIVINGSTANDARDSFURTHERREFORMSARENEEDEDTOREDUCETHEMARKET
ACCESSBARRIERSANDINTERNALINEFFICIENCIESTHATSTILLCREATEUNCERTAINTYFORTRADERSANDINVESTORS
RISEPRODUCTIONCOSTSANDLOWERCONSUMERWELFARE)AMTHUSPLEASEDTOHEAROFTHEVARIOUS
STEPSBEINGTAKENBYTHE"RAZILIANAUTHORITIESTOADDRESSTHESEISSUES)AMALSOHEARTENED
TOHEARTHAT"RAZILISSTRIVINGFORDEEPERINTEGRATIONINWORLDTRADEANDTHATITWILLCONTINUE
TOPLAYANACTIVEROLEINTHE74/!CHIEVINGBOTHOBJECTIVESWOULDBEGREATLYAIDEDBY"RAZIL
ENHANCINGITS74/COMMITMENTSTOALEVELCOMMENSURATEWITHTHEMAJORROLEITPLAYSINTHE
MULTILATERALSYSTEMANDITSAMBITIOUSNEGOTIATINGAGENDAINAREASSUCHASAGRICULTURE
)CLOSETHISMEETINGBYEXPRESSINGAGAINMYAPPRECIATIONFOR"RAZILSCONSTRUCTIVE
ENGAGEMENTINTHIS2EVIEWANDFORTHENUMEROUSANSWERSPROVIDEDTOTHEQUESTIONSASKED
BY-EMBERS-EMBERSLOOKFORWARDTORECEIVINGWRITTENANSWERSTOOUTSTANDINGQUESTIONS
)ALSOTHANKTHEDISCUSSANTANDTHEMANY-EMBERSWHOSEPARTICIPATIONHELPEDMAKETHIS
EXERCISEASUCCESS
3WITZERLANDAND,IECHTENSTEIN
4HESECONDJOINTREVIEWOF3WITZERLANDAND,IECHTENSTEINHASBEENINFORMATIVEOPEN
ANDTHOUGHTPROVOKING4HETWODELEGATIONSLEDBY!MBASSADORS7ASESCHAAND&RICKHAVE
BEENHIGHLYCOOPERATIVEINTHEIRPARTICIPATION7EHAVEGREATLYBENEFITEDFROMTHEPERCEPTIVE
REMARKSMADEBY!MBASSADOR5JAL3INGH"HATIAOURDISCUSSANTANDTHEACTIVEINVOLVEMENT
OFMANY-EMBERS
-EMBERSCOMMENDED3WITZERLANDAND,IECHTENSTEINONTHEIRREFORMSTHROUGHBOTH
UNILATERALANDREGIONALINITIATIVESWHILEMAINTAININGTHE74/ASTHEFOUNDATIONOFTHEIR
EXTERNALTRADEPOLICIES-EMBERSALSOAPPRECIATED3WITZERLANDSTECHNICALCOOPERATIONEFFORTS
INFAVOUROFDEVELOPINGANDACCEDINGCOUNTRIES4HETWOECONOMIESEXPERIENCEDDIFFERING
TRENDSINGROWTHSINCETHEIRLAST4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW402WITHEMPLOYMENTIN,IECHTENSTEIN
GROWINGRAPIDLYAND3WITZERLANDSLOWLYRECOVERINGFROMAPROLONGEDPERIODOFECONOMIC
STAGNATION,IECHTENSTEINHASGREATLYBENEFITEDFROMITSMEMBERSHIPOFTHE%UROPEAN%CONOMIC
!REA3WITZERLANDTOOHASBEENTAKINGSTEPSTOFURTHERINTEGRATEMANYPOLICYAREASWITHTHE
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES%#)NTHISRESPECT-EMBERSENQUIREDABOUTPROGRESSINTHETWO
SETSOFBILATERALAGREEMENTSBETWEEN3WITZERLANDANDTHE%#PARTICULARLYINHARMONIZINGTHEIR
REGULATIONSONGOODSSERVICESANDMOVEMENTOFPERSONS#ONCERNSWEREEXPRESSEDABOUT
POTENTIALLYDISCRIMINATORYASPECTSOFSUCHREGIONALINTEGRATIONFOROTHER74/-EMBERS
-EMBERSNOTEDTHAT3WITZERLANDAND,IECHTENSTEINSTARIFFSTRUCTUREISCOMPLEX4HEIR
COMMONTARIFFCONSISTSENTIRELYOFSPECIFICDUTIES-EMBERSENQUIREDABOUTPLANSTOMOVE
TOADVALOREMDUTIESANDTOREDUCETARIFFSUNILATERALLYASWELLASABOUTVALUATIONOFGOODS
FORINTERNALTAXATIONPURPOSES-EMBERSCOMMENDEDTHEMFORMAINTAININGAGENERALLYLOW
LEVELOFPROTECTIONONNONAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS7HILESOME-EMBERSSHAREDTHECOUNTRIES
AGRICULTURALPOLICYVISIONOTHERSEMPHASIZEDTHECONTRASTBETWEENTHEIROPENNESSINNON
AGRICULTURALTRADEANDTHEIRHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTIONFORMANYAGRICULTURALANDFOODPRODUCTS
#ONCERNSWERERAISEDABOUTBROADAGRICULTURALPOLICYPROSPECTSANDSPECIFICMEASURES
INCLUDINGEXPORTSUBSIDIESDIRECTPAYMENTSANDTARIFFQUOTASANDTHEIRADMINISTRATION
THROUGHINTERALIATHEPRISEENCHARGESYSTEM3EVERAL-EMBERSLOOKFORWARDTOPROGRESS
IN3WITZERLANDSAGRICULTURALREFORM$ELEGATIONSALSOASKEDWHEN3WITZERLANDWOULDPROVIDE
ITSLONGOVERDUENOTIFICATIONSONDOMESTICSUPPORTANDEXPORTSUBSIDIES
3EVERALQUESTIONSWEREASKEDABOUT3WITZERLANDSTECHNICALANDSANITARYPHYTOSANITARY
REGULATIONSINCLUDINGLABELLINGSCHEMESREGULATIONSONGENETICALLYMODIFIEDORGANISMSAND
ENVIRONMENTALMEASURESANDABOUTINTELLECTUALPROPERTYLEGISLATIONNOTABLYONGEOGRAPHICAL
INDICATIONS-EMBERSCOMMENDEDBOTHCOUNTRIESFORNOTHAVINGTAKENANYTRADEREMEDIAL
ACTIONS-EMBERSWELCOMEDTHEONGOINGEFFORTSMADETOINCREASEDOMESTICCOMPETITION
INCLUDINGTHESIGNIFICANTREINFORCEMENTOF3WITZERLANDS,AWON#ARTELSANDCALLEDFORGREATER
COMPETITIONINAREASSTILLUNDERMONOPOLY4HEIMPORTANCEOFSERVICESTOTHETWOECONOMIES
WASNOTEDANDQUESTIONSWEREASKEDABOUTPOLICYDEVELOPMENTSINTELECOMMUNICATIONS
TOURISMELECTRICITYANDGASCONSTRUCTIONANDFINANCIALSERVICESINCLUDINGTHEISSUESOFBANK
SECRECYCOUNTERINGMONEYLAUNDERINGANDTAXEVASION
-EMBERSAPPRECIATEDTHERESPONSESPROVIDEDBYTHETWODELEGATIONSANDLOOKEDFORWARD
TORECEIVINGWRITTENANSWERSONOUTSTANDINGQUESTIONS
4HIS2EVIEWHASGIVEN-EMBERSTHEOPPORTUNITYTOGAINAMUCHBETTERUNDERSTANDING
OFTHEPOLICYDEVELOPMENTSIN,IECHTENSTEINAND3WITZERLANDSINCE4HEWIDEINTEREST
SHOWNBY-EMBERSISREFLECTEDINTHEDEPTHOFTHEINTERVENTIONSTHELARGENUMBEROF
ADVANCEWRITTENQUESTIONSANDTHECOMPREHENSIVEWRITTENREPLIES4HEIMPORTANCEOFFURTHER
REFORMINTHETWOECONOMIESONAN-&.BASISBOTHEXTERNALLYANDINTERNALLYANDOFGREATER
LIBERALIZATIONPARTICULARLYINAGRICULTUREHASBEENEMPHASIZEDREPEATEDLY)SHOULDLIKETO
THANKTHETWODELEGATIONSFORTHEIRWILLINGANDCOOPERATIVEPRESENCEINTHISMEETINGAND
-EMBERSFORTHEIRACTIVEPARTICIPATION
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
4HISBOOKLETCONTAINSPUBLICATIONSWHICHCANBEPURCHASEDDIRECTLYFROMTHE7ORLD4RADE
/RGANIZATION&ORTHEMOSTUPTODATELISTPLEASEVISITTHEONLINEBOOKSHOPONTHE74/
WEBSITEATWWWWTOORG
,EGALPUBLICATIONS
4HE2ESULTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDOF-ULTILATERAL4RADE.EGOTIATIONS4HE,EGAL
4EXTS
4HISBOOKCONTAINSTHELEGALTEXTSOFTHEAGREEMENTSNEGOTIATEDINTHE5RUGUAY2OUND
NOWTHELEGALFRAMEWORKOFTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION4HEAGREEMENTSWILLGOVERNWORLD
TRADEINTOTHESTCENTURY4HEYCOVER
'OODSTHEUPDATED'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4ARIFFSAND4RADE'!44THATINCLUDESNEW
RULESONAGRICULTURETEXTILESANTIDUMPINGSUBSIDIESANDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESIMPORT
LICENSINGRULESOFORIGINSTANDARDSANDPRESHIPMENTINSPECTION4HEORIGINAL'!44TEXTIS
ALSOINCLUDEDINTHISVOLUME
3ERVICESTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4RADEIN3ERVICES'!43)NTELLECTUALPROPERTYTHE
!GREEMENTON4RADE2ELATED)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY2IGHTS42)03$ISPUTESTHENEWDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTMECHANISM
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".0APERBACK
0RICE#(&
,EATHERBOUNDEDITIONWITH"OOKMARKS
0RICE#(&
74/"ASIC)NSTRUMENTSAND3ELECTED$OCUMENTS
4HEOFFICIALCOLLECTIONOFLEGALDOCUMENTSPROTOCOLSANDREPORTSADOPTEDBYTHE7ORLD
4RADE/RGANIZATION)TCONTAINSTHE0ROTOCOLSFOR!CCESSIONFORNEW74/MEMBERSALONGWITH
OTHERLEGALINSTRUMENTS
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
6OLUME)n&EBRUARY)3".
6OLUME))n&EBRUARY)3".
(ARDBACK
#(&
'!44"ASIC)NSTRUMENTSAND3ELECTED$OCUMENTSn6OLn
4HISCOMPLETESETCONTAINSALLVOLUMESOFTHE'!44")3$SERIES4HISANNUALSERIES
PRESENTSTHEPRINCIPALDECISIONSRESOLUTIONSRECOMMENDATIONSANDREPORTSADOPTEDBYTHE
'!44CONTRACTINGPARTIESEVERYYEAR!VOLUMEWASPUBLISHEDEVERYYEARFROMUPTO
#OPUBLISHEDWITH7ILLIAM3(EINCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
(ARDBACK%DITION
0RICE#(&
'!44!NALYTICAL)NDEX'UIDETO'!44,AWAND0RACTICE
4HE'!44SOWNARTICLEBYARTICLEHANDBOOKONTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTDESCRIBINGTHE
DRAFTHISTORYINTERPRETATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFTHERULESBASEDONOFFICIALDOCUMENTARY
RECORDS
4HETHEDITIONISTHEMOSTCOMPLETEANDUPTODATEPRESENTATIONOF'!44LAWITSPANS
TOTHEENDOFWHENTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATIONWASESTABLISHED)TINCLUDES
DECISIONSBY'!44BODIESTHEMANYINTERPRETATIONSOF'!44LAWMADEBYDISPUTESETTLEMENT
PANELSANDANEWCHAPTERONINSTITUTIONALANDPROCEDURALMATTERS
4HOROUGHLYRESEARCHEDEACHCHAPTERANALYSESPRECEDENTSANDPRACTICEANDPRESENTSTHE
RELEVANTMATERIALINTHEORIGINALTEXTWITHFULLDOCUMENTARYREFERENCES
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNANPRESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/3TATUSOF,EGAL)NSTRUMENTS
4HISLOOSELEAFEDITIONISANUPTODATEACCOUNTOFTHELEGALINSTRUMENTSSHOWINGA
COMPLETELISTOFAGREEMENTSANDPROTOCOLSINFORCEANDTHESITUATIONOFTHEIRRATIFICATIONAND
ENTRYINTOFORCE
3UPPLEMENTNªn)3".
3UPPLEMENTNªn)3".
3UPPLEMENTNªn)3".
3UPPLEMENTNªn)3".
0RICE"INDER3UPPLEMENT.O#(&
%ACHSUBSEQUENTSUPPLEMENT#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
74/!NALYTICAL)NDEXˆ'UIDETO74/,AWAND0RACTICE
&IRST%DITIONVOLUMES4HE74/!NALYTICAL)NDEXISTHEAUTHORITATIVEGUIDETOTHE
INTERPRETATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFFINDINGSANDDECISIONSOF74/PANELSTHE74/!PPELLATE
"ODYANDOTHER74/BODIES4HEMATERIALISPRESENTEDINSEPARATECHAPTERSFOREACH74/
AGREEMENT4HESECHAPTERSGENERALLYPRESENTTHETEXTOFTHEPARTICULARARTICLEORAGREEMENT
CHRONOLOGICALLYARRANGEDEXCERPTSOFRELEVANTJURISPRUDENCEANDDECISIONSADISCUSSIONOF
THERELATIONSHIPTOOTHERARTICLESAND74/AGREEMENTSANDCROSSREFERENCESTOTHE'!44
!NALYTICAL)NDEXWHENAPPLICABLE
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
74/!GREEMENTS3ERIES
!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE74/
4HE74/SAGREEMENTSARETHELEGALFOUNDATIONFORTHEINTERNATIONALTRADINGSYSTEMTHAT
ISUSEDBYTHEBULKOFTHEWORLDSTRADINGNATIONS4HISSERIESOFFERSASETOFHANDYREFERENCE
BOOKLETSONSELECTEDAGREEMENTS%ACHVOLUMECONTAINSTHETEXTOFONEAGREEMENTAN
EXPLANATIONDESIGNEDTOHELPTHEUSERUNDERSTANDTHETEXTANDINSOMECASESSUPPLEMENTARY
MATERIAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
'!44AND
4HE74/SAGREEMENTSARETHELEGALFOUNDATIONFORTHEINTERNATIONALTRADINGSYSTEMTHATIS
USEDBYTHEBULKOFTHEWORLDSTRADINGNATIONS4HISSERIESOFFERSASETOFHANDYREFERENCEBOOKLETS
ONSELECTEDAGREEMENTS%ACHVOLUMECONTAINSTHETEXTOFONEAGREEMENTANEXPLANATION
DESIGNEDTOHELPTHEUSERUNDERSTANDTHETEXTANDINSOMECASESSUPPLEMENTARYMATERIAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
!GRICULTURE
4HE74/SAGREEMENTSARETHELEGALFOUNDATIONFORTHEINTERNATIONALTRADINGSYSTEMTHAT
ISUSEDBYTHEBULKOFTHEWORLDSTRADINGNATIONS4HISSERIESOFFERSASETOFHANDYREFERENCE
BOOKLETSONSELECTEDAGREEMENTS%ACHVOLUMECONTAINSTHETEXTOFONEAGREEMENTAN
EXPLANATIONDESIGNEDTOHELPTHEUSERUNDERSTANDTHETEXTANDINSOMECASESSUPPLEMENTARY
MATERIAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/3ANITARY0HYTOSANITARY-EASURES
4HE74/SAGREEMENTSARETHELEGALFOUNDATIONFORTHEINTERNATIONALTRADINGSYSTEMTHAT
ISUSEDBYTHEBULKOFTHEWORLDSTRADINGNATIONS4HISSERIESOFFERSASETOFHANDYREFERENCE
BOOKLETSONSELECTEDAGREEMENTS%ACHVOLUMECONTAINSTHETEXTOFONEAGREEMENTAN
EXPLANATIONDESIGNEDTOHELPTHEUSERUNDERSTANDTHETEXTANDINSOMECASESSUPPLEMENTARY
MATERIAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADE
4HE74/SAGREEMENTSARETHELEGALFOUNDATIONFORTHEINTERNATIONALTRADINGSYSTEMTHAT
ISUSEDBYTHEBULKOFTHEWORLDSTRADINGNATIONS4HISSERIESOFFERSASETOFHANDYREFERENCE
BOOKLETSONSELECTEDAGREEMENTS%ACHVOLUMECONTAINSTHETEXTOFONEAGREEMENTAN
EXPLANATIONDESIGNEDTOHELPTHEUSERUNDERSTANDTHETEXTANDINSOMECASESSUPPLEMENTARY
MATERIAL
.OVEMBER
)3".
0RICE#(&
,EGAL)NSTRUMENTSEMBODYINGTHE2ESULTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDn
4HELEGALINSTRUMENTSEMBODYINGTHERESULTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDOFMULTILATERALTRADE
NEGOTIATIONSADOPTEDIN-ARRAKESHON!PRILPUBLISHEDINASETOFVOLUMES
4HECOMPLETESETCOVERSTHELEGALTEXTSTHEMINISTERIALDECISIONSANDTHE-ARRAKESH
DECLARATIONTHESIGNATORYCOUNTRIESASWELLASTHEINDIVIDUALAGREEMENTSTHESCHEDULESOF
SPECIFICCOMMITMENTSONSERVICESTHETARIFFSCHEDULESFORTRADEINGOODSANDTHE0LURILATERAL
!GREEMENTS
3CHEDULESINTHEORIGINALLANGUAGEONLY
!VAILABLEFROM7ILLIAM3(EIN)NCCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
(ARDBACK%DITION
0RICE#(&
!NNUALPUBLICATIONS
74/!NNUAL2EPORT
4HE!NNUALREPORTOFTHE74/FOCUSESONTHEREGULARACTIVITIESOFTHEORGANIZATIONTHE
DETAILSOFITSCURRENTSTRUCTURESTAFFANDBUDGET4HE!NNUALREPORTISPUBLISHEDINTHEFIRST
HALFOFEACHYEAR
74/!NNUAL2EPORTn)3".
74/!NNUAL2EPORTn)3".
74/!NNUAL2EPORTn)3".
0RICE#(&
7ORLD4RADE2EPORT
4HE7ORLD4RADE2EPORTISANANNUAL74/PUBLICATIONFOCUSEDONTRADETRENDSAND
POLICYISSUES4HEEDITIONREVIEWSRECENTTRADEDEVELOPMENTSANDEXAMINESISSUES
INCLUDINGCOHERENCEINTRADEANDMACROECONOMICPOLICIESGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSANDTHE
LIBERALIZATIONOFTRADEINSERVICESTHROUGHTHETEMPORARYMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONS
7ORLD4RADE2EPORTn)3".
7ORLD4RADE2EPORTn)3".
7ORLD4RADE2EPORTn)3".8
0RICE#(&
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICS
4HISREPORTPROVIDESCOMPREHENSIVESTATISTICSONTRADEINMERCHANDISEANDCOMMERCIAL
SERVICESFORANASSESSMENTOFWORLDTRADEFLOWSBYCOUNTRYREGIONANDMAINPRODUCTGROUPS
ORSERVICECATEGORIES
3OMETABLESANDCHARTSDEPICTTRADEDEVELOPMENTSFROMVARIOUSPERSPECTIVESAND
PROVIDEANUMBEROFLONGTERMTIMESERIES-AJORTRADEDEVELOPMENTSARESUMMARIZEDAND
DISCUSSEDINTHEFIRSTPARTOFTHEREPORTUNDER/VERVIEW$ETAILEDTRADESTATISTICSAREPROVIDED
IN!PPENDIXTABLES
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICSn)3".n.OVEMBER
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICSn)3".8n.OVEMBER
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICSn)3".n.OVEMBER
0RICE#(&
4HE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICSREPORTISALSOAVAILABLEONA#$2OMORONLINEAT
HTTPWWWWTOORGENGLISHRES?ESTATIS?ESTATIS?EHTM
!(ANDBOOKONTHE'!43!GREEMENT
4HISHANDBOOKAIMSTOPROVIDEABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOF'!43ANDTHECHALLENGESAND
OPPORTUNITIESOFTHEONGOINGNEGOTIATIONS&ORUSERSWHOAREFAMILIARWITHTHE'ENERAL
!GREEMENTON4ARIFFSAND4RADE'!44SIMILARITIESANDDIFFERENCESAREPOINTEDOUTWHERE
RELEVANT,IKEWISEFORUSERSWHOAREFAMILIARWITHTHEBALANCEOFPAYMENTSDEFINITIONOF
@TRADEDEPARTURESFROMTHE!GREEMENTSCOVERAGEAREEXPLAINED4OSTIMULATEFURTHER
THINKINGABOUTTHECORECONCEPTSANDIMPLICATIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTSEVERALTEXTBOXESHAVE
BEENINCLUDEDTOPROVIDE@FOODFORTHOUGHTANDATTHEENDOFEACHCHAPTERTESTQUESTIONS
HAVEBEENADDEDTORECAPITULATEANDENSUREUNDERSTANDINGOFTHECORECONTENT
-AY
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
)3".0APERBACK
0RICE#(&
!(ANDBOOKONTHE74/$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT3YSTEM
4HISGUIDEHASBEENPREPAREDBYTHE74/3ECRETARIATTOEXPLAINTHEPRACTICESTHATHAVE
ARISENINTHEOPERATIONOFTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMSINCEITSENTRYINTOFORCEON
*ANUARY)TSDETAILEDCONTENTWILLBEUSEFULTOEXPERTPRACTITIONERSASWELLASTOTHOSE
WANTINGTOGAINABASICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEM
*ULY
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".n0APERBACK
0RICE#(&
)3".n(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
(ANDBOOKSANDGUIDES
!(ANDBOOKOF!NTI$UMPING)NVESTIGATIONS
4HISUNIQUEHANDBOOKPREPAREDBYSPECIALISTSINTHE74/3ECRETARIATCOVERSTHEMAJOR
AREASARISINGINANTIDUMPINGINVESTIGATIONSASEMBODIEDINTHERELEVANT74/PROVISIONS)T
PROVIDESEXPLANATIONSFORGRASPINGTHEINTRICACIESOFANTIDUMPINGPROCEEDINGS4HISBOOKWILL
INTERESTANYONEDEALINGWITHANTIDUMPINGANDRELATEDISSUESININTERNATIONALTRADE
#ANALSOBEORDEREDFROM#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
$ICTIONARYOF4RADE0OLICY4ERMS
7ALTER'OODE
4HISISAGUIDEBYTHE74/AND#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSTOTHEVOCABULARYUSEDIN
TRADENEGOTIATIONS)TSNEARLYENTRIESCOVERINSIMPLELANGUAGETRADITIONAL'!44AND
74/CONCEPTSANDTERMSUSEDINTRADERELATEDACTIVITIES
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
4ARIFF.EGOTIATIONSAND2ENEGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE'!44AND
THE74/n0ROCEDURESAND0RACTICES
4HEPROCEDURESANDPRACTICESTOIMPLEMENTTHEPROVISIONSRELATINGTOTARIFFNEGOTIATIONS
ANDRENEGOTIATIONSHAVEEVOLVEDCONSIDERABLYSINCETHE'!44WASESTABLISHEDIN
4HEPROVISIONSTHEMSELVESHAVEUNDERGONESOMECHANGESINTHELASTFIFTYFOURYEARS
0ROFESSOR(ODAREVIEWSTHEEVOLUTIONOFTHESEPROVISIONSANDOFTHEPROCEDURESADOPTEDAND
PRACTICESFOLLOWEDBYTHECONTRACTINGPARTIESTO'!44ANDTHE-EMBERSOFTHE74/(E
OFFERSSOMECONCLUSIONSANDRECOMMENDATIONS4HISNEWBOOKWILLBEOFPARTICULARINTEREST
TONEGOTIATORSINCLUDING'ENEVABASEDDELEGATIONSMEMBERSOFGOVERNMENTTRADEMINISTRIES
ECONOMISTSANDALLACADEMICSWHOSPECIALISEINTRADEPOLICY
/CTOBER
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
4HE)NTERNATIONALIZATIONOF&INANCIAL3ERVICESn)SSUESAND,ESSONSFOR
$EVELOPING#OUNTRIES
4HE)NTERNATIONALIZATIONOFFINANCIALSERVICESISANIMPORTANTISSUEFORTHESTRENGTHENING
ANDLIBERALIZINGFINANCIALSYSTEMSINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES4HEREHASBEENCONSIDERABLE
SUPPORTFORTHEVIEWTHATINTERNATIONALIZATIONCANASSISTCOUNTRIESINBUILDINGFINANCIAL
SYSTEMSTHATAREMORESTABLEANDEFFICIENTBYINTRODUCINGINTERNATIONALSTANDARDS
ANDPRACTICES!TTHESAMETIMETHEREHAVEBEENCONCERNSABOUTTHERISKSTHAT
INTERNATIONALIZATIONMAYCARRYFORSOMECOUNTRIESPARTICULARLYINTHEABSENCEOFADEQUATE
REGULARATORYSTRUCTURES4HECHAPTERSINTHISBOOKEXAMINEDIFFERENTASPECTSOFTHISDEBATE
THERELATIVEBENEFITSANDCOSTSOFINTERNATIONALIZATIONANDTOGETHERPROVIDEANINSIGHTINTO
THEDIVERSITYANDSIGNIFICANCEOFTHEEFFECTSOFINTERNATIONALIZATIONONDOMESTICFINANCIAL
SYSTEMS
.OVEMBER
#OPUBLISHEDWITH+LUWER,AW)NTERNATIONAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
'UIDETOTHE'!43
4HISWORKBRINGSTOGETHERINONEVOLUMETHEBACKGROUNDPAPERSONMAJORSERVICE
SECTORSPREPAREDBYTHE74/3ECRETARIATFORTHE74/S#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESIN
PREPARATIONFORTHENEWROUNDOFNEGOTIATIONSWHICHSTARTEDIN*ANUARYANDINCLUDES
THEISSUESWHICH74/-EMBERSNEEDTOCONSIDERWHENFRAMINGTHEIRNEGOTIATINGPOSITIONS
ANDOBJECTIVESFORTHENEWROUNDANDPREPARINGTHEIRINDUSTRIESFORAMOREOPENTRADING
ENVIRONMENT
#OPUBLISHEDWITH+LUWER,AW)NTERNATIONALCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
4RADE$EVELOPMENTANDTHE%NVIRONMENT
)NRECENTYEARSTHERELATIONSHIPSBETWEENTRADEANDTHEENVIRONMENTANDTRADEAND
DEVELOPMENTHAVEBECOMEINCREASINGLYCOMPLEX4HENEEDTORECONCILETHECOMPETING
DEMANDSOFECONOMICGROWTHECONOMICDEVELOPMENTANDENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONHAS
BECOMECENTRALTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADEAGENDA)NTHISVOLUMEVARIOUSCOMMENTATORS
DEBATETHEROLEOFTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATIONANDOTHERINSTITUTIONSINADDRESSINGTHESE
CHALLENGES4HEBOOKARISESFROMTHEPAPERSPRESENTEDATTWO(IGH,EVEL3YMPOSIAHOSTEDBY
THE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATIONIN-ARCHON4RADEANDTHE%NVIRONMENTAND4RADEAND
$EVELOPMENT
#OPUBLISHEDWITH+LUWER,AW)NTERNATIONALCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
'UIDETOTHE5RUGUAY2OUND!GREEMENTS
4HISPUBLICATIONISTHEONLYOFFICIALANDCOMPREHENSIVEEXPLANATIONBYTHE74/OFTHE
5RUGUAY2OUNDTREATIES)THELPSREADERSTONAVIGATETHECOMPLEXITIESOFWELLOVER
PAGESOFDECISIONSAGREEMENTSANCOMMITMENTSARISINGOUTOFTHENEGOTIATIONS
#OPUBLISHEDWITH+LUWER,AW)NTERNATIONALCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
2ESHAPINGTHE7ORLD4RADING3YSTEMn3ECONDEDITION
4AKEGOVERNMENTANDTERRITORIESEACHBENTONVIGOROUSLYSEEKINGITSOWN
SELFINTEREST'IVETHEMAMANDATETOREACHAGREEMENTONNEWRULESFORMOREOPEN
MARKETSnNOTONLYFORGOODSBUTFORSERVICESANDINTELLECTUALPROPERTYASWELL!NDGIVETHEM
ATIMELIMITnFOURYEARS)TSOUNDSIMPOSSIBLEANDITALMOSTWAS4HISISTHESTORYTOLDIN
FRANKLIVELYANDNONTECHNICALTERMSOFHOWANDWHYTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDCAMEABOUTWHAT
THEPARTICIPANTCOUNTRIESSOUGHTANDTHETWISTSTURNSSETBACKSANDSUCCESSESOFEACHSTAGE
ANDSECTOROFTHENEGOTIATIONSxANDHOWAFTERSEVENYEARSTHEFINALACHIEVEMENTINMANY
INSTANCESSURPASSEDTHEORIGINALGOALS
#OPUBLISHEDWITH+LUWER,AW)NTERNATIONALCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
$ISPUTESETTLEMENTPUBLICATIONS
4HE74/!PPELLATE"ODY2EPERTORYOF2EPORTSAND!WARDSISTHEESSENTIALRESEARCHTOOL
FORPROFESSIONALSINVOLVEDININTERNATIONALTRADELAW/RIGINALLYDEVELOPEDASANINTERNAL
RESEARCHTOOLTOASSISTTHE!PPELLATE"ODY3ECRETARIATINCARRYINGOUTITSDUTYTOPROVIDELEGAL
SUPPORTTO!PPELLATE"ODY-EMBERSTHE2EPERTORYISNOWBEINGMADEAVAILABLETOTHEPUBLIC
INTHEHOPETHATITWILLBECOMEAPRACTICALTOOLFOROFFICIALSFROM74/-EMBERSACADEMICS
STUDENTSANDPRIVATEPRACTITIONERSOFINTERNATIONALTRADELAWANDDISPUTESETTLEMENT
!VAILABLE-ARCHn%NGLISH
&RENCHAND3PANISHVERSIONSEXPECTEDSUMMER
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".8(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
!(ANDBOOKONTHE74/$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT3YSTEM
4HISGUIDEHASBEENPREPAREDBYTHE74/3ECRETARIATTOEXPLAINTHEPRACTICESTHATHAVE
ARISENINTHEOPERATIONOFTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMSINCEITSENTRYINTOFORCEON
*ANUARY)TSDETAILEDCONTENTWILLBEUSEFULTOEXPERTPRACTITIONERSASWELLASTOTHOSE
WANTINGTOGAINABASICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEM
*ULY
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".0APERBACK
0RICE#(&
)3".(ARDBACK
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
74/!PPELLATE"ODY2EPERTORYOF2EPORTSAND!WARDSn
74/$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT0ROCEDURESnND%DITION
4HENDEDITIONCOPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGETAKESINTOACCOUNTLEGALDECISIONSAND
OTHERLEGALINSTRUMENTSADOPTEDSINCE.EWMATERIALHASBEENADDEDINCLUDINGTHE
@7ORKING0ROCEDURESFOR!PPELLATE2EVIEWANDTHE@2ULESOF#ONDUCTFORTHE$35
G)NTHESECONDEDITIONTHEPROVISIONSONCONSULTATIONANDONDISPUTESETTLEMENTINEACHOF
THE-ULTILATERAL4RADE!GREEMENTSCOVEREDBYTHE$35ARENOWCOLLECTEDTOGETHER/LDER
LESSRELEVANTMATERIALHASBEENREMOVED4HEINTERNALTEXTDESIGNISSOMEWHATALTEREDTOO
ANDCROSSREFERENCESBETWEENTHETEXTSHAVEBEENEXTENDED+EYWORDSWITHINTHEINDEX
HAVEBEENAUGMENTEDTOREFLECTTHEEXTENDEDCOVERAGE4HISISTHEPROCEDURALBIBLEFOR
PRACTITIONERSACADEMICSSTUDENTSANDALLWHONEEDTOINTERACTWITHTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENT
PROCEDURESOFTHE74/0ANELSAND!PPELLATE"ODY
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".0APERBACK
0RICE#(&
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT2EPORTS
4HE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT2EPORTSOFTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION74/INCLUDE0ANELAND
!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSASWELLASARBITRATIONAWARDSINDISPUTESCONCERNINGTHERIGHTSAND
OBLIGATIONSOF74/MEMBERSUNDERTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHING
THE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT2EPORTS#OMPLETE3ET(ARDBACKBOOKS
6OLUMES
0RICEFOR#OMPLETE3ETa
0RICEPERVOLUMEnFROMna
!NALYSISANDSPECIALREPORTS
!LLPUBLICATIONSINTHISCATEGORYAREAVAILABLEASFREEDOWNLOADSONTHE74/WEBSITE
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENTS2EPORTS
4HE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT2EPORTSOFTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION74/INCLUDE0ANELAND
!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSASWELLASARBITRATIONAWARDSINDISPUTESCONCERNINGTHERIGHTSAND
OBLIGATIONSOF74/MEMBERSUNDERTHEPROVISIONSOFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHING
THE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT2EPORTS#OMPLETE3ET(ARDBACKBOOKS
6OLUMES
0RICEFOR#OMPLETE3ETa
0RICEPERVOLUMEnFROMna
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
74/!GREEMENTS0UBLIC(EALTH
4HISJOINTSTUDYBYTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATIONANDTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
3ECRETARIATONTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTRADERULESANDPUBLICHEALTH4HEPAGESTUDY
EXPLAINSHOW74/!GREEMENTSRELATETODIFFERENTASPECTSOFHEALTHPOLICIES)TISMEANTTO
GIVEABETTERINSIGHTINTOKEYISSUESFORTHOSEWHODEVELOPCOMMUNICATEORDEBATEPOLICY
ISSUESRELATEDTOTRADEANDHEALTH4HESTUDYCOVERSAREASSUCHASDRUGSANDINTELLECTUAL
PROPERTYRIGHTSFOODSAFETYTOBACCOANDMANYOTHERISSUESWHICHHAVEBEENSUBJECTTO
PASSIONATEDEBATE)NTHISJOINTEFFORTTHEFIRSTOFITSKIND7(/ANDTHE74/3ECRETARIAT
ENDEAVOURTOSETOUTTHEFACTS
)3".
0RICE#(&
3PECIAL3TUDY.ª!DJUSTINGTO4RADE,IBERALIZATIONn4HE2OLEOF0OLICY
)NSTITUTIONSAND74/$ISCIPLINES
4HISSTRUDYSEEKSTOIDENTIFYTOOLSATTHEDISPOSALOFGOVERNMENTSTOSMOOTHADJUSTMENTTO
MINIMIZEANECONOMYSADJUSTMENTCOSTSANDTOALLEVIATETHEBURDENOFTHOSEWHOSUFFERMOST
)3".
0RICE#(&
3PECIALSTUDY.ª-ARKET!CCESS5NFINISHED"USINESSn0OST5RUGUAY2OUND
)NVENTORY
4HESTUDYPROFILESPOST5RUGUAY2OUNDMARKETACCESSCONDITIONSINTHREEAREASˆ
INDUSTRIALTARIFFSAGRICULTUREANDSERVICESˆTHELATTERTWOOFWHICHAREALREADYTHESUBJECT
OFONGOINGNEGOTIATIONS4HEDETAILEDSTUDYISINTENDEDASACOMPREHENSIVERESOURCEFOR
NEGOTIATORSANDTHEINTERESTEDPUBLIC
)3".
0RICE#(&
3PECIALSTUDY.ª4RADE)NCOME$ISPARITYAND0OVERTY
!74/STUDYWHICHISBASEDONTWOEXPERTREPORTSCOMMISSIONEDBYTHE74/3ECRETARIAT
AIMSTOCLARIFYTHEINTERFACEBETWEENTRADEGLOBALINCOMEDISPARITYANDPOVERTY0ROFESSOR$AN
"EN$AVIDOF4EL!VIV5NIVERSITYTAKESANINDEPHLOOKATTHELINKAGESBETWEENTRADEECONOMIC
GROWTHANDINCOMEDISPARITYAMONGNATIONS0ROFESSOR,!LAN7INTERSOF5NIVERSITYOF3USSEX
DISCUSSESTHEVARIOUSCHANNELSBYWHICHTRADEMAYAFFECTTHEINCOMEOPPORTUNITIESOFPOOR
PEOPLE4HEPUBLICATIONALSOINCLUDESANONTECHNICALOVERVIEWOFTHETWOEXPERTREPORTS
)3".
0RICE#(&
3PECIALSTUDY.ª4RADEANDTHE%NVIRONMENT
4HISSTUDYBYTHE74/ADDRESSESSEVERALKEYQUESTIONSRELATEDTOTHEENVIRONMENT
4HESTUDYSHOWSTHATTRADECOULDPLAYAPOSITIVEROLEINTHEDIFFUSIONOFENVIRONMENTFRIENDLY
TECHNOLOGIESAROUNDTHEWORLDANDISBACKEDUPBYTHEFIVECASESTUDIESONCHEMICAL
INTENSIVEAGRICULTUREDEFORESTATIONGLOBALWARMINGACIDRAINANDOVERFISHING
)3".
0RICE#(&
3PECIALSTUDY.ª4RADE&INANCEAND&INANCIAL#RISES
4HISSTUDYBYTHE74/EXPLAINSTHEBASICLINKSBETWEENTRADEANDTHEFINANCIALSECTORAND
HOWFINANCIALCRISESAREINTERRELATEDWITHTRADE
4HISSTUDYALSOINCLUDESCASESTUDIESONPASTFINANCIALCRISES
)3".
0RICE#(&
3PECIAL3TUDY.ª%LECTRONIC#OMMERCEANDTHEROLEOFTHE74/
4HISSECONDSTUDYINAPOPULARSERIESEXAMINESTHEPOTENTIALTRADEGAINSFROMTHERAPIDLY
INCREASINGUSEOFTHE)NTERNETFORCOMMERCIALPURPOSES4HESTUDYWASWRITTENASAMEANS
OFPROVIDINGBACKGROUNDINFORMATIONFORTHE74/MEMBERSWHOARENOWDEVELOPING
POLICYRESPONSESTOTHISNEWFORMOFCOMMERCE7RITTENBYATEAMOFECONOMISTSFROMTHE
74/3ECRETARIATITIDENTIFIESTHECOMPLEXITIESASWELLASTHEPOTENTIALBENEFITSOFTRADEVIA
THE)NTERNET4HEBOOKDESCRIBESTHEEXTRAORDINARYEXPANSIONOFOPPORTUNITIESTHATELECTRONIC
COMMERCEOFFERSINCLUDINGFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
0RINTVERSIONNOLONGERAVAILABLE$OWNLOADFORFREEFROMTHE74/WEBSITE
3PECIAL3TUDY.ª/PENING-ARKETSIN&INANCIAL3ERVICESANDTHE2OLEOFTHE
'!43
4HISFIRSTPUBLICATIONINANEWSERIESOFSPECIALSTUDIESEXPLORESSOMEOFTHEISSUES
SURROUNDINGTHEFINANCIALSERVICESNEGOTIATIONSANALYZESWHATISATSTAKEANDASSESSESWHAT
74/MEMBERSHAVEALREADYACHIEVEDINPREVIOUSNEGOTIATIONS4HISPAGESTUDYCONTAINS
DETAILEDTABLESCHARTSANDBOXESTOHELPTHEREADERUNDERSTANDSOMEOFTHECHARACTERISTICS
OFTHEFINANCIALSERVICESSECTORANDAPPRECIATETHEFULLBENEFITSOFITSTRADELIBERALIZATION
0RINTVERSIONNOLONGERAVAILABLE$OWNLOADFORFREEFROMTHE74/WEBSITE
$ISCUSSION0APER.ªn3ELECTED)SSUES#ONCERNINGTHE-ULTILATERAL4RADING
3YSTEM
4HISPAPEREXPLORESSELECTEDISSUESTHATWERESTUMBLINGBLOCKSATTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEINCLUDINGINTERNATIONALTRADEANDINVESTMENTANDMARKETACCESSOFDEVELOPING
COUNTRIESINTEXTILESANDCLOTHING
$ECEMBER
)3".
0RICE#(&
$ISCUSSION0APER.ªn4HE4RADE$EBTAND&INANCE.EXUSATTHE#ROSSROADS
OF-ICROAND-ACROECONOMICS
4HISPAPERSEEKSTOCLARIFYHOWTHE74/ISPARTOFTHENATIONALANDINTERNATIONALEFFORTTO
ADDRESSSOMEOFTHECHALLENGESRAISEDBYTHESERELATIONSHIPS)TREVIEWSSOMEOFTHETHEORETICAL
LINKSANDEXISTINGLITERATUREONTHESUBJECTANDANALYSESPRACTICALSTEPSANDPRIORITIESTHATARE
DIRECTLYADDRESSEDINTHENEWLYESTABLISHED7ORKING'ROUPON4RADE$EBTAND&INANCE
.OVEMBER
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
$ISCUSSION0APERS
$ISCUSSION0APERS.ªn4HE'LOBAL4EXTILEAND#LOTHING)NDUSTRYPOSTTHE
!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING
4HISPAPERWRITTENUNDERTHEEXCLUSIVERESPONSIBILITYOFASTAFFMEMBEROFTHE74/
3ECRETARIATINAPERSONALCAPACITYASSESSESSOMEOFTHEPOSSIBILITIESWITHRESPECTTOTHE
POTENTIALIMPACTOFTRADELIBERALIZATIONINTHETEXTILESANDCLOTHINGSECTORWITHTHEENDOF
IMPORTQUOTASON*ANUARY
)3".8
0RICE#(&
$ISCUSSION0APERS.ªn4HE2OLEOF%XPORT4AXESINTHE&IELDOF0RIMARY
#OMMODITIES
4HISPAPEREXAMINESTHEECONOMICEFFECTSOFANEXPORTTAXONCOMMODITYPRICESANDTHE
VOLUMEOFEXPORTS)TEXAMINESHOWWELFARERESULTINGFROMANEXPORTTAXISREDISTRIBUTED
AMONGFOREIGNANDDOMESTICCONSUMERSPRODUCERSANDTHEGOVERNMENTANDTHEEFFECTSOF
ANEXPORTTAXUSEDASANINSTRUMENTOFTRADEPOLICYTOIMPROVEDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTERMS
OFTRADEFAVOURSECONOMICDIVERSIFICATIONANDHELPTHEPOOR
)3".
0RICE#(&
$ISCUSSIONPAPER.ªn)NCOME6OLATILITYIN3MALLAND$EVELOPING%CONOMIES
%XPORT#ONCENTRATION-ATTERS
4HISPAPEREXAMINESTHEEFFECTOFEXPORTCONCENTRATIONONINCOMEVOLATILITYINSMALL
ECONOMIESANDCONCLUDESTHATVOLATILITYISREDUCEDIFSMALLECONOMIESDIVERSIFYTHEIREXPORTS
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/$ISCUSSION0APERSn.ª)MPROVINGTHE!VAILABILITYOF4RADE&INANCEDURING
&INANCIAL#RISES
4HISPAPEREXPLORESTHEREASONSBEHINDTHEFAILUREBYPRIVATEMARKETSANDOTHER
INSTITUTIONSTOMEETDEMANDFORCROSSBORDERANDDOMESTICSHORTTERMTRADEFINANCEDURING
FINANCIALCRISESSUCHASTHEONEWHICHAFFECTEDEMERGINGECONOMIESINTHES
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/$ISCUSSION0APERSn.ª)NDUSTRIAL4ARIFFSANDTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT
!GENDA
#ONTAININGMANYTABLESANDCHARTSTHEPAPERFOCUSESONTHEBASICMANDATEGIVENTO
NEGOTIATORSAT$OHAANDLOOKSATSPECIFICISSUESFACINGDEVELOPEDDEVELOPINGANDLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
)3".
.OLONGERAVAILABLEINPRINTnDOWNLOADFROMTHE74/WEBSITE
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
4RADEPOLICYREVIEWS
3URVEILLANCEOFNATIONALTRADEPOLICIESISAFUNDAMENTALLYIMPORTANTACTIVITYRUNNING
THROUGHOUTTHEWORKOFTHE74/!TTHECENTREOFTHISWORKISTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW
-ECHANISM402-!LL74/MEMBERSAREREVIEWEDTHEFREQUENCYOFEACHCOUNTRYSREVIEW
VARIESACCORDINGTOITSSHAREOFWORLDTRADE
-OREINFORMATIONONTHE74/WEBSITEATHTTPWWWWTOORGENGLISHTRATOP?ETPR?E
TPR?EHTM
4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWSARECOPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
%ACHVOLUMECOSTS#(&
4HEFOLLOWING4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWSWILLTAKEPLACEIN
*AMAICA
*APAN
3IERRA,EONE
1ATAR
-ONGOLIA
0ARAGUAY
.IGERIA
%CUADOR
4HE0HILIPPINES
%GYPT
4RINIDADAND4OBAGO
4UNISIA
'UINEAAND4OGO
"OLIVIA
$JIBOUTI
2OMANIA
-ALAYSIA
&OR4RADE0OLICY2EVIEWSFROMPREVIOUSYEARSPLEASEVISITTHE74/WEBSITE
%LECTRONICPUBLICATIONS
#OMPUTERBASEDTRAINING
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
4HISTRAININGMODULEISAIMEDATANYONEWHONEEDSABASICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTSYSTEM)TWASDEVELOPEDBY74/SPECIALISTSONDISPUTESETTLEMENTANDINCLUDES
INTERACTIVETESTSWHICHALLOWYOUTOMEASUREYOURPROGRESSINLEARNINGTHECONTENT)N
ADDITIONTOTHECOURSEMATERIALITSELFYOUWILLFINDLINKSTOREFERENCEDOCUMENTSSUCHASLEGAL
TEXTSANDOTHEROFFICIAL74/DOCUMENTS4HEREISALSOAPOPUPGLOSSARYFORRELATEDTERMS
&EBRUARY
4RILINGUAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4RADEIN3ERVICES
4HIS#$ISATRAININGCOURSEONTHE'!43USINGTEXTANDINTERACTIVEMETHODSTOENABLE
USERSTOACQUIREADETAILEDKNOWLEDGEOFTHISAGREEMENT)TINCLUDESALIBRARYOFDOCUMENTS
ONTHE'!43INCLUDINGTHEBASIC!GREEMENT
4RILINGUAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
!GREEMENTON3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURES
4HISISTHESECONDINASERIESOFEASYTOUSEINTERACTIVEGUIDESTO74/!GREEMENTSON
#$2/-%ACH#$2/-MODULEISDESIGNEDTOGUIDETHEUSERTHROUGHTHECOMPLEX74/
AGREEMENTSINASIMPLESTEPBYSTEPMANNER4HISMODULEWHICHCOVERSTHE74/!GREEMENT
ON3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESINCLUDESTEXTVIDEOANDAUDIOMATERIALANDIS
COMPLEMENTEDBYAMULTIPLECHOICETESTTOENABLEUSERSTOMONITORTHEIRINDIVIDUALPROGRESS
4HECOMPLETETEXTOFTHE!GREEMENTISALSOINCLUDED
4RILINGUAL
)3".
0RICE#(&
#$2/-74/!NALYTICAL)NDEXn'UIDETO74/,AW0RACTICE
2ESEARCHERSCANUSETHIS#$2/-ASAGUIDETOTHETOTHEINTERPRETATIONANDAPPLICATION
OFFINDINGSANDDECISIONSOF74/PANELSTHE74/!PPELLATE"ODYANDOTHER74/BODIES
4HIS#$2/-PRESENTSTHETEXTOFTHEPARTICULARARTICLESORAGREEMENTSCHRONOLOGICALLY
ARRANGEDEXCERPTSOFRELEVANTJURISPRUDENCEANDDECISIONSDISCUSSIONSOFTHERELATIONSHIPSTO
OTHERARTICLESAND74/AGREEMENTSANDCROSSREFERENCESTOTHE'!44!NALYTICAL)NDEXWHEN
APPLICABLE
-ARCH
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
74/!GREEMENTSON#$2/-4HE,EGAL4EXTSAND3CHEDULES3ERVICES
4HIS#$2/-COPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTAINSTHEUPDATED
SCHEDULESOFSERVICESCOMMITMENTSANDOR-&.EXEMPTIONSFOR74/MEMBERCOUNTRIESTO
THEYEARIN%NGLISHPLUSTHE%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISHVERSIONSOFTHE74/,EGAL
4EXTS
#OPUBLISHEDWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
#$2/-'!44!NALYTICAL)NDEXn'UIDETO'!44,AWAND0RACTICE
4HE'!44SOWNARTICLEBYARTICLEHANDBOOKONTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTDESCRIBINGTHE
DRAFTINGHISTORYINTERPRETATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFTHERULESBASEDONOFFICIALDOCUMENTARY
RECORDS4HETHEDITIONISTHEMOSTCOMPLETEANDUPTODATEPRESENTATIONOF'!44LAW
ITSPANSTOTHEENDOFWHENTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATIONWASESTABLISHED)T
INCLUDESDECISIONSBY'!44BODIESTHEMANYINTERPRETATIONSOF'!44LAWMADEBYDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTPANELSANDANEWCHAPTERONINSTITUTIONALANDPROCEDURALMATTERS4HOROUGHLY
RESEARCHEDEACHCHAPTERANALYSESPRECEDENTSANDPRACTICEANDPRESENTSTHERELEVANT
MATERIALINTHEORIGINALTEXTWITHFULLDOCUMENTARYREFERENCES
%NGLISHONLY
0RICE#(&
#$2/-)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICS
4HEFIGURESHAVEBEENCOMPILEDANDANALYZEDBYTHE74/SECONOMISTSANDSTATISTICIANS
4HEELECTRONICVERSIONOFFERSTHEUSERTHEOPPORTUNITYTOEXAMINEINTERNATIONALTRADE
FIGURESBYCOUNTRYREGIONANDECONOMICSECTOR)TINCLUDESSEARCHANDGRAPHICSCAPABILITIES
PERMITTINGTHERESEARCHERSTOEXAMINEDATAINCHARTTABLEORGRAPHICALFORMATSANDEVENTO
CREATETHEIROWNANALYSESFROMTHEDATABASE
-ARCH
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
)3".8
0RICE#(&
)3".
0RICE#(&
#$2/-4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW
4HIS#$2/-ISANEFFICIENTTOOLTOLOCATECOMPAREANDCONTRASTTHEREVIEWSOFTRADE
POLICIESANDPRACTICESOFTHETWENTYEIGHTMEMBERCOUNTRIESMADEBYTHE7ORLD4RADE
/RGANIZATION74/BETWEENAND4HE#$2/-PROVIDESTHE%NGLISHTEXTOF
THEANDREPORTSANDTHE&RENCHAND3PANISHTEXTOFTHEAND
REPORTS
-ARCH
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN0RESSCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
)3".
0RICE#(&
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
#OMPLETE2ESULTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDOF-ULTILATERAL4RADE.EGOTIATIONS
4HISUNIQUE#$2/-CONTAINSTHECOMPLETELEGALTEXTSANDMARKETOPENINGCOMMITMENTS
OFTHECOUNTRIESWHOPARTICIPATEDINTHE5RUGUAY2OUND)TINCLUDESTHE
CAPABILITYTOORGANIZEINFORMATIONFORSPECIFICCOUNTRIESORCOUNTRYGROUPS4HEMATERIAL
COVERSPAGESOFLEGALTEXTCOVERINGGOODSSERVICESTRADERELATEDINTELLECTUALPROPERTY
RIGHTSDISPUTESETTLEMENTANDINDIVIDUALCOUNTRIESSCHEDULESOFCOMMITMENTSINTHEGOODS
ANDSERVICESAREAS
4RILINGUALVERSION
)3".
3INGLEUSERNETWORKLICENCE
0RICE#(&
-ULTIPLEUSERNETWORKLICENCE
0RICE#(&
#$2/-'!44"ASIC)NSTRUMENTSAND3ELECTED$OCUMENTS
4HEENTIRE'!44"ASIC)NSTRUMENTSAND3ELECTED$OCUMENTS")3$nALLVOLUMESIN
%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISHnONONE#$2/-*OINTLYDEVELOPEDBY"ERNAN!SSOCIATESAND
THE74/THISDISKUSESTECHNOLOGYTHATTURNSTHELARGELIBRARYOFDOCUMENTSINTOAHIGHLY
ACCESSIBLEANDUSEFULTOOLFORRESEARCH)TSRELEASECOINCIDESWITHTHEPUBLICATIONOFTHE
PRINTEDVERSIONOFTHEFINAL'!44")3$SUPPLEMENT7ITHAMULTIPLEUSERLICENCETHEDATACAN
ALSOBEACCESSEDBYSEVERALPEOPLEONACOMPUTERNETWORK
#OPUBLISHEDWITH"ERNAN!SSOCIATESCONTACTDETAILSONPAGE
0RICEISFOR3INGLEUSERNETWORKLICENCE
0RICE#(&
-ULTIPLEUSERNETWORKLICENCE
0RICE#(&
#$2/-)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICS
4HEFIGURESHAVEBEENCOMPILEDANDANALYZEDBYTHE74/SECONOMISTSANDSTATISTICIANS
4HEELECTRONICVERSIONOFFERSTHEUSERTHEOPPORTUNITYTOEXAMINEINTERNATIONALTRADE
FIGURESBYCOUNTRYREGIONANDECONOMICSECTOR)TINCLUDESSEARCHANDGRAPHICSCAPABILITIES
PERMITTINGTHERESEARCHERSTOEXAMINEDATAINCHARTTABLEORGRAPHICALFORMATSANDEVENTO
CREATETHEIROWNANALYSESFROMTHEDATABASE
-ARCH
0RICE#(&
#ANALSOBEORDEREDFROM"ERNAN0RESSCOPUBLISHER
6IDEOS
4OTHEHEARTOFTHE74/
4HISVIDEOEXPLAINSTHE74/THROUGHMEMBERGOVERNMENTSEYES)TSEEKSTOSHEDLIGHT
ONHOWTHE74/SYSTEMWORKSTHROUGHTHEEXPERIENCEANDMOTIVATIONSOFTWOVERYDIFFERENT
COUNTRIES"RAZILALARGEDEVELOPINGNATIONAND.ORWAYASMALLBUTECONOMICALLYADVANCED
STATE
,ENGTHMINUTES
0RICE#(&
3OLVING4RADE$ISPUTES
4HISVIDEOEXPLAINSHOWTRADEDISPUTESBETWEEN74/MEMBERSARESOLVEDTHROUGHTHE
DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEM4HEFIRSTPARTOFTHEVIDEOEXPLAINSHOWTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENT
SYSTEMWASCREATEDBY74/MEMBERSDURINGTHE5RUGUAYROUNDOFGLOBALTRADE
TALKSANDHOWTHESYSTEMOPERATES4HEPROCESSISCLEARLYILLUSTRATEDINTHESECONDPARTOFTHE
VIDEOUSINGSPECIFICCASES
0RICE#(&
&REEPUBLICATIONS
!LLFREEPUBLICATIONSCANBEDOWNLOADEDFROMTHE74/WEBSITE)FYOUREQUIREPRINT
VERSIONSPLEASEEMAILFREE WTOORG
4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/
4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/ISA2EPORTBYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALS#ONSULTATIVE"OARDONTHE
FUTUREOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMINCLUDINGRECOMMENDATIONSONREFORMS
!VAILABLEIN%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISH*ANUARY
4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTATTHE74/
$EVELOPEDTOASSISTPUBLICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHETRADEANDENVIRONMENTDEBATEINTHE
74/THISDOCUMENTBRIEFLYPRESENTSITSHISTORYANDFOCUSESONTRADEANDENVIRONMENTRELATED
ISSUESWITHINTHE$OHAMANDATETHEEFFECTSOFTRADELIBERALIZATIONONTHEENVIRONMENTTHE
RELATIONSHIPBETWEENMULTILATERALENVIRONMENTALAGREEMENTSANDTHE74/ANDAREVIEWOF
TRADEDISPUTESINVOLVINGENVIRONMENTALISSUES
-AY
5NDERSTANDINGTHE74/
!NINTRODUCTIONTOTHE74/WHATITISWHYITWASCREATEDHOWITWORKSANDWHATIT
DOES9OUCANBROWSETHEHTMLVERSIONONTHE74/WEBSITE
4HE74/INBRIEF
!STARTINGPOINTFORESSENTIALINFORMATIONABOUTTHE74/9OUCANBROWSETHEHTML
VERSIONONTHE74/WEBSITE
BENEFITSOFTHE74/TRADINGSYSTEM
&ROMTHEMONEYINOURPOCKETSANDTHEGOODSANDSERVICESTHATWEUSETOAMORE
PEACEFULWORLDnTHE74/ANDTHETRADINGSYSTEMOFFERARANGEOFBENEFITSSOMEWELL
KNOWNOTHERSNOTSOOBVIOUS9OUCANBROWSETHEHTMLVERSIONONTHE74/WEBSITE
COMMONMISUNDERSTANDINGSABOUTTHE74/
)SITADICTATORIALTOOLOFTHERICHANDPOWERFUL$OESITDESTROYJOBS$OESITIGNORETHE
CONCERNSOFHEALTHTHEENVIRONMENTANDDEVELOPMENT%MPHATICALLYNO#RITICISMSOFTHE
74/AREOFTENBASEDONFUNDAMENTALMISUNDERSTANDINGSOFTHEWAYTHE74/WORKS9OU
CANBROWSETHEHTMLVERSIONONTHE74/WEBSITE
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
$OHA$ECLARATIONS
4HISBOOKLETCONTAINSTHEFULLTEXTSOFTHE$ECLARATIONSAND$ECISIONSADOPTEDBY74/
-EMBERSATTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL!LSOINCLUDEDARERELEVANTDOCUMENTSOFTHE74/'ENERAL
#OUNCILDEALINGWITHIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
#ONTACTDETAILSFORCOPUBLISHINGPARTNERS
"ERNAN0RESS
&!SSEMBLY$RIVE
,ANHAM-$
53!
