MINUTES OF THE GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR
ASSOCIATION, LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON 20TH JUNE 2011 AT THE LAGOS
STATE HIGH COURT FOYER
1.0
ATTENDANCE
1.1
Officers
1.
Chijioke Okoli
2.
S.B. Onu
3.
John Duru
3.
Marina Jones
4.
Joyce Oduah
5.
Nelson Ogbuanya
5.
Bode Omoboriowo
6.
Sessi S. Akojenu
7.
Chinedu Nduka
8.
Theodore Jnr. Ezeobi
8.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9.
Chukwuma Ezeala
1.2
-
The Chairman
The Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
Fin. Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
Asst. Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Asst. Fin. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Co-opted Member
Co-opted member
Members
1.
Ugo Silva Osuji
3.
Tony Okwesa
5.
Jonathan Etuyibo
7.
Abioye Akerele
9.
Alajuronye, Obidi Cecil
11.
Alex Muoka
13.
Abanikionda Kafilat Falake
15.
Ekott Uduak J
17.
Adebiyi Olufunmilayo
19.
Martin Ogunleye
21.
Echeme Ekeghe
23.
Ogunyinmi Olasoji
25.
Frank Agbedo
27.
Oluseye Oparanya
29.
Onojighoria Oliko
31
BOB C.O. Ijioma
33.
L.D. Sadiq
35.
Chief Olufemi A. Daramola
37.
Eloka Nwokolo Emma
39.
Philips Njeteneh
41.
Akano Oluwasetitan Modupe
43.
A.S. Abimbola
45.
Owhofawhoraye Stephen A.
47.
Ogunmola Ademayowa (Mrs)
49.
Boko
51.
Jeffrey Ebeh
53.
Ikemefuna Okekwe
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
1
Samuel Ukpong
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Adenike Adeniji
Anikan J. Naknta
Susanne Izilien
Bode Olaosebidar
Okoli Paul
Nwana E. Chuks
Jones Muyiwa Kayode
F.A. Dalmeida
Odupitan Julius A.O
Okey Eneh
Jude Mbaeri
Oludamilola Babalola
Modupe Sowho
Akitola Ejiwunmi
Chikodili Dimezou
Azubulu Nwankenle
Nwoguh Nkemdilim
Udom John Udom
Nneka Mba-Iwehe
Aluce Ochoga (Mrs)
Mnukae Dioru
Ezeokeke Uchenna N.
Chris I. Alumona
Ituah Imhope
Lawrence Austinecoleman
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
Modupe Afikuyomi
Julius Ugese
Adeniyi Olayoole
Kehinde Evbuoma
Chuba Mbanefo
Lanre Oyetunji
Zik Obi II
Faruz Abbas
Egeonu Gloria
Melvina Akala
Femi Fajolu
Nmesoma Onzulams
Adenike Komolafe
Jude N. Iloba
Dayo Onakoya
Grace Adenubi
Balogun Esther O. (Mrs)
Funmi Obinzu-Dosunmu
Torbari D.N.S
Onyinye Ochgbonma
Iheoma Osimiri
Chinweikpeiwu Chukwu`
UE Murphy-Akpieyi (Mrs)
Madueke Okafor
Rahman Oshodi
Amune Aremeyi
Senator Onyeabo Obi
Apebo Michael
Kaigama Sarah
Suokere, Adekunle Agidee
Orie Erimma Gloria
Oluka M. Nwidaa
Atuchuwku Pat
Lucy Udoh
Ekpemying E.O
Porbeni Edward
Kayode Odumosu
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs)
Segun Solomon
Anthonia Eke
Aboye Tam-George
Okafor Ogechukwu
Manasseh Alakiri U.
Silas M.
Dennis O. Akhagba
Eze Obiageli Happiness
Charles Nneji
W.A. Gbadebo
Iwelu Lovetta
Aderonke Sijuwade
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114.
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
2
Bola Arinosharvin
Taiwo Ighalo (Mrs)
Ajifowobaje Tolulope
Neneh Osuala
Dixy Oddiri
M.A. Savage
Ama Fayemiwo (Mrs)
Ezemegbu Loveline
Okeke Ijeoma (Mrs)
Ayanbadejo Bayonle
Carol C. Ndulue
Ikenna Okoli
Fashina Patricia Adeola
Kehinde Osibona
James Asomugha
Okey Ilofufunwa
Ibrahim Abikan
Okey Grace Otera
Hilary N. Umah
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
Emumah Ikenm
O.A. Egwuatu
V.I. Okonkwo
Alfred I. Uwaka
Korede Quadiri
Obi Okwusogu, SAN
M.J Onu Gbanjo
Nwankwnta Ihuoma L.
Nwabunike George C.
Dike Sie
Omijie Peter
Arubaleze Kenechuwku
Ezeani Emeka G.
Chike Odezugo
Ikenna N. Onwusoka
Rosalind Clomavi
Oyedokun Olatunji
Hannibal Uwaifo
Charles Ola-Oni
Uchenna Chikelue
Aneke I. Uzoamaka
Femi Osunkoya
Nwaka Okpokiri
Ogochukwu E.
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Ubuane Ejadaria Ubuare
M.A. Adewopo
Shehu Mustafa
Onyekachi C. Uko
Taiwo O. Taiwo
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173)
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
1.3
Rose Agbo
Oluyemi Adewale
Onyeagwa A.U
Babatunde A. Rufai
Oranmiyan Biobaku
O.T. Opara
Andrew S.
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Chuka Agbu
Sonnie Ekwuowusi
Emeka Nigige SAN
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
Ejiro Onojake
Opete Augustine O
Akin
Supo Olaibi
Stephen Obajaja
Patience R. Onoahegbe
E.gwuane Onyinye N.
Sumi O. Ahonsi
Solomon Balogun
Unachukwu John E.
Osodiuru Samuel Chinedu
T.O. Lawal
Innocent N.O. Okoro
Itamel O. Sylvester
Enyesiobi Ngozi C.
Obim Nnenna M.
Anthony Nnawuihe
Shakinwahi M. Obale
Okoroji Chidi
Foluso Fyokun
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
Olufunmi Oluyede (Mrs)
A.O. Fayokun
Mbanugo Udenze
Owolabi Adeniyi
y. Tunde Adefenni
S.A. Oduroye
Francis Nwajei
Uchenna Owadialo
Damian Ihegazie
Rudolf Ezeani
Ikhalea Augutine
Uzoeghelu-nzube O. joy
Ogor Constance O.
Emeka Okpoko
Apologies
1.
Geff Eze
3
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
Folashade Agbaje
Begbaji A.
Olumide Sofowora
Nkiru Amaechi
Oluseye Amusa
Segun Ololade
Adeleke Benedict
E. A. Otokhina
Julius Iyamu
Adebayo Oriola
Obukohwo Odogun
Oyagha Michael
Busola Asiwaju
Lanre Adebayo
Babatola Apata
Erhianga Odion Eragbai
Pauline Dominic-Fishawu
Vincent E. Buwa
Sulaire-Salmu Z.I
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Kamar Raji
Joseph P. Etim
Lucy Ahaneku
Celestine Nwankwo
Ayedun Oluwatosin
Taofik Oladipo Elias
Ogbonnaya Uko
Mike Moghalu
Anene Nwadukwe
Tolu Opaleye
Bashiru A. Ojo
2)
Chief Theodore Ezeobi, SAN
Adekunle-Tatokun A. (Mrs.)
Enyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Olawale Akoni, SAN
Chris Okeke
Bodunwa Olufemi
Maximus Chike Nwolisa
Osunkoya Oyewale
Atata Anthony
Augustine Egwuatu
Lady Debbie Obodoukwu
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Olumide Ekisola
Egere Christy C.
Cynthia N. Ikpeawu
Ugochukwu Ekeanyanwu
Adeyinka Aroyewun
3.
5.
7.
Mrs. Ono Nkpubre
`Toyin Bashorun
Ambrose Unaneze
4)
6)
Stella Ugboma (Mrs)
Gbolahan Badamosi
2.0
COMMENCEMENT
2.1
The meeting commenced at 1.30pm with the Chairman, Chijioke Okoli presiding.
2,2
The opening prayers was led by Nwako Okpokiri
3.0
CHAIRMAN’S OPENING REMARKS
The Chairman in calling the meeting to order, welcomed all and said that the meeting
for the day would proceed business like.
4.0
MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING
4.1
Copies of the minutes of the previous meeting of May 2011 were distributed and read.
4.2
Typographical errors relating to the following names were corrected:
a) Adenike Adeniji at no. 1 in the list of attendees
b) Ikemefuna Okekwe at no. 134 in the list of attendees
c) Nwana Chuks at paragraph 4.2
4.3
The minutes of the previous meeting was unanimously adopted following a motion
for adoption of same moved by Chuks Nwana and seconded by Ogunfuwa Olawoyin
5.0
IDENTITY CARDS FOR MEMBERS OF N.B.A LAGOS BRANCH
5.1
The need for identity cards for members of the Branch was discussed with robust
contribution from several members.
5.2
The meeting resolved Identity cards be issued to all members of the Branch at a
proposed rate of N500 each.
6.0
REPORT OF COMMITTEE ON THE PROHIBITIVE FILING FEES
The Chairman of the Committee set up to investigate the reported prohibitive filing
fees in the High Court Registry, Mr. Martin Ogunleye addressed the meeting to say
that the report of the Committee would reach the Executive Committee of the Branch
by the end of the subsequent week.
7.0
FUNERAL RITES FOR LATE MICHAEL USIFO
7.1
The meeting was informed that the late Michael Usifo, Esq. has been buried. The
Secretary S.B. Onu represented the Branch at the wake-keep held in the home of the
deceased.
4
7.2
The Branch made a condolence donation of N50,000 to the family of the deceased.
7.3
The Branch also forwarded to the family of the deceased, the sum of N100,000.00
being the money contributed by members of the Branch for the deceased before his
death.
8.0
SECRETARY’S REPORT ON THE MEETING OF THE NATIONAL
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE (NEC) OF N.B.A
8.1
The Secretary S.B. Onu, presented the Secretary’s Report on the meeting of N.E.C of
N.BA held in Abuja in June 2011.
8.2
The Secretary’s Report was adopted following a motion to adopt same moved by
Hannibal Uwaifo and seconded by Mrs. Funmi Oluyede.
9.0
ELECTION OF N.B.A LAGOS IN 2011
9.1
The Election Committee Chairman Obi Okwusogu .S.A.N addressed the meeting and
said that the Branch election would hold on Monday the 18th July 2011 from 10am to
2pm. He gave guidelines for the election.
10.0
BAR ELDERS COMMITTEE ON PEACE BETWEEN THE BRANCH AND
THE STATE CHIEF JUDGE
10.1
Mr. Afro Fayokun, Life Bencher, former General Secretary of the N.B.A and cochairman of the committee to facilitate peaceful co-existence between the Branch and
Hon. Chief Judge addressed the meeting. He noted that the matter has been reported
to the National Judicial Council (N.J.C).
10.2
The Chairman spoke on how things had developed and that he had written to the Hon.
Chief Judge to get a date for an appointment with the Hon. Chief Judge for a meeting
with the N.J.C representative, O.C.J. Okocha, S.A.N
10.3
Chief Emeka Ngige, S.A.N former Secretary of the Branch expressed surprise that the
matter had been reported to the National Judicial Council. He counseled diplomacy in
the handling of the matter.
11.0
BAR CENTRE
The Chairman said that the need for our own Bar Centre to house the Secretariat of
the Branch is self-evident, with what was going on with the Hon. Chief Judge and the
extant notice to quit by the authorities of the Court of Appeal currently
accommodating the Bar Centre.
12.0
LAW SUMMIT
The Chairman announced that the materials in respect of the Law Summit 2011 are
available for the attendees.
5
13.0
MULTI DOOR COURT HOUSE SETTLEMENT WEEK
Mr. Yinka Arowoyen the Deputy Director of the Lagos Multi Door Court House
addressed the meeting and asked that matters be referred to the Lagos Settlement
Week. Members can also act as mediators. The Lagos Settlement Week will hold
14th-18th November 2011
14.0
LAW CONFERENCE ON WOMEN AND CHILDREN
The Chairman of the Committee on Women and Children Law Conference Sonnie
Ekwuowosi addressed the meeting on the Law conference on women and children
holding on 14th – 15th July 2011 at the Nigerian institute of International Affairs.
15.0
Cake cutting ceremony to commemorate the birthdays and anniversaries of members
of the Branch for the month of June was supervised by Funmi Oluyede (Mrs.)
16.0
CLOSING
16.1
The meeting came to an end following a motion for adjournment moved by Ama
Fayemiwo (Mrs.) and seconded by Uche Ikwueme
16.2
Gerty Iloegbunam Emeka said the closing prayers by 3.28 pm
S.B. ONU, Esq.
THE SECRETARY
CHIJIOKE OKOLI, Esq.
THE CHAIRMAN
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR
ASSOCIATION - LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 12TH SEPTEMBER 2011
AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1)
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2)
Alex N. Muoka
3)
Martin A. Ogunleye
4)
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5)
Marian N. Jones
6)
Philips O. Njeteneh
6
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
12)
13)
1.2
Omohafe T. Opara
Tolani Edu-Adeola
Chinedu Nduka
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
Amaka Aneke
Anthony Atata
-
Members
1)
S.B. Onu
3)
Morenike Obi-Farinde
5)
Chief Ademola Sadipe
7)
Nwana E. Chuks
9)
Grace Adenubi
11)
Edem Uko
13)
Cjiba Mbanefo
15)
Funmi Obisan
17)
Uchenna Ezeokeke
19)
Adelowo Folasade Folake
21)
Arogundade Adewale
23)
Akanbi Ahmed
25)
Ayetin Kainayor
27)
Emmanuel Orhono
29)
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
31)
Chijioke Okoli
33)
Hilary N. Umah
35)
Adeniyi Rotimi. B.
37)
Faith Ogbede
39)
Joyce E. Otobo
41)
Arubaleze Kenechukwu
43)
Mohammad Idris Doko
45)
Laolu Owolabi
47)
G.M. Sasore (Mrs)
49)
Oyagha Michael
51)
Shomade Mosunmola
53)
Ejinwa Joy Akeredolu
55)
Oluyemi Adewale
57)
Chika Ozurumba
59)
Ugochukwu C. Okoli
61)
Mbadugha Azuka Fred
63)
Nonso Amaechi
65)
Salam Ibrahim
67)
Toyin Bashorun
69)
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
71)
Ore Moshood A.
73)
Femi Fajolu
75)
Ikechukwu Uwanna
77)
Babatola Apata
79)
Ikhalea Augustine
81)
D.N. S. Torbari
7
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
Supo Olaibi
Ayo Kusamotu
F.A. Dogbajale
Jude U Mbaeri
Loko Olufunke
Udensi Louis
Solomon Balogun
Chinyeaka G. Ireka
Efenwengbe Onyeka
Olapeju Oluwajana
Olukosi Adebola
Timothy Olubor
Uruakpa Chiagoziem C.
Eghosa Akpata
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
32)
Tanline Dominic-Yishawu
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
Bob C.O. Ijioma
Okhueleigbe Aikpehae
Adeyinka Adesanya
Okeke Ejike R.
Anadu Iruoma
L.A. Idu
Euzebro Margaret
Chukwuma Ezeala
Olalekan Akinyemi
Dayo Onakoya
E. Etomi (Mrs)
Bode Omoboriowo
Chikwendu Ogbonna
60)
Chike Christian Okonkwo
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
Joyce Oduah (Mrs)
Adeniyi Olayode
Zik Obi II
Anuriola Victor
Olorungbemi Samuel O.
Olumide Oyesanya
Olaide Odejobi
Kehinde Evbuoma
Anne Aimua
Ike Uko
Margaret Akpoyoware
83)
85)
87)
89)
91)
93)
95)
97)
99)
101)
103)
105)
107)
109)
111)
113)
115)
117)
119)
121)
123)
125)
127)
129)
131)
133)
135)
137)
139)
141)
143)
145)
147)
149)
151)
153)
155)
157)
159)
161)
163)
165)
167)
169)
171)
173)
175)
177)
179)
181)
Otera Grace
Taiwo Omotayo Giwa
Chiamaobi Adiele
Ezemegbu Loveline
Balogun Esther O. (Mrs.)
Nnadozie Nwokorie
R.E. Obianu
Uwala E. Murphy-Akpieyi
Julius Iyamu
A.A. Farinmade
Hannibal Uwaifo
Andy Igbokwe
Adeniji Kayode
Akin Adewopo
Joy O.N. Uzoghelu
Elizabeth Nwokeocha
Obi Okwusogu, SAN
Segun Demuren
C.O. Ekewude
Kamar Raji
Afolabi Balogun
Abimbola Akeredolu
Lucy Ahaneku
Udoji, Andy Nzube
Biodun Hundeyin
Frank B.A. Nabena
Felicia Ajao (Mrs.)
Agu Anaemena R.
Ohuaka Nwokedi
Ndueghe Iwatt
Maximus Chike Nwolisa
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Enyesiobi Ngozi C.
Prisca Anene
Eze Nne C.
Onyeagwa A.U
Sir Emmanuel Ofulue
Seyi Frank Awodugba
Okeke Ijeoma (Mrs)
Stephen Augulu
Ogundele Abiodun I
Shina Fokunmiju
Chukwunonso Nwagu
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
Ayodeji Olakunle Bobaderin
Femi Botoku
Agu, Evelyn C.
Modupe Sowho (Mrs.)
Adeyemi Shokoni-Lawal
Jeffrey Eboh
`
8
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
O.N.O. Nkpubre (Mrs.)
Egeonu Gloria
Yamta Yusuf
Eloka-Nwokolo Emma
Aisida Omotara
Goddy Chuma Amalu
Rosalind Clomavi
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs.)
Mike Moghalu
Geraldine Wey
Alice Ochoga (Mrs.)
Ohakpo Joseph
Iro Augustine
Kwesi Obaseki
Ikechukwu Odoemelam
Aderonke Sijuwade
Anthony O.
Seye Demuren
E.A. Otokhina
Funke Adekoya SAN
Atuchukwu Pat
Olajumoke Larinde
Tunji Gomez
Olivia N. Nwachukwu
Itamah Sylvester
Lyaninwa, A.L
Okoro C.J.
Basiru A. Ojo
140)
Lawrence Austine Coleman
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
Animachaun Bola
Chukwuezuo Nwosu
Kunle Adebayo
Tunji Adesheye
Adewale Akande
Chizoba O. Madubuko
Bertram Chike Anyiam
Jude N. Iloba
Rose Agbo
Chinyere Uhegbu
Sina Sofola SAN
Olayele Awosika
Funmi Dosunmu
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Akin Akinbote
Mbanugo Udenze
Chiwar Mindia Yahaya
Kaduru Chi D.
Oluseye Amua
Bakare L.A.
Anyaso Victoria N
183)
185)
187)
189)
191)
193)
195)
197)
199)
201)
203)
205)
207)
209)
211)
213)
215)
217)
219)
231)
233)
235)
237)
239)
241)
243)
245)
1.3
Kayode Oduwani
Olowojolu Olusemi
Stephen O. Obajaja
Davidson O. Adejunwon
Suzanne Izilien
Chuka Agbu
Celestine Nwankwo
Cyril Anichukwueze
Alfred Akinjo
John Duru
Chukwudi Okobi
Mallam J.A. Adamu
Obiajuru Chinyere
Abioye Akerele
Sandy, Diana Otumeinch
Chief R.A.O. Oriade
Silva Ugo Osuji II
Chike Odezugo
S.A. Adesokan
Emeka Okwuosa
James Okoh
Marcus Eyarhono
Adebiyi Ademola
Francis Ogunbowale
Victor A. Williams
Kolade Olutekunbi (Chief)
Charles Williams
Apologies
1)
Ogbonna Agbafo
3)
Philomena Omorodion (Mrs.)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
Busola Asiwaju
Dennis O. Akhagba
N.I. Quakers
Chinedu Nneke
Mike Idowu
Martin Agoziem Akpaka
Olagbade Benson
Justine I. Enang
Sessi Akojenu
Uba Ogechi
George Nnabuike
Kode Adurayemi
Odupitan, Julius A.O
Ande, J.B
Segun Solomon
Iheoma Osimiri
P.E. Okoli
Ekott Uduak J.
Ifeanyi Eze
Daniju Adeniji Funmilayo
Chukwu Cynthia
Etiti Ernest O.
Mudashiru Airahi
Eze Njoku
Kayode Odumosu
Abraham Okojie
F.A. D’almeida
2)
4)
O.C.K. Unegbu
Ekanem Nakanda
2.
Commencement
2.1
The meeting commenced at 1.10pm with the Chairman – Mr. Taiwo
Taiwo presiding.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mr. Odupitan.
3.
Chairman’s Opening Remarks
3.1
The Chairman called the meeting to order and welcomed members to
the new Legal Year.
4.
Minutes of Previous Meeting
4.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General
Meeting held on the 20th of June, 2011.
9
4.2
Corrections were made to Paragraph 1.2.7 (‘Abioye Akinrele’ should
be ‘Abioye Akerele’), and Paragraph 4.3 (‘Nwanna’ should be
‘Nwana’).
4.3
Chief Ademola Sadipe moved for adoption of the minutes, and Mr.
Afolabi Balogun seconded.
5.
Matters Arising
5.1
Branch Identity Cards
5.1.1 The Chairman stated that the issue would be revisited as it had become
necessary in the light of recent developments.
5.2
Prohibitive Filing Fees
5.2.1 The 1st Vice Chairman reported that the committee had concluded its
deliberations and was about to present a Report to the former Executive
Committee when it found that another review of filing fees had been
done at the Magistrate Court level. The Committee was therefore
reconstituted to look into the review and expand its Report. He assured
the meeting that the final Report would be presented to the new Branch
Executive Committee within the next seven days.
5.2.2 Chief R.A.O. Oriade suggested that the Committee consider the issue
of the constitutionality of late filing penalties.
5.3
Lagos Settlement Week
5.3.1 The Chairman reported that during the Court Vacation the Lagos MultiDoor Courthouse (LMDC) held a training session for members of the
Branch Executive Committee on mediation advocacy.
5.3.2 He explained that the Lagos Settlement Week would hold in
November, 2011, and the LMDC would organise awareness and
mediation advocacy workshops for lawyers.
6.
Report of NEC Meeting
6.1
The Secretary read the Secretary’s Report on the Nigerian Bar
Association - National Executive Committee Meetings of July and
August 2011 – which had been circulated to members. The Report was
adopted by the meeting.
7.
Report on the NBA/AGC
7.1
The Chairman explained that a detailed report of the Nigerian Bar
Association Annual General Meeting could not be presented as the
Branch Officers were (at the time of the AGM) otherwise engaged at
the Referendum on the NBA constitutional amendment - seeking to
10
ensure that the Referendum was free and fair. He added that the timing
of the elections had been altered to coincide with the AGM.
7.2
The 1st Vice Chairman gave a brief report on the 2011 Annual General
Conference in Port-Harcourt. He reported that the Branch provided free
transportation for a number of Branch members and subsidised
accommodation for junior lawyers, the Secretary ensured that all
members who registered through the Branch got their conference
materials, and Branch members participated effectively in the sessions.
He added that the Branch organised a well-attended party on
Wednesday night at one of the night spots in Port-Harcourt.
7.3
He reported further that the Branch was represented by forty-one (41)
delegates at the Referendum called to consider the proposed
amendments to the NBA constitution (apart from the Branch Members
who were automatic delegates by virtue of being Senior Advocates,
Benchers or NEC Members). The delegates met and agreed to vote
against all the planned amendments – in line with the decision of the
Branch. The Referendum held and the results reflected an
overwhelming vote against the changes. He added that the Chairman of
the Electoral Committee in a sudden twist refused to announce the
results and had to be forced to make the announcement. However, at
the AGM the President of the NBA in another twist announced that the
election should be suspended as there was a pending suit restraining the
elections from taking place.
8.
Branch Office Accommodation
8.1
The Chairman reminded the meeting that the Branch Secretariat had
been given notice by the Court of Appeal to vacate the office space
provided for our use. He reported that Executive Committee meetings
were presently being held in the Chairman’s office, whilst the Branch is
looking for alternative accommodation. He added that the Branch is
also considering the option of purchasing a property on the Island,
within the vicinity of the High Court.
9.
Endowment by Chief Wole Olanipekun SAN
9.1
The Chairman reported that at a ceremony in July 2011, Chief Wole
Olanipekun SAN (having publicly declared that he belonged to two
branches – Ilorin and Lagos) called him privately and gave him a
cheque for =N=10million and a letter creating an endowment for young
lawyers who are members of the Lagos Branch. He added that Chief
Wole Olanipekun SAN left the modality for the disbursement of the
fund to the discretion of the Branch, and promised that the fund would
be replenished annually.
9.2
The Chairman stated that a committee would be set up to consider and
advise on the modality for disbursement of the fund, whilst in the
meantime the cheque had been deposited in an interest yielding account
11
in Union Bank of Nigeria Plc for three months. He asked that members
send in their suggestions on the application of the fund to the Executive
Committee.
9.3
Mr. Chijioke Okoli in his comments thanked Chief Wole Olanipekun
SAN for his generosity, and called on wealthy lawyers in the Branch to
emulate his example. He added that there are members of the Branch
who can endow a Bar Centre as Chief Afe Babalola SAN had done in
Ibadan.
10.
State of the Judiciary – NJC/ Justice Salami Issue
10.1
The Chairman reported that there was a protest by members of the
Lagos, Ikeja and Ikorodu Branches of the Nigerian Bar Association on
Thursday the 8th of September, 2011. He apologised that there was very
short notice for the protest occasioned by its urgency.
10.2
He explained that fully robed lawyers marched from the High Court at
Ikeja to Lagos House, at Alausa (the Governor’s Office) and presented
a letter for the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria to Gov.
Fashola SAN – for transmission to the President. He read out the last
paragraph of the letter which was co-signed by the Chairmen and
Secretaries of the three (3) NBA Branches in Lagos.
10.3
He added that on Friday the 9th of September, 2011, members received
strange text messages purporting to emanate from “NBA on NJC”
which sought to cause some confusion and disaffection. He was thus
constrained to send out a disclaimer text the same day.
10.4
Mr. Afolabi Balogun commented that it was rather strange that the
protest march was conducted in full formal robes, and opined that this
should not have been so. Chief Olutekunbi added that the person the
lawyers went to meet was an individual who was not robed to receive
such an audience.
10.5
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN advised that as lawyers we should consider
that the problem between the President of the Court of Appeal and the
immediate past Chief Justice of Nigeria has been politicised, therefore,
in taking decisions to write petitions, to speak on television, or to
march, we should make it clear that the decisions are based solely on
the Rule of Law. She suggested that the Branch Executives should
liaise with the NBA National Executive, and added that at the NBA
Annual Conference in Port Harcourt, the Report of the NBA
Committee that looked into the issue was circulated.
10.6
Concluding her comments, Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN suggested that if
the Bar is arguing that the Rule of Law should be observed then we
must emphasise that fact and do so in a dignified manner. She
cautioned that we should not put ourselves in a situation where people
would say that the profession has been hijacked by politicians. She
12
added that it was wrong for text messages to have gone out stating that
the Chief Judge of Lagos voted in a particular fashion and should be
retired – as it had not been confirmed that she actually voted in the
manner alleged.
11.
Announcements
11.1
The Chairman mentioned that the recently passed Tenancy Law of
Lagos State was generating heated debate, and it would be necessary to
harmonise the position of the Branch as well as sensitise people on the
law. He stated that a committee would be set up to organise a seminar
on the new law.
11.2
Responding to a question by Mr. Gbolahan Gbadamosi as to whether
the purpose of the committee is to look at the implementation of the
law or to protest the law and seek amendments, the Chairman stated
that the purpose is to critically examine the law. He added that the State
Government appears to have realised that there are issues with the
acceptability of the law and has agreed to partner with the Branch in
organising the seminar.
11.3
The Chairman announced that the New Legal Year Service would hold
on Monday the 26th of September, 2011 simultaneously at the
Cathedral Church of Christ and the Lagos Central Mosque. He added
that there would be a Novelty Football March between the Bar and the
Bench as part of the New Legal Year Programme of Events.
11.4
Further announcements were made regarding a forthcoming Catholic
Lawyers Seminar on Islamic Banking, a programme by the ABA
Section on International Law, the NBA/SLP/Lagos State Seminar on
AIDS, and a seminar on Space Law at Four Points Hotel on the 20th of
September, 2011.
11.5
The Chairman mentioned that a letter was received form a member
calling attention to the proposed synergy between SMEDAN and the
Corporate Affairs Commission which was reported in the Punch
Newspaper of Friday 12th August, 2011. He explained that the planned
partnership aims to simplify and fast-track incorporated trustees and
business name registrations and do away with the need to involve
lawyers in the process. He reported that the issue was discussed at the
Executive Committee Meeting and it was agreed that letters should be
written to the Registrar-General of the Commission (complaining about
this threat to lawyers) and the NBA President, and the issue would be
raised at the next NBA National Executive Committee Meeting - as it is
not something that can be dealt with solely at the branch level.
12.
Any Other Business
12.1
The Chairman reported that during the Court Vacation a complaint was
received from a Magistrate at the Igbosere Magistrate Court regarding a
13
lawyer who had extorted =N=100,000 from a litigant on the pretext that
the Magistrate had demanded same before signing a bail bond.
12.2
He added that only recently, he got another complaint from a
Magistrate regarding two (2) learned colleagues who fought physically
at the premises of the Igbosere Magistrate Court. He nominated Messrs.
Gbolahan Gbadamosi and Linus Idu to identify the lawyers involved so
that they can state their side of the story before action is taken on the
matter by the Branch.
13.
Cutting of the Cake
13.1
The Chairman called on Chief Emmanuel Ofulue to supervise the
cutting of the cake for members whose birthdays, wedding
anniversaries or call-to-bar anniversaries fell within the months of
August and September.
14.
Closing
14.1
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde moved for adjournment and Mr. Gbolahan
Gbadamosi seconded.
14.2
The closing prayer was said by Mr. Sina Sofola SAN.
14.3
The meeting ended at 2.30pm.
_________________________
_______________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
ALEX N. MUOKA(Sec)
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 10TH OCTOBER 2011 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
14
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
12)
1.2
Martin A. Ogunleye
Alex N. Muoka
Seth O. S. Amaefule
Marian N. Jones
Philips O. Njeteneh
Omohafe T. Opara
Tolani Edu-Adeola
Chinedu Nduka
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
Amaka Aneke
Anthony Atata
-
1st Vice Chairman
Secretary
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
Stephenson Okulemuja
A.O. Agbola
Alex Uzebu
Rose Agbo
Harrison Emmanuel
Okey Grace Otera
Stephen Obajaja
Gloria Ireka
Okoro C.J
Sumi O. Ahonsi
Ohakpo Joseph O.
Sessi Sonayo Akojenu
Precious Akhanonu
Akachukwu O. Igbowe
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Susan Ebong
Kamar Raji
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs)
Omorodion Philomena
Ezebuiro Ifeoma
Lawrence Austinecoleman
Balogun Esther O.
Hilary N. Umah
Evbuoma T. Itohan
Mrs. R. F. Okunola
Uchenna Chikelue
Oluseye Opasanya
Adekunle Oyesanya
Bisi Iyaniwura
Ohuaka Nwokedi
Supo Olaibi
Kennedy Nwofor
Abiola Adegoke
Okechukwu Ubah
Rosemary Ubah
Victoria Getta
Emureyan M.E
Chike Adezugo
Adeola Gbaja-Biamila
Folakemi Nixon-Kanmu
Members
1)
3)
5)
7)
9)
11)
13)
15)
17)
19)
21)
23)
25)
27)
29)
31)
33)
35)
37)
39)
41)
43)
45)
47)
49)
51)
53)
55)
57)
59)
61)
63)
65)
67)
69)
71)
73)
75)
77)
79)
Ugo-Silva Osuji
A.A. Farinmade
Etiti Ernest O.
Odupitan, Julius A.O
Eze Oby
Iranus Ogunbowale
Sharafa Olaitan
L.A. Idu
W.A. Gbadebo
Nwohawuo Godson
Adebola Lema
Olufemi A. Daramola
Emma E. Igboechi
Umeh C.J
Onwu L.C.
Nnadozie Nwokorie
Uchenna N. Ezeokeke
Ajayi Oladipo
Emmanuel Orhoro
James Okoh
Lanre Ogunlesi
Adegboyega Kolade
Kingsley I. Okoro
Itamah Sylvester
Owonikoko Titilola
Odigboh Terry Uzoh
Abdulkazeem Azeez
A.J. Owonikoko
Ayo Akintunde
Lucy Ahaneku
Nkechi Nnajiofor
C.M. Ozogho
Ogechukwu Nwani
Chukwuma Ezeala
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Kelvin Ojukwu
Modupe Sowho
Oluka M. Nwidaa
Osondu Nwagwu
Opeyemi Ogunleye
15
81)
83)
85)
87)
89)
91)
93)
95)
97)
99)
101)
103)
105)
107)
109)
111)
113)
115)
117)
119)
121)
123)
125)
127)
129)
131)
133)
135)
137)
139)
141)
143)
145)
147)
149)
151)
153)
155)
157)
159)
161)
163)
165)
167)
169)
171)
173)
175)
177)
179)
181)
183)
185)
187)
189)
Nelly Egwuagha
Dennis O. Akhagba
Mike Moghalu
Bakare L.A.
Nonso Azih
Enuwa N.A
Mike Idowu
Folashade Bankole-Ola
Ehiosu Odeh
Dominic Edokpolo
Sandy Diana O.
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Olomofe Tope
Ugo Ewelaku
Olumide Tayo-Lawal
Olubor Timothy
Bola Animashaun
Mike Omani
Okhueleigbe Aikpehae
Akeredolu Abimbola
Anueje Wilson
Okoroji Chidi
John W. Dong
Chief Guy Ikokwu
Egbi U. Ande
Alyce Ochoga (Mrs.)
Dachomo I Dachomo
Nnenna Onyeama
Aghaonu Chris
Anthonia Eke
Vin Onwo
Ikemefuna Okekwe
Ernest U. Orofa
Pretty P.A. Ekpe
Echemazu Chinedu
Chimezie Kalunta
Aluba J. Orji
Okeke Chidiebere
Amaka Itegboje
Egere Christy
Nelson Ogbuanya
Dixy Oddiri
Wale Adesokan
Chikaodili Dimezoro
Ogunbawale Esther
Tunji Gomez
Abioye Akerele
Segun Solomon
Tayo Arojo
Ngozi Eze
Solomon Balogun
Liehe Nnaji
Ejike A. Okpe
Olisa Ifedurbo
Augustine Egwuatu
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
16
Andy Igboekwe
Eghaga Leo
Obagwu Frederick Ajetu
David Zuwam Sarauta
Judith Nankodu
Femi Botoku
Uduak Ekott
Sylvester Ekwueke
Anene Nwadukwe
Nnaji Ifeoma
Uche Stan Obi
Kate Sunshine
Bodunwa Olufemi
G. Adetutu Siyonbola
Abraham Okojie
M.J. Onigbanjo
N. Enebeli
Adebiyi Adewole
H.O. Ndubuisi
Ayodeji Bobaderin
Ntan Ebagie
Oyewo A.B
Toyin Bashorun
Muhammed Jimoh
Emeka Ngige, SAN
Hannibal Uwaifo
Dike Stella
Layi Arikewuyo
Aderonke Sijuwade
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
M.A. Adewope
Ibironke Soetan
Akin Akinbote
Kayode Odumosu
Esther I. Jimoh
Ada Lilian Adakole
Jeffrey Eboh
Ituah Inhanze
Owolabi Adeniyi
Adenike Adeniyi
Marcus Eyarhono
Opete Austin O.
Dayo Onakoya
Kainayor Ayetin
Yomi Okunnu
Olumide Ekisola
George Nnabuike
Jude Uche Mbaeri
OCK Unaegbu
Uwagboi Bivins
John Duru
F.A. Dalmeida
Oyagha Michael
Onojale Ejiro
Olubasola Asewaju
191)
193)
195)
197)
199)
201)
203)
205)
207)
209)
211)
213)
215)
217)
219)
221)
223)
225)
227)
229)
231)
233)
235)
237)
239)
241)
243)
245)
247)
249)
251)
253)
255)
1.3
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
Emmanuel Majiebi
Kehinde Evbuoma
Mindia Y. Chiwar
R.U. Ezeani
A.A. Begbaji
A.A. Oyebode
Femi Bakare
Ifi Onyeka M.
Obiora A. Egwuatu
Joseph P. Etim
Ikenna Okoli
I.T. Okechukwu
Victor Agwu
Daudu Shakirudeen
Onyeagwa A.U. (Mrs)
Oluseun Olowojolu
Ayodeji Faleye
Matthew Nkag
Richard E. Obianu
Adebayo Oriola
Adeniji Kayode
Alfred Uwaka
Dokun Makinde
Jude Oputa
Stanley Iwuala
Maximus C. Nwolisa
Wole Ajewale
M.O. Daudu
Ndueghe Iwatt
J.A. Adamu
Fidelis Esho
Oloyede Oyedumin
2)
Chief Magistrate O. Isaac
In Attendance
1)
3)
1.4
Peter H. Mallong
Seyi Frank Awodugba
Enyiwugh Uwaezue
Atuchukwu Pat
Simon Chingle
E.A. Otokhina
Fredrick Onyeka
Foluso Fayokun
T.O. Lawal
Celestine Nwankwo
A.O. Fayokun
Supo Famuyiwa
DNS Torbari
Bode Omoboriowo
Akintunde Jimoh
A.S. Abimbola (JP)
Paul E.Okoli
Ezemegbu Loveline
Caroline Obi
Anne Aimua
Victor Gwam
Iheoma Osimiri
Zik Obi II
Funke Jagun
Dr. K.U.K Ekwueme
P.R. Onoashagse
Obukohwo Odogun
Nwana E. Chuks
Osighala J.A
Adeniji O. Olayode
Babalola S.K
Tunji Adebayo
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Hon. Justice Atinuke Ipaye
Mr. Niyi Olayode (LMDC)
Apologies
1)
2)
4)
Taiwo O. Taiwo
Funke Adekoya SAN (Mrs.)
Chief G.A. Sadipe
3)
5)
Chairman
Boma Ozobia (Mrs.)
Olufunmi Oluyede (Mrs.)
6)
Joyce Oduah
7)
Chijioke Okoli
8)
10)
Nonso Amaechi
S.B. Onu
9)
Nkiru Amaechi (Mrs)
2.
Commencement
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.10pm with Mr. Martin Ogunleye (the 1 st Vice Chairman) presiding.
17
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mr. Linus Idu.
3.
Chairman’s Opening Remarks
3.1
The 1st Vice Chairman as Chairman of the Meeting welcomed members and conveyed the
apologies of the Branch Chairman who was out of Lagos on an official assignment for the
Branch.
4.
Minutes of Previous Meeting
4.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held on the 12 th of
September, 2011.
4.2
No corrections were made to the Minutes.
4.3
Mr. Abioye Akerele moved for adoption of the minutes and Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo seconded.
5.
Matters Arising
5.1
Report of Committee on Prohibitive Filing Fees
5.1.1
The Chairman of the Meeting mentioned that he had chaired the Committee and called on the
Branch Secretary to read the Committee’s Report on his behalf.
5.1.2
The Secretary read out the Committee’s Report.
5.1.3
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo expressed his view that the increase in filing fees was a necessary corollary
of the usual inflationary trend in the country and it should not be expected that Court Filing Fees
would remain static.
5.1.4
The Chairman of the Meeting explained that the Committee was set up because of complaints by
lawyers at the Branch Meeting in May particularly in relation to certification fees which have
seriously hiked up the cost of compiling records of appeal.
5.1.5
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN commended the Committee for the recommendations in the Report. He
added that the increase also affected the Election Petition Tribunals pointing out that to file an
Election Petition the Petitioner must deposit =N=250,000 as deposit for costs and =N=250,000 as
filing fees – figures which are capable of disenfranchising some litigants at the Tribunals.
5.1.6
Mr. Akin Akinbote commented that the Report did not contain details of the amount of previous
filing fees and the new ones in order to ascertain the percentage of increase. He suggested that
the Report should incorporate such details.
5.1.7
The Chairman of the Meeting thanked the contributors and stated that the Committee would go
back and incorporate the details.
5.2
Committee on Fight by Resident Lawyers
5.2.1
The Chairman of the Meeting called on Mr Linus Idu to present the Committee’s Report.
5.2.2
Speaking to the Report, Mr. Linus Idu stated that the Committee found as a fact that two senior
lawyers were involved in the incident. He explained that the practise at the Igbosere Magistrate
Court is that when the suspects or overnight cases are brought in by the Police there is usually a
scramble for ‘clients’ by the ‘Resident Lawyers’ and the strongest person generally wins.
5.2.3
He added that the practise had bred some animosity among the lawyers with the incursion of any
newcomers being stoutly resisted by the regulars. He reported that the lawyers involved in the
fight were arrested by the Police and detained, they were very embarrassed and were keen on
resolving the matter quietly.
18
5.2.4
On the other aspect of the alleged bribe of =N=100,000.00, Mr. Linus Idu reported that the
Committee found that there were three lawyers involved, but they insisted that the money was
professional fees for their services in the matter.
5.2.5
The meeting discussed the Report and contributions were made by various members. Mr. A.O.
Agbola suggested that the Branch refer the matter to the Disciplinary Committee of the Nigerian
Bar Association as it was a serious matter. He noted that in 2010 a Judge in Bauchi State was
dismissed for fighting in the street.
5.2.6
Ms. Toyin Bashorun opined that the matter confirmed the need for re-orientation and a paradigm
shift by lawyers. She expressed the view that reporting the case to the Disciplinary Committee
would not necessarily help as there are other related conduct that need to be addressed.
5.2.7
Mr. Akin Akinbote insisted that the meeting immediately resolve that the matter be reported to
the Disciplinary Committee. He added that in some jurisdictions the Executive Committee would
have investigated and referred the matter before reporting back to the general meeting.
5.2.8
Following a call for a voice vote by the Chairman of the Meeting, the meeting unanimously
resolved that the matter of the fighting ‘Resident Lawyers’ be reported to the Disciplinary
Committee of the Nigerian Bar Association.
6.
Presentation on Lagos Settlement Week
6.1
The Chairman of the Meeting welcomed Hon. Justice Atinuke Ipaye and Chief Magistrate O.
Isaac of the Lagos State Judiciary to the Meeting, and invited Hon. Justice Atinuke Ipaye to
make her presentation.
6.2
Hon. Justice Atinuke Ipaye introduced members of her team – Chief Magistrate O. Isaac, Mr.
Wale Adesokan (a member of the Branch), and Mr. Niyi Olayode the LMDC Programme Officer
for the Lagos Settlement Week.
6.3
The Hon. Judge explained that she had come to have a chat with the Branch about the
forthcoming Lagos Settlement Week which comes up from the 5th to 9th of December, 2011. She
opined that the two previous editions of the Settlement Week could not be given a pass mark and
it is hoped that the 2011 edition would be more effective.
6.4
The Hon. Judge explained that the Settlement Week is aimed at decongesting the courts and
popularising Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) as a means of settling disputes in Lagos
State. Speaking to the concerns of lawyers in active practice, she submitted that whilst it is
litigation that we are conversant with, there is a need to appreciate that litigation is no longer the
sole door for dispute resolution so we must begin to use the other doors.
6.5
The Hon. Judge introduced the Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse (LMDC) as a court connected
avenue to settling disputes, and stated that Judges of the Lagos High Court would be referring
matters to the LMDC from time to time for speedy and cost-effective resolution via mediation.
She sought the co-operation of the bar – through the willing referral of cases by lawyers without
necessarily waiting for Judges to refer matters, stating that lawyers should not entertain fears
about their fees.
6.6
Continuing with her presentation, the Hon. Judge stated that between the 10 th of October and 2nd,
November 2011, lawyers can examine their cases and present deserving matters for referral to
the settlement week. She introduced two reference materials - copies of the LMDC Brochure
(which she stated would be left with the Branch Library), and a book – ‘Mediation Advocacy’ by
Andrew Goodman - available for purchase at the LMDC.
6.7
The Hon. Judge ended her presentation with an appeal that the Bar join hands in making the 2011
Edition of the Settlement Week a resounding success. She invited questions from the floor.
6.8
Responding to questions from members of the Branch, Hon. Justice Atinuke Ipaye opined that
when clients come to the lawyer with a problem or issue, it is for the lawyer to reflect and advise
19
properly and suggest the appropriate dispute resolution door – as what the litigant wants is a
resolution of the matter and not necessarily a protracted and acrimonious litigation. She stated
that in ten years on the bench she had not seen a litigant who was averse to trying out Alternative
Dispute Resolution, rather it was usually the lawyers who resisted suggested referrals.
6.9
The Hon. Judge conceded that some matters may not be suited for mediation as some cases may
turn on obscure legal points which must be resolved by litigation. She suggested, however, that
progress would be made if lawyers start with the mindset that every matter can be resolved, and
noted that debt recovery matters generally are suited to mediation. She added that even
seemingly intractable land matters can be resolved.
6.10
The Hon. Judge noted that the Lagos Settlement Week process is at absolutely no cost to the
litigants and lawyers, as matters are handled free even if the mediation extends to January. She
also noted that a matter on appeal could be settled so long as the parties are willing to come to
the table.
6.11
The Chairman of the Meeting thanked Hon. Justice Atinuke Ipaye for her presentation. He
expressed the gratitude of the Branch to the Judiciary and the LMDC for the initiative, and
assured that members of the bar were willing and ready to participate effectively in the
Settlement Week.
7.
Seminar on New Tenancy Law
7.1
The Chairman of the Meeting reported that the Committee had been constituted and had
commenced work. He confirmed that the Committee had also met with officials of the Ministry
of Justice and the modalities for the seminar were being worked out.
8.
Branch Office Accommodation
8.1
The Chairman of the Meeting assured members that the Executive Committee was liaising with
the State Chief Judge and working on securing a temporary accommodation within the premises
of the Lagos High Court.
8.2
Members made various comments: Mr. Daramola suggested that the Executive Committee
consider a permanent place as a matter of utmost importance; Mrs. Lucy Ahaneku opined that
some of the money left in the Branch Accounts by the previous Administration could be used to
secure accommodation for the Branch; and Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde suggested that the
Branch rent an office suite near the High Court as a temporary measure.
8.3
The Chairman of the Meeting assured members that the Executive Committee would take note of
the sentiments of members on the accommodation issue.
9.
Committee on Young Lawyers Endowment
9.1
The Secretary reminded the meeting of the Endowment Fund of =N=10,000,000.00 established
by Chief Wole Olanipekun SAN for the benefit of young lawyers in the Branch. He reported that
the Executive Committee had inaugurated a Standing Committee (chaired by Mr. Osaro
Eghobamien SAN and comprised of senior lawyers and some young lawyers) to consider and
advise on the modality for disbursement of the fund, and more generally to handle matters
relating broadly to young lawyers.
9.3
Pa Tunji Gomez suggested that the Committee’s mandate be expanded to include the issue of
minimum salary for young lawyers. He opined that the current peg of =N=25,000.00 is not good
enough, and the Committee should take up the issue with the National body. He also suggested
that the Branch look for avenues of generating briefs and case referrals for young lawyers, and
added that the State Government should be made to firm out small cases to junior lawyers.
9.4
The Chairman of the Meeting thanked Pa Tunji Gomez for his comments, and assured that his
suggestions would be passed on to the Committee.
20
10.
Auditors
10.1
The Chairman of the Meeting reminded members that the former Auditors had resigned at the
last Branch Annual General Meeting and there was need to appoint new Auditors.
10.2
Mazi Unaegbu advised that the Monthly Meeting was not the right forum for the appointment.
He suggested that the Executive Committee should appoint an Auditor who would then be
presented to the next General Meeting for ratification.
11.
Announcements
11.1
The Secretary announced the postponement of the Catholic Lawyers Association Seminar on
Islamic Banking to 14th October, 2011.
11.2
The Secretary announced the deaths of Mrs. Sarah Adesola Olufowobi, the Director of Accounts
of the Lagos State Judiciary, who passed on the 22 nd of September, 2011, and Ms. Olohirhere
Omo-Eboh, the Managing Partner of Consolex Legal Practitioners, who answered the home-call
on the 1st of October, 2011. He gave details of the respective burial programmes and urged
members to attend.
11.3
The meeting rose to observe a one-minute silence in honour of the dear departed.
12.
Any Other Business
12.1
Mr. Dayo Onakoya sought the permission of the meeting to raise the issue of indiscipline
amongst members. He stated that he was in Hon. Justice Onyeabor’s Court the previous week
when two senior lawyers engaged in such unbecoming abusive conduct in open Court that the
Judge was compelled to rise. Some senior members had to intervene and go into chambers to
appeal to her to return and continue sitting. He stated that the Judge urged that the matter be
brought to the attention of the Branch so that members can be disciplined.
12.2
Mrs. R.F. Okunola commented that the issue of ethics had become very critical. She suggested
that the Executive Committee consider bringing people to make presentations at meetings on
proper language, decorum and ethics. She insisted that ethics should be brought to the floor of
the house every month rather than being left to be handled by disciplinary committees.
12.3
Mr. Zik Obi II spoke on the issue of ethics and behaviour of lawyers. He suggested that good
ethics ought to start from the top, and opined that if we have NBA presidents walking out on
Judges it is the example that junior lawyers would follow. He added that Judges were not helping
matters by not reprimanding senior lawyers who misbehave before them.
12.4
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN commended Mrs. R.F. Okunola’s comments. He argued that the issue
of misbehaviour was not restricted to senior lawyers, and agreed with the suggestion that we
should have regular discourses on ethics at our meetings.
12.5
Going further, Chief Emeka Ngige SAN reported a recent development at the office of the
Deputy Sheriff of the High Court. He stated that his office had processed the attachment of some
goods only for the Deputy Sheriff to sell them off without informing anybody. He added that
when his office challenged the sale, the Deputy Sheriff’s office stated that they did not need to
inform anybody of a sale. He ended by stating that under the Sheriff and Civil Process Act,
notice of sale is required to be given to the public and counsel, and suggested that the matter be
taken up by the Branch.
12.6
Mr. Gboyega Kolade complained about the refusal of Court Registrars to give
acknowledgements for letters or documents received by them, which has created a situation
where they can and regularly do deny receipt of same.
12.7
The Chairman of the Meeting stated that the task of revamping our profession is incumbent on all
of us. He urged Chief Emeka Ngige SAN to do a letter to the Branch on the issue of sale of
attached goods so that it can be taken up. He encouraged members who have issues to send in
21
written complaints to the Branch.
13.
Closing
13.1
The Chairman of the Meeting thanked members for attending the meeting – particularly the
senior lawyers who made out time to attend. He thanked Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko (of Synergy
Attorneys) for hosting the meeting, and apologised for the absence of the usual celebratory cake
– promising that there would be a double celebration at the next meeting.
13.2
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde moved for adjournment of the meeting and Mr. Zik Obi II seconded.
13.3
The closing prayer was said by Mrs. R.F. Okunola.
13.4
The meeting ended at 2.47pm.
