Constructions of Climate Justice in German, Indian and US Media Debates
Methodological Documentation
1
Country sample
Germany, India and the US were selected as countries cases. They are major players in international
climate politics and responsible for 26 % of global CO2 emissions (Rank 2, 3 and 6 of the world's
countries by 2010 total CO2 emissions from fossil-fuel burning, cement production, and gas flaring,
cf. Boden et al. 2013). Moreover, they are established democracies with a free press, enabling open
debates about climate governance (Freedom House 2011). As important representatives of the negotiation blocs EU, G77/BASIC and Umbrella within the UNFCCC process they are known to hold diverging interests (cf. Cass 2006; Weidner 2007; Kasa et al. 2008; Selin and VanDeveer 2011; Bidwai 2012;
Audet 2013), enabling me to reconstruct a potentially diverse set of normative climate justice constructions.
2
Mass media sample
I chose leading print media for analysis, i.e. media with a “guiding societal function” (Wilke 1999)
based, for example, on their circulation, reputation or quality. Print media were selected since they
offer a simpler means of collecting and analyzing data (cf. e.g. Doulton and Brown 2009). As previous
studies have shown significant differences between media of different political orientation (e.g. Carvalho and Burgess 2005; Höppner 2010; Feldman et al. 2012; Painter and Ashe 2012; Pasquaré and
Oppizzi 2012), I included two to three newspapers for each country representing the political spectrum (see Table 1).
Table 1: Newspapers included in the study
leftGermany
India
USA
-centerSüddeutsche Zeitung (SZ)
The Hindu
New York Times (NYT)
-right
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ)
Times of India (TOI)
Washington Post (WP)
Wall Street Journal (WSJ)
Selection and classification based on Hans-Bredow-Institut (2009); IfM (2010); Eilders (2002); Kleinsteuber and Thomaß
(2008); Hediger (2007); Groseclose and Milyo (2005); Gentzkow and Shapiro (2010)
The analyzed articles stem from the project Global Media Map on Climate Change (see Schäfer
et al. 2012a; Schmidt et al. 2013), with the exception of the Wall Street Journal, for which an equivalent sampling procedure was followed. To gather the relevant climate change coverage, a complex
search string was employed for full-text searches in electronic databases. This was followed by elaborated automatic and manual checks for duplicates and articles not mentioning climate change in our
sense (for a detailed documentation of the data collection procedure, see Schäfer et al. 2012b).
The article sample for the present project was limited by excluding articles not discussing societal reactions to climate change. However, different types of articles were included, provided that
they included evaluative statements on climate governance by the author of the piece (most of the
time a journalist) or by cited actors. Compared to an exclusive focus on opinion pieces this allowed
for a broader representation of the mediated climate change discussion. While not every single arti-
1
cle was itself debate-oriented, also claims in news oriented pieces can be considered to belong to the
broader debate about the issue.
3
Period of investigation
The period of investigation was limited to certain time frames between 2007 and 2010. The time
period from 2007 to 2010 is characterized by major climate change negotiations on the international
level as well as by many domestic legislative actions (Gupta 2010: 646ff, Townshend et al. 2011).
Correspondingly, public attention for climate change was very high (Grundmann and Krishnamurthy
2010; Jogesh 2012; Broadbent 2013; Schmidt et al. 2013; Hart and Feldman 2014). Several other
studies have chosen similar time periods for similar reasons (Hoffman 2011; Never 2011).
As media cover certain topics mostly due to events (Kriesi 2001; Waldherr 2012), also in the
case of climate change (Schäfer et al. 2014), I focus on several major climate political occasions. In
comparison to a random selection across the whole period this also allows for a better understanding
of the discussion dynamics concerning concrete political initiatives. In particular, the annual UN climate change conferences are of great importance - many actors direct their climate political activities to this period and the media attention is especially high (Benford 2010; Schmidt et al. 2013). The
conferences of 2007 and 2009 received the most attention between 1996 and 2010. Additionally, for
each country I have identified two important national climate governance approaches (based on
Townshend et al. 2011) and subsequently determined the respective time frames of governmental
and/or parliamentary debate and passage.
>
International: Bali Climate Change Conference, 26/11-22/12/2007; Copenhagen Climate
Change Conference, 30/11 – 25/12/2009
>
Germany: Integrated Energy and Climate Program, 20-31/12/2007 and 3-25/6/2008; EU Climate Package, 16-30/1/2008 and 4-24/12/2008 1
India: National Action Plan on Climate Change, 27/6-7/7/2008 and 10-22/12/2008; Climate
Strategy “Taking on Climate Change - Post Copenhagen Domestic Actions”, 15/6-7/7/2010
0F
>
>
USA: American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, 23/1-24/2/2009; American Clean Energy and
Security Act, 23/6-3/7/2009 and 1-31/7/2010
The Wall Street Journal sample is restricted to the 2009 climate change conference and the
2009-2010 national legislation periods.
4
List of analyzed articles
All listed articles have been coded on the article level and include utterances (de-) problematizing
climate change and/or evaluating climate governance (options). Additionally, all bold articles have
been intensively coded on the actor statement level – this coding strategy was used to analyze climate governance evaluations in-depth. A total of 600 articles (out of 1,593 categorized on the article
level) and 1,810 actor statements have been coded intensively and interpreted in-depth.
1
The EU climate package has been included because of the great importance of this supranationally negotiated framework for German climate policies (cf. Bomberg 2012)
2
4.1 Germany
Süddeutsche Zeitung
Date
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
27.11.2007
27.11.2007
27.11.2007
27.11.2007
28.11.2007
29.11.2007
29.11.2007
30.11.2007
30.11.2007
01.12.2007
01.12.2007
01.12.2007
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
05.12.2007
05.12.2007
06.12.2007
Title
"Australiens Allianz mit den USA bleibt bestehen"
Geländewagen auf der Leopoldstraße
Ich möchte Teil einer Umweltbewegung sein
Königlicher Ratgeber
Die Vision von der Maut
Kanzlerin mahnt die Europäer
Sarkozy auf Einkaufstour in China
Warme Zukunft
Arme leiden unter Emissionen der Reichen
"Wir haben einiges versäumt"
"Wir haben nicht mehr viel Zeit"
Programm Bayern 08/15
Rockstar wird Umweltminister
Die Spaßgesellschaft hat Angst
Im Unreinen mit seiner Umwelt
Spanien wird afrikanisch
Feilschen um jedes Wort
Karsten Sach Berlins oberster Klimadiplomat in schwieriger
Mission
Therapie der kleinen Nadelstiche
Tuvalu versinkt im Pazifik
Australien tritt dem Kyoto-Protokoll bei
Beginn der Klimakonferenz auf Bali
Söder will mehr Geld zum Schutz der Alpen
Trotz Krieg und Krisen engagieren sich junge Libanesen für
den Umweltschutz
Klimaschutz soll Verfassungsziel werden
Kommentare
Brief an die Konferenz auf Bali
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
Der Patient Wald leidet weiter
Experten diskutieren über den Klimawandel
Fürs Klima und für Knut
Klimawandel bei Bush
SZ AKTION
Wer lebt, stört
Werner Brinkers Energiemix
AMI, GO HOME
Blick in die Presse
Der Retter der Ozeane
Klimawende 2009
"Klimakatastrophe" ist Wort des Jahres
Barometer für Klimafreunde
Europa bangt um seinen Einfluss in Afrika
Klimaschützer, Klimasünder
Nur die Schweden sind besser
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
Author
Urs Wälterlin
Jeanne Rubner
Silvia Liebrich
Sebastian Beck
Kathrin Werner
Kirsten Ludowig
Markus Balser
Michael Bauchmüller
Dominik Prantl
Christian Sebald
Gerhard Fischer
Thomas Hahn
Klaus Brill
Sebastian Schoepp
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Bauchmüller
Jeanne Ruber
Christopher Schrader
Michael Bauchmüller
Dirk Schönlebe
Michael Bauchmüller
Christian Wernicke und Michael
Bauchmüller
Christian Sebald
Tobias Dorfer, Kirsten Ludowig
Jean-Michel Berg
Werner Brinker
Jacob Heilbrunn
Reymer Klüver
Elke Dolle-Helms
Martin Winter
Wolfgang Roth
3
10.12.2007
10.12.2007
10.12.2007
11.12.2007
11.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
14.12.2007
14.12.2007
14.12.2007
14.12.2007
14.12.2007
14.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
20.12.2007
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
22.12.2007
22.12.2007
24.12.2007
27.12.2007
28.12.2007
28.12.2007
28.12.2007
28.12.2007
Außenansicht
Ist euer Feminismus eine Pose?
Kohlendioxid-Ausstoß soll bis zum Jahr 2050 halbiert werden
Experten diskutieren über den Klimawandel
Gasteig, Black Box 20 Uhr
Gabriel pocht auf klare Vorgaben
Massagen statt Klimaschutz
"Historischer Durchbruch"
Ein alternatives Geschäft
In den Kronen der Giganten
Lampenfieber
USA blockieren Klimagipfel
2050 fest im Blick
Buchtipps
Ein Pranger unter Palmen
EU will USA zum Klimaschutz zwingen
Herausforderung Klimawandel: Eine Diskussionsrunde des
SZ-Forums Wissen und der Umwelt-Akademie München
Sommerhaus, zu spät
Im Zweifel für die Natur
Ringen um Klima-Kompromiss
Ringen um Klima-Kompromiss
US-Autos sollen Benzin sparen
Viel Dreck und ein wenig Silber
Wenn es Nacht wird in Bali
"Das Ergebnis war das Maximum"
Blick in die Presse
Bush hadert mit Klimakonsens
Indiens kleiner Triumph
Nach der Konferenz ist vor der Konferenz
So nah das Ende
Tränen, Jubel und ein Kollaps
Vorwärts in Trippelschritten
Blick in die Presse
Fossiles Denken
Pinot Noir aus Norwegen
Zwei Weltenretter im verbalen Clinch
Mit dem Thermometer auf Rekordjagd
Blick in die Presse
Die Zeit nach dem Erdöl
Größte Gasturbine der Welt im Testlauf
Schwarzenegger klagt gegen Bush
Streit um Klimaschutz am Himmel
Barbara Boxer US-Senatorin und passionierte Kämpferin fürs
Klima
Automanager als Klimaberater
"Wir schleichen nach Bethlehem"
Das war 2007 in Bayern: Orkane, Überschwemmungen,
Waldbrände und ein Winter, der keiner war
Erkaltete Liebe in Zeiten der Erderwärmung
Hölderlin und der Klimawandel
Nigel Purvis
Dirk von Gehlen
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Bauchmüller
Hubertus Breuer
Markus Balser
Michael Bauchmüller
Stefan Kornelius
Michael Bauchmüller
Nico Fried, Michael Bauchmüller
Martin Thurau
Patrick Illinger
Wolfgang Roth
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Bauchmüller
Marc Widmann
Wolfgang Roth
Christopher Schrader
Oliver Meiler
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Bauchmüller
Reymer Klüver
Stefan Kornelius
Jeanne Rubner
Tobias Hürter
Christopher Schrader
Silke Lode
Manfred Hummel
Jens Flottau
Christian Wernicke
Claus Hulverscheidt
Christian Sebald
Nico Fried
4
28.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
29.12.2007
31.12.2007
31.12.2007
31.12.2007
17.01.2008
19.01.2008
21.01.2008
21.01.2008
21.01.2008
22.01.2008
23.01.2008
23.01.2008
24.01.2008
26.01.2008
28.01.2008
28.01.2008
30.01.2008
30.01.2008
30.01.2008
03.06.2008
03.06.2008
03.06.2008
04.06.2008
05.06.2008
06.06.2008
06.06.2008
07.06.2008
07.06.2008
07.06.2008
07.06.2008
07.06.2008
09.06.2008
09.06.2008
10.06.2008
10.06.2008
12.06.2008
12.06.2008
12.06.2008
Das war München 2007: Die Logik des Versorgers, die Langatmigkeit des Verfahrens und die Last der Vergangenheit
2007 - Weltweiter Klimawandel Aufschwung in Deutschland
Streit ums Rauchverbot VfB Stuttgart
Das war 2007 (Januar-Februar)
Das war 2007 (März-April)
Das war 2007 (November-Dezember)
Die Zukunft ist grün
Eine Landkarte ohne Wege aus der Klimafalle
Verlustangst im ärmsten Staat Europas
Vom Saulus zum Paulus - die Wandlung des Al Gore
Vorwahlkampf in den USA (I): Das Duell bei den Demokraten
2007 - ein weltbewegendes Jahr?
Boom bei Öko-Anlagen
Das Gesicht der Kampagne
Die Macht von Gottes Gnaden
Feueralarm unter der Erde
Flocke
Blick in die Presse
Der Mann mit der Pumpe
Eine Bewegung kämpft mit sich selbst
An der baltischen Badewanne
Die Qual mit der Quote
Siemens fordert höhere Klimainvestitionen
Angst vor der Erderwärmung
Feuer, bitte!
Naturschützer gegen neues Kohle-Kraftwerk
Schneebälle gegen die Tabus der Bosse
Schlechtes Klima in der Umweltbehörde
Sündertreff im Paradies
Werden Hurrikane seltener?
Außenansicht
KOMMENTAR
Schönheit versus Klimaschutz
Vom Überfluss und vom Mangel an Wasser
Das Gewächs ist nicht zu stoppen
"Die Kommunen sollten eigene Stadtwerke behalten"
Biosprit spaltet den Ernährungsgipfel
Billionen-Revolution
Hausbesitzern in Not
Internationale Energie-Agentur schlägt Alarm
Leitartikel schreiben ist wie Wäsche machen
LEUTE
MUC: Wachstums-Gegner fordern neue Gutachten
Rückzugsgefechte einer jungen Zivilisation
Große Töne, kleiner Beitrag
Japan soll Vorreiter beim Klimaschutz werden
Außenansicht
Blick in die Presse
Der Abschied von George W. Bush in Meseberg: Nettigkeiten
im Nirgendwo
Stephan Handel
Kurt Kister
Joachim Becker
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael Frank
Jörg Häntzschel
Reymer Klüver
Nikolaus Piper
Marcia Pally
Axel Bojanowski
Olaf Przybilla
Gunnar Herrmann
Michael Bauchmüller
Axel Bojanowski
Jeanne Rubner
Gerd Zitzelsberger
Ralf Wiegand
Gerd Zitzelsberger
Christian Sebald
Michael Bauchmüller
Constanze Stelzenmüller
Christoph Schrader
Alfred Dürr
Hanno Charisius
Jan Bielicki
Christoph Neidhart
Nikolaus Piper
Michael Bauchmüller
Johan Schloemann
Dominik Hutter
Petra Steinberger
Christopher Schrader
Christoph Neidhart
Derek Chollet
Daniel Brössler
5
12.06.2008
12.06.2008
14.06.2008
17.06.2008
17.06.2008
17.06.2008
19.06.2008
19.06.2008
20.06.2008
20.06.2008
21.06.2008
21.06.2008
25.06.2008
05.12.2008
05.12.2008
05.12.2008
06.12.2008
06.12.2008
08.12.2008
08.12.2008
09.12.2008
09.12.2008
Niederlage für Japans Premier
Reformen unerwünscht
Die Ohnmacht der Mächtigen
Ein Lob den Iren
Klimawandel stellt THW vor neue Aufgaben
Weizen im Stresstest
Atomkraft, ja bitte!
Das Klima-Päckchen
Söder fordert von der EU eine "Bergpolitik"
Wandel von jetzt auf gleich
Die geklonte Insel
Meerespolitik ja, Bergpolitik nein
Die traut sich was
Lexikon
Serie
Tagungsbericht
Bericht
Zitat, Männliche Person, Tagungsbericht
Die Denkpause nutzen
Kommentar, Tagungsbericht
Der Streit über den Klimaschutz
Merkels Wende
10.12.2008
10.12.2008
10.12.2008
10.12.2008
"Schnelle Anpassung an Klimawandel"
Barroso: Kein Dissens
Kotau vor der Industrie
Cerstin Gammelin
Zwischen Klimakonferenz und Klimagipfel: Alle bekennen Michael Bauchmüller
sich zum Wandel, handeln sollen andere
"Ehrlich gesagt: Mich pfupfert das"
Claus Hulverscheidt, Hans Werner
Kilz, Heribert Prantl
Blick in die Presse
Das Leiden der Tannen
Katja Auer
Gipfel der großen Erwartungen
Franziska Brüning und Cerstin
Gammelin
Nobelpreis übergeben
"Konferenz in Posen darf nicht scheitern"
Michael Bauchmüller
Kompromissvorschlag auf dem EU-Gipfel
Minister mit Nobelpreis
Patrick Illinger
"Wir haben uns nicht so schnell bewegt wie notwendig"
Jeanne Rubner
Artenschutz für Luftverschmutzer
Wolfgang Roth
Staaten ebnen Weg für neuen Klima-Vertrag
Michael Bauchmüller
Aufstand in Danzig
Dr. Hans Heinrich
Europa als Maß / SZ vom 11. Dezember
Günther Petry
Europa setzt ein Zeichen der Hoffnung
Cerstin Gammelin
Kritik an Klima-Beschlüssen
Blick in die Presse
Heiße Sommer, nasse Winter
Axel Bojanowski
Es werde Licht!