4EL
WWWBERNANCOM
QUERY BERNANCOM
#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESS%UROPE
4HE%DINBURGH"UILDING
3HAFTESBURY2OAD
#AMBRIDGE#"25
4EL
&AX
%MAILUKSALES CAMBRIDGEORG
HTTPUKCAMBRIDGEORG
74/ACTIVITIES
!NNEX))n74/0UBLICATIONS
#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESS.ORTH!MERICAN"RANCH
7ESTTH3TREET
.EW9ORK
.9
53!
4EL
&AX
%MAILINFORMATION CUPORG
HTTPUSCAMBRIDGEORG
+LUWER,AW)NTERNATIONAL
0/"OX
4HE(AGUE
4HE.ETHERLANDS
4EL
&AX
WWWKLUWERLAWCOM
SALES KLIWKAPNL
7ILLIAM3(EIN#O)NC
-AIN3TREET
"UFFALO.EW9ORK
4EL
&AX
WWWWSHEINCOM
MAIL WSHEINCOM
#HAPTER4HREE
/2'!.):!4)/.
3%#2%4!2)!4
!.$ "5$'%4
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
4HEORGANIZATION
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
4HEORGANIZATION
4HE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATIONCAMEINTOBEINGINASTHESUCCESSORTOTHE'ENERAL
!GREEMENTON4ARIFFSAND4RADE'!44WHICHHADBEENESTABLISHEDINTHEWAKEOF
THE3ECOND7ORLD7AR4HE74/SMAINOBJECTIVEISTHEESTABLISHMENTOFRULESFOR-EMBERS
TRADEPOLICYWHICHHELPINTERNATIONALTRADETOEXPANDWITHAVIEWTORAISINGLIVINGSTANDARDS
4HESERULESFOSTERNONDISCRIMINATIONTRANSPARENCYANDPREDICTABILITYINTHECONDUCTOFTRADE
POLICY4HE74/ISPURSUINGTHISOBJECTIVEBY
!DMINISTERINGTRADEAGREEMENTS
!CTINGASAFORUMFORTRADENEGOTIATIONS
3ETTLINGTRADEDISPUTES
2EVIEWINGNATIONALTRADEPOLICIES
!SSISTINGDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINTRADEPOLICYISSUESTHROUGHTECHNICALASSISTANCEAND
TRAININGPROGRAMMES
#OOPERATINGWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
4HE74/HAS-EMBERSACCOUNTINGFOROFWORLDTRADESEEINSIDECOVERFOR
ACOMPLETELISTOF-EMBERS-EMBERSAREMOSTLYGOVERNMENTSBUTCANALSOBECUSTOMS
TERRITORIES.EARLYAPPLICANTSARENEGOTIATINGTOBECOME-EMBERSOFTHE74/$ECISIONS
INTHE74/AREMADEBYTHEENTIREMEMBERSHIPTYPICALLYBYCONSENSUS
4HE74/STOPLEVELDECISIONMAKINGBODYISTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWHICHMEETSAT
LEASTONCEEVERYTWOYEARS)NTHEINTERVALSBETWEENSESSIONSOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
THEHIGHESTLEVEL74/DECISIONMAKINGBODYISTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWHERE-EMBERSARE
USUALLYREPRESENTEDBYAMBASSADORSORHEADSOFDELEGATIONS4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILALSOMEETS
ASTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYANDTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY!TTHENEXTLEVELTHE
'OODS#OUNCIL3ERVICES#OUNCILAND4RADE2ELATED!SPECTSOF)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY42)03
#OUNCILREPORTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
.UMEROUSSPECIALIZEDCOMMITTEESWORKINGGROUPSANDWORKINGPARTIESDEALWITHTHE
INDIVIDUALAGREEMENTSANDOTHERIMPORTANTAREASSUCHASTHEENVIRONMENTDEVELOPMENT
MEMBERSHIPAPPLICATIONSREGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTSTRADEANDINVESTMENTTRADEAND
COMPETITIONPOLICYANDTRANSPARENCYINGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENT
!4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE4.#WASSETUPBYTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONATTHE&OURTH
74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN4HE$ECLARATIONPROVIDESTHEMANDATEFORNEGOTIATIONS
INTHE4.#ANDITSSUBSIDIARIESONARANGEOFSUBJECTS4HE4.#OPERATESUNDERTHEAUTHORITY
OFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
74/STRUCTURE
!LL74/-EMBERSMAYPARTICIPATEINALLCOUNCILSCOMMITTEESETCEXCEPT!PPELLATE"ODY$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENTPANELS
ANDPLURILATERALCOMMITTEES
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGAS
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
"ODY
'ENERAL#OUNCIL
'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGAS
4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW
"ODY
!PPELLATE"ODY
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENTPANELS
#OMMITTEESON
4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT
4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT
3UBCOMMITTEEON,EAST
$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES
#OUNCILFOR
4RADEIN'OODS
#OUNCILFOR
4RADE2ELATED!SPECTS
OF)NTELLECTUAL
0ROPERTY2IGHTS
#OUNCILFOR
4RADEIN3ERVICES
2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS
#OMMITTEESON
#OMMITTEESON
"ALANCEOF0AYMENTS
2ESTRICTIONS
"UDGET&INANCE
AND!DMINISTRATION
-ARKET!CCESS
!GRICULTURE
3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY
-EASURES
4RADEIN&INANCIAL3ERVICES
3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTS
7ORKINGPARTIESON
4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADE
!CCESSION
3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING
-EASURES
7ORKINGGROUPSON
4RADEDEBTANDFINANCE
4RADEANDTECHNOLOGYTRANSFER
)NACTIVE
2ELATIONSHIPBETWEEN
4RADEAND)NVESTMENT
)NTERACTIONBETWEEN
4RADEAND#OMPETITION0OLICY
4RANSPARENCYIN
'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENT
7ORKINGPARTIESON
$OMESTIC2EGULATION
'!432ULES
0LURILATERALS
!NTI$UMPING0RACTICES
4RADEIN#IVIL!IRCRAFT#OMMITTEE
'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENT#OMMITTEE
#USTOMS6ALUATION
2ULESOF/RIGIN
)MPORT,ICENSING
4RADE2ELATED)NVESTMENT
-EASURES
3AFEGUARDS
7ORKINGPARTYON
3TATE4RADING%NTERPRISES
$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
4.#ANDITSBODIES
4RADE.EGOTIATIONS
#OMMITTEE
3PECIAL3ESSIONSOF
0LURILATERAL
.EGOTIATINGGROUPSON
)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY!GREEMENT
#OMMITTEE
-ARKET!CCESS2ULES4RADE&ACILITATION
+EY
2EPORTINGTO'ENERAL#OUNCILORASUBSIDIARY
2EPORTINGTO$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY
0LURILATERALCOMMITTEESINFORMTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILOR'OODS#OUNCILOFTHEIRACTIVITIESALTHOUGHTHESEAGREEMENTSARENOTSIGNED
BYALL74/MEMBERS
4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEEREPORTSTO'ENERAL#OUNCIL
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
4HEORGANIZATION
3ERVICES#OUNCIL42)03#OUNCIL$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
"ODY!GRICULTURE#OMMITTEE4RADEAND
$EVELOPMENT#OMMITTEE4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT
#OMMITTEE
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILALSOMEETSASTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODYAND$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY
3ECRETARIAT
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
3ECRETARIAT
4HE74/3ECRETARIATWITHOFFICESONLYIN'ENEVAHASREGULARSTAFFANDISHEADED
BYA$IRECTOR'ENERAL3INCEDECISIONSARETAKENBY-EMBERSONLYTHE3ECRETARIATHASNO
DECISIONMAKINGPOWERS)TSMAINDUTIESARETOSUPPLYTECHNICALANDPROFESSIONALSUPPORTFOR
THEVARIOUSCOUNCILSANDCOMMITTEESTOPROVIDETECHNICALASSISTANCEFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
TOMONITORANDANALYZEDEVELOPMENTSINWORLDTRADETOPROVIDEINFORMATIONTOTHEPUBLIC
ANDTHEMEDIAANDTOORGANIZETHEMINISTERIALCONFERENCES4HE3ECRETARIATALSOPROVIDES
SOMEFORMSOFLEGALASSISTANCEINTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCESSANDADVISESGOVERNMENTS
WISHINGTOBECOME-EMBERSOFTHE74/
4HE3ECRETARIATSTAFFINCLUDESINDIVIDUALSREPRESENTINGABOUTNATIONALITIES
4HEPROFESSIONALSTAFFISCOMPOSEDMOSTLYOFECONOMISTSLAWYERSANDOTHERSWITHA
SPECIALIZATIONININTERNATIONALTRADEPOLICY4HEREISALSOASUBSTANTIALNUMBEROFPERSONNEL
WORKINGINSUPPORTSERVICESINCLUDINGINFORMATICSFINANCEHUMANRESOURCESANDLANGUAGE
SERVICES4HETOTALSTAFFCOMPLEMENTISCOMPOSEDALMOSTEQUALLYOFMENANDWOMEN4HE
WORKINGLANGUAGESOFTHE74/ARE%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISH
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYWASESTABLISHEDBYTHE5NDERSTANDINGON2ULESAND0ROCEDURES
'OVERNINGTHE3ETTLEMENTOF$ISPUTESTOCONSIDERAPPEALSTODECISIONSBY$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
PANELS4HE!PPELLATE"ODYHASITSOWN3ECRETARIAT4HESEVENMEMBER!PPELLATE"ODY
CONSISTSOFINDIVIDUALSWITHRECOGNIZEDSTANDINGINTHEFIELDSOFLAWANDINTERNATIONALTRADE
4HEYAREAPPOINTEDTOAFOURYEARTERMANDMAYBEREAPPOINTEDONCE
4OTALNUMBEROFREGULARPOSITIONSIS
WHILETOTALSTAFFACTUALLYEMPLOYEDINCLUDING
STAFFWORKINGPARTTIMEIS
%CONOMIC2ESEARCH
AND3TATISTICS
0,OW
)NSTITUTEFOR4RAINING
AND4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION
02OLIAN
4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION!UDIT
*6IGANØ
(UMAN2ESOURCES
-&IGUEROLA
)NFORMATICS
'+ARAM
,ANGUAGE3ERVICES
AND$OCUMENTATION
.*OHNSTONE
4RADE0OLICIES2EVIEW
#"OONEKAMP
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
3ECRETARIAT
4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT
6+ULA OGLU
$EVELOPMENT
!#AMPEAS
$EPUTY$IRECTOR'ENERAL
+!!2ANA
#OUNCIL4.#
%2OGERSON
!DMINISTRATIONAND'ENERAL3ERVICES
2,UTHER
$EPUTY$IRECTOR'ENERAL
2!BBOTT
$$!3PECIAL$UTIES
#/SAKWE
74/3ECRETARIAT
/RGANIZATION#HARTn-ARCH
$IRECTOR'ENERAL
)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY
!/TTEN
%XTERNAL2ELATIONS
!&RANK
!GRICULTUREAND#OMMODITIES
&7OLTER
!CCESSIONS
!(USSAIN
$EPUTY$IRECTOR'ENERAL
&4HOMPSON&LÙRES
/FFICEOFTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
3(ARBINSON
3UPACHAI0ANITCHPAKDI
!PPELLATE"ODY
6(UGHES
4RADEIN3ERVICES
(-AMDOUH
4RADEAND&INANCEAND
4RADE&ACILITATION
2%GLIN
2ULES
*7OZNOWSKI
-ARKET!CCESS
#,'UARDA
,EGAL!FFAIRS
"7ILSON
$EPUTY$IRECTOR'ENERAL
29ERXA
)NFORMATION-EDIA2ELATIONS
+2OCKWELL
4ABLE)))
4ABLEOFREGULARSTAFFBYNATIONALITY
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
3ECRETARIAT
#OUNTRY
!RGENTINA
!USTRALIA
!USTRIA
"ANGLADESH
"ELGIUM
"ENIN
"OLIVIA
"RAZIL
"ULGARIA
#ANADA
#HILE
#HINA
#OLOMBIA
#ONGOTHE$EMOCRATIC2EPUBLICOFTHE
#OSTA2ICA
#ÙTEDg)VOIRE
#UBA
$ENMARK
%CUADOR
%GYPT
%STONIA
&IJI
&INLAND
&RANCE
'ERMANY
'HANA
'REECE
'UATEMALA
(ONDURAS
(ONG+ONG#HINA
(UNGARY
)NDIA
)RELAND
)TALY
*APAN
+ENYA
+OREA2EPUBLICOF
-ALAWI
-ALAYSIA
-AURITIUS
-EXICO
-OROCCO
.ETHERLANDS
.EW:EALAND
.IGERIA
.ORWAY
0ARAGUAY
0ERU
0HILIPPINES
0OLAND
0ORTUGAL
2OMANIA
2WANDA
3ENEGAL
3LOVENIA
3OUTH!FRICA
3PAIN
3RI,ANKA
3WEDEN
3WITZERLAND
4HAILAND
4UNISIA
4URKEY
5GANDA
5NITED+INGDOM
5NITED3TATES
&
-
4OTAL
4ABLE)))CONTINUED
4ABLEOFREGULARSTAFFBYNATIONALITY
5RUGUAY
6ENEZUELA
:IMBABWE
'RAND4OTAL
4ABLE)))
$ISTRIBUTIONOFSTAFFPOSITIONSWITHINTHE74/gSVARIOUSDIVISIONS
$IVISION
2EGULAR3TAFF
$IRECTORS
3ENIOR
'RAND
-ANAGEMENT 4OTAL
3ENIOR-ANAGEMENT
/FFICEOFTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
/FFICESOFTHE$EPUTY$IRECTORS'ENERAL
!CCESSIONS$IVISION
!DMINISTRATIONAND'ENERAL3ERVICES$IVISION
!GRICULTURE#OMMODITIES$IVISION
#OUNCILAND4.#$IVISION
$EVELOPMENT$IVISION
%CONOMIC2ESEARCHAND3TATISTICS$IVISION
%XTERNAL2ELATIONS$IVISION
(UMAN2ESOURCES$IVISION
)NFORMATICS$IVISION
)NFORMATION-EDIA2ELATIONS$IVISION
)NSTITUTEFOR4RAININGAND4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION
)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY$IVISION
,ANGUAGE3ERVICES$OCUMENTATION$IVISION
,EGAL!FFAIRS$IVISION
-ARKET!CCESS$IVISION
2ULES$IVISION
4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION!UDIT
4RADE%NVIRONMENT$IVISION
4RADEAND&INANCEAND4RADE&ACILITATION$IVISION
4RADEIN3ERVICES$IVISION
4RADE0OLICIES2EVIEW$IVISION
!PPELLATE"ODY
0OSTSPENDINGREDEPLOYMENT
'RAND4OTAL
74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS
4HE74/3ECRETARIATISORGANIZEDINTODIVISIONSWITHFUNCTIONALINFORMATIONANDLIAISON
ANDSUPPORTROLES$IVISIONSARENORMALLYHEADEDBYA$IRECTORWHOREPORTSTOA$EPUTY
$IRECTOR'ENERALORDIRECTLYTOTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS
4OTALNUMBEROFREGULARPOSITIONSISWHILETOTALSTAFFACTUALLYEMPLOYEDINCLUDINGSTAFFWORKINGPARTTIMEIS
&UNCTIONALDIVISIONS
!CCESSIONS$IVISION
4HEWORKOFTHEDIVISIONISTOFACILITATETHENEGOTIATIONSBETWEEN74/-EMBERSAND
STATESANDENTITIESREQUESTINGACCESSIONTOTHE74/BYENCOURAGINGTHEIRINTEGRATIONINTOTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMTHROUGHTHEEFFECTIVELIBERALIZATIONOFTHEIRTRADEREGIMESINGOODS
ANDSERVICESANDTOACTASAFOCALPOINTINWIDENINGTHESCOPEANDGEOGRAPHICALCOVERAGEOF
THE74/4HEREAREATPRESENTNEARLYACCESSIONWORKINGPARTIESINOPERATION
!GRICULTUREAND#OMMODITIES$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONHANDLESALLMATTERSRELATEDTOTHEONGOINGNEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTURE
&URTHERMORETHEDIVISIONPROVIDESSUPPORTINTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEEXISTING74/RULES
ANDCOMMITMENTSONAGRICULTUREINCLUDINGBYENSURINGTHATTHEPROCESSFORMULTILATERALLY
REVIEWINGTHESECOMMITMENTSBYTHE#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTUREISORGANIZEDANDCONDUCTED
INANEFFICIENTMANNER4HEWORKOFTHEDIVISIONENCOMPASSESTOFACILITATEIMPLEMENTATION
OFTHE!GREEMENTONTHE!PPLICATIONOF3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESINCLUDING
BYSERVICINGTHE303#OMMITTEE/THERACTIVITIESOFTHEDIVISIONINCLUDESUPPORTFORTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL$ECISIONON-EASURES#ONCERNINGTHE0OSSIBLE.EGATIVE
%FFECTSOFTHE2EFORM0ROGRAMMEON,EAST$EVELOPEDAND.ET&OOD)MPORTING$EVELOPING
#OUNTRIESDEALINGWITHMATTERSRELATEDTOTRADEINFISHERIESANDFORESTRYPRODUCTSASWELL
ASNATURALRESOURCEBASEDPRODUCTSPROVIDINGSERVICESFORDISPUTESETTLEMENTINTHEAREA
OFAGRICULTUREAND303PROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCEINALLAREASUNDERITSPURVIEWAND
COOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSANDTHEPRIVATESECTOR
#OUNCILAND4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONPROVIDESSUPPORTFORSESSIONSOFTHE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINTHEWORKOF
THE'ENERAL#OUNCILTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODYANDTHE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE
)TISRESPONSIBLEFORTHEPREPARATIONANDSERVICINGOFRELEVANTMEETINGSANDCONSULTATIONS
BETWEENMINISTERIALSESSIONSFORPREPARATIONOF"ASIC)NSTRUMENTSAND3ELECTED$OCUMENTS
")3$SUPPLEMENTSANDFORDERESTRICTIONOFDOCUMENTS
$EVELOPMENT$IVISION
4HE$EVELOPMENT$IVISIONISTHEFOCALPOINTFORALLDEVELOPMENTALPOLICYISSUESANDASSISTS
SENIORMANAGEMENTANDTHE3ECRETARIATASAWHOLEONISSUESRELATINGTOTHEPARTICIPATIONOF
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCLUDINGTHELEASTDEVELOPEDAMONGTHEMINTHEMULTILATERALTRADING
SYSTEM4HEDIVISIONSERVICESTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTINREGULARSESSION
ASWELLASITSDEDICATEDSESSIONSONSMALLECONOMIESANDITSSPECIALSESSIONSONSPECIAL
ANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTASWELLASTHENEWLYCONSTITUTED7ORKING'ROUPON4RADEAND
4RANSFEROF4ECHNOLOGY)TSERVICESTHE3UB#OMMITTEEON,$#S)TISALSORESPONSIBLEFOR
THE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK)&HOLDSITSSECRETARIATANDISRESPONSIBLEFORITSMANAGEMENT
STRUCTURESUCHASTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK7ORKING'ROUP)&7'ANDTHE)NTEGRATED
&RAMEWORK3TEERING#OMMITTEE)&3#
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS
$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA3PECIAL$UTIES$IVISION
4HE$$!3$$ISRESPONSIBLEFORTHEDEVELOPMENTASSISTANCEASPECTSOFTHECOTTONISSUE
)TISALSORESPONSIBLEFOROTHER$$!DEVELOPMENTRELATEDSUBSTANTIVEISSUESASDIRECTEDBY
THE$IRECTOR'ENERALFORTHEPURPOSEOFASSISTINGPOSITIVEPROGRESSINTHEPERIODLEADING
UPTOTHE(ONG+ONG-INISTERIAL$ECEMBER4HEDIVISIONUNDERTAKESASSIGNMENTS
ASDETERMINEDBYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALONSELECTEDISSUESRELATINGTOMEMBERSHIPGROUPS
SUCHASTHE'ANDTHE!FRICAN'ROUP4HEDIVISIONWORKSINCLOSECOOPERATIONWITHTHE
RELEVANT$EPUTY$IRECTORS'ENERALAND$IRECTORSOFEXISTINGOPERATIONALDIVISIONSONARANGE
OFDEVELOPMENTORIENTEDISSUESANDSPECIFICASSIGNMENTS4HEPURPOSEISTOACHIEVEAN
ENHANCEDANDSHARPERFOCUSONTHERANGEOFSPECIFICDEVELOPMENTISSUESTHROUGHAMORE
DIRECTENGAGEMENTBYTHE/FFICEOFTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALTOWHICHTHEDIVISIONDIRECTLY
REPORTS
%CONOMIC2ESEARCHAND3TATISTICS$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONPROVIDESECONOMICANALYSISANDRESEARCHINSUPPORTOFTHE74/SOPERATIONAL
ACTIVITIESINCLUDINGMONITORINGANDREPORTINGONCURRENTECONOMICNEWSANDDEVELOPMENTS
)TCARRIESOUTECONOMICRESEARCHONBROADERPOLICYRELATEDTOPICSINCONNECTIONWITHTHE
74/SWORKPROGRAMMEASWELLASONOTHER74/RELATEDTOPICSOFINTERESTTODELEGATIONS
ARISINGFROMTHEONGOINGINTEGRATIONOFTHEWORLDECONOMYTHESPREADOFMARKETORIENTED
REFORMSANDTHEINCREASEDIMPORTANCEOFECONOMICISSUESINRELATIONSBETWEENCOUNTRIES
4HEDIVISIONCONTRIBUTESTOREGULARLYSCHEDULEDANNUALPUBLICATIONSINCLUDINGTHE7ORLD4RADE
2EPORT/THERMAJORACTIVITIESINCLUDEWORKRELATEDTOCOOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONAL
ORGANIZATIONSANDTHEACADEMICCOMMUNITYTHROUGHCONFERENCESSEMINARSANDCOURSES
PREPARATIONOFSPECIALRESEARCHPROJECTSONPOLICYRELATEDTOPICSINTHEAREAOFINTERNATIONAL
TRADEPREPARATIONOFBRIEFINGSTOSENIORMANAGEMENT
/NTHESTATISTICSSIDETHEDIVISIONSUPPORTS74/-EMBERSANDTHE3ECRETARIATWITH
QUANTITATIVEINFORMATIONINRELATIONTOECONOMICANDTRADEPOLICYISSUES4HEDIVISIONISTHE
PRINCIPALSUPPLIEROF74/TRADESTATISTICSTHROUGHTHEANNUALh)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICSv
REPORTAND)NTERNETAND)NTRANETSITES4HEDIVISIONISRESPONSIBLEFORTHEMAINTENANCEAND
DEVELOPMENTOFTHE)NTEGRATED$ATA"ASEWHICHSUPPORTSTHE-ARKET!CCESS#OMMITTEES
INFORMATIONREQUIREMENTSINRELATIONTOTARIFFS4HEDIVISIONSSTATISTICIANSALSOPROVIDE
-EMBERSWITHTECHNICALASSISTANCEINRELATIONTOTHE)NTEGRATED$ATA"ASE!NDFINALLY
THEDIVISIONPLAYSANACTIVEROLEINSTRENGTHENINGCOOPERATIONANDCOLLABORATIONBETWEEN
INTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSINTHEFIELDOFMERCHANDISEANDTRADEINSERVICESSTATISTICSANDIN
ENSURINGTHAT74/REQUIREMENTSINRESPECTTOTHECONCEPTSANDSTANDARDSUNDERPINNINGTHE
INTERNATIONALSTATISTICALSYSTEMAREMET
4HE74/,IBRARYSUPPORTS74/ACTIVITIESANDRESEARCHTHROUGHITSPRINTANDELECTRONIC
COLLECTIONOFDOCUMENTSPROVISIONOFANONLINEPUBLICACCESSCATALOGUEBIBLIOGRAPHIC
REFERENCESERVICESINCLUDING)NTERNETRESEARCHINTERLIBRARYLOANSDEPOSITORYFORNATIONAL
STATISTICSFROM-EMBERANDNON-EMBERCOUNTRIESASWELLASSPECIFICPRODUCTSTATISTICS
DEPOSITORYOF'!4474/DOCUMENTSANDPUBLICATIONSPRINTEDARCHIVESOFTHE74/
)NSTITUTEFOR4RAININGAND4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION
4HE)NSTITUTESMISSIONISTOCONTRIBUTETOTHEFULLERPARTICIPATIONOFBENEFICIARYCOUNTRIESIN
THEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMTHROUGHHUMANRESOURCEDEVELOPMENTINSTITUTIONALCAPACITY
BUILDINGANDINCREASEDPUBLICAWARENESSOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM)TDELIVERS
TECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDTRAININGTHROUGHACTIVITIESINCLUDINGADVISORYMISSIONSSEMINARS
ANDWORKSHOPSONACOUNTRYORREGIONALBASISANDORTECHNICALNOTESONISSUESOFINTEREST
TOBENEFICIARYCOUNTRIESTRADEPOLICYCOURSESTRAININGOFTRAINERSOUTREACHACTIVITIESWITH
UNIVERSITIESANDINTERNETBASEDTRAININGACTIVITIES4HEAIMISTODEVELOPBETTERUNDERSTANDING
OF74/RIGHTSANDOBLIGATIONSADAPTATIONOFNATIONALLEGISLATIONANDINCREASEDPARTICIPATION
OFTHESECOUNTRIESINTHEMULTILATERALDECISIONMAKINGPROCESS,EGALADVICEISALSOMADE
AVAILABLEUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$352ELATEDACTIVITIESINCLUDEESTABLISHINGAND
SUPPORTING74/2EFERENCE#ENTERSWITH)NTERNETCONNECTIVITYANDWITHTRAININGPROVIDEDON
HOWTOTRACKDOWNTRADERELATEDSOURCESONTHE)NTERNETPARTICULARLYTHE74/WEBSITEAND
HOWTOUSEINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYTOOLSTOMEETNOTIFICATIONREQUIREMENTS4HE)NSTITUTE
MANAGESTRUSTFUNDSPROVIDEDBYINDIVIDUALDONORCOUNTRIESFORTHEPURPOSEOFTRAININGAND
TECHNICALCOOPERATION
,EGAL!FFAIRS$IVISION
4HEPRINCIPALMISSIONOFTHE,EGAL!FFAIRS$IVISIONISTOPROVIDELEGALADVICEAND
INFORMATIONTO74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELSOTHER74/BODIES74/-EMBERSANDTHE
74/3ECRETARIAT4HEDIVISIONSRESPONSIBILITIESINCLUDEPROVIDINGTIMELYSECRETARIALAND
TECHNICALSUPPORTANDASSISTANCEONLEGALHISTORICALANDPROCEDURALASPECTSOFDISPUTESTO
74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELSPROVIDINGREGULARLEGALADVICETOTHE3ECRETARIATANDIN
PARTICULARTOTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODYANDITS#HAIRMANONINTERPRETATIONOFTHE$ISPUTE
3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING$3574/AGREEMENTSANDONOTHERLEGALISSUESPROVIDINGLEGAL
INFORMATIONTO74/-EMBERSONTHE$35AND74/AGREEMENTSPROVIDINGLEGALSUPPORT
INRESPECTOFACCESSIONSPROVIDINGTRAININGINRESPECTOFDISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEDURESAND
ON74/LEGALISSUESTHROUGHSPECIALCOURSESONDISPUTESETTLEMENTREGULAR74/TRAINING
COURSESAND74/TECHNICALCOOPERATIONMISSIONSATTENDMEETINGSOFOTHERORGANIZATIONS
WITH74/RELATEDACTIVITIESEG)-&/%#$%NERGY#HARTER
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS
)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY
4HEDIVISIONPROVIDESSERVICETOTHE42)03#OUNCILANDTODISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELS
SERVICETOANYNEGOTIATIONSTHATMAYBELAUNCHEDONINTELLECTUALPROPERTYMATTERSPROVIDES
ASSISTANCETO74/-EMBERSTHROUGHTECHNICALCOOPERATIONINPARTICULARINCONJUNCTION
WITHTHE7ORLD)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY/RGANIZATION7)0/ANDTHROUGHTHEPROVISION
OFINFORMATIONADVICEMOREGENERALLYMAINTAINSANDDEVELOPSLINESOFCOMMUNICATION
WITHOTHERINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSTHE.'/COMMUNITYINTELLECTUALPROPERTY
PRACTITIONERSANDTHEACADEMICCOMMUNITYSOTHATTHEYHAVEANADEQUATEUNDERSTANDINGOF
THE42)03!GREEMENTANDOFTHE74/PROCESSES)NTHEAREAOFCOMPETITIONPOLICYITPROVIDES
SERVICETOWORKINTHE74/ONTHEINTERACTIONBETWEENTRADEANDCOMPETITIONPOLICY
PROVIDESTECHNICALCOOPERATIONINCONJUNCTIONWITH5.#4!$ANDOTHERINTERGOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONSANDINFORMATIONADVICEMOREGENERALLYTO74/-EMBERS)NTHEAREAOF
GOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTTHEDIVISIONPROVIDESSERVICETOWORKINTHE74/ONTRANSPARENCY
INGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTPROVIDESSERVICETOTHE#OMMITTEEESTABLISHEDUNDERTHE
PLURILATERAL!GREEMENTON'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENTANDTODISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELSTHAT
MAYARISEPROVIDESTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDINFORMATIONADVICEMOREGENERALLYTO74/
-EMBERS
-ARKET!CCESS$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONWORKSWITHTHEFOLLOWING74/BODIES
#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSOVERSEESTHEMULTILATERALTRADEAGREEMENTSANDMINISTERIAL
DECISIONSCOVERINGTHEGOODSSECTORANDTAKESACTIONSONTHEISSUESRAISEDBYTHEVARIOUS
COMMITTEESWHICHREPORTTOIT3ERVICINGTHE#OUNCILINCLUDESTHEORGANIZATIONOFFORMAL
MEETINGS4HEDIVISIONALSOARRANGESINFORMALMEETINGSCONSULTATIONSPRIORTOFORMAL
MEETINGS
#OMMITTEEON-ARKET!CCESSSUPERVISESTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFCONCESSIONSRELATING
TOTARIFFSANDNONTARIFFMEASURESPROVIDESAFORUMFORCONSULTATIONONMATTERSRELATINGTO
TARIFFSANDNONTARIFFMEASURESOVERSEESTHEAPPLICATIONOFPROCEDURESFORMODIFICATIONOR
WITHDRAWALOFTARIFFCONCESSIONSENSURESTHAT74/3CHEDULESAREKEPTUPTODATEANDTHAT
MODIFICATIONSINCLUDINGTHOSERESULTINGFROMCHANGESINTARIFFNOMENCLATUREAREREFLECTED
CONDUCTSTHEUPDATINGANDANALYSISOFTHEDOCUMENTATIONONQUANTITATIVERESTRICTIONSAND
OTHERNONTARIFFMEASURESINACCORDANCEWITHTHETIMETABLEANDPROCEDURESAGREEDBYTHE
'!44#/.42!#4).'0!24)%3INAND")3$3ANDAND")3$3
ANDOVERSEESTHECONTENTANDOPERATIONOFANDACCESSTOTHE)NTEGRATED$ATA"ASEAND
WILLDOTHESAMEFORTHEFUTURE#ONSOLIDATED4ARIFF3CHEDULES$ATABASE
#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATION-ONITORANDREVIEWANNUALLYTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOF
THE#USTOMS6ALUATION!GREEMENTPROVIDESERVICETOTHE#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATION
ORGANIZINGMANAGINGTHE74/PROGRAMMEFORTECHNICALASSISTANCEONCUSTOMSVALUATION
FORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHATHAVEINVOKEDTHEFIVEYEARDELAYCOOPERATINGWITHTHE7ORLD
#USTOMS/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATONPROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCETODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
HAVINGREQUESTEDAFIVEYEARDELAYINTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT
#OMMITTEEON2ULESOF/RIGINCARRYINGOUTTHEHARMONIZATIONWORKPROGRAMMEONNON
PREFERENTIALRULESOFORIGINPROVIDESERVICETOTHE#OMMITTEEON2ULESOF/RIGINPROVIDING
INFORMATIONANDADVICETODELEGATIONSPRIVATEPARTIESANDOTHERDIVISIONSINTHE3ECRETARIAT
ONMATTERSRELATINGTORULESOFORIGIN
#OMMITTEEON)MPORT,ICENSING-ONITORINGANDREVIEWINGTHEIMPLEMENTATIONAND
OPERATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON)MPORT,ICENSING0ROCEDURESPROVIDINGINFORMATION
ANDADVICETOACCEDINGCOUNTRIESDELEGATIONSPRIVATEPARTIESANDOTHERDIVISIONSINTHE
3ECRETARIATONMATTERSRELATINGTOIMPORTLICENSING
#OMMITTEEOF0ARTICIPANTSONTHE%XPANSIONOF4RADEIN)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY0RODUCTS
)4!PROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDINFORMATIONTOACCEDINGPARTICIPANTSREVIEWTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE)4!CONTINUETHEWORKTECHNICALANDOTHERWISEWITHRESPECTTO
NONTARIFFBARRIERSANDCLASSIFICATIONISSUESFORREVIEWOFPRODUCTCOVERAGE)4!))PROVIDE
CONTINUINGSUPPORTFORTHENEGOTIATIONSANDTHEFOLLOWUPIFNECESSARY
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS
2ULES$IVISION
4HEROLEOFTHEDIVISIONISTOENSURETHESMOOTHFUNCTIONINGOFALL74/BODIESSERVICED
BYTHEDIVISION4HISINCLUDESFACILITATINGNEWANDONGOINGNEGOTIATIONSANDCONSULTATIONS
MONITORINGIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE74/!GREEMENTSINTHEAREAOFANTIDUMPINGSUBSIDIES
ANDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESSAFEGUARDSSTATETRADINGANDCIVILAIRCRAFTANDACTIVELYASSISTING
INTHEIRIMPLEMENTATIONPROVIDINGALLNECESSARYIMPLEMENTATIONASSISTANCECOUNSELLINGAND
EXPERTADVICETO-EMBERSCONCERNINGTHEABOVEAGREEMENTSPROVIDINGSECRETARIESANDLEGAL
OFFICERSTO74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELSINVOLVINGTHERULESAREAAGREEMENTSANDACTIVE
PARTICIPATIONINTHE74/TECHNICALASSISTANCEPROGRAMME
4HEBODIESSERVICEDBYTHE2ULES$IVISIONARE#OMMITTEEON!NTI$UMPING0RACTICES
#OMMITTEEON3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING-EASURES#OMMITTEEON3AFEGUARDS#OMMITTEE
ON4RADEIN#IVIL!IRCRAFT7ORKING0ARTYON3TATE4RADING%NTERPRISES)NFORMAL'ROUPOF
%XPERTSONTHE#ALCULATIONSOF3UBSIDIESUNDER!RTICLEOFTHE3UBSIDIES!GREEMENT
0ERMANENT'ROUPOF%XPERTS)NFORMAL'ROUPON!NTI#IRCUMVENTION7ORKING'ROUPON
)MPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON!NTI$UMPINGAND7ORKING'ROUPON4RADEAND
#OMPETITIONCOSECRETARY
4ECHNICAL#OOPERATION!UDIT$IVISION
)TSRESPONSIBILITYISTOENSUREONGOINGMONITORINGANDEVALUATIONOFALLFORMSOFTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCEPROVIDEDBYTHE74/
4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONPROVIDESSERVICEANDSUPPORTTO74/COMMITTEESDEALINGWITHTRADEAND
ENVIRONMENTANDTECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADE&OR4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTITSUPPORTSTHE
WORKOFTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENT#4%BYPROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCETO
74/-EMBERSREPORTINGTOSENIORMANAGEMENTAND74/-EMBERSONDISCUSSIONSINOTHER
INTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS)'/SINCLUDINGNEGOTIATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTRADE
RELATEDMEASURESINMULTILATERALENVIRONMENTALAGREEMENTS4HEDIVISIONMAINTAINSCONTACTS
ANDDIALOGUEWITH.'/SANDTHEPRIVATESECTORONISSUESOFMUTUALINTERESTINTHEAREAOF
TRADEANDENVIRONMENT
)TSWORKINTHEAREAOFTECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADEINCLUDESPROVIDINGSERVICETOTHE
7ORKING'ROUPON4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADE7'4"4IFTHE4"4#OMMITTEESODECIDES
PROVIDINGTECHNICALASSISTANCETO74/-EMBERSPROVIDING3ECRETARIATSUPPORTTODISPUTE
PANELSANDACCESSIONSEXAMININGASPECTSOFTHE4"4!GREEMENT4HEDIVISIONFOLLOWSAND
REPORTSONMATTERSRELATEDTOTHE4"4!GREEMENTANDMAINTAINSCONTACTSWITHTHEPRIVATE
SECTORONISSUESOFMUTUALINTERESTINTHISAREA
4RADEAND&INANCEAND4RADE&ACILITATION$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONSERVICESTHENEEDSOF74/-EMBERSAND74/MANAGEMENTINSUPPORTING
THEWORKOFTHE#OMMITTEESON"ALANCEOF0AYMENT2ESTRICTIONSANDON4RADE2ELATED
)NVESTMENT-EASURESTHE.EGOTIATING'ROUPON4RADE&ACILITATIONTHE7ORKING'ROUPSON
4RADE$EBTAND&INANCEANDON4RADEAND)NVESTMENTAND'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGSON
#OHERENCEIN'LOBAL%CONOMIC0OLICYMAKING4HE$IVISIONISRESPONSIBLEFOROVERSEEINGTHE
COOPERATIONAGREEMENTSBETWEENTHE74/ANDTHE"RETTON7OODS)NSTITUTIONS)-&AND
THE7ORLD"ANK4HEDIVISIONCONTRIBUTESTOTHEWORKOFDISPUTEPANELSADDRESSINGMATTERS
FALLINGUNDERITSRESPONSIBILITYANDPROVIDESTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDEXPERTADVICE
TO-EMBERSIN'ENEVAANDINCAPITALS
4RADEIN3ERVICES$IVISION
4HE3ERVICES$IVISIONPROVIDESSUPPORTFORTHENEWROUNDOFSERVICESNEGOTIATIONS
UNDERWAYSINCE)TALSOCONTINUESTOPROVIDESUPPORTFORTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN
3ERVICESANDOTHERBODIESESTABLISHEDUNDERTHE'!43INCLUDINGTHE#OMMITTEEON&INANCIAL
3ERVICESTHE7ORKING0ARTYON$OMESTIC2EGULATIONDISCIPLINESUNDER!RTICLE6)THE
7ORKING0ARTYON'!432ULESDISCIPLINESRELATINGTOSAFEGUARDSSUBSIDIESGOVERNMENT
PROCUREMENTTHE#OMMITTEEON3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTSANYADDITIONALBODIESSETUPUNDER
THE#OUNCILANYDISPUTESETTLEMENTPANELSINVOLVINGSERVICES
/THERWORKINCLUDESPROVIDINGSUPPORTFORTHE#OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS
INITSWORKRELATINGTO!RTICLE6OFTHE'!43ANDFORWORKINGPARTIESONACCESSIONOFNEW
-EMBERSINRELATIONTOSERVICESFACILITATINGTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHERESULTSOFNEGOTIATIONS
ONBASICTELECOMMUNICATIONSFINANCIALSERVICESANDPROFESSIONALSERVICESPARTICIPATINGACTIVELY
INTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDOTHERFORMSOFPUBLICEXPLANATIONOFTHE'!43ANDPROVIDINGA
CONTINUINGSERVICEOFADVICEANDASSISTANCETO'ENEVADELEGATIONSMONITORINGIMPLEMENTATION
OFTHE'!43INTERMSOFNOTIFICATIONSANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFEXISTINGANDNEWCOMMITMENTS
4RADE0OLICIES2EVIEW$IVISION
4HEPRINCIPALTASKOFTHE402$IVISIONISPURSUANTTO!NNEXOFTHE74/!GREEMENT
TOPREPAREREPORTSFORMEETINGSOFTHE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW"ODY402"ATWHICHREVIEWS
OF-EMBERSARECARRIEDOUT4HEDIVISIONPROVIDESASECRETARIATFORTHE402"MEETINGS4HE
DIVISIONALSOPREPARESTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALS!NNUAL/VERVIEWOFTRADEPOLICYDEVELOPMENTS
4HEDIVISIONALSOSUPPORTSTHEWORKOFTHE#OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS
%XTERNAL2ELATIONS$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONISTHEFOCALPOINTFORRELATIONSWITH.ON'OVERNMENTAL/RGANIZATIONS
)NTERNATIONAL)NTERGOVERNMENTAL/RGANIZATIONSWITHPARLIAMENTSANDPARLIAMENTARIANS)TALSO
CARRIESOUTRESPONSIBILITIESINREGARDTOPROTOCOLANDTHEMAINTENANCEOFTHE74/REGISTRY
OFDOCUMENTS)TSPRINCIPLEACTIVITIESARETOORGANIZEANDDEVELOPDIALOGUEWITHCIVILSOCIETY
ANDITSVARIOUSCOMPONENTSTOMAINTAINLIAISONWITHTHE5.SYSTEMANDINPARTICULARWITH
5..EW9ORK(1ANDWITH5.#4!$ANDTHE)4#4HEDIVISIONMAINTAINSLIAISONWITH/%#$
PARTICULARLYWITHTHE4RADE$IRECTORATEREGARDINGSUBSTANTIVEISSUES4HEDIVISIONACTSASTHE
FOCALPOINTINTHE3ECRETARIATTOENSURECOORDINATIONOFATTENDANCEATRELEVANTMEETINGS
ATTENDSMEETINGSONBEHALFOFTHE74/ANDDELIVERSLECTURESANDSPEECHES)TISALSOIN
CHARGEOFOFFICIALRELATIONSWITH-EMBERSINCLUDINGHOSTCOUNTRYANDPROTOCOLMATTERSIN
CLOSELIAISONWITHTHE/FFICEOFTHE$IRECTOR'ENERALANDITMAINTAINSTHE74/$IRECTORY
)NFORMATIONAND-EDIA2ELATIONS$IVISION
!SMANDATEDBY-EMBER'OVERNMENTSTHEFOCUSOFTHEDIVISIONISTOUSEALLTHE
MEANSATITSDISPOSALTOBETTERINFORMTHEPUBLICABOUTTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION4HE
DIVISIONOFFERSTHEPUBLICCLEARANDCONCISEINFORMATIONTHROUGHFREQUENTANDREGULARPRESS
CONTACTAWIDERANGEOFRELEVANTPUBLICATIONSANDANEXTENSIVE)NTERNETSERVICE)TSWORK
INCLUDESPROVIDINGPUBLICATIONSWHICHDELEGATIONSANDTHEPUBLICDEEMNECESSARYTOTHEIR
UNDERSTANDINGOFTRADEANDTHE74/
4HE)NTERNETISANIMPORTANTVEHICLEFORDISTRIBUTING74/INFORMATION4HEh.EWSROOMv
FEATUREONTHE74/WEBSITEWWWWTOORGISACCESSIBLEBYJOURNALISTSFROMAROUNDTHE
WORLDWHILETHEMAIN)NTERNETSITEISACCESSEDBYANAVERAGEOFINDIVIDUALUSERS
EVERYMONTHFROMMORETHANCOUNTRIES7EBCASTINGONTHE)NTERNETISUSEDTOINCREASE
PUBLICACCESSTOSPECIALEVENTSSUCHASMINISTERIALMEETINGSANDSYMPOSIA
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/3ECRETARIAT$IVISIONS
)NFORMATIONANDLIAISONDIVISIONS
3UPPORTDIVISIONS
!DMINISTRATIONAND'ENERAL3ERVICES$IVISION
)TSWORKFOCUSESONENSURINGTHEEFFICIENTFUNCTIONINGOFSERVICESINAALLFINANCIAL
MATTERSINCLUDINGBUDGETPREPARATIONANDCONTROLACCOUNTINGANDPAYROLLBLOGISTICAL
ISSUESRELATEDTOTHEPHYSICALFACILITIESANDCMISSIONSANDOTHERTRAVELARRANGEMENTS4HIS
INCLUDESMONITORINGTHEDECENTRALIZEDBUDGETASWELLASTHE%XTRABUDGETARY&UNDSAND
PROVIDINGTIMELYINFORMATIONTODIVISIONSENSURINGTHEADMINISTRATIVEFUNCTIONINGOFTHE
#OMMITTEEON"UDGET&INANCEAND!DMINISTRATIONMANAGINGTHE74/SPECIFICPENSION
ARRANGEMENTSPROVIDINGINFORMATIONTOSENIORMANAGEMENTANDASSISTINGTHEHOSTCOUNTRY
INTHEPREPARATIONOF74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCES
(UMAN2ESOURCES$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONISRESPONSIBLEFORHUMANRESOURCESMANAGEMENTOF74/STAFFMEMBERS
REGULARANDTEMPORARYINITS'ENEVABASED3ECRETARIAT4HERESPONSIBILITIESSPANDIVISION
RESTRUCTURINGPERFORMANCEMANAGEMENTINCLUDINGDEVELOPMENTANDTRAININGWORKFORCE
PLANNINGRECRUITMENTANDSELECTIONASWELLASCAREERMANAGEMENTINTERNALCAREERMOBILITY
TRANSITIONSANDEXITANDMANAGEMENTOFSTAFFBENEFITSANDENTITLEMENTS)TSOBJECTIVEISTO
RESPONDTOTHEEVOLVINGNEEDSOFTHE74/ALIGNINGITSWORKFORCEANDPROVIDINGSTRATEGIC
ADVISORYSERVICESTOTHESTAFFANDTO74/-EMBERS
)NFORMATICS$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONENSURESTHEEFFICIENTOPERATIONOFTHEINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGY)4
INFRASTRUCTUREASWELLASTHENECESSARYSUPPORTTOCOVERTHEINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYNEEDSOF
-EMBERSAND3ECRETARIAT4HISINCLUDESIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE)4SECURITYPOLICY4HEDIVISION
WORKSTOCONSTANTLYENHANCE)4SERVICESANDPROCEDURESTOBETTERFACILITATEDISSEMINATIONOF
74/INFORMATIONTO-EMBERSANDTHEPUBLICTHROUGHTHE)NTERNETANDSPECIALIZEDDATABASES
4HEDIVISIONSUPPORTSACOMPLEXDESKTOPANDNETWORKENVIRONMENTCOVERINGSTAFF
MEMBERSTEMPORARYSTAFFANDINTERNSANDAMULTITUDEOFSERVICESOFFICEAUTOMATIONEMAIL
)NTRANET)NTERNETMAINFRAMECLIENTSERVERSYSTEMSETC)NRELATIONWITHTHECREATIONOF74/
2EFERENCE#ENTERSINTHECAPITALSOF,$#ANDDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHEDIVISIONPROVIDES)4
EXPERTISEANDPARTICIPATESINTECHNICALCOOPERATIONMISSIONS
,ANGUAGE3ERVICESAND$OCUMENTATION$IVISION
4HEDIVISIONPROVIDESARANGEOFLANGUAGEANDDOCUMENTATIONSERVICESTO-EMBERSAND
TOTHE3ECRETARIATINCLUDINGTRANSLATIONDOCUMENTATIONPRINTINGANDRELATEDTASKS4HE
ADVENTOFTHE)NTERNETHASPROVIDEDTHE3ECRETARIATWITHAPOWERFULVEHICLETODISSEMINATE
ITSDOCUMENTATION4HEVASTMAJORITYOFPEOPLECONSULTING74/SHOMEPAGEVISITTHE,3$$S
DOCUMENTATIONFACILITIES#ONSULTATIONISGROWINGATARATEOFPERMONTH,3$$ENSURES
74/DOCUMENTSPUBLICATIONSANDELECTRONICMATERIALSAREAVAILABLETOTHEPUBLICANDTO
-EMBERSINTHETHREE74/WORKINGLANGUAGESn%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISH
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/BUDGET
74/!PPELLATE"ODYANDITS3ECRETARIAT
4HE74/!PPELLATE"ODY
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYWASESTABLISHEDPURSUANTTOTHE5NDERSTANDINGON2ULESAND
0ROCEDURES'OVERNINGTHE3ETTLEMENTOF$ISPUTESTHEh$35vWHICHISCONTAINEDIN!NNEX
TOTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION4HEFUNCTION
OFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYISTOHEARAPPEALSARISINGFROMPANELREPORTSPURSUANTTO!RTICLE
OFTHE$354HE!PPELLATE"ODYCOMPRISESSEVENMEMBERSRECOGNIZEDAUTHORITIESINLAW
INTERNATIONALTRADEANDTHE74/AGREEMENTSGENERALLYWHORESIDEINDIFFERENTPARTSOFTHE
WORLDANDAREREQUIREDTOBEAVAILABLEATALLTIMESANDONSHORTNOTICETOHEARAPPEALS
)NDIVIDUALMEMBERSOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYARESOMETIMESCALLEDUPONTOACTASARBITRATORS
UNDER!RTICLEOFTHE$35
74/BUDGET
4HE74/DERIVESMOSTOFTHEINCOMEFORITSANNUALBUDGETFROMCONTRIBUTIONSBYITS
-EMBERS4HESEAREESTABLISHEDACCORDINGTOAFORMULABASEDONTHEIRSHAREOFINTERNATIONAL
TRADE4HELISTOF-EMBERSCONTRIBUTIONSFORCANBEFOUNDIN4ABLE4HEBALANCEOF
THEBUDGETISFINANCEDFROMMISCELLANEOUSINCOME
-ISCELLANEOUSINCOMEISEARNEDFROMRENTALFEESANDSALESOF74/PRINTANDELECTRONIC
PUBLICATIONS4HE74/STOTALBUDGETFORTHEYEARISASFOLLOWS
"UDGETFORTHE74/3ECRETARIAT#(&4ABLE
"UDGETFORTHE!PPELLATE"ODYANDITS3ECRETARIAT#(&4ABLE
4OTAL74/"UDGETFORTHEYEAR#(&
4ABLE)))
74/3ECRETARIATBUDGETFOR
0ART
3ECTION
)TEM
!
"
#
$
3ECT7ORK9EARS
3ECT4EMPORARY!SSISTANCE
3ECT#OMMUNICATIONS
3ECT"UILDING&ACILITIES
3ECT0ERMANENT%QUIPMENT
3ECT%XPENDABLE
3ECT#ONTRACTUAL3ERVICES
3ECT3TAFF/VERHEADS
3ECT-ISSIONS
3ECT404#
3ECT6ARIOUS
3ECT5NFORESEEN
3ECT)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTER)4#
'RAND4OTAL
A3ALARY
B0ENSION
C#OMMON3TAFF#OSTS
A4ELECOMMUNICATIONS
B0OSTAL#HARGES
A2ENTAL
B5TILITIES
C-AINTENANCEAND)NSURANCE
A2EPRODUCTION
B/FFICE!UTOMATION
C/THER
D3ECURITY/UTSOURCING#ONTRACT
A4RAINING
B)NSURANCE
C*OINT3ERVICES
D-ISCELLANEOUS
A-ISSIONS/FFICIAL
B-ISSIONS4ECHNICAL
A2EPRESENTATIONAND(OSPITALITY
B$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT0ANELS
E,IBRARY
F0UBLICATIONS
G0UBLIC)NFORMATION!CTIVITIES
H%XTERNAL!UDITORS
I-INISTERIAL/PERATING&UND
J)3/
K/THER
M3ECURITY%NHANCEMENT0ROGRAMME
5NFORESEEN
)4#
#(&
4ABLE)))
"UDGETFORTHE!PPELLATE"ODYANDITS3ECRETARIAT
3ECTION
)TEM
!