_________________________
_______________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
SECRETARY
ALEX N. MUOKA
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 14TH NOVEMBER 2011 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
12)
1.2
Taiwo 0. Taiwo
Alex N. Muoka
Martin Ogunleye
Seth O. S. Amaefule
Marian N. Jones
Philips O. Njeteneh
Tolani Edu-Adeola
Chinedu Nduka
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
Amaka Aneke
Anthony Atata
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
2)
4)
Segun Solomon
Rose A. Ibeh
Members
1.
3.
Ekwonye Uzoma Victor
Obasi Williams Kalu
22
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
Nneamaka
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
Oludukunmola
69.
Ikwuagwu
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
G.M. Sasore (Mrs.)
D.O. Botoku
Adesola Falaiye
Adebayo Olatunji
Onyeagwa Angela U.
Osunkoya Oyewole
Folashade T. Raji
Adeboye Bajulaiye
Rose Agbo
Pat Atuchukwu
Azubuike Nwakenta
Jones Muyiwa Kayode
Uduma Charity J.
Earnest Orofa
Dennis O. Akhagba
Pauline Domnic Yishawu
Emmanuel Orhoro
P.R. Onoabhagbe
Nwabuwe Justice
Agube Efemi
Samuel Ibrahim
Samson Olabiyi
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
Etiti Ernest O.
Gerty Emeka-Iloegbunam
Obagwu Frederick Ajefu
Nwohamuo Godson
Momodu Aliu
Okechukwu Ubah
Ogunmola Ademayowa
Nnenna Onyeama
Mike Moghalu
Izukanachi Chukwu
Ituah Imuanze
Oluwashola Keshinro
Ukwah Christiana
Ayobame A. Iluyomade
Odigie O. Emmanuel
Nwamuo Enyinnaya
Kode Adurayemi
Onyeagha Michael
Uwaifo F. Barry
Toyin Bashorun
Kingsley Ihedi
Olayide Benjamin
Marcus Eyarhono
Akin Dosunmu
Nwalutu, Godiom Obiajulu
Balogun Solomon
50)
52)
54)
56)
A.A. Okunnu
Ayemah Christian
Balogun Oduwasani B.
Mojikun-Chikezie
Dogbajale F.A
Ajiboye E. Olatunju
Adewusi Adedamola
Edohasim Glory
Biodun Hundeyin
N. Abiodun Dabiri
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
Florence A. Agbana
Femi Bakare
Nnena Onyebulam
Akabogu Joy
R.F. Okunola (Mrs)
Balogun
Esther
Akin Akinbote
70)
Chief
Fidelis Ogu
Olayimika Olasewere
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Sessi S. Akojenu
Kanyinsola Abdulsalam
Akinyemi Adebayo
Oluwole Adisa A.
Femi Fajolu
Abiola Adegoke
Percival Oaiya
O. Cheetham-West
Okey Ilofulunwa
Obiagwu Chinyere
A.S. Ayoade
Anurioha Victor
Margret Akpoyoware
Uzoigwe Sopuruchukwu J.
Owonikoko Titilola Precious-Faith
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
Laolu Owolabi
Omisore Mosope
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs)
Kukei Umoye
Bivins Uwagboi
E.A. Elias
Sola Adegbonmire
Ikenna Okoli
Folasade Adetiba
Gogo Karibi-Whyte
Chikwendu Ogbonna
Emeka Okpoko
Anire Kaniyi
Ogbudu, S.B
Adetoun Ogunbunmi
Opanya Marian M.
Chuba Mbanefo
Shofolu Olayemi Olukayode
23
Mike
Allison
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
Nnaji Ifeoma
Arubaleze Kenechukwu
Ayogu Felix Buchi
Abimbola Akeredolu
Eze Vinmartins
Olaide Odejobi
Musibau Alagala
Victor Gwam
Omorodion Philomena
O.A. Jagun
Ogo Onyia
Uchenna Nwadialo
Ahanonu Calista
Olusegun Ogedengbe
Michael Nusa-Yakubu
A.S. Abimbola
Uduak Udofia
Lekan Ogunsile
Kode Adurayemi
Bukola Afolabi
Chinyere Obiagwu
Sisan Ezikpe
Lawrence Austinecoleman
Wale Ilesanmi
Oliko, Onojighofia
John C. Onyeakpa
Shehu Mustafa
Charles A. Mgbajah
Frances Onwunali
Benjamin Eneremadu
Okoroji Chidi
Omoz Evborokhai
Levi Asogwa
O.O.O. Bello
Babatola Apata
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Segun Ololade
Kamar Raji
Emeka Ezeogu
Lawal M. Gbola
Abdulkareem Azeez
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
James Okoh
Otonye Adelaja
Chike Nwolisa
George Nwabuike
Dorcas Odu
Ndueghe Iwatt
Stephen Olasupo Famuyiwa
Egbe U. Ande
E.A. Otokhina
Ike Onwuchuluba
G.O. Onojason
Alli S.B.
Kasali Rasaq A.
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
24
Ejike Okeke R.
Bakare L.A
Njoku Marian C.
Tonia Usman
Marian Olaiya (Mrs)
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
Bode Olaosebekan
Omole Olusoji
Kayode Ojo
Lapite Ayoola O.
Kelvin Ojukwu
Ayo Fakolade
Mallam J.A. Adamu
Boniface Ekong
I. Chris Atunlonia
Adegboyega Kolade
Prince Omotayo Adetona
Dele Thomas-Orogan
Opete Augustin O.
Adaego Nosiri
Uchegbu Ike
Bode Omoboriowo
Ayodele Akintunde
Celestine Nwankwo
Nnadozie Nwokorie
Prisca Anene
H.O. Ndubuisi
Adu Aguocha
Fidelis Egho
Korede Quadri
Chuka Agbu
Daudu Shakirudeen
Smart Iwu
Sina Sofola SAN
Olomofe Tope
Rotola Williams
Irase Ohiokpehai
Adewusi Adedamola
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Ezemegbu Loveline
Adewale Akande
Prince Eddy Njoku
Helen Oputa
E. Ben Ihesiulo
Dan Kizito
Olusegun Dada
Victoria N. Ijetta
Omotimiren Oyewale
Olawale Michael Oredipe
Jecinta C. Kelechi-Ukaonu
George Okusanya
Adeyemi Shekoni-Lawal
D.A. Adegor
Olarenwaju Kazeem
Okoli Paul E.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
279.
281.
283.
285.
287.
289.
291.
293.
295.
297.
299.
301.
303.
305.
307.
309.
311.
313.
315.
317.
319.
321.
323.
325.
F.A. Afuwape
Owolabi Adeniyi Oseni
Ojonah Godson E.
Aderonke Sijuwade
Chidi Ezeikpe
Ogechukwu Ezeani
Kenneth Emeanua
O.N.O. Nkpubre
Ngozi Eze
Anne Abyem
Aluba J. Orji
Mayojun Ashaolu
Faith Ogbede
Iyaniwura A. L.
Joseph P. Etim
N.O. Onuoha
Amaka Itegboje
Tony Okwesa
Oladimeji Idowu
Anthony Uwakwe
N.Enebeli
Akpoyoware Margaret
Ashade Ezekiel O.
Kingsley Ekwem
Anne E. Aimua
Jude Uche Mbaeri
M.A. Sanni
Uba Ogechi
Bolatito Alaofiu
Remi Onobote
Okey Eneh
M.A. Mohammed
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
Hillary Oshomah
Rosalind Clomavi
Andrew Okpataku
Ebeneza B. Ihesiulo
Chikaodili Dimazoro
Chris Aghaonu
Odupitan Julius A.O.
Ezeala Chukwuma W.
Jude O. Okeke
Ozioma Ahaoma
Olasupo Olaibi
Gboyega Odunsi
G. Adetutu Siyanbola
Esomom Jude
Olaoye Modupe
M.A. Mohammed
Adebayo Oriola
Raimi Bukola
H. Umah
Tosin Oke
M.A. Sanni
Lanre Oluyemi
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
278)
280)
282)
284)
286)
288)
290)
292)
294)
296)
298)
300)
302)
304)
306)
308)
310)
312)
314)
316)
318)
320)
322)
324)
326)
25
N. Okonkwo
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
Akingbade Adeyemi (Mrs)
Ajibogun Ololade
Enyesiobi Ngozi
Mindia Y. Chuwar
Wale Adesokan
Ada Mbama
David Angya
Celestine Ogbodo
Constance Ogor O.
Gabriel I.
Ekott Uduak J.
Abiye Tam-George
C.E. Ogoh
F.O. Ojomo
Ifeanyi Ugwu
Chibuzo E. Azubuike
Loko Olufunke
John N. Dong
Sylvester Enuka
Aghogho E. Idigbe
Innocent N.O. Okoro
Blessing Nwozor-Israel
Nonso Ngonadi
Taiwo Adebayo
Tobenna Ilechukwu
Prisca Anene
Dike E. Stephen
Eze O.H. (Mrs.)
Henshaw Olufunke
Etiti Ernest O.
Dike Stella O.
Olasupo Ati-John
Ale-Daniel Olaoluwa
Nwani Ogechukwu
Andy Igbokwe
Olajumoke Larinde
Ugo Silva Osuji II
Bob C.O. Ijioma
Adebiyi Adewole
Ikechukwu Odemelam
Joy O. Nzube-Uzoeghelu
Gloria Ireka
Olufunmi Oluyede
Anumiton Odion Deniel
Victoria Ogundipe-Peters
Owgofawhoraye Stephen
Ogechukwu Okafor
Eric I.
Emmanuel Majebi
Oluyemi Adewale
Taiwo Adebayo
Ebere Sada
Azubike Okaro
327.
329.
331.
333.
335.
337.
339.
341.
343.
345.
347.
349.
351.
353.
355.
357.
359.
361.
363.
365.
367.
369.
371.
373.
375.
377.
379.
381.
383.
385.
389.
391.
393.
395.
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Femi Osunkoya
Chizoba Madubuko
Yamta Yusuf Ali
David Cephas
Olukemi Adeniji
Jeffrey Eboh
Okoronkwo T.N.T
Olivia Nwachukwu
Kolawole Mayomi
Toyin Ogunbami
Dixy Oddiri
A.O. Fayokun
Funmi Obisan
Anthony Abiodun Paul
L.A. Idu
Precious Akhanolu
Rahman Oshodi
Mbanugo Emenike O.
Adeniui Kayode F.
Ujah James
Emeka Chris Ibe
Adams Oluwatosin
Onyejaka Nelson C.
Ayodele A.
Chika Ozurumba
D.A. Adegor
Shehu Mustapha
Paul C. Obi
Chimaobi Adiele
Joyce Oduah
Oyinkan Badejo-Okunsanya
Mindia Y. Chiwar
Anthonia Eke
328)
330)
332)
334)
336)
338)
340)
342)
344)
346)
348)
350)
352)
354)
356)
358)
360)
362)
364)
366)
368)
370)
372)
374)
376)
378)
380)
382)
384)
388)
390)
392)
394)
26
Feyisola Famutimi
John Nwosu
Chukwuma Ezediaro
S.A. Adesokan
Francis Ogunbowale
S. Olaitan
Victor A. Williams
Olumide Oyesanya
Matthias Oawodu
Emmanuel Ofulue
Folasade O. Adetiba
S. Kola Babalola
Chief Olufemi A. Daramola
Eloka-Nwokolo Emma
Dayo Onakoya
Florence A. Agbana
Iheoma Osimiri
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Alfred Uwaka
Akeem Oyeboade
Essien Awuaisua
Ezeokeke Uchenna N.
Tolulope Osunsan
Alfred A.
Nnaemeka Amaechina
Gabriel O. Onojason
Faith Ogbas
Tunji Gomez
Grace Adenubi
Harry O. Ukaejiofor
Babatunde Ogala
Zik Obi II
Emmanuel Umoren
1.3
Apologies
1)
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
Omohafe T. Opara
Mrs. Hairat Balogun
Yemi Candide-Johnson SAN
Seye Opasanya
Grace Otera
Nonso Amaechi
3)
5)
7)
9)
11)
Social Secretary
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu
Mrs Rose Akinbo
S.B. Onu
Mrs. Nkiru Amaechi
2.
Commencement
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.08pm with the Chairman presiding.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mrs. Funmi Oluyede (the NBA National Treasurer).
3.
Chairman’s Opening Remarks
3.1
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting. He apologised for his absence at the last
meeting and explained that he had to represent the Branch at the New Legal Year ceremony of
the Federal High Court in Sokoto.
4.
Minutes of Previous Meeting
4.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held on the 10th of
October, 2011.
4.2
No corrections were made to the Minutes.
4.3
Mr. Mike Moghalu moved for adoption of the minutes and Mr. Emmanuel Majebi seconded. The
minutes were adopted for discussion.
5.
Matters arising from the Minutes
5.1
Committee on Prohibitive Filing Fees
5.1.1
The Chairman reported that the Committee is still fine-tuning its Report and it would be
presented at a subsequent meeting.
5.2
Fight by Resident Lawyers
5.2.1
The Chairman stated that in line with the resolution of the last meeting the Secretary is preparing
a Report on the matter for the NBA Disciplinary Committee.
5.3
Lagos Settlement Week
5.3.1
The Chairman reported that the week of the 5 th to 9th of December, 2011 has been confirmed as
the date for the Lagos Settlement Week. He enjoined members of the Branch to participate
effectively in the Settlement Week.
5.4
Seminar on Tenancy Law
5.4.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that a Report had just been submitted by the (Mr. Niyi
Adegbonmire - led) Committee and would be considered by the Executive Committee before
27
presentation to the meeting. He added that the Committee had in its Report articulated the
position of the Branch on the law - which would be taken to the Stakeholders’ Summit once
same is convened.
5.5
Branch Office Accommodation
5.5.1
The Chairman explained that a response is being expected from the Chief Judge of Lagos State to
our request for allocation of space within the High Court premises in Lagos. He added that the
Executive Committee is also considering the option of renting office space around the Court for
the Branch Secretariat.
5.5.2
The Chairman reported that the Branch Building Committee is also being resuscitated (to
develop a permanent Bar Centre/ Branch Secretariat) and Alhaji Femi Okunnu SAN has agreed
to chair the Committee.
5.6
Young lawyers Committee
5.6.1
The Chairman confirmed that the Committee has started work under the chairmanship of Mr.
Osaro Eghobamien SAN, and a Report would be presented to the house in due course.
6.
Lecture by Prof Taiwo Osipitan SAN
6.1
Mrs. Tolani Edu-Adeola (the Branch Publicity Secretary) introduced the Guest Lecturer – calling
him a ‘teachers’ teacher’.
6.2
Prof Taiwo Osipitan SAN presented his lecture titled “Reflections on Evidence Act 2011”.
6.3
In his lucid lecture style, he took the meeting through the provisions of the new Evidence Act
noting that the law was not really new save for some provisions.
6.4
He commended the drafters of the new Evidence Act, but commented that though they did their
best there is likely to be a minefield of litigation because of the inelegant drafting of the eevidence provisions.
6.5
He ended by stating that the new Evidence Act is a welcome statute, citing the rules on eevidence as a major innovation. He added, however, that the Act does not address all the
problems of electronic evidence.
6.6
Prof. Taiwo Osipitan SAN responded to all the questions raised during the question and answer
session that followed the end of the lecture.
6.7
Mr.s. Tolani Edu-Adeola thanked Prof. Taiwo Osipitan SAN and informed the meeting that, coincidentally, it was the birthday of Prof. Taiwo Osipitan SAN and his wife.
6.8
Members rose up to sing a happy birthday song for Prof. Taiwo Osipitan and his wife.
6.9
The Chairman thanked Prof. Taiwo Osipitan SAN for a brilliant lecture and for responding to all
the questions. He noted that the lecture would qualify for Continuing Legal Education points, and
copies of the lecture would be circulated to members.
6.10
A Birthday Cake was presented to Prof. Taiwo Osipitan SAN as a token of appreciation for the
lecture and to commemorate the day.
7.
Presentation by Law Pavilion
7.1
Mr. Ope Olusaga gave a presentation on the law pavilion electronic law reports. He stated that
the software has over 50,000 cases and it is a very fast means of law research. He noted the
distinct advantage of “Law Pavilion 360 Degrees” which tracks the results of cases up to the
Supreme Court. With this feature, when a user searches for a case – such as a Court of Appeal
28
decision, the software would state if the decision in the case had been overturned at the Supreme
Court.
7.2
Mr. Ope Olugasa stated that another advantage of law pavilion is automatic updates. He noted
that the 2011 Evidence Act had already been updated to all subscribers.
7.3
He announced that law pavilion is doing a promo for Branches of the NBA. The regular price of
‘Law Pavilion 360’ is =N=180,000.00, however there is a weighted quantity discount such that
the price comes down to =N=160,000.00 if 20 members of the Branch are buying,
=N=150,000.00 for 50 members, and =N=130,000.00 for 100 members.
8.
Equipping the Law Library
8.1
The Chairman conveyed the apology of Mrs. Fawehunmi-Biobaku who was to make a
presentation on equipping the law library, and who could not make the meeting due to an
emergency. He announced that the presentation would be deferred to a subsequent meeting.
9.
Announcements
9.1
The Secretary took the announcements. He informed the meeting of the Section on Legal
Practice Law Conference holding in Abuja from the 15 th-17th of November, 2011, the NBAIkorodu Branch Lecture holding on the 16 th of November, 2011, and the FIDA Biennial
Convention holding in Lagos from the 20 th -25th of November, 2011. He enjoined members to
attend the events.
10.
Any Other Business
10.1
The Chairman informed the meeting of an outstanding debt of approximately =N=1,500,000.00
carried over from the last administration arising from the International Law Conference on
Women and Children – which is being paid off. He added that a donation of =N=500,000.00 had
come into the coffers of the Branch in respect of the same Conference.
10.2
The Chairman informed members that the Branch 2011 Dinner would hold in December. He
stated that the Dinner Committee was working very hard to put a befitting dinner in place, and
the date and venue would be communicated in due course.
10.3
The Chairman reported that the Branch had received several complaints from members regarding
the activities of Court Registrars and Bailiffs. He urged members to send in written complaints to
the Branch Secretariat so that the matter can be taken up with the Court authorities.
11.
Cakes
11.1
The Branch presented two Birthday Cakes for the months of October and November.
11.2
The Chairman called on members who were celebrating their birthdays, wedding anniversaries,
and or call-to-bar anniversaries in October and November.
11.3
Mr. Afro Fayokun led the cutting of the cakes for the celebrants.
12.
Closing
12.1
The Chairman thanked members for the unprecedented large turnout at the meeting and called
for suggestions from members on ways to make meetings more interesting. He promised that the
Branch would bring in Guest Lecturers from time to time to address the meeting on topical
issues.
12.2
Pa. Tunji Gomez moved for adjournment, and Mrs. Uche Ikwueme seconded.
12.3
The closing prayer was said by Mrs. Getty Iloegbunam.
29
12.4
The Meeting ended at 3.05pm.
_________________________
_______________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
SECRETARY
ALEX N. MUOKA
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR
ASSOCIATION - LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 12TH DECEMBER 2011
AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1)
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2)
Alex N. Muoka
3)
Martin A. Ogunleye
4)
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5)
Marian N. Jones
6)
Philips O. Njeteneh
7)
Omohafe T. Opara
8)
Chinedu Nduka
9)
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
10)
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
11)
Amaka Aneke
12)
Anthony Atata
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Members
1)
Odupitan, Julius A.O
3)
Francis Ogunbowale
5)
Pamela Unegbu
7)
Dachomo I. Dachomo
9)
Dennis O. Akhagba
11)
Joseph Ikoro
13)
Chief R.A. Oladoye Oriade
15)
Chijioke Okoli
17)
Ayobami Iluyomade
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
Kode Adurayemi
Onyebuchi Aniakor
Solomon Balogun
Olufunmi Oluyede (Mrs)
Efenwagbe Onyeka
Ojuade Olabisi
Onyekachi C. Uko
Adeniyi Olayode
Chief Theodore A. Ezeobi
19)
21)
23)
20)
22)
24)
Charles Nneji
Sumi O. Ahonsi
Emeka Ulachi
1.2
SAN
Jude Uche Mbaeri
F.A. Agbana
Sharafa Olaitan
30
25)
27)
29)
31)
33)
35)
37)
39)
41)
43)
45)
47)
49)
51)
53)
55)
57)
59)
61)
63)
65)
67)
69)
71)
73)
75)
77)
79)
81)
83)
85)
87)
89)
91)
93)
95)
97)
99)
101)
103)
105)
107)
109)
111)
113)
115)
117)
119)
121)
123)
Shola Ibrahim
Rose Agbo
A.O. Fayokun
Chinyere Uhegbu
Dokun Makinde
G.N.A. Enebeli
Owhofawhoraye S.A
Caroline Obi
Paul E. Okoli
Kaduru C.D.
Animashaun Bola
Lawal M.G.
Ibrahim Abikan
Rosalind Clomavi
Akin Akinbote
Osahon Ohuoba
Joy O.N. Uzoegbelu
L.A. Idu
Chidi Ezeikpe
H.O. Ndubuisi
Oluseun Olowojolu
Olusegun Kaji
Ogundana Aderonke O.
Tunji Gomez
Rudolf Ezeani
Aluba J. Orji
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli
Chirah Uzoma
Obukotiwo Odogun
Jones Muyiwa Kayode
Chimaobi Adiele
John Nwosu
Hariat A. Balogun
Funke Adekoya SAN
Eze Vinmartins
A.L. Iyaniwura
Uche U.C
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Hannibal Uwaifo
Emerson Ishiekwene
Kalu K. Obuba
Anire Kanyi
S.A. Adesokan
W.A. Gbadebo
Celestine Nwankwo
Anne Aimua
Onyeagwa Angela U.
Adebayo Oriola
D.N.S Torbari
Lucy Ahaneku
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
31
Dagogo Karibi-Whyte
Simon Chingle
Jude N. Iloba
Adebiyi Adewole
Biodun Hundeyin
Lanre Majekodunmi
Tony Okwesa
Chike Odezugo
Ike Uko
I.J. Oputa
Anthonia Eke
Banjo I. Temitope
Uchenna N. Ezeokeke
Ezemegbu Loveline
Uche Stan Obi
Giwa Taiwo O.
F.A. Dalmeida
Osodiuru Samuel Chinedu
Charles Nzegbuna
Oluseye Amusa
Ogagha Micheal
Abiodun Raji
Olunuga Adesewa J.
George Nnabuike
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
G.M. Sasore
Uwaezuoke Eyinnaya
Nelly K. Egwuagha
Bob C.O. Ijioma
S.B. Onu
George Ekwote
Tara Aisida
Bukola Afolabi
Chijioke A.A
Gloria O. Otu
Ezebuiro E.I (Mrs)
Kayode Odumosu
O.N.O. Nkpubre (Mrs)
Egere Christy C. (Mrs)
Jimoh Muhamed
Sessi Akojenu
Olumide Aju
Grace Adenubi
Alli S.B
Victor Anurioha
Patrick Uhegbu
Nwaebukwu O.
Elias Adedokun
Nasir Salau
Nnawuike, C. Anthony
125)
127)
129)
131)
133)
135)
137)
139)
141)
143)
145)
147)
149)
151)
153)
155)
157)
159)
161)
M.A. Adewopo
James Asomugha
Francis Nwajei
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Nwani Ogechukwu
Ogundele Abiodun
Atunwa W.A.
Ifeoma Obi
Ikenna Okoli
Olubunmi Fashola
Martin Agoziem Akpaka
C.M. Ojogho
Zik Obi II
Ifeanyi Eze
Onyia Ogo
Tayo Arojo
Ukogu Tochukwu
Arubaleze Kenechukwu
Uche Odikwe
Apologies
1)
Emeka Ngige SAN
Farinde
3)
Mrs. Joyce Oduah
5)
Chief Ademola Sadipe
7)
Mrs. Esther Murphy-Akpieyi
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
D.O. Botoku
M.J. Onigbanjo
Olaide Odejobi
Kamar Raji
Emmanuel Ezenachukwu
Enyesiobi Ngozi C.
Adeshina I. Fakunmoju
Lanre Oyetunji
Adekunle Oyesanya
Adebayo Gbenga O.
H.I.C. Ogboh
Olusegun Ogedengbe V.
Okaro Azubike
Aderonke Sijuwade
Funmi Obisan
Ngozi Odejayi
Dupe Ogunbanwo
Peter H. Mallong
G. Adetutu Siyonbola
2)
Mrs.
4)
6)
Chukwuma Ezeala
Mrs. Onoji Oliko
1.3
Morenike
2.
Commencement
2.1
The meeting started at 1.10pm with an opening prayer by Mr. Julius Odupitan.
3.
Chairman’s Opening Remarks
3.1
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting being the last meeting for the
year.
4.
Minutes of Last Meeting
4.1
The meeting went through the minutes of the last meeting held on the 14th of
November, 2011
4.2
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN mentioned that she had sent in an apology to the last
meeting so page 5 of the Minutes should be amended to reflect the apology.
4.3
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede moved for adoption of the minutes as corrected, and Mr.
Chinedu Nduka seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
5.
Matters Arising
32
Obi-
5.1
Committee on Prohibitive Filing Fees
5.1.1 Mr. Martin Ogunleye reported that the Committee is still working on obtaining
details of the percentage increase in filing fees from all the courts.
5.2
Fight by Resident Lawyers
5.2.1 The Chairman confirmed that a report is being sent to the NBA National
Secretariat for action.
5.2.2 In reaction to a concern expressed by Mr. S.B. Onu that the use of the term
‘Resident Lawyers’ does not dignify the profession, the meeting agreed that the
word should be used in inverted comas.
5.3
Lagos Settlement Week
5.3.1 Mrs. Hairat Balogun reported that the Lagos Settlement Week was quite
successful, adding that one of her colleagues in chambers – Mrs. G.M. Sasore –
took part as a mediator. She appealed to members to get involved especially as
mediators, although she noted that it is pro bono work.
5.4
Seminar on new Tenancy Law
5.4.1 The Chairman reported that the Committee headed by Mr. Niyi Adegbonmire
had sent in a Report and the Branch was awaiting word from the Lagos State
Ministry of Justice regarding a date for the proposed seminar. He added that the
Seminar would be a joint one between the three (3) NBA Branches in Lagos
State and the State Ministry of Justice, and the date would be publicised as soon
as confirmation is received from the Ministry.
5.5
Branch Office Accommodation
5.5.1 The Chairman reported that efforts to get a space within the High Court premises
have not worked out, and the Branch is now looking at renting an office space
close to the Lagos High Court.
5.5.2 He added that as a temporary measure the Branch is using a space in the Robing
Room in the Lagos High Court, whilst Executive Committee meetings were held
in the office of the Chairman.
5.5.3 He stated that the Branch Building Committee had been resuscitated and would
be constituted within the week.
5.6
Prof. Osipitan’s Lecture
5.6.2 The Chairman confirmed that soft copies of the lecture had been circulated by
electronic mail to members. He called on members who had not received the
mail to supply their email addresses.
33
5.7
Complaints
5.7.1 The Chairman noted that despite the announcement made at the last meeting no
complaint had been received at the Branch Secretariat.
6.
NEC Meeting Report
6.1
The Secretary read out a Report on the Nigerian Bar Association – National
Executive Council Meeting which held from the 23rd to 25th of November, 2011
at Belajno Suites, Eket, Akwa-Ibom State. Copies of the Report were circulated
to members.
6.2
Mr. Chijioke Okoli commended the Secretary for a well written and lucid NEC
Report. He mentioned that he had read in the papers that the 2012 Federal
Budget Proposal by the President is predicated on fuel subsidy having already
been removed, so it looks like the Government has made up its mind. He
suggested that the Premier Branch should consider further representation to NEC
on the planned removal of fuel subsidy
7.
J.I.C. Taylor Lecture Report
7.1
The 1st Vice Chairman presented a Report on the J.I.C. Taylor Memorial Lecture
which held on Wednesday the 30th of November, 2011 at the Banquet Hall of the
City Hall, Lagos, under the able chairmanship of Alhaji Femi Okunnu SAN,
CON, with the theme ‘Restoring Confidence in the Judiciary – The Role of the
Bar and the Bench’.
7.2
He reported that the event was very well attended by judges of the Court of
Appeal Lagos and the Lagos High Court, distinguished legal practitioners and
other members of the Branch. Thought provoking papers were delivered by Hon.
Justice Mohammed Akanbi CRF Rtd (former President of the Court of Appeal)
and Mr. Oluyele Delano SAN (a senior member of the Branch), and were well
received.
7.3
He ended his Report by stating that the Lecture was rounded off with a Cocktail
Reception. The lecture was hosted by several distinguished members of the
Branch, Etisalat, Crown Flour Mills Limited and Fidelity Bank Plc.
7.4
Commenting on the Report, Mrs. Hairat Balogun opined that the Report should
have mentioned that the daughter of the late Justice J.I.C. Taylor was in
attendance and that was the high point of the lecture.
7.5
The Chairman acknowledged the important roles played by Mrs. Hairat Balogun
in contacting and ensuring the attendance of the daughter and grand-daughter of
the late Justice J.I.C. Taylor, and Mr. Kayode Sofola SAN who was singularly
responsible for getting Etisalat to part-sponsor the event.
8.
Bar Dinner Report
8.1
Reporting on the 2011 Bar Dinner and Award Ceremony, the Dinner Committee
34
Chairman - Mr. Dagogo Karibi-Whyte – explained that the formal report was not
yet ready. He thanked branch members for making the Dinner a huge success,
and the Chairman and Executive Committee for giving the Committee the
chance to serve.
8.2
Members commented favourably on the quality of the Dinner (which held at the
Oriental Hotel, Lekki, Lagos) and commended the prestige and ambience of the
venue and location, the food and drinks, and the content of the programme.
8.3
Mr. Afro Fayokun apologised for coming late to the meeting. He stated that he
was not able to attend the dinner, but needed to mention that a large number of
members of the branch live on the other side of town so we should consider
holding our dinner in more accessible locations. He also questioned the rationale
for the ‘black-tie/ formal dress’ requirement for the dinner and suggested that a
regular suit or national dress should suffice.
9.
Presentation
9.1
The Chairman mentioned that there are three international conferences next year
– in New York, Australia, and Dublin. He introduced Mrs. Dotun Kuye of
‘God’s Heritage Travels and Tours’ (a travel agent/ conference facilitator) to
speak to the meeting about attending the conferences.
9.2
Mrs. Dotun Kuye introduced her company – ‘God’s Heritage Travels and Tours’
– and stated that they have been packaging IBA Conference registration and
attendance for Nigerian lawyers for the last four years. She mentioned the three
big international coming up in 2012 (the American Bar Association Annual
Spring Conference in New York, United States from the 17th to the 21st of April,
2012; the Commonwealth Law Regional Conference in Sydney, Australia from
the 19th to the 22nd of April, 2012; and the International Bar Association
Conference in Dublin, Ireland from the 30th of September to the 5th of October,
2012) and stated that arrangements have to be made early because of the need to
book the Visa interview.
9.3
She explained that her company would arrange conference registration, book
flight tickets, hotel accommodation, and handle visa assistance for intending
attendees. She handed out flyers and asked that interested members put down
their email addresses so that she can contact them.
10.
Announcements
10.1
The Chairman took the announcements. He informed the meeting of the 2011
Chief G.O. Sodipo Memorial Lecture on Monday 12th December, 2011, at the
Henry Fajemirokun Hall, Commerce House, No. 1, Idowu Taylor Street,
Victoria Island, Lagos at 2.00pm; and the first year anniversary service for late
Chief Adigun Ogunseitan (former Chairman of the Premier Branch) on Saturday
24th December, 2011 at 9.00am at the Methodist Church Nigeria Opebi Society,
No. 1-3,Methodist Church Street, Opebi, Lagos.
10.2
He also announced the FIDA Nigeria Lagos Branch Yuletide Charity Visitations
35
to the FIDA Ward at LUTH, Old Peoples’ Home, and Female Psychiatric Ward
at Yaba Psychiatric Hospital on Thursday 15th December, 2011; the FIDA
Nigeria Lagos Branch ‘Partnership on Pro-Bono Matters’; and the American Bar
Association International 2012 Spring Meeting from 17th to 21st April, 2012 at
the Grand Hyatt Hotel, New York, USA; - further information about all of which
can be obtained from Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede on 0806-6553669.
10.3
Finally, the Chairman read out the letter of invitation from Chief Bolaji
Ayorinde SAN to the Branch to attend the funeral programme for his late father
–Honourable Justice T.A.A. Ayorinde (former Chief Judge of Oyo State).
11.
Any Other Business
11.1
Responding to a question by Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN, the Chairman
explained that the Branch Land Allocation in Lekki (along with some other
allocations) had been withdrawn by the Lagos State Government but the Branch
was working to get it returned. He added that in the meantime, the Branch would
give a mandate to the Building Committee to consider buying land within the
vicinity of the Lagos High Court for development.
11.2
Mr. Fayokun mentioned that this would be about the third time the Branch Land
Allocation had been revoked so we should keep it recurring on our agenda so
that we do not lose sight of it.
11.3
Mr. D.N.S. Torbari observed that the since the time of the late Mr. Erasmus
Baderinwa we have not had Branch Calendars or Seasonal Greeting Cards. He
suggested that the Executive Committee restore the items. He also suggested that
the Branch consider buying commodity items during the Christmas period for
sale to members at reduced rates. Finally, he mentioned that some members of
the Branch have important occasions like weddings and invite the Branch and
the Branch neither sends representation nor gifts.
11.4
The Chairman in his response stated that the Branch would try to attend
members’ functions, and would also look into the issue of calendars and seasonal
cards.
11.5
Mrs. Gloria Oshilama-Otu came to introduce the Lagos State ‘Citizens’
Mediation Centre’ and explain its activities. She stated that the Centre started in
1999 and was seeking a closer working relationship with the Branch and its
members.
12.
Cutting of the Cake
12.1
The Branch presented an Anniversary Cake for the month of December.
12.2
The Chairman called on members who were celebrating their birthdays, wedding
anniversaries, and or call-to-bar anniversaries in December to come out for
recognition. He particularly recognised Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede (the NBA
National Treasurer, and a former 2nd Vice Chairman of the Branch) who was
celebrating her 30th wedding anniversary.
36
12.3
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN presided over the cake-cutting ceremony.
13.
Closing
13.1
The Chairman thanked members for the unprecedented large turnout at the
meeting and called for suggestions from members on ways to make meetings
more interesting. He promised that the Branch would bring in Guest Lecturers
from time to time to address the meeting on topical issues. Finally, he urged that
as the year was coming to an end members should try and do things in
moderation
13.2
Mr. W.A. Gbadebo moved for adjournment, and Mr. Uwana Chuks seconded.
13.3
The closing prayer was said by Chief Oriade.
13.4
The Meeting ended at 2.17pm.
_________________________
_______________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
SECRETARY
ALEX N. MUOKA
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 13TH FEBRUARY 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Marian N. Jones
5.
Philips O. Njeteneh
6.
Omohafe T. Opara
7.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
8.
Chinedu Nduka
9.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
10.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
11.
Amaka Aneke
12.
Anthony Atata
-
37
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
1.2
Members
1.
G. Adetutu Siyanbola (Ms.)
3.
F. B. Odesanya
5.
D. O. Botoku
7.
O. Cheetam-West
9.
Victor Adekunle Williams
11.
Chukwuma Ezeala
13.
Emmanuel Orhoro
15.
Miss Patience Patrick Udoh
17.
J. Okoh
19.
Bola Olukosi
21.
Clifford A. Atakere
23.
Ezeijoke Jude N.
25.
Adebiyi Adewole
27.
Okunnu A. A.
29.
Oluwaseun Akintola
31.
M. A. Mohammed
33.
Ananaba Ihuoma
35.
Tomi Adegboyega
37.
Gloria Ireka
39.
Chris Aghaonu
41.
Olajide Benjamin
43.
Sylvester Ekwueme
45.
Hillary N. Umah
47.
Uwha Ikechukwu R.
49.
Ajuba Elemi I.
51.
Jeffery Eboh
53.
Mrs. Susan Asoh-Esong
55.
Mrs. Abiye Tam-George
57.
Ituah Ineh Anze
59.
Tony Okwesa
61.
Tunji Gomez
63.
Busola Asiwaju
65.
Akin Akinbote
67.
Michael Oyagha
69.
Yamta Yusuf Ali
71.
Akachukwu O. Igbokwe
73.
Emmanuel Dangana
75.
N. E. Ogbeide
77.
Rose Agbo
79.
Chuka Agbu
81.
A. J. Owonikoko
83.
Nnenna Onyeama
85.
A. Olagoke
87.
Nnenna Nwahiori
89.
Madubuko C. O.
91.
Omotayo Oviosun
93.
Ifeoma Celine Peters
95.
Ikechukwu Odemekwe
97.
Osunmole Funmilola
99.
Rotimi Ogunjobi
101.
Ebelechukwu Odigwe
103.
Okoroji Chidi
105.
Tosin Adelanwa
107.
Celestine Ogba
38
2.
4.
6.
8.
10.
12.
14.
16.
18.
20.
22.
24.
26.
28.
30
32.
34.
36.
38.
40.
42.
44.
Silva Ugo Osuji
Odupitan, Julius A. O.
Jones Adebayo
G. N. A. Enebeli
M. A. Adewopo
Toyin Bashorun
46.
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
48.
50.
52.
54.
56.
58.
60.
62.
64.
66.
68.
70.
72.
74.
76.
78.
80.
82.
84.
86.
88.
90.
92.
94.
96.
98.
100
102.
104.
106.
108.
Adima Nosarieme E.
Jimoh A. Salawu
Unah Niome Yvette
Mrs. Chiagoziem Dururajis
Sessi S. Akojenu
Ifeoma Ozoagu
Onyekachi C. Uko
Taiwo O. Giwa.
Constance Ogor
Iyaniwura A. L.
Evelyn Eitolepal
Francis Nwajei
Animashaun Bola
N. O. Balogun
Lawal T. Oluwaseye
Florence A. Agbana
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Olusola Keshinro
Dauda Shakirudeen
Lucy Ahaneku
Lanre Oyetunji
Charles Mgbajah
Bode Olaosebikan
Louis Udensi M
Lady Debbie Obodokwu
Nwokorie Charity
Victor Ekeleme Emeruwa
Adeoba Adelekan
E. A. Otokhina
V. Olusegun Ogedengbe
Theodore Ezeobi Jnr
Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya SAN
Mr. Theokalus Asotie
Owonikoko Titilola
Adeniyi Olayode
Patrick Bello
Dennis O. Akhagba
Okechukwu Ubah
Eric Ikwele
Olorungbemi Sam O.
Basiru A. Ojo
Funke Aboyade
George Nwabunike
Felix Asiegbu
Owolabi Adeniyi
Olayinka Ola-Daniels
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
F. A. Dogbajale
Edward Porbeni
Dan Kizito
Stella Ugboma
Joyce Oduah
Zik Obi II
Nwana E. Chuks
J. I. Onyebashi
Nneamaka Mojeku-Chikezie
Taofik O. Elias
Chinyere Uhegbu
Adekunle Oyesanya
Anne Aimua
C. M. Ojogho.
Celestine Nwankwo
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
Hannibal Uwaifo
Ronke Sijuwade
Jamilu Habu Bashir
Nwoye David E.
Abang Etang
Etiti Ernest O
Adebola Lema
Mike Idowu
Uchechi Chima
Austin-Mno Chito Linda.
Owhofawhoraye Stephen
Adesola J. Fagbemi
Ohuaka Nwokedi
Olabimpe Esho
John Duru
Chike Nwolisa
Ikhalen Augustine
Musibau Alagbala
Miss Faith Lawani
J. F. Uzomah
Chijioke Amaka
Okechukwu Akimyeh
Adebayo Gbenga
Eyinnaya Uwaezuroke
Adewunmi Adisa
D. N. S. Torbari.
Felicia E. Ajao
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Francis Ogunbowale
Anthony Banjo
Dayo Famakin – Johnson
Chisom Ojogho
Maduagwu Renny Chibuzor
Anthonia Eke
Sola Adegbonmire
Kehinde Evbuoma
Nnadozie Nwokorie
Odeiji Chidi Kechi
Ifeoma Obi
39
110.
112.
114.
116.
118.
A. Okojie
S. B. Onu
Kunle Kusamotu
Funmi Obisan
Ben Ijewere
120.
Chief Mike Allison-Ikwuagwu
122.
124.
126.
128.
130.
132.
134.
136.
138.
B. I. Oaikhena
Okeke Ijeoma (Mrs.)
Onyeagwa A. U. (Mrs.)
Solomon Balogun
Jones Kayode Muyiwa
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Chris E. Okani
Yemi Okewoye
Oladipo Ajayi
140.
Adekunle-Fatokun, A. (Mrs.)
142.
144.
146.
148.
150.
152.
154.
156.
158.
160.
162.
164.
166.
168.
170.
172.
174.
176.
178.
180.
182.
184.
186.
188.
190.
192.
194.
196.
198.
200.
202.
204.
206.
208.
210.
212.
214.
216.
218.
Nelson Fadeyi
O. C. K. Unegbu
David Sarauta Z.
Marcus Eyarhono
Anichebe Chioma Stella
Stephen Obajaja
Lucy Udoh
Rose Ubajake
Emmanuel Ukpai
Blessing Nwozor – Israel
Patricia Itugbu
Chike Ekwueme
Kainayor Ayetin
Iheoma Osimiri
George Ekwata
Victor Anurioha
Awufuru Ben
Ndueghe Iwatt
E. A. Adesina
Onaibre Amaka
Udenze Ukekene
Ada Udonsi (Mrs.)
Owolabi Adetomi
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Ike Uko
Emma Majebi
Modupe Sowho
Rose Dikeocha
Adebayo Lanre
Olajumoke Larinde
Ezemegbu Loveline
Chikweha Dimedow
Mrs. Olufunke Jagun
Uche Ijoma
Lawrence Austin Coleman
Julius Ugese
Opete A. O.
Funmilola Suleemon
Patience R. Onoabhegbe
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
1.3
Chilaka Dom
Mrs. R. F. Okunola
James Asomugha
Adaku Mbama
Foluso Fayokun
Admiral Lanre Amusu
Tayo Arojo
Boma Ozobia
Bode Omoboriowo
Richard E. Obianu
Adegbamile H. K.
Alumona T. Chris
Omotayo Oriosun
Victor C. Oti
Aluba J. Orji
Charles Uwensuyi-Edosomwan SAN
Aroyewun Rafiu Olatunbosun
Itamah O. Sylvester
Kayode Odumosu
Nwabunike Ezimuor Uche
Benjamin A. Achimugu
L. A. Idu
Inuma Victoria A.
Adeyemi Tajudeen Bolanle
Chijioke Okoli
Apologies
1.
Mr. Obi Okwusogu SAN
3.
John Austin
220.
222.
224.
226.
228
230
232
234.
236.
238.
240.
242.
244.
246.
248.
250.
252.
254.
256.
258.
260.
262
264.
266
N. Enebeli
Mr. Agbara Okezie
Umeh C. Jonathan
Joy O. N. Uzoeghelu
Azubuike Okaro
Odelaja A. O.
Godwin Ola Odunlami
Temiloluwa P. Olabamiji
Benson Akunya
David Angya
Obiora A. Egwuatu
Azubuike Nwenkenfe
Rosemary Ubha
Damian Ihegazie
Olivia N. Nwachukwu
Akingbade Adeyemi
Adejobi Yekini Adegoke
Ikemefuna Okekwe
Obele Akinniranye
A. O. Fayokun
Israel Shola Matesun
Okereke Obina N. C.
Ikenna V. Onwusika
Olufemi Daramola
2.
4.
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
Olasupo Olaibi
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 1.05pm
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mrs. Adetutu Siyanbola.
2.3
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting being the first meeting for the year
2012. He explained that the January meeting was cancelled due to the fuel subsidy
removal protest rally and strike.
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last meeting held on Monday 12 th December,
2011.
3.2
Mr. Nwana Chuks complained that his name was missing on the attendance list. He also
corrected the wrong spelling of his name at paragraph 13.2 of the minutes.
3.3
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo moved for adoption of the minutes, and Mr. Chukwuma Ezeala
seconded.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Seminar on new Tenancy Law
40
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that he had met with the Personal Assistant to the Commissioner
for Justice and is awaiting confirmation of the date for the seminar.
4.2
Branch Office
4.2.1
The Chairman confirmed that the Executive Committee is working on securing an office
space for the Branch Secretariat. He added that some properties had been viewed but
nothing suitable had been found yet.
4.3
Branch Lekki Land
4.3.1
The Chairman reported that the Lagos State Governor had referred the letter of appeal
(for restoration of the allocation) to the Permanent Secretary (‘PS’) in the Lands Bureau,
and that he would be meeting with the PS shortly. He assured members that work is in
progress on getting the allocation restored.
4.4
Prof. Osipitan’s Lecture
4.4.1
Chief Daramola complained that he had not received a soft copy of the lecture.
4.4.2
The Chairman again requested members who have not received a copy of the lecture to
kindly put their names down.
4.4.3
The Chairman reported that Mrs. Hairat Balogun had printed bound copies of the JIC
Taylor Lecture delivered by Hon. Justice Akanbi Rtd, whilst Mr. Yele Delano SAN had
printed bound copies of his own lecture, and both had been made available to the
Branch free of charge. The copies were distributed.
4.5
Complaints.
4.5.1
The Chairman commented on Item 5.7.1 of the minutes, and noted that members had
still not sent in any complaints. He added that complaints should specify the offending
officer or registrar of Court so that necessary action can be taken.
4.5.2
Mr. Afro Fayokun commented that the practice is not just at the Federal High Court but
also at the Lagos High Court, especially in the area of service of court processes and
getting orders and judgments executed. He stated that the whole system needs to be
looked into. He also complained about the Probate Registry, and noted that one cannot
go into the Probate Registry and mention the name of a file and get it unless one
mentions the name of the Registry staff handling the file.
5.
Bar Dinner Committee Report
5.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that the chairman of the 2011 Bar Dinner
Committee (Mr. Dagogo Karibi-Whyte) was absent, as he had to attend his father’s 80 th
birthday celebrations. He added that Mr. Karibi-Whyte has promised to send in his
report.
6.
Young Lawyers’ Committee Report
6.1
The Chairman explained that the chairman of the committee (Mr. Osaro Eghobiamen
SAN) sent in word that he was away to Abuja but an interim report would be presented
by Mr. Obidi Alajuronye (the Branch 2nd Assistant Secretary) and secretary of the
committee.
6.2
Mr. Obidi Alajuronye reported that the Committee had held two meetings so far and
would be coming out with a detailed report shortly. He gave an insight into some of the
issues that the Committee had so far considered, and stated that the Committee is yet to
take a decision on the issue of age definition of young lawyers and had set up a subcommittee to address this issue.
41
6.3
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN asked about the relationship between the Committee and the
Young Lawyers Forum of the NBA, and suggested a liaison between the two.
7.
2nd NBA President’s Roundtable Conference on Human Rights
7.1
The Chairman reported that the 1st Vice Chairman represented the Branch at the ‘2nd
NBA President’s Roundtable Conference on Human Rights’ which held in Abuja on the
9th of December, 2011. He called on Mr. Martin Ogunleye to present his report.
7.2
Mr. Martin Ogunleye read out his report. He noted that the theme of the Conference was
“Human Rights and National Security: The Challenges of Terrorism and Response of
Law Enforcement Agencies in Nigeria”, and it was chaired by Hon Justice Amina
Augie JCA – the chairperson of the NBA Human Rights Institute.
7.3
He reported that the Conference was attended by participants from all 90 Branches of
the NBA, and was held to serve a dual purpose – to mark the World Human Rights Day
(which is observed globally on the 10th of December each year) and to assess the state of
human rights in Nigeria within the context of the response by security agencies to the
upsurge in terror in the country.
7.4
Mr. Martin Ogunleye added that papers were presented by eminent speakers, and the
participants highlighted the challenges militating against the proper observance of
human rights especially by security agencies and agreed that there was need for the
Federal Government to expend more funds to ensure that security agencies are better
trained and equipped.
7.5
The report was adopted for discussion.
7.6
In response to a suggestion by Chief Daramola that copies of important reports
presented should be made available to members, the Chairman noted that Mr. Martin
Ogunleye’s report (which was in writing) was not circulated because it was not
considered very important save for informational purposes.
8.
Matters of Urgent National Interest
8.1
Boko Haram Menace
8.1.1
The Chairman invited members to make brief comments on the issue.
8.1.2
Chief Theodore Ezeoibi SAN stated that what is going on in the North is religious
cleansing. He particularly mentioned the Adazi Nnukwu Community in the Eastern part
of Nigeria which has less than 1000 people and 15 of its members were killed. He
argued that if the killings do not have a religious undertone then mosques would not
have been exempted from the bombings. He insisted that the Branch should condemn
the lackadaisical attitude of the Federal Government which is treating the issue with
‘kid gloves’.
8.1.3
Mazi O.C.K Unegbu suggested that the NBA should take a position to avoid
inflammatory statements. He suggested also that the comments made by the Governor
of the Central Bank of Nigeria on the Boko Haram issue are not right, and raised an
open question as to whether the Governor has a right to appropriate public funds for
donation in the manner that he had done.
8.1.4
Mr. Taofeek Elias in his contribution spoke on the attitude of the Nigerian Police Force.
He argued that corruption in the Force is the major cause of our problems today, and
suggested that the NBA condemn the attitude of the Police on the Boko Haram issue.
8.1.5
Mr. G.N.A. Enebeli commented that there is one man in the country who has the
solution to the Boko Haram issue. He suggested that the NBA should ask the authorities
42
to interview Malam Adamu Ciroma who had stated before the last elections that if
Goodluck Jonathan was elected the country would become ungovernable.
8.1.6
Mr. Afro Fayokun commented that the state of security in the Country has become so
slack, especially given the way the Boko Haram group was targeting Police Stations,
Barracks and even Army Installations. He suggested that the NBA should condemn the
lackadaisical attitude of the government, and stated that a government that cannot
guarantee security is not fit to rule the country.
8.1.7
Mr. Adesola Fagbemi suggested that community police is the only way to ensure
security in the country. Commenting on the proposal to dialogue with the Boko Haram
group, he wondered how the government would negotiate with a faceless organisation.
8.2
Removal of Fuel Subsidy
8.2.1
The Chairman reported that on Monday 9th January, 2012, the Branch held a rally and
marched to State House, Marina, where a letter for the President was delivered to
Governor Fashola SAN. He commended members who showed up for the rally, and
particularly thanked Mr. Afro Fayokun and Mrs. Ayo Obe.
8.2.2
He added that during the protests, he went to the Freedom Park at Ojota to address the
rally, and subsequently a court case was filed on behalf of the Branch against the
Federal Government in respect of the military occupation of Lagos.
8.2.3
He mentioned that a letter was received from Prof. Ben Nwabueze SAN who offered to
lead the legal team. He had also spoken with several senior lawyers from the Branch,
some of whom declined taking an active part in the case but agreed to offer advise. He
asked members who were interested in joining the legal team to put down their names.
8.2.4
The Chairman ended his report by noting that the soldiers have been withdrawn from
Lagos, but the thinking is that the action is important and the court should be asked to
make a pronouncement on the propriety of sending troops into Lagos.