Ian McEwan
Obama will Abhängigkeit vom Öl beenden
Außenansicht
David Miliband
Der unvermeidliche Wandel
Christopher Schrader
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
12.12.2008
12.12.2008
12.12.2008
13.12.2008
13.12.2008
13.12.2008
15.12.2008
15.12.2008
15.12.2008
15.12.2008
16.12.2008
16.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
18.12.2008
18.12.2008
Christoph Neidhart
Christian Sebald
Cornelia Bolesch, Cerstin Gammeln
Jürgen Habermas
Elisabeth Dostert
Stefan Braun
Christopher Schrader
Claudia Fromme
Kassian Stroh
Stefan Braun
Astrid Becker
Cathrin Kahlweit
Cerstin Gammelin
Cathrin Kahlweit
Michael Bauchmüller
Michael
Rubner
Bauchmüller,
Jeanne
6
18.12.2008
18.12.2008
18.12.2008
19.12.2008
19.12.2008
19.12.2008
19.12.2008
20.12.2008
20.12.2008
23.12.2008
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
Deutsche Strategie gegen den Klimawandel
Tollwood-Winterfestival 19.30 Uhr
Von der Burg zucken schon die Blitze
Es gibt eine große Bewegung
Kleine Münchner Vogelkunde (5)
Kommentare
Rick Warren Evangelikaler Prediger bei Obamas Amtseinführung
Bushs letzte Abgase
Wer baut uns jetzt die Arche?
EDF kauft zu, RWE freut sich
Die entscheidenden zwei Grad
Entwicklungsländer einig über Klimagipfel
Die Stimme aus dem Untergrund
Energie auf Halde
Selbstbewusste Chinesen
Reiche Klimafreunde
Streit um Emissionshandel
Die grüne Nation
Interview mit dem städtischen Umweltreferenten
"Immerhin wissen wir, dass die Welt rund ist"
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
Außenansicht
Hallo? Kopenhagen?
Meratus darf nicht sterben
Wozu Klimaschutz?
Alle Wetter
Das größte Rad der Welt
Die Karawane der Vereinten Nationen
Ein Dirigent und 10 000 Stimmen
Ein Pakt für die Alpen
In eisigen Höhen
Operation Zinseszins
Sieben Grad mehr bis 2100
Staatsschutz ermittelt nach Brandanschlägen
Von Anpassung bis Zaster
Weg voller Widersprüche
Zum Klimagipfel
Appell an Klimagipfel
Appell vor Beginn der Klimakonferenz
Blick in die Presse
Der große Schubser
Die Revolution im Kopf
Es schmilzt
Kommentare
Wenn Paketfahrer Sprit sparen
Wind von vorn
Zittern im Treibhaus
Das Klima und der Krieg
Industriestaaten zahlen armen Ländern Milliarden
Klaus Brill
Claus Biegert
Astrid Becker
Jeanne Rubner
Christian Wernicke
Christopher Schrader
Mike Davis
Florian Fuchs
Silvia Liebrich
Toralf Staud
Tim Mennel, Nikolas Wölfing
Stefan Ulrich
Michael Ruhland
Michael Bauchmüller, Julia Amalia
Heyer
Davd Suzuki
Rainer Stadler
Stefanie Paul
Burkhard Müller
Michael Bauchmüller
Wolfgang Roth
Markus Balser
Christian Sebald
Michael Bauchmüller
Christopher Schrader
Ralf Wiegand
Michael Bauchmüller
Cerstin Gammelin
Michael Bauchmüller
Andrian Kreye
Caspar Dohmen
Angelika Slavik
Caspar Dohmen
Martin Hesse
Markus Balser
Arne Perras
Christopher
Schrader,
Gammelin
Cerstin
7
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
Retter des Klimas
Über Generationen hinweg
Zwischen Wohlstand und Glück
Der tödlich lange Weg zur Wasserstelle
Die Wende kommt 2020
Klimaschutz und Verkehr
"Mein Ehrgeiz ist es nicht, der Reichste auf dem Friedhof zu
sein"
Der erste Eklat
Die Weltenretter
Essen mit gutem Gewissen
Gefährliche Metropolen
Mittendrin
SZ AKTION
Wie man Wähler verliert
Der Klimawandel und die Konsequenzen
EU schließt Hilfe für Griechenland aus
Francis Cheneval
Björn Finke
Arne Perras
Jens Flottau
Elisabeth Dostert
Michael Bauchmüller
Wolfgang Roth
Daniela Kuhr
Markus Balser
Stephan Handel
Klaus Brill
Christian Sebald
Cerstin Gammelin und Martin Winter
Martin Kotynek
Ina Kirsch
Lange Schonzeit macht träge
Nachhaltigkeit
Schneefernerhaus
"Verzicht muss nicht sein"
Michael Bauchmüller
Aus der Wirtschaft: "Wir müssen nicht zurück auf die Bäu- Hanni Kinadeter
me"
EU verspricht armen Ländern 7,2 Milliarden Euro
Cerstin
Gammelin,
Michael
Bauchmüller
Forum
Dieter Zetsche
Generation Grün
Jeanne Rubner
Ich und das Weltklima
Michael Bauchmüller
Sehnsucht nach dem grünen Leben
"Zeit für eine Revolution"
Markus Balser
Außenansicht
Meles Zenawi
Die Welt will mitreden
Michael Bauchmüller
Klimaschutz muss sich lohnen
Weltrisiko Klimawandel
Laura Weissmüller
Woche der Entscheidung in Kopenhagen
Michael Bauchmüller
Arme Länder kämpfen um Kyoto-Protokoll
Michael Bauchmüller
Die weißen Kordilleren werden schwarz
Sebastian Schoepp
Friedliche Koexistenz
Martin Kotynek
Tuvalu ist unser Taka-Tuka-Land
Andrian Kreye
"Gibt es keine Lösung, dann gibt es Gewalt"
Michael Bauchmüller
Besuch aus der Heimat des Umweltschutzes
Markus Balser
Campus München: Ergänzungen für den UN-Gipfel
Martin Thurau
Die Zeit läuft ab
Michael Bauchmüller und Julia
Amalia Heyer
Mit Hightech ins Treibhaus
Thorsten Riedl
"Am Ende müssen die Verbraucher zahlen"
Markus Balser
Es ist geschafft
Christopher Schrader
Es ist missglückt
Patrick Illinger
Früchte des Zorns
Martin Kotynek
Klimagipfel vor der Entscheidung
8
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
Krawall in Kopenhagen
Tödliches Klima
Trübe Sicht vom Gipfel
"Heute retten wir die Welt"
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
Blick in die Presse
Captain Planet kehrt zurück
Ein Januskopf in Kopenhagen
Forum
Großer Gipfel, dicke Brocken
18.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
Peter Burghardt
Cerstin Gammelin
M. Balser, M. Bauchmüller, C.
Gammelin, M. Kotynek
Markus Balser
Cerstin Gammelin
Uwe Franke
Michael Bauchmüller, Martin Kotynek
Tobias Kniebe
Tobias Kniebe
Chinas Ministerpräsident kündigt Großes an: Sein Land will Michael Bauchmüller, Markus
die Statistiken verbessern.
Balser
Die Hoffnung stirbt zuletzt
Wolfgang Roth
Die Rechnung, bitte
Petra Steinberger
Eine Frau geht ihren Weg
Cerstin Gammelin
Kopenhagen: Die Nacht des Kompromisses
Nach chaotischen Verhandlungen
Schall und Rauch
Verhandlungen bis in die Nacht
"Globaler Klimakitsch im Plenum"
Christopher Schrader
30 Silberlinge sind nicht genug
Michael Bauchmüller
Berlin startet neuen Anlauf für Klimaabkommen
Cerstin Gammelin und Michael
Bauchmüller
Das 21. Jahrhundert beginnt mit dem Debakel vom 19. Andrian Kreye
Dezember 2009
Das Ende der Kopenhagener Klimakonferenz
Erklärung über das Ungefähre
Michael Bauchmüller
In der Klimakrise
Michael Bauchmüller
Blamables Finale
Wolfgang Roth
"Das konnte nicht klappen"
Patrick Illinger
Außenansicht
Andreas Troge
Falscher Stolz
Alexandra Borchardt
Pekings Pflichten
Henrik Bork
"Ohne den Staat würde der Kapitalismus kollabieren"
Catherine Hoffmann
Wir machen das Klima
Total: 312 articles, of which 168 were coded intensively (604 actor statements).
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung
Date
27.11.2007
27.11.2007
27.11.2007
28.11.2007
30.11.2007
30.11.2007
01.12.2007
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
Title
Illusionen und Fakten
In Australien: Ende einer Ära
Versicherer profilieren sich im Klimaschutz
"Klimawandeltrifft die Armen"
Gefährlicher Unsinn über denKlimawandel
Kontroverse um Energiepolitik
Grüne: Hessen versagt beim Klimaschutz
DerKlimawandelkommt - da hilft alles nichts
Eisbären
Author
Klaus-Dieter Frankenberger
Tilman Spreckelsen
9
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
05.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
08.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
10.12.2007
11.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
14.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
19.12.2007
Ist es nicht schon zu SPÄT?
Käferborstenzählen für das Klima
Was wird aus der Heimat der Eisbären?
Weiße zum Wärmen
Wie warm wird es werden?
Auf der Klima-Allmende
Gabriel: Von Bali nicht zu viel erhoffen
Heller die Lichter nie leuchten
"Wir brauchen drei oder vier ambitionierte Eckpunkte"
Alarmstimmung ist willkommen
Die verborgene Wirtschaftsagenda
Donnerblitz, da braut sich was zusammen
Kyoto-Protokoll war nur Aufwärmübung
Die Universität als Lebensort
"Amerika wird nicht blockieren"
"Strom nicht teurer mit dem Klima-Paket"
Das Weiße Haus gibt sich tatendurstig
"Die Politiker können nicht rechnen"
Der Kerner muss weg!
Netzkosten
Sicher ist: Es wird abkassiert
Zusammenarbeit im Zeichen von Öl, Gas und Eis
Vom Eise befreit sind Pol und Mensch
Blütenträume aus Eisen
Das bewegt die Welt
Forschung: Grundlage
Klima: Irrlehre
Vager Entwurf für die Bali-Abschlusserklärung
Kerry: Auch Demokraten skeptisch
Der Klimapfennig für den Urwald
Klima? Die nächste Wahl kommt schneller
Klimadiplomat
Klimafonds für arme Länder eingerichtet
Ban fordert Agenda für den Klimaschutz
Europa braucht Führung
Hier wedelt der Schwanz mit dem Hund
Klimaretter
Im Ballungsraum tobt ein Sturm um die Windräder
Ärzte gegen geplantes neues Kohlekraftwerk
Heizpilze sterben für Klimaschutz
CO2: Unschuldig
Dem Klima geht es nun etwas besser
Gut für Knut?
"Die Böden sind hier besonders empfindlich"
Amerika distanziert sich vom Klima-Kompromiss
Der Klima-Umbau
Der Wille zum Fortschritt
Vom eigentlichen Ziel verabschiedet
Auch China und Indien sind nun gefordert
Autobauer verlieren Klimastreit
Der Preisschock auf dem Energiemarkt
Ulf von Rauchhaupt
Joachim Müller-Jung
Stuart Pigott
Konrad Mrusek
Holger Schmidt
Konrad Mrusek
Dr. Arend Oetker
Konrad Mrusek
Matthias Rüb
Jens Friedemann
Michael Hanfeld
Hans D. Barbier
Siegfried Thielbeer
Cord Riechelmann
Cornelia Reichert
Dr. Michael Türkay
Wolfgang Meister
Joachim Müller-Jung
Konrad Mrusek
Dr. Eckhardt Lübkemeier
Konrad Mrusek
Stefan Dietrich
Albert Schäffer
Dr. Hans-Gunther Eggert
Winand von Petersdorff
Peter Zitzmann
Konrad Mrusek
Prof. Renate Köcher
10
19.12.2007
19.12.2007
20.12.2007
22.12.2007
22.12.2007
23.12.2007
24.12.2007
24.12.2007
27.12.2007
27.12.2007
28.12.2007
28.12.2007
28.12.2007
29.12.2007
31.12.2007
31.12.2007
16.01.2008
16.01.2008
17.01.2008
17.01.2008
17.01.2008
17.01.2008
17.01.2008
20.01.2008
21.01.2008
21.01.2008
22.01.2008
22.01.2008
23.01.2008
23.01.2008
23.01.2008
23.01.2008
23.01.2008
24.01.2008
24.01.2008
24.01.2008
24.01.2008
24.01.2008
25.01.2008
25.01.2008
25.01.2008
26.01.2008
26.01.2008
27.01.2008
28.01.2008
29.01.2008
30.01.2008
03.06.2008
04.06.2008
04.06.2008
Ohne Reue
Gerald Wagner
Unsere Köpfe des Jahres
Der Anti-Ideologe
Hendrik Kafsack
Gipfel zur Mittelmeer-Union im Juli in Paris
Mehr als Wärme und Asche
Lukas Weber
Und alle Formen offen
Das Klima-Spiel
Holger Schmidt
Thierses Timbre
Timo Frasch
Knapper Sieg
Johannes Leithäuser
Toyota-Manager als Klimaberater
Ein Nobelpreis gegen die Katastrophe
Nobelpreise im Duett, Polareis am Tiefpunkt
Sturm Kyrill wütet über Westeuropa
Japan mahnt China zum Klimaschutz
Der Flughafen und die Fabrik
Erkannt
Die Deutschen geben mehr für Reisen aus
Meeressedimente als Lagerstätten
Horst Rademacher
Auch 2008 werden die Lebensmittel teurer
Deutsche in Davos in zweiter Reihe
Die Kühnheit hatte ihn so weit gebracht
Riesling ein Gewinner desKlimawandels
Weniger als 1000 Winzer im Rheingau
Und plötzlich reißt der Boden auf
Kristina Pezzei
Arche Noah auf dem Main
Der Lieblingsfeind aus Offenbach
Thomas Holl
Weltumsegler, Umweltsegler und die Freude am PS
Walter Wille
Kurze Meldungen
Aus der Gästeliste
Die Angst geht um
Es geht um Profit
Marco Neef
Glos macht Atom-Wahlkampf
Kernkraft fließt in Klimaziele ein
Interdisziplinäre Begegnung
Werner Wenning
Klimaschutz kostet Europäer 3 Euro je Woche
Kosten
Von der hohen Kunst, Flocken auf der Glatze zu drehen
Hannes Hintermeier
Zauberformel: Dreimal 20 bis 2020
Hendrik Kafsack
Idealisten und Realisten
Wer nicht mitmacht, hat schon verloren
Wider die Natur
Karl-Peter Schwarz
Frühstück mit Shimon Peres
Michael Splinter
Inland in Kürze
Die Kunst, ein Gebirge zu zeichnen
Jürgen Kaube
Klima: Japan kündigt Milliardenprogramm an
Die SPD sieht den Lohn ihrer Wahlkampf-Mühen
Die Landtagswahlen weit weg
Peter Schilder
Hunger, Klima, Preise: Die UN halten einen Notfallplan für erforderlich
Klarheit durch den Lissabon-Vertrag
Matthieu Hornung,
Schönlau
Streit über Biosprit auf der FAO-Konferenz
Dr.