"
#
3ECT7ORK9EARS
3ECT4EMPORARY!SSISTANCE
3ECT#OMMUNICATIONS
3ECT"UILDING&ACILITIES
3ECT0ERMANENT%QUIPMENT
3ECT%XPENDABLE
3ECT#ONTRACTUAL3ERVICES
3ECT3TAFF/VERHEADS
3ECT-ISSIONS
3ECT6ARIOUS
'RAND4OTAL
A3ALARY
B0ENSION
C#OMMON3TAFF#OSTS
A4ELECOMMUNICATIONS
B5TILITIES
C-AINTENANCEAND)NSURANCE
A2EPRODUCTION
A4RAINING
B)NSURANCE
D-ISCELLANEOUS
A-ISSIONS/FFICIAL
A2EPRESENTATIONAND(OSPITALITY
D!PPELLATE"ODY-EMBERS
E,IBRARY
L!PPELLATE"ODY/PERATING&UND
#(&
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/BUDGET
0ART
4ABLE)))
-EMBERSgCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHE74/BUDGETANDTHEBUDGETOFTHE!PPELLATE
"ODY
-INIMUMCONTRIBUTIONOFPERCENT
-EMBERS
#ONTRIBUTION
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/BUDGET
#(&
!LBANIA
!NGOLA
!NTIGUAAND"ARBUDA
!RGENTINA
!RMENIA
!USTRALIA
!USTRIA
"AHRAIN
"ANGLADESH
"ARBADOS
"ELGIUM
"ELIZE
"ENIN
"OLIVIA
"OTSWANA
"RAZIL
"RUNEI$ARUSSALAM
"ULGARIA
"URKINA&ASO
"URUNDI
#AMBODIA
#AMEROON
#ANADA
#ENTRAL!FRICAN2EPUBLIC
#HAD
#HILE
#HINA0EOPLEgS2EPUBLICOF
#OLOMBIA
#ONGO
#OSTA2ICA
#ÙTEDg)VOIRE
#ROATIA
#UBA
#YPRUS
#ZECH2EPUBLIC
$EMOCRATIC2EPUBLICOFTHE#ONGO
$ENMARK
$JIBOUTI
$OMINICA
$OMINICAN2EPUBLIC
%CUADOR
%GYPT
%L3ALVADOR
%STONIA
%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
&IJI
&INLAND
&ORMER9UGOSLAV2EPUBLICOF-ACEDONIA
&RANCE
'ABON
'AMBIA
'EORGIA
'ERMANY
'HANA
'REECE
'RENADA
'UATEMALA
4ABLE)))CONTINUED
-EMBERSgCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHE74/BUDGETANDTHEBUDGETOFTHE!PPELLATE
"ODY
-INIMUMCONTRIBUTIONOFPERCENT
#ONTRIBUTION
#(&
'UINEA
'UINEA"ISSAU
'UYANA
(AITI
(ONDURAS
(ONG+ONG#HINA
(UNGARY
)CELAND
)NDIA
)NDONESIA
)RELAND
)SRAEL
)TALY
*AMAICA
*APAN
*ORDAN
+ENYA
+OREA2EPUBLICOF
+UWAIT
+YRGYZ2EPUBLIC
,ATVIA
,ESOTHO
,IECHTENSTEIN
,ITHUANIA
,UXEMBOURG
-ACAO#HINA
-ADAGASCAR
-ALAWI
-ALAYSIA
-ALDIVES
-ALI
-ALTA
-AURITANIA
-AURITIUS
-EXICO
-OLDOVA
-ONGOLIA
-OROCCO
-OZAMBIQUE
-YANMAR5NIONOF
.AMIBIA
.EPAL
.ETHERLANDS+INGDOMOFTHE
.EW:EALAND
.ICARAGUA
.IGER
.IGERIA
.ORWAY
/MAN
0AKISTAN
0ANAMA
0APUA.EW'UINEA
0ARAGUAY
0ERU
0HILIPPINES
0OLAND
0ORTUGAL
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/BUDGET
-EMBERS
4ABLE)))CONTINUED
-EMBERSgCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHE74/BUDGETANDTHEBUDGETOFTHE!PPELLATE
"ODY
-INIMUMCONTRIBUTIONOFPERCENT
-EMBERS
#ONTRIBUTION
#(&
1ATAR
2OMANIA
2WANDA
3AINT,UCIA
3ENEGAL
3IERRA,EONE
3INGAPORE
3LOVAK2EPUBLIC
3LOVENIA
3OLOMON)SLANDS
3OUTH!FRICA
3PAIN
3RI,ANKA
3T+ITTSAND.EVIS
3T6INCENTANDTHE'RENADINES
3URINAME
3WAZILAND
3WEDEN
3WITZERLAND
#HINESE4AIPEI
4ANZANIA
4HAILAND
4OGO
4RINIDADAND4OBAGO
4UNISIA
4URKEY
5GANDA
5NITED!RAB%MIRATES
5NITED+INGDOMOF'REAT
"RITAINAND.ORTHERN)RELAND
5NITED3TATESOF!MERICA
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/BUDGET
5RUGUAY
6ENEZUELA
:AMBIA
:IMBABWE
4/4!,
-ISCELLANEOUSINCOMEFOR
#(&
3ALEOFPUBLICATIONS
3AVINGSONPREVIOUSYEARgSOUTSTANDINGOBLIGATIONS
2ENTALOFMEETINGROOMSOFFICESPACEANDPARKINGAT
#ENTRE7ILLIAM2APPARDTOOTHERS
#ONTRIBUTIONSOF/BSERVER#OUNTRIES
)NTERESTON#URRENT!CCOUNT
6ARIOUS
4/4!,
/RGANIZATION3ECRETARIATANDBUDGET
74/BUDGET
/THER
74/TH!NNIVERSARYn(IGHLIGHTSOFTHEFIRSTDECADE
4HISYEARMARKSTHETHANNIVERSARYOFTHECREATIONOFTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
ON*ANUARYASPARTOFTHEENTRYINTOFORCEOFTHEAGREEMENTSCONCLUDEDUNDERTHE
5RUGUAY2OUNDOFTRADENEGOTIATIONSSIGNEDBYMINISTERSAT-ARRAKESHON!PRIL
4HE74/SROLEATTHECENTREOFTHEWORLDTRADINGSYSTEMASWELLASITSSUCCESSAT
PURSUINGOBJECTIVESSETBYITS-EMBERSHAVEQUICKLYMADEOFITONEOFTHEMOSTVISIBLE
ANDINFLUENTIALMULTILATERALORGANIZATIONS4HISSPECIALSECTIONOFTHE74/!NNUAL2EPORT
PRESENTSSOMEOFTHEHIGHLIGHTSOFTHEWORKACCOMPLISHEDOVERTHEPASTTENYEARS
!NIMPORTANTASPECTOFTHISSECTIONOFTHE!NNUAL2EPORTISTHATITISBASEDONTHEVIEWSOF
SPECIALISTSINTHE74/3ECRETARIATWHOHAVEPROVIDEDTHEIREXPERTISEANDENERGIESINSUPPORT
OFTHEWORKBY74/-EMBERSTOSHAPETHEFIRSTDECADEOFTHE74/
-INISTERIALCONFERENCES
4HE74/!GREEMENTPROVIDESFORAMINISTERIALCONFERENCETOBEHELDATLEASTONCEEVERY
TWOYEARSTOHELPENSURETHEDIRECTANDFORMALINVOLVEMENTOFPOLITICALLEADERSINTHEWORK
OFTHE74/ONAREGULARBASISMINISTERIALINVOLVEMENTOFTHISTYPEDIDNOTEXISTINTHE
'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4ARIFFSAND4RADE'!44THEPREDECESSOROFTHE74/
-INISTERIALCONFERENCESREVIEWONGOINGWORKPROVIDEPOLITICALGUIDANCEANDDIRECTIONTO
THATWORKANDSETTHEAGENDAFORFURTHERWORKASNECESSARY4HEREHAVEBEENFIVEMINISTERIAL
CONFERENCESSINCETHECREATIONOFTHE74/IN4HE3IXTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWILLTAKE
PLACEIN(ONG+ONGTHISYEARFROMTO$ECEMBER
4HEMAJORACHIEVEMENTOFTHEMINISTERIALCONFERENCESTODATEHASBEENTHEIRCONTRIBUTION
TOTHELAUNCHINGOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAATTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE
1ATARIN3UBSEQUENTEFFORTSATTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIALANDINITSAFTERMATHHAVE
CONTRIBUTEDTOADVANCING4HE$OHA!GENDANEGOTIATIONSINCLUDINGTHEAGREEMENTBY74/
-EMBERSON!UGUSTONWHATISBEINGCALLEDTHEh*ULY0ACKAGEv4HETEXTOFTHE
h*ULY0ACKAGEvINCLUDEShFRAMEWORKSvINKEYAREASSUCHASAGRICULTUREANDINDUSTRIALMARKET
ACCESS
74/$IRECTOR'ENERAL3UPACHAI0ANICHPAKDIIDENTIFIEDTHEhACHIEVEMENTSvOFTHEh*ULY
0ACKAGEvASFOLLOWS
$R3UPACHAIPREDICTEDTHATTHEPROGRESSNOWMADEINAGRICULTURENONAGRICULTURALMARKET
ACCESSDEVELOPMENTISSUESANDTRADEFACILITATIONWOULDPROVIDESUBSTANTIALMOMENTUMTO
74/-EMBERSWORKINOTHERIMPORTANTAREASSUCHASRULESSERVICESENVIRONMENTREFORMOF
DISPUTEPROCEDURESANDINTELLECTUALPROPERTYPROTECTION
3UMMARYOFDEVELOPMENTSATMINISTERIALCONFERENCES
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
h&ORTHEFIRSTTIME-EMBERGOVERNMENTSHAVEAGREEDTOABOLISHALLFORMSOF
AGRICULTURALEXPORTSUBSIDIESBYACERTAINDATE4HEYHAVEAGREEDTOSUBSTANTIAL
REDUCTIONSINTRADEDISTORTINGDOMESTICSUPPORTINAGRICULTURE
!SPARTOFTHISAGREEMENTWEHAVEACHIEVEDASIGNIFICANTBREAKTHROUGHINCOTTON
TRADEWHICHOFFERSGREATOPPORTUNITYFORCOTTONFARMERSIN7EST!FRICAANDTHROUGHOUT
THEDEVELOPINGWORLD'OVERNMENTSHAVEAGREEDTOLAUNCHNEGOTIATIONSTOSETNEW
RULESSTREAMLININGTRADEANDCUSTOMSPROCEDURES7EHAVEASSIGNEDOURSELVESAMBITIOUS
GUIDELINESFOROPENINGTRADEINMANUFACTUREDPRODUCTSANDWEHAVESETOURSELVESACLEAR
AGENDAFORIMPROVINGRULESTHATAREOFGREATBENEFITTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
!SIMPORTANTLY74/GOVERNMENTSHAVESHARPENEDTHEFOCUSOFTHE$OHA2OUND
ANDPROVIDEDAFOUNDATIONWHICHWILLENABLENEGOTIATORSTOCONTINUETHESETALKSFROM
SIGNIFICANTLYHIGHERLEVELGREATLYENHANCINGOURCHANCESFORSUCCESSFULCOMPLETIONOF
THESEIMPORTANTTALKSv
3INGAPOREn$ECEMBER
4HE&IRST-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEHELDBYTHE74/-INISTERSEXAMINEDISSUESRELATED
TOTHEWORKOFTHE74/SFIRSTTWOYEARSOFACTIVITYANDTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE
5RUGUAY2OUND!GREEMENTSANDADOPTEDA$ECLARATIONESTABLISHINGAFIRMPOLITICAL
DIRECTIONFORTHEWORKOFTHE74/FORTHECOMINGYEARS
-INISTERSALSOADOPTEDA0LANOF!CTIONFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES,$#S
WHICHOFFEREDACOMPREHENSIVEAPPROACHANDINCLUDEDMEASURESRELATINGTOTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEPREVIOUSLYADOPTED$ECISIONIN&AVOUROF,$#SASWELLASINTHE
AREASOFCAPACITYBUILDINGANDMARKETACCESSFROMA74/PERSPECTIVE)NADDITIONA
PLURILATERAL$ECLARATIONWASADOPTEDBYTHEMINISTERSOFANUMBEROFCOUNTRIESONTHE
EXPANSIONOFWORLDTRADEININFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYPRODUCTS
'ENEVAn-AY
4HE3ECOND-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWASTIMEDTOCOINCIDEWITHTHECOMMEMORATION
OFTHETHANNIVERSARYOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM)NTHEIR$ECLARATIONMINISTERS
LAUNCHEDAWORKPROGRAMMETOENSUREFULLANDFAITHFULIMPLEMENTATIONOFEXISTING
74/AGREEMENTSANDTOPREPAREFORTHE4HIRD-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE)NASEPARATE
$ECLARATIONTHEMINISTERSINSTRUCTEDTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTOESTABLISHACOMPREHENSIVE
WORKPROGRAMMETOEXAMINEALLTRADERELATEDISSUESRELATINGTOGLOBALELECTRONIC
COMMERCETAKINGACCOUNTOFTHENEEDSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDTHEONGOINGWORK
INOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
3EATTLE.OVEMBERn$ECEMBER
4HE4HIRD-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWASEXPECTEDTOLAUNCHABROADWORKPROGRAMME
CONSISTINGOFTRADELIBERALIZATIONNEGOTIATIONSANDOTHERELEMENTSINCLUDING
IMPLEMENTATIONOFEXISTINGAGREEMENTS5LTIMATELYHOWEVERTHE#ONFERENCEDIDNOT
RESULTINTHENECESSARYCONSENSUS
4HEFAILUREOFTHE3EATTLE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCETOLAUNCHANEWROUNDOFTRADE
NEGOTIATIONSEXPOSEDBOTHSIGNIFICANTPOLICYDIFFERENCESAMONG-EMBERGOVERNMENTS
ASWELLASSHORTCOMINGSINTHEWAYTHEBUSINESSOFTHE74/HADBEENCONDUCTEDIN
THERUNUPTOTHE#ONFERENCE&OLLOWING3EATTLE-EMBERSENGAGEDINAPROCESSOF
COLLECTIVEREFLECTIONAIMEDATLEARNINGFROMTHEEXPERIENCEOF3EATTLEREBUILDINGLOST
CONFIDENCEANDKEEPINGTHE74/MOVINGFORWARDINTHEINTERESTSOFALLITS-EMBERS
3EVERALPOINTSWERETAKENUPASIMMEDIATEPRIORITIES4HESEINCLUDEDTAKINGTHE
PROCEDURALSTEPSTOLAUNCHTHENEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTUREANDSERVICESTHATWERE
ALREADYMANDATEDINTHE74/!GREEMENTREACHINGAGREEMENTONAPACKAGEOF
MEASURESFOR,$#SENCOMPASSINGBOTHMARKETACCESSANDCAPACITYBUILDINGTHAT
HADBEENCLOSETOAGREEMENTINPREPARATIONFOR3EATTLETAKINGAFOCUSEDAPPROACH
TOTHEISSUESRELATEDTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFEXISTINGAGREEMENTSRAISEDPARTICULARLY
BYANUMBEROFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINTHEPREPARATIONFOR3EATTLEREVIEWINGTHE
CONSULTATIVEANDDECISIONMAKINGPROCESSESOFTHE74/ANDSUBSEQUENTLYREVIVING
THEELEMENTSOFTHE74/WORKPROGRAMMETHATWEREBUILTINTOTHE74/AGREEMENTS
)NTHECOURSEOFTHECONFIDENCEREBUILDINGEFFORTSANDTHEREFORMED74/OPERATIONS
THATRESULTEDASWELLASOTHERONGOINGWORKGOVERNMENTSBEGANTOCOMETOA
REALIZATIONTHATITWASINTHEINTERESTSOFBOTHDEVELOPEDANDDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTO
REENGAGEINNEWTRADENEGOTIATIONSANDTHATSUCHNEGOTIATIONSCOULDPROMOTETRADE
ANDDEVELOPMENTANDSTRENGTHENPUBLICSUPPORTFORTHETRADINGSYSTEM
4HEPREPARATIONSFORTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWERETHUSLAUNCHED
$OHAn.OVEMBER
4HESUCCESSOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEREFLECTEDTHEDETERMINATION
OF'OVERNMENTSTOOVERCOMEDIFFERENCESANDTOWORKTOGETHERTOMAKETRADEAN
INSTRUMENTFORGLOBALDEVELOPMENTANDPEACEANDSECURITYATATIMEOFCONSIDERABLE
ECONOMICANDPOLITICALUNCERTAINTY4HELEADERSHIPDIRECTIONANDSOLIDARITYSHOWNBY
-EMBERGOVERNMENTSPROVIDEDANENORMOUSBOOSTTOTHECONFIDENCEOFINVESTORS
PRODUCERSTRADERSANDCONSUMERSWORLDWIDEINTHEFACEOFABLEAKSHORTTERMOUTLOOK
FORTHEWORLDECONOMY4HEIMPROVEDWORKINGMETHODSOFTHE74/PUTINPLACEOVER
THEYEARSFOLLOWING3EATTLEALSOCONTRIBUTEDENORMOUSLYTOTHEPOSITIVESPIRITOFTHE
MEETINGANDTOTHEOUTCOME
-INISTERSLAUNCHEDABROADANDAMBITIOUSWORKPROGRAMMEFORTHE74/FORTHE
COMINGYEARSTOADDRESSTHECHALLENGESFACINGTHETRADINGSYSTEMANDTHENEEDS
ANDINTERESTSOFTHEDIVERSE74/MEMBERSHIP4HEWORKPROGRAMMETHEh$OHA
$EVELOPMENT!GENDAvINCORPORATESBOTHACOMPREHENSIVESETOFMULTILATERALTRADE
NEGOTIATIONSASWELLASOTHERACTIVITIESDESIGNEDTOADDRESSTHESECHALLENGESAND
NEEDS
)NPARTICULARTHE$$!REFLECTSASHAREDDESIRETOENSURETHATTHETRADINGSYSTEMIS
RELEVANTANDRESPONSIVETOTHENEEDSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESBYPLACINGDEVELOPMENT
RELATEDISSUESATTHECENTREOFTHE$OHA$ECLARATION)TACKNOWLEDGESTHENEEDTO
ASSISTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESSTRENGTHENTHEIRCAPACITYTOPARTICIPATEMOREFULLYIN
INTERNATIONALTRADEANDINTHEDELIBERATIONSANDMAKETHEIRVOICESHEARD)TOUTLINESA
WORKPROGRAMMEFORIMPLEMENTINGTHESEOBJECTIVESREAFFIRMSTHEROLEOFSPECIALAND
DIFFERENTIALTREATMENTINFOSTERINGDEVELOPMENTANDMARKSANEWDEPARTUREINTHE
APPROACHTOEFFECTIVECAPACITYBUILDINGANDTECHNICALASSISTANCEWITHTHEJOINTPROVISION
OFSUPPORTWITHOTHERAGENCIESANDGOVERNMENTS)TALSOOUTLINESTHEDEVELOPMENT
DIMENSIONSOFMARKETACCESSRULESRELATEDISSUESANDDISPUTESETTLEMENTANDLAUNCHES
WORKONPARTICULARAREASOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYINTERESTINCLUDINGTRADEANDTRANSFER
OFTECHNOLOGYTRADEDEBTANDFINANCEANDSMALLECONOMIES/THERDEVELOPMENT
RELATEDWORKINCLUDESTHEONGOINGEXAMINATIONOFPROPOSALSFORMODIFICATIONSTO
74/PROVISIONSANDPROCEDURESMADEINTHECONTEXTOFTHEPOST5RUGUAY2OUND
IMPLEMENTATIONDISCUSSIONS
)NADDITIONMINISTERSADOPTEDTHEIMPORTANT$ECLARATIONONTHE42)03!GREEMENT
AND0UBLIC(EALTHINRESPONSETOTHECONCERNSEXPRESSEDABOUTTHEPOSSIBLE
IMPLICATIONSOFTHE42)03!GREEMENTFORACCESSTODRUGS$OHAALSOSAWTHEHISTORIC
ACCESSIONSOF#HINAAND#HINESE4AIPEI
#ANCÞNn3EPTEMBER
4HEFIRSTEIGHTMONTHSOFSAWVERYINTENSIVEWORKONALLAREASOFTHE$$!
NEGOTIATIONSINPREPARATIONFORTHE74/S&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWHICHTOOKPLACE
IN#ANCÞN-EXICOFROMTO3EPTEMBER3IGNIFICANTPROGRESSWASMADE
ACROSSTHEBOARDINBRINGING-EMBERSPOSITIONSCLOSERTOGETHER
/VERTHECOURSEOFOVERFIVEDAYSOFINTENSIVECONSULTATIVEWORKATTHEIR#ONFERENCE
MINISTERSMADECONSIDERABLEPROGRESSTOWARDSFULFILLINGTHE$OHAMANDATES(OWEVER
THEYWEREUNABLETOREACHAGREEMENTDURINGTHISSHORTPERIODOFTIMEONATEXTWHICH
WOULDSERVEASAFRAMEWORKFORGUIDINGTHENEGOTIATIONSTOACONCLUSIONBYTHE
MANDATEDDEADLINEOF*ANUARY)NSTEADITWASAGREEDTHATCONSULTATIONSSHOULD
CONTINUEUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWITHTHEAIMOFTAKINGTHEACTION
NECESSARYBYMID$ECEMBERTOENABLE-EMBERSTOMOVEFORWARD7HILETHE$ECEMBER
#OUNCILMEETINGDIDNOTBRINGABOUTAMAJORBREAKTHROUGHTHEKEYISSUESBECAME
CLEARERANDPROGRESSWASMADETOWARDSGETTINGTHE$$!BACKONTRACK
7ORKTHENINTENSIFIEDINTHEFIRSTHALFOFANDAGREEMENTWASREACHEDINTHE
'ENERAL#OUNCILONAPACKAGEOFFRAMEWORKAGREEMENTSATTHEENDOF*ULY
4HISFRAMEWORKDEALREPRESENTEDANIMPORTANTSIGNALTHATGOVERNMENTSAREABLETO
COMETOGETHERTOCONCLUDEMUTUALLYBENEFICIALAGREEMENTSBOOSTINGCONFIDENCEINTHE
WORLDECONOMYANDSTRENGTHENINGTHEFOUNDATIONSOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
7ITHTHISFRAMEWORKDECISIONTHE$$!ISBACKONTRACK&RAMEWORKAGREEMENTS
ARENOWINPLACEFORTHENEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTUREnINCLUDINGCOTTONnANDNON
AGRICULTURALMARKETACCESSAND-EMBERSHAVEAGREEDTOAPACKAGEONDEVELOPMENT
ANDTAKENADECISIONTOBEGINNEGOTIATIONSONTRADEFACILITATION4HEYHAVETHUSFINALLY
LAIDTORESTTHEDISAPPOINTMENTOF#ANCÞNANDSHOWEDTHEIRCOMMITMENTTOFULFILLING
THE$OHAMANDATES4HEDECISIONGIVESASENSEOFTHEPATHTOWARDSTHATSHAREDGOAL
ANDOPENSTHEWAYTOMOVEAHEADWITHRENEWEDMOMENTUMANDASENSEOFPURPOSE
TOWARDSASUCCESSFULCONCLUSIONOFTHE2OUND
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILISTHE74/SHIGHESTDECISIONMAKINGBODYINTHEINTERVALSBETWEEN
MEETINGSOFTHEMINISTERIALCONFERENCE)TCARRIESOUTTHEFUNCTIONSOFTHE74/ASWELLAS
SPECIFICTASKSASSIGNEDTOITBYTHE74/!GREEMENTANDTAKESANYACTIONNECESSARYTOWARDS
THISEND4HECONTRIBUTIONOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILANDITSSUCCESSIVECHAIRPERSONSTOTHE
SMOOTHFUNCTIONINGOFTHE74/ANDITSAGREEMENTSISANACHIEVEMENTINITSELF)NPARTICULAR
DURINGTHELASTTENYEARSTHE#OUNCILHASBEENCALLEDONTOTAKEANINCREASINGLYMAJORROLEIN
THEPREPARATORYWORKFORMINISTERIALCONFERENCESANDINTHEFOLLOWUPTOTHEM
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILPLAYEDAKEYROLEINANUMBEROFTHEMAJORACHIEVEMENTSOFTHE
74/OVERTHISPERIODSUCHASTHEMEASURESTAKENTOREBUILDCONFIDENCEAFTERTHE3EATTLE
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINPARTICULARTHROUGHIMPROVEDCONSULTATIVEPROCEDURESANDMORE
EFFECTIVEPARTICIPATIONOFALL-EMBERSINDECISIONMAKINGTHE$ECISIONON42)03AND0UBLIC
(EALTHIN!UGUSTANDTHE*ULY$ECISIONTOTAKETHE$$!WORKPROGRAMMEAND
NEGOTIATIONSFORWARD
/THERSPECIFICACHIEVEMENTSOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINCLUDEDECISIONSAIMEDAT
IMPROVINGTRANSPARENCYIN74/OPERATIONSTHROUGHBOTHIMPROVEDPUBLICACCESSTO
74/DOCUMENTATIONANDGUIDELINESFORIMPROVINGCOMMUNICATIONWITHCIVILSOCIETY
REPRESENTATIVESANDACHIEVINGBETTERCOOPERATIONANDCOORDINATIONnINECONOMICPOLICY
MAKINGANDTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDCAPACITYBUILDINGEFFORTSnBETWEENTHE)-&7ORLD
"ANK74/ANDOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
'ENERAL#OUNCIL
4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE
4HE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEE4.#OPERATESUNDERTHEAUTHORITYOFTHE'ENERAL
#OUNCILANDWASESTABLISHEDBYTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONWHICHALSOASSIGNEDITTOCREATE
SUBSIDIARYNEGOTIATINGBODIESTOHANDLEINDIVIDUALNEGOTIATINGSUBJECTS4HE4.#DULYSETUP
THENEGOTIATINGBODIESON&EBRUARYANDAPPOINTEDTHEIR#HAIRPERSONS#HAIREDBYTHE
$IRECTOR'ENERALTHE4.#PLAYSAKEYROLEINTHE$OHA2OUNDBYOVERSEEINGTHENEGOTIATIONS
ANDENSURINGTHEOVERALLBALANCEOFTHENEGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE3INGLE5NDERTAKING
4HE4.#SCONTRIBUTIONTOTHENEGOTIATIONSCANBEJUDGEDBYTHELARGENUMBEROFSENIOR
CAPITALBASEDOFFICIALSWHOATTENDITSMEETINGS&ORMANYDELEGATIONSITPROVIDESALINK
BETWEENTHEWORKOFTHENEGOTIATORSIN'ENEVAANDTHEGOVERNMENTSWHICHTHEYREPRESENT
4HISROLEOFBRINGINGPOLITICALINPUTTOTHEWORKIN'ENEVAWILLBEEVENMORECRUCIALASTHE
2OUNDENTERSITSFINALSTAGEWITHNEGOTIATIONSONMODALITIESINKEYAREAS
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY
$ISPUTESETTLEMENTISTHECENTRALPILLAROFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDTHE74/S
UNIQUECONTRIBUTIONTOTHESTABILITYOFTHEGLOBALECONOMY7ITHOUTAMEANSOFSETTLING
DISPUTESTHERULESBASEDSYSTEMWOULDBELESSEFFECTIVEBECAUSETHERULESCOULDNOTBE
ENFORCED4HE74/SPROCEDUREUNDERSCORESTHERULEOFLAWANDMAKESTHETRADINGSYSTEM
MORESECUREANDPREDICTABLE4HESYSTEMISBASEDONCLEARLYDEFINEDRULESWITHTIMETABLESFOR
COMPLETINGACASE2ULINGSAREMADEBYAPANELANDCANBEAPPEALEDTOTHE!PPELLATE"ODY
WHICHCANEITHERUPHOLDMODIFYORREVERSETHELEGALFINDINGSANDCONCLUSIONSOFTHEPANEL
4HERULINGSANDRECOMMENDATIONSOFTHEPANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYMAYEITHERBEENDORSED
ORREJECTEDBYTHE74/SFULLMEMBERSHIPINTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY$3"
4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONVENESASTHE$3"TODEALWITHDISPUTESARISINGFROMANY
AGREEMENTCONTAINEDINTHE&INAL!CTOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUND)NTHELASTTENYEARSITHAS
TAKENUPOVERDISPUTECASESINSOMEMEETINGSnMORETHANTHE'!44DURINGCLOSE
TOHALFACENTURY4HESMOOTHFUNCTIONINGOFTHE$3"THROUGHOUTTHISPERIODHASMADEA
MAJORCONTRIBUTIONTO-EMBERSTRADERELATIONS
4HE74/SWORKONDISPUTESETTLEMENTISDEALTWITHINMOREDETAILBELOW
!CCESSIONSTOTHE74/n
-ORETHANGOVERNMENTSHAVEAPPLIEDTOACCEDETOTHE74/SINCETHE-ARRAKESH
!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE74/ENTEREDINTOFORCEON*ANUARY/FTHESEHAVE
COMPLETEDTHEIRACCESSIONPROCEDURESANDHAVEBECOME74/-EMBERS 4HISREPRESENTSASIGNIFICANTADVANCEFORTHE74/SGOALOFACHIEVINGUNIVERSALSCOPEAND
MEMBERSHIP4HESTEADYINCREASEINMEMBERSHIPINTHEFIRSTDECADEOFTHE74/HASBROUGHT
NEWENTRANTSFROMSEVERALREGIONSOFTHEWORLDWITHDIFFERENCESINSIZETRADESHARESAND
LEVELSOFECONOMICDEVELOPMENT4HISADDSTOTHEDIVERSITYOFTHEORGANIZATIONANDBODES
WELLFORTHEFUTUREOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
#URRENTLY74/S-EMBERSACCOUNTFORMORETHANPERCENTOFWORLDTRADE
4HEMEMBERSHIPSSHAREINWORLDTRADEISSETTORISEEVENFURTHERASTHEGOVERNMENTS
CURRENTLYSEEKINGTOACCEDETOTHE74/CONCLUDETHEIRENTRYNEGOTIATIONS !MONGTHOSE
EXPECTEDTOCONCLUDEACCESSIONNEGOTIATIONSINTHENEARFUTUREARE#APE6ERDE3AMOA
3AUDI!RABIA2USSIAN&EDERATION4ONGA5KRAINEAND6IET.AM
)TISEQUALLYSIGNIFICANTTHATTHEPOLITICALFOCUSOF-EMBERGOVERNMENTSONMAKINGTHE
74/UNIVERSALHASNEITHERBEENDILUTEDNORWEAKENEDBYTHEIRINVOLVEMENTWITHADVANCING
THEMULTILATERALNEGOTIATIONSUNDERTHE$$!
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
#HINA#HINESE4AIPEI
#OMPLETEDACCESSIONSINTHEORDERTHEYHAVE
BECOME74/-EMBERS%CUADOR"ULGARIA
-ONGOLIA0ANAMA+YRGYZ2EPUBLIC,ATVIA
%STONIA*ORDAN'EORGIA!LBANIA/MAN
#ROATIA,ITHUANIA-OLDOVA#HINA#HINESE
4AIPEI&ORMER9UGOSLAV2EPUBLICOF-ACEDONIA
.EPALAND#AMBODIA
/NGOINGACCESSIONSASOF$ECEMBER
!FGHANISTAN!LGERIA!NDORRA
!ZERBAIJAN"AHAMAS"ELARUS"HUTAN"OSNIA
AND(ERZEGOVINA#APE6ERDE%THIOPIA)RAQ
+AZAKHSTAN,AO0$2,EBANON,IBYA2USSIAN
&EDERATION3AMOA3AUDI!RABIA3ERBIA
-ONTENEGRO3EYCHELLES3UDAN4AJIKISTAN
4ONGA5KRAINE5ZBEKISTAN6ANUATU6IET.AM
9EMEN
7HILEEACHCOMPLETEDACCESSIONISNOTEWORTHYINITSOWNRIGHTnAFEWSTANDOUT
4HE&OURTH74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINISREMEMBEREDALMOSTASMUCHFORTHE
ACCESSIONOF#HINAAND#HINESE4AIPEIASITISFORLAUNCHINGTHE$$!NEGOTIATIONS7HILE
#HINASACCESSIONTOOKOVERYEARSTOCOMPLETEINCLUDINGALMOSTEIGHTYEARSASA'!44
7ORKING0ARTYTHEACCESSIONOF#HINESE4AIPEITOOKTENYEARSWITHTHREEYEARSASA'!44
7ORKING0ARTY4HETIMETAKENTOCONCLUDETHESEACCESSIONSREFLECTEDTHEPACEOFDOMESTIC
REFORMSASWELLASTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHESENEGOTIATIONS7ITHITSACCESSION#HINAONEOF
THEFASTESTGROWINGECONOMIESINTHEWORLDAGREEDTOUNDERTAKEASERIESOFIMPORTANT
COMMITMENTSTOOPENANDLIBERALIZEITSECONOMICANDTRADEREGIME4HISHASENABLED#HINA
TOBETTERINTEGRATEINTHEWORLDECONOMYANDFORITSTRADINGPARTNERSITOFFERSGREATERMARKET
ACCESSANDAMOREPREDICTABLEENVIRONMENTFORTRADEANDFOREIGNINVESTMENTINACCORDANCE
WITH74/RULES
4RANSITIONECONOMIES
-ANYOFTHERECENTLYACCEDEDORCURRENTLYACCEDINGGOVERNMENTSHADORAREUNDERGOING
ATRANSITIONFROMCENTRALLYPLANNEDTOMARKETECONOMIES!CCESSIONTOTHE74/HASLED
THESECOUNTRIESnINADDITIONTOTHEUSUALTRADEBENEFITSnTOUNDERPINANDLOCKINTHEIR
AUTONOMOUSDOMESTICREFORMPROCESS4HEDIFFICULTDECISIONSTAKENBYTHESEGOVERNMENTSIN
UNDERTAKINGTHESEREFORMSAREWELLDOCUMENTED"UTTHEIREFFORTSHAVEBEENCOMPENSATED
BYEFFICIENCYGAINSANDINCREASEDGROWTHTRADEORINVESTMENT)NTHECASEOFTHE"ALTIC
REPUBLICSn%STONIA,ATVIA,ITHUANIAn74/ACCESSIONHASBEENASTEPPINGSTONEFORFURTHER
INTEGRATIONANDENTRYINTOTHE%UROPEAN5NION)NASIMILARVEINTHEACCESSIONSOF*ORDAN
#ROATIATHE&ORMER9UGOSLAV2EPUBLICOF-ACEDONIAHAVEBEENBEACONSOFFUTUREPOLITICAL
ANDECONOMICSTABILITYINREGIONSWHICHHAVEBEENCHRONICALLYVOLATILEANDINSECURE
)NYETOTHERINSTANCESACCESSIONREQUESTSFROMCOUNTRIESINWARTORNREGIONSHAVE
COINCIDEDWITHREBUILDINGEFFORTSANDARETURNTONORMALCY)N!FGHANISTANAND)RAQJOINING
THE74/HASBEENVIEWEDASANINSTRUMENTTOPROMOTEPEACEGREATERECONOMICSTABILITYAND
PROSPERITY&ORECONOMICPOWERSLIKE,IBYATHECOMMENCEMENTOF74/ACCESSIONHASMEANT
THEENDOFISOLATION)RANAND3YRIACONTINUETOHAVETHEIRACCESSIONREQUESTSPENDINGBEFORE
THE74/MEMBERSHIP
,EASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES,$#S
,$#SACCOUNTFORABOUTATHIRDOFONGOINGACCESSIONS&ACILITATINGTHEIRINTEGRATIONINTO
THE74/ANDTHERULESBASEDMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMHASBEENASPECIALCHALLENGEAND
PRIORITYFORTHEMEMBERSHIP)N$OHAMINISTERSAGREEDTOFACILITATEANDACCELERATE,$#
ACCESSIONNEGOTIATIONS4HEADOPTIONOFTHE,$#!CCESSION'UIDELINESIN$ECEMBER
PROVEDTOBEATURNINGPOINTINOUREFFORTSTOSIMPLIFYACCESSIONPROCEDURESANDADVANCE,$#
ACCESSIONS4HEFIRSTRESULTSCAMEQUICKLYINTHEACCESSIONPACKAGESOF#AMBODIAAND.EPAL
BEINGADOPTEDAT#ANCÞNIN4HEYWERETHEFIRSTTWO,$#STOACCEDETOTHE74/UNDER
THEPROCEDURESESTABLISHEDIN%FFORTSAREONGOINGTOADVANCEOTHER,$#ACCESSIONS
INCLUDINGTHEPREVIOUSLYINACTIVEONES4ECHNICALASSISTANCEHASBEENSTEPPEDUPATALLSTAGES
OFTHEACCESSIONPROCESSTHOUGHINLIGHTOFTHECONSIDERABLENEEDSMUCHMOREREMAINSTOBE
DONE
!CCESSIONPROCESS
4HEINCREASEINSCOPEANDCOVERAGEOFTHE74/ANDITSAGREEMENTSHASINCREASEDTHE
COMPLEXITYOFTHEACCESSIONNEGOTIATIONSPARTICULARLYWHENCOMPAREDTOACCESSIONTOTHE
'!44/NTHEOTHERHANDTHEPROCESSITSELFHASEVOLVEDANDBECOMEMORESTRUCTUREDAND
TRANSPARENT(OWEVERTHEREISALWAYSMORETHATCANBEDONETOIMPROVETHEACCESSION
PROCESS3OMEHAVEARGUEDTHATTHENEGOTIATIONSREMAINDEMANDINGUNDULYLENGTHYAND
COSTLYFORACCEDINGGOVERNMENTSBOTHINFINANCIALANDHUMANRESOURCETERMS4HECHALLENGE
HASBEENTOBALANCETHESPECIALINTERESTSOFACCEDINGGOVERNMENTSFORENTRYTERMSANDTHE
SYSTEMICINTERESTOF-EMBERSTOMAINTAINTHEINTEGRITYOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM)TIS
EXPECTEDTHATTHEACCESSIONPROCESSWILLSEETHENEWENTRANTSPARTICIPATEASFULLANDEFFECTIVE
PLAYERSINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
4ECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGISOFCRITICALIMPORTANCEFORALLACCEDING
GOVERNMENTSANDATALLSTAGESOFTHEACCESSIONPROCESS#ONSTRAINTSFACEDBYACCEDING
GOVERNMENTSESPECIALLY,$#SINCLUDESCARCEHUMANANDFINANCIALRESOURCESTHEABSENCE
OF74/CONSISTENTLEGISLATIONANDMECHANISMSANDLIMITEDINSTITUTIONALANDNEGOTIATING
CAPACITYTOMANAGETHEACCESSIONPROCESS4ECHNICALASSISTANCEREQUIREDBYACCEDING
GOVERNMENTSRANGESFROMAWARENESSGENERATIONACTIVITIESANDTHEPREPARATIONOF
DOCUMENTATIONTOTHELONGERTERMSUPPORTREQUIREDFORSETTINGUPLEGISLATIVEINFRASTRUCTURE
ANDENFORCEMENTMECHANISMS0RIORITYHASBEENGIVENTOACCEDINGGOVERNMENTSINPARTICULAR
,$#SINTHE74/!NNUAL4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE0LANS(OWEVERGIVENTHEENORMITYOFTHE
TECHNICALASSISTANCENEEDSOFACCEDINGGOVERNMENTSANDTHELIMITEDRESOURCESATTHE
DISPOSALOFTHE74/3ECRETARIATAWIDENINGGAPREMAINSTOBEFILLED
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4ECHNICALASSISTANCE
4RADEINSERVICES
4HECREATIONOFTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4RADEIN3ERVICES'!43CANBEVIEWEDAS
AMILESTONEINTHEHISTORYOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMCOMPARABLETOTHEINCEPTION
OF'!44ITSCOUNTERPARTINMERCHANDISETRADEIN"EYONDITSSIGNIFICANCEFOR
INTERNATIONALRELATIONSTHISEXTENSIONOFTRADERULESREFLECTSAMAJORCHANGEINTHEROLE
OFSERVICESASPARTOFACOUNTRYSECONOMICFABRIC4RADITIONALLYSERVICESHADBEENVIEWED
ESSENTIALLYASDOMESTICACTIVITIESTHATCOULDNOTBETRADEDFORATLEASTTWOREASONSFIRSTTHE
NEEDFORDIRECTPHYSICALCONTACTBETWEENPRODUCERANDCONSUMERINMANYTRADITIONALAREAS
OFPERSONALSERVICESANDSECONDTHEEXISTENCEOFGOVERNMENTMONOPOLIESININFRASTRUCTURE
RELATEDSECTORSSUCHASTELECOMMUNICATIONSTRANSPORTANDVARIOUSINSURANCESECTORS
4HISPERCEPTIONHASCHANGEDSIGNIFICANTLY.EWCOMMUNICATIONTECHNOLOGIESINPARTICULAR
THEASCENTOFTHE)NTERNETHAVEHELPEDTODEVELOPNEWVARIANTSOFHITHERTOLOCATIONRELATED
SERVICESECOMMERCEEBANKINGTELEHEALTHTELEEDUCATIONANDTHUSTOOVERCOME
THECONSTRAINTSOFSPACE)NTURNTHEGRADUALEMERGENCEOFFOREIGNSUPPLIERSHASSTARTED
UNDERMININGSOMELONGENTRENCHEDMONOPOLIESANDEXPOSINGTHEMTOANELEMENTOF
OUTSIDECOMPETITION!TTHESAMETIMEGOVERNMENTSHAVEFOUNDITINCREASINGLYDIFFICULTTO
APPLYESTABLISHEDPRINCIPLESOFPUBLICFINANCEANDADMINISTRATIONTOTHENEWLYEMERGING
TECHNOLOGYDRIVENACTIVITIES!NDATHIRDFACTORENTEREDTHEPOLICYEQUATIONINTERNATIONALLY
MOBILEUSERINDUSTRIESBECAMEINCREASINGLYSENSITIVETOLOCATIONRELATEDCOSTANDEFFICIENCY
DIFFERENTIALSASSOCIATEDWITHSERVICESINNOVATIONANDREFORMININDIVIDUALMARKETS7HETHER
THEYLIKEDITORNOTGOVERNMENTSTHUSHADLITTLEOPTIONBUTTORETHINKTHEIRTRADITIONAL
APPROACHESTOORGANIZINGANDREGULATINGMAJORSERVICESSECTORS4HEPILLARSOFMANY
TRADITIONALMONOPOLIESINCLUDINGINTELECOMMUNICATIONSTRANSPORTANDFINANCESTARTEDTO
CRUMBLE-ARKETACCESSISSUESEMERGEDINSERVICESPOSSIBLYINSLIGHTLYDIFFERENTGUISESAS
THEYHADEMERGEDLONGBEFOREINMERCHANDISETRADE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4RADINGINNEWMODALDIMENSIONS
4HEEXTENSIONOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMTOSERVICESWASMADEPOSSIBLEBY
VARIOUSINNOVATIONSTHATEXTENDEDTHESCOPEANDCOVERAGEOFTHENEW!GREEMENTINTO
@VIRGINTERRITORY4HEPOSSIBLYMOSTOBVIOUSCHANGEISTHEINTRODUCTIONOFTHECONCEPTOF
FOURMODESOFSUPPLY!CCORDINGLYTHESCOPEOF'!43NOTONLYAPPLIESTOCROSSBORDER
TRADEnMODEnLIKEITSPRECURSORINMERCHANDISETRADETHE'!44BUTTOTHREEADDITIONAL
TYPESOFTRANSACTIONSNOTYETREFERREDTOINTRADEAGREEMENTS4HESEARE
MODEnCONSUMPTIONOFSERVICESABROADEXAMPLESTOURISTSSTUDENTSPATIENTS
MODEnCOMMERCIALPRESENCEEXAMPLESINWARDFOREIGNDIRECTINVESTMENTINA
COUNTRYSFINANCIALTELECOMMUNICATIONSORTOURISMSECTORAND
MODEnPRESENCEOFNATURALPERSONSSUPPLYINGSERVICESEXAMPLESFOREIGN
INDEPENDENTPROFESSIONALSSUCHASDOCTORSORFOREIGNSTAFFOFFOREIGNOWNEDBANKS
HOTELSETC
4HEINCLUSIONOFMODESTOREFLECTSTHECONTINUEDNECESSITYTHATINORDERFORMANY
SERVICESTOBETRADEDBOTHSUPPLIERANDUSERCONSUMERMUSTBESIMULTANEOUSLYPRESENTTO
COMPLETETHETRANSACTION)NTURNTHISALSOEXPLAINSWHYUNLIKETHE'!44THE'!43APPLIES
NOTONLYTOTHETREATMENTOFPRODUCTSBUTALSOTOTHETREATMENTOFSUPPLIERSIEPRODUCERS
ANDORDISTRIBUTORS
4HEBREADTHOFTHE!GREEMENTSCOVERAGEANDPOTENTIALAPPLICATIONISBALANCEDBY
MUCHLEEWAYIN-EMBERSASSUMPTIONOFTRADEOBLIGATIONS)NPARTICULARMARKETACCESS
ANDNATIONALTREATMENTnTHETWOMAINPARAMETERSGOVERNINGTRADINGCONDITIONSnARE
GUARANTEEDONLYINTHESECTORSTHATA-EMBERHASLISTEDINITSSCHEDULEOFSPECIFIC
COMMITMENTS@BOTTOMUPAPPROACH!NDEVENSUCHLISTINGOFSECTORSDOESNOT
AUTOMATICALLYAMOUNTTOUNQUALIFIEDMARKETACCESSANDNATIONALTREATMENT2ATHER-EMBERS
AREFREETOATTACHLIMITATIONSORTOFULLYEXCLUDEONEORMOREMODESFROMTHESCOPEOFTHEIR
COMMITMENTS@TOPDOWNANDTHUSRETAINPOLICYDISCRETION4HEFLEXIBILITYTOSELECTSECTORS
ANDTOATTACHLIMITATIONCREATESALMOSTUNLIMITEDSCOPEFORCUSTOMIZINGCOMMITMENTSTO
NATIONALPOLICYCHOICESANDNEGOTIATINGOBJECTIVES4HUSWHILEALL74/-EMBERSARELEGALLY
REQUIREDTOSUBMITASCHEDULEOFCOMMITMENTS!RTICLE88ITMIGHTBEIMPOSSIBLETOFIND
-EMBERSWITHIDENTICALSCHEDULES4HECOMMITMENTSWHICHGOVERNMENTSHAVEASSUMED
UNDERTHE'!43ARETHUSSPECIFICTOPARTICULARSERVICESANDTOTHEPARTICULARMODESBYWHICH
THEYAREDELIVERED
#URRENTLEVELSOFCOMMITMENTS
4HE!GREEMENTSFLEXIBILITYHASAPPARENTLYBEENUSEDTOAVERYLARGEEXTENT3CHEDULED
LEVELSOFCOMMITMENTSVARYWIDELYACROSS-EMBERSSECTORSANDMODESOFSUPPLY
#HARTSHOWSSIGNIFICANTDIFFERENCESINTHEEXTENTTOWHICHINDIVIDUALSECTORSHAVE
BEENINCLUDEDINSCHEDULES2ELEVANTDECISIONSMAYHAVEBEENINFLUENCEDFIRSTBYTHE
DEGREETOWHICHPARTICULARSECTORSHAVETRADITIONALLYBEENOPENTOFOREIGNPARTICIPATION
EGALMOSTALLSCHEDULESCONTAINCOMMITMENTSONTOURISMANAREAINWHICHVIRTUALLYALL
-EMBERSHAVELONGMAINTAINEDCOMPARATIVELYLIBERALINVESTMENTREGIMES3ECONDTHEREIS
ANAPPARENTCONCENTRATIONOFCOMMITMENTSONSECTORSOFGENERALINFRASTRUCTURALIMPORTANCE
THATPROVIDEECONOMYWIDEINPUTSINCLUDINGFINANCIALSERVICESABROADRANGEOFBUSINESS
SERVICESANDCOMMUNICATIONSSERVICES%CONOMICOPENNESSINTHESESECTORSANDTHERELATED
FLOWSOFINVESTMENTSKILLSANDEXPERTISEMAYHAVEBROADGROWTHANDEFFICIENCYEFFECTS
2ELATEDEXPECTATIONSMAYALSOEXPLAINWHYSEVERALDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHATDIDNOTINITIALLY
PARTICIPATEINTHEEXTENDEDNEGOTIATIONSONBASICTELECOMMUNICATIONSINNEVERTHELESS
VOLUNTEEREDDEEPERCOMMITMENTSINTHEWAKEOFTHESENEGOTIATIONS
4HEDIVERSITYOFSECTORCOMMITMENTSREFLECTSINLARGEPARTTHESCHEDULINGDECISIONS
OFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESGIVENTHEIRSHARESOMEPERCENTINTHE74/MEMBERSHIP
4ABLESHOWSTHENUMBEROFCOMMITMENTSINSCRIBEDBYINDIVIDUALGROUPSOF-EMBERS
INDICATINGSTRONGDIFFERENCESBETWEENLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESDEVELOPINGANDTRANSITION
ECONOMIESASWELLASDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES (OWEVERTHECOMMITMENTSUNDERTAKENBYNEW
74/-EMBERSIEDEVELOPINGANDTRANSITIONECONOMIESTHATHAVEJOINEDSINCEARE
COMPARABLEINNUMBERTOTHOSEUNDERTAKENBYDEVELOPED-EMBERS!LSOTHESECOMMITMENTS
TENDTOBEDEEPERIESUBJECTTOASMALLERNUMBEROFLIMITATIONSTHANTHOSEUNDERTAKENBY
OTHER-EMBERS
#HART3ECTORFOCUSOFCURRENTCOMMITMENTS.OVEMBER
.OTE4HEVERTICALAXISDISPLAYSTHENUMBEROF-EMBERSTHATHAVESCHEDULEDATLEASTONESUBSEGMENTOUTOFTHE
LARGESECTORSFROMTOURISMTOEDUCATIONLISTEDHORIZONTALLY%#-EMBERSARECOUNTEDINDIVIDUALLY
4HEAVERAGESFORGROUPSOF-EMBERSMAYMASKWIDEVARIATIONS4HISISPARTICULARLYTHE
CASEFORLEASTDEVELOPEDANDFORDEVELOPINGECONOMIES3OMELEASTDEVELOPED-EMBERS
COMMITTEDASMANYSECTORSASTHEGROUPOFDEVELOPED-EMBERSONAVERAGESEETHIRD
COLUMNIN4ABLE
4ABLE
-EMBERS
,EASTDEVELOPEDECONOMIES
$EVELOPINGTRANSITIONECONOMIES
$EVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
!CCESSIONSSINCE
!LL-EMBERS
!VERAGENUMBEROFSECTORS
COMMITTEDPER-EMBER
2ANGE
,OWESTHIGHESTNUMBER
OFSCHEDULEDSECTORS
n
n
n
n
n
4RANSITIONECONOMIESONLY
4OTALNUMBEROFSECTORS^4OTALNUMBEROF-EMBERS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
#OMMITMENTSOFDIFFERENTGROUPSOF-EMBERS.OVEMBER
3PECIFICCOMMITMENTS
(OWEVERSUCHCOMPARISONSNEEDTOBE
INTERPRETEDWITHCARE&OREXAMPLETHEY
DONOTTAKEINTOACCOUNTDIFFERENCESIN
ECONOMICIMPORTANCEBETWEENSECTORSNORTHE
RESTRICTIVENESSOFTHELIMITATIONSTHATMAYHAVE
BEENATTACHEDININDIVIDUALCASES
5NLIKEPREVIOUSTRADEROUNDSUNDERTHE'!44WHICHESSENTIALLYFOCUSEDONTRADE
LIBERALIZATIONWITHINANESTABLISHEDLEGALFRAMEWORKTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDBROKENEWGROUND
ININTEGRATINGCOMPLETELYNEWAREASnSERVICESANDTRADERELATEDASPECTSOFINTELLECTUAL
PROPERTYRIGHTSnINTOTHESYSTEM&ORSERVICESINPARTICULARANEWLEGALARCHITECTURENEEDED
TOBECREATEDANDFILLEDWITHSUBSTANCE4HISWASANENORMOUSTASKREQUIRINGNEGOTIATORS
TORETHINKANDSOMETIMESREINVENTBASICTRADEPOLICYCONCEPTSANDINSTRUMENTS!PART
FROMTHE%#S3INGLE-ARKETTHEREWASLITTLEEXPERIENCEWITHCOMPREHENSIVESERVICES
TRADEAGREEMENTS!LTHOUGHTEMPTINGITWASIMPOSSIBLETOSIMPLYREAPPLYBASIC'!44
PROVISIONSnGIVENIMPORTANTSTRUCTURALDIFFERENCESBETWEENMERCHANDISEANDSERVICES
TRADEnANDRETAINTHE'!44SFOCUSONMEASURESAFFECTINGTHESALEOFPRODUCTSACROSS
BORDERS4HISMEANTTHATAGREATDEALOFNEGOTIATINGENERGYWENTINTORULEMAKINGPARTLYAT
THEEXPENSEOFMARKETOPENINGNEGOTIATIONS
74/-EMBERSHAVEBEENNEGOTIATINGONSERVICESCONTINUOUSLYSINCETHEENDOF
THE5RUGUAY2OUNDIN$ECEMBER)NADDITIONTOTHENEGOTIATIONSONRULEMAKING
DIRECTEDTOWARDSCOMPLETIONOFTHEFRAMEWORKOFTHE'!43THEREHAVEBEENFOURDISCRETE
NEGOTIATIONSWHOSEPURPOSEWASTHEEXPANSIONOFMARKETACCESSCOMMITMENTSnONFINANCIAL
SERVICESMARITIMETRANSPORTMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONSANDBASICTELECOMMUNICATIONS
4HEESSENTIALMOTIVATIONFORFURTHERNEGOTIATIONINTHEFIRSTTHREECASESWASDISSATISFACTION
WITHTHERESULTSACHIEVEDINTHESESECTORSINTHE5RUGUAY2OUND4HECASEOFBASIC
TELECOMMUNICATIONSHOWEVERWASDIFFERENT.EGOTIATORSHADAGREEDDURINGTHE5RUGUAY
2OUNDTHATTHETIMEWASNOTRIPEFORSUBSTANTIVENEGOTIATIONSINTHATSECTORBECAUSETHE
PROFOUNDECONOMICANDPOLITICALTRANSFORMATIONSITWASUNDERGOINGNOTLEASTINTHE%#WERE
NOTCOMPLETE
4RADEPOLICYMAKERSHAVEOFTENDEBATEDTHEQUESTIONWHETHERITISPRACTICABLETO
ACHIEVESIGNIFICANTLIBERALIZATIONINASELFCONTAINEDORSINGLESECTORNEGOTIATIONORWHETHER
IMPORTANTRESULTSCANONLYBEEXPECTEDINTHECONTEXTOFAMAJORROUNDENCOMPASSINGMANY
SUBJECTSANDTHEREFOREOFFERINGTHEPOSSIBILITYOFTRADEOFFSBETWEENTHEM4HEEXPERIENCEOF
THE5RUGUAY2OUNDCERTAINLYSUGGESTEDTHATTHESHEERSIZEOFTHEUNDERTAKINGANDTHEEXTENT
OFTHEINTERESTSINVOLVEDINTHEENDMADEFAILUREUNTHINKABLEBUTTHELENGTHANDCOMPLEXITY
OFTHE2OUNDALSOCAUSEDSOMETOBELIEVETHATMORELIMITEDEVENSINGLESECTORNEGOTIATIONS
WOULDPRODUCETANGIBLERESULTSWITHINSHORTPERIODS4HEEXPERIENCEOFTHESECTORAL
NEGOTIATIONSINSERVICESTHROWSSOMELIGHTONTHISQUESTION7HEREASTHERESULTSACHIEVED
INMARITIMETRANSPORTANDTHEMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONSWEREFRANKLYDISAPPOINTINGTHE
NEGOTIATIONSONFINANCIALSERVICESANDBASICTELECOMSWERENOTABLYSUCCESSFUL
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
&INANCIALSERVICES
/FTHEPOST5RUGUAY2OUNDNEGOTIATIONSTHOSEONFINANCIALSERVICESWERETHEMOST
PROTRACTEDBUTULTIMATELYONEOFTHEMOSTSUCCESSFUL!LTHOUGHCOUNTRIESHADMADE
COMMITMENTSONFINANCIALSERVICESINTHE2OUNDTHE5NITED3TATESINPARTICULARTOOKTHE
VIEWTHATCOMMITMENTSBYSOMEIMPORTANTPARTNERSANDTHUSTHEOVERALLPACKAGEWERENOT
ADEQUATETOJUSTIFYAFULL-&.COMMITMENTONITSOWNPART4HISWASCONSISTENTWITHALONG
HELD53POSITIONTHATSINCETHEEXISTINGESSENTIALLYBILATERALINTERNATIONALREGIMEINBANKING
ANDRELATEDSERVICESWORKEDREASONABLYWELLTOINTRODUCEANEWSYSTEMOFMULTILATERAL
OBLIGATIONSCOULDONLYBEJUSTIFIEDIFTHEOVERALLLEVELANDQUALITYOFCOMMITMENTSWERE
SUFFICIENTLYHIGH74/-EMBERSTHEREFOREDECIDEDTOCONTINUENEGOTIATIONSINTHESECTORUNTIL
*UNEADEADLINEWHICHWASLATEREXTENDEDTO*ULY4HESTATEDOBJECTIVE
OFTHENEGOTIATIONWASTOSECURESIGNIFICANTIMPROVEMENTOFTHECOMMITMENTSANDTOHAVE
THEMAPPLIEDONAN-&.BASIS
4HEFURTHERNEGOTIATIONSPRODUCEDSUBSTANTIALIMPROVEMENTSINSCHEDULEDCOMMITMENTS
NOTABLYBYALARGENUMBEROFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDRESULTEDINTHEFULLINTEGRATIONOF
FINANCIALSERVICESINTOTHE'!43THETHREATOFWHOLESALE-&.EXEMPTIONSAMOUNTINGTO
THEVIRTUALEXCLUSIONOFTHESECTORWASENDED)TWASNOTABLETHATTHECONCLUDINGPHASESOF
THENEGOTIATIONCOINCIDEDWITHTHEPEAKOFTHE!SIANFINANCIALCRISISINTHELATTERMONTHSOF
ANDTHATTHECRISISHADNOAPPARENTEFFECTONTHECOMMITMENTOF74/-EMBERSTOTHE
PROCESS
)TWASRECOGNIZEDTHATLIBERALIZATIONOFFINANCIALSERVICESUNDERTHE'!43INNOWAY
COMPROMISEDTHEABILITYOFGOVERNMENTSTOPURSUESTRONGREGULATORYPOLICIESORTOTAKEANY
MEASURESNECESSARYTOSAFEGUARDTHEINTEGRITYOFFINANCIALSYSTEMSANDINDEEDTHATTHE
INTRODUCTIONTHROUGHLIBERALIZATIONOFFOREIGNEQUITYCAPITALANDEXPERTISEMIGHTBEEXPECTED
TOINCREASETHESECTORSRESILIENCETOSHOCKS!SARESULTTHENUMBEROF-EMBERSMAKING
COMMITMENTSINTHISSECTOREXCEEDEDSECONDONLYTOTOURISM)THASSINCEFURTHERRISEN
DUETOCOMMITMENTSMADEBYACCEDINGCOUNTRIES
"ASICTELECOMMUNICATIONS
!LTHOUGHAFEW-EMBERSMADECOMMITMENTSONSERVICESFALLINGWITHINTHEDEFINITIONOF
BASICTELECOMMUNICATIONSERVICESTHEYWEREFORTHEMOSTPARTDELIBERATELYLEFTASIDEINTHE
5RUGUAY2OUND4HEINITIALEXTENSIONWASSCHEDULEDTOENDIN!PRILBUTATTHATPOINT
ITWASAGAINIMPOSSIBLETOREACHAGREEMENTTHATAhCRITICALMASSvOFCOMMITMENTSHADBEEN
ACHIEVEDANDTHENEGOTIATIONSWEREPROLONGEDUNTIL&EBRUARY
!TTHATTIMECOMMITMENTSWEREAGREEDBY-EMBERSANDANNEXEDTOTHE&OURTH
0ROTOCOLTOTHE'!434HEYENTEREDINTOFORCEON&EBRUARY4HEMARKETSOFTHE
PARTICIPATINGCOUNTRIESACCOUNTEDFORMORETHANOFGLOBALTELECOMMUNICATIONS
REVENUES4HESUCCESSOFTHISNEGOTIATIONCLEARLYOWEDAGREATDEALTOTHEPROFOUND
CHANGESTAKINGPLACEATTHETIMEINWORLDTELECOMSMARKETS'OVERNMENTMONOPOLIESWERE
BEINGPRIVATIZEDANDSUBJECTEDTOCOMPETITIONUNDERTHEPRESSUREOFCALLBACKANDOTHER
TECHNOLOGIESWHICHMADEITPOSSIBLETOBYPASSHIGHCOSTMONOPOLYSUPPLIERSANDINRESPONSE
TOGROWINGDEMANDOFUSERINDUSTRIESFORBETTERANDCHEAPERSERVICE
5NDERTHE&OURTH0ROTOCOLMORETHANGOVERNMENTSPERMITTEDCOMPETITIVESUPPLYOF
FIXEDPUBLICVOICETELEPHONYUSUALLYTHROUGHTHEESTABLISHMENTOFACOMMERCIALPRESENCE
'IVENTHATBASICTELECOMMUNICATIONSERVICESHADUNTILVERYRECENTLYBEENREGARDED
EVERYWHEREASAhNATURALMONOPOLYvINWHICHTHECONCEPTOFFOREIGNCOMPETITIONSEEMED