8.2.5
Mr. Afro Fayokun suggested that it was not necessary for members to put down their
names, as the action was filed on behalf of the Branch and anytime it comes up
members can appear in court.
8.2.6
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN complained that his views on fuel subsidy were not
reflected in the minutes of the last meeting. He stated that he had argued that ‘fuel
subsidy’ should not be the issue, and he was proved right when after the first day of the
strikes ‘good governance’ rather than ‘fuel subsidy’ became the rallying issue. He added
that senior lawyers would not carry placards for fuel subsidy removal, but would do so
for an anti-corruption crusade.
8.2.7
Mrs. Lucy Ahaneku in her comments, suggested that it is important to raise a legal
team for the action in order to have committed counsel.
9.
Announcements
9.1
Mrs. Boma Ozobia made a brief presentation on the forthcoming Commonwealth
Lawyers Association conference in Sydney, Australia from the 19 th to 22nd of April,
2012. She stated that as Australian Visas are issued out of South Africa, she had spoken
with the High Commission and obtained assurances that visas would be issued and
passports returned within five working days.
9.2
She added that VSF (the agent which receives visa applications on behalf of the High
Commission in Pretoria) had explained that Australian visa applications go out on
Tuesdays and Thursdays, so members are advised to submit their applications a day
before. She stated that the cost of the conference is still less than USD1,000 for
delegates from developing countries, and further information can be obtained from the
43
website – www.commonwealthlawconference2012. She ended with the note that she is
looking forward to seeing as many members as possible at the conference.
9.3
Mr. Sambo from the Nigerian Nuclear Regulatory Agency gave a presentation on a
forthcoming ‘National Training Course for Lawyers on Nuclear Safety and Radiological
Protection’ coming up from the 19th to 21st of March, 2012 in Lagos. He stated that
Nigeria has taken a decision to generate electricity from nuclear power, and added that
Nigerian lawyers have not been trained in this area. The NNRA is seeking to build
capacity in this area of law so that lawyers from outside do not have to be invited to do
all the work.
9.4
The Chairman suggested that the Agency consider reducing the =N=60,000.00 training
fee so that more lawyers would be able to attend.
9.5
The Secretary read out announcements about the temporary relocation of the Ikorodu
High Court to Ikeja Judicial Division – pending completion of the new Ikorodu High
Court Complex; the Otu Oka-Iwu Lagos 2012 Dinner and Awards Night on Friday 17 th
of February, 2012 at the Metropolitan Club, Victoria Island, Lagos; the funeral
ceremony for late High Chief (Hon) Timothy A. Akojenu (JP) the Togan (Otunba) of
Kweme Kingdom, Badagry, Lagos and father of Miss Sessi Akojenu (a very Senior
Officer in the Lagos State Ministry of Justice, active member of the Lagos Branch and
former member of the Branch Executive Committee); and the Nigerian Bar Association
National Executive Committee Meeting holding in Akure, Ondo State from the 22 nd to
24th of February, 2012.
9.6
The Secretary reminded members about the FIDA Nigeria Lagos Branch February 2012
Monthly General Meeting at 3.30pm on Wednesday, 29th February (and all subsequent
last Wednesday of every month) at the FIDA Secretariat; the invitation to join FIDA
Litigation/ADR Committee in ‘Partnership on Pro-Bono Matters"; and the forthcoming
American Bar Association International 2012 Spring Meeting holding from 17 th to 21st
April, 2012 at the Grand Hyatt Hotel, New York, USA.
10.
Any Other Business
10.1
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN stated that he had handed over to the Chairman a
photocopy of page 71 of ‘The Guardian’ Newspaper of Thursday 2 nd February, 2012,
which contained a release from the Deputy Director, Information of the National
Judicial Council (‘NJC’) concerning the report of the Judicial Reform Committee, and
stating that the NBA’s representatives on the Committee (Messrs. J.B. Daudu SAN and
Rotimi Akeredolu SAN) refused to sign the report. He suggested that it is important that
the Branch take a position commending the NBA for refusing to sign the report because
the report recommended that the NJC still be headed by the Chief Justice of Nigeria
(‘CJN’) despite the Bar’s opposition.
10.2
The Chairman stated that he had not seen the report and all the information he has about
the report and the on-going saga were from newspaper reports. He opined that it would
be prudent to hear from the leadership of the NBA at the forthcoming NEC meeting.
10.3
Mr. Afro Fayokun stated that he partly agreed with Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN – in
the sense that the Lagos Branch ought to guide the national body and not wait for the
national body. He argued that the Branch should be able to take an informed decision on
an issue and then push the decision at the NBA/NEC meeting. He agreed that the
information we all have is from the pages of newspapers, however the issues are known
- the slanted composition of the NJC and the powerless position of NBA members of
the NJC. He reminded the meeting that the Branch had made suggestions on the
proposed amendment of the Legal Practitioners Act which included a recommendation
that the CJN should not be the head of the NJC.
10.4
He argued that the Branch should insist that NBA members participate fully in all
deliberations of the NJC, and the CJN should not head the NJC. He stated further that
44
the mode of appointment into the NJC should also be reviewed – arguing that the CJN
should not be the appointing authority. He ended by stating that Messrs. J.B. Daudu
SAN and Rotimi Akeredolu SAN should be commended if they refused to sign the
report for those reasons.
10.5
Lady Debbie Obodoukwu spoke on the issue of appointment of judges commenting that
one of the criteria is that the Chairman of the Branch where the applicant practises
should comment on the candidates suitability. She commented that people who had not
been in practise and who were not suitable were being appointed because the Branches
do not comment on candidates, but leave everything to the NJC and then complain later
on. She concluded that the Branch must take the issue very seriously and follow up on
it.
11.
Cutting of the Cake
11.1
The Chairman called on Chief Charles Uwensuyi-Edosomwan SAN to oversee the
cutting of the Anniversary Cake.
12.
Closing
12.1
Mrs. Chiagoziem Dururajis said the closing prayer.
12.2
The meeting ended at 2.55pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 12TH MARCH 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Officers
Taiwo O. Taiwo
Alex N. Muoka
Martin A. Ogunleye
Mr. Seth Amaefule
Marian N. Jones
Philips O. Njeteneh
Omohafe T. Opara
Tolani Edu-Adeola
Chinedu Nduka
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
Charles O. Ogunfuwa
Amaka Aneke
Anthony Atata
45
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
14.
15.
1.2
1.
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
Ogbonaaya C. Agbafo
Unachukwu J.E. Austin
Members
Hannibal Uwaifo
Edem O. Uko
Nnaemeka Mojekwu Chikezie
Uche Ikwueme
S. A. Adesokan
Emmanuel Ofulue
Emeka Ngige SAN
Onasile Adedigba
Dachomo I. Dachomo
Ikenna okoli
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Bisi Akedu (Mrs)
Nkechi Anuforo
Charles Nneji
Chief Ziggy Azike
Precious Akhanolu
Onyeagwa A. U. (Mrs.)
Olusola Adegbomire
L. A. Idu
Olivia Nwachukwu
Emmanuel Orhoro
Joyce E. Otobo
Nnagozie Azih
Ugo Ewelaku
Carlos O. Mbaka
Ndueghe Iwatt
Jeffery Eboh
G. Adetutu Siyanbola
Aluba J. Orji
Okereke Obinna Esq.
Aladesanmi Rotimi
Segun Ololade
Lawrence Austin-Coleman
Elirim Gujiduo I.
Tayo Olusanya
T. O. Lawal
Tosin Adelanwa
M. O. Igbaji-Egorp
Uwalaka Ogbonna Peter
Dan Kizito
Sylvester M. Emeka
Jude Ogbodo
Lekan Alaka
Anthonia Eke
Alex Uzebu
Lapite Ayoola
Susan Asoh-Ebong
Tolulope Taiwo
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Samuel Adeniji
Uche Stan Obi
-
26.
74.
96.
46
Ex-Officio
Ex-Officio
2.
Adenike Adeniji
4.
Azubuike Nwenkeah
6.
Akeredolu Abimbola
8.
M. A. Adewopo
10.
Abioye Akerele
12.
Foluso Fayokun
14.
Adegboyega Kolade
16.
Adebiyi Adewole
18.
Simon Chingle
20.
Ajiboye Olatunji
22.
Gbenga Durojaiye
24.
Priscilla Ogwemoh
Chika Ozurumba
28.
Rose Agbo
30.
Eloka–Nwokolo Emma
32.
Benjamin A. Achimugu
34.
Anthony N. Nwogbe
36.
Chijioke Okoli
38.
Iheoma Osimiri
40.
Charles A. Okhavhe
42.
Echeme Ekeghe
44.
Chris Aghaonu
46.
Oranmiyan Biobaku
48.
Nkeoyenasoa Enebeli
50.
Umeh C. J
52.
Dennis O. Akhagba
54.
Ikhalea Augustine
56.
Paul Anthony A.
58.
M. A. Thomas
60.
Irase I. Ohvokpehai
62.
Adaku Mbama
64.
Olumide Ekisola
66.
Benita Adinuba
68.
Uzoigwe Sopuruchukwu
70.
Olufunke A. Jagun
72.
Pat Atuluchukwu
Ayogu Felix
76.
N. O. Ohuaka
78.
Bashiru A. Ojo
80.
Femi Fajolu
82.
Nwana E. Chuks
84.
Yemi Kode
86.
Osinowo Oladipo
88.
Ferguson Chioma
90.
Kayode Ojo
92.
Oroma Cookey-Gam
94.
Okey Ezeogu
Okey Ilofulunwa
98.
Ogunsowo A. Moshood
100.
Anene Nwadukwe
102.
Charles N. Sunday
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
Itamah O. Sylvester
Bode Omoboriowo
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
Paschal Ozioko
Othniel A. Ikpiborko
Ireka Gloria
Prince Onwenieke Williams-Joel
Okey Akunyili
Amaka Itegboje
Nneoma Onyema
W. A. Gbadebo
Funmi Obisan (Mrs.)
O. Cheetham – West
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Tochi Godwin Ekwuogo
Nwachukwu O.
Geraldine Wey
Babatola Apata
B. Chike Anyiam
Ngozi Eze
Uche Chiwuzulu
Mr. Daramola
H. O. Ndubiusi
Emmanuel Dangana
Ify Celine Peters
Enyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
Owonikoko Titilola P
Bola Animashaun
Tunde Ogunseitan
Balogun Esther O
Sulaiman Haleema O.
Dawodu Francisca Oluremi
Okey-Joe Onuakalusi
Clifford O. Atakere
F. A. Dalmeida
Wale Banjoko
Chimaobi Adiele
D. N. S. Torbari
Ezenibe Stanley C.
Giwa O. Grace
Olasupo Ademosu
Pauline Dominic-Yishawu
Sumi O. Ahonsi
Nasir A. Bolaji
Peter Omijie
Marcus Eyarhono
Nwamuo Eyinnaya
J. B. Ande
Biodun Hundeyin
Whennayon O. Samuel
Fredrick Ajefu Obagwu
Ibrahim Abikan
Celestine Nwankwo
Sylvester Ekusueme
116.
120.
132.
180.
190.
47
104.
Kassim Moses A
106.
Eze Vinmartins
108.
Geff O. Eze
110.
Oyeyipo James Ibukun
112.
Harrison Emmanuel
114.
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Okey Eneh
118.
Ike Uko
Morenike Obi-Farinde
122.
Mrs. R. F. Okunola
124.
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
126.
Ade Adedeji
128.
Mudashiru Airahi
130.
Egeonu Gloria
Eghaghe Leo
134.
Waive Benjamin
136.
Michael Nusa–Yakubu
138.
M. J. Onigbanjo
140.
Sunday Adara
142.
Kenneth Ahis
144.
S. B. Onu
146.
O. Akinniranye
148.
Emmanuel O. Offor
150.
Odupitan Julius A. O.
152.
Daranijo Rasheedat
154.
Onyebashi Justina I
156.
Solomon Balogun
158.
Iwelu Lovetta
160.
Jude Uche Mbaeri
162.
Lucy Udoh
164.
Bivins Uwagboi
166.
Njoku Chukwuemeka
168.
Obukohwo Odogun
170.
Anne E. Aimua
172.
Temitope Fadeni
174.
Folashade Raji
176.
Iyaniwura A. L
178.
Chris A. Ogbobe
Ejike Okpe
182.
Olajumoke Larinde
184.
Chinonye Obiagwu
186.
Olaosebikan Olabode
188.
Chikaodili Dimazoro
D. O. Botoku
192.
Emeka-Iloegbunam Gerty
194.
Florence A. Agbana
196.
Israel Shola Matesun
198.
Ogo Onyia
200.
Godson E. Ojonah
202.
Oyagha Michael
204.
Austin Modo C.
206.
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
208.
Omorodion Philomena N.
210.
Ozoana Uche Dyrus
212.
Faith Obianwuna
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
279.
281.
283.
285.
287.
289.
291.
293.
295.
297.
299.
301.
303.
305.
307.
309.
311.
313.
315.
317.
319.
321.
Felix Asiegbu
Chisom Ojogho
Tope Olomofe
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Echetabu Theresa C.
Francis E. Akpata
Lucy Ahaneku
Afolabi Balogun
Tara Aisida
Lanre Ogunlesi SAN
Clementine Oyesanya
Yamta Yusuf A.
Mr. Ogala Oseka Jnr
Adekunle Lawal
Kelvin Ojukwu
Otera Grace
Igho Imade Ugbowie
Carol Obi
Adekunle Adeniji
Victor Ukachi
Onyeanusi Scholar Benson
Patience R. Onoobhagse
Seyi Frank Awodugba
Ozim Obasi
Momodu Aliu
Ikechukwu Odomelam
Onaibre Amaka
Bello Yusuff Bamijoko
Mike Idowu
Enyesiobi Ngozi C.
Kaduru Chikezie D.
Sessi S. Akojenu
Paul E. Okoli
Uwala E. Murphy-Akpieyi
Kenechukwu Anbaleye
Okeke Ijeoma
Okafor Chigozie
W. Ekundayo
Harry O. Ukaejiofor
Lanre Oyetunji
George Ekwata
Innocent N. O. Okoro
Joseph Ekene Ndibuagu
Omole Olusoji
Eric Ikwela
Taofik O. Elias
Martin Agoziem Akpaka
Oboku Horsefall
Ifeanyi Ibelegbu
Oluseye Amusa
Dixy Oddiri
Buwa Vincent
H. S. K. Ejimofor
Chidi Oduji
Zik Obi
228.
240.
286.
298.
308.
310.
48
214.
Egere Christy
216.
Blessing J. Oaikhena
218.
Ezemegbu Loveline
220.
Ukogu Tochukwu
222.
Banji Alabi
224.
Adeniji Kayode
226.
Nwotise Chike M.
Chidi Anya
230.
Chidi Anselm Odinkalu
232.
Olumide Oyesanya
234.
Stella I. Kehinde
236.
Mrs. Eli Osoka
238.
Nnawuihe C. Anthony
Augustine Egwuatu
242.
Prof. Bolaji Ikulayo
244.
A. M. Makinde
246.
Toyin Bashorun
248.
Taiwo Giwa
250.
U. J. Ekott
252.
Okoroji Chidi
254.
Supo Adebayo
256.
Nwokecha Elizabeth
258.
S. E. Dike
260.
Rosalind Clomavi
262.
Maduagwu R. C.
264.
Ibelegbu Ifeanyi
266.
Abimbola Owulade
268.
Nelson C. S. Ogbuanya
270.
Ihesiulo E. M.
272.
Boma Enwesi
274.
Eze Njoku
276.
Chike Odezugo
278.
Tony Okwesa
280.
Muhammed M. Imam
282.
George Nwabunike
284.
Victor Sodipe
Tinubu Munirat (Mrs.)
288.
Edward Porbeni
290.
Ikenna Onwusika
292.
Tunji Gomez
294.
Adeniyi Olayode
296.
Uzoeghelu–Nzube O. Joy
Chukwuma J. Okolo
300.
Biriyai Dambo
302.
Oluyemi Adewale
304.
Alfred Uwaka
306.
Bakare L. A.
Ugochukwu C. Hope
Rudolf Ezeani
312.
Obaye Chukwuwiken B.
314.
Eneh Chinyere
316.
Chinyere Uhegbu
318.
Ejiro Onajake
320.
Joyce Oduah
1.3
1.
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
Apologies
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
Alhaji MU Ibrahim
Chief Demola Sadipe
Mrs. Boma Ozobia
Chief Mike Allison-Ikwuagwu
Dayo Onakoya
Mrs. Aramide Adekunle Fatokun
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 1.05pm.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Chief Emeka Ngige SAN.
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
2.
4.
6.
8.
10.
12.
Mr. Oby Okwusogu SAN
Sen. Onyeabo Obi
Mazi O C K Unegbu
Olasupo Olaibi
Mrs. Nkiru Amaechi
Ahmed Akanbi
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General Meeting held
on Monday the 13th of February, 2012.
3.2
Mrs. Hairat Balogun referred to paragraph 4.4.3 of the minutes and clarified that the two
papers were not printed together. The Chairman explained that Hon. Justice M.M. Akanbi CRF
(Rtd)’s paper was printed by Mrs. Hairat Balogun, whilst Mr. Oluyele Delano SAN printed his
own paper.
3.3
Mr. Julius A.O. Odupitan made a correction to paragraph 5.1 of the minutes – which
should have read ‘2011 Bar Dinner Committee’ and not ‘2012 Bar Dinner Committee’.
3.4
Mr M.A. Adewopo moved for adoption of the minutes (as corrected), and Mrs.
Morenike Obi-Farinde seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accommodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committee was still working on securing
office accommodation for the Branch Secretariat. He assured the meeting that progress was being
made.
4.2
Lekki Land
4.2.1
The Chairman reported that he went for a scheduled meeting with the Permanent
Secretary in the Lagos Ministry of Lands, however, the officer had gone out on official duty so
he would have to schedule another meeting.
4.3
Bar Dinner Committee Report
4.3.1
The Chairman explained that the Report would be deferred because the Committee
Secretary (who is to prepare the report) was out of Lagos. He added that the Committee
Chairman had assured him that the Secretary would be back before the end of the week and the
report would be ready before the next meeting.
5.
Law Week Committee
5.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that a Law Week Committee was set up in
December, 2011 to organise the 2012 Law Week. He added that the committee had since set to
49
work, and invited the committee Chairman to make a quick presentation to the house.
5.2
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo (the chairman of the Law Week Committee) gave a brief oral
presentation to the meeting. He stated that the committee is set to organise the 2012 Law Week
as a law conference. The 21st - 25th of May, 2012 had tentatively been chosen as the dates for the
law week, however, in meeting with the Executive Committee, it was discovered that the NBANEC meeting would hold that same week, so the committee would change the date.
5.3
He stated that the theme for the law week is “Challenges and new frontiers in legal
practice in the mega city of Lagos”, and there would be a showpiece session on the state of the
Nigerian nation and quest for a stable polity. He added that Lagos City Hall was selected as the
venue for the law week, because of its historical significance.
5.4
Continuing with his presentation, Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo stated that the committee met
with the Speaker of the Lagos State House of Assembly and the Principal Members of the House.
The committee also met with the State Chief Judge to solicit the co-operation of the Judiciary
and attendance of judges at the law week events, and to appeal that courts should not sit during
the law week or sit early and adjourn cases so that lawyers would be able to attend the
programme. Finally, the committee visited the Nigerian Stock Exchange – as part of the law
week programme would include examining how lawyers can participate in capital market
practice, in addition to looking at new areas of entertainment law, sports law, and intellectual
property law.
5.5
He stated that there would be a formal bar dinner as part of the programme, and warned
that sale of Invitation Cards to the bar dinner would stop 48 hours to the event – in order to avoid
the last minute rush experienced during the 2011 Bar Dinner.
5.6
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo concluded his presentation by urging members to send in
suggested areas of practice deserving of attention during the law week, and assured the meeting
that more information would be forthcoming in the weeks ahead.
5.7
The Chairman thanked Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo for his presentation and called on
members who have suggestions for the committee to send them in to the Branch Secretariat.
6.
NEC Report
6.1
The Secretary read out a Report on the National Executive Committee Meeting of the
Nigerian Bar Association which held from Wednesday 22 nd to Friday 24th February, 2012 at the
Adegbemile Hall of the Ondo State Cultural Centre, Akure, Ondo State.
6.2
Printed copies of the Report were circulated to members.
6.3
The Chairman assured the meeting that a copy of the NEC Meeting Communiqué would
be emailed to members.
6.4
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN corrected item 5.6 of the NEC Report – the spelling of Obollo
Afor and Kabba branches.
6.5
Chief Emmanuel Ofulue moved to adopt the Report for discussion, and Mr. Linus Idu
seconded.
6.6
Mr. Abioye Akerele observed that during the discussion of ‘State of the Nation’ in the
course of the NEC Meeting, a committee headed by Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN was set up to
look into the issue of licensing by the Federal Road Safety Commission (FRSC).
6.7
Chief Emmanuel Ofulue commented on the mention in paragraph 5.2 of the Report that
the 2012 Delegates Election would hold in July, 2012 in Kaduna. He stated that whilst the
convention is to hold delegates’ elections in the home state of the incumbent NBA President, the
security situation in the country made it unsafe to have a gathering of lawyers in Kaduna. He
suggested that the elections should hold in Lagos or Abuja.
50
6.8
Mr. Chijioke Okoli supported the suggestion by Chief Emmanuel Ofulue, and added
that a gathering of lawyers symbolises the very concept of ‘western education’ that the Boko
Haram group is against.
6.9
Chief Ziggy Azike lent his voice of support to the comments and suggested that the
Lagos Branch should write the NBA President conveying the solidarity of the Branch with him
and say that when the situation is more settled we can concede a conference to him, however, the
elections ought not to hold in Kaduna. He added that the Branch did not have to appropriate the
venue to Lagos but could leave the choice of a safe venue to the National Executive Committee.
6.10
The meeting unanimously adopted the suggestion by Chief Ziggy Azike and resolved
that the Executive Committee should immediately write the NBA President in the suggested
terms and copy all Branch Chairmen.
7.
Presentation by First Bank of Nigeria Plc
7.1
The Chairman introduced two staff of First Bank of Nigeria Plc, Retail Banking Unit,
who had come to make a presentation to the meeting.
7.2
Opeolu Aina introduced herself and her colleague - Olawale Rasaq. She stated that the
products they had come to introduce to the members of the Branch are: Personal Loans Against
Salary; Household Equipment Loans; and Home Loans.
7.3
She mentioned that the interest rates can be as low as 19% per annum and could drop
further where the applicants come in as a group. She stated that the interest rate on mortgage
loans is 16% per annum, and added that the Bank would also finance the purchase of brand new
cars with 30% equity contribution by the borrower.
7.4
Responding to questions from members, Opeolu Aina stated that there is an age limit
for the loans as the repayment period would take into account the retirement age of the loan
applicant, whilst Olawale Rasaq clarified that the Bank would consider the cash-flow pattern of
prospective loan applicants who are not in paid employment.
7.5
The Chairman thanked the bankers for the presentation and stated that a small
committee would be set up to work out modalities with the Bank and report back to the House.
Mrs. Gerty Emeka-Iloegbunam and Chief Ugo Ewelaku volunteered to serve on the committee.
8.
Fee Payment
8.1
The Financial Secretary made an announcement on payment of practice fees and branch
dues. He reported that the Branch was surprised at the paltry cheque received from the national
secretariat as the Branch’s 10% share of practice fees paid in 2011. He enjoined members to pay
the appropriate fees on or before the 31 st of March, 2012 cut-off date, and submit copies of their
practice fees payment tellers to the Branch to enable the Branch reconcile records with the
national secretariat.
8.2
Mrs. Hairat Balogun complained that members had been paying practice fees and had
not been issued with any practice licenses as promised by the Association. She threatened that
members would hold a protest march against the Branch and National Executive Committees.
8.3
Responding to a question by Mr. Zik Obi on how age at the bar is calculated for the
purpose of payment of practice fee, the Secretary explained that every lawyer pays his first
practice fee in the year of call and that is counted as the first post-call year.
8.4
Mrs. R F Okunola suggested that the Branch should insist on getting a share of practice
fee payments made after 31st March even if it is less than 10%. She stated that the present
practice whereby the Association receives payments made after 31 st March but does not
recognise them for the purpose of sharing the income with the respective branches was not fair to
the branches.
51
8.5
The Chairman thanked members for their comments and stated that (in line with the
suggestion by Mrs. R.F. Okunola) a letter would be written to the NBA President on the issue
and copied to all the branches.
9.
Announcements
9.1
The Secretary made the following announcements:
9.1.1
Certificates for the NBA AGC 2011 and SLP 2011 Conference are available for
collection at the Bar Secretariat.
9.1.2
The NBA Conference on the Review of Performance of Election Petition Tribunals in
Nigeria comes up on the 15th and 16th of March, 2012 at Homeville Hotel, Benin, Edo State. The
Branch would sponsor 10 young lawyers (1 – 7 years post call) who are ‘up-to-date’ in the
payment of their Branch Dues and active in their participation.
9.1.3
The Nigerian Nuclear Regulatory Agency holds a National Training Course for lawyers
on Nuclear Safety and Radiological Protection at the Sheraton Hotel, Lagos from the 19th to the
21st of March, 2012 at a fee of =N=60,000.00 only.
9.1.4
The NBA Young Lawyers’ Forum Annual Summit holds from the 21 st to 23rd of March,
2012 at the Ceremonial Hall of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja, with the
theme ‘Capacity building for the Young Nigerian Lawyer: the Way Forward’.
9.1.5
The Nigerian Institute of Advanced Legal Studies (NIALS) sent a letter introducing the
Institute as the hub of all law research and legal advanced studies in Nigeria, and inviting
members of the Branch to participate in the continuing legal education programmes of the
Institute.
9.1.6
The Christian Lawyers Fellowship of Nigeria (CLASFON) Lagos invites members to its
Prayer Summit holding on Saturday, 24 th March, 2012 at 9.00am at No. 44A Montgomery Street,
Yaba, Lagos.
9.2
The Secretary announced the demise of Mr. Mogbeyi Sagay SAN, a distinguished
senior lawyer and member of the Branch, in a motor accident. The funeral arrangements as
announced include a Service of Songs at 6.00pm on Thursday 15th March, 2012 at Cathedral
Church of Christ, Marina, Lagos, and a funeral service at the same venue at 11.00am on Friday
16th March, 2012.
10.
Any Other Business
10.1
Chief Dabiri complained about the congestion at the entrance to the meeting venue. He
suggested that the old practice of passing the attendance register round to senior members whilst
seated should be revisited by the Secretary.
10.2
Mr. W.A. Gbadebo reported that the reduced scale of professional fees was further cut
by 50% by First Bank of Nigeria Plc recently. He requested that the Branch look into the issue.
10.3
The Chairman added that he received a similar complaint from a very senior lawyer
regarding Union Bank of Nigeria Plc. He called on members to put their complaints in writing
and give details so that the Branch can look into the issue.
10.4
Mrs. Abimbola Akeredolu called the meeting’s attention to the refusal of the NBA
members (of the committee reviewing the National Judicial Council) to sign the final Report. She
suggested that the position of the Branch on the matter should be re-affirmed at the next NEC
Meeting.
10.5
The Chairman raised the issue of security in the Country, and mentioned that a bomb
was reported to have gone off in Jos the previous day. He invited comments from members so
52
that our collective views can be collated and put across by the Branch.
10.5.1 Mr. Adegboyega Kolade expressed concern at the recent announcement by the Boko
Haram group that it would be taking its attacks to the South West and South East parts of the
Country, with Lagos as the major target. He stressed that members must speak out and insist that
the Federal Government do something to halt the madness.
10.5.2 Mr. Abioye Akerele stated that as far back as 1951 the seeds of Boko Haram were being
planted in the North. He suggested effective liaison with community watch groups and security
organisations to checkmate them.
10.5.3 Chief Emeka Ngige SAN opined that the issue of Boko Haram is political. He reminded
members that the group’s onslaught started when President Goodluck Jonathan took over from
late President Yar’Adua, and remarked that the government should be focused and nondiscriminatory, and seek the co-operation of countries like Israel. He added that the suicide
bombers are products of unemployment and the government should do something about
providing employment.
10.5.4 Mr. Okey-Joe Onuakalusi opined that the issue of security is a personal thing. He
explained that there are actually three Boko Harams - the traditional one, the political faction and
the violent wing. He revealed that the violent wing get as much as =N=10,000,000 for suicide
missions, and added that some northern governors are complicit or compromised as none of them
had come out with any statement condemning the actions of the sect. He suggested that the NBA
counsel northern governors and elders that they would be held responsible for the security
situation in the country.
10.5.5 Mr. Oranmiyan Biobaku stated that he does not see Boko Haram the same way, rather
he sees it as the beginning of a revolution. He suggested that the government should understand
the psychology of the group, and not just gloss over its grievances.
10.5.6 Mr. Emmanuel Dangana opined that we have not told ourselves the whole truth as there
was information in a Sahara Reporters interview about a major financier of the group. He
recalled that the President had said that there were Boko Haram members in his government but
has refused to name them. He suggested that the government empanel a Judicial Commission of
Inquiry to look into the Boko Haram issue.
10.5.7 Mr. D.N.S. Torbari suggested that the NBA should hold a conference and boldly state
its position on the Boko Haram issue. He added that the NBA should support the calls for a
national conference.
10.5.8 Mr. Femi Fajolu suggested that the Bar recognise that Boko Haram is a terrorist group
and is an offshoot of Al Qaeda. He added that the NBA should set up an intelligence unit to
monitor the group’s activities and advise government. He concluded that the country needs to
pray for God’s intervention in the situation.
10.5.9 Anne Aimua suggested that the security agencies should be trained on how to handle
intelligence information and protect informants and witnesses.
10.5.10 Bola Animashaun suggested that traditional rulers should be involved in the fight against
the group, as citizens who notice suspicious persons in their neighbourhoods are generally
reluctant to go to the Police but readily inform their traditional rulers.
10.5.11 The Chairman drew the discussion to a close.
11.
Cutting of the Cake
11.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in March to come forward for the cutting of the cake donated by
Mrs. Joyce Oduah (who was also celebrating her birthday). About 15 members (including Pa
Tunji Gomez) came out.
53
11.2
The cake-cutting ceremony was supervised by Mrs. R.F. Okunola with the support of
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN.
11.3
The meeting joined in singing the birthday chorus for the celebrants.
12.
Closing
12.1
Mr. Gbolahan Gbadamosi moved for adjournment and was seconded by Mrs. Uche
Ikwueme.
12.2
The closing prayer was said by Mr. Geff Eze.
12.3
The meeting ended at 3.07pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 16th APRIL 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH
COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Mr. Seth Amaefule
4.
Marian N. Jones
5.
Philips O. Njeteneh
6.
Omohafe T. Opara
7.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
8.
Chinedu Nduka
9.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
10.
Charles O. Ogunfuwa
11.
Amaka Aneke
12.
Anthony Atata
13.
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
14.
Unachukwu J.E. Austin
-
Chairman
Secretary
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex-Officio
Ex-Officio
Members
1.
Iheoma Osimiri
3.
Laditan Adebowale
2.
4.
Abioye Akerele
Aisida Omotara
1.2
54
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
15
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45,
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
George Ibekwe
Nelly Egwuagha
Kehinde Ayo-Kasumu
Uchenna N. Ezeokeke
Funke Adekoya SAN
Oshodi Olushola
Oluwadamilola Awoniyi
S. A. Adesokan
Olufemi Olaoye
Disu Adetutu
Sylvester M. Emuka
Pa Tunji Gomez
Etiti E.O.
Celestine Nwankwo
I. O. Latunde Dada
Olatunde Kolawole
Chukwuma Ezeala
Nwana E. Chuks
Ikoro Joseph
Balogun E. Olubukunola
Babatola Apata
Egbe U. Ande
Okeke Ijeoma (Mrs.)
Admiral Lanre Amusu Rtd
Zik Obi
F. A. Agbara
Ejimofor Hope
E. A. Otokhina
Ngonabi N
Unan Niome Yvette
Akin Akinbote
Iwuala Murphy-Akpieyi
F. A. Dalmeida
I. R. Chuka
Agube Elemi I
Dele Thomas-Orogan
Solanke Tosin M.
C. I. Igbinedion
Digba Onasile
Ikuesan Oluwadamilola
Francis Nwajei
M. O. Igbaji Egorp
A. O. Odukoya
Odeku Victoria
Egheghe Leo
Obasi Chinyere
Agurummadu Judith O
Dachomo I. Dachomo
Frank Ogbuide
Kukei Umoye
F. O. Mohammed-Noah
Razak O. Abudu
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Dame Priscillia Kuye
Emmanuel Umoren
6.
8.
10.
12.
14.
16.
18.
20.
22.
24.
26.
28.
30.
32.
34.
36.
38.
40.
42.
44.
46.
48.
50.
52.
54
56.
58.
60.
62.
64.
66.
68.
70.
72.
74.
76.
78.
80.
82.
84.
86.
88.
90.
92.
94.
96.
98.
100.
102.
104.
106.
108.
110.
112
114.
55
M. A. Adewopo
Adeniyi Olayode
Tony Okwesa
Chijueke A. A.
Fred Onyeka
Biriyai Dambo
Toyosi Alabi
Abiye Tom-George
Matthew Esonanjor
Edem O. Uko
Jeffrey Eboh
Ame Abyem
Durowaiye Oluwadamilola
W. A. Gbadebo
Grace Eluebo
Sandy Diana
Adelakun O. E. (Mrs.)
Ikenna Okoli
S. B. Onu
Stella Ugboma (Mrs.)
Egere Christy
Peter H. Mallong
Adesewa Olunuga
Tochukwu N. T. Okonkwo
O. C. K. Unegbu
A. O. Nkeonyemesi
Eweke Chinwe M.
Bola Animashaun
Olaosebikan T.Olabode
Kehinde Evbuoma
Olaibi Olasupo
Ogundipe-Peters Victoria
A. A. Paul
Dauda S. O
Adima Nosarieme E.
Achimugu Benjamin
Onyekachi C. Uko
Tunde Ogunseitan
Lucy Ahaneku
Lucky Ekarume
Opete A. O.
Christian Okafor
Njoku Marian Chinyere
Adeyinka Aroyewun
Bode Omoboriowo
Nzekwe Judith
Lanre Oyetunji
Amalla Stephen
Adeniyi Oluwafemi
Nkpubre O. N. O
Nwamuo Enyinnaya
Adebayo O. Ogunmola
Abikan Ibrahim
Asuoha Mathew
Ogochukwu Esan
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213
215
217.
219.
221.
223.
Francis Onwunali
Tosin Omigie
Zephaniah Garba
A. J. Owonikoko SAN
Ndueghe Iwatt
Abiodun Aikomo
Okechukwu Ifeanyi J.
James Asomugha
G. M. Sasore (Mrs.)
Omorodion Philomena
Percival Oaiya
Obele Akinniranye
Jones Adebayo.
Olufunmilayo Oluyede (Mrs.)
Sylvanus Efidi
Adebiyi Adewole
Rose Agbo
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Nwohamuo Godson
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs.)
Anuoluwapo Balogun
Osinubi Opeoluwa
Shehu Mustafa
Abimbola A. Falana
Chukwuemeka Osuji
Sessi Akojenu
Njoku Chukwuemeka
Dennis O. Akhagba
O. R. Kalu
P. R. Onoabhagse
Chika Ozurumba
Kayode Odumosu
D. N. S. Torbari
Kingsley I. Okoro
O. Cheetham-West
Ben A. Eneremadu
Sylvester Ekwueme
Uzo-Peters Adure Z.
Anthonia Eke
Uche Obiorah
Olayide Benjamin
Osunwole Funmilola A.
Abigail Akvayi
Wale Adesokan
Oluwafunke A. Jagun.
Uyi Imadegbelo
Paul A. Nwachukwu
Victor Usifoh
Akeem Oyeboade
Umeh C. Jonathan
Okereke Obinnah N. C.
Nnodozie Nwokorie
Ezemegbu Loveline
Augustine Egwuatu
Emeka-Iloegbunam Gerty
116.
118.
120.
122.
124.
126.
128.
130.
132.
134.
136.
138.
140.
142.
144.
146.
148.
150.
152.
154.
156.
158.
160.
162.
164.
166.
168.
170.
172.
174.
176.
178.
180.
182.
184.
186.
188.
190.
192
194.
196.
198.
200.
202.
204.
206.
208.
210.
212
214
216.
218.
220.
222
224.
56
Chris Alumona
G. O. Odunlami
Joy O. Nzube – Uzoghelu
L. A. Idu
Aluba J. Orji
Aderonke Sijuwade
Jude O. Ezeamaechi.
Emeka Ngige SAN
Kelvin Ojukwu
Ihuoma Pepple
Oliko Onojighofia
Odupitan Julius A. O.
Olajumoke Larinde
Marcus Eyarhono
Silva Ugo Osuji
Oranmiyan Biobaku
Emmanuel Orhoro.
Onyeagwa Angela
Fadeni Nelson
Hillary Umah
Olaolu Akerele
Joyce Oduah
Udoji Andy Nzube
Folashade A. Agbaje
Adeniran Ajagbe
Ogundele Abiodun
G. N. A. Enebeli
Adebayo Oriola
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
Funsho A. Dogba
Samson Olabiyi
Eze Njoku
Wole Araromi
Ernest Orji
Itamah O. Sylvester
Nwokedi Ohuaka
Dururajis Chiagoziem C.
Sheriff Oluwo
Owhofawhoraye A. Stephen
Uche Obiorah
Obiora Atuegwu Egwuatu
Lucy Udoh
Uchenna Nwadialo
Chisom Ojogho
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli
Paul A. Nwachukwu
Nelson C. Onyejaka
Oyagha Michael
Enyesiobi Ngozi
D. O. Botoku
Kaduru Chikezie D.
Adenike Komolafe
Bob C. O. Ijioma
Martin Agoziem Akpaka
Nas Ogunsakin
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
1.3
Opeyemi Ogunleye
Andrew Okpatakwu
Chimaobi Adiele
Azubike Okaro
Orih Odumogwu
Lawrence Austinecoleman O.
Ejiofor Jude
Ogala Osoka
Feyisola O. Ajayi
Elizabeth Osoka
Ayogu Felix
Uturuh Christiana
Femi Fajolu
Olubor Timothy
Ben Ihesiulo
Emmanuel Ukpai
E. C. Ukawoko
Ayo Lapite
Geraldine Wey
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Desmond U. Ozuruigbo
Dr. Nnamdi Dimgba
Apologies
1.
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
3.
Adetutu Siyanbola
5.
Toyin Bashorun
7.
Adekunle Oyesanya
9.
Aramide Adekunle Fatokun (Mrs.)
226.
228.
230.
232.
234.
236.
238.
240
242.
244.
246.
248.
250.
252.
254.
256.
258.
260.
262.
264.
266
Tayo Olusanya
Austin Okonkwo
Carlos O. Mbaka
Ogo Onyia
Tunde Busari
T. O. Lawal
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Chybla Ezekody
Chijioke Esekody
Tochukwu Ukoga
Olaoye Modupe
Kamar Raji
Ifeoma Umeh
Emmanuel Dangana
Efe Etomi
Ndulue Caroline C.
Kayode Ojo
Adeboye Bajulaiye
Foluso Fayokun
Charles Adeogun
Dr. Kruschev Ekwueme
2.
4.
6.
8.
M.U. Ibrahim
Emenike Mbanugo
Ike Uko
Modupe Sowho (Mrs.)
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 1.10pm.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mrs. Debo Laditan.
2.3
The 2nd Vice Chairman (Mr. Seth Amaefule) welcomed members present and
apologised for the absence of the Chairman who was on his way back from the opening
ceremony of the NBA-Ikeja Branch law week. He recognised some senior members of
the Branch who have not attended meetings for a while.
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General Meeting held
on Monday the 12th of March, 2012. No corrections were made to the minutes.
3.2
Mr. W.A. Gbadebo moved for adoption of the minutes and Mr Celestine Nwankwo
seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
The 2nd Vice Chairman informed the meeting that the Chairman would report on the
issues of branch office accommodation and the branch land at Lekki on his arrival.
4.2
Letter to NBA President
57
4.2.1
Responding to comments and questions by Pa Tunji Gomez, Mr. Jeffrey Eboh and Mrs.
Rose Agbo, the Secretary (Mr. Alex Muoka) confirmed that a letter had been sent by the
Branch to the NBA President suggesting that the NBA Delegates Conference holding in
July, 2012 should be moved from Kaduna to a safer location. He added that copies of
the letter are being sent to branches of the NBA.
4.2.2
The meeting discussed the issue of the Delegates Conference and the security situation
in Kaduna at some length. Members suggested various strategies for achieving the
objective of a change of venue.
4.2.3
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN reminded the meeting that the National Executive
Committee (‘NEC’) is the governing body of the NBA and the decision as to where to
hold meetings and elections ultimately rests with it. She stated that as a matter of
convention the last NEC meeting is hosted by the home branch of the outgoing NBA
President, but the location could be changed by NEC. She suggested that if the Branch
feels very strongly about the choice of the Delegates Confernce/ NEC Meeting, the
proper recourse is to reach out to other branches to see what their own views are and if
there is a ground swell of similar views from other branches, then a written resolution
could be sent to the next NEC Meeting to be discussed and put to vote. She ended by
stating that the majority of the votes cast would determine whether the venue would be
shifted or not.
4.2.4
The 2nd Vice Chairman thanked members for their comments and assured the meeting
that the Branch Executive would be guided by their suggestions.
4.3
NBA Election Petition Review Conference Report.
4.3.1
The 2nd Assistant Secretary (Mr. Obidi Alajuronye) presented a detailed report on the
conference.
4.3.2
Pa Tunji Gomez advised that copies of important reports should be circulated prior to
the meeting so that members can go through.
5.
Reports
5.1
The 2nd Vice Chairman explained that reports were still being expected on the J.I.C.
Taylor Memorial Lecture and the 2011 Branch Law Dinner, and would be presented at a
subsequent meeting.
5.2
2012 Branch Law Week
5.2.1
The 2nd Vice Chairman gave a brief report on the 2012 Branch Law Week. He reported
that the law week is scheduled for the 4th to 8th of June, 2012 at the City Hall, Lagos.
5.2.2
He gave an overview of the programme of events - stating that the law week would
commence on Monday 4th of June with a legal clinic, charity visit, and welcome
reception. On Tuesday 5th of June, the formal opening ceremonies would hold, and be
followed with an evening cocktail. There would be breakout sessions and workshops on
Wednesday 6th of June, and a bar dinner in the evening. The programme would continue
on Thursday 7th of June with more breakout sessions in the morning, a bar and bench
forum in the afternoon, and a variety night in the evening. The law week would end on
Friday 8th of June with a session on children’s rights in the morning, a showpiece
session on new frontiers in legal practice in the afternoon, and a closing party in the
evening.
5.2.3
The Law Week Registration Form was distributed to members who were enjoined to fill
and submit same with the applicable payment.
5.2.4
In response to a question from Mr. Gbolahan Gbadamosi, the 2 nd Vice Chairman
58
confirmed that payment for the law week could also be made directly into the Branch
Law Week Account at Skye Bank and the teller should then be submitted with the
registration form.
6.
Announcements
6.1
The Secretary conveyed the apologies of the Branch Social Secretary for the late arrival
of refreshments at the last meeting.
6.2
The Secretary made the following announcements:
6.2.1
Certificates for the NBA AGC 2011 and SLP 2011 Conference were available for
collection at the Bar Secretariat.
6.2.2
Members were invited to put down their names at the Bar Secretariat indicating which
committees they were interested in joining.
6.2.3
Crusade for Justice was inviting members of the Branch to its 10 th year Anniversary
lecture on the 8th of May, 2012 at 10.0am at the Sheraton Hotel and Towers, Ikeja,
Lagos. The theme is “Human Rights Violations and Abuses on our Roads – The Way
Out”. The lead paper would be presented by Prof. Akin Oyebode.
6.2.4
Jean Chiazor & Co. was inviting members of the Branch to the public presentation and
launch of the book “Essays in Admiralty: An Introduction to Legal Issues in Shipping
from a West African Perspective” on Thursday the 10 th of May, 2012 at 10.00am at the
Nigerian Institute of International Affairs (NIIA), Kofo Abayomi Road, Victoria Island,
Lagos. Interested members should please call Jean Chiazor Anishere on 0803-3042063
for an invitation card.
6.2.5
The Lagos Branch annual law week would hold from the 4 th to 8th of June, 2012 at the
City Hall, Lagos. Members were enjoined to block the dates in their diaries.
6.2.6
The annual NBA-Section on Business Law conference holds from the 17th to 20th of
June 2012 at the Eko Hotels and Suites, Lagos with the theme “Global Legal Regime –
Prospects and Challenges”. The sub-theme is “Trends in Global Legal Practice”.
6.2.7
The Secretary announced the following obituaries:
a)
Late Ogonna Chibuzor Agu (Ph.D) – the beloved husband of Mrs. Evelyn C.
Agu (a member of the Branch) - who was until his death an Associate
Professor of Theatre and Media Studies. He was buried on the 30th of March,
2012 at Nnobi in Anambra State.
b)
Late Barrister Cletus Umebuali (of No. 6, Catholic Mission Street, Lagos) –
who died on the 26th of February, 2012 after a protracted illness.
c)
Late Chief Samuel I. Agu (of S.I. Agu & Co. – 15 Catholic Mission Street,
Lagos) - who died on the 28th of March, 2012, and details of whose burial
would be communicated in due course.
6.3
The Financial Secretary (Mr. Philips Njeteneh) made a brief announcement thanking
members who had paid their practice fees and branch dues before the 31 st of March,
2012. He appealed to members who had not already done so to send in copies of their
practice fee payment tellers. He also enjoined members who had not yet paid their
branch dues to endeavour to do so before the 31 st of May, 2012.
7.
Any Other Business
7.1
The Branch Chairman came in at this point and apologised to the meeting. He explained
that he was coming from the opening ceremony of the law week of our sister branch –
59
the Ikeja Branch – whereat he had represented the Branch.
7.2
Mr. Olatunde Kolawole complained about the practice of Court registrars imposing
onerous conditions before terms of bail are perfected. He also complained about
stringent bail conditions, and asked what the branch was doing about this.
7.3
The Chairman reminded the meeting that the Branch had opened a register in the
secretariat for lawyers to give details of complaints against Court registrars so that the
Branch can take the matter up with the presiding Judge or Magistrate. He added that a
directive has already been given by the Chief Justice of Nigeria enjoining Judges not to
impose stringent bail conditions, and concluded that the matter would be raised at the
next bar-bench forum.
7.4
Pa Tunji Gomez suggested that as guardians of the society we should consider taking up
and challenging certain decisions which are inimical to the interest of our clients – such
as the decision in ‘Okafor v. Nweke’.
7.5
The Chairman thanked him for the suggestion and stated that the Branch would look
into the issue.
7.6
Mr. Wale Adesokan informed the meeting that the Supreme Court had decided to take
another look at the ‘Okafor v. Nweke’ decision in two cases to be decided on the 27 th of
May, 2012, and suggested that it would be better to wait and see which way the apex
Court would decide.
7.7
Mr. Obinna Okereke referred the meeting to the press reports concerning the scathing
remarks made by a Federal High Court Judge about five Senior Advocates. He
suggested that the NBA ought to take a position on the matter to prevent the continuing
inflammatory remarks being made by lawyers about the issue.
7.8
Mr Zik Obi reminded the meeting that in 2009 in ‘Peter Obi v. Andy Uba’ the Supreme
Court castigated Mr. J.B. Daudu SAN (the incumbent NBA President) for
unprofessional conduct – for daring to challenge the judgment of the Supreme Court.
The then Chief Justice of Nigeria complained that Senior Advocates were allowing
themselves to be used to harass Judges. He stated that there were some Senior
Advocates who were messing things up and there was a need for more Judges to call
them to order - as when Senior Advocates behave like junior counsel it reflects badly on
all lawyers.
7.9
Mrs. Stella Ugboma opined that we do not know what actually transpired in the court in
question. She recalled that sometime last year, the same Mr. J.B. Daudu SAN walked
out on the Judge. She added that it appeared from the commentaries that the Judge’s
comments were not in relation to any application before him, and apparently extended
to counsel who were not even in the matter. She ended by stating that she had been a
victim of the Judge’s behaviour, and it would be difficult for anybody to defend his
conduct.
7.10
Pa Gomez stated that the solution is very simple – scrap the status of Senior Advocate
of Nigeria. He added that giving a Judge the opportunity to castigate the whole
profession is a very serious issue, and in his over 50 years at the bar he had not seen
more disgraceful conduct.
7.11
Mr. Foluso Fayokun expressed his support for Pa Tunji Gomez’s suggestion. He stated
that many Senior Advocates were not living up to the name, and the institution was long
overdue for cancellation. He reminded the meeting that a resolution to scrap the rank (of
Senior Advocate of Nigeria) was still pending before the NBA-NEC.
7.12
Mr. Abiodun Aikomo stated that he was in Court when the incident happened, and the
accounts in the papers were not all correct. He confirmed that some of the Senior
Advocates mentioned by the Judge had not even appeared in the matter and it was
60
unfair to have castigated them in that fashion.
7.13
On another note, Mr. Otokhina complained about the manner members of the bar are
disenfranchised at elections by the delegates nature of NBA elections. He suggested that
the Branch should set a different tone by electing the delegates to represent the Branch
at the forthcoming NBA elections in July.
7.14
Responding to a complaint by Mr. W.A. Gbadebo about a new practice at the Lands
Bureau at Alausa-Ikeja, which now insists that an original certificate of occupancy
ready for collection would only be released to the owner/ client directly and not to the
solicitor who submitted and processed the application, the Chairman promised that the
Branch would write to the Executive Secretary of the Land Use and Allocation
Committee.
8.
Cutting of the Cake
8.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthdays, wedding
anniversaries, call-to-bar, elevations or promotions etc., in April to come forward for the
cutting of the cake. About seven members (including Mr. Zik Obi, Mrs. Tolani EduAdeoola and Mr. Femi Fajolu) came out.
8.2
The cake-cutting ceremony was supervised by Mrs. Stella Ugboma and the meeting
sang the ‘jolly good fellows’ song which was very ably anchored by Mr. Ogbonnaya
Agbafo – an Ex-Officio member of the Branch Executive Committee.
9.
Closing
9.1
Mr. S.B. Onu moved for adjournment and was seconded by Mrs. Joyce Oduah.
9.2
The closing prayer was said by Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko SAN.
9.3
The meeting ended at 3.04pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 14TH MAY 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH
COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Martin A. Ogunleye
61
Chairman
1st Vice Chairman
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
1.2
Mr. Seth Amaefule
Marian N. Jones
Philips O. Njeteneh
Omohafe T. Opara
Tolani Edu-Adeola
Chinedu Nduka
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
Charles O. Ogunfuwa
Amaka Aneke
Anthony Atata
Ogbonaaya C. Agbafo
Members
1.
D.N.S. Torbari
3.
Anyafobr Sobeolisa
5.
Nelson Tope Fademi
7.
Azusuwu Nwakuh
9.
Botoku D.O.
11.
Nwana E. Chuks
13.
Achimugu Benjamin A.
15.