Justus
11
05.06.2008
07.06.2008
07.06.2008
07.06.2008
08.06.2008
08.06.2008
09.06.2008
09.06.2008
10.06.2008
10.06.2008
10.06.2008
10.06.2008
11.06.2008
11.06.2008
12.06.2008
14.06.2008
14.06.2008
14.06.2008
14.06.2008
15.06.2008
15.06.2008
16.06.2008
16.06.2008
Demokratiegefährdend
Fachzentrum fürKlimawandel
Land plant Zentrum für Klimaforschung
Mehr Öko-Strom gegen denKlimawandel
"Wir haben nicht mehr viel Zeit"
Zeigt her eure Bauten
Eine historische Chance verpasst
TERMINE DER WOCHE
"Marktchancen nutzen"
EU treibt Markt für Verteidigung voran
Nachhaltig mehr Wert
Risiken reduzieren
Bush II auf Augenhöhe
Japan setzt auf mehr Umweltschutz
Eine neue Seite aufschlagen
Der Ebro sinkt, die Laune steigt
Hessisches Zentrum zur Erforschung des Klimas
Koch lobt Homberg für "traumhafte Kulisse"
Riedstadt hält an Solarpark fest
BETREFF: WIR FLIEGEN JETZT GRÜN
Wasser-Expo eröffnet
Afrikanische Hirse für den kalten Norden
Klimaschutz als Wettbewerbsfaktor
16.06.2008
16.06.2008
16.06.2008
17.06.2008
17.06.2008
17.06.2008
18.06.2008
18.06.2008
20.06.2008
20.06.2008
21.06.2008
22.06.2008
22.06.2008
23.06.2008
25.06.2008
04.12.2008
04.12.2008
05.12.2008
London will ratifizieren
Positive Ökobilanz
Und zum Dank ein Netz voller Fußbälle
Die Techno-Kreationisten an der Klimafront
Ihr kleiner grüner Sittich
Vom Himmel gefallen
Al Gore unterstützt Barack Obama
Die CDU will eine grüne Partei werden
Senckenberg wird weiter wachsen
Wasserkampf im Untertaunus
Unternehmen für Klimaschutzstrategie
Konservativer Fortschritt
Zartes vom Ätna
Öko-Diktatur im Rathaus
115 Millionen Euro für Spitzenforschung
Den Klimaschutz verpacken
Jetzt erst recht eine Schuldenregel
CSR - mehr als eine Modeerscheinung
05.12.2008
05.12.2008
05.12.2008
05.12.2008
05.12.2008
06.12.2008
07.12.2008
07.12.2008
Das Prinzip Nachhaltigkeit
Die Krise überwinden
Pilotraum Odenwald
Scheitern an der Finanzkrise?
Südhessen hatKlimawandelim Blick
SPD und Grüne wollen kein "Weiter-so"
"Die Menschen spüren, dass sie sich verzockt haben"
In der Kältekammer
Christiane Harriehausen
Joachim Ganse
Nikolas Busse
Leo Wieland
Brigitte Scherer
Georg Giersberg
Stefan Zanzinger, Sebastian Gallehr, Christoph Frings
Katrin Pötzsch
Wulf Schmiese
Niklas Schenk
Christina Hoffmann
Jordan Mejias
Eva-Maria Magel
Volker Zastrow
Stuart Pigott
Joachim Jahn
Dr. Peter Struck, Dr. Ingolf Deubel
Prof. Dr. Dr. H.C. Mult. Heribert
Meffert
Dietrich Neumann, Dr. Otto Schulz
Sigmar Gabriel
Rainer Hein
Prof. Dr. Reimund Schwarze
Alexander Marguier
Tobias Rüther
12
07.12.2008
08.12.2008
09.12.2008
09.12.2008
09.12.2008
10.12.2008
11.12.2008
12.12.2008
12.12.2008
14.12.2008
14.12.2008
15.12.2008
16.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
18.12.2008
20.12.2008
21.12.2008
22.12.2008
23.12.2008
24.12.2008
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
Warum keiner mehr durchblickt
"Treffen verletzt Chinas Gefühle"
Das Klima und der Chor
Der Weltreisende für die Umwelt
Kühlung für Gletscher
Und derKlimawandel?
Bullman soll für SPD ins Europaparlament
Ban Ki-moon ermahnt die Europäer im Klimaschutz
Europa und der Klimaschutz
Ausland
Heiße Luft
TERMINE DER WOCHE
Mehr Überzeugung
"Den Bankrott einiger EU-Staaten verhindert"
Der rote Teufel in der Klimafalle
Ernst gemeint
Kurze Meldung
Physiker Chu wird Energieminister
Europäisches Klimapaket nimmt die letzte Hürde
Spenderliste Bill Clintons
Klima im Blick
Nachhutgefechte um die "Proposition 8"
Ausland in Kürze
Warum die EU die Glühbirne verbietet
Commonwealth für Klima-Vertrag
Dritte Welt stimmt Klimakurs ab
Schüler gegenKlimawandel
China verteidigt seine Klimapolitik
Gift im Fluss und Babyöl mit Mayonnaise
Neue Hoffnungen für denWeltklimagipfel
Alles nur Zeitungsenten
Am stärksten betroffen
Auf der Klimakonferenz spielt Geld eine wichtige Rolle
Glossar der Klimakonferenz
Klimaschutz als Weltinnenpolitik
Wachstum vor Klimaschutz
Australien ohne Klimagesetz
Die gegenwärtige Klimahysterie ist unbegründet
Bäume, Wölfe und derKlimawandelim Kinzigtal
Der neue Weltmoralapostel
Klima-Gate
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
Umweltminister zuversichtlich vor dem Klimagipfel
Warum die Umweltpolitik neu definiert werden muss
Der Mensch als Heizung
Die konservative Umweltschützerin
Die Menschlichkeit auf dem Prüfstand
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
Kopenhagen naht, die Klimakämpfer geben alles
Schanghai stellt sich auf höheren Meeresspiegel ein
Semesterferien? Werde doch Diplomat!
Nils Minkmar
Harald Staun
Matthias Rüb
Ferran Tarradellas
Jordan Mejias
Matthias Rüb
Hendrick Kafsack
Norbert Röttgen
Professor Dr. Werner Kasig
Luise Glaser-Lotz
Mark Siemons
Jochen Stahnke, Matthias Wyssuwa
Hans-Werner Sinn
Siegfried Thielbeer
Hans Joachin Schellnhiber, Mojib
Latif
Christoph Hein
Til Fähnders
Jana Sinram
13
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
Wassermelonen für Namibia
Wie Kopenhagen ein Erfolg würde
05.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
Wunsch und Wirklichkeit
"Falsche Dämmung macht krank"
"Siemens marschiert an der Spitze der grünen Revolution"
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
12.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
Anpassung ans UNVERMEIDLICHE
Ehrliche Makler
GEHEN SIE INS NETZ?
Meeresspiegel
Rettet erst das Klima, dann die Welt
Ruhe in Frieden
Tao und Katastrophe
"Jetzt erwärmt sich das Klima - und auch die Politik"
Das Klima in Kürze
Das Klima in Kürze
Der Himmel über Kopenhagen
Die Erde erwärmt sich schneller
Die Klagen der Skeptiker
Die Kosten des Klimaschutzes
Entwicklung undKlimawandel
Hoffnung am Horizont
Neue Hoffnung für den Gipfel in Kopenhagen
Neue Töne
Polens Konglomerat aus Kohle und Politik
Bitte mehr Offenheit in der Klimadiskussion
Der Klimagipfel hat begonnen
Die grünen Eminenzen von Kopenhagen
Historisches Gedränge in Hopenhagen
Obama als Hoffnung für Kopenhagen
Die Apokalypse als Gefahr
Mehr Spielraum für Obama im Streit um Emissionsgrenzen
Warum sollten maximal zwei Grad die Welt retten?
ABB erwartet eine längere Investitionsschwäche
EU fördert erstmals CO2-Abscheidung
Kämpfer für ein Klimaabkommen
China legt Gegenentwurf vor
DerTreibhauseffektbeleidigt mich
Die letzten Fortschrittsgläubigen
Eisbären sehen dich an
Nur die Riesenrechner bleiben draußen
Politisierte Wissenschaft
EU-Klimahilfe für arme Länder
"Entweder zahlen wir für Ölscheichs oder Ökoenergie"
Armut hält die Luft rein
Der Skizirkus
Erhöhte Temperatur
Im spärlichen Licht der Stirnlampen
Kaufen statt raufen
Röttgen: Obama muss mehr bieten
Maximilian Weingartner
Ottmar Edenhofer, Nicholas Lord
Stern
Lisa Becker
Birgit Ochs
Alexander Armbruster, Georg
Meck
Julia Gross
Ulf von Rauchhaupt
Jochen Reinecke
Jonas Siehoff
Myles Allen
Mark Siemons
Friedrich Schmidt
Joachim Müller-Jung
Joachim Müller-Jung
Siegfried Thielbeer
Lisa Becker
Erich Weede
Andreas Mihm
Andreas Mihm
Konrad Schuller
Dr. Ulrich Mischke
Matthias Wyssuwa
Joachim Müller-Jung
Alexander Armbruster
Tobias Rüther
Lorenz Jäger
Sandra Kegel
Matthias Wyssuwa
Stefan Dietrich
Konrad Mrusek, Inge Kloepfer
Mark Siemons
Martin Wittmann
Stefan Dietrich
Konrad Schuller
14
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
Und was ist mit Tuvalu ?
Zwei Grad sind nicht genug
Air New Zealand auf dem Weg zur Nachhaltigkeit
Dämmen für die Umwelt - und den Geldbeutel
Das bisschen Klima
Dreißig Prozent Enttäuschung sind vernünftig
Größte Demonstration in der Geschichte Dänemarks
Im Land der krachenden Eisberge
Besuch aus Tuvalu
Mit starkem Karbonfußabdruck
Renault-Wissen
Technik für eine klimafreundliche Welt
Die Angebote der Teilnehmer
Nervensache
Wegen Überfüllung geschlossen
Wenn der Kühlschrank zweimal klingelt
"DerKlimawandelgefährdet Amerikas Sicherheit"
Al Gore: Dramatische Schmelze in der Arktis
Auch Ökos brauchen Büros
Auf zwei Pfaden dem Ziel entgegen
Jetzt sind alle Klimaschützer
Am Mantra wird nicht gerüttelt
Die Soziallehre als Kompass
Gipfelchaos
Hoffnungsschimmer auf dem Gipfeltreffen von Kopenhagen
Mammutkonferenz
Organisatorisches Fiasko
Zielstrebig
Klima
Teilerfolg beim Ringen um die Rettung desWeltklimas
Wer nicht kommt, muss nicht nachgeben
Dekarbonisiert
Erspart uns doch endlich den Kitsch!
Es ging ums Geld
Klimagipfel endet lau
Unter Wasser
Zurück in die Stadt
Die Übereinkunft von Kopenhagen
Klimakatastrophe
Kopenhagen und Spätzle
Merkel: Ergebnisse von Kopenhagen nicht schlechtreden
Über die Wege einer Krankheit, die schon besiegt schien
Zur Kenntnis genommen
Edle Kämpfer
Erfolgreich gescheitert
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
24.12.2009
Gewinner China
Hessische Ideen für Klimaprojekt
"Koalition der Gleichgesinnten" für den Klimaschutz?
Stille Diplomatie und abgestimmtes Vorgehen
Röttgen kritisiert Amerika und China
Matthias Wyssuwa
Nils Minkmar
Jasper von Altenbockum
Matthias Wyssuwa
Siegfried Thielbeer
Thomas Neumann
Hendrick Kafsack, Andreas Mihm
Thomas Thiel
Carina Hübner
Hendrik Kafsack
Torsten Staffeldt
Reinhard Marx
Klaus-Dieter Frankenberger
Siegfried Thielbeer
Luca Breveglieri
Hendrik Kafsack, Andreas Mihm
Konrad Mrusek
Nils Minkmar
Richard Wagner
Bertram Eisenhauer
Volker Zastrow
Andreas Mihm
Matthias Alexander
Andreas Eckert
Hendrik Kafsack
Prof. Dr. Claus Leggewie, Prof. Dr.
Dirk Messner
15
24.12.2009
Wo soll es langgehen in der Umweltpolitik?
Dr. Hermann Pütter
Total: 308 articles, of which 130 were coded intensively (305 actor statements)
4.2 India
The Hindu
Date
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
28.11.2007
28.11.2007
28.11.2007
28.11.2007
28.11.2007
28.11.2007
29.11.2007
30.11.2007
30.11.2007
01.12.2007
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
04.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
09.12.2007
11.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
13.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
17.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
19.12.2007
20.12.2007
20.12.2007
Title
Author
A new East Asian focus on India
Officials urged to reduce pollution
'Tourism has to be environmentally sustainable with global climate change'
New centre in U.K. for genocide studies
Positive outcome expected from conference on climate
U.K.'s expertise, India's skills will help to meet energy needs: envoy
UNDP: help the poor cope with climate change risks
Varsity to set up institute for climate change study
Warming up to an issue
Opening up markets will bring all-round benefits: Stagg
Beware immigration scare stories
EU-India: shared challenges
Soz questions parameters adopted in UNDP report
Climate change hits women the hardest: report
Climate Change --should India change?
NGOs' caution against climate change effects
Manual scavenging must not be reformed, but abolished
Call for more research on climate change
Climate change: action not despair
Need for review of offsetting mechanisms
Experts see thorny road ahead for deforestation negotiations
Stress on improving energy efficiency in transport sector
Nuclear energy not sustainable yet, says Dutch Minister
Pressure on developing nations to adopt emission limits
SAARC legal experts to meet in Colombo: Pranab
What are the issues with air-cons?
A special conclave for children
Farmers of State feel effect of climate change
Climate change could increase tensions
Consensus reached at climate change meet
Time frame sought for GHG emission control
Climate change: talks for post-2012 accord stalled
Climate change talks down to the wire
It is time to catch up with 'green economics,' says Yellappa Reddy
India played key role in Bali negotiations
Low-carbon society will be the future, says Pachauri
U.S. concern on climate change deal not warranted: Sibal
Call to step up rubber cultivation
Global warming & India's responsibility
India, China acted together on Bali road map, says Kapil Sibal
Action plan on climate change by 2008: Sibal
A pyrrhic victory in Bali
France for stronger ties with India
16
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
22.12.2007
29.06.2008
29.06.2008
29.06.2008
30.06.2008
01.07.2008
01.07.2008
03.07.2008
03.07.2008
04.07.2008
05.07.2008
05.07.2008
05.07.2008
05.07.2008
06.07.2008
06.07.2008
06.07.2008
07.07.2008
07.07.2008
07.07.2008
07.07.2008
10.12.2008
10.12.2008
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
11.12.2008
12.12.2008
12.12.2008
13.12.2008
14.12.2008
14.12.2008
14.12.2008
15.12.2008
15.12.2008
15.12.2008
16.12.2008
16.12.2008
16.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
17.12.2008
18.12.2008
18.12.2008
19.12.2008
19.12.2008
Peace on earth
Policy on climate change soon
11th plan will address preparation to face disaster and relief
Another city forest opened
Go in for renewable energy schemes: Manmohan
The French connection
Pranab's call to statisticians
'Climate action plan needs to be transparent'
Manmohan unveils action plan on climate change
Greenpeace official: China, India are facing up to a climate-challenged world
Information on weather changes for farmers
'Change lifestyles to protect environment'
A unique spectacle will unfold at G8 Summit
G-8: world economy will be in focus
SAARC action plan on climate change
Vegetable farming taken to schools
G-8 has no plan to invite India as a new member
India may face pressure to reduce greenhouse gases
Scientists set forth proposals to tame climate
India may face pressure to reduce greenhouse gases
Manmohan to highlight fuel crisis at summit
Rising temperature to hit agriculture production: study
Andrew F. Cooper & Ramesh
Wishing on a star for the G8 summit
Thakur
Climate change talks not fast enough for treaty: U.N. Convention secretary
Collective action needed: experts
Collective action needed: experts
Glaciers of change
UK team to address energy inefficiency in old buildings
'Warm up to need for controlling global warming'
Mary Robinson, Margot Wallstrom,
A new climate deal based on human progress and justice
Gro Harlem Brundtland
Artists document disasters of climate change
Frustration at climate change summit
At climate change meet, rich-poor divide perceptible
'Biomass energy can rescue slump in industrial growth'
Go green, save the world
Call of the wild
Good response to Exnora's 'cool the globe' concept
Rally highlights the importance of conserving wildlife, saving energy
ICMR to set up separate cell for climate change study
Our collective future
'Revive BSRB'
Eric Maskin makes 'mechanism design theory' a piece of cake
'Exponential rise in domestic energy consumption'
'Live in harmony with nature'
RINL launches energy policy
'Need for change in lifestyle to tackle climate change'
Year of interlinked food shortages, climate change and recession
Chilling development in Dubai
'Need for change in lifestyle to tackle climate change'
17
19.12.2008
20.12.2008
20.12.2008
20.12.2008
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
Seminar on 'Coal-based power and alternatives' on Sunday
Effective climate-risk strategies needed: Pachauri
Not just about building designs
We must find our own ways to deal with crises: Manmohan
Choice of climate-change denier
IFAD chief says climate change threat is very real
A rainforest's saga of survival
Corporate houses ignore 'natural debt': Pachauri
Sirsi becomes fifth regional climate centre in the world
Bicycle rally to promote green cause
China's emission reduction target stirs debate
Ananth Krishnan
Manmohan, Obama discuss Afghanistan
Science exhibition shows students at their best
Global emissions 'exceeding carbon budget'
Wide representation from Chennai at UN climate change conference
BJP: don't yield to pressure on climate change
Book on monuments released
Copenhagen 'must fail,' says a pioneer
Sea level rise will not spare India: scientist
BASIC draft calls for technology transfer mechanism
Aarti Dhar
Cabinet meets on Everest
Facing a changing world
Four youths to attend Copenhagen summit
Live under the shade of trees
Promote eco-friendly farming, Punjab Govt. told
'Ramesh has rubbished consistent position on climate change'
Substantial funds for climate study promised
As the glaciers recede...