ANOMALOUSTHISWASAREMARKABLEOUTCOME3INCEITWASCLEARTHATINMANYMARKETS
MONOPOLIESORFORMERMONOPOLIESWOULDCONTINUETOBEDOMINANTFORSOMETIMETOCOMEIT
WASNECESSARYTOTAKEMEASURESTOPREVENTTHENULLIFICATIONOFNEGOTIATEDCOMMITMENTSBY
THEABUSEOFMARKETPOWER4HENECESSITYARISESINPARTICULARBECAUSETHEABILITYTOPROVIDE
PUBLICTELEPHONYDEPENDSONHAVINGACCESSTOTHEEXISTINGNETWORKWHICHINMOSTCASES
CONTINUESTOBEOWNEDORCONTROLLEDBYTHEFORMERMONOPOLY)FINTERCONNECTIONWITHTHE
NETWORKWERENOTTOBEAVAILABLEONREASONABLECOMMERCIALTERMSEFFECTIVECOMPETITION
WOULDBEIMPOSSIBLE
4HEPARTICIPANTSTHEREFORENEGOTIATEDASETOFREGULATORYPRINCIPLESINCLUDINGCOMPETITION
SAFEGUARDSINTERCONNECTIONGUARANTEESTRANSPARENCYINLICENSINGINDEPENDENCEOF
REGULATORSCOMPETITIONNEUTRALUNIVERSALSERVICEMECHANISMSANDFAIRNESSINALLOCATING
SCARCERESOURCESSUCHASRADIOSPECTRUMANDRIGHTSOFWAY4HEPRINCIPLESAREINCLUDEDINA
hREFERENCEPAPERvWHICHPARTICIPANTSWEREFREETOINCLUDEINWHOLEORINPARTASLEGALLY
BINDINGADDITIONALCOMMITMENTINTHEIRSCHEDULES&IFTYSEVEN-EMBERSASSUMEDTHESE
OBLIGATIONSINFULLORWITHONLYMINORMODIFICATIONSATTHETIME3IXCHOSETOCOMMITONA
MODIFIEDORSCALEDDOWNSETOFREGULATORYPRINCIPLESANDAFURTHERSIXMADENOREGULATORY
COMMITMENTS
!SINTHECASEOFFINANCIALSERVICESTHELEVELOFPARTICIPATIONBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESIN
THISNEGOTIATIONWASSTRIKING&ORTYSIXDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDCOUNTRIESINTRANSITIONMANY
OFTHEMVERYSMALLMADECOMMITMENTSINADDITIONTOALLOFTHEINDUSTRIALIZED-EMBERS
OFTHE74/4HESTRONGEMPHASISONMODECOMMITMENTSASWELLASDIRECTCONTACTSWITH
THEGOVERNMENTSCONCERNEDMADEITCLEARTHATTHEIRPARTICIPATIONWASSTRONGLYMOTIVATED
BYTHEINTENTIONTOINDUCEFOREIGNDIRECTINVESTMENTINTHESECTORANDTOPUTINCUMBENT
SUPPLIERSUNDERCOMPETITIVEPRESSURE!FTERTHECONCLUSIONOFTHENEGOTIATIONFIVEADDITIONAL
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESUNILATERALLYSUBMITTEDBASICTELECOMSCOMMITMENTSANDTHREEOFTHE
PARTICIPANTSINTHE&OURTH0ROTOCOLIMPROVEDONTHECOMMITMENTSTHEYHADNEGOTIATED4HESE
BINDINGSOFUNILATERALLIBERALIZATIONBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAPPEARTOBEWITHOUTPRECEDENT
ANDTHEYTESTIFYTOTHERECOGNITIONTHATEFFICIENTANDCOMPETITIVETELECOMMUNICATIONSYSTEMS
AREANECESSITYINMODERNECONOMIES)NADDITIONSEVERALDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHAVESOFAR
INCLUDEDCOMMITMENTSONBASICTELECOMMUNICATIONSINTHEIRSCHEDULESOFACCESSIONTOTHE
74/
4HEDECISIONTOCONTINUENEGOTIATIONONMARITIMETRANSPORTSERVICESWASTAKENINTHE
LASTDAYSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDFOLLOWINGDECISIONSBYTHE5NITED3TATESANDTHE%UROPEAN
5NIONTOMAKENOCOMMITMENTSINTHISSECTOR4HIRTYONEOTHER-EMBERSMAINTAINEDTHE
COMMITMENTSWHICHTHEYHADOFFEREDDURINGTHE2OUNDANDITWASAGREEDTOPROLONG
NEGOTIATIONSUNTIL*UNEATWHICHTIME-EMBERSWOULDBEFREETOIMPROVEMAINTAIN
ORWITHDRAWTHEIRCOMMITMENTSANDTOFINALIZE-&.EXEMPTIONS
)THADBEENRECOGNIZEDTHROUGHOUTTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDTHATTHISSECTORPRESENTEDSPECIAL
POLITICALDIFFICULTIESANDTHESEDIFFICULTIESDIDNOTDIMINISHDURINGTHEPERIODOFEXTENDED
NEGOTIATIONS)NDEEDINTHISCASETHEREISSOMEREASONTOBELIEVETHATNEGOTIATORSCAME
CLOSERTOTHEACHIEVEMENTOFASUCCESSFULOUTCOMEINTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDnINTHESENSEOF
THETABLINGOFCOMMITMENTSBYTHE53ANDTHE%5WHICHWOULDNODOUBTHAVESTIMULATED
FURTHERCOMMITMENTSBYOTHERSnTHANWASPOSSIBLEINTHESELFCONTAINEDNEGOTIATIONSOF
WHICHFAILEDTOPRODUCESIGNIFICANTRESULTS/NLYTWOCOUNTRIES)CELANDAND.ORWAY
IMPROVEDONTHECOMMITMENTSTHEYHADMADEINTHE5RUGUAY2OUND#ANADAAND-ALAYSIA
MODIFIEDTHEIREARLIERCOMMITMENTSAND!USTRIAANDTHE$OMINICAN2EPUBLICDECIDEDTO
WITHDRAWTHEM)TWASAGREEDTOSUSPENDTHENEGOTIATIONSANDTORESUMETHEMATTHE
COMMENCEMENTOFTHENEXTCOMPREHENSIVEROUND4HISISTHEREFORETHEONLYSECTORON
WHICHASPECIFICOBLIGATIONTONEGOTIATEINTHENEWROUNDEXISTS)TISALSOTHEONLYSECTOR
FALLINGWITHINTHESCOPEOFTHE'!43INWHICHTHE-&.PRINCIPLEISNOTFULLYAPPLIEDFOR
THOSE-EMBERSNOTMAKINGCOMMITMENTSONMARITIMETRANSPORTTHE-&.OBLIGATIONWAS
SUSPENDEDUNTILTHEENDOFTHENEWROUNDTHOUGHEXISTINGCOMMITMENTSAREOFCOURSE
APPLIEDONAN-&.BASIS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
-ARITIMETRANSPORT
)TSHOULDNOTBECONCLUDEDFROMTHISTHATTHEREISWIDESPREADPROTECTIONISMIN
MARITIMETRANSPORTINWHICHMANYFORMERLYSIGNIFICANTRESTRICTIONSnFOREXAMPLETHESTRICT
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE5NITED.ATIONS#ODEOF#ONDUCTFOR,INER#ONFERENCESBILATERAL
AGREEMENTSWITHSTATETRADINGCOUNTRIESUNILATERALCARGORESERVATIONSPUBLICMONOPOLYOF
HARBOURSERVICESnHAVEGREATLYDIMINISHEDINTHEPASTYEARS.ONETHELESSTHEREARESTILL
SERIOUSOBSTACLESTODOINGBUSINESSWHICHCOULDBEADDRESSEDINNEGOTIATIONS
-OVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONS
4HEEXTENSIONOFNEGOTIATIONSONTHEMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONSWASMOTIVATEDBY
THEDISSATISFACTIONOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWITHTHELEVELOFCOMMITMENTSUNDERTAKENON
MODEWHICHWERELARGELYCONFINEDTOBUSINESSVISITORSANDINTRACORPORATETRANSFERSOF
MANAGERSANDTECHNICALSTAFF6ERYFEW-EMBERSHAVEMADELIBERALCOMMITMENTSINTHIS
MODEFORWHICHMARKETACCESSCONDITIONSTENDTOBESIGNIFICANTLYMORERESTRICTIVETHANFOR
ANYOTHER
.EGOTIATIONSONMODEWEREEXTENDEDUNTIL*UNETHESAMEASTHEORIGINAL
DEADLINEFORFINANCIALSERVICESWITHTHECLEARIMPLICATIONOFANEGOTIATINGLINKBETWEENTHE
TWO)NDEEDSOMECOUNTRIESMADETHEIRPARTICIPATIONINTHEEXTENDEDFINANCIALSERVICES
NEGOTIATIONSCONDITIONALONIMPROVEDOFFERSINMODE)NTHATSENSETHENEGOTIATIONS
ONMODEWERENOTENTIRELYhSELFCONTAINEDv.EVERTHELESSTHEYPRODUCEDNOMAJOR
BREAKTHROUGH!USTRALIA#ANADATHE%5ANDITS-EMBER3TATES)NDIA.ORWAYAND
3WITZERLANDIMPROVEDONTHECOMMITMENTSTHEYHADMADEINTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDAND
THESEIMPROVEMENTSWEREANNEXEDTOTHE4HIRD0ROTOCOLTOTHE'!434HEIMPROVEMENTS
MOSTLYCONCERNACCESSOPPORTUNITIESFORADDITIONALCATEGORIESOFSERVICESUPPLIERSUSUALLY
INDEPENDENTFOREIGNPROFESSIONALSINANUMBEROFBUSINESSSECTORSORTHEEXTENSIONOFTHEIR
PERMITTEDDURATIONOFSTAY
2ULEMAKINGAGENDA
!PARTFROMTHEMANDATEUNDER!RTICLE8)8EMBODYINGTHEPRINCIPLEOFPROGRESSIVE
LIBERALIZATIONINSUBSEQUENTTRADEROUNDSTHE'!43CONTAINSFOURRULEMAKINGMANDATES
4HEYREFLECTTHATWITHINTHECONSTRAINTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUND-EMBERSWERENOTABLE
TOFULLYEXPLORETHENEEDFORORTHENECESSARYDEPTHOFRULESINCERTAINAREASTHATMAY
SIGNIFICANTLYAFFECTTRADEINSERVICES4HECONTINUEDEXISTENCEOFhWHITESPOTSvINTHE
FRAMEWORKOF'!43MAYNOTONLYBEATTRIBUTABLETOTIMEPRESSUREATTHECONCLUDINGSTAGES
OFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDBUTALSOTOTHEPARTICULARSTRUCTUREOF'!43INCLUDINGTHECONCEPT
OFFOURMODESOFSUPPLYWHICHPREVENTEDNEGOTIATORSTOSIMPLYTRANSPOSECERTAINEXISTING
CONCEPTSFROM'!44INTO'!43
!LTHOUGHTHERULEMAKINGNEGOTIATIONSHAVESTARTEDRELATIVELYSOONAFTERTHECONCLUSION
OFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRELATIVELYLITTLEHEADWAYHASBEENMADETODATE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
$OMESTICREGULATION
4HECOREELEMENTSOFTHE'UIDELINESIN
ADDITIONTOAREMINDEROFTHENOTIFICATION
REQUIREMENTSUNDER!RTICLE6))OFTHE'!43ARE
RECOMMENDATIONSONTHEFORMANDCONTENTOF
-2!S4HE'UIDELINESSTATETHAT-2!SSHOULD
CLEARLYIDENTIFYTHEPARTICIPANTSPURPOSE
OFTHEAGREEMENTSCOPEOFTHEAGREEMENT
DETAILSOFTHEMUTUALRECOGNITIONPROVISIONS
INCLUDINGELIGIBILITYREQUIREMENTSFORRECOGNITION
ASWELLASSPECIFICATIONOFTHECONDITIONS
UNDERWHICHANYADDITIONALSUPPLEMENTARY
REQUIREMENTSMAYBEAPPLIEDMECHANISMSFOR
IMPLEMENTATIONFURTHERLICENSINGORRELATED
REQUIREMENTSANDTERMSFORREVISIONOFTHE
AGREEMENT
!SNOTEDBEFORETHE'!43MAKESACLEARDISTINCTIONBETWEENSPECIFICCOMMITMENTSAS
SPECIFIEDINA-EMBERSSCHEDULEANDTHERIGHTTOPURSUENATIONALPOLICYOBJECTIVESBYWAY
OFREGULATION.EVERTHELESSTHEREMAYBEDIFFERENTOPTIONSTOPURSUETHESAMEREGULATORY
OBJECTIVEANDITAPPEARSONLYREASONABLETOPREVENTTHEGOVERNMENTCONCERNEDFROMUSING
MEASURESTHATAREUNDULYTRADERESTRICTIVE4HISOBJECTIVEISREFLECTEDIN!RTICLE6)OFTHE
'!43WHICHREFERSTOTHREESPECIFICTYPESOFDOMESTICREGULATIONLICENSINGREQUIREMENTS
ANDPROCEDURESQUALIFICATIONREQUIREMENTSANDPROCEDURESANDTECHNICALSTANDARDSAND
MANDATESTHEDEVELOPMENTOFhANYNECESSARYDISCIPLINESv
2ECOGNIZINGASWELLTHATGOVERNMENTREGULATIONISESPECIALLYPERVASIVEINPROFESSIONAL
SERVICESTHEFIRSTSTEPINIMPLEMENTINGTHISMANDATEWASTHE-INISTERIAL$ECISIONON
0ROFESSIONAL3ERVICESANDTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE7ORKING0ARTYON0ROFESSIONAL3ERVICES
7003!FTERSEVERALYEARSOFDIFFICULTDISCUSSIONSESPECIALLYINREGARDTOTHEDELIMITATION
OF!RTICLE6)WITHRESPECTTOTHEMARKETACCESSANDNATIONALTREATMENTPROVISIONSOF!RTICLES
86)AND86))OFTHE'!4374/-EMBERSSUCCEEDEDINCREATINGTHEVOLUNTARY'UIDELINESFOR
-UTUAL2ECOGNITION!GREEMENTSOR!RRANGEMENTSINTHE!CCOUNTANCY3ECTOR 74/DOCUMENT
3,DATED-AYFOLLOWEDBYTHEMANDATORY$ISCIPLINESON$OMESTIC2EGULATION
INTHE!CCOUNTANCY3ECTOR74/DOCUMENT3,DATED$ECEMBER
4HESE!CCOUNTANCY$ISCIPLINESARETHEMOREIMPORTANTOFTHETWOAGREEMENTS4HEYARE
VERYCONCISECOMPRISINGONLYPARAGRAPHSINFOURPAGESSIXPAGESWITHTHEAPPENDIX
4HEMAINACHIEVEMENTISTHATTHE$ISCIPLINESMANDATEAhNECESSITYTESTvFORALLAPPLICABLE
REGULATORYMEASURES74/-EMBERSAREALSOREQUIREDTOEXPLAINUPONREQUESTTHE
SPECIFICOBJECTIVESINTENDEDBYTHEIRACCOUNTANCYREGULATIONSANDAREASKEDTOPROVIDEAN
OPPORTUNITYFORTRADINGPARTNERSTOCOMMENTUPONPROPOSEDACCOUNTANCYREGULATIONSANDTO
GIVECONSIDERATIONTOSUCHCOMMENTS(OWEVERTHE$ISCIPLINESHAVENOTYETBECOMELEGALLY
ENFORCEABLE
4HE$ECISIONOFTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESADOPTINGTHE$ISCIPLINES74/DOCUMENT
3,DATED$ECEMBERSTATESTHATBEFORETHEENDOFTHECURRENTROUNDOF
SERVICESNEGOTIATIONSTHE!CCOUNTANCY$ISCIPLINESANDANYREGULATORYDISCIPLINESDEVELOPED
SUBSEQUENTLYARETOBEINTEGRATEDINTOTHE'!43ANDWILLTHENBECOMEBINDING
"OTHTHE!CCOUNTANCY$ISCIPLINESANDTHE-2!'UIDELINESAREVERYGENERALINSCOPE
ANDADDRESSTHEMOSTFUNDAMENTALMEANSBYWHICHTRADEINACCOUNTANCYANDPOTENTIALLY
INMANYOTHERSERVICESSECTORSCOULDBEOBSTRUCTED)NTHISREGARDTHEYSERVEASAN
INDICATORTOOTHERSERVICESSECTORSTHATTHE74/ISATSOMEPOINTLIKELYTOADDRESSTHEIR
REGULATORYBARRIERSASWELL4HE !CCOUNTANCY$ISCIPLINESAREALSOWELLSUITEDTOSERVEAS
THEFOUNDATIONFORTHESUBSEQUENTDEVELOPMENTOFHORIZONTALLYAPPLICABLEDISCIPLINESFOR
PROFESSIONALSERVICESANDPROBABLYFORTRADEINSERVICESINGENERALASWELLASFORTHE
DEVELOPMENTOFSPECIFICSECTORALMEASURES4HISPOTENTIALLYEXPANDEDAPPLICATIONISTHE
MAINELEMENTOFTHECURRENT'!43WORKONDOMESTICREGULATIONASCONDUCTEDBYTHE
7ORKING0ARTYON$OMESTIC2EGULATION70$2WHICHREPLACEDTHE7ORKING0ARTYON
0ROFESSIONAL3ERVICESIN!PRIL
.EGOTIATINGMANDATEPROGRESSIVELIBERALIZATION
5NLIKETHE'!44THE'!43EXPLICITLYPROVIDESFORFUTURETRADENEGOTIATIONS!CCORDING
TO!RTICLE8)874/-EMBERSARECOMMITTEDTOENTERINTOSUCCESSIVEROUNDSOFSUCH
NEGOTIATIONSTHEFIRSTOFWHICHWASTOSTARThNOTLATERTHANFIVEYEARSFROMTHEDATEOFENTRY
INTOFORCEOFTHE74/!GREEMENTvIE*ANUARY4HEFAILUREOFTHE3EATTLE-INISTERIAL
-EETINGINLATETHUSDIDNOTPREVENTTHESENEGOTIATIONSFROMBEINGLAUNCHED
.EVERTHELESSTHEOVERALLCLIMATEHADDETERIORATEDANDITTOOKMORETHANONEYEARUNTIL
DELEGATIONSIN'ENEVAWEREABLETOAGREEUPONANEGOTIATINGMANDATEFORSERVICES
4HE3EATTLE$RAFT-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONHADCONTAINEDSUCHAMANDATEWHICHINITIALLY
MUSTEREDBROADSUPPORTBUTNOLONGERPROVEDACCEPTABLETOALL-EMBERSASABASISFOR
SINGLETRACKNEGOTIATIONS
)N-ARCHTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICESIN3PECIAL3ESSIONFINALLYAPPROVED
THE@'UIDELINESAND0ROCEDURESFORTHE.EGOTIATIONSON4RADEIN3ERVICES4HETWOPAGE
DOCUMENTINTHREEPARTSBUILDSTOALARGEEXTENTONRELEVANT'!43PROVISIONSINPARTICULAR
!RTICLE)6@)NCREASING0ARTICIPATIONOF$EVELOPING#OUNTRIESAND!RTICLE8)8@.EGOTIATIONOF
3PECIFIC#OMMITMENTS4HE'UIDELINESMAINCONTENTMAYBESUMMARIZEDASFOLLOWS /BJECTIVESAND0RINCIPLES
#ONFIRMATIONOFTHEOBJECTIVEOFPROGRESSIVELIBERALIZATIONASENSHRINEDINRELEVANT
'!43PROVISIONSAPPROPRIATEFLEXIBILITYFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWITHSPECIALPRIORITY
TOBEGIVENTOLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESREFERENCETOTHENEEDSOFSMALLAND
MEDIUMSIZEDSERVICESUPPLIERSPARTICULARLYOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDCOMMITMENT
TORESPECThTHEEXISTINGSTRUCTUREANDPRINCIPLESOFTHE'!43vEGTHEBOTTOMUP
APPROACHTOSCHEDULINGANDTHEFOURMODESOFSUPPLY
3COPE
.OSECTORSORMODESAREEXCLUDEDAPRIORISPECIALATTENTIONTOBEGIVENTOEXPORT
INTERESTSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESRENEGOTIATIONOFEXISTING-&.EXEMPTIONS
-ODALITIESAND0ROCEDURES
#URRENTSCHEDULESASTHESTARTINGPOINTRATHERTHANACTUALMARKETCONDITIONSREQUEST
OFFERNEGOTIATIONSASTHEMAINAPPROACH!RTICLE8)8OFTHE'!43SIMPLYREFERSTOTHE
POSSIBILITYOFBILATERALPLURILATERALANDMULTILATERALNEGOTIATIONSBUTDOESNOTESTABLISH
PRIORITIESNEGOTIATINGCREDITFORAUTONOMOUSLIBERALIZATIONBASEDONCOMMONCRITERIA
ONGOINGASSESSMENTOFTRADEINSERVICES MANDATEFORTHE3ERVICES#OUNCILTOEVALUATE
THERESULTSOFTHENEGOTIATIONSPRIORTOTHEIRCOMPLETIONINTHELIGHTOF!RTICLE)6
%LEMENTSTHATGOBEYONDEXISTING'!43
PROVISIONSAREINITALICS
4HESECRITERIAWEREDEVELOPEDLATERBYTHE
3ERVICES#OUNCIL@-ODALITIESFORTHE4REATMENT
OF!UTONOMOUS,IBERALIZATIONIN74/
DOCUMENT4.3OF-ARCH
4HISASSESSMENTWASNOTINITIALLYCONCEIVED
ASANONGOINGPROCESSBUTSHOULDHAVEBEEN
CONDUCTEDFORTHEPURPOSEOFESTABLISHINGTHE
.EGOTIATING'UIDELINES!RTICLE8)8
)NKEEPINGWITHANOTHERMANDATEUNDER!RTICLE8)8THE.EGOTIATING'UIDELINESWERE
COMPLEMENTEDLATERBYTHE@-ODALITIESFORTHE3PECIAL4REATMENTFOR,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRY
-EMBERS4.34HE-ODALITIESAREINTENDEDTOENSUREhMAXIMUMFLEXIBILITYvFOR,$#S
INTHENEGOTIATIONS-OREOVERALL-EMBERSARECOMMITTEDINTERALIATOEXERCISINGRESTRAINTIN
SEEKINGCOMMITMENTSFROM,$#SASWELLASINPREPARINGTHEIROWNSCHEDULESGIVINGSPECIAL
PRIORITYTOSECTORSANDMODESOFEXPORTINTERESTTOTHESE-EMBERS)NTURNLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESARECALLEDUPONTOINDICATETHEIRPRIORITYSECTORSANDMODESSOTHATTHESECANBE
TAKENINTOACCOUNT2EFERRINGTOMODETHE-ODALITIESRECOGNIZETHEPOTENTIALBENEFITS
PROVIDEDBYTHEMOVEMENTOFNATURALPERSONSTOBOTHSENDINGANDRECIPIENTCOUNTRIES
&URTHER-EMBERSENVISAGETOTHEEXTENTPOSSIBLEANDCONSISTENTLYWITH!RTICLE8)8OFTHE
'!43TOUNDERTAKECOMMITMENTSONTHATMODETAKINGINTOACCOUNThALLCATEGORIESOFNATURAL
PERSONSIDENTIFIEDBY,$#SINTHEIRREQUESTSv
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
)NVIEWOFTHERELATIVELYDETAILED.EGOTIATING'UIDELINESOF-ARCHANDTHE
ABSORPTIONOF-EMBERSATTENTIONBYOTHERISSUESTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION
ESSENTIALLYCONFINEDITSELFTOENDORSINGTHE'UIDELINESANDINTEGRATINGTHESERVICES
NEGOTIATIONSINCLUDINGTHERULEMAKINGPARTSINTHEWIDERFRAMEWORKOFTHE$OHA
$EVELOPMENT!GENDA4HE$OHA$ECLARATIONCONTAINSTARGETDATESFORTHECIRCULATIONOFINITIAL
REQUESTS*UNEANDINITIALOFFERS-ARCHOFSPECIFICCOMMITMENTSAND
ENVISAGESALLNEGOTIATIONSWHICHFORMPARTOFASINGLEUNDERTAKINGTOBECONCLUDEDNOTLATER
THAN*ANUARY
4HE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINEARLY3EPTEMBERMARKEDANEWSETBACKINTHE
PROGRESSOFNEGOTIATIONS4HECONCLUDING3TATEMENTMERELYREAFFIRMEDTHE$OHA$ECLARATIONS
AND$ECISIONSANDRECOMMITTED-EMBERShTOWORKINGTOIMPLEMENTTHEMFULLYAND
FAITHFULLYv2EFLECTINGTHELACKOFPOLITICALIMPETUSTHEREQUESTANDOFFERPROCESSINSERVICES
VIRTUALLYGROUNDTOAHALTINTHEWAKEOF#ANCÞN)TWASNOTUNTILMIDTHATTHE
SOCALLED*ULY0ACKAGE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMMEn$ECISIONADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
ON!UGUSTINJECTEDNEWMOMENTUMINTOTHENEGOTIATIONS
7ITHREGARDTOSERVICESTHE*ULY0ACKAGECONTAINSATARGETDATEOF-AYFORTHE
SUBMISSIONOFREVISEDOFFERSANDADOPTSASETOFRECOMMENDATIONSTHATHADBEENAGREED
BEFOREBYTHE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES3PECIAL3ESSION4HESEINCLUDERECOMMENDATIONS
FOR-EMBERSTHATHAVENOTYETSUBMITTEDINITIALOFFERSTODOSOASSOONASPOSSIBLEENSURING
AHIGHQUALITYOFOFFERSINPARTICULARINSECTORSANDMODESOFEXPORTINTERESTTODEVELOPING
COUNTRIESWITHSPECIALATTENTIONBEINGGIVENTOLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESINTENSIFYINGEFFORTS
TOCONCLUDETHERULEMAKINGNEGOTIATIONSUNDER!RTICLES6)88)))AND86INACCORDANCE
WITHTHEIRMANDATESANDDEADLINESANDPROVIDINGhTARGETEDvTECHNICALASSISTANCETO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWITHAVIEWTOENABLINGTHEMTOPARTICIPATEEFFECTIVELY)NADDITION
THE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN3ERVICES3PECIAL3ESSIONISMANDATEDTOREVIEWPROGRESSINTHE
NEGOTIATIONSANDPROVIDEAFULLREPORTTOTHE4RADE.EGOTIATING#OMMITTEEINCLUDINGPOSSIBLE
RECOMMENDATIONSFORTHEPURPOSEOFTHE3IXTH-INISTERIAL-EETINGIN$ECEMBER
3COPEFORCHANGEINTHECURRENT2OUND
-ANYCURRENTSCHEDULESWITHTHEPOSSIBLEEXCEPTIONOFTHOSESUBMITTEDBYRECENTLY
ACCEDINGCOUNTRIESOFFERSCOPEFORSIGNIFICANTIMPROVEMENTS4HE5RUGUAY2OUNDPROVEDA
LANDMARKEVENTBECAUSEITHELPEDTOESTABLISHASETOFMULTILATERALRULESFORSERVICESTRADE
ANDTHEARCHITECTUREFORFUTURENEGOTIATINGROUNDS!SINDICATEDBEFOREHOWEVERJUDGED
BYTHEBREADTHANDDEPTHOFMOSTCURRENTCOMMITMENTSTHE2OUNDWILLCERTAINLYNOTBE
REMEMBEREDFORITSCONTRIBUTIONTOLIBERALIZATIONOFSERVICESTRADE POSSIBLEEXCEPTIONSARE
THEEXTENDEDNEGOTIATIONSINBASICTELECOMMUNICATIONSANDFINANCIALSERVICES
7HILEDEVELOPINGECONOMIESHAVEUNDERTAKENFEWERCOMMITMENTSONAVERAGETHANOTHER
-EMBERS4ABLEMANYOFTHEMHAVEIMPLEMENTEDSWEEPINGREFORMSINRECENTYEARS
3INCESUCHREFORMSHAVEOFTENBEENASSOCIATEDWITHPROFOUNDINSTITUTIONALCHANGESEGTHE
ABOLITIONOFPREVIOUSTELECOMTRANSPORTORINSURANCEMONOPOLIESTHEYMAYPROVEIRREVERSIBLE
ANDTHUSCOULDNOTEASILYBEUSEDASNEGOTIATINGCOINAGE4OBOLSTERTHEIRNEGOTIATING
POSITIONNEVERTHELESSTHEGOVERNMENTSCONCERNEDMAYREFERTOANDSEEKCREDITUNDERTHE
@-ODALITIESFORTHE4REATMENTOF!UTONOMOUS,IBERALIZATIONADOPTEDBYTHE3ERVICES#OUNCIL
3PECIAL3ESSIONIN-ARCH
7HEREDO-EMBERSCURRENTLYSTANDINTHEREQUESTANDOFFERPROCESS
4HEREARENO74/DOCUMENTSTHATCOULDBEUSEDTOTRACETHEINITIALREQUESTSTHAT
HAVEBEENEXCHANGEDTODATEBETWEEN-EMBERS4HISSTAGEINTHENEGOTIATINGPROCESSIS
ESSENTIALLYBILATERALINNATUREANDISNOTSUBJECTTOANYFURTHERINFORMATIONORNOTIFICATION
REQUIREMENTSLETALONEGUIDELINESCONCERNINGTHESTRUCTUREORCONTENTOFREQUESTS)TISFOR
INDIVIDUAL-EMBERSTODECIDEWHOMTOAPPROACHINWHATFORMANDWHATISSUESTORAISE
UNDERRELEVANT'!43PROVISIONS!NNEXON!RTICLE))%XEMPTIONSASWELLAS!RTICLES86)86))
AND86)))4HEREISTHUSNOBASISTOJUDGEWHETHERANDTOWHATEXTENTLEASTDEVELOPED
PARTICIPANTSHAVEINFACTUSEDTHISEXERCISETOINDICATETHESECTORSANDMODEShTHATREPRESENT
PRIORITYINTHEIRDEVELOPMENTPOLICIESSOTHAT-EMBERSTAKETHESEPRIORITIESINTOACCOUNTIN
THENEGOTIATIONSv !NECDOTALEVIDENCESUGGESTSTHATLARGEDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESHAVECIRCULATEDREQUESTSTO
ALMOSTALLOTHER-EMBERSCOVERINGAWIDERANGEOFSERVICESANDTHATMOSTECONOMICALLY
ADVANCEDDEVELOPING-EMBERSHAVEACTIVELYPARTICIPATEDINTHISPROCESSASWELL4HEREMAY
THUSBENO74/-EMBERTHATHASNOTRECEIVEDATLEASTAHANDFULOFREQUESTSTODATE4HE
INITIALOFFERSOFNEWORIMPROVEDCOMMITMENTSAREMADEKNOWNTOALL74/-EMBERSSINCE
THEENTIREMEMBERSHIPMAYBEAFFECTEDBYTHESECOMMITMENTSENTRYINTOFORCE%NVISAGED
AMENDMENTSAREINSCRIBEDINTOTHEEXISTINGSCHEDULESANDMADECOMMONLYAVAILABLEVIATHE
74/3ECRETARIAT
7HILETHEREQUESTANDOFFERPROCESSSEEMSTOHAVEPROGRESSEDSMOOTHLYTODATEATLEAST
INPROCEDURALTERMSSOMEQUALIFICATIONSMAYBENEEDED&IRSTTHEOVERALLMOMENTUMHAS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
3EEFOREXAMPLEANINFORMALNOTEOFTHE74/
3ECRETARIATOF*UNE@4HE$EVELOPMENTAL
)MPACTOF3ERVICES,IBERALIZATIONUNDER'!43
74/DOCUMENT*OB2EV
74/DOCUMENT4.3OF3EPTEMBER
PARA
NOTBEENPARTICULARLYIMPRESSIVE!TTHETARGETDATEOF-ARCHONLYOFFERSWERE
AVAILABLETOBEFOLLOWEDBYMORESUBMISSIONSPRIORTOTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL-EETINGIN
EARLY3EPTEMBER "YMID*ANUARYTHETOTALNUMBERHADINCREASEDTOCOVERINGOVER74/-EMBERS
WHICHISCLOSETOPERCENTOFTHEMEMBERSHIPPERCENTIFLEASTDEVELOPEDECONOMIES
ANDRECENTLYACCEDING-EMBERSAREEXCLUDED
3ECONDTHEREGIONALDISTRIBUTIONHASREMAINEDUNEVEN7HILERELATIVELYMANYCOUNTRIES
FROM,ATIN!MERICAANDDESPITESIGNIFICANTGAPS!SIAHAVEMADECONTRIBUTIONS!FRICAAND
THE!RABREGIONHAVEREMAINEDLARGELYONTHESIDELINES
4HIRDTHEREISASENSEOFDISAPPOINTMENTCONCERNINGTHE@QUALITYOFOFFERSBOTHIN
TERMSOFNEWSECTORINCLUSIONSANDIMPROVEMENTSOFEXISTINGCOMMITMENTS4HEOVERALL
EMPHASISISONTHESECTORSANDMODESTHATALREADYDOMINATEEXISTINGSCHEDULESWITH
RELATIVELYFEWSIGNIFICANTCHANGESINhSENSITIVEvAREASSUCHASEDUCATIONHEALTHANDOTHER
SOCIALSERVICES#HARTASWELLASMODE 4HUSTHEOVERALLFOCUSHASBEENONIMPROVING
EXISTINGCOMMITMENTSRATHERTHANINSCRIBINGNEWSECTORS#HART(OWEVERTHEPICTUREMAY
CHANGEASARESULTOFADDITIONALDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINPARTICULARTHOSETHATREFRAINEDFROM
UNDERTAKINGBROADCOMMITMENTSINTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDPARTICIPATINGINTHISPROCESS
3INCETHEINITIALOFFERSARESTEPSINALONGERNEGOTIATINGPROCESSITISTOOEARLYTOPASS
JUDGEMENT(EEDINGTHERECOMMENDATIONSCONTAINEDINTHE*ULY0ACKAGEASIGNIFICANT
NUMBEROFGOVERNMENTSCANSTILLBEEXPECTEDTOPREPAREANDSUBMITOFFERSWHILEOTHERSWILL
BEREVISINGnANDUPGRADINGnTHEIREXISTINGOFFERSBY-AY4HEEXTENTTOWHICHTHESE
EXPECTATIONSMATERIALIZEANDTHEFINALOUTCOMEOFALLSERVICESNEGOTIATIONSINCLUDINGTHOSE
ONRULESARESTILLSUBJECTTOANELEMENTOFUNCERTAINTYHOWEVER'IVENTHECONCEPTOF3INGLE
5NDERTAKINGMANY-EMBERSMAYMAKETHEIRFINALPOSITIONCONTINGENTONPROGRESSBEING
ACHIEVEDACROSSALLAREASOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
)NCLUDINGONESCHEDULEFORTHETHEN
-EMBER3TATESOFTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIES
)NTHE74/3ECRETARIATPREPARED
TWOBACKGROUNDNOTESDISCUSSINGRESPECTIVELY
THESTRUCTUREOFCOMMITMENTSSCHEDULEDUNDER
MODE74/DOCUMENT3#7ANDTHOSE
ASSUMEDFORMODESAND74/DOCUMENT
3#7
#HART3ECTORPROFILEOFINITIALOFFERS.OVEMBER
'!" '!"
&#!!#$
!
%$
!
%
!
(
%
"%
$"
#
#%
%
%
!#
$"
#)
#
!
#%
%
$
%
!#
(
!#
"
%#
%
#
#
$"
#
%
%!
#$
!
&
%
'
$
#
'
#!
$%
$
%
&
#
#&
$%
!
%
!
!
&%
!
%
%!
!
#
&
$
!
$
&
&
$$
#
'
%!
$
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
#HART#ONTENTOFINITIALOFFERSNEWCOMMITMENTSVERSUSIMPROVEMENTS.OVEMBER
(
&#!!#$
"#!' %$
%
!#
)
%
$"
%
#%
#
#
"
#%
#
#
$"
%
!#
%
#
%#
%!
$"
!#
%
#$
!
&
$
#!
'
#'
&
$
%
!
%
&%
#
$%
#&
$%
!
!
#
%
!
!
%
!
%
&
&
!
&
$
$
$$
#
'
%!
$
-ARKETACCESS
$OHANONAGRICULTURALMARKETACCESS.!-!NEGOTIATIONS
/NEOFTHEMAJORACHIEVEMENTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDNEGOTIATIONSINTHEAREAOFTARIFFS
WASTHEENHANCEMENTOFTHESECURITYANDPREDICTABILITYOFTHETRADINGENVIRONMENTTHROUGH
THESUBSTANTIALINCREASEINTHENUMBEROFBINDINGS$EVELOPEDCOUNTRIESINCREASEDTHETOTAL
NUMBEROFBOUNDTARIFFLINESFROMTOWHILEDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCREASEDTHEIR
BINDINGSFROMTO!SOFTODAY-EMBERSHAVEBINDINGCOMMITMENTSONMORE
THANOFTHEIRNONAGRICULTURALTARIFFLINESCOUNTINGTHE%#ASONEONMORETHAN
OFTHEIRNONAGRICULTURALTARIFFLINESTENONMORETHAN/NLY-EMBERSHAVE
BINDINGSONLESSTHANOFTHEIRNONAGRICULTURALTARIFFLINES)NTHEAREAOFTARIFFCUTSFOR
INDUSTRIALPRODUCTSTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRESULTEDINATRADEWEIGHTEDTARIFFAVERAGEREDUCTION
OFFROMTOFORDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES(OWEVERITISCLEARTHATWHILEA
SUBSTANTIALLYHIGHERDEGREEOFMARKETSECURITYFORTRADERSANDINVESTORSWASACHIEVEDATTHE
ENDOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDMANYSPECIFICISSUESCONTINUETOCREATEDIFFICULTIESFORTRADERS
INCLUDINGHIGHDUTIESTARIFFPEAKSANDTARIFFESCALATION4HISSITUATIONISWHATTHE$OHA
NONAGRICULTURALMARKETACCESSNEGOTIATIONS.!-!SEEKTOADDRESSALONGWITHNONTARIFF
BARRIERSWHICHHAVEBEENCONSIDEREDBYMANYASBEINGFARMOREPROBLEMATICTHANTARIFFS
3PECIFICALLYTHE$OHAMANDATEON.!-!FORESEESTHEFOLLOWING
7EAGREETONEGOTIATIONSWHICHSHALLAIMBYMODALITIESTOBEAGREEDTO
REDUCEORASAPPROPRIATEELIMINATETARIFFSINCLUDINGTHEREDUCTIONORELIMINATIONOF
TARIFFPEAKSHIGHTARIFFSANDTARIFFESCALATIONASWELLASNONTARIFFBARRIERSINPARTICULAR
ONPRODUCTSOFEXPORTINTERESTTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES0RODUCTCOVERAGESHALLBE
COMPREHENSIVEANDWITHOUTAPRIORIEXCLUSIONS4HENEGOTIATIONSSHALLTAKEFULLYINTO
ACCOUNTTHESPECIALNEEDSANDINTERESTSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY
PARTICIPANTSINCLUDINGTHROUGHLESSTHANFULLRECIPROCITYINREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTSIN
ACCORDANCEWITHTHERELEVANTPROVISIONSOF!RTICLE886)))BISOF'!44ANDTHE
PROVISIONSCITEDINPARAGRAPHBELOW4OTHISENDTHEMODALITIESTOBEAGREEDWILL
INCLUDEAPPROPRIATESTUDIESANDCAPACITYBUILDINGMEASURESTOASSISTLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESTOPARTICIPATEEFFECTIVELYINTHENEGOTIATIONS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4HE.EGOTIATING'ROUPON-ARKET!CCESS.'-!BEGANWORKINGINEARLYON
DEVELOPINGAPROGRAMMEOFWORKWHICHITFINALLYAPPROVEDON*ULY4HISPROGRAMME
ENVISAGEDTHESUBMISSIONOFPROPOSALSONMODALITIESFORMARKETACCESSNEGOTIATIONSIN
THEYEARWITHAVIEWTOPRODUCINGANOVERVIEWOFSUCHPROPOSALSATTHEBEGINNING
OF)TWASENVISAGEDFURTHERTHAT-EMBERSWOULDREACHACOMMONUNDERSTANDING
ONAPOSSIBLEOUTLINEOFMODALITIESBYTHEENDOF-ARCHANDANAGREEMENTON
MODALITIESBY-AY(OWEVERINSPITEOFEFFORTSMADEBYPARTICIPANTSTHEDEADLINE
WASMISSEDANDWORKSHIFTEDTOWARDSAGREEINGONAh&RAMEWORKvFORMODALITIESBYTHE
#ANCÞN-INISTERIALMEETING4HEIDEAWASTOCAPTURECONVERGENCEINSOMEKEYAREASWHILE
ALLOWINGTHENEGOTIATIONSTOMOVETOWARDShFINALMODALITIESvATALATERSTAGE4ODATESOME
-EMBERSHAVEPRESENTEDMORETHANINDIVIDUALANDCOLLECTIVESUBMISSIONSTOTHE
.'-!INDICATINGHOWTHEYCONSIDERTHE$OHAMANDATESHOULDBEFULFILLEDINTHISAREA
4HE*ULY0ACKAGE
4HELATESTSTEPIN.!-!HASBEEN!NNEX"OFTHEDECISIONOF!UGUSTONA
&RAMEWORKCONTAININGTHEINITIALELEMENTSFORFUTUREWORKONMODALITIES4HISDECISIONALSO
RECOGNIZESTHATADDITIONALNEGOTIATIONSAREREQUIREDTOREACHAGREEMENTONTHESPECIFICS
OFFIVEELEMENTSTHEFORMULATHEISSUESCONCERNINGTHETREATMENTOFUNBOUNDTARIFFSTHE
FLEXIBILITIESFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYPARTICIPANTSTHEISSUEOFPARTICIPATIONINTHESECTORAL
TARIFFCOMPONENTANDTHEPREFERENCES4HE.'-!WASINSTRUCTEDTOADDRESSTHESEISSUES
EXPEDITIOUSLYINAMANNERCONSISTENTWITHTHEMANDATEOFPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA
-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONANDTHEOVERALLBALANCETHEREIN
4HE&RAMEWORKON.!-!CONSTITUTESAMAJORSTEPFORWARDASITPROVIDESDIRECTIONTOTHE
NEGOTIATIONSINSOMEOFTHEMAJORISSUES%QUALLYITFLESHESOUTTHEFLEXIBILITIESTHATCOULDBE
GIVENTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCLUDINGTHEEXEMPTIONOFLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESFROM
ANYTARIFFCUT4ECHNICALWORKIN'ENEVAHASALREADYTOUCHEDONAVARIETYOFISSUESINCLUDING
PRODUCTCOVERAGETHETREATMENTOFTARIFFPEAKSHIGHTARIFFSANDTARIFFESCALATIONTHROUGH
THEFORMULAPARTICIPATIONINSECTORALNEGOTIATIONSTHECALCULATIONOFADVALOREMEQUIVALENTS
!6%STHEIDENTIFICATIONOFPRODUCTSOFEXPORTINTERESTTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHEPOSSIBLE
WAYSTOREFLECTTHEPRINCIPLESOFSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTANDLESSTHANFULL
RECIPROCITYINREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTSTHESPECIALPROVISIONSTHATCOULDBEAPPLIEDBYNEWLY
ACCEDED-EMBERSTHEELIMINATIONOFLOWDUTIESNONRECIPROCALPREFERENCESTARIFFREVENUE
DEPENDENCYENVIRONMENTALGOODSASWELLASAPPROPRIATESTUDIESANDCAPACITYBUILDING
MEASURESFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES!SUBSTANTIALAMOUNTOF
TECHNICALWORKANDDIFFICULTPOLITICALDECISIONSARESTILLREQUIREDTOTRANSLATETHIS&RAMEWORK
INTOFULLFLEDGEDMODALITIES
7ORKONNONTARIFFBARRIERSHASPROGRESSEDATASLOWERPACETHANONTARIFFS4HE.'-!
HASBEENGRAPPLINGWITHTWOFUNDAMENTALQUESTIONSWHAT.ON4ARIFF"ARRIERS.4"SSHOULD
BEADDRESSEDINTHE.'-!ANDHOWSHOULDTHEYBEADDRESSED!SAFIRSTSTEPTOANSWERING
THESEQUESTIONSTHE'ROUPEMBARKEDONANIDENTIFICATIONEXERCISEWHERE-EMBERSWERE
REQUESTEDTOIDENTIFY.4"STHATTHEYFELTSHOULDBEADDRESSEDINTHE'ROUP4HE.'-!WILL
NOWBEENGAGEDINAPROCESSOFEXAMININGTHESENOTIFICATIONS)NPARALLELTOTHISMULTILATERAL
PROCESSTHEREHASBEENANEMERGENCEOFAhVERTICAL.4"PROCESSvWHEREINTERESTED
-EMBERSARELOOKINGAT.4"SAFFECTINGAPARTICULARSECTOR0ROPOSALSINTHISREGARDHAVE
COVEREDELECTRONICSAUTOANDAUTOPARTSANDWOODPRODUCTS
#OUNCILFORTRADEINGOODS
4HE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSOVERSEESTHEFUNCTIONINGOFALL-ULTILATERAL4RADE
!GREEMENTSIN'OODSWHICHARETHE'!44THE!GREEMENTSON!GRICULTURE!PPLICATION
OF3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURES4EXTILESAND#LOTHING 4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADE
4RADE2ELATED)NVESTMENT-EASURES!NTI$UMPING#USTOMS6ALUATION0RESHIPMENT
)NSPECTION2ULESOF/RIGIN)MPORT,ICENSING0ROCEDURES3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING
-EASURESAND3AFEGUARDS
4HE'OODS#OUNCILHASCOMMITTEESDEALINGWITHTHEABOVEMENTIONEDAGREEMENTS
)NADDITIONTHEFOLLOWINGBODIESALSOREPORTTOTHE#OUNCIL#OMMITTEEON-ARKET!CCESS
4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODYTHE7ORKING0ARTYON3TATE4RADING%NTERPRISESANDTHE#OMMITTEE
OF0ARTICIPANTSONTHE%XPANSIONOF4RADEIN)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY0RODUCTS
4HE#OUNCILHASCONSIDEREDINPASTYEARSDIFFERENTREQUESTSFORWAIVERSFROM-EMBERS
WHICHWHENAPPROVEDALLOWTHEMTODEVIATEFROMAPROVISIONOFTHE'!444HESE
WAIVERREQUESTSHAVEBEENCONSIDEREDINCONNECTIONWITHDIFFERENTSUBJECTMATTERSSUCHAS
THEINTRODUCTIONOF(ARMONIZED3YSTEMCHANGESTO-EMBERS3CHEDULESOFCONCESSIONSTHE
+IMBERLEY0ROCESS#ERTIFICATION3CHEMEFOR2OUGH$IAMONDSISSUESUNDERTHE74/#USTOMS
6ALUATIONAND42)-S!GREEMENTSANDONPREFERENCESGIVENBYDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTO
GROUPSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESFOREXAMPLETHENEW!#0%#0ARTNERSHIP!GREEMENT
4HE#OUNCILHASALSODEALTWITHTHEREVIEWOFTHEOPERATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON4RADE
2ELATED)NVESTMENT-EASURES42)-S!GREEMENTTHEISSUEOFTRADEFACILITATIONUPUNTILTHE
LAUNCHINGOFNEGOTIATIONSASSETOUTINTHE*ULYPACKAGEANDTHETHREE-AJOR2EVIEWS
OFTHE)MPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING)THASSTARTEDTOCONSIDER
ATTHEREQUESTOFCERTAIN-EMBERSPOST!4#ADJUSTMENTRELATEDISSUES
4HE#OUNCILFOR4RADEIN'OODSHASBEENSUCCESSFULINMONITORINGTHEAGREEMENTS
UNDERITSRESPONSIBILITYANDINPROVIDINGAFORUMATAPOLITICALLEVELWHERE-EMBERSHAVE
DISCUSSEDANDFOUNDSOLUTIONSTOSEVERALCONTROVERSIALSUBJECTSRANGINGFROMTHE+IMBERLEY
#ERTIFICATION0ROCESSANDTHEEXTENSIONOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE42)-3!GREEMENTTO
THENEW!#0%#0ARTNERSHIP!GREEMENTTHUSFACILITATINGTHEIRCONSIDERATIONATTHELEVELOF
THE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
/N*ANUARYTHE!GREEMENTON
4EXTILESEXPIREDINACCORDANCEWITHITSARTICLE
THEREFORETHE4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODY4-"
ALSOCEASEDTOEXIST
4HE#OMMITTEEON-ARKET!CCESS#-!OVERSEESMOSTOFTHEWORKINTHETARIFF
ANDNONTARIFFBARRIERSAREASTHATARENOTSPECIFICALLYDEALTBYOTHER74/BODIES)THAS
THEOBJECTIVEOFISUPERVISINGTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFCONCESSIONSRELATINGTOTARIFFS
ANDNONTARIFFMEASURESASCONTAINEDINTHESCHEDULESOFCONCESSIONSANDSERVINGAS
AFORUMFORCONSULTATIONONTHESEMATTERSIIOVERSEEINGTHEAPPLICATIONOFPROCEDURES
FORMODIFICATIONORWITHDRAWALOFTARIFFANDNONTARIFFCONCESSIONSIIIENSURINGTHAT
'!44SCHEDULESAREKEPTUPTODATEANDTHATMODIFICATIONSAREREFLECTEDTHEREIN
INCLUDINGTHOSERESULTINGFROMCHANGESINTARIFFNOMENCLATUREANDIVOVERSEEINGTHE
CONTENTOPERATIONANDACCESSTOTHE)NTEGRATED$ATA"ASE)$"ANDMORERECENTLYTHE
#ONSOLIDATED4ARIFF3CHEDULE$ATABASE#43!LLTHESEOBJECTIVESAREKEYTOSAFEGUARDING
THERIGHTSANDOBLIGATIONSOF-EMBERSWITHRESPECTTOCONCESSIONSINTHEGOODSAREA
THROUGHTRANSPARENCYANDPREDICTABILITY
'ENERALLYSPEAKINGTHEREAPPEARSTOHAVEBEENARELATIVELYSMOOTHIMPLEMENTATION
OFCOMMITMENTSUNDERTAKENBY-EMBERSDURINGTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDASCONTAINEDINTHEIR
SCHEDULESOFCONCESSIONS4HATISNOTTOSAYTHATTHEREHAVENOTBEENANYCOMPLAINTS
HOWEVERTHEYHAVEBEENLIMITED3OMETARIFFISSUESWHICHHAVECROPPEDUPANDGONEASFAR
ASTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCESSINCLUDETARIFFCLASSIFICATIONMATTERSANDISSUESRELATINGTO
hOTHERDUTIESANDCHARGESv
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4ARIFFSAND.4"S
/NAMORESPECIFICANDTECHNICALLEVEL
#ONCERNINGTHEMODIFICATIONORWITHDRAWALOFTARIFFCONCESSIONSTHROUGH'!44!RTICLE
886)))THISISMOSTLYABILATERALPROCESSWITHTHEOUTCOMEBEINGSUBSEQUENTLYAPPLIEDONAN
-&.BASIS)NANUTSHELL!RTICLE886)))NEGOTIATIONSGIVESA-EMBERTHEPOSSIBILITYTOMODIFYOR
WITHDRAWACONCESSIONSUBJECTTOTHAT-EMBERENTERINGINTOCONSULTATIONSANDORNEGOTIATION
WITHAVIEWTOOFFERINGADEQUATECOMPENSATIONTOTRADINGPARTNERSHOLDINGCERTAINRIGHTS
ONTHATPRODUCT)FNOAGREEMENTISREACHEDANDTHEPROPOSEDMODIFICATIONISNEVERTHELESS
IMPLEMENTEDTHEPOSSIBILITYEXISTSFORTHOSETRADINGPARTNERSTOWITHDRAWSUBSTANTIALLY
EQUIVALENTCONCESSIONSONAN-OST&AVOURED.ATION-&.BASIS7HILEONLYTWENTYTHREE
REQUESTSFORRENEGOTIATIONSHAVEBEENMADEUNDER'!44!RTICLE886)))SINCEWHICH
WOULDSUGGESTTHATIMPLEMENTATIONOFTARIFFCOMMITMENTSUNDERTAKENDURINGTHE5RUGUAY
2OUNDHASNOTCREATEDTOOMANYDIFFICULTIESFOR-EMBERSITISWORTHNOTINGTHATSOME
!RTICLE886)))NEGOTIATIONSHAVEHITTHEMEDIAHEADLINESDUETOTHESENSITIVITYOFTHEPRODUCTS
INVOLVED4HESEINCLUDETHE%#SMODIFICATIONOFCERTAINRICECONCESSIONSANDITSMOVETOA
TARIFFONLYSYSTEMINBANANAS!DDITIONALLY!RTICLE886)))ISUSEDINTHECONTEXTOFTHEFORMATION
OFCUSTOMSUNIONANDAWELLKNOWNEXAMPLEWOULDBETHEENLARGEMENTNEGOTIATIONSOFTHE
%#FROMTOMEMBERSTATESANDTOMEMBERSTATES4HEPROCESSISVERYCOMPLEXIN
THESECIRCUMSTANCESANDNEGOTIATIONSCANTAKEPLACEOVERANUMBEROFYEARS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
7ITHAVIEWTOENSURINGTRANSPARENCYINRESPECTOFCOMMITMENTSTHE#-!AGREED
INFORMALIZEDTHROUGHA#4'DECISIONTHAT-EMBERSSHOULDPREPAREhCONSOLIDATED
LOOSELEAFSCHEDULESv4HEREWASAGROWINGRECOGNITIONTHATITHADBECOMEDIFFICULTTO
IDENTIFYACCURATELYTHECURRENTSTATUSOFCOMMITMENTSOF-EMBERSGIVENTHATINSOME
CASESTHECOMMITMENTSWEREDISPERSEDOVERMANYLEGALINSTRUMENTSSPANNINGYEARS
5NFORTUNATELYONLYAHANDFULOF-EMBERSSUBMITTEDSUCHCONSOLIDATEDSCHEDULESAND
INITIALLYITAPPEAREDTHATTHEGOALOFGROUPINGALLTHECOMMITMENTSOF-EMBERSINONEPLACE
WOULDNOTBEACHIEVED(OWEVERORIGINATINGFROMTHISEXERCISECAMETHEIDEAOFSETTING
UPA#ONSOLIDATED4ARIFF3CHEDULE#43DATABASEWHICHALTHOUGHNOTLEGALLYBINDINGHAS
PROVENTOBEAVERYUSEFULINSTRUMENTFORANALYSISINTHETARIFFAREAINPARTICULARINTHE
CONTEXTOFTHE$OHANEGOTIATIONS4HE#43DATABASECOUPLEDWITHTHE)NTEGRATED$ATA"ASE
)$"WHICHCONTAINSTRADEANDAPPLIEDTARIFFINFORMATIONOF-EMBERSCONSTITUTEPOWERFUL
RESEARCHTOOLSASWITNESSEDBYTHENUMBEROFREQUESTSFORACCESSTOTHESEDATABASESTHATARE
BEINGMADETOTHE#-!BYANUMBEROFORGANIZATIONS
0ROBABLYONEOFTHEMAJORAREASOFTECHNICALWORKINRESPECTOFTARIFFCOMMITMENTS
HASBEENTHEINTRODUCTIONOFNOMENCLATURECHANGESTOSCHEDULESOFCONCESSIONS.EARLY
ALL-EMBERSUSETHE(ARMONIZED(33YSTEMNOMENCLATURETODESCRIBETHEIRPRODUCT
BYPRODUCTCOMMITMENTSINTHEIRSCHEDULES4HE(ARMONIZED3YSTEM#OMMITTEEOFTHE
7ORLD#USTOMS/RGANIZATION7#/WHICHOVERSEESTHE(3UNDERTAKESAPERIODICREVIEW
OFTHE(3TOTAKEACCOUNTOFCHANGESINTECHNOLOGYANDPATTERNSININTERNATIONALTRADE
ANDRECOMMENDSAMENDMENTSTOTHE(34HEFIRSTSETOFSUCHCHANGESCAMEINTOFORCEON
*ANUARY(3ASECONDSETON*ANUARY(3ANDATHIRDSETON*ANUARY
(37ITHAVIEWTOKEEPINGTHEAUTHENTICTEXTSOFSCHEDULESUPTODATEAND
INCONFORMITYWITHTHENATIONALCUSTOMSTARIFFITISNECESSARYFOR-EMBERSTOUPDATEAND
TRANSPOSETHEIR74/COMMITMENTSTOREFLECTEACHOFTHESE(3AMENDMENTS
4HEREQUIREDTRANSPOSITIONINTO(3REMAINSOUTSTANDINGFORMANY-EMBERS
!CKNOWLEDGINGTHEDIFFICULTIESFACEDBYMOSTOFTHE-EMBERSWITHRESPECTTOTHE(3
TRANSPOSITIONIMPROVEDPROCEDURESWEREAPPROVEDINANDTHENREVISEDFURTHERIN
)TISFORESEENTHATAFOURTHSETOFCHANGESTOTHE(3WILLENTERINTOFORCEINENSURINGA
SUBSTANTIALWORKLOADFORTHE#-!INTIMESTOCOME
7ITHREGARDTONONTARIFFBARRIERSTHE#OMMITTEEAGREEDINFORMALIZEDTHROUGH
#4'DECISIONSTHAT-EMBERSSHOULDNOTIFYTHEIRQUANTITATIVERESTRICTIONSANDSHOULDBE
ALLOWEDTHEPOSSIBILITYOFMAKINGREVERSENOTIFICATIONSOFNONTARIFFBARRIERS7HILEACERTAIN
NUMBEROFQUANTITATIVERESTRICTIONSHAVEBEENCOMMUNICATEDMANY-EMBERSHAVEYETTO
COMPLETETHISTASK3INCEONE-EMBERHASMADEAREVERSENOTIFICATIONOFANONTARIFF
BARRIER4HECHALLENGEOFADDRESSING.4"SISCURRENTLYWITHTHE.!-!'ROUPASSEENHEREAFTER
4HE)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY!GREEMENT
4HE-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONON4RADEIN)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY0RODUCTS)4!WAS
CONCLUDEDATTHE74/3INGAPORE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN$ECEMBER4HISPLURILATERAL
AGREEMENTCOMMITSITSPARTICIPANTSTOELIMINATEANDBIND-&.DUTIESANDOTHERDUTIESAND
CHARGESONADEFINEDSETOFINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYPRODUCTSTHATINCLUDESEMICONDUCTORS
SEMICONDUCTORMANUFACTURINGEQUIPMENTCOMPUTERSANDTELECOMMUNICATIONSEQUIPMENT
4HEAGREEMENTCAMEINTOFORCEONCETHEREQUIREMENTWASMETTHATPARTICIPANTSTO
THEAGREEMENTCOVEREDAPPROXIMATELYPERCENTOFWORLDTRADEIN)4!PRODUCTS4HEFIRST
STAGEDREDUCTIONSOFTARIFFSSTARTEDON*ULY3INCETHENTHENUMBEROFPARTICIPANTS
HASINCREASEDTOCOUNTINGTHE%#AS OUTOFWHICHAREDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
4OGETHERTHEYREPRESENTAPPROXIMATELYOFWORLDTRADEININFORMATIONTECHNOLOGY
PRODUCTS-EXICO3OUTH!FRICAAND"RAZILARETHEMOSTIMPORTANTNON)4!PARTICIPANTS
ACCOUNTINGFORAPPROXIMATELYPERCENTOFWORLD)4!TRADE4HE)4!STANDSASTHEMOST
IMPORTANTTRADELIBERALIZATIONINITIATIVEAPPLIEDONAN-&.BASISAFTERTHE5RUGUAY2OUND
4HEVALUEOF)4!EXPORTSGREWCONSISTENTLYFROMTOWHENITPEAKED4HEGROWTH
WASSOSTRONGTHAT)4!EXPORTSACCOUNTEDFORASMUCHASOFWORLDEXPORTSINTHEYEAR
(OWEVERITSSHAREOFWORLDEXPORTSFELLINTOSLIGHTLYMORETHAN)TISWORTH
NOTINGTHATTHESHAREOF)4!PRODUCTSINWORLDTRADESTILLEXCEEDSTHATOFAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS
!h#OMMITTEEOF0ARTICIPANTSONTHE%XPANSIONOF4RADEIN)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY
0RODUCTSvWASESTABLISHEDUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE74/TOIMPLEMENTTHEAGREEMENT)N
THATCONTEXTTHEPARTICIPANTSAPPROVEDATTHEENDOFTHEYEARA7ORK0ROGRAMMEON
NONTARIFFMEASURES.4-SWITHTHEOBJECTIVEOFIDENTIFYINGIMPEDIMENTSTOTRADEIN)4!