Adebiyi Adewale
17.
Sola Adegbonmire
19.
Anthony A. Paul
21.
Paul E. Okoli
23.
Susan Ezeikpe
25.
Jeffrey Eboh
27.
Sharafa Olaitan
29.
Anthony Olowojoba
31.
Hannibal Uwaifo
33.
Olu Akpata
35.
Fredrick Ajepu Obagwu
37.
Agurummadu Judith Ogechi
39.
Adaku Mboma
41.
Kingsley Okoro
43.
Egbewunmi Temilade
45.
Ebele Esther
47.
Chief Olufemi Daramola
49.
Edward Porbeni
51.
Victor C. Anam
53.
Yetunde Ogunmoro
55.
Ituah Imhanze
57.
Kayode Ojo
59.
Oluwatosin Abioye
61.
Chika Ozurumba
63.
Emeka Osuji
65.
Abioye Akerele
67.
Modupe Sowho
69.
Agube Eleni I.
71.
George Nwabuike
73.
Azubike Okaro
75.
Augustine Egwuatu
77.
Okereke Obinna N.C
79.
Chisom Ojogho
81.
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
83.
Theodore Ezeobi Jnr
62
-
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex-Officio
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64
66)
68)
70)
72)
74
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
Ikenna U. Onwusika
Olorungbemi Samuel O.
Emmanuel Onyema
Odupitan Julius A.O.
Adeniji Kayode
Awodugba Seyi Frank
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Victor Anubioha
Bode Ofemiya
Adedayo Abass- Olisa
Chidi Ezeikpe
Fred Onyeka
Nelly Egwuagha
Stephen Obajaja
Chukwuemeka Ezeala
Adekunle Awodeji
Bode Olaosebikan
Jones Muyiwa Kayode
Rose Agbo
Nelson Onyejeka
Orih Odumogwu
Ayoade A.S.
Bivins
Mike Idowu
Etiti Ernest O.
Adesewa Olunuga
Tunji Gomez
Dennis O. Akhagba
Ayo Lapite
Chizoba Ohaji
Ikenna Okoli
M.A. Adewopo
Uchena Nwadialo
Makus Eyarhono
Adima Nosarieme E.
Andrew Ohi Eneakhifo
Olajide Benjamin
Susan O.M. Ebong
F.A. Agbana
Ogundele Abiodun
Ilechukwu E.U
Osaro Equasa
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
188.
189.
191.
Omuojina Emmanuel O
Chiwar Mindia Yahaya
Edwin U. Madubuofu
Anuforo Nkechi Linda
Celestine A. Nwankwo
F.A. D’almeida
Chukwudili Dimeoro
Okeke Chidiebere Kingsley
Okpalano Zik Anthony O.
Nwokodi Ohuaka
J.B. Odesanya
H.O. Ndubuisi
P. Dominic Yishawu
Peter H. Mallong
Jolaoluwa Adewale
Carlos O. Mbaka
Hilary N. Umah
Rasheedat Daranijo
Numa O. Erakpofoke
Matthew Karieren
Onuoha N.O.
Rotimi Adesanmi
S.M. Obale
E.A. Otokhina
Okoroji Chodo
Daud Fazaz S.
Kamar Raji
Emeka Okwuosa
Chief Kolade Olutekunbi
Victor Nwakasi
Adebayo Olanrewaju C.
S.B. Onu
Obukohwo Odogun
Benjamin A. Eneremadu
Anne Aimua
Jimoh Saliu O.
A. Adebayo Oriola
Obi Uchenna C.
Michael Bayowa
N. Ngonadi
D. Ajewole
Olaide Odejobi
Chike Odezugo
Balogun E. O
Tony Onwuoha
W.A. Gbadebo
Amalla A.
Ozuligbo Charles
Joy O. Nzube Uzoeghelu
B.A. Fashanu SAN
Tony Okwesa
Simon Chingle
Amaghiro Chukwuemeka O.
Seyitan O. Akawo
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
189)
190)
192)
63
Rosemary Ubajaka
Aharuella Vinerine O
Rosalind Clomavi
Funso A. Dogba
Edokwe Ijeoma B
Tosin Omigie
Lawrence Austinecolman O.
Kaduru Chikezie D.
Kelvin Ojukwu
Joseph Ojukwu
Godson E. Ogonah
T C Echetabu
Emmanuel Orhoro
Abraham Okojie
Ogbemudia Ifidon
Iheoma Osimiri
John Nwosu
Innocent N.O. Okoro
Babatola Apata
Eweke Chinwe
Chidinma Okoronkwo
Dike E.S
J.O. Osuigwe
L.A. Omar
Omole Olusoji O.
Mohammed M. Imam
Ifeanyi Eze
Bakare L.A
Adaobi Agu
Ogwemoh Priscilla
Abibakare Unegbu
Akin Akinbote
Anichebe Chioma Stella
Runsewe Morountolu
Owhofawhoroge A. Stephen
Sessi Akojenu
Onwuama Ehimeji
Olufunmi Oluyede
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli
A. Idaomi
Charles Musa
Ikechukwu Uwanna
R.O. Aroyewun
Ukwuomah N.C
Uzoamaka Nwafor
Naomi O. Abdul
Omorodion Philomena
Uche Ikwueme
Ngozi Nwangwa
Kunle Jimoh
Sylvester M. Emuka
U.J. Ekott
Adeleke Benedict
Emuveyan Mercy E.
Momodu Aliu
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
279.
281.
283.
285.
1.3
Adeniyi Oluwafemi E.
Apara Akinseye
M.D. Idris
Precious Akhanolu
A.O. Cema
Charity Enyia Odere
P.R. Onwahagbe
Adenike Komolafe
G.O. Odunlami
O.C.K. Unegbu
Akisanya Olamide A.
Silva Ugo Osuji
T.N.T Okonkwo
Ogo Onyia
Obarah Barak
Ifulu Ikechukwu
Uchedu Chinelo E.
Okey Ezeogu
Bode Omoboriowo
Omolara Aremide J.
Obiora A. Egwuatu
Martin A. Akpata
Lema Abina
Dauda S.O
Joyce Akpata
Nkwocha Chudi
C.C. Ndulue
Owolabi Adeniyi Oseni
Kehinde Evbuoma
Rudolf Ezeani
Wale Banjoko
Farinmade A. Amuda
Felicia E. Ajao
Wingate Emmanuel Onyedi
Taofik O. Elias
Makindipe Oluseun O.
Olumide Oyesanya
Enyesiobi Ngozi C
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
I.J. Okechukwu
Lizzy Nwokeocha
Uche Ijoma
Biriyai Dambe
C.A. Nnawuihe
Anthony Nwogbe
Hillary Oshomah
Doyin Olatunji
Apologies
1.
Alex N. Muoka
2.
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
4.
Alhaji M.U.Ibrahim
6.
Dixy Oddiri
8.
Adegboyega Kolade
10.
Joyce Oduah
64
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264.
266)
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
278)
280)
282)
284)
286)
Apara Akinseye
Ugochukwu Ezeaka
Umeh C.
O.N.O. Nkpubre
Okeke Ijeoma
Anthonia Eke
Gloria Ireka
Eghaghe U.
Foluso Fayokun
Ilori-Adeogun O.A
Igeubin Ilee Jonathan
Kayode Odumosu
Toyin Bashorun
S.O. Famuyinla
Odeku Victoria
A.O. Adekoya
Abuye T.
Ogbuou, S.B.
Ezemegbu Loveline
Wahab Ekundayo
C.O. Oni
O. Cheetham-West
Unah Niome Yvette
Richard E. Obianu
Henry Augustina O.
N.O. Balogun
Sylva Ogwemoh
Lucy Ahaneku
Sylvester Ekwueme
Folasade Raji
O.C. Agbafo
Ukogu T.G.
Seindy Diana
Obasi Chinyere
Emenike O. Mbanugo
Greg Okafor
Amalla Stephen
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
M.O. Igbaji Egorp
Olasupo Olaibi
Chinyere Unegbu
Isreal Shola Matesun
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
Kehinde Bashiru
Olugbenga Fabilola
Andrew Ohi Enakhifo
L.A. Idu
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
Secretary
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN
Chief Emma Ofulue
Mrs Boma Ozobia
Ekanem Nakanda
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
12.
Chief Sadipe
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 2.33pm.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mr Olumide Akpata.
2.3
The Chairman apologised for the late start of the meeting and explained that the
Branch Executive Committee had a courtesy visit to the Lagos State Governor –
His Excellency Babatunde Fashola SAN – which could not be re-scheduled.
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General
Meeting held on Monday the 16th of April, 2012.
3.2
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede and Mr Hannibal Uwaifo respectively noted that their
names were omitted from the list of apologies.
3.4
Mrs Uche Ikwueme moved for adoption of the minutes (as corrected), and Mr
Chuks Nwana seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accommodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committee was still working on
securing office accommodation for the Branch Secretariat.
4.2
Lekki Land/ Bar Center
4.2.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committee had fruitful discussions
with the Governor on the Lekki Land. The Governor also promised to be
involved in the building of the Branch Bar Center, and expressed interest in a
Law Library in the Bar Center to help young lawyers do their research.
4.3
NBA Delegates Conference
4.3.1
The Chairman stated he had a discussion with the NBA President – Mr. J.B.
Daudu SAN – who denied insisting that the Delegates Conference must be held
in Kaduna. The President agreed that the NBA/NEC meeting in Lokoja would
decide where the Conference would hold.
4.4
Collection of Certificates of Occupancy by Lawyers at Alausa
4.4.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committee complained to the
Governor regarding the refusal of officers of the Land Registry at Alausa to
release Certificates of Occupancy to lawyers who processed same on behalf of
their clients, and the Governor asked that the matter be discussed with the State
65
Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice. The Chairman stated he would
take-up the matter with the Attorney-General.
5.
Branch Law Week
5.1
The Chairman invited the chair of the Law Week Committee – Mr. Hannibal
Uwaifo - to give an update on the Branch Law week which would hold from the
4th - 8th of June 2012.
5.2
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo outlined the programme for the Law Week and assured
the meeting that everything was almost in place for a successful Law Week. He
enjoined members of the Branch to register for the Law Week in order to gain
access into the programme venues, and particularly appealed to the senior
members of the Branch to participate in the programme. He confirmed that the
Law Week would take place at the City Hall and Protea Hotel at Awolowo
Road, Ikoyi, Lagos.
.
5.3
He harped on the theme for the law week which is “Challenges and new
frontiers in legal practice in the mega city of Lagos”, and asked members to
attend and learn about new opportunities in the Legal Profession
5.4
The Chairman thanked Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo, and invited comments from
members.
5.5
Pa Tunji Gomez thanked the Law Week Committee for the elaborate report on
the Law Week but noted the failure to use senior members of the Branch as
speakers and to chair sessions. He suggested that senior members like Chief
G.O.K Ajayi SAN and Mrs Hairat Balogun be co-opted into the programme.
5.6
Mr. Akin Akinbote suggested that senior members of the Branch should be
visited after letters had been sent to them to solicit their active participation in
the Law Week and funding of the events. He also suggested that the Committee
look at the possibility of reducing the activities on the Law Week programme
because of funding constraints.
5.7
Mr Hannibal Uwaifo in his response stated that the Law Week Committee
would ensure that senior members of the Branch participate actively in the Law
Week programme. He also confirmed that the Law Week Committee had been
able to raise enough funds to cover the expenses for the Law Week programme.
6.
Announcements
6.1
The 1st Assistant Secretary made the following announcements:
6.1.1
Certificates for the NBA-AGC 2011 and SLP 2011 Conference were available
for collection at the Bar Secretariat.
6.1.2
Distinguished members of the Branch – Messrs. Yemi Candide-Johnson SAN
and Supo Shasore SAN were inviting all members of the Branch to the public
presentation of their new book - "Commercial Arbitration. Law and
International Practice in Nigeria" - published by Lexis Nexis, on Friday the 18th
of May 2012 at 9am at City Hall, Lagos.
66
6.1.3
The Nigerian Bar Association - National Executive Committee Meeting holds
from Wednesday 23rd - Friday 25th May, 2012 at Kafas Multipurpose Hall,
Lokoja, Kogi State.
6.1.4
The Lagos Branch Annual Law Week holds from the 4th to 8th of June, 2012 at
the City Hall, Lagos. The law week would commence on Monday 4th of June
with a legal clinic, charity visit, and welcome reception. On Tuesday 5th of June,
the formal opening ceremonies would hold, and be followed with an evening
cocktail. There would be breakout sessions and workshops on Wednesday 6th of
June, and a bar dinner in the evening. The programme would continue on
Thursday 7th of June with more breakout sessions in the morning, a bar and
bench forum in the afternoon, and a variety night in the evening. The law week
would end on Friday 8th of June with a session on children’s rights in the
morning, a showpiece session on new frontiers in legal practice in the afternoon,
and a closing party in the evening.
6.1.5
The 2nd NBA National Criminal Justice Reform Conference holds at the Delta
Convention Centre, Asaba, Delta State from the 3rd to 5th of June, 2012 at 9:00
am daily. The theme of the Conference is “Effective Nation-Wide Anti-Crime
and Security Coverage through the Justice System in Nigeria”. The conference
fee is =N=25,000:00, and is payable into a designated NBA account at Guaranty
Trust Bank Plc.
6.1.6
The Investments and Securities Tribunal, Lagos Zonal Office, holds its June
2012 Seminar, on Monday June 11th 2012 at 9.00am prompt at the Lagos
Resource Centre, Multipurpose Hall, The Arc, No. 9 Anifowose Street, Victoria
Island, Lagos. The seminar would discuss, inter alia, - the Constitutionality of
Special Courts in Nigeria: Focus on the Investments and Securities Tribunal;
the Adequacy of the Legal Framework for Investor Protection Fund; Regulatory
Development and Enforcement in the Capital Market; Fast Track Proceedings;
and E-evidence (e-document, e-records and e-filings). Pre-registration is
required via email to istribunalzo@gmail.com or text to 07027702284 on or
before Friday June 1st 2012.
6.1.7
The annual NBA-Section on Business Law conference holds from the 17th to
20th of June 2012 at the Eko Hotels and Suites, Lagos with the theme “Global
Legal Regime – Prospects and Challenges”. The sub-theme is “Trends in Global
Legal Practice”.
6.1.8
The National Association of Catholic Lawyers holds its General Meeting on
Sunday 20th May, 2012 at St. Dominics Catholic Church, Yaba, Lagos with a
Mass starting at 11am
6.1.9
Members of the Branch who have not paid their practising fees and branch dues
should endeavour to pay and submit copies of their tellers to the Branch
Secretariat.
7.
Any Other Business
7.1
Mrs. Hairat Balogun complained about the congestion at the entrance to the
meeting venue during the signing of the attendance register which is tedious for
senior members. She suggested reverting to the old practice of passing the
attendance register round to senior members.
7.2
The Chairman assured that the signing of the attendance register by senior
67
members of the Branch would be revisited.
7.3
Mr Akin Akinbote raised the issue of the face-off between Medical Doctors and
the Lagos State Government and suggested that the Branch owed a duty to the
people of Lagos State to intervene and pursue a resolution of the matter. He
then moved a motion seeking the setting-up of a committee of elders of the
Branch to mediate between the disputing parties. Mr W.A Gbadebo seconded
the motion which was carried by the meeting.
7.4
At the request of the Chairman, the meeting nominated and appointed the
following senior members into the Committee:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Mr. Taiwo O. Taiwo
Pa Tunji Gomez
Chief G.O.K Ajayi SAN
Mr. B.A Fashanu SAN
Mr. Akin Akinbote
Ms. Toyin Bashorun
Mrs. Olufunmi Oloyede
Mr. W.A Gbadebo
7.5
The Chairman asked members of the Committee to wait behind after the
meeting to discuss the modalities for intervention in the matter.
7.6
Mr. B.A Fashanu SAN suggested that there was an urgent need for the Branch
to have an Anti-Corruption Committee to look into allegations of corruption in
the Branch to ensure sanity in the Branch and at the Bar.
7.7
The Chairman in his response stated that the setting up of the Anti-Corruption
Committee would be looked into.
7.8
Responding to a question by Mr. Foluso Fayokun, the Chairman assured the
meeting that the Branch Bus would be going to Lokoja for the NBA-NEC
Meeting and would convey a limited number of members of the Branch. He
added that interested members should put down their names on a list at the
Branch Secretariat and would have to make their own accommodation
arrangements.
7.9
Mrs. Fafowora complained about the refusal of the Ogun State Governor to sign
Legal Mortgage documents since the inception of his administration and sought
the intervention of the Branch.
7.10
The Chairman assured her that a letter would be written to the Ogun State
Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice on the matter, and added that
incumbent had practised in Lagos before his appointment.
8.
Cutting of the Cake
8.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in May to come forward for the cutting of the cake.
About 16 members (including Marian Jones, Chukwuma Ezeala, Tayo Akpata,
and Jeffery Eboh) came out.
8.2
The cake-cutting ceremony was supervised by Senator Onyeabor Obi and the
meeting sang the ‘jolly good fellows’ song which was ably anchored by Mr
68
Ogbonnaya Agbafo - an Ex-Officio member of the Branch Executive
Committee.
9.
Closing
9.1
Mrs. Balogun moved for adjournment and was seconded by Mr. O.A Egwuatu.
9.2
The closing prayer was said by Pa Odunlami - past Chairman of the Branch in
1986.
9.3
The meeting ended at 3.50pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 11TH JUNE 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH
COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Mr. Seth O.S. Amaefule
5.
Marian N. Jones
6.
Philips O. Njeteneh
7.
Omohafe T. Opara
8.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9.
Chinedu N. Nduka
10.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
11.
Charles O. Ogunfuwa
12.
Amaka I. Aneke
13.
Anthony O. Atata
14.
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
1.2
-
Members
1.
Odupitan, Julius A.O
3.
Uche I. Obi
5.
Folasade Raji
7.
Lawrence Austine Coleman
9.
Chikaodili Dimazoro-Okeke
69
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
nd
2 Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex-Officio
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
S.B. Onu
Emeka Ngige SAN
Olawale Banjoko
Adeniji Oloyede
D.N.S.Torbari
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
Agbana Aribake F.
Apara Akinsanya
Jerry Okoye
Marcus Eyarhono
Irase I. Ohiokpehai
Ojuade Olabisi Tosin
Chief Theodore A. Ezeobi SAN
Charles A. Mgbajah
Rose Agbo
Oluseye Opasanya
Olatunji Momodu
Silva Ugo Osuji
S.O.C. Eghagbe
Kazeem T.M.
Anthonia Eke
Ifeoma Obi
Zik Obi II
Nelly Egwuagha
Anne Aimua
Ikechukwu O. Odoemelam
Nwokedi Ohuama
Rose Hamis
Paul E. Okoli
L.A. Omar
Azubuike Okaro
Bode Olaosebikan
Dennis O. Akhagba
Uchenna Nwadialo
Okeke Ijeoma
Kaduru, C.D
Obiora Atuegwu Egwuatu
A.M. Makinde
Grace Adenubi
Dike E. Stephen
Ndulue Caroline
Theodore Jnr. Ezeobi
Augustine Egwuatu
F.A. Dalmeida
O.N. Nwachukwu
Smart Iwu
Eric Ikwele
O. Akensete
Maduagwu R.C.
Oladotun Linda
Obele Akinniranye
Eze O. H.
Ibironke Soetan
Adaobi Agu
Gogo Karibi-Whyte
Onwuama Chimezie
Toyin Bashorun
Nas Ogunsakin
Ope Ogunleye
Echeme Ekeghe
W.A. Adedeyinbo
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
70
L.A. Idu
W.A. Gbadebo
Tunde Oladipo
Owolabi Adeniyi
Uwala Murphy Akpieyi
Oni Olaoluwa
Sylvester Ekwueme
Fidelis Akra
Dr. K.U.K. Ekwueme
N.C. Ukwuomah
Etiti Ernest O.
Ike Uko
M.A.Saliu
Tunde Ademojo
Uche Okeke
Adebiyi Adewole
Evelyn Agu
Obiagu Chinyere
Hannibal Uwaifo
Agurummadu Judith Ogechi
Okoroji Chudi
Bob C.O. Ijioma
Yamta Yusuf Ali
Enyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Ezemegbu Loveline
Mohammed Mufutau A.
Jude Odome O.
Chike Udezugo
Ikenna V. Onwusika
Pepple, Ihuoma
Agbara Okezie
I.J. Oputa
Onyeagwa Angela U.
Kelvin Ojukwu
Femi Fajolu
Norrison Quakers SAN
Geff O. Eze
S. Amalla
Nwana E. Chuks
Lucy Ahaneku
O. Cheetham-West
G. Adetutu Siyanbola
Oladipo Ajayi
Percival Oaiya
Ann Nkeonyemeri
Dayo Onakoya
Abimbola Akeredolu
Gloria Ireka
A.O.Enakhifo
Obi Uche
Justine Ibor Enang
Fola Alene
George Uwechue SAN
Hillary Oshomah
Okey Eneh
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
Okechukwu Ubah
Chris Nevo
Ifeanyi Iluka
Ikenna Okoli
Adenike Komolafe
Akin Akinbote
M.A. Adewopo
Uba Helen D.
Chiwar Mindia T.
Foluso Fayokun
Hariat Ade Balogun
Isreal Shola Matesun
Abioye Akerele
Owhofowhoraye Stephen
Precious Akhanonu
Joyce E. Otobo
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Atiboye Olatunji
Charles Nneji
T.N.T Okonkwo
D.O. Botoku
Solomon Balogun
Lapite Ayoola
George Nwabunike
Adamu O. Abubakar
Nnamdi Awa-Kalu
Jude Uche Mbaeri
Obukohwo S. Odogun
Tunde Busari
Ayetin Kainayor
M.J. Onigbanjo
A.G. Anafi
Aluba J. Orji
Obasi Chinyere
Prof. Bolaji Ikulayo
Uchenna Chikelue
Ozioma Ahaoma
Ololode Odenga
Carlos Mbaka
Amaghiro Chukwuemeka
Justice C. Iheanacho
Daudu S. Olaide
Odeku Victoria
Eze Njoku
Omoriodion Philomena
Victoria Ogundipe-Peters
Madubuko Chizoba O.
Ben Awurum
Chinedum Edith Ogoh
Adewole Temitope S.
Mbanugo Udenze
Omuojine Emma
Lady Debbie Obodoukwu
Patience Onoabbagbe
Oluwafemi E.
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
71
Alfred Akinjo
Olumide Oyesanya
Ore M. Abdullahi
Olusegun Ogedengbe
Anthony Okpalanozie O
Omole Olusoji
Adebayo Olanrewaju C
Chiwar Mindia T.
Nelson C.S. Ogbuanya
C.A. Nnawuihe
Emeka Nwadioke
O.C.K. Unegbu
Ajewole Duduyemi
Uche Ikwueme
Chukwuma Ezeala
Chijioke Okoli
Adekunle Awodeji
Emmanuel Orhoro
Okafor Ijeoma
Chika Uzorumba
Nelson C. Onyejaka
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Ojo Kayode
P. Dominic-Yishawu
Chikwendu Ogbonna
Vincent C. Owhor
Kenneth Ahia
Chris A. Ogbobe
Sola Adegbonmire
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Adebayo Oriola
Fidelis Adewole
Yetunde Ogunmowo
Joyce Oduah
Stella Ugboma
Pascal Ozioko
Funke Agbor
Unah Niome Yuette
Rotimi Adeniyi
Sunday Onuya
W. Ekundayo
Njoku Beatrice O.
Aisida Omotara
A.O. Ejiwunmi
Sylvester M. Emuka
Eghaghe Blossom
Kehinde Evbuoma
Olatunde Daudu
Bode Omoboriowo
Nnenna Onyemma
Ben Ihesiulo
Ogo Onyia
Uduak Ekott
Momodu Aliu
Sessi S. Akojenu
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267
269.
1.3
Adekunle-Fatokun A.
Olaide Odejobi
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Olomofe Tope
Umeh, C.J
Mrs. Adelakun
M.O. Igbaji-Egorp
Sandy Diana
E.A. Otokhina
Mike Idowu
Emmanuel Ezenachukwu
Lanre Oyetunji
Ike Ifediora
James Asumagha
Tayo Olusanya
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Senator Onyeabor Obi
Olufemi A. Daramola
Geraldine Wey
Uche Ikwueme
Apologies
1.
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
3.
Ms. Toyin Bashorun
5.
Mrs. Debo Laditan
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244.
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
268)
Emeka-Iloegbunam Gerty
Ikechukwu Uwana
Ehiosu Odeh
Onojighofia Oliko
Opajobi Temitayo
S.O. Adeyemo
Abiodun O. Ajayi
Opete A.O
Richard Eke Obianu
Olufemi Olaoye
Layi Arikewuyo
Damian Ihegazie
Celestine Nwankwo
C.I. Ehirim
Aderonke Sijuwade
Emmanuel Umoren
G.M. Sasore
Titilola Akinlawon SAN
Kamar Raji
2.
4.
6.
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
Kehinde Ayo Kasumu
Charles Musa
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 1.23pm.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mr. S.B. Onu.
2.3
The Chairman apologised for the late start of the meeting which was occasioned
by circumstances beyond his control.
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General
Meeting held on Monday the 14th of May, 2012.
3.2
Four members complained about the mis-spelling or omission of their names in
the minutes. A correction was also made that the closing prayer was said by
Mrs. Bukola Balogun.
3.3
Mr. W.A. Gbadebo moved for adoption of the minutes (as corrected), and Mazi
Okechukwu Unegbu seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
3.4
Members stood-up to observe a one-minute silence in remembrance of the
people who died in the Dana Air crash on the 3rd of June, 2012, and also for the
very dear wife of Alhaji M.U. Ibrahim ('Jam Jam') who passed-on recently.
72
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accommodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that the search for suitable office accommodation for
the Branch is still on-going.
4.2
Update on Lekki Land Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman reported that the Branch Building Committee had confirmed that
the Branch Land in Lekki had not been re-allocated. The work of the committee
is on-going.
4.3
Collection of Certificates of Occupancy by Lawyers
4.3.1
The Chairman referred to the complaint by lawyers that the Land Registry Staff
refused to release original Certificates of Occupancy (upon registration) to the
lawyers who had submitted and processed the applications for issuance of the
same Certificates, insisting that the Holders/ Owners must come in person. He
confirmed that the Executive Committee met with the Lagos State AttorneyGeneral and Commissioner for Justice who promised to speak with the officers
of the Land Registry to ensure that the practise is stopped.
4.4
Branch Mediation in Lagos State Government/ Doctors Face-Off
4.41
Mr. Akin Akinbote briefed the meeting on the commendable steps taken by the
Branch in intervening in and helping to resolve the face-off between the Lagos
State Government and striking government doctors.
4.5
2012 Branch Law Week
4.5.1
The Chairman reported that the 2012 Law Week held successfully the previous
week. He thanked all members who contributed to the week and who attended
the programmes. He called on the Law Week Committee Chairman - Mr.
Hannibal Uwaifo - to make a few remarks.
4.5.2
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo thanked members who attended and sponsored the week.
He noted that the intention was to organise a law week befitting of Lagos as the
centre of excellence and this was achieved. He particularly thanked the senior
members of the Branch who contributed to the success of the event and who
sponsored aspects of the law week programme. He thanked the Branch
Executive Committee for support, and also thanked the members of the Law
Week Committee for a job well done. He stated that a detailed report would be
presented at a subsequent meeting.
4.5.3
Mrs. Hairat Balogun congratulated the Law Week Committee for a very good
programme. She however took umbrage at the Committee's decision to make
her 'Queen' of the Variety Night without seeking her prior consent. She also
complained that in spite of her firm's donation, no table was reserved for them
and members of her firm did not get anything to eat at the Dinner. Finally, she
complained that she was conscripted to the Dinner High Table without any
notification or a formal invitation. She suggested that such anomalies be
avoided at future events.
4.5.4
Mr. Emeka Nwagboh congratulated the Law Week Committee members for a
73
job well done. He noted, however, that information about payment for the Law
Week was not properly disseminated such that some young lawyers were turned
back at the venue of some of the programmes. He added that he was lucky to
have money on him otherwise he would have been similarly embarrassed.
4.5.5
The Chairman respnded to the complaints. He reminded the meeting that the
Committee had given adequate notice about the payment of fees. Nevertheless,
he acknowledged that there may have been some shortcomings and apologised
to any persons who might have been turned back.
5.
NEC Meeting Report
5.1
The Secretary presented a Report on the meeting of the National Executive
Committee of the Nigerian Bar Association which held in Lokoja, Kogi State
from 23rd - 25th May, 2012.
5.2
Mr. Olumide Oyesanya moved for adpotion of the Report for discussion and
was seconded by Mrs. Uwana Murphy-Akpieyi.
5.3
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN opined that in the absence of a specicifc item on
the Meeting Agenda for the NBA National Elections and in view of the fact that
the Report broached the matter, he deemed it appropriate to raise the issue of
members of the Branch who were contesting for national elective office – for
discussion.
5.4
Mr. Foluso Fayokun complained that the Report did not mention the names of
members of the Branch who were contesting for office.
5.5
Mr. Zik Obi II suggested that paragraph 5.2 of the Report should have contained
a list of the valid candidates for the elections.
5.6
The Secretary apologised and explained that the list of candidates was omitted
in the interest of keeping the Report brief. He read out the names of persons
who had filed nomination papers and been cleared to contest the various offices.
5.7
At the instance of the Chairman, Lady Debbie Obodoukwu (the Secretary of the
NBA National Election Committee) addressed the meeting regarding persons
who were disqualified from contesting in the elections. She added that of the
five persons who appealled their disqualification only Mr. Paul Ebiala was
subsequently cleared.
5.8
The Chairman thanked Lady Debbie Obodokwu for her explanation. He added
that the Executive Committee was unable to meet the previous week to set
down the agenda for the meeting because of the Branch Law Week and that was
why the NBA Elections Delegates Conference was not put on the agenda as a
line item. He suggested that the issue could be discussed as 'other business'
under the agenda.
5.9
Mr. Ike Uko disagreed with the Chairman's suggestion. He observed that the
meeting had just adopted the NEC Meeting Report the main focus of which was
the July 2012 Delegates Conference in Kaduna – thereby making the Elections
the main issue for the Branch Meeting, and the meeting should discuss the
members of the Branch who were running for office. He added that the meeting
must of necessity discuss the issue of Branch Delegates to Kaduna as there
would be no other opportunity for a discussion by the members before the List
74
of Branch Delegates is sent to the NBA National Secretariat on the 22nd of
June, 2012. He ended with a suggestion that the Branch must of necessity adopt
members of the Branch who were contesting for positions in the elections.
5.10
The Chairman called on the Secretary to read out the names of members of the
Branch who were contesting for various offices.
5.11
The Secretary read out the names of the following members of the Branch who
were contesting for various offices in the NBA National Elections – Chief
Emeka Ngige SAN (for President), Mr. Foluso Fayokun (for 1st Vice
President), Mrs. Joyce Oduah (for Treasurer), and Mr. Gbolahan Gbadamosi
(for Publicity Secretary).
5.12
The Chairman invited comments and suggestions from members.
5.13
Mr. L.A. Idu opined that the candidates from the Branch were credible and
worthy of our support and should be adopted. He added that the Branch should
also reach out to other Branches to support them.
5.14
Mr. Chijioke Okoli associated himself whole-heartedly with the motion by Mr.
L.A. Idu and added that we should have a group interest. He reminded members
that regardless of the fact that Lagos was the first Branch to highlight the danger
of holding the Elections in Kaduna, we should rise up to the challenge of going
there to support our members. He described the members of the Branch who
were contesting for office as first rate candidates.
5.15
Pa Tunji Gomez noted that the Branch has the best candidates to offer. He
noted, however, that we have never in the Branch muffled the opinion of people
who do not agree with us. He took the meeting down memory lane to prior
instances, and concluded that we should not adopt candidates but should leave
delegates free to follow the dictates of their conscience in voting.
5.16
Chief Olufemi Daramola agreed that Pa Tunji Gomez had spoken 'as a matter of
conscience', but argued that the Branch should adopt its candidates. He added
that if a delegate gets to Kaduna and finds a better candidate then he or she can
follow his/ her conscience and vote for that person.
5.17
Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu supported the call for adoption of Branch candidates
stating that it is necessary to send a strong signal to other Branches.
5.18
Mr. Akin Akinbote argued that what is good today should be good for all time,
and the meeting should not take any decision simply because of expediency. He
counselled that the Branch had always had the principle of not adopting
candidates to avoid a situation where there are two candidates from the Branch
contesting for the same office. He ended by suggesting that we can give our
candidates maximum support, and adoption is not the only option for supporting
our members.
5.19
Mr. Oyesanya suggested that the Branch must have a strong position to take to
Kaduna, and if we say that our candidates are credible and worthy then we
should support them. He argued that the Branch should go to Kaduna with a
strong united front.
5.20
Mrs. Stella Ugbomah commented that the NBA President at the Lokoja NEC
Meeting made it impossible to have any venue other than Kaduna and we left
75
Lokoja feeling helpless. She counselled that the fact that the Branch had never
adopted candidates before is not a reason to continue the practice, and opined
that as things change we too should change.
5.21
Responding to comments about the alleged candidacy of Miss. Adetutu
Siyanbola as a member of the Branch who was also contesting for the office of
Treasurer and had obtained a letter of good standing from another Branch, Lady
Debbie Obodoukwu explained that the Electoral Committee did not have the
right to question the Branch of a candidate who had brought a letter of
goodstanding and met all requirements.
5.22
Mr. L.A. Idu moved a motion for the adoption of all four candidates by the
Branch and was seconded by Mr. Chijioke Okoli. Following a voice vote, the
motion was adopted by an overwhelmning majority.
5.23
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN suggested that in addition to the adoption, the
Branch appoint a powerful committee of the house to carry the resolution to
fruition. He added that the committee should be empowered by the Branch to
work to secure victory of the candidates in Kaduna in such ways as would be
permitted by the NBA Constitution.
5.24
In his response, the Chairman reminded the meeting that none of the candidates
had consulted the Branch before seeking office, thus it was an individual pursuit
and not a collective decision.
5.25
On the issue of Branch Delegates, the Chairman noted that the Executive
Committee had not met to set the yardstick and the requirements for those who
would represent the Branch. He opined that the candidates are in a better
position to work with the Executive Committee on the selection of delegates.
He invited members who were interested in being delegates to get in touch with
him noting that those to be selected as delegates must undertake to go to
Kaduna as the Branch could not afford to select persons who would chicken out
at the last minute. He congratulated the four candidates from the Branch and
confirmed that the Executive Committee would meet and subsequently the
selected delegates would be contacted.
5.26
Responding on behalf of the candidates, Chief Emeka Ngige SAN pledged that
the candidates would not disappoint the Branch and would bring far reaching
changes to restore the dignity of the bar. He thanked the Branch Chairman for
his support.
6.
Announcements
6.1
The Chairman reported that Chief Mike Igbokwe SAN lost his mother recently.
He informed members that the service of songs would hold in Lagos whilst the
burial would be held in the eastern part of the Country. He enjoined members to
attend.
6.2
The Secretary made the following announcements:
6.2.1
Certificates for the NBA-AGC 2011 and SLP 2011 Conferences were still
available for collection at the Branch Secretariat.
6.2.2
Registration is ongoing for the NBA-Section on Business Law conference
which holds from the 17th to 20th of June 2012 at the Eko Hotels and Suites,
76
Lagos with the theme “Global Legal Regime – Prospects and Challenges”.
6.2.3
The NBA-Lagos Branch Young Lawyers’ Committee is organising a Young
Lawyers’ Workshop on Tuesday, 26th of 2012 from 10 am - 3pm
6.2.4
The family of our dear member – Mr. Julius Anu-Olu Olatubosun Odupitan
cordially invites all members of the Branch to the 80th Birthday Celebration and
Thanksgiving Service of their father on Saturday 14th of July, 2012 at 10.00am
at The Saviour's Anglican Church, Low-Cost Housing (Jakande) Estate, Church
Street, Oke-Afa, Isolo, Lagos. Reception of guests follows immediately after at
the Church Hall.
6.3
The Chairman specially recognised the presence of three very senior members
of the Branch who regularly attend meetings and functions of the Branch Chief George Uwechue SAN, Pa Tunji Gomez, and Mr. Julius Odupitan.
7.
Any Other Business
7.1
The Chairman reported that the previous week he had represented the Branch at
the presentation of the new Lagos High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules 2012. He
assured members that he would confirm the date the new Rules would become
operational.
7.2
He added that the Family Court Procedure Rules 2012 was also signed into law
by Honorable Justice Inumidun Akande the former Chief Judge of Lagos State.
7.3
Finally, the Chairman noted that Honorable Justice Inumidun Akande had
retired and Honorable Justice Ayotunde Phillips had been confirmed as new
Chief Judge of Lagos State and would be sworn in on Thursday 14th of June,
2012.
8.
Cutting of the Cake
8.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in June to come forward for the cutting of the cake.
Several members (including Chief George Uwechue SAN, Mrs. Obele
Akinniranye, and Seth Amaefule) came out.
8.2
The cake-cutting ceremony was supervised by Mr. Julius Odupitan and Mr
Ogbonnaya Agbafo led the singing of the birthday song.
9.
Closing
9.1
Mrs. Joyce Oduah moved for adjournment and was seconded by Mr. Dayo
Onakoya.
9.2
The closing prayer was said by Mr. Bode Omoboriowo.
9.3
The meeting ended at 3.35pm.
_________________________
_______________________
77
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 10TH SEPTEMBER, 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Mr. Seth O.S. Amaefule
4.
Marian N. Jones
5.
Philips O. Njeteneh
6.
Omohafe T. Opara
7.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
8.
Chinedu N. Nduka
9.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
10.
Charles O. Ogunfuwa
11.
Amaka I. Aneke
12.
Anthony O. Atata
13.
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
-
Chairman
Secretary
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst. Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Financial Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex-Officio
Members
1.
Edem O. Uko
3.
Lucy Udoh
5.
Timothy Olubor
7.
Jones Kayode Muyiwa
9.
Kayode Ademosu
11.
Hannibal Uwaifo
13.
Ajeghongun Olabupe
15.
Chijioke Okoli
17.
Titilola Akinlawon SAN
19.
Pauline Dominic-Yishawu
21.
Nelson C.S. Ogbuanya
23.
Akande I. Olutoba
25.
Balogun Omolade T.
27.
Tara Aisida
29.
Adekunle Lawal
31.
Abioye Akerele
33.
IG Okechukwu
35.
Eric A. Orji
37.
S.B. Aliu
39.
Owolabi Adeniji
41.
H.N. Umah
43.
Florence A. Agbana
45.
Bob C.O. Ijioma
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
Okhueleigbe Aikpehae
H.O. Ndubuisi
Animashaun Bola
Abebiyi Adewale
Nnadozie Nwokorie
Ezemegbu Loveline
Ngozi Nwangwa
Oyagha Michael
Shobamowo Gbolahan J.
Modupe Sowho
Funke Aboyade
Jeffrey Eboh
Agu Adaobi U.
Rose Agbo
Bakare L.A.
Ikwele Eric
Ebelechukwu M. Odigwe
E.A. Otokhina
Grace Eluebo
Boye B.
Marcus Eyarhono
T.O Lawal
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
1.2
78
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137,
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
R.F. Okunola
Bode Omoboriowo
Wahab Ekundayo
Olumide Ekisola
Owhofawhoraye Stephen
Ikechukwu Nwankwo
L.A. Idu
U.U. Ezeaka
Ken Arubaleze
Paul C. Onwuamaegbu
Paul Omoijiade
Chidi Kechi Odiji
N.O. Balogun
Igwubor Ike Jonathan
Okawole Grace A.
Sola Adegbonmire
Sarah Olafare
Ajifowobaye Tolulope
Jimoh Adekunle Rasaki
Joba Akoka
Babatola Apata
Okereke Obinna N.C
Pa. Tunji Gomez
Olakanmi Aromosegbe
Aderonke Sijuwade
Amalla Stephen E.
Rosemary Ubajaku
Pepple Ihuoma
Uwala Murphy Akpieyi
Eloka-Nwokolo Emma
Ferguson Blessing Chioma
Igbonor Oshogwe C.
Tochukwu Chukwunefe
Oputa Jude
Porbeni Edward
Vincent A. Onwo
Silva Ugo Osuji
Nwana Chuks
Tochukwu Ukogu
Odupitan, Julius A.O.
Chike Odejuoe
Tope Olomofe
Dennis O. Akhagba
Adelanwa Oluwatosin
Victor Anuriola
W.A. Gbadebo
Geraldine Wey
Chikaodili Dimazoro-Okeke
Emma Igboehi
Ogundipe-Peters Victoria
Odeku Victoria
M.A. Adewope
Bola Olukosi
Nelly K. Egwuagha
Tahay Iorse-Sheriff
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
79
Chinyere Unaeze
Rudolf Ezeani
Omorodion Philomena
Anthonia Eke
James Asomugha
Rotola Williams
Femi Fajolu
Nwachukwu O.
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Emmanuel Orhoro
Okey Akunyili
Adeniyi Oluwafemi E.
Ukagha Rufus Enyinna
H. J. Raphael
Fayemiwo Aina
Omonike Akinsete
Sharafa Olaitan
Kelvin Ojukwu
Agurummadu Judith
Maduagwu R.C.
U.J. Ekott
S.B. Onu
Austin Ogbodo
Chigbo Anaenugwa
O.R. Kalu
Joy O. N. Uzoeghelu
Ohuaka Nwokedi
Omole Olusoji
Pa G.O. Odunlami
D. Nwokorie
Ojukwu Peter
Akojenu Sessi Sonayon
Adedokun Makinde
Ode Olubukola
Fayemi D.O.
Lucy Ahaneku
Onyeagwa Angela U.
D.N.S. Torbari
Solomon Balogun
Solomon Osakwe
Felicia Ajao
Biriyai Dambo
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Fidelis Egho
Elias Adedokun
Ikhalba Augustine
Adebayo Oriola
George Nwabuike
Uche Ikwueme
Njoku Beatrice O.
Francis Ogunbowale
O.A. Jagun
A.O. Cema
Simon Chingle
Fred Onyeka
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
1.3
Botoku Femi
Chidi Ezeikpe
T. Ejiofor
Onifade Kafayat
Oshodi Olushola
Roseline Akinbo
John Duru
Celestine Nwankwo
Agu Nnaemeka R.
Emeka-Iloegbunam Gerty
Charles Mgbajah
J.F. Uzomah
Sylvester Ekwueme
Uchenna Nwadialu
Ogo Onyia
Nelson Onyejaka
Chikwendu Ogbonna
Emeka Odikpo
Stephen Olasupo Famuyiwa
David Nkire
Lanre Oyetunji
Mac Johnson Okey
Chukwuma Okolo
Okafor Chigoziem O.
Victor Ejeye
Modupe Olaoye
Nkeonynasoa Enebeli
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
A.O. Fayokun
Senator Onyeabor Obi
Apologies
1.
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
3.
Mrs. Hairat Balogun
5.
Alhaji M.U. Ibrahim
7.
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
9.
Gbenga Fabiloba
11.
A.S. Abimbola
13.
Martin Ogunleye
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
176)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
Amaghiro Chukwuemeka
Chief Ladi Williams SAN
Chukwuma Ezeala
Chimezie Kalunta
Fidelis Ethe
Paul E. Okoli
Iheoma Osimiri
Olufemi Badunwa
Abiye Tam-George
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Ore Moshood
Olonu Idowu
M.J. Onigbanjo
Enyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Uloaku Ekwegh
Buwa Vincent
Uba Helen
Uche I. Obi
Kehinde Evbuoma
Joseph E. Ndibuagu
Opete Austin
Augustine Egwuatu
Omotayo Adetona
Tinubu Munirat F.
Iyaniwura Adebisi L.
Umeh C.J.
Akin Akinbote
Zik Obi II
Olufemi A. Daramola
Stella Ugboma
2.
4.
6.
8.
10.
12.
Fabian Ajogwu SAN
Mrs. Boma Ozobia
Mrs. Joyce Oduah
Emenike Mbanugo
Ms. Toyin Bashorun
Akin Akinbote
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 1.15pm with an opening prayer by Mr. Dennis Akagba.
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members back from the long vacation and noted that
some members were still enjoying an extended holiday. He expressed the hope
that the Branch meetings would be more business like this legal year
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General
Meeting held on Monday the 11th of June, 2012.
3.2
Mr. Sylva Ugo Osuji corrected the spelling of his name at No 33 on page 1 of
80
the minutes. Mrs. Titilola Akinlawon SAN corrected para 4.5.3 on page 5, and
Mr. Bayo Oriola made a correction to para 5.11 of the minutes.
3.3
Mr. Nelson Ogbuanya moved for adoption of the minutes and Mr. W.A.
Gbadebo seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accommodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that the Branch Officers met with the new Chief Judge
of Lagos State and she had promised that the Branch would be given space
within the premises of the Lagos High Court.
4.2
Update on Lekki Land Allocation
4.2.1
The Secretary reported that the Branch Building Committee had been meeting
and would present a detailed report by the next meeting.
4.2.2
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN complained that he was not informed that he had
been dropped from the committee.
4.2.3
The Secretary explained that the old Building Committee was disbanded by the
former administraton and nothing was done for two years. The present
administration re-constituted the Building Committee last year and at the time
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN was not in the country. Some old members were
brought back in and new members were co-opted into the committee.
4.3
2012 Law Week Committee Report
4.3.1
The Chairman reported that the chairman of the Law Week Committee had to
leave the meeting early. He confirmed that the Committee's Report is ready and
would be submitted to the Executive Committee before the next meeting.
5.
2012 NBA AGC/AGM Report
5.1
The Secretary presented the Secretary's Report on Nigerian Bar Association
National Executive Committee Meetings and the Annual General Conference
and Annual General Meeting.
5.2
The Report was a 7-page report covering three separate events:
a)
The NBA-NEC Meeting/ Delegates Conference/ Elections held in
Abuja in July 2012;
b)
The Pre-Conference NBA-NEC Meeting held in Abuja in August 2012;
and
c)
The NBA Annual General Conference and Annual General Meeting
held in Abuja in August 2012.
5.3
Mrs. Uche Ikwueme moved for adoption of the Report and Mrs. Geraldine Wey
seconded.
5.4
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN complimented the Secretary on a great report and
presentation. He supported the popular call that the last NBA National
Executive should go on record as the worst that the Association has ever had
and urged the Branch to so hold by a formal resolution. He suggested that
81
people representing the Branch such as the Chairman and Secretary should have
their conference expenses covered by the Branch. He, however, noted that the
Annual General Meeting was an illegal meeting because it was held during the
court vacation.
5.5
Mr. Chijioke Okoli commented that there was a critical point in the Report
about universal lawyers suffrage. He reminded the meeting that during his
administration the Branch had passed a Resolution in support of 'one lawyer one
vote', and should lead the push to scrap the delegates system.
5.6
Mr. Afro Fayokun commented on the crisis at the Annual General Conference
and the exorbitant conference fee. He opined that the protest against the fee
should not have been left to be raised at the conference and the Lagos Branch
appears to have failed in its leadership position. He suggetsed that the Lagos
and Ikeja Branches should have worked together to present a united front.
5.7
He added that the issue of universal suffrage had been raised, and the Branch
should pass a resolution reiterating support for universal lawyers suffrage. He
ended with a comment that the NBA should be able to sanction a president who
has governed badly even after he has left office.
5.8
Mr. Nelson Ogbuanya stated that the Conference raised fundamental issues
especially regarding young lawyers as the increase in fees made it difficult for
them to attend. He deprecated the comments by the former NBA President
about young lawyers being unqualified to vote, and called for de-centralisation
so that lawyers vote at their respective branches in future elections.
5.9
Mr. John Duru commented on the setting-up of a committee to host a 'Bar
Leaders' Summit' by the new NBA President. He asked who the 'bar leaders' are
and noted that the Branch Chairman and Secretary and those of other branches
should be at the meeting if the meeting is to discuss the future of the legal
profession.
5.10
The Chairman reminded the meeting that the Branch took a decision on the
holding of the 2012 Delegates Conference in Kaduna and wrote to the NBA
President and other branches, however, at the Lokoja NEC Meeting, the former
NBA President appeared to have mesmerized the hall and everyone kept quiet.
He noted that the Branch Excecutive Committee is up and doing and speaks up
about perceived issues but the problem is the lack of co-operation from other
branches. He confirmed the pledge of the Branch Executive Committee to
represent the Branch to the best of its collective ability and with the support of
the members. He also reminded the meeting that the Branch had met last year in
Port-Harcourt during the Annual General Conference and was instrumental to
truncating the former NBA President's plans to force through an unpopular
constitutional amendment.
5.11
Mrs. Bola Animashaun commented on the Report by the former NBA Treasurer
about a =N=50m deficit in the accounts. She expressed the hope that this would
not reflect badly on any future aspirant from the Branch.
5.12
The Chairman noted that the refusal of the former NBA President to allow Mrs.
Oluyede function in her office was a matter of public knowledge.
5.13
Mrs. Oluyede spoke briefly on her travails in office and the fact that she was
completely sidelined in the management of the NBA accounts despite her
82
readiness and availability to work and had repeatedly made this known at NEC
meetings and bar meetings. She reiterated that she was not privy to any
transaction relating to the deficit.
5.14
Chief Daramola stated that he had the greatest respect for the former NBA
Treasurer but he expected that when all this was going on she ought to have
resigned. He opined that she acted below our expectations and has a lot of
explanation to make to us, commenting that Nigerians must learn how to resign
from office if they are not satisfied with the way things are being done.
5.15
Mr. Femi Fajolu commended Mrs. Oluyede for not resigning, arguing that if she
had resigned we would not have known about the deficit. He suggested that the
Branch appoint an independent auditor to audit the NBA Accounts and report
the former NBA President to the Police Special Fraud Unit for investigation if
he was found wanting.
5.16
Mr. Paul Omoijiade stated that there were a lot of irregularities in the NBA
Accounts. He reminded the meeting that during the administration of Mr. Olisa
Agbakoba SAN, he had raised issues on the accounts of the Prince Lanke
Odogiyan regime and the accounts was stood down. He noted that the Annual
General Meeting was the proper opportunity for the Treasurer to inform the
whole world of the irregularities. He urged that the Branch pass a resolution
revoking the approval of the accounts at the Annual General Meeting.
5.17
The Chairman noted that the Annual General Meeting is open to all lawyers to
attend and it would be better if members of the Branch attend the Annual
General Meeting in large numbers instead of the very few who go. He noted
again that the Branch was able to work to defeat the constitutional amendments
at the Port-Harcourt Conference because members were there in large numbers
and mobilised the opposition.
5.18
Mr. Afro Fayokun noted that we fail to learn from history. He stated that what
happened to Mrs. Oluyede had happened before to Mrs. Adekoya SAN and she
blew it open in her report. He supported the calls for a review of the NBA
accounts.
5.19
Mr. Afro Fayokun proposed a Resolution that "Lagos Branch do hereby resolve
that the audited accounts of the Nigerian Bar Association as presented at the
2012 Annual General Meeting be re-visited especially the aspect regarding a
=N=50,000,000.00 deficit and moreso when the Treasurer knew nothing about
the accounts". He added that the Resolution should be commuicated to the NBA
President, circulated to all the branches and additional copies be prepared for
circulation to the General Secretary and NEC members at the next NEC
meeting. His motion was seconded by Mr. W.A. Gbadebo.