BASIC draft not hopeful of Copenhagen pact
Aarti Dhar
Call to tackle impact of global warming
'Consistent position on climate change rubbished'
CPI(M) sees flip-flop on climate change
CSD fears land grab scheme at Copenhagen
Delhi gets award for excellence in urban transport
Indian firms way ahead in disclosing carbon emissions
Manmohan to attend climate meet
Danish move will be disastrous for India
Aarti Dhar
Food for thought at Copenhagen
Green tech the way out: VUDA vice-chairman
Hopes raised over climate summit
Aarti Dhar
Jaipur team leaves for Copenhagen
Jairam irons out differences with negotiators
Aarti Dhar
Action plan to tackle water contamination in Bellary
Kolkata rally highlights threat to Sunderbans
Not accepting legally binding cuts: Jairam
Put agriculture high on agenda
'An India that can say yes' to climate change
Awareness of global warming to be created
Call for reliable sensor systems in healthcare
Focus on agriculture instead of industries, policy-makers urged
Ills of global warming highlighted
18
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
14.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
INTACH plans to move closer to rural areas
Nitrous oxide concerns cloud future of biofuels
The climate denial industry seeks to dupe the public. It's working
2000-2009: warmest decade on record
Developing countries slam Danish text
John Vidal
Easing change in the climate will be costly
Government open to private investment in nuclear power
And in this corner, climate doubters
Logo, mascot of National Games unveiled
Multi-disciplinary approach needed to manage water
Promote organic farming: Swadeshi Science Congress
This train offers a peep into the world of science
Wen calls up Manmohan on Copenhagen
Climate: Nepal is a victim
'Firms can do much more on environment front'
TNAU sets up automatic weather stations
Bioflare-2009 held at ANITS
Cycling being promoted in a big way in BRT corridor
IGNOU, WWF tie up
In perpetual motion
Students take out bicycle rally
Bigger focus promised on Kyoto after Afrikan walkout
Priscilla Jebaraj
'Goa Sand Art Festival' at Candolim Beach from Friday
India will not accept cut-off date for carbon emissions: Yechury
Manmohan, Wen likely to meet
Negotiators haggling over words
Priscilla Jebaraj
Rich nations dividing developing countries to weaken voice,
says China
Aarti Dhar
'Role for palaeontology in tackling climate change'
Saving the environment
State unable to meet energy demand, says Eshwarappa
Students told to campaign for conservation of energy
'True progress will promote eternal peace'
Many climate activists left high and dry
Time for consensus has arrived: U.N. chief
Priscilla Jebaraj
Wind energy is attracting investors, and corruption
Climate protesters brave snow flurries, truncheons
Consensus eludes climate talks
Priscilla Jebaraj
Human chain formed to fight climate change
Obama is not saviour of the world. He's still a U.S. president
Jonathan Freedland
We are eternally hopeful: Nirupama Rao
We are eternally hopeful: Nirupama Rao
Bolivia stuns climate summit with target
Climate talks gather momentum
Priscilla Jebaraj
Compromise in sight on international scrutiny
'Like China, India should protect food security'
Bhutan's commitment to climate change unconditional
Birth of BASIC signals decline of G77
Priscilla Jebaraj
Copenhagen finds echoes in Bangalore
Copenhagen summit: City students express solidarity
19
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
25.12.2009
26.12.2009
26.12.2009
15.06.2010
15.06.2010
17.06.2010
18.06.2010
19.06.2010
20.06.2010
20.06.2010
Last-ditch efforts to salvage climate talks at Copenhagen
Make green building code mandatory
Come, let us join hands to save the earth
Copenhagen Accord an 'important beginning'
Copenhagen summit: students express solidarity
CSE, Greenpeace, disappointed
Disseminate benefits of technology: Swaminathan
Fighting climate change
Medha Patkar to back agitation against Hanakon power plant
Review water policy to address climate change: panel
Swaminathan for House panel on climate change
Swaminathan for panel to study climate change
Three-day film festival begins
Water is the climate challenge
Press for deep cuts by developed countries: CPI (M)
TNEB is taking steps to reduce power loss, says Chief Engineer
A damp squib: CPI
Climate summit: where's the beef ?
Copenhagen pact disappointing: Karat
Operationalising climate accord difficult: Ghosh
'People should actively oppose harmful projects'
Stress on protecting waterbodies
The truth of what happened at Copenhagen
A case of missed opportunity
A thrilling performance
'Copenhagen Accord a dilution of the Kyoto Protocol'
India failed to protect people's interests, says Greenpeace
India to draw road map for low-carbon growth
India, China agree to cooperate on climate change
Opposition slams government on Copenhagen
Scientific advances are key to food security: expert
Sovereignity not compromised: Jairam
State lauded for efforts to tap renewable energy
Climate change action plan sought for Karnataka
Climate change will hit small farmers most: Pawar
Effects of aircraft emissions studied
'India failed to raise climate justice issue at Copenhagen'
Let's talk about climate
Outcome good, but not adequate: Pachauri
'Ridiculous to suggest that TERI is a company about money'
They care for the earth, genuinely
Taking stock of Copenhagen
Copenhagen, tsunami and hunger
CPI (M), CPI to take stock of political situation
Gulfs remain after U.N. climate change talks in Bonn
Save species, save Earth
Community colleges for unskilled workers
Climate change: activists seek time to submit suggestions
Africa's angst - and nirvana
Green India Mission is not business as usual, says Jairam
Manmohan: Double farm growth rate to ensure food security
Priscilla Jebaraj
Priscilla Jebaraj
Sushanta Talukdar
Aarti Dhar
Fidel Castro Ruz
Aarti Dhar
Gargi Parsai
Gargi Parsai
T. Jayaraman
M.S. Swaminathan
20
20.06.2010
22.06.2010
22.06.2010
24.06.2010
25.06.2010
25.06.2010
26.06.2010
27.06.2010
27.06.2010
28.06.2010
28.06.2010
29.06.2010
29.06.2010
29.06.2010
29.06.2010
30.06.2010
01.07.2010
01.07.2010
02.07.2010
03.07.2010
04.07.2010
05.07.2010
06.07.2010
06.07.2010
07.07.2010
Meet for paper on environment
Learning to take care of nature
State moves to fight climate change
'Develop renewable energy sources to combat global warming'
Julia Gillard is Australia's first woman Prime Minister
Stress on local action to mitigate the effects of climate change
Master Plan to address needs of expanding metropolis
Delhi to generate power from its daily solid waste
India-Japan parleys on civil nuclear pact to begin tomorrow
'Land identified by UDF regime caught in litigation'
Meet calls for decentralised solid waste management
Champions come in all sizes
Jairam Ramesh calls for carbon budgeting to ensure equity
Japan's new civil nuclear diplomacy
Sensitising farmers to developing techniques, methods under changing climatic conditions
Between reality and 'actual reality'
‘Every citizen must act like an environmentalist'
Seasonal diseases flare up
Youth urged to protect environment
Menon's mission will transcend border issue
Ananth Krishnan
A disaster management plan for Kozhikode
Biju Govind
Menon's focus on expanding economic ties with China
Ananth Krishnan
‘Tackle climate changes through research'
North-East urged to assess climate change impact
Sushanta Talukdar
‘Iron ore dumped on island near Belekeri'
Total: 268 articles, of which 62 were coded intensively (175 actor statements)
Times of India
Date
29.11.2007
29.11.2007
30.11.2007
01.12.2007
02.12.2007
03.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
05.12.2007
05.12.2007
05.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
11.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
14.12.2007
15.12.2007
16.12.2007
Title
After releasing, Montek trashes UNDP report
Earth on fire
Plan on climate behind schedule
Why PM skipped UNDP report release
India against tourists paying carbon tax
For India, status quo is way forward
FICCI seeks tax breaks for carbon credit biz
ICAI to draft accounting norms for carbon trade
Bali meet to impact carbon credit biz
India to gain as Australia signs Kyoto pact
Tech transfer: India gets one up on Japan, Canada
India, China may win battle for climate fund
Poor nations will suffer most from rise in sea level
India, China team up to tackle West bullying
Rally to spread environment message
Poor nations to get climate change cover
Climate talks: Time to act is now, says UN chief
India, US cross swords over Kyoto pact
India agrees to join big emitters at US climate change meet
China blacklists 4,000 foreign firms
Bali roadmap to help seal new deal by '09
Author
21
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
18.12.2007
20.12.2007
01.07.2008
01.07.2008
02.07.2008
02.07.2008
03.07.2008
12.12.2008
12.12.2008
13.12.2008
14.12.2008
15.12.2008
16.12.2008
16.12.2008
17.12.2008
19.12.2008
21.12.2008
22.12.2008
22.12.2008
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
Finally, climate changes for India
'Sibal shocked everyone with aggressive stance'
UN's Ban welcomes Bali climate deal
Restrict use of cars to cut pollution: Panel
Climate action plan pushes for solar energy
Young climate champion
'India's climate change plan is better than China's'
Stage set for domestic trading in energy credits
RestOfWorld
Ahmedabad
The classical have and have not divide is destined to turn the
climate change summit here into a failure.
Climate meet begins amid distrust
Indian against altering UN convention on climate change
Climate plan wants drastic curbs on private cars
Pachauri to visit city
Rich nations refuse to share carbon profit with the poor
Officials welcome proposal on tackling vehicle growth
Bangalore
Solar plant gets green signal
Bengal govt plans energy conservation fund
Pachauri rings Bengal coast alarm
France wants a 'carbon tax' on EU imports
In a move aimed at quelling any doubt about India's position on climate change negotiations, Prime Minister
Manmohan Singh on Friday firmly reiterated the link between accepting an "ambitious" global emission cut target
and clear commitments on sharing the technological and
fiscal burdens.
Opposition BJP on Saturday accused environment minister
Jairam Ramesh of speaking a different language abroad on
the issue of climate change
Key terms for Copenhagen
Green stoves to replace chullahs
India not to follow China on climate commitments
New Delhi: Seeking to match China in public diplomacy over
climate change negotiations, the government is likely to
announce on Thursday its plan to reduce carbon or energy
intensity.
Rise in sea level may hit Kolkata
Those living in coastal areas should be worried:
Minissha's Going Green
India vows 20-25% carbon intensity cuts
No climate sceptics in Lok Sabha
BJP: Carbon intensity cuts 'bad strategy'
Emission intensity can be cut by 37%: Montek
Govt's climate stand runs into rough weather
Isro images show Gangotri glacier receded 1.5km in 30 yrs
Nepal ministers scale new height to fight warming
Our negotiating position has strengthened: Jairam
BHU scientists toil away to prevent local warming
PM to attend climate summit on Dec 18
22
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
Their Copenhagen begins at home
Warming Signals
'Climate change will hit 175m kids every year'
Jairam persuades negotiators to join climate talks
Manmohan going to Copenhagen under pressure: BJP
Carbon credits bring Mittal ?1bn bonanza
Carbon markets are a sham
Cracks appear in G-77 bloc on Day One
70% of CO² from developed world
Climate change: Can we weather it?
For young MPs, it's a climate conundrum
Climate issue a big worry for Indians: Survey
Oppn walks out of RS on `shifting' climate stand
Buddha asks Centre for funds to save Sunderbans
4 from city to attend Copenhagen meet
Warming taking toll on Western Ghats
Climate summit keeps students away from flu scare
Coming, energy-efficiency norms for industry
KKPKP puts forth the merits of recycling at Copenhagen
Small islands group force break in climate talks
`Simple living to fight global warming'
Climate change class to begin soon
Gujarat leaps into sea, emerges power-full
India, China `harmonise' positions on climate change
Students gather drops for cleaner ocean
US not ready to fund developing nations, says special envoy
Delhi's CNG rings bell at climate summit
Cabinet brief says no deviation from India's stated climate
stand
State opens CDM cell to help
acquire carbon credits
Droughts, floods will be
more intense, warns expert
'Oz tweaked its emissions report'
PM Manmohan Singh, Wen may skip Copenhagen
West playing dirty, says African team member
What about 30 million climate refugees?
Plug wastage, you have the power
You can do your bit to save energy. And it starts right there in
your living room
A report prepared by The Energy and Resources Institute
(TERI)
Arnold Schwarzenegger lauds India's solar project
At Copenhagen, state heads' hunt on for excuses
They dream of a rich, green India
Climate change: G77 unites against West's bid to scrap Kyoto
Youth get talking about climate change
Confidential document reveals industrialized countries cheating the world on climate
'Copenhagen turns into a battlefield'
Protest against sponge iron units
23
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
23.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
19.06.2010
24.06.2010
26.06.2010
26.06.2010
04.07.2010
07.07.2010
Climate talks go into overtime, PM Manmohan called back
PIL to promote green energy
We can do with more tech support: PM on climate
A facesaver in Copenhagen scripted by US and 'friends'
Can't settle for less than Kyoto: PM
China's image takes beating
How the Danes did the West's dirty work
India's Harvest of Change
Patkar joins protest against Hanakon project
Win-win situation for India, at least for now
Yechury says job well done, but lists 3 worries for future
'Overcoming hunger, malnutrition is top priority'
After RWH, its time for GWH
We can challenge India on Copenhagen goals: US
Maya slams Pawar for price-hike remarks
'Alternative track to Kyoto open'
India will remain 'flexible' in climate talks, says Ramesh
Orissa presents itself as an example of climate change victim
Developmental Issues
Jaipur: The desert is expanding in Rajasthan
The Union Cabinet on Thursday approved the ambitious National Mission for Enhanced Energy Efficiency
Environmentalists and nature lovers of Banaras Hindu University (BHU) are optimistic about the Green India Mission
initiated by the ministry of environment and forests, Government of India.
A seminar organised on Saturday by the state pollution control board on air pollution in Howrah gave a clue to the state
of affairs in Kolkata's twin city
At a time when corporate world's help is being sought to save
the tigers, corporate giant ITC's 'Classmate' brand of tiger
series notebooks have become instant hit among the students.
Total: 130 articles, of which 35 were coded intensively (67 actor statements)
4.3 USA
New York Times
Date
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
27.11.2007
28.11.2007
28.11.2007
30.11.2007
01.12.2007
Title
Australia's Path Bends Away From U.S.
British Firms Urge Action On Climate
News Summary
U.N. Warns of Climate-Related Setbacks
When Fuel and Politics Mix
Study Details How U.S. Could Cut 28% of Greenhouse Gases
DEAL IN CONGRESS ON PLAN TO RAISE FUEL EFFICIENCY
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
02.12.2007
Greenhouse Villain Could Be a White Knight After All
Housing Crisis? Try Mobile McMansions
The People We Have Been Waiting For
What to Wear? Meteorologists Shape Fashion
Author
RAYMOND BONNER
JULIA WERDIGIER
ANDREW C. REVKIN
EDMUND L. ANDREWS
MATTHEW L. WALD
JOHN M. BRODER and MICHELINE
MAYNARD.
KEVIN CAMERON
JOHN SCHWARTZ
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
MICHAEL BARBARO
24
03.12.2007
Climate Talks Take On Added Urgency After Report
03.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
04.12.2007
05.12.2007
05.12.2007
05.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
07.12.2007
The Climate in Bali and Washington
Being Green: The Young Show the Way
Bringing an Energy Bill Home
Kyoto Ratification First Act of New Leader
Crossing a Threshold On Energy Legislation
None
Precipitation Across U.S. Intensifies Over 50 Years
E.P.A. Is Prodded to Require Cuts in Airliner Emissions
Forest Loss in Sumatra Becomes a Global Issue
Robert O. Anderson, Oil Executive, Dies at 90
Senate Panel Passes Bill to Limit Greenhouse Gases
A Leading Asian Utility to Cut Carbon Emissions
All the Makings of a Carnival, Except the Fun
Turnabout on Fuel Standards
08.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
11.12.2007
11.12.2007
11.12.2007
11.12.2007
11.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
Warming and the Right
As Ice Recedes, Interest Surges
The 7th Annual Year in Ideas
The Harvest Goes Into Overtime
The Power Grid Game: Choose a Catastrophe
Bloomberg Travels to the Old World In Search of New Ideas
In Nobel Speech, Gore Calls for Urgent Climate Action
Mr. Johnson's Unused Authority
News Summary
With Altered Migratory Patterns, Duck Hunting Season Is in a
Blind
Republican Presidential Debate
U.S. Stand On Quotas Deadlocks Climate Talks
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
14.12.2007
A Shameful Presidential Threat
Federal Judge Upholds Law On Emissions In California
Focus of Climate Talks Shifts to Helping Poor Countries Cope
news summary
Will 2008 Be a Postwar Election?