PRODUCTS!RECENTSUCCESSFULOUTCOMEINTHISAREAHASBEENTHEELABORATIONOFGUIDELINES
FOR%LECTROMAGNETIC#OMPATIBILITY%-#AND%LECTROMAGNETIC)NTERFERENCE%-)CONFORMITY
ASSESSMENTPROCEDURES7ORKISONGOINGINTHIS#OMMITTEETOADDRESSOTHER.4"SANDALSO
TOIRONOUTTHEDIVERGENCESINCLASSIFICATIONOFSOMEINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYPRODUCTSWITH
THEGOALOFNARROWINGTHEMDOWNTOONEORTWOCLASSIFICATIONSIFPOSSIBLE
)NADDITIONTHE#OMMITTEEHASREGULARLYREVIEWEDTHESTATUSOFIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE
)4!4HROUGHTHISPROCESSPARTICIPANTSRAISETRADERELATEDCONCERNSON)4PRODUCTSANDNEW
PARTICIPANTSSUBMITTHEIRDOCUMENTATIONFORRECTIFICATIONANDMODIFICATIONOFTHEIR74/
SCHEDULESINORDERTOINCORPORATETHECOMMITMENTSARISINGFROMTHE-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION
&URTHERMOREA74/)NFORMATION4ECHNOLOGY3YMPOSIUMWASHELDON/CTOBER
WITHTHEGOALOFUPDATING)4!PARTICIPANTSANDOTHER74/-EMBERSONDEVELOPMENTSIN
THEINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYAREA)TALSOELICITEDUPDATEDINFORMATIONONTHENATUREOFTRADE
BARRIERSTOTRADEIN)4PRODUCTSANDASSESSEDTHEROLEOF)4TRADEINSUPPORTINGDEVELOPMENT
INTHOSEMARKETSWHERELIBERALIZATIONHASOCCURRED
!LBANIA!USTRALIA"AHRAIN+INGDOMOF
"ULGARIA#ANADA#HINA#OSTA2ICA#ROATIA
%GYPT%L3ALVADOR%#'EORGIA(ONG+ONG
#HINA)CELAND)NDIA)NDONESIA)SRAEL*APAN
*ORDAN+OREA+YRGYZ2EPUBLIC-ACAO#HINA
-ALAYSIA-AURITIUS-OLDOVA-OROCCO.EW
:EALAND.ORWAY/MAN0ANAMA0HILIPPINES
2OMANIA3INGAPORE3WITZERLANDINCLUDING
,IECHTENSTEIN3EPARATE#USTOMS4ERRITORYOF
4AIWAN0ENGHU+INMENAND-ATSU4HAILAND
4URKEYANDTHE5NITED3TATES
4HE!GREEMENTON)MPORT,ICENSINGCAMEINTOFORCEON*ANUARY)TESTABLISHES
DISCIPLINESONUSERSOFIMPORTLICENSINGSYSTEMSWITHTHEPRINCIPALOBJECTIVEOFENSURING
TRANSPARENCYOF-EMBERSIMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURES4HE!GREEMENTAIMSTOSIMPLIFY
CLARIFYANDMINIMIZETHEADMINISTRATIVEREQUIREMENTSNECESSARYTOOBTAINIMPORTLICENCES
!CCORDINGLYTHE#OMMITTEEON)MPORT,ICENSINGWASESTABLISHEDTOAFFORD-EMBERSTHE
OPPORTUNITYOFCONSULTINGONANYMATTERSRELATINGTOTHEOPERATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT
4HE!GREEMENTSTIPULATESTHATALL-EMBERSAREREQUIREDTONOTIFYTHEIRLAWSREGULATIONS
ANDADMINISTRATIVEPROCEDURESRELEVANTTOIMPORTLICENSING-EMBERSAREALSOREQUIRED
TOANNUALLYPROVIDEREPLIESTOTHE1UESTIONNAIREONIMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURESANDTO
NOTIFYTHEINSTITUTIONOFNEWPROCEDURESORMODIFICATIONS3INCETHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHIS
#OMMITTEE-EMBERSHAVENOTIFIEDTHEIRLEGISLATIONANDORPUBLICATIONRELEVANTTO
IMPORTLICENSING-EMBERSHAVESUBMITTEDNOTIFICATIONSRELATINGTOTHEINSTITUTIONOFNEW
IMPORTLICENSINGPROCEDURESORCHANGESINTHESEPROCEDURESAND-EMBERSHAVEPROVIDED
REPLIESTOTHE1UESTIONNAIREATLEASTONCEBUTNONEHAVEREPLIEDANNUALLY%#COUNTEDAS
ONE3TILLMANY-EMBERSHAVENOTSUBMITTEDTHEREQUIREDNOTIFICATIONS4HISUNSATISFACTORY
SITUATIONWITHRESPECTTOCOMPLIANCEWITHTHENOTIFICATIONOBLIGATIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTHAS
SERIOUSLYUNDERMINEDTHEABILITYOFTHE#OMMITTEETOCARRYOUTITSMAINFUNCTIONOFREVIEWING
-EMBERSIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHIS!GREEMENT
!NUMBEROFOTHERISSUESRAISEDBYTHE-EMBERSONIMPORTLICENSINGWEREALSOSOLVED
UNDERTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING!TOTALOFCONSULTATIONSWHEREINTERALIA
IMPORTLICENSINGPROVISIONSWEREMENTIONEDWEREHELDBY-EMBERSINTHELASTTENYEARS
-OSTOFTHEMWERESATISFACTORILYSETTLEDTHROUGHOUTCONSULTATIONSAMONGST-EMBERS
4HROUGHTHEPASTYEARSTHE)MPORT,ICENSING#OMMITTEEHASPROVIDEDAREGULARFORUMFOR
DISCUSSIONOFSPECIFICNOTIFICATIONSSUBMITTEDBY-EMBERSANDOFCONCERNSREGARDINGIMPORT
LICENSINGMATTERS)THASCONTRIBUTEDTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFSTANDARDSONIMPORTLICENSING
REGIMESENSURINGTHATPROCEDURESAPPLIEDFORGRANTINGIMPORTLICENCESDONOTINTHEMSELVES
RESTRICTTRADE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
)MPORTLICENSING
2ULESOFORIGIN
4HE!GREEMENTON2ULESOF/RIGINENTEREDINTOFORCEINASARESULTOFTHE5RUGUAY
2OUNDTRADENEGOTIATIONS4HE!GREEMENTAIMSTOHARMONIZENONPREFERENTIALRULESOFORIGIN
ANDTOENSURETHATSUCHRULESDONOTTHEMSELVESCREATEUNNECESSARYOBSTACLESTOTRADE
5NTILTHECOMPLETIONOFTHE(ARMONIZATION7ORK0ROGRAMME(70-EMBERSAREEXPECTED
TOENSURETHATTHEIRRULESOFORIGINARETRANSPARENTTHATTHEYAREADMINISTEREDINACONSISTENT
UNIFORMIMPARTIALANDREASONABLEMANNER
2ULESOFORIGINAREREGULATIONSTODETERMINETHECOUNTRYINWHICHAGOODWASMADE
4HECOUNTRYOFORIGINOFAPARTICULARGOODISEITHERTHECOUNTRYWHERETHEGOODHASBEEN
WHOLLYOBTAINEDORWHENMORETHANONECOUNTRYISINVOLVEDINTHEPRODUCTIONOFAPARTICULAR
GOODTHECOUNTRYWHERETHELASTSUBSTANTIALTRANSFORMATIONHASBEENCARRIEDOUT
#HANGEOFCLASSIFICATIONOFAGOODINTHE(3NOMENCLATUREISNORMALLYCONSIDEREDASAN
EXPRESSIONOFSUBSTANTIALTRANSFORMATION)FEACHIMPORTEDINPUTMATERIALHASCHANGEDITS
CLASSIFICATIONASARESULTOFTHEPRODUCTIONPROCESSESINACOUNTRYORIGINSHALLBECONFERRED
TOTHATCOUNTRY(OWEVERWHEREEXCLUSIVEUSEOFTHE(3NOMENCLATUREDOESNOTALLOWFOR
THEEXPRESSIONOFSUBSTANTIALTRANSFORMATIONOTHERREQUIREMENTSINCLUDINGADVALOREM
PERCENTAGESANDORMANUFACTURERPROCESSINGOPERATIONSCANBEUSED
.ONPREFERENTIALRULESOFORIGIN.02/AREUSEFULTRADEPOLICYINSTRUMENTSFOR
ORIGINMARKINGANDTRADESTATISTICSASWELLASFORTHEAPPLICATIONOFSPECIFICTRADEMEASURES
TOPARTICULARPRODUCTS4HEQUOTAADMINISTRATIONISALSOBASEDONORIGINDETERMINATIONOF
IMPORTEDGOODSASWELLASTRADEREMEDYINVESTIGATIONS
4HE(70WASLAUNCHEDIN*ULYANDISSTILLUNDERWAY!LTHOUGHSUBSTANTIALPROGRESS
HASBEENMADETHEWORKHASBEENCONSIDERABLYDELAYEDWITHRESPECTTOTHETIMEFRAME
FORESEENINTHE2/!GREEMENTINWHICHTHE(70WASSCHEDULEDTOBECOMPLETEDIN*ULY
ANDALSOINRESPECTTOTHEDECISIONMADEINTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEWHICH
URGEDTHE#OMMITTEEON2ULESOF/RIGINTOCOMPLETETHEWORKBYTHEENDOF
74/DOCUMENT74-).
&ACEDWITHTHEREALITYOFGLOBALIZATIONANDINCREASINGMULTICOUNTRYPRODUCTIONOFAGOOD
THISWORKREQUIRESREACHINGANAGREEMENTONSPECIFICORIGINRULESFOREVERYTARIFFLINEWHICH
AREMORETHAN3IGNIFICANTWORKHASBEENDONEINCLUDINGTHEOVERALLARCHITECTUREOF
HARMONIZEDRULESOFORIGIN(2/ANDDEFINITIONSOFWHOLLYOBTAINEDGOODS4HENUMBEROF
OUTSTANDINGISSUESHOWEVERISSTILLOUTOFANDMOSTOFTHESEISSUESARELINKEDTO
IMPORTANTCOMMERCIALPOLICYCONCERNS-EMBERSAREALSOSPLITONSEVERALSENSITIVEISSUESEG
AUTOMOBILESCOMPUTERSFOOTWEARANDLEATHERPRODUCTS!SCONCERNSTHEMACHINERYSECTOR
-EMBERSAREDIVIDEDBETWEENTHOSEWHOWOULDNOTLIKETOUSETHEADVALOREMPERCENTAGE
RULEANDTHOSETHATFAVOURITSUSEBECAUSEOFTHERAPIDTECHNOLOGICALCHANGEINTHISSECTOR
$ESPITETHESEDIFFICULTIESTHE74/WILLCONTINUEITSWORKTOFULFILITSMANDATE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
#USTOMSVALUATION
4HEBACKBONEOFTHE#USTOMS6ALUATION!GREEMENT#6!GREEMENTISTHESAMEASTHE
'!446ALUATION#ODEWHICHCAMEINTOFORCEINASARESULTOFTHE4OKYO2OUNDTRADE
NEGOTIATIONS4HEPRIMARYBASISFORCUSTOMSVALUEOFAGOODUNDERTHIS!GREEMENTISTHESO
CALLEDhTRANSACTIONVALUEvIETHEPRICEACTUALLYPAIDBYTHEBUYERFORTHEGOODS!LTERNATIVE
FIVEVALUATIONMETHODSAREALSOSETOUTINTHEPRESCRIBEDHIERARCHYTOBEUSEDONLYIFTHE
TRANSACTIONVALUECOULDNOTBEUSED!LLTHESESIXVALUESHOWEVERARETHEPRICESOFAGOOD
DETERMINEDBYTHEMARKETNOTANARBITRARYPRICE"YPREVENTINGCUSTOMSAUTHORITIESFROM
ARBITRARILYINCREASINGTHEPRICEOFIMPORTEDGOODSFORCOLLECTIONOFIMPORTDUTIESANDCHARGES
THE!GREEMENTHASPROVIDEDGREATERPREDICTABILITYANDSIMPLICITYININTERNATIONALTRADE
3INCECUSTOMSDUTIESPROVIDEDAVERYIMPORTANTSHAREOFTOTALGOVERNMENTREVENUEFOR
MANYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESUNDERVALUATIONANDFRAUDCOULDBEASERIOUSTHREATTOTHEIR
FISCALREVENUE4HEREFOREMANYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWERERELUCTANTTOACCEPTTHEIMPORTERS
DECLAREDVALUEASCUSTOMSVALUE!CKNOWLEDGINGTHESEDIFFICULTIESTHE#6!GREEMENT
ALLOWEDDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSTODELAYTHEAPPLICATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTFORFIVE
YEARSORMOREASAGREEDBYTHE#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATION#6#OMMITTEE
$EVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSDUETOACTIVETECHNICALASSISTANCEOVERTHELASTTENYEARS
PROVIDEDBYTHEDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY-EMBERSANDTHEINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSMAINLYTHE
74/7#/AND7ORLD"ANKHAVENOWPHASEDOUTTHESERESERVATIONSNONEAREINVOKINGTHE
PROVISIONOFDELAYEDAPPLICATION&OURDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHOWEVERSTILLMAINTAINMINIMUM
VALUESYSTEMSFORALIMITEDNUMBEROFPRODUCTSSUCHASUSEDCARS
4HE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINALSOTOOKANADDITIONALDECISIONTOPREVENT
CUSTOMSFRAUD!CCORDINGTOTHISDECISIONWHENTHECUSTOMSADMINISTRATIONOFANIMPORTING
-EMBERHASREASONABLEGROUNDSTODOUBTREGARDINGTHETRUTHORACCURACYOFTHEDECLARED
VALUEANDSEEKASSISTANCEFROMTHEEXPORTING-EMBERTHEEXPORTING-EMBERSHALLOFFER
COOPERATIONANDASSISTANCECONSISTENTWITHITSDOMESTICLAWSANDPROCEDURES
74/DOCUMENT74-).4HE#6#OMMITTEEUNDERTHEDIRECTIONOFTHE-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEISWORKINGTOIDENTIFYANDASSESSPRACTICALMEANSTOADDRESSSUCHCONCERNS
INCLUDINGTHEEXCHANGEOFINFORMATIONONEXPORTVALUES
4HE#6!GREEMENTESTABLISHEDTHE4ECHNICAL#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS6ALUATION4##6
UNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE7#/4HE4##6HASBEENWORKINGTOADDRESSTECHNICALQUESTIONS
FACEDBYCUSTOMSAUTHORITIESINTHEDAILYOPERATIONOFTHE#6!GREEMENTANDSETUPVERY
COMPREHENSIVEANDDETAILEDGUIDELINESFORVALUATIONPROCEDURES4HEEFFECTIVEWORKOFTHE
4##6HASHELPEDRESOLVEMANYVALUATIONISSUESWITHOUTTHENEEDOF-EMBERSTOINVOKETHE
74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEDURES)NFACTUPTODATENOCONSULTATIONSINITIATEDUNDERTHE
$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDINGHAVEGONEINTOTHEPANELSTAGE
4HIS!GREEMENTHASBEENSUCCESSFULINTHATITHASPROVIDEDAUNIFORMMETHODOLOGYTO
VALUEGOODSANDALL-EMBERSAREAPPLYINGITALTHOUGHMANYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHAVEHAD
DIFFICULTYIMPLEMENTINGITANDARESTILLINTHEPROCESSOFIMPROVINGITSAPPLICATIONTHROUGH
REFORMSANDMODERNIZATIONOFTHEIRCUSTOMSSERVICES
0RESHIPMENTINSPECTION
4HE!GREEMENTON0RESHIPMENT)NSPECTION03)CAMEINTOFORCEINASARESULTOFTHE
5RUGUAY2OUNDNEGOTIATIONSANDPROVIDESARULEBASEDCODEOFCONDUCTFORTHEACTIVITIESOF
PRESHIPMENTINSPECTIONCOMPANIES4HE!GREEMENTRECOGNIZESTHATSOME74/-EMBERSMAY
WISHTOUSETHESERVICESOFSUCHPRIVATECOMPANIESTOCONTROLOVERANDUNDERINVOICINGAND
FRAUDASWELLASFORTHECONTROLOFQUALITYANDQUANTITYOFIMPORTSENTERINGTHEIRTERRITORIES
4HE!GREEMENTALSOADDRESSESCONCERNSTHATSUCHSERVICESMUSTBECARRIEDOUTWITHOUT
GIVINGRISETOUNNECESSARYDELAYSORUNEQUALTREATMENT
4HE7ORKING0ARTYON0RESHIPMENT)NSPECTIONWASESTABLISHEDINTOREVIEWTHE
OPERATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT)TENDORSEDAPROPOSALBY3WITZERLANDWHICHESTABLISHEDA
MODELCONTRACTWHICHGOVERNMENTSCOULDUSEASABASISINELABORATINGTHEIROWNCONTRACTS
WITH03)COMPANIES4HEWORKINGPARTYHASBEENREPLACEDBYTHE#OMMITTEEON#USTOMS
6ALUATION
4HEDISPUTERESOLUTIONMECHANISMnTHE)NDEPENDENT2EVIEW%NTITY)%nWASESTABLISHED
INASASUBSIDIARYBODYOFTHE#4'4HISISTHEMECHANISMFORDISPUTERESOLUTION
BETWEENEXPORTERSAND03)ENTITIESFORCASESINVOLVINGANALLEGEDVIOLATIONOFTHE!GREEMENT
WHERETHEINTERNALAPPEALSPROCEDUREOFTHE03)ENTITYHASFAILEDTORESOLVETHEDISPUTE4O
DATENOAPPLICATIONFORDISPUTERESOLUTIONHASEVERBEENFILEDWITHTHE)%
4HEPREDOMINANTUSERSOFPRESHIPMENTINSPECTIONSERVICESAREDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
!SOF/CTOBEROFTHECOUNTRIESUSINGPRESHIPMENTINSPECTIONARE!FRICAN
-EMBERS4HE!GREEMENTSEEMSTOHAVEWORKEDSATISFACTORILYANDHASBROUGHTABOUTA
UNIFORMITYINTHEFUNCTIONINGOF03)COMPANIESBYPROVIDINGANINSTITUTIONALFRAMEWORKOF
RIGHTSANDOBLIGATIONSOFBOTHUSER-EMBERSANDEXPORTER-EMBERS
#ONTRARYTOWHATISSOMETIMESPERCEIVEDAGRICULTUREWASCOVEREDUNDERTHEOLD'!44
"UTTHEDISCIPLINESRELATEDTOAGRICULTUREHADBEENRATHERWEAK!SARESULTTRADEINMANY
AGRICULTURALPRODUCTSWASIMPEDEDBYHIGHTARIFFSAHOSTOFNONTARIFFMEASURESAND
INCREASINGRECOURSETOTRADEDISTORTINGSUBSIDIES
4HEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRESULTSHASBEENABIGSTEPFORWARDINCLUDING
ACOLLECTIVE5TURNINTHEDIRECTIONAGRICULTURALPROTECTIONANDSUPPORTHADBEENDEVELOPING
7HOEVERCRITICISESTHESERESULTSSHOULDREVISITTHELITERATUREONTHEAGRICULTURALTRADEBARRIERS
ANDSUBSIDYWARSOFTHESANDS
5PONENTERINGINTOEFFECTTHE74/HASOVERSEENTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHECOMPLEX
NEWRULESGOVERNINGTRADEINAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSANDOFTHERELATEDSPECIFICCOMMITMENTS
BY-EMBERSINTHEAREASOFMARKETACCESSDOMESTICSUPPORTANDEXPORTCOMPETITION
%SSENTIALLYTHISTASKWASCARRIEDOUTBYTHE#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTURESETUPIN
'ENERALLYTHEWORKOFTHE#OMMITTEEHASGREATLYCONTRIBUTEDTOTHESMOOTHIMPLEMENTATION
OFTHERULESANDCOMMITMENTSALTHOUGHINANUMBEROFCASES-EMBERSTOOKRECOURSETOTHE
NEWDISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEDURES
&URTHERMOREINACCORDANCEWITH!RTICLEOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURETHE74/HAS
LAUNCHEDONSCHEDULENEGOTIATIONSTOCONTINUETHEREFORMPROCESSINLINEWITHTHEAGREED
LONGTERMOBJECTIVEOFSUBSTANTIALPROGRESSIVEREDUCTIONSINSUPPORTANDPROTECTIONRESULTING
INFUNDAMENTALREFORM
!TTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEANEWANDMORESPECIFICMANDATEFORTHESE
NEGOTIATIONSWASAGREEDANDTHEYBECAMEPARTOFTHESINGLEUNDERTAKINGUNDERTHE
$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA!FURTHERIMPORTANTSTEPWASTHEAGREEMENTON!UGUST
OFAFRAMEWORKFORESTABLISHINGMODALITIESINAGRICULTURE4HISFRAMEWORKHASGIVEN
FURTHERSUBSTANTIVEPRECISIONTOTHE$OHAMANDATEANDISTHEBASISFORTHENEGOTIATIONSOF
MODALITIESWHICHARECURRENTLYUNDERWAY
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
!GRICULTURE
-ARKETACCESS
!KEYFEATUREOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRESULTSHASBEENTHE
CHANGEOVERFROMASYSTEMWHEREAMYRIADOFNONTARIFFMEASURESGOVERNEDACCESSTO
AGRICULTURALMARKETSTOAREGIMEOFBOUNDTARIFFONLYPROTECTIONPLUSREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTS
4HEKEYOBJECTIVESOFTHISFUNDAMENTALCHANGEHAVEBEENTOSTIMULATEINVESTMENT
PRODUCTIONANDTRADEINAGRICULTUREBYIMAKINGAGRICULTURALMARKETCONDITIONSMORE
TRANSPARENTPREDICTABLEANDCOMPETITIVEIIESTABLISHINGORSTRENGTHENINGTHELINKBETWEEN
NATIONALANDINTERNATIONALAGRICULTURALMARKETSANDTHUSIIIRELYINGMOREPROMINENTLYON
THEMARKETFORGUIDINGSCARCERESOURCESINTOTHEIRMOSTPRODUCTIVEUSESBOTHWITHINTHE
AGRICULTURALSECTORSANDECONOMYWIDE
4OACHIEVETHESEOBJECTIVESAGRICULTURESPECIFICNONTARIFFMEASURESWEREELIMINATEDOR
CONVERTEDINTOORDINARYCUSTOMSDUTIEShTARIFFICATIONv1UANTITATIVEIMPORTRESTRICTIONS
VARIABLELEVIESMINIMUMIMPORTPRICESDISCRETIONARYLICENSINGANDSIMILARNONTARIFFMEASURES
ARENOWPROHIBITEDEXCEPTFORMEASURESPERMITTEDUNDERTHEBALANCEOFPAYMENTSPROVISIONS
OFTHE'!44ANDOTHERGENERALNONAGRICULTURESPECIFIC74/PROVISIONSSUCHASMEASURES
INACCORDANCEWITHTHE!GREEMENTON4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADE4"4ANDTHE!GREEMENT
ONTHE!PPLICATIONOF3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURES303/NAVERAGEFORALL74/
-EMBERSTARIFFIEDPRODUCTSACCOUNTFORAROUNDONEFIFTHOFALLTARIFFITEMSBUTFORANUMBER
OF-EMBERSTHISPERCENTAGEISSUBSTANTIALLYHIGHER
)MPROVEMENTSINMARKETACCESSWEREACHIEVEDBYREDUCINGALLAGRICULTURALTARIFFS
INCLUDINGTHOSERESULTINGFROMTHETARIFFICATIONEXERCISEBYANAVERAGEOFPERCENTOVER
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESPERCENTOVER$EVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
HADTHEOPTIONTOOFFERCEILINGBINDINGSFORPRE5RUGUAY2OUNDUNBOUNDITEMSINSTEADOF
TARIFFICATION!SINMANYCASESTARIFFICATIONRESULTEDINVERYHIGHORPROHIBITIVETARIFFSTARIFF
QUOTASWITHRELATIVELYLOWINQUOTATARIFFRATESHADTOBEESTABLISHEDINORDERTOMAINTAINOR
EXPANDPREEXISTINGMARKETACCESSOPPORTUNITIES4ARIFFQUOTAEXPANSIONWASIMPLEMENTED
INTANDEMWITHTHETARIFFREDUCTIONS&URTHERMORETHETARIFFICATIONPACKAGEINCLUDEDACCESS
TOASPECIALAGRICULTURALSAFEGUARDMECHANISMFORTARIFFIEDPRODUCTSSOASTOSMOOTHTHE
ADJUSTMENTTOTHENEWTARIFFONLYREGIME
-OREOVERTHE74/ENHANCEDPREDICTABILITYANDSECURITYOFMARKETACCESSOPPORTUNITIES
6IRTUALLYALLAGRICULTURALTARIFFSOFALL74/-EMBERSHAVEBEENBOUNDFORONCEAGRICULTURE
ISNOWAHEADOFNONAGRICULTURALGOODS4HEINCIDENCEOFAGRICULTURALTARIFFSREMAINS
NEVERTHELESSDIFFICULTTOASSESSBECAUSEMANYTARIFFSAREBOUNDINNONADVALOREMTERMS
4HEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRESULTSALSOLEDTOPROGRESSINREDUCINGTARIFF
ESCALATION/FTENTHISRESULTEDSIMPLYFROMTHEFACTTHATALREADYPRIORTOTHE2OUNDCERTAIN
AGRICULTURALRAWMATERIALSENTEREDANUMBEROFMARKETSDUTYFREE)NTHESECASESTHETARIFF
CUTSAGREEDUPONINTHE2OUNDHADTOBEMADEONSEMIPROCESSEDORPROCESSEDAGRICULTURAL
PRODUCTSANDTHEREFORETARIFFESCALATIONWASREDUCEDQUASIAUTOMATICALLY(OWEVERTHEISSUE
WASNOTFULLYRESOLVED4ARIFFESCALATIONCONTINUESTOEXISTINANUMBEROFPRODUCTCHAINSSUCH
ASCOCOACOFFEEVEGETABLESFRUITSNUTSANDOILSEEDSINANUMBEROFMARKETS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
$OMESTICSUPPORT
4HEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREHASFUNDAMENTALLYCHANGEDTHE
WAYDOMESTICSUPPORTINFAVOUROFAGRICULTURALPRODUCERSWASTREATEDPRIORTOTHE74/
5NDERTHE!GREEMENTAMAINOBJECTIVEHASBEENTODISCIPLINEANDREDUCETRADEDISTORTING
DOMESTICSUPPORTWHILEATTHESAMETIMEALLOWINGWIDESCOPEFORGOVERNMENTSTODESIGN
DOMESTICAGRICULTURALPOLICIESINTHEFACEOFANDINRESPONSETOTHEWIDEVARIETYOFSPECIFIC
CIRCUMSTANCESININDIVIDUALCOUNTRIESANDINDIVIDUALAGRICULTURALSECTORSINCLUDINGTHE
ACHIEVEMENTOFPOLICYOBJECTIVESRELATEDTONONTRADECONCERNSSUCHASTHENEEDTOPROTECT
THEENVIRONMENTORFOODSECURITY
4HEAPPROACHTHATHASBEENIMPLEMENTEDHASALSOAIMEDTOHELPENSURETHATTHE
SPECIFICBINDINGCOMMITMENTSINTHEAREASOFMARKETACCESSANDEXPORTCOMPETITIONARE
NOTUNDERMINEDTHROUGHDOMESTICSUPPORTMEASURES4HISPOINTISOFPARTICULARVALUETO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESBECAUSETHEDOMESTICSUPPORTCOMMITMENTSAREBYNATUREMAINLYA
DISCIPLINETARGETEDATDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESWHICHCANAFFORDHIGHLEVELSOFSUPPORTFORTHEIR
FARMERSANDWHICHINTHEABSENCEOFSUCHDISCIPLINESCOULDCONTINUETODISTORTCOMPETITION
UNABATEDLYBYBRINGINGTOBEARTHEFINANCIALPOWEROFTHEIRTREASURIES
4OACHIEVEITSOBJECTIVESINTHEAREAOFDOMESTICSUPPORTTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURE
HASINTRODUCEDAFUNDAMENTALDISTINCTIONBETWEENTRADEDISTORTINGDOMESTICSUPPORTONTHE
ONEHANDh!MBER"OXvANDh"LUE"OXvANDDOMESTICSUPPORTMEASURESTHATDONOTORAT
LEASTMINIMALLYDISTORTTRADEANDPRODUCTIONh'REEN"OXv
74/-EMBERSAREFREETOUSEORINTRODUCEDOMESTICSUPPORTMEASURESASTHEYSEEFIT
ASLONGASTHESEMEASURESHAVENOORATMOSTMINIMALTRADEDISTORTINGEFFECTSOREFFECTS
ONPRODUCTIONTHESE'REEN"OXMEASURESAREDEFINEDIN!NNEXTOTHE!GREEMENTON
!GRICULTURE4HE'REEN"OXOFFERSAWIDEVARIETYOFMEASURESTOACHIEVEAWIDEVARIETY
OFPOLICYOBJECTIVESINCLUDINGPUBLICSERVICESRELATEDTORESEARCHPESTANDDISEASECONTROL
ANDINSPECTIONSERVICESTRAININGEXTENSIONANDADVISORYSERVICESMARKETINGANDPROMOTION
SERVICESAVARIETYOFINFRASTRUCTURALSERVICESASWELLASFOODSECURITYPROGRAMMESAND
DOMESTICFOODAID4HE'REEN"OXALSOINCLUDESAGAINSUBJECTTOSPECIFICCRITERIADIRECT
PAYMENTSTOPRODUCERSINCLUDINGDECOUPLEDINCOMESUPPORTINCOMEINSURANCEANDSAFETY
NETPROGRAMMESNATURALDISASTERRELIEFPROGRAMMESSTRUCTURALADJUSTMENTASSISTANCE
THROUGHPRODUCERANDRESOURCERETIREMENTPROGRAMMESASWELLASINVESTMENTAIDSAND
ENVIRONMENTALANDREGIONALASSISTANCEPROGRAMMES
-EASURESNOTQUALIFYINGUNDERTHE'REEN"OXCRITERIAAREINPRINCIPLECONSIDEREDMORE
THANMINIMALLYTRADEDISTORTINGANDTHEREFORESUBJECTTOSPECIFICDISCIPLINESUNDERTHEh!MBER
"OXvANDTHEh"LUE"OXv!MBER"OXMEASURESINCLUDEMARKETPRICESUPPORTPRODUCTION
SUBSIDIESANDINPUTSUBSIDIES!MBER"OXSUPPORTWEREINAGGREGATEREDUCEDBYPERCENT
OVERTHEIMPLEMENTATIONPERIODPERCENTOVERTHEPERIODFOR
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
(OWEVERMOSTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHAVENOTBEENAFFECTEDBYTHEREDUCTIONDISCIPLINE
,EASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESWERENOTREQUIREDTOUNDERTAKEREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTSIN
DOMESTICSUPPORTMARKETACCESSOREXPORTSUBSIDIESALTHOUGHTHEYHAVETORESPECTTHEIR
TARIFFBINDINGSANDTHENEWRULESINTHETHREEAREAS-OSTOTHERDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
HAVEBEENCOVEREDBYTWOOFTHESPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTPROVISIONSCONTAINED
INTHE!GREEMENT&IRSTADEMINIMISPROVISIONALLOWSDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTOPROVIDE
PRODUCTSPECIFICTRADEDISTORTINGDOMESTICSUPPORTUPTOPERCENTOFTHECURRENTVALUE
OFPRODUCTIONOFTHEPRODUCTCONCERNEDANDGENERALhNONPRODUCTSPECIFICvSUPPORTUP
TOPERCENTOFTHECURRENTVALUEOFTOTALAGRICULTURALPRODUCTIONFORDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
THEDEMINIMISLEVELISPERCENT3ECONDLYINCONTRASTTODEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESDEVELOPING
COUNTRIESHAVENOTBEENREQUIREDTOREDUCECERTAINMEASURESTOENCOURAGEAGRICULTURALAND
RURALDEVELOPMENTINVESTMENTSUBSIDIESGENERALLYAVAILABLETOAGRICULTUREINPUTSUBSIDIES
GENERALLYAVAILABLETOLOWINCOMEORRESOURCEPOORFARMERSANDDOMESTICSUPPORTTO
ENCOURAGEDIVERSIFICATIONFROMGROWINGILLICITNARCOTICCROPS
0ARTIALLYDECOUPLEDPAYMENTSUNDERPRODUCTIONLIMITINGPROGRAMMESTHATMEETSPECIFIC
CRITERIASETOUTINTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREHAVEALSOBEENEXEMPTEDFROMREDUCTION
COMMITMENTS3UCHh"LUE"OXvPAYMENTSCURRENTLYUSEDBYNOTMORETHANTHREE74/
-EMBERSCOUNTINGTHE%#ASONE*APANAND.ORWAYAREUNDERTHEEXISTINGPROVISIONS
NOTSUBJECTTOANYLIMIT
4HEDOMESTICSUPPORTREDUCTIONCOMMITMENTSHAVEBEENFULLYIMPLEMENTEDBYTHE
-EMBERSCONCERNED-EMBERSCOUNTINGTHE%#IE%#ANDITSPRE-AY
-EMBER3TATESAND3WITZERLAND,IECHTENSTEINASONE.OTIFICATIONSRECEIVEDTODATESHOW
THATINMOSTCASESTHE74/CEILINGSHAVENOTBEENFULLYUTILISED4HEREHASALSOBEENA
SHIFTFROM!MBER"OXTO'REEN"OXMEASURESnABUILTININCENTIVEINTHE!GREEMENTON
!GRICULTURE
$UETORATHERINEFFECTIVE'!44DISCIPLINESAGRICULTURALEXPORTSUBSIDIESPROLIFERATED
INTHESANDSANDSUCCESSININTERNATIONALMARKETSOFAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS
BECAMEINCREASINGLYDETERMINEDBYTHEFINANCIALPOWERANDLARGESSEOFNATIONALTREASURIES
RATHERTHANTHEEFFICIENCYANDMARKETINGSKILLSOFAGRICULTURALPRODUCERSANDEXPORTERS
%XPORTSUBSIDIESALSOBECAMEAFACTORINDEPRESSINGORDESTABILIZINGWORLDMARKETPRICES
FORAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS4HEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREHASBEGUN
THEPROCESSOFREDRESSINGTHISSITUATIONANDINSODOINGALSOTOIMPROVETHEINTERNATIONAL
COMPETITIVENESSOFNONSUBSIDISERSSUCHASMOSTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDTOENCOURAGE
DOMESTICPRODUCTIONINTHESECOUNTRIESTOTHEEXTENTWORLDPRICESAREALLOWEDTOFEED
THROUGHTOTHEFARMERS
(OWEVERNETFOODIMPORTINGDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHAVEBEENCONCERNEDTHATTHE74/
COMMITMENTSTOREDUCEEXPORTSUBSIDIESWOULDRESULTINASUSTAINEDINCREASEINWORLDPRICES
FORBASICFOODSTUFFSSUCHASCEREALSANDTHUSINCREASETHEIRFOODIMPORTBILLS4HE-INISTERIAL
$ECISIONONTHE0OSSIBLE!DVERSE%FFECTSOFTHE2EFORM0ROGRAMMEON,EAST$EVELOPEDAND
.ET&OOD)MPORTING$EVELOPING#OUNTRIESHASBEENARESPONSETOTHESECONCERNS7HILEA
NUMBEROFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHAVEVOICEDCONCERNSTHATTHE$ECISIONHASNOTBEENFULLY
IMPLEMENTEDSOMEOTHER-EMBERSDONOTCONCUR
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
%XPORTCOMPETITION
3PECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENT
!SNOTEDABOVESPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTISANINTEGRALELEMENTOFTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURE5NDERTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDRESULTS
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHADLOWERORINCASEOFTHELEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESNOREDUCTION
COMMITMENTSINTHEAREASOFMARKETACCESSEXPORTSUBSIDIESANDTRADEDISTORTINGSUPPORTS
ANDLONGERTIMEFRAMESTOIMPLEMENTTHESECOMMITMENTS&URTHERMOREINADDITIONTOTHE
SPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTPROVISIONSREFERREDTOINTHESECTIONONDOMESTICSUPPORT
ABOVETHEREAREALSOSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTRULESWITHRESPECTTODOMESTICFOOD
AIDANDPUBLICSTOCKHOLDINGFORFOODSECURITYPURPOSESUNDERTHE'REEN"OXCERTAINEXPORT
SUBSIDIESANDINTHECONTEXTOFTHEPROVISIONSONEXPORTRESTRICTIONS
-UCHREMAINSTOBEDONE
4HE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURETHATEMERGEDFROMTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDANDITS
IMPLEMENTATIONHASNOTBEENPERFECT&OREXAMPLEDESPITETHEPROGRESSMADE
I FORMANY74/-EMBERSTHEAVERAGELEVELOFBOUNDAGRICULTURALTARIFFSCONTINUESTO
BEMUCHHIGHERTHANTHATFORNONAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS
IIINMANYCASESTHEDISPERSIONOFTARIFFSACROSSAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSCONTINUESTOBE
HIGHERTHANFORNONAGRICULTURALPRODUCTS
IIITARIFFPEAKSAREPRESENTINAWIDERANGEOF74/3CHEDULESAND
IVWHILETHE52BROUGHTPROGRESSINREDUCINGTARIFFESCALATIONTHISPHENOMENON
CONTINUESTOBEAFEATUREOFMANYTARIFFSTRUCTURESALTHOUGHTHEREAREALSOCASESOF
TARIFFDEESCALATION
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
,IKEWISETRADEDISTORTING!MBERAND"LUE"OXSUPPORTCONTINUESTOAMOUNTTOBILLIONSOF
EUROS53DOLLARSYENSETC!NDTHEREDUCTIONSACHIEVEDINTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDSTILLHAVELEFT
PLENTYOFROOMFORSUBSIDIZINGEXPORTSINAVARIETYOFFORMS
4HE5RUGUAY2OUNDNEGOTIATORSACCEPTEDTHATTHERESULTOFTHEIRYEARSOFWORKWASONLY
THEBEGINNINGOFTHEWAYTOWARDSAFAIRANDMARKETORIENTEDAGRICULTURALTRADINGSYSTEM
4HEYBUILTINTOTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTUREAS!RTICLETHEREQUIREMENTTORESTART
NEGOTIATIONSINWITHTHEOBJECTIVEOFFURTHERSUBSTANTIALPROGRESSIVEREDUCTIONSIN
SUPPORTANDPROTECTION4HOSENEGOTIATIONSHAVESTARTEDONSCHEDULEANDARECURRENTLYBEING
PURSUEDUNDERTHENEWMANDATEESTABLISHEDIN3EPTEMBERAT$OHA4HELATESTSTEPHAS
BEENTHEAGREEMENTON!UGUSTOFAFRAMEWORKFORNEGOTIATINGTHEMODALITIESFOR
FURTHERCOMMITMENTSINTHEAREASOFMARKETACCESSDOMESTICSUPPORTANDEXPORTCOMPETITION
ANDRELATEDSTRENGTHENINGOFTHERULESOFTHE!GREEMENTON!GRICULTURE
4HEFRAMEWORKONAGRICULTURECONSTITUTESAMAJORSTEPFORWARD)TFLESHESOUTTHE$OHA
MANDATEBYESTABLISHINGSPECIFICOBJECTIVESFORTHENEGOTIATIONSONAGRICULTUREANDTHE
MEANSTOACHIEVETHEM4OTRANSLATETHEFRAMEWORKINTOFULLYFLEDGEDMODALITIESWILLSTILL
REQUIREALOTOFTECHNICALWORKINALLTHREEPILLARSBEFORETHEOPTIONSARECLEARANDTHE
HARDPOLITICALBARGAININGONTHEREDUCTIONFIGURESIMPLEMENTATIONPERIODSANDOTHERKEY
PARAMETERSCANBEGIN
)TISWORTHUNDERLININGTHATTHE&RAMEWORKALREADYREFLECTSIMPORTANTMOVEMENTSIN
POSITIONSTOWARDSCONVERGENCEINALLTHREEPILLARSMOSTNOTABLYINEXPORTCOMPETITION!TTHE
SAMETIMETHEPOST*ULYWORKHASMADECLEARTHATMANYCONFLICTINGCONCERNSANDAMBITIONS
STILLPERSISTAMONG74/-EMBERS4HESEGAPSINPOSITIONSANDAMBITIONSWILLHAVETOBE
BRIDGEDINTHECOURSEOFTHEWORKAHEAD
4HESEOBSERVATIONSREFERTOTARIFFBINDINGS)T
ISTHEREFOREIMPORTANTTOKEEPINMINDTHATIN
MANYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHEAPPLIEDTARIFFS
AREFREQUENTLYLOWERTHANTHEBOUNDTARIFFS)N
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTHEGAPBETWEENBOUND
ANDAPPLIEDTARIFFRATESISGENERALLYMUCHLESS
SIGNIFICANT
%XPORTSUBSIDIES
)NEXPORTCOMPETITIONTHEFRAMEWORKDOESCONTAINANIMPORTANTDOWNPAYMENTONTHE
RESULTSOFTHENEGOTIATIONSBYINCLUDINGTHEHISTORICCOMMITMENTTOELIMINATEALLFORMSOF
EXPORTSUBSIDIZATIONATADATECERTAIN4HECONCESSIONTOELIMINATEALLSCHEDULEDEXPORT
SUBSIDIESISINTERALIACONDITIONALONPARALLELANDEQUIVALENTCOMMITMENTSWITHRESPECTTO
ALLOTHERFORMSOFEXPORTSUBSIDIZATIONIEINTHEAREASOFOFFICIALLYSUPPORTEDEXPORTCREDITS
EXPORTINGSTATETRADINGENTERPRISESANDNONGENUINEFOODAID
4HEGREATESTCHALLENGESFORTHEWORKAHEADAPPEARTOBEINMARKETACCESS4HEFRAMEWORK
LAYSDOWNTHEBASICAPPROACHFORTARIFFCUTTINGANDAVARIETYOFOTHERINSTRUMENTSTOIMPROVE
MARKETACCESS(OWEVERITALSOINCLUDESSUBSTANTIALFLEXIBILITYANDLEAVESMOSTOFTHE
ELEMENTSUNSPECIFIEDANDSUBJECTTOFURTHERNEGOTIATION
!KEYACHIEVEMENTOFTHEFRAMEWORKISTHEAGREEMENTTHATTHEPRINCIPLEOFhSUBSTANTIAL
IMPROVEMENTvINMARKETACCESSWILLAPPLYFOREACHAGRICULTURALPRODUCTTHE$OHAMANDATE
ONLYESTABLISHEDTHISPRINCIPLEINGENERALTERMS7HILETHEFRAMEWORKENVISAGESFLEXIBILITYFOR
SENSITIVEPRODUCTSTHEYWILLALSOBESUBJECTTOTHISPRINCIPLE
4HETECHNICALWORKIN'ENEVAHASALREADYTOUCHEDONAVARIETYOFMARKETACCESSISSUES
4HEGATEWAYTOPROGRESSISTOAGREEINTHENEARFUTUREONACONVERSIONMETHODOLOGYFOR
NONADVALOREMDUTIESANDSUBSEQUENTLYTOSUBMITTHE ADVALOREMEQUIVALENTS!6%SAS
SOONASPOSSIBLEnWITHOUTTHISINFORMATIONITWILLBEEXTREMELYDIFFICULTTOMAKEPROGRESS
ONTHETIEREDFORMULAANDRELATEDISSUESINCLUDINGTHEISSUESOFSENSITIVEPRODUCTS30AND
33-
4HEAGENDAFORTHEWORKAHEADINCLUDESANUMBEROFOTHERMATTERSINCLUDINGTHE
EROSIONOFLONGSTANDINGPREFERENCESSUCHAS!#0SUGARTARIFFESCALATIONTARIFFQUOTA
ADMINISTRATIONANDTARIFFSIMPLIFICATION/VERALLTHEREISSTILLALONGWAYTOGOINFLESHINGOUT
THEMARKETACCESSSECTIONOFTHEMODALITIESPACKAGE
/BVIOUSLYINDOMESTICSUPPORTASINTHEOTHERAREASIMPORTANTPOLITICALDECISIONSARE
INVOLVED4HEYWILLHAVETOWAITUNTILFURTHERINTENSIVETECHNICALWORKHASCLEAREDTHEGROUND
+EYCHALLENGESINCLUDETHEDEVELOPMENTOFATIEREDFORMULAFORSUBSTANTIALREDUCTIONOFALL
TRADEDISTORTINGSUPPORTTHEISSUEOF"LUE"OXCRITERIAANDTHEREVIEWANDCLARIFICATIONOFTHE
'REEN"OX)NTHE'REEN"OXCONTEXTTHEFRAMEWORKALSOREFERSTONONTRADECONCERNS
&INALLYASDIRECTEDBYTHE!UGUST$ECISIONOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILTHETRADERELATED
ASPECTSOFCOTTONARETAKENUPASPARTOFTHENEGOTIATIONSONTHETHREEPILLARSOFMARKET
ACCESSDOMESTICSUPPORTANDEXPORTCOMPETITION7HILETHENEGOTIATIONSARECARRIEDOUTIN
THE3PECIAL3ESSIONOFTHE#OMMITTEEON!GRICULTUREA3UB#OMMITTEEON#OTTONHASBEEN
SETUPTOFACILITATEPROGRESS
4HE74/HASALSOOVERSEENTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!GREEMENTONTHE!PPLICATIONOF
3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESTHATHADBEENNEGOTIATEDDURINGTHE5RUGUAY2OUND
4HEBASICAIMOFTHE303!GREEMENTISTOMAINTAINTHESOVEREIGNRIGHTOFANYGOVERNMENTTO
PROVIDETHELEVELOFHEALTHPROTECTIONITDEEMSAPPROPRIATEBUTTOENSURETHATTHISSOVEREIGN
RIGHTISNOTMISUSEDFORPROTECTIONISTPURPOSESANDDOESNOTRESULTINUNNECESSARYBARRIERSTO
INTERNATIONALTRADE
!LLGOVERNMENTSACCEPTTHEFACTTHATSOMETRADERESTRICTIONSMAYBENECESSARYTOENSURE
FOODSAFETYANDANIMALANDPLANTHEALTHPROTECTION(OWEVERGOVERNMENTARESOMETIMES
PRESSUREDTOGOBEYONDWHATISNEEDEDFORHEALTHPROTECTIONANDTOUSESANITARYOR
PHYTOSANITARYRESTRICTIONSATTHEBORDERASADISGUISEDMEASURETOSHIELDDOMESTICPRODUCERS
FROMCOMPETITIONFROMABROAD3UCHPRESSURESARELIKELYTOINCREASEASOTHERMARKETACCESS
BARRIERSAREREDUCEDASHASBEENTHECASEINTHECOURSEOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE
5RUGUAY2OUNDRESULTSONMARKETACCESS!SANITARYORPHYTOSANITARYMEASUREWHICHIS
NOTGENUINELYREQUIREDFORHEALTHREASONSCANBEAVERYEFFECTIVEPROTECTIONISTDEVICEAND
BECAUSEOFITSTECHNICALCOMPLEXITYAPARTICULARLYDECEPTIVEANDDIFFICULTBARRIERTOCHALLENGE
4HE303!GREEMENTPERMITSGOVERNMENTSTOADOPTMAINTAINORENFORCEAPPROPRIATE
SANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYPROTECTION"UTTHE!GREEMENTREQUIRESTHAT303MEASURESARE
APPLIEDFORNOOTHERPURPOSETHANFORENSURINGFOODSAFETYANDANIMALANDPLANTHEALTH
ANDITCONTAINSPROVISIONSTOREDUCEPOSSIBLEARBITRARINESSOFDECISIONSANDTOENCOURAGE
CONSISTENTDECISIONMAKINGINTHEAREAOFHEALTHPROTECTION&OREXAMPLETHE!GREEMENT
STIPULATESTHATMEASURESTOENSUREFOODSAFETYORTOPROTECTTHEHEALTHOFANIMALSANDPLANTS
SHOULDBEBASEDASFARASPOSSIBLEONTHEANALYSISANDASSESSMENTOFOBJECTIVEANDACCURATE
SCIENTIFICDATAANDCLARIFIESWHICHFACTORSSHOULDBETAKENINTOACCOUNTINTHEASSESSMENTOF
THEHEALTHRISKSINVOLVED
4HE74/#OMMITTEEON3ANITARYAND0HYTOSANITARY-EASURESADMINISTERSTHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE303!GREEMENT4HE#OMMITTEEHASBEENVERYEFFECTIVEININCREASING
TRANSPARENCYINTHISTECHNICALLYVERYCOMPLEXAREAASWELLASINREDUCINGTRADEFRICTIONS
RESULTINGFROMARBITRARYORUNJUSTIFIABLEDISCRIMINATIONBETWEEN74/-EMBERSWHERE
THESAMECONDITIONSPREVAILORFROMDISGUISEDRESTRICTIONSONINTERNATIONALTRADE4HE303
!GREEMENTENCOURAGESTHEUSEOFINTERNATIONALSTANDARDSGUIDELINESORRECOMMENDATIONS
ANDINTHISREGARDTHE74/HASCLOSELYCOOPERATEDWITHTHERELEVANTINTERNATIONALSTANDARD
SETTINGORGANIZATIONSPARTICULARLYTHE#ODEX!LIMENTARIUS#OMMISSIONTHE7ORLD!NIMAL
(EALTH/RGANIZATIONANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL0LANT0ROTECTION#ONVENTION)NTHECOURSEOFITS
WORKTHE303#OMMITTEEHASDEVELOPEDANDTAKENASERIESOFDECISIONSTOFURTHERCLARIFYAND
REFINETHEPROVISIONSOFTHISIMPORTANT74/AGREEMENT#URRENTLYTHE#OMMITTEECONDUCTS
AFORMALREVIEWOFTHEOPERATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE303!GREEMENTnANOTHER
OPPORTUNITYTOFURTHERADVANCETHE74/PROVISIONSINTHISAREATOTHEBENEFITOF74/
-EMBERS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
3ANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURES
4HE42)03!GREEMENT
4HE74/BROKENEWGROUNDBYINCORPORATINGTHROUGHTHE42)03!GREEMENTRULESON
THEPROTECTIONOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM4HISREFLECTEDTHE
GROWINGIMPORTANCEOFTECHNOLOGYANDCREATIVITYANDTHESTANDARDSOFITSPROTECTIONAS
INTELLECTUALPROPERTYINTHECONDITIONSOFCOMPETITIONFACINGCOUNTRIESINANINCREASINGLY
INTEGRATEDGLOBALECONOMY!LTHOUGHLONGSTANDINGIMPORTANTMULTILATERALCONVENTIONS
ALREADYEXISTEDITHADBECOMEAPPARENTBYTHEMIDSTHATTHEYNOLONGERREPRESENTED
AFUNCTIONINGINTERNATIONALCONSENSUSABOUTTHEEXTENTTOWHICHCOUNTRIESSHOULDPROTECT
THEINTELLECTUALPROPERTYOFTHENATIONALSANDCOMPANIESOFOTHERCOUNTRIESESPECIALLYINTHE
AREAOFINDUSTRIALPROPERTY4HUSONEOFTHEUNDERLYINGPURPOSESOFTHE42)03!GREEMENTISTO
ESTABLISHAFUNCTIONINGMULTILATERALRULEOFLAWINTHISRESPECT
'IVENTHEEXTENSIVESCOPEANDDEMANDINGNATUREOFITSCOMMITMENTSIMPLEMENTATION
OFTHE42)03!GREEMENTATTHENATIONALLEVELHASGONEASWELLASCOULDBEEXPECTED4HE
74/HASSUCCESSFULLYINCORPORATEDANDHANDLEDANEXTENSIVENEWLEGALSYSTEMDIFFERENT
INNATUREINSOMEIMPORTANTRESPECTSFROMTHATOFTHE'!444HEOPERATIONOFTHEDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTSYSTEMINTHISAREAHASGONESMOOTHLY7HILETHEBALANCEFOUNDINTHE42)03
!GREEMENTHASBEENCRITICIZEDFROMBOTHSIDESITREMAINSVERYMUCHTHEKEYSETOFRIGHTS
ANDOBLIGATIONSANDTHEPOINTOFREFERENCEFORDISCUSSIONSININTELLECTUALPROPERTYRELATIONS
BETWEENCOUNTRIES
)MPLEMENTATION
)MPLEMENTATIONBYDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESBYWENTRELATIVELYSMOOTHLYWITHAFEW
DELAYS&ORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAGREATDEALWASDONEEVENBEFORETHEIRDEADLINE
(OWEVERINASIGNIFICANTPROPORTIONOFTHESECOUNTRIESTHEREWERESTILLGAPSIN
ESPECIALLYINSOMEOFTHELESSFAMILIARAREASOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYEGPLANTVARIETY
PROTECTIONANDINTEGRATEDCIRCUITSORINAFEWCASESDUETOPOLITICALDIFFICULTIESESPECIALLY
INTHEPATENTAREA4HESEGAPSHAVENOWLARGELYBEENFILLED4HEREISHOWEVERAHANDFUL
OFVERYSMALLCOUNTRIESWHICHSTILLHAVEMUCHTODO,$#SHAVEUNTILFOR
PHARMACEUTICALSWITHTHEPOSSIBILITYOFANEXTENSION
4HE42)03#OUNCILHASORGANIZEDAPROCESSOFNOTIFICATIONANDSYSTEMATICREVIEW
OFIMPLEMENTINGLEGISLATIONONACOUNTRYBYCOUNTRYBASIS)NADDITIONTOPROMOTING
TRANSPARENCYTHISHASBEENANIMPORTANTINCENTIVETOIMPLEMENTATIONANDALSOACTEDASA
DISPUTEFORESTALLINGMECHANISM
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
$ISPUTESETTLEMENT
4HISWASTHEAUTHORITYGIVENTO%CUADORNOT
TOAPPLYCERTAINOBLIGATIONSONINTELLECTUAL
PROPERTYMATTERSRELATINGTOTHEPROTECTIONOF
PERFORMERSPRODUCERSOFSOUNDRECORDINGS
BROADCASTINGORGANIZATIONSINDUSTRIALDESIGNS
ANDGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSINRESPONSETOA
FAILUREOFTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESTOBRING
ITSBANANAREGIMEINTOCOMPLIANCEWITHITS
'!44OBLIGATIONS
4HEAPPLICATIONOFTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMINTHEAREAOFINTELLECTUAL
PROPERTYWASBOUNDTOBEACHALLENGE)TREPRESENTEDTHEFIRSTTIMETHATPUBLICINTERNATIONAL
LAWINTHEAREAOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYWOULDBESUBJECTTOAFUNCTIONINGMULTILATERAL
DISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMANDSINCETHE42)03!GREEMENTINCORPORATESBYREFERENCE
MUCHOFTHEPREEXISTINGMULTILATERALLAWINTHEAREAOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTYLONGSTANDING
PROVISIONSOFTREATIESMIGHTHAVETOBEINTERPRETEDOFTENFORTHEFIRSTTIME&URTHERITWOULD
BEIMPORTANTTHATTHE74/TRADEBASEDSYSTEMSHOULDSHOWITSELFCAPABLEOFTHEADAPTATIONS
NECESSARYTOHANDLEDISPUTESINTHEINTELLECTUALPROPERTYAREA
3OFARTHEOPERATIONOFTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMINTHE42)03AREAHASGONE
SMOOTHLY4WENTYFIVECOMPLAINTSRELATINGTOSOMESEPARATEMATTERSHAVEBEENLODGED
UNDERTHESYSTEMINTHE42)03AREA0ANELREPORTSANDWHERETHEYHAVEBEENAPPEALED
!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSHAVEBEENADOPTEDINSEVENCASES)NTWOADDITIONALCASESTHOSE
RELATINGTOTHE%#SYSTEMFORTHEPROTECTIONOF')SFORAGRICULTURALPRODUCTSANDFOODSTUFFS
PANELREPORTSHAVEBEENRECENTLYCIRCULATED.INECASESHAVEBEENSETTLEDBILATERALLY
!SREGARDSTHERESTCONSULTATIONSARESTILLPENDINGORTHECASESHAVEBECOMEINACTIVE0ANEL
AND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSHAVECONTRIBUTEDNOTONLYTORESOLVINGTHEDISPUTESINQUESTION
BUTALSOTOCLARIFYINGSOMEIMPORTANTPROVISIONSOFTHE42)03!GREEMENT)NMOSTCASESTHE
RECOMMENDATIONSINADOPTEDREPORTSANDTHERESULTSOFBILATERALSETTLEMENTSAPPEARTOHAVE
BEENIMPLEMENTEDBYTHE-EMBERSCONCERNED)NTWOCASES53#OPYRIGHT!CTAND
53(AVANA#LUBIMPLEMENTATIONISSTILLPENDING
-OST42)03COMPLAINTSHAVEBEENBETWEENDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESWITHSEVENOFTHE
DIRECTEDATDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYRESPONDENTSOFWHICHTWOINVOLVEDTHEESTABLISHMENTOF
PANELS7HILETHISCONCENTRATIONONCOMPLAINTSINVOLVINGDEVELOPEDCOUNTRYPRACTICESWASNOT
UNEXPECTEDPRIORTOTHEDEADLINEFORIMPLEMENTATIONBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWEHAVE
NOTSEENSOFARANYLARGESCALERECOURSETODISPUTESETTLEMENTAGAINSTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
AFTERTHISDATE)NFACTSINCETHATTIMETHEREHAVEONLYBEENTWOCOMPLAINTSFILEDCONCERNING
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRYIMPLEMENTATIONBOTHINANDBOTHSETTLEDBILATERALLY4HEPREFERENCE
HASBEENTOADDRESSDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYIMPLEMENTATIONPROBLEMSTHROUGHTHEREVIEW
PROCESSINFORMALBILATERALDISCUSSIONANDTHEPROVISIONOFTECHNICALASSISTANCE
4ODATETHEREHAVEBEENNOCASEOFA-EMBEROBTAININGAUTHORITYTORETALIATEIN
RESPONSETOTHEFAILUREOFANOTHER-EMBERTOCOMPLYWITHITS42)03OBLIGATIONS4HEREHAS
BEENONLYONEINSTANCEOFAUTHORIZEDCROSSRETALIATIONSOFARUNDERTHEWHOLE74/DISPUTE
SETTLEMENTSYSTEM4HISINVOLVED42)03BUTINTHESENSEOFENABLINGADEVELOPINGCOUNTRY
TOUSEWITHDRAWALOFITS42)03OBLIGATIONSASAMEANSOFPUTTINGPRESSUREONADEVELOPED
COUNTRY-EMBERTOCOMPLYWITHITS'!44OBLIGATIONS $EVELOPMENTSINTHE!GREEMENT
)NSTRUMENTSHAVEBEENAGREEDREGARDINGTHEINTERPRETATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFTHE
SUBSTANTIVEPROVISIONSOFTHE!GREEMENTINONEAREATHATOF42)03AND0UBLIC(EALTH
4HE$OHA$ECLARATIONONTHE42)03!GREEMENTAND0UBLIC(EALTHCONTAINSIMPORTANT
UNDERSTANDINGSONHOWTHE!GREEMENTSHOULDBEINTERPRETEDANDAPPLIED!SCALLEDFOR
BYTHE$OHA$ECLARATION-EMBERSADOPTEDIN!UGUSTAWAIVER$ECISIONPROVIDING
ADDITIONALFLEXIBILITYSOASTOENABLECOUNTRIESWITHINSUFFICIENTDOMESTICMANUFACTURING
CAPACITYTOMAKEEFFECTIVEUSEOFCOMPULSORYLICENSING
4HE42)03#OUNCILHASNOTYETESTABLISHEDAMULTILATERALSYSTEMOFNOTIFICATIONAND
REGISTRATIONOFGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSFORWINESASCALLEDFORBY!RTICLE4HISISUNDER
NEGOTIATIONINTHE$OHA2OUNDWHERETHEMANDATEALSOCOVERSSPIRITS
/THERIMPORTANTISSUESUNDERDISCUSSIONBUTWITHOUTSUBSTANTIVEAGREEMENTASYET
INCLUDE
REVIEWOF!RTICLEB
RELATIONBETWEENTHE42)03!GREEMENTANDTHE#ONVENTIONON"IOLOGICAL$IVERSITY
PROTECTIONOFTRADITIONALKNOWLEDGEANDFOLKLORE
EXTENSIONOFTHEHIGHERLEVELOFPROTECTIONOFGEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONSTOPRODUCTS
OTHERTHANWINESANDSPIRITS
!SREGARDSTHEAPPLICABILITYOFNONVIOLATIONANDSITUATIONCOMPLAINTSINTHE42)03AREA
THEMORATORIUMINTHE42)03!GREEMENTHASBEENSUCCESSIVELYPROLONGEDNOWTOTHE74/
-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCETOBEHELDIN(ONG+ONGIN$ECEMBER
#OOPERATIONWITH7)0/ANDOTHER)'/S
!COOPERATIONAGREEMENTBETWEENTHE7ORLD)NTELLECTUAL0ROPERTY/RGANIZATION7)0/
AND74/ASCALLEDFORBYTHE42)03!GREEMENTCAMEINTOEFFECTININCLUDINGINREGARD
TONOTIFICATIONSANDTECHNICALCOOPERATION4HETWOORGANIZATIONSHAVEEXCELLENTRELATIONSAND
WORKINAMUTUALLYSUPPORTIVEWAY4HE74/ALSOCOOPERATESWITHOTHERINTERGOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONSINCLUDINGTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION7(/)NTERNATIONAL5NIONFOR
0ROTECTIONOF6ARIETIESOF0LANTS50/6&OODAND!GRICULTURE/RGANIZATION&!/7ORLD
#USTOMS/RGANIZATION7#/#ONVENTIONON"IOLOGICAL$IVERSITY#"$ON42)03MATTERS
4ECHNICALASSISTANCE
!GREATDEALOF42)03RELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEHASBEENMADEAVAILABLEMOSTLY
BY7)0/OTHER)'/SANDBILATERALLY4HE74/3ECRETARIATHASALSOMADEASIGNIFICANT
CONTRIBUTION4HE42)03#OUNCILMONITORSTHESEACTIVITIES
4RANSFEROFTECHNOLOGIESTOLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
4HE42)03#OUNCILESTABLISHEDINAPROCEDUREFORTHESYSTEMATICMONITORINGOF
COMPLIANCEBYDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESWITHTHEOBLIGATIONIN!RTICLETOPROVIDEINCENTIVES
TOPROMOTETHETRANSFERTOTECHNOLOGYTO,$#S
7HILEITISGENERALLYRECOGNIZEDTHATTHE42)03!GREEMENTPROVIDESCONSIDERABLEFLEXIBILITY
TOENABLE-EMBERSTOFINETUNETHEBALANCEINTHEINTELLECTUALPROPERTYSYSTEMINTHELIGHT
OFDOMESTICNEEDSANDCIRCUMSTANCESTHEREHASBEENAGREATDEALOFDISCUSSIONINTHE74/
OTHER)'/S.'/SANDACADEMIAABOUTWHETHERTHISISSUFFICIENT4HISISPERHAPSINEVITABLETO
SOMEDEGREEGIVENTHENATUREOFTHEISSUEBUTHASPERHAPSBEENPARTICULARLYINTENSEINTHE
LIGHTOFTHE()6!)$3CRISISANDTHEGROWTHOFANTIGLOBALIZATIONSENTIMENTSINCERTAINQUARTERS
/VERTHELASTDECADETHEBALANCESTRUCKINTHE42)03!GREEMENTHASBEENCRITICIZEDFROM
BOTHSIDES
/NTHEONEHANDITHASNOTBEENACCEPTEDBYALLDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESASNECESSARILY
PROVIDINGFORADEQUATEANDEFFECTIVEPROTECTIONOFTHEIRINTELLECTUALPROPERTYANDTHERE
HASBEENACONTINUINGEFFORTINSOMESUCHQUARTERSTOGETTRADINGPARTNERSTOPROVIDE
ENHANCEDPROTECTIONINIMPORTANTRESPECTS7HILETHE42)03!GREEMENTMAKESITCLEAR
THAT-EMBERSARENOTOBLIGEDTOIMPLEMENTMOREEXTENSIVEPROTECTIONITDOESNOT
PREVENTTHEMFROMDOINGSO1UITEANUMBERHAVEAGREEDWITHTHEIRPARTNERSTOGO
DOWNTHISROADINTHECONTEXTOFBILATERALANDREGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTSWHICHARE
BECOMINGINCREASINGLYWIDESPREAD
/NTHEOTHERHANDTHEREHAVEBEENPROPOSALSTOIMPROVETHEBALANCEINTHE
!GREEMENTFROMTHEPERSPECTIVEOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES%ACHOFTHETHREEMAJOR)0
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4HEBALANCEINTHE42)03!GREEMENT
INITIATIVESTHATHAVEBEENTAKENUPINTHE74/OVERTHELASTDECADEREFLECTINSOME
MEASURETHISTYPEOFCONCERNn42)03ANDPUBLICHEALTHWHERESOMECLARIFICATION
ANDMODIFICATIONWASAGREEDBIOTECHNOLOGYBIODIVERSITYTRADITIONALKNOWLEDGEAND
GEOGRAPHICALINDICATIONS')S
74/DISPUTESETTLEMENT
4HE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMHASBEENWIDELYACCLAIMEDASONEOFTHEMOST
IMPORTANTCOMPONENTSOFTHE74/)TOFFERSAPROCESSOFBINDINGADJUDICATIONWHEREALL74/
-EMBERSCANLITIGATETHEIRDIFFERENCESINARELATIVELYTIMELYANDEFFICIENTMANNER
4HESYSTEMHASGAINEDTHECONFIDENCEOFALL74/-EMBERSBOTHDEVELOPEDANDDEVELOPING
ANDOVERDIFFERENT-EMBERSBOTHDEVELOPEDANDDEVELOPINGHAVELITIGATEDCASESUNDER
THESYSTEM
4HEINSTITUTIONALMACHINERYOFTHENEWSYSTEMHASBEENPUTINPLACEANDRUNSRELATIVELY
SMOOTHLYnINCLUDINGTHECREATIONOFTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYAND
!PPELLATE"ODY3ECRETARIATANDTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT2EGISTRY
4HESYSTEMHASPROVEDITSELFCAPABLEOFPROCESSINGALARGENUMBEROFCASESINCLUDING
MANYSIMULTANEOUSLY/VERPANELSHAVEBEENESTABLISHEDANDAPPEALSPROCESSEDIN
THEFIRSTTENYEARS5PTOTWENTYPANELSHAVEOPERATEDSIMULTANEOUSLYINTHESYSTEMANDUP
TOFOURAPPEALSHAVEBEENBEFORETHE!PPELLATE"ODYATONETIME$ESPITETHISLARGEVOLUME
OFLITIGATIONPANELSHAVEGENERALLYBEENABLETOPROVIDETHEIRFINALREPORTSTOPARTIESWITHIN
NINEMONTHSANDTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASGENERALLYBEENABLETOCOMPLETEAPPEALSWITHIN
THREEMONTHSASENVISAGEDBYTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDING$35
4HANKSTOSTRICTADHERENCEBYPARTICIPANTSINTHESYSTEMPANELLISTSEXPERTS!PPELLATE
"ODYMEMBERS3ECRETARIATSTAFFTOTHE-EMBERADOPTED2ULESOF#ONDUCTTHEPROCESSHAS
BEENCONDUCTEDWITHIMPARTIALITYANDINDEPENDENCE4HEINTEGRITYOFTHESYSTEMHASNEVER
BEENCOMPROMISEDNORCHALLENGEDEVENWHEN-EMBERSMAYHAVEDISAGREEDWITHTHE
DECISIONSORJURISPRUDENCEEMANATINGFROMTHESYSTEM
)NRESPECTOFALLPANELREPORTSANDAPPELLATEREPORTSADOPTEDTODATETHELOSINGPARTY
HASNEVERFAILEDTOCOMMITITSELFTOIMPLEMENTINGTHERULINGSANDRECOMMENDATIONSSETFORTH
7ITHAFEWEXCEPTIONSTHEOVERALLCOMPLIANCERECORDBY-EMBERSHASBEENREMARKABLYGOOD
#HALLENGES
4HECOMPLEXITYANDCOSTSOFLITIGATIONUNDERTHESYSTEMHAVEPROVENHIGHERTHAN
ANTICIPATED4HISMAYHAVEMADETHESYSTEMLESSACCESSIBLETOCERTAINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
!LTHOUGHTHEOVERALLCOMPLIANCERECORDHASBEENGOODINATLEASTCASESRETALIATIONHAS
BEENAUTHORIZEDDUETOLACKOFCOMPLIANCEANDSEVERALCASESARESTILLAWAITINGCOMPLIANCEBY
THELOSINGPARTY0UBLICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHESYSTEMHASNOTBEENADEQUATEWHICHMAYHAVE
LEADTOMORECRITICISMOFTHESYSTEMBYTHEPUBLICATLARGETHANISWARRANTED
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4ENYEARSOF74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEEDINGS
4HE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT-ECHANISMSETUPINISOFTENCITEDASONEOFTHEMAJOR
ACHIEVEMENTSOFTHEMULTILATERALRULESBASEDSYSTEM!LTHOUGH-EMBERSMAYPOINTTO
SPECIFICIMPROVEMENTSTHATCOULDBEMADETOTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMTHEY
GENERALLYCONSIDERTHATTHESYSTEMHASFUNCTIONEDWELL
4HE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMOFFERSAPROCESSOFBINDINGADJUDICATIONWHEREALL74/
SOVEREIGN-EMBERSAREEQUALINARULESBASEDSYSTEM)NITSELFTHEEXISTENCEOFABINDINGAND
AUTOMATICDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMFORSOVEREIGNSTATESINTHE74/ISANACHIEVEMENT
4HENUMBEROFCASESBROUGHTBEFORETHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMHASCONTINUEDTO
INCREASE"ETWEEN*ANUARYAND$ECEMBERCOMPLAINTSHAVEBEENFILED
WITHTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODY$3"OFWHICHHAVERESULTEDINPANELS
5SERSOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEM
!MONGTHETENBIGGESTUSERSOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMATLEASTHALFARE
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES0ANELREPORTSHAVEBEENCIRCULATEDINONETHIRDOFCASESANDOF
THEPANELREPORTSHAVEBEENAPPEALED!PPROXIMATELYTWOTHIRDSOFTHEDISPUTESAREBROUGHT
TOTHE$3"BYINDUSTRIALIZEDCOUNTRIESANDONETHIRDBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES4HEMAINUSERS
OFTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMAREINORDEROFIMPORTANCETHE53!THE%#
#ANADA"RAZIL)NDIA-EXICO*APAN+OREA4HAILANDAND!RGENTINA#HILE
4HE5NITED3TATESHASBROUGHTCOMPLAINTSANDHASBEENRESPONDENTINTHE%#HAS
BROUGHTCOMPLAINTSANDBEENRESPONDENTIN#ANADAHASBEENINVOLVEDINCASES
ASCOMPLAINANTANDASRESPONDENTAND*APANHASBEENCOMPLAINANTINCASESAND
RESPONDENTIN!PPROXIMATELYOFTHECASESHAVEOCCURREDBETWEENTHETWOLARGEST
USERSTHE5NITED3TATESANDTHE%#
!MONGDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHELARGESTUSERSCONTINUETOBE"RAZILCASESAS
COMPLAINANTANDASRESPONDENT)NDIACASESASCOMPLAINANTANDASRESPONDENT
AND!RGENTINAANDCASESRESPECTIVELYASCOMPLAINANTANDRESPONDENT
,EASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES
4HE,EASTDEVELOPED#OUNTRIES,$#SHAVEINGENERALNOTUSEDTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENT
MECHANISMALTHOUGHANUMBERHAVEPARTICIPATEDASTHIRDPARTIESINDISPUTES INADDITION
"ANGLADESHWASTHEFIRST,$#TOREQUESTCONSULTATIONSUNDERTHEMECHANISMIN*ANUARY
)TISANACHIEVEMENTTOHAVEAVAILABLESUCHAMECHANISMWHERESMALLCOUNTRIESHAVE
ANAUTOMATICRIGHTTOINITIATEDISPUTEPROCEEDINGSAGAINSTANYPOWERFUL-EMBERSTHATIT
CONSIDERSTOBEACTINGCONTRARYTOITS74/OBLIGATION
4HECOSTSOFTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEEDINGSCANHOWEVERACTASADETERRENTFOR
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESLIMITEDCAPACITIES!SSISTANCEISBEINGPROVIDEDTO,$#STHATDOWISH
TOUSETHEMECHANISMNOTABLYTHROUGHTHE!DVISORY#ENTREON74/,AW!#7,4HE!#7,
WASFORMEDIN/CTOBERTOHELPDEVELOPINGANDESPECIALLY,$#-EMBERSTOMAKEMORE
EFFECTIVEUSEOFTHE74/SDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMALLCOUNTRIESDESIGNATEDBYTHE
5NITED.ATIONSASLEASTDEVELOPEDTHATARE-EMBERSOFTHE74/AREENTITLEDTOITSSERVICES
FORAMODESTFEE
4YPESOFDISPUTESBROUGHTTOTHE74/
4HE$35NOWALLOWSFOR-EMBERSTOCHALLENGESEVERALMEASURESANDTOFILECOMPLAINTS
UNDERSEVERAL74/AGREEMENTSINASINGLEDISPUTEPROCEEDING4HISALLOWS-EMBERSTO
ADDRESSALLORSEVERALASPECTSOFLARGERDISPUTESANDASSUCHFACILITATEAMORECOMPREHENSIVE
SETTLEMENTOFDISPUTES/NTHEOTHERHANDSUCHCASESTENDTOIMPOSEANENORMOUSWORKLOAD
ONDEVELOPINGANDDEVELOPED74/-EMBERS
4HEMAINAREASOFCOMPLAINT HAVEBEEN'!44REQUESTSOFWHICHHAVE
BEENONNATIONALTREATMENTON-&.TREATMENTANDONQUANTITATIVERESTRICTIONS SUBSIDIESAGRICULTUREANDANTIDUMPING)NFACTMORETHANOFTHE
DISPUTESCONCERNTRADEREMEDIESDISPUTES
.UMBEROFPANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYREPORTSCIRCULATED
/FTHECASESTHATGOTHROUGH74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEDURESALARGENUMBERTENDTO
BERESOLVEDTHROUGHBILATERALCONSULTATIONSBETWEENTHE-EMBERS&ORTHOSECASESTHATGO
BEYONDCONSULTATIONSTOFORMALPANELSTHEMAJORITYGOTOTHEAPPEALSTAGE
4HE$35ALSOFAVOURSTHEGROUPINGOFSTATESANDTHISHASALLOWEDSEVERAL74/-EMBERS
TOJOININANDCOORDINATEANDCOLLABORATETOCHALLENGETOGETHERMEASURESOFOTHER74/
-EMBERSCONSIDERED74/INCONSISTENT&ORINSTANCEONNUMEROUSOCCASIONSTHE%#ANDTHE
53HAVEINITIATEDDISPUTESJOINTLYWITHOTHER-EMBERS4HISHASALLOWEDLESSEXPERIENCED
-EMBERSTODEVELOPEXPERTISEANDBENEFITFROMTHECOLLABORATIONWITHCOCOMPLAINANTS
DURINGTHEPROCEEDINGS%IGHTYTHREEPANELREPORTSANDAPPELLATEREPORTSHAVEBEEN
ADOPTEDBYTHE$3"
,EASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTHATHAVE
PARTICIPATEDINDISPUTESASTHIRDPARTIESINCLUDE
"ANGLADESH"ENIN#HAD-ADAGASCAR-ALAWI
3ENEGALAND4ANZANIA
"ANGLADESHREQUESTEDCONSULTATIONSWITH
)NDIAON*ANUARYREGARDINGTHELATTERS
IMPOSITIONOFANTIDUMPINGDUTIESONIMPORTS
OFLEADACIDBATTERIESFROM"ANGLADESH74/
DOCUMENT74$3&EBRUARYIN
&EBRUARYTHE%#REQUESTEDTOJOINTHESE
CONSULTATIONS74/DOCUMENT74$3
&EBRUARY
"ASEDONCASESASAT3EPTEMBER
4HEREISSOMEDOUBLECOUNTINGASSOMEOF
THECASESBROUGHTUNDER!RTICLE)))OFTHE'!44
AREALSOBROUGHTUNDER!RTICLE)
-EMBERSHAVEINGENERALIMPLEMENTEDTHERECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSMADEBY
PANELSANDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYINTHEhREASONABLEPERIODOFTIMEvDETERMINEDUNDER
!RTICLEOFTHE$354HISISANACHIEVEMENTANDASUCCESSTHE74/-EMBERSBELIEVEIN
THE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMANDRESPECTIT
)TISDISAPPOINTINGTHATCOMPLIANCEISSOMETIMESSLOWTOCOMEANDVERYDIFFICULTTOINDUCE
THROUGHSANCTIONS)NCASESWHERE-EMBERSHAVEFAILEDTOAGREETHROUGHCONSULTATIONS
ONIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE$3"SRECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSRECOURSETOTHEDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTPROCEDURESUNDERTHECOMPLIANCEREVIEWPROCEDUREOFTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
5NDERSTANDING!RTOFTHE$35HASBEENSOUGHT
)TISANACHIEVEMENTESPECIALLYFORWEAKER-EMBERSTOBEABLETORELYONADISPUTE
SETTLEMENTSYSTEMWHICHPROHIBITSANYFORMOFUNILATERALACTIONBY-EMBERSASONLYTHE$3"
ISENTITLEDTOREACHTHECONCLUSIONTHATA-EMBERSMEASUREORANIMPLEMENTINGMEASURE
IS74/INCONSISTENT)NTHISSENSETHEPROCEDURESOFTHE$35NOWREGULATEANDLIMITTHE
EXERCISEOFSANCTIONSANDCOUNTERVAILINGMEASURESOFALL74/-EMBERS
(OWEVERINAFEWCASESUNDERTHE$35COMPLIANCEBY-EMBERSHASBEENCONTESTEDAND
HASRESULTEDINAUTHORIZATIONBYTHE$3"TOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSANDOBLIGATIONSAGAINSTTHE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
)MPLEMENTATIONANDCOMPLIANCE
NONCOMPLYING-EMBERAUTHORIZATIONTOTHEWINNING-EMBERTOEXERCISECOUNTERMEASURES
AGAINSTTHELOSING-EMBER4HECASESTHATHAVERESULTEDINSUCHANAUTHORIZATIONSINCETHE
FORMATIONOFTHE74/ARE
%#BANONMEATANDMEATPRODUCTSCOMPLAINTSBYTHE5NITED3TATESAND#ANADA
%#(ORMONES
%#BANANAREGIMECOMPLAINTSBYTHE5NITED3TATESAND%CUADOR%#"ANANAS)))
"RAZILEXPORTFINANCINGFORAIRCRAFTCOMPLAINTBY#ANADA"RAZIL!IRCRAFT
5NITED3TATES&OREIGN3ALES#ORPORATIONS&3#SCOMPLAINTBYTHE%#53&3#
#ANADAEXPORTCREDITSANDLOANGUARANTEESFORAIRCRAFTCOMPLAINTBY"RAZIL
#ANADA!IRCRAFT#REDITSAND'UARANTEES
5NITED3TATES!NTI$UMPING!CTCOMPLAINTBYTHE%#53!#4
5NITED3TATES/FFSET!CT"YRD!MENDMENTCOMPLAINTSBY"RAZIL#ANADA#HILE%#
)NDIA*APAN+OREAAND-EXICO53/FFSET!CT"YRD!MENDMENT
)NTHE %#"ANANAS)))DISPUTE%CUADORDECIDEDNOTTORETALIATEBECAUSEOFACHANGEIN
THE%#BANANAIMPORTREGIME)NTHECASEOFTHE 53!CTANARBITRATIONDECISIONWAS
CIRCULATEDON&EBRUARYALTHOUGHTHE%#HASNOTASYETREQUESTEDAUTHORIZATION
TOSUSPENDCONCESSIONSANDOBLIGATIONS )NTHECASEOFTHE 53&3#DISPUTETHE%#
SUSPENDEDCONCESSIONSANDOBLIGATIONSON-ARCHONANUMBEROFPRODUCTS
IMPORTEDFROMTHE5NITED3TATES)N.OVEMBERTHE53ADOPTEDANIMPLEMENTATION
ACTWHICHACCORDINGTOTHE53WOULDBECOMPATIBLEWITHITS74/OBLIGATIONS)N.OVEMBER
THE%#HADALSOINITIATEDTHECOMPLIANCEREVIEWPROCEDUREOFTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT
5NDERSTANDING!RTOFTHE$35ALLEGINGTHATASPECTSOFTHE53)MPLEMENTATION
PACKAGEDIDNOTCOMPLYWITHTHE74/!GREEMENT)N*ANUARYTHE%##OUNCIL
ANNOUNCEDITSINTENTIONTOREMOVEITSINCREASEDTARIFFS74/COUNTERMEASURESAND
SANCTIONSMAYHOWEVERHAVEVERYDETRIMENTALEFFECTSONECONOMICACTORSNOTINVOLVEDIN
THESPECIFICDISPUTESANDPARTNERS
&INALLYONESHOULDNOTETHENOVELTYANDIMPACTOFTHEPOSSIBILITYOFFEREDBYTHE$35FOR
74/-EMBERSTOUSECROSSRETALIATIONTHATISTOIMPOSECOUNTERMEASURESINOTHERSECTORS
ORUNDEROTHERAGREEMENTS)NTHEFAMOUS%#n"ANANAS)))DISPUTE%CUADORWASAUTHORIZED
BYTHE$3"TOUSECROSSRETALIATIONAGAINSTIMPORTSFROMTHE%#BUTTHEDISPUTEWASRESOLVED
AMICABLYWITHOUTTHENEEDTORESORTTOTHEUSEOFCOUNTERMEASURES
4HE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT5NDERSTANDINGEXERCISE
4HE$35NEGOTIATIONSHAVECONFIRMED-EMBERSOVERALLSENSETHATTHESYSTEMHASWORKED
WELL)NTHISRESPECTTHE#ONSULTATIVE"OARDS MAINRECOMMENDATIONOFh$ONOHARMvVERY
MUCHECHOESTHESENTIMENTEXPRESSEDBYMANY-EMBERSINTHESENEGOTIATIONS7HILETHIS
ISOFCOURSEAVERYPOSITIVEASSESSMENTOFTHE$35ASITSTANDSITALSOMAKESITDIFFICULTTO
AGREEONANYCHANGEEVENWHENSUCHCHANGESCOULDGENUINELYLEADTOIMPROVEMENTSOR
CLARIFICATIONS
!SIDEFROMSOMESIGNIFICANTBUTQUITETECHNICALISSUESSUCHASTHEGRANTOFAREMAND
AUTHORITYTOTHE!PPELLATE"ODYSOMEISSUESSTANDOUTINPARTICULARACCESSTOTHESYSTEMFOR
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDTHEDIFFICULTIESININDUCINGCOMPLIANCEINSOMECASES
&INALLYONTHEISSUEOFINCREASEDTRANSPARENCYANDACCESSTOTHEPROCEEDINGSBYCIVIL
SOCIETYTHROUGHAMICUSCURIAEBRIEFSOROPENHEARINGSWHICHTHE#ONSULTATIVE"OARD
HIGHLIGHTSASANAREAFORPOTENTIALIMPROVEMENTNOVISIBLEPROGRESSHASBEENMADESOFAR
INTHENEGOTIATIONS4HISISANISSUEWHICHPERHAPSAFFECTSTHEEXTERNALVISIBILITYANDIMAGEOF
THEORGANIZATIONMORETHANTHEFUNCTIONINGOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMITSELF
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
74/DOCUMENT74$3!2"&EBRUARY
4HE5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDTHE3ECRETARIAT
THATITWASWORKINGCONTINUOUSLYWITHTHE
5NITED3TATES#ONGRESSTOENACTLEGISLATIONAND
WOULDCONFERWITHTHE%#AND*APANTOREACH
AMUTUALLYSATISFACTORYRESOLUTIONOFTHEMATTER
74/DOCUMENT74$3!DD
-AY)NASUBSEQUENTNOTIFICATIONTHE
5NITED3TATESNOTIFIEDTHE3ECRETARIATTHATIT
HADURGEDTHE53(OUSEOF2EPRESENTATIVES
TOSUPPORTLEGISLATIONTOREPEALTHE!CT
ATTHEEARLIESTOPPORTUNITY74/DOCUMENT
74$3!DD*ULY
74/$IRECTOR'ENERALS#ONSULTATIVE"OARD
REPORTh4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/v*ANUARY
4HE74/!PPELLATE"ODY
4HEESTABLISHMENTOFASTANDING!PPELLATE"ODYWASONEOFTHEMOSTIMPORTANTCHANGES
TOTHE'!4474/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMRESULTINGFROMTHE5RUGUAY
2OUND4HE!PPELLATE"ODYCONSISTSOFSEVENPERSONSRETAINEDONAPARTTIMEBASISAND
HEARSAPPEALSFROMDECISIONSBY74/0ANELS 7ITHINTHEDESIGNOFTHEIMPROVEDDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTPROCEDURESTHECREATIONOFTHERIGHTTOAPPEALAGAINSTFIRSTINSTANCEPANELREPORTS
WASINTENDEDTOBALANCETHEGREATERhAUTOMATICITYvINTHEPANELPROCEEDINGSINPARTICULAR
THEQUASIAUTOMATICADOPTIONOFPANELREPORTSBYTHE$ISPUTE3ETTLEMENT"ODYTHEh$3"v
)NADDITIONTHE!PPELLATE"ODYASASTANDINGQUASIJUDICIALDISPUTESETTLEMENTORGAN
ISENTRUSTEDWITHENSURINGUNIFORMITYANDCOHERENCEINTHECASELAWSOASTOFURTHERTHE
GOALOFSECURITYANDPREDICTABILITYENSHRINEDINTHE5NDERSTANDINGON2ULESAND0ROCEDURES
'OVERNINGTHE3ETTLEMENTOF$ISPUTESTHEh$35v
/VERTHECOURSEOFTHEPASTTENYEARS
FOURTEENINDIVIDUALSnTHIRTEENMENAND
ONEWOMANnHAVESERVEDORCONTINUETO
SERVEONTHE!PPELLATE"ODY
4HERIGHTTOAPPELLATEREVIEWINANINTERNATIONALDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMWASAT
THETIMEOFTHECONCLUSIONOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDARELATIVENOVELTY!TTHATTIMEVERYFEW
INTERNATIONALDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMSPROVIDEDFORTHEPOSSIBILITYTOAPPEALFROM
DECISIONSOFFIRSTINSTANCEORGANS4ENYEARSLATERTHEREISARGUABLYATRENDnINANUMBEROF
REGIONALINTEGRATIONAGREEMENTSANDOTHERINTERNATIONALDISPUTESETTLEMENTFORAnTOPROVIDE
FORnORATLEASTTOCONSIDERnTHEPOSSIBILITYOFAPPEAL )NTHISCONTEXTTHEEXPERIENCEOFTHE
!PPELLATE"ODYANDITSCONTRIBUTIONTOTHEFUNCTIONING74/SYSTEMAREOFTENTIMESREFERRED
TOASAGUIDINGEXAMPLE
)NITSTENYEARSOFEXISTENCETHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASISSUEDREPORTSANDASOF
*ANUARYWASSEIZEDWITHFOURPENDINGAPPEALS 4HISBODYOFWORKBOTHINITS
ENTIRETYASWELLASBROKENDOWNINTOANNUALAVERAGEFIGURESISMUCHHIGHERTHANTHAT
OFMOSTINTERNATIONALTRIBUNALSORQUASIJUDICIALBODIESSOMEOFWHICHHAVEBEENIN
EXISTENCESIGNIFICANTLYLONGERTHANTHE!PPELLATE"ODY4HISACTIVERECOURSETO!PPELLATE
"ODYPROCEDURESDEMONSTRATES INTERALIATHEHIGHLEVELOFCONFIDENCETHAT74/-EMBERS
HAVEPLACEDANDCONTINUETOPLACEINTHE!PPELLATE"ODY
3INCETHE!PPELLATE"ODYSCASELOADHASCOVEREDAWIDEANDIMPRESSIVEARRAY
OFSUBJECTAREASINCLUDINGAGRICULTURESANITARYANDPHYTOSANITARYMEASURESTEXTILES
TECHNICALBARRIERSTOTRADEANTIDUMPINGANDCOUNTERVAILINGDUTIESSAFEGUARDSDOMESTIC
ANDEXPORTSUBSIDIESTRADEINSERVICESANDINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTS)NADDITION
THE!PPELLATE"ODYHASCLARIFIEDMANYPROVISIONSOFTHE$35RELATEDTOTHECONDUCTOF
PANELAND!PPELLATE"ODYPROCEEDINGSINSODOINGTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASADDRESSED
ISSUESSUCHASSTANDINGANDLEGALINTERESTTERMSOFREFERENCEOFPANELSDUEPROCESS
REQUIREMENTSANDRIGHTSOFTHIRDPARTIES&ORADISPUTESETTLEMENTINSTITUTIONINEXISTENCE
ONLYTENYEARSTHISISANIMPRESSIVEANDVARIEDBODYOFLEGALFINDINGS-OREOVERAS
THERECENT2EPORTBYTHE#ONSULTATIVE"OARDTOTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL 4HE&UTUREOFTHE
74/NOTEDh;T=HEREISNODOUBTTHATTHISJURISPRUDENCEWILLHAVEANEFFECTONGENERAL
INTERNATIONALLAWBROADERTHANTHEBORDERLINESOFTHE74/SYSTEMv )NDEEDSOME
REGIONALTRADEDISPUTESETTLEMENTFORAREFERTO!PPELLATE"ODYFINDINGSINTHEIROWN
DECISIONMAKING
4HEPERCENTAGEOFPANELREPORTSAPPEALEDHASFLUCTUATEDOVERTHEYEARSBUTHAS
AVERAGEDATABOUTPERCENTANDSOFARHASNEVERGONEBELOWPERCENT/VERTHELAST
TWOYEARSTHEPERCENTAGEOFPANELREPORTSAPPEALEDHASSHOWNANINCREASINGTRENDAND
STOODATPERCENTFOR!GAINTHISRELATIVELYHIGHFIGUREWOULDAPPEARTOINDICATE
THE74/-EMBERSCONFIDENCEINTHE!PPELLATE"ODYINITSROLETOPROVIDEHIGHQUALITY
REVIEWOFPANELREPORTSANDTOENSUREUNIFORMITYANDCOHERENCEASWELLASSECURITYAND
PREDICTABILITYINTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEM
0ARTICIPANTSINPROCEEDINGS
!SOFTHEENDOF*ANUARY74/-EMBERS nTHATISMORETHANONEFIFTHOFTHE
74/MEMBERSHIP nHAVEAPPEAREDASAMAINPARTYINPROCEEDINGSBEFORETHE!PPELLATE
"ODYSINCEITSESTABLISHMENTIN4WENTYTWOOFTHESE-EMBERSHAVEACTEDAS
APPELLANTOTHERAPPELLANTANDAPPELLEE&URTHERMOREOFTHESE74/-EMBERSARE
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERSINOTHERWORDSALMOSTPERCENTOFTHE74/-EMBERS
THATHAVEAPPEAREDBEFORETHE!PPELLATE"ODYASEITHERAPPELLANTOTHERAPPELLANTOR
APPELLEEAREDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY-EMBERS
)FWEINCLUDETHOSE-EMBERSTHATHAVEAPPEAREDASTHIRDPARTICIPANTSTHETOTAL
NUMBEROF74/-EMBERSTHATHAVEPARTICIPATEDINPROCEEDINGSBEFORETHE!PPELLATE
"ODYEITHERASAPPELLANTOTHERAPPELLANTAPPELLEEORTHIRDPARTICIPANTRISESTOTHAT
ISALMOSTHALFOFTHEENTIRE74/MEMBERSHIP &IFTYNINEOFTHESE74/-EMBERSOR
PERCENTAREDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
4HUSAVERYSIGNIFICANTPROPORTIONOFTHE74/-EMBERSHIPHASAVAILEDITSELFOFTHE
POSSIBILITYTOPARTICIPATEINPROCEEDINGSBEFORETHE!PPELLATE"ODY3UCHAHIGHRATEOF
PARTICIPATIONARGUABLYSIGNALSHIGHINTERESTONTHEPARTOFTHE74/-EMBERSINDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTANDINPARTICULARAPPELLATEPROCEEDINGS/NEMAYALSOARGUETHATINTHELIGHT
OFTHESIGNIFICANTLEVELOFPARTICIPATIONPROCEEDINGSBEFORETHE!PPELLATE"ODYHAVEMUCH
CONTRIBUTEDTOTHEINTERNALTRANSPARENCYANDLEGITIMACYOFDISPUTESETTLEMENTPROCEEDINGS
WITHINTHE74/-EMBERSHIP
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYHASOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSSTRICTLYADHEREDTOTHETIMELIMITS
FORAPPELLATEPROCEEDINGSASSETFORTHINTHE$35!CCORDINGTO!RTICLEOFTHE$35
APPELLATEPROCEEDINGSSHALLNOTEXCEEDDAYSFROMTHEDATEOFTHEFILINGOFTHENOTICE
OFAPPEAL/VERTHEPASTTENYEARSTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASWORKEDDILIGENTLYTOENSURE
CIRCULATIONOFITSREPORTSWITHINTHISSPECIFIEDTIMELIMITANDWASSUCCESSFULINDOINGSOIN
ALLBUTFOURCASES
4HISSTRICTADHERENCETOARELATIVELYTIGHTDEADLINEnUNUSUALFORANAPPELLATEQUASI
TRIBUNALnISMOSTCERTAINLYANOTEWORTHYACHIEVEMENTGIVENTHATMANYAPPEALSINVOLVE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
%XAMPLESINCLUDE-%2#/352THECURRENT
&REE4RADE!REAOFTHE!MERICASNEGOTIATIONS
ANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL#ENTREFORTHE3ETTLEMENT
OF)NVESTMENT$ISPUTES
%IGHTOFTHESEREPORTSRESULTEDFROM
APPELLATEPROCEEDINGSINCOMPLIANCE
PROCEEDINGSPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE
$35
2EPORTBYTHE#ONSULTATIVE"OARDTOTHE
$IRECTOR'ENERAL4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/P
4HE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESISCOUNTEDASONE
74/-EMBERNOTASTHESUMOFITS-EMBER
3TATESWHOAREALSO74/-EMBERSINTHEIR
OWNRIGHT
!SOF*ANUARYTHE74/COUNTED
-EMBERS
)FTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESISCOUNTEDNOT
ASONE-EMBERBUTRATHERAS-EMBERS
THETOTALNUMBEROF74/-EMBERSTHATHAVE
APPEAREDBEFORETHE!PPELLATE"ODYRISESTO
THATISMORETHANPERCENTOFTHEENTIRE
74/MEMBERSHIP
NUMEROUSANDCOMPLEXQUESTIONSOFLAWANDTHATINAHIGHPROPORTIONOFAPPEALSA
hCROSSAPPEALvWASFILED)TMUSTALSOBEKEPTINMINDTHATTHE!PPELLATE"ODYATVARIOUS
POINTSOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSHASHADTODEALWITHUPTOFOURAPPEALSSIMULTANEOUSLY
ANDTHATAPORTIONOFTHEDAYPERIODHASGENERALLYBEENSETASIDEFORTRANSLATIONOFTHE
2EPORTINTOALLTHREE74/OFFICIALLANGUAGES-OREOVERASEVIDENCEDBYTHERESPECTFOR
THE!PPELLATE"ODYSWORKTHETIMECONSTRAINTSUNDERWHICHTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASTO
OPERATEHAVENOTAFFECTEDTHEQUALITYOFITSLEGALANALYSIS
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYHASBEENMAKINGITSDECISIONSBYCONSENSUS
2ULEOFTHE7ORKING0ROCEDURESSTIPULATESTHATTHE!PPELLATE"ODYANDITSDIVISIONS
hSHALLMAKEEVERYEFFORTTOTAKETHEIRDECISIONSBYCONSENSUSv7HERENOCONSENSUSIS
REACHEDTHEMATTERISTOBEDECIDEDBYAMAJORITYVOTE-OREOVERINDIVIDUAL!PPELLATE"ODY
MEMBERSMAYEXPRESSINDIVIDUALOPINIONSALBEITANONYMOUSLYPURSUANTTO!RTICLEOF
THE$35
$ESPITETHEHIGHNUMBEROFAPPEALSDECIDEDANDDESPITETHEOFTENTIMESDIFFICULTLEGAL
QUESTIONSRAISEDBYTHESECASESTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASINALLBUTONEINSTANCETAKENITS
DECISIONSBYCONSENSUS)NTHATONEINSTANCEADIVISIONMEMBEREXPRESSEDANANONYMOUS
CONCURRENTOPINION4HISBROADCONSENSUSUNDERPINNINGTHEFINDINGSOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODY
ISAREMARKABLEACHIEVEMENT!FTERALLMANYAPPEALSINVOLVECOMPLEXQUESTIONSANDTHE
SEVEN!PPELLATE"ODYMEMBERSORIGINATEFROMDIFFERENTLEGALTRADITIONSANDHAVEDIVERSE
PROFESSIONALBACKGROUNDS4HISHIGHDEGREEOFCONSENSUSBEHINDTHE!PPELLATE"ODYS
FINDINGSPROVIDESTHE74/SYSTEMWITHCLEARPRONOUNCEMENTSONTHELEGALISSUESRAISEDON
APPEALANDADDSTOTHESECURITYANDPREDICTABILITYOFTHEINTERNATIONALTRADINGSYSTEMAS
ENVISAGEDBYTHE$35
5NLIKEPANELSTHATADOPTTHEIRWORKINGPROCEDURESONACASEBYCASEBASISTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYHASPERMANENT7ORKING0ROCEDURES0URSUANTTO!RTICLEOFTHE$35THESE
7ORKING0ROCEDURESSHALLBEDRAWNUPBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYITSELFINCONSULTATIONWITH
THE#HAIRMANOFTHE$3"ANDTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL4HE7ORKING0ROCEDURESADDRESSISSUES
SUCHASDUTIESANDRESPONSIBILITIESOF!PPELLATE"ODYMEMBERSASWELLASTHEDETAILSOFTHE
CONDUCTOFAPPELLATEPROCEEDINGS
4HEEXPERIENCEOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYWITHITS7ORKING0ROCEDURESHASBEEN
OVERWHELMINGLYPOSITIVE4HEALREADYIMPRESSIVECASELOADOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODYOVERTHE
PASTTENYEARSHASNOTREVEALEDANYMAJORSHORTCOMINGSORGAPSINTHE7ORKING0ROCEDURES
4HE!PPELLATE"ODYMODIFIEDTHE7ORKING0ROCEDURESONSEVERALOCCASIONSTHETWOMOST
RECENTCHANGESINANDRESPECTIVELYCONCERNEDISSUESSUCHASTHEPARTICIPATION
OFTHIRDPARTICIPANTSINTHEORALHEARINGSAMENDMENTSTONOTICESOFAPPEALTHETIMINGOF
THEORALHEARINGCLERICALCHANGESTOWRITTENSUBMISSIONSANDTHEREQUIREMENTSFORFILINGAN
hOTHERvAPPEAL4HEMODIFICATIONSDONOTFUNDAMENTALLYCHANGETHEORIGINALVERSIONOFTHE
7ORKING0ROCEDURESBUTRATHERREFLECTANATURALANDONGOINGADJUSTMENTPROCESSINTHE
LIGHTOFTHERICHANDVARIEDEXPERIENCEGENERATEDBYTHE!PPELLATE"ODYSWORK
/VERTHEPASTTENYEARSTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHASEARNEDTHERESPECTOF74/-EMBERS
ASWELLASOFIMPARTIALOBSERVERSINTHEBROADERTRADINGCOMMUNITYANDACADEMIAFORTHE
QUALITYOFTHELEGALANALYSISINITSREPORTSASWELLASFORITSUNDISPUTEDANDUNFLINCHING
IMPARTIALITYANDPROFESSIONALISM4HISISUNDOUBTEDLYDUEINALARGEMEASURETOTHEFACT
THATLEADINGLEGALMINDSHAVEBEENAPPOINTEDTOSERVEONTHE!PPELLATE"ODYASSISTEDBYA
DEDICATED!PPELLATE"ODY3ECRETARIAT
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
!CCEPTANCEOF!PPELLATE"ODYFINDINGS
74/-EMBERSHAVESHOWNAVERYHIGHDEGREEOFACCEPTANCEOF!PPELLATE"ODYFINDINGS
4HATISNOTTOSAYTHATALL74/-EMBERSHAVEATALLTIMESPROMPTLYIMPLEMENTEDTHE
RECOMMENDATIONSANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"MADEATTHERECOMMENDATIONOFTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYORTHATINDIVIDUAL-EMBERSWHOHAVELOSTAPPEALSHAVENOTCRITICIZEDCERTAINRESULTS
FROMTIMETOTIME(OWEVERNO74/-EMBERHASHITHERTOFAILEDTOAGREEORFAILEDTO
EXPRESSITSINTENTIONTOBRINGITSMEASURESINTOCONFORMITYINTHELIGHTOFRECOMMENDATIONS
ANDRULINGSOFTHE$3"MADEATTHERECOMMENDATIONOFTHE!PPELLATE"ODY3IMILARLYINTHE
CURRENT$35REVIEWPROCESSNO74/-EMBERHASSUGGESTEDTHATTHE!PPELLATE"ODYSHOULD
DISCONTINUEITSWORKORINDEEDCHANGEITSPROCEDURESINANYFUNDAMENTALWAY2ATHERON
THECONTRARYASALREADYMENTIONEDTHEREARETHOSEWHOCONSIDERMODELLINGOTHERDISPUTE
SETTLEMENTMECHANISMSAFTERTHE74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTSYSTEMINCLUDINGTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYnWITNESSFORINSTANCETHEDRAFTAGREEMENTFORTHEESTABLISHMENTOFA&REE4RADE!REA
OFTHE!MERICAS
%QUALLYINTHEBROADERTRADEPOLICYCOMMUNITYASWELLASINACADEMIA!PPELLATE"ODY
REPORTSAREGENERALLYAPPRECIATEDFORTHEHIGHQUALITYLEGALANALYSISANDARECONSIDERED
IMPORTANTCONTRIBUTIONSTOMAINTAININGTHEINTELLECTUALCOHERENCEANDPREDICTABILITYOFTHE
GLOBALTRADINGSYSTEM4HATISNOTTOSAYTHATINDIVIDUALREPORTSORFINDINGSARENOTINTENSELY
DISCUSSEDANDOCCASIONALLYCRITICIZED)NDEEDTOANIMPORTANTEXTENTDISCUSSIONSAND
CRITICISMSBYIMPARTIALCOMMENTATORSnTHOSENOTCONSTRAINEDBYAFFILIATIONSWITHPARTICULAR
INTERESTGROUPSnAREAPOSITIVESIGNTHATREFLECTSTHERELEVANCEOFTHEWORKOFTHE!PPELLATE
"ODYFORTHEGLOBALTRADINGSYSTEMASAWHOLE!TTHESAMETIMETHERECENT2EPORTBYTHE
#ONSULTATIVE"OARDTOTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/NOTEDh;I=TISNOT
ALWAYSCLEARTHATSOMEOFTHEHARSHESTCRITICSOF74/JURISPRUDENCEMANYOFWHOMHAVE
ADVOCACYROLESRELATEDTOAVARIETYOFSPECIALINTERESTSHAVETHEBESTINTERESTSOFTHEOVERALL
74/SYSTEMINMINDv
$ESPITETHEMANYCHALLENGESFACINGAQUASIJUDICIALINSTITUTIONATTHEOUTSETOFITS
EXISTENCEWITHINANORGANIZATIONOFALMOSTUNIVERSALMEMBERSHIPTHE!PPELLATE"ODYHAS
OVERTHEFIRSTTENYEARSOFITSEXISTENCECREATEDANIMPRESSIVEHIGHQUALITYBODYOFCASELAW
THEREBYCONTRIBUTINGTOTHEFUNCTIONINGSECURITYANDPREDICTABILITYOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADING
SYSTEM
4HEAREASDEALTWITHUNDER2ULESINCLUDESUBSIDIESSAFEGUARDSANDANTIDUMPING2ULES
HAVEBEENACRUCIALPARTOFTHEMULTILATERALSYSTEMSINCEITSFIRSTIMPLEMENTATIONUNDERTHE
'!44
7ORKOVERTHELASTDECADEHASINCLUDED
s -ONITORINGANDASSISTINGINTHESMOOTHIMPLEMENTATIONBY-EMBERSAND
ESPECIALLYNEWANDDEVELOPING-EMBERSOFTHEIROBLIGATIONSUNDERTHE
5RUGUAY2OUNDAGREEMENTSRELATINGTO2ULESINCLUDING
NOTIFICATIONSOFNEWORAMENDEDTRADEREMEDYLEGISLATIONAND
MEASURES
MULTILATERALREVIEWSOFTRADEREMEDYLEGISLATIONSANDMEASURES
TECHNICALASSISTANCE
4HISHASBEENANIMPORTANTACHIEVEMENTOFTHE74/BECAUSETHEPRESENT
SYSTEMISMUCHMOREEFFICIENTINMONITORINGANDTOSOMEEXTENTINFLUENCING
-EMBERSIMPLEMENTATIONPOLICIESTHANWASTHEOLD'!44
s %FFECTIVEOPERATIONOFTHEDISPUTESETTLEMENTMECHANISMINTHE2ULESAREA
HELPING-EMBERSRESOLVEDIFFERENCESCONCERNINGTHEUNDERSTANDINGAND
APPLICATIONOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDAGREEMENTSINTHISAREA4HE74/DISPUTE
SETTLEMENTSYSTEMHASBEENTHEMOSTIMPORTANTACHIEVEMENTOFTHE74/IN
PARTICULARINTHE2ULESAREAWHEREITSCONTRIBUTIONTOCLARIFYINGANDINTERPRETING
THETEXTSOFTENDELIBERATELYAMBIGUOUSCANNOTBEUNDERESTIMATED
s #ONDUCTOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEASSISTINGPARTICULARLYNEWANDDEVELOPING
-EMBERSINUNDERSTANDINGTHEIRRIGHTSANDOBLIGATIONSUNDERTHE5RUGUAY
2OUND!GREEMENTSINTHE2ULESAREAn
HANDSONASSISTANCEINDRAFTINGLEGALINSTRUMENTSNECESSARYTO
IMPLEMENTTHE!GREEMENTS
ASSISTANCEINESTABLISHINGANDMAKINGOPERATIONALNATIONAL
MECHANISMSTOENABLEDOMESTICAUTHORITIESTOEXERCISERIGHTSUNDER
THE!GREEMENTS
4HENATUREOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEPROVIDEDBYTHE74/INTHE2ULESAREAS
HASCHANGEDREMARKABLYOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSITISNOWVERYHANDSONAND
GENERALLYRECOGNIZEDBYTHERECIPIENTSASTHEMOSTCOMPETENTANDPROFESSIONAL
COMPAREDTOALLOTHERSOURCESOFTECHNICALASSISTANCE
s ,AUNCHINGANDMOVINGFORWARDNEGOTIATIONSINTHE2ULESAREAnTOCLARIFY
ANDIMPROVEASPECTSOFCERTAINOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDAGREEMENTSINTHE
AREAOFFISHERIESSUBSIDIESWITHPOTENTIALBENEFITSFORTRADEANDSUSTAINABLE
DEVELOPMENT74/DISPUTESETTLEMENTCANNOTRESOLVEALLPROBLEMSENCOUNTERED
BY-EMBERSINTHEIMPLEMENTATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFTHE2ULESAGREEMENTS
4HISISWHYITISVERYIMPORTANTTOHAVETHE2ULESNEGOTIATIONSASANINTEGRAL
PARTOFTHE$OHA2OUNDWHICHWASNOTSOOBVIOUSINTHEPREPARATIONPROCESS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