5.20
The Chairman noted that quite a number of the Branch elders were members of
NEC and it would be good if they would all come to NEC meetings to give the
Branch Chairman support since the generality of the members of the Branch are
not NEC members.
5.21
Chief Ademola Sadipe opined that without seeing the Treasurer's Report and
Audited Accounts presented at the Annual General Meeting, it would not be
proper to comment on the accounts. He suggested that members should obtain
copies of the reports and scrutinise them properly.
83
5.22
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN proposed a Resolution that "the Branch do urge
the NBA President and the leadership of the NBA to return to democratic
governance and depart from the autocracy and high-handedness which had
characterised leadership in recent times". The motion was seconded by Mr. Afro
Fayokun.
5.23
The Chairman called for a voice vote on the two resolutions. The resolutions
were carried uanimously.
6.
Announcements
6.1
The Chiarman introduced a book written by a member of the Branch – Mr. Elias
Adedokun - titled 'Handbook on the Innovations of the 2011 Evidence Act'.
6.2
He also introduced another book written by another member of the Branch and
officer at the Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse – Mr. Oyagha Michael - titled
"Money! Catch Them Young – Your Child's Financial Future Begins Now".
6.3
He encouraged members to buy the books, and also to write their own books.
6.4
The Secretary made the following announcements:
6.4.1
Conference bags and materials for the NBA AGC 2012 for those who registered
through the Branch were available for collection from Mr. Alex Goungo at the
Branch Secretariat.
6.4.2
The International Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA) Nigeria Lagos Branch
hosts "a 3-Day International Law Summit on the theme – Human Trafficking:
Prevention, Intervention & Prosecution - with special focus on Labour
Trafficking (from the Village to the City) and Sex Trafficking (from Home to
the Brothel)" from Wednesday 12th – Friday 14th of September, 2012 at the Eko
Hotels & Suites, Victoria Island, Lagos.
6.4.3
The Lagos State Judiciary has announced the programme of events for the
2012/2013 Legal Year opening ceremony, as follows:
a)
Monday 17th September, 2012 – Legal Year Services at 9.00am
simultaneously at the Cathedral Church of Christ, Marina, Lagos and
the Central Mosque, Nnamdi Azikiwe Street, Lagos.
b)
Tuesday 18th September, 2012 – Prison Visit at 10.00am to the Kirikiri
Medium and Maximum Prisons
c)
Wednesday 19th September, 2012 – Stakeholders' Summit on the High
Court of Lagos State (Civil Procedure) Rules 2012 and the Family
Court of Lagos State (Civil Procedure) Rules 2012 at 10.00am at the
City Hall, Lagos
d)
Friday 21st September, 2012 – Law Dinner (by Invitation only) at 6pm
at the City Hall, Lagos
6.4.4
Mrs. Tolani Edu-Adeola (the Branch Publicity Secretary) lost her beloved
mother - Alhaja S.A. Edu. The 40th day Fidau and final burial rites hold on the
22nd of September, 2012 at Bishop Aggey Grounds, off Layo Oyekanmi Street,
Mushin, Lagos at 11.00am.
6.4.5
Sir (High Chief) Olufemi A. Daramola is inviting every member of the Branch
to the launch of his autobiography on the 18th of October, 2012 at 11am at the
Peacock Hall, Island Club, Lagos.
84
6.4.6
The 4th edition of the Lagos Settlement Week will hold from November 5th - 9th,
2012. The Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse (LMDC) is seeking to engage a corps
of Volunteer Mediators to augment its panel and is inviting interested members
of the Branch to apply. Interested members can contact Mrs. Achere Cole at the
LMDC and would participate in a Mediation Coaching programme this month.
7.
Any Other Business
7.1
The Chairman reported to the meeting the announcement of new practise fees
by the NBA. He read out the announcement which was dated 6th day of April,
2012 and stated that "at its meeting held on the 5th of April, 2012, the
General Council of the Bar has approved the following as Practice Fees
payable by all Legal Practitioners ... with immediate effect:
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
Legal Practitioners of less than 5 years
standing post-call
Legal Practitioners of 5 years or more
standing, but less than 10 years post-call
Legal Practitioners of 10 years or more
standing, but less than 15 years post-call
Legal Practitioners of 15 years or more
standing
Senior Advocate of Nigeria and Honourable
Benchers"
Current Fees
Proposed Fees
=N=2,000.00
=N=10,000.00
=N=4,000.00
=N=20,000.00
=N=7,500.00
=N=35,000.00
=N=10,000.00
=N=50,000.00
=N=20,000.00
=N=100,000.00
7.2
Mr. Nelson Ogbuanya raised the issue of the method of calculating age at the
bar. He noted that when it comes to payment of practising fee there is a different
method of calculating age at the bar as opposed to how it is calculated for the
purpose of contesting elections or holding office.
7.3
Mr. Okhueleigbe Aikpehae suggested that the Branch should take note of the
insensitivity of the bar leadership as there are some young lawyers who are
being paid =N=10,000.00 a month. He stated that he is aware that if a fresh
lawyer and a fresh doctor are employed on the same day by the Lagos State
Civil Service, the doctor would be placed on Grade Level 11 whilst the lawyer
would be placed on Level 9 – which is discriminatory. He submitted that the
increase is unreasonable and should be resisted.
7.4
Responding to a question by Mr. Jeffrey Eboh as to whether the issue of
increase of practice fees was not discussed before it was approved, the
Chairman explained that the increase was brought to the penultimate NEC
meeting and NEC members protested but the NBA President noted that the
decision was not a NEC decision but was taken by the General Council of the
Bar. He suggested that we should air our views which can be taken to the next
NEC meeting which can then direct that NEC members in the General Council
of the Bar revisit the decision.
7.5
Mrs. Uche Ikwueme insisted that the NBA should revert to the old fees stating
that she did not see any reason for the increase.
7.6
The Chairman summed up the feeling of members that the Lagos Branch is not
in support of the new regime of fees and stated that he would take the Branch's
view to the next NEC meeting.
7.7
Senator Onyeabo Obi noted that all the matters discussed at the meeting today
were matters that had already happened. He stated that the NBA has its
85
members in the General Council of the Bar who should have properly
represented the bar when the matter of increase in practice fees was being
discussed.
7.8
He added that we complained about NBA accounts but we also have problems
with approving our own accounts. He noted that he had read in the Secretary's
Report that complaints were made at the Annual General Meeting about the
NBA accounts by two members of the Branch but despite that the accounts
were approved. He ended by stating that despite our misgivings, the Branch
cannot sit in appeal over a decision of the NBA AGM.
7.9
Miss. Jane Uzoma complained that some young lawyers do not have a place to
practise and she does not know if the Branch is doing anything to help.
7.10
The Chairman thanked her for the observation and stated that a Register would
be opened at the Secretariat for young lawyers who are looking for placement to
enter their contact details. He suggested that Miss. Jane Uzoma see him after the
meeting for possible employment.
8.
Cutting of the Cake
8.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in September to come forward for the cutting of the
cake.
8.2
Pa. Odunlami (the Chairman of the Branch in 1986) officiated over the cake
cutting exercise. Mrs. Rose Agbo, Mr. D.N.S.Torbari, Mrs. Geraldine Wey,
Mrs. Uche Ikwueme and several others came out.
9.
Closing
9.1
Mr. Zik Obi II moved for adjournment and Mr. Chuks Nwana seconded.
9.2
Mrs. Geraldine Wey said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 3.45pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 8TH OCTOBER, 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
86
1.1
1.2
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin Ogunleye
4.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
5.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
6.
Amaka I. Aneke
7.
Anthony O. Atata
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
Publicity Secretary
2nd Asst. Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Members
1.
A.S. Abimbola JP
3.
Babatola Apata
5.
Ajiboye O. Emmanuel
7.
Ekpo Ejadaro
9.
Theresa Ibas
11.
Nwana E. Chuks
13.
Botoku Femi
15.
Chijioke A.A
17.
Enimini E. Nsuabia
19.
Dayo Onakoya
21.
Nelson Tadeni
23.
Onyedika Nwosu
25.
Chris I. Alumona
27.
Ijebor Wallace
29.
Jacqueline Ezeanyim
31.
M.D. Idris
33.
Gloria Ireka
35.
Ngozi Nwangwa
37.
George Okeke
39.
Omotara Aisida
41.
Victor Chidi Chukwumaeze
43.
Owhofawhoraye Stephen
45.
Akeredolu Abimbola
47.
Isiekwene Amechi
49.
Abe Joshua Oluwafemi
51.
M.I. Alagbala
53.
Fidelis Egho
55.
Kehinde Evbuoma
57.
Aribake Agbana
59.
Yenjep Bueyen
61.
Udoh Lucy P.
63.
Tonia Usman
65.
Downson Maureen
67.
Adekunle Fatokun
69.
Zephaniah Garba
71.
Umeh, C.J
73.
Ajewole Duduyemi
75.
John Nwosu
77.
Lawrence Austinecoleman
79.
Vin Onwo
81.
Folasade Raji
83.
Mbadugha Fred A.
85.
Tahav Iorse-Sheriffs
87.
Paschal Ozioko
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
Abioye Akerele
Odupitan, Julius A.O
D.N.S. Torbari
Chinyere Uhegbu
Ihesiulo Ben
Anyika Jane
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
OCK Unegbu
Pat Atuchukwu
Felicia Ajao
Joyce Otubu
Simon Chingle
Anne Aimua
Joyce Oduah
Igbanor Oshogwo C.
Charles Nneji
Anthonia Eke
Ifeanyi Ilukwe
Pa. Tunji Gomez
Nelson Ogbuanya
Edem O. Uko
Dachomo I. Dachomo
Joseph Ekene Ndibuagu
Patrick N. Iheoma
Nzekwe Judith
Olukosi Adebola
Margaret Akpoyoware
Chiamaobi Adiele
Omotayo Adetona
Onojake Ejiro
Eric Juliana A.
Olowu Teri
Taiwo Ibidapo Obe
Tope Ademola
Obasi Chinyere
Akojenu Sessi
Njoku C.C.
Clifford O. Atakere
Emmanuel Orhoro
Sandy Diana
Obinna Okoli
Silva Ugo Osuji
Rosalind Clomavi
Ken Chinedu Kerieze
87
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
1.3
Shina Balogun
Vincent Omegba
Ifeoma Obi
Akande Olutoba
Justice Nwabuwe
Osunmole F.A
Maximus Nwolisa
Ahmed Akanbi
Foluso Fayokun
Adetola Adeleke
Solomon Balogun
Jeffrey Eboh
Dauda S.O
Lucy Ahaneku
Momodu Aliu
Supo Famuyiwa
O.A. Jagun
Waive Benjamin
E.A. Otokhina
Toyin Bashorun
Emmanuel Adebayo
S.A. Adesokan
I.O. Latundedada
Achere Cole
Owolabi Adeniyi
Apologies
1.
Mrs. Hairat Balogun
3.
Abiye Tam-George
5.
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
7.
Mrs. Ijeoma Okeke
9.
Mrs. Marian Jones
11.
Mr. Philip Njeteneh
13.
Mr. Ogbonnaya Agbafo
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
Sylva Ogwemoh
Iyiola Samuel
Madueke Okafor
Oluyemi Adewale
Oyagha Michael
Mbanugo Udenze
Raph Amobi Chikezie
Patience Onoashefse
Sumi O. Ahonsi
Akin Akintola
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Ngonadi
Emmanuel Umoren
Rosemary Ubajaka
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Olufemi A. Daranmola
Nelly Egwuaghe
Adebiyi Adewole
Abdulmajid Hassan
Gbenga Kolade
M.A. Adewopo
Numa O. Erakpofoke
James Asomogha
Yinka Shitta Bey
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
2.
4.
6.
8.
10.
12.
Mrs. Sade Adetiba
Mr. N.A.B Dabiri
Dennis Akhagba
Mr. S.B. Onu
Mrs. Omohafe Opara
Mr. Chinedu Nduka
2.
Opening
2.1
The meeting started at 1.05 pm with an opening prayer by Mr. Chinweikpe
Iwuchukwu.
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting noting that it was a very rainy
day and the meeting would be quick so that members can get back to their
offices or homes on time.
3.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General
Meeting held on Monday the 10th of September, 2012. No corrections were
made to the minutes.
3.2
Mrs. Felicia Ajao moved for adoption of the minutes, and Mr. Nwana Chuks
seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
88
4.1
Branch Office Accommodation
4.1.1
The Chairman stated that the Branch has confirmed from the Chief Judge that
the Branch would be given a suitable place for use as a branch office. The
Branch had sent in a written request (as directed by the Chief Judge) and had
identified a suitable space within the premises of the Lagos High Court. He
concluded that a reply is being expected from the Chief Judge.
4.2
Update on Lekki Land Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that he and the Secretary would meet with Alhaji Femi
Okunnu SAN during the week to get an update on the allocation. He added that
meanwhile the Branch would ensure payment of all outstanding levies and
charges on the land.
4.2.2
The Chairman also reported that he has been informed of two properties on the
Island that are available for sale. He would inspect the properties and report to
the Building Committee and the house.
4.3
2012 Law Week Committee Report
4.3.1
The Chairman explained that Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo (the chairman of the Law
Week Committee) travelled to Dublin for the International Bar Association
conference and upon his return learnt that his mother had fallen ill, so he had to
travel down to Benin to see her. He concluded that the presentation of the report
of the Law Week Committee would be deferred yet again to the next meeting.
4.4
Accounts
4.4.1
The Chairman stated that the Executive Committee is setting up an Audit
Committee to review the 2011 and 2012 Accounts and had selected Mazi
O.C.K. Unegbu and Chief Ademola Sadipe as members. He added that the
Committee would be chaired by Mazi OCK Unegbu.
4.5
Bar Leaders Summit
4.5.1
The Chairman reported that he attended the Bar Leaders Summit in Abuja on
behalf of the Branch. He explained that a number of issues were discussed at the
Summit but the resolutions reached thereat were yet to be codified.
4.5.2
He added that there have been some very worrisome developments regarding
etiquette and conduct of legal practitioners. He reported that two members of
the profession fought at the Igbosere Magistrate Court recently, and it was
reported in the press. He stated the NBA President read about the fight and
called him to request that the names of the lawyers be sent to the national body
for disciplinary action to be taken.
4.5.3
Mr. Otokhina opined that the Branch should have the apparatus to discipline
members before reporting to the national body.
4.5.4
Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu stated that the NBA Constitution is very clear and matters
of discipline can only be handled by the national body.
4.5.5
Mr. Akerele confirmed that the matter was actually taken up by journalists and
89
reported in the newspapers, so clearly it had become a national issue.
4.5.6
Mr. Ben Ihesiulo suggested that the Branch ought to first identify the people so
that wrong names are not sent to the national body, and a preliminary interview
should be conducted by the Branch with the persons involved.
4.5.7
Mr. Dayo Onakoya stated that the national body (in which disciplinary power
resides) has stepped into the issue, thus our duty is merely to confirm the
identity of the people involved and forward same to the national body.
4.5.8
The meeting gave the Chairman approval to forward the names of the lawyers
involved in the incident to the national body.
4.6
Branch Resolutions
4.6.1
The Chairman confirmed that the resolutions passed at the last Branch Meeting
would be passed to the next NBA-National Executive Commitee Meeting. He
appealed to senior members of the Branch to endeavour to attend the next NEC
meeting and give him support in helping to push the resolutions.
5.
Inauguration of Branch Patrons
5.1
The Chairman stated that a Sub-Committee of the Executive Committee had
been set up to organise the inauguration of the Branch Patrons. He added that
there was a need to add two more persons to the list of Branch Patrons, and this
would be done in due course.
6.
Lagos Settlement Week
6.1
Mr. Michael Oyagha from the Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse (LMDC) came to
give a brief presentation on the Lagos Settlement Week coming up from the
5th-9th of November, 2012. He explained the settlement week process.
6.2
He stated that the LMDC is organising various training sessions to give an
overview of the settlement week and the mediation process. He added that the
training for lawyers would hold between the 16th-18th of October, 2012 at the
LMDC whilst training for parties/ litigants would hold between the 22nd-23rd
of October, 2012.
6.3
He added that any counsel who is desirous of having a matter referred to the
settlement week could approach the LMDC directly and pick up a referral form.
He explained that the settlement week is an opportunity to try and settle matters
and it did not mean that every matter that is referred must be settled.
6.4
The Chairman invited comments and questions from members.
6.5
Mr. Foluso Fayokun stated that he was in court for a matter earlier in the day
and was given a form. He sought for enlightenment about the form.
6.6
Mr. Ben Ihesiulo complained that last year he had a matter in which trial had
started and the Magistrate referred it to the LMDC however the LMDC could
not compel the attendance of the other party so time was wasted and they had to
go back to the court.
6.7
Mr. Nelson Ogbuanya commented that the LMDC needs to do more to educate
90
lawyers so that counsel would come to the settlement week with a view to
settling matters. He added that there is presently a communication gap which
gives room to suspicion by some parties.
6.8
Mr. Chris Alumona sought clarification as to the stage of a matter at which it
would be too late for referral to the settlement week.
6.9
Mr. Dayo Onakoya commented that there has not been enough publicity about
the settlement week, and that matters which are part-heard ought not to be
referred to the LMDC. He noted that the LMDC law gives the Chief Judge
power to refer matters to the LMDC.
6.10
The Chairman reminded members that a discourse on the settlement week had
come up during the Branch Annual General Meeting in July, 2012, when Hon.
Justice Ipaye came with a member of the Branch – Mr. Wale Adesokan – to
address the Branch on the settlement week. He also noted that there were
several notices about the settlement week posted all over the court premises.
6.11
Mr. Oyagha Michael explained that the level of awareness seemed to be on the
increase as the number of referrals this year is higher than the previous years.
He noted, however, that based on the comments more enlightenment would be
done to get the buy-in of lawyers - which is critical to the success of the
programme.
6.12
He noted that usually part-heard cases should not be referred to the settlement
week, but the LMDC has had experiences where trial had started and the
matters were settled through the LMDC.
6.13
He explained that the referral by the Court makes it mandatory that the parties
must attend the settlement week session, but since the mediation process
requires parties to submit and to be willing to negotiate a settlement, parties
who are not comfortable with the process still have the option of either refusing
to submit to mediation or refusing to settle.
6.14
Finally, regarding the referral of matters without the parties notice, he explained
that notices are generally sent out by the Court to parties/ their counsel who are
informed of the referral of the matter to the settlement week. He ended on the
note that the settlement week and the LMDC needs the buy-in of lawyers to
succeed.
7.
Announcements
7.1
The Secretary made the following announcements:
7.1.1
Conference bags and materials for the NBA AGC 2012 for those who registered
through the Branch are available for collection from Mr. Alex Goungo at the
Branch Secretariat.
7.1.2
The finals of the 'Lawyers Table Tennis Open (Mfon Usoro Cup)
Tournament' hold on Saturday 13th October, 2012 at 10.00 am at the
Nigerian Table Tennis Federation Hall at the National Stadium, Surulere,
Lagos. The event (promoted by Mr. Anthony Atata – the Assistant Publicity
Secretary of the Branch) has held yearly since 2009 and has become firmly
implanted on the annual sports calendar of Lagos State. All sports loving (and
sports supporting) lawyers are encouraged to attend.
91
7.1.3
Sir (High Chief) Olufemi A. Daramola invites every member of the Branch to
the launch of his autobiography – "Doctor on Bicycle" on the 18th of October,
2012 at 11.00 am at the Peacock Hall, Island Club, Lagos.
7.1.4
Barrister Lanre and Barrister (Mrs) Rose Akinbo cordially invite all
members of the Branch to the wedding of their daughter – Tolulope Efuosa to
Mr. Joseph Modey Upula on Saturday 20th October, 2012 at 12.00 noon at
The Redeemed Christian Church of God, House of David, No. 30, Fashoro
Street, Surulere, Lagos, with the reception holding at the Lagos State
Recreation Centre, Sam Shonibare Street, off Ogunlana Drive, Surulere, Lagos.
7.1.5
The 4th edition of the Lagos Settlement Week will hold from November 5th 9th, 2012. Members are advised to liaise with various court registrars and the
LMDC to confirm fixtures for their matters which have been referred by the
Trial Judge to the Settlement Week.
7.1.6
The NBA – Section on Legal Practice holds its 6th Annual General
Conference from the 13th to the 15th of November, 2012 at the Jogor Centre,
Liberty Road, Ibadan, Oyo State. The theme of the Conference is "Raising
the Bar: International Best Practices in Legal Practice". Detailed information
and registration forms can be obtained from the SLP website – www.nbaslp.org, or from Mrs. Efunmi Olubanwo the Section Administrator at the NBA
Lagos Office at 96a Medical guild Close, off Bode George Street, off Ajose
Adeogun Street, Victoria Island, Lagos.
8.
Any Other Business
8.1
Mr. Dayo Onakoya observed that whilst the meeting was on he observed a
number of litigants coming out of one of the Court-Rooms in the Foyer. He
reminded the meeting that in earlier times there was an understanding with the
Judges that they would end their court sitting early on Branch meeting days. He
suggested that the Branch Executive Committee liaise with the judiciary to see
how the practice can be re-started.
8.2
Mr. Olutoba Akande commented on the issuance of 'letters of good standing'
and complained that each time a letter is needed, the applicant has to pay a lot
of money. He stated that the last time he applied for a letter he had to make an
additional =N=10,000.00 'unofficial' payment on the ground that 'the letter had
to be done from Abuja'. He suggested that there ought to be a way that members
can apply and obtain required letters through the Branch.
8.3
The Chairman first confirmed from Mr. Olutoba Akande that he was
complaining about 'letters of good standing' issued by the NBA-National
Secretariat. He then noted that the applicant ought to have applied to the Branch
which routinely issues such letters to financial members without any charge or
payment whatsoever.
8.4
Mr. Foluso Fayokun observed that since the present Executive Committee came
into office no committee reports had been received at Branch meetings. He
sought clarification as to whether committees had been set up and insisted that
members of the Branch are entitled to receive reports of such committees.
9.
Cutting of the Cake
92
9.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in October to come forward for the cutting of the
cake. He also invited Mrs. Joyce Oduah – the new National Treasurer – to
preside over the cake-cutting exercise.
9.2
Several people came forward to celebrate their birthdays or anniversaries
including Messrs. Foluso Fayokun, Obidi Cecil Alajuronye, and Abioye
Akerele. Mrs. Joyce Oduah officiated, and was assisted by Pa. Julius Odupitan
who led the singing of the 'happy birthday' chorus for the celebrants.
10.
Closing
10.1
Mr. Adegboyega Kolade moved for adjournment and Mr. Nelson Ogbuanya
seconded.
10.2
Mrs. Abimbola Akeredolu said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at
2.10 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 12TH NOVEMBER, 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2
Alex N. Muoka
3
Martin A. Ogunleye
4
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5
Marian N. Jones
6
Philips Njeteneh
7
Omohafe T. Opara
8
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9
Chinedu Nduka
10
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
11
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
12
Amaka Aneke
13
Anthony Atata
1.2
-
Members
93
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
1.
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
Obukohwo Odogun
Biriyai Dambo
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Segun Solomon
Atumbi Simeon
Babatunde Olubando
Abimbola Eden
Kayode Odumosu
W.A. Gbadebo
Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu
Kenneth Awa
Chukwuma Ezeala
Dagogo Karibi-Whyte
Oluwole Okelana
Solomon Balogun
Celestine Nwankwo
Lucy Ahaneku
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Rudolf Ezeani
Harrison Emmanuel
Joyce Akpata
T.O. Lawal
Idris Balogun
Wahab Edundayo
Maximus Nwolisa
Rose Agbo
Aderemi Bashua
Jude O. Okeke
Eloka-Nwokolo Emma
Adebola Lema
Oluwafemi E.Adeniyi
Evelyn C. Agu
Paschal Ozioko
Owhofawhoraye Stephen A.
Arubalaeze Kenechukwu
Augustine Egwuatu
Ayodeji Olakunle Bobaderin
Adeyemi Shekoni-Lawal
Babatunde Adedeji Ramon
Maduagwu R.C.
Alfred Uwaka
Uche Stan Obi
M.J. Onigbanjo
Adaku Abimbola Ufere
Akerele Olajide
Chijioke A.A.
Innocent David
Dachomo I. Dachomo
A.S. Abimbola
Okereke Obinna N.C
Kingsley Ezenwa Izimah
Ezenduka Aloy
Balogun Omolade T.
Rotimi Aladesanmi
Umoru David
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
94
Hannibal Uwaifo
Femi Fajolu
Egere Christy
Adetola Adeleke
Adebiyi
Felicia Ajao
Christiana O. Obinzu-Dosunmu
Apara Akinsieye
Nwohamuo G.C.
Dayo Onakoya
Onyedika Nwosu
Sylvester Ekwueme
Botoku D.O
Anire Kanyi
Opete A.O
Boma Ozobia
Fehintola Okunola
Odupitan, Julius A.O
Olasupo Ademosu
Nelson Ogbuanya
Emenike Mbanugo
Chidi Ezeikpe
Patrick N. Iheonu
Rosalind Clomavi
Adebayo Oriola
Omorodion Philomena
Theresa Ibas
Anthony Abiodun Paul
Stella Ugboma
Ayeni Fadekemi
Ogechukwu Nwani
Toyin Bashorun
Babatola Apata
Smart Iwu
George C. Nwabuike
Adekunle-Fatokun, Aramide
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Adegboyega Kolade
Yusuf B. Bello
Ohuaka N.O
Bola Animashaun
Gboyega Odunsi
Raluchukwu Nonso Jane
F.C. Nwoke
Bashiru Kenny
Akurich Okechukwu Micheal
Charles O.O
Ogo Onyia
Tolulope Ajifowobaje
Ubah Rosemary
Lawrence Austine-Coleman O.
Fidelis E. Egho
Mindia Yahaya Chiwar
Adekunle Alabi
Okey Eneh
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
Obi Uchenna C.
Ngozi Enyesiobi-Igwesi
Kareem T.M
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Ikeagwuonu Chimaobi M.
Senator Onyeabo Obi
Obele A.
Uche Ikwueme
Femi D. Ojumu
Silva Ugo Osuji
Edem O. Uko
Charles Nneji
Owolabi Adeniyi
Ezemegbu Loveline
Ijeoma Nkuche
Patrick Onoashegbe
A.F. Adeniji
Samuel Etaifo
Kassim M.A
D.N.S. Torbari
Abraham Okojie
O. Cheetham-West
Dupe Ogunsanwo
Ayogu Felix B.
Ikenna Okoli
Kingsley I. Okoro
Madueke Okafor
L.A. Idu
A.O. Fayokun
Anne Aimua
Chinyere Juliana Uhegbu
Agbana Aribake Florence
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
Andrew Ohi Enakhifo
Adaku Mbama
Jude Ogbodo
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Francis O. Babaoye
Efr Ize-Iyamu
Ojeladun Olatunde John
Pat Atuchukwu
Uchenna Uwadiala
Abiye Tam George
S.A. Agidee
Onakoya Tunde
Shola Lamid
Azubike Okaro
Nwachukwu O.
Sharafa Olaitan
M.U. Ibrahim (Jam Jam)
Chidi Anya
R.O. Aroyewun
Dennis O. Akhagba
Emmanuel Umoren
Abimbola Owulade
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
95
Sule M. Damian
Sandy Diana
Ozim Obasi
Enyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Arra, Fedelis Ijege
Lanre Oyetunji
Dixxy Odiri
Hilary N. Umah
Iheoma Osimiri
Edeogbaji Oliver
Maureen O. Omoruayi
Echeme Ekeghe
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Akintunde Jimoh
Andrew Okpataku
Bunmi Ibraheem
Lucy Udah
Bisi Iyaniwura
Okeke Amaka
Olufemi A. Daramola
Temitayo Kareen
Abioye Akerele
Funke Jagun
C.C. Michael Odo
Stephen Olasupo Famuyiwa
Nwana E. Chuks
Emmanuel Orhoro
Zik Obi II
Pa Tunji Gomez
Obiora A. Egwuatu
Alfred Akinjo
I. Olutoba Akande
Chris A. Ogbebe
Bode Omoboriowo
Chris Okeke
Ben Ihesiulo
Kaduru, Chikezie
Olaibi Olasupo
Obasi Casmir Nnamdi
Nze Uchenna C.
Olutayo Arojo
Anthonia Eke
Rotimi Ogunjobi
O. Tara Aisida
Kunle Jimoh
Jones Oseha
Okechukwu Ubah
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli
John Nwosu
Bob C.O. Ijioma
E.A. Otokhina
Francis Onwumah
Adeleke Benedict
Adekunle Adeniyi
Sessi Sonayon Akujenu
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
1.3
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
Joy O. Nzube Uzoeghelu
Morenikeji Akah
Kelvin Ojukwu
Theodore Jnr. Ezeobi
Okoli Ugochukwu C.
Ugwu Washington Ogbonnaya
Bolatilo Fashina
Apologies
1.
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
3.
Chief Ademola Sadipe
5.
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
7.
Mrs. Ijeoma Okeke
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
Sarah Olafare
Nwachukwu Aaron Obasi
Joseph Ikoro
Ande U. Egbe
Ngonadi N.
Eweke Chinwe M.
Promise Gabriel Asikpo
2)
4)
6)
8)
Mrs H. A. Balogun
S.B. Onu
Abimbola akeredolu
Joyce Oduah
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.22 pm.
2.2
The opening prayer was said by Mrs. R.F. Okunola.
2.3
The Chairman explained that the guest lecturer who was scheduled to present
his paper after the consideration of the minutes of the last meeting would have
to be taken first as he had an appointment to see the State Governor.
3.
Lecture by Mr. Fola Arthur-Worrey
3.1
The Chairman introduced the guest lecturer - Mr. Fola Arthur-Worrey, the
former Lagos State Director of Public Prosecution, and later Solicitor-General
and Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Justice. He was also a consultant to
Lagos State on the Criminal Reform Project, a one-time Commissioner for
Lands in Lagos State, and is presently in private practice whilst serving as
Executive Chairman of the Lagos State Security Trust Fund.
3.2
The Chairman added that he is a distinguished writer and has authored 'The
Prosecutor in Public Prosecutions' and 'Cross-Examination – Mastering the Trial
Lawyer's Most Potent Weapon' which he co-authored with Prof. Yemi Osinbajo
SAN. The Chairman invited him to speak on the topic – 'Advocacy in Legal
Proceedings'.
3.3
Mr. Fola Arthur-Worrey commended the Chairman for his kind introduction
and commended him for his conduct in and out of the bar. He commented that
this is his 32nd year in practice and he is troubled about recent developments in
the profession such as the recent fight between lawyers at the Igbosere
Magistrates' Court.
3.4
Starting his lecture, Mr. Fola Arthur-Worrey explained that he would not
presume to lecture such a distinguished audience. He rather proposed to rub
minds with his audience.
3.5
He reminded his audience that in olden times lawyers were referred to as
"Akoni waju Adajo", thus people expected when a lawyer went before the Court
96
that he would be well turned out, speak impeccable English and dazzle the
Court with his erudition and knowledge.
3.6
He stated that the essential ingredient of advocacy is persuasion, or advocacy as
we call it. He posited that before you can persuade another with your argument
you must first persuade yourself. Thus, persuasion is the principle of advocacy
and the first rule of persuasion is to persuade yourself. You must selfinterrogate your argument against the backgorund of the facts and the law, and
once you have persuaded yourself you can sally forth and persuade the Court.
3.7
He proceeded to speak for about an hour spicing his incisive comments with
anecdotes, and with quotes from his book – 'The Prosecutor in Public
Prosecutions'.
3.8
He ended his lecture by advising lawyers not to overload submissions with too
many cases, pointing out that it was sufficient to cite two cases on each point –
the case where the rule was frst established and the most recent case where it
was applied. He counselled against approaching cross-examination without
adequate preparation, and urged lawyers to reduce the number of adjournments
as it is good advocacy to finish cases on time.
3.9
He noted that thousands of lawyers are coming out everyday but the front of the
profession is choked, and suggested that the Nigerian Bar Association as a body
should begin to look at the issue as there is no space at the front. He concluded
by reiterating that 'hated though we are, lawyers are the necessary evils of
modern society. A lawyer is the man who makes the case for the other who
cannot speak. And there is no country on earth that does not have lawyers'.
3.10
The lecture was well received and the Chairman thanked him and called for
questions.
3.11
Mr. Fola Arthur-Worrey responded to the various questions raised.
3.12
The Assistant Publicity Secretary thanked Mr. Fola Arthur-Worrey for his
brilliant lecture which had expanded the understanding of lawyers regarding
advocacy.
4.
Minutes of the Last Meeting
4.1
The Chairman commented on the dressing of lawyers and noted that the Branch
Meeting is a professional business meeting and lawyers should come properly
attired.
4.2
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Branch Monthly General
Meeting held on Monday the 8th October, 2012. A correction was made to
paragraph 3.1 of the minutes.
4.3
Mr Dayo Onakoya moved for adoption of the minutes, and Mr. Ben Ihesiulo
seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
5.
Matters Arising
5.1
Branch Office Accommodation
5.1.1
The Chairman reported that he and the Secretary had met with the Chief Judge
97
on the matter and it would appear that the Branch is in competition with the
Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse (LMDC) for available space in the premises of
the Lagos High Court – since the kick-off of the new Civil Procedure Rules
means that the LMDC would need more space to expand its services. He
assured the meeting that the Branch would definitely get some space within the
premises of the Lagos High Court.
5.2
Update on Lekki Land Allocation
5.2.1
The Chairman stated that the Executive Committee is making arragements to
pay the outstanding charges and levies on the land.
5.3
2012 Law Week Committee Report
5.3.1
The Chairman explained that Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo (the chairman of the Law
Week Committee) has submitted a report which would be considered by the
Executive Committee and then presented to the house.
5.4
Accounts
5.4.1
The Chairman stated that the Executive Committee has set up an Audit
Committee, comprising Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu and Chief Ademola Sadipe as
members, to review the 2011 and 2012 Accounts. He stated that the Committee
would soon meet and submit a report.
5.5
Lawyers' Fight
5.5.1
The Chairman reported that that the letter had gone to the NBA National
Secretariat giving details of the lawyers who fought at the Igbosere Magistrates'
Court.
5.6
Branch Patrons
5.6.1
Mr. Afro Fayokun raised a question about the propriety of appointing persons as
Patrons of the Branch when the Branch Bye-Laws did not provide for such
appointment.
5.6.2
Responding, the Secretary referred to Item 8 of the Minutes of the July 2011
Branch Annual General Meeting whereat the members approved the
appointment of five persons as Branch Patrons. He explained that the Executive
Committee is merely carrying into effect the decision of the Branch.
5.6.3
Mr. Afro Fayokun, however, insisted that if the Branch Bye-Law does not
provide for the appointment of patrons then it should not be done.
6.
Book Launch
6.1
Sir (High Chief) Olufemi Daramola came out to thank members of the Branch
for their presence and support at the recent launch of his autobiography –
Doctor on Bicycle.
6.2
The Chairman informed the meeting that a delegation from the Executive
Committee attended the book launch and made a small donation on behalf of
the Branch.
98
7.
Presentation by First Bank Life Assurance
7.1
The Chairman called on Mr. Femi Sofola from the insurance arm of First Bank
to make a presentation to the meeting.
7.2
Mr. Femi Sofola spoke about the insurance package that his company is
offering to the Branch as a group. He explained that the policy covers death and
permanent disability, and the premium is as low as =N=2,100 per annum for a
=N=250,000 cover or =N=21,000 per annum for a =N=5,000,000 cover. He
stated that his company is already partnering with some other associations on
behalf of their members.
8.
Announcements
8.1
The Secretary made the following announcements:
8.1.1
G.M. Ibru & Co., hosts a one-day seminar on 'The Law of Defamation' at the
Sheraton Hotel, Ikeja, Lagos at 9.00 am on Tuesday the 13th of November,
2012. The theme of the seminar is: "The Challenges of the Law of Defemation
in the face of Rapid Development in Information and Communication
Technology".
8.1.2
The NBA – Section on Legal Practice holds its 6th Annual General Conference
from the 13th to the 15th of November, 2012 at the Jogor Centre, liberty Road,
Ibadan, Oyo State. The theme of the Conference is "Raising the Bar:
International Best Practices in Legal Practice". The Branch Bus will convey the
first five (5) members who have registered for the conference to and from
Ibadan. Members would however have to make their own arrangements for
accommodation and local transportation.
8.1.3
The 5th Edition of the SPA Ajibade Annual Business Luncheon holds at 11.00
am on Thursday the 22nd of November, 2012 at the La Scala Restaurant,
MUSON Centre, Onikan, Lagos. Hon. Justice Aloma Mukhtar GCON, the
Chief Justice of Nigeria has agreed to chair the luncheon. Prof. Fidelis Oditah
QC SAN (a member of the Branch) would speak on the theme 'The Future of
Legal Practice in Nigeria – Specialization and the Barrister-Solicitor Divide',
followed by a panel of four distinguished discussants.
8.1.4
The Nigerian Maritime Law Association holds its 2012 Annual General
Meeting and Lecture from Friday 23rd to Sunday 25th November, 2012 at the
Whispering Palms, Badagry, Lagos.
8.1.5
The 2nd Conference of the Travel, Tourism and Hospitality Committee of the
NBA-Section on Business Law will hold at The Moorhouse Hotel, No. 1,
Bankole Oki Road, Ikoyi, Lagos on the 29th of November, 2012 with the theme
"Hospitality Development in Emerging Markets: Legal Aspects, Trends,
Prospects and Challenges".
8.1.6
The NBA-National Executive Committee Meeting will hold from Wednesday
28th – Friday 30th November, 2012 at the Nelrose Hotel, Government House
Road, Asaba, Delta State.
9.
Any Other Business
9.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committee nominated some
99
members to represent the Branch at the House of Representatives Peoples'
Public Session on the Review of the 1999 Constitution which held on Saturday
the 10th of November, 2012. He read out the names of the members and stated
that some had already sent in their reports which would be collated and
presented to the house at a subsequent date.
9.2
He thanked all the members who accepted the assignment to represent the
Branch (and particularly mentioned Mr. Zik Obi II) – noting that they were
called at very short notice and responded quickly to the call of duty.
9.3
The Chairman read out a letter of thanks from a member of the Branch – Mrs.
Evelyn Agu – whose car (with an NBA sticker) was seized by the NBA Nnewi
Branch/ Central police Station, Nnewi, whilst being driven by her brother. He
commented that it is becoming a matter of embarassment that non-lawyers now
put NBA stickers on their cars.
9.4
Mr. Chidi Ezeikpe sought the permission of the Chairman to make an
announcement about a forthcoming Chess Tournament.
9.5
Pa. Tunji Gomez complained about the attitude of the Sheriffs and asked about
the committees that were set up. He added that the Ikeja Branch had set up a
committee to look into the issue and the Lagos Branch should not be lagging
behind.
9.6
In reply, the Chairman reiterated that several announcements had been made for
people with complaints about Court staff to make a formal complaint at the Bar
Centre and give details, but there had not been any response.
9.7
Mr. Afro Fayokun suggested that the Branch look at the new Lagos State
Traffic Law which, in his view, appears a bit harsh. He stated that the sanctions
in the law on 'okada' riders are even harsher than those for trailer drivers. He
suggested that the Executive Committee set up a committee to look into the law.
9.8
Alhaji M.U. Ibrahim advised that the Branch should be close to the State House
of Assembly so that we can make our input at the point of consideration of a bill
and before it becomes law.
9.9
The Chairman opined that there are so many views to the new Lagos State
Traffic Law. He expressed his own view that the state of anarchy on our roads
warrants a law but it should not be so draconian. He set up a committee
comprising Mr. Linus Idu as chairman and Messrs. Abioye Akerele, Sam Etaifo
and Chinyere Uhegbu to look into the new law and advise the Branch.
9.10
Mr. Bisi Iyaniwura suggested that the Branch should have a standing committee
that would regularly relate with the National and State legislatures to ensure that
we have an input in the legislative process instead of reacting to laws after they
have been passed.
10.
Cutting of the Cake
10.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in November to come forward for the cutting of the
cake. Senator Onyeabo Obi (who will be 74 next week) and several others
including Mrs. Rose Agbo, Mr. Bisi Iyaniwura, Mrs. Chinyere Uhegbu, Mrs.
Marian Jones, and Mr. Obidi Alajuronye came out to mark one anniversary or
100
the other.
10.2
The Chairman invited Alhaji M. U. Ibrahim to supervise the cutting of the cake.
11.
Closing
11.1
Mr. Gbolahan Gbadamosi moved for adjournment and was seconded by Mrs.
Chinyere Uhegbu.
11.2
Mr. Linus Idu said the closing prayer.
11.3
The meeting ended at 3.50 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 10TH DECEMBER, 2012 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5.
Marian N. Jones
6.
Philips Njeteneh
7.
Omohafe T. Opara
8.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9.
Chinedu Nduka
10.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
11.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
12.
Amaka Aneke
13.
Anthony Atata
14.
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex Officio
Members
1.
Hairat A. Balogun OON
3.
Akin Osinbajo
5.
Funke Adekoya SAN
7.
Tunji Gomez
9.
Dayo Onakoya
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN
S.B. Onu
Olufemi A. Daramola
Emenike Mbanugo
1.2
101
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
Promise Gabriel Asikpo
Ikechukwu Odoemelam
A.O. Fayokun
Dennis O. Akhagba
Okechukwu Ubah
Agbana Aribake F.
Adetola Adeleke
Paul Omoijiade
A.S. Abimbola
Edwin Madubuofu
A.U. Chilaka
Sylvanus Efidi
Nwana E. Chuks
A.A. Osara
Ngozi Nwangwa
Adekunle E. Alabi
Ugochukwu Ezeaba
Solomon Balogun
Anthonia Eke
Chief Wale Taiwo
David Duvwode
Augustine Egwuatu
Eric Ikwele
Joyce Oduah
Charles C. Igwe
Lawrence Austine-Coleman
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Grace O. Elueso
D.O. Botoku
Akinwonmi Oluwaseun
J.A. Ugese
Oyeyipo James Ibukun
Victor A. Williams
Zik C. Obi II
Uche Ikwueme
Shina Balogun
Silva Ugo Osuji
D.N.S Torbari
Paul C. Onwuamaegbu
Nelson C. Onyejaka
Precious Akhanolu
Greg Otsu
F.A. Dogbajale
Odigboh Terry U
Obokohwo Ojogun
Jinadu F.B.
Patrick N. Iheonu
Umeh C.S
Chinyere Uhegbu
Olaide Benjamin
Ojeladun Olatunde John
Ologun Moses O.
Obagwu Frederick Ajefu
Folasade Raji
Greg Okafor
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62.
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
102
Etta Ojong Okongor
Kingsley I. Okoro
Shakirudeen Dauda
Obasi Chinyere
O.Cheetham-West
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Odupitan Julius A.O
Lucy Ahaneku
Abiye Tam-George
L.A. Idu
Faud Adebisi Onafuye
Animashaun Bola
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Mosope O. Fagbongbe
Ologwu Moses O.
Geraldine Wey
Funmi Dosunmu
R.F. Okunola
Kareem T.
Uchenna Nwadialo
Abimbola Fatoki
John Duru
J.O. Shaba
Okenna Nnebedun
Ugochukwu Okany
Aluba J. Orji
Olufade Kafayat M.
Egere Christy
Adeola Saba
A.O. Lema
Jane F. Uzomah
Emmanuel Umoren
Celestine Nwankwo
Okonkwo T.N.T
Anthony Nwogbe
Olusola Adegbonmire
Aghaonu Chris
T.O Ibas
Adebiyi Adewole
O.C.K. Unegbu
Rose Dikeocha
Opeyemi Dada
O.E Onaiwu
Hannibal Uwaifo
Oyewo A.B.
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
G. Gloria Ireka
Taiwo Adamson
Anne Aimua
Omuna Amadi Nsirim D.C
Martins Inyang
Fidelis Ijege Akra
Francis Olayemi Babaoye
Okeke Afam O.
Stephen Obajaja
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
1.3
Olumayowa Oluwole
Emeka Opara
Rose Agbo
H.I.C. Ogbolu
Ifelowo Emmanuel
Okonkwo Nkiruka
Kayode A. Odumosu
Anire Kanyi
Seye Apera
Uchenna N. Ezeokeke
Ukandu Ifeoma
Okechukwu Ifeanyi J.
Sylvester Ekwueme
Chief R.A. O. Oriade
Bode Omoboriowo
Rosalind Clomavi
Lawal M. Gbola
Ferguson Chioma
Olubudu, S.B
Maduagwu R.C
Okechukwu Akunyili
Etiti Ernest O.
Chris Okani
Henry O.Ezeanyim
Tochukwu Godwin Ukogu
Clifford O. Atakere
Nelly Egwuagwu
Daranijo Rasheedat
Ohuaka Nwokedi O.
Ikhalea Augustine
Mindia Yahaya Chiwar
Apologies
1.
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
3.
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
5.
Abimbola Akeredolu
7.
Toyin Bashorun
9.
Mrs. Philomena Omorodion
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
Olukosi Adefola
Oluwafemi E. Adeniyi
Nwolisa Maximus Chike
Stella Ugboma
Olagbade Benson
Priscillia Ohaji Echegu
Gogo Karibi-Whyte
W.A. Gbadebo
Harrison Emmanuel
Chukwuma Ezeala
Babatola Apata
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
Sumi O. Ahonsi
Sessi Akojenu
Stephen Amalla
Ogo Onyia
Marcus Eyarhono
Osunkoya Oyewole
Akande I.O.G
Patrick Onoabhagse
Yemi Okewoye
Nasir Salau
I.O. Abdulhameed
Kaduru Chikezie D.
Emmanuel Godspower
Temitayo Kareem
Pepple Ihuoma
Ogundipe-Peters Victoria
Kehinde Bashiru
L. Adebowale Omar
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Prof. Bankole Sodipo
Boma Ozobia
Supo Olaibi
Mrs. Ijeoma Okeke
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.05 pm with an opening prayer by Mrs. Abiye TamGeorge.
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting noting that it is the last
meeting for the year.
3.
Minutes of Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
on the 12th of November, 2012.
103
3.2
Corrections were made to paragraphs 3.5 and 5.6.3 of the minutes, after which
Prince A.S. Abimbola moved for adoption of the minutes and Chuks Uwana
seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accomodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that a meeting was held with the Chief Judge of Lagos
State who has directed that the Chief Registrar identify a space for us within the
premises of the Lagos High Court.
4.1.2
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN suggested that the Branch consider using the space
presently occupied by the High Court Canteen. He stated that the present
structure can be demolished and rebuilt in such a way that the canteen would be
on the ground floor whilst we have our Branch secretariat and offices on the
second and third floors.
4.1.3
Mrs. H.A. Balogun stated that the judiciary has to give us space within the
Court premises - we can mention it to them but we cannot take it as of right.
4.1.4
The Chairman confirmed that shortly after the present administration assumed
office we had gone round and actually considered the canteen space. He added
that since everything belongs to the judiciary we must liaise with the judiciary
for available space.
4.2
Lekki Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that we are in the process of paying for the arrears of land
charges. He added that we also need to pay the Architect and Consultants for
the work done so far, and need to ensure that it is done in such a way as not to
affect the finances of the Branch.
4.3
Law Week Committee Report
4.3.1
The Chairman confirmed that the report had been submited to him by the
Committee chairman – Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo. Unfortunately, he travelled out
for a while and the Executive Committee had not been able to consider the
report. He apologised for the delay and assured that the report would be
presented at the next meeting.
4.4
Audited Accounts
4.4.1
The Chairman confirmed that the Auditors are concluding the review of the
2011/2012 audited accounts.
4.5
Branch Patrons
4.5.1
The Chairman confirmed that the Executive Committee is looking at the matter
again to ensure that everything is done in accordance with the Bye-Laws of the
Branch.
5.
2012 Branch Bar Dinner
5.1
The Chairman invited the chairman of the 2012 Branch Dinner Committee to
104
give a report on the plans for the dinner.
5.2
Mr. Gogo Karibi-Whyte gave a brief presentation on the Branch Bar Dinner
coming up on Wednesday 12th December, 2012. He noted that arrangements
had been made for buses to convey members from the Lagos High Court
premises to the dinner venue and back at the end of the dinner.
6.
Reports
6.1
NBA-NEC November Meeting
6.1.1
The Secretary presented a written report on the NBA National Executive
Comittee meeting which held from the 28th to 30th of November, 2012 at
Asaba, Delta State.
6.1.2
S.B. Onu moved for adoption of the Report and Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu seconded.
The meeting adopted the Report.
6.2
Bar-Bench Forum Report
6.2.1
The Secretary presented a written report on the December 2012 Bar-Bench
Forum which held at the instance of the Chief Judge of the Lagos High Court on
the 4th of December, 2012.
6.2.2
Mrs. Stella Ugbomah moved for adoption of the Report and Gbolahan
Gbadamosi seconded. The Report was adopted for discussion.
6.2.3
The Chairman noted that we had agreed at our meeting that people who have
complaints about sheriffs or other court officials should put their complaints in
writing in a register at the bar centre. He stated that no complaint has been
received from any member of the Branch.
6.2.4
Responding to a suggestion by Chukwumah Ezeala that members could be
encouraged to send in complaints by electronic mail, the Chairman confirmed
that complaints could be sent in to the Branch email address:
'nbalagos@yahoo.com'.
6.2.5
Responding to a further comment, the Chairman noted that the Branch has a
representative on the Public Complaints and Training Committee (Mrs.
Abimbola Akeredolu) to which complaints against any magistrates can be
directed.
7.
Announcements
7.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that Chief Badru Olaogun Life Bencher
would be 80 years old on the 31st of December, 2012, and had invited all
members of the Branch to a double celebration of life at 80 and presentation of
his autobiography 'My Life of Law ... This is My Story' scheduled for the
Greetings Hall of the Yoruba Tennis Club at 10.00 am on Monday the 31st of
December, 2012.
7.2
The Chiarman mentioned that he is sure everyone is concerned about children's
rights because children are being abused more these days. He stated that a
member of the Branch – Mrs Abiye Tam-George – has a Non-Governmental
Organisation that is focused on children and has put together a book on
105
'Children's Rights' which sells for only =N=500. He suggested that the Branch
(as part of our social responsiblity) should purchase a number of copies and
distribute to various schools on the Island.
7.3
The Chairman informed the meeting that the State Attorney-General's office has
constituted a Committee to look into pro-bono practice, and how it can be
enhanced. He stated that the report of the Committee would soon be publicised
and the Branch would ensure that a Pro-Bono Desk is established once the
Branch Secretariat is up and running.
7.4
The Secretary announced the invitation from the Lagos State Government to a
'Stakeholders' Summit on Land Documentation Regulations' on Tuesday the
11th of December, 2012 at 1.30pm at the Adeyemi Bero Auditorium, AlausaIkeja, Lagos.