At Divided Climate Talks, Consensus That U.S. Is at Fault
14.12.2007
15.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
18.12.2007
PETER GELLING and ANDREW C.
REVKIN
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
JOHN M. BRODER
FELICITY BARRINGER
MATTHEW L. WALD
PETER GELLING
DOUGLAS MARTIN
JOHN M. BRODER
KEITH BRADSHER
DAVID M. HERSZENHORN
MICHELINE MAYNARD; John M.
Broder, Nick Bunkley
DAN MITCHELL
ETHAN TODRAS-WHITEHILL
JAN ELLEN SPIEGEL
PETER APPLEBOME.
CLYDE HABERMAN.
SARAH LYALL
WILLIAM YARDLEY
THOMAS FULLER and PETER GELLING; Andrew C. Revkin
JOHN M. BRODER
PETER GELLING
THOMAS FULLER and ELISABETH
ROSENTHAL
Industry Flexes Muscle, and a Weaker Energy Bill Passes
JOHN M. BRODER
Deal on Reviving Climate Treaty Seems Close, but Is Elusive
THOMAS FULLER and ANDREW C.
REVKIN
A Carbon Cap That Starts in Washington
JUDITH CHEVALIER.
As China Goes, So Goes Global Warming
ANDREW C. REVKIN
Climate Plan Looks Beyond Bush's Tenure
THOMAS FULLER and ANDREW C.
REVKIN
In Iowa, Coveted Newspaper Endorsements for Clinton and JEFF ZELENY
McCain Campaigns
It's Too Late for Later
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
None
Candidates Collect Endorsements in Final Days in Iowa
KATHARINE Q. SEELYE
Disappointments on Climate
As Ethanol Takes Its First Steps, Congress Proposes a Giant CLIFFORD KRAUSS
25
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
19.12.2007
19.12.2007
19.12.2007
20.12.2007
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
21.12.2007
22.12.2007
23.01.2009
24.01.2009
24.01.2009
24.01.2009
24.01.2009
24.01.2009
25.01.2009
25.01.2009
26.01.2009
26.01.2009
27.01.2009
27.01.2009
27.01.2009
27.01.2009
29.01.2009
30.01.2009
31.01.2009
31.01.2009
31.01.2009
01.02.2009
01.02.2009
Leap
New Type of Coal Plant Moves Ahead, Haltingly
MATTHEW L. WALD; Andrew C.
Revkin
World Food Supply Is Shrinking, U.N. Agency Warns
ELISABETH ROSENTHAL
Hands Across Iowa
CATE DOTY
House, 314-100, Passes Broad Energy Bill; Bush to Sign It JOHN M. BRODER
Today
What Was That All About?
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
E.P.A. Says 17 States Can't Set Greenhouse Gas Rules for Cars JOHN M. BRODER and FELICITY
BARRINGER; Danny Hakim and
Micheline Maynard
Arrogance and Warming
China Grabs West's Smoke-Spewing Factories
JOSEPH KAHN and MARK LANDLER;
Joseph Kahn reported from Handan, China, and Dortmund, Germany, and Mark Landler from Dortmund. Jake Hooker and Ma Yi contributed reporting from Beijing and
Handan, and Sarah Plass from
Dortmund and Frankfurt.
Denial of California Bid on Emissions Should Have Been Fore- JOHN M. BRODER and MICHELINE
seen
MAYNARD; John M. Broder reported from Washington, and Micheline
Maynard from Detroit.
E.P.A. Ruling Puts California in a Bind
FELICITY BARRINGER
Plan on Airline Emissions Hints at U.S.-Europe Rift
JAMES KANTER
Just What Is the E.P.A. Protecting?
Environmental Issues Slide In Poll of Public's Concerns
ANDREW C. REVKIN
A Better Shade of Green
J. WAYNE LEONARD.
China Jittery About Obama Amid Signs of Harder Line
MARK LANDLER
Europe to Ask Wealthy Nations to Adopt Carbon Trading JAMES KANTER
System
Europe Wants U.S. to Join Carbon Trading Market
JAMES KANTER
More Than Charisma
BOB HERBERT
A Master Juggler In a Job That Demands One
DUNSTAN McNICHOL
China Jittery About Obama Amid Signs of Harder Line
MARK LANDLER
OBAMA'S ORDER LIKELY TO TIGHTEN AUTO STANDARDS
JOHN M. BRODER and PETER
BAKER; Felicity Barringer contributed reporting from Palo Alto, Calif.
Toward a More Energy-Efficient Future
Detroit Calls Emissions Proposals Too Strict
NICK BUNKLEY
Emissions Cut Won't Bring Quick Relief, Scientists Say
CORNELIA DEAN
Geography Is Dividing Democrats Over Energy
JOHN M. BRODER
New Day on Climate Change
CORRECTION
New Jungles Prompt a Debate on Saving Primeval Rain For- ELISABETH ROSENTHAL
ests
Inside the Times, January 31, 2009
Rising Acidity Is Threatening Food Web of Oceans, Science CORNELIA DEAN
Panel Says
The Next Step on Warming
All May Not Be Lost For the American Car
STEVE LOHR
Reinvention or Recovery?
DAVID E. SANGER
26
03.02.2009
03.02.2009
05.02.2009
06.02.2009
06.02.2009
07.02.2009
07.02.2009
07.02.2009
11.02.2009
12.02.2009
12.02.2009
12.02.2009
13.02.2009
14.02.2009
14.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
16.02.2009
18.02.2009
18.02.2009
19.02.2009
20.02.2009
20.02.2009
22.02.2009
22.02.2009
23.02.2009
24.02.2009
23.06.2009
24.06.2009
24.06.2009
24.06.2009
26.06.2009
27.06.2009
28.06.2009
28.06.2009
29.06.2009
29.06.2009
01.07.2009
Old Forests, New Forests
The CO2 Solution: Forests
Laurie Wayburn
Experts in U.S. and China See a Chance for Cooperation EDWARD WONG and ANDREW C.
Against Climate Change
REVKIN
Arctic Sea Partly Closed To Fishing
LESLIE KAUFMAN
Republicans Seize on Nominees' Tax Problems
PETER BAKER
Environmental Views, Past and Present
JOHN M. BRODER, ANDREW C.
REVKIN, FELICITY BARRINGER and
CORNELIA DEAN
Environmental Views, Past and Present
JOHN M. BRODER, ANDREW C.
REVKIN, FELICITY BARRINGER and
CORNELIA DEAN
Environmental Views, Past and Present CLIMATE: The Legacy Andrew C. Revkin
of Kyoto
U.S. Prepares to Broach Hard Issues With China
MARK LANDLER
Big Science Role Is Seen In Global Warming Cure
JOHN M. BRODER and MATTHEW L.
WALD
Ethanol, Just Recently a Savior, Is Struggling
CLIFFORD KRAUSS
Oil Industry Is Stressing Cooperation On Climate
CLIFFORD KRAUSS and JAD
MOUAWAD
U.S. Offers Europe Goodwill, and Expects Something in Re- HELENE COOPER
turn
Clinton Seeks Shift on China And Stresses Engagement
MARK LANDLER
Coal Industry Wins a Round on Mining
ANDREW C. REVKIN
California Drinking Water
Is America Ready to Quit Coal?
MELANIE WARNER
Yes, They Could. So They Did.
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
Clinton, Heading Abroad, Takes Softer Tone on North Korea
MARK LANDLER
An $80 Billion Start
City Must Prepare for Effects of Global Warming, Mayor's MIREYA NAVARRO
Panel Says
E.P.A. Expected to Regulate Carbon Dioxide and Other Heat- JOHN M. BRODER
Trapping Gases
Inside the Times, February 20, 2009
Obama Makes Overtures to Canada Prime Minister
SHERYL GAY STOLBERG; Ian Austen
contributed reporting.
Clinton Paints China Policy With a New Green Hue
MARK LANDLER
Obama Planning To Slash Deficit, Despite Stimulus
JACKIE CALMES
Ms. Jackson Makes a Change
Politics in the Guise of Pure Science
JOHN TIERNEY
President Of Mexico Urges Action On Emissions
REUTERS
Energy Bill Unfinished, but Vote Nears
JOHN M. BRODER
In Bedrock, Clean Energy and Quake Fears
JAMES GLANZ
Inside The Times
The House and Global Warming
House Backs Bill, 219-212, to Curb Global Warming
JOHN M. BRODER
A Non-Ban on Whaling
In Climate Change Bill, What May Become an Election-Year CARL HULSE
Issue
Betraying the Planet
PAUL KRUGMAN
OBAMA OPPOSES TRADE SANCTIONS IN CLIMATE BILL
JOHN M. BRODER
Adding Something for Everyone, House Leaders Gained a JOHN M. BRODER
27
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
02.07.2009
02.07.2009
02.07.2009
03.07.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
Climate Bill
Climate in the Senate
E.P.A. Grants California the Right to Enforce Emissions
E.P.A. Says California May Enforce Emissions
Just Do It
Quotation of the Day
Waxman Is Hospitalized
What's So Super About a Supermajority?
When Our Brains Short-Circuit
Taking Steps to Fight Global Warming
LED Bulbs Save Substantial Energy, a Study Finds
Tree Harvester Offers to Save Indonesian Forest
Europe Stews As Its Clout Diminishes On Climate
Britain: Investigator Assigned To Review Climate R
India Vows To Slow Pace Of Growth In Emissions
Obama Shifts His Visit to Last Day of Climate Conf
ClimateWorks Is Carrying Out New Global
Forecast: Expect Temperatures to Rise in Copenhage
Stolen E-Mail, Stoking the Climate Debate
That Climate Change E-Mail
Will Big Business Save the Earth?
An Affordable Truth
As Obama's Poll NUmbers Fall, Criticism
Beyond Copenhagen
Cap and Fade
Copenhagen Tightens Security Before Meeting, but C
In Face of Skeptics, Experts Affirm Climate Peril
At the Copenhagen Climate Talks
Climate Talks Open With Calls for Urgent
Dot Earth
Greenhouse Gases Imperil Health, E.P.A.
Russia's Carbon Credits Seen as Barrier to Warming
The Endangerment Finding
Violins and Hints of Hades: Delegates Ta
New Data Shows Warming Increased in Last Decade
And in This Corner, Climate Contrarians
Council Passes Curbs on Greenhouse Gases
U.S. Negotiator Dismisses Reparations for Climate
American Climate Envoy's Good Cop, Bad Cop Roles
Global and Local Concerns Cross Paths in
Privacy in a Wired World
The Pulse; Goldfinches Leaving For Cooler Climates
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
Europe Pledges Billions in Climate Change Funding
The Best Way to Cut Carbon Emissons
This Week in Copenhagen
Bloomberg The Bigfoot (In Carbon)
Man-Made Greenergy
Thousands March in Copenhagen, Calling for Action
What's Rotten for Obama in Denmark
In Bolivia, Water and Ice Tell A Story of a Changing Climate
Protesters Mostly Quiet After Day of Act
FELICITY BARRINGER
FELICITY BARRINGER
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
REPRESENTATIVE JOE BARTON,
JOHN M. BRODER
CARL HULSE
NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF
ERIC. A. TAUB
NORIMITSU ONISHI
28
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
25.12.2009
25.12.2009
26.12.2009
27.12.2009
27.12.2009
27.12.2009
29.12.2009
31.12.2009
02.07.2010
03.07.2010
04.07.2010
04.07.2010
05.07.2010
05.07.2010
06.07.2010
07.07.2010
11.07.2010
11.07.2010
14.07.2010
15.07.2010
16.07.2010
18.07.2010
CHINA AND U.S. HIT STRIDENT IMPASSE AT CLIMATE TALKS
Four Sides To Every Story
Tapping the New Gusher
Trusting Nature as the Climate Referee
Wind Energy Is Attracting Investors, and
DEAL SEEN NEAR FOR PAYMENTS TO SAVE FORESTS
Delegates at Talks Scramble as Gulf on Issues Remains
In Copenhagen, 'To Be Elaborated' Means a Stalemate
Outside Climate Talks, Protesters March
Poor and Emerging States Stall Climate Negotiations
At Climate Talks, Trade Pressures Mount
OBAMA HAS GOAL TO WREST A DEAL IN CLIMATE TALKS
5 NATIONS FORGE PACT ON CLIMATE; GOALS GO UNMET
In a Busy Conference Center, an Alphabet Soup of Causes and Clauses
Clear-Cutting the Truth About Trees
Denied Total Victory, Obama Accepts Validation
Grudging Accord on Climate, Along With Plenty of Discord
New Group Seeks to Bring Greener Power t
Off To The Races
Time Warps in the Climate Clash
U.N. Climate Talks 'Take Note' of Accord Backed by U.S.
Copenhagen, and Beyond
Mixed Bag for Obama on Climate Change De
Assessing the Outcome of the Climate Talks
Chinese and British Officials Tangle in Testy Exchange Over Climate Agreement
The Copenhagen That Matters
Chilly Climate for Oil Refiners
Loan Program May Stir Dormant Nuclear In
For Caring Consumers, the Gift of Carbon
The Price of Dissappointment
The Obama Way
Air Quality Guidelines Face Unexpected Critics
Brazil Aims To Prevent Land Grabs In Amazon
To Save the Planet, Save the Seas
Coming Clean About Carbon
Council in France Blocks a Carbon Tax As Weak on P
Britain Curbing Airport Growth To Aid Climate
ELISABETH ROSENTHAL
Papers Show Moynihan In Full Voice Under Nixon
SAM ROBERTS
The Choices That Pay Us Back
ROBERT H. FRANK.
This Year's Maverick
ROBERT DRAPER.
China Fears Warming Effects Of a Rising Consumer Class
KEITH BRADSHER
HEADLINE: Natural Gas and Its Effects on Climate Change
Indonesian Firm Accused of Clearing Rain Forests
AUBREY BELFORD
E.P.A. Issues Rules to Cut Air Pollution From Coal
JOHN M. BRODER
A Climate Change Corrective
Arid Australia Sips Seawater, But the Drink May Be Costly
NORIMITSU ONISHI
Trying to Stop Cattle Burps From Heating Up Planet
NORIMITSU ONISHI
Senate Democrats to Pursue a Smaller Energy Package
PETER BAKER and DAVID M. HERSZENHORN
A Tale of Two Targets
How Can Obama Rebound?
DAVID FRUM, STANLEY B. GREEN-
29
18.07.2010
18.07.2010
20.07.2010
It's Time to Start Worrying Again
To the Mat On Global Warming
Stephen H. Schneider, Climatologist, Is Dead at 65
21.07.2010
21.07.2010
23.07.2010
Overcome By Heat And Inertia
What 7 Republicans Could Do
Democrats Call Off Effort For Climate Bill in Senate
23.07.2010
24.07.2010
25.07.2010
25.07.2010
26.07.2010
26.07.2010
26.07.2010
27.07.2010
28.07.2010
28.07.2010
29.07.2010
30.07.2010
With a Whimper
Change Comes Quickly to a Place That Doesn't Care for It
No Advice Deficit: Suggestions for the President
We're Gonna Be Sorry
Four Ways to Kill a Climate Bill
The Right And The Climate
Who Cooked The Planet?
Pines, Beetles and Bears
Lawmakers Offer Bills To Address Spill Issues
Want the Good News First?
Nuclear Energy: The Safety Issues
Giving Up on a Climate Change Bill
BERG, DONNA BRAZILE, BILL
HILLSMAN, BOB KERREY, MARK
PENN,
ELIZABETH
EDWARDS,
EDWARD J. ROLLINS, KATHLEEN
HALL JAMIESON, MARK BLUMENTHAL, GRAY DAVIS, HAROLD FORD Jr.
, ROBERT SHRUM, JONATHAN ALTER and ARI FLEISCHER
DENNIS LIM
HARRY HURT III
DOUGLAS MARTIN; Felicity Barringer contributed reporting.
DAVID LEONHARDT.
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
CARL HULSE and DAVID M. HERSZENHORN; John M. Broder contributed reporting.
CARL HULSE
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
LEE WASSERMAN.