2ULES
#HALLENGES
2EPORTBYTHE#ONSULTATIVE"OARDTOTHE
$IRECTOR'ENERAL4HE&UTUREOFTHE74/
P
&AILURETOACHIEVETHEFULLDEGREEOFTRANSPARENCYINTHESUBSIDIESAREAENVISIONEDBYTHE
3UBSIDIESAND#OUNTERVAILING-EASURES3#-!GREEMENTDUEPRIMARILYTOTHEUNWILLINGNESS
OF-EMBERSTOBEFORTHCOMINGINTERMSOFTHECOMPLETENESSANDTHOROUGHNESSOFTHEIR
SUBSIDYNOTIFICATIONS
4RADEPOLICIESREVIEW
4HE4RADE0OLICY2EVIEW-ECHANISM402-HASSHOWNSOLIDPROGRESSDURINGTHEFIRST
TENYEARSOFTHE74/BUTTHEPERFORMANCEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS24!SHASBEEN
LESSTHANSTELLARALTHOUGHTHEREISNOWAREALPOSSIBILITYOFIMPROVEMENT
4RADEPOLICYREVIEWS
4HE402-WASPROVISIONALLYESTABLISHEDINTHE'!44INFOLLOWINGTHE-ID4ERM
2EVIEWOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUNDANDBECAMEAPERMANENTINSTRUMENTOFTHE74/WITHTHE
SIGNINGOFTHE&INAL!CTIN-ARRAKESH4HEOBJECTIVESOFTHE-ECHANISMARELAIDOUTIN
!NNEXTOTHE74/!GREEMENT
hTOCONTRIBUTETOIMPROVEDADHERENCEBYALL-EMBERSTORULESDISCIPLINESAND
COMMITMENTSMADEUNDERTHE-ULTILATERAL4RADE!GREEMENTSANDWHEREAPPLICABLE
THE0LURILATERAL4RADE!GREEMENTSANDHENCETOTHESMOOTHERFUNCTIONINGOFTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMBYACHIEVINGGREATERTRANSPARENCYINANDUNDERSTANDINGOF
THETRADEPOLICIESOF-EMBERSv
2EVIEWSHAVEGONEFROMBEINGAhBURDENvTOBEINGhDEMANDDRIVENv)NITIALLYTHELARGER
-EMBERSTHOUGHTTHEIRPOLICIESALREADYWELLKNOWNANDSUFFICIENTLYOFTENDISCUSSEDEGIN
THE'ENERAL#OUNCILASSUCHPUTTINGTOGETHERTHENEEDEDINFORMATIONFORAREVIEWWASFELT
TOBEALMOSTADISTRACTIONFROMMOREIMPORTANTWORKNOTREALLYWORTHTHEEFFORT4HESMALLER
ESPECIALLYLESSERDEVELOPED-EMBERSSAWREVIEWSBYANDLARGEASBEINGBEYONDTHEIR
RESOURCECAPABILITIES.OWASIGNIFICANTNUMBEROF-EMBERSREQUESTREVIEWSANDORACCEPT
ANYDELAYINTHENORMALSCHEDULINGOFREVIEWSWITHLITTLEGRACESUCHTHATTHE3ECRETARIATS
RESOURCESARENOLONGERSUFFICIENTTOTHENEEDEXPRESSEDBY-EMBERSFORREVIEWS%SSENTIALLY
THEREASONSFORTHISCHANGEINATTITUDEARE
THE3ECRETARIATREPORTSALTHOUGHCOMPREHENSIVEHAVEBECOMEMOREFOCUSEDAND
ANALYTICWITHTHE-EMBERSREPORTASACOMPLEMENTARYRATHERTHANCOMPETING
DOCUMENT)NCONSEQUENCETHE-EMBERUNDERREVIEWLEARNSMOREABOUTITSOWN
MEASURESTHE-EMBERSHIPGETSAMORECOMPLETEPICTUREOFTHE-EMBERSPOLICIES
OPTIONSANDCHALLENGESANDTHEPOTENTIALFORDISCUSSIONHASIMPROVED
THE3ECRETARIATHASBECOMEMOREEFFICIENTINCOLLECTINGINFORMATIONFORTHEREPORTS
REDUCINGTHEDEMANDSONTHEAUTHORITIESAND
FORTHELESSERDEVELOPED-EMBERSTHEREVIEWPREPARATIONSHAVETAKENONMUCHMORE
OFACAPACITYBUILDINGANDTECHNICALASSISTANCEDIMENSION!SARESULTTHE-EMBER
LEARNSMOREABOUTTHEECONOMICSOFTHE74/ANDINTHISCONTEXTLOOKSINCREASINGLYTO
THE3ECRETARIATFORANAUDITOFITSPOLICIES
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
.EVERTHELESSTHEREISSTILLALONGWAYTOGO)NPARTICULARTHEDISCUSSIONAMONG-EMBERS
DURINGAREVIEWREMAINSWEAK!LSOFORTHELESSERDEVELOPEDTHELINKAGESTOTHE74/S
TECHNICALASSISTANCEPROGRAMMESHOULDBEIMPROVEDASSHOULDTHEhTIEINvWITHTHE)NTEGRATED
&RAMEWORK&URTHERATTEMPTSCOULDBEMADETOPLACEMOREEMPHASISONTHEhFOLLOWUPvOF
REVIEWSBRINGTHERESULTSTOTHENATIONALPRESS.'/ANDACADEMICCOMMUNITYANDSEEKING
TOGETHERWITHTHEAUTHORITIESABROADERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEIMPLICATIONSOFTRADEANDRELATED
POLICIESEGONCOMPETITIONINVESTMENTTHEENVIRONMENTHEALTH
2EGIONALTRADEAGREEMENTS
4HE#OMMITTEEON2EGIONAL4RADE!GREEMENTS#24!WASESTABLISHEDIN&EBRUARYTO
FACILITATETHEWORKOF-EMBERSINCOMINGTOFINDINGSONTHE74/CONFORMITYOF24!S)THASNOT
WORKEDSINCEITSINCEPTIONTHE#24!HASFAILEDTOADOPTAREPORT4HEREASONSAREVARIOUSBUT
ESSENTIALLYTHEADOPTIONOFAREPORTISAMATTEROFAGREEMENTONTERMSSUCHAShSUBSTANTIALLYALL
TRADEvIN'!44!RTICLE88)64HISISONLYTHEMOSTOBVIOUSOFTHESTUMBLINGBLOCKS
4HE74/ISTHUSWITHOUTEFFECTIVESURVEILLANCEOF24!S)NTHEMEANTIMETHEIRNUMBERHAS
GROWNANDTHEYPRESENTARISKTOTHEMULTILATERALSYSTEM
4HERISKISINCREASINGLYWELLRECOGNIZED)NTHE$$!ITWOULDAPPEARTHAT-EMBERS
AREREADYTOTAKETHEFIRSTSTEPSTOWARDSADDRESSINGTHESITUATION-EMBERSAREMOVING
TOWARDSANAGREEMENTTHATWOULDSIGNIFICANTLYIMPROVETRANSPARENCYWITHRESPECT
TO24!SnCONCURRENTLYREVITALIZINGTHEWORKOFTHE#24!ITISENVISAGEDTHATFUTURE
CONSIDERATIONOF24!SWILLBEBASEDONREPORTSBYTHE3ECRETARIAT)TISHOPEDTHATTHISWILL
HAVEBOTHAhLEARNINGEFFECTvWITH-EMBERSCOMINGTOAPRAGMATICRECOGNITIONTHATFOR
EXAMPLEhSUBSTANTIALLYALLTRADEvREALLYMEANShALLTRADEvIFTHERISKOFNETTRADEDIVERSIONIS
TOBEMINIMIZEDANDTHEWHOLESYSTEMISTOBENEFITnANDAhMORALSUASIONvEFFECTnWITH
24!MEMBERSTHENUNILATERALLYMOVINGTOIMPROVETHEIR24!STOTHEBENEFITOFTHESYSTEM
7ORKINTHE$$!ALSOOFFERSSOMEHOPEFORPROGRESSONSYSTEMICISSUESALTHOUGHITISSTILL
TOOEARLYTOKNOWTHEDIRECTIONANDSCOPEOFSUCHPROGRESS
4RADEANDENVIRONMENT
4HE74/#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTWASCREATEDWITHTHEESTABLISHMENT
OFTHE74/ITSELF4HE#OMMITTEEWASGIVENAFAIRLYBROADREMITTHATALLOWEDITTOEXPLORE
VIRTUALLYALLASPECTSOFTHETRADEANDENVIRONMENTRELATIONSHIP7HILETHE#4%HASOFTENFALLEN
VICTIMTOHIGHEXPECTATIONSITHASTODAYSUCCEEDEDINESTABLISHINGITSELFASANINDISPENSABLE
FORUMONTHETRADEANDENVIRONMENTPOLICYINTERFACE4HEREASONSFORTHISAREASFOLLOWS
)NBEINGTHEONLYSTANDINGCOMMITTEETHATISDEDICATEDTOINTERGOVERNMENTALDIALOGUE
ONTRADEANDENVIRONMENTTHE#4%HASNOPARALLELSINOTHERFORA.EITHERINTHE#OMMISSION
ON3USTAINABLE$EVELOPMENTTHE5NITED.ATIONS%NVIRONMENT0ROGRAMNORIN-%!SIS
THEREAPERMANENTPLATFORMFORTRADEANDENVIRONMENTDISCUSSIONS&URTHERMOREIN-%!S
MULTILATERALENVIRONMENTALPOLICYWITHABEARINGONTRADEISONLYADDRESSEDONAISSUE
BYISSUEBASISINTHE-%!UNDERWHICHTHESPECIFICISSUEFALLS4HE#4%HASTHEFLEXIBILITY
TOADDRESSABSOLUTELYANYISSUERELEVANTTOTRADEANDENVIRONMENTWITHANABILITYTOSHIFT
FROMADISCUSSIONONTRADEANDBIODIVERSITYORCLIMATECHANGETOONEONENVIRONMENTAL
REQUIREMENTSANDMARKETACCESSINTHESAMEMEETING
7HILEVERYUSEFULPOLICYDIRECTIONHASBEENGIVENTOTHETRADEANDENVIRONMENTDEBATE
BY5.%0S'OVERNING#OUNCILTHE#4%ISNOTONLYAPOLITICALBODYBUTALSOAWORKINGGROUP
)NTHE#4%74/-EMBERSCANANDHAVEGONEDOWNTOTHEVERYDETAILSOFTHOSESUBJECTS
THATMAKEUPTHETRADEANDENVIRONMENTDEBATE4HE#4%S2EPORTTOTHE74/S
3INGAPORE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEREFLECTEDTHERESULTOFTHEFIRSTMULTILATERALDEBATETHATTHE
INTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYWASABLETOHAVEINTHISIMPORTANTAREAOFPOLICYINTERFACE
&ORMANYTHE#4%HASDISAPPOINTEDBECAUSEASTHEYHAVEARGUEDITHASOFTENSETTLEDFOR
THELOWESTCOMMONDENOMINATORONWHICHTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYCOULDAGREE4HOSE
WHOMAKETHESECLAIMSPOINTTOTHEFAILUREOFTHE#4%TORECOMMENDANYCHANGESTOTHE
RULESOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
"ECAUSETHE74/OPERATESBYCONSENSUSTHISHASMEANTTHATALLISSUESADDRESSEDBYTHE
#4%HAVEHADTOBEADDRESSEDTOTHESATISFACTIONOFALL(OWEVERTHEMEREEXISTENCEOFTHE
#4%nMORESPECIFICALLYITSPERMANENTORSTANDINGNATUREnHASENSUREDENGAGEMENTBY
THEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYASAWHOLE)NTHE#4%THEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYFINDSITSELF
OBLIGATEDTODISCUSSTHEIMPACTOFTRADEPOLICYONTHEENVIRONMENTANDOFENVIRONMENTAL
POLICYONTRADE5NDERTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDATHE#4%HASBEENWORKINGON
IDENTIFYINGTHESITUATIONSINWHICHTHEREMOVALOFTRADEDISTORTIONSANDRESTRICTIONS
WOULDBENEFITTRADEENVIRONMENTANDDEVELOPMENTnCOULDLEADTOhWINWINWINv
SITUATIONSnNOTABLYINAGRICULTUREENERGYFISHERIESANDFORESTRYSECTORS
-OREOVERWHILETHE#4%HASNOTRECOMMENDEDANYCHANGESTOTHERULESOFTHE
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMITSWORKDIDLEADTOTHEFIRSTEVERSETOFhENVIRONMENTv
NEGOTIATIONSINTHEHISTORYOFTHE'!4474/!NUMBEROFTRADEANDENVIRONMENTISSUESARE
NOWKEYCOMPONENTSOFTHE$OHA2OUND
)NTHEPRINCIPALRECOMMENDATIONOFTHE2IO%ARTH3UMMITTOTHEMULTILATERAL
TRADINGSYSTEMHADBEENTOCOMPLETETHE5RUGUAY2OUND4ENYEARSLATERTHE7ORLD
3UMMITON3USTAINABLE$EVELOPMENTCALLEDONTHE74/TOCOMPLETETHE$OHA2OUND
4HESERECOMMENDATIONSHAVEBEENPREMISEDONTWOVERYIMPORTANTNOTIONSONETHAT
TRADELIBERALIZATIONLEADSTOAMOREEFFICIENTALLOCATIONOFRESOURCESANDTWOTHATTRADE
LIBERALIZATIONHASTHECAPACITYTOGENERATETHEINCOMEGROWTHTHATDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
NEEDTOPROTECTTHEIRENVIRONMENT)NTHEWORDSOF'RO(ARLEM"RUNDTLANDITCANCOMBAT
THEhPOLLUTIONOFPOVERTYv!STHE7ORLD#OMMISSIONON%NVIRONMENTAND$EVELOPMENT
HADSTATEDINhPOVERTYREDUCESPEOPLESCAPACITYTOUSERESOURCESINASUSTAINABLE
MANNERvINTENSIFYINGPRESSUREONTHEENVIRONMENT)NCONTRIBUTINGTOLIFTINGDEVELOPING
ANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESOUTOFPOVERTYANDALLOCATINGRESOURCESnNATURALAND
OTHERWISEnMOREEFFICIENTLYWORLDWIDETHE$OHA2OUNDISLIKELYTODELIVERIMPORTANT
BENEFITSFORTHEENVIRONMENT
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
%NSURINGANEFFICIENTALLOCATIONOFRESOURCESONAGLOBALSCALE
!FFIRMINGTHEIMPORTANCEOFMULTILATERALENVIRONMENTAL
COOPERATION
-UCHDISCUSSIONATTHEINTERNATIONALLEVELHASTAKENPLACEONTHEROLEOFTRADEPOLICYIN
ADDRESSINGTRANSBOUNDARYANDGLOBALENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS)N0RINCIPLEOFTHE
2IO%ARTH3UMMITAFFIRMEDTHAT
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
h4RADEPOLICYMEASURESFORENVIRONMENTALPURPOSESSHOULDNOTCONSTITUTEAMEANS
OFARBITRARYORUNJUSTIFIABLEDISCRIMINATIONORADISGUISEDRESTRICTIONONTRADE5NILATERAL
ACTIONSTODEALWITHENVIRONMENTALCHALLENGESOUTSIDETHEJURISDICTIONOFTHEIMPORTING
COUNTRYSHOULDBEAVOIDED%NVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSSHOULDASFARASPOSSIBLEBE
BASEDONANINTERNATIONALCONSENSUSv
#ONSISTENTLYWITH0RINCIPLETHE74/SUCCEEDEDININAFFIRMINGTHEIMPORTANCEOF
MULTILATERALCOOPERATIONINTHEENVIRONMENTALSPHERE-ORESPECIFICALLYTHE74/S#OMMITTEE
ON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTSTATEDTHAThTHE74/ENDORSESANDSUPPORTSMULTILATERAL
SOLUTIONSBASEDONINTERNATIONALCOOPERATIONANDCONSENSUSASTHEBESTANDMOSTEFFECTIVE
WAYFORGOVERNMENTSTOTACKLEENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSOFATRANSBOUNDARYORGLOBALNATUREv
)NADDITIONTHE74/WENTASFARASTOACKNOWLEDGETHATWHILETRADERESTRICTIONSARENOTTHE
ONLYNORNECESSARILYTHEMOSTEFFECTIVEPOLICYINSTRUMENTTOUSEINMULTILATERALENVIRONMENTAL
AGREEMENTSINCERTAINCASESTHEYCANPLAYANIMPORTANTROLE4HEENDORSEMENTBYTHE74/
OFMULTILATERALSOLUTIONSTOENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSREPRESENTEDANIMPORTANTACHIEVEMENT
FORTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYINTHATTHE74/SUPPORTEDINTERNATIONALCOOPERATIONFORTHE
PURSUITOFINTERNATIONALENVIRONMENTALGOALS
)NADDITIONASPARTOFTHEENVIRONMENTALPACKAGEOFTHE$OHA2OUNDGOVERNMENTSHAVE
AGREEDTOLAUNCHNEWNEGOTIATIONSONTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEEN74/RULESAND-%!STO
ENSURETHEIRMUTUALSUPPORTIVENESS2EGARDLESSOFWHATTHEOUTCOMEOFTHESENEGOTIATIONS
WILLBETHEYHAVEALREADYSUCCEEDEDINPUTTINGTHESPOTLIGHTONTHENEEDFORCOHERENCEAND
CONSISTENCYBETWEENDIFFERENTBODIESOFINTERNATIONALLAW)NSODOINGTHEYHAVELEDAND
ARELEADINGEVERYDAYTOMUCHGREATERCOORDINATIONBETWEENTHETRADEANDENVIRONMENTAL
COMMUNITIES7HEREASTRADEFORAWERETHEEXCLUSIVEPRESERVEOFTRADEOFFICIALSAND
ENVIRONMENTALTHEEXCLUSIVEPRESERVEOFENVIRONMENTALOFFICIALSONLYADECADEAGOTODAYIT
ISPOSSIBLETOSEEENVIRONMENTALOFFICIALSIN74/MEETINGSANDTRADEOFFICIALSIN-%!S)T
ISONLYTHROUGHMOREEFFECTIVENATIONALANDINTERNATIONALCOORDINATIONWITHINANDBETWEEN
GOVERNMENTSANDINSTITUTIONSTHATREALMUTUALSUPPORTIVENESSBETWEENDIFFERENTBODIESOF
LAWCANBEACHIEVED
/NEOFTHEEXPLICITWAYSINWHICHTHE74/HASLENTITSSUPPORTFORMULTILATERALSOLUTIONS
TOGLOBALENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMSWASWITNESSEDINTHE3HRIMP4URTLECASE)NADISPUTE
THATPITTEDTHE5NITED3TATESAGAINSTFOUR!SIANSNATIONSn)NDIA4HAILAND0AKISTANAND
-ALAYSIAONATRADEMEASUREENACTEDBYTHE53WITHTHEAIMOFSEATURTLECONSERVATIONTHE
74/RECOMMENDEDTHATTHE53PURSUEACOOPERATIVEMULTILATERALENVIRONMENTALAPPROACH
#ONSISTENTLYWITH0RINCIPLEOFTHE2IO$ECLARATIONTHE!PPELLATE"ODYWROTETHATTHE
CONSERVATIONOFHIGHLYMIGRATORYSPECIESOFSEATURTLESDEMANDEDhCONCERTEDANDCOOPERATIVE
EFFORTSONTHEPARTOFTHEMANYCOUNTRIESWHOSEWATERSARETRAVERSEDINTHECOURSEOF
RECURRENTSEATURTLEMIGRATIONSv
)TWASASARESULTOFTHISRULINGTHATA-EMORANDUMOF5NDERSTANDINGONTHE
#ONSERVATIONAND-ANAGEMENTOF-ARINE4URTLESANDTHEIR(ABITATSOFTHE)NDIAN/CEAN
AND3OUTH%AST!SIAHASNOWBEENNEGOTIATEDUNDERTHEAUSPICESOFTHE#ONVENTIONONTHE
#ONSERVATIONOF-IGRATORY3PECIES4HE-O5WHICHISANONBINDINGAGREEMENTPUTSIN
PLACEAFRAMEWORKTHROUGHWHICHSTATESOFTHE)NDIAN/CEANAND3OUTH%AST!SIANREGIONAS
WELLASOTHERCONCERNEDSTATESCANWORKTOGETHERTOCONSERVEANDREPLENISHDEPLETEDMARINE
TURTLEPOPULATIONSFORWHICHTHEYSHARERESPONSIBILITY4HISOBJECTIVEISACHIEVEDTHROUGHTHE
COLLECTIVEIMPLEMENTATIONOFA#ONSERVATIONAND-ANAGEMENT0LAN
h'REENPROTECTIONISMv
4HEMAINOBJECTIVEOFTHE74/ISTOENSUREANOPENEQUITABLEANDNONDISCRIMINATORY
MULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM)NOTHERWORDSALEVELPLAYINGFIELDFORALL)NPURSUINGTHIS
OBJECTIVEOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSTHE74/HASNOTLIMITEDITSSCRUTINYTOTARIFFSBUTHAS
ALSOLOOKEDATNONTARIFFBARRIERSTOTRADE)NTHEAREAOFPRODUCTREGULATIONSTHE74/AND
INPARTICULARTHE!GREEMENTON4ECHNICAL"ARRIERSTO4RADEHAVEENSHRINEDACERTAINSETOF
PRINCIPLESTHATMUSTBEREFLECTEDUPONINTHEENACTMENTOFANYPRODUCTREGULATION0RIME
AMONGSTTHESEISTHATOFNONDISCRIMINATIONWHICHCALLSONCOUNTRIESNOTTODISCRIMINATEIN
THEAPPLICATIONOFTHEIRSTANDARDSnENVIRONMENTALOROTHERWISEnBETWEENTHEPRODUCTSTHEY
IMPORTANDTHEONESTHATTHEYTHEMSELVESPRODUCEORBETWEENTHEPRODUCTSTHATTHEYIMPORT
FROMDIFFERENTTRADINGPARTNERS
4HESERULESHAVEHADIMPORTANTIMPLICATIONSFORENVIRONMENTALREGULATIONSWHICH
REPRESENTNOTJUSTANACHIEVEMENTFORMULTILATERALTRADEBUTANACHIEVEMENTFOR
ENVIRONMENTALPOLICYTOO4AKEASITUATIONINWHICHAGOVERNMENTENFORCESANENVIRONMENTAL
STANDARDONIMPORTEDPRODUCTSBUTNOTONTHELIKEPRODUCTSTHATITITSELFPRODUCES3UCH
ASITUATIONWOULDNOTONLYHARMTRADEBYSUBJECTINGIMPORTEDGOODSTOHIGHERSTANDARDS
BUTWOULDALSOHURTTHEENVIRONMENT/RTAKEANOTHERSITUATIONINWHICHAGOVERNMENT
ENFORCESANENVIRONMENTALSTANDARDONIMPORTEDPRODUCTSTHATITIMPORTSFROMONEOFITS
TRADINGPARTNERSBUTNOTONLIKEPRODUCTSIMPORTEDFROMOTHERDESTINATIONS/NCEAGAIN
SUCHALACKOFCONSISTENCYINTHEENFORCEMENTOFANENVIRONMENTALSTANDARDWOULDHELP
NEITHERTRADENORTHEENVIRONMENT4HUSINREQUIRINGGOVERNMENTSTOOBSERVETHEPRINCIPLE
OFNONDISCRIMINATIONINTHEPREPARATIONANDAPPLICATIONOFPRODUCTREGULATIONSOVERTHE
PASTTENYEARSTHE74/HASCONTRIBUTEDTOAMORECONSISTENTAPPLICATIONOFENVIRONMENTAL
POLICIES)NSODOINGITHASWEEDEDOUTPROTECTIONISTMEASURESHIDINGUNDERTHEGUISEOF
ENVIRONMENTALPRESERVATION
4HE'ASOLINEDISPUTEBETWEENTHE5NITED3TATES"RAZILAND6ENEZUELASENTANIMPORTANT
MESSAGETOREGULATORSBECAUSEENVIRONMENTALDAMAGEDOESNOTDEPENDONTHENATIONALITY
OFTHEPOLLUTERENVIRONMENTALPOLICIESMUSTNOTDISCRIMINATE)NTHISDISPUTETHE!PPELLATE
"ODYFOUNDTHATTHE53HADHELDTHEGASOLINETHATITIMPORTEDFROM"RAZILAND6ENEZUELATO
AHIGHERSTANDARDUNDERITS#LEAN!IR!CTTHANTHEONETHATITDOMESTICALLYPRODUCED
)TTHEREFORECALLEDFORSTRICTEROBSERVANCEOFTHEPRINCIPLEOFNONDISCRIMINATION&OLLOWING
THISDISPUTETHE53AMENDEDITSREGULATIONTOENSUREAMORECONSISTENTAPPLICATIONOFITSAIR
QUALITYSTANDARDS!TRIUMPHFORTRADEBUTALSOTRIUMPHFORTHEENVIRONMENT
&ISHSTOCKDEPLETION
74/-EMBERSRECOGNIZEDVERYEARLYONINTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND%NVIRONMENTTHAT
ONEOFTHEPRINCIPALWAYSINWHICHTHE74/COULDCONTRIBUTETOENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION
WOULDBETHROUGHTHEREMOVALOFENVIRONMENTALLYHARMFULTRADERESTRICTIONSANDDISTORTIONS
4HE#4%SMANYYEARSOFWORKONTHISISSUESUCCEEDEDINTHELAUNCHOFFISHERIESSUBSIDIES
NEGOTIATIONSINTHE$OHA2OUNDnANISSUEOFPRESSINGCONCERNTOTHEENVIRONMENTAL
COMMUNITY)NTHEFISHERIESSECTORITHASBEENWIDELYRECOGNIZEDTHATCOSTREDUCINGOR
REVENUEENHANCINGSUBSIDIESHAVEINCREASEDFISHINGINPARTICULARINOPENACCESSWATERS
!CCORDINGTOTHE&!/WORLDSMAJORFISHSTOCKSAREEITHERALREADYFULLYEXPLOITED
OVERFISHEDDEPLETEDORRECOVERINGFROMDEPLETION-OREOVERACCORDINGTO77&SUBSIDIES
REPRESENTOFFISHINGINDUSTRYREVENUEANDFLOWTOFLEETSWHOSEAGGREGATESIZEAND
POWERISALREADYASMUCHASPERCENTOVERCAPACITY4HISHASLEDTOSITUATIONINWHICHTOO
MANYFISHERMENARECHASINGAFTERTOOFEWFISH
)NITSDELIBERATIONSINTHISAREATHE74/HASFOUNDTHATMANYOFTHESUBSIDIESINQUESTION
TAKEFORMSTHATARENOTEASYTODETECTSUCHASSUBSIDIESFORVESSELCONSTRUCTIONORFREE
ACCESSTOPORTS74/NEGOTIATIONSAIMEDATRESTRICTINGENVIRONMENTALLYHARMFULFISHING
SUBSIDIESARENOWUNDERWAYTOADDRESSTHESEDISTORTIONS
4HEPLURILATERAL!GREEMENTON'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENTWASNEGOTIATEDINTHE5RUGUAY
2OUND4HESENEGOTIATIONSACHIEVEDATENFOLDEXPANSIONOFCOVERAGEOVERANEARLIER
AGREEMENTUNDERTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4ARIFFSAND4RADE'!44EXTENDINGINTERNATIONAL
COMPETITIONTOINCLUDENATIONALANDLOCALGOVERNMENTENTITIESWHOSECOLLECTIVEPURCHASESARE
WORTHSEVERALHUNDREDBILLIONDOLLARSEACHYEAR4HENEWAGREEMENTALSOEXTENDSCOVERAGETO
SERVICESINCLUDINGCONSTRUCTIONSERVICESPROCUREMENTATTHESUBCENTRALLEVELFOREXAMPLE
STATESPROVINCESDEPARTMENTSANDPREFECTURESANDPROCUREMENTBYPUBLICUTILITIES
4HEPRESENTAGREEMENTTOOKEFFECTON*ANUARY
)MPLEMENTATIONOFTHEAGREEMENTHASGONESMOOTHLYWITHTHEFOLLOWINGDEVELOPMENTS
s -EMBERSHIPHASCONSIDERABLYEXPANDEDTOCOVER74/-EMBERSIN
.INE-EMBERSAREINTHEPROCESSOFNEGOTIATINGACCESSION
s 0ARTIESAREENGAGEDINAMAJORRENEGOTIATIONTOUPDATETHERULESFURTHER
EXPANDCOVERAGEANDELIMINATEDISCRIMINATORYPROVISIONSWHICHTHEYAIMTO
CONCLUDEBYTHEBEGINNINGOF
-ULTILATERAL7ORKING'ROUPON4RANSPARENCYIN'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENT
s 4HE7ORKING'ROUPESTABLISHEDATTHE3INGAPORE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN
EXAMINEDEXISTINGNATIONALANDINTERNATIONALEXPERIENCEWITHRESPECTTO
TRANSPARENCYINGOVERNMENTPROCUREMENTANDASSESSEDELEMENTSOFAPOSSIBLE
MULTILATERALAGREEMENTINTHISAREA
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
'OVERNMENTPROCUREMENT
s !LTHOUGHNOAGREEMENTWASREACHEDONPOSSIBLEMODALITIESFORNEGOTIATIONS
ONTHISISSUEANDITWASSUBSEQUENTLYDROPPEDFROMTHENEGOTIATINGAGENDAOF
THE$OHA2OUNDTHE7ORKING'ROUPSWORKANDRELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCE
ACTIVITIESHAVECONTRIBUTEDTOENHANCEDUNDERSTANDINGOFTHISISSUEINTHE
FRAMEWORKOFTHE74/ANDTOTHEWORKOFOTHERBODIESWORKINGONRELATED
ISSUESIETHE#OMMITTEEON'OVERNMENT0ROCUREMENTANDTHE7ORKING0ARTY
ON'!432ULES
#OMPETITIONPOLICY
4HE7ORKING'ROUPONTHE)NTERACTIONBETWEEN4RADEAND#OMPETITION0OLICYESTABLISHED
ATTHE3INGAPORE-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCESYSTEMATICALLYEXAMINEDTHELINKSBETWEENTRADEAND
COMPETITIONPOLICYANDTHEPOTENTIALCONTRIBUTIONOFCLOSERMULTILATERALCOOPERATIONINTHISAREA
!LTHOUGHNOAGREEMENTWASREACHEDONPOSSIBLEMODALITIESFORNEGOTIATIONSANDTHE
ISSUEWASSUBSEQUENTLYDROPPEDFROMTHENEGOTIATINGAGENDAOFTHE$OHA2OUNDTHE
7ORKING'ROUPSWORKANDRELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEACTIVITIESHAVECONTRIBUTEDTO
ENHANCEDINTERNATIONALUNDERSTANDINGONCOMPETITIONISSUES!NESTIMATEDTO74/
-EMBERCOUNTRIESHAVENOWADOPTEDCOMPETITIONLAWSANDAGROWINGNUMBEROFCOUNTRIES
AREPARTICIPATINGINBILATERALORREGIONALCOOPERATIONARRANGEMENTS
#OHERENCE
'LOBALIZATIONHASINCREASEDTHENEEDFORCLOSERCOOPERATIONBETWEENTHEMULTILATERAL
INSTITUTIONSWITHKEYROLESINTHEFORMULATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFDIFFERENTELEMENTSOF
THEFRAMEWORKFORGLOBALECONOMICPOLICYINPARTICULARTHE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UND
)-&THE7ORLD"ANKANDTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION%ACHOFTHESEORGANIZATIONSHASA
MANDATEFORSUCHCOOPERATIONINTHEAGREEMENTSUNDERWHICHTHEYHAVEBEENESTABLISHED
3TARTINGFROMITSESTABLISHMENTTHE74/HASMADECONSIDERABLEPROGRESSINDEVELOPING
REGULARCONTACTSANDWORKINGRELATIONSHIPSWITHTHE)-&7ORLD"ANK5.#4!$ANDOTHER
MULTILATERALORGANIZATIONSINVOLVEDINGLOBALECONOMICTRADEANDDEVELOPMENTPOLICIES
4HE74/ANDTHESEINSTITUTIONSHAVESIGNEDAGREEMENTSAMONGTHEMSELVESFORMUTUAL
COOPERATIONANDREGULARCONSULTATIONWHICHIDENTIFYMECHANISMSDESIGNEDTOFOSTERGREATER
COHERENCEINGLOBALECONOMICPOLICYMAKING
4RADEANDFINANCE
-OST74/-EMBERSHAVENOWELIMINATEDTRADERESTRICTIVEMEASURESTHEYMAINTAINED
UNDERTHE74/AGREEMENTSCOVERINGBALANCEOFPAYMENTS!RTICLES8))AND86)))"OF'!44
THE5NDERSTANDINGONTHE"ALANCEOF0AYMENTSPROVISIONSOFTHE'!44!RTICLE
8))OFTHE'!43ANDTHE!GREEMENTON4RADE2ELATED)NVESTMENT-EASURES42)-S4HESE
PROVISIONSNONETHELESSPROVIDEFLEXIBILITYFOR-EMBERSTOUSETHEMEASURESAGAINONA
TEMPORARYBASISASNECESSARYANDSUBJECTTOCERTAINCONDITIONSBUTWITHOUTUNDERMININGTHE
MARKETACCESSCOMMITMENTSONWHICHTHESUCCESSOFTHERULESBASEDTRADINGSYSTEMRESTS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4RADEFACILITATION
.EGOTIATIONSONTRADEFACILITATIONWEREFORESEENINTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA
LAUNCHEDATTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEINANDWEREFORMALLYLAUNCHEDBYTHE
4.#IN/CTOBERWHENTHE.EGOTIATING'ROUPON4RADE&ACILITATIONWASESTABLISHED
4HE'ROUPSMANDATEISASFOLLOWS
!NNEX$-ODALITIESFOR.EGOTIATIONSON4RADE&ACILITATION
.EGOTIATIONSSHALLAIMTOCLARIFYANDIMPROVERELEVANTASPECTSOF!RTICLES66)))
AND8OFTHE'!44WITHAVIEWTOFURTHEREXPEDITINGTHEMOVEMENTRELEASE
ANDCLEARANCEOFGOODSINCLUDINGGOODSINTRANSIT .EGOTIATIONSSHALLALSOAIM
ATENHANCINGTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDSUPPORTFORCAPACITYBUILDINGINTHISAREA
4HENEGOTIATIONSSHALLFURTHERAIMATPROVISIONSFOREFFECTIVECOOPERATIONBETWEEN
CUSTOMSORANYOTHERAPPROPRIATEAUTHORITIESONTRADEFACILITATIONANDCUSTOMS
COMPLIANCEISSUES
)TISUNDERSTOODTHATTHISISWITHOUTPREJUDICE
TOTHEPOSSIBLEFORMATOFTHEFINALRESULTOFTHE
NEGOTIATIONSANDWOULDALLOWCONSIDERATIONOF
VARIOUSFORMSOFOUTCOMES
4HERESULTSOFTHENEGOTIATIONSSHALLTAKEFULLYINTOACCOUNTTHEPRINCIPLEOFSPECIAL
ANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTFORDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES-EMBERS
RECOGNIZETHATTHISPRINCIPLESHOULDEXTENDBEYONDTHEGRANTINGOFTRADITIONAL
TRANSITIONPERIODSFORIMPLEMENTINGCOMMITMENTS)NPARTICULARTHEEXTENTAND
THETIMINGOFENTERINGINTOCOMMITMENTSSHALLBERELATEDTOTHEIMPLEMENTATION
CAPACITIESOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPED-EMBERS)TISFURTHERAGREEDTHATTHOSE
-EMBERSWOULDNOTBEOBLIGEDTOUNDERTAKEINVESTMENTSININFRASTRUCTUREPROJECTS
BEYONDTHEIRMEANS
,EASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY-EMBERSWILLONLYBEREQUIREDTOUNDERTAKECOMMITMENTSTO
THEEXTENTCONSISTENTWITHTHEIRINDIVIDUALDEVELOPMENTFINANCIALANDTRADENEEDSOR
THEIRADMINISTRATIVEANDINSTITUTIONALCAPABILITIES
!SANINTEGRALPARTOFTHENEGOTIATIONS-EMBERSSHALLSEEKTOIDENTIFYTHEIRTRADE
FACILITATIONNEEDSANDPRIORITIESPARTICULARLYTHOSEOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESANDSHALLALSOADDRESSTHECONCERNSOFDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESRELATEDTOCOSTIMPLICATIONSOFPROPOSEDMEASURES
)TISRECOGNIZEDTHATTHEPROVISIONOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDSUPPORTFORCAPACITY
BUILDINGISVITALFORDEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTOENABLETHEMTOFULLY
PARTICIPATEINANDBENEFITFROMTHENEGOTIATIONS-EMBERSINPARTICULARDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESTHEREFORECOMMITTHEMSELVESTOADEQUATELYENSURESUCHSUPPORTAND
ASSISTANCEDURINGTHENEGOTIATIONS
3UPPORTANDASSISTANCESHOULDALSOBEPROVIDEDTOHELPDEVELOPINGANDLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESIMPLEMENTTHECOMMITMENTSRESULTINGFROMTHENEGOTIATIONS
INACCORDANCEWITHTHEIRNATUREANDSCOPE)NTHISCONTEXTITISRECOGNIZEDTHAT
NEGOTIATIONSCOULDLEADTOCERTAINCOMMITMENTSWHOSEIMPLEMENTATIONWOULD
REQUIRESUPPORTFORINFRASTRUCTUREDEVELOPMENTONTHEPARTOFSOME-EMBERS
)NTHESELIMITEDCASESDEVELOPEDCOUNTRY-EMBERSWILLMAKEEVERYEFFORTTO
ENSURESUPPORTANDASSISTANCEDIRECTLYRELATEDTOTHENATUREANDSCOPEOFTHE
COMMITMENTSINORDERTOALLOWIMPLEMENTATION)TISUNDERSTOODHOWEVERTHAT
INCASESWHEREREQUIREDSUPPORTANDASSISTANCEFORSUCHINFRASTRUCTUREISNOT
FORTHCOMINGANDWHEREADEVELOPINGORLEASTDEVELOPED-EMBERCONTINUESTO
LACKTHENECESSARYCAPACITYIMPLEMENTATIONWILLNOTBEREQUIRED7HILEEVERYEFFORT
WILLBEMADETOENSURETHENECESSARYSUPPORTANDASSISTANCEITISUNDERSTOODTHAT
THECOMMITMENTSBYDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTOPROVIDESUCHSUPPORTARENOTOPEN
ENDED
-EMBERSAGREETOREVIEWTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFTHESUPPORTANDASSISTANCEPROVIDED
ANDITSABILITYTOSUPPORTTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHERESULTSOFTHENEGOTIATIONS
)NORDERTOMAKETECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGMOREEFFECTIVE
ANDOPERATIONALANDTOENSUREBETTERCOHERENCE-EMBERSSHALLINVITERELEVANT
INTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSINCLUDINGTHE)-&/%#$5.#4!$7#/ANDTHE7ORLD
"ANKTOUNDERTAKEACOLLABORATIVEEFFORTINTHISREGARD
$UEACCOUNTSHALLBETAKENOFTHERELEVANTWORKOFTHE7#/ANDOTHERRELEVANT
INTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSINTHISAREA
0ARAGRAPHSOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONSHALLAPPLYTOTHESE
NEGOTIATIONS!TITSFIRSTMEETINGAFTERTHE*ULYSESSIONOFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL
THE4RADE.EGOTIATIONS#OMMITTEESHALLESTABLISHA.EGOTIATING'ROUPON4RADE
&ACILITATIONANDAPPOINTITS#HAIR4HEFIRSTMEETINGOFTHE.EGOTIATING'ROUPSHALL
AGREEONAWORKPLANANDSCHEDULEOFMEETINGS
)NCONNECTIONWITHTHISPARAGRAPH-EMBERS
NOTETHATPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL
$ECLARATIONADDRESSESRELEVANTTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDINGCONCERNSOF
-EMBERS
/N*ANUARYTHE74/!GREEMENTON4EXTILESAND#LOTHING!4#EXPIRED
4HECOMPLETIONOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHETENYEARTRANSITIONPERIODENDEDTHESPECIAL
ANDDISCRIMINATORYREGIMETHATHADLASTEDFORMORETHANYEARS7ITHTHEFULLANDTIMELY
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!4#TRADEINTEXTILEANDCLOTHINGPRODUCTSISNOWGOVERNEDBY
THENORMAL'!4474/RULESANDDISCIPLINES4HE!4#WASPARTOFTHEBROADERPACKAGEOF
THEOUTCOMESFROMTHE5RUGUAY2OUND)TREPRESENTEDAVERYDELICATEBALANCETOGETHER
WITHTHEOTHERLEGALRESULTSFROMTHE5RUGUAY2OUND4HE!4#WASCONSIDEREDBYSEVERAL
74/-EMBERSINPARTICULARTHEEXPORTINGDEVELOPING-EMBERSASONEOFTHEMOST
IMPORTANTRESULTSOFTHELAST2OUND4HETIMELYANDFULLIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!4#STANDS
ASONEOFTHESALUTARYACHIEVEMENTSOFTHEPASTTENYEARSINTHE74/#OMPLETIONOF
IMPLEMENTATIONINSTITUTIONALLYSTRENGTHENEDTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
!SARESULTOFTHEEXPIRYOFTHE!4#ALLTHEBILATERALQUOTASMAINTAINEDUNDERITHAVE
BEENELIMINATEDANDCONSEQUENTLYTHEELIMINATIONOFTHECOSTOFPROTECTION
4HEELIMINATIONOFPROTECTIONCOSTSWILLBEBENEFICIALFORTHEGLOBALECONOMYINWELFARE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4EXTILES
ANDEFFICIENCYGAINSINCREASEDMARKETACCESSOPPORTUNITIESANDCONSUMERWELFARE
$EVELOPEDANDDEVELOPING-EMBERSSTANDTOGAINPARTICULARLYTHELATTERBECAUSEOFTHEIR
SIGNIFICANTCOMPARATIVEADVANTAGESINTHESECTOR
)NTHESHORTTERMHOWEVERADJUSTMENTCOSTSARELIKELYTORESULTFROMTHEABOLITIONOF
QUOTASFORSOME-EMBERS4HEISSUEOFADJUSTMENTCOSTSPOSESCHALLENGESFORTHETRADING
SYSTEMPARTICULARLYFORFURTHERLIBERALIZATION4HISISSUEOFPOST!4#!DJUSTMENT2ELATED
)SSUESWASINTRODUCEDONTHEAGENDAOFTHE#4'ANDOFTHE3UB#OMMITTEEON,$#S)TIS
BEINGDISCUSSEDBYTHEMEMBERSHIP3EVERALUSEFULIDEASANDAPPROACHESHAVEEMERGEDIN
THEONGOINGDISCUSSIONS)NTHE74/3ECRETARIATORGANIZEDFIVEREGIONALWORKSHOPS
TOADDRESSTHEISSUEOFh0OST!4#!DJUSTMENT2ELATED)SSUESvANDTOPREPARETHE
MEMBERSHIPFOR!4#EXPIRYANDTOCONTRIBUTETOABETTERUNDERSTANDINGBYALL-EMBERSOF
THEACHIEVEMENTSARISINGFROM!4#IMPLEMENTATIONTHEBENEFITSFORTHEGLOBALECONOMY
BUTALSOTHECHALLENGEOFADJUSTMENT3YSTEMICALLYTHEISSUEOFADJUSTMENTCOSTSHASBEEN
RAISEDATTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILMEETINGSONCOHERENCEBYTHE$IRECTOR'ENERAL!TTHIS
FORUMTHE"RETTON7OODS)NSTITUTIONSWITHTHE74/AREEXPLORINGANDIDENTIFYINGWAYS
TOADDRESS INTERALIALIBERALIZATIONRELATEDADJUSTMENTCHALLENGES
!4#IMPLEMENTATIONANDEXPIRYYIELDEDSYSTEMICALLYIMPORTANTLESSONSFOR
IMPLEMENTATIONINOTHER74/AREAS4HESELESSONSAREBEINGCAREFULLYSTUDIEDANDWILL
FURTHERSTRENGTHENTHETRADINGSYSTEM&ORINSTANCETHE4EXTILES-ONITORING"ODY4-"A
SEMIJUDICIALBODYCREATEDBYTHE!4#SIGNIFICANTLYCONTRIBUTEDTOFULL!4#IMPLEMENTATION
)TCONSISTENTLYAPPLIEDSTRINGENTSTANDARDSINREVIEWINGDISPUTESBETWEEN-EMBERS
UNDERTHE!4#PARTICULARLYTOTHOSEDISPUTESRELATEDTOTRANSITIONALSAFEGUARDMEASURES)TS
OBSERVATIONSFINDINGSANDJURISPRUDENCEHOLDLESSONSOFVITALIMPORTANCEFORTHEFUTURE
#OTTON
)NTHEPREPARATORYPROCESSFORTHE&IFTH74/-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN#ANCÞN-EXICO
"ENIN"URKINA&ASO#HADAND-ALIWITHBROADSUPPORTPRESENTEDASECTORAL)NITIATIVEON
COTTON4HEYARGUEDTHATTHESUBSIDIESPROVIDEDBYCERTAIN74/-EMBERSTOTHEIRCOTTON
GROWERSDISTORTEDTRADEANDIMPEDEDTHEBENEFITSOFANOPENCOMPETITIVEANDNON
DISCRIMINATORYRULESBASEDMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM4HE3ECTORAL)NITIATIVEON#OTTONMADE
EVIDENTTHENECESSITYFORADJUSTMENTWITHINTHETRADINGSYSTEMFORAPPROPRIATERESPONSESIN
THOSEAREASWHERETRADEANDDEVELOPMENTISSUESINTERSECT
74/-EMBERSRESPONDEDTOTHECHALLENGE4HEYENGAGEDINTENSIVELYONTHETRADEAND
DEVELOPMENTISSUESARISINGFROMTHE3ECTORAL)NITIATIVEON#OTTON#ONSULTATIONSCONTINUED
AFTERTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL!SARESULTOFTHECONSULTATIONS-EMBERSAGREEDTODISTINGUISH
BETWEENTHETRADEANDTHEDEVELOPMENTASPECTSOFTHE)NITIATIVETOTREATTHEMAPPROPRIATELY
BUTWITHTHEOVERALLOBJECTIVEOFACHIEVINGCOMPLEMENTARITYONTHETWOASPECTS4HE74/
3ECRETARIATORGANIZEDAN!FRICAN2EGIONAL7ORKSHOPON#OTTONIN#OTONOUFROMTHERDTO
TH-ARCH4HEFINALAGREEDh/UTCOMESvFROMTHE7ORKSHOPWEREKEYINTHECOTTON
RELATEDDECISIONSAGREEDBY74/-EMBERSINTHE*ULY0ACKAGE4HOSEh/UTCOMESvNOW
CONSTITUTETHEBASISFORTHEPARTNERSHIPBYTHETRADEANDTHEDEVELOPMENTCOMMUNITIESIN
THEFOLLOWUPANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEDEVELOPMENTASSISTANCEASPECTSOFTHECOTTONISSUE
INTHE$OHA7ORK0ROGRAMME!TTHESAMETIMEASAGREEDBY-EMBERSINTHE*ULY0ACKAGE
THE4RADE!SPECTSOF#OTTONWILLBEADDRESSEDAMBITIOUSLYEXPEDITIOUSLYANDSPECIFICALLY
WITHINTHEAGRICULTURENEGOTIATIONS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4ECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDTRAINING
7ITHTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE74/4RADE2ELATED4ECHNICAL!SSISTANCE!CTIVITIES424!
GREATLYEXPANDEDINSCOPEANDINCREASEDINQUANTITYREFLECTINGTHEINCREASINGPARTICIPATIONOF
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAND,$#SINTHEWORKOF74/ANDTHECENTRALPLACEOFDEVELOPMENTISSUES
THEREIN4HE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA$$!HASMADE424!ACOREFUNCTIONOFTHE74/
!CHIEVEMENTSINTHEFIRSTTENYEARS
s %XPANSIONINSCOPEANDINCREASEINTHENUMBEROF424!SEEGRAPHANNEXED
s #ONSISTENTINCREASEINNUMBERSINALLREGIONSWITHSPECIALATTENTIONTO!FRICA
AND,$#S)NOFTHEACTIVITIESWEREFOR!FRICA
s 4HEANNUALBUDGETFOR424!FORIS#(&MILLIONMILLIONOFWHICHIS
FROMTHEREGULARBUDGETTHERESTFROMVOLUNTARYCONTRIBUTIONSSEEGRAPH
s 4HE$$!'LOBAL4RUST&UND'4&INWASINTENDEDTOENHANCEFINANCIAL
STABILITYANDTOWEANDONORSFROMTHEHABITOFEARMARKINGFUNDSFORTHEIR
PREFERREDPROJECTS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
s -ONITORINGANDEVALUATION-%HASBEENFUNCTIONINGASFROM
s )NTHETENYEARSOF74/THENUMBEROFTRADEPOLICYCOURSESCARRIEDOUT
ISONETHIRDOFTHENUMBERDONEINTHEALMOSTYEARSOFTHE'!44!SA
COMPLEMENTASERIESOFCOURSESOFASHORTERDURATIONHAVEBEENORGANIZED
s 2EGIONALTRADEPOLICYCOURSES40#SARENOWOFFEREDASWELL
s 4HE74/S424!ISCONTAINEDINTHEANNUALTECHNICALASSISTANCEPLANh0LANv
APPROVEDBY-EMBERSWHICHALSOSERVESASTHEBASISFORSEEKINGTHERESOURCES
NECESSARYFORITSIMPLEMENTATION
s 4HE0LANARTICULATEDAROUNDANUMBEROFDISTINCTPRODUCTSPUTSAPREMIUMON
QUALITYRATHERTHANQUANTITYITEMPHASIZESTHEOBJECTIVESTOBEACHIEVEDFOR
EACHTYPEOFPRODUCTITPUTSAPREMIUMONPARTNERSHIPSANDCOLLABORATIONWITH
OTHER)'/SANDITINTRODUCESCONSIDERABLEFLEXIBILITYTOENHANCERESPONSIVENESS
)TISCARRIEDOUTBY)44#ANDOPERATIONALDIVISIONS/UTSIDECONSULTANTSARE
USEDBUTRARELYTHE-EMBERSHAVEACLEARPREFERENCEFOR74/STAFFAS
RESOURCEPERSONS
s %FFORTSAREMADETOAVOIDDUPLICATION4HEDONORSHAVECREATEDTHROUGHA
COLLABORATIONBETWEENTHE/%#$ANDTHE74/ADEDICATEDDATABASEOF424!
s 0ARTNERSHIPSREPRESENTASIGNIFICANTPROPORTIONOFTHEREGIONALACTIVITIESINTHE
0LANANDWAYSAREBEINGSOUGHTCONSTANTLYTOENHANCETHISCOLLABORATION
BOTHTOEXPLOITSYNERGIESANDTOTAKEACCOUNTOFCOMPARATIVEADVANTAGE4HIS
INCLUDESASIGNIFICANTPROGRAMMEOFPARTNERSHIPSWITHACADEMICINSTITUTIONSIN
THEREGIONS
s #OLLABORATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS!TOTALOF-O5S
CURRENTLYEXISTBUTADHOCCOOPERATIONISALSORELEVANT"YWAYOFILLUSTRATION
THE-O5WITH5.)$/ISGEAREDTOWARDSADDRESSINGSUPPLYSIDECONSTRAINTS
!NOTHERARRANGEMENTWITH)!$").4!,COMESLARGELYINSUPPORTOF424!AT
REGIONALLEVEL
s 4HEACTIVITIESENCOMPASSEDINTHEPROGRAMMEh0ARTNERSHIPSFOR4RAINING
AND#APACITY"UILDINGANINTEGRATEDAPPROACHvJOINTLYDEVELOPEDWITH
THE%CONOMIC2ESEARCHAND3TATISTICAL$IVISIONISANIMPORTANTSTEPINTHE
SUSTAINABILITYOF4!
s /THERINNOVATIONSINCLUDEGUIDANCEONNEEDSASSESSMENTINCREASEDFOCUS
ON,$#SOUTREACHTONONGOVERNMENTALSECTORSESPECIALLYPARLIAMENTARIANS
ETRAININGANDHIGHERLEVELINSTRUCTIONAIMEDATOFFICIALSALREADYHAVINGBEEN
THROUGHTHEBASICTRAINING
s 4HREEIMPORTANTPROGRAMMESRUNJOINTLYWITHOTHER)'/S
O *)4!0FOR!FRICANCOUNTRIESCARRIEDOUTINPARTNERSHIPWITH5.#4!$
AND)4#
O )NTEGRATED&RAMEWORK)&FOR,$#SINCOOPERATIONWITHTHOSETWO
PLUSTHE7ORLD"ANK5.$0AND)-&
O 4HE3TANDARDSAND4RADE$EVELOPMENT&ACILITY34$&LAUNCHEDIN
ASAJOINTINITIATIVEOFTHE&!//)%7ORLD"ANK7(/AND
74/TOASSISTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESENHANCETHEIRCAPACITYTOMEET
INTERNATIONAL303STANDARDS
s !NIMPORTANTINNOVATIONINTHEDECADEHASBEENDISTANCELEARNINGAND
ELECTRONICTOOLS3INCETHEPUBLICAND-EMBERSONLY74/WEBSITESHAVE
BEENGREATLYIMPROVED
O 2EFERENCE#ENTRESHAVEBEENESTABLISHEDINCOUNTRIES
-EMBERSANDNON-EMBERSOFTHE74/
O 4HEDISTANCELEARNINGPAGEOFTHEPUBLIC74/WEBSITEGIVESACCESSTO
COMPUTERBASEDTRAININGMODULESTHATAREAVAILABLEFORSELFTRAININGTO
ANYONEINTERESTEDEITHERTHROUGH#$2/-ORTHROUGHETRAINING
O !SOFTWARETHE4OOLKITFOR.EGOTIATORSHASBEENDESIGNEDTOASSIST
NEGOTIATORSINMULTILATERALREGIONALANDBILATERALNEGOTIATIONS
ANDPROVIDESANINTEGRATEDSETOFTOOLSDEALINGWITHTEXTUALAND
QUANTITATIVEDATABASES
#HALLENGES
s 74/REGULARBUDGETFOR4!HASREMAINEDCONSTANTOVERTIME3EEGRAPHS
FURTHERDOWNWHILEDEMANDFOR4!ACTIVITIESHASCONTINUEDTORISE
s 7ITHSOMANYPROVIDERSOF424!THEREISOVERLAP4HEREISATENDENCYAMONG
BENEFICIARIESTOCHOPANDCHANGEAGREEDARRANGEMENTSFORACTIVITIESWHICH
CAUSESDISRUPTIONANDIMPEDESIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE0LAN
s 4HEREAREPROBLEMSOFABSORPTIONCAPACITYESPECIALLYAMONGTHESMALLER
BENEFICIARIES
s 4HENEEDTOOPERATEASELECTIONOFPARTICIPANTSEVENFORSHORTACTIVITIES!TTHE
PRESENTTIMESELECTIONTAKESPLACEONLYFORTHEMONTH40#ANDSPECIALISED
COURSESIN'ENEVA
s !MEANINGFULANDCONSTANT4RAININGOF4RAINERSPROGRAMMEISINDISPENSABLE
PROVIDEDSUFFICIENTATTENTIONANDABOVEALLFINANCIALMEANSAREMADE
AVAILABLE
s )NRELATIONTOTHEOBJECTIVEOFAVOIDINGDUPLICATIONTHE/#$%74/$ATABASE
424!ISFORTHEMOMENTNOTPROSPECTIVEANDSONOTOFMUCHHELPINPLANNING
424!ANDFOSTERINGCOHERENCE
s 4HESUSTAINABILITYOFCAPACITYBUILDINGCONTINUESTOBEIMPEDEDBYTHEUSUAL
GOVERNMENTPRACTICEOFHIGHTURNOVEROFTRAINEDOFFICIALS2EFERENCE#ENTRE
#OORDINATORSETC
s )NTERNETCONNECTIONCOSTSARESOMETIMESHIGHINPARTICULARIN,$#SALTHOUGHA
REMEDYISBEINGTRIEDTHROUGHAGLOBALPROVIDER
s 4HECHALLENGEWEARENOWFACINGISTOFURTHERINTEGRATE)4BASEDSOLUTIONSIN
74/TRAININGANDTECHNICALCOOPERATIONACTIVITIES
s 4HEREISANEEDTOPRIORITISEBUTWHOSHOULDBEMAINLYRESPONSIBLEFORTHAT
)TISGENERALLYACCEPTEDTHATINADEMANDDRIVENCONTEXTTHEMAIN
RESPONSIBILITYLIESWITHTHEBENEFICIARIES
.UMBEROF424!ACTIVITIES
74/TECHNICALASSISTANCEnEXPENDITURE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
"
"!