7.5
The Secretary announced an invitation from Chief Bolaji Ayorinde SAN (the
Chairman of the Board of the Legal Aid Council) to a Book Presentation in his
honour on Wednesday the 12th of December, 2012 at 4.00 pm at the
Metropolitan Club, Kofo Abayomi Street, Victoria Island, Lagos. He stated that
the event would be chaired by Hon. Justice Adesola Oguntade CON, JSC, with
Chief Wole Olanipekun SAN OFR as the Chief Presenter.
8.
Any Other Business
8.1
Pa Tunji Gomez complained passionately about the astronomical increase of
over 500% in the annual bar practice fee. He noted that the proposal was not
discussed at the branch level and is unacceptable. He proposed a motion that the
Branch reject the arbitrary increase becasue we were not consulted before the
decision was taken, and argued that Lawyers must have an input into the
practice fee as the juniors will not be able to pay the increased fee.
8.2
The Chairman confirmed that at the NBA-NEC meeting in Asaba, Delta State in
November, 2012, he had informed NBA-NEC that the Lagos Branch did not
accept the increase and that the NBA would need to revert to us by 31st
December 2012 on the issue otherwise members of the Branch would not pay.
He added that the NBA President infomed the NEC meeting that the General
Council of the Bar would meet on the 14th of December, 2012 to consider and
review the position.
8.3
Hannibal Uwaifo seconded the motion, which was approved by the meeting.
8.4
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN addressed the meeting and advised that the General
Council of the Bar would be meeting on Friday 14th December, 2012 and the
decision of the Branch should be conveyed formally in writing to the Council
before the meeting so that it can be considered at the meeting.
8.5
The meeting agreed with the suggestion and the Chairman undertook to
personally convey a letter to that effect to the General Council of the Bar.
8.6
Chief Olufemi Daramola directed the attention of the Branch Human Rights
Committee to a 'concentration camp' at the back of the State Secretariat at
Alausa, Ikeja. He stated that there is a magistrate court there but the extent of
inhuman and degrading treatment being meted out to people accused of sundry
offences is horrific.
106
8.7
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN informed the meeting that she met with the new
Presiding Judge of the Lagos Division of the Court of Appeal who is interested
in enhancing the appellate delivery process. The Presiding Judge informed her
that she had been round the court and spoken with various officers who assured
her that there is no problem, but she wants to hear from the bar. Mrs. Adekoya
SAN suggested that the Branch urgently put together a position paper
(articulated by those members who are active in the Court of Appeal) indicating
what the problems are.
8.8
The Chairman requested Chief Emeka Ngige SAN to kindly prepare the
position paper to the Court of Appeal on behalf of the Branch. He invited
interested members to send in their comments and complaints to Chief Ngige
SAN either by electronic or surface mail at: 'ngigelawfirm@gmail.com', or No
84 Lewis Street, 2nd Floor, Lafiaji, Lagos, by Friday 14th December, 2012.
8.9
Mrs. Aroyewun of the Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse ('LMDC') came to inform
the meeting of the implementation of the new High Court Rules which will start
on the 31st of December, 2012. She explained that every originating process
must be accompanied by a pre-action protocol that the applicant has tried to
resolve the dispute by alternative dispute resolution ('ADR'), and all suits would
be screened and if deemed suitable for ADR would be referred to the LMDC.
She added that the LMDC would be organising a free ADR-Track Workshop to
explain ADR and the ADR-Track process on the 24th of January, 2013 at the
LMDC from 10.00 am to 2.00 pm, and invited members of the Branch to take
advantage of proximity and attend.
8.10
The Chairman thanked Mrs. Aroyewun for her presentation and enjoined the
LMDC to consider using a much bigger venue such as the High Court Foyer as
the LMDC has very limited space which cannot contain the number of lawyers
that would be interested in attending the workshop.
8.11
Responding to a question by Mr. Fayokun regading the reported closure of the
Victoria Island, Lagos Office of the NBA National Secretariat, Mrs. Joyce
Oduah (the National Treasurer) confirmed that the office was shut down
temporarily because of the huge rent, but would be re-opened in a few months
when the new NBA Building at Adeola Hopewell is completed.
8.12
Mrs. Joyce Oduah also informed the meeting of new innovations in the NBA
National Treasury. She mentioned that every branch of the NBA has been given
a branch code which should be stated on the bank teller when paying bar
practice fees to enable the NBA National Secretariat track payments from the
branches. She stated that the branch code for Lagos Branch is 058. She added
that members would also be able to pay online, and would be able to generate or
receive a receipt from the Bank upon making payment.
8.13
Responding to a comment by Mrs. Bola Animashaun that the Branch should
have a website and official email address and not just a 'yahoomail' acccount,
the Chairman confirmed that the Branch has a web-site 'www.nbalagos.org'
which is already up and would soon be fully functional.
9.
Cutting of the Cake
9.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that a former Branch Chairman - Sir
Emmanuel Ofulue - turned 76 years on Saturday the 8th of December, 2012.
107
9.2
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in December to come forward for the cutting of the
cake. About 17 members came out to mark one anniversary or the other,
including: Mrs. Stella Ugbomah, Chief Ademola Sadipe, Mr. Dayo Onakoya,
Prince A.S. Abimbola, Mrs. Bola Animashaun, Mrs. Rose Agbo, Joyce Oduah,
Anthonia Eke, and Charles Ola-Oni.
9.3
The Chairman invited Mr. Akin Osinbajo (former Attorney-General of Ogun
State) to supervise the cutting of the cake.
10.
Closing
10.1
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo moved for adjournment and by Mr.Zik Obi II seconded.
10.2
Mrs. Joyce Oduah said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 2.40 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 14TH JANUARY, 2013 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5.
Marian N. Jones
6.
Philip O. Njeteneh
7.
Omohafe T. Opara
8.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9.
Chinedu N. Nduka
10.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
11.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
12.
Amaka I. Aneke
13.
Anthony O. Atata
14.
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
1.2
-
Members
1.
Olasupo Olaibi
3.
Odupitan, Julius A.O.
5.
Funke Adekoya SAN
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex Officio
2)
4)
6)
108
Hannibal Uwaifo
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN
A. J. Owonikoko SAN
7.
9.
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
Zik Obi II
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
Dayo Onakoya
A.O. Fayokun
Hariat A. Balogun
Uwensuyi Edosomwan SAN
Tunji Gomez
Joyce Oduah (Mrs)
Aghaonu Chris
Obagwu Frederick Ajefu
Chief Wale Taiwo
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Afam Okeke
Oyinkan A. Bello
Ike Uko
Akra Fidelis
Victor Aramide
Clifford O. Atakere
Anichebe Chioma Stella
Rosalind Clomavi
Nweke A. Ojo
Iheoma Osimiri
Frances O. Babaoye
Okechukwu Ifeanyi
Olagbani Oladipo
S.B. Onu
Ada Mbama
Charles Nneji
Emmanuel Orhoro
Marcus Eyarhowo
Obiora Atuegwu Egwuatu
John Ayeni
Ogundipe-Peters Victoria
Agbana Aribake F.
B.A. Ayeni
Chidi Kechi Oduji
Emmanuel Dangana
Promise Gabriel Asikpo
Anthonia Eke
Tunde Busari
Oluyemi Adewale
Uwala E. Murphy-Akpieyi (Mrs)
Uchenna N. Ezeokeke
Adeleke Yusuff
A.O. Okpalanozie
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
M.F. Thomas
Dennis O. Akhagba
Nelson Ogbuanya
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Joy O. Nzube Uheghelu
Bashua Ibraheem
Michael Akpan
Yetunde Bashiru
Unah Niome Yvette
109
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
Okey Akunyili
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Olufemi A. Daramola
Toyin Bashorun
Stella Ugboma (Mrs)
Emmanuel Ofulue
O. Akinniranye (Mrs)
Awobona Olumide
Nwana E. Chuks
Okongor Etta
Fred Onyeka
Kareem T.M
Ibas Theresa O.
Adebiyi Adewole
Atunwa Omowunmi
Onatibigha Samuel
A.O. Lema
T.Y. Iorse-Sherirfs
Sandy Diana
Kayode Odumosu
Bunmi Ibrahim
Oyeyipo J. Ibukun
Emeka Opara
Botoku Femi
T.O. Chukwumerije
O.C.K. Unegbu
Funso A. Dogbajale
Okechukwu Ubah
Duvwode David
Bob C. O Ijioma
Omuna-Amadi Nsirim
Wale Adesokan
Uchenna Nwadialo
Busola Asiwajie
Oyagha Michael
Irase I. Ohiokpahai
Otse Somine F.
Olusola Adegbonmire
Emmanuel Ezenachukwu
Funke Jagun
Okoroji Chidi
Fidelis Egho
John Onyeakpa
Olushola Keshinro
Kamar Raji
Arubaleze Kenechukwu
Adenike Komolafe
Bode Omoboriowo
Lanre Gina-Osagie
Okonkwo T.N.T
Lukman Agbola
Tegah Ojo (Mrs)
Jide Akerele
Ozioma Cynthia Ukawoko
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
Abiodun Aikomo
Kaduru, C.D
Kassim Moses
Okala O. Uche
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Okoro C.J
Abimbola Fatoki
Obi Okwusogu SAN
Ugbeye E. Solomon
Nelson Fadeni
D.N.S Torbari
Kingsley Ugoagha
Folasade Raji
Onyekachi C. Uko
Paul E. Okoli
Udoji Andy Nzube
O.N.O Nkpubre (Mrs)
Iyaniwura Adebisi L.
Babatola Apata
E.A. Otokhina
Jude Uche Mbaeri
Joshua Yisa
Lucy Udoh
Adekunle Oyesanya SAN
Lucy Ahaneku
Obiajuru Chinyere
A.M. Makinde
Ada Udonsi (Mrs)
Ngozi Akandu
Olajide Benjamin
Emeka-Iloegbunam Gerty
Martins Inyang
Williams Anthony Kehinde
Lawal K.S
Emenike Mbanugo
Naami Abdul
K. Oduntan
Onuoha N.O
Oputa Jude
Ngozi Okeke
Dom Okpala
Abioye Akerele
James Asomugha
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs)
Emmanuel Umoren
Ike C. Ibeku
Umeh C.S
Segun Fowowe
Igwe C.C.
Silas Momoh
N.C. Ukwuomah
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli
Onifade Kafayat
Dele Thomas-Orogan
Ogo Onyia
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
110
Patience Onoashagse
Onaiwu E. Omoroagbe
Harrison Emmanuel
Stephen Amalla
Vera Obi-Ijiomah
Nwankwo Ngozi
Agu R. Nnaemeka
Ebere Nwokoro
Silva Ugo Osuji
Ijeoma Nkuche
Solomon Balogun
Jimoh Saka Agaka
Olalekan Idowu
Shobamowo Gbolahan J.
Abiye Tam-George
Chike Odezugo
L.A. Idu
Sharafa Olaitan
Olutayo Arojo
Biriyai Dambo
Patrick N. Iheonu
B. Popoola Mordi
Obiageli Eze
Rose Agbo
W.A. Gbadebo
Patricia Ese
Chukwuma Ezeala
Akande Olutoba I
Augustine Egwuatu
Ikechukwu Odoemelam
Ologwu Moses Ogbonna
Oluwatoyin Bashorun
Chinyere Uhegbu
Adeniyi Oluwafemi E.
Uduak Bhavnaani
Abimbola Faloye
Idedia Sandra
Adekunle Adesanya
Kolade Olutekunbi
John Duru
Innocent N.O. Okoro
Joy Idiakheua-Ikhine
Ejike Okeke
Mindia Yahaya Chiwar
David Umoru
Tony Ezeani
Rotimi Aladesanmi
Hilary N. Umah
Adebayo Oriola
R.C. Maduagwu
Maximus C. Nwolisa
Sule M. Damian
Chijioke Okoli
Okereke Obinna N.C.
Uche Obiorah
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
279.
281
1.3
Ojuade Olabisi
Ezemegbu Loveline
Celestine Nwankwo
Ikenna Onwusika
Andrew Ojochogwu Ameh
Anozie Awambu
Jude Ogbodo
Jamilu Habu Bashir
Oluwole Okelana
Wingate, Emmanuel
Abikan Ibrahim
Ifeanyi Ilukwe
Kachi Ihesiulo
Adamu Ahmed Sa’ad
Ronke Sijuwade
Alfred I. Uwaka
Ekpo Egadano
Agu, Evelyn C.
Elias A.
Mike Idowu
Adaobi Agu
Funmi Obisan
Omotayo Oriosun
Oluwafemi Olayinka
Ekott U. J
Nwachukwu O.
Bola Animashaun
Sylvester Ekwueme
Apologies
1.
Boma Ozobia
3.
Olatunde Daudu
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
278)
280)
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Tony Okwesa
Olaide Odetobi
Edward Porbeni
Olabode Oteniye
Olabode Olaosibikan
Chinyere Obasi
Ogbonnaya Uko
Charles Musa
Muyiwa Abe
George Nwabunike
Kelvin Ojukwu
Constance Igbrude
Layi Arikewuyo
Uche Stan Obi
Jude Igbanoi
Oshodi Olushola
Theodore Jnr. Ezeobi
Owhofowhoraye Stephen
Olugbenga Fabilola
N.O. Balogun
W. Ekundayo
Dime Agbuire
Boye Bajulaiye
Esther Modo
Okey Eneh
Yamta Yusuf Ali
2)
Abimbola Akeredolu
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.13 pm with an opening prayer by Mr. D. O. Botoku.
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members to the first Branch meeting of the year.
3.
Minutes of Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
on the 10th of December, 2012.
3.2
No corrections were made to the minutes. Mrs. Bunmi Ibraheem, however,
complained that her name appeared to have been omitted from the minutes.
3.3
Chief Wale Taiwo moved for adoption of the minutes and Mrs. H.A. Balogun
seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accomodation
111
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that he spoke with the Chief Registrar of the Lagos
High Court who confirmed that the Chief Judge has directed him (the Chief
Registrar) to identify a space for us within the premises of the Lagos High
Court.
4.1.2
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN suggested that the Branch consider using the space
presently occupied by the High Court Canteen. He stated that the present
structure can be demolished and re-built in such a way that the canteen would
be on the ground floor whilst we have our Branch Secretariat and offices on the
second and third floors.
4.1.3
Mrs. H.A. Balogun stated that the Judiciary has to give us space within the
Court premises - we can mention it to them but we cannot take it as of right.
4.1.4
The Chairman confirmed that shortly after his administration assumed office we
had gone round and actually considered the canteen space. He added that since
everything belongs to the Judiciary we must liaise with the Judiciary for
available space.
4.2
Lekki Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that we are in the process of paying for the arrears of land
charges. He added that we also need to pay the Architect and Consultants for
the work done so far, and need to ensure that it is done in such a way as not to
affect the finances of the Branch.
4.3
Law Week Committee Report
4.3.1
Mr. Hannibal Uwaifo presented the 2012 Law Week Committee Report. He
ended with an announcement that photographs and the video album for the law
week are ready.
4.3.2
Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko SAN moved for adoption of the Report, and Chief
Ademola Sadipe seconded.
4.3.3
The Chairman called for comments.
4.3.4
Pa. Tunji Gomez congratulated the committee for doing a good job. He added,
however, that members pay dues to the Branch and appear to get nothing for it.
He suggested that junior lawyers who want to attend Branch events should be
given a special dispensation. He also suggested that members who have served
the Association for a number of years should be recognised and invited to attend
events.
4.3.5
Mrs. Stella Ugbomah commended the committee for a job well done, noting
that the law week was well planned and implemented. She complained,
however, that the flasks and other souvenir items did not go round, and stated
that there should have been enough to go round to every delegate.
4.3.6
Mr. Afro Fayokun joined in commending the committee for a job well done. He
noted that we are trying to move forward and we should consider having lunch
events in between bar dinners as dinners tend to be few, far between and late in
the day and so older members of the Branch are not able to attend. He recalled
that in past years, lunches used to hold regularly at the law school dining hall
and were sometimes combined with lectures etc.
112
4.3.7
Speaking further, Mr. Afro Fayokun expressed some concern on the insistence
on black-tie dinners. He wondered whether we are progressing or retrogressing,
and asked why people cannot attend dinners in national dress. He suggested that
members should be encouraged to attend dinners in national dress.
4.3.8
Following murmurs of assent with the suggestion, the Chairman put the issue to
the vote and it was generally agreed that at dinners members may come in
black-tie or full national/ traditional dress.
4.3.9
Following a suggestion by Chief Emeka Ngige SAN, the meeting directed the
Law Week Committee to upload the photographs and video to the Branch
website.
4.4
2012 Branch Bar Dinner Report
4.4.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that the 2012 Branch Bar Dinner
Committee Report is not yet ready.
4.5
Audited Accounts
4.5.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that the Branch Audit Committee is still
working on the review of the accounts.
4.6
Branch Patrons
4.6.1
Referring to the issue raised by Mr. Afro Fayokun at the November, 2012
Branch Monthly Meeting regarding the legality of appointing Branch Patrons
when the Bye-Laws do not provide for the position, the Chairman confirmed
that the matter of appointment of Branch Patrons has been rested.
4.6.2
Mr. S.B. Onu (the immediate past Branch Secretary) reminded the meeting that
the decision to appoint Branch Patrons was taken at an Annual General
Meeting, and stated that it was doubtful if a Monthly General Meeting can
upturn a decision of the Annual General Meeting.
4.6.3
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN informed the meeting that a branch of the NBA had
amended its bye-laws to include Branch Patrons and this was rejected by the
National body as branch bye-laws must conform with the National Constitution
and the National Constitution does not make provision for patrons.
4.6.4
In response to a question by Chief Emeka Ngige SAN about the status of the
amendment of the Branch Bye-Laws, the Chairman reported that a small
committee headed by Mr. Zik Obi II is working on a review and once the draft
is ready it would be presented to the general meeting for ratifictaion.
4.7
Bar Practice Fees
4.7.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that a circular had been circulated by the
NBA National Secretariat reducing the increased bar practice fees by 50%. He
noted that a decision was taken by the Branch in December before the reduction
and meanwhile some of lawyers had gone to court to challenge the increased
fee. He sought the position of members regarding the reduced fees noting that
there is deadline for payment of the Bar Practice Fees and consequences for
non-payment.
113
4.7.2
In response to a request by Mr. Afro Fayokun, the Chairman read out the old
fees in effect as at January, 2012, the increased fees announced in April 2012,
and the reduced fees announced in December, 2012.
4.7.3
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN proposed that since the reviewed Bar Practice Fees
would translate to an increase in the purse of the association, the Lagos Branch
should accept the reduction in good faith and lead the call for an increase in the
percentage of the Bar Practice Fee that is allocated to the branches.
4.7.4
Mrs. Uche Ikwueme expressed a contrary view. She insisted that a 50% increase
over the old fees at the most would have sufficed. She noted that members do
not enjoy anythng from the NBA National despite payment of practice fee. Mr.
Bisi Iyaniwura on his part suggested that an increase of not more than 100% of
the old fees would have been acceptable.
4.7.5
Mr. Ike Uko stated that he is opposed to the increase. He argued that the
National body is not doing enough work, and ought to reach out to more
lawyers who are presently not paying their practice fees rather than overburdening those who are already paying. He suggested that the Premier Branch
show leadership by advising the National body on how to generate funds
without over-burdening lawyers.
4.7.6
Pa. Tunji Gomez stated that he is strongly opposed to the increase as the Bar
Council has no authority to increase the Bar Practice Fees. He argued that
members should refuse to abide the increase, and stated that whilst senior
lawyers could afford to pay the increased fee a lot of young lawyers would be
impoverished by it.
4.7.7
The Chairman stated that he had just been informed by the 2nd Vice-Chairman
(who is one of the Plaintiffs in the court action filed to challenge the increased
fees) that there is a motion for injunction filed in the suit and the matter is
therefore sub-judice. He added that at the last NBA-NEC Meeting in Asaba, the
NBA President had announced an increase in the percentage of allocation of Bar
Practice Fees to branches - rom 10% to 15%.
4.7.8
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN stated that he had refrained from making comments
on the issue because of his position during his NBA presidential election
campaign when he had advocated complete reversal of the increase. He noted
that apart from Lagos, there were lawyers in other states who are in very dire
straits and cannot afford to pay an increased fee. He suggested that to avoid
being caught by the payment deadline and the implication of non-payment, and
in the light of the suit, a pragmatic solution is to pay the fee now without
prejudice to the suit and if the court nullifies the increase then any excess sum
paid can be credited to future payments.
4.7.9
In response to a suggestion by Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu that we should pay the old
rate now and if we lose the law suit then we can pay the difference later, the
Chairman gave a point of information that the banks would not accept any
payment based on the old rate.
4.7.10 In response to a request from Ms. Toyin Bashorun for details of the Suit No and
names of the parties to the law suit (so that members who were interested can
follow the case), the Chairman noted that although he was informed that he was
named a Defendant to the suit he had not been served with the processes and so
114
does not have the information.
4.7.11 The meeting deferred further discussion on the issue to the February, 2013
Branch Meeting.
4.8
Position Paper to Court of Appeal
4.8.1
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN reported that a call was put out for memoranda from
members but he had not received any. He confirmed that he is working on the
position paper, and appealed to members who have any input to send same to
him quickly as he has until next week to turn in his Report to the Branch
Executive Committee for onward submission to the Presiding Judge of the
Court of Appeal, Lagos Division.
5.
Any Other Business
5.1
Report by Mrs. Abimbola Akeredolu
5.1.1
The Chairman read out the report by Mrs. Abimbola Akeredolu who was
nominated to represent the Branch on the Public Complaints and Training
Committee, and conveyed her apology for her unavoidable absence at the
meeting. He urged members to send in their complaints and take advantage of
the committee.
5.2
Branch NEC Representative
5.2.1
The Chairman suggested that going forward the Branch should continue the
practice of appointing the immediate past Chairman as the Branch
Representative to the NBA National Executive Committee. On this basis, he
nominated Mr. Chijioke Okoli (his immediate predecessor-in-office) to replace
Mr. Foluso Fayokun as the Branch NEC Representative.
5.2.2
The meeting approved the nomination, and Mr. Chijioke Okoli accepted the
appointment.
5.3
Welfare Committee
5.3.1
The Chairman noted that members do not appear to take their medical and
health issues very seriously. On this basis, he announced the appointment of Dr.
Timi Austen-Peters, Mrs. Akeredolu, Mrs. Tolani Edu-Adeola, Mr. Bisi
Iyaniwura, Mr. Linus Idu, Mrs. Ngozi Nwangwa, and Mr. Ike Uko as members
of the Branch Welfare Committee.
5.3.2
Responding to a question by Mr. Afro Fayokun about the basis of the welfare
programme and committee, and what would become of the national welfare
programme, the Chairman stated that the Branch Welfare Committee would
consider the national welfare scheme (if any) in the course of their
deliberations.
5.3.3
The Chairman announced further that a committee would be set-up to organise a
workshop on the new Lagos High Court Civil Procedure Rules, and another
committee on the Child Rights Law would also be set up.
5.3.4
The Chairman mentioned that young lawyers come to meetings seeking
employment. He opined that we may need to do background checks on them as
115
he had a bad experience with a young lawyer who stood up at a meeting seeking
employment and he offered her a job in his firm only to have her stop work
without notice or reason.
6.
Announcements
6.1
The Chairman read out a letter of appreciation from Chief Badru Olaogun Life
Bencher thanking the Branch for the moral and financial support at his 80th
birthday and launch of his autobiography. He conveyed the apology of Chief
Olaogun who had wanted to be at the meeting to personally express his thanks.
6.2
The Chairman announced the loss of a member of the Branch Secretariat staff,
Mrs Comfort Edet on Tuesday the 8th of January, 2013 - from complications
following child brith. Members rose to observe a one-minute silence in her
honour.
6.3
The Chairman reported on the passage of the Honourable Justice Mrs. Wasilat
Abisoye Esther Ayo (nee Shitta-Bey) of the Lagos High Court who died from
illness on the 30th of December, 2012 at the age of 47 years. He added that the
Branch Executive Committee paid a condolence visit to the family, and
members of the Branch were present at the funeral programme.
6.4
The Secretary took the other announcements:
6.4.1
Our sister branch – the NBA-Ikeja Branch – has extended an invitation to the
Executive and all members of the Premier Branch to attend the Chief Gani
Fawehinmi Annual Lecture on Tuesday the 15th of January, 2013 at 10.00 am at
the Airport Hotel, Obafemi Awolowo Way, Ikeja, Lagos. The theme of the
lecture is "Economy, Politics, Human Rights: Wither Nigeria?" with Prof. Chidi
Odinkalu (Chair – National Human Rights Commission) and Mr. Abiodun
Owonikoko SAN as the Guest Lecturers.
6.4.2
The new High Court of Lagos State (Civil Procedure) Rules 2012 came into
force on the 31st of December, 2012. Members should endeavour to obtain
copies of the new Rules and familiarise themselves with the changes. Also, the
Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse is organising a Workshop on the ADR-Screening
aspects of the new Rules on Thursday 17th January, 2013 and Thusday the 24th
January, 2013 at 9.00 am at the LMDC.
6.4.3
The current NBA National Treasurer and an active member of the Branch –
Mrs. Joyce Oduah – was inviting members of the Branch to the funeral
ceremony of her late mother – Deaconess Kate Etim Bassey – who died on the
15th of December, 2012. The Christian wake-Keep/ Service of Songs, Funeral
Service, Interment and Reception would take place in her home-town of Oron,
Akwa Ibom State from the 24th to the 25th of January, 2013.
7.
Cutting of the Cake
7.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in January to come forward for the cutting of the
cake.
7.2
Some members came out to mark one anniversary or the other, including:
Messrs. Kazeem, Gbolahan Gbadamosi, D.N.S Torbari, and Emmanuel Orhoro.
116
7.3
The Chairman invited Mr. S.B. Onu to supervise the cutting of the cake.
8.
Closing
8.1
Mrs. Stella Ugbomah moved for adjournment and Ms. Toyin Bashorun
seconded.
8.2
Mrs. Uche Ikueme said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 3.00 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 11TH FEBRUARY, 2013 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5.
Marian N. Jones
6.
Philip O. Njeteneh
7.
Omohafe T. Opara
8.
Chinedu N. Nduka
9.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
10.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
11.
Amaka I. Aneke
12.
Anthony O. Atata
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Members
1.
Hairat A. Balogun
3.
Tunji Gomez
5.
Zik C. Obi II
7.
Morenike Obi-Farinde
9.
Omole Olusoji
11.
Adeniji Adenike
13.
Dachomo I. Dachomo
15.
Ajiboye Olatunji
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
G.M. Sasore
Senator Onyeabo Obi
S.B. Onu
Toyin Ogunbambi
Agu Nnaemeka
Babatola Apata
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Shobamowo Gbolahan J.
1.2
117
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
Ugochukwu Ezeaka
Kehinde Bastairu ECP
Christy Egere
Chukwuma Ezeala
Anne Aimua
Onyeagwu Angela Uzoka
Nwana E. Chuks
Adebisi Adedamola
Odupitan, Julius A.O.
Emmanuella C. Ekeanyanwu
Toyin Bashorun
Uwala Murphy-Akpieyi
Rose Agbo
Dr. Ogbai Omo-Eboh
Abiye Tam-George
Hillary Oshomah
Biriyai Dambo
Geff O. Eze
Owolabi Adeniyi Oseni
Gloria Ireka
Kenneth Ahia
M.A. Adewopo
Ngozi Opara
Agu Chikodi Rosary
Anene Nwadukwe
Ifeanyi Ilukwe
Shuaib Alaran
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Maduagwu Remigus
Vivian Okoh-Olutunpese
Mindia Yahaya Chiwar
Gyang Daniel
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Adebayo Olanrewaju
Obiageli Eze
Uzoeghelu-Nzube O. Joy
Dooshima Mayange
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
Adeyinka Adeyemi
Paul E. Okoli
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Raph Amobi Chikezie
Olutayo Arojo
Okey Eneh
Ezioma C. Ukawoko
Okoh Susan Neka
Olusesi Adewale
Ifeanyi Okechukwu
Peter H. Mallong
Ayodele Akintunde
Innocent David
Ladipo Abiola Olaide
Alfred Opeyemi Adekoya
Tayo Tiwo
Noble Uchechukwu
118
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
40)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
Nelson C. Onyejaka
Ijeoma Nkuche
Olorungbemi Samuel O.
Uche Ikwueme
A.M. Makinde
Funmi Obisan
Lawrence Austincoleman O.
Matthew Egbadon
Okorie Paulinus
Funke Adekoya SAN
R.F. Okunola
Hannibal Uwaifo
Mausi Segun
Solomon Afahokor
Kayode Odumosu
Ernest Emezie Orji
Aribake F. Agbana
Anthonia Eke
Okereke Obinna N.C.
Ezemegbu Loveline
Ikenna Okoli
Rose Hamis
Elizabeth Egwu
Aluba J. Orji
Patrick N. Iheonu
Efe Ize-Iyamu
I.O. Abdulhameed
72)
Akunyili Okechukwu Michael
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
Eric Ikwele
Yasir Satay
Emmanuel Umoren
Etiti E.O.
Egbe U. Andelene
Kaduru, Chikezie D.
Oshodi Olushola
Okeke Ejikemeuwa
Chinyere Uhegbu
Amaghiro Chukwuemeka O.
Ekott U.J.
S. Abayomi Oyebola
Chikwendu Ogbonna
Alfred Akinjo
Fidelis Ijege Akra
Nzekwe Judith
Opete A.O.
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli
Olushola Keshinro
Emeka Opara
Irase E. Ohiokpehai
Oluwatoyin Akintunde
Afolabi Esther Moronke
Emeka C. Nwosu
Promise Gabriel Asikpo
Abiodun Adewale
Kayode Ojo
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
Ikoro Joseph
Lapite Olusola E.
Augustine Egwuatu
Ore Moshood A.
Bode Omoboriowo
Emeka Nwadioke
M.J. Onigbanjo
Aderonke Sijuwade
Gboyega Kolade
Aghaonu Chris
Solomon Balogun
T.N.T. Okonkwo
Yemi Ajala
Ugo Ewelaku
Ekwuye Lovely Nkiruka
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
Patience Onoashagse
Austin-Modo Chilo
Marcus Eyarhono
Celestine Nwankwo
Maximus C. Nwolisa
Jamilu Habu Bashir
Ologwu Moses Ogbonna
W.A. Gbadebo
Funmi Obinzu-Dosunmu
Rosalind Clomavi
Kayode Jones
John Duru
Ikhile A. Stella
Olatunji Dawodu
Jide Akerele
Wahab Ekundayo
Biodun Hundeyin
Charles Nneji
Edem O. Uko
Owhofawhoroge Stephen A.
H.O. Ndubuisi
Clifford O. Atakere
Oladipo O. Ajayi
James Okoh
Abimbola Owulade
Francis Nwajei
N.O. Onuoha
Ifeoma Obi
Ofoegbu Spade
Victor O. Usifoh
Arogundade, Olawale
Chidi Kechi Odufi
Adeniyi Oluwafemi E.
Uti Theodore
Umeh, C.J
Ezeanekwe Godwin C.
Ogo Onyia
Precious Akhanolu
Sule M. Danian
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
119
Constance Igbrude
Linda Oladotun A.
Rotimi Ogunjobi
George Nwabunike
Fatoki Abimbola
Owootomo Oluwo
James Edet Edem
Gerty Emeka-Iloegbunam
Odupitan, Julius A.O.
Ugbeye E. Solomon
Silva Ugo Osuji
Olayide Benjamin
Omuwa Amadi Nsirim D.C
Femi D. Ojumu
Oyetomi Goddey E.
Jeffrey Eboh
Taofik Oladipo Elias
S.B. Alli
Sandy Diana
Dennis O. Akhagba
Chinyere Obasi
Martins Inyang
Adekunle Fatokun, Aramide
Mbanugo Udenze
Nonso Ngonadi
Nelson Ogbuanya
Andrew Ohi Enakhifo
Lucy Ahaneku
Patricia O. Asemota
Ogunkunle Olubunmi
Tochukwu Onyiuke
E.A. Otokhina
Ajayi, Jonathan Olusegun
D.N.S. Torbari
Abayomi Begbaji
Anichebe Chioma Stella
Chris A. Ogbobe
Stephen Amalla
Chisanya E. Wagbaranta
Uduak Bhavnaani
Ero Kate E.
M.O. Igbaji Egorp
U.N. Ezeokeke
Kalunta Chimezie
Egbunike E. Onyeka
L.A. Idu
Osunbor L. Adesuwa
Edward Porbeni
Okonkwo Nkiruka
Timi Bukkie
Sylvester Ekwueme
Sunday A. Adesokan
Chris E. Omoru
Afinjuomo Charles
Fidelis Egho
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
1.3
Grace O. Eluebo
Imran A. Agunbiade
Ohuaka Nwokedi
Egeonu Gloria N.
I.Z. Fakunmoju
Lapite Ayoola O.
Njoku Marian C.
Cosmos Chukwuma
Babatunde Adefila
Obiora Egwuatu
Omorodion Philomena
Femi Fajolu
Chief George Nnachor
Uche Emmanuel Obiorah
Oyesanya Olumide
Ngozi Nwankwo
Apologies
1.
Boma Ozobia
3.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
5.
Ogbonnaya C. Agbafo
7.
Olayemi Adewale
9.
Dayo Onakoya
11.
Chief Ademola Sadipe
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262
264)
266)
268)
Animashaun Bola
Margaret Akpoyoware
Ukogu Tochukwu G
O. Cheetham-West
Ruth C. Enudi
M.U. Ibrahim
Tara Aisida
Ferguson Chioma
Uchenna Nwadialo
Adenike Komolafe
Otera Grace
Alumona I.C.
Emmanuel Orhoro
Joseph Ekene Ndibuagu
Enobong Etteh
Okey Ilofulunwa
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
Abioye Akerele
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Joyce Oduah
Olasupo Olaibi
Gbenga Fabilola
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.10 pm with an opening prayer by Mrs Funmi Obisan.
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting.
3.
Minutes of Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
on the 14th of January, 2013.
3.2
Corrections were made to some of the names in paragraph 1.2 of the minutes.
3.3
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde moved for adoption of the minutes as corrected and
Mr. S.B. Onu seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accomodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committtee is still awaiting the
decision of the State Judiciary regarding allocation of a space within the
premises of the Lagos High Court. He added that if nothing concrete happens by
the end of March, a suitable accomodation would be rented in the vicinity of the
Court.
4.2
Lekki Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that the Branch is still in the process of paying for the
120
arrears of land charges. He added that the Executive Committee has not been
able to lay hands on documents relating to the allocation and is working with
officials at the State Secretariat to locate the documents from the Registry File.
4.3
2012 Branch Bar Dinner Report
4.3.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that the 2012 Branch Bar Dinner
Committee Report is still being expected from the committee.
4.4
Audited Accounts
4.4.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that the Branch Audit Committee is still
working on the review of the accounts, and all necessary documents have been
passed over to the committee.
4.5
Bar Practice Fees
4.5.1
The Chairman explained that the court case instituted by some members of the
Branch is pending before the Federal High Court. He was informed that the
matter came up the previous week, the Plaintiffs moved an ex parte application
for some orders and the Trial Judge adjourned his ruling to the 18th of
February, 2013. He concluded that the matter is subjudice so there will be no
discussion on the issue for now.
4.6
Position Paper to Court of Appeal
4.6.1
The Chairman stated that the Executive Committee is awaiting the report from
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN. He noted that people who have been to the Court of
Appeal in the last two or three weeks would have noticed an improvement in the
rate at which the Justices of Appeal are working.
5.
Lawyers' Estate Project
5.1
The Chairman stated that there is an on-going Lawyers' Estate Project being
promoted by Mr. Gboyega Kolade. He invited Mr. Gboyega Kolade to give a
report on the work done so far.
5.2
Mr. Gboyega Kolade stated that the project actually started in 2008, but
previous Branch Chairmen did not appear to understand the vision or were just
not interested. He thanked Mr. Taiwo O. Taiwo for taking it as part of his
regime agenda so that the project can take-off.
5.3
He commented that he had made presentations at a previous Branch meeting
showing the survey of the initial parcel of land. However, because of the delay
in concluding purchase, the landowners broke up the parcel and sold off
portions of the land. He stated that he has now secured a contiguous parcel of
about 1,500 plots near Eleko Beach Junction. He has been discussing with the
landowners and has convinced them to accept a price of =N=550,000 per plot,
with payment within a 300-days period, whilst the common or shared areas
would go for =N=350,000 per plot. He explained that within the first 100-days
interested members would pay =N=250,000 to the coffers of the Branch (for
remittance to the vendors), =N=150,000 would be paid within the next 100
days, and the balance of =N=150,000 would be paid within the last 100-days.
He added that he had negotiated a discounted survey fee of =N=90,000 per plot
(which would cover the cost of the perimeter survey and individual plots).
121
5.4
Continuing with his presentation, Mr. Gboyega Kolade stated that the
landowning family wanted separate fees for the foundation and roofing stages,
but he had negotiated a flat rate of =N=100,000 to cover both. He added that he
had approached the Lagos State Governor to assist with reducing the ratification
fees on the land, and was informed that there is a mortgage scheme that
members can buy into.
5.5
The Chairman thanked Mr. Gboyega Kolade for his report and stated that the
Executive Committee would meet to fine-tune the Report and brief the General
Meeting. He invited comments from members.
5.6
Mrs. Hairat Balogun opined that the meeting had noted the Report and the
Executive Committee would work on it and revert back to the General Meeting.
6.
Presentation by Justice For All Group
6.1
The Chairman invited Mrs. Mausi Segun and Mrs. Funmi Obisan of the 'Justice
For All Group' to make a presentation on the work they have been doing with
the Branch Human Rights Committee.
6.2
Mrs. Mausi Segun explained that she works with the National Human Rights
Commission and is presently working on a 'Duty Solicitors' Project targetted at
identified Police Stations. She stated that there is an on-going pilot scheme at
the Isolo Police Station – with the co-operation of the Divisional Police Officer.
The Project introduced staff training and registers to the Station with a roster for
8 participating law firms and organisations which send in designated lawyers at
any time to check the registers, go into the cells and speak with suspects to
ascertain if there are any rights violations going on. She conceded that the
police officers are not happy about the scheme but have no choice because the
Project has the consent of the Inspector General of Police. She added that a
DPO left the Station because of the scheme, but the policemen there now are
working better.
6.3
Continuing with her presentation, Mrs. Mausi Segun stated that the Project
cannot take on all Police Stations, but the plan is to cover at least one station in
every Police Command in Lagos State within the next one year. She added that
the Project requires the buy-in of lawyers and law firms which can commit to
the scheme and assign a lawyer. She asked volunteer lawyers and law firms to
contact her (on 08023137487 or 08054707559), Mrs. Obisan (on 07063186582
or 07058849208), or Mr. Martin Ogunleye (the Branch 1st Vice Chairman).
6.4
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde commended Mrs. Mausi Segun and Mrs. Funmi
Obisan, and noted that she had seen evidence of the scheme at work. She
volunteered to be part of the scheme.
6.5
The Chairman mentioned that he visited Ikoyi Prison and found over 1,400
'awaitng trial men' as opposed to only about 200 convicted inmates – in a prison
designed to house 800 inmates. He stressed the need for lawyers to take up the
fight on behalf of the oppressed masses.
7.
Report on NBA Peace and Security Summit
7.1
The Chairman presented a report on the NBA Peace and Security Summit which
held in Abuja on the 30th and 31st of January, 2013, with the theme
122
“Comprehensive and Sustainable Peace and Security in a Plural Society:
Extreme Challenges to Nigeria's Internal Security”. The Summit was hosted by
the NBA in a bid 'to identify with and/or contribute to the collective effort at
finding comprehensive and sustainable peace and security in Nigeria'.
7.2
He stated that the Summit had several distinguished persons in attendance
including the Hon. Attorney General and Minister for Justice - Mohammed
Bello Adoke SAN (who represented the President), General Muhammadu
Buhari, a representative of General Abdulsalam Abubakar, Senator Umaru
Dahiru (Chairman, Senate Committee on the Judiciary, who represented the
Senate President), the Chief Justice of Nigeria, Hon. Justice Miriam Aloma
Mukhtar (who chaired the Opening Ceremony), Chief Emeka Anyaoku (former
Secretary General of the Commonwealth who chaired the Showcase Session),
Chief A. K. Horsfall (former Director-General of the SSS - who delivered the
Keynote Address), representatives of the Chief of Defence Staff, Chief of Naval
State, Minister of Federal Capital Territory, the Minister of Interior,
representatives of the Sultan of Sokoto, the Igwe of Onitsha and the Oni of Ife,
many Senior Advocates of Nigeria, top Judicial Officers, members of the
Diplomatic Corp, the Clergy, representatives of NANS, serving and retired
Military and Police Officers.
7.3
He concluded his report by reading out the 23-point recommendations of the
Summit as captured in the commuique.
8.
J.I.C. Taylor Lecture
8.1
The Chairman called on the 1st Vice Chairman to present a report on the plans
for the J.I.C. Taylor Lecture.
8.2
The 1st Vice Chairman informed the meeting that the lecture was to have held
at the end of 2012 but there were a lot of activities competing for limited time
and resources. He stated that the 9th Edition of the J.I.C. Taylor Lecture would
hold on a date in March, 2013 at the Federal Palace Hotel, Victoria Island,
Lagos, with Prof. Olawoyin SAN as chairman. He added that more information
about the lecture would be circulated to members as the arrangements are
firmed up.
9.
Branch 2013 Elections
9.1
The Chairman stated that by July 2013 the present administration would vacate
office, and some people have already started campaigning ahead of the Branch
2013 elections without the whistle being blown.
9.2
He stated that in consideration of the limited time and the need to ensure the
smooth and orderly conduct of the elections, the Executive Committee met and
decided to re-appoint the 2011 Branch Election Committee headed by Mr. Obi
Okwusogu SAN which had successfully conducted two previous elections. He
added that the Committee would set the guidelines for the elections in
accordance with the Branch Bye-Laws, and assured the meeting that he would
not interfere in the elections and has no interest whatsoever in any candidate for
any office.
9.3
The meeting unanimously approved the re-appointment of the Branch Election
Committee under the chairmanship of Mr. Obi Okwusogu SAN and comprising
of Messrs. Lanre Oyetunji, Ayo Akintnde, E.A. Otokhina and Cosmos
123
Chukwuocha.
9.4
Ms. Toyin Bashorun stated that she got an email from the Branch Secretary in
which he alluded to his being one of the contestants for the office of Chairman
in the forthcoming elections. She queried the propriety of the Branch Secretary
using his office to campaign moreso when the whistle had not yet been blown.
9.5
The Chairman thanked her for her comment and stated that he is bothered by the
number of text messages and solicitations that he has been receiving. He opined
that nobody can stampede him out of office, but expressed the view that it is not
unusual for candidates to express their interest and intentions ahead of the start
of formal campaigns. He added that it is in the character of the Secretary to
inform members of developments in the Branch including news of the elections.
10.
Any Other Business
10.1
Mr. Femi Ojumu raised the issue of the SCUML Registration which has raised a
lot of interesting questions. He expressed concern about the transaction costs
surrounding the registration and reporting obligations.
10.2
The Chairman stated that he brought up the issue at the last NBA-NEC Meeting
and the NBA President stated that the NBA is working on it. He was recently
informed by the NBA President that no decision has been taken but the issue
would be discussed at the next NBA-NEC Meeting fixed for the 20th - 22nd of
February, 2013.
10.3
Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya SAN stated that the power of the NBA lies with the
Branches. She suggested that the Lagos Branch whose members are most
affected by the implementation of the regulations should articulate a position
and take to the NBA-NEC Meeting. She expressed her view that without going
into the pros and cons of the regulations, the reporting limits are rather onerous.
She added that the burden is also a heavy one as every law firm must now have
a Risk Assessment Officer, and reminded members that the lawyer who was
jailed in the UK in the James Ibori case was the firm's Risk Assessment Officer.
10.4
Ms. Toyin Bashorun agreed with Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya SAN and added that
the registration form itself is clearly not designed for lawyers. She stated that it
was the informative email from the Branch Secretary that alerted her about the
matter and she is also concerned about the confidentiality aspects of the
reporting obligations.
10.5
The meeting unanimously adopted Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya SAN's suggestion,
and a Committee was immediately set up comprising Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya
SAN, Mr. Babajide Ogundipe, Mrs. Toyin Ogunbambi, Ms. Toyin Bashorun,
Mr. Moyo Onigbanjo, and Mr. Nelson Ogbuanya – to quickly put together a
Branch Memorandum on the SCUML Registration Requirements for
presentation to the February NBA-NEC Meeting.
10.6
Pa Tunji Gomez stated that he had been reliably informed that the NBA
President decided without any discussion that observers would no longer be
permitted at NBA-NEC Meetings. He opined that it is a very disturbing
development as observers have always been allowed at national meetings to
take the benefit of additional ideas. He added that shutting out observers is not
done anywhere in the world, and requested that the Branch Chairman convey
this to the NEC Meeting.
124
10.7
Pa Tunji Gomez also expressed surprise that despite the pendency of a case in
court challenging the increase in Bar Practice Fees, some lawyers were rushing
to pay. He insisted that it is only the Hon. Attorney-General that can increase
bar practice fees in consultation with the bar association and not the bar council.
He added that our duty as lawyers is to respect the law, and urged members to
support his call that as long as the case is in court we can only pay the old fees.
10.8
Mr. Marcus Erhayano stated that for a long time nothing has been heard about
the large sum of money donated to the Branch for young lawyers. He argued
that we preach about the welfare of young lawyers everyday, and wondered
why the money had not been disbursed to young lawyers.
10.9
The Chairman, in his response, explained that =N=10 million each was given to
two Branches (Ilorin and Lagos) by Chief Wole Olanipekun SAN. Ilorin Branch
bought 7 vehicles with their donation, but he doesnt know how the cars were
distributed among the young lawyers in the branch. He stated that we have a
much larger number of young lawyers in Lagos, and need to ensure that the
money is put to the best possible use, thus, the Executive Committee put the
money in an interest yielding acount in the Bank and appointed a committee
headed by Mr. Osaro Eghobamien SAN to consider and make recommendations
for the use and application of the fund. He added that meanwhile, part of the
interest on the money was used last year to sponsor young lawyers to a
conference in Benin.
10.10
Concluding his response, the Chairman noted that Mr. Osaro Eghobamien
SAN's Committee has just sent in a detailed report on the 7th of February 2013
which the Executive Committee would consider and report back to the house.
10.11
Mr. Obinna Okereke complained about the difficulty with parking spaces within
and outside the Lagos High Court and especially at the Tafawa Balewa Square
Complex / Glass House Commercial Courts. He urged the Executive Committee
to intervene.
1012
The Chairman explained that for security reasons the Tafawa Balewa Square
management and the Presidency had given a directive that the TBS/ Glass
House Carpark should not be used as a public car park but this does not affect
the public fee-paying carpark at the Campbell Street end of the Square. He
noted that it appears that lawyers had become more prosperous and there were
much more cars now – with the attendant logistics problem of adequate parking
spaces.
10.13
Pa Tunji Gomez suggested that the Executive Committee look into the matter of
the delay in hearing cases in Court. He added that the 'sword of Damocles' of
'NJC Returns' hanging over the head of Judges is not a good development.
10.14
Mr. Emeka Nwosu disagreed with Pa Tunji Gomez, and argued that a major
part of the delay is caused by lawyers who are not doing what they ought to do.
10.15
Mr. Chris Omoru rasied the issue of receipts for payment of Bar Practice Fee.
He noted that in previous years, lawyers received a receipt upon payment of the
fee, but now we pay into the bank and there is no receipt which creates a
problem for people who are applying for notary public etc.
10.16
The Chairman stated that the bank deposit teller slip now stands as the receipt of
125
payment of the Bar Practice Fee, nevertheless, he assured that the matter would
be taken up with the NBA national office.
10.17
Mr. Stephen Owhofowhoraye complained that the prisons are congested, and
yet the bail conditions in the Magistrates Court are so tight that even people
who have been granted bail cannot fulfil the onerous conditions and this is
causing further delay and keeping people in detention for inordinately long
periods. He stated that Magistrates require the Prosecutor to verify the Surety's
home address, and there is now an established practice whereby Prosecutors
demand between =N=20,000 – =N=50,000 before going to verify addresses. He
added that Court Registrars have taken over the job of lawyers and even keep
bail bonds with them. In some cases, after bail has been pronounced, the
Registrars call accused persons and offer to perfect their bail terms for them. He
urged the Chairman to look into the situation.
10.18
Mrs. Anne Aimua complained that the people who suffer most are the very poor
people who cannot even afford the kind of sums being demanded from them.
And Mrs. R.F. Okunola added that some lawyers also advise clients to pay the
sums being demanded in order to secure bail, whilst some Magistrates refuse to
see lawyers who approach them to complain or protest about the conditions of
bail and the process of securing it.
10.19
Mr. Samuel Olorungbemi stated that he had an experience in a Magistrate Court
where the Registrar approached his client and offered to secure his bail at a cost
of =N=30,000! He also complained that there seemed to be a bail racket in
operation in some Courts such that if one was not a 'resident lawyer' in the
court, one's bail bond would be frustrated.
10.20
Mr. Emeka Okoli opined that we would not be doing ourselves any good if we
do not take the necessary steps to stem the rot. He stated that we have ourselves
to blame, as lawyers have hobb-nobbed with prosecutors and registrars and
compromised ourselves. He argued that a strongly-worded complaint letter
should be written, and suggested that a committee comprising of members of
the Executive Committee and some senior members of the Branch should meet
with the Attorney-General, the Chief Judge and, if necessary, the State
Governor over the matter.
10.21
The Chairman agreed with the comments and added that there is an additional
requirement in the High Court for Sureties to provide their tax receipts. He
stated that he would seek audience with the State Attorney-General and
Commissioner for Justrice on the issue, and added that the Executive
Committee would meet with the Chief Judge on the issue of stringent bail
conditions in the Magistrate Courts. He reminded the meeting of the subsisting
agreement that anybody who has a complaint against a judiciary staff should
send in a complaint to the Branch Secretariat, and noted that so far none has
been received.
10.22
Mr. Adegboyega Kolade commented that in the past, the Branch worked to
ensure that people who impersonate lawyers do not go scot free, and a joint
committee of the Lagos and Ikeja Branches was set up to follow up reported
cases with the police. He added that sometime ago a case was filed against him
by one such impersonator, and he had just seen the person sitting right behind
him at the meeting.
10.23
The Chairman stated that the gentleman in question – Mr. Jones Muyiwa
126
Kayode - actually sent him a text seeking welfare support and stating that he
intends seeking an elective office in the Branch. He expressed doubts as to the
man's mental capacity. He called Mr. Jones Muyiwa Kayode to stand up and
warned him to stop paying Bar Practice Fees, attending our meetings and
practising as a lawyer.
10.24
Alhaji M.U. Ibrahim argued that it is not an issue that should be taken lightly.
We have crooks in our midst and the person should be arrested and prosecuted.
11.
Announcements
11.1
The Chairman read out an invitation to members of the Branch to an event on
Thursday the 14th of February, 2013 at 10.00am at the Muson Centre in honour
of Mr. Segun Onakoya who is marking 40years at the bar.