ROSS DOUTHAT
PAUL KRUGMAN
JOHN M. BRODER
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
Total: 245 articles, of which 73 were coded intensively (321 actor statements)
Washington Post
Date
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
26.11.2007
27.11.2007
27.11.2007
30.11.2007
02.12.2007
03.12.2007
03.12.2007
06.12.2007
06.12.2007
07.12.2007
Title
As the Price of Oil Soars, Many Turn to Renewables; New
Business Models, Technology Tap Into Trend
Climate Obstacles Ahead
None
Bush Meets Al Gore: Effect On Permafrost Unknown
Green Marketing Review Is Put on Fast Track at FTC
150 Global Firms Seek Mandatory Cuts in Greenhouse Gas
Emissions
Imagining the Holidays
Author
Steven Mufson
Sebastian Mallaby
Peter Baker
Steven Mufson
Juliet Eilperin
Amy Tan, Gary Shteyngart, Alice
McDermott, Christopher Buckley,
Geraldine Brooks
A New Green Economics; The Test for the World In Bali and Ban Ki-moon
Beyond
Taking on the Economics of Gender Inequity
Valerie Strauss
Overweight Kids At Risk as Adults; Study Finds Problems Even Rob Stein
Among Those Who Eventually Slim Down
Senate Panel Advances Bill to Cut Greenhouse Gases
Broad Energy Bill Passed by House; Car Mileage, Renewable Jonathan Weisman and Steven
30
07.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
08.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
09.12.2007
10.12.2007
11.12.2007
11.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
12.12.2007
13.12.2007
13.12.2007
14.12.2007
14.12.2007
15.12.2007
15.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
16.12.2007
17.12.2007
17.12.2007
18.12.2007
18.12.2007
19.12.2007
20.12.2007
20.12.2007
21.12.2007
Power Addressed
Mufson
In Twilight of His Career, Warner Now an Environmental David A. Fahrenthold
Maverick
Routes to Easing Climate Change
Matt Kallman; Brad Heavner
Senate To Rework Ambitious Energy Bill; Vehicle Fuel Effi- Steven Mufson and Jonathan
ciency Expected to Be the Focus
Weisman
Take the Carbon-Neutral Road to Splitsville
James Valvo
Election? Here's How You Do It, Mate.
John Barron
Fuel for Consensus; Congress can agree on improved gas-saving standards for autos.
Green House and Senate
Preserving Tropical Forests Is Key Issue at Talks on Global Juliet Eilperin and Steven Mufson
Warming
In Norway for Nobel Ceremony, Gore Extols 'People Power'
Mary Jordan
For U.S., Policy Discord Plays Out at Bali Climate Change Talks Juliet Eilperin
Gore Accepts Nobel Prize With Call for Bold Action; Former Mary Jordan
Vice President Depicts Climate Change As 'Threat to the Survival of Our Civilization'
A Greener Steel Industry
Andrew G. Sharkey III
Food vs. Fuel
Robert J. Samuelson
Hard Choices on Climate Can Wait for Next President, Aides Juliet Eilperin
Indicate
Region Is Urged To Build Greener; Council Wants Laws To Aid David A. Fahrenthold
Environment
U.S. Strategy Succeeds in Bali; Climate Talks Turn to Efforts Juliet Eilperin
Other Than Emissions Targets
Europeans Raise Ante at Bali Climate Talks; U.S. Stance on Juliet Eilperin
Emissions Targets Prompts Threat to Boycott Bush Forum
Senate Passes Energy Bill Without House Tax Package
Steven Mufson
Climate Change Compromise Plan Offered in Bali
Juliet Eilperin
Waiting on the EPA; It's time the agency allowed California's tougher tailpipe emissions standards
to take effect.
Bali Forum Backs Climate 'Road Map'; U.S. Accedes on Aid Juliet Eilperin
Pledges, Wins Fight to Drop Specific Targets for Emissions
Cuts
Letters To the Editor
Limousines Stretching Toward Greener Times
Warren Brown
There's No Such Thing as Free Green
Waiting on the EPA; It's time the agency allowed California's tougher tailpipe emissions standards
to take effect.
A weekly roundup of the buzz from the Sunday talk shows
Zachary A. Goldfarb
As Temperatures Rise, Health Could Decline
David Brown
Longtime Foes Face Off Over Mirant Power Plant; N.Va. Dis- Kirstin Downey
pute Puts Ex-U.S. Officials at Odds Again
Stalling in Bali; The Bush administration continues to say one thing and do another on climate
change.
House Sends President An Energy Bill to Sign
Steven Mufson; Washington Post
Staff Writer
EPA Chief Denies Calif. Limit on Auto Emissions; Rules Would Juliet Eilperin; Washington Post
Target Greenhouse Gases
Staff Writer
Taking a Turn for the Weird
David S. Broder
State Will Challenge The EPA's Rejection Of Calif. Standards; David A. Fahrenthold
Md. Aims to Protect Its Own Law
31
21.12.2007
22.12.2007
23.01.2009
23.01.2009
25.01.2009
25.01.2009
25.01.2009
26.01.2009
27.01.2009
27.01.2009
28.01.2009
29.01.2009
29.01.2009
01.02.2009
03.02.2009
04.02.2009
04.02.2009
05.02.2009
06.02.2009
06.02.2009
07.02.2009
10.02.2009
10.02.2009
11.02.2009
11.02.2009
13.02.2009
14.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
15.02.2009
What Was in That Office, Anyway? You Tell Us.
Al Kamen
Health Care Pushed to Fore By Calif. Vote; Senate to Debate Karl Vick
House-Passed Bill As the Feb. 5 Primaries Draw Near
CONTINUOUS
NEWS
UPDATES:
VOIC- Lisa Rein
ES.WASHINGTONPOST.COM/ANNAPOLIS
Study Ties Tree Deaths To Change in Climate
Juliet Eilperin
Energy Costs Generating Light-Bulb Solutions
Lisa Rein; Washington Post Staff
Writer
Go Slow, Foodies. It's the Way to Win.
Jane Black
Warming Trends Alter Conservation; Experts Think Old Para- Juliet Eilperin
digm of Fixed Boundaries Will Not Work as Sea Levels Rise
Obama to Take Steps On Car Fuel Efficiency
Juliet Eilperin and Steven Mufson
Long Droughts, Rising Seas Predicted Despite Future CO2 Juliet Eilperin
Curbs
Obama Issues Orders Toward More Fuel-Efficient Cars
Steven Mufson and Juliet Eilperin;
Washington Post Staff Writers
Agent of (Climate) Change; President Obama ends White House inaction -- but there's a better
way to tackle greenhouse gas emissions.
Gore Urges Cap on Carbon Emissions, Global Climate Pact; He Juliet Eilperin
Tells Senators the Situation Is Dire
With Al Due Respect, We're Doomed
Dana Milbank
Once the Stimulus Kicks In, the Real Fight Begins
Robert B. Reich
Energy Provision May Test Priorities
Steven Mufson
Democrats Pen Principles for Climate-Change Bills; Senate Juliet Eilperin
Panel Sets Goal of Creating Cap-and-Trade System
Line Items in the Stimulus Package
Salazar Voids Drilling Leases On Public Lands in Utah
Juliet Eilperin; Washington Post
Staff Writer
Clinton Packs Full Asia Agenda for First Trip as Secretary of Glenn Kessler; Washington Post
State
Staff Writer
Commercial Fishing Is Barred in Parts of Arctic
Juliet Eilperin
Global Smarminess
The Checkup; Health in the News and in Your Life
Adapted
from
voices.washpost.com/checkup
U.N. Chief Wants Obama at Climate-Change Summit
Colum Lynch
CONTINUOUS
NEWS
UPDATES:
VOIC- Annapolis Digest
ES.WASHINGTONPOST.COM/ANNAPOLIS
GM Slashing 10,000 Jobs; White-Collar Workers Also Face Pay Kendra Marr
Cuts Up to 10 Percent
CONTINUOUS
NEWS
UPDATES:
VOIC- Richmond Digest
ES.WASHINGTONPOST.COM/VIRGINIAPOLITICS
Congress Passes Stimulus Package; After Voting Largely Along Shailagh Murray and Paul Kane
Party Lines, $787 Billion Bill Goes to Obama
Can One Household Save the Planet?; No, but the planet Liza Mundy
can't be saved without it.
China Is at the Heart of Clinton's First Trip; Bush Solidified Glenn Kessler
Relations; Now the Obama White House Will Push for Broader Cooperation
Dark Green Doomsayers
George F. Will
Just the Start; After a Stimulus Victory, Hurdles for Obama
David S. Broder
Scientists: Pace of Climate Change Exceeds Estimates
Kari Lydersen
When Extinction Isn't Natural Selection
Andrew Keegan
32
16.02.2009
17.02.2009
18.02.2009
19.02.2009
20.02.2009
20.02.2009
21.02.2009
21.02.2009
23.02.2009
24.02.2009
23.06.2009
23.06.2009
24.06.2009
24.06.2009
25.06.2009
25.06.2009
26.06.2009
26.06.2009
26.06.2009
27.06.2009
27.06.2009
27.06.2009
27.06.2009
28.06.2009
28.06.2009
29.06.2009
29.06.2009
29.06.2009
30.06.2009
30.06.2009
01.07.2009
Climate Change Solutions; Sen. Boxer is open to everything -- except what might work best.
Alternative Energy Still Facing Headwinds; Despite Obama's Peter Slevin and Steven Mufson
Support, Projects Tripped Up by Financing, Logistics
EPA May Reverse Bush, Limit Carbon Emissions From Coal- Steven Mufson and Juliet Eilperin
Fired Plants
Obama Hoping to Reinforce U.S. Trade Relationship With Michael D. Shear
Canada
Trouble Trickles From Steep Drop in Oil Prices; Once Flush Steven Mufson
Global Economies, Energy Projects Stall
U.S. Has Dual Task On Climate Change; To Sway Both Con- Juliet Eilperin
gress, Other Nations To Approve Cuts in Greenhouse Gases
Cap-and-Trade Is the Way to Cut Emissions
Clinton Criticized for Not Trying to Force China's Hand; Advo- Glenn Kessler
cacy Groups Urge Her to Put Human Rights Front and Center
Climate Fears Are Driving 'Ecomigration' Across Globe
Shankar Vedantam
U.S. May Set Greenhouse Gas Standard for Cars
Juliet Eilperin
Climate Bill to Cost Average Consumer $175 a Year: CBO
Steven Mufson
Confidence in Stimulus Plan Ebbs, Poll Finds; Obama's Ap- Dan Balz and Jon Cohen
proval Rating Remains High, but Shift in Public Outlook Has
Political Implications
Students Without Borders; Online Communication Facilitates Maria Glod
Global Collaboration at Area Schools
Vote Set on House Climate Bill; Cap-and-Trade Legislation Steven Mufson
Advances Despite Some Resistance
A Greener Look for Coal; The Waxman-Markey energy bill reflects a commitment to lower costs
for cleaner coal, but will it work?
Limits on Emissions Have Wide Support
Steven Mufson and Jennifer Agiesta
Close Win Predicted For Cap-and-Trade Bill; House Speaker Paul Kane, Ben Pershing and David
Reports 'Progress'
A. Fahrenthold
For the Farm Lobby, Too Much Is Never Enough
Steven Pearlstein
Waxman-Markey; Action on climate change is overdue. But is this the best we can hope for?
GOD IN GOVERNMENT : The Best From This Week's Blog
In Close Vote, House Passes Climate Bill; Measure Aims to Steven Mufson, David A. FahrenChange Energy Use
thold and Paul Kane;
Obama, Merkel Find Much To Discuss; Climate Change Michael A. Fletcher
Among Topics
Politics Digest
House Votes
Mythical Tax Has Farmers Defending Cow Gas; Powerful Dina Cappiello; Associated Press
Lobby Ensures That Agriculture Is Exempt From Methane
Regulation
Obama Praises Climate Bill's Progress but Opposes Its Tar- Steven Mufson
iffs
Time for Iron Man
E.J. Dionne Jr.
Will Obama Follow Bush Or FDR?
Benjamin Wittes and Jack Goldsmith
Despite Majority, Obama to Be Tested; Diverse Ideology Cuts Shailagh Murray and Dan Balz
Democrats' Edge
Diva's 3-Ring Circus Starts Small
Amy Argetsinger and Roxanne Roberts
Cap and Traitors; 8 Republicans Stand Tall on Climate Michael Gerson
Change
33
01.07.2009
02.07.2009
02.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
02.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
06.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
EPA to Let Calif. Set Own Auto Emissions Limits
David A. Fahrenthold
Md. Seeks to Enlighten Residents on Using Less Energy; Katherine Shaver
Campaign Focuses On Saving Money
The New Energy Politics
E.J. Dionne Jr.
An Undeserved Penalty for Ethanol
Courage on Climate Change
Nation Digest
Obama Reaches Out Before Vatican Trip; 'Robust' Health Jacqueline L. Salmon
Worker Protection Backed
A party both united and divided; Opposition to Obama is Jon Cohen and Dan Balz
strong, but Republicans are split on GOP's direction and
leaders
Carbon-credit dispute threatens new climate deal; Russia Philip P. Pan
wants surplus carried over, but environmentalists call it
counterproductive and unearned
Pioneering new climate-change policies
Target practice in Copenhagen
Eugene Robinson
The e-mail storm over climate change
Moves by U.S., China induce India to do its bit on climate
Rama Lakshmi
An energy answer in the shale below?; New technology Steven Mufson
opens vast stores of natural gas, and the land rush is on
As emissions increase, carbon 'sinks' get clogged; World's Juliet Eilperin
oceans, forests becoming less able to absorb CO2
Digest
Republicans call for halt to climate efforts
los angeles times
Clean energy conservatives can embrace
James Murdoch
In a shift, India announces plan to slow pace of carbon Rama Lakshmi
emissions
Official questions pollution proposal; OMB says views of Juliet Eilperin
economist on rule are 'irrelevant'
Hopes for climate deal get a boost; Obama changes plans on Juliet Eilperin
talks, will attend at critical juncture
In e-mails, science of warming is hot debate; Stolen files of David A. Fahrenthold and Juliet
'Climate-gate' suggest some viewpoints on change are disre- Eilperin
garded
Dutch defense against climate change: Adapt; As the world Anthony Faiola and Juliet Eilperin
works to prevent disaster, the Netherlands plans for it
The climate-change travesty
George F. Will
To really save the planet, stop going green
Mike Tidwell
Topic A
Fresh air in Copenhagen; A sound approach for getting climate-change aid to developing countries
U.S. urged to do more on climate
Juliet Eilperin
EPA is preparing to regulate emissions in Congress's stead
Steven Mufson and David A.
Fahrenthold
Planet Panel; washingtonpost.com/planetpanel
A lingering pool of disbelief; Despite a decade of record Blaine Harden
drought, Australian farmers refuse to buy into climate
change
Copenhagen's political science
Sarah Palin
Post Carbon; washingtonpost.com/ climate-change
Juliet Eilperin
34
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
12.12.2009
12.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
13.12.2009
14.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
Court constricts W.Va. wind farm to protect bats; Company Maria Glod
must apply for special permit to build more turbines
Curbing carbon; EPA intervention should prod Congress to act.
For leader with flair for drama, a notable role on climate Emily Wax
stage
Mohamed Nasheed
Sacrificing for the planet
U.S. pushes for emissions cuts from China, developing na- Juliet Eilperin
tions
War president will address incongruity of accepting peace Michael A. Fletcher
prize
On Sarah Palin's climate stance
Senators propose cutting greenhouse gas emissions 17% by David A. Fahrenthold and Juliet
2020; 3 release 'framework' of bill to send message to cli- Eilperin
mate conference
Two sides of the ocean; one climate plea; D.C area students Michael Alison Chandler
hold own conference with peers in Copenhagen
Whose war on science?
Michael Gerson
Fire and ice in the global warming debate
U.N. group drafts plan to reduce emissions; Document Juliet Eilperin
points to obstacles ahead, but could lead to final deal
How governors could guide a Grand New Party
The Sunday Take
Protesters demand 'climate justice'; Little progress in U.N. Juliet Eilperin
talks, as Copenhagen rally draws tens of thousands
The year is over. But is it history?
Carlos Lozada
U.S. unveils plan to rev up clean technology in poor nations; Juliet Eilperin
Nations pledge funds to make renewable energy more accessible
Another source of greenhouse gas
Nina Shen Rastogi
Deep-sea glider; The first robot to cross the Atlantic offers David Brown
new possibilities for ocean and climate research
Palin's own 'Climate-gate'
Eugene Robinson
Planet Panel; washingtonpost.com/planetpanel
Poor nations stall talks on global warming; WALKOUT MAY Juliet Eilperin
NOT DELAY DEAL Negotiators hope to have agreement by
Friday
We must combat climate change
At Copenhagen, key decisions unresolved; Funding, compli- Juliet Eilperin
ance are sticking points in climate talks
Greater sea-level rise from warming predicted
Juliet Eilperin
More fuel for the climate debate
More talk, less support
George F. Will
Rotting in Denmark?; World leaders remain far from a deal in Copenhagen.