#!
"!$
"
74/TECHNICALASSISTANCEnRESOURCES
#" $
" #"!
# #"
$EVELOPMENT
4HISAREAOF74/ACTIVITYISFOCUSEDONPOLICYISSUESRELATINGTOTHEPARTICIPATIONOF
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCLUDINGTHELEASTDEVELOPEDAMONGTHEMINTHEMULTILATERALTRADING
SYSTEM4HEWORKOFTHE3ECRETARIATINTHISAREAISCARRIEDOUTUNDERTHEAEGISOFTHE
#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTINREGULARSESSIONANDITS3UB#OMMITTEEONLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESASWELLASITSDEDICATEDSESSIONSONSMALLECONOMIESANDITSSPECIAL
SESSIONSONSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTANDTHE7ORKING'ROUPON4RADEAND4RANSFER
OF4ECHNOLOGY
0ROGRESSINTHISAREAOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSHASBEENMARKEDBYTHEFOLLOWING
n%STABLISHMENTOFTHE3UBCOMMITTEEON,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES
ANDSTRENGTHENINGOFTHEMANDATEOFTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND
$EVELOPMENT
4HE3UB#OMMITTEEON,$#SISOPENTOALL-EMBERSOFTHE74/DEVELOPEDAND
DEVELOPINGALIKEANDPROVIDESANIMPORTANTFORUMFORDISCUSSINGANDDEBATINGTHETRADE
CONCERNSOFTHE,$#-EMBERSOFTHE74/
4HEMANDATEOFTHE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTESTABLISHEDINTO
KEEPUNDERCONTINUOUSREVIEW0ART)6OFTHE'!44WASSTRENGTHENEDINWITHTHE
#OMMITTEEBEINGDESIGNATEDASTHEFOCALPOINTFORALLTHEWORKONDEVELOPMENTALISSUESIN
THE74/ANDFORDEVELOPMENTRELATEDACTIVITIESINOTHERMULTILATERALAGENCIES
n&IRST-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEn3INGAPORE
-INISTERSADOPTEDTHE#OMPREHENSIVEAND)NTEGRATED74/0LANOF!CTIONFORTHE
,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES4HEYAGREEDTOORGANIZEAMEETINGWITH5.#4!$ANDTHE
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTREASSOONASPOSSIBLEINWITHTHEPARTICIPATIONOFAID
AGENCIESMULTILATERALFINANCIALINSTITUTIONSANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTOASSIST,$#S
BUILDTRADECAPACITYANDINTEGRATETRADEISSUESINTOTHEIROVERALLNATIONALDEVELOPMENT
STRATEGIES4HE!CTION0LANALSOURGED-EMBERSTOIMPROVEMARKETACCESSFOR,$#S
0LANSTOESTABLISHAN)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKOFTECHNICALASSISTANCEFOR,$#SWEREAGREED
IN3INGAPORETHEREBYLAUNCHINGWHATHASTURNEDINTOAMAJORDEVELOPMENTASSISTANCE
PROGRAMMEFORTHELEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESSEEBELOW
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
n!PRILn-!22!+%3($ECLARATION
-INISTERSADOPTTHE$ECLARATIONWHICHSTATESTHAThTHERESULTSOFTHE5RUGUAY2OUND
NEGOTIATIONSEMBODYPROVISIONSCONFERRINGDIFFERENTIALANDMOREFAVOURABLETREATMENT
FORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCLUDINGSPECIALATTENTIONTOTHEPARTICULARSITUATIONOFLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES-INISTERSRECOGNIZETHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHESE
PROVISIONSFORTHELEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESANDDECLARETHEIRINTENTIONTOCONTINUETOASSIST
ANDFACILITATETHEEXPANSIONOFTHEIRTRADEANDINVESTMENTOPPORTUNITIESv
"YADOPTINGTHEABOVE$ECLARATION74/-EMBERSACKNOWLEDGEDTHEDIVERSITYOFTHE
74/SMEMBERSHIP4HEYRECOGNIZEDTHATMUCHASSISTANCEWOULDNEEDTOBEGIVENTO
DEVELOPINGANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES4ENYEARSAFTERTHEENTRYINTOFORCEOFTHE74/
ISSUESRELATEDTOSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTPROVISIONSAND,$#CONCERNSANDISSUES
REMAINATTHETOPOFTHE74/SACTIVITIESANDNEGOTIATINGAGENDA
n(IGH,EVEL-EETING&OR,$#Sn'ENEVA
)NTHE74/CONVENEDA(IGH,EVEL-EETINGON)NTEGRATED)NITIATIVESFOR,EAST
$EVELOPED#OUNTRIES4RADEDEVELOPMENT(,-/NTHEAGENDAWEREISSUESRELATEDTO
STRENGTHENINGTHETRADECAPACITIESOF,$#SINCLUDINGSUPPLYSIDECAPACITIESANDIMPROVED
MARKETACCESSFORTHEIRPRODUCTSANDSERVICES!TTHE(,-THE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFOR
,EAST$EVELOPED#OUNTRIESWASLAUNCHEDBYSIXMULTILATERALORGANIZATIONSTHE)-&THE
)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRE5.#4!$5.$0THE7ORLD"ANKANDTHE74/4HE(,-ALSO
ENCOURAGED-EMBERSTOTAKEMARKETACCESSMEASURESINFAVOUROF,$#S
4HEMAINOBJECTIVESOFTHE)&ASRESTRUCTUREDINARETOMAINSTREAMTRADEINTO
,$#SNATIONALDEVELOPMENTPLANSSUCHASTHE0OVERTY2EDUCTION3TRATEGY0APERSANDTO
COORDINATETHEDELIVERYOFTRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEANDCAPACITYBUILDING
)TCOMBINESEFFORTSOFTHE,$#SWITHTHOSEOFTHESIX)&COREAGENCIESANDOTHER
DEVELOPMENTPARTNERSINCLUDINGTHEDONORCOMMUNITY3OME,$#SHAVEEXPRESSEDAN
INTERESTINTHE)&ANDOFTHEMARECURRENTLYATVARIOUSSTAGESOFTHE)&PROCESS
)NCREASINGLYTHE)&MODELISRECOGNIZEDASAVIABLEMODELFORFOSTERINGTRADE
DEVELOPMENTIN,$#S3INCETHE(,-MANYSUBSTANTIALMARKETACCESSMEASURESINFAVOUROF
,$#SHAVEBEENUNDERTAKENSEEBELOW
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
n'ENEVA7EEK
4HEFIRST'ENEVA7EEKEVENTFOR74/NONRESIDENT-EMBERSAND/BSERVERSWASHELD
FROMTO.OVEMBER4HE'ENEVA7EEKPROGRAMMEISNOWENTERINGITSSIXTHYEARAND
HASPROVEDTOBEAVERYVALUABLEOPPORTUNITYFOROFFICIALSFROMGOVERNMENTSWHICHDONOT
HAVEOFFICESIN'ENEVATOBEABLETOFAMILIARIZETHEMSELVESWITHTHEACTIVITIESOFTHE74/
ANDMOREIMPORTANTLYKEEPSTHEMABREASTOFTHEONGOINGNEGOTIATIONS!TPRESENTTHERE
ARE74/-EMBERSnMANYOFTHEMSMALLISLANDSORLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESnWITHOUT
REPRESENTATIONIN'ENEVA!NOTHERNINECOUNTRIESWITHOUTMISSIONSARE/BSERVERSTOTHE74/
ANDINTHEPROCESSOFACCEDINGTOTHE74/
n&OURTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEn$OHA1ATAR
-INISTERSADOPTTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAANDAGREETOAREVIEWOFTHEPROVISIONS
FORSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTSOASTOSTRENGTHENTHEMANDMAKETHEMMOREPRECISE
EFFECTIVEANDOPERATIONAL4HEYALSOAGREEDTOSTARTA7ORK0ROGRAMMEFOR3MALL%CONOMIES
ANDTOESTABLISHA7ORKING'ROUPON4RADEAND4RANSFEROF4ECHNOLOGY
4HENEWROUNDOFNEGOTIATIONSPLACESDEVELOPMENTATTHEHEARTOFTHE$OHA
$EVELOPMENT!GENDAANDHASRAISEDTHEHOPEOFMANYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDIN
PARTICULARTHATOFTHE,$#STHATTHEIRCONCERNSWOULDBEADDRESSEDINTHECOURSEOFA
MULTILATERALNEGOTIATION
74/-EMBERSCOMMITTEDTHEMSELVESTOREVIEWALLSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENT
PROVISIONSINPARAGRAPHOFTHE$$!ANDINPARAGRAPHAGREEDTOFRAMERESPONSESTO
THETRADERELATEDISSUESIDENTIFIEDFORTHEFULLERINTEGRATIONOFSMALLVULNERABLEECONOMIES
INTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDNOTTOCREATEASUBCATEGORYOF74/-EMBERS
0ARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA-INISTERIAL$ECLARATIONESTABLISHEDA7ORKING'ROUPTO
EXAMINETHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTRADEANDTRANSFEROFTECHNOLOGYANDOFANYPOSSIBLE
RECOMMENDATIONSONSTEPSTHATMIGHTBETAKENWITHINTHEMANDATEOFTHE74/TOINCREASE
FLOWSOFTECHNOLOGYTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
)NPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA$ECLARATION-EMBERSCOMMITTEDTHEMSELVESTOPROVIDE
DUTYFREEANDQUOTAFREEMARKETACCESSFORPRODUCTSORIGINATINGIN,$#S!SMANYAS
74/-EMBERSAND/BSERVERSCOUNTINGTHE%UROPEAN#OMMUNITIESASONEHAVESOFAR
UNDERTAKENMEASURESTOIMPROVEMARKETACCESSCONDITIONS)NPARAGRAPHOFTHE$OHA
-INISTERIAL$ECLARATION-INISTERSENDORSEDTHE)NTEGRATED&RAMEWORKFORLEASTDEVELOPED
COUNTRIESASAVIABLEMODELFOR,$#STRADEDEVELOPMENT
n&EBRUARYn-EMBERSAGREEONA74/7ORK0ROGRAMME&OR,$#S
-EMBERSAGREEDTOAWORKPROGRAMMEFORTHE,$#SDESIGNEDTOASSISTTHEMWITHTHEIR
INTEGRATIONINTOTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM-EMBERSALSOADOPTEDTHE'UIDELINESFORTHE
!CCESSIONOF,$#S4HE'UIDELINESENCOURAGE-EMBERSTOEXERCISERESTRAINTWHENSEEKING
CONCESSIONSANDCOMMITMENTSFROM,$#SANDALLOW,$#SGREATERFLEXIBILITYINIMPLEMENTING
VARIOUS74/AGREEMENTS
n&EBRUARYn#OMMITTEE/N4RADE!ND$EVELOPMENT)N3PECIAL3ESSION
%STABLISHED
4HE#OMMITTEEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENTIN3PECIAL3ESSIONWASSETUPTOCARRYOUT
THEWORKPROGRAMMEONSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTINPURSUANCEOFPARAGRAPH
OFTHE$OHA$ECLARATION!VERYLARGENUMBEROF!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSWEREMADE
BYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWHICHALONGWITHTHECROSSCUTTINGISSUESWERETAKENUPFOR
CONSIDERATIONINTHE3PECIAL3ESSION"YTHE#ANCÞN-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCE-EMBERSHAD
BEENABLETOAGREEINPRINCIPLETO!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALS
n&IFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEn#ANCÞN-EXICO
-INISTERSAPPROVED74/-EMBERSHIPFOR#AMBODIAAND.EPALTHEFIRSTTWOLEAST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTOJOINTHE74/!NOTHERNINE,$#SONETHIRDOFALLACCEDING
GOVERNMENTSAREINDIFFERENTSTAGESOFTHEACCESSIONPROCESS-EMBERSFAILEDTOADOPTTHE
PACKAGEOF!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSNEGOTIATEDINTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINTHERUNUPTO
#ANCÞN
n4HE*ULY$ECISIONn'ENEVA
4HE$ECISIONREACHEDON!UGUSTCOMMITS-EMBERSTOFULFILLINGTHEDEVELOPMENT
DIMENSIONOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAANDSETSOUTAROADMAPFORFURTHERPURSUING
THEREVIEWOFSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENT
$EVELOPMENTISSUESAREATTHECOREOFhTHE*ULY$ECISIONv3PECIALCONSIDERATIONWAS
GIVENTOTHENEGOTIATIONSONADDRESSINGTHESPECIFICTRADEANDDEVELOPMENTRELATED
CONCERNSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES4HEREWASALSOASTRONGEMPHASISONADDRESSINGCAPACITY
CONSTRAINTS
!DEADLINEOF*ULYWASSETFORTHE3PECIAL3ESSIONTOCOMPLETEITSREVIEWOFALLTHE
OUTSTANDING!GREEMENTSPECIFICPROPOSALSANDTOREPORTTOTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILWITHCLEAR
RECOMMENDATIONSFORADECISION4HE3PECIAL3ESSIONWASALSOINSTRUCTEDTOADDRESSALLOTHER
OUTSTANDINGWORKINCLUDINGONTHECROSSCUTTINGISSUESTHEMONITORINGMECHANISMAND
THEINCORPORATIONOFSPECIALANDDIFFERENTIALTREATMENTINTOTHEARCHITECTUREOF74/RULES
&URTHERMOREALL74/BODIESTOWHICHPROPOSALSIN#ATEGORY))HADBEENREFERREDWEREALSO
ASKEDTOEXPEDITIOUSLYCOMPLETETHECONSIDERATIONOFTHOSEPROPOSALSANDREPORTWITHCLEAR
RECOMMENDATIONSFORADECISIONNOLATERTHAN*ULY
7ITHTHE*ULY$ECISION-EMBERSAGREEDTHATINTHEONGOINGMARKETACCESSNEGOTIATIONS
ON!GRICULTUREAND.!-!SPECIALATTENTIONSHOULDBEPAIDTOTHESPECIFICTRADEAND
DEVELOPMENTNEEDSOFDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCLUDINGISSUESOFFOODSECURITYRURAL
DEVELOPMENTPREFERENCESCOMMODITIESANDNETFOODIMPORTS4HE$ECISIONREITERATESTHE
NEEDTOADDRESSTRADERELATEDISSUESOFINTERESTTOSMALLVULNERABLEECONOMIES
4HE*ULY$ECISIONALSOLAUNCHEDNEGOTIATIONSON4RADE&ACILITATION4HEMODALITIESFOR
THESENEGOTIATIONSSEEKTOPROTECTTHEINTERESTOF,$#SANDPROVIDEFLEXIBILITYINUNDERTAKING
COMMITMENTSWITHSEPARATEPROVISIONS)NREGARDTO,$#STHE'ENERAL#OUNCILCONFIRMED
THATNOTHINGINTHE*ULY$ECISIONWOULDINANYWAYDETRACTFROMTHESPECIALPROVISIONSFOR
,$#SALREADYAGREEDTOBY-EMBERS
%CONOMICRESEARCH
4HEMOSTSIGNIFICANTACHIEVEMENTINRESEARCHATTHE74/OVERTHELASTTENYEARSISTHE
ESTABLISHMENTOFTHE7ORLD4RADE2EPORTIN4HISFLAGSHIPPUBLICATIONISRECEIVING
GROWINGATTENTIONANDISGENERALLYREGARDEDASAQUALITYCONTRIBUTIONTOTRADEPOLICYDEBATES
4HE742ISAUTHOREDPRIMARILYBYRESEARCHSTAFFWITHCOOPERATIONFROMINTERESTEDMEMBERS
OFOTHERDIVISIONS4YPICALLYTHE742CONTAINSAREVIEWOFSALIENTDEVELOPMENTSANDTRENDSIN
WORLDTRADETHREEESSAYSONTOPICALTRADEPOLICYISSUESANDALONGERSTUDYONACORETHEME
3INCEWEHAVEALSOESTABLISHEDTHREEADDITIONALSERIESOFPUBLICATIONSSPECIAL
STUDIESDISCUSSIONPAPERSANDWORKINGPAPERSELECTRONICONLY -OSTOFTHESESTUDIESARE
AUTHOREDBYRESEARCHSTAFFBUTALSOWITHCONTRIBUTIONSFROMSTAFFINOTHERDIVISIONS
)NPARTNERSHIPWITH#AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESSWELAUNCHEDAMULTIDISCIPLINARY
PROFESSIONALJOURNALTHE7ORLD4RADE2EVIEWWHICHISPUBLISHEDTHREETIMESAYEAR
4HE$IRECTOROF2ESEARCHISANEXOFFICIOMEMBEROFTHE%DITORIAL"OARDANDTHEOTHER
MEMBERSOFTHE"OARDAREINTERNATIONALLYRENOWNEDECONOMISTSLAWYERSANDPOLITICAL
SCIENTISTS4HE*OURNALHASCONTRIBUTEDTOAHIGHERPROFILEFORTHE74/3ECRETARIATIN
PROFESSIONALTRADEPOLICYCIRCLES4HE*OURNALISREFEREEDTHROUGHTHEUSUALPEERPROCESSFOR
PROFESSIONALJOURNALSANDMAINTAINSRIGOROUSACADEMICSTANDARDS&ROMOURPERSPECTIVE
THISISVERYIMPORTANTPARTICULARLYBECAUSEEDITORIALPOLICYISINDEPENDENTOFTHE74/
3ECRETARIATnOURREPRESENTATIONONTHE"OARDDOESNOTENTAILVETOPOWEROVERWHATIS
PUBLISHEDSOANALYTICALRIGOURISOURSHIELD
)NCLOSECOOPERATIONWITHTHE)NSTITUTEFOR4RAININGAND4ECHNICAL#OOPERATIONTHE
RESEARCHSTAFFHAVEBEENBUILDINGWORKINGRELATIONSHIPSWITHTHEACADEMICCOMMUNITYIN
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWITHAVIEWTOSTRENGTHENINGHOMEGROWNTRADERELATEDANALYSISTO
SUPPORTDECISIONMAKERSINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES0ARTOFTHESEEFFORTSAREFOCUSEDONJOINT
TEACHINGOFGOVERNMENTOFFICIALSBYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRYSCHOLARSANDTHE3ECRETARIATONTHE
REGIONALTRADEPOLICYCOURSES4HISASPECTOFOURPARTNERSHIPWITHTHEACADEMICCOMMUNITYIS
3PECIAL3TUDIESARESUBSTANTIALPAPERSTHAT
EXPLOREPARTICULARPOLICYISSUESOFTOPICAL
INTERESTTOTHE74/$ISCUSSIONPAPERSARE
SHORTERANALYSESTHATSEEKTODOTHESAME
THING7ORKINGPAPERSAREONLYPUBLISHEDON
THEWEBSITEANDAREWORKINPROGRESS3OMEOF
THESEPAPERSAREMORETECHNICALINNATUREAND
MAYBELESSACCESSIBLETOAWIDENONSPECIALIST
AUDIENCE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
MANAGEDBY)44#ANDENJOYSWIDEPARTICIPATIONFROMTHERESTOFTHE3ECRETARIATCFSECTION
ONTECHNICALCOOPERATIONANDTRAINING/NTHERESEARCHSIDEWEALSOWORKWITH)44#AND
FUNDINGFROMTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDA'LOBAL4RUST&UND$$!'4&TOPROMOTETRADE
RELATEDRESEARCHOFRELEVANCETOTHE74/WHICHISDISSEMINATEDTOINTERESTEDDEVELOPING
COUNTRYGOVERNMENTS7EHAVEBEENENGAGEDINORAREPLANNINGJOINTRESEARCHWITHPARTNER
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRYACADEMICINSTITUTIONSANDINDIVIDUALSFROMVARIOUSDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
INMOSTREGIONSASWELLINSOMECASESWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALINSTITUTIONSONAVARIETYOF
TOPICSINCLUDINGSTANDARDSREGIONALISMDATADEVELOPMENTDECISIONMAKINGPROCESSESON
74/MATTERSANDSECONDHANDCLOTHINGMARKETSIN!FRICA
$$!'4&FUNDSHAVEALSOBEENUSEDTOESTABLISHTHE74/0HD0ROGRAMME5NDERTHIS
PROGRAMMEUPTOSTUDENTSPERYEARFROMDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESREGISTEREDFORDOCTORAL
STUDIESONTRADERELATEDISSUESCANSPENDUPTOSIXMONTHSINTHE3ECRETARIATWORKINGON
THEIRTHESES1UALIFYINGSTUDENTSMUSTHAVEALREADYMADEPROGRESSINTHEIRTHESESANDBE
RECOMMENDEDBYTHEIRHOMEUNIVERSITIES)NDIVIDUALSINTHE3ECRETARIATPROVIDEMENTORING
SUPPORT4HISPROGRAMMESEEKSTOSTRENGTHENTRADERELATEDRESEARCHCAPACITYINDEVELOPING
COUNTRIESANDTOIDENTIFYINDIVIDUALSWHOMAYLATERWORKWITHUSASTEACHINGANDRESEARCH
PARTNERS
#HALLENGES
4HESTANDINGOFTHE74/3ECRETARIATASALEGITIMATEANDIMPORTANTSOURCEOFANALYSISOF
TRADEPOLICYISSUESHASYETTOBEACCEPTEDINSOMEQUARTERS7IDERAPPRECIATIONISNEEDEDOF
THEREASONSWHYTHE74/SHOULDHAVEINDEPENDENTANALYTICALCAPACITYANDTHEFREEDOMTO
TACKLECOMPLEXANDSOMETIMESCONTENTIOUSISSUESFROMANANALYTICALPERSPECTIVE-EMBERS
ARERIGHTTOOBJECTTOWORKTHATINTERFERESWITHSENSITIVENEGOTIATIONSBUTNOTTOSTIFLE
DISCUSSIONANDANALYSISTHATCONTRIBUTESTOCLEARERANDMOREINFORMEDTHINKINGONISSUES
THATMUSTBEADDRESSEDINTHETRADINGSYSTEM$ENIALOFFREEDOMFORTHE3ECRETARIATTOMAKE
THISCONTRIBUTIONWEAKENSTHESTANDINGOFTHE74/ASANINSTITUTIONANDTHEEFFECTIVENESS
OFINTERNATIONALCOOPERATIONINTRADEPOLICY)TALSOYIELDSTHEFIELDTOOTHERINSTITUTIONSAND
INDIVIDUALSTHATDONOTALWAYSCONTRIBUTEPOSITIVELYTOCONSTRUCTIVEENGAGEMENT
4RADESTATISTICS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4RADEPOLICYDATA
4HE74/SHOULDBETHEAUTHORITATIVESOURCEINTHEAREAOFTRADEPOLICYDATA'OOD
PROGRESSHASBEENMADEINTHISDIRECTIONOVERTHELASTDECADEBUTMUCHREMAINSTOBEDONE
4HE)NTEGRATED$ATA"ASE)$"INITSPRESENTFORMWASESTABLISHEDFOLLOWINGTHEDECISION
OFTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILINTHATALL74/-EMBERSWOULDSUBMITIMPORTSTATISTICSAND
TARIFFINFORMATIONATTHEMOSTDETAILEDLEVELTOTHE74/3ECRETARIATONANANNUALBASIS4HE
#ONSOLIDATED4ARIFF3CHEDULES#43DATABASEWASESTABLISHEDINONTHEBASISOFA
DECISIONBYTHE#OMMITTEEON-ARKET!CCESS4HE#43CONTAINS74/-EMBERSBOUNDTARIFFS
ANDITINCLUDESALSOSUPPLEMENTARYCOMMITMENTSINAGRICULTUREDOMESTICSUPPORTEXPORT
SUBSIDIESANDTARIFFQUOTAINFORMATION
4HE$IVISIONHASDEVELOPEDARANGEOFSOFTWARETOOLSINCLUDINGTHE)NTERNET!NALYSIS
&ACILITYAND&ILE4RANSFER&ACILITYTOALLOW74/-EMBERSTOACCESSANDANALYSE)$"#43DATA
74/INFORMATIONONMARKETACCESSCONDITIONSANDTRADELINKEDATTHEMOSTDETAILEDLEVEL
INCLUDEDINTHE)$"#43DATABASESISAUNIQUEANDAUTHORITATIVESOURCEOFINFORMATIONTHAT
HASSUBSTANTIALLYIMPROVEDTHECAPACITYOFTHE74/3ECRETARIAT74/-EMBERSACCEDING
COUNTRIESANDAUTHORIZEDINTERNATIONALORGANISATIONSTOCARRYOUTTRADEPOLICYANALYSIS
$ATACANBEACCESSEDTHROUGHTHE)NTERNETORVIA#$2/-S
4OADDRESSEXISTINGLIMITATIONSINTERMSOFCOVERAGEANDACCESSTO)$"#43SEEBELOW
THE3ECRETARIATHASJOINTLYESTABLISHEDTHE#OMMON!NALYTICAL-ARKET!CCESS$ATABASE
#!-!$INCOOPERATIONWITHTHE)4#AND5.#4!$4HISNEWDATABASEISBEINGBUILTUP
USINGTHECOREMARKETACCESSINFORMATIONFROM)$"#43SUPPLEMENTEDWITHINFORMATIONFROM
THE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTER)4#AND5.#4!$SUCHASFORCOUNTRIESNOTINCLUDEDINTHE
)$"PREFERENTIALDUTIESANDADVALOREMEQUIVALENTS4HISINFORMATIONWILLBEAMAJORINPUT
FORTHE74/SREGULARRESEARCHWORK!MONGTHEOBJECTIVESOF#!-!$ARE
!CHIEVEMENTOFUNIVERSALDATACOVERAGEINTERMSOFCOUNTRIESDUTIESINCLUDING
PREFERENCESANDADVALOREMEQUIVALENTS
2EDUCEDDUPLICATIONOFRESOURCESINTHEPRODUCTIONANDDISSEMINATIONOFMARKET
ACCESSDATAAMONGINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
)MPROVEDDATAQUALITYANDCOHERENCEWITHTHEREDUCTIONANDELIMINATIONOF
INCONSISTENCIESAMONGDIFFERENTSOURCES4HISWILLENSURETHATTHEDIFFERENTSTAKEHOLDERS
INVOLVEDINTRADEPOLICYWORKWILLUSETHESAMEVERIFIEDANDCONSISTENTDATA
0ROVISIONTOTRADEPOLICYRESEARCHERSWORLDWIDEOFARELEVANTDERIVEDDATASETIN
COMPLIANCEWITH74/)4#AND5.#4!$DISSEMINATIONPOLICIESWHICHWILLRESULTINA
BETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFTRADEPOLICYOPTIONSPARTICULARLYFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
)NTERNATIONALTRADESTATISTICS
!SWITHTRADEPOLICYDATATHE74/ISALSOEXPECTEDTOBEANAUTHORITATIVESOURCEIN
THEAREAOFINTERNATIONALTRADESTATISTICS4HESTATISTICSTEAMPROVIDES74/-EMBERSAND
THEGENERALPUBLICWITHUPTODATEANDHIGHQUALITYTRADESTATISTICSTHROUGHANANNUAL
PUBLICATIONTHE)NTERNATIONAL4RADE3TATISTICSREPORTANDTHROUGHSEVERALUSERFRIENDLYTOOLS
SUCHAS#$2/-SORINTERACTIVEONLINEDATABASESONTHE)NTERNET
4HE3ECRETARIATCONVENESTHE)NTER!GENCY4ASK&ORCEON)NTERNATIONAL-ERCHANDISE4RADE
3TATISTICSANDPARTICIPATESACTIVELYINTHE)NTER!GENCY4ASK&ORCEON3TATISTICSOF)NTERNATIONAL
4RADEIN3ERVICES4HELATTERADDRESSESTHELACKOFINFORMATIONONTRADEINSERVICESWHICHISAN
IMPORTANTISSUEINTHECONTEXTOF'!43"OTHTHESEBODIESAREESTABLISHEDUNDERTHEAEGISOF
THE5NITED.ATIONS3TATISTICAL#OMMISSION
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERNATIONALORGANISATIONSHASINCREASEDOVERTHEYEARSRESULTING
INAMOREEFFICIENTALLOCATIONOFRESOURCESFORDATACOLLECTIONANDTHEDISSEMINATIONOF
MERCHANDISETRADESTATISTICSAMONGINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
)NTHECASEOFSTATISTICSONTRADEINSERVICESANEW-ANUALON3TATISTICSON)NTERNATIONAL
4RADEIN3ERVICES-3)43HASBEENESTABLISHED4HISWASAMAJORENDEAVOURBYTHE
INTERNATIONALAGENCIESINVOLVEDINSTATISTICSONTRADEINSERVICESANDISPARTICULARLYUSEFUL
FORTHESTATISTICALMONITORINGOFTHE'ENERAL!GREEMENTON4RADEIN3ERVICES'!43-OST
DEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESNOWCOMPILEANDPUBLISHSTATISTICSONINTERNATIONALTRADEINSERVICES
ACCORDINGTOINTERNATIONALSTANDARDSDEFINEDINTHE-3)43"UTCLEARINTERNATIONALLYAGREED
COMPILATIONGUIDELINESFORTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOF-3)43INDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESSTILLNEEDTO
BEWORKEDOUT
#HALLENGES
74/LIBRARY
4HE,IBRARYINTHEPASTTENYEARSHASFOCUSEDONPROVIDINGMOREACCESSTODOCUMENTSAND
QUALITYINFORMATIONFORUSERSBOTHINSIDEANDOUTSIDETHE,IBRARYSPACE!NONLINEDATABASE
HASBEENESTABLISHEDFORTHECOLLECTIONREPLACINGTHECARDCATALOGUE4HE,IBRARYWILLSOONBE
OPENINGITSCATALOGUETOOUTSIDEUSERSOVERTHE)NTERNET4HISALONGWITHTHEDEVELOPMENTOF
WEBPAGESFORTHE,IBRARYWILLHELP-EMBERSANDACADEMICSCOLLABORATINGON74/ISSUES
)NADDITIONCONSIDERABLELEGALMATERIALWASACQUIREDTOSUPPLEMENTTHEEXISTING
ECONOMICSBASEDCOLLECTIONANDTOCOVERNEWDOMAINSOFWORKOFTHE74/!N!RCHIVES
3ECTIONCONTAININGTHECOMPLETECOLLECTIONOF'!4474/DOCUMENTSFROMWASOPENED
INORDERTOFACILITATEACCESSTOTHISIMPORTANTPARTOFTHEINSTITUTIONALMEMORY
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
/NTHETRADEPOLICYFRONT)$"COUNTRYCOVERAGEISLIMITEDASANUMBEROFCOUNTRIESDO
NOTCOMPLYWITHTHEIRNOTIFICATIONOBLIGATIONSDUEINSOMECASESTOALACKOFRESOURCESOR
THEINADEQUATECAPACITYOFSTATISTICALSYSTEMS
$ATACOVERAGEINTHE)$"ISALSOLIMITEDWHEREINFORMATIONISLACKINGONAPPLIED
PREFERENTIALDUTIESANDADVALOREMEQUIVALENTSOFNONADVALOREMDUTIES4HESEPROBLEMS
REFLECTTHENARROWNESSOF-EMBERSNOTIFICATIONREQUIREMENTS
)NFORMATIONCONTAINEDINTHE)$"#43ISRESTRICTEDTOAUTHORIZEDUSERS74/-EMBERS
ACCEDINGCOUNTRIESTHATSUPPLYDATAFORTHE)$"ANDSOMEINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
4HEREFOREMANYTRADEPOLICYANALYSTSCANNOTMAKEUSEOFTHISINFORMATIONFORTHEBENEFITOF
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES
4HESERESTRICTEDDISSEMINATIONPOLICIESTOGETHERWITHLIMITATIONSONNOTIFICATION
REQUIREMENTSHAVELEDOTHERORGANIZATIONSTOCOLLECTANDPROCESSTHEIROWNDATAON
MARKETACCESSCONDITIONSRESULTINGINADUPLICATIONOFWORKANDRESOURCESBYINTERNATIONAL
ORGANIZATIONSNOTTOMENTIONTHEIMPLICATIONSOFTHISSITUATIONFORTHE74/SSTANDING
INMATTERSOFDATA4HERECENT#!-!$INITIATIVEISANATTEMPTTOADDRESSSOMEOFTHESE
DIFFICULTIESBUTITWILLNOTSOLVEALLPROBLEMSANDINANYCASE#!-!$ISGOINGTONEEDMORE
SOLIDSUPPORTIFTHEINITIATIVEISTOFLOURISH
%XTERNALRELATIONS
#OOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS
4HEMANDATEOFTHE74/WHENITWASESTABLISHEDININCLUDEDACOMMITMENTTO
COOPERATIONWITHTRADERELATEDINTERNATIONALORGANIZATIONS
!RTICLE6OFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATION
STATESh4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILSHALLMAKEAPPROPRIATEARRANGEMENTSFOREFFECTIVE
COOPERATIONWITHOTHERINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSTHATHAVERESPONSIBILITIES
RELATEDTOTHOSEOFTHE74/v!RTICLE)))STATESh7ITHAVIEWTOACHIEVING
GREATERCOHERENCEINGLOBALECONOMICPOLICYMAKINGTHE74/SHALLCOOPERATEAS
APPROPRIATEWITHTHE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UNDANDWITHTHE)NTERNATIONAL"ANKFOR
2ECONSTRUCTIONAND$EVELOPMENTANDITSAFFILIATEDAGENCIESv
$URINGITSFIRSTTENYEARSOFEXISTENCETHE74/HASADVANCEDSIGNIFICANTLYITSCOOPERATION
ANDCOLLABORATIONWITHOTHERINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS2ELATIONSWEREESTABLISHED
IMMEDIATELYWITHTHE5NITED.ATIONSTHROUGHANEXCHANGEOFLETTERSIN3EPTEMBER
SIGNEDBYTHE74/$IRECTOR'ENERALAND5.3ECRETARY'ENERAL)NTHEFOLLOWINGTWOYEARS
FORMALCOOPERATIONAGREEMENTSWERECONCLUDEDWITHTHE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UND
AND7ORLD"ANK2ELATIONSHAVEALSOBEENESTABLISHEDWITHMANYOTHERINTERNATIONALAND
REGIONALBODIESINVOLVEDWITHTRADERELATEDSUBJECTSANDTHROUGHTHESETIESTHE74/IS
WORKINGTOENSURETHERESOURCESANDEXPERTISEOFTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYREMAIN
FOCUSEDCOORDINATEDANDRELEVANTTOTHEMOSTPRESSINGGLOBALNEEDS#OOPERATIONINCLUDES
RECIPROCALPARTICIPATIONATMEETINGSINFORMATIONSHARINGJOINTRESEARCHANDCOLLABORATION
BETWEENSECRETARIATS
)NITSEFFORTSTOADVANCETHEDEVELOPMENTDIMENSIONOFTRADETHE74/HASDEVELOPED
CLOSETIESWITHTHE5NITED.ATIONS#ONFERENCEON4RADEAND$EVELOPMENT5.#4!$
PARTICULARLYINTHEAREASOFCAPACITYBUILDINGANDTRADERELATEDTECHNICALASSISTANCETO
DEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESANDLEASTDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES/THERINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS
THATCOOPERATEWITHTHE74/ONTHEDEVELOPMENTDIMENSIONINCLUDEINTERALIATHE5NITED
.ATIONS$EVELOPMENT0ROGRAMME)NTERNATIONAL4RADE#ENTRE)NTERNATIONAL-ONETARY&UND
AND7ORLD"ANK4HE74/HASALSOCONCLUDEDMEMORANDAOFUNDERSTANDINGWITHARANGE
OFINTERNATIONALANDREGIONALINSTITUTIONSFORJOINTACTIVITIESCOLLABORATIONANDDELIVERYOF
TECHNICALASSISTANCE
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
2ELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
4HE74/ISONEOFASMALLNUMBEROFINTERGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSWHOSEFOUNDING
DOCUMENTREFERSEXPLICITLYTORELATIONSWITHNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS
!RTICLE6OFTHE-ARRAKESH!GREEMENT%STABLISHINGTHE7ORLD4RADE/RGANIZATIONSTATES
h4HE'ENERAL#OUNCILMAYMAKEAPPROPRIATEARRANGEMENTSFORCONSULTATIONANDCOOPERATION
WITHNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSCONCERNEDWITHMATTERSRELATEDTOTHOSEOFTHE74/v
2ELATIONSWITHNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSWEREFURTHERELABORATEDINASETOFGUIDELINES
ADOPTEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILIN*ULY74,4HEGUIDELINESINTERALIAhRECOGNIZE
THEROLE.'/SCANPLAYTOINCREASETHEAWARENESSOFTHEPUBLICINRESPECTOF74/ACTIVITIESv
)TISNOTEWORTHYTOOTHAT74/-EMBERSMOVEDIMMEDIATELYINTOAGREEGUIDELINES
ONRELATIONSWITH.'/SANDTHEYCOMMITTEDINTHESAMEDECISIONTOIMPROVETRANSPARENCY
ANDDEVELOPCOMMUNICATIONWITHCIVILSOCIETYGROUPS4HE74/HASMADESIGNIFICANTPROGRESS
INTHEAREASOFEXTERNALCOMMUNICATIONSANDSTRENGTHENINGOFRELATIONSWITHCIVILSOCIETY
0ROGRESSHASBEENACHIEVEDINAMANNERCONSISTENTWITHTHEINTERGOVERNMENTALCHARACTER
OFTHE74/ANDCONSISTENTALSOWITHTHEWIDELYHELDVIEWAMONG-EMBERSTHATPRIMARY
RESPONSIBILITYFORCOMMUNICATINGTHEBUSINESSOFTHEORGANIZATIONRESTSWITH-EMBERS
THEMSELVES
4HE$IRECTOR'ENERALHISDEPUTIESANDOTHER3ECRETARIATSTAFFMEETROUTINELYWITH.'/
REPRESENTATIVESnBOTHIN'ENEVAANDINOTHERVENUES-EMBERSOFCIVILSOCIETYAND.'/
REPRESENTATIVESAREALSOINALMOSTDAILYCONTACTWITH%XTERNAL2ELATIONS$IVISIONANDIN
ADDITION
3ECRETARIATOFFICIALSPARTICIPATEOFTENINMAJORMEETINGSWHERETRADERELATEDSUBJECTSOF
INTERESTTOCIVILSOCIETYAREDISCUSSED!SWELLBRIEFINGSON74/MEETINGSAREORGANIZED
REGULARLYFOR'ENEVABASED.'/REPRESENTATIVESAND.'/SAREALSOINVITEDTOATTENDISSUE
SPECIFICSYMPOSIA)NTHELATTERREGARDTHE74/SANNUALPUBLICSYMPOSIUMISNOWAMAJOR
EVENTONTHEINTERNATIONALCALENDARANDPROVIDESANEXTREMELYUSEFULPLATFORMFORDIALOGUE
AMONGALLSTAKEHOLDERSOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEM
5NDERPROCEDURESAGREEDBYTHE'ENERAL#OUNCIL.'/SAREABLETOATTEND74/
MINISTERIALCONFERENCESANDBEPRESENTATPLENARYSESSIONSOFTHE#ONFERENCE)NCONTRAST
TOTHEPARTICIPANTSREPRESENTING.'/SWHOATTENDEDTHEFIRST74/-INISTERIAL
#ONFERENCEIN3INGAPOREINTHEREWEREPARTICIPANTSREPRESENTING.'/SAT
THEFIFTH-INISTERIAL#ONFERENCEIN#ANCÞN-EXICOnANEARSEVENFOLDINCREASE
)NFURTHERRESPONSETOTHEGROWINGPUBLICINTERESTINTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMINRECENT
YEARSANDTHEEXPANDINGROLEOFCIVILSOCIETYININTERNATIONALPROCESSES.'/SARENOWINVITED
TO74/INFORMALLYTOPRESENTPOLICYRESEARCHANDANALYSISDIRECTLYTO74/-EMBERS.'/
POSITIONPAPERSARECOMPILEDANDCIRCULATEDTO74/-EMBERSONAMONTHLYBASISAND74/
ELECTRONICNEWSBULLETINSARECIRCULATEDTO.'/SEVERYFORTNIGHT
)NTHE'ENERAL#OUNCILDECIDEDTOEXPEDITETHEDERESTRICTIONOFDOCUMENTS4HIS
MOVEHASGENERATEDAFLOODOFEASILYACCESSIBLEDOCUMENTATIONnMUCHOFITAVAILABLEALMOST
SIMULTANEOUSLYWITHITSDELIVERYTO-EMBERSnANDMEANS74/NEGOTIATIONSCANNOWBE
FOLLOWEDTHROUGHFIRSTHANDSOURCES4AKENTOGETHERWITHTHEINTRODUCTORYANDEXPLANATORY
MATERIALNOWONTHE74/WEBSITE74/SWORKPROGRAMMEISNOWREMARKABLYTRANSPARENT
3INCE3EATTLEIN74/HASCOMPLETEDMANYPROGRAMMESOFOUTREACHACTIVITIES
FORPARLIAMENTARIANSANDCIVILSOCIETY)NANDACTIVITIESINCLUDEDREGIONAL
WORKSHOPSFORPARLIAMENTARIANSIN!FRICA#ARIBBEAN,ATIN!MERICA0ACIFICAND!SIAAND
SIMILARWORKSHOPSFORCIVILSOCIETYREPRESENTATIVESIN%NGLISHSPEAKINGAND&RENCHSPEAKING
!FRICA)NALLOUTREACHACTIVITIESTHEOBJECTIVESWEREESSENTIALLYSIMILARTOFOSTERGREATER
PUBLICUNDERSTANDINGOFANDINTERESTINTHE74/TOINFORMPARLIAMENTARIANSCIVILSOCIETY
REPRESENTATIVESONTHEOPERATIONSOFTHEMULTILATERALTRADINGSYSTEMANDKEYISSUESONTHE
INTERNATIONALTRADEAGENDAANDTOENCOURAGEANEXCHANGEOFVIEWSONTRADERELATEDAND
DEVELOPMENTRELATEDISSUES4HEOUTREACHACTIVITIESHAVEBEENWELCOMEDBY74/-EMBERS
ANDFURTHERACTIVITIESAREPLANNEDIN)NADDITIONTOTHESEACTIVITIESOTHERASPECTSOF
74/SCURRENTDRIVETOENGAGEWITHPARLIAMENTARIANSINCLUDESATTENDANCEATSEMINARSAND
WORKSHOPSANDPARTICIPATIONINVARIOUSPARLIAMENTARYDIALOGUESONTRADE
0UBLICANDMEDIAINFORMATION
4HEESTABLISHMENTOFTHE74/INGENERATEDTREMENDOUSINTERESTINTHENEW
ORGANIZATIONAMONGMEMBERSOFTHEMEDIAINPOLITICALCIRCLESAMONGACADEMICSANDINTHE
GENERALPUBLIC
4HEROLEANDINFLUENCEOFTHEORGANIZATIONWASTHESUBJECTOFGREATSPECULATIONDUEIN
PARTTOTHECREATIONOFAMUCHMOREEFFECTIVESYSTEMOFDISPUTESETTLEMENTANDTOTHEFACT
THATTHE74/SMANDATEININTERNATIONALTRADEEXTENDEDBEYONDTHEGOODSTREATIESCOVERED
BYITSPREDECESSORTHE'!44ANDINTOTHEREALMSOFTRADEINSERVICESAGRICULTURETEXTILESAND
THEPROTECTIONOFINTELLECTUALPROPERTY
'REATEFFORTHASBEENMADEFROMTHEONSETTOENSURETHATTHEPUBLICISINFORMEDINTHE
MOSTTRANSPARENTMANNERPOSSIBLEOFTHEACTIVITIESANDOBJECTIVESOFTHE74/4HROUGHDAILY
PRESSBRIEFINGSTHEINTERNETDOZENSOFPUBLICATIONSANDLECTURESFORSTUDENTSANDTHEPUBLIC
INFORMATIONPROFESSIONALSINTHE74/3ECRETARIATHAVEDISSEMINATEDINFORMATIONACROSSTHE
WORLD
4HERESULTOVERTHEFIRSTTENYEARSOFTHE74/HASBEENENHANCEDUNDERSTANDINGBYMEDIA
ANDTHEPUBLICWORLDWIDEOFTHETRUEROLEANDTHEIMPORTANTBENEFITSOFINTERNATIONALTRADE
FORTHEIRECONOMIESANDABETTERAPPRECIATIONOFTHECONTRIBUTIONTHE74/HASMADETO
GLOBALECONOMICGROWTHANDDEVELOPMENT
74/PRESSOFFICERSWORKWITHJOURNALISTSONEVERYCONTINENTMAKINGNEWSINFORMATION
AVAILABLEDIRECTLYANDTHROUGHTHEINTERNET3PECIALINFORMATIONSESSIONSFORJOURNALISTS
FROMDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAREORGANIZEDONAREGULARBASISTOASSISTDEVELOPINGCOUNTRY
JOURNALISTSINTHEIREFFORTSATFOLLOWINGTHEWORKOFTHE74/
4HE74/HOLDSDAILYMEDIABRIEFINGSONNEWDEVELOPMENTSANDHASORGANIZEDTHOUSANDS
OFNEWSCONFERENCESONSPECIALEVENTSOFTENUSINGTHEINTERNETTOEXTENDTHEREACHOFTHESE
SESSIONSTOJOURNALISTSAROUNDTHEWORLD4HEWORKOFEXPLAININGTHECOMPLEXPROCESSFOR
TRADENEGOTIATIONSESPECIALLYSINCETHELAUNCHOFTHE$OHA$EVELOPMENT!GENDAIN
HASPROVEDTOBEVERYEFFECTIVEINDEMYSTIFYINGBOTHTHEPROCESSANDTHESOMETIMESABSTRUSE
SUBJECTMATTEROFTHENEGOTIATIONSnWITHNOW-EMBERSPARTICIPATINGDEALINGWITH
OVEREXISTINGAGREEMENTSNEGOTIATINGTHOUSANDSOFPAGESOFNEWPROPOSALSALLOFWHICH
REQUIREEXPLANATIONANDBACKGROUNDINFORMATIONINORDERTOBEUNDERSTOODBYMEDIAANDTHE
PUBLIC
4HEFIVE74/MINISTERIALCONFERENCESHAVEATTRACTEDTHOUSANDSOFJOURNALISTSWHOHAVE
REPORTEDONEVENTSUNFOLDINGATTHEBIANNUALMEETINGS4HESEOCCASIONSHAVEBEENUSEDTO
PROVIDEINTENSIVEBRIEFINGSFORJOURNALISTSONTHEWORKOFTHEMINISTERSASWELLASBACKGROUND
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
-EDIARELATIONS
SESSIONSONGENERAL74/MATTERS$ETAILEDINFORMATIONKITSAREPRODUCEDANDDISTRIBUTEDTO
JOURNALISTSATTENDINGTHESEMEETINGS
74/WEBSITE
4HE74/WEBSITEHASGROWNFROMANELECTRONICBROCHUREOFSEVERALHUNDREDPAGESIN
TOAFULL74/PORTALOFTENSOFTHOUSANDSOFPAGESDATABASESETCWHICHINTHEPAST
YEARATTRACTEDOVERMILLIONVISITORS4HEMOSTRECENTSURVEYOFTHEWEBSITESUSERSCONFIRMS
ITHASBECOMEANINVALUABLETOOLFORSTUDENTSACADEMICSLEGALANDOTHERTRADESPECIALISTS
BUSINESSESINVOLVEDINTRADEAND.'/SANDTHATITISANIMPORTANTSOURCEOFGENERAL
INFORMATIONFORTHEPUBLIC6ISITORSTOTHEWEBSITEDOWNLOADMILLIONSOFPAGESOFLEGAL
TEXTSINFORMATIONBROCHURESNEWSRELEASESEVERYMONTH4HEINCREASINGUSEOFWEBCASTING
FOREVENTSSUCHASMINISTERIALCONFERENCESMAJORNEWSCONFERENCESANDTRAININGSESSIONS
HASFURTHEREXPANDEDTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFTHEWEBSITEINREACHINGMEDIAANDTHEPUBLIC
WORLDWIDE
74/PUBLICATIONS
4HE74/HASPUBLISHEDNEARLYTITLESIN%NGLISH&RENCHAND3PANISHVERSIONSSINCE
4HELISTINCLUDESLEGALTEXTSREPORTSONDISPUTESETTLEMENTSANDOTHERSPECIALIZED
MATERIALSWHICHAREUSEDBYACADEMICSTRADEOFFICIALSANDTRADEEXPERTSAROUNDTHEWORLD
!SECONDFOCUSOFTHEPUBLICATIONSPROGRAMHASBEENTHEPRODUCTIONOF'UIDESAND
(ANDBOOKSWHICHEXPLAINFORTHELAYMANORTRADESPECIALISTSSPECIFICASPECTSOFTHE
ORGANIZATIONSWORK4HESEHAVEBECOMEBASICTEACHINGANDWORKINGTOOLSFORMINISTRIES
UNIVERSITIES.'/SANDBUSINESSES4HE74/SINFORMATIONPUBLICATIONSSUCHAS
h5NDERSTANDINGTHE74/vHAVEBECOMESTANDARDSFORANYONESEEKINGANINTRODUCTIONTOTHE
74/)NADDITIONTOPRINTVERSIONSOFITSPUBLICATIONSTHE74/MAKESMOSTOFTHEMAVAILABLE
ASFREEDOWNLOADSONITSWEBSITE4HISINCLUDESTHE74/!NNUAL2EPORTANDTHE74/7ORLD
4RADE2EPORTnOVERCOPIESOFEACHOFTHESEREPORTSWASDOWNLOADEDFROMTHE74/
WEBSITEINTHEPASTYEAR
0UBLICINFORMATIONSESSIONSANDVISITS
74/TH!NNIVERSARY
4HE74/SHEADQUARTERSIN'ENEVATHE#ENTRE7ILLIAM2APPARDISVISITEDBYTHOUSANDS
OFSTUDENTSBUSINESSPEOPLEANDOTHERGROUPSEVERYYEARWHOATTENDORGANIZEDINFORMATION
SESSIONSWHERETHEYAREABLETOHAVEEXCHANGESWITH74/OFFICIALSONCURRENTISSUESAND
SPECIALIZEDTRADETOPICS!BOUTVISITORSHAVEATTENDEDSUCHSESSIONSSINCE
7/"Ê*1
/" -
850 /, /" Ê/,Ê-//-/
-ÊÓääx
/…ˆÃÊÀi«œÀÌÊ«ÀœÛˆ`iÃÊVœ“«Ài…i˜ÃˆÛi]Ê
ÃÌ>̈Ã̈VÃʜ˜ÊÌÀ>`iʈ˜Ê“iÀV…>˜`ˆÃiÊ
>˜`ÊVœ““iÀVˆ>ÊÃiÀۈViÃÊvœÀÊ>˜Ê>ÃÃiÃÓi˜ÌÊ
œvÊܜÀ`ÊÌÀ>`iÊyœÜÃÊLÞÊVœÕ˜ÌÀÞ]Ê
Ài}ˆœ˜Ê>˜`ʓ>ˆ˜Ê«Àœ`ÕVÌÊ}ÀœÕ«ÃÊ
œÀÊÃiÀۈViÊV>Ìi}œÀˆið
>œÀÊÌÀ>`iÊ`iÛiœ«“i˜ÌÃÊ>ÀiÊÃՓ“>Àˆâi`Ê
>˜`Ê`ˆÃVÕÃÃi`ʈ˜Ê̅iÊwÀÃÌÊ«>ÀÌʜvÊ̅iÊÀi«œÀÌʈ˜Ê
̅iÊ"ÛiÀۈiÜ°ÊiÌ>ˆi`ÊÌÀ>`iÊÃÌ>̈Ã̈VÃÊ
>ÀiÊ«ÀœÛˆ`i`ʈ˜Ê««i˜`ˆÝÊÌ>Lið
*OUFSOBUJPOBM
USBEFTUBUJTUJDT
œÛi“LiÀÊÓääx
- ʙӇnÇä‡ÎΣ·Ç
*ÀˆVi\Ê
Êxä
7",Ê/,Ê,*",/ÊÓääx
803-%53"%&3&1035
/…iÊ7œÀ`Ê/À>`iÊ,i«œÀÌʈÃÊ̅iʓœÃÌÊÀiVi˜ÌÊ
>``ˆÌˆœ˜Ê̜Ê̅iʘ˜Õ>Ê-iÀˆiÃÊ>˜`ÊvœVÕÃiÃÊ
œ˜ÊëiVˆwVÊÌÀ>`iÊ«œˆVÞʈÃÃÕiÃÊʜvÊVÕÀÀi˜ÌÊ
ˆ˜ÌiÀiÃÌ°Ê/…iÊVœÀiÊ̜«ˆVÊ>``ÀiÃÃi`ʈ˜Ê̅iÊ
ÓääxÊ,i«œÀÌʈÃÊ̅iÊÀi>̈œ˜Ã…ˆ«ÊLiÌÜii˜Ê
ÃÌ>˜`>À`ÃÊ>˜`ÊÊÌÀ>`i°Ê/…iÊ,i«œÀÌÊ>ÃœÊ
Vœ˜Ì>ˆ˜ÃÊ̅ÀiiÊŜÀÌiÀÊiÃÃ>ÞÃʜ˜Ê̅iÊÕÃiÊ
œvʵÕ>˜ÌˆÌ>̈ÛiÊiVœ˜œ“ˆVÊ>˜>ÞÈÃʈ˜Ê7/"Ê
`ˆÃ«ÕÌiÊÃiÌ̏i“i˜ÌÊ«ÀœVii`ˆ˜}Ã]ÊÌÀ>`iÊ
ˆ˜Ê>ˆÀÊÌÀ>˜Ã«œÀÌÊÃiÀۈViÃ]Ê>˜`ʜvvŜÀˆ˜}Ê
ÃiÀۈViðÊ/…iÊ,i«œÀÌÊ>ÃœÊÀiۈiÜÃÊÌÀi˜`Ãʈ˜Ê
ˆ˜ÌiÀ˜>̈œ˜>ÊÌÀ>`i°ÊÊ
ՏÞÊÓääx
- ʙӇnÇä‡ÎΣä‡Ó
*ÀˆVi\Ê
ÊÈä
/"Ê",,Ê*-Ê
" /
/\
7/"Ê*ÕLˆV>̈œ˜Ã]Ê£x{]ÊÀÕiÊ`iÊ>ÕÃ>˜˜i]Ê£Ó££Êi˜iÛ>ÊÓ£]Ê-܈ÌâiÀ>˜`
/i\Ê­{£ÊÓÓ®ÊÇΙÊxÓÊänÊ >Ý\Ê­{£ÊÓÓ®ÊÇΙÊxÇʙÓÊ “>ˆ\Ê«ÕLˆV>̈œ˜ÃJÜ̜°œÀ}
"À`iÀÊ̅ÀœÕ}…ÊœÕÀÊ"˜‡ˆ˜iÊLœœŽÃ…œ«Ê>ÌÊÜÜÜ°Ü̜°œÀ}
UI"OOJWFSTBSZ
803-%53"%&03("/*;"5*0/
"QSJMm645SBEF3FQSFTFOUBUJWF.JDLFZ,BOUPS4JHOT
UIF'JOBM"DUPGUIF6SVHVBZ3PVOEBU.BSSBLFTI
4FQUFNCFSm7JDFOUF'PY1SFTJEFOUPG.FYJDPBUUIF
'JGUI.JOJTUFSJBM$BODÙO
%FDFNCFSm1FUFS4VUIFSMBOE$IBJSNBOPGUIF
5SBEF/FHPUJBUJPOT$PNNJUUFFDMPTFTUIF6SVHVBZ
3PVOE/FHPUJBUJPOT
.BZm8PSMEMFBEFSTHBUIFSBUUIF4FDPOE.JOJTUFSJBM$POGFSFODF
(FOFWBGPSUIFUIBOOJWFSTBSZPGUIF("55850USBEJOHTZTUFN
.BZm/FMTPO.BOEFMB4PVUI"GSJDBO1SFTJEFOUBUUIF
4FDPOE.JOJTUFSJBM$POGFSFODF(FOFWB
*Àˆ˜Ìi`ÊLÞÊ̅iÊ7/"Ê-iVÀiÌ>Àˆ>ÌʇÊÈnä°x