11.2
The Secretary took the other announcements:
11.2.1 Members of the Branch were invited to a public lecture to mark the 80th
Birthday of Alhaji Lateef Olufemi Okunnu SAN CON at the Nigerian Institute
of Inernational Affairs, Victoria Island, Lagos on Tuesday 19th of February,
2013 at 10.00am.
11.2.2 A letter was received from Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede (former 2nd Vice Chairman
of the Branch, and former National Treasurer) in her capacity as newly
appointed Co-Chair of the International Bar Association African Regional
Forum (the first Nigerian to hold that office) introducing the new officers for
the forum for the next two years. The Secretary noted that the new officers of
the Forum include eight distinguished members of the Branch: Mrs. Olufunmi
Oluyede (Co-Chair), Dr. Nechi Ezeako (Secretary), Prof. Olanrewaju Adigun
Fagbohun (Publications Officer), Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya SAN (Advisory
Board Member), Mrs. Dorothy Ufot SAN (Advisory Board Member), Chief
Sena Anthony (Advisory Board Member), Mr. Gbenga Oyebode (Advisory
Board Member) and Mr. Jonathan Ikiebe (Law Firm Management Liaison).
12.
Cutting of the Cake
12.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in February to come forward for the cutting of the
cake.
12.2
Eleven members came out to mark one anniversary or the other, including:
Messrs. S.B. Onu, Gboyega Kolade, Femi Ojumu, and Ms. Chinyere Obasi.
12.3
The Chairman invited Mr. Mbanugo Udenze to supervise the cutting of the
cake.
13.
Closing
13.1
Mr. Zik Obi II moved for adjournment and Pa Tunji Gomez seconded.
13.2
Mrs. Ijeoma Okeke said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 3.20 pm.
127
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 11TH MARCH, 2013 AT THE FOYER OF THE
HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
1.2
Taiwo O. Taiwo
Alex N. Muoka
Martin A. Ogunleye
Seth O. S. Amaefule
Marian N. Jones
Philip O. Njeteneh
Tolani Edu-Adeola
Chinedu N. Nduka
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
Amaka I. Aneke
Anthony O. Atata
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
O.C.K. Unegbu
S.B. Onu
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN
Anire Kanyi
Rudolf Ezeani
Matthew Esonanjor
Hilary N. Umah
Okala O Uche
Emerson C. Ishiekwene
Michael Nusa-Yakubu
Matthew Egbadon
Stephen Obajaja
Austin-Modo (Mrs)
Wofai Jimmy Robert
D.N.S. Torbari
Solomon Balogun
Abiye Tam-George
Kayode Adewusi
Onyeagwa Angela
Asenuga Busayo
Folarin A. Dalmeida
Members
1.
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Toyin Bashorun
Anne Aimua
Chief Wale Taiwo
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
Nelson C.S. Ogbuanya
Tahav Iorse-Sheriffs
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Nzekwe Judith
Edem O. Uko
Chukwuma Ezeala
M.A. Adewopo
Kola Ogunade
Ibas Theresa O.
Kassim Moses
Odupitan, Julius A.O.
Bunmi Ajayi
Clifford O. Atakere
Doyin Bishi
Adefisoye L. Okunade
128
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
Gogo Karibi-Whyte
Kehinde Bashiru ECP
Ogundipe Peters Victoria
Idedia Sandra
Oladipo O. Ajayi
Adaku Mbama
Okewole Grace
Chidi Okoroji
Ema Itoro
Daniel C. Okonkwo
Atunwa Omowunmi
T.N.T Okonkwo
Olumide Oyesanya
Edwin Madubuofor
Geraldine Wey
H. Nnaemeka Nnubia
Fidelis I.Akra
Shauib Alaran
Opete A.O.
Damian Ihegazie
Yemi Ajala
Egeonu Gloria
Mike Idowu
Katung Clotus
Ayodele Akintunde
Owolabi Adeniji
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Okobiemen Joseph
David Dawode
Ore Ohakpo
Omorodion Philomena
Chidi Ezikpe
Aderonke Sijuwade
Chika Ajaero
Celestine Nwankwo
Runsewe Funsho
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli-Taiya
Abisoye Omotayo T.
Naomi O. Abdul
Mindia Y. Chiwak
Martin Agoziem Akpaka
Oboku Horsfall
Nwankenta Ihuoma L.
Ihesiulo E.
Adam O. Wahab
Kelly Agbonze
Toyin Akintunde
Chilaka Uzoamaka
Okeke Chidiebere Kingsley
Adekunle Alabi
James Asomugha
Ugochukwu Ezeako
H.O. Ndubuisi
Mbanugo Udenze
Cynthia E. Ukawoko
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
129
Bob C.O. Ijioma
Bode Omoboriowo
Momodu Aliu
Shakirullahi M. Obale
Mrs. Ama Fayemiwo
Anthonia Eke
Frank Agbedo
Amaghiro Chukwuemeka O.
Babs Animashaun
Opeyemi Afeni
James Okoh
Patience Onoaghagse
Temilola Abdul
Vincent Buwa
Jeffrey Eboh
M.O. Daudu
Akindoyin Tomiwa David
Precious Akhanonu
Magaret Akpoyora
Enyesiobi Ngozi O.
Edward Porbeni
Laura Williams
Olusola A. Olarenwaju
B.A. Olaogun
Olujumobi Orioye
Eric Ikwele
Silva Ugo Osuji II
Obasi Chinyere
Francis Nwajei
Andy C. Igbokwe
Patience Okereke
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
Egbe U. Ande
Ngozi Akandu
Sadat Quadri
Ngozi Ngonadi
Obiora Afuegwu Egwuatu
Olatunde Kolawole
Emmanuel Umoren
George Nnabuike
Chimezie Kalunta
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
E.A. Otokhina
Victor Anumoha
Emmanuela Ikolodo
Nwana E. Chuks
Augustine N. Ohinmah
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Obiageli Eze
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Mayor Asiegbu
Oludayo B. Ogunjebe
Linda Oladotun A.
Oshodi Olushola
Onuoha N.O.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
Oluwafemi E. Adeniyi
Enaboye Osegie
Olugbenga Fabilola
Uzoeghelu-Nzube O. Joy
Dachomo I. Dachomo
A.M. C. Ginigeme
Benjamin N. Jato
Ajiboye Olatunji
Zephaniah, Jeremiah
Babatola Apata
Dr. Theodore Okonkwo
Edeogbaji Olivia
Adenike Komolafe
Owhofawhoraye Stephen
Anthony Banjo
Rose Agbo
Dennis O. Akhagba
A. A. Osoko
Adebayo Oriola
Omuna-Amadi Nsirim D. C.
Lilian Eronini
Egbunike Emmanuel Onyeka
Chike Odezugo
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Martins Inyang
Ijeoma Nusche
Obinna Okoli
Ogo Onyia
Kayode Odumosu
Okereke Obiorah
Akinwonmi Seun
Bola Animashaun
Geff O. Eze
Osunkoya Oyewole
Greg Okafor
Emmanuel Majebi
Kunle Jimoh
Tara Nosida
Jude Igbanoi
Kunle Uthman
Dapo Opeaye
Obele Akinniranye
Supo Famuyiwa
Olajumoke Larinde
Muyiwa Abe
Samuel Okon Ekpeowua
Umatechukwu Obinna Chinedu
Ikenna U. Onwusika
W. Ekundayo
Victor A. Williams
Uduak Bhavnami
Sam Olorungbemi
Okey Ilofulunwa
Vivian Olutunfase
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
130
F.A.Dagbajale
Dixy Oddiri
Kelechi E. Nweke
Gboyega Kolade
Hannibal Uwaifo
Odigboh T.
Nonso Ngonadi
Francis Rotimi Adeniji
Abioye Akerele
Ugbeye Esegbuyota Solomon
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs.)
Sanni A. Helen
Agu Nnaemeka
Francis Ogunbowale
Stephen Amalla
Matesun Israel
Paul E. Okoli
Paul Omoijiade
Adekunle-Fatokun Aramide
I. O. Abdulhameed
Patrick N. Iheonu
Wingate Emmanuel O.
F. A. Dogbajale
Olajide Benjamin
Ologwu Moses Ogbonnia
Mamudu Yahaya A.
Nelson C. Onyejaka
Okoro C. J.
Akerele Olajide
Bede C Duru
Lucy Ahaneku
Azubuike Okaro
Iheoma Osimiri
Rosalind Clomavi
Fortune Ezeah
Maximus Nwolisa
Jude Ogbodo
Nasir Runmonkun
Helen Mbakwe
Nnaji Giniki Catherine
Okey Nwachukwu
Ikhalea Augustine
Alfred Akinjo
Adeleke Solanke
Nelly K Egwuagha
Ukogu Tochukwu Godwin
Nga Chidozie Daze
Adeyemi S. Dossou
Chilaka Dom
Ebere Sada
Kareem T. M
G. E. Oyefumi
Ngozi B. Nwakwo
Sherifat Abdulkareem
Richard Obiamiwe
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
279.
281.
283.
285.
287.
289.
291.
293.
295.
297.
299.
301.
303.
305.
307.
309.
1.3
Oluwole Okelana
Vincent Owhor
Noble Uchechukwu
Lanre Oyetunji
Nwankwor Nwanne
Lawrence Austinecoleman O.
Jude Uche Mbaeri
Basiru A. Ojo
Lizzy Nwokocha
Oliko Onojighofia
Rotimi Ogunjobi
Marcus Eyarhono
Francis Akinlotan
T. P. Olatunde (Mrs.)
Ibrahim Abikan
Chinyere Uhegbu
Abayomi Begbaji
Ogbudu B. S
Olanrewaju Majekodunmi
Lady Debbie Obodoukwu
Obiegwu Uchenna Valentine
Femi Fajolu
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
278)
280)
282)
284)
286)
288)
290)
292)
294)
296)
298)
300)
302)
304)
306)
308)
Anne Abyem
Sylvester Ekwueme
Ekott Uduak J
Otera Grace
George Opeyemi Okusanya
Umeh C. J.
Kamar Raji
Charles Mgbajah
W. A. Gbadebo
Akinsete Omonike
Kelvin Ojukwu
Oluwafunke Jagun
I. J. Okechukwu
Okechukwu Mbah
Akande I. Olutobi
Shobamowo Gbolahan J
Obi Uchenna
Frances Onwumali
Toyin Ogunbambi
Ajibola Ibaru
Sandy Diana
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
Senator Onyeabo Obi
Mr. Zik Obi II
M.U. Ibrahim
Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
Olasupo Olaibi
Omohafe Opara
Apologies
1.
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
Mrs. Hairat Balogun
Mrs. Olufunke Adekoya SAN
Mrs. Boma Ozobia
Dame Priscilla Kuye
Adenike Adeniji
Moyo Onigbanjo
Ogbonna Agbafo
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.08 pm with an opening prayer by Mr. Gbolahan
Gbadamosi.
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members to the third meeting of the year.
3.
Minutes of Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
on the 11th of February, 2013. No corrections were made to the minutes.
3.2
Mr. S.B Onu moved for adoption of the minutes and Mrs. Anne Aimua
seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accomodation
131
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that he met with the Chief Judge on the issue and he has
been directed to meet with the Deputy Chief Registrar of the Court to decide on
a place. He expects to meet with the Deputy Chief Registrar this week and
report back to the house.
4.2
Lekki Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that the Branch is still in the process of paying the backlog of land charges.
4.3
2012 Branch Bar Dinner Report
4.3.1
The Chairman confirmed that he has just been informed by Mr. Gogo KaribiWhyte that the 2012 Bar Dinner Committee Report would be submitted this
week and presented at the next meeting.
4.4
Audited Accounts
4.4.1
The Chairman invited the members of the Branch Audit Committee – Mazi
O.C.K. Unegbu and Chief Ademola Sadipe to brief the meeting.
4.4.2
Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu confirmed that the Committee has concluded its review of
the 2011/2012 accounts and is waiting to hear from the officers and the
Auditors before finalising its report.
4.5
Position Paper to the Court of Appeal
4.5.1
The Chairman confirmed that the position paper prepared by Chief Emeka
Ngige SAN had been submitted to the Presiding Judge of the Lagos Division of
the Court of Appeal. He added that he found the Position Paper most incisive
and is convinced that the Presiding Judge would find it most useful in making
needed changes at the Court.
4.5.2
The Chairman thanked the learned Senior Advocate for a job well done.
4.5.3
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN informed the meeting that the report was a first part
and a second part would be done in due course.
4.6
J.I.C. Taylor Lecture
4.6.1
The Chairman called on the 1st Vice Chairman to update the meeting on the
plans for the J.I.C. Taylor Lecture.
4.6.2
The 1st Vice Chairman (the Chairman of the J.I.C. Taylor Lecture Committee)
informed the meeting that the lecture would hold on the 27th of March, 2013 at
the Federal Palace Hotel, Victoria Island, Lagos. He added that further details
would be sent to members by sms and email.
5.
Reports
5.1
Public Complaints and Training Committee Report
5.1.1
The Chairman reported that Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde has succeeded Mrs.
Abimbola Akeredolu as the Branch Representative on the Public Complaints
and Training Committee, following Mrs. Akeredolu's appointment as
132
Honourable Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice of Ogun State.
5.1.2
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde reported that the Committee met recently to
consider 7 petitions. She stated that 2 of the Petitions were withdrawn, whilst
more information was requested on the other 5. She added that the other issue
discussed at the meeting was a report from the NBA-Ikeja Branch on the restructuring of the Sheriffs' Section of the High Court.
5.1.3
She advised that members of the Branch should always follow up when
execution is levied so that the attached goods are not sold behind them - as that
formed the bulk of the complaints by the Ikeja Branch in their report to the
Committee.
5.1.4
The Chairman suggested that the Lagos Branch should make an input into how
the office of the Deputy Sheriff should be re-organised. He suggested that the
Branch set up an ad-hoc Committee to suggest ways of improving the Deputy
Sheriff's section, and craved the indulgence of the meeting to name Mr. S.B.
Onu as Chairman of the Committee and Mrs. Anne Aimua, Bode Omoboriowo,
and Mr. Oyesanya as members – with a mandate to look into ways of reorganising the Sheriffs' Section and send their findings to the 'Judiciary SubCommittee on Re-organising the Sheriffs' Office'.
5.2
Bar-Bench Forum
5.2.1
The Chairman reported that a Bar-Bench Forum held on the 5th of March, 2013.
He attended in the company of Mrs. Hairat Balogun, Pa Tunji Gomez, and Mrs.
Tolani Edu-Adeola (the Publicity Secretary). He stated that the bar had very
useful discussions with the State Chief Judge and her senior Judges, and the
Chief Judge decided at the Forum that there would be a Valedictory Court
Session in honour of the late past Branch Chaiman – Mr. Akin Akinbote.
5.2.2
He added that a lot of the discussions at the Forum centered on the conduct of
Magistrates (who were represented in some large number). The Judges also
complained severally about lawyers' cell phones going off in Court, and the
manner of dressing by some lawyers. The concensus was that Judges and
Magistrates should take control of their Courts and discourage wrong dressing.
5.2.3
He reported that the Judiciary is working on a review of Court filing fees.
5.3
NBA-NEC Meeting Report
5.3.1
The Secretary presented the NBA-NEC Meeting Report which was circulated in
hard-copy.
5.3.2
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde moved for adoption of the Report and Mrs. Uche
Ikwueme seconded. The Report was adopted for discussion.
5.3.3
Ms. Toyin Bashorun sought clarification on what lawyers are expected to do
now with the NBA-NEC decision on the SCUML registration and reporting
obligations.
5.3.4
Responding, the Chairman confirmed that the NBA is set to go to Court on the
issue. He read out the names of the members of the Branch Committee who
prepared the Memorandum to NEC and did the Branch proud at the Makurdi
NEC meeting. He thanked them for a job well done and requested that they
133
stand up for recognition.
5.3.5
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN commended the Secretary for a painstaking Report on
the Makurdi NEC Meeting. He suggested that subsequent reports should be
accompanied by a copy of the Meeting Communique and circulated via email.
5.3.6
Continuing, Chief Emeka Ngige SAN noted that the report had omitted two
important issues. First, he stated that he had drawn NEC's attention to the fact
that (contrary to the former practice where the list is published in three papers
and reflected in the minutes) the Minutes of the Asaba NEC Meeting did not
contain the list of co-opted NEC members announced by the NBA President. He
suggested that the Branch should keep this point in view, and insist that the list
of co-opted members must be made available so that everybody knows who the
co-opted members are.
5.3.7
Secondly, Chief Emeka Ngige SAN noted that the report failed to reflect the
comments by the NBA President on the court case instituted by some members
of the Branch against the NBA on the increase of Bar Practice Fees and the
attempt to obtain an interlocutory order from the Court.
5.3.8
Pa. Tunji Gomez expressed joy that Chief Emeka Ngige SAN was at the
meeting. He sought clarification as to whether Chief Ngige SAN received any
support when he decried NEC's departure from the long tradition of allowing
observers at NEC meetings. He stated that the Lagos Branch must make its
stand clear - that it wants observers at NEC meetings.
5.3.9
On the issue of Bar Practice Fees, Pa. Tunji Gomez reported that the case is still
on and would come up again on the 18th of March, 2013. He insisted that no
dedicated member of the Branch should pay practice fees until the case is
decided, and added that (at the forthcoming Branch elections) members should
not vote for any person who pays the fee before the case is decided - as the
increase shows great insensitivity to the plight of junior lawyers.
5.3.10 Chief Emeka Ngige SAN informed the meeting that judiciary workers have
commenced a strike action and Courts in Abuja and Awka did not sit earlier in
the day. He opined that if the strike extends and catches up with the case then
we would lose out. He expressed his view that paying the Fee would not detract
from the efficacy of the suit. On the issue of observers at NEC meetings, he
reported that he was the lone voice at the Makurdi NEC Meeting. He added that
he had always made his view on the issue known to the NBA President, and had
consistently advocated for observers to be allowed to speak at meetings.
5.3.11 Mrs. Toyin Ogunbambi stated that she received a text from the NBA stating that
the practice fees had been reviewed downwards. She noted that some people
may be pursuing a Notary Public appointment, etc., and must pay by the 31st of
March, 2013.
5.3.12 Speaking on the issue of observers at NEC meetings, Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu
noted that he had been an observer at NEC meetings for some time and
observers had made valuable contributions that helped to shape important
decisions. He noted that the Annual General Meeting (AGM) is the highest
ruling body of the NBA, he had attended all recent AGMs and the issue of
observers was not raised at any.
5.3.13 Concluding his comments, Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu proposed a motion that in view
134
of the fact that there had been no decision by any organ of the Bar to scrap
observer status at NEC meetings the Lagos Branch should insist on the right of
observers to attend NEC meetings until the AGM decides otherwise. Pa. Tunji
Gomez seconded the motion which was unanimously carried by the meeting.
5.3.14 The Chairman stated that the position would be conveyed to the next NEC
meeting.
5.3.15 On the issue of Bar Practice Fees, in response to a suggestion by Mrs. Morenike
Obi-Farinde that the Branch resolve to pay the old rate, the Chairman noted that
the receiving banks would not accept payment of the old rate. The Chairman
concluded that payment should be a matter of individual choice, otherwise
members can pay the new rate and if the action succeeds then the overpayment
would be a credit owed by the NBA.
6.
Valedictory Court Session for late Mr. Akin Akinbote
6.1
The Chairman announced the passing on of Mr. Akin Akinbote – who served
the Branch in several capacities and was Chairman of the Branch from 2003 to
2005 – and reported on the Valedictory Court Session held in his honour on
Friday the 8th of March, 2013. He expressed appreciation to the Honourable
Chief Judge of Lagos State who ensured that a full Valedictory Court Session
was held,and who attended with almost all her Judges.
6.2
He spoke briefly about Mr. Akinbote's illness which culminated in his demise,
noting that the fact and extent of the ailment did not come to light until it was
very late. He mentioned the steps he took when he learnt of the situation and the
intervention by the Lagos State Governor and several well-meaning members of
the Branch and other lawyers who donated generously towards his treatment.
He noted that although the donations came in late, they would still be useful to
the widow and tender-aged children that Mr. Akinbote left behind.
6.3
He thanked the Redeemed Christian Church of God for organising the wakekeep and burial ceremony, and noted that the NBA President attended both the
wake-keep and valedictory court session.
6.4
He ended with a prayer for the repose of late Mr. Akin Akinbote's soul. He went
on to commiserate with the members of the Ikeja Branch who lost a colleague –
Mrs. Jane Igbasan – in an accident.
6.5
Pa. Tunji Gomez congratulated the Chairman and Executive Committee for
giving our late chairman a befitting burial. He added that he was worried about
the absence of an insurance scheme for members, and noted that if we had one
our late chairman may have been in a better position. He appealed that the
Branch Executive Committee should institute a group insurance scheme for the
Branch before leaving office.
6.6
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN joined Pa. Tunji Gomez in commending the Executive
Committee for putting up a good showing for the late Mr. Akinbote. He advised
that the Branch should also write the Chief Judge and thank her for her support.
He noted that at the last NEC Meeting there was a report on a national welfare
scheme which would be funded from the bar practice fees paid by members. He
counselled that the Branch should put pressure on the national body to make the
scheme a reality otherwise the Branch should quickly do something of its own.
He noted that his town union (which has a membership of about 1,000 persons)
135
has a welfare scheme and beneficiaries receive as much as =N=750,000.
6.7
The Chairman thanked members for their contributions. He noted that he had
sent a thank you message to the Chief Judge but would take Chief Ngige SAN's
suggestion and write her formally. On the welfare scheme, he stated that the
Executive Committee has started work on an insurance scheme for members,
and is speaking with the insurance arm of First Bank. He expressed hope that a
proposal would be ready for presentation at the next meeting.
6.8
Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu explained that he was a member of a national committee
under Mr. Akeredolu SAN's presidency which had done some work on the
welfare scheme. He suggested that the Executive Committee should also
consider Union Assurance in addition to First Bank. He, however, insisted that
the national body should now be able to provide comprehensive cover for all
lawyers with the increased practice fees.
7.
Any Other Business
7.1
Ms. Toyin Bashorun sought to bring to the notice of the members a recent
develoment in criminal practice whereby a suspect who is undergoing trial is
suddenly on the pardon list without notice and without the lawyer being in the
picture – with the effect that the lawyer appears in court on the next date of
adjournment not knowing that the client has already been pardoned.
7.2
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN opined that it is a serious development and suggested
that the 1st Vice Chairman (as chair of the Branch Human Rights Committee)
should look into it and advise the house.
7.3
Mr. Ugbeye Solomon asked about the Branch Identity Card. He complained that
in the course of travelling outside Lagos, one is regularly harrassed by police
men and soldiers who insist on production of an identity card even if one has an
NBA sticker on the vehicle. He also asked what can be done about unauthorised
use of NBA stickers by non-lawyers.
7.4
The Chairman agreed that something needs to be done about Branch Identity
Cards and use of NBA stickers. He invited members to send in suggestions.
7.5
Dr. Theodore Okonkwo suggested that we need at least two microphones for the
floor, and immediately made a donation to cover the cost of their purchase.
7.6
Responding to a question by Mazi O.C.K. Unegbu, the Chairman confirmed
that by the next meeting the Branch Election Committee would be up and
running. He appealed to interested candidates to sheath their swords.
7.7
The Chairman stated that there is a library of online resources available to
lawyers. He invited Mr. Abbass Adebowale to speak on a law reporting service.
7.8
Mr. Adebowale gave a brief presentation on his company
www.askthelawyeronline.com – which reports decisions of the appellate courts
and offers case summary services. He invited members to subscribe, noting that
his company was offering two services (online and print services) for the price
of one.
8.
Cutting of the Cake
136
8.1
The Chairman reminded members that last Friday (8th of March, 2013) was the
International Women's Day whilst Sunday (10th of March, 2013) was Mothers'
Day. Accordingly, he invited mothers having four or more children to come
forward and represent all mothers in the Branch. He also invited members who
were celebrating their birthday, wedding anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in March
to come forward for the cutting of the cake.
8.2
12 members came out to mark one anniversary or the other, including Pa. Tunji
Gomez, Mrs. Joyce Oduah, and Mrs. Rose Agbo,
8.3
The Chairman invited Mrs. Toyin Ogunbambi and Mr. Mbanugo Udenze to
supervise the cutting of the cake.
9.
Closing
9.1
Mrs. Joyce Oduah moved for adjournment and Mrs. Fayemiwo seconded.
9.2
Mrs. Majekodunmi said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 3.18 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 8TH APRIL, 2013 AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH
COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Seth O. S. Amaefule
4.
Marian N. Jones
5.
Philip O. Njeteneh
6.
Omohafe T. Opara
7.
Chinedu N. Nduka
8.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
9.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
10.
Amaka I. Aneke
11.
Anthony O. Atata
12.
Ogbonnaya Agbafo
-
Chairman
Secretary
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex-Officio
Members
1.
Adedoyin Adeleye
2)
Onyeka Egbunike
1.2
137
3.
5.
7.
9.
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
Oluwafemi E. Adeniyi
Uduak Bhavnani
M.A. Adewopo
Taiwo Ibidapo-Obe
Patience Onoashagse
Rose Agbo
Mrs. R. Fehintola Okunola
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs.)
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN
A.O Fayokun
M.U Ibrahim (Jam-Jam)
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
S.B Onu
Mrs. G.M Sasore
Babatola Apata
Chief Ademola Sadipe
Joseph Ekene Ndibuagu
Uloaku Ekwegh
Anthony Ezenduka
Inyang Martins M.
Marcus Eyarhono
Owolabi Adeniyi
Unachukwu John E.
Geff O. Eze
Chinyere Uhegbu
Botoku Femi
Akinwonmi Seun
Adeleke Solanke
Osunwole Funmilola
Grace Eluebo
Akunyili Okechukwu
Ikhuoriah Zuma Jennifer
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Jimoh Mukaila
Kehinde Ayinde
Opete A.O.
Sule M. Danian
Umeh, C.J.
Kehinde Bashiru
Okeke Chidiebere Kingsley
Adebayo Olanrewaju C.
Dixy Oddiri
Adeleke Benedict
Uduak Ekott
Eric Ikwele
Emmanuel Umoren
Shobamowo, Gbolahan J.
Obi Uchenna Casmir
Nwankenta Ihuoma L.
Nwankenta Azubuike
Femi Fajolu
Temitayo Kareem
Oladipo Ajayi
Nelly Egwuagha
Aghaonu Chris
4)
6)
8)
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
138
Jeffrey Eboh
Alfred Akinjo
Emmanuel Orhoro
Celestine Nwonkwo
Ike Uko
Mbanugo Udenze
Chief Wale Taiwo
Zik C. Obi II
Chijioke Okoli
A.J. Owonikoko SAN
Olufemi A. Daramola
Agu Nnaemeka R.
H. Ade Balogun
Samuel Okechukwu
Okoroji Chidi
E. Olubukunola Balogun
Geraldine Wey
Abioye Akerele
Ologwu Moses Ogbonnia
Silva Ugo Osuji II
Ajibike Alaka
Kaduru, Chikezie D.
Jimoh S.O
Fatoki Abimbola O.
Raph Amobi Chikezie
Sunday A. Adesokan
Ademuyiwa Abe
Adeola Gbadebo
Olukayode Adewusi
Maduagwu Remigus
Anichebe Chioma Stella
Kehinde Evbuoma
Nneka Omeaku
Odejimi Ronke
Okpe A. Ejike
Eric Orji A.
Dennis O. Akhagba
N.O Erakpofoke
George Nwabunike
Okonkwo, Chike Christian
B. Chike Anyiam
Olasupo Ati-John
Iyaniwura Adebisi L.
Amaghiro Chukwuemeka O.
M.O Igbaji Egorp
Okeiyi Maureen Ifeyinwa
Olasumbo Adejumo
Francis Nwajei
Vivian C. Madu
Okonkwo Nkiruka
Abiaziem Amarachi
Joseph Jibaoh
Ihuoma Pepple
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Ohakpo Joseph
113.
115.
117.
119.
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203.
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
Emeka Ogbodo
Agbana Florence A.
Obasi Chinyere
Jamilu Habu Bashir
Frank Agbedo
Kamar Raji
Rosemary Ubajaka
Obi Okwusogu SAN
Omole Olusoji
Ikenna V. Onwusika
Francis Olayemi Babaoye
M.J. Onigbanjo
Oliko, Onojighofia
Nwadukwe Anene
I.C. Papp Alumona
Jamiu Abayomi Sulaimon
Precious Akhanolu
Hannibal Uwaifo
Oshodi Olushola
Ibrahim Abikan
Kayode Odumosu
Kola Ogunade
Okechukwu P. Ubah
Folasade Raji
Nkeonyenasoa Enebeli Taiya (Mrs.)
Lucy Ahaneku
Obukohwo Odogun
Egere Christy C.
Abiye Tam-George
Odupitan, Julius A.O
Owhofawhoraye S.A
Stephen Obajaja
Olukayode Oseni
Mrs. Funke Adekoya, SAN
Anne Aimua
Balogun Solomon
Adeniji Adenike
Okpataku Andrew.
Lilian I. Eronini
Adebayo Oriola
Julius Ugeze
Victor Anurioha
Agu Chikodi Rosary
Isu Ewa Isu
O.N. Akinniranye
Jonathan Olusegun Ajayi
K.M. Oduntan
Rowland Uzoechi
Anaeto Chibuzo
Wahab Ekundayo
Anyigor Chioma Leonora
Onyedika Nwosu
Mary Akin-Ajayi
Unah N. Yvette
Ebere Nwokoro
139
114)
116)
118)
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
Ifeoma Obi (Mrs.)
Emma Omuojine
Mindia Y. Chiwar
Olawole Okelane
Tara Aisida
Cynthia N. Ikpeama
Agbana Aribake F.
Patrick Okonjo
A.S Abimbola
Andrew Ohi Enakhifo
Ikhalea O. Augustine
Okonkwo T.N.T
Bode Omoboriowo
Ilukwe Ifeanyi
Oseni Surajudeen Abiodun
Obiora Atuegwu Egwuatu
Babalola, Sulaimon Kolawole
Anthonia Eke
D.N.S Torbari
Okeke Ijeoma
Edem O. Uko
Ajiboye K. Kayode
Onome Patricia Asemota
Ayetin Kainayor
Peter H. Mallong
Biriyai Dambo
Ngozi Nwangwa
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Jude O. Ezeamaechi
Adaku Mbama
Etiti E.O
Ugbeye Esegbuyota Solomon
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Ms. Funke Aboyade
Olasupo Ademosu
Onyeagwa Angela Ozoka (Mrs.)
Clifford O. Atakere
Obiageli Eze
Ezemegbu Loveline
Ugochukwu Ezeaba
Ejadario Ekpo
Omowunmi Atunwa
Lemea Keziah Nkipnee
Olushola Keshinro
Gloria Ireka
Rotimi Aladesanmi
Lucky Ekarume
Ebere Sada (Mrs.)
Janet Obadare (Mrs.)
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Nwonyishi N. Abundantius
Dr. Theodore Okonkwo
Ngozi B. Nwankwo
Ngozi Enyesiobi-Igwesi
Ufoadu Wilson Oluaji
223.
225.
227.
229.
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
246.
248.
250.
252.
254.
256.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
1.3
Edward Porbeni
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Promise Gabriel Asikpo
Emokpae Stephanie U.
Obasi Williams Kalu
Omijie Peter
Tochukwu Onyiuke
Tinubu Munirat Folasade
Egeonu Gloria
Ehirim Barbara Uche
Irase I. Ohiokpehai
Nas Ogunsakin
Botu Oluwatobiloba B.
Maximus Chike Nwolisa
BivinisUwagboi
Chief George O. Nnachor
Sunkanmi Babatunde
R.A Bello
Emeka B. Nwankwo
Austin Castro Ginigeme
Ngozi Ngonadi (Mrs.)
Caroline C. Ndulue
Frances Onwunali
Enyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Emeka Nwawuli
L.A. Idu
Victoria Abijo
Chuks Nwana
Apologies
1.
Senator Onyeabo Obi
3.
Joyce Oduah
5.
Mrs. Sade Adetiba
7.
Kagho Omomadia
9.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
224)
226)
228)
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
245)
247)
249)
251)
253)
255)
255)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
Mbuzwe Veronica
Rosalind Clomavi
Ikpa, Ifeanyichukwu L.
Rosemary Ubah
Sylvester Ekwueme
Victor Usifoh
Okafor Chigozie
Morenikeji Akah
Biodoumoye Yousuo
Peace Okoro
Somto Arinze
Opeyemi Ogunleye
Okechukwu Ezeogu
Asenuga Busayo
Matthew E. Ero
Olutayo Arojo
O.O. Adejumo (Mrs.)
Emeka Okpoko
Odigboh Terry Uzoh
Obi Uchenna Casmir
Chidi Kechi Oduji
Otera Grace
Boye Bajulaiye
Funmi Obisan
Onyeka Ugochukwu
Okoli Paul
Mrs. Murphy Akpieyi
2)
4)
6)
8)
10)
Boma Ozobia
Dayo Onakoya
Adegboyega Kolade
Chukwuemeka Daniels
Martin Ogunleye
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.12 pm .
2.2
The Chairman welcomed members to the meeting. He noted that officers from
the Lagos State Internal Revenue Service would make a presentation in the
course of the meeting on the requirements for tax compliance prior to the 12th
April, 2013 announced date when the Lagos State Government would start
implementing the civil and criminal sanctions under the Personal Income Tax
Law.
2.3
He called on Mrs. Morenike Obifarinde to lead the meeting in reciting the NBA
Prayer.
3.
Minutes of Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
140
on the 11th of March, 2013. A correction was made to paragraph 4.6.2 of the
minutes.
3.2
Mrs. Morenike Obifarinde moved for adoption of the minutes and Mrs. G.
Sasore seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accomodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that two available rooms had been identified within the
premises of the Lagos High Court and he would approach the Chief Judge to
allocate the rooms for use as the Branch Office.
4.2
Lekki Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that the Branch is still in the process of paying the backlog of land charges.
4.3
2012 Branch Bar Dinner Report
4.3.1
The Chairman reported that the Committee Chairman (Mr. Gogo Karibi-Whyte)
has not yet sent in the report.
4.4
Audited Accounts
4.4.1
Chief Ademola Sadipe confirmed that his Committee (and the Branch Treasurer
and Financial Secretary) met with the Branch Auditors the previous week. He
stated that his Committee's Report would be concluded within the week.
4.5
J.I.C Taylor Lecture
4.5.1
The Chairman reported that the Committee Chair (the 1st Vice Chairman – Mr.
Martin Ogunleye) was out of town. He confirmed that the Committee was hard
at work on plans for the lecture which would hold before the end of the month.
4.6
Ad-Hoc Committee on Sheriffs' Section
4.6.1
The Chairman stated that the Chairman of the Committee (Mr. S.B. Onu) had
not yet sent in a report.
4.6.2
Responding to a question by the Chairman, Mrs. Morenike Obifarinde
confirmed that the Public Complaints and Training Committee had not held any
meeting since the Branch March Meeting.
4.7
Branch Insurance Scheme
4.7.1
The Chairman reported that the Branch is in discussions with the insurance
subsidiary of First Bank and Aiico Insurance Plc, and would soon be sending
out messages to members on the information required by the companies for an
insurance policy.
5.
Presentations
5.1
Section on Legal Practice ('SLP')
141
5.1.1
The Chairman invited Mrs. Efunmi Olubanwo (the Administrator of the SLP,
and herself a senior lawyer) to address the meeting. He commended her for the
very good training programme the SLP held in Lagos the previous week.
5.1.2
Mrs. Olubanwo made a brief presentation introducing the SLP. She expressed
her view that all lawyers in practice should be members of the SLP. She spoke
about the recent training, and added that another seminar would be holding in
Benin on the challenges of proving title to land.
5.1.3
She reminded members that from 2012, it had become compulsory to be
registered with a Section of the NBA in order to attend the NBA Annual
Conference. She encouraged members to join the SLP and added that a person
can hold simultaneous membership of both the SLP and the Section on Business
Law. She mentioned that several prominent members of the Lagos Branch are
officers and members of the SLP.
5.1.4
She ended her presentation by stating that the SLP moves its annual conference
around Nigeria. She added that details of the SLP's programmes would be sent
to members, and the Membership Form and further details can be obtained from
the section's website.
5.2
Lagos State Internal Revenue Service ('LIRS')
5.2.1
The Chairman reported that the Lagos State Government recently held a
Stakeholders' Meeting with professionals and announced its intention to begin
enforcement of criminal and civil sanctions on defaulters under the Personal
Income Tax Law with effect from the 12th of April, 2013. He added that in order
to ensure that members were well informed, he had invited senior officials of
the LIRS to enlighten members on compliance obligations under the law.
5.2.2
The Chairman displayed the bundle distributed to meeting attendees by the
LIRS Team (which contained Personal Income Tax Forms and compact discs
containing tax payment information), and introduced the six-man team from the
LIRS led by Mr. F.T Abass (the Director of Personal Income Tax).
5.2.3
Mr. F.T. Abass introduced the members of his team: Mr. B.C. Alli (Deputy
Director of Personal Income Tax), Mr. Babatunde Alagbada (Revenue Manager,
Personal Income Tax), Mr Abiru (Head, Informal Professional Unit), Mr. L.O.
Adetola (Station Manager, City Hall Tax Office), and Mrs. M.M. Aboyade-Cole
(Station Manager, Tinubu Tax Office).
5.2.4
Mr. Abass began his presentation by stating that he had come with his team to
sensitise members so that nobody would have any reason not to pay tax. He
reminded members that the law requires every resident income earner to declare
his income to the LIRS honestly, compute the tax attendant to that income, and
pay the tax promptly.
5.2.5
He stated that members can comply by completing the Tax Form A which gives
all the information required for the Tax Office to compute the tax. He added
that a Form B (which has the applicable income tax so that the tax payer can
immediately know his tax bill) could also be completed.
5.2.6
He pointed out that the taxpayer can state what he deems as his income, and this
is better than waiting for the Tax Office to give a best of judgment ('BOJ')
142
assessment. He explained that the law requires personal income tax returns to be
filed on or before the 31st of March for the preceding year's income, and if a
person fails to do this, the Tax Office would raise a BOJ assessment. He added
that in giving the BOJ assessment, the LIRS adopts a scientific approach and
considers what obtains in the industry – by looking at the income of a legal
practitioner of similar age at bar to the defaulting tax-payer.
5.2.7
He added that a number of members have private offices and employ staff, thus
as employers of labour, it is the practitioner's responsibility to deduct Pay As
You Earn ('PAYE') Tax from the employees' remuneration and remit to the
Government on a monthly basis by the 10th day of the following month.
5.2.8
Regarding PAYE, he noted that it is part of the employer's responsibility to file
an annual return at the end of each year to account for his/ her duty as an agent
in deducting tax from staff emolument and remiting same to the LIRS as
principal.
5.2.9
He noted that it is also a practitioner's responsibility upon receipt of fees from a
client (who has removed a portion of the fee as withholding tax) to ensure that
the client remits the deduction to the Tax Authority so that it would be a credit
for the practitioner's income tax.
5.2.10 He summarised the three applicable aspects of income tax as:
a)
Personal income tax as a person - which must be filed and paid by the
31st of March of each year;
b)
Responsibility as an agent of government in deducting tax from
employee emoluments and remitting same to the government by the
10th day of the following month, and at the end of the year filing the
employees' tax return by the 31st of January of the following year; and
c)
Withholding tax deductions from clients which should be remitted to
the tax authority and tracked as a credit for the practitioner's income tax
liability.
5.2.11 He gave suggestions regarding payment of tax into the bank and advised that
tax payers ensure that payments are made to bank cashiers and not other
persons, and preferably by bank drafts which can be traced. He also advised that
in making tax payments, tax payers should ensure that their names are stated in
a consistent manner.
5.2.12 He noted that there are penalties for failure to abide by the stipulated tax
payment dates.He stated that failure to file annual returns for employees results
in a liability of =N=500,000 for corporate entities and =N=50,000 for
individuals; and failure to pay personal income tax by 31st of March results in a
fine of =N=50,000 in addition to the tax burden.
5.2.13 Questions were asked and comments made by several members including High
Chief Olufemi Daramola, Ms. Toyin Bashorun, Mrs. Lucy Ahaneku, Mr.
Chijioke Okoli, Mr. Bisi Iyaniwura, Ms. Lilian Eronini, Mr. D.N.S Torbari,
Chief Mrs. Balogun, Chief Wale Taiwo, Mrs. R.F Okunola, Ms Funke Aboyade
and Mr. Abioye Akerele.
5.2.14 Responding, Mr. Abass opined that his experience as a tax collector shows that
143
tax is an emotional issue. He stated that there is no bias or arbitrariness in tax
assessments, noting that tax is according to capacity, thus you can only pay tax
on your income. He advised that if any person goes to a tax office and feels that
they have been given an arbitrary assessment over and above their real income,
they can report to him and make a full disclosure under oath of their income.
5.2.15 He added that often the problem is in the definition of income as some people
feel that income is the surplus of earnings after expenses, but income is earnings
before any expense deduction. He stated that the process of assessment and
payment has been so simplified that anybody can now walk into a bank, fill a
self assessment form and pay immediately based on his/ her self assessed
income.
5.2.16 Speaking on the E-Tax card, he noted that once a person pays tax and fills out
the E-Tax Card Form the card would be processed for him or her. Subsequently,
the tax payer merely submits the card with a renewal form each year and the
payment is up-dated.
5.2.17 On withholding tax, Mr. Abass noted that it is the responsibility of the tax payer
to ensure that every client who deducts withholding tax from a fee payment
remits the deduction. He added that even if the client joins deductions from
several different professionals/ consultants and remits enbloc, the client would
attach a schedule giving details of the different tax payers and each tax payer
can have a stamped photocopy of the schedule for use as evidence of his/ her
tax credit.
5.2.18 On the issue of residency for tax purposes, he stated that if you are resident in
Lagos State you must pay your personal income tax here and nobody can
compel you to pay personal income tax elsewhere, and vice versa.
5.2.19 Concluding his response, Mr. Abass noted that the real problem is that people
generally do not declare their true income and pay appropriate tax thereon. He
stated, for example, that when a Nigerian who amassed assets and did not
disclose his true income dies the question of how much the benefactor was
paying as tax during his lifetime would arise and could create a problem when
the family seeks to do an assent or vesting deed to transfer the assets.
5.2.20 Mr. Abass ended by apologising for any rude treatment from his staff, and gave
out his cellphone numbers for people to call in and report any difficulties they
may have – 08077333939 and 07032662066
5.3
Funmi Quadri & Co.
5.3.1
Mr. Tope Ayanmade from Funmi Quadri & Co., gave a brief presentation on his
company's software which comprises Rules of Court and Law Reports. He
stated that the product comes in three versions: a multiuser USB version which
can be downloaded on a system and is updated automatically once the system is
connected to the internet; an iPad version; and a tablet PC version.
5.3.2
He stated that the USB version costs =N=100,000, but a 10% discount is being
offered to Lagos Branch members and payment can be split into 3 installments.
6.
Announcements
6.1
The Secretary made the following announcements:
144
6.1.1
The 18th Commonwealth Law Association Conference would hold from the 14th
to 18th of April, 2013 in Cape Town, South Africa. Information about the
conference can be obtained from the conference website –
'www.commonwealthlaw2013.org'. Registration and travel arrangements can
also be made through Leisure Afrique Ltd – 'info@leisureafrique.travel'.
6.1.2
The Catholic Lawyers Association of St. Agnes Catholic Church, Maryland,
Lagos sent an invitation to the 1st Sylvia Shinaba SAN Memorial Lecture on
Sunday 21st April, 2013 at 1.00 pm at the McGovern Hall, St Agnes Parish,
Maryland, Lagos. The Honourable Chief Judge of Lagos would deliver the
lecture on the topic "Empowering Women in Nigeria: Keeping the Promise of
the Law".
6.1.3
The NBA-Section on Business Law's 7th Annual Business Law
Conference would hold from the 17th to 19th of June, 2013 at the Eko Hotel &
Suites, Victoria Island, Lagos, with the theme: “The Legal Profession in an
Emerging Economy".
6.2
The Financial Secretary made an announcement that members who have paid
their 2013 Bar Practice Fees should submit photocopies of the Bank Teller to
the Bar Centre. He also reminded members of the need to pay their 2013 Branch
Dues on or before the 31st of May, 2013.
7.
Any Other Business
7.1
The Chairman announced that Mr. Bisi Iyaniwura had been appointed as Chair
of the Branch Child Rights' Committee, with Mrs. Funmi Obisan, Mrs. Abiye
Tam-George, Ms. Theresa O. Ibas and Mr. D.N.S Torbari as members. The
committee would, inter alia, organise an event to mark Children's Day.
7.2
The Chairman raised the issue of the recent announcements that the Nigeria
Police would begin enforcement of the ban on tinted glasses on vehicles. He
added that he had started removing the tinted film on his vehicle's glasses.
7.3
Mr. Bisi Iyaniwura deprecated the announcement, especially in relation to
vehicles with factory-tinted glasses, stating that there is an on-going law suit on
the matter. He suggested that the NBA write the Inspector General of Police
('IGP') to abide by the rule of law.
7.4
Chief Frank Agbedo pointed out that the matter is in court and the IGP (who is a
party to the suit) had submitted to the jurisdiction of the court and is represented
by counsel, therefore he should not take the law into his own hands. He
suggested that the Branch write the IGP urging him to respect the rule of law
and await the outcome of the court case.
7.5
The Chairman summed up the views and stated that the Branch would write to
the IGP on the issue and copy the Lagos State Commissioner of Police.
7.6
Mrs. Cynthia Ngozi Ikpama (a member of the Branch and Chief Superintendent
of Police) intervened and explained that anybody with a vehicle with factory
tinted glasses is allowed to seek a permit from the Police. She offered to help
any member of the Branch who requires assistance with obtaining the permit
and gave out her cell-phone number - 08033021798.
145
8.
Cutting of the Cake
8.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in April to come forward for the cutting of the
cake.
8.2
Seven members came out to mark one anniversary or the other, including Mr.
Otokhina, Mr Alfred Akinjo , Mrs. Abimbola Fatoki and Mrs. Akpieyi.
8.3
The Chairman invited Mr. Soji Omole to supervise the cutting of the cake.
9.
Closing
9.1
Mr. S.B. Onu moved for adjournment and Mrs. Akpieyi seconded.
9.2
Mr. Chuks Nwana said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 3.40 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 13TH MAY, 2013 AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH
COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5.
Marian N. Jones
6.
Philip O. Njeteneh
7.
Omohafe T. Opara
8.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9.
Chinedu N. Nduka
10.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
11.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
12.
Amaka I. Aneke
13.
Anthony O. Atata
14.
Ogbonnaya Agbafo
1.2
-
Members
1. Chief Theodore Ezeobi SAN
3.
Balogun E. Olubukunola (Mrs.)
5.
Falaiye Olawale G.
7.
Mazi O.C.K Unegbu
9.
Odupitan, Julius AO.
2)
146
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Asst. Publicity Secretary
Ex-Officio
Emmanuel Ofulue
4)
Mrs. Funmi Obisan
6)
Chief Ademola Sadipe
8)
Kenneth O. Onyema
10)
Okereke Obinna
11.
13.
15.
17.
19.
21.
23.
25.
27.
29.
31.
33.
35.
37.
39.
41.
43.
45.
47.
49.
51.
53.
55.
57.
59.
61.
63.
65.
67.
69.
71.
73.
75.
77.
79.
81.
83.
85.
87.
89.
91.
93.
95.
97.
99.
101.
103.
105.
107.
109.
111.
113.
115.
117.
119.
Babatola Apata
Elizabeth Nwokeocha
Okey Ilofulunwa
Rotimi Ogunjobi Esq.
Jonathan Olusegun Ajayi
Damilola Amore
Nelson C. Onyejaka
Chief Emeka Ngige, SAN
Tunji Gomez
G.M Sasore
Zik C. Obi II
L.A. Idu
Chukwuma Ezeala
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Chilaka Uzoamaka Angela
Juniper S. Musa
Chinenye C. Unaeze
Folasade Raji
Akerele Olajide G.
Ifeanyi Ilukwe
Osunwole Funmilola
Okala Onuka Uche
Chinyere Obasi
Chinweikpe Iwuchukwu
Marcus Eyarhono
Chukwuoha Anthony O.
Ajise Oduwa Jennifer
Grace Okewole
Nwokocha Elizabeth
Harrison Emmanuel
Wingate, Emmanuel
Ogundipe-Peters Victoria
Pauline Dominic-Yishawu
Tochukwu G. Ukogu
Emeka C. Nnamani
Patience Onoashagbe
Oluwafunke A. Jagun
Ologwu Moses Ogbonnia
Emeka Nwadioke
A.S Abimbola (JP)
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Nwana E. Chuks
Stephen Amalla
Sylvester Ekwueme
Anthony Nwogbe
Bash A. Ojo
Dayo Famakin-Johnson
Mofoluwaso King
Kehinde Evbuoma
Uba Ogechi
Prisca Anene
Ehumadu A.N
Obiora Egwuatu
Gabriel E. Ojiekhudu
Martin A. Akpaka
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
120)
147
Ezemegbu Loveline
Rosalina Clomavi
Odegboh Terry
Wahab Ekundayo
Chizelu Emejulu
Eric Ikwele
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
Pa G.O Odunlami
A.O Fayokun
M.Obifarinde
Chief K.S Olutekunbi
Olumide Oyesanya
Abiye Tam-George
Okonkwo T.N.T
Patience Patrick Udoh
Ebenezer A. Akindolie
Ngozi N. Nwangwa
Njoku Chukwuemeka C.
Anene Nwadukwe
Frances Onwunali
Gloria Ireka
Echeme Ekeghe
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Onyekachi C. Uko
Abimbola Owulade
Frank Agbedo
Umeh C.J
Ugbeye E. Solomon
Adeyemi S. Dossou
Omiyale Amaka
Udoh, Lucy P.
Dauda Shakirudeen
Nwonyishi N. Abundantius
Lucky Ayeki
Florence Agbara
Chizelu Emejulu
Onyema Val. Ejikeme
W.A Gbadebo
Nsirim Omuna-Amadi
Momodu Aliu
Akunyili Okey
George Nwabunike
Emeka Okpoko
Mary Akin-Ajayi
Nelson C.S. Ogbuanya
Onifade Kafayat
Temitayo Kareem
Idedia Sandra
Jide Akerele
Ferguson Chioma (Mrs.)
Uchenna Nwadialo
Uzoamaka A. Chilaka
Idowu Olaniyi
Orakwelu Uche
121.
123.
125.
127.
129.
131.
133.
135.
137.
139.
141.
143.
145.
147.
149.
151.
153.
155.
157.
159.
161.
163.
165.
167.
169.
171.
173.
175.
177.
179.
181.
183.
185.
187.
189.
191.
193.
195.
197.
199.
201.
203,
205.
207.
209.
211.
213.
215.
217.
219.
221.
223.
225.
227.
229.
I.O Abdulhameed
Mbanugo Udenze
David Durwode
Adebayo Oriola
Otera Grace
Biriyai Dambo
Edward Porbeni
Okey Eneh
Achunine, Peter C.