Signs of hope emerge at climate conference; OVERTURES Juliet Eilperin and David A. FahON BOTH SIDES Obama's Friday visit expected to be pivotal renthold
Time's come for Postal Service fleet to go green, lawmaker Ed O'Keefe
says; Bill includes $65 million for electric vehicles with powersaving system
5; QUESTIONS ABOUT THE COPENHAGEN CLIMATE TALKS
David A. Fahrenthold and Juliet
Eilperin
The climate conspiracy that isn't
Michael E. Mann
The greening of the grand wedding; Chefs whose nuptial Emily Wax
35
18.12.2009
19.12.2009
19.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
20.12.2009
21.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
01.07.2010
01.07.2010
02.07.2010
04.07.2010
07.07.2010
11.07.2010
11.07.2010
11.07.2010
12.07.2010
12.07.2010
13.07.2010
15.07.2010
16.07.2010
16.07.2010
16.07.2010
18.07.2010
18.07.2010
18.07.2010
20.07.2010
feasts cost 15,000 trees daily are pushed to try biomass fuel
U.S. urges carbon cuts in the developing world; Aid pledged
for poor nations China must agree to monitoring, Clinton
says
5; Questions about the Copenhagen climate talks
Climate deal falls short of key goals; COMPROMISE IN COPENHAGEN Major nations reach accord, but fail to craft a
treaty
Copenhagen talks show U.S., China may shape future
Juliet Eilperin and Anthony Faiola
David A. Fahrenthold
Juliet Eilperin and Anthony Faiola
Anthony Faiola, Juliet Eilperin and
John Pomfret
Hope and funding for saving forests around the world; Pro- Juliet Eilperin
jects create financial incentive to leave trees alone
One cheer for Copenhagen; An agreement makes some -- if not enough -- headway. Cue the U.S.
Senate.
Topic A
China, U.S. hail climate accord as poorer nations denounce Associated Press
it; World powers defend nonbinding deal that disappoints
advocates
The political world's winners and losers in health-care reform
Dam break illustrates EPA's burden
David A. Fahrenthold
Dubious 'wins' in Copenhagen and Congress
George F. Will
Planet Panel; washingtonpost.com/planetpanel
Democrats, don't be afraid to care
E.J. Dionne Jr.
Limit outdoor chores in the July heat
Jeanne Huber Special to The Washington Post
Carbon pricing won't achieve emissions goals
Vinod Khosla
DIGEST
Queen Elizabeth's subdued visit to New York; Monarch Colum Lynch
speaks to U.N. 'Peace is the hardest form of leadership'
Health care. Wall Street. Energy. Immigration. Why the ob- Michael Lind
session with all-or-nothing fixes has Washington running in
circles.; Health care. Wall Street. Energy. Immigration. Why
the obsession with all-or-nothing fixes has Washington running in circles.
Outspoken; A conversation with Yvo de Boer Ex-climate-change chief
Try to imagine D.C. without so much A.C.; Dept. of What If
Stan Cox
Climate debate unmoved by spill; Legislative gridlock re- David A. Fahrenthold and Juliet
mains as demand for gasoline rises in U.S.
Eilperin
Congress returns to more of the same, and then some
Shailagh Murray
Magical thinking is not an energy strategy
Allan Sloan
House Democrats hit boiling point; Obama tries to quell up- Paul Kane
rising Anger over taking risks, getting little in return
A clean-energy start; Majority Leader Harry Reid's modest bill lays some useful groundwork.
Americans want clean energy
Can regulation beget innovation?
Steven Pearlstein
America's petro-state; Environmental ruin. Poverty. Corrup- Steven Mufson
tion. What Louisiana has in common with the world's oil-rich
nations.
It's about seeing the forest and the trees in Calif.; Scientists Paul Rogers
study global warming's effect on redwoods and sequoias
Topic A
How big a burden is livestock?
Nina Shen Rastogi
36
20.07.2010
23.07.2010
23.07.2010
24.07.2010
25.07.2010
25.07.2010
27.07.2010
27.07.2010
28.07.2010
29.07.2010
Stanford climatologist was a leader in research about global T. Rees Shapiro
warming
None
POST PARTISAN; Excerpts from The Post's opinion blog, updated daily at washingtonpost.com/postpartisan
Builders weigh going green against losing greenbacks
Katherine Salant
Mammoth hunters had effect on climate; Study: Man helped Yereth Rosen
create a prehistoric global warming
Outlook chilly for a smart climate bill; A failure to prioritize limits Democrats' chances of putting
a price on carbon.
Among House Democrats, a sense of abandonment; Carbon- Paul Kane and Shailagh Murray
cap backers say party leaders left them exposed on hated
issue
Kerry's lonely push on climate change
On tax fight, Obama can't afford to lose
Steven Pearlstein
How Washington failed on climate change
Stephen Stromberg
Total: 216 articles, of which 76 were coded intensively (162 actor statements)
Wall Street Journal
Date
24.06.2009
25.06.2009
25.06.2009
25.06.2009
26.06.2009
26.06.2009
27.06.2009
29.06.2009
29.06.2009
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
01.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
03.07.2009
30.11.2009
Title
Corporate News: GCL-Poly Plans to Purchase Chinese Solar
Parts Maker
U.S. News: Climate Bill Is Expected to Reverberate in 2010
Vote
U.S. News: White House Hosts Bipartisan Immigration Talks
The Cap and Tax Fiction
Ahead of the Tape
Potomac
Watch
The Climate Change Climate Change
House Passes Climate Bill --- Republicans Say Proposals Will
Hurt Economy; Prospects in Senate Are Murky
Democrats Present Hurdles for Obama
U.S. News: Obama Wary of Tariff Provision --- Trade Proposal in Climate Bill a Potential Problem as Action Moves to
Senate
China Is Expected to Block Imports of Chicken From U.S.
ITC Revs Up for 'Green' Grids
U.S. News: Franken Heads to Senate, Bolsters Democrats'
Hand --- Minnesota Court Confirms Razor-Thin Election Win,
but Party's Filibuster-Proof Majority Is Vulnerable to Internal Fissures
It Was Settled: The Sun Orbits the Earth
Currents -- Religion: In Political Ads, Christian Left Mounts
Sermonic Campaigns
Potomac
Watch
The EPA Silences a Climate Skeptic
U.S. News: State's Renewable-Energy Focus Risks Power
Shortages
World News: Climate Declaration To Get Global Boost
The Carbonated Congress
Climate Change and Melting Glaciers
Author
Jeffrey Ng and Yvonne Lee
Greg Hitt and Stephen Power
Jonathan Weisman
Carolyn Cui
Kimberley A. Strassel
Greg Hitt and Stephen Power
Naftali Bendavid and Greg Hitt
Greg Hitt and Naftali Bendavid
Lauren Etter and Stephen Power
Mark Peters
Naftali Bendavid and Greg Hitt
Stephanie Simon
Kimberley A. Strassel
Rebecca Smith
Jonathan Weisman
Bjorn Lomborg
37
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
30.11.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
01.12.2009
02.12.2009
02.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
03.12.2009
04.12.2009
04.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
05.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
07.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
08.12.2009
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
Information Age: The Web Discloses Inconvenient Climate
Truths
World News: Australia And U.S. To Discuss Climate
World News: China Defends Yuan Policy in Face of EU Criticism
Global
View
Climategate: Follow the Money
The Climate Science Isn't Settled
U.S. News --- CAPITAL JOURNAL: Measuring the Return on
Diplomacy
U.S. News: Climate Scientist Steps Down --- British Researcher Leaves Post Temporarily Amid Probe Sparked by
Hacked Emails
Letters to the Editor
Heard
on
the
Street
Wind Power Winds Up China's Competitors
Wonderland: Climategate: Science Is Dying
U.S. News: U.S. Watch
The High Costs of Copenhagen
World News: India to Cut Emissions, but Fight Targets
World News: Obama, in Shift, Expects Climate Deal at
Summit --- President Changes Schedule to Join Other Leaders, Signaling Revived Effort
World News: U.N. Panel to Probe Claims on Manipulating
Climate Data
Notable &Quotable
Business Fumes Over EPA Rule --- Carbon-Dioxide Emissions
to Face Curbs
Environment (A Special Report) --- Editor's Note
Environment (A Special Report) --- How Green Is Your IQ? So,
you think you know the environment; Let's see
Environment (A Special Report) --- If It Warms Up, Who's
Going to Pay?
Environment (A Special Report) --- Keeping It Frozen: In
Alaska, a low-tech solution helps the ground stay cold
enough, for now
Information Age: Climate of Uncertainty Heats Up
Environment (A Special Report) --- Who Wants What in
Copenhagen
Corporate News: EPA Declares Greenhouse Gases a Danger -- Controversial Formal Label Opens Door to New Emissions
Regulations for Power Plants, Refiners, Smelters and Others
EPA's Carbon Proposal Riles Industries --- Airlines, Utilities,
Others Say New Rules Would Undercut U.S. Firms; Some
Want Congress to Act
Global
View
The Totalities of Copenhagen
The Copenhagen Concoction
What's News
World-Wide
From Copenhagen to Congress
U.S. News -- The Climate Conference -- Copenhagen: Developing Nations Call for Rich to Aid Emissions Cuts
L. Gordon Crovitz
Iain McDonald
James T. Areddy
Bret Stephens
Richard S. Lindzen
Gerald F. Seib
Keith Johnson, Jeffrey Ball and
Gautam Naik
Andrew Peaple
Daniel Henninger
Stephen Power
Richard K. Lester
Eric Yep
Stephen Power
Guy Chazan
Jeffrey Ball and Charles Forelle
Lawrence Rout
Keith Johnson
Samuel Fankhauser
Jim Carlton
L. Gordon Crovitz
Ian Talley
Rebecca Smith and Timothy Aeppel
Bret Stephens
Fred Krupp
Alessandro
Williams
Torello
and
Selina
38
09.12.2009
09.12.2009
10.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
11.12.2009
12.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
14.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
15.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
16.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
17.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
18.12.2009
19.12.2009
21.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
22.12.2009
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
U.S. News: Big Utility Turns Bullish on Carbon Capture
World News: Obama's Nobel Balance --- Speech Will Address
Irony of Accepting Peace Prize Amid War
For Global Finance, Global Regulation
Obama Defends 'Just War' at Oslo
Rebecca Smith
Elizabeth Williamson
Gordon Brown and Nicolas Sarkozy
Elizabeth Williamson and Jonathan
Weisman
Watch Kimberley A. Strassel
Potomac
The EPA's Carbon Bomb Fizzles
World News -- The Climate Conference: Copenhagen: Soros Alessandro Torello
Proposes Way To Fund CO2 Cuts
Naked Copenhagen
Richard Muller
Climate Summit: Obama Efforts Face Diplomatic Hurdles
Stephen Power and Jonathan
Weisman
Climate Summit: U.S. and China Square Off on Aid --- Beijing Jeffrey Ball
Says It Still Deserves Billions to Help It Move to Cleaner
Growth
Whole Foods Republicans
Michael J. Petrilli
What's News
World-Wide
The Climate Conference -- Copenhagen: World's Top Pollut- Shai Oster
er Emerges As Green-Technology Leader
Time for a Smarter Approach to Global Warming
Bjorn Lomborg
Climate Summit: Copenhagen Dispatches
Banker Baiting 101
'Clean Coal' Project Stalls
Siobhan Hughes
Climate Summit: Compliance Checks Prove a Big Hurdle
Stephen Power
The
Property
Report Christina S.N. Lewis
Green Builders Awaiting the Green --- Distribution of Billions
of Dollars in Stimulus Aid Could Take Months Amid Long Lead
Times
The Copenhagen Shakedown
Climate Summit: U.K. Becomes a Test Case for Clean-Energy Guy Chazan
Plans
Climate Summit: EU Emission Target Sparks Controversy
Charles Forelle
Letters to the Editor
Climate Summit: Plan Counts on Private Funding to Curb Jeffrey Ball
CO2
How to Manufacture a Climate Consensus
Patrick J. Michaels
Showdown at Climate Talks --- Obama Jets to Denmark, U.S. Stephen Power, Guy Chazan, ElizaBacks $100 Billion Annual Aid to Clinch Carbon Deal
beth Williamson and Jeffrey Ball
Copenhagen's Lesson in Limits
Health-Care Overhaul: Democrats Pin 2010 Hopes on Bill --- Jonathan Weisman
Infighting, Struggles on Legislative Priorities Stand as Hurdles
for Party Leadership
Heard
on
the
Street Matthew Curtin
Green Investments Are Being Clouded by Copenhagen
Time for a Climate Change Plan B
Nigel Lawson
World News: Carbon-Permit Slide Reflects Copenhagen Dis- Keith Johnson
appointment
After Summit, 'Cleantech' Firms Reset Strategy
Spencer Swartz and Jim Carlton
Heard
on
the
Street Liam Denning
Delays Out of Copenhagen Fire Up Coal
39
23.12.2009
23.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
24.12.2009
01.07.2010
03.07.2010
06.07.2010
06.07.2010
06.07.2010
06.07.2010
06.07.2010
08.07.2010
09.07.2010
09.07.2010
12.07.2010
12.07.2010
12.07.2010
14.07.2010
15.07.2010
16.07.2010
17.07.2010
17.07.2010
17.07.2010
19.07.2010
19.07.2010
20.07.2010
20.07.2010
23.07.2010
U.S. News: Alabama Democrat, Vexed by Party's Agenda,
Jumps to GOP
Letters to the Editor
They're Organized and on the Move
There Are Tea Parties and Tea Parties, And Here the Twain
Meet, Uneasily --- Mr. Richardson, Who Knows How to Brew,
Visits Ms. Sims, Steeped in Politics
U.S. News --- CAPITAL: Economic Reality Drives Agenda
Letters to the Editor
Global Warming in the Days of Old With Vikings Bold
U.S. News --- CAPITAL: Free-Trade Winds May Be Picking Up
Again
U.S. News: Smaller Oil Firms Might Exit Gulf, Browner Says
Obama Decried, Then Used, Some Bush Drilling Policies
U.S. News: Cost of Stimulus Cash Vexes Universities --- While
Grateful for Extra Research Funds, Many Schools Find Their
Indirect Expenses a Burden and Want More Federal Money
World News: Review Seeks Change at Climate Panel --- Dutch
Agency Backs U.N. on Warming, Spots Error, Calls for Broader
Summary
Letters to the Editor
It Will Kill U.S. Jobs, Won't Reduce Carbon Emissions
What's News
World-Wide
World News: Report Backs Climate Data, Scolds Scientists
REVIEW
&OUTLOOK
(Editorial)
The
White
House
Gets
Drilled
Peter Wallsten
The Obama-Pelosi Lame Duck Strategy
Commodities
Report
Changes Choke Cap-and-Trade Market
The Climategate Whitewash Continues
World News: Plan to Save Indonesia's Forests Hits Snags --Environmentalists Warn of Loopholes As Industries Lobby for
Land Rights
Bookshelf
Real Government Efficiency
U.S. News --- CAPITAL: Rousing the Spirits of Business to
Create More Jobs
World News: World Watch
U.S. News: Governor Names Ally to Byrd Seat
WEEKEND INVESTOR --- The New Basics: Oops: 'Socially Responsible' Funds Hold Big Stakes of BP
U.S. News: U.S. Watch
World News: Australia Vote to Test Strength of Labor's Hand
--- Prime Minister Gillard and Opposition Rival Abbott Launch
Campaigns for August Vote, Striking Populist Stances
REVIEW &OUTLOOK (Editorial)
A Climate Absolution?
A Staunch and Self-Confident Ally
China Tops U.S. in Energy --- Asian Giant Emerges as No. 1
User of Power, Reshaping Oil Markets, Diplomacy
U.S. News: Senate Halts Effort to Cap Emissions --- Democrats
John Fund
Mark Peters
Barry Newman
David Wessel
David Wessel
Siobhan Hughes
Neil King Jr. and Keith Johnson
Cari Tuna
Jeffrey Ball
Jeffrey Ball and Guy Chazan
Patrick J. Michaels
Patrick Barta
Jeffrey Collins
David Wessel
Kris Maher
Eleanor Laise
Rachel Pannett and Lyndal McFarland
David Cameron
Spencer Swartz and Shai Oster
Stephen Power
40
24.07.2010
24.07.2010
28.07.2010
Forgo Centerpiece of President Obama's Energy Plan, as Capand-Trade Fails to Lure Broad Political Support
World News: Australia Reaffirms Its Green Initiatives
Rachel Pannett
Letters to the Editor
'Follow the Money' Applies to Science
City News: Cities Seek Clout for 'Green' Taxi Rules
Devlin Barrett
Total: 113 articles, of which 56 were coded intensively (176 actor statements)
5
Coding instrument
To analyze the normative demands and controversies in public communication on climate governance, I followed a qualitative coding and interpretation approach (Gläser and Laudel 2009). The mass
media articles were coded in two steps. In the first step, several categories on the article level were
assigned. Additionally, text passages characterizing the problem climate change were coded (according to the respective codes listed below) and evaluative statements related to climate governance
(including demands to pursue a certain option) were identified. This step involved two extensively
trained student assistant. The training included discussions and reliability checks until a high agreement was reached. In a second step, the actor statements were coded intensively using a detailed,
theoretically informed codebook. This step was solely conducted by the author.