M.S Umar
Julius Ugese
Bola Arumashaun
Okey Nwachukwu
Arubaleze, Kenechukwu
Okolo Chukwuma
Unah Niome Yvette
Obi Uchenna Casmir
Muyiwa Abe
Ngonadi Ngozi
Kolade Sofola
Adaku Mbamea
Funmi Adeniyi
Alfred Uwaka
Cosmas Chukwuma
Philomena Omorodion
Joseph Ikoro
Bishi Adedoyin
Kayode Ajiboye
Prince Ikechukwu Nwafuru
Dixy Oddiri
Uduak Bhavnani
Israel Adelakun Oyebimbola E.
Femi Olayinka
Ifeanyi Eze
Silva Ugo Osuji II
Edeogbaji, Oliver
Matthew Karieren
Kayode Ojo
Owhofawhoraye S.A
Uwala E. Murphy-Akpieyi
Ijeoma Nkuche
Desire Butoku
Oluwole Okelana
Ihesiulo E. Ben
Adesola Falaiye
Ayo Adesanmi
Israel Shola Matesun
Augustine Okeh
Rudolf Ezeani
Akeem Oyeboade
Alli S.B.
Celestine Nwankwo
Oby Ofili
Mohammed Yilji Jibrin
Ikenna U. Onwusika
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
230)
148
T.M Kareem
Noah Adewale
D.N.S Torbari Esq.
Agu Nnaemeka R.
Joy O. Nzube Uzoeghelu
Numa O. Erakpofoke
Moses Ani
Francis Chuka Agbu SAN
Igodo, C. O.
John Onyeakpa
Nnenna Onyeama
Prince B. Ude Ikpenwa
Dupe Ogunbanwo
Ikuesan Oluwadamilola
Ngozi Enyesiobi-Igwesi
Omole Olusoji
Ayodeji Bobaderin
Cynthia N. Ikpeama
Okeke Ifeoma
Oboku Horsfall
Caroline C. Ndulue
Jinadu Babajide
Jeffery Eboh
Sylva Ogwemoh
O. Akinniranye
Ihuoma Pepple
Shitta Omoshola
Adekunle Alabi
Tosin Fashogbon
Ero Kate
Adeola Saba
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Aderonke Sijuwade
Chijioke A.A.
Okoroji Chidi
Kenneth Onyema
C. O. Obinzu-Dosunmu
Bode Omoboriowo
Rose Agbo
Fidelis Egho
Ada Udongi
Udoji Andy Nzube
Janet Obadare
Tara Aisida
Abioye Akerele
Shobamowo, G. Joseph
Abraham Oluwabunmi
Ndieghe Iwatt
Hannibal Uwaifo
Dennis O. Akhagba
F.A.Dalmeida
Layo Sunmonu
N.C. Ukwuomah
Pa Odunlami G.O
Owolabi Adeniyi
231.
233.
235.
237.
239.
241.
243.
245.
247.
249.
251.
253.
255.
257.
259.
261.
263.
265.
267.
269.
271.
273.
275.
277.
279.
281.
283.
285.
287.
289.
291.
293.
295.
297.
1.3
R.C. Maduagwu
Ojo Olawale Michael
Victor Usifoh
Okeke Nwamaka M.
Oluwafemi Adeniyi
Oluwabusola A. Fuwa
Egeonu Gloria
Olakunle Olanrewaju
Ijomah Richard Bonny
Ezeokeke U.N
Chief E.A Otokhina
Lawrence Austine Coleman
Ifeanyi Ilukwe
Andrew Ohi Enakhifo
Musibau I. Alagbala
F.R. Adeniyi
Aliu Ajayi
Asuoha Matthew
Ilemobayo T. Mercy
Emmanuel Orhoro
Adedamola Adebisi
Onyenweuzo J.
Dele Ojogbede
Nnaji Chidume Einika C.
Chief Wale Taiwo
Adekunle-Fatokun, Aramide
Kamar Raji
Igwekile Vera
Gboyega Kolade
Ebenezer A.
Panox, Alex Tunde
Etiti E.O
Anthonia Eke
Obi, Uche Stan
Apologies
1.
Senator Onyeabo Obi
3.
Boma Ozobia
5.
Dr. Theodore Okonkwo
7.
S.B. Onu
9.
Dayo Onakoya
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
278)
280)
282)
284)
286)
288)
290)
292)
294)
296)
298)
Joyce Oduah (Mrs.)
Augustine Egwuato
S. Famuyiwa
Okpataku Elizabeth
Onyeka E. Egbuike
Okeke Ngozi
Ifeoma Obi
Mrs. Susan Esang
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Olajide Benjamin
Egbe U. Aride
Anene Nwadukwe
A.G. Anafi
Mindia Y. Chiwar
Sandy Diana
Gyang Daniel
Edem O. Uko
Sodje E.P.
Simon Chingle
Oyayipo J. Ibukun
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs.)
Okeke Ejike
Kaduru, Chikezie D.
Bivins Uwagboi
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
Aluba J. Orji
Sessi S. Akojenu
Mojirola Fayokun
Konze Kennedy C.
Ajose Moses
Kayode Odumosu
Abaniwonda K. Foluke
Lucky Ekarume
Stephen Obajaja
2)
4)
6)
8)
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede
Seyi Akinwunmi
Olasupo Olaibi
Geff Eze
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 2.40 pm.
2.2
The Chairman apologised for pushing back the meeting by an hour and a half
explaining that it was occassioned by the on-going NBA National Rule of Law
Workshop holding at the City Hall, Lagos – which many members of the
Branch were obliged to attend.
3.
Lecture by Mr. John Tingle
3.1
The Chairman explained that Mr. Chuka Agbu SAN's lawfirm – Lexaviar
149
Partners – had sponsored the visit of a Guest Lecturer from the United
Kingdom.
3.2
The Publicity Secretary introduced the Guest Lecturer – Mr. John Tingle – the
Head of International Development of the Nottingham Law School, Nottingham
Trent University.
3.3
Mr. John Tingle addressed the meeting on the topic – "Medical Litigation in
England: A Call for Professionalism of Healthcare Staff and How Lawyers Can
Help Achieve This".
3.4
He noted that historically, the pace of medical malpractice cases was dictated by
the parties. Thus, prior to 1996, civil trials in medical malpractice cases were
more of a trial by ambush with the parties not really knowing what case they
were coming to answer to. However, the 1996 Pre-Action Protocols in England
revolutionised malpractice cases by requiring hospitals to disclose all necessary
information to the other side. The reforms put the judge in the driving seat and
enshrined effective case management procedures.
3.5
He explained that the reforms were driven by the Government response to the
growing number of avoidable patient deaths in hospitals – which led to the
setting up of the Lord Francis Panel. The Panel Report identifies the patient as
the most important person in the medical care cycle.
3.6
He added that every NHS Hospital in Engand is now required to state how it is
goin to implement the Report. Thus, the focus has changed from hospital's
concern with balancing the books (a system in which the doctors and nurses do
not primarily focus on patient care) to a system where they should not
necessarily be more academic but more practical and caring.
3.7
He concluded his presentation by advising that our duty as lawyers is to identify
new ways of making doctors and nurses more concerned about the patients
under their care – for instance by identifying fundamental rights provisions that
can be used to trigger hospital adminsitrators to take more painstaking care of
their patients.
3.8
He rounded up his presentation to much applause, and responded to questions
from members.
3.9
The Chairman called on Mr. Ogbonnaya Agbafo (an Ex-Officio member of the
Executive Committee) to give the vote of thanks.
3.10
Mr. Ogbonnaya Agbafo thanked the law firm of Lexaviar Partners for their
generosity in bringing the Guest Lecturer. He briefly recapped some key themes
of the lecture such as: a conscious policy of error avoidance; and a new
awareness that the law would be enforced, and suggested that the lecture be
reproduced in a form that can be used as a first step in policy formulation in the
area of medical malpractice in Nigeria.
3.11
On behalf of the Executive Committee and members of the Branch he thanked
Mr. John Tingle for the short but impactful lecture.
3.12
The Chairman thanked Lexaviar Partners and Mr. Chuka Agbu again for
facilitating the lecture, and enjoined other large hearted members of the Branch
to follow te example.
150
4.
Minutes of Last Meeting
4.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
on the 8th of April, 2013. Chief Emeka Ngige SAN made a correction to
paragraph 6.2 of the minutes and suggested that the minutes should reflect the
announcement made by the Financial Secretary.
4.2
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN moved for adoption of the minutes as corrected, and
Mr Bode Omoboriowo seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
5.
Matters Arising
5.1
Branch Office Accomodation
5.1.1
The Chairman reported that two available rooms had been identified within the
premises of the Lagos High Court and he would approach the Chief Judge to
allocate the rooms for use as the Branch Office.
5.1.2
In response to a question by Mr. A.O. Fayokun, the Chairman confirmed that
the rooms are bigger and he hoped that the Branch Office would move before
the next meeting. The Chairman also stated that the Chief Judge had sent
someone to inspect the Robbing Room for the purpose of renovating it.
5.2
Lekki Allocation
5.2.1
The Chairman stated that the Branch is still in the process of paying the backlog of land charges.
5.3
2012 Branch Bar Dinner Report
4.3.1
The Chairman reported that the Executive Committee is still awaiting the report
from the Committee Chairman (Mr. Gogo Karibi-Whyte).
5.4
Audited Accounts
4.4.1
Mazi O.C.K.Unegbu handed over the Audit Committee Report to the Chairman,
and the Chairman stated that the Executive Committee would consider it at the
next meeting and brief the General Meeting.
5.5
J.I.C Taylor Lecture
5.5.1
The 1st Vice Chairman stated that the lecture had been re-scheduled again in
view of the on-going NBA National Workshop and the unavoidable absence of
the Guest Speaker. He added that the lecture has been moved to the 28th of May,
2013.
5.6
Ad-Hoc Committee on Sheriffs' Section
5.6.1
The Chairman reported that the chairman of the Committee (Mr. S.B. Onu) sent
in an apology because his brother was killed in rather shocking circumstances in
the village and he was busy with arrangements for the burial.
5.7
Branch Insurance Scheme
151
5.7.1
The Chairman reported that the Branch had zeroed in on two providers, viz: the
insurance subsidiary of First Bank and Aiico Insurance Plc, and was negotiating
the applicable premiums and scope of cover.
5.7.2
Mr. A.O. Fayokun reminded the meeting of his earlier objection that the Branch
should not organise its own insurance scheme, as it should be a national matter.
He stated that the National Body has a well established scheme which is paid
for from our annual subscription, and if the National scheme is no longer
operative, we as the Premier Branch should champion its resuscitation.
5.7.3
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN rose to support Mr. A.O. Fayokun's suggestion and
to give additional information. She explained that the administration of Chief
Wole Olanipekun SAN (as NBA President, and in which she served as 1st Vice
President) the National Body put in an insurance scheme which was paid for
from the NBA's purse. She stated that the scheme appears to have lapsed as the
next Administration did not continue to pay the premium.
5.7.4
She opined that nothing stops us from having multiple insurance policies,
pointing out that the law requires compulsory life insurance under the Pencom
Regulations for every employer with five or more employees.
5.7.5
Chief Emeka Ngige SAN whilst agreeing with Mr. A.O. Fayokun stated that
nothing stops the Branch from doing its own scheme provided the premium
would be deducted from Branch Dues and not made an additional burden on
members.
5.7.6
The Chairman reminded the meeting that the issue had been discussed and
agreed upon at a previous Branch Meeting and it was on that basis that the
Executive Committee went into discussions with insurance companies. He
added that the focus is to see how the burden can be reduced for members who
are interested.
5.7.7
Mr. A.O. Fayokun queried why the Branch was not ready to champion the push
to resuscitate the National scheme. He noted that the Branch Chairman is very
close to the NBA President and can raise the issue with him. He concluded that
he was not opposed to the Branch scheme, but the Chairman should give details
and confirm that the premium would be paid from the current Branch Dues.
5.7.8
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde suggested that the Executive Committee should coopt seasoned people in the negotiations with the insurance companies because
of the fine print embedded in insurance policies.
6.
Branch 2013 Law Week
6.1
The Chairman read out the names of members of the Branch 2013 Law Week
Committee, which had been inaugurated and had set to work.
7.
Branch 2013 Elections
7.1
The Chairman informed the meeting that Mr. Obi Okwusogu SAN had declined
the appointment as Chairman of the Election Committee (in the light of pressing
assignments from the National Body). He stated that the Executive Committee
had elevated Mr. Lanre Oyetunji as chairman, and appointed Mr. Geff Eze to
complete the membership of the committee. He stated that the Executive
Committee had decided that the Elections would hold on Monday the 8th of
152
July, 2013, whilst the Branch Annual General Meeting would hold on Thursday
the 11th of July, 2013 – at which the new Executive Committee would be
presented to the Branch. He noted that the Election Manifesto Day would hold
at the June General Meeting.
7.2
In response to a protest by Mrs. Uche Ikwueme that there were no women in the
Election Committee, the Chairman stated that in view of the fact that the Branch
Bye-Laws specified a five-member composition the Executive Committee
would consider removing one of the members and replacing him with a woman.
8.
Mr. Celestine Nwankwo's Case
8.1
Pa Tunji Gomez reported that a member of the Branch was arrested for
allegedly driving on the BRT Lane, charged to Court and remanded in Badagry
Prison for some days. He added that the matter would come up on the morrow
(Tuesday 14th May, 2013) and the Ikeja Branch had taken the matter up.
8.2
The Chairman thanked him and stated that he was fully aware of the matter. He
briefed the meeting on the steps he took immediately he was informed of the
matter. He assured members that he was working on it and had been speaking
with Mr. Celestine Nwankwo. He added that there were conflicting reports
about what happened.
8.3
Mr. Celestine Nwankwo came out to explain what actually happened. He stated
that he was driving on the Ikorodu Road close to Maryland when he was
accosted by Lastma officials who forcefully assaulted and arrested him despite
his insistence (and the corroboration of another motorist) that he did not drive
on the BRT. He added that he was taken to the Special Court near the State
Secretariat, Alausa-Ikeja, Lagos where his vehicle was impounded. He was
taken before a Magistrate at about 6.00 pm and formally charged.
8.4
He stated that he pleaded not guilty, and a lawyer (who there on some other
business) announced appearance for him and pleaded that as a lawyer he should
be allowed bail on his self-recognisance. The Magistrate refused that plea and
granted bail with two Sureties with =N=50,000 and evidence of five-years Tax
Clearance Certificates. He added that he immediately called a relative who
came with two civil servants but the Magistrate had closed and left by the time
they arrived. He explained that he slept with the Police that night and the next
day was taken to Badagry Prison. On Thursday (after the Public Holiday), he
perfected the bail terms and was released on bail.
8.5
The Chairman stated that the 1st Vice Chairman (as chair of the Branch Human
Rights Committee) would lead a team of lawyers to represent Mr. Celestine
Nwankwo in Court. He called for volunteers.
8.6
Mr. A.O. Fayokun argued that the matter should not be treated with kid gloves.
He insisted that the Branch must make noise about it, as it made no sense for a
lawyer to go to Court and plead that he is a lawyer and another lawyer would
send him to Siberia. He insisted that it was a matter that the Chairman must
handle personally.
8.7
Pa Tunji Gomez agreed that the Chairman should lead the team of lawyers and
the Branch Bus should carry as many lawyers as were prepared to go.
8.8
The Chairman agreed to lead the team, and called on every member to be there.
153
He added that an sms message would be sent out to all members.
9.
SCUML Registration
9.1
The Chairman called on Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN to brief the meeting about
the status of the case filed by the NBA National Body.
9.2
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN informed the meeting that in addition to the
Originating Summons, the NBA also filed a Motion for Interlocutory Injunction
to restrain Central Bank of Nigeria from enforcing the directive on complianve
by lawyers. She stated that Central Bank of Nigeria had filed a response, so the
NBA issued a letter to the Respondents advising that they maintain status quo in
view of the case and pending motion.
9.3
She stated that the NBA's legal team is being led by Chief Wole Olanipekun
SAN. The matter would come up on the 24th of May, 2013 before Hon. Justice
Kolawole at the Federal High Court, Abuja, however the Court would not likely
sit on that date as the Judge was reportedly out of the country and not likely to
be back by then.
9.4
She added that they had received reports that in two cases accounts were
blocked on the 1st of May, 2013, until two days later when the lawyers involved
informed the Bank that the NBA had gone to Court and the accounts were
unblocked.
9.5
Mr. Babatola Apata thanked Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN, and noted that whilst
the reprieve was for existing accounts, lawyers seeking to open new accounts
were being required by banks to show evidence of Scuml registration.
10.
Any Other Business
10.1
The Chairman informed the meeting of the kidnap of the wife, daughter and
driver of Hon Justice Bode Rhodes-Vivour JSC. He noted that Mrs. Doyin
Rhodes-Vivour is an active and very supportive member of the Branch.
10.2
He stated that he accompanied the NBA President on a visit to the RhodesVivour Residence to empathise with the learned Jurist. As at the time of their
visit the kidnappers had not yet contacted the family but had contacted some
other people.
10.3
The Chairman added that he had issued a Press Release to Silverbird Television
appealing to the kidnappers to release the victims. He implored members to
continue praying for the release of the victims, and urged people to be security
conscious.
10.4
In response to a question by Mr. Zik Obi about whether there was a chance that
the new Branch Bye-Laws would be adopted at the Branch Annual General
Meeting, the Chairman stated that the Executive Committee would work
towards that.
10.5
Mr. Gboyega Kolade asked about the fate of the lawyers estate.
11.
Announcements
11.1
The Chairman informed the meeting of a vacancy announcement for a young
154
lawyer between 2-4 years post-call. Interested persons should submit their
Resumes at the Branch Office on or before Friday 17th May, 2013.
11.2
The Secretary made the following announcements:
11.2.1 NBA Rule of Law Workshop holds from the 12th to 14th of May, 2013 at the
City Hall, Lagos with the theme "The Rule of Law the Bedrock for Sustainable
Democracy and Development in Nigeria".
11.2.2 The International Legal Practice and Law Firm Management Committees of the
NBA-Section on Legal Practice holds a one-day workshop on 'Productivity
Tools for Sole Practitioners and Small Law Firms' on Friday 17 th May, 2013 at
the Leadership and Vision Centre, 25b Macdonald Road, off Lateef Jakande
Road, Ikoyi, Lagos from 9.00 am to 3.00 pm..
11.2.3 The Federal Inland Revenue Service, Onikan Integrated Tax Office invites
members to attend a sensitization programme between Professionals and FIRS
to educate and create awareness on the management of Value Added Tax
(VAT) remittance to FIRS. The programme holds on Tuesday 21st may, 2013 at
the FIRS, Onikan Micro and Small tax Office, 4th Floor, City Hall, Catholic
Mission Street, Lagos at 10.00 am.
11.2.4 The NBA National Executive Committee Meeting holds from the 5th to 7th of
June, 2013 at Ijaw House, near NNPC Filling Station, Yenagoa, Bayelsa State.
11.2.5 Perchstone and Graeys invites members to its Annual Lecture Series for 2013
on the theme “Securing Energy for Emerging Markets – The African-Asian
Experience". The conference holds on Friday the 7th of June, 2013 at 9.30 am at
the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry, FICCI,
Federation House, Tansen Marg, New Delhi 110001 India.
11.2.6 The 7th Annual Business Law Conference of the NBA – Section on Business
Law (SBL) is scheduled to hold from June 17th – 19th 2013 at the Eko Hotel and
Suites, Victoria Island, Lagos, with the theme: “The Legal Profession in an
Emerging Economy”. Detailed information about conference fees and
registration can be obtained from the SBl website 'www.nba-sbl.org'. You can
also contact the hardworking Section Administrator - Mr. Endurance O.
Uhumuavbi on 08054881300 or via email 'endurance@nba-sbl.org'.
11.2.7 The 2nd Forum on Anti-Corruption West Africa Edition holds on the 18th and
19th of June, 2013 at the Four Points by Sheraton Hotel, Lagos. Ms Arunma
Otteh (the SEC DG) leads 'an exceptional speaker faculty to provide practical
guidance on how to resolve complex anti-bribery compliance issues'. The
conference (which has pre and post- conference working groups on the 17th and
20th of June, 2013) is a must-attend event for general counsel and also for
external counsel specialising in international trade, compliance, litigations
mergers and joint ventures. The conference fee ranges from $1995 to $3345,
and registration may be done online at 'www.c5-Online.com/ACWestAfrica'.
11.3
The Financial Secretary announced that the 31st of May, 2013 is the last date for
payment of Branch Dues (for eligibility to vote and or be voted for at the
forthcoming Branch Elections). He also requested that persons who have not yet
submitted the photocopy of their 2013 Bar Practice Fee Teller/ Receipt should
please send same to the Branch Office.
155
12.
Cutting of the Cake
12.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in May to come forward for the cutting of the cake.
12.2
Over 20 members came out to mark one anniversary or the other.
12.3
The Chairman invited Mrs. Obele Akinniranye to supervise the cutting of the
cake.
14.
Closing
14.1
Mrs. Morenike Obi-Farinde moved for adjournment and Mr. Soji Omole
seconded.
14.2
Miss. Ande Egbe said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 5.00 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION – LAGOS BRANCH
MINUTES
OF THE MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING OF THE NIGERIAN BAR ASSOCIATION LAGOS BRANCH HELD ON MONDAY 10TH JUNE, 2013 AT THE FOYER OF THE HIGH
COURT OF LAGOS STATE, IGBOSERE, LAGOS
1.
Attendance
1.1
Officers
1.
Taiwo O. Taiwo
2.
Alex N. Muoka
3.
Martin A. Ogunleye
4.
Seth O. S. Amaefule
5.
Marian N. Jones
6.
Philip O. Njeteneh
7.
Omohafe T. Opara
8.
Tolani Edu-Adeola
9.
Chinedu N. Nduka
10.
Obidi Cecil Alajuronye
11.
Charles Ola-Oni Ogunfuwa
12.
Amaka I. Aneke
13.
Ogbonnaya Agbafo
-
Chairman
Secretary
1st Vice Chairman
2nd Vice Chairman
Treasurer
Financial Secretary
Social Secretary
Publicity Secretary
1st Asst Secretary
2nd Asst Secretary
Asst. Fin Secretary
Asst. Social Secretary
Ex-Officio
Members
1)
Seni Adio, Esq.
3)
Olufunmi Oluyede (Mrs.)
5)
Gogo Karibi-Whyte
7)
Nwana E. Chuks
2)
4)
6)
8)
Senator Mike Ajegbo CON
Hannibal Uwaifo
Annie Aimua
Chief Ademola Sadipe
1.2
156
9)
11)
13)
15)
17)
19)
21)
23)
25)
27)
29)
31)
33)
35)
37)
39)
41)
43)
45)
47)
49)
51)
53)
55)
57)
59)
61)
63)
65)
67)
69)
71)
73)
75)
77)
79)
81)
83)
85)
87)
89)
91)
93)
95)
97)
99)
101)
103)
105)
106)
109)
111)
113)
115)
117)
Gbolahan Gbadamosi
Emeka-Iloegbunam, Gerty
Joy O. Nzube Uzoeghelu
Uche Ikwueme (Mrs.)
Geff O. Ize
Odupitan, Julius A.O
Uduak Bhavnani
Ejadairo O. Ekpo
Ero Kate E.
Solomon Afahokor
Wahas Ekundayo
Evelyn C. Agu
Owhofawhoraye S.A
Uwadehwe Ogheneavona
Vivian Okoh-Olutunfase
Hilary Ndubuisi Umah
Owonikoko Titiola P.
Arogundade, Olawale Y.
Mary Akin-Ajayi
Godwin N.A Enebeli
Olusola Adegbonmire
Ama Fayemiwo (Mrs.)
Ngozi Nwangwa
Roma Wayo
Omorodion Philomena N.
Rose Agbo
Chikwendu Ogbonna
Mbanugo Udenze
Adeniji Adenike
Agbana Aribake F.
Frances Onwunali
Ubani-Ukoma Lawrence
Ihesiulo E.
Oboma, Patrick Hans
Adebisi Sanda
Grace Adenubi
Obieze Ogochukwu
Ologwu Moses Ogbonnia
Chinwe Mbakwem
Egeonu Gloria
Bello Yusuff B.
Oshodi Olushola
A.S Abimbola
Angya A. David
Biriyai Dambo
Gyang Daniel
Aghaonu Chris
Dave Eluemunor
Hilary Ekpo
Bolanle Fatile
Chike Odezugo
Uduak John Ekott
Oby Ofili
Irase I. Ohiokpehai
Olatunji Momodu
10)
12)
14)
16)
18)
20)
22)
24)
26)
28)
30)
32)
34)
36)
38)
40)
42)
44)
46)
48)
50)
52)
54)
56)
58)
60)
62)
64)
66)
68)
70)
72)
74)
76)
78)
80)
82)
84)
86)
88)
90)
92)
94)
96)
98)
100)
102)
104)
106)
108)
110)
112)
114)
116)
118)
157
Chukwuma Ezeala
Adekunle-Fatokun, Aramide
Lucy Ahaneku
Amaka Itegboje
Onyeagwa Angela U. (Mrs.)
Geraldine Wey
Otera Grace
Harrison Emmanuel
Ugbeye E. Solomon
Tochukwu Godwin Ukogu
Jonathan Olusegun Ajayi
Victor Usifoh
Miss A.O Somoye
Onafadeji Opeoluwa
Chijioke A.A.
Edem O. Uko
Oluwashola Keshinro
Adeniyi Oluwafemi E.
Cosmas Chukwuma
F.B. Odesanya
Wale Williams
Ezemegbu Loveline
Adebayo Oriola
Ifeanyi Okechukwu
Okereke Patrick
Obiora Atuegwu Egwuatu
Chief Emeka Ngige, SAN
Omotayo Adetona Esq.
B. Onwuka Igwe
Ihuoma Pepple
Ikenna Okoli
Abdulrasheed Ibrahim
Matthew Nkap
Vincent Owhor
Adekunle Alabi
Obi Uchenna
Kalunta Chimezie
Obaremo Olawale O.
Ikechukwu Obi
Ukaejiofor Harry O.
Adeola Saba
Umoru David
Ibukun Orekoya
Aluba J. Orji
Emmanuel Orhoro
Charles Nneji
H.O Ndubuisi
Enobong Etteh
Derby Abu
Promise Asikpo
Paul E. Okoli
Eze Anthony Chikaodili
Patience Onoashagse
Chinyere Uhegbu
Layo Olugbemi
119)
121)
123)
125)
127)
129)
131)
133)
135)
137)
139)
141)
143)
145)
146)
149)
151)
153)
155)
157)
159)
161)
163)
165)
167)
169)
171)
173)
175)
177)
179)
181)
183)
185)
187)
189)
191)
193)
195)
197)
199)
201)
203)
205)
207)
209)
211)
213)
215)
217)
219)
221)
223)
225)
227)
Chijioke Okoli
Chief Wale Taiwo
Toyin Ogunbambi
Omotara Aisida
Lilian Eronini (Miss)
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN
Kenny Bashiru
Adekunle Oyesanya, SAN
Fidelis Egho
Onyeka E. Egbunike
Mindia Yahaya Chiwar
Anayo Gabriel Ishiwu
U.E Udoh
Anthony N. Nwogbe
Anyaegbunam Nonyelum
Alli S.B.
Lawrence Austinecoleman O.
Benson Akunya
Lucky Ayeki
Olumide Oyesanya
Anthony Banjo
Ajise Oduwa Jennifer (Mrs.)
Kunle Jimoh
Etiti E.O
Anuoluwapo Cardoso
Chukwudi Nneke
Eneze Chioma Stella
Geroge Nwabunike
Damilola Amore
Ndueghe Iwatt
Ifeanyi Ilukwe
Ngozi Igwesi
Rotimi Ogunjobi Esq.
Etiuzalle Emma L.
Ejike Okeke K.
Israel Shola Matesun
Kenneth C. Joshua
Ajoola Lepite
Owolabi Adeniyi
Anthonia Eke
Mrs. Mercy Okereke
Jude Nkeonye Iloba
Clifford O.Atakere
Nelson Ogbuanya
F.R Adeniji
Yomi Fagbayi
O. Cheetham-West
S. Famuyiwa
Nnenna Onyeama
Fagbure Aderinsola
A.O Lema
Chief Frank Agbedo
John Duru
Bolatumi Animashaun
F.A. Dogbajale
120)
122)
124)
126)
128)
130)
132)
134)
136)
138)
140)
142)
144)
146)
148)
150)
152)
154)
156)
158)
160)
162)
164)
166)
168)
170)
172)
174)
176)
178)
180)
182)
184)
186)
188)
190)
192)
194)
196)
198)
200)
202)
204)
206)
208)
210)
212)
214)
216)
218)
220)
222)
224)
226)
228)
158
Emmanuel Ofulue
A.O Fayokun
Morenike Obi-Farinde
Joyce Oduah (Mrs.)
Mrs. Stella Ugboma
Onebu Temidayo O.
Akerele Olajide G.
Martin Agozien Akpaka
Edward Porbeni
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Chidiebere Kingsley Okeke
Stephen O. Obajaja
Emeka Nwadioke
Sylvester Ekwueme
Augustine Egwuatu
Bob C.O. Ijioma
Layi Arikewuyo
Onyejaka Nelson C.
Njoku Chukwuemeka
Adenike Komolafe
Edwin U. Madubuofu
Grace Okewole A.
Okeke Ijeoma (Mrs.)
Aribisala Adekunle N.
Davies Olayinka
Adebukunola Timi
Uche Nwammadu
Shobamowo, G. Joseph
Egbe U. Ande
Juniper S. Musa
Arubaleze Kenechukwu
Oyeyipo J. Ibukun
Olufemi Botoku
Olakanmi Arowosegbe
Ugwu Leonard
Oluwagbope Adenuga
Stephen Amalla
Nwanyishi N. Abundantus
Fidelis Ijege Akra
Ogbudu S.B.
Pat Atuchukwu
Onyebuchi Ede
Silva Ugo Osuji II
Diana Sandy
Austin Modo Chilo (Mrs.)
Abdulwahab Abubakar
Bode Omoboriowo
Odufa Etoegbe
Okechukwu Ubah
Eric Ikwele
Charles Nneji
Dayo Onakoya
Fidelis Ijege Akra
Obiageli Eze
Emokpae Stephanie U.
229)
231)
233)
235)
237)
239)
241)
243)
245)
247)
249)
251)
253)
255)
257)
259)
261)
263)
265)
267)
269)
271)
273)
275)
277)
279)
281)
283)
285)
287)
289)
291)
293)
295)
297)
399)
301)
303)
305)
307)
309)
311)
313)
315)
317)
319)
321)
323)
325)
327)
329)
331)
333)
335)
337)
Mohammed Yilji Jabrin
Okafor Chigozie O.
Ogo Onyia
Olufunke Loko
Foluso Fayokun
Dorothy Bassey
Kenneth Ahia
Tochukwu Chukwumerije
Madueke Okafor
Sunday A. Adesokan
Wale Adesokan
Okey Ilofulunwa
Funmi Adeniyi
Umeh, C.J.
Akinjeji Omolara
Obinna Okereke
Cythia N. Ikpeama
Joe Onyenweuzi
Adesayo Adekunle
Osaro Eguasa
Nkechi Nnajiofor
Abiye Tam-George
Shadrack Chidozie Orekwu
Chike Achike-Onua
Andrew Ohi Enakhifo
Adeleke Benedict
Osuala E. Nwagbara
Oluwole Okelana
Okeke Nwamaka M.
Anne Nneka Ukute
Akeem Oyeboade
Dero Daniels
Omole Olusoji
Bolarinwa Gbemi
Justine I. Enang
Okechukwu Ubah
Tunji Gomez
Edem O. Uko
Obasi Chinyere
Mallong Peter H.
Samuel O. Olorungbemi
Torbari D.N.S
Rosalind Clomavi
Sam M. Iloabuchi
Onyeka E. Egbunike
Jimoh Saka Agaka
A.J. Owonikoko SAN
Mazi O.C.K Unegbu
Abioye Akerele
Aghaonu Chris
H.O. Ndubuisi
Agbana Florence
Oduntan K.M
Silva Ugo Osuji II
Onyebuchi Ede
230)
232)
234)
236)
238)
240)
242)
244)
246)
248)
250)
252)
254)
256)
258)
260)
262)
264)
266)
268)
270)
272)
274)
276)
278)
280)
282)
284)
286)
288)
290)
292)
294)
296)
298)
300)
302)
304)
306)
308)
310)
312)
314)
316)
318)
320)
322)
324)
326)
328)
330)
332)
334)
336)
338)
159
Nnamani Emeka C.
Tinubu M.F. (Mrs.)
Uche Nwadialo
Marcus Eyarhowo
Olufemi Onakoya
Chuks Nwana
Eyinnaya Uwaezuoke
Ikechukwu Uwanna
Samuel Okon Ekpeowoh
Abaniwonda Kafilat Foluke
Dike E. Stephen
Kosile O. Princess
Osunnole Funmilola
Kamar Raji
Babatola Apata
Prince Azubuike Onyekwelu
Ibas, Theresa O.
Mrs. Ogunsanmi
Linda A. Oladotun
Onuoha Ndubisi
Steven Majebi
Adetola Adeleke
Emeka Ogbodo
Chizelu Emejulu
R.C. Maduagwu
Chike M. Nwolisa
Elizabeth Nwokocha
Francis Nwajei
Oboku Horsfall
George Opeyemi Okusanya
Chika Kalu
Femi Fajolu
Uko Ike
Celestine Nwankwo
Precious Akhanolu
Chris Okeke
Godwin N.A. Enebeli
E.O Etiti Esq.
Onwukeme Maduka
Paul C. Onwuamaegbu
Onakoya Tunde
Ugo Ewelaku
Abimbola K. Olatunbosun
Nwokorie Charity
Francis Ogunbowale
Ajiboye-Olatunji
John Nwosu
Victor Usifoh
S.A Adesokan
Ifeji Okechukwu Charles
Dave Eluemunor
Chizelu Emejulu
Kehinde Evbuoma
Clifford O. Atakere
Adaku Mbama
339)
341)
343)
1.3
Dennis O. Akhagba
Rotimi Aladesanmi
Bunmi Ibrahim
Apologies
1)
Zik obi II
3)
S.B. Onu
5)
Gboyega Kolade
340)
342)
344)
Oluyemi Adewale
Okey Nwachukwu
Patrick N. Iheonu
2)
4)
6)
Boma Ozobia
Supo Olaibi
Anthony Atata
2.
Opening
2.1
The Meeting started at 1.10 pm.
2.2
Mrs. Lucy Ahaneku said the NBA Prayer.
3.
Minutes of Last Meeting
3.1
The meeting considered the minutes of the last Monthly General Meeting held
on the 13th of May, 2013.
3.2
Mrs. Uche Ikwueme moved for adoption of the minutes, and Chief Ademola
Sadipe seconded. The minutes were adopted for discussion.
4.
Matters Arising
4.1
Branch Office Accomodation
4.1.1
The Chairman reported that the Branch is still awaiting a response from the
Chief Judge formally allocating an office space to the Branch.
4.2
Lekki Allocation
4.2.1
The Chairman stated that the Branch is still trying to locate the file at Alausa.
He added that if it is not found then the next administration would continue the
process.
4.3
Audited Accounts
4.3.1
The Chairman reported that the full Executive Committee could not consider
the Audit Committee Report because he and the Secretary were away to
Yenegoa, Bayelsa State for the NBA-NEC meeting from Tuesday to Friday of
the previous week. He assured the members that the Executive Committee
would consider the Report and revert back to the house by the next general
meeting.
4.4
Ad-Hoc Committee on Sheriffs' Section
4.4.1
The Chairman stated that the chairman of the Committee (Mr. S.B. Onu) had
again sent in an apology.
4.5
Branch Insurance Scheme
160
4.5.1
The Chairman reported that he had made enquiries from the NBA-Ikeja Branch
and learnt that each member of the Branch pays a separate fee of =N=5,000
along with their Branch Due for insurance cover.
4.5.2
The Chairman introduced Mr. Femi Sofola from FBN Life Assurance
Company, who gave a brief presentation. Mr. Sofola stated that the policy
covers death and personal injury (permanent disability, temporary disability and
medical). He explained that the cover for death is =N=750,000, permanent
disability is =N=250,000, temporary disability is a limit of =N=250,000 and
medical is a limit of =N=100,000. He noted that being a group policy, the
premium is a flat rate of =N=5,000 per member per annum irrespective of age.
4.5.3
Messrs. O.C.K. Unegbu and Chuks Nwana suggested that the Branch get an
Insurance Broker to advise properly on the scope of cover and handle the
insurance.
4.5.4
In response to questions from members about the working of the scheme, the
Chairman stated that the Branch would put out a register so that from the next
legal year interested members would pay the applicable premium together with
their Branch Dues. He noted that it is not a mandatory scheme, and only
members who are interested and pay the premium would be covered.
4.6
Mr. Celestine Nwankwo's Case
4.6.1
The Chairman noted that members were probably already aware of the outcome
of the case from newspaper reports. He confirmed that Mr. Celestine Nwankwo
was discharged by the Magistrate and is considering his options. He invited the
meeting to applaud all the members who attended Court on the last adjourned
date.
4.7
Kidnap of the Rhodes-Vivours
4.7.1
The Chairman noted again that members were aware from newspaper reports
and other news media that Justice Bode Rhodes-Vivour's wife, daughter and
driver had been released by the kidnappers.
5.
Reports
5.1
2012 Branch Dinner Committee Report
5.1.1
The Chairman reported that he spoke with Mr. Gogo Karibi-Whyte who stated
that the report is not ready because he is expecting some information from the
Branch Treasurer. He assured the meeting that the Report would be submitted
before he leaves office.
5.2
J.I.C Taylor Lecture Committee Report
5.2.1
Presenting an interim oral report, Mr. Martin Ogunleye explained that the 9th
J.I.C Taylor memorial lecture held on the 31st May, 2013 at the City Hall, Lagos
and was well attended. He complained about a text message being circulated
disparaging him and stated that the J.I.C Taylor Lecture Committee was not in
charge of the purchase or distribution of laptops to young lawyers which was
done at the end of the lecture.
5.2.2
The Chairman confirmed that the J.I.C Taylor Lecture Committee did not
161
consider or discuss the issue of distribution of laptops. He added that a different
Committee was set up on the issue of laptops, and he saw the list of
beneficiaries for the first time at the lecture.
5.3
NBA-NEC Meeting Report
5.3.1
The Secretary explained that the NBA-NEC Meeting report was not ready as the
meeting ended the previous Friday and the Communiqué had not yet been
issued by the NBA.
6.
2013 Branch Law Week
6.1
The Chairman reported that the 2013 Branch Law Week Committee was ready
to deliver a first-class law week. He stated that the registration forms were ready
and invited the chairman of the Committee - Mr. Seyi Akinwunmi - to address
the meeting on the plans for the law week.
6.2
Mr. Seyi Akinwunmi stated that it was a great honour to have been appointed to
lead the organising committee. He noted that the preparations started late but
the Committee members were very committed.
6.3
He gave an overview of the programme for the Law Week, stating that the week
would start on Sunday the 23rd of June, 2013 with a novelty Football Match at
the Campos Square, Lagos. On Monday the 24th a Lawyers' Welfare Forum
would hold at which various medical practitioners would be invited to conduct
free health screening for members. He added that the traditional visit to Ikoyi
Prisons would hold that same day and appealed to members to donate items for
the visit.
6.4
He stated that the theme for the Law Week is "The State of the Nigerian Nation
and the Scourge of Insecurity", and Prof. Itse Sagay had agreed at very short
notice to be the keynote speaker at the opening session on Tuesday 25th June.
He added that on Wednesday 26th June, there would be breakout sessions in the
morning and a Bar-Bench Forum in the afternoon.
6.5
Continuing, Mr. Seyi Akinwunmi stated that on Thursday 26th June, there would
a session on security in conjunction with the American Embassy to be chaired
by Alhaji Musiliu Smith (the former Inspector General of Police), with
members of the Lagos State Security Council and the Lagos State
Commissioner of Police in attendance. In the evening, the Law Week Dinner
would hold at the City Hall. He noted that the Committee had arranged for the
"Sharp Band" and extracted a promise of the band's best performance, so that
the dinner would be the crowning 'after event' to commemorate the week.
6.6
He noted that one of the problems with the dinner is affordability and assured
that the Committee had come out with a very low registration fee rate to
encourage members to attend en masse.
6.7
He spoke about the cost of the Law Week, which includes the cost of hall hire,
tea and coffee breaks, drinks, lunch, memorabilia, bags, and noted that the total
budget was under =N=20,000,000 and was about half of the cost of the 2012
Law Week. He stated that the Committee has reached out to firms, corporate
organisations, and the State Government, but noted that the money cannot come
from those sources alone and therefore the members must support the fundraising efforts. He ended by requesting that the Branch give the Committee
162
=N=7,000,000 whilst the Committee would raise =N=13,000,000, and he
started the ball rolling with a personal donation of =N=500,000.
6.8
The Chairman stated that he would personally sponsor 10 young lawyers to the
Law Week by paying their registration and dinner fees.
6.9
Sen. Mike Ajegbo CON stated that the Committee made a request for seed
money from the Branch and nothing had been said about it. He urged the
Executive Committee to go ahead and release the funds to the Law Week
Committee.
7.
2013 Branch Elections
7.1
The Chairman noted that the Election Committee had already released the
guidelines for the Elections and handbills and posters were already flying. He
appealed to contestants to keep the contest civil, and invited the Election
Committee to address the meeting.
7.2
A member of the Election Committee - Mr. Geff Eze – came out and apologised
for the absence of the Committee chairman and Secretary (who were both out of
Lagos). He gave a brief report of the work of the Committee and noted that the
Election Guidelines had been published and the nomination forms were
available at the Bar Centre.
7.3
He noted that there were some challenges which had been communicated to the
Executive Committee, and in particular the list of eligible voters (which is
supposed to be published 30 days to the elections holding on the 8th of July,
2013) was still being awaited from the Branch Secretariat.
7.4
He assured the meeting that the Election Committee is poised to ensure a free,
fair and transparent election, and urged everyone to co-operate with the
Committee. He noted that the Committee had received comments and
complaints about previous election malpractices and would ensure that all the
loopholes are plugged.
7.5
Mr. Chijioke Okoli commented that at the NBA-NEC Meeting the previous
week some attention was drawn to the ferocious interest that bar elections at the
national and branch levels attract. He suggested that it is important for the rules
to be scrupulously followed so that all contestants can abide by the outcome. He
noted that the list must come out 30 days before the elections and it is
worrisome that up to today the list of eligible voters has still not been released.
7.6
The Chairman assured the Committee that the list was being finalised and
would get to them shortly. He noted the comments by Mr. Chijioke Okoli, and
reminded him that during his tenure the Voters' List was not published 30 days
before the elections. Nevertheless, he concluded that the Executive Committee
would consider the issue and if the need arises would consider pushing back the
date of the elections.
8.
Presentation by Heritage Travels
8.1
Mrs. Dotun Kuye (of Heritage Travels and Tours Limited) came out to
introduce her company and speak on their package for registration, visa
assistance, flight tickets, hotel booking and sightseeing for members interested
in attending the International Bar Association 2013 Conference in Boston from
163
the 6th to 11th of October, 2013. She distributed flyers and conference
registration forms.
9.
Any Other Business
9.1
The Chairman read out a letter from the Chief Judge of Lagos State – Hon.
Justice A.A. Phillips – informing the Branch of the take-off of the Judiciary
Information System 'JIS' (scheduled to 'go live' on or before the end of June,
2013). The JIS would inter alia enable counsel file cases on-line and make
payments over a secure web portal, track cases on-line, and ensure fair,
transparent and timely resolution of conflicts.
9.2
The Chairman reported that at the last NBA-NEC Meeting a proposal was
submitted for amendment of the NBA Constitution. He stated that the Branch
would need to look carefully at the proposals and set up a committee to consider
the proposals, comprising Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko SAN, Mr. Chijioke Okoli,
Mrs. Olufunmi Oluyede, Chief Wale Taiwo, Mrs. Fayemiwo, Mr. Mbanugo
Udenze, and Mr. Enobong Etteh.
9.3
Mrs. Funke Adekoya SAN informed the meeting that under the NBA
Constitution there is a deadline for submission of resolutions prior to a
Delegates' Conference, and the deadline would expire on the 20th of June, 2013.
She suggested that the meeting give the Executive Committee the power to
accept the Committee's Report and pass on same to the National Body - as the
Committee would have only one week to consider and make recommendations
on the proposals.
9.4
Mr. Afro Fayokun stated that any memorandum to be sent to the National Body
by the Branch must be considered at a Branch Meeting before being sent. He
noted that the Branch still does not have a Secretariat. He complained that he
was one of those who pushed for the holding of the J.I.C Taylor Memorial
Lecture, and at the last meeting the 1st Vice Chairman stated that the lecture had
been postponed, suddenly the lecture held and most of the members of the
Branch were not aware. He noted that the NBA Ikeja Branch always sends text
messages for its events to its members and even to members of other branches,
and expressed the hope that the lacunae in communication would not happen
again with the 2013 Branch Law Week. He advised that the Executive
Committee should always give adequate notice to the members, and ended his
comments by wondering whether we can continue to claim to be the 'Premier
Branch' without a secretariat or bar centre.
9.5
The Chairman thanked him for his comments. He noted that the Branch has a
way of disseminating information to members and that was why a large number
of members turned out for the lecture.
9.6
In response to a question by Mr. Chijioke Okoli, the Chairman confirmed that
the Branch Annual General Meeting would hold in July.
10.
Announcements
10.1
The Secretary made the following announcements:
10.1.1 Deloitte Corporate Services Limited in collaboration with Odade Consulting
holds a one-day seminar on Corporate Governance on the 13th of June, 2013 at
Le Meridien Ogeyi Place, Starwood Hotels and Resorts, 45 Tombia Street,
164
G.R.A II, Port-Harcourt, Rivers State. The fee is =N=80,000, and enquiries can
be directed to Oluseun Oluwole on 08056598430 or 'ooluwole@deloitte.com',
or Joyce Akpata on 08033110898 or 'joyce.akpata@odadeconsulting.com'.
10.1.2 The 7th Annual Business Law Conference of the Nigerian Bar Association –
Section on Business Law (SBL) is scheduled to hold from June 17th – 19th
2013 at the Eko Hotel and Suites, Victoria Island, Lagos, with the theme: “The
Legal Profession in an Emerging Economy”. Detailed information about
conference fees and registration can be obtained from the SBL website
'www.nba-sbl.org', or the Section Administrator - Mr. Endurance O.
Uhumuavbi on 08054881300 or via email 'endurance@nba-sbl.org'.
10.1.3 The 2nd Forum on Anti-Corruption West Africa Edition holds on the 18th and
19th of June, 2013 at the Four Points by Sheraton Hotel, Lagos. The conference
has pre and post- conference working groups on the 17th and 20th of June, 2013
and is a must-attend event for general counsel and also for external counsel
specialising in international trade, compliance, litigations mergers and joint
ventures. The conference fee ranges from $1995 to $3345, and registration may
be done online at 'www.c5-Online.com/ACWestAfrica'.
10.1.4 The Real Estate Lawyers Association of Nigeria invites members to its 2013
Summit slated for Thursday 20th of June, 2013 at 10.00 am at the Metropolitan
Club, Kofo Abayomi Street, Victoria Island, Lagos. The theme of the Summit is
"Foreclosure Law and Processes in Relation to Mortgage Security in Nigeria",
and Prof. I.O. Smith SAN would deliver the keynote address, whilst the event
would be chaired by Hon. Justice S.M.A Belgore (the former Chief Justice of
Nigeria).
10.1.5 Odade Consulting invites interested members to a training on “Mastering the
Art of Cross Examination” which is designed to provide participants with
essential grounding on how to conduct an effective cross examination of a
particular type of trial witness. The training is scheduled to hold on the 25th of
June, 2013 at Odade Consulting Training Room Comfort House, 3rd Floor 13,
Hughes Avenue, Alagomeji, Yaba Lagos at 9.00 am prompt. The training fee of
=N=35,000.00 can be paid into Odade Consulting: GTB Account No:
0010901961
10.1.6 The Centre for Commercial Law Development and Kenna Partners invites
members of the Branch to the presentation of the Book 'Corporate Governance
& Group Dynamics' by Dr. Fabian Ajogwu SAN on Friday the 28th of June,
2013 from 10.00 am – 12.00 noon at the Oriental Hotel, Victoria Island, Lagos.
The book presentation would be chaired by Chief Olusegun Osunkeye OFR, the
President of the Society for Corporate Governance Nigeria.
10.1.7 The NBA Young Lawyers' Forum Annual Summit holds from the 3rd to 5th of
July, 2013 at the Chief Judge's Ceremonial Court Hall, High Court Complex,
Port Harcourt, Rivers State, with the theme "Raising the Bar and Standards for
the Young Nigerian Lawyer in the Legal Profession". The summit fee is
=N=1,000 for registered members and =N=2,000 for non-members.
10.1.8 The International Bar Association African Regional Forum has sent out a
reminder that article submissions for the next issue of the Forum Newsletter
(which will be published ahead of the IBA Conference in Boston), are still
welcome. The focus of the next issue will be international courts and tribunals,
and their influence in Africa, but submissions may be of any subject of interest
165
to the Forum. The deadline for submissions is Friday 21 June 2013. Articles
should be in the region of 500-1,500 words and be sent in MS Word format.
Text layout should be kept simple, with regular headings and paragraphs, and
the author's name, email address, as well as the name of the firm and city in
which the author is based should be stated. Contributions should be sent via
email to Anne Bodley - annebodley@yahoo.com, and the Newsletter Editor –
Prof. Olanrewaju Fagbohun - fagbohun@elri-ng.org.
10.1.9 The Lagos Court of Arbitration (LCA) invites legal practitioners in Lagos and
Nigeria to take advantage of the promotional membership rate (=N=15,000) and
join the LCA membership programme, which has been developed to
focus interest, knowledge and educate individuals interested in commercial
arbitration and alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Members of the LCA
benefit from international networks and world class training and events which
provide innovative forums for the exchange of ideas and champion positive
developments in the Nigerian and West African dispute resolution
industry. LCA members are entitled to list academic publications on the LCA
website, take part in the activities of the LCA interest groups and at an
additional fee be listed in the LCA Panel of Neutrals (after qualification).
Details may be obtained from - www.lagosarbitration.org.
10.2
The Secretary announced that the meeting was being hosted by Chief Wale
Taiwo in commemoration of his birthday on the 6th of June, 2013.
11.
Cutting of the Cake
11.1
The Chairman invited members who were celebrating their birthday, wedding
anniversary, call-to-bar etc., in June to come forward for the cutting of the cake.
11.2
About 13 members came out to mark one anniversary or the other including
Chief Wale Taiwo and Mr. Mbanugo Udenze.
11.3
The Chairman invited Mr. Abiodun Owonikoko SAN to supervise the cutting of
the cake.
12.
Closing
12.1
Mr. Gbolahan Gbadamosi moved for adjournment and Mrs. Gerty EmekaIloegbunam seconded.
12.2
Mr. Adetona said the closing prayer, and the meeting ended at 2.55 pm.
_________________________
TAIWO O. TAIWO
CHAIRMAN
_______________________
ALEX N. MUOKA
SECRETARY
166