The instrument for this intensive coding builds on existing approaches such as public justification analysis (Luhtakallio and Ylä-Anttila 2011; Gladarev and Lonkila 2013) and valuation analysis
(Schmidtke and Nullmeier 2011; Rantala 2012; Hurrelmann et al. 2013). Using this approaches, I
elaborated an own analytical framework which I discuss in detail elsewhere (Schmidt 2015 [forthcoming]). As I aimed for a typology of moral valuation patterns, I used a “theoretical sampling” strategy (Corbin 2003) to determine the articles and statements for analysis – until “saturation” was
reached, that is, when no new aspects arose (Merkens 2003).
The coding was carried out with the help of QDA Miner – a software for qualitative data analysis. This allows for an easy management of the data and, more important, facilitates the retrieval of
coded segments and the preparation of the results through various technical functions (Kuckartz
2007).
The different climate justice patterns were constructed by carefully analyzing co-occurrences,
comparing the statements of one actor (group) and by contrasting the coded segments repeatedly
with similar and diverging instances. This inductive approach was complemented by a theoretically
informed view on the material, especially drawing from moral sociology (e.g. Thévenot et al. 2000)
and normative climate justice conceptions (for details, see Schmidt 2015 [forthcoming]).
A full version of the codebooks including detailed instructions and definitions (in German) can
be requested from the author. What follows is an abbreviated, translated version that gives an overview of the logic and scope of the coding approach.
6
Codebook article-level and problem definition
Article-level variables
ART_DATE:
Article publication date
41
ART_TITEL:
Article title
ART_AUTOR:
Name of the Author
ART_TYPE:
Article genre
ANLASS:
Reason / trigger for coverage

Political activity
Differentiation (for this and the following codes) between






o
Emerging from the inner logic of the system
o
Addressed to the public
Scientific activity
Economic activity
Civil society activity
Cultural activity
Problems indicating climate change
Further activities / occassions
REL_TRANKP: Prominence of transnational climate politics within the Article.
Differentiation (for this and the following variables) between



Central topic (Sole topic, main topic or most important topic)
Side topic / mentioned
Not a topic
REL_AUSKP:
Prominence of foreign climate politics within the article.
REL_NATKP:
Prominence of national climate politics within the article.
REL_SUBKP:
Significance of subnational climate politics within the article.
Codes for the statement level
Problem definition
It is coded as to whether climate change is being described as a problem, and how so. Is it described
as existing and anthropogenic? What causes and perpetrators are mentioned? Which consequences/impacts of climate change are mentioned for which geographical entities? All instances mentioning/relating to these issues and the categories below are coded.
Existence of climate change



Existence of climate change is rejected
Climate change is described as currently and prospectively existing
The existence or occurrence of climate change is described as possible, but not fully assured
Causes of Climate Change
Mankind / general anthropogenic causes
Differentiation (for this and the following codes) between



mentioned as a cause
described as the prime cause
described as one of many causes
42
 described as only subordinate cause
Greenhouse gas emissions
Current lifestyle
Population growth
Economy in general
Economic system
Industrial production
Agriculture and food industry
Individual transport
Fossil fuels
Deforestation
Feedback effects
Other, non-anthropogenic causes
Causal agents
Who (collective as well as individual agents) is mentioned as responsible for causing climate change?
Transnational collectives
Industrial countries
Differentiation (for this and the following codes) between
 mentioned
 prime causal entities
 one of many causally responsible entities
 causal responsibility of entity subordinate / irrelevant
Developing countries
…
Individual countries
USA
…
Impacts
Which impacts of climate change are described? Classification of the described impacts as well as
their evaluation.
General impacts
Differentiation (for this and the following codes) between
 mentioned
 described as a problem
 described as a distributive problem
 described as not problematic
Impacts on nature
Impacts on mankind in general
43
Impacts on human rights
Impacts on human living environment
Impact on human nutritional situation
Impact on the economy
Impact on human health
Impact on resource conflicts
Affected
Who is described as being affected by the (coded) impacts of climate change?
Affected transnational collectives
Future generations
Developing countries
Least developed countries
…
Affected countries
India
Indonesia
…
Description of distributive issues
The codes in this category are used to code statements concerning the disparities / inequalities in
causal responsibility and affectedness/susceptibility to the impacts of climate change.
Distribution of impacts
Disparity of causation and impact
Unequal, rival use of the atmosphere/climate system
Evaluation of solutions / options for actions on climate change
Statements evaluating climate policy institutions, decisions, decision-making processes and measures
are coded. Every evaluative judgement regarding climate policy measures (existing and suggested) is
relevant. Furthermore demands and suggestions regarding action on climate change are relevant.
Evaluative actor statements are defined by:



A directly or indirectly quoted agent or the journalist expressing the evaluation (speaker)
An object (a decision, measure, decision-making process, institution) which is being evaluated
One (or both) of the following elements:
o
Direction of the evaluation (negative, positive, ambivalent)
o
Rationale of the evaluation (Evaluation criterion)
Evaluation of transnational institutions, decision-making processes & policies
Evaluation of national institutions, decision-making processes & policies
44
Evaluation of subnational institutions, decision-making processes & policies
Evaluation of general institutions, decision-making processes & policies
7
Codebook for the in-depth analysis of evaluative actor statements
Speaker
SPR_TYP:




Speaker type
Not evident
Collective agent
Individual agent representing a collective agent
Individual Akteur
SPR_HER:
Geographical/institutional origin of the speaker
 List of transnational institutions, regions, country groups and countries
SPR_SEG:
socio-cultural sphere which the actor comes from / represents
Characterization of the evaluation
BEW_TYP: Evaluation type




Existing governance
Governance option
Proposal of other actor
None
BEW_VERANT: Institutional attribution of the evaluated object
 List of transnational institutions, regions, country groups and countries
BEW_OBJ:
Which solution approaches (mitigation, adaptation, geo-engineering, specific aspects
of the former) are evaluated?
BEW_STEU:
Governance instrument or mechanism of the evaluated object
BEW_REL:
Relational element of evaluation: Does the evaluation compare the position of two or
more social groups and how so?



No relation
Equal relation without disadvantage
Collective/Individual coded in focus has disadvantage
BEW_FOK:
Collective/Individual in focus of evaluation
BEW_VGL:
Collective/Individual that it is compared with
Evaluation pattern: Direction and criteria of evaluation
BEW_RICH:
Direction of the evaluation
45



positive
ambivalent
negative
Goods and Rights
Goods for human use
Material welfare in general
Differentiation (for this and the following codes) between
 explicitly described as worthy (of protection)
 implicitly described as worthy (of protection)
 mentioned, but rejected as relevant
 mentioned as issue of distribution conflict
Jobs
Natural resources
Nature as space for human recreation
Human living space
Infrastructure
Emissions / emission rights
Cultural goods
Poverty alleviation
Food
Burdens
Costs of climate policies in general
Emission reductions
Costs of adaptation
Rights
Human rights in general
Freedom from bodily harm
Civil rights (Negative freedoms)
Political rights
Social rights
Cultural rights
Further
Creation
Nature / non-human environment for its own sake
Governance principles (see Schmidt 2012)
Justice in general
Differentiation (for this and the following principles) between
46



explicitly applied/demanded
implicitly applied
mentioned, but rejected as relevant/appropriate principle
Distributive justice
Equality
Grandfathering/Dessert
Need
Responsibility/Polluter Pays
Ability to pay
Market justice
Proportional distribution (according to GDP) of emissions
Intergenerational justice
Other output principles
Effectiveness
In terms of stabilizing the climate system
In terms of other problems
Efficiency
Proportionality (balance between the restriction imposed and the benefit of the measure)
Procedural justice
Democratic principles in general
Public opionion / responsiveness
Participation
Participation of civil society
Participation of scientific actors
Participation of business actors
Openness for information
Completeness and accuracy
Transparency
Neutrality
Reversibility
Accountability
Deliberation
Institutional & other principles
Subsidiarity
Self-determination
Reliability (of governance decisions)
47
Leadership
Credibility
Feasibility
Demands
FORDER:



Does the evaluation contain a demand?
No demand/commitment
Contains demand
Contains commitments
 Coding of demand/commitment according to same logic as above
References
Audet R (2013) Climate Justice and Bargaining Coalitions. Int Environ Agreem 13(3):369-386
Benford RD (2010) Framing global governance from below. In: Bjola C, Kornprobst M (eds) Arguing Global
Governance. Routledge, London & New York, pp 67–84
Bidwai P (2012) Climate Change, India and the Global Negotiations. Soc Change 42(3):375–390
Boden
T,
Andres
B,
Marland
G
(2013)
Fossil-Fuel
CO2
Emissions.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3334/CDIAC/00001_V2013. Accessed 09 April 2014
Bomberg E (2012) Mind the (Mobilization) Gap: Comparing Climate Activism in the United States and
European Union. Rev Pol Res 29(3):408–430
Broadbent J (2013) Asian Societies and Climate Change: The Variable Diffusion of Global Norms. Globality
Studies Journal(32)
Carvalho A, Burgess J (2005) Cultural Circuits of Climate Change in U.K. Broadsheet Newspapers, 1985–
2003. Risk Anal 25(6):1457–1469
Cass LR (2006) The Failures of American and European Climate Policy. State University of New York Press,
Albany
Corbin JM (2003) Grounded Theory. In: Bohnsack R, Marotzki W, Meuser M (eds) Hauptbegriffe
Qualitative Sozialforschung. Leske + Budrich, Opladen, pp 70–75
Doulton H, Brown K (2009) Ten years to prevent catastrophe? Discourses of climate change and
international development in the UK press. Glob Environ Change 19(2):191–202
Eilders C (2002) Conflict and Consonance in Media Opinion. Eur J Commun 17(1):25–63
Feldman L, Maibach EW, Roser-Renouf C, Leiserowitz A (2012) Climate on Cable. Int J Press Pol 17(1):3–31
Freedom House (2011) Freedom in the World 2011. http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedomworld/freedom-world-2011. Accessed 07 May 2014
Gentzkow M, Shapiro JM (2010) What Drives Media Slant? Econometrica 78(1):35–71
Gladarev B, Lonkila M (2013) Justifying Civic Activism in Russia and Finland. J Civ Soc 9(4):375–390
Gläser J, Laudel G (2009) Experteninterviews und qualitative Inhaltsanalyse als Instrumente
rekonstruierender Untersuchungen, 3rd edn. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden
Groseclose T, Milyo J (2005) A Measure of Media Bias. Q J Econ 120(4):1191–1237
Grundmann R, Krishnamurthy R (2010) The discourse of climate change: A corpus-based approach. Critical
Approaches to Discourse Analysis across Disciplines 4(2):125–146
Hans-Bredow-Institut (ed) (2009) Internationales Handbuch Medien, 28th edn. Nomos, Baden-Baden
Hart PS, Feldman L (2014) Threat Without Efficacy? Climate Change on U.S. Network News. Sci Commun
36(3):325–351
Hediger V (2007) Asien. In: Thomaß B (ed) Mediensysteme im internationalen Vergleich. UVK, Konstanz,
pp 299–313
Hoffman AJ (2011) Talking Past Each Other? Cultural Framing of Skeptical and Convinced Logics in the
Climate Change Debate. Organ Environ 24(1):3–33
48
Höppner C (2010) Rereading Public Opinion Polls on Climate Change in the UK Press. Int J Commun 4:977–
1005
Hurrelmann A, Gora A, Wagner A (2013) The legitimation of the European Union in the news media: three
treaty reform debates. J Eur Public Pol 20(4):515–534
Institut für Medien- und Kommunikationspolitik (IfM) (2010) Die führenden internationalen Zeitungen im
Vergleich. http://www.mediadb.eu/tageszeitungen/50-zeitungen.html. Accessed 08 April 2014
Jogesh A (2012) A Change in Climate? In: Dubash NK (ed) Handbook of Climate Change and India.
earthscan, London, pp 266–286
Kasa S, Gullberg A, Heggelund G (2008) The Group of 77 in the International Climate Negotiations. Int
Environ Agreem 8(2):113-127
Kleinsteuber HJ, Thomaß B (2008) The German Media Landscape. In: Terzis G (ed) European Media
Governance. Intellect Books, Bristol, pp 111Kriesi H (2001) Die Rolle der Öffentlichkeit im politischen Entscheidungsprozess. Discussions Paper, P 01701. Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin für Sozialforschung, Berlin
Kuckartz U (2007) Einführung in die computergestützte Analyse qualitativer Daten, 2nd edn. VS Verlag für
Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden
Luhtakallio E, Ylä-Anttila T (2011) Julkisen oikeuttamisen analyysi sosiologisena tutkimusmenetelmänä.
Sosiol 48(1):34–51
Merkens H (2003) Auswahlverfahren, Sampling, Fallkonstruktion. In: Flick U, Kardorff E von, Steinke I
(eds) Qualitative Forschung. Rowohlt, Reinbek bei Hamburg, pp 286–299
Never B (2011) Who Drives Change? GIGA Working Papers, 174, Hamburg
Painter J, Ashe T (2012) Cross-national Comparison of the Presence of Climate Scepticism in the Print Media
in Six Countries, 2007–10. Environ Res Lett 7(4):1–8
Pasquaré FA, Oppizzi P (2012) How do the media affect public perception of climate change and
geohazards? An Italian case study. Glob Planet Change 90-91:152–157
Rantala T (2012) Legitimacy of Forest and Nature Conservation Policy. Scand J For Res 27(2):164–176
Schäfer MS, Ivanova A, Schmidt A (2012a) Issue-Attention: Mediale Aufmerksamkeit für den Klimawandel
in 26 Ländern. In: Neverla I, Schäfer MS (eds) Das Medien-Klima. Springer VS, Wiesbaden, pp 121–142
Schäfer MS, Ivanova A, Schmidt A (2014) What Drives Media Attention for Climate Change? Explaining
Issue Attention in Australian, German and Indian Print Media from 1996 to 2010. International
Communication Gazette 76(2):152–176
Schäfer MS, Ivanova A, Schmidt A, Murmann J (2012b) Medienaufmerksamkeit für den Klimawandel.
http://tiny.cc/MAfCC
Schmidt A (2012) Justice in the Public Climate Debate: Claims & Related Policy Preferences in Comparative
Perspective.
Schmidt A (2015 [forthcoming]) Moralvorstellungen in der öffentlichen Debatte: Konzeptionelle und
methodische Überlegungen zu Relevanz und empirischer Untersuchung [Morality in the public debate:
Conceptual and methodological considerations on its relevance and empirical investigation]. Stud
Commun Media(2)
Schmidt A, Ivanova A, Schäfer MS (2013) Media Attention for Climate Change around the World: A
Comparative Analysis of Newspaper Coverage in 27 Countries. Glob Environ Change 23(5):1233–1248
Schmidtke H, Nullmeier F (2011) Political Valuation Analysis and the Legitimacy of International
Organizations. Ger Policy Stud 7(3):117–153
Selin H, VanDeveer SD (2011) US climate change politics and policymaking. Wiley Interdiscip Rev Clim
Change 2(1):121–127
Thévenot L, Moody M, Lafaye C (2000) Forms of Valuing Nature. In: Lamont M, Thévenot L (eds)
Rethinking Comparative Cultural Sociology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 229–272
Townshend T, Fankhauser S, Matthews A, Feger C, Liu J, Narciso Thais (2011) GLOBE Climate Legislation
Study. GLOBE International; Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment
Waldherr A (2012) Die Dynamik der Medienaufmerksamkeit. Nomos, Baden-Baden
Weidner H (2007) Deutsche Klimapolitik: Erfolgreich und gerecht? Zur Rolle von Fairnessnormen. In: Jacob
K, Biermann F, Busch P, Feindt PH (eds) Politik und Umwelt, 1st edn. VS Verlag für
Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden, pp 452–478
49
Wilke J (1999) Leitmedien und Zielgruppenorgane. In: Wilke J (ed) Mediengeschichte der Bundesrepublik
Deutschland. BPB, Bonn, pp 302–329
50